25.03.2013 Views

GRBMP 2nd Newsletter_Final.pdf - GANGAPEDIA

GRBMP 2nd Newsletter_Final.pdf - GANGAPEDIA

GRBMP 2nd Newsletter_Final.pdf - GANGAPEDIA

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

From the Coordinator’s Desk<br />

Grbmpvaataa-<br />

GBP­IIT Bulletin<br />

A Quarterly <strong>Newsletter</strong> of the Consortia of 7 IITs for Communicating Various Aspects of<br />

Ganga River Basin Environment Management Plan<br />

GBP/IIT/QNL/5­6 November 4, 2011<br />

In an endeavor to prepare framework for developing Ganga River<br />

Basin Environment Management Plan (GRB EMP), the Consortia of<br />

7 IITs are engaged in wide ranging consultations with various<br />

stakeholders. The consensus appears to be that the plan should<br />

be consistent with the premise that river Ganga (i) is lively, holy<br />

and unique amongst all rivers of India, if not of the world; (ii) is to<br />

be viewed as World’s Natural Heritage*; and (iii) must flow<br />

uninterruptedly from her source to destination, and sustain all<br />

natural and indigenous living forms and systems.<br />

The overarching objective of the GRB EMP is the restoration of<br />

wholesomeness of rivers in the Ganga basin while ensuring<br />

appropriate management of water, sediments and energy (both<br />

demand and supply) to accommodate the pressures of increased<br />

population, urbanization, industrialization and agriculture.<br />

Restoring wholesomeness of rivers means ensuring the sanctity of<br />

the fundamental aspects of the river system as imbibed in the<br />

following “Panch Sutras”:<br />

1. Continuous flow (Aivarla Qaara),<br />

2. Un‐polluted flow (inama-la Qaara),<br />

3. Longitudinal, lateral and vertical connectivity of the river<br />

system,<br />

4. Adequate space for various river functions, and<br />

5. River as an ecological entity.<br />

With this background, following four broad objectives in context<br />

of the preparation of GRB EMP may be set:<br />

Environmental Flows to be maintained in all minor and<br />

major tributaries and main stem of the river Ganga.<br />

All anthropogenic activities must ensure maintenance of<br />

river bed and river water quality to suit ecological and<br />

socio‐cultural functions.<br />

Utilize excess water (available runoff from rainfall and<br />

snowmelt over and above environmental flows)<br />

judiciously, equitably and effectively for sustainable<br />

development.<br />

All human activities/interventions, whether existing,<br />

being implemented, and/or proposed in the Ganga<br />

Basin to be planned and modified appropriately in a<br />

* Seven of the Ten Criteria of the UNESCO’s<br />

Revised Operational Guidelines for the<br />

Implementation of the World Heritage Convention<br />

(2005) considered to be met by the river Ganga:<br />

1. to exhibit an important interchange of human<br />

values, over a span of time or within a cultural<br />

area of the world, on developments in<br />

architecture or technology, monumental arts,<br />

town‐planning or landscape design;<br />

2. to bear a unique or at least exceptional<br />

testimony to a cultural tradition or to a<br />

civilization which is living or which has<br />

disappeared;<br />

3. to be an outstanding example of a traditional<br />

human settlement, land‐use, or sea‐use which<br />

is representative of a culture (or cultures), or<br />

human interaction with the environment<br />

especially when it has become vulnerable<br />

under the impact of irreversible change;<br />

4. to contain superlative natural phenomena or<br />

areas of exceptional natural beauty and<br />

aesthetic importance;<br />

5. to be outstanding examples representing major<br />

stages of earth's history, including the record of<br />

life, significant on‐going geological processes in<br />

the development of landforms, or significant<br />

geomorphic or physiographic features;<br />

6. to be outstanding examples representing<br />

significant on‐going ecological and biological<br />

processes in the evolution and development of<br />

terrestrial, fresh water, coastal and marine<br />

ecosystems and communities of plants and<br />

animals;<br />

7. to contain the most important and significant<br />

natural habitats for in‐situ conservation of<br />

biological diversity, including those containing<br />

threatened species of outstanding universal<br />

value from the point of view of science or<br />

conservation.<br />

transparent manner i.e. undertake any activity/intervention only after achieving broad consensus (from<br />

conception through implementation and operation) amongst all stakeholders.


In orrder<br />

to achieeve<br />

the abovve<br />

mentionedd<br />

objectives, , following pr rinciples andd<br />

criteria mayy<br />

be adopted d:<br />

Apply modern scieence<br />

and neww<br />

technologiies<br />

but with traditional wwisdom<br />

(&aana Qaara + jana &aan na).<br />

Precauutionary<br />

Prinnciples<br />

must apply whereever<br />

knowled dge gaps andd<br />

uncertaintiies<br />

exist.<br />

Multi‐ ‐disciplinary inputs needded,<br />

but neeed<br />

to be ca autious abouut<br />

only “Expperts”<br />

and “Some “ Influeential<br />

Stakehholders”<br />

drivving<br />

the proccess.<br />

Processs<br />

should ideeally<br />

start frrom<br />

smaller watersheds and build up<br />

in a nested<br />

manner to o the higher sub‐<br />

basin level, and thhen<br />

to the baasin<br />

level.<br />

Keep fflexibility<br />

to cater to futuure<br />

needs and<br />

changing contexts. c<br />

Clearlyy<br />

articulate choices andd<br />

the trade‐off<br />

involved d – Environmental<br />

Flowws,<br />

Irrigation n, Hydro poower,<br />

Domestic,<br />

Commeercial<br />

and Industrial<br />

neeeds<br />

or in oth her words Ennvironmental,<br />

Social, Cultural,<br />

Econoomic,<br />

and Financial<br />

criteeria<br />

must be given appropriate<br />

weigh htages.<br />

Need to treat parrts/portions<br />

of basin with<br />

heavy inte erventions (hhighly<br />

altered/modified)<br />

differently from<br />

portioons<br />

with low interventionn<br />

intensity (nnear<br />

pristine) ).<br />

Avoidiing<br />

and eliminating<br />

polluution<br />

through<br />

all direct and a visible annthropogenicc<br />

activities (z zero tolerancce<br />

or<br />

concept<br />

of zero discharge).<br />

Considder<br />

surface and groundd<br />

water toggether;<br />

Explore<br />

all posssible<br />

meanss<br />

of storing g water keeeping<br />

continnuous<br />

flow, aand<br />

longitudinal,<br />

lateral aand<br />

vertical connectivity c of the riverss.<br />

Existinng<br />

water usees<br />

to be proteected<br />

but care<br />

taken that<br />

existing ineequities<br />

are nnot<br />

perpetua ated.<br />

Creating<br />

broad puublic<br />

acceptance<br />

of the pplan<br />

(local bo odies, state aassemblies<br />

and<br />

parliament<br />

to debatee<br />

and<br />

approve).<br />

Creation<br />

of structuures<br />

to monitor<br />

and regulate<br />

the im mplementatioon<br />

(nested governance;<br />

central c and sstate<br />

governnment<br />

to serve<br />

as mentoor<br />

and local communitie es assigned rroles,<br />

responnsibilities<br />

and d rights on wwater<br />

considdering<br />

comprromises<br />

by/nneeds<br />

of upsstream/downstream<br />

commmunities.<br />

A river basin may be viewwed<br />

and mo odeled as a ttree<br />

(e.g. Baanyan<br />

Trree<br />

as showwn<br />

in the addjacent<br />

pictu ure) having numerous leeaves<br />

(reepresenting<br />

numerous watersheds) ) and many small and large<br />

brranches<br />

(representing<br />

small st treams/minoor<br />

and mmajor<br />

tributaries).<br />

Itt<br />

is important<br />

to realize that t health oof<br />

each and eevery<br />

watershed<br />

is paramountt<br />

to the ma aintenance oof<br />

the healtth<br />

of<br />

streams/<br />

tribuutaries,<br />

as aalso<br />

the health<br />

of the mmain<br />

stem oof<br />

the<br />

rivver<br />

in the bbasin.<br />

Hencee<br />

a bottom‐up<br />

approacch<br />

of conseerving<br />

watersheds,<br />

sstreams<br />

andd<br />

tributaries, , and wetlands<br />

to the main<br />

stem<br />

of the rivver<br />

is essential.<br />

While<br />

in terms oof<br />

actions ceertain<br />

issues (e.g. pollution),<br />

stretche es (e.g. mostt<br />

polluted sttretches),<br />

are eas or parts (e.g.<br />

mosst<br />

sensitive and<br />

fragile Gaangotri<br />

Valleey<br />

or some wwetlands)<br />

ma ay be addresssed<br />

on priorrity<br />

dependin ng upon urgeency,<br />

availability<br />

of reesources<br />

(e.gg.<br />

data and information)<br />

and time required r to ccomplete,<br />

annd<br />

integrate e upwards too<br />

the<br />

basin<br />

level (parts<br />

to the whole<br />

conceppt),<br />

the thouught<br />

process s has to be the other wway,<br />

i.e. who ole to the pparts.<br />

Simiilarly,<br />

GRB EMMP<br />

should bbe<br />

prepared based on souund<br />

scientific<br />

principles aand<br />

with appplication<br />

of modern/stat<br />

m te‐of‐<br />

the‐ ‐art tools, tecchniques<br />

andd<br />

methods bbut<br />

with tradditional<br />

know wledge and bbeliefs<br />

(e.g. ssubtle<br />

quality y of Ganga wwater<br />

as expressed<br />

thrrough<br />

followwing<br />

“Shloka” ” may also haave<br />

to be giv ven due conssideration).<br />

Asyaaa<br />

jalsya gauNaaa<br />

: SaItatvama\, ssvaadutvama,<br />

sva vaCtvama, Atyanntar}cyatvama\<br />

, paqtatvama\,<br />

paavanatvama\ ma\, paapahairtvamma\,<br />

taRYNaamaaohQQvaMsatvama\,<br />

dIp panatvama\, pa`&aaQQaairtvaMca,<br />

[it ita rajainaV-NaT T :<br />

TThe<br />

qualities oof<br />

the Ganga wwater<br />

are: Cooolness,<br />

sweetnness,<br />

transpar rency, high tonic<br />

property, wholesomene ess, potability, , ability<br />

to remove evils, ability tto<br />

resuscitate ffrom<br />

swoon ccaused<br />

by deh hydration, digeestive<br />

propertty<br />

and ability to t retain wisddom<br />

The use of tradittional<br />

knowledge/beliefss<br />

and precauutionary<br />

principle<br />

thus may<br />

imply thaat<br />

due consid deration be ggiven<br />

to thhe<br />

subtle quuality<br />

of Gannga<br />

water annd<br />

scientific efforts shou uld continuee<br />

to further uunderstanding<br />

on traditional<br />

knowwledge<br />

and bbeliefs.<br />

The policy frameework<br />

propoosed<br />

as abovve<br />

for preparring<br />

GRB EMP<br />

needs to bbe<br />

discussed at several fo orums by various<br />

stakkeholders.<br />

Feeedback,<br />

suggestions<br />

andd<br />

comments will be highl ly appreciateed.<br />

Vinod<br />

Tare, Profe fessor, IIT Kaanpur


Uppdates<br />

<strong>GRBMP</strong>P<br />

is now GRRB<br />

EMP: On the advice oof<br />

Shri Jairam m Ramesh, tthe<br />

then Minister<br />

of Sta ate (Indepenndent<br />

Charge)<br />

of the MoEF,<br />

the Gangga<br />

River Bassin<br />

Managem ment Plan (G<strong>GRBMP</strong>)<br />

has been referr red as the Ganga<br />

River Basin<br />

Environnment<br />

Managgement<br />

Plann<br />

(GRB EMP) since July 7, 2011.<br />

Geo‐sppatial<br />

Databaase<br />

Managemment<br />

(GDM) , one of the thematic grroups<br />

of GRBB<br />

EMP has re ecently launched<br />

its ownn<br />

website (wwww.gangalaaya.in;<br />

can aalso<br />

be acce essed througgh<br />

www.ganngapedia.in)<br />

to provide data<br />

storagee,<br />

retrieval, visualization<br />

and searcch<br />

capabilities<br />

along wwith<br />

relevant<br />

interfaces s for simulaation,<br />

predicttion<br />

and anaalysis<br />

of dataa<br />

for use of all thematic c groups andd<br />

policy makkers<br />

associated<br />

with the GRB<br />

EMP.<br />

Thhematic<br />

GGroup<br />

Actiivities<br />

Enviironmental<br />

QQuality<br />

and Pollution (EQQP):<br />

The EQP Groupp<br />

is involved<br />

in collectting<br />

and analyzing<br />

som me primary and mostly secondary data relateed<br />

to<br />

population,<br />

watter<br />

supply, sewage generation,<br />

coollection<br />

and<br />

treatment,<br />

status annd<br />

performa ance of sewwage<br />

treatment<br />

plantts<br />

(STPs) in the<br />

class I annd<br />

II cities/toowns<br />

in the entire Gangga<br />

River Basin<br />

for estima ation of polluution<br />

loadd<br />

in the Gangga<br />

River and its tributariees<br />

due to doomestic<br />

activ vities (point ssources).<br />

Datta<br />

generated d from this ggroup<br />

will form an impportant<br />

commponent<br />

in preparation<br />

oof<br />

GRB EMP. . In view of the uneven rainfall distr ribution over<br />

the<br />

yearrs<br />

and variattion<br />

in dischharge<br />

in rivers<br />

of the Gaanga<br />

Basin, limitations l oof<br />

managing STPs and ET TPs in India, , and<br />

increeasing<br />

gap bbetween<br />

estimated<br />

finanncial<br />

outlay and funds available, a thee<br />

group is wworking<br />

passionately<br />

towwards<br />

prommoting<br />

Zero Liquid Dischharge<br />

(i.e. reecycling<br />

and reuse of tre eated wastewwater)<br />

and mmanagement<br />

t regime throough<br />

public‐private<br />

partnership<br />

( PPP) in dommestic<br />

as welll<br />

as industri ial sectors inn<br />

the entire Ganga River r Basin. The EQP<br />

grouup<br />

has so farr<br />

prepared foollowing<br />

repoorts:<br />

Guidelines<br />

for the PPreparation<br />

of Urban Rivver<br />

Managem ment Plan (URMP)<br />

for all Class I Town ns in Ganga RRiver<br />

Basin<br />

Sewagee<br />

Treatment in Class I Towns:<br />

Recommmendations<br />

s and Guidellines<br />

Guideliines<br />

for Impllementation<br />

of Sewage Collection, Diversion, PPumping,<br />

Treeatment,<br />

and d Reuse (Sewwage<br />

CDPTR) ) Infrastructuure<br />

in Class I Towns<br />

Wastewwater<br />

Reuse Projects Woorldwide:<br />

Coollation<br />

of Selected<br />

Internnational<br />

Casee<br />

Studies and d Experiencees<br />

Emerging<br />

Contaminnants<br />

in Ganga<br />

River Basin<br />

with Speci ial Emphasiss<br />

on Pesticidees<br />

The group plans to prepare ffollowing<br />

repports<br />

by the end of Dece ember 2011:<br />

Water QQuality<br />

in thee<br />

Ganga Riveer<br />

– A Case foor<br />

Adopting Tertiary Treaatment<br />

Pollutioon<br />

Load in thhe<br />

Ganga Rivver<br />

and Her Tributaries due to Dommestic<br />

Activities<br />

in Class I and II Towns<br />

in<br />

Uttar Prradesh<br />

Purn nendu Bose, , Group Leadder<br />

and Prof fessor, IIT Kaanpur<br />

Watter<br />

Resourcees<br />

Managemment<br />

(WRM):<br />

The WRM groupp<br />

has decided<br />

to use hyddrological,<br />

hyydraulic<br />

and groundwateer<br />

models foor<br />

the study. The SWAT, HEC‐<br />

RAS and MODFLLOW<br />

modelss<br />

have been selected in the respect tive categoriies.<br />

The maiin<br />

reason for<br />

selecting tthese<br />

moddels<br />

is that these are pproven<br />

moddels<br />

in theirr<br />

categories and are avvailable<br />

in ppublic<br />

doma ain. A reporrt<br />

on<br />

methodology<br />

addopted<br />

has been prepared<br />

and being<br />

circulated.<br />

The statuus<br />

of the acctivities<br />

of WRM W group is as<br />

folloows:


Hydroloogical<br />

and hydraulic daata<br />

issues aare<br />

causing delay in pprogress<br />

for hydrologica al and hydrraulic<br />

modeling.<br />

Respectiive<br />

groups in<br />

all IITs aree<br />

eagerly wa aiting for the<br />

data to become<br />

avail lable so thatt<br />

the<br />

modeling<br />

work can be completeed.<br />

As far aas<br />

the groundwater<br />

moddeling<br />

work is<br />

concerned,<br />

model set up for Chammbal<br />

river bas sin, a tributaary<br />

of<br />

Yamuna<br />

river basinn<br />

has been taken up too<br />

start with. The information<br />

and innput<br />

data su uch as horizoontal<br />

hydraulic<br />

conductivvity,<br />

conducctance<br />

of rivver<br />

bed, aqu uifer parameeters<br />

(thickness,<br />

bottom elevation, eetc.),<br />

well draaft<br />

based onn<br />

block wise iinformation<br />

are being ac cquired and pput<br />

in place.<br />

The DEEM<br />

of SRTM (90m resoluution)<br />

is beinng<br />

used to generate g cross<br />

sections oof<br />

streams in n the absencce<br />

of<br />

actual ccross<br />

sectionns<br />

that are being<br />

obtaineed<br />

through th he primary survey.<br />

Thesee<br />

data are be eing used to start<br />

gettingg<br />

the first cuut<br />

results thhat<br />

will be uupdated<br />

with h the more refined data<br />

once mad de available. The<br />

hydraulic<br />

modelingg<br />

also requirees<br />

detailed gauge<br />

dischar rge data thatt<br />

is still awaitted.<br />

Ashvin<br />

K Gosaiin,<br />

Group Leeader<br />

and Pr rofessor, IIT DDelhi<br />

Fluvvial<br />

Geomorpphology<br />

(FGMM):<br />

The FGM Group is involved in mapping aand<br />

characteerizing<br />

the Ganga G River aand<br />

her majoor<br />

tributaries s for geomorphic<br />

asseessment<br />

of river<br />

conditioon.<br />

Data gennerated<br />

fromm<br />

this group will form ann<br />

important ccomponent<br />

in developinng<br />

an<br />

ecossystem‐based<br />

managemment<br />

of the Ganga River.<br />

Till now, the group hhas<br />

prepareed<br />

two reports<br />

titled, AActive<br />

Flooodplain<br />

Mappping‐<br />

defining<br />

the ‘river sspace’<br />

and DDelineation<br />

of f Valley Marrgin<br />

and Geomorphic<br />

Mapping<br />

of Chaannel<br />

Belt and Active Floodplain oof<br />

the Gangaa<br />

River. Twoo<br />

group mee etings cum wworkshops<br />

wwere<br />

held recently<br />

to finnalize<br />

geommorphic<br />

chaaracterizationn<br />

of the Gannga<br />

River annd<br />

to define e templates for the majoor<br />

attributes s of River Sttyles.<br />

Thesse<br />

templatess<br />

along with the River Styyle<br />

differenttiation<br />

will fu urther be useed<br />

to assess the geomorphic<br />

conditioon<br />

of<br />

the Ganga River.<br />

Following tthe<br />

main stem,<br />

the geommorphic<br />

map pping of majoor<br />

tributariess<br />

is also near r completionn<br />

and<br />

the group is finaalizing<br />

the river<br />

style fraamework<br />

forr<br />

the tributar ries as well. The group is<br />

also involv ved in compuuting<br />

stream<br />

power ddistribution<br />

inn<br />

the Gangaa<br />

basin. This will help to better undeerstand<br />

the rriver<br />

dynami ics and sedimment<br />

depoosition<br />

in thee<br />

whole basiin.<br />

FFGM<br />

group me<br />

(22 nd eeting at ISI, K<br />

– 233<br />

rd Kolkata<br />

August, 20111)<br />

A visitt<br />

to the Check<br />

during the FG<br />

(12 th – 14 t<br />

k Dam site in JJNU<br />

Campus<br />

GM group meeeting<br />

th<br />

October, 20111)<br />

FGM group<br />

(12 th meeting at JN<br />

– 14 th NU, New Delhi i<br />

Octoberr,<br />

2011)<br />

FGM M group members<br />

at field ssite<br />

for river su urvey<br />

Rajiv Sinha, , Group Leadder<br />

and Profe fessor, IIT Kaanpur


Ecology and Biodiversity (ENB):<br />

A one day workshop was held on August 6, 2011 at IIT, Kanpur. Presentations were made on “Floral and Faunal<br />

Diversity of Upper Ganga Segment, Middle Ganga Segment and Lower Ganga Segment”. A preliminary note on Fish<br />

and Fisheries was also circulated. A brief presentation on “ Higher vertebrates in Ganga river was made by WWF,<br />

New Delhi and Microbial Diversity in Ganga river by IIT K and IIT R. Workshop recommendations are given elsewhere<br />

in this newsletter.<br />

A meeting of team members of IITK and IITR was held to review the progress of primary data collection on Microbial<br />

Diversity and suggest measures for future sampling and differentiation at IITK on September 3, 2011. To review the<br />

progress of ENB and EQP group a meeting was held on October 8, 2011 at IITR. It was decided that in addition to<br />

work at hand the following will also be done by IITR: Collation of information on Macro invertebrates in Ganga River<br />

and Riparian vegetation in Ganga River basin. The group has prepared following two reports so far:<br />

Floral and Faunal Diversity of Upper Ganga<br />

Floral and Faunal Diversity of Middle Ganga<br />

The tentative titles of the reports under preparation are as follows:<br />

Floral and Faunal Diversity of Lower Ganga (Part I and II) Varanasi to Farakka and Farakka to Ganga Sagar<br />

Higher Vertebrates in Ganga River<br />

Preliminary report on Microbial Diversity in Ganga River.<br />

R P Mathur, Group Leader and Advisor, GRB EMP Project, IIT Kanpur<br />

Socio‐Economic and Socio‐Cultural (SEC):<br />

The SEC group in the first phase concentrated on collating information related to agriculture and livelihood in the<br />

Ganga Basin and has prepared following reports:<br />

Trends in Agriculture and Agriculture Practices in Ganga Basin: An Overview<br />

Trends in Agriculture and Agriculture Practices in Upper Ganga Basin (Uttarakhand )<br />

Trends in Agriculture and Agriculture Practices in Middle Ganga Basin (Uttar Pradesh)<br />

Trends in Agriculture and Agriculture Practices in Lower Ganga Basin (Bihar)<br />

Trends in Agriculture and Agriculture Practices in Lower Ganga Basin (West Bengal)<br />

Livelihood Aspects of the Ganga River Basin<br />

The group organized a workshop at IIT Delhi during June 13‐14, 2011 to deliberate on preparation of next set of<br />

reports, develop methodology and contents, and identify the data sources for the reports. The group is now involved<br />

in (i) preparing status reports on urbanization and industrialization, (ii) demographic and socio‐economic analysis,<br />

(iii) mapping of cultural and religious activities, and (iv) developing methodology for water accounting.<br />

S P Singh, Group Leader and Professor, IIT Roorkee<br />

Policy, Law and Governance (PLG):<br />

The problems in the Ganga River Basin is the result of a diverse set of complex and interlinked factors, from the<br />

interaction and intervention of technological, socio‐cultural, political, and institutional factors. As a background, a<br />

detailed analysis of the earlier efforts to improve the river water quality through the GAP I and II was undertaken.<br />

One of the reports prepared along with EQP group presents an analysis of the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities<br />

and threats (SWOT) of the GAP and consolidates the available knowledge and insights in order to understand<br />

nuances and complexity involved in design, implementation, monitoring and regulation aspects of the GAP. The PLG<br />

group started working on two issues related to the major objectives (Aivarla Qaara and inama-la Qaara ) of GRB EMP: urban<br />

sanitation issues in Uttar Pradesh and environmental clearance of large dams in Uttarakhand.<br />

Studies on Urban Sanitation: Two reports pertaining to urban sanitation issues have been prepared. The first one<br />

provides a conceptual framework for the studies of PLG group. It attempts to articulate a systematic,<br />

comprehensive, conceptually sound, and internally consistent perspective—and an analytical framework based on<br />

it—that is focused on issues of policies and governance. A conceptual schema—called as the ‘Governance Grid’—a<br />

comprehensive and conceptually coherent schema of the actual process of governance as it generally unfolds in<br />

reality is presented. The schema begins with the ground‐level problems in any sector and helps identify the core<br />

governance maladies of different types in the sector. To address these maladies, appropriate changes in—or<br />

creation of new—policy instruments and/ or governing agencies is then suggested. The major argument is that core<br />

governance maladies cannot be cured by technical, financial, or managerial ‘fixes’. It also makes a note that all


governance problems cannot be addressed using the policy and institutional ‘fixes’ either, as they cannot resolve<br />

such problems rooted in the ‘political bottom‐line’. In other words, the problems rooted in the adverse balance of<br />

political‐economic powers acting against the goals set for the governance of the sector can be resolved only through<br />

political action by the sections of society supporting the goals set for governance. Based on this, a related report<br />

presents an analysis of the ground‐level situation of the sewage conveyance and treatment systems in the Kanpur<br />

city in the state of Uttar Pradesh. The objective is to bring out important policy and governance related lacunas in<br />

the sector, causing continued release of partially treated or untreated sewage and faecal‐matter in the river Ganga.<br />

This report broadly follows the template presented in the first report of the group and provides background<br />

information on Kanpur with the focus on the activities of the Ganga Action Plan (Phase I and II) in the city. The<br />

findings focus on different deficiencies in the performance of the sewage system in the city of Kanpur. Further, it<br />

presents the review and analysis of various major Policy Instruments (PIs), the in‐depth analysis of the lacunas in the<br />

Governing Agencies (GAs) and provides a set of recommendations with a three‐pronged strategy.<br />

Studies on Environmental Clearance of Hydro Power Projects: Hydropower development as an activity, involves<br />

many stakeholders ranging from the state to the people and from commercial developers to the environmentalists,<br />

and their differential and often contradictory perspectives and interests. Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and<br />

Environmental Clearance (EC) for the government is a management tool that can show a pathway to achieve<br />

developmental goals without compromising environmental protection objective; for developers it is an essential<br />

procedural requirement to initiate project activities and for environmental activists and project affected people the<br />

only way to safeguard their interests. The first report pertaining to this aspect has systematically mapped the<br />

institutional structure for environmental governance in India and especially highlights the critical perspectives from<br />

the civil society angle. It has brought out the misalignment of goals and expectations from the EIA‐EC process that<br />

leads to violations of policies, bringing out the limitations of the existing institutional frameworks, procedures and<br />

implementation. The second report analyzes one important step in EC ‐the Public Hearing and Consultation (PC)<br />

process‐ which is mandatory for hydropower projects to ensure transparency, accountability and participation. It is<br />

an important vehicle in democratic environmental decision making by developing an arena where the views and<br />

suggestions of public are incorporated. Eight case studies of projects sampled for both the main tributaries of River<br />

Ganga (Bhagirathi and Alaknanda) were undertaken to understand the issues that illustrated the lacunas in the<br />

present PC process. Both reports provide a set of recommendations meant to be widely debated by all stakeholders<br />

to arrive at consensus solutions to this major issue threatening Aivarla Qaara of the river.<br />

Studies on Legal Aspects: The reports dealing with legal aspects analyze the legislations at the central and state<br />

levels, with specific reference to the portion of the state of West Bengal in Ganga River Basin. It is noted that these<br />

legislations have been enacted with different objectives and at different times, and have created provisions<br />

regarding the prevention and conservation of river resources. The processes like irrigation, preservation and<br />

distribution of the waters, issues of sanitation, water pollution, etc. have been addressed under these acts. All<br />

relevant acts, notifications, have been described and briefly discussed providing a preliminary analysis.<br />

N C Narayanan, Group Leader and Associate Professor, IIT Bombay<br />

Geo‐spatial Database Management (GDM):<br />

Under the Ganga River Basin Environment Management Plan (GRB EMP), different thematic groups have been<br />

identified that work together for achieving the goals of the project. A key component that binds all the groups<br />

together is the Geo‐spatial Database Management (GDM) group. This group is responsible for handling the data<br />

needs of all the other groups, and is therefore, central to the entire project. The main task of the group is to set up a<br />

data repository that stores and manages all information produced and used by scientists and researchers linked with<br />

the project. A geo‐spatial database server running at the backend provides much of the capabilities including data<br />

upload/download facilities, security, access control rights, querying and visualization. A GIS frontend has been<br />

created that allows different map layers to be overlaid, visualized, and downloaded. A new portal,<br />

http://www.gangalaya.in/, has been registered that serves as the entry point to the database. Facilities have also<br />

been put in place for common users to browse and download certain data.<br />

Harish Karnick, Group Leader and Professor, IIT Kanpur


Communication (COM):<br />

To achieve the goal of communication, mass awareness and information dissemination amongst the people, a<br />

websites namely, Gangapedia was launched. The English version of Gangapedia (GP) website<br />

(http://www.gangapedia.in) was first launched in July 2010, as the common public platform for public at large to<br />

interact, express, share and discuss their views and opinions.<br />

Though the quantum of data on the river system is voluminous, there are numerous lacunae in the information that<br />

still needs to be plugged. The repository of data and information should be such which is easily accessible and<br />

understandable by anyone. The group has come up with Cmaps which are pictorial representations easy to<br />

comprehend at a quick glance by anyone. The immense amount of data generated by many institutions and<br />

organizations is being visualized in the form of these knowledge based models. They form a very powerful<br />

visualization tool when it comes to comparing and understanding various aspects of the Ganga basin at a quick<br />

glance.<br />

For the community not so well versed with the English language, the need to have a Hindi version of the GP website<br />

was felt. The communication group has been able to co‐create contents in Hindi on the ‘read and write’ GP website.<br />

It is hoped that the numerous organizations involved in different aspects of Ganga river studies will also be assisted<br />

by such efforts.<br />

T V Prabhakar, Group Leader and Professor, IIT Kanpur<br />

Environmental Flows (EFL):<br />

The Environmental Flows or E‐Flows group has prepared state‐of‐the‐art report on E‐Flows in reference to the rivers<br />

of the Ganga Basin. After considerable debate within and outside the group following definition for E‐flows has been<br />

adopted. The group has decided to use Building Block Methodology (BBM), as this was successfully piloted through<br />

the Living Ganga Programme of WWF‐India in which many Faculty members from different IITs participated. The<br />

group has benefitted from the experiences and learning of that exercise.<br />

"Environmental Flows are a regime of flow in a river or stream that describes the temporal and spatial<br />

variation in quantity and quality of water required for freshwater as well as estuarine systems to perform<br />

their natural ecological functions (including sediment transport) and support the spiritual, cultural and<br />

livelihood activities that depend on these ecosystems"<br />

After several rounds of discussions with SEC, ENB, FGM and WRM groups, about three sites downstream of each of<br />

the important river confluences on Alaknanda/Mandakini (namely Vishnu Prayag, Karn Prayag, and Rudra Prayag), 16<br />

sites from Gangotri to Farraka, and three sites on river Hugli have been identified for E‐Flows assessment. The IIT<br />

team has also taken up the survey work to get reliable data on cross‐sections at each of these sites. Although the<br />

socio‐cultural surveys and field visits are about to begin, the group is awaiting the hydrology data for the river Ganga<br />

from the Government of India. It is essential to have long‐term (at least for continuous 30 years) flow data for a river<br />

system for assessment of E‐Flows.<br />

First Set of Reports<br />

Nitin Kaushal, Convener and Senior Manager‐Water Resources at WWF India<br />

001_GBP_IIT_GEN_DAT_01_Ver 1_Dec 2010: River Ganga at a Glance: Identification of Issues and Priority Actions<br />

for Restoration<br />

002_GBP_IIT_EQP_S&R_01_Ver 1_Dec 2010: Guidelines for the Preparation of Urban River Management Plan<br />

(URMP) for all Class I Towns in Ganga River Basin<br />

003_GBP_IIT_EQP_S&R_02_Ver 1_Dec 2010: Sewage Treatment in Class I Towns: Recommendations and<br />

Guidelines<br />

004_GBP_IIT_EQP_S&R_03_Ver 1_Dec 2010: Guidelines for Implementation of Sewage Collection, Diversion,<br />

Pumping, Treatment, and Reuse (Sewage CDPTR) Infrastructure in Class I Towns<br />

005_GBP_IIT_FGM_DAT_01_Ver 1_Dec 2010: Active Floodplain Mapping: Defining the “River Space”


Highlights of Some of the Second Set of Draft Reports<br />

Strength, Weakness, Opportunity and Threat (SWOT) Analysis of Ganga Action Plan<br />

The major strengths of GAP include strategizing of interception and diversion of nalas, creation of<br />

institutional structure, basis for future tariff policies design and funding responsibilities of the ULBs and the<br />

state governments with respect to Ganga, peer review and monitoring of GAP through various stakeholders,<br />

appointment of independent agencies for water quality monitoring, improvements in river water quality,<br />

creation of knowledge base and awareness building.<br />

The major weakness of GAP remains in limited scope of issues addressed neglecting non‐point sources of<br />

pollution, fixing of inadequate water quality standards blindly following the western countries, improper<br />

collection of sewage, over‐designed STPs, influence of aid on inappropriate sewage treatment technology<br />

like UASB, irregular maintenance by ULBs, unclear and unviable financial models and improper management<br />

of industrial wastes.<br />

The opportunities of GAP lie on learning experience of sewage treatment technology for employing new<br />

technology, adoption of river basin approach, Govt.’s commitment to raise adequate funds and awareness<br />

and inclination of civil society contribution.<br />

The threats and challenges of GAP include divergence of River Action Plans (RAPs) with broader<br />

development policies, influence of bilateral and multilateral funding on policy matters, wastage of funds and<br />

challenges in experimenting with regulatory authorities.<br />

Wastewater Reuse Projects Worldwide: Collation of Selected International Case Studies and Experiences<br />

Inclusions of highly treated wastewater reuse alternatives in demand driven river basin management plan<br />

like GRB EMP<br />

In context of integrated urban water management, promotion of zero discharge municipality/city adopting<br />

reuse of tertiary‐treated wastewater in the Ganga Basin<br />

Groundwater recharge through seasonal storage in surface reservoirs and irrigation with highly reclaimed<br />

water in the Ganga Basin<br />

Awareness on potential benefits and research on plausible health impacts of wastewater reuse<br />

Floral and Faunal Diversity in Upper Ganga Segment: Gangotri – Haridwar (Upstream Bhimgoda Barrage)<br />

The differences in aquatic biodiversity, both floral and faunal (viz. phytoplankton, periphyton, zoobenthos,<br />

zooplanktons and consumers including fish population) in three different stretches, namely Gangotri to<br />

Gangani, Gangani to Devprayag, and Devprayag to Haridwar of the Upper Ganga segment are being<br />

characterized.<br />

Delineation of Valley Margin and Geomorphic Mapping of Channel Belt and Active Floodplain of the Ganga River<br />

Significant diversity in terms of valley width and geomorphic features in different reaches of the Ganga river<br />

provide important input for E‐Flows assessment in relation to hydrological regime.<br />

Stretches with wide valleys and active floodplains are potential sites for creating artificial recharge.<br />

Channel‐belt and floodplain features provide valuable insights to the possible habitats for aquatic and land<br />

biota.<br />

Mapping of Policy Instruments and Governance Agencies for Environmental Clearance of Hydropower Projects in<br />

Upper Ganga Segment<br />

Mandatory pre‐environmental clearance for mini and small scale hydropower projects based on EIA studies<br />

conducted by the independent and competent technical authority and financed by MoEF‐recognized<br />

consortium of developers.<br />

Transparent and accountable decision making process through public proceedings of various stakeholders on<br />

the EIA study findings.<br />

Assessment of Public Consultation Process for Environmental Clearance of Hydropower Projects in Upper Ganga<br />

Segment<br />

Restructure Public Consultation process with more public participation and strengthen EC process in<br />

environmental decision making for expediting the project clearance and implementation, avoiding financial<br />

losses due to public protests and making the process more transparent and accountable.<br />

Environmental Flows: State‐of‐the‐Art with Special Reference to Rivers in the Ganga River Basin<br />

E‐flows assessment is critical in the context of integrated river basin approach such as GRB EMP.<br />

The Building Block Methodology (BBM), a flexible and robust method, is highly suitable for E‐Flows<br />

assessment for rivers like the Ganga having diverse socio‐cultural and livelihood aspects.


Livelihood<br />

Aspects<br />

of the Gaanga<br />

River BBasin:<br />

Overviiew<br />

and Map pping of Touurism<br />

on Main<br />

Stem of River R Ganga<br />

Status oof<br />

the livelihoods<br />

in the whole Gangga<br />

river basin n and tourissm‐related<br />

livvelihoods<br />

es specially in tthree<br />

states, vviz.<br />

Uttara Khhand,<br />

Uttar PPradesh<br />

and Bihar in the basin are annalyzed.<br />

Emeerging<br />

Contaminants<br />

in GGanga<br />

River Basin with SSpecial<br />

Emph hasis on Pesticides<br />

The preesence<br />

of emerging<br />

contaminants<br />

especially pesticides p (DDDT<br />

and HCCH<br />

mainly) level in various<br />

environmmental<br />

mediia<br />

and fish tisssues<br />

in the Ganga river basin are revviewed.<br />

Constannt<br />

monitoringg<br />

and analyssis<br />

of widelyy<br />

used pestic cides in various<br />

environmental<br />

med dia suggestedd<br />

for<br />

comprehhensive<br />

risk assessment.<br />

An OOverview<br />

of Trends in Aggriculture<br />

annd<br />

Agriculture<br />

Practices<br />

Increaseed<br />

crop outpput<br />

during laast<br />

four deccades<br />

with intensive<br />

culltivation<br />

andd<br />

crop diversification<br />

duue<br />

to<br />

improveed<br />

irrigation ffacilities.<br />

Decline in agriculturral<br />

area due tto<br />

growing inndustrialization<br />

and urbaanization.<br />

Increasee<br />

in use of fertilizers<br />

and modern agricultural<br />

equ uipments.<br />

The status of agriculture (i.e. land‐use,<br />

cropping<br />

pattern, irrigation sttatus,<br />

use oof<br />

fertilizers s, practices and<br />

prodductivity)<br />

annd<br />

its impliccations<br />

withh<br />

specific reeference<br />

to the portionn<br />

of the Gaanga<br />

Basin in states off<br />

the<br />

Uttaarakhand,<br />

Utttar<br />

Pradesh, , Bihar and WWest<br />

Bengal for preparat tion of GRB EEMP<br />

has beeen<br />

presented d in four sepaarate<br />

repoorts.<br />

Pulpp<br />

and Paper Industries inn<br />

Ganga Basiin:<br />

Achievingg<br />

Zero Liquid d Discharge<br />

Shifting towards zerro<br />

liquid disccharge<br />

paraddigm<br />

(i.e. rec cycling and reuse of treated<br />

wastew water) emplooying<br />

tertiary treatment ffollowed<br />

by RO technology<br />

and ad dopting Design,<br />

Build, Finance<br />

and Operate (DBFO)<br />

model hhave<br />

been reecommended<br />

for pulp and<br />

paper industries<br />

in tthe<br />

Ganga River<br />

Basin to o save riverss<br />

and<br />

help maintain<br />

“Aivarrla<br />

Qaara and innama-la<br />

Qaara”.<br />

Mappping<br />

of Releevant<br />

Legislaations<br />

Appliccable<br />

to the West Benga al Portion of the Ganga RRiver<br />

Basin<br />

In orderr<br />

to conservee<br />

river resourrces,<br />

the legislations<br />

at the<br />

central and<br />

state leveels,<br />

with specific<br />

reference<br />

to<br />

the porttion<br />

of the sstate<br />

of the West Bengaal<br />

in the Gan nga River Baasin<br />

(GRB) foor<br />

various in nfrastructuree<br />

and<br />

processees<br />

like irrigattion,<br />

preservvation<br />

and diistribution<br />

of<br />

the water, issues of sannitation,<br />

wat ter pollution, , etc.<br />

have been<br />

reviewedd.<br />

Major<br />

Eventts<br />

Meetingg<br />

of the Prooject<br />

Manageement<br />

Board<br />

(PMB): Fir rst PMB meeeting<br />

was heeld<br />

on July 7, 7 2011 at BBoard<br />

Room, IIT<br />

Delhi. Proofessor<br />

Devaang<br />

Khakhar, , Chairman, PMB and Director,<br />

IIT BBombay<br />

chair red the meeeting.<br />

All the three experrt<br />

members, , Swami Aviimukteshwaranand<br />

Saraaswati,<br />

Dr BBharat<br />

Jhunjhunwala<br />

and<br />

Dr<br />

Madhavv<br />

A Chitale wwere<br />

present apart from representatives<br />

of Minisstry<br />

of Enviroonment<br />

and Forests, Minnistry<br />

of Wateer<br />

Resources,<br />

Directors oof<br />

IITs and Professor<br />

Vin nod Tare, Coordinator,<br />

TTeam<br />

GRB EM MP. All memmbers<br />

were of the opinionn<br />

that it is unnrealistic<br />

to address all issues<br />

withinn<br />

the stipulatted<br />

time of 18 months ggiven<br />

the consstraint<br />

of avaailability<br />

of ddata/informaation<br />

and the e variety of iissues<br />

that nneed<br />

to be co onsidered. Itt<br />

was<br />

decided that IITs willl<br />

continue thhe<br />

project foor<br />

much long ger time requuesting<br />

suppport<br />

from MH HRD, if the MMoEF<br />

has constraints<br />

in pproviding<br />

addditional<br />

finaancial<br />

suppo ort and exteending<br />

the pproject<br />

duration<br />

beyondd<br />

the<br />

stipulateed<br />

time periood.


Mark off<br />

Completionn<br />

of One Yeaar<br />

Since Signning<br />

of Mem morandum of<br />

Agreement<br />

between IITs<br />

and MOEEF:<br />

A<br />

meetingg<br />

was held with Shri Jaairam<br />

Rameesh,<br />

Hon’ble e Minister, MMoEF<br />

and rrepresentativ<br />

ves of IIT TTeam<br />

including<br />

Professor DDevang<br />

Khakkhar,<br />

Directoor,<br />

IIT Bomba ay, Professorr<br />

Sanjay Dhande,<br />

Directo or, IIT Kanpurr<br />

and<br />

Professoor<br />

Vinod Taree,<br />

Coordinattor,<br />

GRBEMPP<br />

Project at New N Delhi onn<br />

July 7, 20111<br />

to mark on ne year of siggning<br />

of MoA. . The First <strong>Newsletter</strong><br />

(VVol<br />

1‐4) prepared<br />

by the IIT Team waas<br />

presentedd<br />

to the Hon n’ble Minister.<br />

In<br />

the meeeting,<br />

the Hoon’ble<br />

Minisster<br />

suggesteed<br />

that the project titlee<br />

may be moodified<br />

as Ganga<br />

River BBasin<br />

Environmment<br />

Managgement<br />

Plan (GRB EMP) . Project Coo ordinator presented<br />

the highlights of o the First Set<br />

of<br />

Reports and stated that the draft<br />

reportss<br />

have been n revised considering<br />

thhe<br />

comment ts received from<br />

various stakeholderrs.<br />

The Honn’ble<br />

Minister<br />

stated that<br />

IITs shoould<br />

give reecommendations<br />

with their<br />

considerred<br />

opinion and suggesteed<br />

that the FFirst<br />

Set of Reports R should<br />

be submittted<br />

shortly for the followw<br />

up<br />

action by<br />

the ministrry.<br />

Third PICC<br />

Meeting, , July 26, 20111,<br />

IIT Delhi:<br />

The meetin ng was chaireed<br />

by Professsor<br />

Vinod Ta are, Coordinator,<br />

Team GGRB<br />

EMP. Thhe<br />

Thematicc<br />

Group leaders<br />

and institute<br />

representatives<br />

attended th he meeting. The<br />

contentious<br />

issues rrelated<br />

to thhe<br />

First Set of Reports were w discusssed<br />

in the mmeeting.<br />

Pro ofessor Purneendu<br />

Bose, Grroup<br />

Leader, , EQP presennted<br />

detailedd<br />

account of f various meetings,<br />

particularly<br />

the meetings m helld<br />

on<br />

May 18, , 2011 and Juuly<br />

7, 2011, with the minnistry.<br />

After considerable<br />

discussions<br />

PICC unanimously<br />

resoolved<br />

that IIT reports shhould<br />

reflectt<br />

the considdered<br />

opinio on of the cconcerned<br />

TThematic<br />

Groups<br />

after due<br />

considerration<br />

to the<br />

commennts<br />

receivedd<br />

from various<br />

individduals/groupss/governmen<br />

nt departmeents/<br />

ministriees.<br />

EQP Grouup<br />

was authoorized<br />

to revvize<br />

its report ts included in<br />

the First Seet<br />

of Reports s.<br />

Third Workshop<br />

of EENB<br />

Group: The third woorkshop<br />

of ENB E Group wwas<br />

held on AAugust<br />

6, 20 011 at IIT Kannpur.<br />

The worrkshop<br />

was aattended<br />

by the invited eexperts<br />

in th he field, Dr R K Sinha, Dr R C Trivedi, Dr K K Vass, Dr K<br />

D Joshi, Dr R S Ambhast,<br />

Dr Prakash<br />

Nautiyaal,<br />

and Dr Na aveen Ambhhast<br />

besides members of f Team ENB from<br />

various IITs (Kanpurr,<br />

Roorkee, Guwahati, KKharagpur)<br />

and a WWF‐Inndia.<br />

Professsor<br />

Vinod Ta are, Coordinator,<br />

Team GRRB<br />

EMP and Professor R P Mathur, GGroup<br />

Leader r, ENB coorddinated<br />

the pproceedings<br />

of the worksshop.<br />

In the Brrain<br />

Storming<br />

Session following<br />

thinggs<br />

emerged through t conssensus:<br />

Gannga<br />

river ecosystem,<br />

ass<br />

of now, is by and large<br />

an altereed<br />

eco‐systeem.<br />

It is diff ficult to sett<br />

any<br />

refeerence<br />

condiition<br />

as not mmuch<br />

historical<br />

informat tion is availabble.<br />

For ecological rrestoration<br />

inn<br />

the Ganga River Basin,<br />

main stem of the riverr,<br />

some impo ortant tributaries<br />

andd<br />

some repreesentative<br />

wetlands<br />

mayy<br />

be consider red as repressentative<br />

of tthe<br />

basin.<br />

Bassed<br />

on the sscattered<br />

hisstorical<br />

inforrmation<br />

and expert opinnion<br />

indicatoor<br />

flora and fauna species<br />

in<br />

various<br />

stretches<br />

on mainn<br />

stem and important tributaries, along with desired den nsities wherrever<br />

posssible,<br />

can bbe<br />

used to set target environment<br />

management<br />

class. SSimilar<br />

exerc cise can alsoo<br />

be<br />

atteempted<br />

for tthe<br />

riparian fflora<br />

and fauuna.<br />

It iss<br />

important tto<br />

consider ddesired<br />

riverr<br />

conditions (channel as well as activve<br />

flood plain)<br />

for survivval<br />

as<br />

welll<br />

flourishing of indicator species.<br />

Linkkages<br />

betweeen<br />

biotic ( (mostly of identified in ndicator speecies)<br />

and aabiotic<br />

components<br />

cann<br />

be<br />

estaablished<br />

based<br />

on informmation<br />

availaable<br />

in literat ture and connsultation<br />

with<br />

experts.<br />

Inteerventions<br />

mmay<br />

mostly bbe<br />

required to improve the abiotic componentss<br />

(e.g. maint tenance of wwater<br />

quaality/pollutioon<br />

prevention,<br />

reducing water abstra actions, avoiding<br />

or proper<br />

design of o barriers inn<br />

the<br />

formm<br />

of barragges/dams<br />

too<br />

ensure smmooth<br />

movem ment (both upstream aand<br />

downstream)<br />

of crritical<br />

indiicator<br />

speciees,<br />

maintenaance<br />

of ecological<br />

flows and substraate<br />

conditionns<br />

for surviv val and breeding,<br />

etc. .). These willl<br />

be suggesteed<br />

by the othher<br />

thematic c groups, nammely<br />

EQP, WWRM,<br />

FGM an nd PLG.<br />

In ssome<br />

cases ddirect<br />

biotic interventionns<br />

may also be required.<br />

These wouuld<br />

be in the form of suppport<br />

for breeding inddigenous<br />

speecies.<br />

It is noot<br />

desirable to<br />

introduce exotic speciees.


Bio‐monitoring should be emphasized. A report can be prepared on bio‐monitoring. Saprobity Index,<br />

P/R ratio, diversity level could be included in bio‐monitoring.<br />

Average fish catch during 1950‐1980 could be set as target on the main stem of the river. Some of the<br />

other targets could be (i) appearance of Dolphins with some suggested sighting frequency in the main<br />

stem of the river from Bijnor to Farakka, and Yamuna up to Delhi, (ii) Indian major carps in specified<br />

stretches, (iii) native and sensitive species of Plecoptera, Ephemeroptera/Trichoptera, (iv) ratio of<br />

Bacillariophyceae/Cholorophyceae and Cyanophyceae, etc.<br />

Review Meeting with Secretary, MoEF: A meeting to review the preparation of the Ganga River Basin<br />

Environment Management Plan (GRB EMP) was held on September 14, 2011 at Paryavaran Bhawan, New<br />

Delhi under the chairmanship of Shri T Chatterjee, Secretary, MoEF. The meeting was attended by Professor<br />

Devang Khakhar, Chairman, PMB and Director, IIT Bombay; Professor Sanjay G Dhande, Director, IIT Kanpur;<br />

Professor Gautam Barua, Director, IIT Guwahati, Professor Vinod Tare, Coordinator, Team GRB EMP and Dr<br />

Geneviece Connors, Water Specialist, World Bank besides the representatives of MoEF including Ms Mira<br />

Mehrishi, Additional Secretary, MoEF. Being the Chairman of PMB, Professor Khakhar handed over a set of<br />

first five reports relating to the GRB EMP, prepared by the IIT consortium, to the Secretary, MoEF. It was<br />

informed to the Secretary, MoEF that the first set of reports were prepared in December 2010 and have<br />

been widely circulated and discussed at various forums including the Standing Committee constituted by<br />

MoEF for this purpose, consultative workshop with the NGRBA expert members and PMB of the IIT<br />

consortium. In the meeting, Professor Tare informed that a special task group for environmental flows (E‐<br />

Flows) has been constituted. IIT consortium raised its concerns in the meeting over the data availability. It<br />

was informed that much of the data of the river flow is yet to be received from the government. Further,<br />

most of the data received from the CWC is in hardcopy, which will take many months to convert into digital<br />

form. Digital soil data of the river basin has also not been received from National Bureau of Soil Survey &<br />

Land Use Planning, Nagpur. Moreover, IIT consortium is carrying out the exercise of sectional survey of the<br />

river, while the information is already available with the CWC. In this context, Professor Dhande requested<br />

the Secretary, MoEF to take up the matter at his level to provide these data. The Secretary, MoEF assured<br />

the IIT consortium that all efforts will be made to address the issues relating to the supply of data for<br />

preparation of E‐Flows report under the GRB EMP.<br />

Consultative Workshop of PLG Group: The PLG Thematic Group organized a Consultative Workshop on<br />

October 15‐16, 2011 at Rajiv Gandhi School of Intellectual Property Law, Indian Institute of Technology<br />

Kharagpur. The Consultative Workshop was organized with the objective of examining the need and<br />

framework of comprehensive legislation on River Basin Management.<br />

The organizers invited experts from several sectors representing views from respective areas. Amongst<br />

participants, lawyers, activists, environmentalists, engineers, academics and researchers were invited to<br />

present their views on River Basin Management Plan. To name a few, Mr Ramaswamy Iyer, Ms Ram Rauta,<br />

Professor M K Ramesh, Mr Videh Upadhaya, Mr Panjwani, Mr Parityosh Tygi and Mr G N Kathpalia were<br />

distinguished speakers in the Workshop. From IITs, Dr Vinod Tare (IIT Kanpur), Dr Shyam Asholekar (IIT<br />

Bombay), Dr N C Narayan (IIT Bombay), Dr D J Sen (IIT Kharagpur) were present. The Workshop was<br />

inaugurated by Professor Majumdar, Deputy Director, IIT Kharagpur.<br />

The Workshop witnessed deliberations on issues of Need for Legislative and Regulatory framework on River<br />

Ganga, Prevention, Conservation and Development of River Ganga, River Basin Management and<br />

Implementation Agencies and Adjudication and Dispute Settlement Mechanism. The Workshop was<br />

coordinated by Dr Indrajit Dube along with Dr Dipa Dube and Dr Uday Shankar. All participants supported<br />

the resolution that a comprehensive National Ganga River Basin Act is necessary and IIT Team should take<br />

the lead based on deliberations of the workshop.


Internattional<br />

Worksshop<br />

on ‘PPPP<br />

Models and<br />

Technolog gical Solutionns<br />

for Sewagge<br />

and Wast te Management’:<br />

An interrnational<br />

woorkshop<br />

on tthe<br />

public‐private‐partne<br />

ership (PPP) and technoological<br />

solut tions for sewwage<br />

and wasste<br />

management<br />

was hheld<br />

at Vishwwakarma<br />

Bh hawan, Indiaan<br />

Institute of Technolo ogy Delhi duuring<br />

Septembber<br />

22–23, 2011 to expplore<br />

state‐oof‐the‐art<br />

technological<br />

solutions cooupled<br />

with PPP models<br />

for<br />

sewage and industrial<br />

effluents in India, in general, and d the Gangaa<br />

River Basinn<br />

in particula ar. More thaan<br />

30<br />

delegatees<br />

representting<br />

about 122<br />

countries including Ita aly, France, GGermany,<br />

UKK,<br />

Israel, Aus stralia, Denmmark,<br />

Singapore,<br />

etc. sharred<br />

international<br />

experiences<br />

and explored e thee<br />

possibilitiees<br />

of bilatera al or multilaateral<br />

cooperaation<br />

on advaanced<br />

technoological<br />

applications<br />

cou upled with PP PP solutions at the works shop. Five mmodel<br />

projectss<br />

pertaining tto<br />

managemment<br />

of sewaage<br />

and indu ustrial efflueent<br />

employinng<br />

Zero Liquid<br />

Dischargee<br />

and<br />

PPP moddel<br />

have beeen<br />

proposedd<br />

as part of tthe<br />

preparat tion of GRB EMP at the workshop. Mr M Sanmit Ahuja,<br />

CEO of EETI<br />

Dynamics,<br />

a UK baseed<br />

economicc<br />

development<br />

focused eenterprise,<br />

served<br />

as Co‐organiser<br />

of<br />

the<br />

workshoop<br />

and greattly<br />

facilitatedd<br />

participatiion<br />

of intern national deleegates<br />

in thee<br />

workshop. ETI Dynamics<br />

is<br />

collaborrating<br />

with thhe<br />

IIT Consortia<br />

to facilitate<br />

interacti ion with manny<br />

countries interested in<br />

participatioon<br />

in<br />

gigantic task of restooring<br />

the heaalth<br />

of riverss<br />

in the Gang ga Basin. Proofessor<br />

Mukeesh<br />

Khare, IIT T Delhi serveed<br />

as<br />

local cooordinator.<br />

EETI<br />

Dynamiccs<br />

is also sppearheading<br />

the settingg<br />

up of inteernational<br />

fo ocus groups and<br />

internattional<br />

Ganga River knowlledge<br />

centrees<br />

with Unive ersity of Soutthampton<br />

(UUK)<br />

already taking t the lead<br />

in<br />

establishhing<br />

one.<br />

14th Intternational<br />

River Sympoosium,<br />

Brisbbane:<br />

Dr Vin nod Tare, Professor,<br />

Envvironmental<br />

Engineeringg<br />

and<br />

Manageement<br />

Prograamme,<br />

Depaartment<br />

of CCivil<br />

Engineer ring, IIT Kanpur<br />

and Cooordinator,<br />

Co onsortia of Seven<br />

IITs for Preparationn<br />

of GRB EMMP<br />

was invitted<br />

to delive er a talk on ‘Preparing the First Ga anga River BBasin<br />

Manageement<br />

Plan’ aat<br />

the 14th Innternational<br />

River Sympo osium, Brisbane,<br />

Australia:<br />

Septembe er 26‐29, 2011.<br />

Fortthcoming<br />

Ev vents<br />

First NNational<br />

Stuudents’<br />

Confference<br />

on RRiver<br />

Basin Planning P (BRRiP‐2011)<br />

Orrganized<br />

by Consortia C off<br />

7<br />

IITs aat<br />

IIT Kanpurr:<br />

November 4–5, 2011<br />

FGM Thematic Grroup<br />

Meetinng<br />

at Patna UUniversity:<br />

December D 222–23,<br />

2011<br />

IITT<br />

Bombay<br />

IIT Delhi<br />

IIT MMadras<br />

Mail us your valua able feedbackss<br />

and suggesttions<br />

at ganga apedia@gmaiil.com<br />

IIT Kanpur<br />

IIT Guwwahati<br />

Vinod Tare e; vinod@iitk. ac.in;<br />

Subrataa<br />

Hait; subrat ta.hait@gmail.com<br />

Rakeshh<br />

Mishra; rmi ishraz@yahooo.com<br />

RRasmi<br />

Sanghi; rsanghi@iitkk.ac.in<br />

Tripti Singh; triptis@gmaiil.com<br />

Shaashikant<br />

Patel;<br />

spatel@iitkk.ac.in<br />

Shivam KKapoor;<br />

shiva amkpr@yahooo.com<br />

IIT Roorkee<br />

Attributioons<br />

IIT Kharagpur

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!