07.07.2013 Views

bid evaluation report procurement of hospital, ophthalmology and ...

bid evaluation report procurement of hospital, ophthalmology and ...

bid evaluation report procurement of hospital, ophthalmology and ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

Category: Anesthesia<br />

1 Analgesia Unit 2 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Therapy<br />

Equipment<br />

Enotonox Apparatus UK GBP 200,000 400,000.00 1,200.00 2,400.00 371,112.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

1 Analgesia Unit 2 QFR Enterprise Aeonmed Aeon 7200 China USD 0.00 5,500.00 11,000.00 1,060,400.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

2 BiPAP Continous Flow System 4 QFR Enterprise BMC Medical RESmart BPAP-25 China PKR 85,000 340,000.00 85,000.00 340,000.00 340,000.00 1 Rejected, not FDA approved.<br />

2 BiPAP Continous Flow System 4 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Bipap Pro Holl<strong>and</strong> USD 0.00 1,654.00 6,616.00 637,782.40 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

2 BiPAP Continous Flow System 4 Mediurge AirLiquide Medical MONNAL T30<br />

Systems<br />

France Euro 0.00 2,090.00 8,360.00 1,050,935.60 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

2 BiPAP Continous Flow System 4 Noor International H<strong>of</strong>frichter GmbH H<strong>of</strong>frichter Friend II ST 20 Germany Euro 0.00 2,500.00 10,000.00 1,257,100.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

2 BiPAP Continous Flow System 4 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Philips/Respironics BiPAP Sinchrony USA USD 440,000 1,760,000.00 4,200.00 16,800.00 1,619,520.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

4 Induction Unit Wall Mounted 2 Bios OES Medical ASTRA-3 UK GBP 0.00 6,590.00 13,180.00 2,038,023.40 1 Technically acceptable - they have quoted<br />

absorber circuit additinally<br />

5 Laryngoscope 20 Biologic Medical Friedrich Bosch<br />

Germany Euro 0.00 60.00 1,200.00 150,852.00 1 Rejected as they have not quoted with<br />

Systems<br />

GmbH<br />

flexible tip, Friedrich Bosch does not<br />

manufacture laryngoscopes<br />

5 Laryngoscope 20 Strongman Medical Local Local PKR 9,250 185,000.00 9,250.00 185,000.00 185,000.00 2 Rejected as they have not quoted with<br />

flexible tip<br />

5 Laryngoscope 20 Paktech Instrument Hillbro Pakistan PKR 84,400 1,688,000.00 84,400.00 1,688,000.00 1,688,000.00 3 Rejected as they have not quoted with<br />

Co.<br />

flexible tip<br />

5 Laryngoscope 20 Nasa Medical Corp. Mahe 04.203.01 Germany Euro 0.00 715.00 14,300.00 1,797,653.00 4 Rejected as they have not quoted with<br />

flexible tip<br />

5 Laryngoscope 20 All Med Solution Karl Storz Karl Storz Laryngoscope Germany Euro 0.00 748.00 14,960.00 1,880,621.60 5 Rejected as they have not quoted with<br />

flexible tip<br />

5 Laryngoscope 20 Ameer Din<br />

Instruments<br />

Heine Flex Tip Germany PKR 120,000 2,400,000.00 120,000.00 2,400,000.00 2,400,000.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

5 Laryngoscope 20 Mediurge Hersill Spain Euro 0.00 1,275.00 25,500.00 3,205,605.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

6 Ventilator 40 QFR Enterprise Aeonmed 590 China USD 0.00 7,750.00 310,000.00 29,884,000.00 1 Rejected, Tidal Volume only 50 to 1500ml<br />

6 Ventilator 40 Biotech Pakistan Mindray E3 China USD 0.00 7,800.00 312,000.00 30,076,800.00 2 Rejected, Tidal volume range upto 2L<br />

against 3L. Paediatric only no neonate<br />

6 Ventilator 40 QFR Enterprise Aeonmed 590 China USD 0.00 9,200.00 368,000.00 35,475,200.00 3 Rejected, Tidal Volume only 50 to 1500ml<br />

6 Ventilator 40 Hospicare Systems Newport E360 S USA USD 0.00 10,700.00 428,000.00 41,259,200.00 4 Rejected. This is althogh technically OK but<br />

is very old technology <strong>and</strong> not upgradeable<br />

in future. Running cost is high. Oxygen cell<br />

life is less than year, back up battery time<br />

is low, Flow sensors fragile, Old model<br />

likely to go out <strong>of</strong> production<br />

6 Ventilator 40 Biotech Pakistan Care Fusion VELA USA USD 0.00 11,355.00 454,200.00 43,784,880.00 5 Rejected, Tidal volume range upto 2L<br />

against 3L. Paediatric only no neonate<br />

6 Ventilator 40 Artema Medical IMT Medical Bella Vista 1000 Switzerl<strong>and</strong> USD 0.00 11,550.00 462,000.00 44,536,800.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

6 Ventilator 40 Hospicare Systems Covidien PB 840 USA USD 0.00 12,300.00 492,000.00 47,428,800.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

6 Ventilator 40 Hospicare Systems Siareton 4000 ICU Italy Euro 0.00 10,500.00 420,000.00 52,798,200.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

6 Ventilator 40 Noor International Hamilton C1 Switzerl<strong>and</strong> Swiss Franc 0.00 13,200.00 528,000.00 55,033,440.00 9 Rejected, Tidal volume range upto 2L<br />

against 3L. Paediatric only no neonate<br />

6 Ventilator 40 Sherazi Trading G.E. Engstrom Pro USA 1 Year USD 0.00 14,786.00 591,440.00 57,014,816.00 10 Technically Acceptable<br />

6 Ventilator 40 Mediurge AirLiquide Medical Extend xp France Euro 0.00 11,990.00 479,600.00 60,290,516.00 11 Rejected, Tidal volume range upto 2L<br />

Systems<br />

against 3L. Paediatric only no neonate<br />

6 Ventilator 40 Noor International Hamilton C2 Switzerl<strong>and</strong> Swiss Franc 0.00 15,600.00 624,000.00 65,039,520.00 12 Rejected, Tidal volume range upto 2L<br />

against 3L. Paediatric only no neonate<br />

6 Ventilator 40 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare V200 USA USD 0.00 18,230.00 729,200.00 70,294,880.00 13 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 1 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

7 Ventillator Transport 10 QFR Enterprise Aeonmed 510 China USD 0.00 2,000.00 20,000.00 1,928,000.00 1 Rejected, not tranport vent<br />

7 Ventillator Transport 10 Biotech Pakistan O-Two Medical ATV + Canada USD 0.00 6,000.00 60,000.00 5,784,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

7 Ventillator Transport 10 Noor International Smiths Medical Para PAC Plus UK GBP 0.00 3,850.00 38,500.00 5,953,255.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

7 Ventillator Transport 10 Hospicare Systems Newport HT70 Plus USA USD 0.00 6,300.00 63,000.00 6,073,200.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

7 Ventillator Transport 10 Bios Airon PNEUTON-A USA USD 0.00 6,950.00 69,500.00 6,699,800.00 5 Rejected - Tidal volume 360 to 1500 ML<br />

<strong>and</strong> pneumatic drive which makes it<br />

technicaly not a transport vent<br />

7 Ventillator Transport 10 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Siare SIRIO S2/T taly Euro 700,000 7,000,000.00 5,400.00 54,000.00 6,788,340.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

7 Ventillator Transport 10 Noor International H<strong>of</strong>frichter GmbH Carat II Germany Euro 0.00 6,250.00 62,500.00 7,856,875.00 7 Technically Accpetable<br />

7 Ventillator Transport 10 Hospicare Systems Siare Falco 101 Italy Euro 0.00 6,500.00 65,000.00 8,171,150.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

7 Ventillator Transport 10 Biotech Pakistan Care Fusion LTV 1000 USA USD 0.00 10,140.00 101,400.00 9,774,960.00 9 Rejected, not tranport vent<br />

7 Ventillator Transport 10 Mediurge AirLiquide Medical MONNAL T60<br />

Systems<br />

France Euro 0.00 8,690.00 86,900.00 10,924,199.00 10 Technically Acceptable<br />

7 Ventillator Transport 10 Artema Medical IMT Medical Bella Vista 1000 Switzerl<strong>and</strong> USD 0.00 11,550.00 115,500.00 11,134,200.00 11 Technically Acceptable<br />

7 Ventillator Transport 10 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Triology 202 USA USD 0.00 13,125.00 131,250.00 12,652,500.00 12 Technically Acceptable<br />

Category: Angiography<br />

8 Act Machine 2 Iqbal & Company ITC Hemoc Hron Response USA USD 693,315 1,386,630.00 5,783.00 11,566.00 1,114,962.40 1<br />

Item Dropped<br />

8 Act Machine 2 Medicore Instrumentation<br />

Laboratory<br />

Gem PCL Plus USA USD 0.00 5,795.00 11,590.00 1,117,276.00 2<br />

8 Act Machine 2 Medequips Actalye CAT-5755 USA USD 0.00 6,000.00 12,000.00 1,156,800.00 3<br />

8 Act Machine 2 ACP Systems Medtronics Act Plus USA PKR 800,000 1,600,000.00 800,000.00 1,600,000.00 1,600,000.00 4<br />

9 Angiography Machine 2 Medequips Toshiba INFX-8000F Japan USD 0.00 525,000.00 1,050,000.00 101,220,000.00 1<br />

Item Dropped<br />

9 Angiography Machine 2 Medequips Toshiba INFX-8000V Japan USD 0.00 545,000.00 1,090,000.00 105,076,000.00 2<br />

9 Angiography Machine 2 Sherazi Trading G.E. Annova 2100 Optima<br />

Edition<br />

USA 1 Year USD 0.00 623,600.00 1,247,200.00 120,230,080.00 3<br />

9 Angiography Machine 2 Seimens Seimens ARTIS Zee Floor Germany USD 0.00 707,000.00 1,414,000.00 136,309,600.00 4<br />

9 Angiography Machine 2 Technology Links Shimadzu Bransist Alexa - C12 Japan USD 0.00 791,000.00 1,582,000.00 152,504,800.00 5<br />

9 Angiography Machine 2 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Allura Xper FD10 Holl<strong>and</strong> USD 0.00 794,768.00 1,589,536.00 153,231,270.40 6<br />

10 Haemodynamic Monitor 2 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Xper Flex Cardio Holl<strong>and</strong> USD 0.00 48,900.00 97,800.00 9,427,920.00 1<br />

Item Dropped<br />

10 Haemodynamic Monitor 2 Medequips Mckesson Horizon Cardiology HEMO USA USD 0.00 49,500.00 99,000.00 9,543,600.00 2<br />

10 Haemodynamic Monitor 2 Seimens Seimens Axiom Sensis Lite Germany USD 0.00 58,500.00 117,000.00 11,278,800.00 3<br />

10 Haemodynamic Monitor 2 Sherazi Trading G.E. MAC LAB USA 1 Year USD 0.00 59,900.00 119,800.00 11,548,720.00 4<br />

10 Haemodynamic Monitor 2 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Xper Flex Cardio Holl<strong>and</strong> USD 0.00 99,945.00 199,890.00 19,269,396.00 5<br />

11 Portable Echo with TEE 2 Biotech Services Esaote S.p.a MyLab 30 CV Italy Euro 0.00 28,900.00 57,800.00 7,266,038.00 1<br />

11 Portable Echo with TEE 2 Biotech Pakistan Mindray DC-7 China USD 0.00 59,766.80 119,533.60 11,523,039.04 2<br />

11 Portable Echo with TEE 2 Sherazi Trading G.E. Logiq E USA USD 0.00 59,786.00 119,572.00 11,526,740.80 3<br />

11 Portable Echo with TEE 2 Biotech Pakistan Mindray M7 China USD 0.00 72,373.80 144,747.60 13,953,668.64 4<br />

11 Portable Echo with TEE 2 Seimens Seimens ACUSON X300 PE Germany USD 0.00 89,500.00 179,000.00 17,255,600.00 5<br />

11 Portable Echo with TEE 2 Sherazi Trading G.E. Vivid Q USA USD 0.00 95,786.00 191,572.00 18,467,540.80 6<br />

11 Portable Echo with TEE 2 Medequips Toshiba APLIO-400 Japan USD 0.00 96,750.00 193,500.00 18,653,400.00 7<br />

11 Portable Echo with TEE 2 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare HD11 XE Holl<strong>and</strong> USD 0.00 111,789.00 223,578.00 21,552,919.20 8<br />

11 Portable Echo with TEE 2 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare CX50 Holl<strong>and</strong> USD 0.00 148,262.00 296,524.00 28,584,913.60 9<br />

Item Dropped<br />

Page 2 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No<br />

Category: CSSD<br />

Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

12 CSSD 1 QFR Enterprise Laoken/Local China USD 0.00 123,300.00 123,300.00 11,886,120.00 1 Technically Accpetable, Prices for Washer<br />

disinfector <strong>and</strong> low heat plasma sterilzer<br />

are given in USD, Rest in @ PRK 1595000<br />

<strong>and</strong> should be included in total price<br />

12 CSSD 1 QFR Enterprise Laoken/Local China/Pak USD 0.00 136,725.00 136,725.00 13,180,290.00 2 Technically Accpetable Prices for Washer<br />

disinfector <strong>and</strong> low heat plasma sterilzer<br />

are given in USD, Rest in @ PRK 1595000<br />

<strong>and</strong> should be included in total price<br />

12 CSSD 1 Winmed Win<br />

Industries/Steel Co<br />

Italy/Pakistan PKR 12,014,000 12,014,000.00 12,014,000 12,014,000.00 12,014,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable but low heat<br />

sterilizer not quoted<br />

12 CSSD 1 Strongman Medical Strongman/Laoken China/Pak USD 0.00 78,000.00 78,000.00 7,519,200.00 4 Technically Acceptable - Prices for Washer<br />

disinfector <strong>and</strong> low heat plasma sterilzer<br />

are given in USD, Rest in @ PRK 6533000<br />

<strong>and</strong> should be included in total price<br />

12 CSSD 1 Summit Inter Trade Getinge/Hupfer/Jo<br />

hnson <strong>and</strong><br />

johnson<br />

12 CSSD 1 Radiant Medical Antonio Meta<br />

Chana<br />

Sweaden/Germa<br />

ny/USA/Pak<br />

Euro 0.00 200,460.00 200,460.00 25,199,826.60 5 Technically Acceptable USD 23900 for<br />

Autoscrub <strong>and</strong> PKR 950000 is for RO unit<br />

not included in main price<br />

Spain Euro 0.00 225,283.00 225,283.00 28,320,325.93 6 Technically Acceptable PKR 500000 for RO<br />

plan with water s<strong>of</strong>tner, Cleaning <strong>and</strong><br />

washing gun with sets <strong>of</strong> 8 nozzles included<br />

12 CSSD 1 Mediurge Steris Coop. Amsco Century Medium USA USD 0.00 384,500.00 384,500.00 37,065,800.00 7 Technically Accpetable<br />

Category: Medical Furniture<br />

13 Bed Intensive Care (Electrical) 20 Winmed Win Industries WM 5000 (Delux) Local PKR 142,500 2,850,000.00 142,500.00 2,850,000.00 2,850,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

13 Bed Intensive Care (Electrical) 20 Strongman Medical Strongman 230-EX-02 Local PKR 164,000 3,280,000.00 164,000 3,280,000.00 3,280,000.00 2 Rejected Non ABS head foot end<br />

13 Bed Intensive Care (Electrical) 20 Biotech Pakistan Hill Rom 405 USA USD 0.00 2,140.00 42,800.00 4,125,920.00 3 Conditionally Acceptable. No <strong>of</strong> motors not<br />

specified, IV pole not included<br />

13 Bed Intensive Care (Electrical) 20 Strongman Medical Strongman 238-EX-05 Local PKR 217,000 4,340,000.00 217,000 4,340,000.00 4,340,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

13 Bed Intensive Care (Electrical) 20 Medequips Paramount Bed PA-64205C-EX (Qualitas Japan USD 0.00 2,875.00 57,500.00 5,543,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

Co. Ltd.<br />

"B")<br />

13 Bed Intensive Care (Electrical) 20 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Piyar Group 4090 Iran USD 350,000 7,000,000.00 3,250.00 65,000.00 6,266,000.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

13 Bed Intensive Care (Electrical) 20 Radiant Medical Haelvoet Olympia II Belgium Euro 2,680.00 53,600.00 6,738,056.00 7 Technically Accpetable<br />

13 Bed Intensive Care (Electrical) 20 Radiant Medical Sigma Care E 640A Taiwan USD 3,600.00 72,000.00 6,940,800.00 8 Technically Accpetable<br />

13 Bed Intensive Care (Electrical) 20 Biotech Pakistan Hill Rom HR900 USA USD 0.00 3,670.00 73,400.00 7,075,760.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

13 Bed Intensive Care (Electrical) 20 T.K. medical<br />

Zongshan Aolike ALK06-B09P China USD 0.00 4,200.00 84,000.00 8,097,600.00 10 Technically Acceptable<br />

Instrument<br />

Medical<br />

13 Bed Intensive Care (Electrical) 20 Mediurge Linet Eleganza 3XC Czech<br />

Rpublic/Germany<br />

Euro 3,499.00 69,980.00 8,797,185.80 11 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 3 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

14 Bed Intensive Care (Hydrolic) 80 Biotech Pakistan Acare HCB M0032 China USD 0.00 600.00 48,000.00 4,627,200.00 1 Rejected, Manual Beds Quoted against<br />

Hydraulic<br />

14 Bed Intensive Care (Hydrolic) 80 T.K. medical<br />

Instrument<br />

Local Local PKR 126,000 10,080,000.00 126,000 10,080,000.00 10,080,000.00 2 Samples rejected<br />

14 Bed Intensive Care (Hydrolic) 80 Strongman Medical Strongman 225-H-00 Local PKR 133,000 10,640,000.00 133,000 10,640,000.00 10,640,000.00 3 Rejected Non ABS head foot end<br />

14 Bed Intensive Care (Hydrolic) 80 Winmed Win Industries WM 6000 Local PKR 134,500 10,760,000.00 134,500.00 10,760,000.00 10,760,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

14 Bed Intensive Care (Hydrolic) 80 Strongman Medical Strongman 225-HP-00 Local PKR 157,000 12,560,000.00 157,000 12,560,000.00 12,560,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

14 Bed Intensive Care (Hydrolic) 80 Biotech Pakistan Hill Rom 305 USA USD 0.00 1,745.00 139,600.00 13,457,440.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

14 Bed Intensive Care (Hydrolic) 80 Medequips Paramount Bed<br />

Co. Ltd.<br />

Japan USD 0.00 1,775.00 142,000.00 13,688,800.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

14 Bed Intensive Care (Hydrolic) 80 Radiant Medical Sigma Care B 850A Taiwan USD 0.00 1,994.00 159,520.00 15,377,728.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

14 Bed Intensive Care (Hydrolic) 80 Mediurge Linet Eleganza Smart Czech<br />

Rpublic/Germany<br />

Euro 0.00 2,160.00 172,800.00 21,722,688.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

14 Bed Intensive Care (Hydrolic) 80 Radiant Medical Haelvoet Olympia II Belgium Euro 0.00 2,680.00 214,400.00 26,952,224.00 10 Technically Acceptable<br />

15 Linen Trolley 20 T.K. medical<br />

Instrument<br />

Local Local PKR 19,000 380,000.00 19,000 380,000.00 380,000.00 1 Samples rejected<br />

15 Linen Trolley 20 Strongman Medical Strongman 345-LT-00 Local PKR 22,000 440,000.00 22,000 440,000.00 440,000.00 2 Samples rejected<br />

15 Linen Trolley 20 Winmed Win Industries LT 10 Local PKR 26,000 520,000.00 26,000.00 520,000.00 520,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

15 Linen Trolley 20 Strongman Medical Strongman Custom Local PKR 28,500 570,000.00 28,500 570,000.00 570,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

15 Linen Trolley 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-HK-350 Pakistan PKR 38,000 760,000.00 38,000 760,000.00 760,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

15 Linen Trolley 20 Mediurge CFS CLEAN (1110) Italy Euro 0.00 1,170.00 23,400.00 2,941,614.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

16 Cabinet Catherter 2 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro Pakistan PKR 63,333 126,666.00 63,333 126,666.00 126,666.00 1<br />

Item Dropped<br />

16 Cabinet Catherter 2 Strongman Medical Strongman 600-CC-00 Local PKR 80,000 160,000.00 80,000 160,000.00 160,000.00 2<br />

16 Cabinet Catherter 2 Mediurge InterMetro SXRD72SCATH1 USA USD 0.00 3,560.00 7,120.00 686,368.00 3<br />

17 Cabinet CD 2 Strongman Medical Strongman 620-CD-00 Local PKR 27,500 55,000.00 27,500 55,000.00 55,000.00 1<br />

Item Dropped<br />

17 Cabinet CD 2 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro Pakistan PKR 38,000 76,000.00 38,000 76,000.00 76,000.00 2<br />

17 Cabinet CD 2 Mediurge InterMetro SXRD72TU6 USA USD 0.00 2,895.00 5,790.00 558,156.00 3<br />

18 Cabinet Intrument 20 T.K. medical<br />

Instrument<br />

Local Local PKR 21,000 420,000.00 21,000 420,000.00 420,000.00 1 Samples rejected<br />

18 Cabinet Intrument 20 Strongman Medical Strongman 620-IC-00 Local PKR 27,500 550,000.00 27,500.00 550,000.00 550,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

18 Cabinet Intrument 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-HK-808 Pakistan PKR 55,733 1,114,660.00 55,733 1,114,660.00 1,114,660.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

18 Cabinet Intrument 20 Mediurge CFS V/140 Italy Euro 0.00 1,125.00 22,500.00 2,828,475.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

18 Cabinet Intrument 20 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 271.512 Germany Euro 0.00 2,525.00 50,500.00 6,348,355.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

19 Chair Anaethesthetist 9 Strongman Medical Strongman 310-KB Local PKR 5,500 49,500.00 5,500.00 49,500.00 49,500.00 1 Technically Acceptable. Qty. increased 10<br />

Nos.<br />

19 Chair Anaethesthetist 9 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-PR-4019 Pakistan PKR 19,000 171,000.00 19,000 171,000.00 171,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

19 Chair Anaethesthetist 9 Mediurge Midmark<br />

(Promotal)<br />

66-927 France Euro 0.00 550.00 4,950.00 622,264.50 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

19 Chair Anaethesthetist 9 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 222.01.167 Germany Euro 0.00 1,033.00 9,297.00 1,168,725.87 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 4 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

20 Locker Bedside 80 Faraz Associated M. Zafar Steel<br />

Furniture<br />

Pakistan PKR 7,400 592,000.00 7,400 592,000.00 592,000.00 1 Rejected. Sample not provided.<br />

20 Locker Bedside 80 Winmed Win Industries WM 100 Local PKR 8,000 640,000.00 8,000.00 640,000.00 640,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

20 Locker Bedside 80 Strongman Medical Strongman 106-BP-00 Local PKR 8,750 700,000.00 8,750 700,000.00 700,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

20 Locker Bedside 80 Biotech Pakistan Acare CV9000 China USD 0.00 98.00 7,840.00 755,776.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

20 Locker Bedside 80 T.K. medical<br />

Instrument<br />

Local Local PKR 11,300 904,000.00 11,300 904,000.00 904,000.00 5 Samples rejected<br />

20 Locker Bedside 80 Radiant Medical Sigma Care CA 002 Taiwan USD 0.00 123.00 9,840.00 948,576.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

20 Locker Bedside 80 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Medik Medical YA-0111A China USD 16,000 1,280,000.00 150.00 12,000.00 1,156,800.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

20 Locker Bedside 80 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-WF-560 Pakistan PKR 16,466 1,317,280.00 16,466 1,317,280.00 1,317,280.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

20 Locker Bedside 80 Biotech Pakistan Hill Rom BC251 USA USD 0.00 295.00 23,600.00 2,275,040.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

20 Locker Bedside 80 Radiant Medical Haelvoet Advance Belgium Euro 0.00 289.00 23,120.00 2,906,415.20 10 Technically Acceptable<br />

20 Locker Bedside 80 Mediurge Linet Spol. S r.o. Eleganza Classic Czech Republic Euro 0.00 395.00 31,600.00 3,972,436.00 11 Technically Acceptable<br />

21 Bedside Benches 80 Strongman Medical Strongman 120-SM-00 Local PKR 5,000 400,000.00 5,000.00 400,000.00 400,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

21 Bedside Benches 80 T.K. medical<br />

Instrument<br />

Local Local PKR 6,400 512,000.00 6,400 512,000.00 512,000.00 2 Samples rejected<br />

21 Bedside Benches 80 Strongman Medical Strongman 115-K-00 Local PKR 8,200 656,000.00 8,200 656,000.00 656,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

22 Patient Stool 20 Strongman Medical Strongman 310-KM-00 Local PKR 3,500 70,000.00 3,500.00 70,000.00 70,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

22 Patient Stool 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB=PR-412 Pakistan PKR 5,067 101,333.40 5,067 101,333.40 101,333.40 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

22 Patient Stool 20 T.K. medical<br />

Instrument<br />

Local Local PKR 6,200 124,000.00 6,200 124,000.00 124,000.00 3 Samples rejected<br />

22 Patient Stool 20 Winmed Win Industries WM 200PS Local PKR 8,500 170,000.00 8,500 170,000.00 170,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

22 Patient Stool 20 Mediurge CFS 14007-2 Italy Euro 0.00 340.00 6,800.00 854,828.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

23 Scrub Sink Single 5 Strongman Medical Strongman 570-KU-03 Local PKR 161,500 807,500.00 161,500 807,500.00 807,500.00 1 Samples rejected<br />

23 Scrub Sink Single 5 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-OT-820 Pakistan PKR 175,000 875,000.00 175,000 875,000.00 875,000.00 2 Samples rejected<br />

23 Scrub Sink Single 5 Strongman Medical Strongman 570-SU-03 Local PKR 180,500 902,500.00 180,500 902,500.00 902,500.00 3 Samples rejected<br />

23 Scrub Sink Single 5 Winmed Win Industries SS 2000 Local PKR 275,000 1,375,000.00 275,000.00 1,375,000.00 1,375,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

23 Scrub Sink Single 5 Radiant Medical Mac Medical SS32 IR USA USD 0.00 5,042.00 25,210.00 2,430,244.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

23 Scrub Sink Single 5 Mediurge ATOS 18003614 Surgical Sink 3 P-<br />

Knee Control<br />

Italy Euro 0.00 4,350.00 21,750.00 2,734,192.50 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

23 Scrub Sink Single 5 All Med Solution KLS Martin 2-093-3 Germany Euro 0.00 6,977.00 34,885.00 4,385,393.35 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

24 Table Overbed Cantilever Autorise 80 Radiant Medical Sigma Care SE 021 Taiwan USD 0.00 67.00 5,360.00 516,704.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

24 Table Overbed Cantilever Autorise 80 Winmed Win Industries WM 200 Local PKR 7,500 600,000.00 7,500.00 600,000.00 600,000.00 2 Slected due to Margin <strong>of</strong> Preference on<br />

local made product. Technically Acceptable<br />

24 Table Overbed Cantilever Autorise 80 Faraz Associated M. Zafar Steel<br />

Furniture<br />

Pakistan PKR 8,250 660,000.00 8,250 660,000.00 660,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

24 Table Overbed Cantilever Autorise 80 T.K. medical<br />

Instrument<br />

Local Local PKR 8,750 700,000.00 8,750 700,000.00 700,000.00 4 Samples rejected<br />

24 Table Overbed Cantilever Autorise 80 Biotech Pakistan Acare 300-CS China USD 0.00 98.00 7,840.00 755,776.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

24 Table Overbed Cantilever Autorise 80 Strongman Medical Strongman 108-H-00 Local PKR 10,500 840,000.00 10,500 840,000.00 840,000.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 5 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

24 Table Overbed Cantilever Autorise 80 Strongman Medical Strongman 108-HT-00 Local PKR 12,500 1,000,000.00 12,500 1,000,000.00 1,000,000.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

24 Table Overbed Cantilever Autorise 80 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-WF-630 Pakistan PKR 19,000 1,520,000.00 19,000 1,520,000.00 1,520,000.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

24 Table Overbed Cantilever Autorise 80 Biotech Pakistan Hill Rom OBT 634 USA USD 0.00 225.00 18,000.00 1,735,200.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

24 Table Overbed Cantilever Autorise 80 Radiant Medical Haelvoet Litavo Belgium Euro 0.00 252.00 20,160.00 2,534,313.60 10 Technically Acceptable<br />

24 Table Overbed Cantilever Autorise 80 Mediurge Linet Spol. S r.o. Solido Czech Republic Euro 0.00 330.00 26,400.00 3,318,744.00 11 Technically Acceptable<br />

25 Treatment Trolley 20 T.K. medical<br />

Instrument<br />

Local Local PKR 26,000 520,000.00 26,000 520,000.00 520,000.00 1 Samples rejected<br />

25 Treatment Trolley 20 Strongman Medical Strongman 414-DX-HT Local PKR 44,000 880,000.00 44,000 880,000.00 880,000.00 2 Samples rejected<br />

25 Treatment Trolley 20 Winmed Win Industries ER 1000 Local PKR 52,000 1,040,000.00 52,000.00 1,040,000.00 1,040,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

25 Treatment Trolley 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-WF-320 Pakistan PKR 114,000 2,280,000.00 114,000 2,280,000.00 2,280,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

25 Treatment Trolley 20 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 285.100/285.055/207.147 Germany Euro 0.00 2,923.00 58,460.00 7,349,006.60 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

25 Treatment Trolley 20 Mediurge Haus TED 461EMCST Horizon<br />

Multi.Purpose Stretcher<br />

USA USD 0.00 4,490.00 89,800.00 8,656,720.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

26 Trolley Anaesthesia 2<br />

Shelves/1Drawer<br />

9 Strongman Medical Strongman 510-TMD Local PKR 19,500 175,500.00 19,500 175,500.00 175,500.00 1 Samples rejected<br />

26 Trolley Anaesthesia 2<br />

9 T.K. medical<br />

Local Local PKR 22,000 198,000.00 22,000 198,000.00 198,000.00 2 Samples rejected<br />

Shelves/1Drawer<br />

Instrument<br />

26 Trolley Anaesthesia 2<br />

9 Winmed Win Industries WM 200I Local PKR 26,000 396,000.00 26,000.00 234,000.00 234,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable. Qty. increased 10<br />

Shelves/1Drawer<br />

Nos.<br />

26 Trolley Anaesthesia 2<br />

9 Paktech Instrument Hillbro Pakistan PKR 38,000 342,000.00 38,000 342,000.00 342,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

Shelves/1Drawer<br />

Co.<br />

26 Trolley Anaesthesia 2<br />

Shelves/1Drawer<br />

9 Mediurge CFS CFS 01 A (SPECIAL) Italy Euro 0.00 560.00 5,040.00 633,578.40 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

26 Trolley Anaesthesia 2<br />

Shelves/1Drawer<br />

9 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 232.03.522/200.03.246 Germany Euro 0.00 561.00 5,049.00 634,709.79 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

26 Trolley Anaesthesia 2<br />

Shelves/1Drawer<br />

9 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Medik Medical YA-AT7500IE China USD 110,000 990,000.00 1,025.00 9,225.00 889,290.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

27 Trolley General Purpose S.S. 20 Strongman Medical Strongman 510-TM-00 Local PKR 13,250 265,000.00 13,250 265,000.00 265,000.00 1 Sample not provided<br />

27 Trolley General Purpose S.S. 20 Faraz Associated M. Zafar Steel<br />

Furniture<br />

Pakistan PKR 14,400 288,000.00 14,400 288,000.00 288,000.00 2 Sample not provided<br />

27 Trolley General Purpose S.S. 20 T.K. medical<br />

Instrument<br />

Local Local PKR 19,800 396,000.00 19,800 396,000.00 396,000.00 3 Samples rejected<br />

27 Trolley General Purpose S.S. 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-OTE-410 Pakistan PKR 29,133 582,666.60 29,133 582,666.60 582,666.60 4 Samples rejected<br />

27 Trolley General Purpose S.S. 20 Winmed Win Industries WM 200I Local PKR 36,000 720,000.00 36,000.00 720,000.00 720,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

27 Trolley General Purpose S.S. 20 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 232.03.521 Germany Euro 0.00 453.00 9,060.00 1,138,932.60 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

27 Trolley General Purpose S.S. 20 Mediurge CFS CFS 01 F Italy Euro 0.00 560.00 11,200.00 1,407,952.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

28 Trolley Instrument Catheter S.S. 4 Strongman Medical Strongman 510-TXX Local PKR 35,000 140,000.00 35,000 140,000.00 140,000.00 1<br />

Item Dropped<br />

28 Trolley Instrument Catheter S.S. 4 Winmed Win Industries WM 200I Local PKR 45,000 180,000.00 45,000 180,000.00 180,000.00 2<br />

28 Trolley Instrument Catheter S.S. 4 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-0TE-410 Pakistan PKR 60,800 243,200.00 60,800 243,200.00 243,200.00 3<br />

28 Trolley Instrument Catheter S.S. 4 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 232.03.571 Germany Euro 0.00 522.00 2,088.00 262,482.48 4<br />

28 Trolley Instrument Catheter S.S. 4 Mediurge InterMetro MW108 USA USD 0.00 900.00 3,600.00 347,040.00 5<br />

Page 6 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

29 Trolley Medicine Ward Lockable<br />

LGE<br />

6 Strongman Medical Strongman 604-CT-05 Local PKR 32,500 195,000.00 32,500 195,000.00 195,000.00 1 Sample rejected<br />

29 Trolley Medicine Ward Lockable 6 Faraz Associated M. Zafar Steel<br />

Pakistan PKR 44,800 268,800.00 44,800 268,800.00 268,800.00 2 Sample not provided<br />

LGE<br />

Furniture<br />

29 Trolley Medicine Ward Lockable<br />

LGE<br />

6 Winmed Win Industries WM410 Local PKR 55,000 330,000.00 55,000.00 330,000.00 330,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

29 Trolley Medicine Ward Lockable 6 Paktech Instrument Hillbro HLB-WF-350 Pakistan PKR 88,667 532,000.02 88,667 532,000.02 532,000.02 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

LGE<br />

Co.<br />

29 Trolley Medicine Ward Lockable<br />

LGE<br />

6 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Medik Medical YA-MT7500IA China USD 110,000 660,000.00 1,025.00 6,150.00 592,860.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

29 Trolley Medicine Ward Lockable<br />

LGE<br />

6 Mediurge CFS UNIT DOSE Italy Euro 0.00 1,115.00 6,690.00 840,999.90 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

30 Trolley Patient Notes 3 Strongman Medical Strongman 616-RT-05 Local PKR 15,000 45,000.00 15,000.00 45,000.00 45,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

30 Trolley Patient Notes 3 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Caromed HS-02CHT25D China USD 65,000 195,000.00 575.00 1,725.00 166,290.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

30 Trolley Patient Notes 3 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro Pakistan PKR 63,333 189,999.99 63,333 189,999.99 189,999.99 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

30 Trolley Patient Notes 3 Mediurge CFS MINIDELTA Trolley Italy Euro 0.00 1,160.00 3,480.00 437,470.80 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

31 Trolley Patient<br />

Preparation/Dressing<br />

4 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 28,500 114,000.00 28,500.00 114,000.00 114,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

31 Trolley Patient<br />

4 Paktech Instrument Hillbro HLB-WF-345 Pakistan PKR 70,933 283,733.32 70,933 283,733.32 283,733.32 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

Preparation/Dressing<br />

Co.<br />

31 Trolley Patient<br />

Preparation/Dressing<br />

4 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Caromed MT-750 China USD 110,000 440,000.00 1,025.00 4,100.00 395,240.00 3 Rejected, SS required<br />

31 Trolley Patient<br />

Preparation/Dressing<br />

4 Mediurge CFS CFS 04 Italy Euro 0.00 990.00 3,960.00 497,811.60 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

31 Trolley Patient<br />

Preparation/Dressing<br />

4 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 260.031/202.300/202.347 Germany Euro 0.00 1,179.00 4,716.00 592,848.36 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

32 Trolley Plaster 4 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 28,500 114,000.00 28,500.00 114,000.00 114,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

32 Trolley Plaster 4 Strongman Medical Strongman 530-OT-00 Local PKR 44,000 176,000.00 44,000 176,000.00 176,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

32 Trolley Plaster 4 Mediurge CFS CFS 04 Italy Euro 0.00 990.00 3,960.00 497,811.60 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

32 Trolley Plaster 4 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 260.031/202.300/202.347 Germany Euro 0.00 1,179.00 4,716.00 592,848.36 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

32 Trolley Plaster 4 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-WF-345 Pakistan PKR 212,800 851,200.00 212,800 851,200.00 851,200.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

33 Trolley Patient Transfer-St<strong>and</strong>ard 20 Paktech Instrument Hillbro HLB-OTE-411 Pakistan PKR 81,067 1,621,333.40 81,067 1,621,333.40 1,621,333.40 1 Sample rejected<br />

Accessories<br />

Co.<br />

33 Trolley Patient Transfer-St<strong>and</strong>ard<br />

Accessories<br />

20 Strongman Medical Strongman 220-RH-02 Local PKR 87,000 1,740,000.00 87,000.00 1,740,000.00 1,740,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

33 Trolley Patient Transfer-St<strong>and</strong>ard<br />

Accessories<br />

33 Trolley Patient Transfer-St<strong>and</strong>ard<br />

Accessories<br />

33 Trolley Patient Transfer-St<strong>and</strong>ard<br />

Accessories<br />

33 Trolley Patient Transfer-St<strong>and</strong>ard<br />

Accessories<br />

20 Strongman Medical Strongman 220-RH-01 Local PKR 102,000 2,040,000.00 102,000 2,040,000.00 2,040,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

20 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Medik Medical YA-J2B China USD 130,000 2,600,000.00 1,075.00 21,500.00 2,072,600.00 4 Technicaly Acceptable<br />

20 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 285.100/285.050/207.147 Germany Euro 0.00 2,153.00 43,060.00 5,413,072.60 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

20 Mediurge CFS L0503-211 Italy Euro 0.00 2,330.00 46,600.00 5,858,086.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 7 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

34 Wheel Chair 10 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 13,500 135,000.00 13,500.00 135,000.00 135,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

34 Wheel Chair 10 Mediurge Vermeiren Delight 708 Belgium Euro 0.00 390.00 3,900.00 490,269.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

34 Wheel Chair 10 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro Pakistan PKR 304,000 3,040,000.00 304,000 3,040,000.00 3,040,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

35 Foot Step 100 Strongman Medical Strongman 331-AS-00 Local PKR 1,650 165,000.00 1,650 165,000.00 165,000.00 1 Sample rejected<br />

35 Foot Step 100 Faraz Associated M. Zafar Steel<br />

Furniture<br />

Pakistan PKR 2,400 240,000.00 2,400 240,000.00 240,000.00 2 Sample not provided<br />

35 Foot Step 100 T.K. medical<br />

Instrument<br />

Local Local PKR 2,500 250,000.00 2,500 250,000.00 250,000.00 3 Sample rejected<br />

35 Foot Step 100 Strongman Medical Strongman 331-AS-SS Local PKR 3,200 320,000.00 3,200 320,000.00 320,000.00 4 sample rejected<br />

35 Foot Step 100 Winmed Win Industries WM110 Local PKR 3,800 380,000.00 3,800.00 380,000.00 380,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

35 Foot Step 100 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-WF-740 Pakistan PKR 4,687 468,667.00 4,687 468,667.00 468,667.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

35 Foot Step 100 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-WF-750 Pakistan PKR 7,600 760,000.00 7,600 760,000.00 760,000.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

35 Foot Step 100 Mediurge CFS HT270 Italy Euro 0.00 90.00 9,000.00 1,131,390.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

35 Foot Step 100 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 251.05.101 Germany Euro 0.00 202.00 20,200.00 2,539,342.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

36 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> 20 Strongman Medical Strongman 327-SS-00 Local PKR 4,300 86,000.00 4,300 86,000.00 86,000.00 1 Sample rejected<br />

36 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> 20 Strongman Medical Strongman 326-BX-00 Local PKR 6,000 120,000.00 6,000.00 120,000.00 120,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

36 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-WF-725 Pakistan PKR 6,587 131,733.40 6,587 131,733.40 131,733.40 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

36 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> 20 Faraz Associated M. Zafar Steel<br />

Furniture<br />

Pakistan PKR 8,250 165,000.00 8,250 165,000.00 165,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

36 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> 20 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Medik Medical YA-12111 China USD 9,500 190,000.00 88.00 1,760.00 169,664.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

36 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> 20 Winmed Win Industries WMIV Local PKR 8,500 170,000.00 8,500 170,000.00 170,000.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

36 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> 20 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz 242.05.235 Germany Euro 0.00 258.00 5,160.00 648,663.60 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

36 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> 20 Mediurge CFS In-12122 Italy Euro 0.00 310.00 6,200.00 779,402.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

37 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> wall mounted 80 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 2,500 200,000.00 2,500 200,000.00 200,000.00 1 Sample rejected<br />

37 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> wall mounted 80 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-WF-730 Pakistan PKR 3,800 304,000.00 3,800 304,000.00 304,000.00 2 Sample rejected<br />

37 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> wall mounted 80 Winmed Win Industries WM/IV2 Local PKR 6,500 520,000.00 6,500.00 520,000.00 520,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

37 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> wall mounted 80 Faraz Associated M. Zafar Steel<br />

Furniture<br />

Pakistan PKR 8,250 660,000.00 8,250 660,000.00 660,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

37 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> wall mounted 80 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Local Local PKR 15,000 1,200,000.00 15,000 1,200,000.00 1,200,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

37 Infusion St<strong>and</strong> wall mounted 80 Mediurge CFS Italy Euro 0.00 220.00 17,600.00 2,212,496.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

Category: Hollow Wear<br />

38 Bedpan Perfection Patren S/S<br />

Adult<br />

20 Faraz Associated Sur-Med Pakistan PKR 2,000 40,000.00 2,000 40,000.00 40,000.00 1 Sample not provided<br />

38 Bedpan Perfection Patren S/S 20 Paktech Instrument Hillbro 81360-02 Pakistan PKR 2,160 43,200.00 2,160.00 43,200.00 43,200.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

Adult<br />

Co.<br />

38 Bedpan Perfection Patren S/S 20 Paktech Instrument OTINS Surgical PKR 2,308 46,153.80 2,308 46,153.80 46,153.80 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

Adult<br />

Co.<br />

38 Bedpan Perfection Patren S/S 20 Paktech Instrument Hillbro 81361-02 Pakistan PKR 2,400 2,400 48,000.00 48,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

Adult<br />

Co.<br />

38 Bedpan Perfection Patren S/S<br />

Adult<br />

20 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 4,000 80,000.00 4,000 80,000.00 80,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

39 Bucket 10 Litre Plastic 4 0.00 0.00 0.00 NOT QUOTED<br />

Page 8 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

40 Dish Kidney 30 Paktech Instrument Hillbro 81300-01 (150 x 75 x<br />

Pakistan PKR 272 11,520.00 272.00 8,160.00 8,160.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

Co.<br />

30mm)<br />

40 Dish Kidney 30 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro 81360-02 (200 x 35mm_ Pakistan PKR 384 13,153.80 384 11,520.00 11,520.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

40 Dish Kidney 30 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

OTINS Surgical Pakistan PKR 438 15,360.00 438 13,153.80 13,153.80 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

40 Dish Kidney 30 Paktech Instrument Hillbro 81360-03 (10", 250 x 120 Pakistan PKR 512 19,200.00 512 15,360.00 15,360.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

Co.<br />

x 40)<br />

40 Dish Kidney 30 Paktech Instrument Hillbro 81360-04 (300 x 155 x Pakistan PKR 640 21,600.00 640 19,200.00 19,200.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

Co.<br />

50mm)<br />

40 Dish Kidney 30 Faraz Associated Sur-Med Pakistan PKR 720 28,500.00 720 21,600.00 21,600.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

40 Dish Kidney 30 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 950 31,200.00 950 28,500.00 28,500.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

41 Jug Graduated S/S 1000ml 2 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro 81440-03 Pakistan PKR 1,040 2,080.00 1,040.00 2,080.00 2,080.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

41 Jug Graduated S/S 1000ml 2 Faraz Associated Sur-Med Pakistan PKR 1,360 2,720.00 1,360 2,720.00 2,720.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

41 Jug Graduated S/S 1000ml 2 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

OTINS Surgical Pakistan PKR 1,446 2,892.30 1,446 2,892.30 2,892.30 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

41 Jug Graduated S/S 1000ml 2 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 1,935 3,870.00 1,935 3,870.00 3,870.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

42 Jug Polyprop 500ml 2 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

OTINS Surgical Pakistan PKR 1,092 2,184.62 1,092.31 2,184.62 2,184.62 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

42 Jug Polyprop 500ml 2 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 1,585 3,170.00 1,585 3,170.00 3,170.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

43 Kick Bucket 12 Faraz Associated M. Zafar Steel<br />

Furniture<br />

Pakistan PKR 4,000 48,000.00 4,000 48,000.00 48,000.00 1 Sample not provided<br />

43 Kick Bucket 12 Strongman Medical Strongman 550-KB-00 Local PKR 6,000 72,000.00 6,000.00 72,000.00 72,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

43 Kick Bucket 12 Winmed Win Industries WM100KB Local PKR 7,500 90,000.00 7,500 90,000.00 90,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

43 Kick Bucket 12 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-OTE-413 Pakistan PKR 17,733 212,799.96 17,733 212,799.96 212,799.96 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

44 St<strong>and</strong> Bowl Double Horizontal 8 Faraz Associated M. Zafar Steel<br />

Furniture<br />

Pakistan PKR 5,600 44,800.00 5,600 44,800.00 44,800.00 1 Sample not provided<br />

44 St<strong>and</strong> Bowl Double Horizontal 8 Strongman Medical Strongman 555-BD-00 Local PKR 8,500 68,000.00 8,500.00 68,000.00 68,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable. Qty. increased 10<br />

Nos.<br />

44 St<strong>and</strong> Bowl Double Horizontal 8 Winmed Win Industries BS 200 Local PKR 10,500 84,000.00 10,500 84,000.00 84,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

44 St<strong>and</strong> Bowl Double Horizontal 8 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro Pakistan PKR 12,667 101,333.36 12,667 101,333.36 101,333.36 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

45 St<strong>and</strong> Bowl Single Horizontal 8 Faraz Associated M. Zafar Steel<br />

Furniture<br />

Pakistan PKR 4,000 32,000.00 4,000 32,000.00 32,000.00 1 Sample not provided<br />

45 St<strong>and</strong> Bowl Single Horizontal 8 Strongman Medical Strongman 555-DS-00 Local PKR 6,100 48,800.00 6,100.00 48,800.00 48,800.00 2 Technically Acceptable. Qty. increased 10<br />

Nos.<br />

45 St<strong>and</strong> Bowl Single Horizontal 8 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-OTR-900 Pakistan PKR 7,600 60,800.00 7,600 60,800.00 60,800.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

45 St<strong>and</strong> Bowl Single Horizontal 8 Winmed Win Industries BS 100 Local PKR 9,000 72,000.00 9,000 72,000.00 72,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

46 Table Mayo Height Adjustable 8 Faraz Associated M. Zafar Steel<br />

Furniture<br />

Pakistan PKR 7,200 57,600.00 7,200 57,600.00 57,600.00 1 Sample not provided<br />

46 Table Mayo Height Adjustable 8 Strongman Medical Strongman 540-MS-00 Local PKR 15,500 124,000.00 15,500 124,000.00 124,000.00 2 Sample rejected<br />

46 Table Mayo Height Adjustable 8 Winmed Win Industries WM 1000M Local PKR 18,000 144,000.00 18,000.00 144,000.00 144,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable. Qty. increased 10<br />

Nos.<br />

46 Table Mayo Height Adjustable 8 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

46 Table Mayo Height Adjustable 8 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro HLB-HK-807 Pakistan PKR 21,533 172,266.64 21,533 172,266.64 172,266.64 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

Hillbro Pakistan PKR 38,667 309,333.36 38,667 309,333.36 309,333.36 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 9 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

47 Tray Instrument 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro 81310-09 Pakistan PKR 1,200 24,000.00 1,200.00 24,000.00 24,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

47 Tray Instrument 20 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 1,390 27,800.00 1,390 27,800.00 27,800.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

47 Tray Instrument 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

OTINS Surgical Pakistan PKR 1,538 30,769.20 1,538 30,769.20 30,769.20 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

47 Tray Instrument 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro 81310-11 Pakistan PKR 1,840 36,800.00 1,840 36,800.00 36,800.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

47 Tray Instrument 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro 81312-09 Pakistan PKR 2,080 41,600.00 2,080 41,600.00 41,600.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

47 Tray Instrument 20 Faraz Associated Sur-Med Pakistan PKR 2,160 43,200.00 2,160 43,200.00 43,200.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

47 Tray Instrument 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro 81312-11 Pakistan PKR 3,040 60,800.00 3,040 60,800.00 60,800.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

48 Urinal Female S/S 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

OTINS Surgical male/female Pakistan PKR 962 19,230.80 961.54 19,230.80 19,230.80 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

48 Urinal Female S/S 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro 88.147.32 Pakistan PKR 1,200 24,000.00 1,200 24,000.00 24,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

48 Urinal Female S/S 20 Faraz Associated Sur-Med Pakistan PKR 1,680 33,600.00 1,680 33,600.00 33,600.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

48 Urinal Female S/S 20 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 1,800 36,000.00 1,800 36,000.00 36,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

49 Urinal Male S/S 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

OTINS Surgical male/female Pakistan PKR 962 19,230.80 961.54 19,230.80 19,230.80 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

49 Urinal Male S/S 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Hillbro 88.147.31 Pakistan PKR 1,200 24,000.00 1,200 24,000.00 24,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

49 Urinal Male S/S 20 Faraz Associated Sur-Med Pakistan PKR 1,680 33,600.00 1,680 33,600.00 33,600.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

49 Urinal Male S/S 20 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 1,800 36,000.00 1,800 36,000.00 36,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

50 Vomit Bowl with Lid 20 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 1,190 23,800.00 1,190.00 23,800.00 23,800.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

50 Vomit Bowl with Lid 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

50 Vomit Bowl with Lid 20 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Category: Hospital Equipment<br />

51 Analyser Blood Gas 3 A.M. Sales <strong>and</strong><br />

Services<br />

51 Analyser Blood Gas 3 Medicore Instrumentation<br />

Laboratory<br />

OTINS Surgical Pakistan PKR 1,923 38,461.60 1,923 38,461.60 38,461.60 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

Hillbro 81470-01/1230-02 Pakistan PKR 2,016 40,320.00 2,016 40,320.00 40,320.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

Nova Biomedical Satat pr<strong>of</strong>ile pHox Plus USA USD 0.00 5,500.00 16,500.00 1,590,600.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

5700 USA USD 0.00 12,770.00 38,310.00 3,693,084.00 2 Technically Acceptable Reagent Packs test<br />

IQM cartridges <strong>and</strong> CVP packs as optional<br />

item<br />

51 Analyser Blood Gas 3 Noor International Radiometer ABL 80 Denmark USD 0.00 13,000.00 39,000.00 3,759,600.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

51 Analyser Blood Gas 3 Noor International Radiometer ABL 800 Denmark USD 0.00 27,000.00 81,000.00 7,808,400.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

52 Baloon Pump 3 Iqbal & Company Aero Int. AutoCat 2 Wave USA USD 6,699,535 20,098,605.00 57,843.00 173,529.00 16,728,195.60 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

53 Sternum Saw 2 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Dimeda 33.326.05 Germany Euro 0.00 4,102.00 8,204.00 1,031,324.84 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

53 Sternum Saw 2 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Dimeda 33.308.35 Germany Euro 0.00 4,727.00 9,454.00 1,188,462.34 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

53 Sternum Saw 2 Med-Elec. Corp De Soutter DPX170 (Pneumatic) UK GBP 0.00 3,881.00 7,762.00 1,200,238.06 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

53 Sternum Saw 2 Fazal Din <strong>and</strong> Sons Conmed-Linvatec (Pneumatic) USA USD 0.00 6,667.00 13,334.00 1,285,397.60 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

53 Sternum Saw 2 Mediurge MicroAire Surgical<br />

Instruments<br />

USA USD 0.00 13,990.00 27,980.00 2,697,272.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

53 Sternum Saw 2 Sherazi Trading B Braun GB091R Germany Euro 0.00 10,873.00 21,746.00 2,733,689.66 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

53 Sternum Saw 2 Fazal Din <strong>and</strong> Sons Conmed-Linvatec (Electrical) USA USD 0.00 15,096.00 30,192.00 2,910,508.80 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

53 Sternum Saw 2 Med-Elec. Corp De Soutter RDX 600 (Electrical) UK GBP 0.00 9,882.00 19,764.00 3,056,107.32 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 10 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

54 Drill Set Orthopedic 2 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Dimeda 33.326.05 Germany Euro 0.00 8,029.00 16,058.00 2,018,651.18 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

54 Drill Set Orthopedic 2 Mediurge MicroAire Surgical<br />

Instruments<br />

USA USD 0.00 15,230.00 30,460.00 2,936,344.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

54 Drill Set Orthopedic 2 Fazal Din <strong>and</strong> Sons Aygun Turkey Euro 0.00 12,058.00 24,116.00 3,031,622.36 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

54 Drill Set Orthopedic 2 Med-Elec. Corp De Soutter MPX 610/DPX676 UK GBP 0.00 11,076.50 22,153.00 3,425,518.39 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

54 Drill Set Orthopedic 2 Sherazi Trading B Braun Acculan 3Ti Drill Germany Euro 0.00 21,035.00 42,070.00 5,288,619.70 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

55 Drill ENT 2 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Dimeda 39.112.00 Germany Euro 0.00 5,563.00 11,126.00 1,398,649.46 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

55 Drill ENT 2 Sherazi Trading B Braun MicroLAN 100 Germany Euro 0.00 7,000.00 14,000.00 1,759,940.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

55 Drill ENT 2 Mediurge MicroAire Surgical<br />

Instruments<br />

USA USD 0.00 9,900.00 19,800.00 1,908,720.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

55 Drill ENT 2 Endo Kare EG70339050 USD 0.00 11,828.00 23,656.00 2,280,438.40 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

55 Drill ENT 2 Fazal Din <strong>and</strong> Sons Conmed-Linvatec USA USD 0.00 12,354.00 24,708.00 2,381,851.20 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

55 Drill ENT 2 All Med Solution Karl Storz Karl Storz Drill ENT Germany Euro 0.00 10,696.00 21,392.00 2,689,188.32 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

56 Arthroscope System 1 Nasa Medical Corp. Mahe Germany Euro 0.00 24,291.00 24,291.00 3,053,621.61 1 Rejected, camera not HD<br />

56 Arthroscope System 1 Mediurge Ginni GmbH Germany Euro 0.00 39,786.00 39,786.00 5,001,498.06 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

56 Arthroscope System 1 Biologic Medical<br />

Systems<br />

Beholzer GmbH Germany Euro 0.00 44,150.00 44,150.00 5,550,096.50 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

56 Arthroscope System 1 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Dimeda 33.308.35 Germany Euro 0.00 55,049.00 55,049.00 6,920,209.79 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

56 Arthroscope System 1 Noor International LUT GmbH Arthroscope System Germany Euro 0.00 59,000.00 59,000.00 7,416,890.00 5 Rejected, camera model quoted not<br />

specified, Scopes not quoted<br />

56 Arthroscope System 1 All Med Solution Karl Storz Arthroscope System Germany Euro 0.00 77,235.00 77,235.00 9,709,211.85 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Nasa Medical Corp. Mahe Germany Euro 0.00 31,452.00 31,452.00 3,953,830.92 1 Technically Rejected.<br />

57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Mediurge Ginni GmbH Germany Euro 0.00 31,786.00 31,786.00 3,995,818.06 2 Technically Acceptable. Qty increased 2<br />

Nos.<br />

57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Dimeda Germany Euro 0.00 40,360.00 40,360.00 5,073,655.60 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Sherazi Trading B Braun Laproscope Germany Euro 0.00 47,553.00 47,553.00 5,977,887.63 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Biologic Medical Beholzer GmbH Germany Euro 0.00 63,714.00 63,714.00 8,009,486.94 5 Technically Acceptable - Instruments<br />

Systems<br />

quoted seperately for selection<br />

57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Noor International LUT GmbH Laproscope System Germany Euro 0.00 53,812.39 53,812.39 6,764,755.55 6 Rejected, camera not HD<br />

57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 All Med Solution Karl Storz Laproscopic Surgery<br />

System<br />

Germany Euro 0.00 56,307.00 56,307.00 7,078,352.97 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

57 Laproscopic Surgery System 1 Endo Kare Olympus Japan PKR 10,760,950 10,760,950.00 10,760,950 10,760,950.00 10,760,950.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Biologic Medical<br />

Systems<br />

Innomed Cardio 8 200B Hungry Euro 0.00 3,225.00 38,700.00 4,864,977.00 1 Technically Acceptable, crash cart local<br />

58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Hospicare Systems Primedic XD10 Germany Euro 0.00 4,500.00 54,000.00 6,788,340.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Biotech Pakistan Mindray AVALO + BeneHeart D3 China USD 0.00 6,570.00 78,840.00 7,600,176.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Medsis Life Point Pro Biphasic<br />

Defibrillator<br />

Turkey PKR 650,000 7,800,000.00 650,000 7,800,000.00 7,800,000.00 4 Rejected, no AED, No Pacemaker<br />

58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Sherazi Trading G.E. R2K USA USD 0.00 7,500.00 90,000.00 8,676,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Biotech Pakistan Caspa Solution <strong>and</strong> AVALO+LP20e<br />

Physio-Cintrol<br />

USA USD 0.00 7,750.00 93,000.00 8,965,200.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Hospicare Systems Primedic XD110 Germany Euro 0.00 6,200.00 74,400.00 9,352,824.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Bios Osatu/Hersill Reanibex-700/R-8002 Spain Euro 0.00 6,735.00 80,820.00 10,159,882.20 8 Technically acceptable with minor<br />

devoation in cart configuration.<br />

Defibrilator Rejected as pacing <strong>and</strong><br />

memory not quoted<br />

Page 11 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Radiant Medical Water Loo USRLA3369 M-Series USA USD 0.00 10,252.00 123,024.00 11,859,513.60 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

58 Crash Cart with Defib biphasic 12 Medequips Nihon<br />

Kohde/Armstrong<br />

Medical<br />

PAPE-1/TEC-5531K Japan/USA USD 0.00 11,080.00 132,960.00 12,817,344.00 10 Technically Acceptable<br />

59 Defibrillator - AED 12 La Computa Vision Anjue Medical<br />

Equipment Co.<br />

AED 7000 China USD 0.00 1,400.00 16,800.00 1,619,520.00 1 Rejected. Chinese origin. No FDA approved.<br />

59 Defibrillator - AED 12 Biotech Pakistan Physio-Control LP-1000 USA USD 0.00 1,890.00 22,680.00 2,186,352.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

59 Defibrillator - AED 12 La Computa Vision Yangzhou guo Tai 8000B, Defi Monitor,<br />

China USD 0.00 3,200.00 38,400.00 3,701,760.00 3 Rejected, not AED<br />

Co.<br />

Desktop<br />

59 Defibrillator - AED 12 Artema Medical Innomed Cardio 8 360B Hungry Euro 0.00 3,500.00 42,000.00 5,279,820.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

59 Defibrillator - AED 12 Sherazi Trading G.E. R-AED USA USD 0.00 5,100.00 61,200.00 5,899,680.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

59 Defibrillator - AED 12 Bios Osatu Reanibex-700 Spain Euro 0.00 4,290.00 51,480.00 6,471,550.80 6 Technically accpetable<br />

59 Defibrillator - AED 12 Radiant Medical Zoll AED Pro USA USD 0.00 6,190.00 74,280.00 7,160,592.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

59 Defibrillator - AED 12 Medequips Nihon Kohden TEC-5531K Japan USD 0.00 6,500.00 78,000.00 7,519,200.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

59 Defibrillator - AED 12 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Heart Start XL+ Europe USD 0.00 7,292.00 87,504.00 8,435,385.60 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

60 Diagnostic Set 40 La Computa Vision Medico Industries China PKR 9,744 389,760.00 9,744 389,760.00 389,760.00 1 Sample not provided.<br />

60 Diagnostic Set 40 Biologic Medical F. Bosch Diagnostic Germany Euro 0.00 85.00 3,400.00 427,414.00 2 Rejected. F Bocsh does not make<br />

Systems<br />

diagnostic sets<br />

60 Diagnostic Set 40 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 22,500 900,000.00 22,500 900,000.00 900,000.00 3 Rejected, local<br />

60 Diagnostic Set 40 Latif Brothers Neitz BX-Alpha-134 Japan JPY 0.00 43,900.00 1,756,000.00 2,053,115.20 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

60 Diagnostic Set 40 Mediurge Riester GmbH 3744-550 RI-SCOPE L<br />

Otoscope/Opthalposcope<br />

Germany Euro 0.00 465.00 18,600.00 2,338,206.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

60 Diagnostic Set 40 Biotech Pakistan Welch Allyn USA USD 0.00 680.00 27,200.00 2,622,080.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

60 Diagnostic Set 40 Ameer Din<br />

Instruments<br />

Heine K180 Germany PKR 68,750 2,750,000.00 68,750 2,750,000.00 2,750,000.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

61 External Pace Maker Single<br />

Chamber<br />

12 Med-Elec. Corp FIAB S.p.a. 4427 Italy Euro 0.00 900.00 10,800.00 1,357,668.00 1 Rejected, no details given<br />

61 External Pace Maker Single 12 Radiant Medical APC Cardio EV-4543 UK/USA GBP 0.00 798.00 9,576.00 1,480,736.88 2 Technically Acceptable. However Single<br />

Chamber<br />

Vascular<br />

Chamber. Package price is higher then<br />

Limited/Oace<br />

Medical<br />

Medtronics.<br />

61 External Pace Maker Single<br />

Chamber<br />

12 ACP Systems Medtronics 5348 USA PKR 140,000 1,680,000.00 140,000.00 1,680,000.00 1,680,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

61 External Pace Maker Single<br />

Chamber<br />

62 External Pace Maker Dual<br />

Chamber<br />

62 External Pace Maker Dual<br />

Chamber<br />

62 External Pace Maker Dual<br />

Chamber<br />

12 Medil<strong>and</strong> Pakistan Maquet Getinge<br />

Group<br />

T10 Germany Euro 0.00 1,899.00 22,788.00 2,864,679.48 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

4 ACP Systems Medtronics 5388 USA PKR 325,000 1,300,000.00 325,000.00 1,300,000.00 1,300,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

4 Medil<strong>and</strong> Pakistan Maquet Getinge<br />

Group<br />

4 Radiant Medical APC Cardio<br />

Vascular<br />

Limited/Oace<br />

Medical<br />

T20 Germany Euro 0.00 2,800.00 11,200.00 1,407,952.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

Micro-Pace EP=4580 UK/USA GBP 0.00 3,085.00 12,340.00 1,908,134.20 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 12 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Noor International Doctor.Mach<br />

GmbH<br />

Mach 115 (Helogen) Germany Euro 0.00 550.00 4,400.00 553,124.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Biologic Medical<br />

Systems<br />

Acem StarLED1 Evo Italy Euro 0.00 595.00 4,760.00 598,379.60 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Biotech Pakistan Welch Allyn GS-600 44605** USA USD 0.00 970.00 7,760.00 748,064.00 3 Technically Acceptable (LED)<br />

63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 QFR Enterprise ORDISI L21-25R Spain Euro 0.00 1,400.00 11,200.00 1,407,952.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Hoora Pharma Maquet Blue 30 MOB France Euro 0.00 1,419.00 11,352.00 1,427,059.92 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 All Med Solution KLS Martin Germany Euro 0.00 2,160.00 17,280.00 2,172,268.80 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Technology Links Trilux AURINIO L50 SD Mobile Germany Euro 0.00 2,200.00 17,600.00 2,212,496.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Radiant Medical Trumpf Truelight-1000 Germany Euro 0.00 2,353.00 18,824.00 2,366,365.04 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Mediurge Derungs Licht AG D med Triango 30 F Switzerl<strong>and</strong> Swiss Franc 0.00 3,995.00 31,960.00 3,331,190.80 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

63 Lamp Examination Mobile 8 Ameer Din<br />

Instruments<br />

Heine HL5000 Germany PKR 67,000 536,000.00 67,000 536,000.00 536,000.00 10 Technically Acceptable<br />

64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 QFR Enterprise ORDISI FLH2310 Spain Euro 0.00 125.00 2,500.00 314,275.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Biologic Medical<br />

Systems<br />

Burtom Medical LE35 USA USD 0.00 320.00 6,400.00 616,960.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Noor International Doctor.Mach<br />

GmbH<br />

Makrolux Germany Euro 0.00 300.00 6,000.00 754,260.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Biotech Pakistan Welch Allyn GS-300 44415** USA USD 0.00 435.00 8,700.00 838,680.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Ameer Din<br />

Instruments<br />

Heine HL1200 Germany PKR 43,000 860,000.00 43,000 860,000.00 860,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Mediurge Derungs Licht AG D med Oculux 12PLX Switzerl<strong>and</strong> Swiss Franc 0.00 1,350.00 27,000.00 2,814,210.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Hoora Pharma Maquet Blue 30 W France Euro 0.00 1,976.00 39,520.00 4,968,059.20 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

64 Lamp Examination Wall Mounted 20 Technology Links Trilux AURINIO L50 SD Mobile Germany Euro 0.00 2,200.00 44,000.00 5,531,240.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

65 Nebuliser Heavy Duty 2 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Philips Respironics 90543 China USD 0.00 31.50 63.00 6,073.20 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

65 Nebuliser Heavy Duty 2 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Philips Respironics Pro China USD 0.00 47.00 94.00 9,061.60 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

65 Nebuliser Heavy Duty 2 Mediurge HIRTZ & Co GmbH HICO-Ultrasonet 810 Germany Euro 0.00 899.00 1,798.00 226,026.58 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

66 Nebuliser Ultrasonic 8 Mediurge HIRTZ & Co GmbH HICO-Ultrasonet 810 Germany Euro 0.00 1,225.00 9,800.00 1,231,958.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

66 Nebuliser Ultrasonic 8 Hoora Pharma Maquet U 910 Germany Euro 0.00 1,562.00 12,496.00 1,570,872.16 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

68 Pump Syring 100 QFR Enterprise Beijing XinFeng<br />

Medical<br />

Tecgnology<br />

FA312 China USD 0.00 300.00 30,000.00 2,892,000.00 1 Rejected. Chineses origin.<br />

68 Pump Syring 100 Bios SINOMDT SN-50C6 China USD 0.00 345.00 34,500.00 3,325,800.00 2 Technicaly accpetable. However, not<br />

considered due to chinese origin.<br />

68 Pump Syring 100 Biotech Pakistan Mindray SK500II China USD 0.00 500.00 50,000.00 4,820,000.00 3 Rejected. Chineses origin.<br />

68 Pump Syring 100 Ittefaq Sons Advanced SP-100S USA USD 0.00 771.40 77,140.00 7,436,296.00 4 Technically Acceptable but no installed<br />

base<br />

68 Pump Syring 100 B. Braun Sharing<br />

Expertise<br />

B.Braun Perfusor Compact S Germany USD 0.00 850.00 85,000.00 8,194,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

68 Pump Syring 100 Noor International Top Coop. Top-5300 Japan USD 0.00 900.00 90,000.00 8,676,000.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

68 Pump Syring 100 Hospicare Systems Medima S Pol<strong>and</strong> Euro 0.00 725.00 72,500.00 9,113,975.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

68 Pump Syring 100 Mediurge FRESENIUS Injectomat Aglia France Euro 0.00 765.00 76,500.00 9,616,815.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

68 Pump Syring 100 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Viltechmeda SEP 10S Europe Euro 110,000 11,000,000.00 790.00 79,000.00 9,931,090.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 13 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

68 Pump Syring 100 Medequips Atom Medical<br />

Corp.<br />

S-1235 Japan JPY 0.00 107,100.00 10,710,000.00 12,522,132.00 10 Technically Acceptable<br />

68 Pump Syring 100 Radiant Medical CME T34L Germany Euro 0.00 1,081.00 108,100.00 13,589,251.00 11 Technically Acceptable<br />

69 Pump Volumetric Infusion 100 Bios SINOMDT SN-1800 China USD 0.00 450.00 45,000.00 4,338,000.00 1 Meets the specs. However, not considered<br />

due to chinese origin.<br />

69 Pump Volumetric Infusion 100 QFR Enterprise Beijing XinFeng<br />

Medical<br />

Tecgnology<br />

SA212 China USD 0.00 530.00 53,000.00 5,109,200.00 2 Rejected. Chineses origin.<br />

69 Pump Volumetric Infusion 100 Biotech Pakistan Mindray SK600II China USD 0.00 550.00 55,000.00 5,302,000.00 3 Rejected. Chineses origin.<br />

69 Pump Volumetric Infusion 100 Ittefaq Sons Advanced IP-100 USA USD 0.00 750.40 75,040.00 7,233,856.00 4 Technically Acceptable but no installed<br />

base<br />

69 Pump Volumetric Infusion 100 B. Braun Sharing<br />

Expertise<br />

B.Braun Infusomat P Germany USD 0.00 1,070.00 107,000.00 10,314,800.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

69 Pump Volumetric Infusion 100 Noor International Top Coop. Top-3300 Japan USD 0.00 1,075.00 107,500.00 10,363,000.00 6 Technicaly accpetable.<br />

69 Pump Volumetric Infusion 100 Hospicare Systems Moog DF12 Lithuania Euro 0.00 875.00 87,500.00 10,999,625.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

69 Pump Volumetric Infusion 100 Medequips Atom Medical<br />

Corp.<br />

P-600 Japan JPY 0.00 99,800.00 9,980,000.00 11,668,616.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

69 Pump Volumetric Infusion 100 Mediurge FRESENIUS Volumat Aglia France Euro 0.00 1,010.00 101,000.00 12,696,710.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

69 Pump Volumetric Infusion 100 Radiant Medical CME CMExpress Germany Euro 0.00 1,031.00 103,100.00 12,960,701.00 10 Technically acceptable<br />

70 Resuscitation Bag Adult 20 Mediurge VBM GmbH Germany Euro 0.00 255.00 5,100.00 641,121.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

70 Resuscitation Bag Adult 20 Faraz Associate Mercury Medical USA/Malysia PKR 2,640 52,800.00 2,640.00 52,800.00 52,800.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

71 Resuscitation Bag Child 10 Faraz Associate Mercury Medical USA/Malysia PKR 2,640 26,400.00 2,640.00 26,400.00 26,400.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

71 Resuscitation Bag Child 10 Mediurge VBM GmbH Germany Euro 0.00 215.00 2,150.00 270,276.50 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

72 Ripple Mattress with Motor 10 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Clearview RC202 Korea USD 0.00 47.00 470.00 45,308.00 1 Rejected, not a ripple mattress<br />

72 Ripple Mattress with Motor 10 Mediurge Hirtz & Co HICO DECUBIMAT 370 Germany Euro 0.00 725.00 7,250.00 911,397.50 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

72 Ripple Mattress with Motor 10 Biotech Pakistan Hill Rom P-280 USA USD 0.00 1,650.00 16,500.00 1,590,600.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

73 ScalePatient W/Height<br />

10 Paktech Instrument<br />

China PKR 28,000 280,000.00 28,000.00 280,000.00 280,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

Measurement<br />

Co.<br />

73 ScalePatient W/Height<br />

Measurement<br />

74 Sphygmomanometer Anaeroid<br />

Wall Type<br />

74 Sphygmomanometer Anaeroid<br />

Wall Type<br />

74 Sphygmomanometer Anaeroid<br />

Wall Type<br />

74 Sphygmomanometer Anaeroid<br />

Wall Type<br />

74 Sphygmomanometer Anaeroid<br />

Wall Type<br />

74 Sphygmomanometer Anaeroid<br />

Wall Type<br />

10 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

40 Ameer Din<br />

Instruments<br />

Seca 755 Germany PKR 84,000 840,000.00 84,000 840,000.00 840,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

Heine GammaXXL Germany PKR 21,000 840,000.00 21,000.00 0.00 0.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

40 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Certeza CR2004 China USD 0.00 20.00 800.00 77,120.00 2 Technically Acceptable (Sample required)<br />

40 Biologic Medical<br />

Systems<br />

F. Bosch Maximed W Germany Euro 0.00 90.00 3,600.00 452,556.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

40 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Penlon Sphygmomanometer<br />

Anaeroid Wall Type<br />

UK GBP 16,000 640,000.00 90.00 3,600.00 556,668.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

40 Medicore WA Baum O950 USA PKR 21,500 860,000.00 21,500 860,000.00 860,000.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

40 Mediurge Riester GmbH 1459 40 Big Ben Germany Euro 0.00 190.00 7,600.00 955,396.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 14 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

75 Sphygmomanometer Mercurial 10 Muslim Medical Certeza CR-2003 China USD 0.00 60.00 600.00 57,840.00 1 Technically Acceptable.<br />

Mobile<br />

Services<br />

75 Sphygmomanometer Mercurial 10 Biologic Medical F. Bosch Maximed S Germany Euro 0.00 140.00 1,400.00 175,994.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

Mobile<br />

Systems<br />

75 Sphygmomanometer Mercurial<br />

Mobile<br />

10 Mediurge Riester GmbH Empire (Floor Design) Germany Euro 0.00 299.00 2,990.00 375,872.90 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

75 Sphygmomanometer Mercurial<br />

Mobile<br />

10 Medicore WA Baum O250 USA PKR 55,500 555,000.00 55,500 555,000.00 555,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

76 Stethoscope 100 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Certeza CR3002 China USD 0.00 2.00 200.00 19,280.00 1 Technically Acceptable.<br />

76 Stethoscope 100 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Gowl<strong>and</strong> 9-8890 China PKR 313 31,333.00 313 31,333.00 31,333.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

76 Stethoscope 100 Medicore WA Baum 2700 USA PKR 2,400 240,000.00 2,400 240,000.00 240,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

76 Stethoscope 100 Faraz Associate Pakistan/China PKR 4,000 400,000.00 4,000 400,000.00 400,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

76 Stethoscope 100 Mediurge Riester GmbH Duplex de lux 4061-01 Germany Euro 0.00 75.00 7,500.00 942,825.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

76 Stethoscope 100 Ameer Din<br />

Instruments<br />

Heine Gama 3.1 Germany PKR 3,995 399,500.00 3,995 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

77 Suction Unit 20 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Smaf YX940D China USD 0.00 275.00 5,500.00 530,200.00 1 Rejected. Glass bottles<br />

77 Suction Unit 20 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Smaf YX980D China USD 0.00 500.00 10,000.00 964,000.00 2 Technically Accpetable.<br />

77 Suction Unit 20 Biologic Medical<br />

Systems<br />

Techno-GAZ TECNO-40 Italy Euro 0.00 550.00 11,000.00 1,382,810.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

77 Suction Unit 20 Bios Hersill Euro VAC H-40 Spain Euro 0.00 679.00 13,580.00 1,707,141.80 4 Techncally Acceptable with minor<br />

deviation in vacuum @ 650 instead <strong>of</strong> 700<br />

mmHg<br />

77 Suction Unit 20 Mediurge Hersill Euro VAC H-40 Spain Euro 0.00 975.00 19,500.00 2,451,345.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

77 Suction Unit 20 QFR Enterprise ORDISI FV-1220SH Spain Euro 0.00 1,050.00 21,000.00 2,639,910.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

77 Suction Unit 20 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers MG Electric SAM-35 UK GBP 160,000 3,200,000.00 970.00 19,400.00 2,999,822.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

77 Suction Unit 20 T.K. medical<br />

Instrument<br />

Techno-GAZ TECNO-40 Italy Euro 0.00 1,550.00 31,000.00 3,897,010.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

77 Suction Unit 20 Noor International Medela AG Dominant 50 Switzerl<strong>and</strong> Swiss Franc 0.00 2,850.00 57,000.00 5,941,110.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

77 Suction Unit 20 Hoora Pharma Maquet 2080 Germany Euro 0.00 2,953.00 59,060.00 7,424,432.60 10 Technically Accpetable<br />

78 Thermal Blankets (For<br />

hypothermia Treatment)<br />

10 Medica Sorin Group GmbH 16-10-51 Peads Germany Euro 0.00 418.00 4,180.00 525,467.80 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

78 Thermal Blankets (For<br />

hypothermia Treatment)<br />

10 Medica Sorin Group GmbH 16-10-50 adult Germany Euro 0.00 428.00 4,280.00 538,038.80 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

78 Thermal Blankets (For<br />

10 Medil<strong>and</strong> Pakistan CSZ Cincinati Sub Warm Air 135 USA USD 0.00 4,000.00 40,000.00 3,856,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

hypothermia Treatment)<br />

Zero<br />

78 Thermal Blankets (For<br />

hypothermia Treatment)<br />

10 Mediurge Stihler Electronics Austopad Germany Euro 0.00 6,290.00 62,900.00 7,907,159.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

79 Tourniquet Pneumatic 4 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Dimeda 33.101.01 Germany Euro 0.00 223.00 892.00 112,133.32 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

79 Tourniquet Pneumatic 4 Mediurge VBM GmbH 19-22-500 Tourniquet<br />

4500<br />

Germany Euro 0.00 2,090.00 8,360.00 1,050,935.60 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

79 Tourniquet Pneumatic 4 Fazal Din <strong>and</strong> Sons Hammar Plast<br />

Medical<br />

Sweaden Euro 0.00 3,001.00 12,004.00 1,509,022.84 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

79 Tourniquet Pneumatic 4 Bios Ulrich Elsa-UT1380 Germany Euro 0.00 3,410.00 13,640.00 1,714,684.40 4 Techncaillcy acceptable with minor<br />

deviation as manual override is not<br />

provided<br />

Page 15 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

80 Tourniquet Quick Release 10 Mediurge VBM GmbH 20-30-100 Tourniquet<br />

Tourny III<br />

Germany Euro 0.00 20.00 200.00 25,142.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

80 Tourniquet Quick Release 10 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

81 Vascular Doppler 1 Biologic Medical<br />

System<br />

Dimeda 33.101.01 Germany Euro 0.00 76.00 760.00 95,539.60 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

Huntleigh MD-2 UK GBP 0.00 1,145.00 1,145.00 177,051.35 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

81 Vascular Doppler 1 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Huntleigh Dopplex 200 UK GBP 500,000 500,000.00 2,950.00 2,950.00 456,158.50 2 Rejected, probes not quoted<br />

82 Warmer Blood Dry Heat Type 10 Radiant Medical Barkey S-Line Germany Euro 0.00 1,126.00 11,260.00 1,415,494.60 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

82 Warmer Blood Dry Heat Type 10 Hospicare Systems Nuova Nuova 05 Germany Euro 0.00 1,150.00 11,500.00 1,445,665.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

82 Warmer Blood Dry Heat Type 10 Biotech Pakistan Biegler BW685 Austria Euro 0.00 1,190.00 11,900.00 1,495,949.00 3 Rejected, uses disposable dedicated set<br />

82 Warmer Blood Dry Heat Type 10 Mediurge Stihler Electronics ASTOTHERM Plus Germany Euro 0.00 1,840.00 18,400.00 2,313,064.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

82 Warmer Blood Dry Heat Type 10 Sherazi Trading G.E. EnFlo USA USD 0.00 2,786.00 27,860.00 2,685,704.00 5 Rejected, uses disposable dedicated set<br />

Category: Monitoring<br />

83 Central Station 5 Nasa Medical Corp. Comen STAR 8800 China USD 0.00 1,350.00 6,750.00 650,700.00 1 Rejected, not wireless<br />

83 Central Station 5 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Biolight M6000C China USD 0.00 2,000.00 10,000.00 964,000.00 2 Rejected, not FDA approved.<br />

83 Central Station 5 Biologic Medical<br />

System<br />

Lutech Goldway USA USD 0.00 2,450.00 12,250.00 1,180,900.00 3 Rejected. No data no model for central<br />

station, based on PC <strong>and</strong> s<strong>of</strong>tware, wireless<br />

connectivity not possible<br />

83 Central Station 5 Biotech Pakistan Mindray Hyper Visor VI China USD 0.00 4,345.00 21,725.00 2,094,290.00 4 Techncailllay acceptable<br />

83 Central Station 5 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare UT4800 China USD 0.00 7,211.00 36,055.00 3,475,702.00 5 Rejected, hard wire connectivity<br />

83 Central Station 5 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Intelli VUE M3 140 Europe USD 0.00 9,479.00 47,395.00 4,568,878.00 6 Rejected, hard wire connectivity<br />

83 Central Station 5 Sherazi Trading G.E. i-Centeral USA USD 0.00 16,786.00 83,930.00 8,090,852.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

83 Central Station 5 Medequips Nihon Kohden CNS-9601K Japan USD 0.00 26,800.00 134,000.00 12,917,600.00 8 Rejected - for 16 beds only otherwise<br />

Technicaly OK with wireless networking<br />

84 Pulse Oximeter 20 Ittefaq Sons Advanced PO-100B USA USD 0.00 280.00 5,600.00 539,840.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

84 Pulse Oximeter 20 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Biolight M800 China USD 0.00 450.00 9,000.00 867,600.00 2 Technically Acceptable (h<strong>and</strong> held)<br />

84 Pulse Oximeter 20 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Biolight V6 China USD 0.00 525.00 10,500.00 1,012,200.00 3 Technically Acceptable (vital sign monitor)<br />

84 Pulse Oximeter 20 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare G3 China USD 652.00 13,040.00 1,257,056.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

84 Pulse Oximeter 20 T.K. medical<br />

Instrument<br />

Charmcare Accuro Korea USD 0.00 690.00 13,800.00 1,330,320.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

84 Pulse Oximeter 20 Artema Medical Innomed Accuro Hungry Euro 700.00 14,000.00 1,759,940.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

84 Pulse Oximeter 20 Radiant Medical Nonin Medical PulseSense USA USD 0.00 1,177.00 23,540.00 2,269,256.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

84 Pulse Oximeter 20 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Dixtal Novametrix 520A USA USD 120,000 2,400,000.00 1,200.00 24,000.00 2,313,600.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

84 Pulse Oximeter 20 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Sure Sign VMI Europe USD 1,385.00 27,700.00 2,670,280.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

84 Pulse Oximeter 20 Sherazi Trading G.E. Truset USA USD 0.00 1,486.00 29,720.00 2,865,008.00 10 Technically Acceptable<br />

84 Pulse Oximeter 20 Biotech Pakistan Mindray VS-800 China USD 0.00 700.00 5,600.00 539,840.00 11 Technically Acceptable<br />

84 Pulse Oximeter 20 Hospicare Systems Nelcor N600X USA USD 13,500.00 270,000.00 26,028,000.00 12 Technically Acceptable<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with<br />

Trolly<br />

8 La Computa Vision Nihon Kohden Cardi<strong>of</strong>ax S USA/Japan PKR 0.00 2,588.00 20,704.00 20,704.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with<br />

Trolly<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with<br />

Trolly<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with<br />

Trolly<br />

8 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Biolight E70 China USD 0.00 1,000.00 8,000.00 771,200.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

8 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Dong Jiang ECG1220 China USD 0.00 1,200.00 9,600.00 925,440.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

8 La Computa Vision Shenzhen Jumper<br />

Medical<br />

Equipment<br />

JPD-E12 wih trolley China USD 0.00 1,459.00 11,672.00 1,125,180.80 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 16 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with 8 T.K. medical<br />

Aspel Ascard MR.Grey V.001 Pol<strong>and</strong> Euro 0.00 1,130.00 9,040.00 1,136,418.40 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

Trolly<br />

Instrument<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with 8 Biologic Medical Labtech EC-12RT Hungry Euro 0.00 1,195.00 9,560.00 1,201,787.60 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

Trolly<br />

SYstem<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with<br />

Trolly<br />

8 Artema Medical Innomed Heart Screen 80G-L Hungry Euro 0.00 1,200.00 9,600.00 1,206,816.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with<br />

Trolly<br />

8 Bios BTL BTL-08 MT-Plus Europe Euro 0.00 1,250.00 10,000.00 1,257,100.00 8 Technically Acceptable, local trolley,<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with<br />

Trolly<br />

8 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Aspel Ascard MR.Grey V.201 Pol<strong>and</strong> Euro 185,000 1,480,000.00 1,290.00 10,320.00 1,297,327.20 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with<br />

Trolly<br />

8 Nasa Medical Corp. Comen CM1200 China USD 0.00 1,755.00 14,040.00 1,353,456.00 10 Technically Acceptable<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with<br />

Trolly<br />

8 Medequips Nihon Kohden ECG-1250K Japan USD 0.00 2,100.00 16,800.00 1,619,520.00 11 Technically Acceptable<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with<br />

Trolly<br />

8 Sherazi Trading G.E. Mac 800 USA USD 0.00 2,999.00 23,992.00 2,312,828.80 12 Technically Acceptable<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with<br />

Trolly<br />

8 Radiant Medical Cardilline SPA AR-2100 View BT Italy Euro 0.00 2,857.00 22,856.00 2,873,227.76 13 Technically Acceptable<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with<br />

Trolly<br />

8 Radiant Medical Fukuda Denshy CARDIMAX FX-8322 Japan JPY 0.00 357,000.00 2,856,000.00 3,339,235.20 14 Technically Acceptable<br />

85 ECG 12 Channel Interprative with<br />

Trolly<br />

8 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare TC20 Europe USD 0.00 6,563.00 52,504.00 5,061,385.60 15 Technically Acceptable<br />

86 Holter Monitor with 4 REC 1 Iqbal & Company PBI & BREAMER DL800 USA USD 1,535,628 1,535,628.00 12,366.00 12,366.00 1,192,082.40 1 Technically Acceptable.<br />

86 Holter Monitor with 4 REC 1 Biologic Medical<br />

System<br />

Labtech EC-2H Hungry Euro 0.00 9,786.00 9,786.00 1,230,198.06 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

86 Holter Monitor with 4 REC 1 Bios BTL BTL-08 H-300 Europe Euro 0.00 10,400.00 10,400.00 1,307,384.00 3 Techncailllay acceptable<br />

86 Holter Monitor with 4 REC 1 Mediurge Biomedical System C2000 Holter System Belgium USD 0.00 13,800.00 13,800.00 1,330,320.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

86 Holter Monitor with 4 REC 1 Med-Elec. Corp Norav Medical Dl900 Germany USD 0.00 14,500.00 14,500.00 1,397,800.00 5 Technically Acceptable but only 4<br />

recorders quoted against 12<br />

86 Holter Monitor with 4 REC 1 Artema Medical Innomed ARGU Sys ++ FD/Clinic Hungry Euro 0.00 15,000.00 15,000.00 1,885,650.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

86 Holter Monitor with 4 REC 1 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Aspel ASPEKT 702 Pol<strong>and</strong> Euro 2,100,000 2,100,000.00 15,400.00 15,400.00 1,935,934.00 7 Technically Acceptable but only 4<br />

recorders quoted against 12<br />

86 Holter Monitor with 4 REC 1 Radiant Medical Cardilline SPA Q Holter with Click Holter Italy Euro 0.00 15,812.00 15,812.00 1,987,726.52 8 Techncailllay acceptable Price included 12<br />

Recorder<br />

recorders<br />

86 Holter Monitor with 4 REC 1 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare DigiTrak XP Europe USD 0.00 26,125.00 26,125.00 2,518,450.00 9 Technically Acceptable but only 1<br />

recorders quoted against 12<br />

86 Holter Monitor with 4 REC 1 Sherazi Trading G.E. Mars V7 USA USD 0.00 34,786.00 34,786.00 3,353,370.40 10 Technically Acceptable but only 4<br />

recorders quoted against 12<br />

87 ETT Machine 1 Biologic Medical<br />

System<br />

Labtech 12-RS Hungry Euro 0.00 8,600.00 8,600.00 1,081,106.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

87 ETT Machine 1 Bios BTL BTL-08 E-300 Europe Euro 0.00 10,592.00 10,592.00 1,331,520.32 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

87 ETT Machine 1 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Aspel Cardio Test Complete with<br />

Treadmill B612<br />

Pol<strong>and</strong> Euro 1,500,000 1,500,000.00 11,400.00 11,400.00 1,433,094.00 3 Rejected, no BP measurement<br />

87 ETT Machine 1 Artema Medical Innomed EET Machine Hungry Euro 0.00 14,000.00 14,000.00 1,759,940.00 4 Rejected, no BP measurement<br />

87 ETT Machine 1 Med-Elec. Corp Norav Medical 1200W Germany USD 0.00 19,900.00 19,900.00 1,918,360.00 5 Techncailllay acceptable<br />

87 ETT Machine 1 Iqbal & Company Pulse Biomedical ETT machine USA USD 2,101,211 2,101,211.00 20,804.00 20,804.00 2,005,505.60 6 Techncailllay acceptable<br />

87 ETT Machine 1 Radiant Medical Cardilline SPA Q Stress italy Euro 0.00 16,807.00 16,807.00 2,112,807.97 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

87 ETT Machine 1 Sherazi Trading G.E. CASE v 6.6 USA USD 0.00 32,540.00 32,540.00 3,136,856.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 17 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

88 Monitor Anaesthesia Gas 9 Noor International Saadat Alborz B9 Malysia PKR 690,000 6,210,000.00 690,000 6,210,000.00 6,210,000.00 1 Rejected. Iranian origin. Not FDA approved.<br />

88 Monitor Anaesthesia Gas 9 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Biolight M9000A China USD 0.00 8,500.00 76,500.00 7,374,600.00 2 Rejected, no multigas module<br />

88 Monitor Anaesthesia Gas 9 Biotech Pakistan Mindray iPM12 China USD 0.00 9,110.00 81,990.00 7,903,836.00 3 Techncailllay acceptable<br />

88 Monitor Anaesthesia Gas 9 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Biolight M9500 China USD 0.00 9,500.00 85,500.00 8,242,200.00 4 Rejected, no multigas module<br />

88 Monitor Anaesthesia Gas 9 Biotech Pakistan Mindray iPM9800 China USD 0.00 10,318.00 92,862.00 8,951,896.80 5 Techncailllay acceptable<br />

88 Monitor Anaesthesia Gas 9 Biotech Pakistan Mindray Beneview T5 China USD 0.00 11,423.00 102,807.00 9,910,594.80 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

88 Monitor Anaesthesia Gas 9 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare G60 China USD 0.00 16,420.00 147,780.00 14,245,992.00 7 Technically acceptable<br />

88 Monitor Anaesthesia Gas 9 Sherazi Trading G.E. P650 USA USD 0.00 16,690.00 150,210.00 14,480,244.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

88 Monitor Anaesthesia Gas 9 Med-Elec. Corp Charter Kontron Envoy 4000 UK USD 0.00 16,727.00 150,543.00 14,512,345.20 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

88 Monitor Anaesthesia Gas 9 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Intelli VUE MP40 Europe USD 0.00 20,418.00 183,762.00 17,714,656.80 10 Technically Accpetable<br />

88 Monitor Anaesthesia Gas 9 Medequips Nihon Kohden BSM-6501K Japan USD 0.00 20,900.00 188,100.00 18,132,840.00 11 Technically Acceptable with minor<br />

deviation in module configuration<br />

89 Monitor Multiparameter CCU 20 Nasa Medical Corp. Comen STAR 8000B China USD 0.00 930.00 18,600.00 1,793,040.00 1 Rejected. As Central Monitor rejected.<br />

89 Monitor Multiparameter CCU 20 Biologic Medical<br />

System<br />

Lutech Goldway DataLys 780 USA USD 0.00 4,575.00 91,500.00 8,820,600.00 2 Rejected. As Central Monitor rejected.<br />

89 Monitor Multiparameter CCU 20 Biotech Pakistan Mindray iPM9800 China USD 0.00 5,710.00 114,200.00 11,008,880.00 3 Techncailllay acceptable<br />

89 Monitor Multiparameter CCU 20 Noor International Saadat B9 with Cardiac Output<br />

Capnography <strong>and</strong> IBP<br />

Facility<br />

Malysia PKR 580,000 11,600,000.00 580,000 11,600,000.00 11,600,000.00 4 Rejected, no central station<br />

89 Monitor Multiparameter CCU 20 Biotech Pakistan Mindray Beneview T5 China USD 0.00 7,110.00 142,200.00 13,708,080.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

89 Monitor Multiparameter CCU 20 Sherazi Trading G.E. B40 USA USD 0.00 7,786.00 155,720.00 15,011,408.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

89 Monitor Multiparameter CCU 20 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Biolight M9000A China USD 0.00 8,500.00 170,000.00 16,388,000.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

89 Monitor Multiparameter CCU 20 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare G60 China USD 0.00 9,840.00 196,800.00 18,971,520.00 8 Not accpeted as central is rejected<br />

89 Monitor Multiparameter CCU 20 Biotech Pakistan Mindray iPM12 China USD 0.00 11,895.00 237,900.00 22,933,560.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

89 Monitor Multiparameter CCU 20 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Biolight A5 China USD 0.00 12,000.00 240,000.00 23,136,000.00 10 Technically Acceptable<br />

89 Monitor Multiparameter CCU 20 Sherazi Trading G.E. DASH-5000 USA USD 0.00 12,290.00 245,800.00 23,695,120.00 11 Technically Acceptable<br />

89 Monitor Multiparameter CCU 20 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Intelli Vue MP 40 Europe USD 0.00 16,042.00 320,840.00 30,928,976.00 12 Not accpeted as central is rejected<br />

89 Monitor Multiparameter CCU 20 Medequips Nihon Kohden BSM-6501K Japan USD 0.00 20,150.00 403,000.00 38,849,200.00 13 Technically Acceptable with wireless<br />

connectivity<br />

90 Monitor Multiparameter ICU 60 La Computa Vision Shenzhen Jumper<br />

Medical<br />

Equipment<br />

JPD-800B (12.1") China USD 0.00 744.00 44,640.00 4,303,296.00 1 Rejected, no central station<br />

90 Monitor Multiparameter ICU 60 Nasa Medical Corp. Comen C50 China USD 0.00 1,215.00 72,900.00 7,027,560.00 2 Rejected. As Central Monitor rejected.<br />

90 Monitor Multiparameter ICU 60 Biotech Pakistan Mindray I MEC-12 China USD 0.00 4,400.00 264,000.00 25,449,600.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

90 Monitor Multiparameter ICU 60 Biotech Pakistan Mindray I PM 9800 China USD 0.00 4,755.00 285,300.00 27,502,920.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

90 Monitor Multiparameter ICU 60 Biotech Pakistan Mindray Beneview T5 China USD 0.00 5,960.00 357,600.00 34,472,640.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

90 Monitor Multiparameter ICU 60 Sherazi Trading G.E. B20 USA USD 0.00 6,786.00 407,160.00 39,250,224.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

90 Monitor Multiparameter ICU 60 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare G30 China USD 0.00 7,229.00 433,740.00 41,812,536.00 7 Not accpeted as central is rejected<br />

90 Monitor Multiparameter ICU 60 Muslim Medical<br />

Services<br />

Biolight M8000A China USD 0.00 8,500.00 510,000.00 49,164,000.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

90 Monitor Multiparameter ICU 60 Biotech Pakistan Mindray I PM 12 China USD 0.00 9,110.00 546,600.00 52,692,240.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

90 Monitor Multiparameter ICU 60 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Intelli Vue MP 20 Europe USD 0.00 12,396.00 743,760.00 71,698,464.00 10 Not accpeted as central is rejected<br />

90 Monitor Multiparameter ICU 60 Medequips Nihon Kohden BSM-6301K Japan USD 0.00 12,950.00 777,000.00 74,902,800.00 11 Technically Acceptable with wireless<br />

connectivity<br />

Page 18 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

91 Monitor Vital Sign 20 Muslim Medical Biolight M7000 China USD 700.00 14,000.00 1,349,600.00 1 Rejected. Chinese origin. Not FDA<br />

Services<br />

approved.<br />

91 Monitor Vital Sign 20 Biologic Medical<br />

System<br />

Lutech Goldway DataLys 780 USA USD 0.00 1,470.00 29,400.00 2,834,160.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

91 Monitor Vital Sign 20 Biotech Pakistan Mindray I MEC-8 China USD 0.00 1,530.00 30,600.00 2,949,840.00 3 Rejected, 8.4" screen against 10"<br />

91 Monitor Vital Sign 20 QFR Enterprise Ktmed KTPM-1050 Korea USD 1,700.00 34,000.00 3,277,600.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

91 Monitor Vital Sign 20 Nasa Medical Corp. Comen C80 China USD 1,715.00 34,300.00 3,306,520.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

91 Monitor Vital Sign 20 Biologic Medical<br />

System<br />

Infunix IP-4050 Purescope Korea USD 1,786.00 35,720.00 3,443,408.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

91 Monitor Vital Sign 20 Biotech Pakistan Mindray I MEC-10 China USD 0.00 1,810.00 36,200.00 3,489,680.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

91 Monitor Vital Sign 20 Sherazi Trading G.E. Dinamap V100 USA USD 0.00 1,999.00 39,980.00 3,854,072.00 8 Rejected, no wave forms, only numeric<br />

91 Monitor Vital Sign 20 Bios Infinium Medical OMNI Express USA USD 0.00 2,325.00 46,500.00 4,482,600.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

91 Monitor Vital Sign 20 Artema Medical Innomed Innocare-S Hungry Euro 2,450.00 49,000.00 6,159,790.00 10 Rejected, Screen size 7" against 8.4<br />

91 Monitor Vital Sign 20 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare G30 Europe USD 4,870.00 97,400.00 9,389,360.00 11 Technically Acceptable<br />

91 Monitor Vital Sign 20 Medequips Nihon Kohden BSM-3562K Japan USD 0.00 5,324.00 106,480.00 10,264,672.00 12 Technically Acceptable<br />

91 Monitor Vital Sign 20 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Intelli Vue MP 5 Europe USD 6,708.00 134,160.00 12,933,024.00 13 Technically Acceptable<br />

Category: O.T.<br />

93 Diathermay Unit Mono <strong>and</strong><br />

Bipolar<br />

10 Hospicare Systems Valley Lab Force FX8CS USA USD 0.00 5,700.00 57,000.00 5,494,800.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

93 Diathermay Unit Mono <strong>and</strong><br />

Bipolar<br />

10 Radiant Medical Conmed System-2450 USA USD 0.00 5,789.00 57,890.00 5,580,596.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

93 Diathermay Unit Mono <strong>and</strong><br />

Bipolar<br />

10 All Med Solution KLS Martin ME MB3 Germany Euro 0.00 4,500.00 45,000.00 5,656,950.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

93 Diathermay Unit Mono <strong>and</strong><br />

Bipolar<br />

10 Noor International Bovie Medical IDS-300 USA USD 0.00 6,200.00 62,000.00 5,976,800.00 4 Rejected 200 W against 300W<br />

93 Diathermay Unit Mono <strong>and</strong> 10 Paktech Instrument Dimeda 97.000.5 Germany Euro 0.00 5,668.00 56,680.00 7,125,242.80 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

Bipolar<br />

Co.<br />

93 Diathermay Unit Mono <strong>and</strong><br />

Bipolar<br />

10 Sherazi Trading B Braun GN300 Germany Euro 0.00 5,986.00 59,860.00 7,525,000.60 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

93 Diathermay Unit Mono <strong>and</strong> 10 Paktech Instrument Lamidey noury V10GMC3 France Euro 0.00 8,625.00 86,250.00 10,842,487.50 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

Bipolar<br />

Co.<br />

93 Diathermay Unit Mono <strong>and</strong> 10 Latif Brothers Erbe Vio 300S Germany Euro 0.00 8,780.00 87,800.00 11,037,338.00 8 Technically Acceptable, Price <strong>of</strong> imported<br />

Bipolar<br />

trolley included. Local Trolley is also<br />

available worth PKR 25650<br />

93 Diathermay Unit Mono <strong>and</strong><br />

Bipolar<br />

10 Radiant Medical Emed Spectrum Pol<strong>and</strong> Euro 0.00 9,490.00 94,900.00 11,929,879.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

94 Fibrillator 2 Medica Sorin Group GmbH Fi 20M Germany Euro 0.00 2,850.00 5,700.00 716,547.00 1 Item Dropped<br />

95 Heart Lung Machine 2 Medica Sorin Group GmbH C5 Germany Euro 0.00 84,786.00 169,572.00 21,316,896.12 1<br />

95 Heart Lung Machine 2 Medica Sorin Group GmbH S5 Germany Euro 0.00 94,786.00 189,572.00 23,831,096.12 2<br />

95 Heart Lung Machine 2 Medil<strong>and</strong> Pakistan Maquet Gatinge<br />

Group<br />

HL20 Vario Twin Germany Euro 0.00 104,300.00 208,600.00 26,223,106.00 3<br />

96 Hypo/hyperthermia Unit 2 Mediurge Hirtz & Co Hico VarioTherm 555 Germany Euro 0.00 8,490.00 16,980.00 2,134,555.80 1<br />

96 Hypo/hyperthermia Unit 2 Medica Sorin Group GmbH 2T Germany Euro 0.00 17,300.00 34,600.00 4,349,566.00 2<br />

96 Hypo/hyperthermia Unit 2 Medil<strong>and</strong> Pakistan Maquet Gatinge<br />

Group<br />

HCU-30 Germany Euro 0.00 24,800.00 49,600.00 6,235,216.00 3<br />

97 Infusor Pressure 10 Mediurge VBM GmbH 57-06-100 VBM Infusor<br />

1000<br />

Germany Euro 0.00 195.00 1,950.00 245,134.50 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 19 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

98 Lamp Operating Major with 9 Biologic Medical Acem StaLED5+StarLED3 Evo<br />

Italy Euro 0.00 8,650.00 77,850.00 9,786,523.50 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

Camera<br />

System<br />

Plus<br />

98 Lamp Operating Major with 9 T.K. medical<br />

Bowin Medical Co LEDTECH 7050 China USD 0.00 15,300.00 137,700.00 13,274,280.00 2 Rejected, No camera<br />

Camera<br />

Instrument<br />

98 Lamp Operating Major with<br />

Camera<br />

9 Mediurge Steris Harmony VLED USA USD 0.00 20,900.00 188,100.00 18,132,840.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

98 Lamp Operating Major with<br />

Camera<br />

9 Biotech Pakistan Mindray HyLED8600 China USD 0.00 24,150.00 217,350.00 20,952,540.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

98 Lamp Operating Major with 9 Noor International Doctor Mach LED 5SC/2SC Germany Euro 0.00 18,950.00 170,550.00 21,439,840.50 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

Camera<br />

GmbH<br />

98 Lamp Operating Major with<br />

Camera<br />

9 Biotech Pakistan Mindray HyLED9500+9700 China USD 0.00 27,245.00 245,205.00 23,637,762.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

98 Lamp Operating Major with 9 Radiant Medical Trumpf Truelight-3510-3300/SD- Germany Euro 0.00 22,689.00 204,201.00 25,670,107.71 7 Technically acceptable<br />

Camera<br />

200<br />

98 Lamp Operating Major with<br />

Camera<br />

9 Coral Medical Surgiris X3ST-X2ST France Euro 0.00 23,661.00 212,949.00 26,769,818.79 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

98 Lamp Operating Major with 9 All Med Solution KLS Martin MAR LED E15, MAR LED Germany Euro 0.00 25,800.00 232,200.00 29,189,862.00 9 Technically Acceptable<br />

Camera<br />

E9<br />

98 Lamp Operating Major with<br />

Camera<br />

9 Hoora Pharma Maquet 500-300 France Euro 0.00 27,914.00 251,226.00 31,581,620.46 10 Technically Acceptable<br />

98 Lamp Operating Major with<br />

Camera<br />

9 Radiant Medical Trumpf i LED5-iLED3/SD-200 Germany Euro 0.00 31,740.00 285,660.00 35,910,318.60 11 Technically Acceptable (LED)<br />

98 Lamp Operating Major with 9 Technology Links Trilux AURINIO<br />

Germany Euro 0.00 41,500.00 373,500.00 46,952,685.00 12 Technically Acceptable<br />

Camera<br />

L120/L160/Monitor<br />

Support Pm<br />

99 Operating Microscope 1 Eastern Optical Co. Moller-Wedel<br />

Haag-Streit<br />

Universa 300 (ENT) Germany Euro 0.00 29,750.00 29,750.00 3,739,872.50 1 Rejected, very basic manual microscope<br />

99 Operating Microscope 1 Eastern Optical Co. Surgical Moller-Wedel<br />

Haag-Streit<br />

Surgical<br />

Universa 300 (Surgery) Germany Euro 0.00 29,760.00 29,760.00 3,741,129.60 2 Rejected, very basic manual microscope<br />

99 Operating Microscope 1 Radiant Medical Karl Kaps SOM-62 Germany Euro 0.00 30,100.00 30,100.00 3,783,871.00 3 Rejected. only for Opthalmology<br />

Attachment for Neuro <strong>and</strong> Vascular<br />

Surgery are not accpetable being very<br />

basic.<br />

99 Operating Microscope 1 Latif Brothers Karl Zeiss OPMI 1FR (Opthalmology) Germany Euro 0.00 30,522.00 30,522.00 3,836,920.62 4 Not Acceptable. Beam Splitter, Video<br />

Camera attachment in cluding 1 CCD Video<br />

camera, 32'' LCD screen, DVD recorder,<br />

Sterio Co observation attachment with<br />

three axes inclination <strong>and</strong> image erection,<br />

Binocular Tube, 10X eye pieces with<br />

Dioptric adjustment<br />

99 Operating Microscope 1 Latif Brothers Karl Zeiss OPMI 1FC Germany Euro 0.00 36,292.00 36,292.00 4,562,267.32 5 Not Acceptable, Beam Splitter, Video<br />

Camera attachment in cluding 1 CCD Video<br />

camera, 32'' LCD screen, DVD recorder,<br />

Sterio Co observation attachment with<br />

three axes inclination <strong>and</strong> image erection,<br />

Binocular Tube, 10X eye pieces with<br />

Dioptric adjustment<br />

99 Operating Microscope 1 Eastern Optical Co. Moller-Wedel Allegra 500 (ENT) Germany Euro 0.00 38,580.00 38,580.00 4,849,891.80 6 Rejected. Dedicated ENT, no coobservation<br />

Haag-Streit<br />

Surgical<br />

tube attachment possible,<br />

Page 20 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

99 Operating Microscope 1 Latif Brothers Karl Zeiss OPMI-LUMERA I<br />

Germany Euro 0.00 62,082.00 62,082.00 7,804,328.22 7 Technically Acceptable, Beam Splitter,<br />

(Opthalmology)<br />

Video Camera attachment in cluding 1 CCD<br />

Video camera, 32'' LCD screen, DVD<br />

recorder, Sterio Co observation attachment<br />

with three axes inclination <strong>and</strong> image<br />

erection, Binocular Tube, 10X eye pieces<br />

with Dioptric adjustment<br />

99 Operating Microscope 1 Eastern Optical Co. Moller-Wedel<br />

Haag-Streit<br />

Surgical<br />

99 Operating Microscope 1 Eastern Optical Co. Moller-Wedel<br />

Haag-Streit<br />

Surgical<br />

Moller Hi-R 900 (Eye) Germany Euro 0.00 62,435.00 62,435.00 7,848,703.85 8 Technically Acceptable Video System for<br />

teaching, Stereo Scopic observer head, wild<br />

angle fundus observating unit<br />

Moller Hi-R 700 (Surgery) Germany Euro 0.00 64,870.00 64,870.00 8,154,807.70 9 Technically Acceptable Video System for<br />

teaching, Stereo Scopic observer head<br />

99 Operating Microscope 3 Latif Brothers Karl Zeiss OPMI-Vario Germany Euro 0.00 96,856.00 290,568.00 36,527,303.28 10 Technically Acceptable, Beam Splitter,<br />

Video Camera attachment in cluding 1 CCD<br />

Video camera, 32'' LCD screen, DVD<br />

recorder, Sterio Co observation attachment<br />

with three axes inclination <strong>and</strong> image<br />

erection, Binocular Tube, 10X eye pieces<br />

with Dioptric adjustment, Motorized XY<br />

device, Sterio Beam Spiltter with 0-180<br />

degree binocular tube, 10X eye Pieces for<br />

two surgeon working face to face, Spare<br />

Xenon lamp assembly containing two<br />

lamps, Notorized lifting collar<br />

99 Operating Microscope 1 Latif Brothers Karl Zeiss Neuro /<br />

ENT<br />

99 Operating Microscope 1 Latif Brothers Karl Zeiss Surgery /<br />

ENT<br />

OPMI-Varo 700 Germany Euro 0.00 103,593.00 103,593.00 13,022,676.03 11 Technically Acceptable, Super Lux Xenon<br />

Lamp Exchange, Autobalance, XY coupling,<br />

Sterio Co observation attachment with<br />

three axes inclination <strong>and</strong> image erection,<br />

Binocular Tube, 10X eye pieces with<br />

Dioptric adjustment, Integrated MediLive<br />

Trio, 3CCD SD Camera Pal, Video <strong>and</strong><br />

image recording via USB, Sterio Beam<br />

Spiltter with 0-180 degree binocular tube.<br />

OPMI-Varo 700 Germany Euro 0.00 117,593.00 117,593.00 14,782,616.03 11 Technically Acceptable, Super Lux Xenon<br />

Lamp Exchange, Autobalance, XY coupling,<br />

Sterio Co observation attachment with<br />

three axes inclination <strong>and</strong> image erection,<br />

Binocular Tube, 10X eye pieces with<br />

Dioptric adjustment, Integrated MediLive<br />

Trio, 3CCD SD Camera Pal, Video <strong>and</strong><br />

image recording via USB, Sterio Beam<br />

Spiltter with 0-180 degree binocular tube,<br />

10X eye Pieces for two surgeon working<br />

face to face.<br />

Page 21 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

100 Prism Loup Operating 10 Latif Brothers Neitz BLS-3 Japan PKR 233,050.00 2,330,500.00 233,050.00 2,330,500.00 2,330,500.00 2 Technically Acceptable, LED Spot<br />

illuminator with recharable bateery <strong>and</strong><br />

100 Prism Loup Operating 10 Latif Brothers Neitz BLSP-4 Japan PKR 257,500.00 2,575,000.00 257,500.00 2,575,000.00 2,575,000.00<br />

charger<br />

100 Prism Loup Operating 10 Latif Brothers Neitz BLP-6 Japan PKR 257,500.00 2,575,000.00 257,500.00 2,575,000.00 2,575,000.00<br />

100 Prism Loup Operating 10 Ameer Din<br />

Instruments<br />

Heine Germany PKR 690,000 6,900,000.00 690,000.00 6,900,000.00 6,900,000.00 1 Technically Acceptable. Complete Set<br />

100 Prism Loup Operating 10 Mediurge Integra (Luxtec) USA USD 0.00 17,250.00 172,500.00 16,629,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable, Lite plus head b<strong>and</strong><br />

system, rolling st<strong>and</strong> included as options<br />

101 Surgical P<strong>and</strong>ant 9 QFR Enterprise Aeonmed CP8300 China USD 0.00 5,100.00 45,900.00 4,424,760.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

101 Surgical P<strong>and</strong>ant 9 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Uzumcu 5070.80 Turkey USD 650,000 5,850,000.00 6,250.00 56,250.00 5,422,500.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

101 Surgical P<strong>and</strong>ant 9 Biotech Pakistan Mindray HyPort 3000 SUR-I China USD 0.00 6,685.00 60,165.00 5,799,906.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

101 Surgical P<strong>and</strong>ant 9 Radiant Medical Trumpf Kalino Port (1285) Germany Euro 0.00 7,385.00 66,465.00 8,355,315.15 4 Technically Acceptable Perfusionist<br />

Pendant<br />

101 Surgical P<strong>and</strong>ant 9 Radiant Medical Trumpf Kalino Port (1285) Germany Euro 0.00 8,477.00 76,293.00 9,590,793.03 5 Technically Acceptable Surgeon Pendant<br />

101 Surgical P<strong>and</strong>ant 9 Mediurge Module Tecnik DVE5100-1000/BSP<br />

Germany Euro 0.00 9,300.00 83,700.00 10,521,927.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

GmbH<br />

2500Tr<br />

101 Surgical P<strong>and</strong>ant 9 Radiant Medical Trumpf Kalino Port (1265) Germany Euro 0.00 10,127.00 91,143.00 11,457,586.53 7 Technically Acceptable Anaesthesia<br />

Pendant<br />

101 Surgical P<strong>and</strong>ant 9 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

Nuvo V06F39 USA USD 0.00 17,188.00 154,692.00 14,912,308.80 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus<br />

Mattress<br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus<br />

Mattress<br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus<br />

Mattress<br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus<br />

Mattress<br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus<br />

Mattress<br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus<br />

Mattress<br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus<br />

Mattress<br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus<br />

Mattress<br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus<br />

Mattress<br />

5 La Computa Vision Harbin Howell HE-608K China USD 0.00 4,800.00 24,000.00 2,313,600.00 1 Rejected, no accessories quoted,<br />

Medical Apparatus<br />

<strong>and</strong> Instrument<br />

orthopaedic attachment not quoted<br />

5 QFR Enterprise Co. Aeonmed AEGSTAB OP830 China USD 0.00 8,000.00 40,000.00 3,856,000.00 2 Rejected, orthoapedic attachement <strong>and</strong><br />

other accessories not quoted<br />

1 Biologic Medical Takeuchi<br />

TS-103 Japan JPY 0.00 17,233,575.00 17,233,575.00 20,149,495.89 6 Technically Accpetable, comprehansive<br />

System<br />

Manufacturing<br />

<strong>of</strong>fer for selection <strong>of</strong> accessories, Set <strong>of</strong><br />

St<strong>and</strong>ard accessories, General surgery,<br />

Trolley for accessories <strong>and</strong> components,<br />

accessories for uorology <strong>and</strong><br />

gyneacology.orthopedic extention units,<br />

Accessories set for ENT <strong>and</strong> plastic Surgery,<br />

Opthalmology, Neuro Surgery <strong>and</strong><br />

cardiovascular surgery in cluded. The Price<br />

is with 9 Tables <strong>and</strong> one set <strong>of</strong> Accessories<br />

9 T.K. medical<br />

Heal Force HFease400 China USD 0.00 13,800.00 124,200.00 11,972,880.00 3 Rejected, no accessories no ortho<br />

Instrument<br />

attachment quoted<br />

9 Biotech Pakistan Mindray HyBase 3000 China USD 0.00 18,615.00 167,535.00 16,150,374.00 4 Not Acceptable. Acceories not quoted<br />

9 Biotech Pakistan Mindray Hy Base 6100 China USD 0.00 20,505.00 184,545.00 17,790,138.00 5 Not Acceptable. Acceories not quoted<br />

9 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

HilBro HLB-OT-821 + HLB-OT-825 Pakistan PKR 2,266,667 20,400,000.03 2,266,667 20,400,000.03 20,400,000.03 7 Rejected, hydraulic only<br />

9 All Med Solution KLS Martin ETIUDA Five Sections (4- Germany Euro 0.00 22,897.00 206,073.00 25,905,436.83 8 Rejected, no accessories quoted,<br />

02-5)<br />

orthopaedic attachment not quoted<br />

9 Hoora Pharma Maquet Alpha Classic 1118.06 China Euro 0.00 23,082.00 207,738.00 26,114,743.98 9 Rejected, basic model quoted without<br />

accessories<br />

Page 22 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus<br />

Mattress<br />

9 Med-Elec. Corp MIZU Medical Japan JPY 0.00 2,860,000.00 25,740,000.00 30,095,208.00 10 Not Acceptable. Acceories not quoted<br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus 9 Nasa Medical Corp. Schmitz Mobilis 300 CE/G-161.335 Germany Euro 0.00 26,852.00 241,668.00 30,380,084.28 11 Technically Acceptable Accessories <strong>and</strong><br />

Mattress<br />

orthopedic accessories included<br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus 1 Radiant Medical Trumpf Mars 2.02 Germany Euro 0.00 313,031.38 313,031.38 39,351,174.78 12 Technically Accpetable, comprehansive<br />

Mattress<br />

<strong>of</strong>fer for selection <strong>of</strong> accessories, Set <strong>of</strong><br />

St<strong>and</strong>ard accessories, General surgery,<br />

Trolley for accessories <strong>and</strong> components,<br />

accessories for uorology <strong>and</strong><br />

gyneacology.orthopedic extention units,<br />

Accessories set for ENT <strong>and</strong> plastic Surgery,<br />

Opthalmology, Neuro Surgery <strong>and</strong><br />

cardiovascular surgery in cluded. The Price<br />

is with 9 tables <strong>and</strong> one each set <strong>of</strong><br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus 1 Radiant Medical Trumpf Saturn Select 3.03 Germany Euro 0.00 312,989.85 312,989.85 39,345,954.04 13 Technically Accpetable, comprehansive<br />

Mattress<br />

<strong>of</strong>fer for selection <strong>of</strong> accessories, Set <strong>of</strong><br />

St<strong>and</strong>ard accessories, General surgery,<br />

Trolley for accessories <strong>and</strong> components,<br />

accessories for uorology <strong>and</strong><br />

gyneacology.orthopedic extention units,<br />

Accessories set for ENT <strong>and</strong> plastic Surgery,<br />

Opthalmology, Neuro Surgery <strong>and</strong><br />

cardiovascular surgery in cluded. The Price<br />

is with 9 tables <strong>and</strong> one each set <strong>of</strong><br />

102 Table Operating 5 Sections Plus 5 Mediurge Steris Unimax USA/Europe Euro 0.00 53,290.00 266,450.00 33,495,429.50 14 accessorries<br />

Technically Acceptable, Uorology,<br />

Mattress<br />

gyneacology <strong>and</strong> orthopedic attchement<br />

Category: Radiology<br />

103 C-Arm 9" 1 La Computa Vision Nanjing Hua Dong DG3310C 5KW<br />

Electronics Group<br />

Medical<br />

Equipment Co.<br />

China USD 0.00 28,500 28,500.00 2,747,400.00 1 Rejected, 5 kW Generator aganst 6 kW<br />

103 C-Arm 9" 1 Bios Allengers Allengers HF 49 with 9"I.I India USD 0.00 29,000.00 29,000.00 2,795,600.00 2 Rejected 3.5 kw Generator,<br />

103 C-Arm 9" 1 Seimens Seimens Siremobil Compact L Germany USD 0.00 55,000.00 55,000.00 5,302,000.00 3 Rejected 1.4 kW generator<br />

103 C-Arm 9" 1 Sherazi Trading G.E. OEC 850 USA USD 0.00 59,000.00 59,000.00 5,687,600.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

103 C-Arm 9" 1 Medequips Toshiba SXT-2000 Japan USD 0.00 76,700.00 76,700.00 7,393,880.00 5 Technicaly Acceptable<br />

103 C-Arm 9" 1 Ittefaq Sons Technix TCA 6 R 9 1 K Italy Euro 0.00 77,500.00 77,500.00 9,742,525.00 6 Technically OK but no installed base<br />

103 C-Arm 9" 1 Technology Links Shimadzu Wha-200 Pleno Japan USD 0.00 114,000.00 114,000.00 10,989,600.00 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

103 C-Arm 9" 1 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare BV PULSERA Holl<strong>and</strong> USD 0.00 175,000.00 175,000.00 16,870,000.00 8 Technically Acceptable<br />

104 Gamma Camera with HotLAB 1 Seimens Seimens C.Cam System Germany USD 0.00 429,400.00 429,400.00 41,394,160.00 1 Item Dropped<br />

104 Gamma Camera with HotLAB 1 Sherazi Trading G.E. NM 615 USA USD 0.00 523,786.00 523,786.00 50,492,970.40 2<br />

104 Gamma Camera with HotLAB 1 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare CardioMD Series III Holl<strong>and</strong> USD 0.00 682,060.00 682,060.00 65,750,584.00 3<br />

105 Illumator X-Ray 10 Strongman Medical Strongman 335-XR-02 Local PKR 6,250 62,500.00 6,250.00 62,500.00 62,500.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

105 Illumator X-Ray 10 Faraz Associate M.Zafar Furniture Pakistan PKR 11,200 112,000.00 11,200 112,000.00 112,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

105 Illumator X-Ray 10 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

HilBro HLB=o974 Pakistan PKR 12,667 126,666.70 12,667 126,666.70 126,666.70 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

105 Illumator X-Ray 10 Strongman Medical Strongman 335-LED-02 Local PKR 26,000 260,000.00 26,000 260,000.00 260,000.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 23 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

106 Mobile X-ray 300mA 2 Bios Dong Mun DM-325MR Korea USD 0.00 15,750.00 31,500.00 3,036,600.00 1 Rejected due to chinese origin.<br />

106 Mobile X-ray 300mA 2 Seimens Seimens Polymobil Plus Germany USD 0.00 22,000.00 44,000.00 4,241,600.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

106 Mobile X-ray 300mA 2 Ittefaq Sons IMD Basic 100-30 Italy Euro 0.00 18,000.00 36,000.00 4,525,560.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

106 Mobile X-ray 300mA 2 Medequips Toshiba IME-100L Japan USD 0.00 25,220.00 50,440.00 4,862,416.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

106 Mobile X-ray 300mA 2 All Med Solution Philips Healthcare Practice 360 Holl<strong>and</strong> USD 0.00 36,459.00 72,918.00 7,029,295.20 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

106 Mobile X-ray 300mA 2 Technology Links Shimadzu MobileArt Evolution 32 Japan USD 0.00 39,000.00 78,000.00 7,519,200.00 6 Technically Acceptable<br />

106 Mobile X-ray 300mA 2 Sherazi Trading G.E. TMX+ USA USD 0.00 39,786.00 79,572.00 7,670,740.80 7 Technically Acceptable<br />

Category: Opthalmology<br />

107 Phaco Machine 1 Faraz Associate Sur-Med Pakistan PKR 17,560 17,560.00 17,560 17,560.00 17,560.00 1 Rejected, Only instrument quoted<br />

107 Phaco Machine 1 Latif Brothers Karl Zeiss Visalis 100 Germany Euro 0.00 18,930.00 18,930.00 2,379,690.30 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

107 Phaco Machine 1 Jasani Scientifics Optikon Italy PKR 2,800,000 2,800,000.00 2,800,000 2,800,000.00 2,800,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

107 Phaco Machine 1 Radiant Medical abbot Medical<br />

Optics<br />

Sovereign Compact USA USD 0.00 49,990.00 49,990.00 4,819,036.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

107 Phaco Machine 1 Radiant Medical abbot Medical<br />

Optics<br />

Signature TM USA USD 0.00 74,000.00 74,000.00 7,133,600.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

108 AB Scan 1 Latif Brothers Quantel Medical Compact Touch France Euro 0.00 12,350.00 12,350.00 1,552,518.50 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

108 AB Scan 1 Ameer Din<br />

Instruments<br />

Sonomed USA PKR 1,585,000 1,585,000.00 1,585,000 1,585,000.00 1,585,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

108 AB Scan 1 Jasani Scientifics Nidek Echoscan US-4000 Japan PKR 2,750,000 2,750,000.00 2,750,000 2,750,000.00 2,750,000.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

109 Opthalmic Operating Chair 2 Strongman Medical Strongman 313-DX-00 Local PKR 8,500 17,000.00 8,500 17,000.00 17,000.00 1 Rejected, not for operation room<br />

109 Opthalmic Operating Chair 2 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

HilBro Pakistan PKR 63,333 126,666.66 63,333 126,666.66 126,666.66 2 Rejected, not for operation room<br />

109 Opthalmic Operating Chair 2 Latif Brothers Takagi OC-1A Japan JPY 0.00 299,000.00 598,000.00 699,181.60 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

109 Opthalmic Operating Chair 2 Radiant Medical Akrus ak-5010MBS Germany Euro 0.00 8,800.00 17,600.00 2,212,496.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

109 Opthalmic Operating Chair 2 Radiant Medical Akrus SC-500 Germany Euro 0.00 9,200.00 18,400.00 2,313,064.00 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

110 Autoclave for Instruments 1 QFR Enterprise Laoken LK/MMQ-DO.020 China USD 0.00 1,895.00 1,895.00 182,678.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

110 Autoclave for Instruments 1 QFR Enterprise Laoken LK/MMQ-DO.025 China USD 0.00 1,980.00 1,980.00 190,872.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

112 Micro Surgical Catract Set 1 Faraz Associate Sur-Med Pakistan PKR 10,800 10,800.00 10,800 10,800.00 10,800.00 1 Rejected. Not zomex<br />

112 Micro Surgical Catract Set 1 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 139,000 139,000.00 139,000 139,000.00 139,000.00 2 Rejected. Not zomex<br />

112 Micro Surgical Catract Set 1 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

HilBro Pakistan PKR 150,052 150,052.00 150,052 150,052.00 150,052.00 3 Rejected. Not zomex<br />

112 Micro Surgical Catract Set 1 Omer Traders Zomex/Frimen PK/China PKR 381,400 381,400.00 381,400.00 381,400.00 381,400.00 4 Technically Acceptable, Single envelop<br />

113 Micro Surgical Trab Set 1 Faraz Associate Sur-Med Pakistan PKR 10,776 10,776.00 10,776 10,776.00 10,776.00 1 Rejected. Not zomex<br />

113 Micro Surgical Trab Set 1 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

HilBro Pakistan PKR 16,892 16,892.00 16,892 16,892.00 16,892.00 2 Rejected. Not zomex<br />

113 Micro Surgical Trab Set 1 Strongman Medical Strongman Local PKR 31,250 31,250.00 31,250 31,250.00 31,250.00 3 Rejected. Not zomex<br />

113 Micro Surgical Trab Set 1 Omer Traders Zomex/Frimen PK/China PKR 58,035 58,035.00 58,035.00 58,035.00 58,035.00 4 Technically Acceptable, Single envelop<br />

Page 24 <strong>of</strong> 25


COMPARATIVE STATEMENT / TECHNICAL COMMENTS<br />

PROCUREMENT OF HOSPITAL, OPHTHALMOLOGY AND DENTAL EQUIPMENT / INSTRUMENTS / FURNITURE<br />

INVITATION FOR BID No. DUHS/P&D/2012/2710 Dated 05 November 2012 OPENED ON 10 DECEMBER 2012<br />

S No Equipment Qty Supplier Manufacturer Model Country <strong>of</strong> Origin Warranty Currency<br />

<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

Unit Price FOR Total Price FOR Unit Price C&F Total Price C&F Total Price PRS. Status Remarks<br />

114 instrument Trolley Faraz Associate M.Zafar Furniture Pakistan PKR 25,600 0.00 25,600 0.00 0.00 1 Sample not provided.<br />

114 instrument Trolley 1 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

HilBro HLB-OTE-410 Pakistan PKR 10,000 10,000.00 10,000.00 10,000.00 10,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

114 instrument Trolley 1 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

HilBro HLB-2466 Pakistan PKR 12,667 12,666.67 12,667 12,666.67 12,666.67 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

114 instrument Trolley 1 Strongman Medical Strongman 510-TM-00 Local PKR 13,500 13,500.00 13,500 13,500.00 13,500.00 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

114 instrument Trolley 1 Paktech Instrument<br />

Co.<br />

HilBro HLB-OTE-410 Pakistan PKR 29,133 29,133.33 29,133 29,133.33 29,133.33 5 Technically Acceptable<br />

Category: Dental Section<br />

115 Panoramic Dental X-Ray 1 Hyderabad Dental Ow<strong>and</strong>y I-MAX Touch Pan.CEPH France Euro 0.00 30,000.00 30,000.00 3,771,300.00 3 Technically Acceptable, no brouchures <strong>of</strong><br />

Supply Co.<br />

technical data provided only description.<br />

115 Panoramic Dental X-Ray 1 Bios Planmeca Planmeca/Promax Finl<strong>and</strong> Euro 0.00 33,100.00 33,100.00 4,161,001.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

115 Panoramic Dental X-Ray 1 Combined Engineers Soredex Cranex 3D Finl<strong>and</strong> Euro 0.00 29,450.00 29,450.00 3,702,159.50 1 Printer Dicom, Online UPS, Computer is<br />

included. Site preparation included as<br />

options<br />

116 Computer aided Design-Computer<br />

aided Milling for Dental Prosthetic<br />

(Cad Cam)<br />

1 Chughtai Dental<br />

Supply<br />

117 MRI Competable Monitor 1 Biologic Medical<br />

System<br />

VHF/Dekema/Dent<br />

al Wings/3M ESPE<br />

CAM4-K4 3M ESPE Lava<br />

Addition/ AUSTROMAT<br />

Basic/ I Series /Lava<br />

Design 7<br />

Germany/Canada Euro 0.00 77,000.00 77,000.00 9,679,670.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

MIPM Tesla Guard germany Euro 0.00 21,786.00 21,786.00 2,738,718.06 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

117 MRI Competable Monitor 1 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Schiller MAGLIFE Switzerl<strong>and</strong> USD 3,950,000 3,950,000.00 37,500.00 37,500.00 3,615,000.00 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

117 MRI Competable Monitor 1 Medequips Medrad VERIS (Cardiac with<br />

Temp.)<br />

USA USD 0.00 58,500.00 58,500.00 5,639,400.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

117 MRI Competable Monitor 1 Biologic Medical<br />

System<br />

MIPM Tesla M3 Germany Euro 0.00 55,534.00 55,534.00 6,981,179.14 4 Technically Acceptable<br />

118 1 Bios OES Medical Astra-3 with Orion UK GBP 0.00 11,600.00 11,600.00 1,793,708.00 1 Technically Acceptable<br />

118 MRI Competable Anaesthesia<br />

machine<br />

118 MRI Competable Anaesthesia<br />

machine<br />

1 St<strong>and</strong>ard Suppliers Penlon Prima 102 MRI UK GBP 2,850,000 2,850,000.00 16,250.00 16,250.00 2,512,737.50 2 Technically Acceptable<br />

1 Mediurge Hersill Regina MRI Spain Euro 0.00 27,200.00 27,200.00 3,419,312.00 3 Technically Acceptable<br />

Page 25 <strong>of</strong> 25

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!