The Call of the Wild - Bibliotecadigital.puc-campinas.edu.br
The Call of the Wild - Bibliotecadigital.puc-campinas.edu.br
The Call of the Wild - Bibliotecadigital.puc-campinas.edu.br
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
AC@;6E@7C6663@@<<<strong>br</strong> />
5($/,=$d®2<<strong>br</strong> />
@TQ/MXX[R`TQCUXP<<strong>br</strong> />
6MOW8[ZP[Z<<strong>br</strong> />
&KDSWHU,<<strong>br</strong> />
,QWRWKH3ULPLWLYH<<strong>br</strong> />
2OGORQJLQJVQRPDGLFOHDS<<strong>br</strong> />
&KDILQJDWFXVWRPVFKDLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
$JDLQIURPLWVEUXPDOVOHHS<<strong>br</strong> />
:DNHQVWKHIHULQHVWUDLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNGLGQRWUHDGWKHQHZVSDSHUVRUKHZRXOGKDYHNQRZQWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
WURXEOHZDVEUHZLQJQRWDORQHIRUKLPVHOIEXWIRUHYHU\WLGH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDWHUGRJVWURQJRIPXVFOHDQGZLWKZDUPORQJKDLUIURP3XJHW<<strong>br</strong> />
6RXQGWR6DQ'LHJR%HFDXVHPHQJURSLQJLQWKH$UFWLFGDUNQHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGIRXQGD\HOORZPHWDODQGEHFDXVHVWHDPVKLSDQGWUDQVSRUWDWLRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
FRPSDQLHVZHUHERRPLQJWKHILQGWKRXVDQGVRIPHQZHUHUXVKLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWRWKH1RUWKODQG7KHVHPHQZDQWHGGRJVDQGWKHGRJVWKH\<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDQWHGZHUHKHDY\GRJVZLWKVWURQJPXVFOHVE\ZKLFKWRWRLODQG<<strong>br</strong> />
IXUU\FRDWVWRSURWHFWWKHPIURPWKHIURVW<<strong>br</strong> />
1
%XFNOLYHGDWDELJKRXVHLQWKHVXQNLVVHG6DQWD&ODUD9DOOH\<<strong>br</strong> />
-XGJH0LOOHUVSODFHLWZDVFDOOHG,WVWRRGEDFNIURPWKHURDG<<strong>br</strong> />
KDOIKLGGHQDPRQJWKHWUHHVWKURXJKZKLFKJOLPSVHVFRXOGEH<<strong>br</strong> />
FDXJKWRIWKHZLGHFRROYHUDQGDWKDWUDQDURXQGLWVIRXUVLGHV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHKRXVHZDVDSSURDFKHGE\JUDYHOOHGGULYHZD\VZKLFKZRXQGDERXW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURXJKZLGHVSUHDGLQJODZQVDQGXQGHUWKHLQWHUODFLQJERXJKVRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WDOOSRSODUV$WWKHUHDUWKLQJVZHUHRQHYHQDPRUHVSDFLRXV<<strong>br</strong> />
VFDOHWKDQDWWKHIURQW7KHUHZHUHJUHDWVWDEOHVZKHUHDGR]HQ<<strong>br</strong> />
JURRPVDQGER\VKHOGIRUWKURZVRIYLQHFODGVHUYDQWVFRWWDJHV<<strong>br</strong> />
DQHQGOHVVDQGRUGHUO\DUUD\RIRXWKRXVHVORQJJUDSHDUERUV<<strong>br</strong> />
JUHHQSDVWXUHVRUFKDUGVDQGEHUU\SDWFKHV7KHQWKHUHZDVWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
SXPSLQJSODQWIRUWKHDUWHVLDQZHOODQGWKHELJFHPHQWWDQNZKHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
-XGJH0LOOHUVER\VWRRNWKHLUPRUQLQJSOXQJHDQGNHSWFRROLQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
KRWDIWHUQRRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGRYHUWKLVJUHDWGHPHVQH%XFNUXOHG+HUHKHZDVERUQDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
KHUHKHKDGOLYHGWKHIRXU\HDUVRIKLVOLIH,WZDVWUXHWKHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHUHRWKHUGRJV7KHUHFRXOGQRWEXWEHRWKHUGRJVRQVRYDVWD<<strong>br</strong> />
SODFHEXWWKH\GLGQRWFRXQW7KH\FDPHDQGZHQWUHVLGHGLQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
SRSXORXVNHQQHOVRUOLYHGREVFXUHO\LQWKHUHFHVVHVRIWKHKRXVH<<strong>br</strong> />
DIWHUWKHIDVKLRQRI7RRWVWKH-DSDQHVHSXJRU
GRJ1HYHUWKHOHVVRQHKXQGUHGDQGIRUW\SRXQGVWRZKLFKZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
DGGHGWKHGLJQLW\WKDWFRPHVRIJRRGOLYLQJDQGXQLYHUVDOUHVSHFW<<strong>br</strong> />
HQDEOHGKLPWRFDUU\KLPVHOILQULJKWUR\DOIDVKLRQ'XULQJWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IRXU\HDUVVLQFHKLVSXSS\KRRGKHKDGOLYHGWKHOLIHRIDVDWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
DULVWRFUDWKHKDGDILQHSULGHLQKLPVHOIZDVHYHQDWULIOH<<strong>br</strong> />
HJRWLVWLFDODVFRXQWU\JHQWOHPHQVRPHWLPHVEHFRPHEHFDXVHRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHLULQVXODUVLWXDWLRQ%XWKHKDGVDYHGKLPVHOIE\QRWEHFRPLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
DPHUHSDPSHUHGKRXVHGRJ+XQWLQJDQGNLQGUHGRXWGRRUGHOLJKWV<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGNHSWGRZQWKHIDWDQGKDUGHQHGKLVPXVFOHVDQGWRKLPDVWR<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHFROGWXEELQJUDFHVWKHORYHRIZDWHUKDGEHHQDWRQLFDQGD<<strong>br</strong> />
KHDOWKSUHVHUYHU<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGWKLVZDVWKHPDQQHURIGRJ%XFNZDVLQWKHIDOORIZKHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH.ORQGLNHVWULNHGUDJJHGPHQIURPDOOWKHZRUOGLQWRWKHIUR]HQ<<strong>br</strong> />
1RUWK%XW%XFNGLGQRWUHDGWKHQHZVSDSHUVDQGKHGLGQRWNQRZ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDW0DQXHORQHRIWKHJDUGHQHUVKHOSHUVZDVDQXQGHVLUDEOH<<strong>br</strong> />
DFTXDLQWDQFH0DQXHOKDGRQHEHVHWWLQJVLQ+HORYHGWRSOD\<<strong>br</strong> />
&KLQHVHORWWHU\$OVRLQKLVJDPEOLQJKHKDGRQHEHVHWWLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHDNQHVVIDLWKLQDV\VWHPDQGWKLVPDGHKLVGDPQDWLRQFHUWDLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
)RUWRSOD\DV\VWHPUHTXLUHVPRQH\ZKLOHWKHZDJHVRID<<strong>br</strong> />
JDUGHQHUVKHOSHUGRQRWODSRYHUWKHQHHGVRIDZLIHDQGQXPHURXV<<strong>br</strong> />
SURJHQ\<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH-XGJHZDVDWDPHHWLQJRIWKH5DLVLQ*URZHUV$VVRFLDWLRQDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHER\VZHUHEXV\RUJDQL]LQJDQDWKOHWLFFOXERQWKHPHPRUDEOH<<strong>br</strong> />
QLJKWRI0DQXHOVWUHDFKHU\1RRQHVDZKLPDQG%XFNJRRII<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURXJKWKHRUFKDUGRQZKDW%XFNLPDJLQHGZDVPHUHO\DVWUROO<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGZLWKWKHH[FHSWLRQRIDVROLWDU\PDQQRRQHVDZWKHPDUULYH<<strong>br</strong> />
DWWKHOLWWOHIODJVWDWLRQNQRZQDV&ROOHJH3DUN7KLVPDQWDONHG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWK0DQXHODQGPRQH\FKLQNHGEHWZHHQWKHP<<strong>br</strong> />
FRPPDQG%XWWRKLVVXUSULVHWKHURSHWLJKWHQHGDURXQGKLVQHFN<<strong>br</strong> />
VKXWWLQJRIIKLVEUHDWK,QTXLFNUDJHKHVSUDQJDWWKHPDQZKR<<strong>br</strong> />
PHWKLPKDOIZD\JUDSSOHGKLPFORVHE\WKHWKURDWDQGZLWKDGHIW<<strong>br</strong> />
WZLVWWKUHZKLPRYHURQKLVEDFN7KHQWKHURSHWLJKWHQHG<<strong>br</strong> />
PHUFLOHVVO\ZKLOH%XFNVWUXJJOHGLQDIXU\KLVWRQJXHOROOLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
RXWRIKLVPRXWKDQGKLVJUHDWFKHVWSDQWLQJIXWLOHO\1HYHULQ<<strong>br</strong> />
DOOKLVOLIHKDGKHEHHQVRYLOHO\WUHDWHGDQGQHYHULQDOOKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
OLIHKDGKHEHHQVRDQJU\%XWKLVVWUHQJWKHEEHGKLVH\HV<<strong>br</strong> />
JOD]HGDQGKHNQHZQRWKLQJZKHQWKHWUDLQZDVIODJJHGDQGWKHWZR<<strong>br</strong> />
PHQWKUHZKLPLQWRWKHEDJJDJHFDU<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHQH[WKHNQHZKHZDVGLPO\DZDUHWKDWKLVWRQJXHZDVKXUWLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGWKDWKHZDVEHLQJMROWHGDORQJLQVRPHNLQGRIDFRQYH\DQFH<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHKRDUVHVKULHNRIDORFRPRWLYHZKLVWOLQJDFURVVLQJWROGKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKHUHKHZDV+HKDGWUDYHOOHGWRRRIWHQZLWKWKH-XGJHQRWWR<<strong>br</strong> />
NQRZWKHVHQVDWLRQRIULGLQJLQDEDJJDJHFDU+HRSHQHGKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
H\HVDQGLQWRWKHPFDPHWKHXQEULGOHGDQJHURIDNLGQDSSHGNLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHPDQVSUDQJIRUKLVWKURDWEXW%XFNZDVWRRTXLFNIRUKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
+LVMDZVFORVHGRQWKHKDQGQRUGLGWKH\UHOD[WLOOKLVVHQVHV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHUHFKRNHGRXWRIKLPRQFHPRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHNLGQDSSHUXQGLGWKHEORRG\ZUDSSLQJVDQGORRNHGDWKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
ODFHUDWHGKDQG,I,GRQWJHWWKHK\GURSKRE\<<strong>br</strong> />
,WOOEHEHFDXVH\RXZDVERUQWRKDQJODXJKHGWKHVDORRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
NHHSHU+HUHOHQGPHDKDQGEHIRUH\RXSXOO\RXUIUHLJKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
DGGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
'D]HGVXIIHULQJLQWROHUDEOHSDLQIURPWKURDWDQGWRQJXHZLWKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
OLIHKDOIWKURWWOHGRXWRIKLP%XFNDWWHPSWHGWRIDFHKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
WRUPHQWRUV%XWKHZDVWKURZQGRZQDQGFKRNHGUHSHDWHGO\WLOO<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\VXFFHHGHGLQILOLQJWKHKHDY\EUDVVFROODUIURPRIIKLVQHFN<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHQWKHURSHZDVUHPRYHGDQGKHZDVIOXQJLQWRDFDJHOLNHFUDWH<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHUHKHOD\IRUWKHUHPDLQGHURIWKHZHDU\QLJKWQXUVLQJKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZUDWKDQGZRXQGHGSULGH+HFRXOGQRWXQGHUVWDQGZKDWLWDOO<<strong>br</strong> />
PHDQW:KDWGLGWKH\ZDQWZLWKKLPWKHVHVWUDQJHPHQ":K\ZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\NHHSLQJKLPSHQWXSLQWKLVQDUURZFUDWH"+HGLGQRWNQRZ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZK\EXWKHIHOWRSSUHVVHGE\WKHYDJXHVHQVHRILPSHQGLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
FDODPLW\6HYHUDOWLPHVGXULQJWKHQLJKWKHVSUDQJWRKLVIHHW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKHQWKHVKHGGRRUUDWWOHGRSHQH[SHFWLQJWRVHHWKH-XGJHRU<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHER\VDWOHDVW%XWHDFKWLPHLWZDVWKHEXOJLQJIDFHRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VDORRQNHHSHUWKDWSHHUHGLQDWKLPE\WKHVLFNO\OLJKWRID<<strong>br</strong> />
WDOORZFDQGOH$QGHDFKWLPHWKHMR\IXOEDUNWKDWWUHPEOHGLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNVWKURDWZDVWZLVWHGLQWRDVDYDJHJURZO<<strong>br</strong> />
%XWWKHVDORRQNHHSHUOHWKLPDORQHDQGLQWKHPRUQLQJIRXUPHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
HQWHUHGDQGSLFNHGXSWKHFUDWH0RUHWRUPHQWRUV%XFNGHFLGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUWKH\ZHUHHYLOORRNLQJFUHDWXUHVUDJJHGDQGXQNHPSWDQGKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VWRUPHGDQGUDJHGDWWKHPWKURXJKWKHEDUV7KH\RQO\ODXJKHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
SRNHGVWLFNVDWKLPZKLFKKHSURPSWO\DVVDLOHGZLWKKLVWHHWK<<strong>br</strong> />
WLOOKHUHDOL]HGWKDWWKDWZDVZKDWWKH\ZDQWHG:KHUHXSRQKHOD\<<strong>br</strong> />
GRZQVXOOHQO\DQGDOORZHGWKHFUDWHWREHOLIWHGLQWRDZDJRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHQKHDQGWKHFUDWHLQZKLFKKHZDVLPSULVRQHGEHJDQDSDVVDJH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURXJKPDQ\KDQGV&OHUNVLQWKHH[SUHVVRIILFHWRRNFKDUJHRI<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPKHZDVFDUWHGDERXWLQDQRWKHUZDJRQDWUXFNFDUULHGKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKDQDVVRUWPHQWRIER[HVDQGSDUFHOVXSRQDIHUU\VWHDPHUKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVWUXFNHGRIIWKHVWHDPHULQWRDJUHDWUDLOZD\GHSRWDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
ILQDOO\KHZDVGHSRVLWHGLQDQH[SUHVVFDU<<strong>br</strong> />
)RUWZRGD\VDQGQLJKWVWKLVH[SUHVVFDUZDVGUDJJHGDORQJDWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WDLORIVKULHNLQJORFRPRWLYHVDQGIRUWZRGD\VDQGQLJKWV%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
QHLWKHUDWHQRUGUDQN,QKLVDQJHUKHKDGPHWWKHILUVWDGYDQFHV<<strong>br</strong> />
RIWKHH[SUHVVPHVVHQJHUVZLWKJURZOVDQGWKH\KDGUHWDOLDWHGE\<<strong>br</strong> />
WHDVLQJKLP:KHQKHIOXQJKLPVHOIDJDLQVWWKHEDUVTXLYHULQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
5
DQGIURWKLQJWKH\ODXJKHGDWKLPDQGWDXQWHGKLP7KH\JURZOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGEDUNHGOLNHGHWHVWDEOHGRJVPHZHGDQGIODSSHGWKHLUDUPVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
FURZHG,WZDVDOOYHU\VLOO\KHNQHZEXWWKHUHIRUHWKHPRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
RXWUDJHWRKLVGLJQLW\DQGKLVDQJHUZD[HGDQGZD[HG+HGLGQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
PLQGWKHKXQJHUVRPXFKEXWWKHODFNRIZDWHUFDXVHGKLPVHYHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
VXIIHULQJDQGIDQQHGKLVZUDWKWRIHYHUSLWFK)RUWKDWPDWWHU<<strong>br</strong> />
KLJKVWUXQJDQGILQHO\VHQVLWLYHWKHLOOWUHDWPHQWKDGIOXQJKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWRDIHYHUZKLFKZDVIHGE\WKHLQIODPPDWLRQRIKLVSDUFKHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VZROOHQWKURDWDQGWRQJXH<<strong>br</strong> />
+HZDVJODGIRURQHWKLQJWKHURSHZDVRIIKLVQHFN7KDWKDG<<strong>br</strong> />
JLYHQWKHPDQXQIDLUDGYDQWDJHEXWQRZWKDWLWZDVRIIKHZRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
VKRZWKHP7KH\ZRXOGQHYHUJHWDQRWKHUURSHDURXQGKLVQHFN<<strong>br</strong> />
8SRQWKDWKHZDVUHVROYHG)RUWZRGD\VDQGQLJKWVKHQHLWKHUDWH<<strong>br</strong> />
QRUGUDQNDQGGXULQJWKRVHWZRGD\VDQGQLJKWVRIWRUPHQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
DFFXPXODWHGDIXQGRIZUDWKWKDWERGHGLOOIRUZKRHYHUILUVWIHOO<<strong>br</strong> />
IRXORIKLP+LVH\HVWXUQHGEORRGVKRWDQGKHZDVPHWDPRUSKRVHG<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWRDUDJLQJILHQG6RFKDQJHGZDVKHWKDWWKH-XGJHKLPVHOI<<strong>br</strong> />
ZRXOGQRWKDYHUHFRJQL]HGKLPDQGWKHH[SUHVVPHVVHQJHUVEUHDWKHG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKUHOLHIZKHQWKH\EXQGOHGKLPRIIWKHWUDLQDW6HDWWOH<<strong>br</strong> />
)RXUPHQJLQJHUO\FDUULHGWKHFUDWHIURPWKHZDJRQLQWRDVPDOO<<strong>br</strong> />
KLJKZDOOHGEDFN\DUG$VWRXWPDQZLWKDUHGVZHDWHUWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
VDJJHGJHQHURXVO\DWWKHQHFNFDPHRXWDQGVLJQHGWKHERRNIRU<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHGULYHU7KDWZDVWKHPDQ%XFNGLYLQHGWKHQH[WWRUPHQWRU<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGKHKXUOHGKLPVHOIVDYDJHO\DJDLQVWWKHEDUV7KHPDQVPLOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
JULPO\DQGEURXJKWDKDWFKHWDQGDFOXE<<strong>br</strong> />
VXIILFLHQWIRUWKHSDVVDJHRI%XFNVERG\$WWKHVDPHWLPHKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GURSSHGWKHKDWFKHWDQGVKLIWHGWKHFOXEWRKLVULJKWKDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
$QG%XFNZDVWUXO\DUHGH\HGGHYLODVKHGUHZKLPVHOIWRJHWKHU<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUWKHVSULQJKDLUEULVWOLQJPRXWKIRDPLQJDPDGJOLWWHULQ<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVEORRGVKRWH\HV6WUDLJKWDWWKHPDQKHODXQFKHGKLVRQH<<strong>br</strong> />
KXQGUHGDQGIRUW\SRXQGVRIIXU\VXUFKDUJHGZLWKWKHSHQWSDVVLRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
RIWZRGD\VDQGQLJKWV,QPLGDLUMXVWDVKLVMDZVZHUHDERXW<<strong>br</strong> />
WRFORVHRQWKHPDQKHUHFHLYHGDVKRFNWKDWFKHFNHGKLVERG\DQG<<strong>br</strong> />
EURXJKWKLVWHHWKWRJHWKHUZLWKDQDJRQL]LQJFOLS+HZKLUOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
RYHUIHWFKLQJWKHJURXQGRQKLVEDFNDQGVLGH+HKDGQHYHUEHHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
VWUXFNE\DFOXELQKLVOLIHDQGGLGQRWXQGHUVWDQG:LWKD<<strong>br</strong> />
VQDUOWKDWZDVSDUWEDUNDQGPRUHVFUHDPKHZDVDJDLQRQKLVIHHW<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGODXQFKHGLQWRWKHDLU$QGDJDLQWKHVKRFNFDPHDQGKHZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
EURXJKWFUXVKLQJO\WRWKHJURXQG7KLVWLPHKHZDVDZDUHWKDWLW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVWKHFOXEEXWKLVPDGQHVVNQHZQRFDXWLRQ$GR]HQWLPHVKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FKDUJHGDQGDVRIWHQWKHFOXEEURNHWKHFKDUJHDQGVPDVKHGKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
GRZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
$IWHUDSDUWLFXODUO\ILHUFHEORZKHFUDZOHGWRKLVIHHWWRR<<strong>br</strong> />
GD]HGWRUXVK+HVWDJJHUHGOLPSO\DERXWWKHEORRGIORZLQJIURP<<strong>br</strong> />
QRVHDQGPRXWKDQGHDUVKLVEHDXWLIXOFRDWVSUD\HGDQGIOHFNHG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKEORRG\VODYHU7KHQWKHPDQDGYDQFHGDQGGHOLEHUDWHO\GHDOW<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPDIULJKWIXOEORZRQWKHQRVH$OOWKHSDLQKHKDGHQGXUHGZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
DVQRWKLQJFRPSDUHGZLWKWKHH[TXLVLWHDJRQ\RIWKLV:LWKDURDU<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWZDVDOPRVWOLRQOLNHLQLWVIHURFLW\KHDJDLQKXUOHGKLPVHOI<<strong>br</strong> />
DWWKHPDQ%XWWKHPDQVKLIWLQJWKHFOXEIURPULJKWWROHIW<<strong>br</strong> />
FRROO\FDXJKWKLPE\WKHXQGHUMDZDWWKHVDPHWLPHZUHQFKLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
GRZQZDUGDQGEDFNZDUG%XFNGHVFULEHGDFRPSOHWHFLUFOHLQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
DLUDQGKDOIRIDQRWKHUWKHQFUDVKHGWRWKHJURXQGRQKLVKHDG<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGFKHVW<<strong>br</strong> />
)RUWKHODVWWLPHKHUXVKHG7KHPDQVWUXFNWKHVKUHZGEORZKH<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGSXUSRVHO\ZLWKKHOGIRUVRORQJDQG%XFNFUXPSOHGXSDQGZHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
GRZQNQRFNHGXWWHUO\VHQVHOHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
+HVQRVORXFKDWGRJEUHDNLQWKDWVZRW,VD\RQHRIWKHPHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
RQWKHZDOOFULHGHQWKXVLDVWLFDOO\<<strong>br</strong> />
'UXWKHUEUHDNFD\XVHVDQ\GD\DQGWZLFHRQ6XQGD\VZDVWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
UHSO\RIWKHGULYHUDVKHFOLPEHGRQWKHZDJRQDQGVWDUWHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
KRUVHV<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNVVHQVHVFDPHEDFNWRKLPEXWQRWKLVVWUHQJWK+HOD\<<strong>br</strong> />
7
ZKHUHKHKDGIDOOHQDQGIURPWKHUHKHZDWFKHGWKHPDQLQWKHUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
VZHDWHU<<strong>br</strong> />
$QVZHUVWRWKHQDPHRI%XFNWKHPDQVROLORTXL]HGTXRWLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
IURPWKHVDORRQNHHSHUVOHWWHUZKLFKKDGDQQRXQFHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FRQVLJQPHQWRIWKHFUDWHDQGFRQWHQWV:HOO%XFNP\ER\KH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHQWRQLQDJHQLDOYRLFHZHYHKDGRXUOLWWOHUXFWLRQDQGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
EHVWWKLQJZHFDQGRLVWROHWLWJRDWWKDW
GHFLGHGDQGWKHKDOIEUHHGEHJDQKLVULVHLQ%XFNVHVWLPDWLRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHRWKHUGRJPDGHQRDGYDQFHVQRUUHFHLYHGDQ\DOVRKHGLGQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
DWWHPSWWRVWHDOIURPWKHQHZFRPHUV+HZDVDJORRP\PRURVH<<strong>br</strong> />
IHOORZDQGKHVKRZHG&XUO\SODLQO\WKDWDOOKHGHVLUHGZDVWREH<<strong>br</strong> />
OHIWDORQHDQGIXUWKHUWKDWWKHUHZRXOGEHWURXEOHLIKHZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
QRWOHIWDORQH'DYHKHZDVFDOOHGDQGKHDWHDQGVOHSWRU<<strong>br</strong> />
\DZQHGEHWZHHQWLPHVDQGWRRNLQWHUHVWLQQRWKLQJQRWHYHQZKHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH1DUZKDOFURVVHG4XHHQ&KDUORWWH6RXQGDQGUROOHGDQGSLWFKHG<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGEXFNHGOLNHDWKLQJSRVVHVVHG:KHQ%XFNDQG&XUO\JUHZ<<strong>br</strong> />
H[FLWHGKDOIZLOGZLWKIHDUKHUDLVHGKLVKHDGDVWKRXJK<<strong>br</strong> />
DQQR\HGIDYRUHGWKHPZLWKDQLQFXULRXVJODQFH\DZQHGDQGZHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
WRVOHHSDJDLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
'D\DQGQLJKWWKHVKLSWKUREEHGWRWKHWLUHOHVVSXOVHRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
SURSHOOHUDQGWKRXJKRQHGD\ZDVYHU\OLNHDQRWKHULWZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
DSSDUHQWWR%XFNWKDWWKHZHDWKHUZDVVWHDGLO\JURZLQJFROGHU$W<<strong>br</strong> />
ODVWRQHPRUQLQJWKHSURSHOOHUZDVTXLHWDQGWKH1DUZKDOZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
SHUYDGHGZLWKDQDWPRVSKHUHRIH[FLWHPHQW+HIHOWLWDVGLGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
RWKHUGRJVDQGNQHZWKDWDFKDQJHZDVDWKDQG)UDQFRLVOHDVKHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHPDQGEURXJKWWKHPRQGHFN$WWKHILUVWVWHSXSRQWKHFROG<<strong>br</strong> />
VXUIDFH%XFNVIHHWVDQNLQWRDZKLWHPXVK\VRPHWKLQJYHU\OLNH<<strong>br</strong> />
PXG+HVSUDQJEDFNZLWKDVQRUW0RUHRIWKLVZKLWHVWXIIZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
IDOOLQJWKURXJKWKHDLU+HVKRRNKLPVHOIEXWPRUHRILWIHOO<<strong>br</strong> />
XSRQKLP+HVQLIIHGLWFXULRXVO\WKHQOLFNHGVRPHXSRQKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
WRQJXH,WELWOLNHILUHDQGWKHQH[WLQVWDQWZDVJRQH7KLV<<strong>br</strong> />
SX]]OHGKLP+HWULHGLWDJDLQZLWKWKHVDPHUHVXOW7KH<<strong>br</strong> />
RQORRNHUVODXJKHGXSURDULRXVO\DQGKHIHOWDVKDPHGKHNQHZQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZK\IRULWZDVKLVILUVWVQRZ<<strong>br</strong> />
&KDSWHU,,<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH/DZRI&OXEDQG)DQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNVILUVWGD\RQWKH'\HDEHDFKZDVOLNHDQLJKWPDUH(YHU\<<strong>br</strong> />
KRXUZDVILOOHGZLWKVKRFNDQGVXUSULVH+HKDGEHHQVXGGHQO\<<strong>br</strong> />
MHUNHGIURPWKHKHDUWRIFLYLOL]DWLRQDQGIOXQJLQWRWKHKHDUWRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLQJVSULPRUGLDO1ROD]\VXQNLVVHGOLIHZDVWKLVZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
QRWKLQJWRGREXWORDIDQGEHERUHG+HUHZDVQHLWKHUSHDFHQRU<<strong>br</strong> />
UHVWQRUDPRPHQWVVDIHW\$OOZDVFRQIXVLRQDQGDFWLRQDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
HYHU\PRPHQWOLIHDQGOLPEZHUHLQSHULO7KHUHZDVLPSHUDWLYH<<strong>br</strong> />
10
QHHGWREHFRQVWDQWO\DOHUWIRUWKHVHGRJVDQGPHQZHUHQRWWRZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
GRJVDQGPHQ7KH\ZHUHVDYDJHVDOORIWKHPZKRNQHZQRODZEXW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHODZRIFOXEDQGIDQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
+HKDGQHYHUVHHQGRJVILJKWDVWKHVHZROILVKFUHDWXUHVIRXJKW<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGKLVILUVWH[SHULHQFHWDXJKWKLPDQXQIRUJHWDEOHOHVVRQ,WLV<<strong>br</strong> />
WUXHLWZDVDYLFDULRXVH[SHULHQFHHOVHKHZRXOGQRWKDYHOLYHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WRSURILWE\LW&XUO\ZDVWKHYLFWLP7KH\ZHUHFDPSHGQHDUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ORJVWRUHZKHUHVKHLQKHUIULHQGO\ZD\PDGHDGYDQFHVWRD<<strong>br</strong> />
KXVN\GRJWKHVL]HRIDIXOOJURZQZROIWKRXJKQRWKDOIVRODUJH<<strong>br</strong> />
DVVKH7KHUHZDVQRZDUQLQJRQO\DOHDSLQOLNHDIODVKD<<strong>br</strong> />
PHWDOOLFFOLSRIWHHWKDOHDSRXWHTXDOO\VZLIWDQG&XUO\VIDFH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVULSSHGRSHQIURPH\HWRMDZ<<strong>br</strong> />
,WZDVWKHZROIPDQQHURIILJKWLQJWRVWULNHDQGOHDSDZD\EXW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHUHZDVPRUHWRLWWKDQWKLV7KLUW\RUIRUW\KXVNLHVUDQWR<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHVSRWDQGVXUURXQGHGWKHFRPEDWDQWVLQDQLQWHQWDQGVLOHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
FLUFOH%XFNGLGQRWFRPSUHKHQGWKDWVLOHQWLQWHQWQHVVQRUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
HDJHUZD\ZLWKZKLFKWKH\ZHUHOLFNLQJWKHLUFKRSV&XUO\UXVKHG<<strong>br</strong> />
KHUDQWDJRQLVWZKRVWUXFNDJDLQDQGOHDSHGDVLGH+HPHWKHU<<strong>br</strong> />
QH[WUXVKZLWKKLVFKHVWLQDSHFXOLDUIDVKLRQWKDWWXPEOHGKHU<<strong>br</strong> />
RIIKHUIHHW6KHQHYHUUHJDLQHGWKHP7KLVZDVZKDWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
RQORRNLQJKXVNLHVKDGZDLWHGIRU7KH\FORVHGLQXSRQKHU<<strong>br</strong> />
VQDUOLQJDQG\HOSLQJDQGVKHZDVEXULHGVFUHDPLQJZLWKDJRQ\<<strong>br</strong> />
EHQHDWKWKHEULVWOLQJPDVVRIERGLHV<<strong>br</strong> />
6RVXGGHQZDVLWDQGVRXQH[SHFWHGWKDW%XFNZDVWDNHQDEDFN<<strong>br</strong> />
+HVDZ6SLW]UXQRXWKLVVFDUOHWWRQJXHLQDZD\KHKDGRI<<strong>br</strong> />
ODXJKLQJDQGKHVDZ)UDQFRLVVZLQJLQJDQD[HVSULQJLQWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
PHVVRIGRJV7KUHHPHQZLWKFOXEVZHUHKHOSLQJKLPWRVFDWWHU<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHP,WGLGQRWWDNHORQJ7ZRPLQXWHVIURPWKHWLPH&XUO\ZHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
GRZQWKHODVWRIKHUDVVDLODQWVZHUHFOXEEHGRII%XWVKHOD\<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHUHOLPSDQGOLIHOHVVLQWKHEORRG\WUDPSOHGVQRZDOPRVW<<strong>br</strong> />
OLWHUDOO\WRUQWRSLHFHVWKHVZDUWKDOIEUHHGVWDQGLQJRYHUKHU<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGFXUVLQJKRUULEO\7KHVFHQHRIWHQFDPHEDFNWR%XFNWR<<strong>br</strong> />
WURXEOHKLPLQKLVVOHHS6RWKDWZDVWKHZD\1RIDLUSOD\<<strong>br</strong> />
2QFHGRZQWKDWZDVWKHHQGRI\RX:HOOKHZRXOGVHHWRLWWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
KHQHYHUZHQWGRZQ6SLW]UDQRXWKLVWRQJXHDQGODXJKHGDJDLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGIURPWKDWPRPHQW%XFNKDWHGKLPZLWKDELWWHUDQGGHDWKOHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
KDWUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
%HIRUHKHKDGUHFRYHUHGIURPWKHVKRFNFDXVHGE\WKHWUDJLF<<strong>br</strong> />
SDVVLQJRI&XUO\KHUHFHLYHGDQRWKHUVKRFN)UDQFRLVIDVWHQHG<<strong>br</strong> />
XSRQKLPDQDUUDQJHPHQWRIVWUDSVDQGEXFNOHV,WZDVDKDUQHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
11
VXFKDVKHKDGVHHQWKHJURRPVSXWRQWKHKRUVHVDWKRPH$QGDV<<strong>br</strong> />
KHKDGVHHQKRUVHVZRUNVRKHZDVVHWWRZRUNKDXOLQJ)UDQFRLV<<strong>br</strong> />
RQDVOHGWRWKHIRUHVWWKDWIULQJHGWKHYDOOH\DQGUHWXUQLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKDORDGRIILUHZRRG7KRXJKKLVGLJQLW\ZDVVRUHO\KXUWE\<<strong>br</strong> />
WKXVEHLQJPDGHDGUDXJKWDQLPDOKHZDVWRRZLVHWRUHEHO+H<<strong>br</strong> />
EXFNOHGGRZQZLWKDZLOODQGGLGKLVEHVWWKRXJKLWZDVDOOQHZ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGVWUDQJH)UDQFRLVZDVVWHPGHPDQGLQJLQVWDQWREHGLHQFHDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
E\YLUWXHRIKLVZKLSUHFHLYLQJLQVWDQWREHGLHQFHZKLOH'DYHZKR<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVDQH[SHULHQFHGZKHHOHUQLSSHG%XFNVKLQGTXDUWHUVZKHQHYHU<<strong>br</strong> />
KHZDVLQHUURU6SLW]ZDVWKHOHDGHUOLNHZLVHH[SHULHQFHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLOHKHFRXOGQRWDOZD\VJHWDW%XFNKHJURZOHGVKDUSUHSURRI<<strong>br</strong> />
QRZDQGDJDLQRUFXQQLQJO\WKUHZKLVZHLJKWLQWKHWUDFHVWRMHUN<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNLQWRWKHZD\KHVKRXOGJR%XFNOHDUQHGHDVLO\DQGXQGHU<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHFRPELQHGWXLWLRQRIKLVWZRPDWHVDQG)UDQFRLVPDGHUHPDUNDEOH<<strong>br</strong> />
SURJUHVV(UHWKH\UHWXUQHGWRFDPSKHNQHZHQRXJKWRVWRSDW<<strong>br</strong> />
KRWRJRDKHDGDWPXVKWRVZLQJZLGHRQWKHEHQGVDQGWR<<strong>br</strong> />
NHHSFOHDURIWKHZKHHOHUZKHQWKHORDGHGVOHGVKRWGRZQKLOODW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHLUKHHOV<<strong>br</strong> />
7UHHYDLUJRRGGRJV)UDQFRLVWROG3HUUDXOW'DW%XFNKHHP<<strong>br</strong> />
SRROODNKHOO,WLFKKHHPTXHHNDVDQ\WLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
%\DIWHUQRRQ3HUUDXOWZKRZDVLQDKXUU\WREHRQWKHWUDLOZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVGHVSDWFKHVUHWXUQHGZLWKWZRPRUHGRJV%LOOHHDQG-RH<<strong>br</strong> />
KHFDOOHGWKHPWZREURWKHUVDQGWUXHKXVNLHVERWK6RQVRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
RQHPRWKHUWKRXJKWKH\ZHUHWKH\ZHUHDVGLIIHUHQWDVGD\DQG<<strong>br</strong> />
QLJKW%LOOHHVRQHIDXOWZDVKLVH[FHVVLYHJRRGQDWXUHZKLOH<<strong>br</strong> />
-RHZDVWKHYHU\RSSRVLWHVRXUDQGLQWURVSHFWLYHZLWKD<<strong>br</strong> />
SHUSHWXDOVQDUODQGDPDOLJQDQWH\H%XFNUHFHLYHGWKHPLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
FRPUDGHO\IDVKLRQ'DYHLJQRUHGWKHPZKLOH6SLW]SURFHHGHGWR<<strong>br</strong> />
WKUDVKILUVWRQHDQGWKHQWKHRWKHU%LOOHHZDJJHGKLVWDLO<<strong>br</strong> />
DSSHDVLQJO\WXUQHGWRUXQZKHQKHVDZWKDWDSSHDVHPHQWZDVRIQR<<strong>br</strong> />
DYDLODQGFULHGVWLOODSSHDVLQJO\ZKHQ6SLW]VVKDUSWHHWK<<strong>br</strong> />
VFRUHGKLVIODQN%XWQRPDWWHUKRZ6SLW]FLUFOHG-RHZKLUOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
DURXQGRQKLVKHHOVWRIDFHKLPPDQHEULVWOLQJHDUVODLGEDFN<<strong>br</strong> />
OLSVZULWKLQJDQGVQDUOLQJMDZVFOLSSLQJWRJHWKHUDVIDVWDVKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FRXOGVQDSDQGH\HVGLDEROLFDOO\JOHDPLQJWKHLQFDUQDWLRQRI<<strong>br</strong> />
EHOOLJHUHQWIHDU6RWHUULEOHZDVKLVDSSHDUDQFHWKDW6SLW]ZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUFHGWRIRUHJRGLVFLSOLQLQJKLPEXWWRFRYHUKLVRZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
GLVFRPILWXUHKHWXUQHGXSRQWKHLQRIIHQVLYHDQGZDLOLQJ%LOOHHDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
GURYHKLPWRWKHFRQILQHVRIWKHFDPS<<strong>br</strong> />
%\HYHQLQJ3HUUDXOWVHFXUHGDQRWKHUGRJDQROGKXVN\ORQJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
OHDQDQGJDXQWZLWKDEDWWOHVFDUUHGIDFHDQGDVLQJOHH\HZKLFK<<strong>br</strong> />
12
IODVKHGDZDUQLQJRISURZHVVWKDWFRPPDQGHGUHVSHFW+HZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
FDOOHG6ROOHNVZKLFKPHDQVWKH$QJU\2QH/LNH'DYHKHDVNHG<<strong>br</strong> />
QRWKLQJJDYHQRWKLQJH[SHFWHGQRWKLQJDQGZKHQKHPDUFKHG<<strong>br</strong> />
VORZO\DQGGHOLEHUDWHO\LQWRWKHLUPLGVWHYHQ6SLW]OHIWKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
DORQH+HKDGRQHSHFXOLDULW\ZKLFK%XFNZDVXQOXFN\HQRXJKWR<<strong>br</strong> />
GLVFRYHU+HGLGQRWOLNHWREHDSSURDFKHGRQKLVEOLQGVLGH2I<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLVRIIHQFH%XFNZDVXQZLWWLQJO\JXLOW\DQGWKHILUVWNQRZOHGJH<<strong>br</strong> />
KHKDGRIKLVLQGLVFUHWLRQZDVZKHQ6ROOHNVZKLUOHGXSRQKLPDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VODVKHGKLVVKRXOGHUWRWKHERQHIRUWKUHHLQFKHVXSDQGGRZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
)RUHYHUDIWHU%XFNDYRLGHGKLVEOLQGVLGHDQGWRWKHODVWRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHLUFRPUDGHVKLSKDGQRPRUHWURXEOH+LVRQO\DSSDUHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
DPELWLRQOLNH'DYHVZDVWREHOHIWDORQHWKRXJKDV%XFNZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
DIWHUZDUGWROHDUQHDFKRIWKHPSRVVHVVHGRQHRWKHUDQGHYHQPRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
YLWDODPELWLRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KDWQLJKW%XFNIDFHGWKHJUHDWSUREOHPRIVOHHSLQJ7KHWHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
LOOXPLQHGE\DFDQGOHJORZHGZDUPO\LQWKHPLGVWRIWKHZKLWH<<strong>br</strong> />
SODLQDQGZKHQKHDVDPDWWHURIFRXUVHHQWHUHGLWERWK<<strong>br</strong> />
3HUUDXOWDQG)UDQFRLVERPEDUGHGKLPZLWKFXUVHVDQGFRRNLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
XWHQVLOVWLOOKHUHFRYHUHGIURPKLVFRQVWHUQDWLRQDQGIOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
LJQRPLQLRXVO\LQWRWKHRXWHUFROG$FKLOOZLQGZDVEORZLQJWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
QLSSHGKLPVKDUSO\DQGELWZLWKHVSHFLDOYHQRPLQWRKLVZRXQGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
VKRXOGHU+HOD\GRZQRQWKHVQRZDQGDWWHPSWHGWRVOHHSEXWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IURVWVRRQGURYHKLPVKLYHULQJWRKLVIHHW0LVHUDEOHDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
GLVFRQVRODWHKHZDQGHUHGDERXWDPRQJWKHPDQ\WHQWVRQO\WRILQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWRQHSODFHZDVDVFROGDVDQRWKHU+HUHDQGWKHUHVDYDJHGRJV<<strong>br</strong> />
UXVKHGXSRQKLPEXWKHEULVWOHGKLVQHFNKDLUDQGVQDUOHGIRUKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVOHDUQLQJIDVWDQGWKH\OHWKLPJRKLVZD\XQPROHVWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
)LQDOO\DQLGHDFDPHWRKLP+HZRXOGUHWXUQDQGVHHKRZKLVRZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WHDPPDWHVZHUHPDNLQJRXW7RKLVDVWRQLVKPHQWWKH\KDG<<strong>br</strong> />
GLVDSSHDUHG$JDLQKHZDQGHUHGDERXWWKURXJKWKHJUHDWFDPS<<strong>br</strong> />
ORRNLQJIRUWKHPDQGDJDLQKHUHWXUQHG:HUHWKH\LQWKHWHQW"<<strong>br</strong> />
1RWKDWFRXOGQRWEHHOVHKHZRXOGQRWKDYHEHHQGULYHQRXW<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHQZKHUHFRXOGWKH\SRVVLEO\EH":LWKGURRSLQJWDLODQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VKLYHULQJERG\YHU\IRUORUQLQGHHGKHDLPOHVVO\FLUFOHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WHQW6XGGHQO\WKHVQRZJDYHZD\EHQHDWKKLVIRUHOHJVDQGKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VDQNGRZQ6RPHWKLQJZULJJOHGXQGHUKLVIHHW+HVSUDQJEDFN<<strong>br</strong> />
EULVWOLQJDQGVQDUOLQJIHDUIXORIWKHXQVHHQDQGXQNQRZQ%XWD<<strong>br</strong> />
IULHQGO\OLWWOH\HOSUHDVVXUHGKLPDQGKHZHQWEDFNWR<<strong>br</strong> />
LQYHVWLJDWH$ZKLIIRIZDUPDLUDVFHQGHGWRKLVQRVWULOVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHUHFXUOHGXSXQGHUWKHVQRZLQDVQXJEDOOOD\%LOOHH+H<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLQHGSODFDWLQJO\VTXLUPHGDQGZULJJOHGWRVKRZKLVJRRGZLOO<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGLQWHQWLRQVDQGHYHQYHQWXUHGDVDEULEHIRUSHDFHWROLFN<<strong>br</strong> />
13
%XFNVIDFHZLWKKLVZDUPZHWWRQJXH<<strong>br</strong> />
$QRWKHUOHVVRQ6RWKDWZDVWKHZD\WKH\GLGLWHK"%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
FRQILGHQWO\VHOHFWHGDVSRWDQGZLWKPXFKIXVVDQGZDVWHHIIRUW<<strong>br</strong> />
SURFHHGHGWRGLJDKROHIRUKLPVHOI,QDWULFHWKHKHDWIURPKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
ERG\ILOOHGWKHFRQILQHGVSDFHDQGKHZDVDVOHHS7KHGD\KDG<<strong>br</strong> />
EHHQORQJDQGDUGXRXVDQGKHVOHSWVRXQGO\DQGFRPIRUWDEO\<<strong>br</strong> />
WKRXJKKHJURZOHGDQGEDUNHGDQGZUHVWOHGZLWKEDGGUHDPV<<strong>br</strong> />
1RUGLGKHRSHQKLVH\HVWLOOURXVHGE\WKHQRLVHVRIWKHZDNLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
FDPS$WILUVWKHGLGQRWNQRZZKHUHKHZDV,WKDGVQRZHG<<strong>br</strong> />
GXULQJWKHQLJKWDQGKHZDVFRPSOHWHO\EXULHG7KHVQRZZDOOV<<strong>br</strong> />
SUHVVHGKLPRQHYHU\VLGHDQGDJUHDWVXUJHRIIHDUVZHSWWKURXJK<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPWKHIHDURIWKHZLOGWKLQJIRUWKHWUDS,WZDVDWRNHQWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
KHZDVKDUNLQJEDFNWKURXJKKLVRZQOLIHWRWKHOLYHVRIKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUHEHDUVIRUKHZDVDFLYLOL]HGGRJDQXQGXO\FLYLOL]HGGRJ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGRIKLVRZQH[SHULHQFHNQHZQRWUDSDQGVRFRXOGQRWRIKLPVHOI<<strong>br</strong> />
IHDULW7KHPXVFOHVRIKLVZKROHERG\FRQWUDFWHGVSDVPRGLFDOO\<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGLQVWLQFWLYHO\WKHKDLURQKLVQHFNDQGVKRXOGHUVVWRRGRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
HQGDQGZLWKDIHURFLRXVVQDUOKHERXQGHGVWUDLJKWXSLQWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
EOLQGLQJGD\WKHVQRZIO\LQJDERXWKLPLQDIODVKLQJFORXG(UH<<strong>br</strong> />
KHODQGHGRQKLVIHHWKHVDZWKHZKLWHFDPSVSUHDGRXWEHIRUHKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGNQHZZKHUHKHZDVDQGUHPHPEHUHGDOOWKDWKDGSDVVHGIURPWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WLPHKHZHQWIRUDVWUROOZLWK0DQXHOWRWKHKROHKHKDGGXJIRU<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPVHOIWKHQLJKWEHIRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
$VKRXWIURP)UDQFRLVKDLOHGKLVDSSHDUDQFH:RW,VD\"WKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GRJGULYHUFULHGWR3HUUDXOW'DW%XFNIRUVXUHOHDUQTXHHNDV<<strong>br</strong> />
DQ\WLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
3HUUDXOWQRGGHGJUDYHO\$VFRXULHUIRUWKH&DQDGLDQ*RYHUQPHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
EHDULQJLPSRUWDQWGHVSDWFKHVKHZDVDQ[LRXVWRVHFXUHWKHEHVW<<strong>br</strong> />
GRJVDQGKHZDVSDUWLFXODUO\JODGGHQHGE\WKHSRVVHVVLRQRI%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
7KUHHPRUHKXVNLHVZHUHDGGHGWRWKHWHDPLQVLGHDQKRXUPDNLQJD<<strong>br</strong> />
WRWDORIQLQHDQGEHIRUHDQRWKHUTXDUWHURIDQKRXUKDGSDVVHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\ZHUHLQKDUQHVVDQGVZLQJLQJXSWKHWUDLOWRZDUGWKH'\HD<<strong>br</strong> />
&DQRQ%XFNZDVJODGWREHJRQHDQGWKRXJKWKHZRUNZDVKDUGKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IRXQGKHGLGQRWSDUWLFXODUO\GHVSLVHLW+HZDVVXUSULVHGDWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
HDJHUQHVVZKLFKDQLPDWHGWKHZKROHWHDPDQGZKLFKZDVFRPPXQLFDWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WRKLPEXWVWLOOPRUHVXUSULVLQJZDVWKHFKDQJHZURXJKWLQ'DYH<<strong>br</strong> />
DQG6ROOHNV7KH\ZHUHQHZGRJVXWWHUO\WUDQVIRUPHGE\WKH<<strong>br</strong> />
KDUQHVV$OOSDVVLYHQHVVDQGXQFRQFHUQKDGGURSSHGIURPWKHP<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH\ZHUHDOHUWDQGDFWLYHDQ[LRXVWKDWWKHZRUNVKRXOGJRZHOO<<strong>br</strong> />
14
DQGILHUFHO\LUULWDEOHZLWKZKDWHYHUE\GHOD\RUFRQIXVLRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
UHWDUGHGWKDWZRUN7KHWRLORIWKHWUDFHVVHHPHGWKHVXSUHPH<<strong>br</strong> />
H[SUHVVLRQRIWKHLUEHLQJDQGDOOWKDWWKH\OLYHGIRUDQGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
RQO\WKLQJLQZKLFKWKH\WRRNGHOLJKW<<strong>br</strong> />
'DYHZDVZKHHOHURUVOHGGRJSXOOLQJLQIURQWRIKLPZDV%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHQFDPH6ROOHNVWKHUHVWRIWKHWHDPZDVVWUXQJRXWDKHDG<<strong>br</strong> />
VLQJOHILOHWRWKHOHDGHUZKLFKSRVLWLRQZDVILOOHGE\6SLW]<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNKDGEHHQSXUSRVHO\SODFHGEHWZHHQ'DYHDQG6ROOHNVVRWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
KHPLJKWUHFHLYHLQVWUXFWLRQ$SWVFKRODUWKDWKHZDVWKH\ZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
HTXDOO\DSWWHDFKHUVQHYHUDOORZLQJKLPWROLQJHUORQJLQHUURU<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGHQIRUFLQJWKHLUWHDFKLQJZLWKWKHLUVKDUSWHHWK'DYHZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
IDLUDQGYHU\ZLVH+HQHYHUQLSSHG%XFNZLWKRXWFDXVHDQGKH<<strong>br</strong> />
QHYHUIDLOHGWRQLSKLPZKHQKHVWRRGLQQHHGRILW$V<<strong>br</strong> />
)UDQFRLVVZKLSEDFNHGKLPXS%XFNIRXQGLWWREHFKHDSHUWRPHQG<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVZD\VWKDQWRUHWDOLDWH2QFHGXULQJDEULHIKDOWZKHQKHJRW<<strong>br</strong> />
WDQJOHGLQWKHWUDFHVDQGGHOD\HGWKHVWDUWERWK'DYHDQG6RO<<strong>br</strong> />
OHNVIOHZDWKLPDQGDGPLQLVWHUHGDVRXQGWURXQFLQJ7KH<<strong>br</strong> />
UHVXOWLQJWDQJOHZDVHYHQZRUVHEXW%XFNWRRNJRRGFDUHWRNHHS<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHWUDFHVFOHDUWKHUHDIWHUDQGHUHWKHGD\ZDVGRQHVRZHOOKDG<<strong>br</strong> />
KHPDVWHUHGKLVZRUNKLVPDWHVDERXWFHDVHGQDJJLQJKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
)UDQFRLVVZKLSVQDSSHGOHVVIUHTXHQWO\DQG3HUUDXOWHYHQKRQRUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNE\OLIWLQJXSKLVIHHWDQGFDUHIXOO\H[DPLQLQJWKHP<<strong>br</strong> />
,WZDVDKDUGGD\VUXQXSWKH&DQRQWKURXJK6KHHS&DPSSDVW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH6FDOHVDQGWKHWLPEHUOLQHDFURVVJODFLHUVDQGVQRZGULIWV<<strong>br</strong> />
KXQGUHGVRIIHHWGHHSDQGRYHUWKHJUHDW&KLOFRRW'LYLGHZKLFK<<strong>br</strong> />
VWDQGVEHWZHHQWKHVDOWZDWHUDQGWKHIUHVKDQGJXDUGV<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUELGGLQJO\WKHVDGDQGORQHO\1RUWK7KH\PDGHJRRGWLPHGRZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHFKDLQRIODNHVZKLFKILOOVWKHFUDWHUVRIH[WLQFWYROFDQRHV<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGODWHWKDWQLJKWSXOOHGLQWRWKHKXJHFDPSDWWKHKHDGRI/DNH<<strong>br</strong> />
%HQQHWWZKHUHWKRXVDQGVRIJROGVHHNHUVZHUHEXLOGLQJERDWV<<strong>br</strong> />
DJDLQVWWKHEUHDNXSRIWKHLFHLQWKHVSULQJ%XFNPDGHKLVKROH<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWKHVQRZDQGVOHSWWKHVOHHSRIWKHH[KDXVWHGMXVWEXWDOOWRR<<strong>br</strong> />
HDUO\ZDVURXWHGRXWLQWKHFROGGDUNQHVVDQGKDUQHVVHGZLWKKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
PDWHVWRWKHVOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
7KDWGD\WKH\PDGHIRUW\PLOHVWKHWUDLOEHLQJSDFNHGEXWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
QH[WGD\DQGIRUPDQ\GD\VWRIROORZWKH\EURNHWKHLURZQWUDLO<<strong>br</strong> />
ZRUNHGKDUGHUDQGPDGHSRRUHUWLPH$VDUXOH3HUUDXOW<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDYHOOHGDKHDGRIWKHWHDPSDFNLQJWKHVQRZZLWKZHEEHGVKRHVWR<<strong>br</strong> />
PDNHLWHDVLHUIRUWKHP)UDQFRLVJXLGLQJWKHVOHGDWWKHJHH<<strong>br</strong> />
SROHVRPHWLPHVH[FKDQJHGSODFHVZLWKKLPEXWQRWRIWHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
15
3HUUDXOWZDVLQDKXUU\DQGKHSULGHGKLPVHOIRQKLVNQRZOHGJHRI<<strong>br</strong> />
LFHZKLFKNQRZOHGJHZDVLQGLVSHQVDEOHIRUWKHIDOOLFHZDVYHU\<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLQDQGZKHUHWKHUHZDVVZLIWZDWHUWKHUHZDVQRLFHDWDOO<<strong>br</strong> />
'D\DIWHUGD\IRUGD\VXQHQGLQJ%XFNWRLOHGLQWKHWUDFHV<<strong>br</strong> />
$OZD\VWKH\EURNHFDPSLQWKHGDUNDQGWKHILUVWJUD\RIGDZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
IRXQGWKHPKLWWLQJWKHWUDLOZLWKIUHVKPLOHVUHHOHGRIIEHKLQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHP$QGDOZD\VWKH\SLWFKHGFDPSDIWHUGDUNHDWLQJWKHLUELW<<strong>br</strong> />
RIILVKDQGFUDZOLQJWRVOHHSLQWRWKHVQRZ%XFNZDVUDYHQRXV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHSRXQGDQGDKDOIRIVXQGULHGVDOPRQZKLFKZDVKLVUDWLRQIRU<<strong>br</strong> />
HDFKGD\VHHPHGWRJRQRZKHUH+HQHYHUKDGHQRXJKDQGVXIIHUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
IURPSHUSHWXDOKXQJHUSDQJV
ILJKW%XWWKHFOXERIWKHPDQLQWKHUHGVZHDWHUKDGEHDWHQLQWR<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPDPRUHIXQGDPHQWDODQGSULPLWLYHFRGH&LYLOL]HGKHFRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
KDYHGLHGIRUDPRUDOFRQVLGHUDWLRQVD\WKHGHIHQFHRI-XGJH<<strong>br</strong> />
0LOOHUVULGLQJZKLSEXWWKHFRPSOHWHQHVVRIKLVGHFLYLOL]DWLRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVQRZHYLGHQFHGE\KLVDELOLW\WRIOHHIURPWKHGHIHQFHRID<<strong>br</strong> />
PRUDOFRQVLGHUDWLRQDQGVRVDYHKLVKLGH+HGLGQRWVWHDOIRU<<strong>br</strong> />
MR\RILWEXWEHFDXVHRIWKHFODPRURIKLVVWRPDFK+HGLGQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
URERSHQO\EXWVWROHVHFUHWO\DQGFXQQLQJO\RXWRIUHVSHFWIRU<<strong>br</strong> />
FOXEDQGIDQJ,QVKRUWWKHWKLQJVKHGLGZHUHGRQHEHFDXVHLW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVHDVLHUWRGRWKHPWKDQQRWWRGRWKHP<<strong>br</strong> />
+LVGHYHORSPHQWRUUHWURJUHVVLRQZDVUDSLG+LVPXVFOHVEHFDPH<<strong>br</strong> />
KDUGDVLURQDQGKHJUHZFDOORXVWRDOORUGLQDU\SDLQ+H<<strong>br</strong> />
DFKLHYHGDQLQWHUQDODVZHOODVH[WHUQDOHFRQRP\+HFRXOGHDW<<strong>br</strong> />
DQ\WKLQJQRPDWWHUKRZORDWKVRPHRULQGLJHVWLEOHDQGRQFH<<strong>br</strong> />
HDWHQWKHMXLFHVRIKLVVWRPDFKH[WUDFWHGWKHODVWOHDVWSDUWLFOH<<strong>br</strong> />
RIQXWULPHQWDQGKLVEORRGFDUULHGLWWRWKHIDUWKHVWUHDFKHVRI<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVERG\EXLOGLQJLWLQWRWKHWRXJKHVWDQGVWRXWHVWRIWLVVXHV<<strong>br</strong> />
6LJKWDQGVFHQWEHFDPHUHPDUNDEO\NHHQZKLOHKLVKHDULQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
GHYHORSHGVXFKDFXWHQHVVWKDWLQKLVVOHHSKHKHDUGWKHIDLQWHVW<<strong>br</strong> />
VRXQGDQGNQHZZKHWKHULWKHUDOGHGSHDFHRUSHULO+HOHDUQHGWR<<strong>br</strong> />
ELWHWKHLFHRXWZLWKKLVWHHWKZKHQLWFROOHFWHGEHWZHHQKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
WRHVDQGZKHQKHZDVWKLUVW\DQGWKHUHZDVDWKLFNVFXPRILFH<<strong>br</strong> />
RYHUWKHZDWHUKROHKHZRXOGEUHDNLWE\UHDULQJDQGVWULNLQJLW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKVWLIIIRUHOHJV+LVPRVWFRQVSLFXRXVWUDLWZDVDQDELOLW\WR<<strong>br</strong> />
VFHQWWKHZLQGDQGIRUHFDVWLWDQLJKWLQDGYDQFH1RPDWWHUKRZ<<strong>br</strong> />
EUHDWKOHVVWKHDLUZKHQKHGXJKLVQHVWE\WUHHRUEDQNWKHZLQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWODWHUEOHZLQHYLWDEO\IRXQGKLPWROHHZDUGVKHOWHUHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VQXJ<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGQRWRQO\GLGKHOHDUQE\H[SHULHQFHEXWLQVWLQFWVORQJGHDG<<strong>br</strong> />
EHFDPHDOLYHDJDLQ7KHGRPHVWLFDWHGJHQHUDWLRQVIHOOIURPKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
,QYDJXHZD\VKHUHPHPEHUHGEDFNWRWKH\RXWKRIWKHEUHHGWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WLPHWKHZLOGGRJVUDQJHGLQSDFNVWKURXJKWKHSULPHYDOIRUHVWDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
NLOOHGWKHLUPHDWDVWKH\UDQLWGRZQ,WZDVQRWDVNIRUKLPWR<<strong>br</strong> />
OHDUQWRILJKWZLWKFXWDQGVODVKDQGWKHTXLFNZROIVQDS,Q<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLVPDQQHUKDGIRXJKWIRUJRWWHQDQFHVWRUV7KH\TXLFNHQHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ROGOLIHZLWKLQKLPDQGWKHROGWULFNVZKLFKWKH\KDGVWDPSHG<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWRWKHKHUHGLW\RIWKHEUHHGZHUHKLVWULFNV7KH\FDPHWRKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKRXWHIIRUWRUGLVFRYHU\DVWKRXJKWKH\KDGEHHQKLVDOZD\V<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGZKHQRQWKHVWLOOFROGQLJKWVKHSRLQWHGKLVQRVHDWDVWDU<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGKRZOHGORQJDQGZROIOLNHLWZDVKLVDQFHVWRUVGHDGDQGGXVW<<strong>br</strong> />
SRLQWLQJQRVHDWVWDUDQGKRZOLQJGRZQWKURXJKWKHFHQWXULHVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURXJKKLP$QGKLVFDGHQFHVZHUHWKHLUFDGHQFHVWKHFDGHQFHV<<strong>br</strong> />
17
ZKLFKYRLFHGWKHLUZRHDQGZKDWWRWKHPZDVWKHPHDQLQJRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VWLIIQHVVDQGWKHFROGDQGGDUN<<strong>br</strong> />
7KXVDVWRNHQRIZKDWDSXSSHWWKLQJOLIHLVWKHDQFLHQWVRQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
VXUJHGWKURXJKKLPDQGKHFDPHLQWRKLVRZQDJDLQDQGKHFDPH<<strong>br</strong> />
EHFDXVHPHQKDGIRXQGD\HOORZPHWDOLQWKH1RUWKDQGEHFDXVH<<strong>br</strong> />
0DQXHOZDVDJDUGHQHUVKHOSHUZKRVHZDJHVGLGQRWODSRYHUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
QHHGVRIKLVZLIHDQGGLYHUVVPDOOFRSLHVRIKLPVHOI<<strong>br</strong> />
&KDSWHU,,,<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH'RPLQDQW3ULPRUGLDO%HDVW<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHGRPLQDQWSULPRUGLDOEHDVWZDVVWURQJLQ%XFNDQGXQGHUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ILHUFHFRQGLWLRQVRIWUDLOOLIHLWJUHZDQGJUHZ
GLVWULEXWHGWKHILVKZKLFKKHKDGILUVWWKDZHGRYHUWKHILUH%XW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKHQ%XFNILQLVKHGKLVUDWLRQDQGUHWXUQHGKHIRXQGKLVQHVW<<strong>br</strong> />
RFFXSLHG$ZDUQLQJVQDUOWROGKLPWKDWWKHWUHVSDVVHUZDV6SLW]<<strong>br</strong> />
7LOOQRZ%XFNKDGDYRLGHGWURXEOHZLWKKLVHQHP\EXWWKLVZDVWRR<<strong>br</strong> />
PXFK7KHEHDVWLQKLPURDUHG+HVSUDQJXSRQ6SLW]ZLWKDIXU\<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLFKVXUSULVHGWKHPERWKDQG6SLW]SDUWLFXODUO\IRUKLVZKROH<<strong>br</strong> />
H[SHULHQFHZLWK%XFNKDGJRQHWRWHDFKKLPWKDWKLVULYDOZDVDQ<<strong>br</strong> />
XQXVXDOO\WLPLGGRJZKRPDQDJHGWRKROGKLVRZQRQO\EHFDXVHRI<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVJUHDWZHLJKWDQGVL]H<<strong>br</strong> />
)UDQFRLVZDVVXUSULVHGWRRZKHQWKH\VKRWRXWLQDWDQJOHIURP<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHGLVUXSWHGQHVWDQGKHGLYLQHGWKHFDXVHRIWKHWURXEOH$D<<strong>br</strong> />
DKKHFULHGWR%XFN*LILWWRKHHPE\*DU*LILWWRKHHP<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHGLUW\WHHI<<strong>br</strong> />
6SLW]ZDVHTXDOO\ZLOOLQJ+HZDVFU\LQJZLWKVKHHUUDJHDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
HDJHUQHVVDVKHFLUFOHGEDFNDQGIRUWKIRUDFKDQFHWRVSULQJLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNZDVQROHVVHDJHUDQGQROHVVFDXWLRXVDVKHOLNHZLVH<<strong>br</strong> />
FLUFOHGEDFNDQGIRUWKIRUWKHDGYDQWDJH%XWLWZDVWKHQWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHXQH[SHFWHGKDSSHQHGWKHWKLQJZKLFKSURMHFWHGWKHLUVWUXJJOH<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUVXSUHPDF\IDULQWRWKHIXWXUHSDVWPDQ\DZHDU\PLOHRIWUDLO<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGWRLO<<strong>br</strong> />
$QRDWKIURP3HUUDXOWWKHUHVRXQGLQJLPSDFWRIDFOXEXSRQDERQ\<<strong>br</strong> />
IUDPHDQGDVKULOO\HOSRISDLQKHUDOGHGWKHEUHDNLQJIRUWKRI<<strong>br</strong> />
SDQGHPRQLXP7KHFDPSZDVVXGGHQO\GLVFRYHUHGWREHDOLYHZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
VNXONLQJIXUU\IRUPVVWDUYLQJKXVNLHVIRXURUILYHVFRUHRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHPZKRKDGVFHQWHGWKHFDPSIURPVRPH,QGLDQYLOODJH7KH\KDG<<strong>br</strong> />
FUHSWLQZKLOH%XFNDQG6SLW]ZHUHILJKWLQJDQGZKHQWKHWZRPHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
VSUDQJDPRQJWKHPZLWKVWRXWFOXEVWKH\VKRZHGWKHLUWHHWKDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
IRXJKWEDFN7KH\ZHUHFUD]HGE\WKHVPHOORIWKHIRRG3HUUDXOW<<strong>br</strong> />
IRXQGRQHZLWKKHDGEXULHGLQWKHJUXEER[+LVFOXEODQGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
KHDYLO\RQWKHJDXQWULEVDQGWKHJUXEER[ZDVFDSVL]HGRQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
JURXQG2QWKHLQVWDQWDVFRUHRIWKHIDPLVKHGEUXWHVZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
VFUDPEOLQJIRUWKHEUHDGDQGEDFRQ7KHFOXEVIHOOXSRQWKHP<<strong>br</strong> />
XQKHHGHG7KH\\HOSHGDQGKRZOHGXQGHUWKHUDLQRIEORZVEXW<<strong>br</strong> />
VWUXJJOHGQRQHWKHOHVVPDGO\WLOOWKHODVWFUXPEKDGEHHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
GHYRXUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
,QWKHPHDQWLPHWKHDVWRQLVKHGWHDPGRJVKDGEXUVWRXWRIWKHLU<<strong>br</strong> />
QHVWVRQO\WREHVHWXSRQE\WKHILHUFHLQYDGHUV1HYHUKDG%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
VHHQVXFKGRJVLWVHHPHGDVWKRXJKWKHLUERQHVZRXOGEXUVW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURXJKWKHLUVNLQV7KH\ZHUHPHUHVNHOHWRQVGUDSHGORRVHO\LQ<<strong>br</strong> />
GUDJJOHGKLGHVZLWKEOD]LQJH\HVDQGVODYHUHGIDQJV%XWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
19
KXQJHUPDGQHVVPDGHWKHPWHUULI\LQJLUUHVLVWLEOH7KHUHZDVQR<<strong>br</strong> />
RSSRVLQJWKHP7KHWHDPGRJVZHUHVZHSWEDFNDJDLQVWWKHFOLIIDW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHILUVWRQVHW%XFNZDVEHVHWE\WKUHHKXVNLHVDQGLQDWULFH<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVKHDGDQGVKRXOGHUVZHUHULSSHGDQGVODVKHG7KHGLQZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
IULJKWIXO%LOOHHZDVFU\LQJDVXVXDO'DYHDQG6ROOHNV<<strong>br</strong> />
GULSSLQJEORRGIURPDVFRUHRIZRXQGVZHUHILJKWLQJEUDYHO\VLGH<<strong>br</strong> />
E\VLGH-RHZDVVQDSSLQJOLNHDGHPRQ2QFHKLVWHHWKFORVHG<<strong>br</strong> />
RQWKHIRUHOHJRIDKXVN\DQGKHFUXQFKHGGRZQWKURXJKWKHERQH<<strong>br</strong> />
3LNHWKHPDOLQJHUHUOHDSHGXSRQWKHFULSSOHGDQLPDOEUHDNLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
LWVQHFNZLWKDTXLFNIODVKRIWHHWKDQGDMHUN%XFNJRWD<<strong>br</strong> />
IURWKLQJDGYHUVDU\E\WKHWKURDWDQGZDVVSUD\HGZLWKEORRGZKHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVWHHWKVDQNWKURXJKWKHMXJXODU7KHZDUPWDVWHRILWLQKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
PRXWKJRDGHGKLPWRJUHDWHUILHUFHQHVV+HIOXQJKLPVHOIXSRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQRWKHUDQGDWWKHVDPHWLPHIHOWWHHWKVLQNLQWRKLVRZQWKURDW<<strong>br</strong> />
,WZDV6SLW]WUHDFKHURXVO\DWWDFNLQJIURPWKHVLGH<<strong>br</strong> />
3HUUDXOWDQG)UDQFRLVKDYLQJFOHDQHGRXWWKHLUSDUWRIWKHFDPS<<strong>br</strong> />
KXUULHGWRVDYHWKHLUVOHGGRJV7KHZLOGZDYHRIIDPLVKHGEHDVWV<<strong>br</strong> />
UROOHGEDFNEHIRUHWKHPDQG%XFNVKRRNKLPVHOIIUHH%XWLWZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
RQO\IRUDPRPHQW7KHWZRPHQZHUHFRPSHOOHGWRUXQEDFNWRVDYH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHJUXEXSRQZKLFKWKHKXVNLHVUHWXUQHGWRWKHDWWDFNRQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WHDP%LOOHHWHUULILHGLQWREUDYHU\VSUDQJWKURXJKWKHVDYDJH<<strong>br</strong> />
FLUFOHDQGIOHGDZD\RYHUWKHLFH3LNHDQG'XEIROORZHGRQKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
KHHOVZLWKWKHUHVWRIWKHWHDPEHKLQG$V%XFNGUHZKLPVHOI<<strong>br</strong> />
WRJHWKHUWRVSULQJDIWHUWKHPRXWRIWKHWDLORIKLVH\HKHVDZ<<strong>br</strong> />
6SLW]UXVKXSRQKLPZLWKWKHHYLGHQWLQWHQWLRQRIRYHUWKURZLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
KLP2QFHRIIKLVIHHWDQGXQGHUWKDWPDVVRIKXVNLHVWKHUHZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
QRKRSHIRUKLP%XWKHEUDFHGKLPVHOIWRWKHVKRFNRI6SLW]V<<strong>br</strong> />
FKDUJHWKHQMRLQHGWKHIOLJKWRXWRQWKHODNH<<strong>br</strong> />
/DWHUWKHQLQHWHDPGRJVJDWKHUHGWRJHWKHUDQGVRXJKWVKHOWHULQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHIRUHVW7KRXJKXQSXUVXHGWKH\ZHUHLQDVRUU\SOLJKW7KHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVQRWRQHZKRZDVQRWZRXQGHGLQIRXURUILYHSODFHVZKLOHVRPH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHUHZRXQGHGJULHYRXVO\'XEZDVEDGO\LQMXUHGLQDKLQGOHJ<<strong>br</strong> />
'ROO\WKHODVWKXVN\DGGHGWRWKHWHDPDW'\HDKDGDEDGO\WRUQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURDW-RHKDGORVWDQH\HZKLOH%LOOHHWKHJRRGQDWXUHGZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
DQHDUFKHZHGDQGUHQWWRULEERQVFULHGDQGZKLPSHUHGWKURXJKRXW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHQLJKW$WGD\EUHDNWKH\OLPSHGZDULO\EDFNWRFDPSWRILQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHPDUDXGHUVJRQHDQGWKHWZRPHQLQEDGWHPSHUV)XOO\KDOI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHLUJUXEVXSSO\ZDVJRQH7KHKXVNLHVKDGFKHZHGWKURXJKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VOHGODVKLQJVDQGFDQYDVFRYHULQJV,QIDFWQRWKLQJQRPDWWHU<<strong>br</strong> />
KRZUHPRWHO\HDWDEOHKDGHVFDSHGWKHP7KH\KDGHDWHQDSDLURI<<strong>br</strong> />
3HUUDXOWVPRRVHKLGHPRFFDVLQVFKXQNVRXWRIWKHOHDWKHUWUDFHV<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGHYHQWZRIHHWRIODVKIURPWKHHQGRI)UDQFRLVVZKLS+H<<strong>br</strong> />
20
EURNHIURPDPRXUQIXOFRQWHPSODWLRQRILWWRORRNRYHUKLVZRXQGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
GRJV<<strong>br</strong> />
$KP\IULHQVKHVDLGVRIWO\PHEEHLWPHN\RXPDGGRJGRVH<<strong>br</strong> />
PDQ\ELWHV0HEEHDOOPDGGRJVDFUHGDP:RW\RXWLQNHK<<strong>br</strong> />
3HUUDXOW"<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHFRXULHUVKRRNKLVKHDGGXELRXVO\:LWKIRXUKXQGUHGPLOHVRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDLOVWLOOEHWZHHQKLPDQG'DZVRQKHFRXOGLOODIIRUGWRKDYH<<strong>br</strong> />
PDGQHVVEUHDNRXWDPRQJKLVGRJV7ZRKRXUVRIFXUVLQJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
H[HUWLRQJRWWKHKDUQHVVHVLQWRVKDSHDQGWKHZRXQGVWLIIHQHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WHDPZDVXQGHUZD\VWUXJJOLQJSDLQIXOO\RYHUWKHKDUGHVWSDUWRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHWUDLOWKH\KDG\HWHQFRXQWHUHGDQGIRUWKDWPDWWHUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
KDUGHVWEHWZHHQWKHPDQG'DZVRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH7KLUW\0LOH5LYHUZDVZLGHRSHQ,WVZLOGZDWHUGHILHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IURVWDQGLWZDVLQWKHHGGLHVRQO\DQGLQWKHTXLHWSODFHVWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHLFHKHOGDWDOO6L[GD\VRIH[KDXVWLQJWRLOZHUHUHTXLUHGWR<<strong>br</strong> />
FRYHUWKRVHWKLUW\WHUULEOHPLOHV$QGWHUULEOHWKH\ZHUHIRU<<strong>br</strong> />
HYHU\IRRWRIWKHPZDVDFFRPSOLVKHGDWWKHULVNRIOLIHWRGRJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
PDQ$GR]HQWLPHV3HUUDXOWQRVLQJWKHZD\EURNHWKURXJKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
LFHEULGJHVEHLQJVDYHGE\WKHORQJSROHKHFDUULHGZKLFKKHVR<<strong>br</strong> />
KHOGWKDWLWIHOOHDFKWLPHDFURVVWKHKROHPDGHE\KLVERG\%XW<<strong>br</strong> />
DFROGVQDSZDVRQWKHWKHUPRPHWHUUHJLVWHULQJILIW\EHORZ]HUR<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGHDFKWLPHKHEURNHWKURXJKKHZDVFRPSHOOHGIRUYHU\OLIHWR<<strong>br</strong> />
EXLOGDILUHDQGGU\KLVJDUPHQWV<<strong>br</strong> />
1RWKLQJGDXQWHGKLP,WZDVEHFDXVHQRWKLQJGDXQWHGKLPWKDWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGEHHQFKRVHQIRUJRYHUQPHQWFRXULHU+HWRRNDOOPDQQHURI<<strong>br</strong> />
ULVNVUHVROXWHO\WKUXVWLQJKLVOLWWOHZHD]HQHGIDFHLQWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IURVWDQGVWUXJJOLQJRQIURPGLPGDZQWRGDUN+HVNLUWHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IURZQLQJVKRUHVRQULPLFHWKDWEHQWDQGFUDFNOHGXQGHUIRRWDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
XSRQZKLFKWKH\GDUHGQRWKDOW2QFHWKHVOHGEURNHWKURXJK<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWK'DYHDQG%XFNDQGWKH\ZHUHKDOIIUR]HQDQGDOOEXWGURZQHG<<strong>br</strong> />
E\WKHWLPHWKH\ZHUHGUDJJHGRXW7KHXVXDOILUHZDVQHFHVVDU\<<strong>br</strong> />
WRVDYHWKHP7KH\ZHUHFRDWHGVROLGO\ZLWKLFHDQGWKHWZRPHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
NHSWWKHPRQWKHUXQDURXQGWKHILUHVZHDWLQJDQGWKDZLQJVR<<strong>br</strong> />
FORVHWKDWWKH\ZHUHVLQJHGE\WKHIODPHV<<strong>br</strong> />
$WDQRWKHUWLPH6SLW]ZHQWWKURXJKGUDJJLQJWKHZKROHWHDPDIWHU<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPXSWR%XFNZKRVWUDLQHGEDFNZDUGZLWKDOOKLVVWUHQJWKKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUHSDZVRQWKHVOLSSHU\HGJHDQGWKHLFHTXLYHULQJDQGVQDSSLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
DOODURXQG%XWEHKLQGKLPZDV'DYHOLNHZLVHVWUDLQLQJEDFNZDUG<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGEHKLQGWKHVOHGZDV)UDQFRLVSXOOLQJWLOOKLVWHQGRQV<<strong>br</strong> />
21
FUDFNHG<<strong>br</strong> />
$JDLQWKHULPLFHEURNHDZD\EHIRUHDQGEHKLQGDQGWKHUHZDVQR<<strong>br</strong> />
HVFDSHH[FHSWXSWKHFOLII3HUUDXOWVFDOHGLWE\DPLUDFOH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLOH)UDQFRLVSUD\HGIRUMXVWWKDWPLUDFOHDQGZLWKHYHU\WKRQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGVOHGODVKLQJDQGWKHODVWELWRIKDUQHVVURYHLQWRDORQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
URSHWKHGRJVZHUHKRLVWHGRQHE\RQHWRWKHFOLIIFUHVW<<strong>br</strong> />
)UDQFRLVFDPHXSODVWDIWHUWKHVOHGDQGORDG7KHQFDPHWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VHDUFKIRUDSODFHWRGHVFHQGZKLFKGHVFHQWZDVXOWLPDWHO\PDGH<<strong>br</strong> />
E\WKHDLGRIWKHURSHDQGQLJKWIRXQGWKHPEDFNRQWKHULYHU<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKDTXDUWHURIDPLOHWRWKHGD\VFUHGLW<<strong>br</strong> />
%\WKHWLPHWKH\PDGHWKH+RRWDOLQTXDDQGJRRGLFH%XFNZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
SOD\HGRXW7KHUHVWRIWKHGRJVZHUHLQOLNHFRQGLWLRQEXW<<strong>br</strong> />
3HUUDXOWWRPDNHXSORVWWLPHSXVKHGWKHPODWHDQGHDUO\7KH<<strong>br</strong> />
ILUVWGD\WKH\FRYHUHGWKLUW\ILYHPLOHVWRWKH%LJ6DOPRQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
QH[WGD\WKLUW\ILYHPRUHWRWKH/LWWOH6DOPRQWKHWKLUGGD\<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUW\PLOHVZKLFKEURXJKWWKHPZHOOXSWRZDUGWKH)LYH)LQJHUV<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNVIHHWZHUHQRWVRFRPSDFWDQGKDUGDVWKHIHHWRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
KXVNLHV+LVKDGVRIWHQHGGXULQJWKHPDQ\JHQHUDWLRQVVLQFHWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GD\KLVODVWZLOGDQFHVWRUZDVWDPHGE\DFDYHGZHOOHURUULYHU<<strong>br</strong> />
PDQ$8GD\ORQJKHOLPSHGLQDJRQ\DQGFDPSRQFHPDGHOD\GRZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
OLNHDGHDGGRJ+XQJU\DVKHZDVKHZRXOGQRWPRYHWRUHFHLYH<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVUDWLRQRIILVKZKLFK)UDQFRLVKDGWREULQJWRKLP$OVRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GRJGULYHUUXEEHG%XFNVIHHWIRUKDOIDQKRXUHDFKQLJKWDIWHU<<strong>br</strong> />
VXSSHUDQGVDFULILFHGWKHWRSVRIKLVRZQPRFFDVLQVWRPDNHIRXU<<strong>br</strong> />
PRFFDVLQVIRU%XFN7KLVZDVDJUHDWUHOLHIDQG%XFNFDXVHGHYHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHZHD]HQHGIDFHRI3HUUDXOWWRWZLVWLWVHOILQWRDJULQRQH<<strong>br</strong> />
PRUQLQJZKHQ)UDQFRLVIRUJRWWKHPRFFDVLQVDQG%XFNOD\RQKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
EDFNKLVIRXUIHHWZDYLQJDSSHDOLQJO\LQWKHDLUDQGUHIXVHGWR<<strong>br</strong> />
EXGJHZLWKRXWWKHP/DWHUKLVIHHWJUHZKDUGWRWKHWUDLODQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHZRUQRXWIRRWJHDUZDVWKURZQDZD\<<strong>br</strong> />
$WWKH3HOO\RQHPRUQLQJDVWKH\ZHUHKDUQHVVLQJXS'ROO\ZKR<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGQHYHUEHHQFRQVSLFXRXVIRUDQ\WKLQJZHQWVXGGHQO\PDG6KH<<strong>br</strong> />
DQQRXQFHGKHUFRQGLWLRQE\DORQJKHDUWEUHDNLQJZROIKRZOWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
VHQWHYHU\GRJEULVWOLQJZLWKIHDUWKHQVSUDQJVWUDLJKWIRU%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
+HKDGQHYHUVHHQDGRJJRPDGQRUGLGKHKDYHDQ\UHDVRQWRIHDU<<strong>br</strong> />
PDGQHVV\HWKHNQHZWKDWKHUHZDVKRUURUDQGIOHGDZD\IURPLW<<strong>br</strong> />
LQDSDQLF6WUDLJKWDZD\KHUDFHGZLWK'ROO\SDQWLQJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
IURWKLQJRQHOHDSEHKLQGQRUFRXOGVKHJDLQRQKLPVRJUHDWZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVWHUURUQRUFRXOGKHOHDYHKHUVRJUHDWZDVKHUPDGQHVV+H<<strong>br</strong> />
SOXQJHGWKURXJKWKHZRRGHGEUHDVWRIWKHLVODQGIOHZGRZQWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
22
ORZHUHQGFURVVHGDEDFNFKDQQHOILOOHGZLWKURXJKLFHWRDQRWKHU<<strong>br</strong> />
LVODQGJDLQHGDWKLUGLVODQGFXUYHGEDFNWRWKHPDLQULYHUDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
LQGHVSHUDWLRQVWDUWHGWRFURVVLW$QGDOOWKHWLPHWKRXJKKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GLGQRWWRRNKHFRXOGKHDUKHUVQDUOLQJMXVWRQHOHDSEHKLQG<<strong>br</strong> />
)UDQFRLVFDOOHGWRKLPDTXDUWHURIDPLOHDZD\DQGKHGRXEOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
EDFNVWLOORQHOHDSDKHDGJDVSLQJSDLQIXOO\IRUDLUDQGSXWWLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
DOOKLVIDLWKLQWKDW)UDQFRLVZRXOGVDYHKLP7KHGRJGULYHU<<strong>br</strong> />
KHOGWKHD[HSRLVHGLQKLVKDQGDQGDV%XFNVKRWSDVWKLPWKHD[H<<strong>br</strong> />
FUDVKHGGRZQXSRQPDG'ROO\VKHDG<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNVWDJJHUHGRYHUDJDLQVWWKHVOHGH[KDXVWHGVREELQJIRU<<strong>br</strong> />
EUHDWKKHOSOHVV7KLVZDV6SLW]VRSSRUWXQLW\+HVSUDQJXSRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNDQGWZLFHKLVWHHWKVDQNLQWRKLVXQUHVLVWLQJIRHDQGULSSHG<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGWRUHWKHIOHVKWRWKHERQH7KHQ)UDQFRLVVODVKGHVFHQGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
DQG%XFNKDGWKHVDWLVIDFWLRQRIZDWFKLQJ6SLW]UHFHLYHWKHZRUVW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLSSLQJDV\HWDGPLQLVWHUHGWRDQ\RIWKHWHDPV<<strong>br</strong> />
2QHGHYLOGDW6SLW]UHPDUNHG3HUUDXOW6RPHGDPGD\KHHP<<strong>br</strong> />
NHHOGDW%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
'DW%XFNWZRGHYLOVZDV)UDQFRLVVUHMRLQGHU$OOGHWDP,<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDWFKGDW%XFN,NQRZIRUVXUH/LVVHQVRPHGDPILQHGD\KHHP<<strong>br</strong> />
JHWPDGODNKHOODQGHQKHHPFKHZGDW6SLW]DOOXSDQVSLWKHHP<<strong>br</strong> />
RXWRQGHVQRZ6XUH,NQRZ<<strong>br</strong> />
)URPWKHQRQLWZDVZDUEHWZHHQWKHP6SLW]DVOHDGGRJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
DFNQRZOHGJHGPDVWHURIWKHWHDPIHOWKLVVXSUHPDF\WKUHDWHQHGE\<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLVVWUDQJH6RXWKODQGGRJ$QGVWUDQJH%XFNZDVWRKLPIRURI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHPDQ\6RXWKODQGGRJVKHKDGNQRZQQRWRQHKDGVKRZQXS<<strong>br</strong> />
ZRUWKLO\LQFDPSDQGRQWUDLO7KH\ZHUHDOOWRRVRIWG\LQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
XQGHUWKHWRLOWKHIURVWDQGVWDUYDWLRQ%XFNZDVWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
H[FHSWLRQ+HDORQHHQGXUHGDQGSURVSHUHGPDWFKLQJWKHKXVN\LQ<<strong>br</strong> />
VWUHQJWKVDYDJHU\DQGFXQQLQJ7KHQKHZDVDPDVWHUIXOGRJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKDWPDGHKLPGDQJHURXVZDVWKHIDFWWKDWWKHFOXERIWKHPDQLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHUHGVZHDWHUKDGNQRFNHGDOOEOLQGSOXFNDQGUDVKQHVVRXWRI<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVGHVLUHIRUPDVWHU\+HZDVSUHHPLQHQWO\FXQQLQJDQGFRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
ELGHKLVWLPHZLWKDSDWLHQFHWKDWZDVQRWKLQJOHVVWKDQ<<strong>br</strong> />
SULPLWLYH<<strong>br</strong> />
,WZDVLQHYLWDEOHWKDWWKHFODVKIRUOHDGHUVKLSVKRXOGFRPH%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDQWHGLW+HZDQWHGLWEHFDXVHLWZDVKLVQDWXUHEHFDXVHKHKDG<<strong>br</strong> />
EHHQJULSSHGWLJKWE\WKDWQDPHOHVVLQFRPSUHKHQVLEOHSULGHRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDLODQGWUDFHWKDWSULGHZKLFKKROGVGRJVLQWKHWRLOWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ODVWJDVSZKLFKOXUHVWKHPWRGLHMR\IXOO\LQWKHKDUQHVVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
23
EUHDNVWKHLUKHDUWVLIWKH\DUHFXWRXWRIWKHKDUQHVV7KLVZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHSULGHRI'DYHDVZKHHOGRJRI6ROOHNVDVKHSXOOHGZLWKDOO<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVVWUHQJWKWKHSULGHWKDWODLGKROGRIWKHPDWEUHDNRIFDPS<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDQVIRUPLQJWKHPIURPVRXUDQGVXOOHQEUXWHVLQWRVWUDLQLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
HDJHUDPELWLRXVFUHDWXUHVWKHSULGHWKDWVSXUUHGWKHPRQDOOGD\<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGGURSSHGWKHPDWSLWFKRIFDPSDWQLJKWOHWWLQJWKHPIDOOEDFN<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWRJORRP\XQUHVWDQGXQFRQWHQW7KLVZDVWKHSULGHWKDWERUHXS<<strong>br</strong> />
6SLW]DQGPDGHKLPWKUDVKWKHVOHGGRJVZKREOXQGHUHGDQGVKLUNHG<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWKHWUDFHVRUKLGDZD\DWKDUQHVVXSWLPHLQWKHPRUQLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
/LNHZLVHLWZDVWKLVSULGHWKDWPDGHKLPIHDU%XFNDVDSRVVLEOH<<strong>br</strong> />
OHDGGRJ$QGWKLVZDV%XFNVSULGHWRR<<strong>br</strong> />
+HRSHQO\WKUHDWHQHGWKHRWKHUVOHDGHUVKLS+HFDPHEHWZHHQKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGWKHVKLUNVKHVKRXOGKDYHSXQLVKHG$QGKHGLGLW<<strong>br</strong> />
GHOLEHUDWHO\2QHQLJKWWKHUHZDVDKHDY\VQRZIDOODQGLQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
PRUQLQJ3LNHWKHPDOLQJHUHUGLGQRWDSSHDU+HZDVVHFXUHO\<<strong>br</strong> />
KLGGHQLQKLVQHVWXQGHUDIRRWRIVQRZ)UDQFRLVFDOOHGKLPDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VRXJKWKLPLQYDLQ6SLW]ZDVZLOGZLWKZUDWK+HUDJHGWKURXJK<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHFDPSVPHOOLQJDQGGLJJLQJLQHYHU\OLNHO\SODFHVQDUOLQJVR<<strong>br</strong> />
IULJKWIXOO\WKDW3LNHKHDUGDQGVKLYHUHGLQKLVKLGLQJSODFH<<strong>br</strong> />
%XWZKHQKHZDVDWODVWXQHDUWKHGDQG6SLW]IOHZDWKLPWRSXQLVK<<strong>br</strong> />
KLP%XFNIOHZZLWKHTXDOUDJHLQEHWZHHQ6RXQH[SHFWHGZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
LWDQGVRVKUHZGO\PDQDJHGWKDW6SLW]ZDVKXUOHGEDFNZDUGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
RIIKLVIHHW3LNHZKRKDGEHHQWUHPEOLQJDEMHFWO\WRRNKHDUW<<strong>br</strong> />
DWWKLVRSHQPXWLQ\DQGVSUDQJXSRQKLVRYHUWKURZQOHDGHU%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
WRZKRPIDLUSOD\ZDVDIRUJRWWHQFRGHOLNHZLVHVSUDQJXSRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
6SLW]%XW)UDQFRLVFKXFNOLQJDWWKHLQFLGHQWZKLOHXQVZHUYLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWKHDGPLQLVWUDWLRQRIMXVWLFHEURXJKWKLVODVKGRZQXSRQ%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKDOOKLVPLJKW7KLVIDLOHGWRGULYH%XFNIURPKLVSURVWUDWH<<strong>br</strong> />
ULYDODQGWKHEXWWRIWKHZKLSZDVEURXJKWLQWRSOD\+DOI<<strong>br</strong> />
VWXQQHGE\WKHEORZ%XFNZDVNQRFNHGEDFNZDUGDQGWKHODVKODLG<<strong>br</strong> />
XSRQKLPDJDLQDQGDJDLQZKLOH6SLW]VRXQGO\SXQLVKHGWKHPDQ\<<strong>br</strong> />
WLPHVRIIHQGLQJ3LNH<<strong>br</strong> />
,QWKHGD\VWKDWIROORZHGDV'DZVRQJUHZFORVHUDQGFORVHU%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
VWLOOFRQWLQXHGWRLQWHUIHUHEHWZHHQ6SLW]DQGWKHFXOSULWVEXW<<strong>br</strong> />
KHGLGLWFUDIWLO\ZKHQ)UDQFRLVZDVQRWDURXQG:LWKWKHFRYHUW<<strong>br</strong> />
PXWLQ\RI%XFNDJHQHUDOLQVXERUGLQDWLRQVSUDQJXSDQGLQFUHDVHG<<strong>br</strong> />
'DYHDQG6ROOHNVZHUHXQDIIHFWHGEXWWKHUHVWRIWKHWHDPZHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
IURPEDGWRZRUVH7KLQJVQRORQJHUZHQWULJKW7KHUHZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
FRQWLQXDOELFNHULQJDQGMDQJOLQJ7URXEOHZDVDOZD\VDIRRWDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
DWWKHERWWRPRILWZDV%XFN+HNHSW)UDQFRLVEXV\IRUWKHGRJ<<strong>br</strong> />
GULYHUZDVLQFRQVWDQWDSSUHKHQVLRQRIWKHOLIHDQGGHDWKVWUXJJOH<<strong>br</strong> />
24
EHWZHHQWKHWZRZKLFKKHNQHZPXVWWDNHSODFHVRRQHURUODWHUDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
RQPRUHWKDQRQHQLJKWWKHVRXQGVRITXDUUHOOLQJDQGVWULIHDPRQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHRWKHUGRJVWXUQHGKLPRXWRIKLVVOHHSLQJUREHIHDUIXOWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNDQG6SLW]ZHUHDWLW<<strong>br</strong> />
%XWWKHRSSRUWXQLW\GLGQRWSUHVHQWLWVHOIDQGWKH\SXOOHGLQWR<<strong>br</strong> />
'DZVRQRQHGUHDU\DIWHUQRRQZLWKWKHJUHDWILJKWVWLOOWRFRPH<<strong>br</strong> />
+HUHZHUHPDQ\PHQDQGFRXQWOHVVGRJVDQG%XFNIRXQGWKHPDOODW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZRUN,WVHHPHGWKHRUGDLQHGRUGHURIWKLQJVWKDWGRJVVKRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZRUN$OOGD\WKH\VZXQJXSDQGGRZQWKHPDLQVWUHHWLQORQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WHDPVDQGLQWKHQLJKWWKHLUMLQJOLQJEHOOVVWLOOZHQWE\7KH\<<strong>br</strong> />
KDXOHGFDELQORJVDQGILUHZRRGIUHLJKWHGXSWRWKHPLQHVDQGGLG<<strong>br</strong> />
DOOPDQQHURIZRUNWKDWKRUVHVGLGLQWKH6DQWD&ODUD9DOOH\<<strong>br</strong> />
+HUHDQGWKHUH%XFNPHW6RXWKODQGGRJVEXWLQWKHPDLQWKH\ZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHZLOGZROIKXVN\EUHHG(YHU\QLJKWUHJXODUO\DWQLQHDW<<strong>br</strong> />
WZHOYHDWWKUHHWKH\OLIWHGDQRFWXUQDOVRQJDZHLUGDQGHHULH<<strong>br</strong> />
FKDQWLQZKLFKLWZDV%XFNVGHOLJKWWRMRLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
:LWKWKHDXURUDERUHDOLVIODPLQJFROGO\RYHUKHDGRUWKHVWDUV<<strong>br</strong> />
OHDSLQJLQWKHIURVWGDQFHDQGWKHODQGQXPEDQGIUR]HQXQGHULWV<<strong>br</strong> />
SDOORIVQRZWKLVVRQJRIWKHKXVNLHVPLJKWKDYHEHHQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GHILDQFHRIOLIHRQO\LWZDVSLWFKHGLQPLQRUNH\ZLWKORQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
GUDZQZDLOLQJVDQGKDOIVREVDQGZDVPRUHWKHSOHDGLQJRIOLIH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHDUWLFXODWHWUDYDLORIH[LVWHQFH,WZDVDQROGVRQJROGDV<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHEUHHGLWVHOIRQHRIWKHILUVWVRQJVRIWKH\RXQJHUZRUOGLQD<<strong>br</strong> />
GD\ZKHQVRQJVZHUHVDG,WZDVLQYHVWHGZLWKWKHZRHRI<<strong>br</strong> />
XQQXPEHUHGJHQHUDWLRQVWKLVSODLQWE\ZKLFK%XFNZDVVRVWUDQJHO\<<strong>br</strong> />
VWLUUHG:KHQKHPRDQHGDQGVREEHGLWZDVZLWKWKHSDLQRI<<strong>br</strong> />
OLYLQJWKDWZDVRIROGWKHSDLQRIKLVZLOGIDWKHUVDQGWKHIHDU<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGP\VWHU\RIWKHFROGDQGGDUNWKDWZDVWRWKHPIHDUDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
P\VWHU\$QGWKDWKHVKRXOGEHVWLUUHGE\LWPDUNHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FRPSOHWHQHVVZLWKZKLFKKHKDUNHGEDFNWKURXJKWKHDJHVRIILUH<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGURRIWRWKHUDZEHJLQQLQJVRIOLIHLQWKHKRZOLQJDJHV<<strong>br</strong> />
6HYHQGD\VIURPWKHWLPHWKH\SXOOHGLQWR'DZVRQWKH\GURSSHG<<strong>br</strong> />
GRZQWKHVWHHSEDQNE\WKH%DUUDFNVWRWKH
OLJKW<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH\PDGH6L[W\0LOHZKLFKLVDILIW\PLOHUXQRQWKHILUVWGD\<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGWKHVHFRQGGD\VDZWKHPERRPLQJXSWKH
EHQGDIWHUEHQGEXWKHFRXOGQRWJDLQ+HOD\GRZQORZWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
UDFHZKLQLQJHDJHUO\KLVVSOHQGLGERG\IODVKLQJIRUZDUGOHDSE\<<strong>br</strong> />
OHDSLQWKHZDQZKLWHPRRQOLJKW$QGOHDSE\OHDSOLNHVRPH<<strong>br</strong> />
SDOHIURVWZUDLWKWKHVQRZVKRHUDEELWIODVKHGRQDKHDG<<strong>br</strong> />
$OOWKDWVWLUULQJRIROGLQVWLQFWVZKLFKDWVWDWHGSHULRGVGULYHV<<strong>br</strong> />
PHQRXWIURPWKHVRXQGLQJFLWLHVWRIRUHVWDQGSODLQWRNLOO<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLQJVE\FKHPLFDOO\SURSHOOHGOHDGHQSHOOHWVWKHEORRGOXVWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
MR\WRNLOODOOWKLVZDV%XFNVRQO\LWZDVLQILQLWHO\PRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWLPDWH+HZDVUDQJLQJDWWKHKHDGRIWKHSDFNUXQQLQJWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLOGWKLQJGRZQWKHOLYLQJPHDWWRNLOOZLWKKLVRZQWHHWKDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVKKLVPX]]OHWRWKHH\HVLQZDUPEORRG<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHUHLVDQHFVWDV\WKDWPDUNVWKHVXPPLWRIOLIHDQGEH\RQG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLFKOLIHFDQQRWULVH$QGVXFKLVWKHSDUDGR[RIOLYLQJWKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
HFVWDV\FRPHVZKHQRQHLVPRVWDOLYHDQGLWFRPHVDVDFRPSOHWH<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUJHWIXOQHVVWKDWRQHLVDOLYH7KLVHFVWDV\WKLVIRUJHWIXOQHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
RIOLYLQJFRPHVWRWKHDUWLVWFDXJKWXSDQGRXWRIKLPVHOILQD<<strong>br</strong> />
VKHHWRIIODPHLWFRPHVWRWKHVROGLHUZDUPDGRQDVWULFNHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
ILHOGDQGUHIXVLQJTXDUWHUDQGLWFDPHWR%XFNOHDGLQJWKHSDFN<<strong>br</strong> />
VRXQGLQJWKHROGZROIFU\VWUDLQLQJDIWHUWKHIRRGWKDWZDVDOLYH<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGWKDWIOHGVZLIWO\EHIRUHKLPWKURXJKWKHPRRQOLJKW+HZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
VRXQGLQJWKHGHHSVRIKLVQDWXUHDQGRIWKHSDUWVRIKLVQDWXUH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWZHUHGHHSHUWKDQKHJRLQJEDFNLQWRWKHZRPERI7LPH+H<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVPDVWHUHGE\WKHVKHHUVXUJLQJRIOLIHWKHWLGDOZDYHRI<<strong>br</strong> />
EHLQJWKHSHUIHFWMR\RIHDFKVHSDUDWHPXVFOHMRLQWDQGVLQHZ<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWKDWLWZDVHYHU\WKLQJWKDWZDVQRWGHDWKWKDWLWZDVDJORZ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGUDPSDQWH[SUHVVLQJLWVHOILQPRYHPHQWIO\LQJH[XOWDQWO\<<strong>br</strong> />
XQGHUWKHVWDUVDQGRYHUWKHIDFHRIGHDGPDWWHUWKDWGLGQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
PRYH<<strong>br</strong> />
%XW6SLW]FROGDQGFDOFXODWLQJHYHQLQKLVVXSUHPHPRRGVOHIW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHSDFNDQGFXWDFURVVDQDUURZQHFNRIODQGZKHUHWKHFUHHNPDGH<<strong>br</strong> />
DORQJEHQGDURXQG%XFNGLGQRWNQRZRIWKLVDQGDVKHURXQGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHEHQGWKHIURVWZUDLWKRIDUDEELWVWLOOIOLWWLQJEHIRUHKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
KHVDZDQRWKHUDQGODUJHUIURVWZUDLWKOHDSIURPWKHRYHUKDQJLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
EDQNLQWRWKHLPPHGLDWHSDWKRIWKHUDEELW,WZDV6SLW]7KH<<strong>br</strong> />
UDEELWFRXOGQRWWXUQDQGDVWKHZKLWHWHHWKEURNHLWVEDFNLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
PLGDLULWVKULHNHGDVORXGO\DVDVWULFNHQPDQPD\VKULHN$W<<strong>br</strong> />
VRXQGRIWKLVWKHFU\RI/LIHSOXQJLQJGRZQIURP/LIHVDSH[LQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHJULSRI'HDWKWKHIDOOSDFNDW%XFNVKHHOVUDLVHGDKHOOV<<strong>br</strong> />
FKRUXVRIGHOLJKW<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNGLGQRWFU\RXW+HGLGQRWFKHFNKLPVHOIEXWGURYHLQXSRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
27
6SLW]VKRXOGHUWRVKRXOGHUVRKDUGWKDWKHPLVVHGWKHWKURDW<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH\UROOHGRYHUDQGRYHULQWKHSRZGHU\VQRZ6SLW]JDLQHGKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
IHHWDOPRVWDVWKRXJKKHKDGQRWEHHQRYHUWKURZQVODVKLQJ%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
GRZQWKHVKRXOGHUDQGOHDSLQJFOHDU7ZLFHKLVWHHWKFOLSSHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WRJHWKHUOLNHWKHVWHHOMDZVRIDWUDSDVKHEDFNHGDZD\IRU<<strong>br</strong> />
EHWWHUIRRWLQJZLWKOHDQDQGOLIWLQJOLSVWKDWZULWKHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VQDUOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
,QDIODVK%XFNNQHZLW7KHWLPHKDGFRPH,WZDVWRWKHGHDWK<<strong>br</strong> />
$VWKH\FLUFOHGDERXWVQDUOLQJHDUVODLGEDFNNHHQO\ZDWFKIXO<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUWKHDGYDQWDJHWKHVFHQHFDPHWR%XFNZLWKDVHQVHRI<<strong>br</strong> />
IDPLOLDULW\+HVHHPHGWRUHPHPEHULWDOOWKHZKLWHZRRGVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
HDUWKDQGPRRQOLJKWDQGWKHWKULOORIEDWWOH2YHUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLWHQHVVDQGVLOHQFHEURRGHGDJKRVWO\FDOP7KHUHZDVQRWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IDLQWHVWZKLVSHURIDLUQRWKLQJPRYHGQRWDOHDITXLYHUHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
YLVLEOHEUHDWKVRIWKHGRJVULVLQJVORZO\DQGOLQJHULQJLQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IURVW\DLU7KH\KDGPDGHVKRUWZRUNRIWKHVQRZVKRHUDEELW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHVHGRJVWKDWZHUHLOOWDPHGZROYHVDQGWKH\ZHUHQRZGUDZQXS<<strong>br</strong> />
LQDQH[SHFWDQWFLUFOH7KH\WRRZHUHVLOHQWWKHLUH\HVRQO\<<strong>br</strong> />
JOHDPLQJDQGWKHLUEUHDWKVGULIWLQJVORZO\XSZDUG7R%XFNLWZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
QRWKLQJQHZRUVWUDQJHWKLVVFHQHRIROGWLPH,WZDVDVWKRXJK<<strong>br</strong> />
LWKDGDOZD\VEHHQWKHZRQWHGZD\RIWKLQJV<<strong>br</strong> />
6SLW]ZDVDSUDFWLVHGILJKWHU)URP6SLW]EHUJHQWKURXJKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
$UFWLFDQGDFURVV&DQDGDDQGWKH%DUUHQVKHKDGKHOGKLVRZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKDOOPDQQHURIGRJVDQGDFKLHYHGWRPDVWHU\RYHUWKHP%LWWHU<<strong>br</strong> />
UDJHZDVKLVEXWQHYHUEOLQGUDJH,QSDVVLRQWRUHQGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
GHVWUR\KHQHYHUIRUJRWWKDWKLVHQHP\ZDVLQOLNHSDVVLRQWR<<strong>br</strong> />
UHQGDQGGHVWUR\+HQHYHUUXVKHGWLOOKHZDVSUHSDUHGWRUHFHLYH<<strong>br</strong> />
DUXVKQHYHUDWWDFNHGWLOOKHKDGILUVWGHIHQGHGWKDWDWWDFN<<strong>br</strong> />
,QYDLQ%XFNVWURYHWRVLQNKLVWHHWKLQWKHQHFNRIWKHELJZKLWH<<strong>br</strong> />
GRJ:KHUHYHUKLVIDQJVVWUXFNIRUWKHVRIWHUIOHVKWKH\ZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
FRXQWHUHGE\WKHIDQJVRI6SLW])DQJFODVKHGIDQJDQGOLSVZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
FXWDQGEOHHGLQJEXW%XFNFRXOGQRWSHQHWUDWHKLVHQHP\VJXDUG<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHQKHZDUPHGXSDQGHQYHORSHG6SLW]LQDZKLUOZLQGRIUXVKHV<<strong>br</strong> />
7LPHDQGWLPHDJDLQKHWULHGIRUWKHVQRZZKLWHWKURDWZKHUHOLIH<<strong>br</strong> />
EXEEOHGQHDUWRWKHVXUIDFHDQGHDFKWLPHDQGHYHU\WLPH6SLW]<<strong>br</strong> />
VODVKHGKLPDQGJRWDZD\7KHQ%XFNWRRNWRUXVKLQJDVWKRXJKIRU<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHWKURDWZKHQVXGGHQO\GUDZLQJEDFNKLVKHDGDQGFXUYLQJLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
IURPWKHVLGHKHZRXOGGULYHKLVVKRXOGHUDWWKHVKRXOGHURI<<strong>br</strong> />
6SLW]DVDUDPE\ZKLFKWRRYHUWKURZKLP%XWLQVWHDG%XFNV<<strong>br</strong> />
VKRXOGHUZDVVODVKHGGRZQHDFKWLPHDV6SLW]OHDSHGOLJKWO\DZD\<<strong>br</strong> />
28
6SLW]ZDVXQWRXFKHGZKLOH%XFNZDVVWUHDPLQJZLWKEORRGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
SDQWLQJKDUG7KHILJKWZDVJURZLQJGHVSHUDWH$QGDOOWKHZKLOH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHVLOHQWDQGZROILVKFLUFOHZDLWHGWRILQLVKRIIZKLFKHYHUGRJ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHQWGRZQ$V%XFNJUHZZLQGHG6SLW]WRRNWRUXVKLQJDQGKH<<strong>br</strong> />
NHSWKLPVWDJJHULQJIRUIRRWLQJ2QFH%XFNZHQWRYHUDQGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKROHFLUFOHRIVL[W\GRJVVWDUWHGXSEXWKHUHFRYHUHGKLPVHOI<<strong>br</strong> />
DOPRVWLQPLGDLUDQGWKHFLUFOHVDQNGRZQDJDLQDQGZDLWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
%XW%XFNSRVVHVVHGDTXDOLW\WKDWPDGHIRUJUHDWQHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
LPDJLQDWLRQ+HIRXJKWE\LQVWLQFWEXWKHFRXOGILJKWE\KHDGDV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHOO+HUXVKHGDVWKRXJKDWWHPSWLQJWKHROGVKRXOGHUWULFNEXW<<strong>br</strong> />
DWWKHODVWLQVWDQWVZHSWORZWRWKHVQRZDQGLQ+LVWHHWK<<strong>br</strong> />
FORVHGRQ6SLW]VOHIWIRUHOHJ7KHUHZDVDFUXQFKRIEUHDNLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
ERQHDQGWKHZKLWHGRJIDFHGKLPRQWKUHHOHJV7KULFHKHWULHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WRNQRFNKLPRYHUWKHQUHSHDWHGWKHWULFNDQGEURNHWKHULJKW<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUHOHJ'HVSLWHWKHSDLQDQGKHOSOHVVQHVV6SLW]VWUXJJOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
PDGO\WRNHHSXS+HVDZWKHVLOHQWFLUFOHZLWKJOHDPLQJH\HV<<strong>br</strong> />
OROOLQJWRQJXHVDQGVLOYHU\EUHDWKVGULIWLQJXSZDUGFORVLQJLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
XSRQKLPDVKHKDGVHHQVLPLODUFLUFOHVFORVHLQXSRQEHDWHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQWDJRQLVWVLQWKHSDVW2QO\WKLVWLPHKHZDVWKHRQHZKRZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
EHDWHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHUHZDVQRKRSHIRUKLP%XFNZDVLQH[RUDEOH0HUF\ZDVD<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLQJUHVHUYHGIRUJHQGHUFOLPHV+HPDQRHXYUHGIRUWKHILQDO<<strong>br</strong> />
UXVK7KHFLUFOHKDGWLJKWHQHGWLOOKHFRXOGIHHOWKHEUHDWKVRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHKXVNLHVRQKLVIODQNV+HFRXOGVHHWKHPEH\RQG6SLW]DQGWR<<strong>br</strong> />
HLWKHUVLGHKDOIFURXFKLQJIRUWKHVSULQJWKHLUH\HVIL[HGXSRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
KLP$SDXVHVHHPHGWRIDOO(YHU\DQLPDOZDVPRWLRQOHVVDV<<strong>br</strong> />
WKRXJKWXUQHGWRVWRQH2QO\6SLW]TXLYHUHGDQGEULVWOHGDVKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VWDJJHUHGEDFNDQGIRUWKVQDUOLQJZLWKKRUULEOHPHQDFHDVWKRXJK<<strong>br</strong> />
WRIULJKWHQRIILPSHQGLQJGHDWK7KHQ%XFNVSUDQJLQDQGRXWEXW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLOHKHZDVLQVKRXOGHUKDGDWODVWVTXDUHO\PHWVKRXOGHU7KH<<strong>br</strong> />
GDUNFLUFOHEHFDPHDGRWRQWKHPRRQIORRGHGVQRZDV6SLW]<<strong>br</strong> />
GLVDSSHDUHGIURPYLHZ%XFNVWRRGDQGORRNHGRQWKHVXFFHVVIXO<<strong>br</strong> />
FKDPSLRQWKHGRPLQDQWSULPRUGLDOEHDVWZKRKDGPDGHKLVNLOODQG<<strong>br</strong> />
IRXQGLWJRRG<<strong>br</strong> />
&KDSWHU,9<<strong>br</strong> />
:KR+DV:RQWR0DVWHUVKLS<<strong>br</strong> />
29
(K":RW,VD\",VSLNWUXHZHQ,VD\GDW%XFNWZRGHYLOV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KLVZDV)UDQFRLVVVSHHFKQH[WPRUQLQJZKHQKHGLVFRYHUHG6SLW]<<strong>br</strong> />
PLVVLQJDQG%XFNFRYHUHGZLWKZRXQGV+HGUHZKLPWRWKHILUHDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
E\LWVOLJKWSRLQWHGWKHPRXW<<strong>br</strong> />
'DW6SLW]ILJKWODNKHOOVDLG3HUUDXOWDVKHVXUYH\HGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
JDSLQJULSVDQGFXWV<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGDW%XFNILJKWODNWZRKHOOVZDV)UDQFRLVVDQVZHU$Q<<strong>br</strong> />
QRZZHPDNHJRRGWLPH1RPRUH6SLW]QRPRUHWURXEOHVXUH<<strong>br</strong> />
:KLOH3HUUDXOWSDFNHGWKHFDPSRXWILWDQGORDGHGWKHVOHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GRJGULYHUSURFHHGHGWRKDUQHVVWKHGRJV%XFNWURWWHGXSWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
SODFH6SLW]ZRXOGKDYHRFFXSLHGDVOHDGHUEXW)UDQFRLVQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
QRWLFLQJKLPEURXJKW6ROOHNVWRWKHFRYHWHGSRVLWLRQ,QKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
MXGJPHQW6ROOHNVZDVWKHEHVWOHDGGRJOHIW%XFNVSUDQJXSRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
6ROOHNVLQDIXU\GULYLQJKLPEDFNDQGVWDQGLQJLQKLVSODFH<<strong>br</strong> />
(K"HK")UDQFRLVFULHGVODSSLQJKLVWKLJKVJOHHIXOO\/RRNDW<<strong>br</strong> />
GDW%XFN+HHPNHHOGDW6SLW]KHHPWLQNWRWDNHGHMRE<<strong>br</strong> />
*RZD\&KRRNKHFULHGEXW%XFNUHIXVHGWREXGJH<<strong>br</strong> />
+HWRRN%XFNE\WKHVFUXIIRIWKHQHFNDQGWKRXJKWKHGRJJURZOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKUHDWHQLQJO\GUDJJHGKLPWRRQHVLGHDQGUHSODFHG6ROOHNV7KH<<strong>br</strong> />
ROGGRJGLGQRWOLNHLWDQGVKRZHGSODLQO\WKDWKHZDVDIUDLGRI<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFN)UDQFRLVZDVREGXUDWHEXWZKHQKHWXUQHGKLVEDFN%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
DJDLQGLVSODFHG6ROOHNVZKRZDVQRWDWDOOXQZLOOLQJWRJR<<strong>br</strong> />
)UDQFRLVZDVDQJU\1RZE\*DU,IHH[\RXKHFULHGFRPLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
EDFNZLWKDKHDY\FOXELQKLVKDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNUHPHPEHUHGWKHPDQLQWKHUHGVZHDWHUDQGUHWUHDWHGVORZO\<<strong>br</strong> />
QRUGLGKHDWWHPSWWRFKDUJHLQZKHQ6ROOHNVZDVRQFHPRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
EURXJKWIRUZDUG%XWKHFLUFOHGMXVWEH\RQGWKHUDQJHRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FOXEVQDUOLQJZLWKELWWHUQHVVDQGUDJHDQGZKLOHKHFLUFOHGKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDWFKHGWKHFOXEVRDVWRGRGJHLWLIWKURZQE\)UDQFRLVIRUKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVEHFRPHZLVHLQWKHZD\RIFOXEV7KHGULYHUZHQWDERXWKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZRUNDQGKHFDOOHGWR%XFNZKHQKHZDVUHDG\WRSXWKLPLQKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
ROGSODFHLQIURQWRI'DYH%XFNUHWUHDWHGWZRRUWKUHHVWHSV<<strong>br</strong> />
)UDQFRLVIROORZHGKLPXSZKHUHXSRQKHDJDLQUHWUHDWHG$IWHU<<strong>br</strong> />
VRPHWLPHRIWKLV)UDQFRLVWKUHZGRZQWKHFOXEWKLQNLQJWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNIHDUHGDWKUDVKLQJ%XW%XFNZDVLQRSHQUHYROW+HZDQWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
QRWWRHVFDSHDFOXEELQJEXWWRKDYHWKHOHDGHUVKLS,WZDVKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
30
E\ULJKW+HKDGHDUQHGLWDQGKHZRXOGQRWEHFRQWHQWZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
OHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
3HUUDXOWWRRNDKDQG%HWZHHQWKHPWKH\UDQKLPDERXWIRUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
EHWWHUSDUWRIDQKRXU7KH\WKUHZFOXEVDWKLP+HGRGJHG<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH\FXUVHGKLPDQGKLVIDWKHUVDQGPRWKHUVEHIRUHKLPDQGDOO<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVVHHGWRFRPHDIWHUKLPGRZQWRWKHUHPRWHVWJHQHUDWLRQDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
HYHU\KDLURQKLVERG\DQGGURSRIEORRGLQKLVYHLQVDQGKH<<strong>br</strong> />
DQVZHUHGFXUVHZLWKVQDUODQGNHSWRXWRIWKHLUUHDFK+HGLGQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
WU\WRUXQDZD\EXWUHWUHDWHGDURXQGDQGDURXQGWKHFDPS<<strong>br</strong> />
DGYHUWLVLQJSODLQO\WKDWZKHQKLVGHVLUHZDVPHWKHZRXOGFRPHLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGEHJRRG<<strong>br</strong> />
)UDQFRLVVDWGRZQDQGVFUDWFKHGKLVKHDG3HUUDXOWORRNHGDWKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDWFKDQGVZRUH7LPHZDVIO\LQJDQGWKH\VKRXOGKDYHEHHQRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHWUDLODQKRXUJRQH)UDQFRLVVFUDWFKHGKLVKHDGDJDLQ+H<<strong>br</strong> />
VKRRNLWDQGJULQQHGVKHHSLVKO\DWWKHFRXULHUZKRVKUXJJHGKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
VKRXOGHUVLQVLJQWKDWWKH\ZHUHEHDWHQ7KHQ)UDQFRLVZHQWXSWR<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKHUH6ROOHNVVWRRGDQGFDOOHGWR%XFN%XFNODXJKHGDVGRJV<<strong>br</strong> />
ODXJK\HWNHSWKLVGLVWDQFH)UDQFRLVXQIDVWHQHG6ROOHNVV<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDFHVDQGSXWKLPEDFNLQKLVROGSODFH7KHWHDPVWRRG<<strong>br</strong> />
KDUQHVVHGWRWKHVOHGLQDQXQEURNHQOLQHUHDG\IRUWKHWUDLO<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHUHZDVQRSODFHIRU%XFNVDYHDWWKHIURQW2QFHPRUH)UDQFRLV<<strong>br</strong> />
FDOOHGDQGRQFHPRUH%XFNODXJKHGDQGNHSWDZD\<<strong>br</strong> />
7URZGRZQGHFOXE3HUUDXOWFRPPDQGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
)UDQFRLVFRPSOLHGZKHUHXSRQ%XFNWURWWHGLQODXJKLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WULXPSKDQWO\DQGVZXQJDURXQGLQWRSRVLWLRQDWWKHKHDGRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WHDP+LVWUDFHVZHUHIDVWHQHGWKHVOHGEURNHQRXWDQGZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
ERWKPHQUXQQLQJWKH\GDVKHGRXWRQWRWKHULYHUWUDLO<<strong>br</strong> />
+LJKO\DVWKHGRJGULYHUKDGIRUHYDOXHG%XFNZLWKKLVWZRGHYLOV<<strong>br</strong> />
KHIRXQGZKLOHWKHGD\ZDV\HW\RXQJWKDWKHKDGXQGHUYDOXHG<<strong>br</strong> />
$WDERXQG%XFNWRRNXSWKHGXWLHVRIOHDGHUVKLSDQGZKHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
MXGJPHQWZDVUHTXLUHGDQGTXLFNWKLQNLQJDQGTXLFNDFWLQJKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VKRZHGKLPVHOIWKHVXSHULRUHYHQRI6SLW]RIZKRP)UDQFRLVKDG<<strong>br</strong> />
QHYHUVHHQDQHTXDO<<strong>br</strong> />
%XWLWZDVLQJLYLQJWKHODZDQGPDNLQJKLVPDWHVOLYHXSWRLW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDW%XFNH[FHOOHG'DYHDQG6ROOHNVGLGQRWPLQGWKHFKDQJHLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
OHDGHUVKLS,WZDVQRQHRIWKHLUEXVLQHVV7KHLUEXVLQHVVZDVWR<<strong>br</strong> />
WRLODQGWRLOPLJKWLO\LQWKHWUDFHV6RORQJDVWKDWZHUHQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWHUIHUHGZLWKWKH\GLGQRWFDUHZKDWKDSSHQHG%LOOHHWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
31
JRRGQDWXUHGFRXOGOHDGIRUDOOWKH\FDUHGVRORQJDVKHNHSW<<strong>br</strong> />
RUGHU7KHUHVWRIWKHWHDPKRZHYHUKDGJURZQXQUXO\GXULQJWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ODVWGD\VRI6SLW]DQGWKHLUVXUSULVHZDVJUHDWQRZWKDW%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
SURFHHGHGWROLFNWKHPLQWRVKDSH<<strong>br</strong> />
3LNHZKRSXOOHGDW%XFNVKHHOVDQGZKRQHYHUSXWDQRXQFHPRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
RIKLVZHLJKWDJDLQVWWKHEUHDVWEDQGWKDQKHZDVFRPSHOOHGWRGR<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVVZLIWO\DQGUHSHDWHGO\VKDNHQIRUORDILQJDQGHUHWKHILUVW<<strong>br</strong> />
GD\ZDVGRQHKHZDVSXOOLQJPRUHWKDQHYHUEHIRUHLQKLVOLIH<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHILUVWQLJKWLQFDPS-RHWKHVRXURQHZDVSXQLVKHGURXQGO\<<strong>br</strong> />
DWKLQJWKDW6SLW]KDGQHYHUVXFFHHGHGLQGRLQJ%XFNVLPSO\<<strong>br</strong> />
VPRWKHUHGKLPE\YLUWXHRIVXSHULRUZHLJKWDQGFXWKLPXSWLOOKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FHDVHGVQDSSLQJDQGEHJDQWRZKLQHIRUPHUF\<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHJHQHUDOWRQHRIWKHWHDPSLFNHGXSLPPHGLDWHO\,WUHFRYHUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
LWVROGWLPHVROLGDULW\DQGRQFHPRUHWKHGRJVOHDSHGDVRQHGRJ<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWKHWUDFHV$WWKH5LQN5DSLGVWZRQDWLYHKXVNLHV7HHNDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
.RRQDZHUHDGGHGDQGWKHFHOHULW\ZLWKZKLFK%XFNEURNHWKHPLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WRRNDZD\)UDQFRLVVEUHDWK<<strong>br</strong> />
1HYDLUHVXFKDGRJDVGDW%XFNKHFULHG1RQHYDLUH+HHP<<strong>br</strong> />
ZRUWKRQHWRXVDQGROODLUE\*DU(K":RW\RXVD\3HUUDXOW"<<strong>br</strong> />
$QG3HUUDXOWQRGGHG+HZDVDKHDGRIWKHUHFRUGWKHQDQGJDLQLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
GD\E\GD\7KHWUDLOZDVLQH[FHOOHQWFRQGLWLRQZHOOSDFNHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
KDUGDQGWKHUHZDVQRQHZIDOOHQVQRZZLWKZKLFKWRFRQWHQG,W<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVQRWWRRFROG7KHWHPSHUDWXUHGURSSHGWRILIW\EHORZ]HURDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
UHPDLQHGWKHUHWKHZKROHWULS7KHPHQURGHDQGUDQE\WXUQDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHGRJVZHUHNHSWRQWKHMXPSZLWKEXWLQIUHTXHQWVWRSSDJHV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH7KLUW\0LOH5LYHUZDVFRPSDUDWLYHO\FRDWHGZLWKLFHDQGWKH\<<strong>br</strong> />
FRYHUHGLQRQHGD\JRLQJRXWZKDWKDGWDNHQWKHPWHQGD\VFRPLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
LQ,QRQHUXQWKH\PDGHDVL[W\PLOHGDVKIURPWKHIRRWRI/DNH<<strong>br</strong> />
/H%DUJHWRWKH:KLWH+RUVH5DSLGV$FURVV0DUVK7DJLVKDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
%HQQHWWVHYHQW\PLOHVRIODNHVWKH\IOHZVRIDVWWKDWWKHPDQ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKRVHWXUQLWZDVWRUXQWRZHGEHKLQGWKHVOHGDWWKHHQGRID<<strong>br</strong> />
URSH$QGRQWKHODVWQLJKWRIWKHVHFRQGZHHNWKH\WRSSHG:KLWH<<strong>br</strong> />
3DVVDQGGURSSHGGRZQWKHVHDVORSHZLWKWKHOLJKWVRI6NDJXD\DQG<<strong>br</strong> />
RIWKHVKLSSLQJDWWKHLUIHHW<<strong>br</strong> />
,WZDVDUHFRUGUXQ(DFKGD\IRUIRXUWHHQGD\VWKH\KDGDYHUDJHG<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUW\PLOHV)RUWKUHHGD\V3HUUDXOWDQG)UDQFRLVWKUHZFKHVWVXS<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGGRZQWKHPDLQVWUHHWRI6NDJXD\DQGZHUHGHOXJHGZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
LQYLWDWLRQVWRGULQNZKLOHWKHWHDPZDVWKHFRQVWDQWFHQWUHRID<<strong>br</strong> />
32
ZRUVKLSIXOFURZGRIGRJEXVWHUVDQGPXVKHUV7KHQWKUHHRUIRXU<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHVWHUQEDGPHQDVSLUHGWRFOHDQRXWWKHWRZQZHUHULGGOHGOLNH<<strong>br</strong> />
SHSSHUER[HVIRUWKHLUSDLQVDQGSXEOLFLQWHUHVWWXUQHGWRRWKHU<<strong>br</strong> />
LGROV1H[WFDPHRIILFLDORUGHUV)UDQFRLVFDOOHG%XFNWRKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
WKUHZKLVDUPVDURXQGKLPZHSWRYHUKLP$QGWKDWZDVWKHODVW<<strong>br</strong> />
RI)UDQFRLVDQG3HUUDXOW/LNHRWKHUPHQWKH\SDVVHGRXWRI<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNVOLIHIRUJRRG<<strong>br</strong> />
$6FRWFKKDOIEUHHGWRRNFKDUJHRIKLPDQGKLVPDWHVDQGLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
FRPSDQ\ZLWKDGR]HQRWKHUGRJWHDPVKHVWDUWHGEDFNRYHUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHDU\WUDLOWR'DZVRQ,WZDVQROLJKWUXQQLQJQRZQRUUHFRUG<<strong>br</strong> />
WLPHEXWKHDY\WRLOHDFKGD\ZLWKDKHDY\ORDGEHKLQGIRUWKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVWKHPDLOWUDLQFDUU\LQJZRUGIURPWKHZRUOGWRWKHPHQZKR<<strong>br</strong> />
VRXJKWJROGXQGHUWKHVKDGRZRIWKH3ROH<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNGLGQRWOLNHLWEXWKHERUHXSZHOOWRWKHZRUNWDNLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
SULGHLQLWDIWHUWKHPDQQHURI'DYHDQG6ROOHNVDQGVHHLQJWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVPDWHVZKHWKHUWKH\SULGHGLQLWRUQRWGLGWKHLUIDLUVKDUH<<strong>br</strong> />
,WZDVDPRQRWRQRXVOLIHRSHUDWLQJZLWKPDFKLQHOLNHUHJXODULW\<<strong>br</strong> />
2QHGD\ZDVYHU\OLNHDQRWKHU$WDFHUWDLQWLPHHDFKPRUQLQJWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FRRNVWXUQHGRXWILUHVZHUHEXLOWDQGEUHDNIDVWZDVHDWHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHQZKLOHVRPHEURNHFDPSRWKHUVKDUQHVVHGWKHGRJVDQGWKH\<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHUHXQGHUZD\DQKRXURUVREHIRUHWKHGDUNQHVVIHOOZKLFKJDYH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDUQLQJRIGDZQ$WQLJKWFDPSZDVPDGH6RPHSLWFKHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IOLHVRWKHUVFXWILUHZRRGDQGSLQHERXJKVIRUWKHEHGVDQGVWLOO<<strong>br</strong> />
RWKHUVFDUULHGZDWHURULFHIRUWKHFRRNV$OVRWKHGRJVZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
IHG7RWKHPWKLVZDVWKHRQHIHDWXUHRIWKHGD\WKRXJKLWZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
JRRGWRORDIDURXQGDIWHUWKHILVKZDVHDWHQIRUDQKRXURUVR<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKWKHRWKHUGRJVRIZKLFKWKHUHZHUHILYHVFRUHDQGRGG7KHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHUHILHUFHILJKWHUVDPRQJWKHPEXWWKUHHEDWWOHVZLWKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ILHUFHVWEURXJKW%XFNWRPDVWHU\VRWKDWZKHQKHEULVWOHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VKRZHGKLVWHHWKWKH\JRWRXWRIKLVZD\<<strong>br</strong> />
%HVWRIDOOSHUKDSVKHORYHGWROLHQHDUWKHILUHKLQGOHJV<<strong>br</strong> />
FURXFKHGXQGHUKLPIRUHOHJVVWUHWFKHGRXWLQIURQWKHDGUDLVHG<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGH\HVEOLQNLQJGUHDPLO\DWWKHIODPHV6RPHWLPHVKHWKRXJKWRI<<strong>br</strong> />
-XGJH0LOOHUVELJKRXVHLQWKHVXQNLVVHG6DQWD&ODUD9DOOH\DQG<<strong>br</strong> />
RIWKHFHPHQWVZLPPLQJWDQNDQG
IDPLOLDULW\WKHLQVWLQFWVZKLFKZHUHEXWWKHPHPRULHVRIKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
DQFHVWRUVEHFRPHKDELWVZKLFKKDGODSVHGLQODWHUGD\VDQGVWLOO<<strong>br</strong> />
ODWHULQKLPTXLFNHQHGDQGEHFRPHDOLYHDJDLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
6RPHWLPHVDVKHFURXFKHGWKHUHEOLQNLQJGUHDPLO\DWWKHIODPHV<<strong>br</strong> />
LWVHHPHGWKDWWKHIODPHVZHUHRIDQRWKHUILUHDQGWKDWDVKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FURXFKHGE\WKLVRWKHUILUHKHVDZDQRWKHUDQGGLIIHUHQWPDQIURP<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHKDOIEUHHGFRRNEHIRUHKLP7KLVRWKHUPDQZDVVKRUWHURIOHJ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGORQJHURIDUPZLWKPXVFOHVWKDWZHUHVWULQJ\DQGNQRWW\<<strong>br</strong> />
UDWKHUWKDQURXQGHGDQGVZHOOLQJ7KHKDLURIWKLVPDQZDVORQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGPDWWHGDQGKLVKHDGVODQWHGEDFNXQGHULWIURPWKHH\HV+H<<strong>br</strong> />
XWWHUHGVWUDQJHVRXQGVDQGVHHPHGYHU\PXFKDIUDLGRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GDUNQHVVLQWRZKLFKKHSHHUHGFRQWLQXDOO\FOXWFKLQJLQKLVKDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLFKKXQJPLGZD\EHWZHHQNQHHDQGIRRWDVWLFNZLWKDKHDY\<<strong>br</strong> />
VWRQHPDGHIDVWWRWKHHQG+HZDVDOOEXWQDNHGDUDJJHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
ILUHVFRUFKHGVNLQKDQJLQJSDUWZD\GRZQKLVEDFNEXWRQKLVERG\<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHUHZDVPXFKKDLU,QVRPHSODFHVDFURVVWKHFKHVWDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VKRXOGHUVDQGGRZQWKHRXWVLGHRIWKHDUPVDQGWKLJKVLWZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
PDWWHGLQWRDOPRVWDWKLFNIXU+HGLGQRWVWDQGHUHFWEXWZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
WUXQNLQFOLQHGIRUZDUGIURPWKHKLSVRQOHJVWKDWEHQWDWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
NQHHV$ERXWKLVERG\WKHUHZDVDSHFXOLDUVSULQJLQHVVRU<<strong>br</strong> />
UHVLOLHQF\DOPRVWFDWOLNHDQGDTXLFNDOHUWQHVVDVRIRQHZKR<<strong>br</strong> />
OLYHGLQSHUSHWXDOIHDURIWKLQJVVHHQDQGXQVHHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
$WRWKHUWLPHVWKLVKDLU\PDQVTXDWWHGE\WKHILUHZLWKKHDG<<strong>br</strong> />
EHWZHHQKLVOHJVDQGVOHSW2QVXFKRFFDVLRQVKLVHOERZVZHUHRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVNQHHVKLVKDQGVFODVSHGDERYHKLVKHDGDVWKRXJKWRVKHGUDLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
E\WKHKDLU\DUPV$QGEH\RQGWKDWILUHLQWKHFLUFOLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
GDUNQHVV%XFNFRXOGVHHPDQ\JOHDPLQJFRDOVWZRE\WZRDOZD\V<<strong>br</strong> />
WZRE\WZRZKLFKKHNQHZWREHWKHH\HVRIJUHDWEHDVWVRISUH\<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGKHFRXOGKHDUWKHFUDVKLQJRIWKHLUERGLHVWKURXJKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
XQGHUJURZWKDQGWKHQRLVHVWKH\PDGHLQWKHQLJKW$QGGUHDPLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHUHE\WKH
UHVWDWOHDVW%XWLQWZRGD\VWLPHWKH\GURSSHGGRZQWKH
WKHEHDWHQWUDLODWWDFNLQJ6ROOHNVZLWKKLVWHHWKUXVKLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
DJDLQVWKLPDQGWU\LQJWRWKUXVWKLPRIILQWRWKHVRIWVQRZRQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
RWKHUVLGHVWULYLQJWROHDSLQVLGHKLVWUDFHVDQGJHWEHWZHHQKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGWKHVOHGDQG$WKHZKLOHZKLQLQJDQG\HOSLQJDQGFU\LQJZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
JULHIDQGSDLQ7KHKDOIEUHHGWULHGWRGULYHKLPDZD\ZLWKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLSEXWKHSDLGQRKHHGWRWKHVWLQJLQJODVKDQGWKHPDQKDG<<strong>br</strong> />
QRWWKHKHDUWWRVWULNHKDUGHU'DYHUHIXVHGWRUXQTXLHWO\RQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDLOEHKLQGWKHVOHGZKHUHWKHJRLQJZDVHDV\EXWFRQWLQXHGWR<<strong>br</strong> />
IORXQGHUDORQJVLGHLQWKHVRIWVQRZZKHUHWKHJRLQJZDVPRVW<<strong>br</strong> />
GLIILFXOWWLOOH[KDXVWHG7KHQKHIHOODQGOD\ZKHUHKHIHOO<<strong>br</strong> />
KRZOLQJOXJXEULRXVO\DVWKHORQJWUDLQRIVOHGVFKXUQHGE\<<strong>br</strong> />
:LWKWKHODVWUHPQDQWRIKLVVWUHQJWKKHPDQDJHGWRVWDJJHUDORQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
EHKLQGWLOOWKHWUDLQPDGHDQRWKHUVWRSZKHQKHIORXQGHUHGSDVW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHVOHGVWRKLVRZQZKHUHKHVWRRGDORQJVLGH6ROOHNV+LV<<strong>br</strong> />
GULYHUOLQJHUHGDPRPHQWWRJHWDOLJKWIRUKLVSLSHIURPWKHPDQ<<strong>br</strong> />
EHKLQG7KHQKHUHWXUQHGDQGVWDUWHGKLVGRJV7KH\VZXQJRXWRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHWUDLOZLWKUHPDUNDEOHODFNRIH[HUWLRQWXUQHGWKHLUKHDGV<<strong>br</strong> />
XQHDVLO\DQGVWRSSHGLQVXUSULVH7KHGULYHUZDVVXUSULVHGWRR<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHVOHGKDGQRWPRYHG+HFDOOHGKLVFRPUDGHVWRZLWQHVVWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VLJKW'DYHKDGELWWHQWKURXJKERWKRI6ROOHNVVWUDFHVDQGZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
VWDQGLQJGLUHFWO\LQIURQWRIWKHVOHGLQKLVSURSHUSODFH<<strong>br</strong> />
+HSOHDGHGZLWKKLVH\HVWRUHPDLQWKHUH7KHGULYHUZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
SHUSOH[HG+LVFRPUDGHVWDONHGRIKRZDGRJFRXOGEUHDNLWVKHDUW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURXJKEHLQJGHQLHGWKHZRUNWKDWNLOOHGLWDQGUHFDOOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
LQVWDQFHVWKH\KDGNQRZQZKHUHGRJVWRRROGIRUWKHWRLORU<<strong>br</strong> />
LQMXUHGKDGGLHGEHFDXVHWKH\ZHUHFXWRXWRIWKHWUDFHV$OVR<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\KHOGLWDPHUF\VLQFH'DYHZDVWRGLHDQ\ZD\WKDWKHVKRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
GLHLQWKHWUDFHVKHDUWHDV\DQGFRQWHQW6RKHZDVKDUQHVVHGLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
DJDLQDQGSURXGO\KHSXOOHGDVRIROGWKRXJKPRUHWKDQRQFHKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FULHGRXWLQYROXQWDULO\IURPWKHELWHRIKLVLQZDUGKXUW6HYHUDO<<strong>br</strong> />
WLPHVKHIHOOGRZQDQGZDVGUDJJHGLQWKHWUDFHVDQGRQFHWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VOHGUDQXSRQKLPVRWKDWKHOLPSHGWKHUHDIWHULQRQHRIKLVKLQG<<strong>br</strong> />
OHJV<<strong>br</strong> />
%XWKHKHOGRXWWLOOFDPSZDVUHDFKHGZKHQKLVGULYHUPDGHD<<strong>br</strong> />
SODFHIRUKLPE\WKHILUH0RUQLQJIRXQGKLPWRRZHDNWRWUDYHO<<strong>br</strong> />
$WKDUQHVVXSWLPHKHWULHGWRFUDZOWRKLVGULYHU%\FRQYXOVLYH<<strong>br</strong> />
HIIRUWVKHJRWRQKLVIHHWVWDJJHUHGDQGIHOO7KHQKHZRUPHG<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVZD\IRUZDUGVORZO\WRZDUGZKHUHWKHKDUQHVVHVZHUHEHLQJSXW<<strong>br</strong> />
RQKLVPDWHV+HZRXOGDGYDQFHKLVIRUHOHJVDQGGUDJXSKLVERG\<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKDVRUWRIKLWFKLQJPRYHPHQWZKHQKHZRXOGDGYDQFHKLVIRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
OHJVDQGKLWFKDKHDGDJDLQIRUDIHZPRUHLQFKHV+LVVWUHQJWK<<strong>br</strong> />
36
OHIWKLPDQGWKHODVWKLVPDWHVVDZRIKLPKHOD\JDVSLQJLQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VQRZDQG\HDUQLQJWRZDUGWKHP%XWWKH\FRXOGKHDUKLPPRXUQIXOO\<<strong>br</strong> />
KRZOLQJWLOOWKH\SDVVHGRXWRIVLJKWEHKLQGDEHOWRIULYHU<<strong>br</strong> />
WLPEHU<<strong>br</strong> />
+HUHWKHWUDLQZDVKDOWHG7KH6FRWFKKDOIEUHHGVORZO\UHWUDFHG<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVVWHSVWRWKHFDPSWKH\KDGOHIW7KHPHQFHDVHGWDONLQJ$<<strong>br</strong> />
UHYROYHUVKRWUDQJRXW7KHPDQFDPHEDFNKXUULHGO\7KHZKLSV<<strong>br</strong> />
VQDSSHGWKHEHOOVWLQNOHGPHUULO\WKHVOHGVFKXUQHGDORQJWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDLOEXW%XFNNQHZDQGHYHU\GRJNQHZZKDWKDGWDNHQSODFH<<strong>br</strong> />
EHKLQGWKHEHOWRIULYHUWUHHV<<strong>br</strong> />
&KDSWHU9<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH7RLORI7UDFHDQG7UDLO<<strong>br</strong> />
7KLUW\GD\VIURPWKHWLPHLWOHIW'DZVRQWKH6DOW:DWHU0DLO<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWK%XFNDQGKLVPDWHVDWWKHIRUHDUULYHGDW6NDJXD\7KH\<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHUHLQDZUHWFKHGVWDWHZRUQRXWDQGZRUQGRZQ%XFNVRQH<<strong>br</strong> />
KXQGUHGDQGIRUW\SRXQGVKDGGZLQGOHGWRRQHKXQGUHGDQGILIWHHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHUHVWRIKLVPDWHVWKRXJKOLJKWHUGRJVKDGUHODWLYHO\ORVW<<strong>br</strong> />
PRUHZHLJKWWKDQKH3LNHWKHPDOLQJHUHUZKRLQKLVOLIHWLPH<<strong>br</strong> />
RIGHFHLWKDGRIWHQVXFFHVVIXOO\IHLJQHGDKXUWOHJZDVQRZ<<strong>br</strong> />
OLPSLQJLQHDUQHVW6ROOHNVZDVOLPSLQJDQG'XEZDVVXIIHULQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
IURPDZUHQFKHGVKRXOGHUEODGH<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH\ZHUHDOOWHUULEO\IRRWVRUH1RVSULQJRUUHERXQGZDVOHIWLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHP7KHLUIHHWIHOOKHDYLO\RQWKHWUDLOMDUULQJWKHLUERGLHV<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGGRXEWLQJWKHIDWLJXHRIDGD\VWUDYHO7KHUHZDVQRWKLQJWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
PDWWHUZLWKWKHPH[FHSWWKDWWKH\ZHUHGHDGWLUHG,WZDVQRWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GHDGWLUHGQHVVWKDWFRPHVWKURXJKEULHIDQGH[FHVVLYHHIIRUWIURP<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLFKUHFRYHU\LVDPDWWHURIKRXUVEXWLWZDVWKHGHDGWLUHGQHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWFRPHVWKURXJKWKHVORZDQGSURORQJHGVWUHQJWKGUDLQDJHRI<<strong>br</strong> />
PRQWKVRIWRLO7KHUHZDVQRSRZHURIUHFXSHUDWLRQOHIWQR<<strong>br</strong> />
UHVHUYHVWUHQJWKWRFDOOXSRQ,WKDGEHHQDOOXVHGWKHODVW<<strong>br</strong> />
OHDVWELWRILW(YHU\PXVFOHHYHU\ILEUHHYHU\FHOOZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
WLUHGGHDGWLUHG$QGWKHUHZDVUHDVRQIRULW,QOHVVWKDQ<<strong>br</strong> />
ILYHPRQWKVWKH\KDGWUDYHOOHGWZHQW\ILYHKXQGUHGPLOHVGXULQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHODVWHLJKWHHQKXQGUHGRIZKLFKWKH\KDGKDGEXWILYHGD\V<<strong>br</strong> />
UHVW:KHQWKH\DUULYHGDW6NDJXD\WKH\ZHUHDSSDUHQWO\RQWKHLU<<strong>br</strong> />
ODVWOHJV7KH\FRXOGEDUHO\NHHSWKHWUDFHVWDXWDQGRQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
37
GRZQJUDGHVMXVWPDQDJHGWRNHHSRXWRIWKHZD\RIWKHVOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
0XVKRQSRRUVRUHIHHWVWKHGULYHUHQFRXUDJHGWKHPDVWKH\<<strong>br</strong> />
WRWWHUHGGRZQWKHPDLQVWUHHWRI6NDJXD\'LVLVGHODV'HQZH<<strong>br</strong> />
JHWRQHORQJUHV(K")RUVXUH2QHEXOO\ORQJUHV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHGULYHUVFRQILGHQWO\H[SHFWHGDORQJVWRSRYHU7KHPVHOYHV<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\KDGFRYHUHGWZHOYHKXQGUHGPLOHVZLWKWZRGD\VUHVWDQGLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHQDWXUHRIUHDVRQDQGFRPPRQMXVWLFHWKH\GHVHUYHGDQLQWHUYDO<<strong>br</strong> />
RIORDILQJ%XWVRPDQ\ZHUHWKHPHQZKRKDGUXVKHGLQWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
.ORQGLNHDQGVRPDQ\ZHUHWKHVZHHWKHDUWVZLYHVDQGNLQWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGQRWUXVKHGLQWKDWWKHFRQJHVWHGPDLOZDVWDNLQJRQ$OSLQH<<strong>br</strong> />
SURSRUWLRQVDOVRWKHUHZHUHRIILFLDORUGHUV)UHVKEDWFKHVRI<<strong>br</strong> />
+XGVRQ%D\GRJVZHUHWRWDNHWKHSODFHVRIWKRVHZRUWKOHVVIRUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDLO7KHZRUWKOHVVRQHVZHUHWREHJRWULGRIDQGVLQFHGRJV<<strong>br</strong> />
FRXQWIRUOLWWOHDJDLQVWGROODUVWKH\ZHUHWREHVROG<<strong>br</strong> />
7KUHHGD\VSDVVHGE\ZKLFKWLPH%XFNDQGKLVPDWHVIRXQGKRZ<<strong>br</strong> />
UHDOO\WLUHGDQGZHDNWKH\ZHUH7KHQRQWKHPRUQLQJRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IRXUWKGD\WZRPHQIURPWKH6WDWHVFDPHDORQJDQGERXJKWWKHP<<strong>br</strong> />
KDUQHVVDQGDOOIRUDVRQJ7KHPHQDGGUHVVHGHDFKRWKHUDV<<strong>br</strong> />
+DODQG&KDUOHV&KDUOHVZDVDPLGGOHDJHGOLJKWLVKFRORUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
PDQZLWKZHDNDQGZDWHU\H\HVDQGDPXVWDFKHWKDWWZLVWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
ILHUFHO\DQGYLJRURXVO\XSJLYLQJWKHOLHWRWKHOLPSO\GURRSLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
OLSLWFRQFHDOHG+DOZDVD\RXQJVWHURIQLQHWHHQRUWZHQW\ZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
DELJ&ROWVUHYROYHUDQGDKXQWLQJNQLIHVWUDSSHGDERXWKLPRQD<<strong>br</strong> />
EHOWWKDWIDLUO\EULVWOHGZLWKFDUWULGJHV7KLVEHOWZDVWKHPRVW<<strong>br</strong> />
VDOLHQWWKLQJDERXWKLP,WDGYHUWLVHGKLVFDOORZQHVVD<<strong>br</strong> />
FDOORZQHVVVKHHUDQGXQXWWHUDEOH%RWKPHQZHUHPDQLIHVWO\RXWRI<<strong>br</strong> />
SODFHDQGZK\VXFKDVWKH\VKRXOGDGYHQWXUHWKH1RUWKLVSDUWRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHP\VWHU\RIWKLQJVWKDWSDVVHVXQGHUVWDQGLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNKHDUGWKHFKDIIHULQJVDZWKHPRQH\SDVVEHWZHHQWKHPDQDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH*RYHUQPHQWDJHQWDQGNQHZWKDWWKH6FRWFKKDOIEUHHGDQGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
PDLOWUDLQGULYHUVZHUHSDVVLQJRXWRIKLVOLIHRQWKHKHHOVRI<<strong>br</strong> />
3HUUDXOWDQG)UDQFRLVDQGWKHRWKHUVZKRKDGJRQHEHIRUH:KHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
GULYHQZLWKKLVPDWHVWRWKHQHZRZQHUVFDPS%XFNVDZDVOLSVKRG<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGVORYHQO\DIIDLUWHQWKDOIVWUHWFKHGGLVKHVXQZDVKHG<<strong>br</strong> />
HYHU\WKLQJLQGLVRUGHUDOVRKHVDZDZRPDQ0HUFHGHVWKHPHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
FDOOHGKHU6KHZDV&KDUOHVVZLIHDQG+DOVVLVWHUDQLFH<<strong>br</strong> />
IDPLO\SDUW\<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNZDWFKHGWKHPDSSUHKHQVLYHO\DVWKH\SURFHHGHGWRWDNHGRZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHWHQWDQGORDGWKHVOHG7KHUHZDVDJUHDWGHDORIHIIRUW<<strong>br</strong> />
38
DERXWWKHLUPDQQHUEXWQREXVLQHVVOLNHPHWKRG7KHWHQWZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
UROOHGLQWRDQDZNZDUGEXQGOHWKUHHWLPHVDVODUJHDVLWVKRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
KDYHEHHQ7KHWLQGLVKHVZHUHSDFNHGDZD\XQZDVKHG0HUFHGHV<<strong>br</strong> />
FRQWLQXDOO\IOXWWHUHGLQWKHZD\RIKHUPHQDQGNHSWXSDQ<<strong>br</strong> />
XQEURNHQFKDWWHULQJRIUHPRQVWUDQFHDQGDGYLFH:KHQWKH\SXWD<<strong>br</strong> />
FORWKHVVDFNRQWKHIURQWRIWKHVOHGVKHVXJJHVWHGLWVKRXOGJR<<strong>br</strong> />
RQWKHEDFNDQGZKHQWKH\KDGSXWLWRQWKHEDFNDQGFRYHUHGLW<<strong>br</strong> />
RYHUZLWKDFRXSOHRIRWKHUEXQGOHVVKHGLVFRYHUHGRYHUORRNHG<<strong>br</strong> />
DUWLFOHVZKLFKFRXOGDELGHQRZKHUHHOVHEXWLQWKDWYHU\VDFNDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\XQORDGHGDJDLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KUHHPHQIURPDQHLJKERULQJWHQWFDPHRXWDQGORRNHGRQJULQQLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGZLQNLQJDWRQHDQRWKHU<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHGRJVVSUDQJDJDLQVWWKHEUHDVWEDQGVVWUDLQHGKDUGIRUDIHZ<<strong>br</strong> />
PRPHQWVWKHQUHOD[HG7KH\ZHUHXQDEOHWRPRYHWKHVOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHOD]\EUXWHV,OOVKRZWKHPKHFULHGSUHSDULQJWRODVKRXW<<strong>br</strong> />
DWWKHPZLWKWKHZKLS<<strong>br</strong> />
%XW0HUFHGHVLQWHUIHUHGFU\LQJ2K+DO\RXPXVWQWDVVKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FDXJKWKROGRIWKHZKLSDQGZUHQFKHGLWIURPKLP7KHSRRUGHDUV<<strong>br</strong> />
1RZ\RXPXVWSURPLVH\RXZRQWEHKDUVKZLWKWKHPIRUWKHUHVWRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHWULSRU,ZRQWJRDVWHS<<strong>br</strong> />
3UHFLRXVORW\RXNQRZDERXWGRJVKHUEURWKHUVQHHUHGDQG,<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLVK\RXGOHDYHPHDORQH7KH\UHOD]\,WHOO\RXDQG\RXYH<<strong>br</strong> />
JRWWRZKLSWKHPWRJHWDQ\WKLQJRXWRIWKHP7KDWVWKHLUZD\<<strong>br</strong> />
2QHRIWKHRQORRNHUVZKRKDGEHHQFOHQFKLQJKLVWHHWKWRVXSSUHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
KRWVSHHFKQRZVSRNHXS<<strong>br</strong> />
,WVQRWWKDW,FDUHDZKRRSZKDWEHFRPHVRI\RXEXWIRUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GRJVVDNHV,MXVWZDQWWRWHOO\RX\RXFDQKHOSWKHPDPLJKW\<<strong>br</strong> />
ORWE\EUHDNLQJRXWWKDWVOHG7KHUXQQHUVDUHIUR]HIDVW7KURZ<<strong>br</strong> />
\RXUZHLJKWDJDLQVWWKHJHHSROHULJKWDQGOHIWDQGEUHDNLW<<strong>br</strong> />
RXW<<strong>br</strong> />
$WKLUGWLPHWKHDWWHPSWZDVPDGHEXWWKLVWLPHIROORZLQJWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
DGYLFH+DOEURNHRXWWKHUXQQHUVZKLFKKDGEHHQIUR]HQWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VQRZ7KHRYHUORDGHGDQGXQZLHOG\VOHGIRUJHGDKHDG%XFNDQGKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
PDWHVVWUXJJOLQJIUDQWLFDOO\XQGHUWKHUDLQRIEORZV$KXQGUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
\DUGVDKHDGWKHSDWKWXUQHGDQGVORSHGVWHHSO\LQWRWKHPDLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
VWUHHW,WZRXOGKDYHUHTXLUHGDQH[SHULHQFHGPDQWRNHHSWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WRSKHDY\VOHGXSULJKWDQG+DOZDVQRWVXFKDPDQ$VWKH\VZXQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
RQWKHWXUQWKHVOHGZHQWRYHUVSLOOLQJKDOILWVORDGWKURXJKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ORRVHODVKLQJV7KHGRJVQHYHUVWRSSHG7KHOLJKWHQHGVOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
ERXQGHGRQLWVVLGHEHKLQGWKHP7KH\ZHUHDQJU\EHFDXVHRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
LOOWUHDWPHQWWKH\KDGUHFHLYHGDQGWKHXQMXVWORDG%XFNZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
UDJLQJ+HEURNHLQWRDUXQWKHWHDPIROORZLQJKLVOHDG+DO<<strong>br</strong> />
FULHG:KRDZKRDEXWWKH\JDYHQRKHHG+HWULSSHGDQGZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
SXOOHGRIIKLVIHHW7KHFDSVL]HGVOHGJURXQGRYHUKLPDQGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GRJVGDVKHGRQXSWKHVWUHHWDGGLQJWRWKHJD\HW\RI6NDJXD\DV<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\VFDWWHUHGWKHUHPDLQGHURIWKHRXWILWDORQJLWVFKLHI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKRURXJKIDUH<<strong>br</strong> />
.LQGKHDUWHGFLWL]HQVFDXJKWWKHGRJVDQGJDWKHUHGXSWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VFDWWHUHGEHORQJLQJV$OVRWKH\JDYHDGYLFH+DOIWKHORDGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WZLFHWKHGRJVLIWKH\HYHUH[SHFWHGWRUHDFK'DZVRQZDVZKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVVDLG+DODQGKLVVLVWHUDQGEURWKHULQODZOLVWHQHG<<strong>br</strong> />
XQZLOOLQJO\SLWFKHGWHQWDQGRYHUKDXOHGWKHRXWILW&DQQHGJRRGV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHUHWXUQHGRXWWKDWPDGHPHQODXJKIRUFDQQHGJRRGVRQWKH/RQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
7UDLOLVDWKLQJWRGUHDPDERXW%ODQNHWVIRUDKRWHOTXRWKRQH<<strong>br</strong> />
RIWKHPHQZKRODXJKHGDQGKHOSHG+DOIDVPDQ\LVWRRPXFKJHW<<strong>br</strong> />
ULGRIWKHP7KURZDZD\WKDWWHQWDQGDOOWKRVHGLVKHVZKRV<<strong>br</strong> />
JRLQJWRZDVKWKHPDQ\ZD\"*RRG/RUGGR\RXWKLQN\RXUH<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDYHOOLQJRQD3XOOPDQ"<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGVRLWZHQWWKHLQH[RUDEOHHOLPLQDWLRQRIWKHVXSHUIOXRXV<<strong>br</strong> />
0HUFHGHVFULHGZKHQKHUFORWKHVEDJVZHUHGXPSHGRQWKHJURXQGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
DUWLFOHDIWHUDUWLFOHZDVWKURZQRXW6KHFULHGLQJHQHUDODQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VKHFULHGLQSDUWLFXODURYHUHDFKGLVFDUGHGWKLQJ6KHFODVSHG<<strong>br</strong> />
41
KDQGVDERXWNQHHVURFNLQJEDFNDQGIRUWKEURNHQKHDUWHGO\6KH<<strong>br</strong> />
DYHUUHGVKHZRXOGQRWJRDQLQFKQRWIRUDGR]HQ&KDUOHVHV6KH<<strong>br</strong> />
DSSHDOHGWRHYHU\ERG\DQGWRHYHU\WKLQJILQDOO\ZLSLQJKHUH\HV<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGSURFHHGLQJWRFDVWRXWHYHQDUWLFOHVRIDSSDUHOWKDWZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
LPSHUDWLYHQHFHVVDULHV$QGLQKHU]HDOZKHQVKHKDGILQLVKHG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKKHURZQVKHDWWDFNHGWKHEHORQJLQJVRIKHUPHQDQGZHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURXJKWKHPOLNHDWRUQDGR<<strong>br</strong> />
7KLVDFFRPSOLVKHGWKHRXWILWWKRXJKFXWLQKDOIZDVVWLOOD<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUPLGDEOHEXON&KDUOHVDQG+DOZHQWRXWLQWKHHYHQLQJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
ERXJKWVL[2XWVLGHGRJV7KHVHDGGHGWRWKHVL[RIWKHRULJLQDO<<strong>br</strong> />
WHDPDQG7HHNDQG.RRQDWKHKXVNLHVREWDLQHGDWWKH5LQN5DSLGV<<strong>br</strong> />
RQWKHUHFRUGWULSEURXJKWWKHWHDPXSWRIRXUWHHQ%XWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
2XWVLGHGRJVWKRXJKSUDFWLFDOO\EURNHQLQVLQFHWKHLUODQGLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
GLGQRWDPRXQWWRPXFK7KUHHZHUHVKRUWKDLUHGSRLQWHUVRQHZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
D1HZIRXQGODQGDQGWKHRWKHUWZRZHUHPRQJUHOVRILQGHWHUPLQDWH<<strong>br</strong> />
EUHHG7KH\GLGQRWVHHPWRNQRZDQ\WKLQJWKHVHQHZFRPHUV%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGKLVFRPUDGHVORRNHGXSRQWKHPZLWKGLVJXVWDQGWKRXJKKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VSHHGLO\WDXJKWWKHPWKHLUSODFHVDQGZKDWQRWWRGRKHFRXOGQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
WHDFKWKHPZKDWWRGR7KH\GLGQRWWDNHNLQGO\WRWUDFHDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDLO:LWKWKHH[FHSWLRQRIWKHWZRPRQJUHOVWKH\ZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
EHZLOGHUHGDQGVSLULWEURNHQE\WKHVWUDQJHVDYDJHHQYLURQPHQWLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLFKWKH\IRXQGWKHPVHOYHVDQGE\WKHLOOWUHDWPHQWWKH\KDG<<strong>br</strong> />
UHFHLYHG7KHWZRPRQJUHOVZHUHZLWKRXWVSLULWDWDOOERQHVZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHRQO\WKLQJVEUHDNDEOHDERXWWKHP<<strong>br</strong> />
:LWKWKHQHZFRPHUVKRSHOHVVDQGIRUORUQDQGWKHROGWHDPZRUQRXW<<strong>br</strong> />
E\WZHQW\ILYHKXQGUHGPLOHVRIFRQWLQXRXVWUDLOWKHRXWORRNZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
DQ\WKLQJEXWEULJKW7KHWZRPHQKRZHYHUZHUHTXLWHFKHHUIXO<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGWKH\ZHUHSURXGWRR7KH\ZHUHGRLQJWKHWKLQJLQVW\OHZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
IRXUWHHQGRJV7KH\KDGVHHQRWKHUVOHGVGHSDUWRYHUWKH3DVVIRU<<strong>br</strong> />
'DZVRQRUFRPHLQIURP'DZVRQEXWQHYHUKDGWKH\VHHQDVOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKVRPDQ\DVIRXUWHHQGRJV,QWKHQDWXUHRI$UFWLFWUDYHO<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHUHZDVDUHDVRQZK\IRXUWHHQGRJVVKRXOGQRWGUDJRQHVOHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWZDVWKDWRQHVOHGFRXOGQRWFDUU\WKHIRRGIRUIRXUWHHQGRJV<<strong>br</strong> />
%XW&KDUOHVDQG+DOGLGQRWNQRZWKLV7KH\KDGZRUNHGWKHWULS<<strong>br</strong> />
RXWZLWKDSHQFLOVRPXFKWRDGRJVRPDQ\GRJVVRPDQ\GD\V<<strong>br</strong> />
4('0HUFHGHVORRNHGRYHUWKHLUVKRXOGHUVDQGQRGGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
FRPSUHKHQVLYHO\LWZDVDOOVRYHU\VLPSOH<<strong>br</strong> />
/DWHQH[WPRUQLQJ%XFNOHGWKHORQJWHDPXSWKHVWUHHW7KHUHZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
QRWKLQJOLYHO\DERXWLWQRVQDSRUJRLQKLPDQGKLVIHOORZV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH\ZHUHVWDUWLQJGHDGZHDU\)RXUWLPHVKHKDGFRYHUHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GLVWDQFHEHWZHHQ6DOW:DWHUDQG'DZVRQDQGWKHNQRZOHGJHWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
42
MDGHGDQGWLUHGKHZDVIDFLQJWKHVDPHWUDLORQFHPRUHPDGHKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
ELWWHU+LVKHDUWZDVQRWLQWKHZRUNQRUZDVWKHKHDUWRIDQ\<<strong>br</strong> />
GRJ7KH2XWVLGHVZHUHWLPLGDQGIULJKWHQHGWKH,QVLGHVZLWKRXW<<strong>br</strong> />
FRQILGHQFHLQWKHLUPDVWHUV<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNIHOWYDJXHO\WKDWWKHUHZDVQRGHSHQGLQJXSRQWKHVHWZRPHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGWKHZRPDQ7KH\GLGQRWNQRZKRZWRGRDQ\WKLQJDQGDVWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GD\VZHQWE\LWEHFDPHDSSDUHQWWKDWWKH\FRXOGQRWOHDUQ7KH\<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHUHVODFNLQDOOWKLQJVZLWKRXWRUGHURUGLVFLSOLQH,WWRRN<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHPKDOIWKHQLJKWWRSLWFKDVORYHQO\FDPSDQGKDOIWKHPRUQLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WREUHDNWKDWFDPSDQGJHWWKHVOHGORDGHGLQIDVKLRQVRVORYHQO\<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWIRUWKHUHVWRIWKHGD\WKH\ZHUHRFFXSLHGLQVWRSSLQJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
UHDUUDQJLQJWKHORDG6RPHGD\VWKH\GLGQRWPDNHWHQPLOHV2Q<<strong>br</strong> />
RWKHUGD\VWKH\ZHUHXQDEOHWRJHWVWDUWHGDWDOO$QGRQQRGD\<<strong>br</strong> />
GLGWKH\VXFFHHGLQPDNLQJPRUHWKDQKDOIWKHGLVWDQFHXVHGE\WKH<<strong>br</strong> />
PHQDVDEDVLVLQWKHLUGRJIRRGFRPSXWDWLRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
,WZDVLQHYLWDEOHWKDWWKH\VKRXOGJRVKRUWRQGRJIRRG%XWWKH\<<strong>br</strong> />
KDVWHQHGLWE\RYHUIHHGLQJEULQJLQJWKHGD\QHDUHUZKHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
XQGHUIHHGLQJZRXOGFRPPHQFH7KH2XWVLGHGRJVZKRVHGLJHVWLRQV<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGQRWEHHQWUDLQHGE\FKURQLFIDPLQHWRPDNHWKHPRVWRIOLWWOH<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGYRUDFLRXVDSSHWLWHV$QGZKHQLQDGGLWLRQWRWKLVWKHZRUQ<<strong>br</strong> />
RXWKXVNLHVSXOOHGZHDNO\+DOGHFLGHGWKDWWKHRUWKRGR[UDWLRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVWRRVPDOO+HGRXEOHGLW$QGWRFDSLWDOOZKHQ0HUFHGHV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKWHDUVLQKHUSUHWW\H\HVDQGDTXDYHULQKHUWKURDWFRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
QRWFDMROHKLPLQWRJLYLQJWKHGRJVVWLOOPRUHVKHVWROHIURPWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ILVKVDFNVDQGIHGWKHPVO\O\%XWLWZDVQRWIRRGWKDW%XFNDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHKXVNLHVQHHGHGEXWUHVW$QGWKRXJKWKH\ZHUHPDNLQJSRRU<<strong>br</strong> />
WLPHWKHKHDY\ORDGWKH\GUDJJHGVDSSHGWKHLUVWUHQJWKVHYHUHO\<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHQFDPHWKHXQGHUIHHGLQJ+DODZRNHRQHGD\WRWKHIDFWWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVGRJIRRGZDVKDOIJRQHDQGWKHGLVWDQFHRQO\TXDUWHUFRYHUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
IXUWKHUWKDWIRUORYHRUPRQH\QRDGGLWLRQDOGRJIRRGZDVWREH<<strong>br</strong> />
REWDLQHG6RKHFXWGRZQHYHQWKHRUWKRGR[UDWLRQDQGWULHGWR<<strong>br</strong> />
LQFUHDVHWKHGD\VWUDYHO+LVVLVWHUDQGEURWKHULQODZVHFRQGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPEXWWKH\ZHUHIUXVWUDWHGE\WKHLUKHDY\RXWILWDQGWKHLURZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
LQFRPSHWHQFH,WZDVDVLPSOHPDWWHUWRJLYHWKHGRJVOHVVIRRG<<strong>br</strong> />
EXWLWZDVLPSRVVLEOHWRPDNHWKHGRJVWUDYHOIDVWHUZKLOHWKHLU<<strong>br</strong> />
RZQLQDELOLW\WRJHWXQGHUZD\HDUOLHULQWKHPRUQLQJSUHYHQWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHPIURPWUDYHOOLQJORQJHUKRXUV1RWRQO\GLGWKH\QRWNQRZKRZ<<strong>br</strong> />
WRZRUNGRJVEXWWKH\GLGQRWNQRZKRZWRZRUNWKHPVHOYHV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHILUVWWRJRZDV'XE3RRUEOXQGHULQJWKLHIWKDWKHZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
DOZD\VJHWWLQJFDXJKWDQGSXQLVKHGKHKDGQRQHWKHOHVVEHHQD<<strong>br</strong> />
43
IDLWKIXOZRUNHU+LVZUHQFKHGVKRXOGHUEODGHXQWUHDWHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
XQUHVWHGZHQWIURPEDGWRZRUVHWLOOILQDOO\+DOVKRWKLPZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHELJ&ROWVUHYROYHU,WLVDVD\LQJRIWKHFRXQWU\WKDWDQ<<strong>br</strong> />
2XWVLGHGRJVWDUYHVWRGHDWKRQWKHUDWLRQRIWKHKXVN\VRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VL[2XWVLGHGRJVXQGHU%XFNFRXOGGRQROHVVWKDQGLHRQKDOIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
UDWLRQRIWKHKXVN\7KH1HZIRXQGODQGZHQWILUVWIROORZHGE\WKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKUHHVKRUWKDLUHGSRLQWHUVWKHWZRPRQJUHOVKDQJLQJPRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
JULWWLO\RQWROLIHEXWJRLQJLQWKHHQG<<strong>br</strong> />
%\WKLVWLPHDOOWKHDPHQLWLHVDQGJHQWOHQHVVHVRIWKH6RXWKODQG<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGIDOOHQDZD\IURPWKHWKUHHSHRSOH6KRUQRILWVJODPRXUDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
URPDQFH$UFWLFWUDYHOEHFDPHWRWKHPDUHDOLW\WRRKDUVKIRU<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHLUPDQKRRGDQGZRPDQKRRG0HUFHGHVFHDVHGZHHSLQJRYHUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GRJVEHLQJWRRRFFXSLHGZLWKZHHSLQJRYHUKHUVHOIDQGZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
TXDUUHOOLQJZLWKKHUKXVEDQGDQGEURWKHU7RTXDUUHOZDVWKHRQH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLQJWKH\ZHUHQHYHUWRRZHDU\WRGR7KHLULUULWDELOLW\DURVH<<strong>br</strong> />
RXWRIWKHLUPLVHU\LQFUHDVHGZLWKLWGRXEOHGXSRQLW<<strong>br</strong> />
RXWGLVWDQFHGLW7KHZRQGHUIXOSDWLHQFHRIWKHWUDLOZKLFKFRPHV<<strong>br</strong> />
WRPHQZKRWRLOKDUGDQGVXIIHUVRUHDQGUHPDLQVZHHWRIVSHHFK<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGNLQGO\GLGQRWFRPHWRWKHVHWZRPHQDQGWKHZRPDQ7KH\KDG<<strong>br</strong> />
QRLQNOLQJRIVXFKDSDWLHQFH7KH\ZHUHVWLIIDQGLQSDLQWKHLU<<strong>br</strong> />
PXVFOHVDFKHGWKHLUERQHVDFKHGWKHLUYHU\KHDUWVDFKHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
EHFDXVHRIWKLVWKH\EHFDPHVKDUSRIVSHHFKDQGKDUGZRUGVZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
ILUVWRQWKHLUOLSVLQWKHPRUQLQJDQGODVWDWQLJKW<<strong>br</strong> />
&KDUOHVDQG+DOZUDQJOHGZKHQHYHU0HUFHGHVJDYHWKHPDFKDQFH,W<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVWKHFKHULVKHGEHOLHIRIHDFKWKDWKHGLGPRUHWKDQKLVVKDUH<<strong>br</strong> />
RIWKHZRUNDQGQHLWKHUIRUERUHWRVSHDNWKLVEHOLHIDWHYHU\<<strong>br</strong> />
RSSRUWXQLW\6RPHWLPHV0HUFHGHVVLGHGZLWKKHUKXVEDQGVRPHWLPHV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKKHUEURWKHU7KHUHVXOWZDVDEHDXWLIXODQGXQHQGLQJIDPLO\<<strong>br</strong> />
TXDUUHO6WDUWLQJIURPDGLVSXWHDVWRZKLFKVKRXOGFKRSDIHZ<<strong>br</strong> />
VWLFNVIRUWKHILUHDGLVSXWHZKLFKFRQFHUQHGRQO\&KDUOHVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
+DOSUHVHQWO\ZRXOGEHOXJJHGLQWKHUHVWRIWKHIDPLO\<<strong>br</strong> />
IDWKHUVPRWKHUVXQFOHVFRXVLQVSHRSOHWKRXVDQGVRIPLOHVDZD\<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGVRPHRIWKHPGHDG7KDW+DOVYLHZVRQDUWRUWKHVRUWRI<<strong>br</strong> />
VRFLHW\SOD\VKLVPRWKHUVEURWKHUZURWHVKRXOGKDYHDQ\WKLQJWR<<strong>br</strong> />
GRZLWKWKHFKRSSLQJRIDIHZVWLFNVRIILUHZRRGSDVVHV<<strong>br</strong> />
FRPSUHKHQVLRQQHYHUWKHOHVVWKHTXDUUHOZDVDVOLNHO\WRWHQGLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWGLUHFWLRQDVLQWKHGLUHFWLRQRI&KDUOHVVSROLWLFDO<<strong>br</strong> />
SUHMXGLFHV$QGWKDW&KDUOHVVVLVWHUVWDOHEHDULQJWRQJXHVKRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
EHUHOHYDQWWRWKHEXLOGLQJRID
UHPDLQHGXQEXLOWWKHFDPSKDOISLWFKHGDQGWKHGRJVXQIHG<<strong>br</strong> />
0HUFHGHVQXUVHGDVSHFLDOJULHYDQFHWKHJULHYDQFHRIVH[6KHZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
SUHWW\DQGVRIWDQGKDGEHHQFKLYDOURXVO\WUHDWHGDOOKHUGD\V<<strong>br</strong> />
%XWWKHSUHVHQWWUHDWPHQWE\KHUKXVEDQGDQGEURWKHUZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
HYHU\WKLQJVDYHFKLYDOURXV,WZDVKHUFXVWRPWREHKHOSOHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH\FRPSODLQHG8SRQZKLFKLPSHDFKPHQWRIZKDWWRKHUZDVKHU<<strong>br</strong> />
PRVWHVVHQWLDOVH[SUHURJDWLYHVKHPDGHWKHLUOLYHVXQHQGXUDEOH<<strong>br</strong> />
6KHQRORQJHUFRQVLGHUHGWKHGRJVDQGEHFDXVHVKHZDVVRUHDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WLUHGVKHSHUVLVWHGLQULGLQJRQWKHVOHG6KHZDVSUHWW\DQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VRIWEXWVKHZHLJKHGRQHKXQGUHGDQGWZHQW\SRXQGVDOXVW\ODVW<<strong>br</strong> />
VWUDZWRWKHORDGGUDJJHGE\WKHZHDNDQGVWDUYLQJDQLPDOV6KH<<strong>br</strong> />
URGHIRUGD\VWLOOWKH\IHOOLQWKHWUDFHVDQGWKHVOHGVWRRG<<strong>br</strong> />
VWLOO&KDUOHVDQG+DOEHJJHGKHUWRJHWRIIDQGZDONSOHDGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKKHUHQWUHDWHGWKHZKLOHVKHZHSWDQGLPSRUWXQHG+HDYHQZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
DUHFLWDORIWKHLUEUXWDOLW\<<strong>br</strong> />
2QRQHRFFDVLRQWKH\WRRNKHURIIWKHVOHGE\PDLQVWUHQJWK7KH\<<strong>br</strong> />
QHYHUGLGLWDJDLQ6KHOHWKHUOHJVJROLPSOLNHDVSRLOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
FKLOGDQGVDWGRZQRQWKHWUDLO7KH\ZHQWRQWKHLUZD\EXWVKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GLGQRWPRYH$IWHUWKH\KDGWUDYHOOHGWKUHHPLOHVWKH\XQORDGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHVOHGFDPHEDFNIRUKHUDQGE\PDLQVWUHQJWKSXWKHURQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VOHGDJDLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
,QWKHH[FHVVRIWKHLURZQPLVHU\WKH\ZHUHFDOORXVWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VXIIHULQJRIWKHLUDQLPDOV+DOVWKHRU\ZKLFKKHSUDFWLVHGRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
RWKHUVZDVWKDWRQHPXVWJHWKDUGHQHG+HKDGVWDUWHGRXW<<strong>br</strong> />
SUHDFKLQJLWWRKLVVLVWHUDQGEURWKHULQODZ)DLOLQJWKHUHKH<<strong>br</strong> />
KDPPHUHGLWLQWRWKHGRJVZLWKDFOXE$WWKH)LYH)LQJHUVWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GRJIRRGJDYHRXWDQGDWRRWKOHVVROGVTXDZRIIHUHGWRWUDGHWKHP<<strong>br</strong> />
DIHZSRXQGVRIIUR]HQKRUVHKLGHIRUWKH&ROWVUHYROYHUWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
NHSWWKHELJKXQWLQJNQLIHFRPSDQ\DW+DOVKLS$SRRUVXEVWLWXWH<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUIRRGZDVWKLVKLGHMXVWDVLWKDGEHHQVWULSSHGIURPWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VWDUYHGKRUVHVRIWKHFDWWOHPHQVL[PRQWKVEDFN,QLWVIUR]HQ<<strong>br</strong> />
VWDWHLWZDVPRUHOLNHVWULSVRIJDOYDQL]HGLURQDQGZKHQDGRJ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZUHVWOHGLWLQWRKLVVWRPDFKLWWKDZHGLQWRWKLQDQGLQQXWULWLRXV<<strong>br</strong> />
OHDWKHU\VWULQJVDQGLQWRDPDVVRIVKRUWKDLULUULWDWLQJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
LQGLJHVWLEOH<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGWKURXJKLWDOO%XFNVWDJJHUHGDORQJDWWKHKHDGRIWKHWHDPDV<<strong>br</strong> />
LQDQLJKWPDUH+HSXOOHGZKHQKHFRXOGZKHQKHFRXOGQRORQJHU<<strong>br</strong> />
SXOOKHIHOOGRZQDQGUHPDLQHGGRZQWLOOEORZVIURPZKLSRUFOXE<<strong>br</strong> />
GURYHKLPWRKLVIHHWDJDLQ$OOWKHVWLIIQHVVDQGJORVVKDGJRQH<<strong>br</strong> />
RXWRIKLVEHDXWLIXOIXUU\FRDW7KHKDLUKXQJGRZQOLPSDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
45
GUDJJOHGRUPDWWHGZLWKGULHGEORRGZKHUH+DOVFOXEKDGEUXLVHG<<strong>br</strong> />
KLP+LVPXVFOHVKDGZDVWHGDZD\WRNQRWW\VWULQJVDQGWKHIOHVK<<strong>br</strong> />
SDGVKDGGLVDSSHDUHGVRWKDWHDFKULEDQGHYHU\ERQHLQKLVIUDPH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHUHRXWOLQHGFOHDQO\WKURXJKWKHORRVHKLGHWKDWZDVZULQNOHGLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
IROGVRIHPSWLQHVV,WZDVKHDUWEUHDNLQJRQO\%XFNVKHDUWZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
XQEUHDNDEOH7KHPDQLQWKHUHGVZHDWHUKDGSURYHGWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
$VLWZDVZLWK%XFNVRZDVLWZLWKKLVPDWHV7KH\ZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
SHUDPEXODWLQJVNHOHWRQV7KHUHZHUHVHYHQDOOWRJHWKHULQFOXGLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
KLP,QWKHLUYHU\JUHDWPLVHU\WKH\KDGEHFRPHLQVHQVLEOHWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ELWHRIWKHODVKRUWKHEUXLVHRIWKHFOXE7KHSDLQRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
EHDWLQJZDVGXOODQGGLVWDQWMXVWDVWKHWKLQJVWKHLUH\HVVDZ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGWKHLUHDUVKHDUGVHHPHGGXOODQGGLVWDQW7KH\ZHUHQRWKDOI<<strong>br</strong> />
OLYLQJRUTXDUWHUOLYLQJ7KH\ZHUHVLPSO\VRPDQ\EDJVRIERQHV<<strong>br</strong> />
LQZKLFKVSDUNVRIOLIHIOXWWHUHGIDLQWO\:KHQDKDOWZDVPDGH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\GURSSHGGRZQLQWKHWUDFHVOLNHGHDGGRJVDQGWKHVSDUN<<strong>br</strong> />
GLPPHGDQGSDOHGDQGVHHPHGWRJRRXW$QGZKHQWKHFOXERUZKLS<<strong>br</strong> />
IHOOXSRQWKHPWKHVSDUNIOXWWHUHGIHHEO\XSDQGWKH\WRWWHUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WRWKHLUIHHWDQGVWDJJHUHGRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHUHFDPHDGD\ZKHQ%LOOHHWKHJRRGQDWXUHGIHOODQGFRXOGQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
ULVH+DOKDGWUDGHGRIIKLVUHYROYHUVRKHWRRNWKHD[HDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
NQRFNHG%LOOHHRQWKHKHDGDVKHOD\LQWKHWUDFHVWKHQFXWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FDUFDVVRXWRIWKHKDUQHVVDQGGUDJJHGLWWRRQHVLGH%XFNVDZ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGKLVPDWHVVDZDQGWKH\NQHZWKDWWKLVWKLQJZDVYHU\FORVHWR<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHP2QWKHQH[WGD\.RRQDZHQWDQGEXWILYHRIWKHPUHPDLQHG<<strong>br</strong> />
-RHWRRIDUJRQHWREHPDOLJQDQW3LNHFULSSOHGDQGOLPSLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
RQO\KDOIFRQVFLRXVDQGQRWFRQVFLRXVHQRXJKORQJHUWRPDOLQJHU<<strong>br</strong> />
6ROOHNVWKHRQHH\HGVWLOOIDLWKIXOWRWKHWRLORIWUDFHDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDLODQGPRXUQIXOLQWKDWKHKDGVROLWWOHVWUHQJWKZLWKZKLFK<<strong>br</strong> />
WRSXOO7HHNZKRKDGQRWWUDYHOOHGVRIDUWKDWZLQWHUDQGZKR<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVQRZEHDWHQPRUHWKDQWKHRWKHUVEHFDXVHKHZDVIUHVKHUDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNVWLOODWWKHKHDGRIWKHWHDPEXWQRORQJHUHQIRUFLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
GLVFLSOLQHRUVWULYLQJWRHQIRUFHLWEOLQGZLWKZHDNQHVVKDOIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WLPHDQGNHHSLQJWKHWUDLOE\WKHORRPRILWDQGE\WKHGLPIHHO<<strong>br</strong> />
RIKLVIHHW<<strong>br</strong> />
,WZDVEHDXWLIXOVSULQJZHDWKHUEXWQHLWKHUGRJVQRUKXPDQVZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
DZDUHRILW(DFKGD\WKHVXQURVHHDUOLHUDQGVHWODWHU,WZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
GDZQE\WKUHHLQWKHPRUQLQJDQGWZLOLJKWOLQJHUHGWLOOQLQHDW<<strong>br</strong> />
QLJKW7KHZKROHORQJGD\ZDVDEOD]HRIVXQVKLQH7KHJKRVWO\<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLQWHUVLOHQFHKDGJLYHQZD\WRWKHJUHDWVSULQJPXUPXURI<<strong>br</strong> />
DZDNHQLQJOLIH7KLVPXUPXUDURVHIURPDOOWKHODQGIUDXJKWZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHMR\RIOLYLQJ,WFDPHIURPWKHWKLQJVWKDWOLYHGDQGPRYHG<<strong>br</strong> />
46
DJDLQWKLQJVZKLFKKDGEHHQDVGHDGDQGZKLFKKDGQRWPRYHG<<strong>br</strong> />
GXULQJWKHORQJPRQWKVRIIURVW7KHVDSZDVULVLQJLQWKHSLQHV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHZLOORZVDQGDVSHQVZHUHEXUVWLQJRXWLQ\RXQJEXGV6KUXEV<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGYLQHVZHUHSXWWLQJRQIUHVKJDUEVRIJUHHQ&ULFNHWVVDQJLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHQLJKWVDQGLQWKHGD\VDOOPDQQHURIFUHHSLQJFUDZOLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLQJVUXVWOHGIRUWKLQWRWKHVXQ3DUWULGJHVDQGZRRGSHFNHUV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHUHERRPLQJDQGNQRFNLQJLQWKHIRUHVW6TXLUUHOVZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
FKDWWHULQJELUGVVLQJLQJDQGRYHUKHDGKRQNHGWKHZLOGIRZO<<strong>br</strong> />
GULYLQJXSIURPWKHVRXWKLQFXQQLQJZHGJHVWKDWVSOLWWKHDLU<<strong>br</strong> />
)URPHYHU\KLOOVORSHFDPHWKHWULFNOHRIUXQQLQJZDWHUWKHPXVLF<<strong>br</strong> />
RIXQVHHQIRXQWDLQV$8WKLQJVZHUHWKDZLQJEHQGLQJVQDSSLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH
7KDWVEHFDXVH\RXUHQRWDIRRO,VXSSRVHVDLG+DO$OOWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VDPHZHOOJRRQWR'DZVRQ+HXQFRLOHGKLVZKLS*HWXSWKHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFN+L*HWXSWKHUH0XVKRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQZHQWRQZKLWWOLQJ,WZDVLGOHKHNQHZWRJHWEHWZHHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
DIRRODQGKLVIROO\ZKLOHWZRRUWKUHHIRROVPRUHRUOHVVZRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
QRWDOWHUWKHVFKHPHRIWKLQJV<<strong>br</strong> />
%XWWKHWHDPGLGQRWJHWXSDWWKHFRPPDQG,WKDGORQJVLQFH<<strong>br</strong> />
SDVVHGLQWRWKHVWDJHZKHUHEORZVZHUHUHTXLUHGWRURXVHLW7KH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLSIODVKHGRXWKHUHDQGWKHUHRQLWVPHUFLOHVVHUUDQGV-RKQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQFRPSUHVVHGKLVOLSV6ROOHNVZDVWKHILUVWWRFUDZOWR<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVIHHW7HHNIROORZHG-RHFDPHQH[W\HOSLQJZLWKSDLQ3LNH<<strong>br</strong> />
PDGHSDLQIXOHIIRUWV7ZLFHKHIHOORYHUZKHQKDOIXSDQGRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHWKLUGDWWHPSWPDQDJHGWRULVH%XFNPDGHQRHIIRUW+HOD\<<strong>br</strong> />
TXLHWO\ZKHUHKHKDGIDOOHQ7KHODVKELWLQWRKLPDJDLQDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
DJDLQEXWKHQHLWKHUZKLQHGQRUVWUXJJOHG6HYHUDOWLPHV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQVWDUWHGDVWKRXJKWRVSHDNEXWFKDQJHGKLVPLQG$<<strong>br</strong> />
PRLVWXUHFDPHLQWRKLVH\HVDQGDVWKHZKLSSLQJFRQWLQXHGKH<<strong>br</strong> />
DURVHDQGZDONHGLUUHVROXWHO\XSDQGGRZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KLVZDVWKHILUVWWLPH%XFNKDGIDLOHGLQLWVHOIDVXIILFLHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
UHDVRQWRGULYH+DOLQWRDUDJH+HH[FKDQJHGWKHZKLSIRUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FXVWRPDU\FOXE%XFNUHIXVHGWRPRYHXQGHUWKHUDLQRIKHDYLHU<<strong>br</strong> />
EORZVZKLFKQRZIHOOXSRQKLP/LNHKLVPDWHVKHEDUHO\DEOHWR<<strong>br</strong> />
JHWXSEXWXQOLNHWKHPKHKDGPDGHXSKLVPLQGQRWWRJHWXS<<strong>br</strong> />
+HKDGDYDJXHIHHOLQJRILPSHQGLQJGRRP7KLVKDGEHHQVWURQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
XSRQKLPZKHQKHSXOOHGLQWRWKHEDQNDQGLWKDGQRWGHSDUWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
IURPKLP:KDWRIWKHWKLQDQGURWWHQLFHKHKDGIHOWXQGHUKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
IHHWDOOGD\LWVHHPHGWKDWKHVHQVHGGLVDVWHUFORVHDWKDQGRXW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHUHDKHDGRQWKHLFHZKHUHKLVPDVWHUZDVWU\LQJWRGULYHKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
+HUHIXVHGWRVWLU6RJUHDWO\KDGKHVXIIHUHGDQGVRIDUJRQH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVKHWKDWWKHEORZVGLGQRWKXUWPXFK$QGDVWKH\FRQWLQXHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WRIDOOXSRQKLPWKHVSDUNRIOLIHZLWKLQIOLFNHUHGDQGZHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
GRZQ,WZDVQHDUO\RXW+HIHOWVWUDQJHO\QXPE$VWKRXJKIURP<<strong>br</strong> />
DJUHDWGLVWDQFHKHZDVDZDUHWKDWKHZDVEHLQJEHDWHQ7KHODVW<<strong>br</strong> />
VHQVDWLRQVRISDLQOHIWKLP+HQRORQJHUIHOWDQ\WKLQJWKRXJK<<strong>br</strong> />
YHU\IDLQWO\KHFRXOGKHDUWKHLPSDFWRIWKHFOXEXSRQKLVERG\<<strong>br</strong> />
%XWLWZDVQRORQJHUKLVERG\LWVHHPHGVRIDUDZD\<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGWKHQVXGGHQO\ZLWKRXWZDUQLQJXWWHULQJDFU\WKDWZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
LQDUWLFXODWHDQGPRUHOLNHWKHFU\RIDQDQLPDO-RKQ7KRUQWRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
VSUDQJXSRQWKHPDQZKRZLHOGHGWKHFOXE+DOZDVKXUOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
EDFNZDUGDVWKRXJKVWUXFNE\DIDLOLQJWUHH0HUFHGHVVFUHDPHG<<strong>br</strong> />
48
&KDUOHVORRNHGRQZLVWIXOO\ZLSHGKLVZDWHU\H\HVEXWGLGQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
JHWXSEHFDXVHRIKLVVWLIIQHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
-RKQ7KRUQWRQVWRRGRYHU%XFNVWUXJJOLQJWRFRQWUROKLPVHOIWRR<<strong>br</strong> />
FRQYXOVHGZLWKUDJHWRVSHDN<<strong>br</strong> />
,I\RXVWULNHWKDWGRJDJDLQ,OONLOO\RXKHDWODVWPDQDJHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WRVD\LQDFKRNLQJYRLFH<<strong>br</strong> />
,WVP\GRJ+DOUHSOLHGZLSLQJWKHEORRGIURPKLVPRXWKDVKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FDPHEDFN*HWRXWRIP\ZD\RU,OOIL[\RX,PJRLQJWR<<strong>br</strong> />
'DZVRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQVWRRGEHWZHHQKLPDQG%XFNDQGHYLQFHGQRLQWHQWLRQRI<<strong>br</strong> />
JHWWLQJRXWRIWKHZD\+DOGUHZKLVORQJKXQWLQJNQLIH<<strong>br</strong> />
0HUFHGHVVFUHDPHGFULHGODXJKHGDQGPDQLIHVWHGWKHFKDRWLF<<strong>br</strong> />
DEDQGRQPHQWRIK\VWHULD7KRUQWRQUDSSHG+DOVNQXFNOHVZLWKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
D[HKDQGOHNQRFNLQJWKHNQLIHWRWKHJURXQG+HUDSSHGKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
NQXFNOHVDJDLQDVKHWULHGWRSLFNLWXS7KHQKHVWRRSHGSLFNHG<<strong>br</strong> />
LWXSKLPVHOIDQGZLWKWZRVWURNHVFXW%XFNVWUDFHV<<strong>br</strong> />
+DOKDGQRILJKWOHIWLQKLP%HVLGHVKLVKDQGVZHUHIXOOZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVVLVWHURUKLVDUPVUDWKHUZKLOH%XFNZDVWRRQHDUGHDGWR<<strong>br</strong> />
EHRIIXUWKHUXVHLQKDXOLQJWKHVOHG$IHZPLQXWHVODWHUWKH\<<strong>br</strong> />
SXOOHGRXWIURPWKHEDQNDQGGRZQWKHULYHU%XFNKHDUGWKHPJR<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGUDLVHGKLVKHDGWRVHH3LNHZDVOHDGLQJ6ROOHNVZDVDWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKHHODQGEHWZHHQZHUH-RHDQG7HHN7KH\ZHUHOLPSLQJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VWDJJHULQJ0HUFHGHVZDVULGLQJWKHORDGHGVOHG+DOJXLGHGDW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHJHHSROHDQG&KDUOHVVWXPEOHGDORQJLQWKHUHDU<<strong>br</strong> />
$V%XFNZDWFKHGWKHP7KRUQWRQNQHOWEHVLGHKLPDQGZLWKURXJK<<strong>br</strong> />
NLQGO\KDQGVVHDUFKHGIRUEURNHQERQHV%\WKHWLPHKLVVHDUFK<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGGLVFORVHGQRWKLQJPRUHWKDQPDQ\EUXLVHVDQGDVWDWHRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WHUULEOHVWDUYDWLRQWKHVOHGZDVDTXDUWHURIDPLOHDZD\'RJ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGPDQZDWFKHGLWFUDZOLQJDORQJRYHUWKHLFH6XGGHQO\WKH\<<strong>br</strong> />
VDZLWVEDFNHQGGURSGRZQDVLQWRDUXWDQGWKHJHHSROHZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
+DOFOLQJLQJWRLWMHUNLQWRWKHDLU0HUFHGHVVVFUHDPFDPHWR<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHLUHDUV7KH\VDZ&KDUOHVWXUQDQGPDNHRQHVWHSWRUXQEDFN<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGWKHQDZKROHVHFWLRQRILFHJLYHZD\DQGGRJVDQGKXPDQV<<strong>br</strong> />
GLVDSSHDU$\DZQLQJKROHZDVDOOWKDWZDVWREHVHHQ7KH<<strong>br</strong> />
ERWWRPKDGGURSSHGRXWRIWKHWUDLO<<strong>br</strong> />
-RKQ7KRUQWRQDQG%XFNORRNHGDWHDFKRWKHU<<strong>br</strong> />
49
SDUWQHUVKLSZLWKWKH-XGJHVJUDQGVRQVDVRUWRISRPSRXV<<strong>br</strong> />
JXDUGLDQVKLSDQGZLWKWKH-XGJHKLPVHOIDVWDWHO\DQGGLJQLILHG<<strong>br</strong> />
IULHQGVKLS%XWORYHWKDWZDVIHYHULVKDQGEXUQLQJWKDWZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
DGRUDWLRQWKDWZDVPDGQHVVLWKDGWDNHQ-RKQ7KRUQWRQWRDURXVH<<strong>br</strong> />
7KLVPDQKDGVDYHGKLVOLIHZKLFKZDVVRPHWKLQJEXWIXUWKHUKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVWKHLGHDOPDVWHU2WKHUPHQVDZWRWKHZHOIDUHRIWKHLUGRJV<<strong>br</strong> />
IURPDVHQVHRIGXW\DQGEXVLQHVVH[SHGLHQF\KHVDZWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHOIDUHRIKLVDVLIWKH\ZHUHKLVRZQFKLOGUHQEHFDXVHKHFRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
QRWKHOSLW$QGKHVDZIXUWKHU+HQHYHUIRUJRWDNLQGO\<<strong>br</strong> />
JUHHWLQJRUDFKHHULQJZRUGDQGWRVLWGRZQIRUDORQJWDONZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHPJDVKHFDOOHGLWZDVDVPXFKKLVGHOLJKWDVWKHLUV+H<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGDZD\RIWDNLQJ%XFNVKHDGURXJKO\EHWZHHQKLVKDQGVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
UHVWLQJKLVRZQKHDGXSRQ%XFNVRIVKDNLQJKLPEDFNDQGIRUWK<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHZKLOHFDOOLQJKLPLOOQDPHVWKDWWR%XFNZHUHORYHQDPHV<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNNQHZQRJUHDWHUMR\WKDQWKDWURXJKHPEUDFHDQGWKHVRXQGRI<<strong>br</strong> />
PXUPXUHGRDWKVDQGDWHDFKMHUNEDFNDQGIRUWKLWVHHPHGWKDWKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
KHDUWZRXOGEHVKDNHQRXWRIKLVERG\VRJUHDWZDVLWVHFVWDV\<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGZKHQUHOHDVHGKHVSUDQJWRKLVIHHWKLVPRXWKODXJKLQJKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
H\HVHORTXHQWKLVWKURDWYLEUDQWZLWKXQXWWHUHGVRXQGDQGLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWIDVKLRQUHPDLQHGZLWKRXWPRYHPHQW-RKQ7KRUQWRQZRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
UHYHUHQWO\H[FODLP*RG\RXFDQDOOEXWVSHDN<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNKDGDWULFNRIORYHH[SUHVVLRQWKDWZDVDNLQWRKXUW+H<<strong>br</strong> />
ZRXOGRIWHQVHL]H7KRUQWRQVKDQGLQKLVPRXWKDQGFORVHVR<<strong>br</strong> />
ILHUFHO\WKDWWKHIOHVKERUHWKHLPSUHVVRIKLVWHHWKIRUVRPH<<strong>br</strong> />
WLPHDIWHUZDUG$QGDV%XFNXQGHUVWRRGWKHRDWKVWREHORYH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZRUGVVRWKHPDQXQGHUVWRRGWKLVIHLJQHGELWHIRUDFDUHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
)RUWKHPRVWSDUWKRZHYHU%XFNVORYHZDVH[SUHVVHGLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
DGRUDWLRQ:KLOHKHZHQWZLOGZLWKKDSSLQHVVZKHQ7KRUQWRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WRXFKHGKLPRUVSRNHWRKLPKHGLGQRWVHHNWKHVHWRNHQV8QOLNH<<strong>br</strong> />
6NHHWZKRZDVZRQWWRVKRYHKHUQRVHXQGHU7KRUQWRQVKDQGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
QXGJHDQGQXGJHWLOOSHWWHGRU1LJZKRZRXOGVWDONXSDQGUHVW<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVJUHDWKHDGRQ7KRUQWRQVNQHH%XFNZDVFRQWHQWWRDGRUHDWD<<strong>br</strong> />
GLVWDQFH+HZRXOGOLHE\WKHKRXUHDJHUDOHUWDW7KRUQWRQV<<strong>br</strong> />
IHHWORRNLQJXSLQWRKLVIDFHGZHOOLQJXSRQLWVWXG\LQJLW<<strong>br</strong> />
IROORZLQJZLWKNHHQHVWLQWHUHVWHDFKIOHHWLQJH[SUHVVLRQHYHU\<<strong>br</strong> />
PRYHPHQWRUFKDQJHRIIHDWXUH2UDVFKDQFHPLJKWKDYHLWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZRXOGOLHIDUWKHUDZD\WRWKHVLGHRUUHDUZDWFKLQJWKHRXWOLQHV<<strong>br</strong> />
RIWKHPDQDQGWKHRFFDVLRQDOPRYHPHQWVRIKLVERG\$QGRIWHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
VXFKZDVWKHFRPPXQLRQLQZKLFKWKH\OLYHGWKHVWUHQJWKRI%XFNV<<strong>br</strong> />
JD]HZRXOGGUDZ-RKQ7KRUQWRQVKHDGDURXQGDQGKHZRXOGUHWXUQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHJD]HZLWKRXWVSHHFKKLVKHDUWVKLQLQJRXWRIKLVH\HVDV<<strong>br</strong> />
51
%XFNVKHDUWVKRQHRXW<<strong>br</strong> />
)RUDORQJWLPHDIWHUKLVUHVFXH%XFNGLGQRWOLNH7KRUQWRQWR<<strong>br</strong> />
JHWRXWRIKLVVLJKW)URPWKHPRPHQWKHOHIWWKHWHQWWRZKHQKH<<strong>br</strong> />
HQWHUHGLWDJDLQ%XFNZRXOGIROORZDWKLVKHHOV+LVWUDQVLHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
PDVWHUVVLQFHKHKDGFRPHLQWRWKH1RUWKODQGKDGEUHGLQKLPD<<strong>br</strong> />
IHDUWKDWQRPDVWHUFRXOGEHSHUPDQHQW+HZDVDIUDLGWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQZRXOGSDVVRXWRIKLVOLIHDV3HUUDXOWDQG)UDQFRLVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH6FRWFKKDOIEUHHGKDGSDVVHGRXW(YHQLQWKHQLJKWLQKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
GUHDPVKHZDVKDXQWHGE\WKLVIHDU$WVXFKWLPHVKHZRXOGVKDNH<<strong>br</strong> />
RIIVOHHSDQGFUHHSWKURXJKWKHFKLOOWRWKHIODSRIWKHWHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKHUHKHZRXOGVWDQGDQGOLVWHQWRWKHVRXQGRIKLVPDVWHUV<<strong>br</strong> />
EUHDWKLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
%XWLQVSLWHRIWKLVJUHDWORYHKHERUH-RKQ7KRUQWRQZKLFK<<strong>br</strong> />
VHHPHGWREHVSHDNWKHVRIWFLYLOL]LQJLQIOXHQFHWKHVWUDLQRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
SULPLWLYHZKLFKWKH1RUWKODQGKDGDURXVHGLQKLPUHPDLQHGDOLYH<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGDFWLYH)DLWKIXOQHVVDQGGHYRWLRQWKLQJVERUQRIILUHDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
URRIZHUHKLV\HWKHUHWDLQHGKLVZLOGQHVVDQGZLOLQHVV+HZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
DWKLQJRIWKHZLOGFRPHLQIURPWKHZLOGWRVLWE\-RKQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQVILUHUDWKHUWKDQDGRJRIWKHVRIW6RXWKODQGVWDPSHG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKWKHPDUNVRIJHQHUDWLRQVRIFLYLOL]DWLRQ%HFDXVHRIKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
YHU\JUHDWORYHKHFRXOGQRWVWHDOIURPWKLVPDQEXWIURPDQ\<<strong>br</strong> />
RWKHUPDQLQDQ\RWKHUFDPSKHGLGQRWKHVLWDWHDQLQVWDQW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLOHWKHFXQQLQJZLWKZKLFKKHVWROHHQDEOHGKLPWRHVFDSH<<strong>br</strong> />
GHWHFWLRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
+LVIDFHDQGERG\ZHUHVFRUHGE\WKHWHHWKRIPDQ\GRJVDQGKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IRXJKWDVILHUFHO\DVHYHUDQGPRUHVKUHZGO\6NHHWDQG1LJZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
WRRJRRGQDWXUHGIRUTXDUUHOOLQJEHVLGHVWKH\EHORQJHGWR-RKQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQEXWWKHVWUDQJHGRJQRPDWWHUZKDWWKHEUHHGRUYDORU<<strong>br</strong> />
VZLIWO\DFNQRZOHGJHG%XFNVVXSUHPDF\RUIRXQGKLPVHOIVWUXJJOLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUOLIHZLWKDWHUULEOHDQWDJRQLVW$QG%XFNZDVPHUFLOHVV+H<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGOHDUQHGZHOOWKHODZRIFOXEDQGIDQJDQGKHQHYHUIRUHZHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
DQDGYDQWDJHRUGUHZEDFNIURPDIRHKHKDGVWDUWHGRQWKHZD\WR<<strong>br</strong> />
'HDWK+HKDGOHVVRQHGIURP6SLW]DQGIURPWKHFKLHIILJKWLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
GRJVRIWKHSROLFHDQGPDLODQGNQHZWKHUHZDVQRPLGGOHFRXUVH<<strong>br</strong> />
+HPXVWPDVWHURUEHPDVWHUHGZKLOHWRVKRZPHUF\ZDVDZHDNQHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
0HUF\GLGQRWH[LVWLQWKHSULPRUGLDOOLIH,WZDVPLVXQGHUVWRRG<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUIHDUDQGVXFKPLVXQGHUVWDQGLQJVPDGHIRUGHDWK.LOORUEH<<strong>br</strong> />
NLOOHGHDWRUEHHDWHQZDVWKHODZDQGWKLVPDQGDWHGRZQRXW<<strong>br</strong> />
RIWKHGHSWKVRI7LPHKHREH\HG<<strong>br</strong> />
+HZDVROGHUWKDQWKHGD\VKHKDGVHHQDQGWKHEUHDWKVKHKDG<<strong>br</strong> />
52
GUDZQ+HOLQNHGWKHSDVWZLWKWKHSUHVHQWDQGWKHHWHUQLW\<<strong>br</strong> />
EHKLQGKLPWKUREEHGWKURXJKKLPLQDPLJKW\UK\WKPWRZKLFKKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VZD\HGDVWKHWLGHVDQGVHDVRQVVZD\HG+HVDWE\-RKQ7KRUQWRQV<<strong>br</strong> />
ILUHDEURDGEUHDVWHGGRJZKLWHIDQJHGDQGORQJIXUUHGEXW<<strong>br</strong> />
EHKLQGKLPZHUHWKHVKDGHVRIDOOPDQQHURIGRJVKDOIZROYHVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLOGZROYHVXUJHQWDQGSURPSWLQJWDVWLQJWKHVDYRURIWKHPHDW<<strong>br</strong> />
KHDWHWKLUVWLQJIRUWKHZDWHUKHGUDQNVFHQWLQJWKHZLQGZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPOLVWHQLQJZLWKKLPDQGWHOOLQJKLPWKHVRXQGVPDGHE\WKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLOGOLIHLQWKHIRUHVWGLFWDWLQJKLVPRRGVGLUHFWLQJKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
DFWLRQVO\LQJGRZQWRVOHHSZLWKKLPZKHQKHOD\GRZQDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
GUHDPLQJZLWKKLPDQGEH\RQGKLPDQGEHFRPLQJWKHPVHOYHVWKHVWXII<<strong>br</strong> />
RIKLVGUHDPV<<strong>br</strong> />
6RSHUHPSWRULO\GLGWKHVHVKDGHVEHFNRQKLPWKDWHDFKGD\PDQNLQG<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGWKHFODLPVRIPDQNLQGVOLSSHGIDUWKHUIURPKLP'HHSLQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUHVWDFDOOZDVVRXQGLQJDQGDVRIWHQDVKHKHDUGWKLVFDOO<<strong>br</strong> />
P\VWHULRXVO\WKULOOLQJDQGOXULQJKHIHOWFRPSHOOHGWRWXUQKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
EDFNXSRQWKHILUHDQGWKHEHDWHQHDUWKDURXQGLWDQGWRSOXQJH<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWRWKHIRUHVWDQGRQDQGRQKHNQHZQRWZKHUHRUZK\QRUGLG<<strong>br</strong> />
KHZRQGHUZKHUHRUZK\WKHFDOOVRXQGLQJLPSHULRXVO\GHHSLQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUHVW%XWDVRIWHQDVKHJDLQHGWKHVRIWXQEURNHQHDUWKDQGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
JUHHQVKDGHWKHORYHIRU-RKQ7KRUQWRQGUHZKLPEDFNWRWKHILUH<<strong>br</strong> />
DJDLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQDORQHKHOGKLP7KHUHVWRIPDQNLQGZDVDVQRWKLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
&KDQFHWUDYHOOHUVPLJKWSUDLVHRUSHWKLPEXWKHZDVFROGXQGHU<<strong>br</strong> />
LWDOODQGIURPDWRRGHPRQVWUDWLYHPDQKHZRXOGJHWXSDQGZDON<<strong>br</strong> />
DZD\:KHQ7KRUQWRQVSDUWQHUV+DQVDQG3HWHDUULYHGRQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ORQJH[SHFWHGUDIW%XFNUHIXVHGWRQRWLFHWKHPWLOOKHOHDUQHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\ZHUHFORVHWR7KRUQWRQDIWHUWKDWKHWROHUDWHGWKHPLQD<<strong>br</strong> />
SDVVLYHVRUWRIZD\DFFHSWLQJIDYRUVIURPWKHPDVWKRXJKKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IDYRUHGWKHPE\DFFHSWLQJ7KH\ZHUHRIWKHVDPHODUJHW\SHDV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQOLYLQJFORVHWRWKHHDUWKWKLQNLQJVLPSO\DQGVHHLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
FOHDUO\DQGHUHWKH\VZXQJWKHUDIWLQWRWKHELJHGG\E\WKHVDZ<<strong>br</strong> />
PLOODW'DZVRQWKH\XQGHUVWRRG%XFNDQGKLVZD\VDQGGLGQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
LQVLVWXSRQDQLQWLPDF\VXFKDVREWDLQHGZLWK6NHHWDQG1LJ<<strong>br</strong> />
)RU7KRUQWRQKRZHYHUKLVORYHVHHPHGWRJURZDQGJURZ+H<<strong>br</strong> />
DORQHDPRQJPHQFRXOGSXWDSDFNXSRQ%XFNVEDFNLQWKHVXPPHU<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDYHOOLQJ1RWKLQJZDVWRRJUHDWIRU%XFNWRGRZKHQ7KRUQWRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
FRPPDQGHG2QHGD\WKH\KDGJUXEVWDNHGWKHPVHOYHVIURPWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
SURFHHGVRIWKHUDIWDQGOHIW'DZVRQIRUWKHKHDGZDWHUVRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
7DQDQDWKHPHQDQGGRJVZHUHVLWWLQJRQWKHFUHVWRIDFOLII<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLFKIHOODZD\VWUDLJKWGRZQWRQDNHGEHGURFNWKUHHKXQGUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
53
IHHWEHORZ-RKQ7KRUQWRQZDVVLWWLQJQHDUWKHHGJH%XFNDWKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
VKRXOGHU$WKRXJKWOHVVZKLPVHL]HG7KRUQWRQDQGKHGUHZWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
DWWHQWLRQRI+DQVDQG3HWHWRWKHH[SHULPHQWKHKDGLQPLQG<<strong>br</strong> />
-XPS%XFNKHFRPPDQGHGVZHHSLQJKLVDUPRXWDQGRYHUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FKDVP7KHQH[WLQVWDQWKHZDVJUDSSOLQJZLWK%XFNRQWKHH[WUHPH<<strong>br</strong> />
HGJHZKLOH+DQVDQG3HWHZHUHGUDJJLQJWKHPEDFNLQWRVDIHW\<<strong>br</strong> />
,WVXQFDQQ\3HWHVDLGDIWHULWZDVRYHUDQGWKH\KDGFDXJKW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHLUVSHHFK<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQVKRRNKLVKHDG1RLWLVVSOHQGLGDQGLWLVWHUULEOH<<strong>br</strong> />
WRR'R\RXNQRZLWVRPHWLPHVPDNHVPHDIUDLG<<strong>br</strong> />
,PQRWKDQNHULQJWREHWKHPDQWKDWOD\VKDQGVRQ\RXZKLOHKHV<<strong>br</strong> />
DURXQG3HWHDQQRXQFHGFRQFOXVLYHO\QRGGLQJKLVKHDGWRZDUG<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
3\-LQJRZDV+DQVVFRQWULEXWLRQ1RWPLQHVHOIHLWKHU<<strong>br</strong> />
,WZDVDW&LUFOH&LW\HUHWKH\HDUZDVRXWWKDW3HWHV<<strong>br</strong> />
DSSUHKHQVLRQVZHUHUHDOL]HG%ODFN%XUWRQDPDQHYLOWHPSHUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGPDOLFLRXVKDGEHHQSLFNLQJDTXDUUHOZLWKDWHQGHUIRRWDWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
EDUZKHQ7KRUQWRQVWHSSHGJRRGQDWXUHGO\EHWZHHQ%XFNDVZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVFXVWRPZDVO\LQJLQDFRUQHUKHDGRQSDZVZDWFKLQJKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
PDVWHUVHYHU\DFWLRQ%XUWRQVWUXFNRXWZLWKRXWZDUQLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
VWUDLJKWIURPWKHVKRXOGHU7KRUQWRQZDVVHQWVSLQQLQJDQGVDYHG<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPVHOIIURPIDOOLQJRQO\E\FOXWFKLQJWKHUDLORIWKHEDU<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRVHZKRZHUHORRNLQJRQKHDUGZKDWZDVQHLWKHUEDUNQRU\HOS<<strong>br</strong> />
EXWDVRPHWKLQJZKLFKLVEHVWGHVFULEHGDVDURDUDQGWKH\VDZ<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNVERG\ULVHXSLQWKHDLUDVKHOHIWWKHIORRUIRU%XUWRQV<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURDW7KHPDQVDYHGKLVOLIHE\LQVWLQFWLYHO\WKURZLQJRXWKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
DUPEXWZDVKXUOHGEDFNZDUGWRWKHIORRUZLWK%XFNRQWRSRIKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNORRVHGKLVWHHWKIURPWKHIOHVKRIWKHDUPDQGGURYHLQDJDLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUWKHWKURDW7KLVWLPHWKHPDQVXFFHHGHGRQO\LQSDUWO\<<strong>br</strong> />
EORFNLQJDQGKLVWKURDWZDVWRUQRSHQ7KHQWKHFURZGZDVXSRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNDQGKHZDVGULYHQRIIEXWZKLOHDVXUJHRQFKHFNHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
EOHHGLQJKHSURZOHGXSDQGGRZQJURZOLQJIXULRXVO\DWWHPSWLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WRUXVKLQDQGEHLQJIRUFHGEDFNE\DQDUUD\RIKRVWLOHFOXEV$<<strong>br</strong> />
PLQHUVPHHWLQJFDOOHGRQWKHVSRWGHFLGHGWKDWWKHGRJKDG<<strong>br</strong> />
VXIILFLHQWSURYRFDWLRQDQG%XFNZDVGLVFKDUJHG%XWKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
UHSXWDWLRQZDVPDGHDQGIURPWKDWGD\KLVQDPHVSUHDGWKURXJK<<strong>br</strong> />
HYHU\FDPSLQ$ODVND<<strong>br</strong> />
54
DWHURQLQWKHIDOORIWKH\HDUKHVDYHG-RKQ7KRUQWRQVOLIH<<strong>br</strong> />
LQTXLWHDQRWKHUIDVKLRQ7KHWKUHHSDUWQHUVZHUHOLQLQJDORQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGQDUURZSROLQJERDWGRZQDEDGVWUHWFKRIUDSLGVRQWKH)RUW\<<strong>br</strong> />
0LOH&UHHN+DQVDQG3HWHPRYHGDORQJWKHEDQNVQXEELQJZLWKD<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLQ0DQLODURSHIURPWUHHWRWUHHZKLOH7KRUQWRQUHPDLQHGLQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ERDWKHOSLQJLWVGHVFHQWE\PHDQVRIDSROHDQGVKRXWLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
GLUHFWLRQVWRWKHVKRUH%XFNRQWKHEDQNZRUULHGDQGDQ[LRXV<<strong>br</strong> />
NHSWDEUHDVWRIWKHERDWKLVH\HVQHYHURIIKLVPDVWHU<<strong>br</strong> />
$WDSDUWLFXODUO\EDGVSRWZKHUHDOHGJHRIEDUHO\VXEPHUJHG<<strong>br</strong> />
URFNVMXWWHGRXWLQWRWKHULYHU+DQVFDVWRIIWKHURSHDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLOH7KRUQWRQSROHGWKHERDWRXWLQWRWKHVWUHDPUDQGRZQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
EDQNZLWKWKHHQGLQKLVKDQGWRVQXEWKHERDWZKHQLWKDGFOHDUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHOHGJH7KLVLWGLGDQGZDVIO\LQJGRZQVWUHDPLQDFXUUHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
DVVZLIWDVDPLOOUDFHZKHQ+DQVFKHFNHGLWZLWKWKHURSHDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
FKHFNHGWRRVXGGHQO\7KHERDWIOLUWHGRYHUDQGVQXEEHGLQWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
EDQNERWWRPXSZKLOH7KRUQWRQIOXQJVKHHURXWRILWZDVFDUULHG<<strong>br</strong> />
GRZQVWUHDPWRZDUGWKHZRUVWSDUWRIWKHUDSLGVDVWUHWFKRIZLOG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDWHULQZKLFKQRVZLPPHUFRXOGOLYH<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNKDGVSUXQJLQRQWKHLQVWDQWDQGDWWKHHQGRIWKUHHKXQGUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
\DUGVDPLGDPDGVZLUORIZDWHUKHRYHUKDXOHG7KRUQWRQ:KHQKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IHOWKLPJUDVSKLVWDLO%XFNKHDGHGIRUWKHEDQNVZLPPLQJZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
DOOKLVVSOHQGLGVWUHQJWK%XWWKHSURJUHVVVKRUHZDUGZDVVORZ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHSURJUHVVGRZQVWUHDPDPD]LQJO\UDSLG)URPEHORZFDPHWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IDWDOURDULQJZKHUHWKHZLOGFXUUHQWZHQWZLOGHUDQGZDVUHQWLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
VKUHGVDQGVSUD\E\WKHURFNVZKLFKWKUXVWWKURXJKOLNHWKHWHHWK<<strong>br</strong> />
RIDQHQRUPRXVFRPE7KHVXFNRIWKHZDWHUDVLWWRRNWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
EHJLQQLQJRIWKHODVWVWHHSSLWFKZDVIULJKWIXODQG7KRUQWRQNQHZ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWWKHVKRUHZDVLPSRVVLEOH+HVFUDSHGIXULRXVO\RYHUDURFN<<strong>br</strong> />
EUXLVHGDFURVVDVHFRQGDQGVWUXFNDWKLUGZLWKFUXVKLQJIRUFH<<strong>br</strong> />
+HFOXWFKHGLWVVOLSSHU\WRSZLWKERWKKDQGVUHOHDVLQJ%XFNDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
DERYHWKHURDURIWKHFKXUQLQJZDWHUVKRXWHG*R%XFN*R<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNFRXOGQRWKROGKLVRZQDQGVZHSWRQGRZQVWUHDPVWUXJJOLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
GHVSHUDWHO\EXWXQDEOHWRZLQEDFN:KHQKHKHDUG7KRUQWRQV<<strong>br</strong> />
FRPPDQGUHSHDWHGKHSDUWO\UHDUHGRXWRIWKHZDWHUWKURZLQJKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
KHDGKLJKDVWKRXJKIRUDODVWORRNWKHQWXUQHGREHGLHQWO\<<strong>br</strong> />
WRZDUGWKHEDQN+HVZDPSRZHUIXOO\DQGZDVGUDJJHGDVKRUHE\<<strong>br</strong> />
3HWHDQG+DQVDWWKHYHU\SRLQWZKHUHVZLPPLQJFHDVHGWREH<<strong>br</strong> />
SRVVLEOHDQGGHVWUXFWLRQEHJDQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH\NQHZWKDWWKHWLPHDPDQFRXOGFOLQJWRDVOLSSHU\URFNLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHIDFHRIWKDWGULYLQJFXUUHQWZDVDPDWWHURIPLQXWHVDQGWKH\<<strong>br</strong> />
55
UDQDVIDVWDVWKH\FRXOGXSWKHEDQNWRDSRLQWIDUDERYHZKHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQZDVKDQJLQJRQ7KH\DWWDFKHGWKHOLQHZLWKZKLFKWKH\<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGEHHQVQXEELQJWKHERDWWR%XFNVQHFNDQGVKRXOGHUVEHLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
FDUHIXOWKDWLWVKRXOGQHLWKHUVWUDQJOHKLPQRULPSHGHKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
VZLPPLQJDQGODXQFKHGKLPLQWRWKHVWUHDP+HVWUXFNRXWEROGO\<<strong>br</strong> />
EXWQRWVWUDLJKWHQRXJKLQWRWKHVWUHDP+HGLVFRYHUHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
PLVWDNHWRRODWHZKHQ7KRUQWRQZDVDEUHDVWRIKLPDQGDEDUH<<strong>br</strong> />
KDOIGR]HQVWURNHVDZD\ZKLOHKHZDVEHLQJFDUULHGKHOSOHVVO\<<strong>br</strong> />
SDVW<<strong>br</strong> />
+DQVSURPSWO\VQXEEHGZLWKWKHURSHDVWKRXJK%XFNZHUHDERDW<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHURSHWKXVWLJKWHQLQJRQKLPLQWKHVZHHSRIWKHFXUUHQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVMHUNHGXQGHUWKHVXUIDFHDQGXQGHUWKHVXUIDFHKHUHPDLQHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WLOOKLVERG\VWUXFNDJDLQVWWKHEDQNDQGKHZDVKDXOHGRXW+H<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVKDOIGURZQHGDQG+DQVDQG3HWHWKUHZWKHPVHOYHVXSRQKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
SRXQGLQJWKHEUHDWKLQWRKLPDQGWKHZDWHURXWRIKLP+H<<strong>br</strong> />
VWDJJHUHGWRKLVIHHWDQGIHOOGRZQ7KHIDLQWVRXQGRI<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQVYRLFHFDPHWRWKHPDQGWKRXJKWKH\FRXOGQRWPDNHRXW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHZRUGVRILWWKH\NQHZWKDWKHZDVLQKLVH[WUHPLW\+LV<<strong>br</strong> />
PDVWHUVYRLFHDFWHGRQ%XFNOLNHDQHOHFWULFVKRFN+HVSUDQJWR<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVIHHWDQGUDQXSWKHEDQNDKHDGRIWKHPHQWRWKHSRLQWRIKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
SUHYLRXVGHSDUWXUH<<strong>br</strong> />
$JDLQWKHURSHZDVDWWDFKHGDQGKHZDVODXQFKHGDQGDJDLQKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VWUXFNRXWEXWWKLVWLPHVWUDLJKWLQWRWKHVWUHDP+HKDG<<strong>br</strong> />
PLVFDOFXODWHGRQFHEXWKHZRXOGQRWEHJXLOW\RILWDVHFRQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WLPH+DQVSDLGRXWWKHURSHSHUPLWWLQJQRVODFNZKLOH3HWH<<strong>br</strong> />
NHSWLWFOHDURIFRLOV%XFNKHOGRQWLOOKHZDVRQDOLQH<<strong>br</strong> />
VWUDLJKWDERYH7KRUQWRQWKHQKHWXUQHGDQGZLWKWKHVSHHGRIDQ<<strong>br</strong> />
H[SUHVVWUDLQKHDGHGGRZQXSRQKLP7KRUQWRQVDZKLPFRPLQJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
DV%XFNVWUXFNKLPOLNHDEDWWHULQJUDPZLWKWKHZKROHIRUFHRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHFXUUHQWEHKLQGKLPKHUHDFKHGXSDQGFORVHGZLWKERWKDUPV<<strong>br</strong> />
DURXQGWKHVKDJJ\QHFN+DQVVQXEEHGWKHURSHDURXQGWKHWUHH<<strong>br</strong> />
DQG%XFNDQG7KRUQWRQZHUHMHUNHGXQGHUWKHZDWHU6WUDQJOLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
VXIIRFDWLQJVRPHWLPHVRQHXSSHUPRVWDQGVRPHWLPHVWKHRWKHU<<strong>br</strong> />
GUDJJLQJRYHUWKHMDJJHGERWWRPVPDVKLQJDJDLQVWURFNVDQGVQDJV<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\YHHUHGLQWRWKHEDQN<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQFDPHWREHOO\GRZQZDUGDQGEHLQJYLROHQWO\SURSHOOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
EDFNDQGIRUWKDFURVVDGULIWORJE\+DQVDQG3HWH+LVILUVW<<strong>br</strong> />
JODQFHZDVIRU%XFNRYHUZKRVHOLPSDQGDSSDUHQWO\OLIHOHVVERG\<<strong>br</strong> />
1LJZDVVHWWLQJXSDKRZOZKLOH6NHHWZDVOLFNLQJWKHZHWIDFH<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGFORVHGH\HV7KRUQWRQZDVKLPVHOIEUXLVHGDQGEDWWHUHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
KHZHQWFDUHIXOO\RYHU%XFNVERG\ZKHQKHKDGEHHQEURXJKW<<strong>br</strong> />
56
DURXQGILQGLQJWKUHHEURNHQULEV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KDWVHWWOHVLWKHDQQRXQFHG:HFDPSULJKWKHUH$QGFDPS<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\GLGWLOO%XFNVULEVNQLWWHGDQGKHZDVDEOHWRWUDYHO<<strong>br</strong> />
7KDWZLQWHUDW'DZVRQ%XFNSHUIRUPHGDQRWKHUH[SORLWQRWVR<<strong>br</strong> />
KHURLFSHUKDSVEXWRQHWKDWSXWKLVQDPHPDQ\QRWFKHVKLJKHURQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHWRWHPSROHRI$ODVNDQIDPH7KLVH[SORLWZDVSDUWLFXODUO\<<strong>br</strong> />
JUDWLI\LQJWRWKHWKUHHPHQIRUWKH\VWRRGLQQHHGRIWKHRXWILW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLFKLWIXUQLVKHGDQGZHUHHQDEOHGWRPDNHDORQJGHVLUHGWULS<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWRWKHYLUJLQ(DVWZKHUHPLQHUVKDGQRW\HWDSSHDUHG,WZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
EURXJKWDERXWE\DFRQYHUVDWLRQLQWKH(OGRUDGR6DORRQLQZKLFK<<strong>br</strong> />
PHQZD[HGERDVWIXORIWKHLUIDYRULWHGRJV%XFNEHFDXVHRIKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
UHFRUGZDVWKHWDUJHWIRUWKHVHPHQDQG7KRUQWRQZDVGULYHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
VWRXWO\WRGHIHQGKLP$WWKHHQGRIKDOIDQKRXURQHPDQVWDWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWKLVGRJFRXOGVWDUWDVOHGZLWKILYHKXQGUHGSRXQGVDQGZDON<<strong>br</strong> />
RIIZLWKLWDVHFRQGEUDJJHGVL[KXQGUHGIRUKLVGRJDQGD<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLUGVHYHQKXQGUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
3RRKSRRKVDLG-RKQ7KRUQWRQ%XFNFDQVWDUWDWKRXVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
SRXQGV<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGEUHDNLWRXW"DQGZDONRIIZLWKLWIRUDKXQGUHG\DUGV"<<strong>br</strong> />
GHPDQGHG0DWWKHZVRQD%RQDQ]D.LQJKHRIWKHVHYHQKXQGUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
YDXQW<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGEUHDNLWRXWDQGZDONRIIZLWKLWIRUDKXQGUHG\DUGV-RKQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQVDLGFRROO\<<strong>br</strong> />
:HOO0DWWKHZVRQVDLGVORZO\DQGGHOLEHUDWHO\VRWKDWDOO<<strong>br</strong> />
FRXOGKHDU,YHJRWDWKRXVDQGGROODUVWKDWVD\VKHFDQW$QG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHUHLWLV6RVD\LQJKHVODPPHGDVDFNRIJROGGXVWRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VL]HRIDERORJQDVDXVDJHGRZQXSRQWKHEDU<<strong>br</strong> />
1RERG\VSRNH7KRUQWRQVEOXIILIEOXIILWZDVKDGEHHQFDOOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
+HFRXOGIHHODIOXVKRIZDUPEORRGFUHHSLQJXSKLVIDFH+LV<<strong>br</strong> />
WRQJXHKDGWULFNHGKLP+HGLGQRWNQRZZKHWKHU%XFNFRXOGVWDUW<<strong>br</strong> />
DWKRXVDQGSRXQGV+DOIDWRQ7KHHQRUPRXVQHVVRILWDSSDOOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
KLP+HKDGJUHDWIDLWKLQ%XFNVVWUHQJWKDQGKDGRIWHQWKRXJKW<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPFDSDEOHRIVWDUWLQJVXFKDORDGEXWQHYHUDVQRZKDGKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IDFHGWKHSRVVLELOLW\RILWWKHH\HVRIDGR]HQPHQIL[HGXSRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPVLOHQWDQGZDLWLQJ)XUWKHUKHKDGQRWKRXVDQGGROODUVQRU<<strong>br</strong> />
KDG+DQVRU3HWH<<strong>br</strong> />
57
,YHJRWDVOHGVWDQGLQJRXWVLGHQRZZLWKWZHQW\ILIW\SRXQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VDFNVRIIORXURQLW0DWWKHZVRQZHQWRQZLWKEUXWDOGLUHFWQHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
VRGRQWOHWWKDWKLQGHU\RX<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQGLGQRWUHSO\+HGLGQRWNQRZZKDWWRVD\+HJODQFHG<<strong>br</strong> />
IURPIDFHWRIDFHLQWKHDEVHQWZD\RIDPDQZKRKDVORVWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
SRZHURIWKRXJKWDQGLVVHHNLQJVRPHZKHUHWRILQGWKHWKLQJWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLOOVWDUWLWJRLQJDJDLQ7KHIDFHRI-LP2%ULHQD0DVWRGRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
.LQJDQGROGWLPHFRPUDGHFDXJKWKLVH\HV,WZDVDVDFXHWR<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPVHHPLQJWRURXVHKLPWRGRZKDWKHZRXOGQHYHUKDYHGUHDPHG<<strong>br</strong> />
RIGRLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
&DQ\RXOHQGPHDWKRXVDQG"KHDVNHGDOPRVWLQDZKLVSHU<<strong>br</strong> />
6XUHDQVZHUHG2%ULHQWKXPSLQJGRZQDSOHWKRULFVDFNE\WKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VLGHRI0DWWKHZVRQV7KRXJKLWVOLWWOHIDLWK,PKDYLQJ-RKQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWWKHEHDVWFDQGRWKHWULFN<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH(OGRUDGRHPSWLHGLWVRFFXSDQWVLQWRWKHVWUHHWWRVHHWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WHVW7KHWDEOHVZHUHGHVHUWHGDQGWKHGHDOHUVDQGJDPHNHHSHUV<<strong>br</strong> />
FDPHIRUWKWRVHHWKHRXWFRPHRIWKHZDJHUDQGWROD\RGGV<<strong>br</strong> />
6HYHUDOKXQGUHGPHQIXUUHGDQGPLWWHQHGEDQNHGDURXQGWKHVOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKLQHDV\GLVWDQFH0DWWKHZVRQVVOHGORDGHGZLWKDWKRXVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
SRXQGVRIIORXUKDGEHHQVWDQGLQJIRUDFRXSOHRIKRXUVDQGLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHLQWHQVHFROGLWZDVVL[W\EHORZ]HURWKHUXQQHUVKDGIUR]HQ<<strong>br</strong> />
IDVWWRWKHKDUGSDFNHGVQRZ0HQRIIHUHGRGGVRIWZRWRRQHWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNFRXOGQRWEXGJHWKHVOHG$TXLEEOHDURVHFRQFHUQLQJWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
SKUDVHEUHDNRXW2%ULHQFRQWHQGHGLWZDV7KRUQWRQVSULYLOHJH<<strong>br</strong> />
WRNQRFNWKHUXQQHUVORRVHOHDYLQJ%XFNWREUHDNLWRXWIURPD<<strong>br</strong> />
GHDGVWDQGVWLOO0DWWKHZVRQLQVLVWHGWKDWWKHSKUDVHLQFOXGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
EUHDNLQJWKHUXQQHUVIURPWKHIUR]HQJULSRIWKHVQRZ$PDMRULW\<<strong>br</strong> />
RIWKHPHQZKRKDGZLWQHVVHGWKHPDNLQJRIWKHEHWGHFLGHGLQKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
IDYRUZKHUHDWWKHRGGVZHQWXSWRWKUHHWRRQHDJDLQVW%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHUHZHUHQRWDNHUV1RWDPDQEHOLHYHGKLPFDSDEOHRIWKHIHDW<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQKDGEHHQKXUULHGLQWRWKHZDJHUKHDY\ZLWKGRXEWDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
QRZWKDWKHORRNHGDWWKHVOHGLWVHOIWKHFRQFUHWHIDFWZLWKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
UHJXODUWHDPRIWHQGRJVFXUOHGXSLQWKHVQRZEHIRUHLWWKHPRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
LPSRVVLEOHWKHWDVNDSSHDUHG0DWWKHZVRQZD[HGMXELODQW<<strong>br</strong> />
7KUHHWRRQHKHSURFODLPHG,OOOD\\RXDQRWKHUWKRXVDQGDW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWILJXUH7KRUQWRQ:KDWG\HVD\"<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQVGRXEWZDVVWURQJLQKLVIDFHEXWKLVILJKWLQJVSLULW<<strong>br</strong> />
58
ZDVDURXVHGWKHILJKWLQJVSLULWWKDWVRDUVDERYHRGGVIDLOVWR<<strong>br</strong> />
UHFRJQL]HWKHLPSRVVLEOHDQGLVGHDIWRDOOVDYHWKHFODPRUIRU<<strong>br</strong> />
EDWWOH+HFDOOHG+DQVDQG3HWHWRKLP7KHLUVDFNVZHUHVOLP<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGZLWKKLVRZQWKHWKUHHSDUWQHUVFRXOGUDNHWRJHWKHURQO\WZR<<strong>br</strong> />
KXQGUHGGROODUV,QWKHHEERIWKHLUIRUWXQHVWKLVVXPZDVWKHLU<<strong>br</strong> />
WRWDOFDSLWDO\HWWKH\ODLGLWXQKHVLWDWLQJO\DJDLQVW<<strong>br</strong> />
0DWWKHZVRQVVL[KXQGUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHWHDPRIWHQGRJVZDVXQKLWFKHGDQG%XFNZLWKKLVRZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
KDUQHVVZDVSXWLQWRWKHVOHG+HKDGFDXJKWWKHFRQWDJLRQRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHH[FLWHPHQWDQGKHIHOWWKDWLQVRPHZD\KHPXVWGRDJUHDW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLQJIRU-RKQ7KRUQWRQ0XUPXUVRIDGPLUDWLRQDWKLVVSOHQGLG<<strong>br</strong> />
DSSHDUDQFHZHQWXS+HZDVLQSHUIHFWFRQGLWLRQZLWKRXWDQRXQFH<<strong>br</strong> />
RIVXSHUIOXRXVIOHVKDQGWKHRQHKXQGUHGDQGILIW\SRXQGVWKDWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHLJKHGZHUHVRPDQ\SRXQGVRIJULWDQGYLULOLW\+LVIXUU\FRDW<<strong>br</strong> />
VKRQHZLWKWKHVKHHQRIVLON'RZQWKHQHFNDQGDFURVVWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VKRXOGHUVKLVPDQHLQUHSRVHDVLWZDVKDOIEULVWOHGDQGVHHPHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WROLIWZLWKHYHU\PRYHPHQWDVWKRXJKH[FHVVRIYLJRUPDGHHDFK<<strong>br</strong> />
SDUWLFXODUKDLUDOLYHDQGDFWLYH7KHJUHDWEUHDVWDQGKHDY\IRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
OHJVZHUHQRPRUHWKDQLQSURSRUWLRQZLWKWKHUHVWRIWKHERG\<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKHUHWKHPXVFOHVVKRZHGLQWLJKWUROOVXQGHUQHDWKWKHVNLQ0HQ<<strong>br</strong> />
IHOWWKHVHPXVFOHVDQGSURFODLPHGWKHPKDUGDVLURQDQGWKHRGGV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHQWGRZQWRWZRWRRQH<<strong>br</strong> />
*DGVLU*DGVLUVWXWWHUHGDPHPEHURIWKHODWHVWG\QDVW\D<<strong>br</strong> />
NLQJRIWKH6NRRNXP%HQFKHV,RIIHU\RXHLJKWKXQGUHGIRUKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
VLUEHIRUHWKHWHVWVLUHLJKWKXQGUHGMXVWDVKHVWDQGV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQVKRRNKLVKHDGDQGVWHSSHGWR%XFNVVLGH<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHFURZGZDVZDWFKLQJFXULRXVO\7KHDIIDLUZDVJURZLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
P\VWHULRXV,WVHHPHGOLNHDFRQMXUDWLRQ$V7KRUQWRQJRWWRKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
IHHW%XFNVHL]HGKLVPLWWHQHGKDQGEHWZHHQKLVMDZVSUHVVLQJLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKKLVWHHWKDQGUHOHDVLQJVORZO\KDOIUHOXFWDQWO\,WZDVWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
DQVZHULQWHUPVQRWRIVSHHFKEXWRIORYH7KRUQWRQVWHSSHG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHOOEDFN<<strong>br</strong> />
1RZ%XFNKHVDLG<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNWLJKWHQHGWKHWUDFHVWKHQVODFNHGWKHPIRUDPDWWHURI<<strong>br</strong> />
VHYHUDOLQFKHV,WZDVWKHZD\KHKDGOHDUQHG<<strong>br</strong> />
*HH7KRUQWRQVYRLFHUDQJRXWVKDUSLQWKHWHQVHVLOHQFH<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNVZXQJWRWKHULJKWHQGLQJWKHPRYHPHQWLQDSOXQJHWKDWWRRN<<strong>br</strong> />
XSWKHVODFNDQGZLWKDVXGGHQMHUNDUUHVWHGKLVRQHKXQGUHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
ILIW\SRXQGV7KHORDGTXLYHUHGDQGIURPXQGHUWKHUXQQHUVDURVH<<strong>br</strong> />
DFULVSFUDFNOLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
+DZ7KRUQWRQFRPPDQGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNGXSOLFDWHGWKHPDQRHXYUHWKLVWLPHWRWKHOHIW7KH<<strong>br</strong> />
FUDFNOLQJWXUQHGLQWRDVQDSSLQJWKHVOHGSLYRWLQJDQGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
UXQQHUVVOLSSLQJDQGJUDWLQJVHYHUDOLQFKHVWRWKHVLGH7KHVOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVEURNHQRXW0HQZHUHKROGLQJWKHLUEUHDWKVLQWHQVHO\<<strong>br</strong> />
XQFRQVFLRXVRIWKHIDFW<<strong>br</strong> />
1RZ086+<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQVFRPPDQGFUDFNHGRXWOLNHDSLVWROVKRW%XFNWKUHZ<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPVHOIIRUZDUGWLJKWHQLQJWKHWUDFHVZLWKDMDUULQJOXQJH+LV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKROHERG\ZDVJDWKHUHGFRPSDFWO\WRJHWKHULQWKHWUHPHQGRXV<<strong>br</strong> />
HIIRUWWKHPXVFOHVZULWKLQJDQGNQRWWLQJOLNHOLYHWKLQJVXQGHU<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHVLON\IXU+LVJUHDWFKHVWZDVORZWRWKHJURXQGKLVKHDG<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUZDUGDQGGRZQZKLOHKLVIHHWZHUHIO\LQJOLNHPDGWKHFODZV<<strong>br</strong> />
VFDUULQJWKHKDUGSDFNHGVQRZLQSDUDOOHOJURRYHV7KHVOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
VZD\HGDQGWUHPEOHGKDOIVWDUWHGIRUZDUG2QHRIKLVIHHW<<strong>br</strong> />
VOLSSHGDQGRQHPDQJURDQHGDORXG7KHQWKHVOHGOXUFKHGDKHDGLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKDWDSSHDUHGDUDSLGVXFFHVVLRQRIMHUNVWKRXJKLWQHYHUUHDOO\<<strong>br</strong> />
FDPHWRDGHDGVWRSDJDLQKDOIDQLQFKDQLQFKWZR<<strong>br</strong> />
LQFKHV7KHMHUNVSHUFHSWLEO\GLPLQLVKHGDVWKHVOHGJDLQHG<<strong>br</strong> />
PRPHQWXPKHFDXJKWWKHPXSWLOOLWZDVPRYLQJVWHDGLO\DORQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
0HQJDVSHGDQGEHJDQWREUHDWKHDJDLQXQDZDUHWKDWIRUDPRPHQW<<strong>br</strong> />
60
WKH\KDGFHDVHGWREUHDWKH7KRUQWRQZDVUXQQLQJEHKLQG<<strong>br</strong> />
HQFRXUDJLQJ%XFNZLWKVKRUWFKHHU\ZRUGV7KHGLVWDQFHKDGEHHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
PHDVXUHGRIIDQGDVKHQHDUHGWKHSLOHRIILUHZRRGZKLFKPDUNHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHHQGRIWKHKXQGUHG\DUGVDFKHHUEHJDQWRJURZDQGJURZ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLFKEXUVWLQWRDURDUDVKHSDVVHGWKHILUHZRRGDQGKDOWHGDW<<strong>br</strong> />
FRPPDQG(YHU\PDQZDVWHDULQJKLPVHOIORRVHHYHQ0DWWKHZVRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
+DWVDQGPLWWHQVZHUHIO\LQJLQWKHDLU0HQZHUHVKDNLQJKDQGV<<strong>br</strong> />
LWGLGQRWPDWWHUZLWKZKRPDQGEXEEOLQJRYHULQDJHQHUDO<<strong>br</strong> />
LQFRKHUHQWEDEHO<<strong>br</strong> />
%XW7KRUQWRQIHOORQKLVNQHHVEHVLGH%XFN+HDGZDVDJDLQVW<<strong>br</strong> />
KHDGDQGKHZDVVKDNLQJKLPEDFNDQGIRUWK7KRVHZKRKXUULHGXS<<strong>br</strong> />
KHDUGKLPFXUVLQJ%XFNDQGKHFXUVHGKLPORQJDQGIHUYHQWO\DQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VRIWO\DQGORYLQJO\<<strong>br</strong> />
*DGVLU*DGVLUVSOXWWHUHGWKH6NRRNXP%HQFKNLQJ,OO<<strong>br</strong> />
JLYH\RXDWKRXVDQGIRUKLPVLUDWKRXVDQGVLUWZHOYHKXQGUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
VLU<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQURVHWRKLVIHHW+LVH\HVZHUHZHW7KHWHDUVZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
VWUHDPLQJIUDQNO\GRZQKLVFKHHNV6LUKHVDLGWRWKH6NRRNXP<<strong>br</strong> />
%HQFKNLQJQRVLU
JRWEDFNWRKLP)URPWKHEHJLQQLQJWKHUHKDGEHHQDQDQFLHQWDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
UDPVKDFNOHFDELQ'\LQJPHQKDGVZRUQWRLWDQGWRWKHPLQHWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VLWHRIZKLFKLWPDUNHGFOLQFKLQJWKHLUWHVWLPRQ\ZLWKQXJJHWV<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWZHUHXQOLNHDQ\NQRZQJUDGHRIJROGLQWKH1RUWKODQG<<strong>br</strong> />
%XWQROLYLQJPDQKDGORRWHGWKLVWUHDVXUHKRXVHDQGWKHGHDG<<strong>br</strong> />
ZHUHGHDGZKHUHIRUH-RKQ7KRUQWRQDQG3HWHDQG+DQVZLWK%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGKDOIDGR]HQRWKHUGRJVIDFHGLQWRWKH(DVWRQDQXQNQRZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDLOWRDFKLHYHZKHUHPHQDQGGRJVDVJRRGDVWKHPVHOYHVKDG<<strong>br</strong> />
IDLOHG7KH\VOHGGHGVHYHQW\PLOHVXSWKH
IDLUDVDQ\WKH6RXWKODQGFRXOGERDVW,QWKHIDOORIWKH\HDU<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\SHQHWUDWHGDZHLUGODNHFRXQWU\VDGDQGVLOHQWZKHUHZLOG<<strong>br</strong> />
IRZOKDGEHHQEXWZKHUHWKHQWKHUHZDVQROLIHQRUVLJQRIOLIH<<strong>br</strong> />
RQO\WKHEORZLQJRIFKLOOZLQGVWKHIRUPLQJRILFHLQVKHOWHUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
SODFHVDQGWKHPHODQFKRO\ULSSOLQJRIZDYHVRQORQHO\EHDFKHV<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGWKURXJKDQRWKHUZLQWHUWKH\ZDQGHUHGRQWKHREOLWHUDWHGWUDLOV<<strong>br</strong> />
RIPHQZKRKDGJRQHEHIRUH2QFHWKH\FDPHXSRQDSDWKEOD]HG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURXJKWKHIRUHVWDQDQFLHQWSDWKDQGWKH/RVW&DELQVHHPHG<<strong>br</strong> />
YHU\QHDU%XWWKHSDWKEHJDQQRZKHUHDQGHQGHGQRZKHUHDQGLW<<strong>br</strong> />
UHPDLQHGP\VWHU\DVWKHPDQZKRPDGHLWDQGWKHUHDVRQKHPDGHLW<<strong>br</strong> />
UHPDLQHGP\VWHU\$QRWKHUWLPHWKH\FKDQFHGXSRQWKHWLPHJUDYHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZUHFNDJHRIDKXQWLQJORGJHDQGDPLGWKHVKUHGVRIURWWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
EODQNHWV-RKQ7KRUQWRQIRXQGDORQJEDUUHOOHGIOLQWORFN+HNQHZ<<strong>br</strong> />
LWIRUD+XGVRQ%D\&RPSDQ\JXQRIWKH\RXQJGD\VLQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
1RUWKZHVWZKHQVXFKDJXQZDVZRUWKLWVKHLJKWLQEHDYHUVNLQV<<strong>br</strong> />
SDFNHGIODW$QGWKDWZDVDOOQRKLQWDVWRWKHPDQZKRLQDQ<<strong>br</strong> />
HDUO\GD\KDGUHDUHGWKHORGJHDQGOHIWWKHJXQDPRQJWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
EODQNHWV<<strong>br</strong> />
6SULQJFDPHRQRQFHPRUHDQGDWWKHHQGRIDOOWKHLUZDQGHULQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\IRXQGQRWWKH/RVW&DELQEXWDVKDOORZSODFHULQDEURDG<<strong>br</strong> />
YDOOH\ZKHUHWKHJROGVKRZHGOLNH\HOORZEXWWHUDFURVVWKHERWWRP<<strong>br</strong> />
RIWKHZDVKLQJSDQ7KH\VRXJKWQRIDUWKHU(DFKGD\WKH\ZRUNHG<<strong>br</strong> />
HDUQHGWKHPWKRXVDQGVRIGROODUVLQFOHDQGXVWDQGQXJJHWVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\ZRUNHGHYHU\GD\7KHJROGZDVVDFNHGLQPRRVHKLGHEDJV<<strong>br</strong> />
ILIW\SRXQGVWRWKHEDJDQGSLOHGOLNHVRPXFKILUHZRRGRXWVLGH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHVSUXFHERXJKORGJH/LNHJLDQWVWKH\WRLOHGGD\VIODVKLQJRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHKHHOVRIGD\VOLNHGUHDPVDVWKH\KHDSHGWKHWUHDVXUHXS<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHUHZDVQRWKLQJIRUWKHGRJVWRGRVDYHWKHKDXOLQJLQRIPHDW<<strong>br</strong> />
QRZDQGDJDLQWKDW7KRUQWRQNLOOHGDQG%XFNVSHQWORQJKRXUV<<strong>br</strong> />
PXVLQJE\WKHILUH7KHYLVLRQRIWKHVKRUWOHJJHGKDLU\PDQFDPH<<strong>br</strong> />
WRKLPPRUHIUHTXHQWO\QRZWKDWWKHUHZDVOLWWOHZRUNWREHGRQH<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGRIWHQEOLQNLQJE\WKHILUH%XFNZDQGHUHGZLWKKLPLQWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
RWKHUZRUOGZKLFKKHUHPHPEHUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHVDOLHQWWKLQJRIWKLVRWKHUZRUOGVHHPHGIHDU:KHQKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDWFKHGWKHKDLU\PDQVOHHSLQJE\WKHILUHKHDGEHWZHHQKLVNQHHV<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGKDQGVFODVSHGDERYH%XFNVDZWKDWKHVOHSWUHVWOHVVO\ZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
PDQ\VWDUWVDQGDZDNHQLQJVDWZKLFKWLPHVKHZRXOGSHHUIHDUIXOO\<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWRWKHGDUNQHVVDQGIOLQJPRUHZRRGXSRQWKHILUH'LGWKH\<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDONE\WKHEHDFKRIDVHDZKHUHWKHKDLU\PDQJDWKHUHGVKHOO<<strong>br</strong> />
ILVKDQGDWHWKHPDVKHJDWKHUHGLWZDVZLWKH\HVWKDWURYHG<<strong>br</strong> />
63
HYHU\ZKHUHIRUKLGGHQGDQJHUDQGZLWKOHJVSUHSDUHGWRUXQOLNH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHZLQGDWLWVILUVWDSSHDUDQFH7KURXJKWKHIRUHVWWKH\FUHSW<<strong>br</strong> />
QRLVHOHVVO\%XFNDWWKHKDLU\PDQVKHHOVDQGWKH\ZHUHDOHUW<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGYLJLODQWWKHSDLURIWKHPHDUVWZLWFKLQJDQGPRYLQJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
QRVWULOVTXLYHULQJIRUWKHPDQKHDUGDQGVPHOOHGDVNHHQO\DV<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFN7KHKDLU\PDQFRXOGVSULQJXSLQWRWKHWUHHVDQGWUDYHO<<strong>br</strong> />
DKHDGDVIDVWDVRQWKHJURXQGVZLQJLQJE\WKHDUPVIURPOLPEWR<<strong>br</strong> />
OLPEVRPHWLPHVDGR]HQIHHWDSDUWOHWWLQJJRDQGFDWFKLQJQHYHU<<strong>br</strong> />
IDOOLQJQHYHUPLVVLQJKLVJULS,QIDFWKHVHHPHGDVPXFKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
KRPHDPRQJWKHWUHHVDVRQWKHJURXQGDQG%XFNKDGPHPRULHVRI<<strong>br</strong> />
QLJKWVRIYLJLOVSHQWEHQHDWKWUHHVZKHUHLQWKHKDLU\PDQURRVWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
KROGLQJRQWLJKWO\DVKHVOHSW<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGFORVHO\DNLQWRWKHYLVLRQVRIWKHKDLU\PDQZDVWKHFDOO<<strong>br</strong> />
VWLOOVRXQGLQJLQWKHGHSWKVRIWKHIRUHVW,WILOOHGKLPZLWKD<<strong>br</strong> />
JUHDWXQUHVWDQGVWUDQJHGHVLUHV,WFDXVHGKLPWRIHHODYDJXH<<strong>br</strong> />
VZHHWJODGQHVVDQGKHZDVDZDUHRIZLOG\HDUQLQJVDQGVWLUULQJV<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUKHNQHZQRWZKDW6RPHWLPHVKHSXUVXHGWKHFDOOLQWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUHVWORRNLQJIRULWDVWKRXJKLWZHUHDWDQJLEOHWKLQJEDUNLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
VRIWO\RUGHILDQWO\DVWKHPRRGPLJKWGLFWDWH+HZRXOGWKUXVW<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVQRVHLQWRWKHFRROZRRGPRVVRULQWRWKHEODFNVRLOZKHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
ORQJJUDVVHVJUHZDQGVQRUWZLWKMR\DWWKHIDWHDUWKVPHOOVRU<<strong>br</strong> />
KHZRXOGFURXFKIRUKRXUVDVLILQFRQFHDOPHQWEHKLQGIXQJXV<<strong>br</strong> />
FRYHUHGWUXQNVRIIDOOHQWUHHVZLGHH\HGDQGZLGHHDUHGWRDOO<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWPRYHGDQGVRXQGHGDERXWKLP,WPLJKWEHO\LQJWKXVWKDW<<strong>br</strong> />
KHKRSHGWRVXUSULVHWKLVFDOOKHFRXOGQRWXQGHUVWDQG%XWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GLGQRWNQRZZK\KHGLGWKHVHYDULRXVWKLQJV+HZDVLPSHOOHGWR<<strong>br</strong> />
GRWKHPDQGGLGQRWUHDVRQDERXWWKHPDWDOO<<strong>br</strong> />
,UUHVLVWLEOHLPSXOVHVVHL]HGKLP+HZRXOGEHO\LQJLQFDPS<<strong>br</strong> />
GR]LQJOD]LO\LQWKHKHDWRIWKHGD\ZKHQVXGGHQO\KLVKHDGZRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
OLIWDQGKLVHDUVFRFNXSLQWHQWDQGOLVWHQLQJDQGKHZRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
VSULQJWRKLVIHHWDQGGDVKDZD\DQGRQDQGRQIRUKRXUV<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURXJKWKHIRUHVWDLVOHVDQGDFURVVWKHRSHQVSDFHVZKHUHWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
QLJJHUKHDGVEXQFKHG+HORYHGWRUXQGRZQGU\ZDWHUFRXUVHVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WRFUHHSDQGVS\XSRQWKHELUGOLIHLQWKHZRRGV)RUDGD\DWD<<strong>br</strong> />
WLPHKHZRXOGOLHLQWKHXQGHUEUXVKZKHUHKHFRXOGZDWFKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
SDUWULGJHVGUXPPLQJDQGVWUXWWLQJXSDQGGRZQ%XWHVSHFLDOO\KH<<strong>br</strong> />
ORYHGWRUXQLQWKHGLPWZLOLJKWRIWKHVXPPHUPLGQLJKWV<<strong>br</strong> />
OLVWHQLQJWRWKHVXEGXHGDQGVOHHS\PXUPXUVRIWKHIRUHVWUHDGLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
VLJQVDQGVRXQGVDVPDQPD\UHDGDERRNDQGVHHNLQJIRUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
P\VWHULRXVVRPHWKLQJWKDWFDOOHGFDOOHGZDNLQJRUVOHHSLQJDW<<strong>br</strong> />
DOOWLPHVIRUKLPWRFRPH<<strong>br</strong> />
64
2QHQLJKWKHVSUDQJIURPVOHHSZLWKDVWDUWHDJHUH\HGQRVWULOV<<strong>br</strong> />
TXLYHULQJDQGVFHQWLQJKLVPDQHEULVWOLQJLQUHFXUUHQWZDYHV<<strong>br</strong> />
)URPWKHIRUHVWFDPHWKHFDOORURQHQRWHRILWIRUWKHFDOOZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
PDQ\QRWHGGLVWLQFWDQGGHILQLWHDVQHYHUEHIRUHDORQJGUDZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
KRZOOLNH\HWXQOLNHDQ\QRLVHPDGHE\KXVN\GRJ$QGKHNQHZ<<strong>br</strong> />
LWLQWKHROGIDPLOLDUZD\DVDVRXQGKHDUGEHIRUH+HVSUDQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURXJKWKHVOHHSLQJFDPSDQGLQVZLIWVLOHQFHGDVKHGWKURXJKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZRRGV$VKHGUHZFORVHUWRWKHFU\KHZHQWPRUHVORZO\ZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
FDXWLRQLQHYHU\PRYHPHQWWLOOKHFDPHWRDQRSHQSODFHDPRQJWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WUHHVDQGORRNLQJRXWVDZHUHFWRQKDXQFKHVZLWKQRVHSRLQWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WRWKHVN\DORQJOHDQWLPEHUZROI<<strong>br</strong> />
+HKDGPDGHQRQRLVH\HWLWFHDVHGIURPLWVKRZOLQJDQGWULHGWR<<strong>br</strong> />
VHQVHKLVSUHVHQFH%XFNVWDONHGLQWRWKHRSHQKDOIFURXFKLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
ERG\JDWKHUHGFRPSDFWO\WRJHWKHUWDLOVWUDLJKWDQGVWLIIIHHW<<strong>br</strong> />
IDOOLQJZLWKXQZRQWHGFDUH(YHU\PRYHPHQWDGYHUWLVHGFRPPLQJOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKUHDWHQLQJDQGRYHUWXUHRIIULHQGOLQHVV,WZDVWKHPHQDFLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WUXFHWKDWPDUNVWKHPHHWLQJRIZLOGEHDVWVWKDWSUH\%XWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZROIIOHGDWVLJKWRIKLP+HIROORZHGZLWKZLOGOHDSLQJVLQD<<strong>br</strong> />
IUHQ]\WRRYHUWDNH+HUDQKLPLQWRDEOLQGFKDQQHOLQWKHEHG<<strong>br</strong> />
RIWKHFUHHNZKHUHDWLPEHUMDPEDUUHGWKHZD\7KHZROIZKLUOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
DERXWSLYRWLQJRQKLVKLQGOHJVDIWHUWKHIDVKLRQRI-RHDQGRI<<strong>br</strong> />
DOOFRUQHUHGKXVN\GRJVVQDUOLQJDQGEULVWOLQJFOLSSLQJKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
WHHWKWRJHWKHULQDFRQWLQXRXVDQGUDSLGVXFFHVVLRQRIVQDSV<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNGLGQRWDWWDFNEXWFLUFOHGKLPDERXWDQGKHGJHGKLPLQZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
IULHQGO\DGYDQFHV7KHZROIZDVVXVSLFLRXVDQGDIUDLGIRU%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
PDGHWKUHHRIKLPLQZHLJKWZKLOHKLVKHDGEDUHO\UHDFKHG%XFNV<<strong>br</strong> />
VKRXOGHU:DWFKLQJKLVFKDQFHKHGDUWHGDZD\DQGWKHFKDVHZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
UHVXPHG7LPHDQGDJDLQKHZDVFRUQHUHGDQGWKHWKLQJUHSHDWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKRXJKKHZDVLQSRRUFRQGLWLRQRU%XFNFRXOGQRWVRHDVLO\KDYH<<strong>br</strong> />
RYHUWDNHQKLP+HZRXOGUXQWLOO%XFNVKHDGZDVHYHQZLWKKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
IODQNZKHQKHZRXOGZKLUODURXQGDWED\RQO\WRGDVKDZD\DJDLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
DWWKHILUVWRSSRUWXQLW\<<strong>br</strong> />
%XWLQWKHHQG%XFNVSHUWLQDFLW\ZDVUHZDUGHGIRUWKHZROI<<strong>br</strong> />
ILQGLQJWKDWQRKDUPZDVLQWHQGHGILQDOO\VQLIIHGQRVHVZLWKKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHQWKH\EHFDPHIULHQGO\DQGSOD\HGDERXWLQWKHQHUYRXVKDOI<<strong>br</strong> />
FR\ZD\ZLWKZKLFKILHUFHEHDVWVEHOLHWKHLUILHUFHQHVV$IWHU<<strong>br</strong> />
VRPHWLPHRIWKLVWKHZROIVWDUWHGRIIDWDQHDV\ORSHLQDPDQQHU<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWSODLQO\VKRZHGKHZDVJRLQJVRPHZKHUH+HPDGHLWFOHDUWR<<strong>br</strong> />
%XFNWKDWKHZDVWRFRPHDQGWKH\UDQVLGHE\VLGHWKURXJKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VRPEUHWZLOLJKWVWUDLJKWXSWKHFUHHNEHGLQWRWKHJRUJHIURP<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLFKLWLVVXHGDQGDFURVVWKHEOHDNGLYLGHZKHUHLWWRRNLWV<<strong>br</strong> />
65
ULVH<<strong>br</strong> />
2QWKHRSSRVLWHVORSHRIWKHZDWHUVKHGWKH\FDPHGRZQLQWRDOHYHO<<strong>br</strong> />
FRXQWU\ZKHUHZHUHJUHDWVWUHWFKHVRIIRUHVWDQGPDQ\VWUHDPVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURXJKWKHVHJUHDWVWUHWFKHVWKH\UDQVWHDGLO\KRXUDIWHUKRXU<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHVXQULVLQJKLJKHUDQGWKHGD\JURZLQJZDUPHU%XFNZDVZLOGO\<<strong>br</strong> />
JODG+HNQHZKHZDVDWODVWDQVZHULQJWKHFDOOUXQQLQJE\WKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VLGHRIKLVZRRGEURWKHUWRZDUGWKHSODFHIURPZKHUHWKHFDOO<<strong>br</strong> />
VXUHO\FDPH2OGPHPRULHVZHUHFRPLQJXSRQKLPIDVWDQGKHZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
VWLUULQJWRWKHPDVRIROGKHVWLUUHGWRWKHUHDOLWLHVRIZKLFK<<strong>br</strong> />
WKH\ZHUHWKHVKDGRZV+HKDGGRQHWKLVWKLQJEHIRUHVRPHZKHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWKDWRWKHUDQGGLPO\UHPHPEHUHGZRUOGDQGKHZDVGRLQJLW<<strong>br</strong> />
DJDLQQRZUXQQLQJIUHHLQWKHRSHQWKHXQSDFNHGHDUWK<<strong>br</strong> />
XQGHUIRRWWKHZLGHVN\RYHUKHDG<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH\VWRSSHGE\DUXQQLQJVWUHDPWRGULQNDQGVWRSSLQJ%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
UHPHPEHUHG-RKQ7KRUQWRQ+HVDWGRZQ7KHZROIVWDUWHGRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WRZDUGWKHSODFHIURPZKHUHWKHFDOOVXUHO\FDPHWKHQUHWXUQHGWR<<strong>br</strong> />
KLPVQLIILQJQRVHVDQGPDNLQJDFWLRQVDVWKRXJKWRHQFRXUDJHKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
%XW%XFNWXUQHGDERXWDQGVWDUWHGVORZO\RQWKHEDFNWUDFN)RU<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHEHWWHUSDUWRIDQKRXUWKHZLOGEURWKHUUDQE\KLVVLGH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLQLQJVRIWO\7KHQKHVDWGRZQSRLQWHGKLVQRVHXSZDUGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
KRZOHG,WZDVDPRXUQIXOKRZODQGDV%XFNKHOGVWHDGLO\RQKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZD\KHKHDUGLWJURZIDLQWDQGIDLQWHUXQWLOLWZDVORVWLQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
GLVWDQFH<<strong>br</strong> />
-RKQ7KRUQWRQZDVHDWLQJGLQQHUZKHQ%XFNGDVKHGLQWRFDPSDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VSUDQJXSRQKLPLQDIUHQ]\RIDIIHFWLRQRYHUWXUQLQJKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
VFUDPEOLQJXSRQKLPOLFNLQJKLVIDFHELWLQJKLVKDQGSOD\LQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHJHQHUDOWRPIRRODV-RKQ7KRUQWRQFKDUDFWHUL]HGLWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLOHKHVKRRN%XFNEDFNDQGIRUWKDQGFXUVHGKLPORYLQJO\<<strong>br</strong> />
)RUWZRGD\VDQGQLJKWV%XFNQHYHUOHIWFDPSQHYHUOHW7KRUQWRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
RXWRIKLVVLJKW+HIROORZHGKLPDERXWDWKLVZRUNZDWFKHGKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLOHKHDWHVDZKLPLQWRKLVEODQNHWVDWQLJKWDQGRXWRIWKHP<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWKHPRUQLQJ%XWDIWHUWZRGD\VWKHFDOOLQWKHIRUHVWEHJDQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WRVRXQGPRUHLPSHULRXVO\WKDQHYHU%XFNVUHVWOHVVQHVVFDPHEDFN<<strong>br</strong> />
RQKLPDQGKHZDVKDXQWHGE\UHFROOHFWLRQVRIWKHZLOGEURWKHU<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGRIWKHVPLOLQJODQGEH\RQGWKHGLYLGHDQGWKHUXQVLGHE\VLGH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURXJKWKHZLGHIRUHVWVWUHWFKHV2QFHDJDLQKHWRRNWR<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDQGHULQJLQWKHZRRGVEXWWKHZLOGEURWKHUFDPHQRPRUHDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKRXJKKHOLVWHQHGWKURXJKORQJYLJLOVWKHPRXUQIXOKRZOZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
QHYHUUDLVHG<<strong>br</strong> />
66
+HEHJDQWRVOHHSRXWDWQLJKWVWD\LQJDZD\IURPFDPSIRUGD\VDW<<strong>br</strong> />
DWLPHDQGRQFHKHFURVVHGWKHGLYLGHDWWKHKHDGRIWKHFUHHN<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGZHQWGRZQLQWRWKHODQGRIWLPEHUDQGVWUHDPV7KHUHKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDQGHUHGIRUDZHHNVHHNLQJYDLQO\IRUIUHVKVLJQRIWKHZLOG<<strong>br</strong> />
EURWKHUNLOOLQJKLVPHDWDVKHWUDYHOOHGDQGWUDYHOOLQJZLWKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ORQJHDV\ORSHWKDWVHHPVQHYHUWRWLUH+HILVKHGIRUVDOPRQLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
DEURDGVWUHDPWKDWHPSWLHGVRPHZKHUHLQWRWKHVHDDQGE\WKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
VWUHDPKHNLOOHGDODUJHEODFNEHDUEOLQGHGE\WKHPRVTXLWRHV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLOHOLNHZLVHILVKLQJDQGUDJLQJWKURXJKWKHIRUHVWKHOSOHVVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WHUULEOH(YHQVRLWZDVDKDUGILJKWDQGLWDURXVHGWKHODVW<<strong>br</strong> />
ODWHQWUHPQDQWVRI%XFNVIHURFLW\$QGWZRGD\VODWHUZKHQKH<<strong>br</strong> />
UHWXUQHGWRKLVNLOODQGIRXQGDGR]HQZROYHUHQHVTXDUUHOOLQJRYHU<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHVSRLOKHVFDWWHUHGWKHPOLNHFKDIIDQGWKRVHWKDWIOHGOHIW<<strong>br</strong> />
WZREHKLQGZKRZRXOGTXDUUHOQRPRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHEORRGORQJLQJEHFDPHVWURQJHUWKDQHYHUEHIRUH+HZDVD<<strong>br</strong> />
NLOOHUDWKLQJWKDWSUH\HGOLYLQJRQWKHWKLQJVWKDWOLYHG<<strong>br</strong> />
XQDLGHGDORQHE\YLUWXHRIKLVRZQVWUHQJWKDQGSURZHVV<<strong>br</strong> />
VXUYLYLQJWULXPSKDQWO\LQDKRVWLOHHQYLURQPHQWZKHUHRQO\WKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VWURQJVXUYLYHG%HFDXVHRIDOOWKLVKHEHFDPHSRVVHVVHGRID<<strong>br</strong> />
JUHDWSULGHLQKLPVHOIZKLFKFRPPXQLFDWHGLWVHOIOLNHDFRQWDJLRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WRKLVSK\VLFDOEHLQJ,WDGYHUWLVHGLWVHOILQDOOKLVPRYHPHQWV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVDSSDUHQWLQWKHSOD\RIHYHU\PXVFOHVSRNHSODLQO\DVVSHHFK<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWKHZD\KHFDUULHGKLPVHOIDQGPDGHKLVJORULRXVIXUU\FRDWLI<<strong>br</strong> />
DQ\WKLQJPRUHJORULRXV%XWIRUWKHVWUD\EURZQRQKLVPX]]OHDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
DERYHKLVH\HVDQGIRUWKHVSODVKRIZKLWHKDLUWKDWUDQPLGPRVW<<strong>br</strong> />
GRZQKLVFKHVWKHPLJKWZHOOKDYHEHHQPLVWDNHQIRUDJLJDQWLF<<strong>br</strong> />
ZROIODUJHUWKDQWKHODUJHVWRIWKHEUHHG)URPKLV6W%HUQDUG<<strong>br</strong> />
IDWKHUKHKDGLQKHULWHGVL]HDQGZHLJKWEXWLWZDVKLVVKHSKHUG<<strong>br</strong> />
PRWKHUZKRKDGJLYHQVKDSHWRWKDWVL]HDQGZHLJKW+LVPX]]OH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVWKHORQJZROIPX]]OHVDYHWKDWZDVODUJHUWKDQWKHPX]]OHRI<<strong>br</strong> />
DQ\ZROIDQGKLVKHDGVRPHZKDWEURDGHUZDVWKHZROIKHDGRQD<<strong>br</strong> />
PDVVLYHVFDOH<<strong>br</strong> />
+LVFXQQLQJZDVZROIFXQQLQJDQGZLOGFXQQLQJKLVLQWHOOLJHQFH<<strong>br</strong> />
VKHSKHUGLQWHOOLJHQFHDQG6W%HUQDUGLQWHOOLJHQFHDQGDOOWKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
SOXVDQH[SHULHQFHJDLQHGLQWKHILHUFHVWRIVFKRROVPDGHKLPDV<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUPLGDEOHDFUHDWXUHDVDQ\WKDWLQWHOOLJHQFHURDPHGWKHZLOG$<<strong>br</strong> />
FDUQLYRURXVDQLPDOOLYLQJRQDVWUDLJKWPHDWGLHWKHZDVLQIXOO<<strong>br</strong> />
IORZHUDWWKHKLJKWLGHRIKLVOLIHRYHUVSLOOLQJZLWKYLJRUDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
YLULOLW\:KHQ7KRUQWRQSDVVHGDFDUHVVLQJKDQGDORQJKLVEDFND<<strong>br</strong> />
VQDSSLQJDQGFUDFNOLQJIROORZHGWKHKDQGHDFKKDLUGLVFKDULQJLWV<<strong>br</strong> />
SHQWPDJQHWLVPDWWKHFRQWDFW(YHU\SDUWEUDLQDQGERG\QHUYH<<strong>br</strong> />
WLVVXHDQGILEUHZDVNH\HGWRWKHPRVWH[TXLVLWHSLWFKDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
67
EHWZHHQDOOWKHSDUWVWKHUHZDVDSHUIHFWHTXLOLEULXPRU<<strong>br</strong> />
DGMXVWPHQW7RVLJKWVDQGVRXQGVDQGHYHQWVZKLFKUHTXLUHG<<strong>br</strong> />
DFWLRQKHUHVSRQGHGZLWKOLJKWQLQJOLNHUDSLGLW\4XLFNO\DVD<<strong>br</strong> />
KXVN\GRJFRXOGOHDSWRGHIHQGIURPDWWDFNRUWRDWWDFNKHFRXOG<<strong>br</strong> />
OHDSWZLFHDVTXLFNO\+HVDZWKHPRYHPHQWRUKHDUGVRXQGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
UHVSRQGHGLQOHVVWLPHWKDQDQRWKHUGRJUHTXLUHGWRFRPSDVVWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
PHUHVHHLQJRUKHDULQJ+HSHUFHLYHGDQGGHWHUPLQHGDQGUHVSRQGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWKHVDPHLQVWDQW,QSRLQWRIIDFWWKHWKUHHDFWLRQVRI<<strong>br</strong> />
SHUFHLYLQJGHWHUPLQLQJDQGUHVSRQGLQJZHUHVHTXHQWLDOEXWVR<<strong>br</strong> />
LQILQLWHVLPDOZHUHWKHLQWHUYDOVRIWLPHEHWZHHQWKHPWKDWWKH\<<strong>br</strong> />
DSSHDUHGVLPXOWDQHRXV+LVPXVFOHVZHUHVXUFKDUJHGZLWKYLWDOLW\<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGVQDSSHGLQWRSOD\VKDUSO\OLNHVWHHOVSULQJV/LIHVWUHDPHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKURXJKKLPLQVSOHQGLGIORRGJODGDQGUDPSDQWXQWLOLWVHHPHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWLWZRXOGEXUVWKLPDVXQGHULQVKHHUHFVWDV\DQGSRXUIRUWK<<strong>br</strong> />
JHQHURXVO\RYHUWKHZRUOG<<strong>br</strong> />
1HYHUZDVWKHUHVXFKDGRJVDLG-RKQ7KRUQWRQRQHGD\DVWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
SDUWQHUVZDWFKHG%XFNPDUFKLQJRXWRIFDPS<<strong>br</strong> />
:KHQKHZDVPDGHWKHPRXOGZDVEURNHVDLG3HWH<<strong>br</strong> />
3\MLQJR,WLQNVRPLQHVHOI+DQVDIILUPHG<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH\VDZKLPPDUFKLQJRXWRIFDPSEXWWKH\GLGQRWVHHWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
LQVWDQWDQGWHUULEOHWUDQVIRUPDWLRQZKLFKWRRNSODFHDVVRRQDVKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVZLWKLQWKHVHFUHF\RIWKHIRUHVW+HQRORQJHUPDUFKHG$W<<strong>br</strong> />
RQFHKHEHFDPHDWKLQJRIWKHZLOGVWHDOLQJDORQJVRIWO\FDW<<strong>br</strong> />
IRRWHGDSDVVLQJVKDGRZWKDWDSSHDUHGDQGGLVDSSHDUHGDPRQJWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VKDGRZV+HNQHZKRZWRWDNHDGYDQWDJHRIHYHU\FRYHUWRFUDZO<<strong>br</strong> />
RQKLVEHOO\OLNHDVQDNHDQGOLNHDVQDNHWROHDSDQGVWULNH<<strong>br</strong> />
+HFRXOGWDNHDSWDUPLJDQIURPLWVQHVWNLOODUDEELWDVLW<<strong>br</strong> />
VOHSWDQGVQDSLQPLGDLUWKHOLWWOHFKLSPXQNVIOHHLQJDVHFRQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WRRODWHIRUWKHWUHHV)LVKLQRSHQSRROVZHUHQRWWRRTXLFN<<strong>br</strong> />
IRUKLPQRUZHUHEHDYHUPHQGLQJWKHLUGDPVWRRZDU\+HNLOOHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WRHDWQRWIURPZDQWRQQHVVEXWKHSUHIHUUHGWRHDWZKDWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
NLOOHGKLPVHOI6RDOXUNLQJKXPRUUDQWKURXJKKLVGHHGVDQGLW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZDVKLVGHOLJKWWRVWHDOXSRQWKHVTXLUUHOVDQGZKHQKHDOOEXW<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGWKHPWROHWWKHPJRFKDWWHULQJLQPRUWDOIHDUWRWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
WUHHWRSV<<strong>br</strong> />
$VWKHIDOORIWKH\HDUFDPHRQWKHPRRVHDSSHDUHGLQJUHDWHU<<strong>br</strong> />
DEXQGDQFHPRYLQJVORZO\GRZQWRPHHWWKHZLQWHULQWKHORZHUDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
OHVVULJRURXVYDOOH\V%XFNKDGDOUHDG\GUDJJHGGRZQDVWUD\<<strong>br</strong> />
SDUWJURZQFDOIEXWKHZLVKHGVWURQJO\IRUODUJHUDQGPRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
68
IRUPLGDEOHTXDUU\DQGKHFDPHXSRQLWRQHGD\RQWKHGLYLGHDW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHKHDGRIWKHFUHHN$EDQGRIWZHQW\PRRVHKDGFURVVHGRYHU<<strong>br</strong> />
IURPWKHODQGRIVWUHDPVDQGWLPEHUDQGFKLHIDPRQJWKHPZDVD<<strong>br</strong> />
JUHDWEXOO+HZDVLQDVDYDJHWHPSHUDQGVWDQGLQJRYHUVL[<<strong>br</strong> />
IHHWIURPWKHJURXQGZDVDVIRUPLGDEOHDQDQWDJRQLVWDVHYHQ%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
FRXOGGHVLUH%DFNDQGIRUWKWKHEXOOWRVVHGKLVJUHDWSDOPDWHG<<strong>br</strong> />
DQWOHUVEUDQFKLQJWRIRXUWHHQSRLQWVDQGHPEUDFLQJVHYHQIHHW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKLQWKHWLSV+LVVPDOOH\HVEXUQHGZLWKDYLFLRXVDQGELWWHU<<strong>br</strong> />
OLJKWZKLOHKHURDUHGZLWKIXU\DWVLJKWRI%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
)URPWKHEXOOVVLGHMXVWIRUZDUGRIWKHIODQNSURWUXGHGD<<strong>br</strong> />
IHDWKHUHGDUURZHQGZKLFKDFFRXQWHGIRUKLVVDYDJHQHVV*XLGHGE\<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWLQVWLQFWZKLFKFDPHIURPWKHROGKXQWLQJGD\VRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
SULPRUGLDOZRUOG%XFNSURFHHGHGWRFXWWKHEXOORXWIURPWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
KHUG,WZDVQRVOLJKWWDVN+HZRXOGEDUNDQGGDQFHDERXWLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
IURQWRIWKHEXOOMXVWRXWRIUHDFKRIWKHJUHDWDQWOHUVDQGRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHWHUULEOHVSOD\KRRIVZKLFKFRXOGKDYHVWDPSHGKLVOLIHRXW<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKDVLQJOHEORZ8QDEOHWRWXUQKLVEDFNRQWKHIDQJHGGDQJHU<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGJRRQWKHEXOOZRXOGEHGULYHQLQWRSDUR[\VPVRIUDJH$W<<strong>br</strong> />
VXFKPRPHQWVKHFKDUJHG%XFNZKRUHWUHDWHGFUDIWLO\OXULQJKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
RQE\DVLPXODWHGLQDELOLW\WRHVFDSH%XWZKHQKHZDVWKXV<<strong>br</strong> />
VHSDUDWHGIURPKLVIHOORZVWZRRUWKUHHRIWKH\RXQJHUEXOOV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZRXOGFKDUJHEDFNXSRQ%XFNDQGHQDEOHWKHZRXQGHGEXOOWRUHMRLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHKHUG<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHUHLVDSDWLHQFHRIWKHZLOGGRJJHGWLUHOHVVSHUVLVWHQWDV<<strong>br</strong> />
OLIHLWVHOIWKDWKROGVPRWLRQOHVVIRUHQGOHVVKRXUVWKHVSLGHULQ<<strong>br</strong> />
LWVZHEWKHVQDNHLQLWVFRLOVWKHSDQWKHULQLWVDPEXVFDGH<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLVSDWLHQFHEHORQJVSHFXOLDUO\WROLIHZKHQLWKXQWVLWVOLYLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
IRRGDQGLWEHORQJHGWR%XFNDVKHFOXQJWRWKHIODQNRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
KHUGUHWDUGLQJLWVPDUFKLUULWDWLQJWKH\RXQJEXOOVZRUU\LQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHFRZVZLWKWKHLUKDOIJURZQFDOYHVDQGGULYLQJWKHZRXQGHG<<strong>br</strong> />
EXOOPDGZLWKKHOSOHVVUDJH)RUKDOIDGD\WKLVFRQWLQXHG%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
PXOWLSOLHGKLPVHOIDWWDFNLQJIURPDOOVLGHVHQYHORSLQJWKHKHUG<<strong>br</strong> />
LQDZKLUOZLQGRIPHQDFHFXWWLQJRXWKLVYLFWLPDVIDVWDVLW<<strong>br</strong> />
FRXOGUHMRLQLWVPDWHVZHDULQJRXWWKHSDWLHQFHRIFUHDWXUHV<<strong>br</strong> />
SUH\HGXSRQZKLFKLVDOHVVHUSDWLHQFHWKDQWKDWRIFUHDWXUHV<<strong>br</strong> />
SUH\LQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
$VWKHGD\ZRUHDORQJDQGWKHVXQGURSSHGWRLWVEHGLQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
QRUWKZHVWWKHGDUNQHVVKDGFRPHEDFNDQGWKHIDOOQLJKWVZHUHVL[<<strong>br</strong> />
KRXUVORQJWKH\RXQJEXOOVUHWUDFHGWKHLUVWHSVPRUHDQGPRUH<<strong>br</strong> />
UHOXFWDQWO\WRWKHDLGRIWKHLUEHVHWOHDGHU7KHGRZQFRPLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLQWHUZDVKDUU\LQJWKHPRQWRWKHORZHUOHYHOVDQGLWVHHPHG<<strong>br</strong> />
69
WKH\FRXOGQHYHUVKDNHRIIWKLVWLUHOHVVFUHDWXUHWKDWKHOGWKHP<<strong>br</strong> />
EDFN%HVLGHVLWZDVQRWWKHOLIHRIWKHKHUGRURIWKH\RXQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
EXOOVWKDWZDVWKUHDWHQHG7KHOLIHRIRQO\RQHPHPEHUZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
GHPDQGHGZKLFKZDVDUHPRWHULQWHUHVWWKDQWKHLUOLYHVDQGLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHHQGWKH\ZHUHFRQWHQWWRSD\WKHWROO<<strong>br</strong> />
$VWZLOLJKWIHOOWKHROGEXOOVWRRGZLWKORZHUHGKHDGZDWFKLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVPDWHVWKHFRZVKHKDGNQRZQWKHFDOYHVKHKDGIDWKHUHGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
EXOOVKHKDGPDVWHUHGDVWKH\VKDPEOHGRQDWDUDSLGSDFHWKURXJK<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHIDGLQJOLJKW+HFRXOGQRWIROORZIRUEHIRUHKLVQRVHOHDSHG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHPHUFLOHVVIDQJHGWHUURUWKDWZRXOGQRWOHWKLPJR7KUHH<<strong>br</strong> />
KXQGUHGZHLJKWPRUHWKDQKDOIDWRQKHZHLJKHGKHKDGOLYHGD<<strong>br</strong> />
ORQJVWURQJOLIHIXOORIILJKWDQGVWUXJJOHDQGDWWKHHQGKH<<strong>br</strong> />
IDFHGGHDWKDWWKHWHHWKRIDFUHDWXUHZKRVHKHDGGLGQRWUHDFK<<strong>br</strong> />
EH\RQGKLVJUHDWNQXFNOHGNQHHV<<strong>br</strong> />
)URPWKHQRQQLJKWDQGGD\%XFNQHYHUOHIWKLVSUH\QHYHUJDYH<<strong>br</strong> />
LWDPRPHQWVUHVWQHYHUSHUPLWWHGLWWREURZVHWKHOHDYHVRI<<strong>br</strong> />
WUHHVRUWKHVKRRWVRI\RXQJELUFKDQGZLOORZ1RUGLGKHJLYHWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZRXQGHGEXOORSSRUWXQLW\WRVODNHKLVEXUQLQJWKLUVWLQWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
VOHQGHUWULFNOLQJVWUHDPVWKH\FURVVHG2IWHQLQGHVSHUDWLRQKH<<strong>br</strong> />
EXUVWLQWRORQJVWUHWFKHVRIIOLJKW$WVXFKWLPHV%XFNGLGQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
DWWHPSWWRVWD\KLPEXWORSHGHDVLO\DWKLVKHHOVVDWLVILHGZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHZD\WKHJDPHZDVSOD\HGO\LQJGRZQZKHQWKHPRRVHVWRRG<<strong>br</strong> />
VWLOODWWDFNLQJKLPILHUFHO\ZKHQKHVWURYHWRHDWRUGULQN<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHJUHDWKHDGGURRSHGPRUHDQGPRUHXQGHULWVWUHHRIKRUQVDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHVKDPEOLQJWURWJUHZZHDNDQGZHDNHU+HWRRNWRVWDQGLQJIRU<<strong>br</strong> />
ORQJSHULRGVZLWKQRVHWRWKHJURXQGDQGGHMHFWHGHDUVGURSSHG<<strong>br</strong> />
OLPSO\DQG%XFNIRXQGPRUHWLPHLQZKLFKWRJHWZDWHUIRUKLPVHOI<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGLQZKLFKWRUHVW$WVXFKPRPHQWVSDQWLQJZLWKUHGOROOLQJ<<strong>br</strong> />
WRQJXHDQGZLWKH\HVIL[HGXSRQWKHELJEXOOLWDSSHDUHGWR%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWDFKDQJHZDVFRPLQJRYHUWKHIDFHRIWKLQJV+HFRXOGIHHOD<<strong>br</strong> />
QHZVWLULQWKHODQG$VWKHPRRVHZHUHFRPLQJLQWRWKHODQG<<strong>br</strong> />
RWKHUNLQGVRIOLIHZHUHFRPLQJLQ)RUHVWDQGVWUHDPDQGDLU<<strong>br</strong> />
VHHPHGSDOSLWDQWZLWKWKHLUSUHVHQFH7KHQHZVRILWZDVERUQHLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
XSRQKLPQRWE\VLJKWRUVRXQGRUVPHOOEXWE\VRPHRWKHUDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VXEWOHUVHQVH+HKHDUGQRWKLQJVDZQRWKLQJ\HWNQHZWKDWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ODQGZDVVRPHKRZGLIIHUHQWWKDWWKURXJKLWVWUDQJHWKLQJVZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
DIRRWDQGUDQJLQJDQGKHUHVROYHGWRLQYHVWLJDWHDIWHUKHKDG<<strong>br</strong> />
ILQLVKHGWKHEXVLQHVVLQKDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
$WODVWDWWKHHQGRIWKHIRXUWKGD\KHSXOOHGWKHJUHDWPRRVH<<strong>br</strong> />
GRZQ)RUDGD\DQGDQLJKWKHUHPDLQHGE\WKHNLOOHDWLQJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
70
VOHHSLQJWXUQDQGWXUQDERXW7KHQUHVWHGUHIUHVKHGDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
VWURQJKHWXUQHGKLVIDFHWRZDUGFDPSDQG-RKQ7KRUQWRQ+H<<strong>br</strong> />
EURNHLQWRWKHORQJHDV\ORSHDQGZHQWRQKRXUDIWHUKRXUQHYHU<<strong>br</strong> />
DWORVVIRUWKHWDQJOHGZD\KHDGLQJVWUDLJKWKRPHWKURXJKVWUDQJH<<strong>br</strong> />
FRXQWU\ZLWKDFHUWLWXGHRIGLUHFWLRQWKDWSXWPDQDQGKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
PDJQHWLFQHHGOHWRVKDPH<<strong>br</strong> />
$VKHKHOGRQKHEHFDPHPRUHDQGPRUHFRQVFLRXVRIWKHQHZVWLULQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHODQG7KHUHZDVOLIHDEURDGLQLWGLIIHUHQWIURPWKHOLIH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLFKKDGEHHQWKHUHWKURXJKRXWWKHVXPPHU1RORQJHUZDVWKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
IDFWERUQHLQXSRQKLPLQVRPHVXEWOHP\VWHULRXVZD\7KHELUGV<<strong>br</strong> />
WDONHGRILWWKHVTXLUUHOVFKDWWHUHGDERXWLWWKHYHU\EUHH]H<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLVSHUHGRILW6HYHUDOWLPHVKHVWRSSHGDQGGUHZLQWKHIUHVK<<strong>br</strong> />
PRUQLQJDLULQJUHDWVQLIIVUHDGLQJDPHVVDJHZKLFKPDGHKLPOHDS<<strong>br</strong> />
RQZLWKJUHDWHUVSHHG+HZDVRSSUHVVHGZLWKDVHQVHRIFDODPLW\<<strong>br</strong> />
KDSSHQLQJLILWZHUHQRWFDODPLW\DOUHDG\KDSSHQHGDQGDVKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FURVVHGWKHODVWZDWHUVKHGDQGGURSSHGGRZQLQWRWKHYDOOH\WRZDUG<<strong>br</strong> />
FDPSKHSURFHHGHGZLWKJUHDWHUFDXWLRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KUHHPLOHVDZD\KHFDPHXSRQDIUHVKWUDLOWKDWVHQWKLVQHFN<<strong>br</strong> />
KDLUULSSOLQJDQGEULVWOLQJ,WOHGVWUDLJKWWRZDUGFDPSDQG-RKQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQ%XFNKXUULHGRQVZLIWO\DQGVWHDOWKLO\HYHU\QHUYH<<strong>br</strong> />
VWUDLQLQJDQGWHQVHDOHUWWRWKHPXOWLWXGLQRXVGHWDLOVZKLFKWROG<<strong>br</strong> />
DVWRU\DOOEXWWKHHQG+LVQRVHJDYHKLPDYDU\LQJGHVFULSWLRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
RIWKHSDVVDJHRIWKHOLIHRQWKHKHHOVRIZKLFKKHZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
WUDYHOOLQJ+HUHPDUNHGGLHSUHJQDQWVLOHQFHRIWKHIRUHVW7KH<<strong>br</strong> />
ELUGOLIHKDGIOLWWHG7KHVTXLUUHOVZHUHLQKLGLQJ2QHRQO\KH<<strong>br</strong> />
VDZDVOHHNJUD\IHOORZIODWWHQHGDJDLQVWDJUD\GHDGOLPEVR<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWKHVHHPHGDSDUWRILWDZRRG\H[FUHVFHQFHXSRQWKHZRRG<<strong>br</strong> />
LWVHOI<<strong>br</strong> />
$V%XFNVOLGDORQJZLWKWKHREVFXUHQHVVRIDJOLGLQJVKDGRZKLV<<strong>br</strong> />
QRVHZDVMHUNHGVXGGHQO\WRWKHVLGHDVWKRXJKDSRVLWLYHIRUFH<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGJULSSHGDQGSXOOHGLW+HIROORZHGWKHQHZVFHQWLQWRD<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLFNHWDQGIRXQG1LJ+HZDVO\LQJRQKLVVLGHGHDGZKHUHKH<<strong>br</strong> />
KDGGUDJJHGKLPVHOIDQDUURZSURWUXGLQJKHDGDQGIHDWKHUVIURP<<strong>br</strong> />
HLWKHUVLGHRIKLVERG\<<strong>br</strong> />
$KXQGUHG\DUGVIDUWKHURQ%XFNFDPHXSRQRQHRIWKHVOHGGRJV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQKDGERXJKWLQ'DZVRQ7KLVGRJZDVWKUDVKLQJDERXWLQD<<strong>br</strong> />
GHDWKVWUXJJOHGLUHFWO\RQWKHWUDLODQG%XFNSDVVHGDURXQGKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLWKRXWVWRSSLQJ)URPWKHFDPSFDPHWKHIDLQWVRXQGRIPDQ\<<strong>br</strong> />
YRLFHVULVLQJDQGIDOOLQJLQDVLQJVRQJFKDQW%HOO\LQJIRUZDUG<<strong>br</strong> />
WRWKHHGJHRIWKHFOHDULQJKHIRXQG+DQVO\LQJRQKLVIDFH<<strong>br</strong> />
71
IHDWKHUHGZLWKDUURZVOLNHDSRUFXSLQH$WWKHVDPHLQVWDQW%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
SHHUHGRXWZKHUHWKHVSUXFHERXJKORGJHKDGEHHQDQGVDZZKDWPDGH<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVKDLUOHDSVWUDLJKWXSRQKLVQHFNDQGVKRXOGHUV$JXVWRI<<strong>br</strong> />
RYHUSRZHULQJUDJHVZHSWRYHUKLP+HGLGQRWNQRZWKDWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
JURZOHGEXWKHJURZOHGDORXGZLWKDWHUULEOHIHURFLW\)RUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ODVWWLPHLQKLVOLIHKHDOORZHGSDVVLRQWRXVXUSFXQQLQJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
UHDVRQDQGLWZDVEHFDXVHRIKLVJUHDWORYHIRU-RKQ7KRUQWRQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKDWKHORVWKLVKHDG<<strong>br</strong> />
7KH
$OOGD\%XFNEURRGHGE\WKHSRRORUURDPHGUHVWOHVVO\DERXWWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
FDPS'HDWKDVDFHVVDWLRQRIPRYHPHQWDVDSDVVLQJRXWDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
DZD\IURPWKHOLYHVRIWKHOLYLQJKHNQHZDQGKHNQHZ-RKQ<<strong>br</strong> />
7KRUQWRQZDVGHDG,WOHIWDJUHDWYRLGLQKLPVRPHZKDWDNLQWR<<strong>br</strong> />
KXQJHUEXWDYRLGZKLFKDFKHGDQGDFKHGDQGZKLFKIRRGFRXOGQRW<<strong>br</strong> />
ILOO$WWLPHVZKHQKHSDXVHGWRFRQWHPSODWHWKHFDUFDVVHVRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
7KLVZDVVXIILFLHQWWRIOLQJWKHZKROHSDFNIRUZDUGSHOOPHOO<<strong>br</strong> />
FURZGHGWRJHWKHUEORFNHGDQGFRQIXVHGE\LWVHDJHUQHVVWRSXOO<<strong>br</strong> />
GRZQWKHSUH\%XFNVPDUYHOORXVTXLFNQHVVDQGDJLOLW\VWRRGKLP<<strong>br</strong> />
LQJRRGVWHDG3LYRWLQJRQKLVKLQGOHJVDQGVQDSSLQJDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
JDVKLQJKHZDVHYHU\ZKHUHDWRQFHSUHVHQWLQJDIURQWZKLFKZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
DSSDUHQWO\XQEURNHQVRVZLIWO\GLGKHZKLUODQGJXDUGIURPVLGHWR<<strong>br</strong> />
VLGH%XWWRSUHYHQWWKHPIURPJHWWLQJEHKLQGKLPKHZDVIRUFHG<<strong>br</strong> />
EDFNGRZQSDVWWKHSRRODQGLQWRWKHFUHHNEHGWLOOKHEURXJKW<<strong>br</strong> />
XSDJDLQVWDKLJKJUDYHOEDQN+HZRUNHGDORQJWRDULJKWDQJOH<<strong>br</strong> />
LQWKHEDQNZKLFKWKHPHQKDGPDGHLQWKHFRXUVHRIPLQLQJDQGLQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WKLVDQJOHKHFDPHWRED\SURWHFWHGRQWKUHHVLGHVDQGZLWK<<strong>br</strong> />
QRWKLQJWRGREXWIDFHWKHIURQW<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGVRZHOOGLGKHIDFHLWWKDWDWWKHHQGRIKDOIDQKRXUWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZROYHVGUHZEDFNGLVFRPILWHG7KHWRQJXHVRIDOOZHUHRXWDQG<<strong>br</strong> />
OROOLQJWKHZKLWHIDQJVVKRZLQJFUXHOO\ZKLWHLQWKHPRRQOLJKW<<strong>br</strong> />
6RPHZHUHO\LQJGRZQZLWKKHDGVUDLVHGDQGHDUVSULFNHGIRUZDUG<<strong>br</strong> />
RWKHUVVWRRGRQWKHLUIHHWZDWFKLQJKLPDQGVWLOORWKHUVZHUH<<strong>br</strong> />
ODSSLQJZDWHUIURPWKHSRRO2QHZROIORQJDQGOHDQDQGJUD\<<strong>br</strong> />
DGYDQFHGFDXWLRXVO\LQDIULHQGO\PDQQHUDQG%XFNUHFRJQL]HGWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLOGEURWKHUZLWKZKRPKHKDGUXQIRUDQLJKWDQGDGD\+HZDV<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKLQLQJVRIWO\DQGDV%XFNZKLQHGWKH\WRXFKHGQRVHV<<strong>br</strong> />
7KHQDQROGZROIJDXQWDQGEDWWOHVFDUUHGFDPHIRUZDUG%XFN<<strong>br</strong> />
ZULWKHGKLVOLSVLQWRWKHSUHOLPLQDU\RIDVQDUOEXWVQLIIHG<<strong>br</strong> />
QRVHVZLWKKLP:KHUHXSRQWKHROGZROIVDWGRZQSRLQWHGQRVHDW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHPRRQDQGEURNHRXWWKHORQJZROIKRZO7KHRWKHUVVDWGRZQ<<strong>br</strong> />
DQGKRZOHG$QGQRZWKHFDOOFDPHWR%XFNLQXQPLVWDNDEOH<<strong>br</strong> />
DFFHQWV+HWRRVDWGRZQDQGKRZOHG7KLVRYHUKHFDPHRXWRI<<strong>br</strong> />
KLVDQJOHDQGWKHSDFNFURZGHGDURXQGKLPVQLIILQJLQKDOI<<strong>br</strong> />
IULHQGO\KDOIVDYDJHPDQQHU7KHOHDGHUVOLIWHGWKH\HOSRIWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
SDFNDQGVSUDQJDZD\LQWRWKHZRRGV7KHZROYHVVZXQJLQEHKLQG<<strong>br</strong> />
\HOSLQJLQFKRUXV$QG%XFNUDQZLWKWKHPVLGHE\VLGHZLWKWKH<<strong>br</strong> />
ZLOGEURWKHU\HOSLQJDVKHUDQ<<strong>br</strong> />
<<strong>br</strong> />
$QGKHUHPD\ZHOOHQGWKHVWRU\RI%XFN7KH\HDUVZHUHQRWPDQ\<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKHQWKH
JUHDWHUWKDQWKH\VWHDOLQJIURPWKHLUFDPSVLQILHUFHZLQWHUV<<strong>br</strong> />
UREELQJWKHLUWUDSVVOD\LQJWKHLUGRJVDQGGHI\LQJWKHLUEUDYHVW<<strong>br</strong> />
KXQWHUV<<strong>br</strong> />
1D\WKHWDOHJURZVZRUVH+XQWHUVWKHUHDUHZKRIDLOWRUHWXUQ<<strong>br</strong> />
WRWKHFDPSDQGKXQWHUVWKHUHKDYHEHHQZKRPWKHLUWULEHVPHQ<<strong>br</strong> />
IRXQGZLWKWKURDWVVODVKHGFUXHOO\RSHQDQGZLWKZROISULQWVDERXW<<strong>br</strong> />
WKHPLQWKHVQRZJUHDWHUWKDQWKHSULQWVRIDQ\ZROI(DFKIDOO<<strong>br</strong> />
ZKHQWKH
Change language