20.05.2013 Views

Gastrojejunostomy: a simple method of

Gastrojejunostomy: a simple method of

Gastrojejunostomy: a simple method of

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Annals <strong>of</strong> the Royal College <strong>of</strong> Surgeons <strong>of</strong> England (1986) vol. 68<br />

<strong>Gastrojejunostomy</strong>: a <strong>simple</strong> <strong>method</strong> <strong>of</strong><br />

treatment <strong>of</strong> gastric volvulus<br />

A G FARKAS NlB BS<br />

Senior House Officer<br />

L R CELESTIN FRCS<br />

Consultant Surgeon<br />

Department <strong>of</strong> General Surgery, Frenchay Hospital, Bristol<br />

Key words: GASTROE{INTEROSTOMY; STOMACH, VOlNVIULUS; SURGERY<br />

Summary<br />

Ten patients treated for gastric volvulus over eleven years are reviewed.<br />

Nine were treated successfully by gastrojejunostomy. The '1)<br />

advantages <strong>of</strong> this <strong>simple</strong> procedure are discussed. Changes occurring<br />

in the position <strong>of</strong> the pylorus may predispose to this condition.<br />

Introduction<br />

Gastric volvulus is an unusual condition involving rotation<br />

<strong>of</strong> the stomach around either its longitudinal (organo-axial)<br />

or transverse (mesentcro-axial) axis (Fig. 1). It may present<br />

cither acutely or chronically and be either total or partial.<br />

The condition was described by Berti in 1866 (1) present-<br />

to<br />

ing classically as Borchardt's triad (2): (i) retching with<br />

inability to vomit,Borchardtgstriad (2) (ii) etchinability to<br />

pass a nasogastric tube. It usually occurs in association<br />

with large hiatus herniae (3). Other recognised associations<br />

are with ligamentous laxity <strong>of</strong> the stomach attachments,<br />

congenital bands traumatic diaphragmatic hernia and<br />

eventration <strong>of</strong> the diaphragm (6).<br />

Many reports <strong>of</strong> this condition have described a multitude<br />

<strong>of</strong> treatments (4-7). Tanner (6) enumerated these:<br />

repair <strong>of</strong> diaphragmatic hernia, division <strong>of</strong> adherent bands,<br />

gastropexy, gastropexy with colonic displacement, partial<br />

gastrectomy, gastrojcjunostomy, fundo-antral gastrogastrostomy,<br />

repair <strong>of</strong> eventration <strong>of</strong> diaphragm. In addition<br />

endoscopy has been used (8).<br />

<strong>Gastrojejunostomy</strong> was first described as a successful A<br />

treatment by Neumann in 1906 (9). Individual cases have<br />

been reported since, most recently by Thorpe in 1981 (10).<br />

We report our experience <strong>of</strong> this condition in ten patients.<br />

Patients and <strong>method</strong>s<br />

Over the past eleven years ten patients, all female, with<br />

gastric volvulus have been treated surgically. All were<br />

associated with large para-oesophagael hiatus herniae. The<br />

axis <strong>of</strong> rotation was recorded in seven cases. Five had<br />

organo-axial rotation and two mesentero-axial.<br />

An abdominal approach was used in all cases. The<br />

principal treatment in nine was retrocolic gastrojejunostomy.<br />

This was performed by anastomosing the greater<br />

curve <strong>of</strong> the stomach to the jejunum as closely as possible to<br />

the duodeno-jejunal flexure. A two layer anastomosis <strong>of</strong><br />

continuous chromic catgut and interrupted linen was used.<br />

F IG. I Above, organo-axial rotation <strong>of</strong> stomach around longitudin-<br />

Correspondence to: Dr A G Farkas, 11, Myrtle Road, Bristol al axis; below, mesentero-axial rotation <strong>of</strong> stomach around trans-<br />

BS2 8BL verse axis.


108 A G Farkas and L R Celestin<br />

TABLE I. Details <strong>of</strong> the ten patients treated.<br />

Age<br />

Case Sex Presentation Treatment Outcome<br />

1 82F Pain and <strong>Gastrojejunostomy</strong> Symptoms relieved<br />

vomiting Repair <strong>of</strong> hiatus Alive<br />

2 68F Vomiting Total gastrectomy Died <strong>of</strong> anastomotic<br />

dehiscence<br />

3 82F Pain and <strong>Gastrojejunostomy</strong> Well until unrelated<br />

vomiting death 2 years<br />

4 69F Pain and <strong>Gastrojejunostomy</strong> Well until died <strong>of</strong><br />

vomiting Repair <strong>of</strong> hiatus carcinoma <strong>of</strong> stomach<br />

4 years<br />

5 81F Haematemesis <strong>Gastrojejunostomy</strong> Symptoms relieved<br />

Excision gastric Died <strong>of</strong> adhesive<br />

ulcer obstruction 2 months<br />

6 83F Pain and <strong>Gastrojejunostomy</strong> Well until unrelated<br />

vomiting death 3 months<br />

7 75F Pain <strong>Gastrojejunostomy</strong> Symptoms relieved<br />

Repair <strong>of</strong> hiatus Alive<br />

8 81F Haematemesis <strong>Gastrojejunostomy</strong> Symptoms relieved<br />

Repair <strong>of</strong> hiatus Alive<br />

9 58F Haematemesis <strong>Gastrojejunostomy</strong> Symptoms relieved<br />

Splenectomy Alive<br />

10 68F Dysphagia <strong>Gastrojejunostomy</strong> Symptoms relieved<br />

Repair oesophageal Alive<br />

tear<br />

The hiatus was repaired in four cases using interrupted<br />

nylon sutures.<br />

In case 2 difficult mobilization <strong>of</strong> the stomach resulted in<br />

gastric perforation necessitating thoraco-abdominal gastrectomy.<br />

In case 5 a bleeding gastric ulcer was excised. In<br />

case 9 splenectomy was carried out and in case 10 an<br />

oesophageal tear repaired following difficulties in mobilising<br />

the stomach.<br />

Results<br />

The ten cases are summarised in Table I. All nine patients<br />

treated by gastrojejunostomy had relief <strong>of</strong> symptoms following<br />

surgery and are either alive or have died from unrelated<br />

causes. The only perioperative mortality among all patients<br />

FIG. 2 Radiograph <strong>of</strong> organo-axial rotation.<br />

was in case 2 following total gastrectomy. Case 5 died<br />

following a laparotomy for adhesions two months after<br />

gastrojejunostomy and excision <strong>of</strong> gastric ulcer; case 6 died<br />

<strong>of</strong> unrelated causes 3 months after surgery.<br />

We have not encountered any recurrence <strong>of</strong> symptoms in<br />

this group <strong>of</strong> patients.<br />

Discussion<br />

The significance <strong>of</strong> the axis about which the stomach<br />

rotates has been discussed extensively (7, 11). The pylorus is<br />

normally situated to the right <strong>of</strong> the midline at the level <strong>of</strong><br />

the first lumbar intervertebral space. In volvulus the pylorus,<br />

as found at surgery, is in the midline at the level <strong>of</strong> the<br />

body <strong>of</strong> LI (Figs. 2 and 3). In para-oesophageal herniation<br />

FiG. 3 Diagram <strong>of</strong> radiograph in Fig. 2 showing movement <strong>of</strong><br />

greater curve A to A' and lesser curve B to B'. Pylorus P moves<br />

upwards and to the midline P'.


migration <strong>of</strong> the stomach into the chest is a factor leading to<br />

movement <strong>of</strong> the pylorus and duodenum across the midline.<br />

We suggest that though herniation is the aetiological factor,<br />

migration <strong>of</strong> the pylorus may predispose to volvulus, as it<br />

only occurs when the distance between cardia and pylorus<br />

is such as to allow abnormal mobility <strong>of</strong> the stomach.<br />

The aim <strong>of</strong> surgical correction is relief <strong>of</strong> symptoms and<br />

prevention <strong>of</strong> recurrence. The average age in our series was<br />

74: any procedure in this elderly population should be as<br />

<strong>simple</strong> as possible. The diaphragmatic hiatus was repaired<br />

in cases when it was readily accessible but was felt to be <strong>of</strong><br />

secondary importance and not to warrant more extensive<br />

surgery. Symptoms <strong>of</strong> reflux oesophagitis are rare, due to an<br />

increased oesophago-gastric angle (6). <strong>Gastrojejunostomy</strong><br />

at the fixed point <strong>of</strong> the duodeno-jejunal juction tethers the<br />

untwisted stomach in the abdomen and prevents recurrent<br />

volvulus. This procedure carries the further advantage <strong>of</strong><br />

preventing the not infrequent migration <strong>of</strong> the transverse<br />

colon into the chest anterior to the stomach. Fixation by<br />

anastomosis does not break down as may happen in <strong>simple</strong><br />

gastropexy (6).<br />

<strong>Gastrojejunostomy</strong> is a <strong>simple</strong> and effective treatment for<br />

gastric volvulus. Morbidity and mortality in this series has<br />

been associated with extensive gastric mobilization or the<br />

performance <strong>of</strong> surgical procedures in addition to gastrojejunostomy.<br />

We suggest that these should be avoided when<br />

possible.<br />

Notes on books<br />

Atlas <strong>of</strong> Human Anatomy by J A Gosling, P F Harris, J R<br />

Humpherson, I Whitmore and P L T Wilan. Illustrated.<br />

1985. Gower Medical Publishing Limited, London. £19.50.<br />

Originating from the Manchester University Department <strong>of</strong> Anatomy<br />

this folio volume comprises high quality colour photographs<br />

<strong>of</strong> cadaver dissections accompanied by a coloured line diagram <strong>of</strong><br />

the photograph fully labelled. A succinct text accompanies the<br />

illustrations.<br />

The photographs are <strong>of</strong> outstanding quality and there can be<br />

few students <strong>of</strong> anatomy who will fail to enjoy studying this<br />

vilume. It complements existing texts and should have a ready sale<br />

in view <strong>of</strong> the remarkably low price.<br />

Radiation Protection in Hospitals by Richard F Mould.<br />

201 pages, illustrated. 1985. Adam Hilger, Bristol. £19.50.<br />

Personnel in the Departments <strong>of</strong> Nuclear Medicine, Diagnostic<br />

Radiology and Radiotherapy ali need to know the principles and<br />

importance <strong>of</strong> radiation protection. This book tells all. It has<br />

evolved over many years <strong>of</strong> lecturing on the topic <strong>of</strong> radiation<br />

protection to a wide spectrum <strong>of</strong> hospital staff and is written in a<br />

most readable style. Numerous illustrations, including the judicious<br />

use <strong>of</strong> cartoons, enliven the pages.<br />

Head and Neck Cancer edited by Robert E Wittes. 350<br />

pages, illustrated. 1985. John Wiley, Chichester. £37.50.<br />

Selected areas <strong>of</strong> current interest in head and neck cancer comprise<br />

this volume. Epidemiology, staging, treatment and prevention,<br />

cells in culture and <strong>method</strong>ology are the headings <strong>of</strong> the five<br />

sections covered. Particularly emphasised is the increasing use <strong>of</strong><br />

combined modality treatment. Fully referenced and handsomely<br />

produced.<br />

Congenital Heart Surgery: Current Techniques and<br />

Controversies edited by Anthony L Moulton. 347 pages,<br />

illustrated. Butterworths, London. £95.00.<br />

Forty-two authors from 8 different countries describe their<br />

approaches to 7 different congenital heart defects. With more than<br />

500 illustrations and many tables the different surgical approaches<br />

are detailed together with extinwive references to the literature.<br />

A <strong>simple</strong> <strong>method</strong> <strong>of</strong> treatment <strong>of</strong> gastric volvulus 109<br />

References<br />

I Berti A. Singalore attortigliamento dele'es<strong>of</strong>ago col duodeno<br />

seguita rapida morte. Gazz Med Ital Prov Veneti 1866;9:139.<br />

2 Borchardt M. Zun Pathalogie and Therapie des Magenvolvulus.<br />

Arch Klin Chir 1904;74:243.<br />

3 Vernhet J, Carabalona JP, Carabalona P. Les volvulus intrathoraciques<br />

de l'estomac au cours des hernies hiatales.<br />

Chirurgie 1980; 106:756-4.<br />

4 Dalgard BJ. Volvulus <strong>of</strong> the stomach. Acta Chir Scanda<br />

1952; 103:131-53.<br />

5 Buchanan J. Volvulus <strong>of</strong> the stomach. Br J Surg 1932;18:99-<br />

112.<br />

6 Tanner NC. Chronic and recurrent volvulus <strong>of</strong> the stomach.<br />

Am J Surg 1968; 115:505-15.<br />

7 Wastell C, Ellis H. Volvulus <strong>of</strong> the stomach. Br J Surg<br />

1971 ;58:557-62.<br />

8 Patel NM. Endoscopic correction chronic gastric volvulus.<br />

Gastrointest Endosc 1983;29:63.<br />

9 Neumann. Uber den Volvulus des Magens. Dtsch Z Chir<br />

1906;85: 136-50.<br />

10 Thorpe JAC. Chronic gastric volvulus-aetiology and treatment.<br />

BrJ Clin Pract 1981;35:161-2.<br />

11 Carter R, Brewer LA, Hinshaw DB. Acute gastric volvulus.<br />

AmJ Surg 1980;140:99-106.<br />

12 Askew AR. Treatment <strong>of</strong> acute and chronic gastric volvulus.<br />

Ann R Coll Surg Eng 1978;60:326-8.<br />

Manual on the AO/ASIF Tubular External Fixator by<br />

G Hierholzer, Th Ruedi, M Allgower and J Schatzker. 100<br />

pages, illustrated. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. DM 86.<br />

This is a specialized book for orthopaedic surgeons. It outlines the<br />

principal features <strong>of</strong> the tubular system <strong>of</strong> external fixation which<br />

was developed by the Working Group for Osteosynthesis <strong>of</strong> the<br />

AO/ASIF. It is copiously illustrated and handsomely produced on<br />

high quality paper.<br />

Surgical Endoscopy edited by Thomas L Dent, William E<br />

Strodel, Jeremiah G Turcotte and Mary L. Harper. 536<br />

pages, illustrated. 1985. Year Book Medical Publishers,<br />

Chicago. £57.<br />

Diagnostic and therapeutic endoscopy <strong>of</strong> the gastrointestinal tract<br />

and biliary tree, together with bronchoscopy, arthroscopy, cystoscopy<br />

and laparoscopy are covered in this concentrated text. Thirty<br />

three chapters comprise essays presented at a postgraduate symposium<br />

held in May 1985 in Michigan. Topical, readable and<br />

recommended.<br />

Surgical Care II by Robert E Condon and Jerome De<br />

Cosse. 431 pages, illustrated. 1985. Lea and Febiger, Philadelphia.<br />

$71.<br />

Applied surgical physiology is emphasised throughout this wideranging<br />

volume which covers such diverse subjects as gastrointestinal<br />

motility, massive intestinal resection, cerebrovascular disorders,<br />

the pathology <strong>of</strong> sepsis and wound healing. The volume is<br />

intended as a reference text for students as well as the practising<br />

surgeon. Each <strong>of</strong> the twenty one chapters is well referenced and<br />

the book is attractively produced on art paper.<br />

1985 Year Book <strong>of</strong> Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery<br />

edited by FrederickJ McCoy. 320 pages, illustrated. 1985.<br />

Year Book Medical Publishers, Chicago. £49.50.<br />

This is the sixteenth annual volume <strong>of</strong> a well-known series. It<br />

abstracts important articles published during the last few months<br />

and adds substantive editorial comments. Required reading for all<br />

plastic surgeons.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!