New Jersey - Digital Publishing
New Jersey - Digital Publishing
New Jersey - Digital Publishing
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Corner offiCe<br />
Banks, credit unions must<br />
compete on level ground<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>Jersey</strong>’s credit unions have been trying to make the<br />
case recently that they should be allowed to take municipal<br />
deposits in order to drive more competition.<br />
And while <strong>New</strong> <strong>Jersey</strong>’s banks welcome free competition, credit<br />
unions have an unfair advantage, because they don’t pay taxes<br />
and are not subject to the same requirements as banks.<br />
Credit unions have the special federal<br />
privilege of a tax exemption because their<br />
legal mandate is to serve people of modest<br />
means. However, with this special privilege<br />
come limitations, such as business lending<br />
and field of membership restrictions.<br />
Credit unions cannot serve<br />
the general public, and are charged<br />
with serving only consumers in their<br />
field of membership. To join a credit<br />
union, you must have a common<br />
bond. This common bond has now<br />
been stretched beyond recognition,<br />
as there are now 167 credit unions<br />
nationally with more than $1 billion<br />
in assets, including some that serve<br />
areas larger than states.<br />
There’s some evidence that credit<br />
unions are no longer fulfilling their<br />
mission of serving people of modest means.<br />
The National Community Reinvestment Coalition,<br />
a consumer group, released a study<br />
in September 2009 that found banks outperformed<br />
credit unions in serving people of<br />
modest means.<br />
Congress limited credit unions’ abil-<br />
nJBiZ opinion poll<br />
While business owners stand to gain<br />
quite a bit from Chris Christie’s<br />
budget plan,<br />
many responders to our<br />
most recent poll said<br />
the gains for executives<br />
are balanced by interests<br />
of residents.<br />
Still, business owners<br />
are heaping praise<br />
on the governor, with<br />
Pro Fire Systems’<br />
Len Guancione’s<br />
“thank God for Christie”<br />
response summing<br />
up how most feel about<br />
the plan.<br />
Steve Struthers,<br />
of DynTek, said Christie<br />
“is taking the courageous<br />
route by doing<br />
what he thinks is the best thing for the economy,<br />
regardless of whose toes he steps on.”<br />
Richard Monsen, of Monsen Engineering<br />
Co., said the effort is “hardly a windfall<br />
ity to lend to businesses in 1998 because<br />
it wanted to ensure credit unions remained<br />
focused on their specific mission of meeting<br />
the needs of consumers, not businesses.<br />
As part of their “special status,” Congress<br />
“There’s some evidence<br />
that credit<br />
unions are no longer<br />
fulfilling their<br />
mission of serving<br />
people of modest<br />
means.<br />
”<br />
– John E. McWeeney Jr.<br />
chose to cap credit unions’ business lending<br />
at 12.25 percent of assets. Business<br />
loans under $50,000 do not count against<br />
this cap, nor does the guaranteed portion<br />
of Small Business Administration loans.<br />
Yet, credit unions have been lobbying for<br />
expanded business lending.<br />
for business owners.”<br />
“If <strong>New</strong> <strong>Jersey</strong> is to survive, we must<br />
strengthen our business community to create<br />
jobs and pay taxes,” he wrote.<br />
Reader JoAnn Dixon, meanwhile, took<br />
issue with the Legislature, which “seem(s) to<br />
Credit unions want it both ways. They<br />
want expanded powers in the areas of municipal<br />
deposits and business lending, but they<br />
still want to hide under the cloak of their<br />
tax exemption. As credit union membership<br />
expands, so does the cost to American taxpayers,<br />
who underwrite the credit union industry’s<br />
tax subsidy to the tune of more than<br />
$1.3 billion a year. At a time when budgets<br />
are under severe stress, why are taxpayers still<br />
subsidizing credit unions?<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>Jersey</strong>’s banks have been serving<br />
consumers, businesses, and all levels of<br />
state and local government for well over<br />
a century. On the government side, this<br />
includes not just taking deposits, but also<br />
buying short-term and long-term debt,<br />
which provide critical funding to meet the<br />
government’s operating and capital needs.<br />
There is no shortage of competition for<br />
government deposits or any other type of<br />
banking services in <strong>New</strong> <strong>Jersey</strong>.<br />
If credit unions want to expand their<br />
services, they have the option of converting<br />
to a mutual savings bank char-<br />
ter. A mutual charter would preserve<br />
mutual ownership for their members<br />
and allow them to break free from<br />
restrictions, such as the one on business<br />
lending.<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>Jersey</strong>’s banks welcome free<br />
competition, but they deserve a level<br />
playing field. If there are credit unions<br />
in <strong>New</strong> <strong>Jersey</strong> that want to operate<br />
like banks, they should stop hiding<br />
behind their tax exemption, change<br />
their charter and become banks. That<br />
means paying taxes and reinvesting in <strong>New</strong><br />
<strong>Jersey</strong>’s communities just like <strong>New</strong> <strong>Jersey</strong>’s<br />
banks do.<br />
John E. McWeeney Jr. is president and CEO<br />
of the Cranford-based <strong>New</strong> <strong>Jersey</strong> Bankers<br />
Association.<br />
A good budget for business, but it’s not a windfall<br />
Chris Christie's budget plan:<br />
21.5%<br />
Is a runaway<br />
win for<br />
business<br />
owners<br />
17.3%<br />
Cuts programs<br />
with proven<br />
economic<br />
strength<br />
61.2%<br />
64.7%<br />
Offers a<br />
balanced mix<br />
for execs and<br />
residents<br />
Critical to<br />
keeping jobs<br />
in the state<br />
be against anything he wants to do. I’m not a<br />
Republican, but the guy seems to be on track<br />
to lead <strong>New</strong> <strong>Jersey</strong> out of<br />
the wilderness and tax<br />
morass we’ve been in.”<br />
But reader David<br />
Melvin said some cuts<br />
went bone deep, like<br />
those to infrastructure.<br />
“The Swiss just built<br />
the longest train tunnel<br />
in the world, while we<br />
canceled the most important<br />
train tunnel in<br />
the world.” And fellow<br />
reader Pam Pernot said<br />
many of Christie’s cuts<br />
“are short-term, Band-<br />
Aid cuts. It’s time he<br />
starts to think long-term<br />
benefits to the state …<br />
beyond the next election.”<br />
NEXT WEEK:<br />
A plan to redevelop the Meadowlands<br />
HOW TO REACH US<br />
Mailing address<br />
njbiz, 220 Davidson Ave., Suite 302<br />
Somerset, NJ 08873<br />
Phone (732) 246-7677<br />
Fax: editorial (732) 846-0421<br />
Fax: advertising (732) 249-8952<br />
Fax: oPerations (732) 846-0421<br />
subscriPtions (866) 288-7699<br />
rePrints For article reprints, please<br />
contact our reprint coordinator at<br />
Wright’s Reprints: 1-877-652-5295.<br />
For photos, please see www.njbiz.com/photos<br />
PubliSheR<br />
thomas F. curtin tcurtin@njbiz.com<br />
Advertising<br />
DiReCTOR OF SAleS<br />
Mark cialdella mcialdella@njbiz.com<br />
SeNiOR ACCOuNT exeCuTive<br />
Penelope spencer pspencer@njbiz.com<br />
ACCOuNT exeCuTiveS<br />
susan alexander salexander@njbiz.com<br />
ryan boyd rboyd@njbiz.com<br />
samantha d’amore sdamore@njbiz.com<br />
craig Fallon cfallon@njbiz.com<br />
jessica holmes jholmes@njbiz.com<br />
joe Malone jmalone@njbiz.com<br />
editOriAL<br />
eDiTOR<br />
sharon Waters swaters@njbiz.com<br />
DePuTY eDiTOR - NeWS<br />
joe st. arney jarney@njbiz.com<br />
DePuTY eDiTOR & RePORTeR<br />
health Care/Nonprofits<br />
beth Fitzgerald bfitzgerald@njbiz.com<br />
COPY/lAYOuT eDiTOR<br />
Meghan shapiro mshapiro@njbiz.com<br />
STAFF WRiTeRS<br />
Finance/Accounting/law<br />
Martin c. daks mdaks@njbiz.com<br />
Pharmaceuticals/energy/Retail<br />
jared Kaltwasser jkaltwasser@njbiz.com<br />
Trenton bureau/Sports and entertainment<br />
andrew Kitchenman akitchenman@njbiz.com<br />
Real estate/economic Dev./environment<br />
evelyn lee elee@njbiz.com<br />
Central <strong>Jersey</strong><br />
laura Mortkowitz lmortkowitz@njbiz.com<br />
PhOTOgRAPheR<br />
christina Mazza cmazza@njbiz.com<br />
ReSeARCheR<br />
danielle neufell dneufell@njbiz.com<br />
Art / PrOdUCtiOn<br />
DeSigN MANAgeR<br />
darren Phillips dphillips@njbiz.com<br />
DeSigNeRS<br />
Kevin Paccione kpaccione@njbiz.com<br />
sara siano ssiano@njbiz.com<br />
DeSigN iNTeRN<br />
julie hertz design@njbiz.com<br />
events<br />
eveNTS DiReCTOR<br />
Wendy berg wberg@journalpub.com<br />
eveNTS AND MARKeTiNg COORDiNATOR<br />
sarah spangler sspangler@njbiz.com<br />
BUsiness OPerAtiOns<br />
buSiNeSS MANAgeR<br />
annMarie Karczmit akarczmit@njbiz.com<br />
MARKeTiNg MANAgeR<br />
anne beck abeck@njbiz.com<br />
ADMiNiSTRATive ASSiSTANT<br />
jessica Perry jperry@njbiz.com<br />
Published by Journal Publications inc.<br />
david a. schankweiler, ceo<br />
lawrence M. Kluger, President<br />
www.njbiz.com njbiz ◆ March 7, 2011 13