09.02.2013 Views

MEAT Sector Analyse

MEAT Sector Analyse

MEAT Sector Analyse

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

SMEI II Inception Report page 1<br />

THE EUROPEAN UNION’S IPA 2008 PROGRAMME<br />

FOR THE REPUBLIC OF ALBANIA<br />

“Capacity Building for Implementing the Rural<br />

Development Strategy”<br />

Delegation Agreement No: 2009/212-470<br />

Analysis of Meat <strong>Sector</strong><br />

A project funded by<br />

the European Union and the Federal<br />

Government of Germany<br />

April 2010<br />

This project is funded by<br />

The European Union and The Federal Government of Germany<br />

A project implemented by<br />

Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische<br />

Zusammenarbeit (GTZ) GmbH


ALBANIA<br />

“Capacity Building for Implementing<br />

the Rural Development Strategy”<br />

Support to the Albanian Ministry of Agriculture,<br />

Food and Consumer Protection<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Dr.Martin Mautner Markhof / office@agroservice.com<br />

Prof. Dr.Bahri Musabelliu<br />

Alban Zusi<br />

April 2010<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 1<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study


CONTENT<br />

ABBREVIATIONS<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

0) EXECUTIVE SUMMARY………………………………………………………………………..7<br />

1) BACKGROUND AND KEY FIGURES………………………………………………………..11<br />

2) PRODUCER/FARMERS……………………………………………………………………….14<br />

Cattle……………………………………………………………………………………………..14<br />

Sheep and goats………………………………………………………………………………..16<br />

Pigs………………………………………………………………………………………………19<br />

Poultry……………………………………………………………………………………………20<br />

Animal feeding…………………………………………………………………………………..21<br />

Animal feed producers……………………………………………………………………….22<br />

3) PROCESSING INDUSTRY…………………………………………………………………....23<br />

Slaughterhouses………………………………………………………………………………..23<br />

Keputa………………………………………………………………………………………….25<br />

Meat processing companies…………………………………………………………………..26<br />

EHW GmbH……………………………………………………………………………………27<br />

KMY…………………………………………………………………………………………….27<br />

Meat Master…………………………………………………………………………………...28<br />

Darb Univers Frigo Darb………………………………………………………………….....28<br />

TONA Co………………………………………………………………….............................28<br />

DEKON FRIGO…………………………………………………………………...................28<br />

EL FRIGO 2……………………………………………………………………………………28<br />

FRIGO ALBA………………………………………………………………….......................29<br />

FIX-PRO shpk………………………………………………………………………………...29<br />

HAKO…………………………………………………………………………………………..29<br />

ALBIDEA ………………………………………………………………………………………29<br />

ROZAFA KACI shpk………………………………………………………………………….30<br />

I.N.C.A Nord Fish…………………………………………………………………................30<br />

4) GOVERNMENT POLICY FOR THE SECTOR AND INSTITUTIONAL ISSUES………...31<br />

Cattle………………………………………………………………………………………..….31<br />

Sheep……………………………………………………………………………………….….31<br />

Land property and reform……………………………………………………………...…….32<br />

Mountain areas………………………………………………………………………………..33<br />

Value Added Tax……………………………………………………………………………...34<br />

5) MARKET AND TRADE………………………………………………………………………...34<br />

Availability of products……………………………………………………………………...….34<br />

Supply chain…………………………………………………………………………………….34<br />

Consumption pattern…………………………………………………………………….……..35<br />

Legal framework for trade …………………………………………………………………….36<br />

Agro-food trade balance……………………………………………………………………….37<br />

6) LEVEL OF ATTAINMENT OF RELEVANT EU STANDARDS …………………………...39<br />

Occupational health and safety………………………………………………………….……39<br />

Environment……………………………………………………………………………………..39<br />

Food safety ……………………………………………………………………………………..40<br />

Animal health and welfare……………………………………………………………………..42<br />

Competent authorities………………………………………………………………………….44<br />

National Strategy for Development and Integration (NSDI) 2007-2013………………….45<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 2


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Agriculture and fisheries……………………………………………………………………….46<br />

Farm level……………………………………………………………………………………….46<br />

Processing level………………………………………………………………………………...47<br />

7) PAST TRENDS AND FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS IN TERMS OF INVESTMENTS…...47<br />

Past trends……………………………………………………………………………………....47<br />

Actual situation………………………………………………………………………………….47<br />

Future developments…………………………………………………………………………..48<br />

8) IDENTIFICATION OF POTENTIAL AND NEEDS FOR THE SECTOR…………...……..49<br />

9) IDENTIFICATION OF TRAINING NEEDS FOR THE SECTOR…………………………..62<br />

Training needs for farmers…………………………………………………………………….63<br />

Training needs for slaughterhouse’s staff……………………………………………………63<br />

Training needs for meat processor’s staff……………………………………………………63<br />

Training needs for the public administration…………………………………………………63<br />

10) OUTCOME………………………………………………………………………………………64<br />

Overview of the meat sector ………………………………………………………………….64<br />

Potentials and obstacles……………………………………………………………………….65<br />

Final recommendations in order to target the specific investments ……………………...66<br />

LITERATURE AND WEBSITES CONSIDERED…………………………………………………69<br />

Map 1: Land use in Albania<br />

Map 2: Administration in Albania<br />

Table 1: Sub-sector’s contribution to the agricultural added value (in Lek and %)<br />

Table 2: Output of animal products<br />

Table 3: Animals in Albania (heads in 000)<br />

Table 4: Meat production 2000 – 2009<br />

Table 5: Average live weight of calves when slaughtered<br />

Table 6: Revenues per sheep and year; meat vs. milk<br />

Table 7: Break - even points for milk and meat<br />

Table 8: Poultry meat farm<br />

Table 9: Investment of the agro-industry in Lek million<br />

Table 10: Sausage and ham production of the agro-industry<br />

Table 11: Average size of agricultural enterprises and cooperatives<br />

Table 12: Livestock production<br />

Table 13: Meat consumption<br />

Table 14: Agro-food import and export<br />

Table 15: Import of agricultural and food products by quantity and value<br />

Table 16: Export of agricultural and food products by quantity and value<br />

Table 17: Investments in Albanian agroindustry<br />

Table 18: Animals in Albania (heads in 000)<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 3


Map 1: Land use in Albania<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

(Source: SHUNDI, Andrea Prof.: Country Pasture/Forage Resource Profiles Albania; 2006)<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 4


Map 2: Administration in Albania<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 5<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Albania is divided into 12 administrative divisions called counties or in Albanian qark/qarku',<br />

often also prefekturë/prefektura; furthermore there are 65 municipalities and 308 communes.<br />

No Regions Area km²<br />

1 Berat 1802<br />

2 Diber 2507<br />

3 Durres 827<br />

4 Elbasan 3278<br />

5 Fier 1887<br />

6 Gjirokaster 2883<br />

7 Korce 3711<br />

8 Kukes 2373<br />

9 Lezhe 1581<br />

10 Shkoder 3562<br />

11 Tirana 1586<br />

12 Vlora 2706<br />

ALBANIA 28703


ABBREVIATIONS<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

ADAMA Albanian Dairy and Meat Association<br />

ATTC Agricultural Technology Transfer Centres<br />

BSE Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy, a cattle disease<br />

CAP Common Agricultural Policy<br />

CARDS Community Assistance for Reconstruction, Development and Stabilisation<br />

CEFTA Central European Free Trade Agreement<br />

CESVI Cooperazione e Sviluppo, an Italian NGO<br />

EC European Commission<br />

FVO Food and Veterinary Office (Ireland)<br />

GAP Good Agricultural Practice<br />

GDP Gross Domestic Product<br />

GOA Government of Albania<br />

GTZ German Agency for Technical Cooperation<br />

HACCP Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Point<br />

IPA Instrument for Pre-Accession Assistance<br />

IPARD Instrument for Pre-Accession Assistance on Rural Development<br />

ISO International Organisation for Standardisation<br />

Lek Albanian Currency<br />

MAFCP Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Consumer Protection<br />

NFA National Food Authority<br />

NGO Non Governmental Organisation<br />

NSDI National Strategy for Development and Integration<br />

OIE World Organisation for Animal Health<br />

SLI State Labour Inspectorate<br />

SR Small Ruminants<br />

SWOT Strengths Weaknesses Opportunities and Threats<br />

VAT Value Added Tax<br />

WTO World Trade Organisation<br />

Exchange rate (1 st April 2010)<br />

Euro : Lek = 1 : 139,344000<br />

Source: http://ec.europa.eu/budget/inforeuro/index.cfm?fuseaction=currency_historique&<br />

currency= 6&Language=en<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 6


O. Executive Summary<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

This meat sector study was prepared during January to April 2010 within the framework of<br />

the EU / GTZ project „Capacity Building for Implementing the Rural Development Strategy“ to<br />

provide a quantitative and qualitative description of the meat sector in Albania; starting from<br />

livestock keepers to slaughterhouses and meat processors. In addition a SWOT analysis<br />

accomplished the potential and weak points of the meat sector and summarized all the<br />

findings. This was necessary to have a sound base for upcoming decisions within the<br />

Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Consumer Protection (MAFCP), especially related to the<br />

envisaged Instrument for Pre-Accession Assistance on Rural Development (IPARD) support<br />

scheme. This scheme intends to assist financially investment in agriculture holdings, in<br />

processing and marketing of the agricultural products. Other recommendations which will not<br />

find IPARD support – as they do not fit the criteria of the two mentioned measures – have<br />

been made and eventually the Government of Albania (GOA) will find financing means<br />

trough national support programmes.<br />

The objective of this meat sector analysis was to give a quantitative and qualitative<br />

description of the Albanian meat sector, addressing both production and processing.<br />

The following methodology and approach were applied to write this study:<br />

a) Desk research;<br />

b) Intensive expert talks with MAFCP staff but also with the Agricultural Technology<br />

Transfer Centres (ATTC) and other institutions;<br />

c) Visit of more than 15 farms (see also ANNEX 1);<br />

d) Individual meeting with leading representatives of the meat processing industry<br />

(including visits of several processing plants and slaughterhouses), representatives of<br />

associations, traders and importers (see also ANNEX 1);<br />

e) More than 10 Focus Group meetings in all major geographical areas (political regions)<br />

to get immediate insight into the husbandry sector and to collect additional baseline<br />

data;<br />

f) Discussions with other internationally funded projects in this sector.<br />

In order to make the study transparent the focus was on cattle, sheep, goats, pigs and<br />

chicken only; other animal origin sectors (horse, buffalo, ostrich etc) have not been included.<br />

SWOT analyses have been made for each sub-group (farmers, slaughterhouses and meat<br />

processors) and the most important weaknesses in the sector are:<br />

• Unfavourable entity structures in production as most animals are kept by subsistence<br />

farmers on holdings with 1.2 – 1.8 ha;<br />

• High level of land fragmentation;<br />

• High fodder costs as almost all components have to be imported;<br />

• Low competitiveness and efficiency of production;<br />

• Unfavourable business environment for slaughterhouses which therefore are running at<br />

low capacity or not at all;<br />

• Unfavourable entity structures in processing especially for small meat processing<br />

plants slaughterhouses (the 5 - 10 big players are doing fine);<br />

• Insufficient attainment of national and/or EU standards at farm, slaughterhouse and<br />

small processing plant level;<br />

• Insufficient knowledge on modern production techniques / technologies and standards<br />

at farm and slaughterhouse level;<br />

• Insufficient professional advisory service.<br />

The outcome of the study shows very mixed results for the sub-groups. The results are<br />

astonishing.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 7


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

The livestock husbandry deals on one side with ruminants like cows, sheep and goats and<br />

on the other side with pigs and poultry.<br />

The ruminants are taking advantage of the Albanian pastures which are plentiful available.<br />

However the number of all ruminants heads is going continuously down due to:<br />

• Limited farm size and dominance of subsistence farming with livestock farmers not able<br />

to invest;<br />

• As meat production with ruminants requires long production cycle we face a slow return<br />

on investment; (situation is better with dairy farmers as they get regular cash revenues<br />

by selling milk);<br />

• Poor premises and outdated technology, for example stables without windows and too<br />

little and old tractors;<br />

• Poor infrastructure; for example missing water holes in remote areas;<br />

• Poor marketing channels and no uniform offer regarding qualities and quantities;<br />

• Very limited demand from the slaughterhouses and meat processors;<br />

• Migration to urban areas.<br />

On the other side are the pig and poultry producers and the animal head counts are<br />

increasing continuously. Also here we have two different groups with quite different<br />

performances. There are the subsistence farmers again who keep a dozen chickens in the<br />

backyard for self-consumption and additionally often 2 - 3 piglets – also for self consumption.<br />

The more commercial pig farmers are struggling with the following handicaps:<br />

• No specialisation of pig farms because piglets of good quality and sufficient quantities<br />

(uniform groups) cannot be purchased on weekly markets so that farmers have to get<br />

involved in the whole process: mother sows – piglet production – fattening;<br />

• Consequently piglets have been imported (from Serbia and other countries) and as it<br />

was more profitable importers brought in 80 – 90 kg pigs almost ready for slaughtering;<br />

• Main reason why imports of ready pigs are cheaper is that fodder, if not produced on<br />

the farm, is expensive;<br />

• Poor marketing channels and no uniform offer of fattened pigs regarding qualities and<br />

quantities.<br />

The situation in the chicken sector looks much better as here are several investors active<br />

who have the funds for this capital-intensive business with fast returns on investments. Often<br />

these investors are already active in agribusiness for example with feed production<br />

companies or slaughterhouses. There is a trend to establish a complete integrated chain of<br />

operations, from chicken farms to feed mill and retail outlets. These new chicken farms of<br />

agribusiness type can therefore also use cheaper fodder as it is produced often in own feed<br />

mills.<br />

Coming to the processors we also see quite different performances; slaughterhouses<br />

underperform and meat processing companies do well.<br />

In Albania there are many slaughterhouses not in operation (see also UNDP Albania; The<br />

Agribusiness <strong>Sector</strong> in Albania, Inward Investment Opportunities; 05) and the active around<br />

20 slaughterhouses do daily slaughtering of 1 – 2 cattle and / or few pigs or small ruminants.<br />

All slaughterhouses are working far below their capacities because nobody forces the traders<br />

and butchers to slaughter there; this will be one of the main activities of the upcoming<br />

National Food Authority (NFA). Therefore slaughterhouses face no or limited raw material<br />

supply. Usually the facilities are outdated and in most cases they do not even comply with<br />

the Albanian law. Consequently EU standards on hygiene, public authority, traceability and<br />

HACCP are not fulfilled and liquid and solid waste material is just dumped into landfills or<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 8


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

washed away by the nearby river. The condition of the existing premises is poor so that most<br />

likely just new Greenfield investments in slaughterhouses will improve the situation.<br />

In contrast to the slaughterhouse sector the Albanian top meat processing companies like<br />

EHW, KMY, TONA and others are doing fine. The 10 biggest processing companies cover<br />

around 80 % of the market share, are financially strong and consider further investments with<br />

and without upcoming IPARD-support.<br />

Considering the whole meat sector under IPARD support schemes, there is definitely a need<br />

for financial support. In livestock farming the best potential is still within cattle and small<br />

ruminants as these livestock farms could make use of the natural advantages (i.e. pastures)<br />

which Albania has available. Less needs for financial support is required in the pig production<br />

and almost none in chicken farming.<br />

Also the processing sector has different stakeholders. Slaughterhouses will be needed in the<br />

future and as refurbishment is too expensive new slaughterhouses will have to be build.<br />

There is enough private interest in case that the competent authorities will start channelling<br />

all animals through slaughterhouses within the next months. Nevertheless IPARD funding will<br />

be needed.<br />

For the meat processing companies the authors see fewer necessities to support as the big<br />

players are doing fine and have a quite high level of standards already fulfilled. They are<br />

keen to export and need urgently improvements in the veterinary and food inspection system.<br />

Finally it has to be stressed out that Albania has no rendering plant and therefore all waste<br />

material from farms to slaughterhouses and meat processors are dumped into landfills. It is<br />

highly recommended to encourage the establishment of such a plant; this could be done also<br />

by the private sector especially of IPARD funding will be available and the NFA enforce<br />

relevant laws.<br />

Having covered the production side the study had also a look on the governmental<br />

stakeholders such as MAFCP, ATTC, NFA and others. These governmental bodies will need<br />

specific capacity building programmes to better understand the commercial side of the meat<br />

sector, IPRAD requirements regarding farmers and processors and their upcoming<br />

investment proposals and many more.<br />

For this meat sector study official data from MAFCP have been used wherever possible.<br />

Taking in consideration the overall situation in the sector and the results of the SWOT -<br />

analyses future interventions in the sector should be oriented mainly to:<br />

• Improve entity structure in production and processing and increase the competitiveness<br />

of the sector;<br />

• Increase overall competitiveness through investments for application of modern<br />

production techniques and technologies;<br />

• Improve status of attainment of national and EU standards on occupational health and<br />

safety, environmental issues, food and feed safety, animal health, animal welfare and<br />

more; these standards are closely related with the EU accession requirements;<br />

• Improve vocational training;<br />

• Improve performance and offer of service providers.<br />

Investment in Agricultural Holdings<br />

The following investments should be supported under IPARD:<br />

• Construction/extension/modernisation of animal shelters;<br />

• Construction and/or renovation of storage buildings and machine sheds;<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 9


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

• Silage handling equipment and machinery, on-farm animal feed preparation, handling,<br />

distribution systems and storage;<br />

• Automatic feeding & drinking equipment, watering, heating and ventilation, automating<br />

environmental control systems including energy-saving equipments authorised and<br />

defined under Directive 2007/43/EC;<br />

• Investments for manure handling, storage and treatment facilities;<br />

• Animal handling equipment and facilities (e.g. weighing, disinfection);<br />

• Transportation equipment compatible with Community animal welfare standards;<br />

• Watering systems;<br />

• Fences and gates;<br />

• Special equipment for weighing, health control;<br />

• Biogas facilities;<br />

• Purchase of specialized technological equipment including IT and software (herd<br />

management, animal registry, general farm management).<br />

The ranking of investment priorities according to the different types of animals should be as<br />

follows: sheep – cattle – goats – pigs – poultry.<br />

Investment in Processing and Marketing of the Agricultural Products<br />

The following investments should be supported under IPARD:<br />

• Construction or renovation of slaughterhouses;<br />

• Renovation of meat processing enterprises;<br />

• Equipment for improvement of hygiene and product quality, in full compliance with<br />

Community standards;<br />

• Investments for establishment of food safety systems (HACCP, GMP and GHP)<br />

including laboratories and equipment to improve the control of the product quality and<br />

hygiene;<br />

• Certification costs;<br />

• Improvement of environmental protection; equipment and facilities for reprocessing of<br />

intermediate products and processable wastes; treatment and elimination of wastes:<br />

waste water works in slaughterhouses and fat catcher facilities for meat processing<br />

establishments;<br />

• Investment for slaughtering animals in conditions compatible with animal welfare;<br />

• Purchase of equipment for packaging;<br />

• Cold storage equipment, purchasing refrigerated transport means of carcass and meat<br />

products;<br />

• IT hardware and software for product and process management, Software & tracking<br />

system to implement traceability of carcass and meat inside the processing<br />

establishment.<br />

The ranking of investment priorities in the processing sector should be as follows:<br />

slaughterhouses - (rendering plants) – meat processors.<br />

Beside IPARD funding the agricultural sector would need substantially more support from the<br />

GOA. The current allocation of the budget for the sector agriculture and rural development<br />

makes just 2.2 % while the agricultural sector still produces more than 15 % of the GDP.<br />

Despite progress in many sectors the agriculture and rural development sector is and will be<br />

in the near future the backbone of all economic development in Albania.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 10


I. Background and Key Figures<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Albania has a population of more than 3 million inhabitants, and eventually the same number<br />

of Albanians who work and live abroad. The northern, north-eastern, south-eastern and<br />

central areas are characterized by hilly-mountainous terrain; whereas the north southern /<br />

costal area along the Adriatic and Ionian coast is lowland. It has a total land area of 28,750<br />

km² (equivalent to 2,875,000 ha); 696,000 ha are classified as agricultural land and<br />

2,179,000 ha as forestry, pasture and other fond. (Source: MAFCP; Statistical Yearbook<br />

2009) Out of the last group, around 423,000 ha are considered pastures.<br />

After 46 years of centrally planned economy, Albania’s agriculture has changed dramatically<br />

since the early 1990s. Before transition there have been 550 large state farms and<br />

cooperatives in Albania. After the collapse of the system and after the land distribution, which<br />

did not took place in the north, there have been about 467,000 very small family farms<br />

whereas today just 357,027 farm households are left with an average 1.5 ha - divided into 4<br />

parcels. On each farm live 4.8 people so that in total 1.7 million people are involved in<br />

farming activities; about 50 % of the population lives in rural areas.<br />

Despite being fragmented, this small farming agriculture has initially been vital to the<br />

alleviation of poverty in rural areas and provision to the urban markets with some elementary<br />

and indispensable foodstuff such as vegetables, meat and other dairy stuff. With 59 % of<br />

total labour and 21 % of GDP the agricultural sector, including also forestry, hunting and<br />

fishery, continues to be an important sector of the Albanian economy. Nevertheless the<br />

contribution to the GDP was continuously falling since 2005 (20.6 %), 2006 (19.4 %), 2007<br />

(18.9 %) and 2008 (16.5 %). (Source: INSTAT)<br />

Around 1.7 million people live on farms but the trend shows that many young people do not<br />

take over the subsistence farms of their parents or give up their farm activities and move to<br />

bigger towns; in these cases animals are sold or slaughtered but the land is kept as land<br />

property offers high financial security; sometimes the land is rented out to neighbours but<br />

often left alone without any use.<br />

Albanian farming is predominantly at subsistence level and most of the agricultural product is<br />

destined to home consumption. As a result only 18 % of crop production, 30 % of livestock<br />

products and a few percentages of off-farm processed products reach the market. Household<br />

income range differs between families living in mountain areas (poor) to those in the plains<br />

(less poor).<br />

As the centrally planned economy collapsed, the market-driven economy forced farmers over<br />

night to change their way of farming. Major shifts in agricultural production patterns have<br />

taken place with a significant increase of animal production that compensated the respective<br />

drop in crop and fruit production. Current production systems have mainly evolved as<br />

adjustment to the new situation with very small and fragmented farms which have to face<br />

other major constraints such as a poor physical infrastructure, lacking state or privately<br />

operated services, lack of food processing industries and an imperfect market.<br />

The agricultural sector’s contribution to the GDP can be allocated to the following subsectors.<br />

Table 1: Sub-sector’s contribution to the agricultural added value (in Lek and %)<br />

Nr. Description 2000 2006 2007 2008 2009<br />

Total mio LEK 126116 147306 149802 155669 159080<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 11


1 Livestock 71460 86633 90101 86882 87727<br />

2 Field crop 42483 42226 40482 45741 47352<br />

3 Fruit trees 12173 18446 19219 23046 24001<br />

Nr. % 2000 2006 2007 2008 2009<br />

1 Livestock 57% 59% 60% 56% 55%<br />

2 Field crop 34% 29% 27% 29% 30%<br />

3 Fruit trees 10% 13% 13% 15% 15%<br />

(Source: MAFCP; Statistical Yearbook 2009)<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Agricultural production and incomes contributes to the GDP; the major sub-group within<br />

agriculture is the livestock production with about 55 % of the total production of the sector,<br />

followed by field crops with 30 % and fruit production with 15 %.<br />

Over the last years the overall output of crops increased whereas the output of livestock<br />

(animal products) decreased.<br />

Table 2: Output of animal products<br />

Output in % 2007 2008<br />

Cattle 26 21<br />

Pigs 5 5<br />

Sheep and goats 15 13<br />

Poultry 4 5<br />

Milk 38 42<br />

Eggs 10 11<br />

Other animal products 2 3<br />

Total 100 100<br />

(Source: INSTAT)<br />

In the above table it can be seen that milk became more important but in total the meat<br />

sector is slightly ahead; within the different products cattle decreased the most, followed by<br />

sheep and goats whereas poultry increased and pigs remained stable.<br />

Since 1990 the total numbers for cattle, goats and chicken decreased whereas the<br />

population of sheep and pigs grew slightly. In the period 2000 – 2009 cattle, sheep and goats<br />

have been declining whereas pigs and chicken have been growing.<br />

Table 3: Animals in Albania (heads in 000)<br />

Livestock 2000 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009<br />

Cattle 728 655 634 577 541 494<br />

Cows 448 430 420 396 360 353<br />

Sheep & goats 3045 2701 2770 2729 2620 2540<br />

Sheep 1939 1760 1830 1853 1800 1768<br />

Milked sheep 1448 1312 1426 1378 1321 1309<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 12


Goats 1104 941 940 876 820 772<br />

Milked goats 800 701 700 620 610 574<br />

Pigs 103 147 152 147 161 160<br />

Sow 10 13 13 16 14 13<br />

Poultry 5291 6432 6200 7135 8100 8313<br />

Chicken 4087 4671 4572 4712 5000 5138<br />

(Source: MAFCP; Statistical Yearbook 2009)<br />

Table 4: Meat production 2000 – 2009<br />

000/Ton<br />

90<br />

80<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

0<br />

Prodhimi i mishit<br />

Meat production<br />

2000 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009<br />

Gjedhi Cattle Te imtash Sheep$goat Derri Pig Shpendi Poutry<br />

(Source: MAFCP; Statistical Yearbook 2009)<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

The meat consumption in Albania is already at 40 kg per capita but still far away from EU<br />

levels which are more than twice as high.<br />

Beside the farms there are in the value chain also the slaughtering and processing<br />

companies. With the exception of a few modern chicken slaughtering facilities there are<br />

almost no operating slaughterhouses in the country. The consequence or the reason for this<br />

fact is that animals are slaughtered generally on the farm or in some cases in primitive<br />

slaughter rooms on farms or in butcher shops.<br />

A different picture can be seen in the meat processing sector; there are several companies<br />

active and the bigger companies are very close to EU standards.<br />

As the local meat is limited and expensive, processing companies are importing 95 % of their<br />

needed raw meat mainly from Brazil and Canada, usually as deep frozen meat.<br />

In other words there is no link between Albanian livestock farmers and Albanian meat<br />

processing industry. More details in the next chapters.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 13


II. Producers/Farmers<br />

Cattle<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

According to MAFCP there are 297,418 farms keeping animals and out of them 226,442<br />

farms keep cattle. The total number of cattle is decreasing over the last years; from 634,000<br />

in 2006, to 577,000 in 2007 and finally to 494,000 in 2009; number of cows is 353,000.<br />

Major regions with cattle farms are Fier, Elbasan, Tirana and Shkoder.<br />

On Albanian farms the following – mainly milk oriented - breeds can be encountered; Jersey<br />

(35 %), Laramane e zeze (Black & White) (29 %), domestic breeds like (15 %), Holstein (13<br />

%) and Simmental (3 %) and others like Taranteze. (Source: MAFCP, 2008, Technical<br />

Report)<br />

The way the cattle are kept on the farms is quite different; on one side there are many small<br />

subsistence farms with 1 – 2 cows, mainly for milking. Albanian average herd size is 2.4<br />

cattle. Animals are staying in primitive tied stall barns, often without any windows. All the<br />

work is done by hand; feeding, removing the manure and also milking.<br />

On the other side there are specialised farms, many more on milk than on meat, with better<br />

premises, even of the majority uses old existing buildings which are slightly adapted.<br />

Nevertheless electricity is often missing, windows very limited so that it is quite dark in the<br />

stables and just a handful of farms has a dung removal installation – partly because labour is<br />

so cheap. Again with very few exceptions there are no manure handling, storage and<br />

treatment facilities.<br />

The number of farms having more than 5 heads is 2,904 and equivalents to around 1 % of all<br />

cattle farms. 20 farms in Albania have more than 50 heads; Lushnja is one farm with 200<br />

calves for fattening.<br />

Slaughtering of cattle is done partly on the farm by the farmer or the butcher who then takes<br />

the meat to his shop. Or the butcher does the slaughtering behind his shop as clients want to<br />

see live animals and are sceptical about readymade de-boned. The correct way foresees<br />

that cattle are slaughtered in approved slaughterhouses; but given the small number of<br />

slaughterhouses – around 20 – in operation and the fact that many of them process just 2<br />

cows a day, one may conclude that slaughtering is not properly done according to the law.<br />

The liquid and solid waste from slaughtering on the farm or in small slaughter points is<br />

bought into illegal landfills and taken away by nearby rivers.<br />

As most farmers are not specialised in meat production they slaughter their animals, calves,<br />

too young and before gaining sufficient weight. The average live weight of slaughtered calves<br />

is about 180 – 200 kg (150 - 170 kg), which is economically much too low; sometimes male<br />

veal is slaughtered with 3 - 4 months and a live weight of 100 kg! Reasons for to early<br />

slaughtering are the demand for very young animals (of all kinds) and the unavailability of<br />

cheap fodder.<br />

Interesting to note that the demand is not expressed in higher prices for younger animals;<br />

experts from the Agriculture Know-How Transfer Centre in Fushe Kruje mentioned that the<br />

sales price for 1 kg live weight is around Lek 300 regardless if the animals has 200 or 400 kg.<br />

To stop the trend slaughtering young animals the MAAR started recently an awareness<br />

campaign promoting 12 months old calves with 400 kg live weight as the ideal weight for<br />

slaughtering.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 14


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Actually the corresponding law is prepared but the draft version does not show any<br />

requirement regarding minimum live weight at time of slaughtering.<br />

The fattening is also correlated to the milk price as when the milk price is low in May and<br />

June, farmers tend to fatten calves longer and not to sell cheap milk.<br />

Table 5: Average live weight of calves when slaughtered<br />

Regions Calf (kg)<br />

Berat 160<br />

Dibër 160<br />

Durrës 240<br />

Elbasan 182<br />

Fier 200<br />

Gjirokastër 130<br />

Korçë 180<br />

Kukës 160<br />

Lezhë 83<br />

Shkodër 140<br />

Tiranë 180<br />

Vlorë 180<br />

ALBANIA 166<br />

(Source: MAFCP, , Technical Report)<br />

The Focus Group meetings showed a different picture as average live weight of bulls when<br />

slaughtered was between 200 and 400 kg, with a majority at 300 kg upwards; calves are<br />

between 6 and 15 months old.<br />

Price per kg live weight of calves, regardless if male or female is between 300 and 450 Lek;<br />

around Euro 2 – 3 per kg. Price for bulls and oxen is Lek 280 – 350, around Euro 2 – 2.50<br />

per kg. Farmers interested in fattening calves buy them often just a few days old for a price<br />

of Euro 120 – 150.<br />

Corresponding prices in Austria (March 2010) at farm gate are for bulls (live weight 680 kg!)<br />

and oxen Euro 1.64- 1.79, female calves Euro 1.21 – 1.37, cows Euro 0.80 – 1.06 and calves<br />

for slaughtering Euro 2.59 – 2.97; all prices without VAT, which is usually kept by the farmer.<br />

(Source: Kaerntner Bauer, Markt & Preis, No 9, 2010)<br />

The Focus Group meetings found out that farmers are selling their animals on specific animal<br />

markets, in a limited amount to traders, to a big deal to the local butcher shops and none of<br />

them to slaughterhouses, except one farmer.<br />

A meat classification system of carcasses of slaughter animals for cattle and veal (SEUROP)<br />

and related quality payment scheme is not in place and therefore farm output differs<br />

extremely in weight, colour, fat content and age.<br />

4 % of the farmers have no education at all, 16 % visited the primary school and 48 % also<br />

the secondary school. The educational background is limited as there are almost no<br />

vocational schools which would be needed to train small holders.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 15


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Financing for agricultural investment projects almost cannot be obtained from commercial<br />

banks, as land ownership and title are not always secure and banks are generally not much<br />

interested in agricultural land as collateral. Furthermore interest rates are high so that<br />

financing is brought up within the family, in case that there are investment projects at all.<br />

The cooperation between farmers, which is starting slowly in advanced countries like Austria,<br />

hardly exists in Albania. In the previous system farmers have been forced to cooperate and<br />

now farmers are staunchly independent, even though they could farm more profitably if they<br />

work together. Suggestions for cooperation could start in division of labour or specialising the<br />

cattle farms; one produces calves and the other one specialises in fattening them.<br />

Cattle, especially from subsistence farms, have usually no open yard and graze in the<br />

neighbourhood of the farm (and along the streets), regardless of the ownership of the land:<br />

Albania has around 423,000 ha of pastures and around 38 % are still owned by the state.<br />

The possibilities for expansion of natural pasture are limited due to the geographical situation<br />

in Albania with substantial mountainous area. Therefore increased feed must come from<br />

improved production of fodder such as lucernes, maize and other grasses, and improved<br />

utilization of industrial by-products such as olive cake, bran and soybean meal. Maize silage<br />

is almost unknown. Forage crops are now grown on 200,000 hectares (Source: MAFCP;<br />

Statistical Yearbook 2009), or 40 % of the cropped arable land, with lucernes comprising<br />

about two-thirds of this area. Most is harvested by hand – as agricultural equipment is too<br />

expensive - and there are problems with weeds and poor storage of hay.<br />

Generally there is room for improvements – especially on the small farms - concerning<br />

forage quality, management and feeding practices and also availability of clean seed.<br />

Grazing resources including pasture, forest, and some agricultural land are fundamental for<br />

livestock raising, but have degraded significantly over the last 20 years, particularly in land<br />

close to communities where over-grazing and over-cutting of wood have resulted in reduced<br />

productivity and soil erosion. (Source: SHUNDI, Andrea Prof.: Country Pasture/Forage<br />

Resource Profiles Albania; 2006)<br />

Bigger farms are managed better but have to purchase partly fodder from the market as<br />

farms are often too small to produce enough forage; that might start even with hay.<br />

Due to the small size of the herds biogas facilities are not in place.<br />

Governmental policy aims to stimulate just milk cow farmers. There is no support for meat<br />

production. Veterinary services are available to limited amount; actually only 61 % of the<br />

cows are artificially inseminated; one third of the Holstein and Jersey cows is inseminated<br />

with meat breeds such as Limousin and Charolais exclusively for meat production.<br />

Summarizing one might say that cattle farmers producing meat are oriented towards the<br />

fresh market, as imported deep frozen beef is much cheaper and therefore the meat<br />

processing industry is not interested in local beef.<br />

Cattle usually do not reach more than 420 – 460 kg live weight and average price therefore is<br />

Lek 320 -330 / kg.<br />

Sheep and goats<br />

55.942 of all farms in Albania keep sheep and 26.175 keep goat; the majority of sheep farm<br />

also keeps goats. The total number of sheep is almost constant; 1.830.000 in 2006,<br />

1.853.000 in 2007 and 1.768.000 in 2009; the number of milked sheep is always around<br />

400,000 lower. Figures for goats look as follows: 940.000 in 2006, 876.000 in 2007 and<br />

772,000 in 2009; the number of milked goats is always around 200,000 lower.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 16


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Sheep and goat farming plays a key environmental role that includes the natural upkeep of<br />

less fertile areas, the maintenance of biodiversity, sensitive ecosystems and water quality,<br />

the fight against erosion, floods, avalanches and fires. In Albania sheep and goat farming<br />

takes place in less favoured areas, where such farming is very often the only agricultural<br />

option and which therefore makes a crucial contribution to the economy in rural areas.<br />

Major regions with sheep and goat farms are Vlore, Gjirokaster, Fier and Elbasan. Goats<br />

prefer even more mountainous regions and better goat husbandry conditions are therefore in<br />

Kukes, Diber and Shkoder.<br />

Albanian farmers keep the following sheep breeds: Tsigaja (45 %), Komune (22 %), Merinos<br />

(12 %), Ruda (8 %), Mati (5 %), Bardhoka (5 %), Ile de France (1 %) and Awassi (1 %).<br />

Albanian farmers keep the following goat breeds: Muzhak (70 %), Mat (9 %), Has (6 %),<br />

Capore (5 %), Dukati (3 %), Velipoja (1 %), Dragobia (1%), Liqenasi (1 %) and Alpine (1 %).<br />

(Source: MAFCP, 2008, Technical Report)<br />

The average sheep flock size in the country counts 44 heads, the figure for goats is 45<br />

animals. Countrywide small flock sizes between 5 and 50 heads are still very numerous as<br />

many sheep are raised for self-consumption and just 3,177 farmers have between 100 and<br />

200 heads; only 797 have more than 200 heads. Corresponding goat figures are 914 and<br />

293. This is less than 10 % of all the farms with small ruminants and these 5,000 farms can<br />

be considered commercial small ruminant farms.<br />

Sheep and goats – when produced commercially - are kept in transhumance as long as there<br />

are enough opportunities for grazing; on some summer pastures farmers built very simple<br />

barns to shelter animals; in winter times the small ruminants are in better, but simple barns<br />

on the farm. Small ruminants of subsistence farmers are often kept on the farm.<br />

Husbandry of small ruminants can be done in several ways:<br />

1) Extensive system with transhumance from 6 to 8 months (all regions)<br />

2) Semi-intensive system with transhumance from 5 to 6 months (Gjirokastra)<br />

3) Grazing system on permanent pastures close to the holding<br />

4) Grazing on natural pasture in walking distance, with return of sheep or goats in the<br />

evening to the holding<br />

The feeding system in Albania is mostly based on grazing, at least for 5 months per year.<br />

Transhumance requires often daily distances of 30 km; this is very difficult for the animals<br />

especially if they cannot find water; cases are reported where animals have access to water<br />

holes every other day.<br />

In the winter period the “intensive” holdings feed animals with preserved forage (hay, alfalfa)<br />

and cereals, either produced on the farm or purchased; the harder the winter the more<br />

concentrates will be used. The feeding costs get also higher when animals must be kept<br />

longer in stables due to climatic conditions; animals must be fed in stables for a period of<br />

three to six months.<br />

In the current production system, the milk constitutes an important part of the breeders'<br />

income. The milk is either processed directly by the shepherd, or sold to small dairies for<br />

production of Kaskavall or Feta cheese. The milk makes up to 46 % of the total income from<br />

sheep. The income from meat is obtained through the sale of lambs and of cull-animals. The<br />

lambs are always sold by kilogram and best price can be achieved in December and the<br />

lowest price in August. (Source: UNDP Albania; “Strengthening the Marketing of Small<br />

Ruminants” Project, 2005)<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 17


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

A milk sheep could deliver 70 litres of milk annually which equivalents to LEK 7,000. The<br />

alternative would be to feed a lamb which could be sold with 20 kg live weight for LEK 7,000<br />

or eventually with 30 kg live weight for LEK 9,000.<br />

Table 6: Revenues per sheep and year; meat vs. milk<br />

Lamb (meat) 20 kg 350 Lek/kg 7000<br />

or 30 kg 300 Lek/kg 9000<br />

Sheep (milk) 70 l 100 Lek/l 7000<br />

(Source: Expert’s calculation, 2010)<br />

Milk versus meat, the utilization of milk<br />

The decision of using milk either for selling it to dairies or for fattening of the lambs should be<br />

based on the conversion rate milk to meat and the prices for the different products. The<br />

current conditions (2010) are summarized in the following table.<br />

Table 7: Break - even points for milk and meat<br />

Assuming 6 kg of milk, necessary to grow 1 kg of live weight in lambs, only a meat price of<br />

600 ALL/kg LW would valorise the milk with 100 ALL / kg of milk, currently paid by the dairy<br />

processors in Saranda. (right arrow).<br />

During the top season, at live weight prices of 450 ALL (Saranda, December 2009), the litre<br />

of milk would be valorised with 75 ALL through feeding, against the 100 ALL which are paid<br />

by the dairy, hence clearly in favour of selling the milk (central arrow).<br />

When meat prices fall to the level of 300 ALL / kg LW , the litre of milk is valorised equally<br />

(break - even) through feeding to the lamb and to selling of milk, at a milk price of 60 ALL /<br />

litre, which is close to the conditions reported in Korca in the southern part of the country (left<br />

arrow).<br />

Although – as shown above - the price relations are clearly in favour of milk production, the<br />

farmers however underlined that they intend to produce both: milk and meat, probably to<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 18


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

reduce risks and due to the need and the distribution of cash income (lamb before Christmas,<br />

monthly milk cash income during January and February). (Source: UNDP Albania / MOLLA A;<br />

Base Line Study on Production Systems and Economics of Sheep Husbandry in Southern<br />

Albania, 2010)<br />

The Focus Group meetings mentioned that lambs when slaughtered are between 3 and 6<br />

months old and have a live weight between 20 and 40 kg, but mainly between 20 and 30 kg;<br />

in case that lambs are slaughtered for religious holidays they are usually younger and not<br />

that heavy. Regular prices are Lek 300 – 350 per kg live weight, in Euro 2.20 – 2.50.<br />

Corresponding prices in Austria (March 2010) at farm gate are for lambs alive with 40 – 45<br />

kg are Euro 2.05 (very good quality) and the others for Euro 1.65 per kg. Cull ewe have a<br />

price of Euro 0.50 per kg alive. All prices are without VAT, which is usually kept by the farmer.<br />

(Source: Kaerntner Bauer, Markt & Preis, No 9, 2010)<br />

Average live weight of lambs when slaughtered is in many cases too low but often farmers<br />

sell lambs early as prices are good before religious holidays and others want to focus more<br />

on milk and try to sell lamb as early as possible – neglecting the opportunity to feed it with<br />

something else instead of mother milk.<br />

Slaughtering of small ruminants is done on the farms, by the butchers in the slaughter points<br />

and a few in slaughterhouses. Situation is worse than with cattle as animals are smaller and<br />

easier to slaughter.<br />

Pigs<br />

According to MAFCP there are 297,418 farms keeping animals and out of them 42,036 farms<br />

keep pigs. The total number of pigs is steadely growing and reached 160,000 in 2009 and<br />

out of them 13,000 mother sows. Most pigs are raised in these small farms and bigger units<br />

are rare; in 2008, there were about 330 farms with 6 - 10 pigs, 181 farms with 11- 50 heads<br />

and 17 farms with more than 50 heads. For example DRIZA, a mixed operation and an<br />

agribusiness key player, keeps 30 sows and thus fattens 600 – 800 pigs per year.<br />

Around 70 % of the piglets are produced in an extensive production system but 90 % of the<br />

pigs are grown in an intensive system.<br />

Some pig fattening farms imported in the past piglets with around 25 kg live weight; as<br />

animal feed is expensive and therefore the production costs high, they shifted the weight of<br />

imported animals from 25 kg to 80 kg! Almost finished pigs - 56,000 heads according to<br />

official statistics - are getting fattened until they are sold, generally within two weeks.<br />

In Albania the breeds large white and landrace and all cross-breeds can be found. Premises<br />

reflect the farmer’s attitude if the fattening is just for auto-consumption or a commercial<br />

business; from big brand new stables with automatic feeding technique to simple barns<br />

where beside the 2 cows and 5 sheep also 2 pig are fattened.<br />

Corresponding is also the slaughtering, which might take place in basic slaughter rooms next<br />

to the fattening stables or in so called slaughtering points close to high frequented roads or<br />

simply in the backyard of a farm. The slaughter-weights vary between 70 and 120 kg alive.<br />

Pig husbandry is both a profitable and fragile undertaking; prices are changing rapidly, also<br />

of imported animals and therefore the business is not predictable. As animal feed is<br />

expensive and farmers lack of financial resources, early slaughtering of underweight pigs is<br />

widespread and reduces the profitability. Other obstacle is that livestock farmers have just<br />

limited knowledge about low-fat meat production which is best preferred. Hence, 20-30 % of<br />

carcass weight loss because of fat, affects heavily profit reduction.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 19


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

A family can make a living off 5 sows but pig production costs are high – this is because the<br />

majority of feed grains and all soya have to be imported plus these imported feedstuffs then<br />

attract a tax of 20 %.<br />

Farmers with 1 or 2 sows feed them on home grown feeds. Maize is commonly grown and<br />

dried in open racks. Most small farmers have a couple of cows with the milk being used for<br />

cheese production. The whey is then used as pig feed. Farmers who have 5 sows or more<br />

buy in pig feed. Buying and selling of pigs is done through numerous local markets.<br />

Feed is bagged in meal or pellets form and all feeding is done by hand. Most farmers dump<br />

all the slaughtering by-products and the liquid waste usually runs into the nearby river.<br />

(Source: LUMB, Stuart; Albanian Pig Production; 2004)<br />

Poultry<br />

The total number of poultry is steadely growing and reached 8,313,000 in 2009; out of them<br />

5,138,000 chickens – after 4,087,000 in 2000. The chicken (broiler) sector, even affected by<br />

the avian influenza in 2006, is growing fast. According to MAFCP there are 297,418 farms<br />

keeping animals and out of them 279,522 farms raise chicken.<br />

As the total number of chickens is around five million, in average there are 18 chickens on a<br />

farm (Source: MAFCP; Statistical Yearbook 2009).<br />

The small farmers have just 5 – 10 chicken and grow their own feed such as maize. Chicken<br />

are usually kept in small premises or together with the other farm animals. Manure storage is<br />

not known and slaughtering takes place on the farm. Consequently the productivity is low<br />

and just the surplus is sold in the neighbourhood.<br />

As it is seen from the data of the following table shows that there are 38 meat oriented<br />

poultry farms, 17 out of them keep more than 10,000 heads like “Driza Ltd”, Fier with an<br />

annual capacity of more than 1 million heads, “Uina Ltd”, Librazhd with an annual capacity of<br />

600 thousand heads, “Agrozo Ltd”, Lushnje, with an annual capacity of about 800 thousand<br />

heads, “Chicken Farm” Kavaje, with an annual capacity of about 1.5 million heads and<br />

“Shehu” Korce, with an annual capacity of about 600 thousand heads.<br />

Table 8: Poultry meat farm<br />

Poultry meat farm 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009<br />

Total numbers 23 20 29 36 38<br />

1000 - 5000 Head 11 8 7 17 16<br />

5000 -10000 Head 3 3 6 5 5<br />

over 10000 Head 9 9 16 14 17<br />

(Source: MAFCP; Statistical Yearbook 2009)<br />

Due to the expansion of these centres, broiler production increased from 4,000 tons in 2000<br />

to 16,000 tons in 2008 and 17,000 tons in 2009 (Source: MAFCP; Statistical Yearbook 2009).<br />

In 2009 total live weight production in Albania reached 143,000 tons; cattle 66,000 tons,<br />

sheep and goat 44,000 tons, pigs 16,000 tons and poultry 17,000 tons or 11,88 % of the total<br />

production.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 20


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

This is substantially more than y few years ago but compared to the EU 27 with 23.1 kg /<br />

capita still low.<br />

There is no other sector in Albania where the difference between subsistence farmers and<br />

professional, commercial farmers is that vast like in broiler production. As this is a very<br />

capital intensive business, big players invest substantial amounts of money and can expect a<br />

high and especially fast return.<br />

The production is growing faster than the consumption and self-sufficiency is now at around<br />

50 %.<br />

During the focus group meetings 10 very different representatives of chicken farmers have<br />

been interviewed. There have been farmers producing up to 150 chickens a year and they<br />

can be considered as self-suppliers. On the other side there have been two farmers selling<br />

30,000 and 450,000 chicken a year.<br />

The breeds encountered are called “shot” and “red broiler”.<br />

The finished chicken had a live weight between 1 and 2 kg, in some cases up to 3 and 4 kg.<br />

According to the interviewees the chicken sales price per kg live weight varied between Lek<br />

170 and 700! The average poultry meat price per kg is between Lek 300 and 1,000!<br />

While small holders consume everything within their family and sell nothing at all, the biggest<br />

chicken farmer mentioned that he makes Lek 243 million per year; i.e. Euro 1.7 million!<br />

As mentioned above the small producers with around 100 chickens consumed all of them<br />

within their families; most of the chickens have been marketed in the village directly to<br />

consumers or in the next town to consumers – that includes also the farmer producing<br />

450,000 chickens a year. Rather small quantities have been sold to traders and<br />

slaughterhouses.<br />

The commercial poultry farms (layers, broilers, turkeys) use more than 80 % of the total<br />

150,000 t of finished feed sold in Albania. In an agribusiness sense poultry is the most<br />

developed, organised and updated sector.<br />

Through partnership between ENZY food processing company and ABDUA company a<br />

hatchery poultry farm has been established near Kavaja. The joint operation is producing<br />

one-day old broiler chicks and has started to supply several Albanian chicken producers.<br />

Other one-day old broilers are imported from Greece.<br />

Animal feeding<br />

The meat production is still done with a low level of inputs; the extensive system of<br />

production is dominant. Statistics show that about 85 % of cattle, 97 % of small ruminants, 70<br />

% of piglets and 50 % of poultry, are being bred extensively. This is the situation as the farms<br />

are very small and financing for improvements usually not available. Even inefficient, the<br />

husbandry systems, especially of small ruminants and cattle, are generating income.<br />

More advanced production systems using higher inputs can be found in pork production, 80<br />

% of the sows, 85 % of poultry, and 20% of cows. Almost 100 % of the poultry farms, 15 % of<br />

cattle farms and 90 % of pig farms are using high inputs. Cattle ranchers are sometimes<br />

feeding the animals intensively if they are focused on milk production.<br />

Animal feed producers<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 21


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

The three big fodder producers AGROTEK ALB shpk, Aiba Company shpk and Floryhen<br />

shpk control 70 – 80 % of the market in Albania. They offer different forms of concentrates,<br />

premixes, microelements, raw materials such as soya bean, fish meal, maize, wheat etc.<br />

Usually feed products are pressed into pellet forms. Wheat and barley is purchased mainly<br />

locally, but other inputs such as soya are imported from Greece, Italy and Serbia. Feed is<br />

produced for cattle, sheep, goat, pigs and poultry; main customers are chicken and pig farms<br />

with 40 % each; the rest of the products is for cattle, sheep and goat farms. Distribution takes<br />

place trough partly exclusive distributors and just big farms are served directly.<br />

Product prices vary between Lek 35 – 100 plus 20 % VAT per kg; estimated market volume<br />

is 50 – 60,000 tons annually. The feed producers are often certified in ISO 9001:2000,<br />

Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Point (HACCP) and other quality management<br />

programmes.<br />

As farmers have often limited access to extension services the feed producers provide also<br />

services in veterinary and zoo technical consulting or assist farmers in getting in touch with<br />

experts.<br />

The companies are also involved in “neighbouring businesses” such as egg production or<br />

slaughterhouses.<br />

Producers see a major threat for their sector in the limited availability of raw materials; as a<br />

consequence many products like soya have to be imported and transport costs are high.<br />

Fodder is cheaper for example in Serbia and as it is cheaper to transport 1 kg of pork meat<br />

(produced in Serbia) instead of 4 kg of cereals (for the production of 1 kg of pork meat in<br />

Albania), feed producers are afraid of the increasing competition in this sector; competition<br />

became stronger with the Central European Free Trade Agreement (CEFTA) and will get<br />

more intensive when approaching the European Union.<br />

The Albanian feed industry offers all kinds of feeds for the local livestock producers, except<br />

fish and pet food. A few feed mills offer the feed in both mash and pelleted form. Almost all<br />

raw ingredients are imported like soya (up to 24,000 to / year) and grains, except for<br />

limestone. The main sources for raw materials are neighbouring countries, mainly Italy and<br />

Greece but other countries, like France, Romania, Bulgaria, are also used. The biggest<br />

constraint for direct imports from big producers such as the USA, Brazil and Argentina is the<br />

fact that Albania’s main harbour, Durres on the Mediterranean Sea, can receive shiploads to<br />

a maximum of 12,000 metric tonnes. Therefore all ships have to be reloaded in Greece and<br />

that increases the costs.<br />

Albanian feed mills are quite familiar with the well-known companies such as: Bühler, Brock,<br />

Van Aarsen, Big Dutchman, Facco, Chore Times, Pas Reform, Farmer, Chemifarma,<br />

Lohman, Schauman, etc.<br />

III. PROCESSING INDUSTRY<br />

Slaughterhouses<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 22


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

During the communist regime, meat was a rare and rationed product. It was not even allowed<br />

to keep animals in private gardens and consequently the meat consumption was very low.<br />

Therefore also the need for slaughterhouses was limited.<br />

Today the meat consumption is already at 40 kg per capita but still far away from EU levels<br />

which are twice as high. With the increasing meat consumption the slaughterhouses became<br />

more important.<br />

According to MAFCP only few slaughterhouses in Albania are operating according to<br />

national legislation. In the 12 administrative regions the situation looks as follows:<br />

1. Berat<br />

Kucova: There is a slaughterhouse managed by the municipality which meets somehow the<br />

requirements.<br />

Çorovoda: The old slaughterhouse is out of function. A new slaughterhouse is under<br />

discussion and eventually financed by MAFCP and FAO.<br />

Poliçan: A new slaughterhouse will is under consideration, financed by MAFCP.<br />

2. Diber<br />

With the exception of KEPUTA shpk in Burrel no other slaughterhouse in this district fulfils<br />

sanitary-veterinary requirements.<br />

3. Durres<br />

Durres: There is a private slaughterhouse which somehow meets the requirements, but is<br />

still missing some equipment.<br />

4. Elbasan<br />

Elbasan: The municipality slaughterhouse does not correspond to the national requirements.<br />

A new slaughterhouse will is under consideration, financed by MAFCP.<br />

Gramsh: Municipality has a slaughterhouse which meets somehow sanitary-veterinary<br />

conditions.<br />

5. Fier<br />

This district shows 10 operating slaughterhouses, 3 in Fier, 2 in Patos (one for poultry), 2 in<br />

Ballsh, and three in Lushnja (one of them for poultry); except the one in Divjaka they are<br />

operating satisfactory according to national standards..<br />

6. Gjirokaster<br />

Gjirokaster: On district level, there is one slaughterhouse under reconstruction.<br />

Tepelena has one slaughterhouse which is approved by the veterinary service.<br />

In Permet an Italian NGO - Cooperazione e Sviluppo (CESVI) - established a<br />

slaughterhouse.<br />

7. Korce<br />

Novosella has one slaughterhouse provided with all the facilities in conformity with EU<br />

legislation (15 heads / hour); it is regularly inspected by the veterinary inspectorate.<br />

8. Kukes<br />

Kukes has one public slaughterhouse which is under the privatization process; it has been<br />

built by a project and meets the sanitary-veterinary requirements for such an activity.<br />

9. Lezhe<br />

Lezha has one acceptable private slaughterhouse for cattle and pigs.<br />

10. Shkoder<br />

No operating slaughterhouses in this district that fulfils sanitary-veterinary requirements.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 23


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

11. Tirana<br />

Tirana has one private slaughterhouse (KMY/Yzberish), which meets all the requirements but<br />

is used only for the company’s needs.<br />

12. Vlora<br />

No operating slaughterhouses in this district that fulfils sanitary-veterinary requirements.<br />

UNDP is working on an MAFCP financed slaughterhouse with high standards, but it was not<br />

in operation by summer 2010.<br />

(Source: MAFCP; Slaughterhouses in Albania, present situation and prospect; 2006)<br />

In Albania there are many slaughterhouses not in operation and the remaining less than 20<br />

slaughterhouses – that correspond more or less to national standards - do often daily<br />

slaughtering of 1 – 2 cattle and / or few pigs or small ruminants. All slaughterhouses are<br />

working far below their capacities which often vary from 10 - 40 cattle and 20 - 100 small<br />

ruminants per day. One of the reasons therefore is that authorities do not force the traders<br />

and butchers to slaughter there. Therefore slaughterhouses face no or limited raw material<br />

supply. Usually the facilities are outdated and in most cases they do not even comply with<br />

the Albanian law. EU standards on hygiene, public authority, traceability and HACCP are not<br />

fulfilled.<br />

For example many slaughterhouses only separate the carcass from the entrails, leaving<br />

other operations to butchers, such as separation of internal organs from the carcass and<br />

breaking of the bulk and anatomical cuts, that are even harder for authorities to check and<br />

monitor. (Source: FAO / VERCUNI, A. et ZHLLIMA, E.: The food supply and distribution<br />

system of Tirana, Albania; 2008)<br />

As the costs of setting up slaughterhouses depend less on the walls and more on electricity<br />

and water supply, stainless steel equipment, modern machinery, sufficient space (away from<br />

housing areas), cooling rooms and more, it is not economically justified to refurbish (very<br />

poor) existing slaughterhouses.<br />

All the slaughterhouses in the country are considered Small and Medium Enterprises as they<br />

have less than 250 employees and a turnover not reaching Euro 50 million annually.<br />

Regarding the poultry sector there are three major slaughterhouses for poultry in rather good<br />

condition:<br />

• Chicken Farm in Kavaja (fully automatic slaughterhouse belonging to Frigofood<br />

company)<br />

• AGRIZOO in Lushnja region (half automatic)<br />

• DRIZA in Fier region (half automatic)<br />

Smaller ones are located in Korca, Fier, Lushnja etc.<br />

Slaughtering points<br />

In Albania there are more than 200 slaughtering points with primitive equipment and without<br />

control of local authorities. Very often these slaughtering points are located on the roadside<br />

of major roads like Tirana - Shkoder; usually the facility includes just one room with a<br />

refrigerator and the meat for sale is hanging outside so that it is good visible to all drivers<br />

coming along the road. This type of “slaughterhouses” does not correspond to Albanian law<br />

and several times such slaughtering points or butcher shops have been closed by the police;<br />

as these facilities are not registered the veterinary inspectors are not entitled to control them<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 24


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

and therefore the police has to intervene. On the other side it has to be mentioned that some<br />

of these practices look more hygienic than official slaughterhouses which are usually in a<br />

rather poor condition.<br />

Fees for slaughtering<br />

The fees for slaughtering in registered slaughterhouses have not been much increased since<br />

2004 and are now according to expert’s opinions as follows:<br />

• 600 Lek for grown up cattle<br />

• 500 Lek for calves<br />

• 400 Lek for sheep and goat<br />

• 500 Lek for pigs<br />

The corresponding meat inspection fees are as follows:<br />

• 400 Lek for cattle<br />

• 200 Lek for calves<br />

• 200 Lek for small stock<br />

• 100-200 Lek for pigs<br />

Municipalities are in most cases the owner of the existing slaughterhouses and therefore<br />

they are often poorly managed. In some cases the municipalities rent the facility out to the<br />

private sector. In both cases the low number of slaughters does not cover the investment<br />

cost, in many cases not even the running costs. For example there are slaughterhouses with<br />

adequate equipment to hang up the slaughtered animals but the equipment is not used as it<br />

does not pay off for a few animals per day.<br />

Veterinary inspections do not always take place according to the law and make thus doubtful<br />

slaughters statistics and control of epizootic situation. One reason therefore might be also<br />

the double authority in the veterinary inspection that source from the Law No.8652 dated 31 st<br />

July 2000 “On the organization and functionality of local government”. Because of that<br />

sometimes nobody takes the responsibility to enforce the proper inspections.<br />

In general, liquid and solid slaughter residues (waste) are not treated according to hygiene<br />

and environment requirements, but are directly disposed into sewer channels and dumped<br />

into landfills.<br />

Keputa<br />

The company KEPUTA shpk was established in 2003 in the city of Burrel, Diber county. Also<br />

the slaughterhouse is located there.<br />

Main activities include buying of live animals in the region and slaughtering; further activities<br />

are meat processing and trade of fresh meat. The number of employees is 4 and the annual<br />

turnover roughly Euro 65,000. All the required raw meat for processing is from the internal<br />

market.<br />

KEPUTA is the first and the only slaughterhouse in Albania that applied for an EU Number to<br />

export fresh meat; process still pending.<br />

Investment plan focuses on new equipment for processing.<br />

Meat processing companies<br />

In contrast to the slaughterhouse sector the Albanian top meat processing companies like<br />

EHW, KMY, TONA and others are doing fine. The 10 biggest processing companies cover<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 25


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

around 80 % of the market share; they are financially strong and consider further<br />

investments with and without upcoming IPARD-support.<br />

Table 9: Investment of the agro-industry in Lek million<br />

Year 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009<br />

Investments 121 105 100 67 92 426 170 119 174 35<br />

(Source: MAFCP; Statistical Yearbook 2009)<br />

Nevertheless the official investments of the agro-industry made just Euro 250,000 in 2009<br />

(equivalent to 35 million Lek).<br />

Assuming that the imported beef and pork meat is used by the meat processing industry<br />

(2007: 6.705 tons beef and 15.139 tons pork meat; 2008: 5.377 tons beef and 11.529 tons<br />

pork meat), the total raw material input into the meat industry makes 16,906 tons (2008);<br />

some very little volume of fresh meat could be added, for example for prosciutto.<br />

Table 10: Sausage and ham production of the agro-industry<br />

Year 2000 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009<br />

Sausage and<br />

ham production<br />

in tons<br />

4055 9485 9824 9145 10341 8878<br />

(Source: MAFCP; Statistical Yearbook 2009)<br />

All the 65 meat processing companies (Source: MAFCP; Statistical Yearbook 2009) in the<br />

country are considered Small and Medium Enterprises as they have less than 250<br />

employees and a turnover not reaching Euro 50 million annually.<br />

The meat processed is mainly pork, but also poultry and beef and sausage-making products<br />

prevail in the production structure. Companies use sophisticated technology in processing<br />

frozen meat but face limited know how in processing fresh meat.<br />

The leading companies have a sound documentation of their production including traceability<br />

and applied HACCP. Albanian standards according to Food Law and orders of MAFCP are<br />

often applied; even EU standards on hygiene, public authority, traceability and HACCP are in<br />

place at big companies which are almost ready for EU export licences.<br />

The premises of the top meat processing companies like EHW, KMY, TONA and others are<br />

very modern and fulfil in many cases already EC standards.<br />

A specific weakness is the waste disposal as there are nowhere liquid or solid waste disposal<br />

systems in place; all the leftovers are bought into illegal landfills and are running into the<br />

nearby rivers. The companies are aware of this deficit but as veterinary inspection do not<br />

insist on better technical solutions the situation remains as it is now.<br />

In Albania there are several important and successful meat processing companies and the<br />

major companies are presented here in brief.<br />

EHW GmbH<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 26


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

The company was established in 1992 on the Motorway to Durres, 4 k west of Tirana, is<br />

owned by the family Leka and an Italian partner at equal shares and has its main activities in<br />

processing meat into 70 kinds of salami (würstel, parizier, llukanik, milan, naples, saxony,<br />

montana and suxhuk salami) ham, ham with chicken fillet, chicken würstel, grill meatballs<br />

and an Italian San Daniele style ham (prosciutto). The products are sold in 13 EHW butcher<br />

shops (10 in Tirana) and according to the management EHW has 60 % market share in<br />

Tirana and 40 % in Albania!<br />

Due to the high local prices for meat all the required raw meat for processing is imported<br />

from Brazil, USA and Canada. The imported volume is around 3,500 tons per year what<br />

results in a daily processed amount of 10 tons. The company employs 200 people and<br />

makes an annual turnover of roughly Euro 20 million.<br />

IQNET and other international recognised certification companies have certified the company<br />

regarding quality management ISO 9001:2000, HACCP, food safety and others. Like the<br />

other Albanian meat processors also EHW is not importing the meat directly from abroad but<br />

uses the services of an international trader who purchases the meat on its own behalf or on<br />

behalf of EHW.<br />

Next steps will be an enlargement of the product range by additional trading products,<br />

especially cheese. But also fresh meat is sold in EHW shops; it is delivered there directly<br />

from 2 - 3 good local slaughterhouses. Main problem is limited supply of local meat and<br />

especially the inability to export due to non-enforcement of the veterinary law.<br />

Further investments could cover sewage water plant, especially to get rid of the fat swimming<br />

on top of this sewage water.<br />

KMY/Yzberish<br />

KMY is one of the oldest food processing companies in Albania. It started its activity in 1993<br />

in the city of Tirana where is located its factory. The number of employees is 330. The range<br />

of products has been increased over the years.<br />

Currently the company produces more than 30 high quality products such as salami, ham,<br />

fresh and frozen meat because the company has a slaughterhouse on its own which is not<br />

open to the public.<br />

The required raw meat for processing is imported from:<br />

• Brazil, USA ,Canada, Uruguay 90 %<br />

• EU countries 7 %<br />

• Internal market 3 %<br />

KMY owns also a farm which is not in operation due to higher costs for raising pork, beef, etc.<br />

Actually the farm is used only as a collection point.<br />

KMY’s investments plans are:<br />

• Capacity expansion<br />

• Certification according to International Quality Standards to get in line with norms<br />

required by EU<br />

Meat Master<br />

The company was established a few years ago by Mr. Nrdek KIMCA, General Director and<br />

his two brothers in Shkoder. With one shift the company can process weekly 1,500 pigs and<br />

500 cattle. The Albanian agriculture does not supply enough animals. Constraints are that<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 27


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

cattle are getting slaughtered too early, in Shkoder with 200 kg live weight; he would prefer<br />

500 kg. He furthermore mentioned that small livestock keepers face problems when<br />

accessing the market. Regarding slaughterhouses there is none of acceptable quality, not<br />

even the FAO prototypes, and therefore he will invest into a new slaughterhouse outside<br />

town soon; he will relocate the whole company in a Greenfield investment.<br />

Darb Univers Frigo Darb<br />

The company was established as a wholesale trading company by Mr. Rifat KOPLIKU and<br />

Mr. Ajet XHAFERI 1997 in Shkoder; trade volume is 6 – 7 tons per day. In 2004 they started<br />

additionally meat processing and nowadays they have a daily output of 2.5 tons. Product<br />

range includes prosciutto, würstel (to be cooked) and salami. Pork is their main product and<br />

chicken is just very limited. DARB UNIVERS FRIGO DARB employs 85 people. 60 % of their<br />

processed products are sold in own shops. But the role of supermarkets is getting more<br />

important.<br />

TONA Co<br />

TONA CO is one of the oldest food processing companies in Albania. It started its activity in<br />

1992 in the city of Korca. The product range has been increased through the years. Starting<br />

with only three traditional salami products that were produced before 1998, nowadays the<br />

company produces more than 40 high quality products such as: sausages, salami, ham,<br />

fresh and frozen meat, and recently canned meat. The number of employees is 70 and the<br />

annual turnover roughly Euro 1 million. The company is certified regarding quality<br />

management ISO 9001:2000, HACCP, food safety and others.<br />

70 % of the raw meat for processing is imported from America (Brazil, USA, Canada,<br />

Uruguay) and from 30 % from Europe (Italy, Spain). TONA meat products are now offered<br />

through a large number of markets and supermarkets to over 70 % of the Albanian<br />

population. TONA CO LTD has a distributing network spread in all the main cities of Albania.<br />

TONA CO is an active member of ADAMA (Association of Dairy and Meat Processing<br />

Companies). The investment plan focuses on a new slaughterhouse.<br />

DEKON FRIGO<br />

DEKON FRIGO was established in 1992 in the city of Elbasan; the company employs 20<br />

persons and is certified regarding quality management ISO 9001:2000, HACCP, food safety<br />

and others. The raw meat is imported from:<br />

• Brazil, Canada, New Zealand 90 %<br />

• Italy, France 10 %<br />

The company processes chicken, pork and veal and just started an investment phase for<br />

setting up a refrigerating chamber; financing will be needed for the second phase which will<br />

cover the completion of refrigerating rooms.<br />

EL FRIGO 2<br />

The company started its activities in 1991 and employs 150 persons; the annual turnover is<br />

roughly Euro 12 million. EL FRIGO 2 is certified regarding quality management ISO<br />

9001:2000, HACCP, food safety and others. The raw meat is imported from:<br />

• Brazil, Canada 92-93 %<br />

• Italy, France 7-8 %<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 28


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

EL FRIGO 2 produces 45 % of their produce based on chicken, 35 % on pork and 20 % on<br />

veal. The management is afraid that the EU will not allow imports from Latin America and are<br />

wondering where they might get their raw meat from.<br />

Investment plans are discussed to set up an HACCP system.<br />

FRIGO ALBA<br />

The company started its activities in 2005. The number of employees is 17 and FRIGO ALBA<br />

makes an annual turnover of roughly Euro 8 million. Raw meat is imported from:<br />

• Brazil, Argentina, Canada 90 %<br />

• Italy, France 10 %<br />

The company produces 5 % of their produce based on chicken, 75 % on pork and 20 % on<br />

veal.<br />

The next investment should focus on building of refrigerating chambers.<br />

FIX-PRO shpk<br />

FIX-PRO shpk was established in 2003 in the city of Korca. The range of products includes<br />

more than 50 high quality products such as: sausages, salami, ham, fresh and frozen meat,<br />

llukanik etc. The company employs 60 people and makes an annual turnover of roughly Euro<br />

2 million. The company is certified regarding quality management ISO 9001:2000, HACCP,<br />

food safety and others.<br />

FIX-PRO shpk has a distributing network covering all the main cities of Albania. The<br />

company bases its success in the provision of high quality meat processing ingredients,<br />

continuous investments in new technologies, promotion of new products, marketing,<br />

promotional campaigns, etc. The investments plans focus on a new cold storage facility and<br />

on the enlargement of the production capacity.<br />

HAKO<br />

HAKO is one of the oldest meat processing companies in Albania. It started its activity in<br />

1998 in the city of Tirana where also the factory is located. The company produces more<br />

than 60 high quality products such as: sausages, salami, ham, fresh and frozen meat, and<br />

recently canned meat. The number of employees is 120 and the annual turnover roughly<br />

Euro 1.8 million. All the required raw meat for processing is imported from Italy and other<br />

countries. HAKO meat products are now offered through a large number of markets and<br />

supermarkets.<br />

The investment plan covers:<br />

• Treatment of water systems<br />

• Air conditioning systems in working place<br />

• Chilling rooms<br />

• Enlargement of working places<br />

ALBIDEA<br />

The company ALBIDEA was established in Tirana 2002 and main activity is swine breeding,<br />

fattening and slaughtering of their own pigs. The number of employees is 10, and the annual<br />

turnover around Euro 200,000. ALBIDEA is one of Albania’s few fresh meat producers. The<br />

company sells its fresh meat through franchised shops and to other meat processors.<br />

Future investments plans include<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 29


1. Building a new slaughterhouse<br />

2. Increasing of production capacity from 250 sows to 500 until 2012<br />

BARDHI shpk<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

The company started its activity in 1996 in the city of Tirana where also the factory is located.<br />

The range of products includes among others more than 15 high quality products such as:<br />

salami, ham, sausages, etc.<br />

BARDHI shpk employs 12 people and makes an annual turnover of roughly Euro 500,000.<br />

The company is certified regarding quality management ISO 9001:2000, HACCP, food safety<br />

and others.<br />

Actually all raw meat for processing is imported from:<br />

• 90 % from EU countries (Italy, France, Blegium)<br />

• 10 % from Brazil, USA, Canada etc.<br />

BARDHI’s investment plan covers<br />

• General reconstruction<br />

• Laboratory for minimal analyzes<br />

• Vacuum equipment<br />

ROZAFA KACI shpk<br />

The meat processing company was established in Shkodra in 2002. The company produces<br />

the most popular products such as salami, ham and others.<br />

ROZAFA KACI has 15 employees and makes an annual turnover of roughly Euro 200,000.<br />

Also this company is certified regarding quality management ISO 9001:2000, HACCP, food<br />

safety and others.<br />

The company processed exclusively loclally produce meat! The investment plan focuses on<br />

all kind of new equipment.<br />

I.N.C.A Nord Fish<br />

The company I.N.C.A Nord Fish was established in 2007 and the factory is located in city of<br />

Lezhe. The main activity is the selection and calibration of natural casing for sausage (pig<br />

casing, beef casing, horse casing, sheep casing). The number of employees is 30 and the<br />

annual turnover roughly Euro 700,000. Actually I.N.C.A Nord Fish is processing natural<br />

casings that origin from Italy, Holland, Poland, Hungary etc.<br />

The company is collecting and recycling just very small quantities because the waste from<br />

slaughterhouses is presently dumped illegally into landfills.<br />

Processing natural casings would help farmers to gain an extra Euro 10 per head of the<br />

slaughtered animals. Recycling would reduce waste which causes environmental pollution<br />

today.<br />

The investment plan includes<br />

• New equipment for selecting<br />

• Air conditioning systems in working place<br />

• Chilling rooms<br />

• Depurator for water system<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 30


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Besides these industrial plants there are also crafts facilities (objects of a smaller production<br />

capacities) like Profast and Caca in Korca, Arani-Expres Tirana and Erda and Kenedi and<br />

Arilta-B in Tirana, Isai in Elbasan, Sauli in Fier, Gerosi in Lushnje and ALSA in Vlora finally<br />

and facilities in the framework of the farms; these two types of processors are not so<br />

important for the Albanian market.<br />

IV. Government Policy for the <strong>Sector</strong><br />

According to the Agriculture and Food <strong>Sector</strong> Strategy 2007 – 2013 the government policy<br />

for the sector has be characterised as a primarily indirect support, which has focused on the<br />

following main aspects:<br />

• Rehabilitation of infrastructure (irrigation and drainage, markets and laboratories)<br />

• Establishment of a business-friendly environment (privatisation and distribution of the<br />

land and properties of the former cooperatives and agricultural farms, as well as of the<br />

assets of the agro-processing enterprises, start of the land cadastre for vineyards, 50<br />

% completed; next steps will cover the olive cadastre and then the one for agricultural<br />

land)<br />

• Support to farmer services such as technical advice, for agricultural extensionists,<br />

through which thousands of farmers and agriculture specialists were trained and the<br />

agricultural extension service was restructured towards a new policy and system<br />

• Institutional strengthening by providing new technical and administrative knowledge<br />

and experience through training and formal qualifications to technical and<br />

administrative staff of the Ministry and its structures<br />

By indirect support is understood the relative lack of credit and grants directed by the<br />

government to farmers.<br />

Since 2007 Albanian farmers benefited from a grant scheme that supported fruit and grapes<br />

production everywhere in the whole country. Furthermore the interest rate for loans in storing,<br />

processing of farm products (crop, fruits and livestock products), and agricultural machinery<br />

has been subsidised with up to 70% of interest rate. For investments in the agro-processing<br />

and export related activities loan guaranties have been provided.<br />

Regarding livestock there are two further programmes in place since 2009.<br />

Cattle<br />

The GOA supported milk farmers with a premium per head for milk producing cows, if the<br />

farmer owns more than 10 cows, if they are ear-tagged and if the sales a verified through<br />

official bills. In 2008 Euro 889,000 and in 2009 Euro 1,218,000 have been paid to 843<br />

respectively 1229 farms; that corresponds Euro 1,055 per milk farm in 2008 and Euro 991 in<br />

2009.<br />

A similar support scheme is not in place for cattle meat production.<br />

Sheep<br />

The GOA supported sheep milk farmers with a premium of Lek 500 per head for milk<br />

producing sheep, if the farmer owns more than 50 animals, if they are ear-tagged and if the<br />

sales are verified through official bills.<br />

A similar support scheme is not in place for sheep meat production.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 31


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

The milk farmer support is ongoing and nowadays the government policy as described in the<br />

Agriculture and Food <strong>Sector</strong> Strategy 2007 – 2013 sets one of their priorities in the promotion<br />

of high level of food safety of agricultural or agro-processing products. This can be realised<br />

along the following lines:<br />

• Introduction of obligatory requirements for the implementation of the self-control system<br />

HACCP and the adoption of ISO standards<br />

• Improvement of the control of hygiene and sanitation conditions of agribusinesses<br />

• Registration and effective supervision of animal health<br />

• Improvement of animal breeding conditions<br />

The 2010 Albanian budget for agriculture, food and consumer protection is around Euro 11<br />

million; that can be seen as a small budget compared to the sector’s contribution to the GDP.<br />

Actually the MAFCP is in the process to get restructured by the newly appointed Minister of<br />

Agriculture; among others this affects the independent NFA which will be in charge of all the<br />

veterinary and food control in Albania; but also the set-up of the Regional Directorates<br />

(RDAFCP) might be overhauled and the existing extension service improved – so that it<br />

might fit also in assisting farmers to apply for IPARD measures.<br />

Regarding the NFA there is an EC project “Implementation of the Establishment of National<br />

Food Authority Albania” (Ref: EuropeAid/122779/C/SER/AL; 2007 - 2011) in the<br />

implementation phase so that Albania will be in the position to adopt the EU legislation and<br />

enforce a national legislation on food safety and control issue. The project is dealing with the<br />

food inspection system, the veterinary and phyto-sanitary border control, the functional<br />

relations between NFA and Ministries, the capacity of the inspection and laboratory network<br />

at central and regional level, chain of command in case of emergency situations and other<br />

relevant issues.<br />

Land property and reform<br />

In Albania, land ownership and its redistribution in different historic moments has been the<br />

main issue accompanying the whole process of development in agriculture. Modification of<br />

property structures has always been made under the pressure of social-political factors.<br />

During socialism era, there were only two prevailing forms of land property: State owned<br />

agricultural enterprises and agricultural cooperatives. The following table offers information<br />

about the rates of their size increase.<br />

Table 11: Average size of agricultural enterprises and cooperatives<br />

Year<br />

Agricultural<br />

enterprise<br />

No Average<br />

size (ha)<br />

Agricultural<br />

cooperatives<br />

No Average<br />

size (ha)<br />

1950 19 668 90 245<br />

1960 32 1801 1484 212<br />

1970 50 2218 551 824<br />

1980 56 2690 422 1260<br />

1985 68 2557 416 1281<br />

1987 77 2343 416 1272<br />

(Source: Expert’s calculation)<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 32


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Referring to the table it results that during a 30-year period (1950 - 1980) both agricultural<br />

enterprises and co-ops experienced a large concentration of land under their property. In<br />

1980, average size of an agricultural enterprise mounted to 2690 ha and for agricultural coops<br />

the analogue figure was 1260 ha. By the end of ‘90s, all agricultural land belonged to<br />

492 agricultural units (both enterprises and co-ops).<br />

Under these conditions, approval of a law for agrarian reform was a necessity. First moment<br />

that marked the initiation of the process was the approval by the Albanian Parliament of the<br />

“Law on land”, No 7501, 19 July 1991. This law conveyed the first steps of an agrarian<br />

reform law. It involved the issues of land distribution, but constituted ate the same time a law<br />

for land property. It paved the way to a series of laws that aimed, on one hand, to complete<br />

land property rights and on the other hand, to regulate normal implementation of the reform.<br />

Another important problem emerging during the implementation of the agrarian reform is the<br />

attitude towards Law on Land and the ways of its implementation in different areas of country.<br />

Attitude towards Law has been accompanied with some problems related to its<br />

implementation.<br />

• Law non-implementation or lack of full knowledge of law: In this case, farmers have<br />

returned to their former property before the socialist system. This phenomenon is<br />

predominant in some areas, especially in north Albania; interesting to note that the<br />

today’s average farm size is not bigger in the north than in the south.<br />

• Partial law implementation or partial knowledge on law: Partial implementation of law<br />

means that farmers have returned to their formerly properties, but they have seized as<br />

much land as defined by law. This phenomenon is predominant in central Albania.<br />

• Correct implementation of law or full knowledge of law means that all households own<br />

land according to the Low and they also own official documents for all land plots.<br />

These phenomena have laid the foundation for different conflicts. Most prevailing conflicts<br />

are:<br />

• Conflicts between ex-owners regarding property boundaries<br />

• Conflicts between farmers who didn’t own land, but became land owners during the<br />

implementation of 1945’s Reform, and the farmers that claim this land because of in<br />

heritage<br />

• Conflicts between native farmers and the ones that settled in after 1945<br />

Regardless of the attitude towards law implementation, process of land privatization<br />

preconditioned the presence of a minimal size and considerably fragmented farm. This was<br />

caused by proportional division of land and the amount of land available in every village.<br />

Implementation of land reform brought about the following picture as regards the farm size.<br />

Around 58 % of farms are up to 1 ha, 30.1 % has 1-2 ha and only 11.8 have over 2 ha. –<br />

Experts mentioned that many people giving up their farming activities do not rent out officially<br />

their agricultural land and therefore the statistics look worse that reality; nevertheless the<br />

average farm size is too small in Albania.<br />

Mountain areas<br />

The Albanian agriculture in mountain areas has its specificities related to their special land,<br />

climatic, natural, historic and social conditions. As a result of these conditions, farms in these<br />

areas are smaller, product and input markets are more distant, rural infrastructure is weaker,<br />

development opportunities are more limited, economic and social development is delayed,<br />

schooling and education are less advanced and poverty more widespread. For these<br />

reasons, there are harder development challenges and the policy approaches to agricultural<br />

development may differ from those applied in lowland areas.<br />

Value Added Tax<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 33


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Farmers in Albania are usually not involved in the VAT scheme; that means they are selling<br />

their produce without VAT to registered processors. These processors will have to add 20 %<br />

VAT at the end on top of their final product. The consumer has to pay a 20 % higher price if<br />

purchasing at official channels instead of the informal market.<br />

As the government has already realised that the informal market must be transferred fast into<br />

the formal sector, also this VAT problematic has to be solved. Small farmers in Austria can<br />

pay their taxes as a lump sum and in this case they are allowed to issue invoices with VAT<br />

but the farmers do not have to transfer this tax to the government; they can keep it. For the<br />

farmer the scheme is the same with and without VAT but for the buyer it is better as they can<br />

deduct the VAT paid to the small farmers from the amount they have to transfer later on to<br />

the government when selling the final product.<br />

According to NSDI a value-added tax reimbursement up to 6 % is on its way. (Source: NSDI<br />

2007-2013)<br />

V. MARKET AND TRADE<br />

Availability of products<br />

In Albania meat of cattle, small ruminants, pigs and poultry is available from local production.<br />

The produced quantities from slightly more than 300,000 farms are as follows:<br />

Table 12: Livestock production<br />

Description 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009<br />

Live weight in 000 tons 112 114 118 123 129 133 137 158 141 143<br />

Cattle 63 62 64 65 66 68 69 83 66 66<br />

Sheep & goat 35 37 38 38 42 41 44 46 43 44<br />

Pig 10 10 11 12 13 15 15 16 16 16<br />

Poultry 4 4 6 8 9 9 10 13 16 17<br />

(Source: MAFCP; Statistical Yearbook 2009).<br />

Above figures show that there was a substantial higher level of production in 2007 than in the<br />

last two years. Over the last 10 years Albania showed an increase of almost 30 % in the total<br />

livestock production, especially in poultry and also in pigs.<br />

Supply chain<br />

In most countries the primary producers – the livestock farmers – are linked to the<br />

slaughterhouses and meat processing companies as producers sell their products to the<br />

processors. The situation is different in Albania. Not many slaughterhouses are in function as<br />

farmers, traders and butchers are not forced by the MAFCP and the National Food Authority<br />

to make use of them. Therefore slaughtering is done illegally in uncertified premises; in the<br />

best case it takes place in primitive slaughter points as it can be seen right next to the<br />

highway Tirana – Shkoder.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 34


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Furthermore meat prices are high even when the meat comes directly from the farm –<br />

compared to imported deep frozen meat from Brazil, Italy, Greece and other countries. For<br />

cheaper prices, reliable supply, standardized quality (sometimes of questionable quality) and<br />

easier logistics all meat processors in Albania use imported meat which comes into Albania<br />

by a few importers who have a monopoly on this activity. A few meat processors buy<br />

additionally Albanian fresh meat on the market to sell it in their own shops eventually as loss<br />

leader for their main product range based on imported deep frozen meat.<br />

Summarizing one could say that the Albanian agricultural sector produces almost enough<br />

meat of ruminants but has huge deficits in pork and chicken. The production will not increase<br />

substantially as long as the processing sector will not buy the locally produced meat. The<br />

processors industry will switch to local meat if cheap imports are no longer available and if<br />

Albanian producers can compete pricewise with the EU member states.<br />

The links between primary producers and first and second processing companies are in<br />

practice not in place; investments in slaughterhouses will be a first step to make products<br />

attractive for meat processors in respect to quantities and qualities.<br />

Consumption pattern<br />

As in Mediterranean countries, the staples in Albania are cereals, particularly bread and<br />

spaghetti, and starchy roots. Potatoes are widely used baked, fried and boiled, especially in<br />

lower income families. The common foods usually complementing the staples are dairy<br />

products (milk, butter and cheese), meats (bovine, mutton and goat meat), fats and oils,<br />

vegetables (tomatoes, eggplants). The types of dishes are mainly cooked vegetables with<br />

meat (cattle and pig meat), oven-baked or cooked potatoes, cooked beans and leeks, and<br />

cabbage which is consumed predominantly in winter. Tomato salads with cheese and olive<br />

oil, along with fried potatoes, eggplants, peppers and lettuce are eaten in the summer.<br />

There is no significant variation among regions or ethnic groups in staples and dishes. The<br />

meat consumption is almost at the same level in all Albania. However, there is a higher<br />

consumption of pork in the catholic areas (Mirdita, Lezha, Shkodra and Burrel), compared<br />

with the rest of Albania and a higher consumption of mutton in the southern part of Albania<br />

(Përmet, Tepelena and Vlora).<br />

In Albania there are huge differences between urban and rural areas. In rural areas, because<br />

Albanian farms are subsistence farms with low cash revenues, the diet is based on<br />

consumption of fresh farm products such as tomatoes, lettuce, eggplants, cabbage, peppers<br />

and dairy products (fresh milk, butter and cheese). In urban areas the population is far more<br />

dependent upon imported food supplies, not only in respect to meat but also cereals,<br />

vegetables and oil.<br />

Between 1988 and 2002 the consumption of meat, fish, milk and eggs more than doubled<br />

and the meat consumption is still growing as seen in the next table.<br />

Table 13: Meat consumption<br />

Annual human consumption of certain agricultural products (kg/head)<br />

2002 2005 2007<br />

Total meat (without offal) 19,3 33,4 43,0<br />

of which: - Beef & veal 13,7 17,9 17,8<br />

- Pork 0,2 0,5 3,1<br />

- Poultry 3,0 8,5 7,9<br />

- Sheep & goats 1,9 1,7 2,0<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 35


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

(Source: INSTAT (Living Standard Measurement Survey (LSMS), 2002, 2005 and Household<br />

Budget Survey (HBS) 2006-2007)<br />

This table gives details about the various types of meat consumption but does not explain the<br />

remaining rest which was around 10 kg in 2007; most likely the given figures are based on<br />

local production and the missing difference is covered by imports of live animals and meat,<br />

often in deep frozen form. (See also below Table 13)<br />

As comparison the total meat consumption (including poultry) in Austria was 2007 100.2 kg /<br />

capita and 2008 98.4 kg / capita (Source: http://www.ama-marketing.at/home/groups/7/<br />

Pro_Kopf_Verbrauch_Fleisch.pdf)<br />

Actually the meat consumption is low, even compared to other countries on the Western<br />

Balkans. One important reason for low meat consumption is the high cost of meat products<br />

in comparison to other products; at the same time that explains why the consumption of<br />

relatively cheap poultry meat is growing so fast.<br />

The sheep and goat meat is expensive, mainly because keeping of small ruminants is not at<br />

the state of the art; breeding is not consequently done, fertility and reproduction rate is low<br />

and the slaughtering weight of lambs is too low; often just 11 kg – especially before religious<br />

holidays Furthermore as a result of migration – especially of young people - into the cities,<br />

the interest in keeping small ruminants is declining. Successfully pilot projects - as presently<br />

implemented by UNDP are supporting the establishment of a food chain for lamb meat – will<br />

present new ways of income generating opportunities trough lamb meat. Traditionally on the<br />

Western Balkans eat a lot of sheep and goat meat. Having in mind not so much the EU<br />

figures of average sheep consumption of 2.3 kg/capita (2009) but more the consumption<br />

habits in neighbouring Greece where the average sheep meat consumption reached 7.4 kg /<br />

capita in 2007, there is potential for further increase.<br />

The outlook for meat producers is very good if one assumes that the Albanian meat<br />

consumption will get closer to the Austrian one; that means the consumption might more<br />

than double in the future.<br />

Legal framework for trade<br />

Albania became in 2000 a member of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) and in 2007 it<br />

entered the Central European Free Trade Agreement (CEFTA). Regarding the EU accession<br />

Albania is a potential candidate country and submitted its application for EU membership on<br />

28 April 2009.<br />

The European Union generally allows imports of fresh meat and meat products into the<br />

European Union if the veterinary certification is in place which is based on the recognition of<br />

the competent authority of the non-EU country by the Directorate-General for Health and<br />

Consumer Protection. This formal recognition of the reliability of the competent authority is a<br />

pre-requisite for the country to be eligible and authorized for export to the European Union.<br />

Legally legitimate and adequately empowered authorities in the exporting country must<br />

ensure credible inspection and controls throughout the production chain, which cover all<br />

relevant aspects of hygiene, animal health and public health.<br />

For meat and meat products from all species, countries of origin must be on a positive list of<br />

eligible countries for the relevant product. The eligibility criteria are:<br />

• Exporting countries must have a competent veterinary authority which is responsible<br />

throughout the food chain. The Authorities must be empowered, structured and<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 36


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

resourced to implement effective inspection and guarantee credible certification of the<br />

relevant veterinary and general hygiene conditions.<br />

• The country or region of origin must fulfil the relevant animal health standards. This<br />

implies that the country should be a member of the World Organisation for Animal<br />

Health (OIE) and should meet that organisation’s standards and reporting obligations.<br />

Adequate veterinary services must ensure effective enforcement of all necessary<br />

health controls.<br />

• The national authorities must also guarantee that the relevant hygiene and public<br />

health requirements are met. The hygiene legislation contains specific requirements on<br />

the structure of establishments, equipment and operational processes for slaughter,<br />

cutting, storage and handling of meat. These provisions are aimed at ensuring high<br />

standards and at preventing any contamination of the product during processing.<br />

• A monitoring system must be in place to verify compliance with EU requirements on<br />

residues of veterinary medicines, pesticides and contaminants.<br />

• A suitable monitoring programme must be designed by the competent authority and<br />

submitted to the European Commission for initial approval and yearly renewal.<br />

• Imports are only authorised from approved establishments (e.g. slaughterhouses,<br />

cutting plants, game handling establishments, cold stores, meat processing plants),<br />

which have been inspected by the competent authority of the exporting country and<br />

found to meet EU requirements. The authority provides the necessary guarantees and<br />

is obliged to carry out regular inspections.<br />

• For the import of meat from bovine, ovine or caprine animal species (cattle, sheep and<br />

goats), exporting countries have to apply for determination of their BSE status. This<br />

status is based on a risk assessment and is linked to specific BSE-related import<br />

conditions.<br />

• An inspection by the Commission’s Food and Veterinary Office is necessary to confirm<br />

compliance with the above requirements. Such an inspection mission is the basis of<br />

establishing confidence between the EU Commission and the competent authority of<br />

the exporting country.<br />

Having all these requirements in mind it is clear that without a well established National Food<br />

Authority Albania will continue to face this trade barrier and will not be able to export meat.<br />

Agro-food trade balance<br />

The table below shows that an increased international trade also bears some risks. On one<br />

side Albania was able to export more products than in the past but also many more products<br />

came into the country due to missing or reduces import tariffs.<br />

Table 14: Agro-food import and export<br />

Trade Units 2005 2006 2007 2008<br />

Agro-food trade mill. EUR 428 502 735 651<br />

Agro-food exports mill. EUR 46 54 76 60<br />

Agro-food imports mill. EUR 382 448 659 591<br />

Agro-food trade balance mill. EUR -335 -394 -584 -531<br />

Share of agro-food trade<br />

in:<br />

- Total exports % 11 11 10 9<br />

- Total imports % 89 89 90 91<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 37


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Note: Agro-food trade according to Combine Nomenclature of Custom Tariffs (CNCT).<br />

(Source: General Directory of Customs, Albania)<br />

Table 15: Import of agricultural and food products by quantity and value<br />

Import of agricultural and food products<br />

Unit 2007 2008 2007 in 000 LEK 2008 in 000 LEK<br />

Livestock 7.391.160 9.023.400<br />

cattle 000 head 52 64 2.276.366 2.479.392<br />

poultry 000 head 4.476 5.574 210.316 268.586<br />

pigs 000 head 31 56 387.082 672.386<br />

equidae 000 head 0 0 9.300 670<br />

other live animals 000 head 92 113 48.794 72.005<br />

beef Ton 6.705 5.377 858.203 846.315<br />

pork Ton 15.139 11.529 1.796.132 1.594.187<br />

mutton Ton 596 599 80.163 90.697<br />

poultry meat Ton 14.968 19.295 1.515.161 2.203.047<br />

giblets Ton 1.002 1.805 145.318 670.778<br />

stomach animals Ton<br />

000<br />

240 366 47.273 91.544<br />

eggs<br />

pieces 81 91 10.109 21.124<br />

honey Ton 18 27 6.943 12.669<br />

If one assumes that the 64,000 heads of imported cattle are used for meat and if each cattle<br />

has around 380 kg meat, than that would result in 24,320 tons. Adding now the imported<br />

beef of 5,377 tons, the total import would come to 29,697 tons. This total import figure<br />

divided by 3 million inhabitants makes an extra 10 kg per capita and that figure could explain<br />

the missing difference in Table 11: Meat consumption (see above).<br />

Table 16: Export of agricultural and food products by quantity and value<br />

Export of agricultural and food products<br />

Unit 2007 2008 2007 in 000 LEK 2008 in 000 LEK<br />

Livestock 374.585 1.043.400<br />

cattle 000 head<br />

poultry 000 head<br />

pigs 000 head<br />

equidae 000 head<br />

other live animals 000 head 78 79 73.817 63.771<br />

beef Ton<br />

pork Ton<br />

mutton Ton<br />

poultry meat Ton 1 5 116 1.417<br />

giblets Ton 47 23 33.389 40.112<br />

stomach animals Ton<br />

000<br />

229 1.235 49.338 615.683<br />

eggs<br />

pieces 33.309 46.743 217.925 321.716<br />

honey Ton - 5 - 701<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 38


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

The government will have to create better export opportunities as the gap is getting much too<br />

wide and there are no more opportunities to stop the imports.<br />

VI. LEVEL OF ATTAINMENT OF RELEVANT EU STANDARDS<br />

This chapter deals with occupational health and safety, environmental issues, food and feed<br />

safety, animal health, animal welfare.<br />

Occupational health and safety<br />

In the staff working document entitled “Albania 2009 Progress Report” it is mentioned that<br />

there has been progress in the area of health and safety at work as the government adopted<br />

in May 2009 the National Strategy for Occupational Health and Safety 2009-2013 and its<br />

accompanying action plan. The Occupational Health and Safety section of the Ministry of<br />

Labour, Social Affairs and Equal Opportunities (MLSAE) was upgraded and entrusted with<br />

the implementation of the strategy and action plan. An internal audit department was<br />

established in the State Labour Inspectorate (SLI) in April 2009. The first of the 24 local<br />

inspectorates planned to strengthen the SLI was established in April 2009.<br />

The Albanian Law No 10138 dated 11.05.2009 for the Public Health passed recently the<br />

parliament but enforcement of occupational health and safety remains poor and the number<br />

of accidents at the workplace is high, particularly in the construction, mining and mineral<br />

processing sectors. The labour inspection system does not cover the agricultural sector and<br />

it becomes clear that the occupational health and safety requires substantial improvements,<br />

especially in slaughterhouses and Albania has to consider these issues for farmers and farm<br />

workers.<br />

Environment<br />

Regarding environmental standards the “Albania 2009 Progress Report” complains that there<br />

has been limited progress in the area of horizontal legislation. Albania adopted legislation in<br />

January 2009 to ratify the Protocol on Control of Emissions of Nitrogen Oxides or their<br />

Transboundary Fluxes to the 1979 Geneva Convention on Long-Range Transboundary Air<br />

Pollution. Two public hearings were held with regard to the project for the construction of a<br />

thermal power plant in the Durres area. Notifications of public hearings were published on<br />

the website of the Ministry of the Environment, Forest and Water Administration (MEFWA),<br />

the website of the Aarhus Centre and local newspapers. However, the new draft Law on<br />

Environmental Protection, which incorporates a number of important Directives such as IPPC,<br />

LCP, Seveso II, public participation and the Water Framework Directive, has not yet been<br />

adopted. The new draft law on Environmental Impact Assessment is also pending adoption.<br />

No progress can be reported as regards air quality, environmental noise and just some<br />

progress in the area of waste management. The rehabilitation of toxic hot spots progressed<br />

and 35 new untreated hot spots have been identified. The construction of new landfills is<br />

underway. However, legislative development is lagging behind. A strategy for waste<br />

management has not yet been established. Uncontrolled dumping and burning of waste still<br />

persists and is particularly acute in rural areas. Substantial efforts are required to reduce<br />

waste generation and promote recycling.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 39


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

There has been some progress as regards water quality. Two wastewater treatment plants<br />

became operational, work on another one was completed and three more are under<br />

construction. However, surface waters are still affected by uncontrolled discharges of solid<br />

waste. The national strategy for water supply and sewerage has not been adopted.<br />

Implementing legislation and action plans for legislative approximation to the Water<br />

Framework Directive and the Nitrates and Urban Waste Water Directives are pending<br />

adoption.<br />

There was some progress on nature protection. The total coverage of protected areas<br />

increased to 12.58 % of the territory with the designation of the ‘Bredhi Hotoves-Dangelli’<br />

ecosystem as a national park. In January 2009 the government approved a decree on the<br />

criteria for the establishment of the biodiversity inventory and monitoring network.<br />

There was no progress as regards industrial pollution control and risk management. No<br />

developments can be reported in the area of chemicals and genetically modified organisms.<br />

Efforts are required to enhance inter-ministerial coordination to monitor the use of chemicals<br />

present on the market. There is no central register of chemicals and genetically modified<br />

organisms.<br />

Efforts continue to be required to strengthen the administrative capacity of all institutions<br />

involved in environmental policy making and to implement the 2008 cross-cutting strategy for<br />

the environment. Inter-institutional cooperation and coordination remain poor. Additional<br />

monitoring and inspection capacity continue to be required at regional level. Overall, there<br />

have been some positive legislative developments but implementation and enforcement<br />

remain weak. Preparations in the field of environment are advancing slowly but remain at an<br />

early stage for a number of sectors.<br />

Summarising one might say that there are no rules and regulations in place to improve<br />

environmental standards on farms in Albania. The CAP ensures that its rules are compatible<br />

with environmental requirements and that CAP measures promote the development of<br />

agricultural practices preserving the environment and safeguarding the countryside. Farmers<br />

are encouraged to continue playing a positive role in the maintenance of the countryside and<br />

the environment.<br />

This is achieved by a) targeting aid at rural development measures promoting<br />

environmentally sustainable farming practices, like agri-environment schemes and b)<br />

enhancing compliance with environmental laws by sanctioning the non-respect for these laws<br />

by farmers through a reduction in support payments from the CAP.<br />

Especially with regard to the storage of manure and slurry the level of environment protection<br />

is very low in Albania. Several visited farms had not adequate storage places for manure or<br />

slurry. First of all creating awareness on this issue by information and training will be<br />

necessary. But also on the processing side the handling of solid and liquid waste is in a poor<br />

state as there is usually no waste disposal system in place; leftovers are dumped into illegal<br />

landfills and run into nearby rivers. Finally it must be mentioned that Albania has no<br />

rendering or incineration plant!<br />

Food safety<br />

For the time being the national food hygiene laws and regulations in the Albanian meat<br />

sector are defined by the following laws and orders:<br />

• Law No 9308 from 4 th November 2004 “For the veterinary service and inspectorate”<br />

(Mbi sherbimin dhe inspektoriatin veterinar) which regulates hygienic conditions and<br />

food safety aspects;<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 40


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

• Order of Minister No 292 from 12 th June 2006 „Sanitary conditions in fresh meat trade”<br />

(Mbi kushtet shendetesore per vendosjen ne treg te mishit te fresket)<br />

• Law No.9863 from 28 th January 2008 “Food law” (Per ushqimin) which deals with the<br />

norms and general directives for hygiene and food safety and feed for animals; this law<br />

is harmonized with the EU Regulation 178/2002 and has set a 5-year transition period<br />

for the full implementation of all its provisions;<br />

• Different internal orders and regulations from the ministry;<br />

• Law No 9135 from 11 th September 2003, “For the consumer protection” which defines<br />

the consumer‘s right, relationship between consumers and producers, shoppers,<br />

suppliers, service providers, and institutions of the market control, and standardization.<br />

The objective of the law is protection of the health, environment, assurance of the life,<br />

and the consumer’s right.<br />

The MAFCP is working within the framework of CARDS 2005 to produce a new order of<br />

minister on food safety for meat sector which will be composed according to the following EC<br />

regulations:<br />

• Regulation (EC) No 178/2002 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 28<br />

January2002 laying down the general principles and requirements of food law,<br />

establishing the European Food Safety Authority and laying down procedures in<br />

matters of food safety<br />

• Regulation (EC) No 852/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29<br />

April 2004 on the hygiene of foodstuffs<br />

• Regulation (EC) No 853/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29<br />

April 2004 laying down specific hygiene rules for food of animal origin<br />

• Regulation (EC) No 854/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29<br />

April 2004 laying down specific rules for the organisation of official controls on products<br />

of animal origin intended for human consumption<br />

• Regulation (EC) No 882/2004 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 29<br />

April 2004 on official controls performed to ensure the verification of compliance with<br />

feed and food law, animal health and animal welfare rules<br />

The new Albanian formulation will reflect all the mentioned EC regulations, the GOA will<br />

transpose relevant EU legislation in national law which should enter in force by end of 2010.<br />

According to the “Albania 2009 Progress Report” there has been limited progress in the area<br />

of food safety and veterinary and phyto-sanitary policy. The National Food Authority was<br />

established, but it is not yet operational due to staffing problems (which is still true in May<br />

2010). In the food sector implementing legislation has been adopted mainly in the areas of<br />

import requirements for animal products (certificates), flavourings and food for particular<br />

nutritional uses. Some progress can be reported on laboratory capacity, particularly as<br />

regards histamine and residues. However, legal limits for microbiological contamination of<br />

raw milk are still significantly less stringent than EU standards.<br />

A very limited amount of legislation was adopted in the veterinary sector. The identification of<br />

bovines is not yet finalised and deficiencies in the registration of their movements jeopardise<br />

the utility of the current database. The current registration of small ruminants is not used for<br />

epidemiological purposes. No progress can be reported in the animal welfare sector. The<br />

legislative framework remained substantially unchanged in the phyto-sanitary sector. Only a<br />

few legislative acts were adopted, mainly in the area of plant protection products. Overall,<br />

there has been little progress in the areas of food safety and veterinary and phyto-sanitary<br />

policy. The legal framework improved, but compliance with EU standards remains poor.<br />

There has been some progress in the area of fisheries. ...<br />

Animal health and welfare<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 41


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

After the 1990s, the transition from big state enterprises to small home-based ones created<br />

favourable premises for the introduction and persistence of different pathogens and for the<br />

change of the general epidemiological situation in the country, as the risk for public health<br />

from zoonotic diseases increased. Moreover, the insufficient control of animal movement has<br />

brought about a rapid increase of animal disease prevalence in the whole country. Albania is<br />

currently free from foot and mouth disease, cattle contagious pleuromonia, small ruminants’<br />

pest, pig vesicular disease, as well as African swine fever.<br />

Some diseases included in the list of the World Organisation of Animal Health are present in<br />

the country and cause important economic losses to farmers, such as: Newcastle disease,<br />

classical swine fever, cattle anaplasmosis, cattle babesiosis, anthrax, tuberculosis, cattle<br />

brucellosis, brucellosis melitensis, contagious agalaxis, varoatosis in bees etc. As a result,<br />

human infection cases from zoonotic diseases have increased: about 400 cases of<br />

salmonelosis, about 700 cases of brucellosis, about 100 cases of leismanosis, and 60 cases<br />

of anthrax.<br />

The screening of animals for the above infections on more than a third of the total animal<br />

population (brucellosis of small ruminants, cattle tuberculosis) has shown a prevalence from<br />

0.64-5% for brucellosis melitensis and of 0.19% for tuberculosis. For this reason, even the<br />

control of these infections is very difficult.<br />

National programmes are prepared and implemented by the veterinary service for the control<br />

of animal diseases, especially for zoonotic diseases with risks also for humans. The<br />

veterinary budget is used for the control of diseases like tuberculosis, brucellosis, anthrax,<br />

and classical swine fever; the national programmes for the monitoring of residues, the<br />

monitoring of water and molluscs, and the animal identification and livestock farm registration<br />

system. About 10% of the total veterinary budget is used for emergencies (such as outbreak<br />

and elimination of illnesses, avian influenza). - All other illnesses present in Albania, whether<br />

infectious or parasitic of a non-endemic character are covered by the farmers themselves.<br />

Table ??: Status of main infectious diseases that affect animal health in Albania<br />

Disease Occurrence, Surveillance and Control<br />

Anthrax Occurs regularly. Control policy is to vaccinate animals in<br />

villages where disease has been confirmed and prophylactic<br />

vaccination in villages that have been classified as historical<br />

foci of disease.<br />

Bovine tuberculosis Could be increasing in frequency. Partial annual screening of<br />

cattle and removal of reactors<br />

Brucellosis in cattle Appears to be increasing in frequency, definitive diagnoses of<br />

Br. melitensis, Br. abortus not confirmed. Partial screening of<br />

cattle and removal of reactors, vaccination of young stock to<br />

Brucellosis in small<br />

ruminants<br />

be introduced<br />

Widespread and present in 22 districts. Partial screening of<br />

small ruminants and removal of reactors combined with<br />

vaccination of young replacement stock.<br />

Classical Swine Fever Reported since 1996 but believed to be enzootically<br />

established in small backyard pig herds in north Albania<br />

Newcastle disease Appear to occur each year causing serious losses in village<br />

backyard poultry flocks. Active surveillance implemented by<br />

owners in industrial flocks.<br />

Highly Pathogenic Avian<br />

Influenza<br />

Last reported in 2006, partial active surveillance implemented.<br />

Foot and mouth disease Last reported in 1996<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 42


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Rabies Last reported in 2006, active surveillance in wildlife (foxes,<br />

wolfs and bats)<br />

Contagious bovine<br />

Last reported in 1933<br />

pleuropneumonia<br />

Sheep and goat pox Last reported in 1934<br />

Rinderpest Last reported in 1934<br />

Source: European Union – Albania subcommittee on agriculture and fisheries, Tirana, 2 nd<br />

March 2010<br />

The competent authority (AHPPD) for animal health covering the whole of the Republic of<br />

Albania approved the contingency plans for following diseases in 2008 and 2009:<br />

• Contingency plan of CSF disease is updated<br />

• Contingency plan of ND disease is updated<br />

• Contingency plan of AI disease is approved<br />

• Contingency plan of Rabies disease is approved<br />

• Contingency plan of FMD is update<br />

Source: European Union – Albania subcommittee on agriculture and fisheries, Tirana,<br />

2 nd March 2010<br />

Having visited several livestock farms in Albania it is obvious that Animal health and welfare<br />

issues are not taken serious by most farmers; there are many stables with no or too few<br />

windows, manure is not removed properly, animals are often not registered and not<br />

vaccinates and so on.<br />

The European Union intends to protect and raise the health status and condition of animals<br />

in the Community, in particular food-producing animals, whilst permitting intra-Community<br />

trade and imports of animals and animal products in accordance with the appropriate health<br />

standards and international obligations.<br />

• Preventive health measures on intra-community trade and imports of:<br />

• live animals<br />

• semen, ova and embryos<br />

• products of animal origin<br />

• Community legislation on animal diseases:<br />

• new Animal Health Strategy to improve the prevention and control of animal<br />

disease in the EU<br />

• control measures, to be taken as soon as the presence of a disease is suspected<br />

• eradication and monitoring programmes, for the diseases that are already within the<br />

Community<br />

• EU financial contribution<br />

• Other activities:<br />

• Community Veterinary Emergency Team<br />

• identification measures, to guarantee the traceability of the animals<br />

According to the European Union animals are sentient beings. The general aim is to ensure<br />

that animals need not endure avoidable pain or suffering and obliges the owner / keeper of<br />

animals to respect minimum welfare requirements.<br />

• Community Action Plan on the Protection and Welfare of Animals 2006-2010<br />

• EU legislation on the protection of animals<br />

• on the farm (European Convention for the Protection of Animals kept for Farming<br />

Purposes, protection of farmed animals (of chickens kept for meat production, of<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 43


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

laying hens, of pigs, of calves intended for slaughter and the keeping of wild<br />

animals in zoos)<br />

• during transport (community standards on staging points)<br />

• at time of slaughter or killing (European Convention on the protection of animals at<br />

the time of slaughter, protection of animals at the time of killing, protection of<br />

animals used for experimental purposes)<br />

• Related international issues<br />

• International Animal Welfare Issues<br />

• Council of Europe<br />

• OIE<br />

• Other activities like implementation control of legislation or scientific advice<br />

Since the beginning of 2010 an EU funded project “Improving the Consumer Protection<br />

against Zoonotic Diseases in Albania” (EUROPEAID/128304/C/SER/AL) is going on and is<br />

supporting beside many other aspects also the area of veterinary legislation to assist MAFCP<br />

in updating of the veterinary law taking into account the new legal and institutional framework<br />

of food safety in Albania.<br />

In Albania the legislation on animal health and welfare aspects as well as disease control is<br />

in place but often not enforced; for example animal movements are not controlled at all.<br />

However, very often policies remain insufficiently implemented and insufficiently enforced<br />

mainly due to a lack of advocacy groups and due to weaknesses of public administration. It<br />

seems that political ambitions are much stronger than what public administration can<br />

manage. (Source: SKRELI, 2007)<br />

Official statements are not available as the FVO had no missions to Albania in relation to<br />

animal welfare since 2004.<br />

Competent authorities<br />

The main organisations (competent authorities) in charge of control for food and feed safety,<br />

animal health and animal welfare in Albania is the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and<br />

Consumer Protection. For the time being there are the following institutions involved on<br />

regional and local levels involved:<br />

• Regional Directory of Agriculture, Food and Consumer Protection<br />

• Regional Directorate of Public Health<br />

• Local Veterinary Office<br />

Furthermore there are several laboratories dealing with the safety issues such as<br />

• National Reference Laboratory, Food Safety & Veterinary Institute<br />

• National Reference Laboratory, Public Health Institute<br />

• Regional Veterinary Laboratories<br />

• Regional Food Laboratories<br />

• Regional Public Health Laboratories<br />

Actually the NFA is in the process of getting active by hiring office space, staff and by taking<br />

over several functions which have been under several authorities in the past.<br />

The below chart demonstrates how the organisation of food safety, animal health and plant<br />

protection will look alike by the end of 2011; the upcoming 12 regional Food and Plant<br />

Protection laboratories will carry out all chemical and physical analyses on food of animal<br />

and non – animal origin.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 44


SITUATION ON 2011<br />

MINISTRY OF EDUCATION<br />

AND SCIENCE<br />

(MoES)<br />

PLANT PROTECTION<br />

DEPARTEMENT(Albanian<br />

Agriculture University)<br />

MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE,<br />

FOOD AND CONSUMER<br />

PROTECTION<br />

(MoAFCP)<br />

IFSV<br />

11 VETERINARY<br />

LABORATORIES<br />

LEGEND<br />

IFSV – INSTITUTE OF FOOD SAFETY AND VETERINARY<br />

NFA – NATIONAL FOOD AUTHORITY<br />

BIP- BORDER INSPECTION POST<br />

-MoAFCP<br />

-MoES<br />

DIRECTORATE OF FOOD<br />

SAFETY AND CONSUMER<br />

PROTECTION<br />

(Policy and legislacion)<br />

GENERAL DIRECTORATE<br />

OF FOOD SAFETY AND<br />

CONSUMER PROTECTION<br />

DIRECTORATE OF ANIMAL<br />

HEALTH AND PLANT<br />

PROTECTION<br />

(Still inspection)<br />

ANIMAL HEALTH<br />

SECTOR<br />

PLANT<br />

PROTECTION<br />

SECTOR<br />

12 FOOD<br />

LABORATORIES<br />

NFA<br />

GENERAL<br />

DIRECTORATE<br />

12 REGIONAL<br />

DIRECTORATES<br />

OF NFA<br />

9 BIP<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

FOOD SAFETY<br />

INSPECTORATE<br />

ANIMAL HEALTH<br />

INSPECTORATE<br />

PLANT<br />

PROTECTION<br />

INSPECTORATE<br />

(Source: EC Health and Consumers Directorate-General, Directorate F - Food and<br />

Veterinary Office, DG (SANCO) /8127/2009 - CP Pre – Draft, Country Profile of Albania on<br />

Food and Feed Safety, Animal Health, Animal Welfare and Plant Health; 2009)<br />

National Strategy for Development and Integration (NSDI) 2007-2013<br />

Albania shows a low level of attainment of relevant EU standards. In the National Strategy for<br />

Development and Integration (NSDI) 2007-2013 the European Commission is quoted<br />

regarding progress against the accession criteria such as European standards: On fulfilling<br />

the European standards and establishing administrative and institutional structures to<br />

guarantee the implementation of the acquis communautaire, the creation of new structures to<br />

co-ordinate the substance of EU reforms and manage the resources to implement them is<br />

appreciated.<br />

The NSDI continues with strategic priorities and goals and states that the public programmes<br />

that support agricultural and rural development will be consolidated in accordance with EU<br />

practices, with the aim to support sustainable development in this area, and the Payments<br />

Agency will be established in the long term. Modern systems of food safety will be introduced<br />

gradually and the institutions that guarantee its standards will be consolidated.<br />

The challenges in agriculture are described as follows: The agricultural sector suffers from<br />

the small size of farms and the fragmentation of farm land, which is a barrier to production<br />

and marketing. This could be addressed through the development of a system of collection<br />

points and wholesale markets. Product competitiveness is low, as the cost is relatively high<br />

and output quality is low, which is caused primarily by the inadequate level of technologies<br />

and agricultural knowledge but also by the low level of farmer organisation, the relative lack<br />

of market information and the underdeveloped commercial infrastructure.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 45


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Currently, export opportunities for agricultural and agro-industrial products are very<br />

constrained as a result of the low level of agricultural and agro-processing industrial<br />

production; the lack of trade facilitations; the low food safety standards; and the weak<br />

competitiveness. Meeting the veterinary, phyto-sanitary and food security conditions of the<br />

SAA and Interim Agreement will be a difficult challenge. The standards to be achieved relate<br />

to a very broad area covering production, marketing, safety and quality certificate conditions<br />

for goods and services, processing, and inspection and control services.<br />

According to NSDI the agricultural policy of the GOA has the following strategic priorities:<br />

• Increase financial support<br />

• Improve the management, irrigation and drainage of land<br />

• Improve the marketing of agricultural and agro-processing products<br />

• Improve the level and quality of technologies, information and knowledge applied by<br />

farmers and agro-processing<br />

• Increase the quality and safety of agricultural and agro-processing products<br />

Agriculture and fisheries<br />

Some progress was achieved in the area of agriculture and rural development policy. The<br />

Agency for Agriculture and Rural Development was set up as the paying agency to manage<br />

direct support to agriculture and rural areas. The Agency has 86 staff and operates in all 12<br />

regions of the country. It provides a good starting point towards the establishment of an<br />

IPARD Agency. Preparations for IPARD advanced with the appointment of the prospective<br />

Managing Authority in June 2009. However, the Rural Development Strategy will require<br />

substantial improvements to serve as a basis for the IPARD programme.<br />

The 2009 budget for the direct support scheme remains stable at € 7 million. Direct support<br />

to farmers resulted in an increase in plantations of permanent crops such as fruit, olive and<br />

citrus trees and vineyards. Other direct support measures covered, among other things, drip<br />

irrigation, organic certification, mushroom culture and snail breeding. There have been efforts<br />

to improve quality and marketing overall. ... The Agriculture Information Centres received<br />

additional material resources and organised promotion activities. However, land<br />

fragmentation continues to hamper efficient farming and results in low productivity and<br />

incomes. Uncertainties about property rights hinder the development of a functioning land<br />

market. Structural weaknesses such as poor infrastructure and marketing systems, lack of<br />

cooperation between producers and business sectors and insufficient knowledge about food<br />

quality and safety standards hold back the development of the agricultural sector. The share<br />

of the total budget allocated to agriculture remains small. The trade deficit in agricultural<br />

products continued to increase. Overall, the agricultural sector remains weak. It lacks<br />

competitiveness and has difficulties facing competition from imported goods.<br />

Farm level<br />

Farmers often do not respect Albanian standards and regulations (for example environmental<br />

or occupational safety) and the authorities in charge often do not enforce them properly. Also<br />

the implementation of quality standards leave some room for improvements.<br />

Common EU standards such as the Good Agricultural Practice (GAP) have no equivalent yet<br />

in the Albanian law.<br />

Processing level<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 46


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

The performance of Albania on the areas of quality, hygiene, and food safety at farm and<br />

slaughterhouse level leaves room for substantial improvements. The situation is better with<br />

the meat processing companies, even if none of them has an EU approval for exports (EU<br />

export certificates).<br />

The GOA is aware of the requirements of the European Union and of the necessity to<br />

transpose EU legislation in national law. This has been partly done but even in cases where<br />

it was done the enforcement of these laws does not take place or just in a limited amount.<br />

VII. PAST TRENDS AND FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS IN TERMS OF INVESTMENT<br />

Past trends<br />

In former days the agricultural policy was not very much oriented towards meat production<br />

and processing as the average meat consumption was around 20 kg per year and capita.<br />

Keeping of private livestock was forbidden and all facilities like livestock farms,<br />

slaughterhouses and meat processing plants have been state-owned. After the collapse of<br />

the system none of the slaughterhouses and meat processors continued to operate.<br />

Actual situation<br />

On the farm level there are two categories of farmers; the subsistence farmer who was not<br />

investing in the past and who will not invest in the future simply because he has not the<br />

financial means to do so. Repair work is done to keep the small farms running but for<br />

additional, more future oriented investments there are no funds available. (This might also be<br />

the case for investments under IPARD measures for which the pre-financing capacity is not<br />

in place.)<br />

The other group of farmers are the commercial ones with more than 20 cattle heads or<br />

10,000 chickens, etc.; these farmers have the funds and invest in improved production<br />

facilities; especially the capital intensive poultry farms have invested substantial amounts of<br />

money and all these rather commercial farms will also apply for IPARD measures. The trend<br />

was to get bigger units and this will continue, eventually with investments in vertical<br />

integration such as fodder production (own feed mills) and / or slaughtering lines (and also<br />

steps towards better market access which could mean own shops). So far both groups have<br />

not invested in manure storage or environmental issues.<br />

Whereas there are no data available on the farm sector, some key figures could be found<br />

regarding the agroindustry in general and their investments.<br />

Table 18: Investments in Albanian agroindustry<br />

Description 2000 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009<br />

Agroindustry Investiment Mln. Lek 898 2917 2045 3052 2063 612<br />

Number of enterprises 1844 2060 2053 2040 2117 2081<br />

Number of meat processing enterprises 62 59 57 69 75 65<br />

Investments of meat processing sector Mln.Lek 121 426 170 119 174 35<br />

Number of employees 9076 9865 9995 10293 10919 10262<br />

Value of products (price of 2006) Mln. Lek 27990 42790 46431 47970 51353 51693<br />

(Source: MAFCP; Statistical Yearbook 2009)<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 47


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

The investments of the meat processing enterprises are quite balanced over the years, in<br />

sharp contrast to the remaining agroindustry.<br />

The processing sector can also be divided into two groups; the non-performing<br />

slaughterhouses which are hardly gaining any profit out of their (too limited) operations;<br />

refurbishment of existing poor slaughterhouse facilities would be too expensive and therefore<br />

the trend will go towards Greenfield investments, especially when supported by IPARD<br />

measures.<br />

The other sub-group are the meat processing plants which do economically fine, especially<br />

when thinking on the 8 big ones which control around 80 % of the market. The past and<br />

future trend goes towards improving the technology and fulfilling standards. When<br />

interviewed the management of these processing plants mentioned the following envisaged<br />

investments:<br />

• Capacity expansion;<br />

• Enlargement of working places;<br />

• Refrigerating and chilling rooms;<br />

• Air conditioning systems in working place;<br />

• Certification according to International Quality Standards to get in line with norms<br />

required by EU such as HACCP system;<br />

• Sewage water plant, treatment of water systems;<br />

• Complete new company as a Greenfield investment.<br />

So far both processing groups have not invested in manure storage or environment<br />

protection.<br />

As Albania has no rendering plant it seems logical that investors will show up as soon as the<br />

veterinary inspections are functioning and IPARD funds available.<br />

It might be assumed that especially the meat processing plants do some not registered<br />

businesses which would make it more difficult to speak officially about investments.<br />

The reaction on the announced IPARD programme was very positive from the already well<br />

performing companies and rather reluctant from the other ones.<br />

Future developments<br />

Also in Albania the future development will see the further commercialisation of livestock<br />

farming and meat processing.<br />

.<br />

The cattle farming will improve because it fits to the Albanian landscape with pastures; the<br />

future looks good if import prices for deep frozen meat will go up or import will cease at all<br />

due to uncertain origin of products and if slaughterhouses will improve and offer reliable<br />

services for the processing industry.<br />

The small ruminants might also improve as well also because the Albanian landscape with<br />

pastures fits even better for sheep and goats. Main target will remain the fresh meat market<br />

and to keep almost self sufficiency should be feasible; additionally export markets may open<br />

as soon as the NFA will perform their duties.<br />

The Albanian market is not ideal for pork meat as 70 % of the population are Muslims.<br />

However pig production might develop moderately with a slow increase in the number of pigs<br />

being produced for market, especially if the fodder costs will get cheaper. The production will<br />

include the whole production cycle including mother sows, piglets production and fattening.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 48


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Chicken farming will continue as long as the local demand will be satisfied; therefore<br />

substantial investment will be needed and certain investors, eventually from surrounding<br />

businesses like feed mills and slaughterhouses will enter the market.<br />

All farmers facing better market perspectives will invest to increase the profitability of their<br />

production.<br />

As the EU standards will request substantial investments especially for slaughterhouses and<br />

meat processing companies, almost all of the few operating slaughterhouses and a great<br />

part of small-scale meat processing companies will go out of business.<br />

As mentioned above there is a trend to establish a complete integrated chain of operations,<br />

from livestock farms to feed mill and retail outlets<br />

A few slaughterhouses might be refurbished like the one in Saranda. However, as Albania<br />

will need slaughterhouses according to EU food-safety standards, new slaughterhouses will<br />

be established on the green fields as this is more economically than rehabilitating the old<br />

ones.<br />

Due to chronically lack of finances MAFCP will - assisted by IPARD - also consider to<br />

encourage private investors to build and manage the new slaughterhouses; especially as the<br />

old system failed in which the government / MAFCP built the slaughterhouses and then<br />

handed them over to municipalities which rented them out to private entrepreneurs.<br />

Finally the big players of the meat processing sector will continue to invest also because they<br />

will have to partly switch from deep frozen meat as raw material to fresh meat which will be<br />

partially locally produced.<br />

VIII. Identification of potentials and needs of the sector<br />

This chapter provides a SWOT analysis. The section of the producers is divided into cattle,<br />

sheep and goats, pigs and poultry whereas the section processors will include the<br />

slaughterhouses and the meat processors.<br />

The SWOT analysis is in a certain way a black and white picture of the sector and will deal<br />

with analyse the internal factors (strengths and weaknesses) and the external factors<br />

(opportunities and threats).<br />

CATTLE S – Strengths W – Weaknesses<br />

Meat<br />

Animals<br />

Internal factors Internal factors<br />

Breeds, flock<br />

Breeds are more suitable for milk<br />

size …<br />

than for meat production<br />

Very few farmers focus on meat<br />

production<br />

Few farms with more than 50 heads 99 % of all cattle farms have less<br />

than 5 heads<br />

Stables Some modern stables Stables for 1-2 cows are primitive,<br />

dark, unclean, no air circulation etc;<br />

do not respect animal welfare<br />

standards<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 49


Manure<br />

handling<br />

Feeding Bigger farms produce own fodder<br />

and purchase feed concentrates<br />

from modern local feed mills<br />

Technology,<br />

mechanisation<br />

…<br />

Slaughtering<br />

(location, live<br />

weight …)<br />

Bigger farms have tractors and<br />

agr.equipment<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

No manure removal systems in<br />

place; manure is used as fertilizer<br />

on the fields and slurry just runs into<br />

the nearby river; does not respect<br />

environmental standards<br />

On small farms cattle graze in the<br />

neighbourhood of the farm (and<br />

along the streets), little use of self<br />

grown maize and wheat; very little<br />

feed concentrates<br />

Also bigger farms have to purchase<br />

partly fodder from the market as<br />

farms are often too small to produce<br />

enough forage<br />

Small farms are still doing<br />

everything by hand - feeding,<br />

removing the manure, milking etc.<br />

a) on the farm by the farmer, b) by<br />

the butcher on the farm or in small<br />

butcher shops, c) in<br />

slaughterhouses - transport of<br />

animals does not fit standards<br />

Live weight of slaughtered calves is<br />

often too low and therefore low<br />

profitability; reasons are demand for<br />

very young animals (of all kinds)<br />

and the unavailability of cheap<br />

fodder<br />

Meat classification and quality<br />

payments do not exist and farm<br />

output differs extremely in weight,<br />

age and breed<br />

Farmer<br />

Education Educational background is limited<br />

as almost no vocational schools<br />

which would be needed to train<br />

small holders.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 50


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

CATTLE O – Opportunities T – Threats<br />

Meat External factors External factors<br />

Land Pastures in Albania good for grazing;<br />

(climate, "alping" the cattle during summer not<br />

rainfall,<br />

mountains)<br />

in place yet<br />

Market<br />

Forage crops on 200,000 ha plus<br />

423,000 ha pastures<br />

Good climate, sufficient rainfall<br />

Extension of forage area limited<br />

Local Per capita consumption is increasing<br />

consumption but compared to EU level quite low;<br />

and beef for processing is mainly<br />

production imported and could be replaced by<br />

local production<br />

Price Price per kg is high Production costs are high<br />

Trade<br />

(import,<br />

export)<br />

Almost no export yet and imported<br />

beef could be produced locally<br />

No exports feasible due to non<br />

enforcement of food safety laws<br />

Legal base Laws and regulations not enforced<br />

Services NFA under preparation that will<br />

better coordinate the inspections<br />

Extension service underdeveloped;<br />

financial services for farmers almost<br />

not available<br />

Subsidies IPARD offers co-financing No budgetary support for meat<br />

production<br />

Public<br />

Public rural infrastructure<br />

infrastructure<br />

underdeveloped<br />

No market information system in<br />

place<br />

Farmer's<br />

Farmers not well organised, no<br />

organisation<br />

Producer Groups on the ground<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 51


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

SHEEP & S – Strengths W – Weaknesses<br />

GOATS<br />

Animals<br />

Internal factors Internal factors<br />

Breeds, flock<br />

Room for genetic improvements<br />

size … Average flock size 44 / 45 heads;<br />

small flock sizes are still very<br />

numerous as many sheep are<br />

raised for self-consumption and just<br />

3,177 farmers have between 100<br />

and 200 heads; only 797 have more<br />

than 200 heads; goat figures are<br />

914 and 293 = less than 10 % of all<br />

the farms with SR and these 5,000<br />

farms can be considered<br />

commercial small ruminant farms;<br />

total population 2.62 million SR<br />

Stables No stables except shelters when<br />

pastoralising, in winter poor dark<br />

stable, low ceiling etc not<br />

corresponding to animal welfare<br />

standards<br />

Manure<br />

No manure removal systems in<br />

handling<br />

place; manure is used as fertilizer<br />

on the fields and slurry just runs into<br />

the nearby river; does not respect<br />

environmental standards<br />

Feeding 4 systems: 1) Extensive system with Limited fodder production, therefore<br />

transhumance from 6 to 8 months no reserves. Generally low input of<br />

(all regions), 2) Semi-intensive<br />

system with transhumance from 5 to<br />

6 months (Gjirokastra), 3) Grazing<br />

system on permanent pastures<br />

close to the holding, 4) Grazing on<br />

natural pasture in walking distance,<br />

with return of sheep or goats in the<br />

evening to the holding<br />

feed concentrates<br />

Technology, Bigger farms have tractors and Small farms are still doing<br />

mechanisation agr.equipment for hay making etc everything by hand - feeding,<br />

…<br />

removing the manure, milking etc.<br />

Slaughtering<br />

Slaughtering on farms by farmers,<br />

(location, live<br />

by the butchers in the slaughter<br />

weight …)<br />

Farmer<br />

points and a few in<br />

slaughterhouses. Situation is worse<br />

than with cattle; live weight too low<br />

Education Educational background is limited<br />

as almost no vocational schools<br />

which would be needed to train<br />

small holders.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 52


SHEEP & O – Opportunities T – Threats<br />

GOATS External factors External factors<br />

Land Pastures in Albania good for grazing<br />

Market<br />

Local<br />

consumption<br />

and<br />

production<br />

Forage crops on 200,000 ha plus<br />

423,000 ha pastures<br />

Good climate, sufficient rainfall<br />

2 kg / capita and year = 6,000 tons<br />

Price Prices are Lek 300 – 350 per kg, in<br />

Euro 2.20 – 2.50. Seasonal price<br />

Trade<br />

(import,<br />

export)<br />

Legal base<br />

fluctuations, best in December<br />

Import of 599 tons mutton - if the<br />

figure is correct than self-sufficiency<br />

just 90 %<br />

Services NFA under preparation that will<br />

better coordinate the inspections<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Extension of forage area limited<br />

Often not good timing in producing<br />

lambs: Price the same as in Austria<br />

(reduced export expectations)<br />

No exports feasible due to non<br />

enforcement of food safety laws<br />

Extension service underdeveloped;<br />

financial services for farmers almost<br />

not available<br />

Subsidies IPARD offers co-financing No budgetary support for meat<br />

production<br />

Public<br />

Public rural infrastructure<br />

infrastructure<br />

underdeveloped<br />

No market information system in<br />

place<br />

Farmer's<br />

Farmers not well organised,<br />

organisation<br />

Producer Groups just starting<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 53


PIGS S – Strengths W – Weaknesses<br />

Internal factors Internal factors<br />

Animals<br />

Breeds, flock<br />

size …<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Large white, landrace are good Cross-breeds and other breeds less<br />

profitable<br />

17 farms with more than 50 pigs; 40,000 farms with 1 - 5 pigs mostly<br />

DZIRA - 30 sows and 6 - 800<br />

fattening pigs per year<br />

for auto-consumption<br />

Stables Good stables at commercial farms Poor, dark premises at subsistence<br />

farms<br />

Manure First farms under construction with No manure removal systems in<br />

handling advanced technology, also in place; manure is used as fertilizer<br />

manure management<br />

on the fields and slurry just runs into<br />

the nearby river; does not respect<br />

environmental standards<br />

Feeding High input of concentrates, On small farms low input (low<br />

sometimes farms have on feed concentrates), home grown fodder<br />

mixing; expensive production - from limited fields; feed<br />

sometimes maize grown<br />

concentrates expensive as imported<br />

Technology, Bigger farms have tractors and On the farm small farmers do<br />

mechanisation agr.equipment<br />

everything by hand - feeding,<br />

…<br />

removing the manure, etc... On the<br />

fields machinery is missing,<br />

sometimes they buy (expensive)<br />

services from private tractor owners<br />

Slaughtering On farm slaughtering in basic For auto-consumption slaughtering<br />

(location, live slaughter rooms; on bigger farms takes place on farm without<br />

weight …)<br />

Farmer<br />

veterinary inspection takes place veterinary control (also relevant for<br />

local sales); much slaughtering in so<br />

called slaughtering points - often<br />

along major roads<br />

Slaughter-weights 70 - 120 kg alive;<br />

no uniform products - at least not<br />

from small holders; lack of<br />

knowledge about low-fat meat<br />

production which is best preferred -<br />

20-30 % of carcass weight loss<br />

because of fat, affects heavily profit<br />

reduction<br />

Education Educational background is limited<br />

as almost no vocational schools<br />

which would be needed to train<br />

small holders.<br />

Focus / Highly focused if commercially done Subsistence farmers have<br />

specialisation<br />

additionally few chickens for autoconsumption<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 54


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

PIGS O – Opportunities T – Threats<br />

External factors External factors<br />

Land Climate fits for pig farms Farms too small for fodder<br />

(climate,<br />

rainfall,<br />

mountains)<br />

Market<br />

production<br />

Local 56,000 pigs are imported plus<br />

consumption 11,529 tons meat (corresponding to<br />

and 230,580 pigs), mostly deep frozen<br />

production from Brazil; local production is<br />

161,000 pigs; = 7,45 kg / head and<br />

35 % self-sufficiency; consumer<br />

trend towards fresh meat and<br />

growing meat consumption offers<br />

new opportunities<br />

Price Average price live weight Lek /kg 2 - Imported deep frozen pork is very<br />

300, average live weight when<br />

sold/slaughtered 70-110 kg<br />

cheap (around USD 2 / kg)<br />

Trade<br />

Imports almost finished pigs with 80<br />

(import,<br />

kg; no exports feasible due to non<br />

export)<br />

enforcement of food safety laws<br />

Products<br />

Legal base<br />

Besides fresh meat also processed<br />

products, if imports can be<br />

substituted<br />

Services Bigger farmers have their own Extension service underdeveloped,<br />

experts and are internationally farmers need advice in fodder<br />

connected<br />

production and nutrition; financial<br />

services for farmers almost not<br />

available<br />

Subsidies NAF in preparation Veterinary inspections weak and not<br />

coordinated between MAFCP and<br />

municipalities<br />

Public<br />

infrastructure<br />

IPARD offers co-financing No budgetary support for pig farmers<br />

Farmer's<br />

Farmers not well organised, no<br />

organisation<br />

Producer Groups on the ground<br />

Cooperation No strategy for vertical integration<br />

Low level of cooperation between<br />

pig breeders<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 55


POULTRY S – Strengths W – Weaknesses<br />

Internal factors Internal factors<br />

Animals<br />

Breeds, flock<br />

size …<br />

Good breeds as 50 % of broilers in<br />

commercial farms<br />

36 farms with more than 1,000<br />

heads; out of them 14 farms with<br />

more than 10,000 heads; DZIRA<br />

produces 2,000,000 broilers per year<br />

(= 8 cycles = 250,000 broilers / cycle<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Many farms do not produce more<br />

than 100 broilers a year - but they<br />

keep other animals too<br />

Stables Good stables at commercial farms No specific premises at subsistence<br />

farms<br />

Manure<br />

Commercial farms produce much<br />

handling<br />

manure but just have limited land<br />

available<br />

Feeding Commercial concentrates as<br />

provided by Agrotec, Dzira, Aiba;<br />

bigger farms mix the fodder<br />

components themselves<br />

Extensively with left over in the farm<br />

Limited own fodder production,<br />

therefore high feed costs in general<br />

No quality schemes as finished<br />

chickens have live weight between 1<br />

and 2 kg, in some cases up to 3 and<br />

4 kg<br />

Marketing Professionally done by commercial<br />

producers<br />

Some good slaughterhouses for<br />

chicken such as Chicken Farm,<br />

AGRIZOO, DRIZA<br />

Farmer<br />

Education Well trained big producers, clear<br />

focus on broiler production<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 56<br />

No marketing activities, just sold on<br />

the farm or on weekly markets<br />

(Slaughtering on the small farms<br />

without any veterinary control)<br />

Educational background is limited as<br />

almost no vocational schools which<br />

would be needed to train small<br />

holders.


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

POULTRY O – Opportunities T – Threats<br />

External factors External factors<br />

Land<br />

(climate,<br />

rainfall,<br />

mountains)<br />

Market<br />

Not much space needed<br />

Fits for poultry farming<br />

Local Consumption approaching 10 kg /<br />

consumption capita, self-sufficiency now 50 % -<br />

and production and consumption<br />

production expected to growth - EU<br />

consumption 24 kg / capita<br />

Market will move towards fresh meat<br />

and away from imported deep frozen<br />

broilers<br />

Price Poultry meat farm sales price per kg<br />

is between Lek 300 and 1,000!<br />

Trade 50 % of broilers imported, mostly as No export feasible due to non<br />

(import, deep frozen meat<br />

enforcement of food safety laws -<br />

export)<br />

except Kosovo<br />

Products<br />

Legal base<br />

Development into other poultry<br />

productions – turkey breeding and<br />

processing, free range chicken,<br />

organic chicken<br />

Services NFA under preparation that will Extension service underdeveloped;<br />

better coordinate the inspections financial services for (small) farmers<br />

almost not available but needed as<br />

broiler production is capital intensive;<br />

big producers have often already<br />

other business and therefore<br />

collaterals<br />

Subsidies IPARD offers co-financing No budgetary support for meat<br />

production<br />

Public<br />

Public rural infrastructure<br />

infrastructure<br />

underdeveloped, also poor power<br />

supply; farms need generator<br />

Farmer's<br />

Farmers not well organised, no<br />

organisation<br />

Producer Groups on the ground<br />

Cooperation Low level of cooperation between<br />

poultry breeders; contract farming<br />

not in place yet<br />

No strategy for horizontal and<br />

vertical integration (from genetics to<br />

retail markets)<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 57


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

SLAUGHTER- S – Strengths W – Weaknesses<br />

HOUSES Internal factors Internal factors<br />

Management Cheap labour force available Municipalities are in most cases the<br />

and work force<br />

owner and therefore poor<br />

management; exception:<br />

municipalities rent the facility out to<br />

the private sector<br />

Labour force incl. management is<br />

not trained in traceability, HACCP<br />

…<br />

Finances Individual slaughterhouses face<br />

expenditures but no revenues<br />

Focus / 3 slaughterhouses for chicken are Pigs are usually slaughtered at<br />

specialisation working fine; Chicken farms<br />

(Frigofood), AGRIZOO in Lushnja<br />

region and DRIZA in Frier<br />

slaughtering points<br />

Facilities Outdated facilities, often not even<br />

complying the Albanian law<br />

Technology Outdated or not applied technology;<br />

running costs for cold rooms too<br />

expensive<br />

Quality control Quality is not an issue as payment<br />

does not depend on quality - just on<br />

quantity<br />

Standards Albanian standards according to<br />

Food Law and orders of MAFCP<br />

often not applied, EU standards on<br />

hygiene, public authority, traceability<br />

and HACCP also not applied<br />

Raw material Animals are raised all over the No or limited raw material supply<br />

supply country and so are the<br />

slaughterhouses located<br />

Waste (liquid,<br />

No waste disposal system in place;<br />

solid)<br />

leftovers bought into illegal landfills<br />

and runs into next river<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 58


SLAUGHTER-<br />

O – Opportunities T – Threats<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

HOUSES External factors External factors<br />

Market No enforcement of veterinary law;<br />

inspections do not take place and<br />

slaughtering can be done<br />

anywhere<br />

Volume Increased local production and<br />

consumption will require also meat<br />

processing based on local<br />

production; furthermore<br />

slaughtering of imported live<br />

animals possible<br />

Sales price Slaughtering fees acceptable by<br />

slaughterhouses if volume<br />

increases strongly; furthermore<br />

additional revenues due to by-<br />

Slaughtering fees "higher" than if<br />

done illegally in the backyard; 600<br />

Lek for grown up cattle, 500 Lek for<br />

calves, 400 Lek for sheep and<br />

goat, 500 Lek for pigs<br />

Sales channels<br />

products like intestines<br />

Market outlets are looking for<br />

certified meat<br />

Trade (import, Exporters to EU will technically Imported meat does not require<br />

export)<br />

Policy<br />

have to use certified fresh meat for<br />

processing specialities<br />

local slaughtering plants<br />

Subsidies IPARD offers financial support of<br />

up to 50 % of investment costs<br />

No MAFCP support<br />

Public<br />

Existing public slaughterhouses No vocational "butcher" training<br />

infrastructure<br />

(vocational<br />

training, rural<br />

roads,<br />

slaughterhouses<br />

…)<br />

could eventually be upgraded available<br />

Food safety Food safety in place would improve No local interest, neither from<br />

tourism<br />

authorities nor from customers<br />

No rendering or incineration plant<br />

in the country<br />

Veterinary Veterinary inspectors available Control institutions in MAFCP and<br />

inspection<br />

National Food Authority not well<br />

(transport<br />

papers)<br />

coordinated yet<br />

Veterinary law not enforced;<br />

transport papers and slaughtering<br />

register during controls never<br />

required<br />

MAFCP strategy Slaughterhouses will face a revival To enable just one slaughterhouse<br />

if slaughtering point will be finally in the middle of each province; to<br />

closed by local authorities (NFA) believe that this slaughterhouse<br />

must be governmental owned<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 59


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

<strong>MEAT</strong><br />

S – Strengths W – Weaknesses<br />

PROCESSORS Internal factors Internal factors<br />

Management Cheap labour force available and More qualified manager are needed<br />

and work force existing management very qualified but engineers from university not<br />

suitable<br />

Finances Bigger companies financially Lek depreciation causes worries as<br />

strong; further investments all the input is imported and mostly<br />

foreseen<br />

paid in Euro<br />

Focus / Priorities are pork, poultry and beef Until now imported raw material is<br />

specialisation<br />

too cheap and local production<br />

cannot compete<br />

Facilities Modern premises at main<br />

Not one company has adequate<br />

companies<br />

waste disposal system<br />

Technology Sophisticated technology in Limited technology in processing<br />

processing frozen meat<br />

fresh meat<br />

Quality control Documentation, traceability, Laboratories missing and also<br />

HACCP applied at least at the smaller companies do not apply<br />

biggest companies<br />

HACCP rules, etc.<br />

Standards Albanian standards according to<br />

Food Law and orders of MAFCP<br />

often applied, EU standards on<br />

hygiene, public authority,<br />

traceability and HACCP also<br />

applied with the big companies;<br />

almost ready for EU export licences<br />

Raw material Cheap raw material available No linkage to domestic fresh meat<br />

supply through import (Brazil, Canada,<br />

India, Italy …)<br />

production<br />

Waste (liquid,<br />

No waste disposal system in place;<br />

solid)<br />

leftovers brought into illegal landfills<br />

and runs into next river<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 60


<strong>MEAT</strong><br />

O – Opportunities T – Threats<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

PROCESSORS External factors External factors<br />

Market No enforcement of veterinary law;<br />

inspections do not take place and<br />

slaughtering can be done anywhere<br />

Volume Local meat consumption will grow<br />

On the long run there is export<br />

potential<br />

Diversification of products and<br />

substitution of high value imports<br />

such as prosciutto (hotels,<br />

restaurants)<br />

Sales price Rather low for the time being<br />

Sales channels Direct sales to supermarkets<br />

(Euromax, Conad, Big Market) and<br />

smaller retailers, furthermore<br />

company-owned outlets (EHW,<br />

Trade (import,<br />

export)<br />

KMY)<br />

Exports to EU as soon as National<br />

Food Authority will be approved as<br />

effective authority<br />

Policy<br />

Subsidies IPARD offers financial support of<br />

Public<br />

infrastructure<br />

(vocational<br />

training, rural<br />

roads,<br />

slaughterhouses<br />

…)<br />

up to 50 % of investment costs<br />

Supermarkets are just starting and<br />

will become more powerful<br />

Kosovo does not have pork<br />

imports; all other markets within<br />

Europe closed<br />

No MAFCP support<br />

No rendering or incineration plant in<br />

the country<br />

Food safety All smaller processors need<br />

improvements in food safety<br />

Veterinary Veterinary inspectors available Veterinary inspectors are not up to<br />

inspection<br />

date and veterinary inspection<br />

(transport<br />

needs improvement, especially in<br />

papers)<br />

documentation and traceability<br />

Veterinary law not enforced;<br />

transport papers and slaughtering<br />

register during controls never<br />

required<br />

MAFCP Gov.policy set priorities in the Institutional communication with the<br />

strategy promotion of high level of food private sector poor; lack of<br />

safety of agricultural or agro- involvement of businesses in policy<br />

processing products; Introduction of making; up-front consultations<br />

obligatory requirements for the<br />

implementation of the self-control<br />

system HACCP and the adoption of<br />

ISO standards; Improvement of the<br />

control of hygiene and sanitation<br />

conditions of agribusinesses<br />

missing<br />

No convincing strategy about future<br />

use of fresh and domestic meat<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 61


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

The above SWOT analysis shows that there are several weaknesses and it will require<br />

special efforts to make the sector competitive before participation in the EU market.<br />

Summarising it could be said that the Albanian meat sector will need:<br />

• More organised farmers; could be in joint companies or Producer Groups; PGs would<br />

be important preconditions for improving the economic efficiency of the farming<br />

community; experiences in other countries indicate that weakness regarding the<br />

producers' fragmentation and badly organised sales activities could be overcome<br />

considerably by forming producer and marketing associations;<br />

• More vocational training, starting in school (age 10 – 15) and including also specific<br />

courses for farmers; furthermore better management / business administration should<br />

be offered at university level as output of universities do not fulfil the meat industry’s<br />

requirements;<br />

• More commercially oriented livestock keeping with an orientation towards ruminants to<br />

avoid high fodder costs because fodder is presently imported;<br />

• New slaughterhouses as Greenfield investments;<br />

• Meat processing companies with better technology so that they will be able to process<br />

local fresh meat on the long run.<br />

A successful implementation of IPARD would require the following (not exhaustive list):<br />

• Farmers must get informed by MAFCP about the agricultural policy, projects and<br />

upcoming programmes, especially about subsidies;<br />

• Farmers will need support in preparing project proposals; courses should be arranged<br />

by MAFCP for their extension people as well as for interested private persons (farmers<br />

and/or private consultants);<br />

• Banks must get informed by MAFCP that farmers will apply for IPARD funds and<br />

therefore part of the on-farm investments can be considered as co-financed (=reducing<br />

risks for banks).<br />

The meat sector is yet not well prepared for participation in the EU market; but the sector<br />

could build-up strength to resist the resulting competition pressure by making better use of<br />

the natural resources (especially the availability of pastures for ruminants) and the cheap and<br />

motivated labour force at the processing industry. IPARD funds will be highly welcomed to<br />

achieve the goal of improved competitiveness.<br />

IX. IDENTIFICATION OF TRAINING NEEDS IN THE SECTOR<br />

Based on the previous analyses the meat sector in Albania is facing a number of challenges<br />

like awakening consumer food safety concerns, difficulties in attracting high calibre workers<br />

and managers, stricter regulations for the industry while adapting to EU requirements and<br />

increasing competition within a more liberalized market. Tailor-made training courses could<br />

overcome these deficits. As each stakeholder in the meat sector has to face different<br />

requirements the training needs might be grouped as follows:<br />

• Training needs for farmers<br />

• Training needs for slaughterhouse’s staff<br />

• Training needs for meat processor’s staff<br />

• Training needs for the public administration<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 62


Training needs for farmers<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

First farmers must get identified who have the potential to produce livestock in a<br />

commercially viable way by the end of 2012. Based on today’s knowledge the following<br />

courses should be offered to farmers by the public extension service and private experts in<br />

the following fields:<br />

• Livestock management (animal welfare – also during transport, breeding, nutrition,<br />

GAP, veterinary issues, animal identification, hygiene concerning production and onfarm-slaughtering,<br />

basic food processing);<br />

• Manure storage and management;<br />

• Occupational health and safety;<br />

• Making use of market information systems;<br />

• Intensified cooperation among the farmers, for example by setting up producer groups.<br />

Training needs for slaughterhouse’s staff<br />

Courses should be offered to employees of slaughterhouses by the public extension service<br />

and private experts including ones from ADAMA (Albanian Dairy and Meat Association) in<br />

the following fields:<br />

• Management (writing business plans, financing, accounting, human resources<br />

development ...);<br />

• In-company training for workers, industrial abattoir workers and deboners / trimmers<br />

regarding new technology, food safety ...;<br />

• National and EU standards from animal welfare, occupational health and safety, food<br />

safety systems to environmental issues (like rendering plants).<br />

Training needs for meat processor’s staff<br />

Courses should be offered to employees of meat processing companies by the public<br />

extension service, ADAMA and private experts in the following fields:<br />

• Management (writing business plans, financing, accounting, human resources<br />

development, language skills, opening export markets ...);<br />

• In-company training for workers (new technology, food safety ...);<br />

• National and EU standards from animal welfare, occupational health and safety, food<br />

safety systems to environmental issues (like rendering plants).<br />

Training needs for the public administration<br />

The civil servants should be brought in the position to understand how commercial<br />

companies are functioning; just by understanding the farmers and processors the staff of<br />

NFA, MAFCP and other subordinated institutions will be in the position to advice and support<br />

them – also in respect to their upcoming IPARD applications:<br />

• Workshops on EU guidelines from farm to fork including directives for meat plants and<br />

their application in the meat industry;<br />

• IPARD applications (design and evaluation of investment projects, application forms ...);<br />

• Training in the practices of general food safety and HACCP application plus traceability<br />

in the food chain;<br />

• Laboratory requirements and techniques in the meat industry;<br />

• General business training to include such topics as overall cost control and analysis,<br />

cost price calculations, selling price setting and negotiation techniques, the importance<br />

of the market chain etc.;<br />

• English language courses;<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 63


• Computer training.<br />

X. Outcome<br />

Overview of the meat sector<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

Since the collapse of the old system Albania has seen many changes and improvements.<br />

The agricultural sector was the backbone of all economic development and even as his<br />

importance is slowly decreasing, it is one of the most important sectors in the completely<br />

Albanian economy.<br />

Agriculture contributes nowadays around 16.5 % to the GDP (2008); the major sub-group<br />

within agriculture is the livestock production with about 55 % of the total production of the<br />

sector, followed by field crops with 30 % and fruit production with 15 %. Within the livestock<br />

sector milk production is as important as meat production.<br />

In the period 2000 – 2009 cattle, sheep and goats have been declining whereas pigs and<br />

chicken have been growing.<br />

Table 18: Animals in Albania (heads in 000)<br />

Livestock 2000 2009<br />

Cattle 728 494<br />

Cows 448 353<br />

Sheep & goats 3045 2540<br />

Sheep 1939 1768<br />

Milked sheep 1448 1309<br />

Goats 1104 772<br />

Milked goats 800 574<br />

Pigs 103 160<br />

Sow 10 13<br />

Poultry 5291 8313<br />

Chicken 4087 5138<br />

(Source: MAFCP; Statistical Yearbook 2009)<br />

Having the natural resources of Albania with more than 400,000 ha of permanent grassland<br />

in mind this situation is paradox as the animals which need pastures like cows, sheep and<br />

goats are getting fewer whereas the pigs and chicken, which depend heavily on expensive<br />

imported feed, are growing by numbers.<br />

This paradox might be explicable as chicken – despite being a capital-intensive business –<br />

enable a fast return on investments; this kind of investment is mostly coming from nonfarming<br />

investors.<br />

This situation regarding pigs is actually determined by big importers who do not import<br />

piglets with 25 kg like in the previous years but 80 – 90 kg pigs which are almost ready for<br />

slaughtering. Reasons therefore are that piglets are not available, at least not in sufficient<br />

quantities and qualities, and therefore the import of live animals is required. As it is cheaper<br />

to import a pig with 80 kg of live weight than a piglet with 25 kg plus substantial amounts of<br />

corn, Albania faces the situation of having imports of 80 kg pigs – almost ready for<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 64


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

slaughtering. In other words a big part of the increased local pig production is based on<br />

increased imports.<br />

Mainly subsistence farmer keeps sheep and goats and just around 5,000 holdings can be<br />

considered as commercial small ruminant farms. As people are moving to urban areas fewer<br />

people are interested to work with small ruminants, especially in transhumance. The price<br />

level is still high for sheep and goats and will not allow further substantial increase.<br />

Similar issues could explain the situation with cattle; there are few commercial dairy farms in<br />

Albania and even less cattle fattening farms; so most animals are kept by small holders for<br />

auto-consumption. Regarding the two main production opportunities – milk and meat –<br />

farmers often chose the milk production as it enables a small but continuously income<br />

whereas meat production requires one year minimum to get a well-fattened cattle and often<br />

farmers do not have the funds to bridge such a long period without income.<br />

In addition, the meat processing sector shows a very inconsistent picture. Under the former<br />

government the agricultural policy did not focused on meat production and therefore there<br />

have been very limited slaughterhouse capacities and meat processing companies. After the<br />

collapse most companies closed down – before and after the privatisation - and as a result<br />

there are not many slaughterhouses left in operation. Due to missing enforcement of<br />

appropriate veterinary inspections slaughtering of animals takes place all over the country<br />

except in slaughterhouses. The few remaining operating slaughterhouses do not generate<br />

profit as they are working far below their capacities and therefore no investment takes place.<br />

Experts are convinced that almost all the existing slaughterhouses – regardless if in<br />

operation or already closed – will not be upgraded to EU standards simply as a Greenfield<br />

investment would be cheaper. However these investments are not taking place yet as the<br />

law is not enforced and if farmers and butchers have the choice between official inspected<br />

slaughterhouse and an illegal slaughter point in the backyard of the farm or the butcher shop<br />

then they prefer the cheaper solution – in the backyards. In other words under the present<br />

circumstances slaughterhouses cannot be a profitable business.<br />

The situation is different with meat processors; all the big 8 – 10 companies depend almost<br />

exclusively on imported deep frozen meat from Brazil, Canada, USA and the European<br />

Union. This meat is very cheap and processing it enables a sound return on investments.<br />

The bigger companies are often close to EU standards and just need minor improvements.<br />

Exports towards the EU member countries but also other neighbouring countries do not take<br />

place because of the missing veterinary inspections in accordance with the EU regulations.<br />

Nevertheless these processing companies are willing and able to invest further into<br />

upgrading the standards so that they might export as soon as the legal environment will<br />

enable that.<br />

Potentials and obstacles<br />

From the point of self sufficiency there is room for increased production in all livestock farms<br />

except sheep and goats as Albania is almost self-sufficient in this category. As described<br />

above there is a big potential for new slaughterhouses – which should be build right from the<br />

beginning according to EU standards – as all the existing ions are outdated in respect of<br />

technology but more important hygiene, animal welfare and food safety. The most advanced<br />

stakeholders in this supply chain are the meat processing companies as they need just little<br />

further investments to fulfil EU requirements.<br />

There are several reasons why the listed potentials are not used (yet). The farming sector is<br />

too much struggling with subsistence farming and there are not many commercial farmers.<br />

Many older subsistence farms will come to an end as soon as the old owners will die and the<br />

young ones will move to urban areas to find better paid jobs. As soon as a sound cadastre<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 65


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

system will be in place transfer of agricultural land either by purchase or rent will increase.<br />

This will give motivated small holders the chance to increase their production and to make<br />

the step from subsistence to market oriented farming. Bigger farms will encourage a more<br />

commercial acting.<br />

Beside the size of agricultural holdings also their premises such as stables will need some<br />

upgrading and here IPARD funds will have a big impact as soon as they will be available.<br />

Furthermore it will be important to have well trained farmers who have a clear focus and<br />

good commercial understanding. The public extension service and private experts will face<br />

new challenges to overcome the actual deficits.<br />

As IPARD funds will require from farmers also a fulfilling of at national and soon of EU<br />

standards it will be crucial that farmers are aware of these standards related to occupational<br />

health and safety, environmental issues, food and feed safety, animal health, animal welfare<br />

and others.<br />

Actually fodder costs are too high. Also the fodder production is not as good as it could be<br />

and on the almost 200,000 ha there is a lot of room for improvements. Fodder must be<br />

produced in a larger scale to decrease the production costs. Then also the locally produced<br />

fodder like alfa-alfa, maize silage and others will become competitive towards the imported<br />

one.<br />

Investments in agricultural holdings as enabled by the upcoming IPARD programme will<br />

push the sector. The investments which will not be eligible under IPARD must find cofinancing<br />

in national support programmes.<br />

The same is valid for the meat processing sector and the investments will have to focus on<br />

newly established slaughterhouses and hopefully a rendering plant. The meat processing<br />

companies will also benefit from the IPARD programme but most likely the big ones will find<br />

their way also without support programmes like in the past. It should be mentioned that the<br />

enforcement of better waste disposal will find broader acceptance if co-financed by IPARD.<br />

Final recommendations in order to target the specific investments<br />

The farming community is urgently waiting for the IPARD support, at least the kind of farmers<br />

who are trained and motivated to make their living out of commercial farming. These farmers<br />

will find their way to pre-finance their investments under IPARD and will therefore benefit<br />

from the new support scheme. The majority will not be willing or able to do more than<br />

subsistence farming and will on the long run stop their farming activities.<br />

Concerning the meat processing sector the slaughterhouses must be newly build and<br />

managed by the private sector under strong monitoring by the NFA. Without prospering<br />

slaughterhouses the Albanian farmers will not find access to the meat processing sector. To<br />

make slaughterhouses profitable the NFA must stop all illegal animal movements and<br />

slaughtering as soon as possible. Then these slaughterhouses will be a bottleneck and will<br />

enable an improved veterinary control scheme. At the same time they will provide sufficient<br />

quantities in different certified qualities to the processing industries.<br />

The meat processors, especially the bigger ones, are doing fine and will not face many<br />

difficulties fulfilling EU standards. They also do not worry about more expensive imported<br />

meat as long as all competitors have to use the same raw material.<br />

It will be the big challenge for MAFCP to improve the livestock sector and to increase the<br />

food safety by channelling all animals to slaughterhouses. Having better local fresh meat –<br />

for fresh meat consumption but also for processing – the industry will make use of it.<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 66


Proposed Measures under IPARD Axis 1<br />

Investment in Agricultural Holdings<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

The following investments should be supported under IPARD:<br />

• Construction/extension/modernisation of animal shelters;<br />

• Construction and/or renovation of storage buildings and machine sheds;<br />

• Silage handling equipment and machinery, on-farm animal feed preparation, handling,<br />

distribution systems and storage;<br />

• Automatic feeding & drinking equipment, watering, heating and ventilation, automating<br />

environmental control systems including energy-saving equipments authorised and<br />

defined under Directive 2007/43/EC;<br />

• Investments for manure handling, storage and treatment facilities;<br />

• Animal handling equipment and facilities (e.g. weighing, disinfection);<br />

• Transportation equipment compatible with Community animal welfare standards;<br />

• Watering systems;<br />

• Fences and gates;<br />

• Special equipment for weighing, health control;<br />

• Biogas facilities;<br />

• Purchase of specialized technological equipment including IT and software (herd<br />

management, animal registry, general farm management).<br />

Size of projects<br />

The maximum and minimum limits of total value of eligible investments per project are:<br />

• Minimum € 5,000<br />

• Maximum € 500,000<br />

Ranking<br />

Sheep – cattle – goats – pigs – poultry<br />

Investment in Processing and Marketing of the Agricultural Products<br />

The following investments should be supported under IPARD:<br />

• Construction or renovation of slaughterhouses;<br />

• Renovation of meat processing enterprises;<br />

• Equipment for improvement of hygiene and product quality, in full compliance with<br />

Community standards;<br />

• Investments for establishment of food safety systems (HACCP, GMP and GHP)<br />

including laboratories and equipment to improve the control of the product quality and<br />

hygiene;<br />

• Certification costs;<br />

• Improvement of environmental protection; equipment and facilities for reprocessing of<br />

intermediate products and processable wastes; treatment and elimination of wastes:<br />

waste water works in slaughterhouses and fat catcher facilities for meat processing<br />

establishments;<br />

• Investment for slaughtering animals in conditions compatible with animal welfare;<br />

• Purchase of equipment for packaging;<br />

• Cold storage equipment, purchasing refrigerated transport means of carcass and meat<br />

products;<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 67


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

• IT hardware and software for product and process management, Software & tracking<br />

system to implement traceability of carcass and meat inside the processing<br />

establishment;<br />

• …<br />

Size of projects<br />

The maximum and minimum limits of total value of eligible investments per project are:<br />

• Minimum € 10,000<br />

• Maximum € 500,000<br />

Ranking<br />

Slaughterhouses - (rendering plants) – meat processors<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 68


LITERATURE AND WEBSITES CONSULTED<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

CEUENS / Centre for EU Enlargment Studies; Gjergji Vurmo, Institute for Democracy and<br />

Mediation, edited by Balázs Szent-Iványi; Relations of Albania with the EU; 2008<br />

Commission of the European Communities; staff working document “Albania 2009 Progress<br />

Report”; 2009<br />

SKRELI, E.: Project for Sustainable Agriculture and Rural Development in Mountain Regions<br />

(SARD – M); Assessment of strengths and weaknesses of mountain policies in South East<br />

Europe: National report of Albania; 2007<br />

European Commission – Agriculture and Rural development; Albania - Agriculture and<br />

Enlargement; 2009<br />

European Union – Albania subcommittee on agriculture and fisheries, Tirana, 2 nd March<br />

2010<br />

FAO / VERCUNI, A. et ZHLLIMA, E.: The food supply and distribution system of Tirana,<br />

Albania; 2008<br />

General Directory of Customs, Albania EC Health and Consumers Directorate-General,<br />

Directorate F - Food and Veterinary Office, DG (SANCO) /8127/2009 - CP Pre – Draft,<br />

Country Profile of Albania on Food and Feed Safety, Animal Health, Animal Welfare and<br />

Plant Health; 2009<br />

GIL, J.M. Gil, GRACIA, A. and ANGULA, A.M. Angula; Trends in the consumption of animal<br />

food products in Mediterranean countries; Unidad de Economía Agraria, SIA-DGA, Zaragoza,<br />

Spain; Departamento de Análisis Económico, Universidad de Zaragoza, Spain<br />

Kaerntner Bauer, Markt & Preis, No 9, 2010 (Austrian Farmer Magazin)<br />

Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Consumer Protection (MAFCP); Agriculture and Food<br />

<strong>Sector</strong> Strategy 2007 – 2013; 2007<br />

Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Consumer Protection (MAFCP); Statistical Yearbook 2009<br />

(preliminary version); 2010<br />

Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Consumer Protection (MAFCP); Technical Report; 2008<br />

Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Consumer Protection (MAFCP); Statistical Yearbook 2009<br />

Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Consumer Protection (MAFCP); Slaughterhouses in<br />

Albania, present situation and prospect; 2006<br />

National Strategy for Development and Integration (NSDI) 2007-2013<br />

SHUNDI, Andrea Prof.: Country Pasture/Forage Resource Profiles Albania; 2006)<br />

LUMB, Stuart; Albanian Pig Production; 2004<br />

UNDP Albania / MAUTNER MARKHOF, M. et al; “Strengthening the Marketing of Small<br />

Ruminants” Project, 2005<br />

UNDP Albania / MOLLA A; Base Line Study on Production Systems and Economics of<br />

Sheep Husbandry in Southern Albania, 2010<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 69


Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study<br />

UNDP Albania; The Agribusiness <strong>Sector</strong> in Albania, Inward Investment Opportunities; 05<br />

World Bank; Albania: Strategic Policies for a More Competitive Agriculture <strong>Sector</strong>;<br />

Discussion Draft; 2007<br />

World Bank; Albania – Agro-processing development project, 1995<br />

http://ec.europa.eu/budget/inforeuro/index.cfm?fuseaction=currency_historique&currency=6&<br />

Language=en<br />

http://www.ama-marketing.at/home/groups/7/Pro_Kopf_Verbrauch_Fleisch.pdf<br />

http://www.undp.org.al/index.php?page=detail&id=147<br />

http://www.fleischerhandwerk.de/upload/pdf/GB08_Fleischverzehr.pdf (about sheep<br />

consumption in Greece)<br />

http://www.animal-health-online.de/lme/2010/05/10/eu-pro-kopf-verbrauch-vongeflugelfleisch-leicht-gestiegen/4621/<br />

(about poultry consumption in the EU 27)<br />

Meat <strong>Sector</strong> Study, page 70

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!