12.07.2013 Views

Issue 42 - Columbia: A Journal of Literature and Art

Issue 42 - Columbia: A Journal of Literature and Art

Issue 42 - Columbia: A Journal of Literature and Art

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

SO m e f e a S t<br />

FICTION -<br />

SAMANTHA GILLISON 24 The Upper Canada Holding Company<br />

He could no sooner have been the rabbi his<br />

mother wanted than a warlock.<br />

STEPHANIE DICKINSON 50 Dalloway & Hannah<br />

His robe clings to his breasts, <strong>and</strong> they're<br />

aset <strong>of</strong> perfect tennis balls.<br />

KIRSTY GUNN 70 The Pass<br />

All you can imagine is the way ahead,<br />

who'll be there, who's waiting.<br />

LYDIA DAVIS 135 Enlightened<br />

She is 54 years old <strong>and</strong> no more enlightened,<br />

as far as Ican see, than when I first knew her.<br />

DALIA AZIM 144 By Way <strong>of</strong> Toronto<br />

It was what she had come to think <strong>of</strong> when she thought <strong>of</strong><br />

America: endlessness, emptiness.<br />

POETRY- -<br />

JAMES DOYLE 23 The Banquet Master<br />

mead <strong>and</strong> cider streaming from the table's / edge<br />

JE NIFER MICHAEL HECHT 32 The Way-Out Way Out<br />

to our surprise, the mess <strong>of</strong> lines / forms an image<br />

ALLEN GROSSMAN 34 Winter at the Sea Shore<br />

Timor Mortis, Inc., ASwitchboard Memory


MARY ZOO 48 Twin<br />

Of all the street's windows, only yours dreams.<br />

EAMON GRENNAN 65 Feast<br />

New Year's Day: Looking for a Sign<br />

Morning under Muckish<br />

What Shadows<br />

Weather <strong>Art</strong>ists<br />

In the dormitory <strong>of</strong> the oak, the saint tended the flame<br />

THYLIAS MOSS 80 Ghee Glee<br />

Fork Addiction<br />

The Culture <strong>of</strong> Reena <strong>and</strong> the Bear<br />

The Culture <strong>of</strong> Mr. Wonderful<br />

Promise her anything: give her foia gras:/stuff it down her throat<br />

L1AM RECTOR 97 Our Hero Galliano<br />

New York City<br />

Soon the City<br />

On the fire escapes / In asleeveless T-shirt / Smoking acigar<br />

ERIN BELIEU 104 from In The Red Dress I Wear to Your Funeral<br />

Your c<strong>of</strong>fin is atough room. / Mourners talk through my set<br />

LUCIA BRYANT 124 La Cabre<br />

Oh, he trimmed stalky blades, for sure, / but erratically, whimsically<br />

PRISCILLA BECKER 1<strong>42</strong> Villanelle<br />

The Sound <strong>of</strong> the Closing Door<br />

Ihave come to regard the wide arms / <strong>of</strong> the chair as an only mother.<br />

NONFICTION II<br />

JOE WENDEROTH 100 from Agony: Agony <strong>and</strong> the University<br />

Theater People are special; their nearness to Agony is unique.<br />

Their sadness sometimes overwhelms them.<br />

HAMILTON WALTERS 108 Steel Smoke<br />

In Subic, mere enlisted rubes metamorphosed into godkings,<br />

such was the blessing <strong>and</strong> curse <strong>of</strong> being an<br />

American with asteady paycheck.<br />

JAMES DAVIS 126 Gigi<br />

But that year, we left early with our packaged dog, fully<br />

upholstered in white curls except for b<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> apricot in her ears.<br />

EULA BISS 136 Watch Out for L<strong>and</strong> Mines<br />

Teachers have the terribly difficult job <strong>of</strong> controlling large<br />

groups <strong>of</strong>people who haventyet fully learned how to be controlled<br />

STUART LEWIS 157 Pants<br />

It was an odd scene because, in the slot, there is asudden<br />

absence <strong>of</strong> social nicety. Patients are attacked on all sides.<br />

INTERVIEW II<br />

NONFICTION II ART II<br />

MARSHA RECKNAGLE 11 When You Walk from This Room<br />

Stories that spring from the unconscious sometimes<br />

speak the truth.<br />

PETER TRACHTENBERG 38 from The Book <strong>of</strong> Calamities<br />

In Rw<strong>and</strong>a, the killing took place in public. Everybody saw it.<br />

All you had to do was look out through your garden gate.<br />

.....It........ ..<br />

AMY BLOOM 116 interview by Leyla Ertegun<br />

Idon't care if it took the author 10 years to write that<br />

shitty sentence or five minutes. If it's not good, it's not good.<br />

JACK PIERSON ii Self Portrait #15<br />

iv Self Portrait #11<br />

vi Self Portrait #4<br />

x Self Portrait #19<br />

xiv Self Portrait #17<br />

xvi Self Portrait #1


ART II<br />

ANTHONY GOICOLEA ii Pool Pushers<br />

v Tree Dwellers<br />

vii Dead Forest<br />

viii Boys' Room<br />

xii Still Life with Pig<br />

DINOS & JAKE CHAPMAN iii Fuck Face<br />

ix Tragic Anatomies<br />

xiii DNA Zygotic<br />

xv Zygotic Acceleration, Biogenetic<br />

De-sublimated Libidinal Model<br />

(enlarged x1000)<br />

II II<br />

Editor's Note<br />

rankl)', it's hard to believe the number <strong>of</strong> pigs in this issue. Every<br />

time there was an opportunit)T, we seemed to sa)', but how might we<br />

get another pig in there? Can we bring in Charlotte's Web? Though<br />

one <strong>of</strong> the editors noted, "I love pigs - they're delicious," many<br />

don't even eat The Pork. For instance, I was raised by a macrobiotic<br />

vegetarian who went so far as to strike night-shade vegetables from<br />

our fridge due to their resemblances to flesh. No eggplant, tomato, or<br />

avocado. In teenaged rebellion I ate Whopper Juniors <strong>and</strong> left the<br />

receipts in the key dish, in my pants pocket, in the drawer with playing<br />

cards <strong>and</strong> batteries. Once, after a particularly nasty fight I cooked<br />

bacon in my mother's iron skillet -left the residue to cake, her next<br />

com pone was my delicious secret <strong>and</strong> resulted in stomach cramps<br />

for the whole family. But mostly my diet has been free <strong>of</strong> sentients.<br />

Another editor's favorite picture <strong>of</strong> herself is st<strong>and</strong>ing next to a giant<br />

hog in Ecuador. She wanted to use it on her license. Another claimed<br />

that even the smell <strong>of</strong> ham caused her stomach to wrench. And yet<br />

after reading James Doyle's poem about the banquet <strong>and</strong> Thylias<br />

Moss's about clarified butter we found ourselves wanting more.<br />

What we need is a pig on a spit - can we make it turn as the reader<br />

flips through pages? The idea was that each st<strong>of</strong>)T, poem, photo, <strong>and</strong><br />

essay would be a part <strong>of</strong> a massive <strong>and</strong> growing feast - the kind<br />

where something bleeds then gets slow-cooked to perfection over<br />

lightly smoking hickory or cherry. There are shifts to tend the fire.<br />

It is only the way we carne to underst<strong>and</strong> this, <strong>Columbia</strong>'s <strong>42</strong>nd <strong>Issue</strong>.<br />

We set out with no thematic directive, put no constraints on what<br />

content to look for. There are essays about Rw<strong>and</strong>a, a good dog,<br />

teaching, whoring in Phuket; stories about camping, old friends,<br />

growing up, <strong>and</strong> getting the hell out; poems about fashion, a goat,<br />

Manhattan, <strong>and</strong> quietly watching; art that is wetter than words, seas<br />

<strong>of</strong> bodies, a town in the trees, <strong>and</strong> portraits <strong>of</strong> men growing young.<br />

And a lot <strong>of</strong> pigs. Thank you for picking up this issue, for subscribing,<br />

for flipping through at the library: It is all for you dear reader,<br />

enjoy the feast.<br />

Very Truly Yours,


II<br />

When Augustus came out on the porch the blue<br />

pigs were eating a rattlesnake - not a very big<br />

one. It had probably just been crawling around<br />

looking for shade when it ran in to the pigs. They<br />

were having a fine tug-<strong>of</strong>-war with it, <strong>and</strong> its<br />

rattling days were over. The sow had it by the<br />

neck, <strong>and</strong> the shoat had the tail.<br />

II<br />

- LARRY MCMURTRY<br />

from Lonesome Dove<br />

\<br />

by Marsha<br />

Recknagle<br />

so m e f e a 5 t<br />

When You Walk<br />

from This Room<br />

he students crowded around a conference table made<br />

<strong>of</strong> the same particle-board brown as the Ouija board<br />

I'd touched lightly, but <strong>of</strong>ten, as a child. When first I<br />

walked into the classroom, I was irritated that there<br />

were no windows, no space for me to pace around in<br />

my cowboy boots, swirl my gauzy skirts.<br />

My teaching techniques - swirl, pace, match the momentum <strong>of</strong> my<br />

thoughts with h<strong>and</strong>s flying as if I were in a game <strong>of</strong> charades ­<br />

would be restricted this semester by setting.<br />

I looked up at the blank faces: John with the curly hair <strong>and</strong><br />

sneaky eyes, Megan, skin luminous, Brenna, her teeth <strong>and</strong> the<br />

whites <strong>of</strong> her eyes startling in contrast to her olive skin. Shiny sleek<br />

seals, I thought, <strong>and</strong> imagined tossing a beach ball into the air, saw<br />

it in my mind's eye - round <strong>and</strong> rolling <strong>and</strong> colorful, creating a<br />

stir, like my words that I hoped would bounce from student to student,<br />

forming balloons <strong>of</strong> ideas above their heads.<br />

I touched the table with my fingertips, saw the traces <strong>of</strong> my<br />

prints on the cheap surface, thought <strong>of</strong> making a mark in the<br />

room. Tried, by tapping my fingers on the tabletop, not only to<br />

predict the future but form it. Rock/Paper/Scissors. The class is<br />

destined to hatch like a brood during the gestation period we call<br />

a semester. Brazen or beat-down, all in the future, up to me, up to<br />

us, how we nurture, what we need.


were my own, a strange turn <strong>of</strong> phrase, the possessiveness that took<br />

root. She told me later that after the first day <strong>of</strong> class she thought she<br />

wanted to grow up to be me. A compliment, a complement, Kelly.<br />

In Kelly's freshman class I'd taught her Mrs. Dalloway. Stories<br />

<strong>and</strong> poems by D.H. Lawrence. The Left H<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> Darkness. The<br />

Ghostwriter. By her senior year I'd taught her how to eat before she<br />

drank wine, how to dance alone without self-consciousness, how to<br />

dance with a woman with total self-consciousness, how to flirt with<br />

her ice-blue eyes, how to think about the maternal, separation individuation,<br />

the porous boundaries between mothers <strong>and</strong> daughters,<br />

thinking this would help her with her mother, who couldn't st<strong>and</strong><br />

that I had taught Kelly to read, flirt, <strong>and</strong> drink wine.<br />

I would embrace "differance," as the French theorists called what<br />

we usually resist. I would be the good mother. I would banish the<br />

bad mother. It was fierce, in fact, the battle between us, Kelly's<br />

mother <strong>and</strong> myself, though one fought behind the scenes, behind the<br />

conscious scrim that held us back, kept us from crossing - the line,<br />

each other.<br />

My dissertation had been psychoanalytic: women's autobiographies.<br />

I'd read Winnicott, Freud, Melanie Klein. Books with wondrous<br />

titles: This Sex Which Is Not One, The (M)other Tongue. There<br />

were lots <strong>of</strong> parentheses in the titles, in the configuring <strong>of</strong> the way a<br />

woman writes herself into relation. Writing a book is compared to<br />

giving birth, ink compared to milk, a mother entangled forever with<br />

the daughter <strong>and</strong> vice versa. I was born to my mother late - she<br />

already had three children, <strong>and</strong> her first-born had a baby too soon,<br />

out <strong>of</strong> wedlock, as they say. Overwhelmed with children, my mother<br />

railed out loud to me, who sat on the kitchen floor quietly turning<br />

the pages <strong>of</strong> my Golden Books. Children! Children having children!<br />

This, she told me time after time, robs one <strong>of</strong> childhood.<br />

I was frightened <strong>of</strong> children, the idea <strong>of</strong> children. Those thieves.<br />

Kelly's boyfriend delivered the news <strong>of</strong> her car crash. He was so<br />

slight in build that he looked like a teenager. Born in Hawaii, he was<br />

exotic, had burnished skin, almond eyes. He walked into the room<br />

that contained the fall class: a Ryan, a Tyndall, two Johns, Brenna,<br />

Megan, <strong>and</strong> 12 others. It was the second week <strong>of</strong> the semester. A<br />

year before - or maybe even in the freshman class four years before<br />

- Kelly had decided to pursue a Ph.D. in literature. Accepted to<br />

Michigan with a large scholarship, she was thrilled. The trunk <strong>of</strong> her<br />

car was filled - she didn't plan on going back to where she was<br />

from for a long time; maybe she was thinking, not ever. While in<br />

Ennis packing for Michigan, she called me each day: the car wasn't<br />

ready; her father was dilly-dallying; she was antsy to take<strong>of</strong>f. Finally<br />

the father asked her: Would she take her mother along on the trip?<br />

Make it girls' night out. A road trip. Kelly <strong>and</strong> her mother hadn't<br />

been getting along for several years; Kelly was turning into a creature<br />

her mother didn't know - <strong>and</strong> didn't really like. She let something<br />

happen to me, Kelly tells me one day while we are having c<strong>of</strong>fee. Her<br />

eyes darted back <strong>and</strong> forth as if she were watching a movie. She talks<br />

to me as if she is doing a voice-over for the movie before her eyes. It<br />

was an old man at the gas station. Down the feeder road.<br />

Did she know? I asked.<br />

She knew <strong>and</strong> didn't know, Kelly said.<br />

It will be dramatic, the wreck, the telling <strong>of</strong> the wreck. An appearance<br />

at the classroom door - Kelly's boyfriend, so full <strong>of</strong> arrogance<br />

with the news that he wears a half-smile, proud that he has such a<br />

story. He will paraphrase what Kelly, <strong>and</strong> then I, will elaborate on:<br />

Kelly's mother drove <strong>of</strong>f an overpass. The car tumbled <strong>and</strong> turned<br />

three times, l<strong>and</strong>ing upright.<br />

Her mother died.<br />

Kelly lived <strong>and</strong> lived <strong>and</strong> lived. The implication <strong>of</strong> that sentence,<br />

what seems to follow naturally, is that she lived happily ever after.<br />

Her mother had mentioned the movie Thelma <strong>and</strong> Louise when they<br />

waved good-bye to the father who stood in his cowboy hat <strong>and</strong> boots<br />

in the gravel driveway <strong>and</strong> raised his h<strong>and</strong> in the way ranchers do, a<br />

small salute, then the tap on the car door as if it is a horse in which<br />

they are entrusting the safety <strong>of</strong> the rider. Then Kelly <strong>and</strong> her mother<br />

were <strong>of</strong>f - just like Thelma <strong>and</strong> Louise, her mother repeated, laughing,<br />

tossing her hair back, as if tossing something away from her.<br />

Kelly's mother didn't like being a rancher's wife, "out in the sticks,"<br />

she complained to Kelly the night before the accident, in the small<br />

motel. She always thought she <strong>and</strong> her husb<strong>and</strong> would move to<br />

Dallas, buy one <strong>of</strong> those houses with white columns outside, walk-in<br />

closets inside. She spoke <strong>of</strong> the fictional house in detail, the sparkle,<br />

the wonder <strong>of</strong> it, especially compared to the dusty dirt-yard <strong>of</strong> their<br />

home <strong>of</strong> 20-some-odd years that was filled with stray dogs <strong>and</strong><br />

tractor parts, the place Kelly had described in her essay for graduate<br />

school as authentic, regional in a world gone homogenous, a place<br />

that made her unique, a st<strong>and</strong>out among the Northeastern applicants,<br />

a place appealing in memory, on paper, but a place to be left behind.<br />

Kelly's real life was just about to begin - in Ann Arbor, far from<br />

WHEN YOU WALK OUT OF THIS ROOM 17


(the only living son <strong>of</strong> the 12 children his wife would give birth to)<br />

<strong>and</strong> was confronted by his father-in-Iaw's blue eyes gazing up at<br />

him. Manusz tried to beat his father-in-Iaw's ghost out <strong>of</strong> his son,<br />

but it refused to budge. Instead it stared out at Manusz from his<br />

young son's face, mocking, judging, making him wild with aggravation<br />

so that finally Oskar was not allowed to look at his father. His<br />

mother had hoped that her father's troublesome ghost wouldn't be<br />

able to follow them on the difficult, confusing trip to America, but it<br />

was worse in New York between her son <strong>and</strong> husb<strong>and</strong> than it had<br />

ever been between her husb<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> father in Hungary.<br />

His mother had hoped Oskar would be a rabbi, which Manusz<br />

thought was a great joke. Every afternoon before he went out,<br />

Manusz Tiklowicz beat his son <strong>and</strong> then locked him in their apartment<br />

with its nailed-shut windows. Study hard, you wretch, he'd<br />

shout, you monkey, as he walked down the hall.<br />

By the time he was 14, Tiklowicz had taught himself to read<br />

English poetry; with money he earned carting coal for a mikvah on<br />

Ludlow Street, he bought leather-bound books <strong>of</strong> Shelley, Keats <strong>and</strong><br />

Byron. He spent restless nights in the tiny tenement apartment listening<br />

to his coughing, snoring, muttering, whimpering sisters<br />

sleep while he mulled over a line <strong>of</strong> verse; Beauty is truth, truth<br />

beauty, - that is all Ye know on earth, <strong>and</strong> all ye need to know. How<br />

easy in the early dawn to pull the nail out <strong>of</strong> the window frame<br />

<strong>and</strong> climb up the fire escape <strong>and</strong> greet a startled Alberto sipping<br />

watery hot milk.<br />

There was no question in Oskar's mind that God didn't exist; he<br />

could no sooner have been the rabbi his mother wanted than a<br />

warlock. He started a coal-carting business with Alberto, <strong>and</strong> the<br />

two <strong>of</strong> them dragged the heavy sacks up <strong>and</strong> down narrow tenement<br />

staircases <strong>and</strong> fire escapes from dawn until nightfall.<br />

And then, when he cut <strong>of</strong>f his peyess, his father broke his nose.<br />

He overheard a friend <strong>of</strong> his father's talking about the fur business<br />

in Canada. Oskar decided to go <strong>and</strong> take Alberto with him.<br />

"It'll be like back in Mauritania," Oskar teased his solemn friend.<br />

"When you rode with Berbers across the Atlas mountains. And, you<br />

know, those Berbers are Jews. Like a lost tribe."<br />

But Alberto followed Oskar to Canada the way he had followed<br />

him through the New York ghetto his entire adolescence without<br />

a second thought like the Sephardic brides weighted down with<br />

silver, their palms tattooed in henna curlicues, their fingertips blood-red,<br />

<strong>and</strong> cheeks decorated with black kohl triangles, that he had watched<br />

trail after their grooms along the cobbled streets <strong>of</strong> the Fez mella.<br />

Alberto was Oskar's shadow: a quiet, motherless, fatherless child,<br />

preoccupied with the memories that had followed him from Morocco,<br />

the visions that crawled into his eyes when he slept or breathed in<br />

the smell <strong>of</strong> horse dung in the hot sun or listened to the clang ting<br />

clang <strong>of</strong> the blacksmith's hammer on Delancey Street. But Oskar was<br />

a star in the blacked-out sky, allowing light, possibility into the world<br />

for Alberto. Oskar conjured money, supplies; wrote to his mother's<br />

cousin who had a seed-exporting business in Montreal. Then he flew<br />

north to Canada like an eagle, with Alberto under his wing.<br />

The two <strong>of</strong> them camped <strong>and</strong> travelled through Upper Ontario the<br />

summer <strong>of</strong> 1907; they hired a dour Ojibwa man to canoe them from<br />

lake to bog to lake, along freezing, rushing rivers, past beaver dams<br />

<strong>and</strong> Indian settlements, under swarms <strong>of</strong> geese, clouds <strong>of</strong> mosquitoes,<br />

<strong>and</strong> black flies. They were Champlain <strong>and</strong> Frontenac, Oskar declared,<br />

pushing along in birch canoes, the wealth <strong>of</strong> the forests unfolding<br />

before them. They bought beaver pelts from Huron <strong>and</strong> Ojibwa Indians<br />

<strong>and</strong> baskets from a Cree woman with a swollen, goitered neck for<br />

Alberto's little sister, Mila. Oskar heard about a nickel mine near Dorset<br />

<strong>and</strong> they went to visit. Tiklowicz had an uncanny gift for business: it<br />

frightened Alberto a little (his own mother's superstitions with her<br />

H<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> Fathma <strong>and</strong> magic necklaces <strong>of</strong> colored glass still lurked inside<br />

him.) He had always known that Oskar had Sight. He could overhear a<br />

sentence, a detail, <strong>and</strong> know if something would work, if a trapper was<br />

lying, what would make money, what they should do. Oskar gave<br />

their business a name, too, on the third night they camped out: The<br />

Upper Canada Holding Company.<br />

The night they spent on the shores <strong>of</strong> Lake Erskine was cool. Alberto<br />

waded into the water <strong>and</strong> caught three rainbow trout. Oskar fried them<br />

in lard with thick slices <strong>of</strong> yellow onion, black pepper <strong>and</strong> potatoes. He<br />

made c<strong>of</strong>fee <strong>and</strong> they drank it sweet with condensed milk <strong>and</strong> had a<br />

fishy-tasting cake <strong>of</strong> frying-pan bread. Oskar had borrowed money<br />

from his mother's cousin in Montreal <strong>and</strong> he had invested it now,<br />

almost all <strong>of</strong> it, for the Upper Canada Holding Company. They<br />

owned that night, the two <strong>of</strong> them, a quarter interest in the Dorset<br />

nickel mine they had visited, fifty shares in the Baptiste-Kearney cadmium<br />

mine, a tiny stake in a timber company out <strong>of</strong> Dwight, <strong>and</strong> 70<br />

beaver pelts. Almost everything was leveraged against each other, a<br />

house <strong>of</strong> cards waiting to be pushed over. But Oskar didn't Inind. He<br />

understood what he had invested in.


They wore sweaters <strong>and</strong> knit wool caps <strong>and</strong> smoked cigarettes<br />

while they drank their c<strong>of</strong>fee <strong>and</strong> looked out at the dark settling on the<br />

lake. The whole place pulsed with the night: frogs <strong>and</strong> cicadas chorusing<br />

back <strong>and</strong> forth, black clouds <strong>of</strong> bats shivering above the tree<br />

canopy <strong>and</strong> then melting into the black night sky. Oskar kept a diary <strong>of</strong><br />

their trip in a cardboard-covered notebook. He fished it out <strong>of</strong> his pack<br />

<strong>and</strong> flipped through the pages, stopping to check a list, write a note in<br />

the firelight. Across the front cover he had written in black ink: UPPER<br />

CANADA HOLDING COMPANY O. Tiklowicz, A. Levi props.<br />

He had pasted maps onto its pages, train tickets, labels from<br />

the first tins <strong>of</strong> condensed milk <strong>and</strong> navy beans they ate,<br />

receipts, bills, a h<strong>and</strong>-written contract,<br />

a snapshot <strong>of</strong> the two <strong>of</strong> them with<br />

Your great-greatgreat-gr<strong>and</strong>father<br />

probably spit on<br />

Columbus <strong>and</strong><br />

de Torres as he<br />

ran to make the<br />

boat to Tangiers.<br />

their packs strapped on at Haliburton<br />

station. He sketched the lakes they<br />

paddled over, jack pines, Alberto fishing,<br />

Ojibwa birch canoes bobbing in the<br />

waves; he wrote notes about the mines,<br />

trappers, traders they met, the diarrhea,<br />

poison ivy, <strong>and</strong> stinging black fly<br />

bites that plagued them both; he jotted<br />

down poems that echoed in his mind<br />

when he looked out at the smoky bluegreen<br />

forest that flowed like a river<br />

over the mountains <strong>and</strong> lake-studded<br />

valleys <strong>of</strong> Upper Canada. He had carefully<br />

pasted in a cutting from The Globe<br />

& Mail about the future <strong>of</strong> the Hudson's Bay Company <strong>and</strong><br />

wrote tiny notes in pencil along the margins.<br />

"You see, Europe is a lady <strong>of</strong> advancing years," Oskar said, shutting<br />

the book <strong>and</strong> shaking his finger at Alberto's smiling face.<br />

"Sophisticated. Gorgeous. But when you bend down to kiss her, the<br />

sweat in her armpits, the breath in her mouth she smells sour, <strong>of</strong><br />

Death. But Canada!" He was shouting now, his voice a high-pitched<br />

squeak in the night, clapping his h<strong>and</strong>s to punctuate his sentences,<br />

performing for Alberto <strong>and</strong> the crackling fire <strong>and</strong> the slick-furred<br />

otters who peered at them from the lake shallows. "Canada is the<br />

beautiful virgin girl bursting with the life! With swelled, firm<br />

breasts. She is ready to clasp a Jew to her warm body! Her breath is<br />

sweet, her mouth hungry!"<br />

Alberto laughed at the impossible image <strong>of</strong> his skinny, toothless<br />

friend with his face in some girl's chest.<br />

"What a rabbi you'd make," Alberto said. ''It's not too late, you know."<br />

"It's so funny, ha ha, my fall from grace," Oskar said, smiling, his<br />

face covered in the smile, his small, delicate h<strong>and</strong>s stretching out to<br />

embrace the whole night. "But this is exactly the place for us, Bertie.<br />

Up here with the Indians," he gestured, pointing at the creatures<br />

watching them from the lake, "with the animals."<br />

Alberto siniled <strong>and</strong> nibbled on a piece <strong>of</strong> the frying-pan bread.<br />

Oskar's voice, the fire, the smell <strong>of</strong> smoke <strong>and</strong> the spruce needlecovered<br />

earth made the night unfurl in front <strong>of</strong> him: he could see his<br />

life as a series <strong>of</strong> places - Ontario, New York, the steamship, his<br />

father's store in the melfa with its hundreds <strong>of</strong> hammered tin <strong>and</strong><br />

glass lanterns hanging from the ceiling, lined up on rickety shelves<br />

gleaming in the North African sun. He sawall those places eInpty <strong>of</strong><br />

people, quiet, only angles <strong>and</strong> shadows, turning them over in his<br />

mind like a child with a seashell. Oskar nudged the coals in the fire<br />

with a stick, sending sparks <strong>and</strong> crackles <strong>and</strong> a puff <strong>of</strong> smoke into the<br />

blue-black night.<br />

"You know, we're like the Jew Columbus who set sail on the<br />

ninth <strong>of</strong> Ab looking for cinnamon sticks <strong>and</strong> discovered the world,"<br />

Oskar said.<br />

"What are you talking about?" Alberto laughed. "Christopher<br />

Columbus was a converso?"<br />

"Of course he was. Don't you even know that? Why else were<br />

there only Jews on his trip as his advisors? You ever heard about<br />

Luis de Torres? Why were all the investors Jews? Tell me, my<br />

Spanish-speaking friend - why did he choose to sail into the great<br />

blue beyond for the Indes on the very same, exact day the Gr<strong>and</strong><br />

Inquisitor had sent every Jew in Spain packing <strong>and</strong> all the ports<br />

were clogged with weeping <strong>and</strong> wailing yentas? Your great-greatgreat-gr<strong>and</strong>father<br />

probably spit on Columbus <strong>and</strong> de Torres as he<br />

ran to make the boat for Tangiers."<br />

"Stop it," Alberto laughed. "Next it's going to be - you know that<br />

English Jew, Henry Hudson? This guy would not drink a cup <strong>of</strong> tea<br />

with everyone else on Yom Kippur! No, not a sip!"<br />

"Believe, don't believe. It's true." Oskar shrugged his shoulders.<br />

Alberto, still laughing, began to stack the pans, the enamelled tin<br />

plates <strong>and</strong> cups, the flame-blackened lard pail. Tiklowicz was quiet as<br />

they cleaned up from dinner, all <strong>of</strong> a sudden seized with one <strong>of</strong> his<br />

somber moods. He squatted at the fire, smoking <strong>and</strong> peering into the<br />

smoldering purple <strong>and</strong> red flames, the orange coals. Alberto went<br />

into the tent, shook out the blankets. He heard Tiklowicz moving


around, boots scraping on the rocks, the fire stoked. He heard the<br />

cooking pans clang together as Tiklowicz strung them up onto the<br />

branches <strong>of</strong> the huge spruce tree. And then Oskar's squeaky voice<br />

declaiming into the darkness, his voice full <strong>of</strong> emotion:<br />

She walks in beauty, like the night<br />

Of cloudless climes <strong>and</strong> starry skies;<br />

And all that's best <strong>of</strong> dark <strong>and</strong> bright<br />

Meet in her aspect <strong>and</strong> her eyes:<br />

Thus mellow'd to that tender light<br />

Which heaven to gaudy day denies.<br />

As he lay down under his blankets, a blister <strong>of</strong> happiness burst<br />

inside Alberto, trickling through him until his entire being was<br />

warm from it. Everything around him, the faint sound <strong>of</strong> waves lapping<br />

at the shore, the cool, tender summer air covering them like a<br />

duvet, the sound <strong>of</strong> Oskar's voice, a crying loon flying over the lake,<br />

the rustling breeze <strong>and</strong> jack pines that grew gnarled <strong>and</strong> bent along<br />

the shore, all felt part <strong>of</strong> him. Tiklowicz was right - <strong>of</strong> all the places<br />

he had moved through, this was the only one he had ever wanted to<br />

stay in. It was as though for the first time since he was a boy in the<br />

mella <strong>and</strong> had watched his father, all beat up <strong>and</strong> bleeding, die that<br />

Alberto's nerves had become untangled <strong>and</strong> were loose <strong>and</strong> free,<br />

drifting inside his soul like the fingers <strong>of</strong> a sea anemone fluttering in<br />

underwater currents, letting him feel the universe as it spun by. He<br />

fell into sleep that night like he was diving into the lake, buoyed by<br />

happiness, the happiest he'd ever felt.<br />

When Alberto woke up, Tiklowicz was swhnming. Mist rose from<br />

the gray-blue water. Night still hung in the air <strong>and</strong> faint clouds<br />

stretched between skinny poplars <strong>and</strong> spruce trees like webs <strong>of</strong> cotton<br />

wool. Oskar waded out <strong>of</strong> the lake up onto the narrow stone<br />

beach naked, white from the cold, his penis curled between his legs.<br />

Steam evaporated <strong>of</strong>f his warm body into the dawn. He began shivering<br />

when he was drinking his c<strong>of</strong>fee; soon he was burning with<br />

fever <strong>and</strong> crawled back into the tent. Without thinking what he was<br />

doing, Alberto picked him up <strong>and</strong> carried him through the sundrenched<br />

morning along the overgrown logger's path, startling the<br />

wood thrushes <strong>and</strong> orioles in the understory. The day became suffused<br />

with the smell <strong>of</strong> pine needles <strong>and</strong> the sun-warmed earth.<br />

Alberto left Oskar at the road-head under an aspen, lying on his<br />

side in the shade, <strong>and</strong> went back to their campsite. And it was then,<br />

as he retraced his steps <strong>and</strong> gathered up the two packs, stuffing them<br />

with pots <strong>and</strong> pans <strong>and</strong> blankets <strong>and</strong> cans <strong>of</strong> food <strong>and</strong> their loaf <strong>of</strong><br />

bread <strong>and</strong> wax paper-wrapped cheese <strong>and</strong> clothes <strong>and</strong> Oskar's diary<br />

- then carrying everything, sweating in the bright, unfiltered light,<br />

that he learned that time was liquid; that it runs in a great rushing<br />

forward that sometimes gets diverted into pools that swirl in endless<br />

circles. That a person can spend his lifetime, caught, floating in a<br />

moment. By the time they got to Toronto, to the Royal Eglinton hospital,<br />

Oskar couldn't speak from the chattering <strong>of</strong> his teeth.<br />

Alberto sat in the hospital with Oskar. The influenza ward was<br />

long <strong>and</strong> full <strong>of</strong> muted sunlight, quiet except for the padding <strong>of</strong> wool<br />

felt slippers on the rubber-tiled floor, <strong>and</strong> the coughs <strong>and</strong> moans <strong>of</strong><br />

febrile men. For the three days before Oskar died, Alberto was overwhelmed<br />

by his friend's raging fever. It seeped into Alberto <strong>and</strong><br />

exploded in his mind until everything was clouded. A pretty Scottish<br />

nurse came <strong>and</strong> wiped Tiklowicz down with ice water. She wiped his<br />

thin body with a flannel, carefully tracing his bony knees <strong>and</strong> hips,<br />

the hollow <strong>of</strong> his collarbone. Oskar was flushed deep red, his skin<br />

raised in goose pimples.<br />

On the dawn <strong>of</strong> the third day that Oskar was in the hospital, it<br />

began to rain. Alberto watched the rain drip down the windowpane<br />

all day. He thought <strong>of</strong> his mother, the H<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> Fathma around her<br />

neck, her beautiful brown eyes wet <strong>and</strong> round watching him, sending<br />

him away forever as he stood on the crowded deck <strong>of</strong> the steamship<br />

next to his sister, Mila. In the early evening, just as the rain stopped<br />

<strong>and</strong> the sky above Toronto turned orange <strong>and</strong> pink <strong>and</strong> red from the<br />

sunset, he knew that Oskar was about to die; he knew it with as<br />

much certainty as if it had already happened <strong>and</strong> he were remembering<br />

it. He bent next to Oskar's hot, flushed face, breathed in his sour<br />

fever <strong>and</strong> kissed his cheek "Oskar," he said, <strong>and</strong> then quickly, without<br />

thinking, he whispered into his ear, "don't worry, I'll stay here<br />

with you. I won't go back I won't ever go back" III<br />

Tllr IInnrn nllllni IInlF'\lUn nnllnlU\f


y Allen<br />

Grossman<br />

Winter at the Sea Shore<br />

"Nightfall.<br />

Journey's end.<br />

Having come this far,<br />

we are at the shore.<br />

Look up. Over there!<br />

That high tower<br />

is mind.<br />

Look down.<br />

This world below us<br />

is a furious coast.<br />

Think back over<br />

the straightening<br />

<strong>of</strong> the seasons. Remember!<br />

Sowing, then burgeoning,<br />

then seed-fall. And now<br />

this harvest:<br />

winter<br />

wheat."<br />

"Allen, what is that flail<br />

on your shoulder?<br />

What is it for?"<br />

"It's the oar<br />

that brought us<br />

to this night<br />

<strong>and</strong> furious coast<br />

among winds."<br />

"Look! The high tower<br />

strews signals.<br />

Listen! Zeus, the counsellor,<br />

decrees snow."


(Clticago/ 19£8)<br />

Timor Mortis Inc" ASwitchboard Memory<br />

The business plan <strong>of</strong> Timor Mortis, Inc.<br />

required reconstruction <strong>of</strong> its switchboard.<br />

As soon as it was cOlnpleted, Beatrice<br />

appeared from her grave to man a position.<br />

Outgoing - from below, local- requires<br />

that she reach down, pull up a plug, <strong>and</strong> then<br />

throw the plug into a socket above<br />

her head, so that she can say to anyone,<br />

with a nUlnber, a long way <strong>of</strong>f: "It's time."<br />

Incoming - from above, afar - requires<br />

that she reach up above her head, grab a<br />

plug, <strong>and</strong> throw it into a socket with<br />

the corresponding number beneath her knees.<br />

"Somebody is calling, calling, calling, calling..."


y Peter<br />

Trachtenberg<br />

5 0 m e<br />

f e a 5 t<br />

from The Book<br />

<strong>of</strong> Calamities<br />

e'd heard the announcement on the radio that people<br />

weren't allowed to leave their homes, <strong>and</strong> we thought,<br />

okay, no problem. We heard gunshots around the<br />

neighborhood. We heard yelling. The house was<br />

surrounded by soldiers. I saw the comm<strong>and</strong>ing <strong>of</strong>ficer,<br />

he was one <strong>of</strong> our neighbors. He beat down the door.<br />

He said, lIyou, K. II - my husb<strong>and</strong>'s name was K. - IIWhat are you<br />

doing here when everybody else is outside being checked by security?<br />

Come out with your identity card." My husb<strong>and</strong> went outside with his<br />

card, <strong>and</strong> then from April 7th till the 14th they held him at the roadblock,<br />

right nearby. So he would have seen them torturing other men <strong>and</strong> young<br />

people, young boys. They cut <strong>of</strong>f men's genitals <strong>and</strong> fed them to the dogs.<br />

They hacked people to death with machetes. He watched all <strong>of</strong> it. And at<br />

two or three one morning, it was his misfortune to be tortured, too. He<br />

died on the 15th, very early in the morning.<br />

Not "he was killed," but "he died." Rw<strong>and</strong>ans <strong>of</strong>ten used that<br />

innocuous phrase when speaking <strong>of</strong> loved ones they'd lost in the<br />

genocide. I took it for an attempt at normalization. During World<br />

War II, the Nazis had committed most <strong>of</strong> their crimes away from<br />

eyewitnesses, herding their victims to remote killing grounds or<br />

sequestering them in death camps whose function was betrayed<br />

only by the pillars <strong>of</strong> smoke that rose from their chimneys.<br />

Afterwards it was possible - if not particularly credible - for<br />

people to say they hadn't known. In Rw<strong>and</strong>a, though, the killing<br />

took place in public. Everybody saw it. All you had to do was look<br />

out through your garden gate. All over Kigali, bodies lay piled on<br />

the roadside like sacks <strong>of</strong> refuse until they were picked up by<br />

garbage trucks. Hutu <strong>of</strong>fice girls in white dresses picked their way<br />

to work between spreading puddles <strong>of</strong> blood. General Romeo<br />

Dallaire describes seeing one such girl slip <strong>and</strong> fall. She got up<br />

quickly, but still, he writes, "it was as if someone had painted her<br />

body <strong>and</strong> her dress with a dark red oil. She became hysterical looking<br />

at it, <strong>and</strong> the more she screamed, the more attention she drew." I<br />

What need was there for anyone to be more explicit? I hadn't been<br />

in Rw<strong>and</strong>a long before I was taking it for granted that when anyone<br />

spoke <strong>of</strong> a death ten years before, he meant a death by violence.<br />

Murder had become a natural death.<br />

On the 18th, at nine in the morning, a group <strong>of</strong> soldiers <strong>and</strong> militiamen<br />

came to my house. They told me, IIGive us the money your husb<strong>and</strong> left<br />

you. 1I<br />

My husb<strong>and</strong>'s body was being dragged through the street, no one had<br />

buried him. They formed mountains, the bodies <strong>of</strong> all the men <strong>and</strong> boys<br />

they'd killed. And I said, III don't have any money. We don't have any<br />

money." They carried me from the living room <strong>and</strong> took me into a bedroom;<br />

my mother-in-law was shut up in another room. And from that day until<br />

the end <strong>of</strong> the war, the soldiers raped me. They were at it day <strong>and</strong> night, day<br />

<strong>and</strong> night, all <strong>of</strong> them. They came in all together, they dropped their pants at<br />

the same moment, <strong>and</strong> they raped me, jostling each other. There was always<br />

another group waiting in the living room. If one man left, another one came<br />

in to take his place, one after another. In the fifth month <strong>of</strong> my pregnancy, I<br />

aborted. They took me to the hospital for the abortion, <strong>and</strong> they told me, "We<br />

killed your brothers <strong>and</strong> sisters with machetes, but you, we're just going to<br />

rape you till you're dead." That whole time I was naked, I never had clothes<br />

on. I was completely swollen. I had infections, I kept vomiting. I couldn't<br />

even cry because I wanted to die <strong>and</strong> I couldn't die.<br />

In the midst <strong>of</strong> violence, especially if that violence is prolonged, a<br />

relationship sometimes forms between perpetrators <strong>and</strong> victims. It is<br />

not a true relationship, in the sense <strong>of</strong> something freely chosen, only<br />

the simulacrum <strong>of</strong> one or, more accurately, a parody. It may come<br />

into being because the victims implicitly underst<strong>and</strong> that their survival<br />

depends on winning the good-will <strong>of</strong> their captors or because<br />

even killers - maybe especially killers - need to feel that they are<br />

good people <strong>and</strong> will seek validation <strong>of</strong> their goodness from the very<br />

ones they are about to kill. It may simply be that when human<br />

beings are forced together, over time, they fall by inertia into the<br />

lulling rhythms <strong>and</strong> protocols <strong>of</strong> society. For such reasons, a group <strong>of</strong>


soldiers <strong>and</strong> militiamen might interrupt months <strong>of</strong> rape <strong>and</strong> sexual<br />

torture to take their victim to the hospital for an abortion <strong>of</strong> her<br />

husb<strong>and</strong>'s child. It's startling to realize that at the height <strong>of</strong> the<br />

genocide Rw<strong>and</strong>a's hospitals were still functioning, treating old<br />

people with pneumonia, children with broken arms. And, <strong>of</strong> course,<br />

delivering babies.<br />

What was the meaning <strong>of</strong> that gesture? On one level, the abortion<br />

was a continuation <strong>of</strong> the violence these men were inflicting on their<br />

captive, an intensification <strong>of</strong> it, a rape committed in the deepest<br />

parts <strong>of</strong> her body. As a Catholic, the woman would experience it as a<br />

murder <strong>of</strong> the life within her, <strong>of</strong> her husb<strong>and</strong>'s life, because it was<br />

his baby they were killing; they were killing him all over again. And<br />

at the same time, she would know that she was being spared, since<br />

it wasn't uncommon for genocidaires to terminate the pregnancies <strong>of</strong><br />

Tutsi women by cutting them open <strong>and</strong> ripping their unborn babies<br />

from their wombs. And so, at some point in the procedure, perhaps<br />

only for a moment, she might feel a trelnor <strong>of</strong> gratitude, <strong>and</strong> in recollection<br />

this gratitude would be the most terrible thing <strong>of</strong> all.<br />

If I go before the court, if I tell them what happened, ifI say what was<br />

done to my body, people will mock me. All I want to say is that they made<br />

me suffer. I want to tell the story <strong>of</strong> my suffering. And I want the one who<br />

raped me to underst<strong>and</strong> that he tortured me, that he's guilty. I want him to<br />

underst<strong>and</strong> what he did - freely, without being forced - I want him to<br />

admit his blame.<br />

The woman who told me this story was named Athanasie M. She<br />

was 45, with a h<strong>and</strong>some oval face that had begun to s<strong>of</strong>ten with<br />

age <strong>and</strong> very large dark eyes that looked even larger because <strong>of</strong> the<br />

dark circles beneath them. The whole time she spoke she held my<br />

eyes with hers. Once she had been a girl on one <strong>of</strong> the thous<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong><br />

haystack-shaped hills that make up the Rw<strong>and</strong>an l<strong>and</strong>scape ­<br />

Rw<strong>and</strong>a, pays des milles collines - destined for a life <strong>of</strong> farming beans<br />

<strong>and</strong> sorghum. Against all expectations she had gotten an education<br />

<strong>and</strong> become a gym teacher at a polytechnic in Kigali. She had married,<br />

borne children. And then the life she had won for herself had<br />

been torn asunder <strong>and</strong> she had been turned into a sort <strong>of</strong> domestic<br />

animal, naked <strong>and</strong> speechless, kept alive only to be abused until it<br />

would be time to kill her. It seemed a miracle that she could speak.<br />

But she could write; she had a journal that she had written about her<br />

ordeal. "Each page," she said, "is a thous<strong>and</strong> tears." Now Athanasie<br />

worked at a women's center counseling other survivors <strong>of</strong> rape <strong>and</strong><br />

sexual torture, many <strong>of</strong> whom were sick with AIDS. In this regard,<br />

she considered herself fortunate. As a result <strong>of</strong> what had been done<br />

to her she could no longer perform any kind <strong>of</strong> physical labor, not<br />

even sweep a floor, but she didn't have the virus <strong>and</strong> could look forward<br />

to a long life. Perhaps it's better to say that she could anticipate<br />

a normal lifespan, which for a Rw<strong>and</strong>an woman in 2002 was<br />

46.8 years. 2<br />

I had been recommended to Athanasie by someone in the<br />

States, <strong>and</strong> when our interview was over she told me, "When you see<br />

David, you must remember to tell him how fat I've gotten." The<br />

pride in her voice took me aback until I remembered the possible<br />

connotations <strong>of</strong> thinness.<br />

The clinic was a complex <strong>of</strong> low grey cinderblock buildings decorated<br />

inside with the drawings <strong>of</strong> the clients <strong>and</strong> their children, crude<br />

productions <strong>of</strong> crayon, glitter <strong>and</strong> con- ..<br />

struction paper mounted on the walls<br />

with yellowing tape. When I left, a group<br />

<strong>of</strong> women was dancing in the earth yard.<br />

They were welcoming some visitors from<br />

a Canadian aid organization. The dancers'<br />

movements were fierce, strutting; they<br />

held their arms out from their sides, their<br />

fingers splayed <strong>and</strong> quivering, <strong>and</strong> lifted<br />

their knees high, like wading birds.<br />

Drums sounded. The women dipped,<br />

took a step forward, a step to the side, a<br />

step back, each pent inside her square <strong>of</strong><br />

an invisible grid drawn on the red earth.<br />

Some <strong>of</strong> theln looked quite old, their faces<br />

seamed, their eyes dim. Their limbs might<br />

have been made <strong>of</strong> twisted rope. One<br />

woman had only one leg, on which she<br />

The women<br />

dipped, took a<br />

step to the side,<br />

astep back, each<br />

pent inside her<br />

square <strong>of</strong> an<br />

invisible grid<br />

drawn on the<br />

red earth.<br />

hopped unceasingly, as if trying to pound a stake into :he ground. Up<br />

<strong>and</strong> down she leapt, grinning <strong>and</strong> triumphant <strong>and</strong> ternble. I suppose<br />

she was trying to proclaim victory over her disfigurement, but to me<br />

she seemed like a reproach to the world <strong>of</strong> the whole.<br />

A few weeks earlier, at a cocktail party at the American Club in<br />

Kigali, I'd been introduced to a man who worked for a Christian<br />

conflict-management organization. He was running reconciliation<br />

workshops. Reconciliation was a word you heard a great deal in<br />

Rw<strong>and</strong>a. You heard it from government <strong>of</strong>ficials, including elnployees<br />

<strong>of</strong> the eponymous Unity <strong>and</strong> Reconciliation Commission, <strong>and</strong> the<br />

spokespersons <strong>of</strong> victims' groups, from ex-detenus, perpetrato:s who<br />

had served their time in prison, <strong>and</strong>, more rarely, from rescapes, the


itself," Athanasie told me. "True justice."<br />

I thought I understood this, <strong>and</strong> not just because what had happened<br />

here suggested a Platonic archetype <strong>of</strong> injustice, a crime so<br />

immense as to make any response to it seeIn pathetically, even<br />

insultingly, inadequate. (Hannah Arendt was speaking <strong>of</strong> genocide<br />

when she said that we "are unable to forgive what [we] cannot punish<br />

[<strong>and</strong>] we are unable to punish what has turned out to be unforgivable.")4<br />

In the hierarchy <strong>of</strong> human needs, justice may be only a<br />

tier below shelter or mother-love. Maybe it represents father-love, a<br />

love that, unlike the magnanimous, blanketing kind mothers are<br />

supposed to give us, is based on distinctions, boundaries, equivalency,<br />

one thing for another. One symbol for such love is a staff,<br />

which leads some people to think <strong>of</strong> it as merely punitive. But a<br />

staff is also used for pointing. Human justice, in Biiber's formulation,<br />

is each person getting what he deserves, while divine justice is<br />

each person getting what he is. By this formulation, divine justice<br />

began on the first day <strong>of</strong> creation, when God parted the heavens<br />

from the earth. When He cast Eve <strong>and</strong> Adam out <strong>of</strong> paradise, He<br />

wasn't punishing an act so much as decreeing that this, henceforth,<br />

was what it would mean to be human - that is, mortal, homeless,<br />

<strong>and</strong> ashamed.<br />

Human justice is human: it applies to relations between human<br />

beings or between human beings <strong>and</strong> the man-made artifact <strong>of</strong> the<br />

State. The afflictions sent by God or nature don't trouble us the<br />

same way wrongs committed by other people do. The very word<br />

"wrongs" is indicative, since it isn't used <strong>of</strong> nature. A tidal wave<br />

may kill a quarter <strong>of</strong> a million people <strong>and</strong> a man with a knife only<br />

one, yet it's the murderer who inspires not just horror but outrage<br />

<strong>and</strong> it's the murderer we seek to punish. King Xerxes flogging the<br />

sea is only an image <strong>of</strong> the folly <strong>of</strong> power. I do not think this difference<br />

stems solely from the human capacity for malice. Eichmann<br />

appears to have sent millions to the gas chambers without feeling<br />

much <strong>of</strong> it. Men know that God <strong>and</strong> nature are bigger <strong>and</strong> more<br />

powerful than they are (though in our time, this knowledge may be<br />

fading), but we think <strong>of</strong> other men as our equals, not in the social,<br />

but the creaturely sense, as beings moved by the same desires <strong>and</strong><br />

aversions as ourselves <strong>and</strong> subject to the same laws <strong>of</strong> pain <strong>and</strong><br />

death. Every crime shatters this equality. When one man kills<br />

another man, he declares that he is big <strong>and</strong> the other is small, is<br />

nothing. If the victim's wife <strong>and</strong> children are forced to witness this,<br />

they too are made nothing. When a chemical plant discharges poison<br />

gas that wipes out a village, all its people are made nothing <strong>and</strong><br />

their annihilation is compounded when the <strong>of</strong>ficers <strong>of</strong> the chemical<br />

company are allowed to live on without consequence. Among the<br />

things I heard during my time in Rw<strong>and</strong>a, one <strong>of</strong> the most painful<br />

was uttered almost incidentally by a rescapee after I asked her if she<br />

believed Tutsi <strong>and</strong> Hutu could ever truly be reconciled. "It is impossible,"<br />

she began, <strong>and</strong> I think she meant to explain, methodically,<br />

impersonally, why this should be so. But suddenly she clutched her<br />

head <strong>and</strong> blurted, "l'etais tres abaissee." I<br />

would translate it as "1 was so degrad­<br />

ed" or "abased," except the French<br />

more clearly expresses the idea <strong>of</strong> being<br />

lowered. At that moment everything that<br />

had been done to this woman snapped<br />

into focus with such clarity that I could<br />

no more st<strong>and</strong> to look at her directly<br />

than if she had been the sun.<br />

From the state's perspective, justice<br />

has multiple functions, froIn ensuring<br />

that the criminal cannot harm others to<br />

deterring future wrongdoers. To victilns<br />

<strong>of</strong> crime, however, or to their survivors,<br />

the purpose <strong>of</strong> justice is to restore the<br />

Thous<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> Tutsi<br />

women were dying<br />

<strong>of</strong> AIOS, which the<br />

rape squads had<br />

deployed as a<br />

weapon <strong>of</strong> delayed<br />

biological warfare.<br />

equality between themselves <strong>and</strong> the persons who wronged them. s<br />

That this equality is spiritual is evident from the fact that it may be<br />

restored even to the dead. It's precisely when justice is denied that<br />

people most long for it, even if they can only ilnagine the world in<br />

which it exists. Hell was invented because on earth men commit<br />

crime after crime <strong>and</strong> grow fat while their victims' children go hungry.<br />

And perhaps the belief in hell - hell even more than heaven ­<br />

was enough to console entire nations during the thous<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> years<br />

in which they suffered at the h<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> others without redress, without<br />

even the acknowledgment that a wrong had been done to theIn.<br />

Personally, I doubt it. And I think that societies that fail to<br />

address the great crimes in their past remain blighted by them. The<br />

long backwardness <strong>and</strong> impoverishment <strong>and</strong> brutality <strong>of</strong> the<br />

AInerican South, conditions that afflicted whites as well as blacks,<br />

must have had something to do with the unburied corpse <strong>of</strong> slavery,<br />

a corpse that wasn't a corpse at all because in some ways it was still<br />

alive, the haint at the crossroads, the hellhound on everybody's<br />

trail. Russia may have emerged from the 80-year sleep <strong>of</strong> communism,<br />

but it is still dreaming <strong>of</strong> the crimes that were committed in<br />

communism's name; only in dreams can it name the crimes out


y Mary Zoo<br />

Twin<br />

selected poems<br />

Of all the street's windows, only yours dreams.<br />

Barely twenty the child you were<br />

clitnbed the spiral staircase toward the moon<br />

seeking ocean, its twisting<br />

scorched by moonlight.<br />

You too felt the pull <strong>of</strong> it,<br />

that heavy seed filled with time.<br />

Waves dragged in your ear,<br />

chained, unchained, the slow war<br />

flowing froin some eternal center.<br />

A future waiting to be yours<br />

lay beyond a bridge <strong>of</strong> stars.<br />

You watched them pass,<br />

the long animal shadows <strong>of</strong> youth,<br />

partner to the dancing coin<br />

that rose <strong>and</strong> spun <strong>and</strong> would not fall.<br />

C<strong>and</strong>le<br />

Deep in its mantle,<br />

the arrow that rises<br />

from the cliff<br />

<strong>of</strong> its own cutting<br />

descends through<br />

flesh <strong>and</strong> fat,<br />

climbing the hungry<br />

root whose flame<br />

feeds the round<br />

light that eats<br />

its way up.


mother was an academic over there <strong>and</strong> now works at Nails Nails<br />

Nails. She taught her daughter first-class English. Ziva likes to talk<br />

about the blizzards <strong>of</strong> St. Petersburg, <strong>and</strong> how as a girl she skated<br />

the frozen Neva, ice cocooning the 60 rivers <strong>and</strong> canals. She talks<br />

about 30-below-zero temperatures as she paints tiny stars on inchlong<br />

fingernails. Hannah inherited her mother's love <strong>of</strong> winter. Fat<br />

snow, not the pitiful stringy snow we have here. I remember snow<br />

like that from when I was little little <strong>and</strong> my father carrying me.<br />

"1 hope your father has those maple cookies."<br />

"It's Kim. Remeinber that, Hannah."<br />

Daddy opens the door in a peach-colored satin robe <strong>and</strong> hugs <strong>and</strong><br />

kisses me, the towel around his neck<br />

smelling <strong>of</strong> lavender. "Happy Valentine's<br />

We used to go<br />

to Central Park to<br />

watch the swans<br />

but lately Hannah's<br />

been spending<br />

every minute with<br />

her lipstick.<br />

Day." Then he takes Hannah's h<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong><br />

pulls her inside for a hug. "Happy Cupid<br />

to you too."<br />

At first I don't look at him because I'm<br />

afraid. When he had his chin surgery he<br />

went battered-woman black <strong>and</strong> blue for<br />

weeks <strong>and</strong> when he reduced his Adam's<br />

apple, his voice changed.<br />

"Guys, what's different?" he asks in<br />

his whisper, pivoting for us in the foyer.<br />

His robe clings to his breasts, <strong>and</strong><br />

they're a set <strong>of</strong> perfect tennis balls. He<br />

must have had the gummy bear implants.<br />

He hasn't said anything about mine that finally are budding like the<br />

green tomatoes Mrs. Hertzberg grows in her classroom.<br />

"From the towel around your neck I gather you're about to take a<br />

shower in the afternoon," I say, knowing what he wants me to notice.<br />

"When you lived at home, you took showers in the morning.'.'<br />

He places his h<strong>and</strong>s on his hips. "I'm going to a party tonIght.<br />

Something else has changed."<br />

"You're growing your hair out, Mrs. Cadorine?" Hannah says. She<br />

is smart <strong>and</strong> can blab about Pavlova, Nijinsky, <strong>and</strong> the ballet. But<br />

mostly it's lip liner <strong>and</strong> short or long strokes <strong>and</strong> how to apply<br />

foundation to blend <strong>and</strong> conceal. She's set on becoming a make-up<br />

artist for TV.<br />

"Daddy wants to be called Kiln," I reinind her. "Even Gr<strong>and</strong>ma<br />

calls him that. He's going to a clinic where they sew hair plugs into<br />

your scalp."<br />

"Hair is hard," he says, his mouth losing its smile for an instant.<br />

His hair is strawberry blond <strong>and</strong> long thin wisps <strong>of</strong> it are arranged<br />

over the top <strong>of</strong> his head. Not even estrogen helps, <strong>and</strong> the hair plugs<br />

are a money tar pit. I remember when Daddy lived at home his hair<br />

would fall out <strong>and</strong> stick to the sides <strong>of</strong> the tub like slivery goldfish,<br />

<strong>and</strong> Mommy would laugh. His skin is ultra-smooth from electrolysis.<br />

Hannah told me about the white nights back home where dusk <strong>and</strong><br />

dawn meet in summer skies. That's what Daddy's face reminds me<br />

<strong>of</strong>, or a mute swan whose plumage is gone.<br />

He turns, pulling his robe tighter, sucking in his stomach, raising<br />

his chin. "The results were very pleasing."<br />

"You've grown a chest for the party," I blurt out. "You've had the<br />

gummy bears."<br />

Daddy grins. "That's right, but for more than just the party. For<br />

forever."<br />

"Can we go with you to the party?" Hannah asks.<br />

"Chairman Mao wouldn't want that, Hannah. You know how<br />

Dalloway's mother is. Her brain might appear to be t<strong>of</strong>u <strong>and</strong> eggplant<br />

but she manages to find out everything."<br />

"Oh, please," Hannah begs.<br />

I wonder how many potential customers she thinks she might<br />

meet. Hannah is taking an Internet cosmetology course. This week's<br />

lesson is brow makeover make-up tips. Nothing at Bronx Science<br />

interests her as much. We used to go to Central Park to watch the<br />

swans, but lately Hannah's been spending every minute with her lipsticks.<br />

I used to fill notebooks about migrating birds. The birds are<br />

confused. They don't know summer from winter <strong>and</strong> they're not sure<br />

when to fly. The trees are just as bewildered when green buds appear<br />

in February. I think I'm the only one who's worried about the birds.<br />

"Dalloway <strong>and</strong> parties don't mix," Daddy explains, ushering us<br />

into the dining area where the table is decked out <strong>and</strong> waiting. "It<br />

wouldn't be any fun for you guys. It's an adult Valentine gala."<br />

Daddy shouldn't have said gala, now she will want more than ever to<br />

go. He's practicing his feminization walk: use hips not whole body, foot,<br />

thigh, leg. "Let me show you the dessert course. You can have your own<br />

soiree right here."<br />

Hannah's lips turn down.<br />

"Sounds great to me," 1 say, following Daddy into the dining area.<br />

On the table, maroon napkins are folded like sails <strong>of</strong> yachts, spoons<br />

<strong>and</strong> forks rest against the silver moon <strong>of</strong> the chafing dish, which is<br />

filled with Godiva foil-wrapped Valentines. Fresh cut flowers sprout<br />

from a vase, leaves like red pepper rinds that have been shined.<br />

"Dutch apple <strong>and</strong> strawberry rhubarb pies. Maple cookies with an


inch <strong>of</strong> frosting. This way for main courses <strong>and</strong> appetizers," he<br />

says, whipping open the refrigerator to show <strong>of</strong>f individual tins<br />

from Good-N-Plenty. "Chicken tenders, vegetable pot pies <strong>and</strong><br />

empanadas. You could snack <strong>and</strong> have a movie marathon. I got<br />

three Hitchcocks! Dalloway's favorites."<br />

It would be heaven to sit with a Dutch apple pie between my<br />

knees <strong>and</strong> watch Vertigo, to pick apart the walnuts <strong>and</strong> brown sugar<br />

while Jimmy Stewart hangs by his fingertips from the edge <strong>of</strong> a<br />

building, to crunch pieces <strong>of</strong> crust <strong>and</strong> pluck out syrupy apples as<br />

Kim Novak drifts like humidity at the florists around the peonies<br />

<strong>and</strong> lilies. Hitchcock doesn't show, but suggests, the gnats halfheartedly<br />

circling the blooms. To be back in time with basically a<br />

whole pie <strong>and</strong> no school the next day. What could be better?<br />

I drop my overnight bag <strong>and</strong> go for a fork <strong>and</strong> plate, the glass<br />

ones in the shape <strong>of</strong> sunfish. "Do you want rhubarb or apple,<br />

Hannah?"<br />

"Both," Hannah says.<br />

"Me too." I stab the rhubarb with a pie cutter. "What about you,<br />

Daddy?" I've always loved Daddy's sweet tooth.<br />

"I can't, Dalloway, I have to watch my waist."<br />

"I miss seeing your love h<strong>and</strong>les," I say, balancing a heaping slice<br />

<strong>of</strong> apple pie on the prongs <strong>of</strong> my fork. "Hannah, he used to have a<br />

hula-hoop <strong>of</strong> fat right above his belt <strong>and</strong> when I was a little girl I<br />

grabbed onto it thinking it was his h<strong>and</strong>."<br />

"Hula-hoop, what is that?" she asks.<br />

"It was a plastic hoop that you threw your hips around inside <strong>of</strong>."<br />

"Throw your hips, how?"<br />

Daddy gets himself a glass <strong>of</strong> water from the sink <strong>and</strong> pulls out<br />

a drawer. Both <strong>of</strong> us automatically close in. The drawer is full <strong>of</strong><br />

punch-out pill cards, samples, the kind doctors give away. I pick<br />

up a pill card. Under plastic in neat rows are purplish tablets the<br />

color <strong>of</strong> vitamin B-12. Two <strong>of</strong> them are missing. He snatches the<br />

card back.<br />

"What's all this, Mrs. Cadorine?" Hannah asks.<br />

At first, he doesn't answer. Then he pushes another tablet from<br />

the punch-out card <strong>and</strong> pops it into his mouth. "It's Kim, remember?<br />

These are hormones."<br />

Hannah dislikes drugs. She saw her father make syringes out <strong>of</strong><br />

sewing needles <strong>and</strong> ballpoint pens, inject over-the-counter cough<br />

syrup directly into a muscle. Near the end, her father lived in a<br />

packing box with a mongrel <strong>and</strong> when he begged on the street his<br />

sign read, "Please help me buy food for my dog. ff<br />

Hannah said<br />

Russians love animals much more than people.<br />

Daddy washes down what was in his mouth.<br />

"Are they making you a woman?" I ask.<br />

He nods.<br />

Hannah licks at her new hyper-shine lipstick. The teentastics at<br />

school are leery <strong>of</strong> her, as if one <strong>of</strong> their eyes might go blind if they<br />

hung around her.<br />

Daddy takes another drink <strong>of</strong> water, <strong>and</strong> then holds out the glass<br />

like he's toasting Hannah. "What I wouldn't give to look like you."<br />

"If I can make you look like me will you take us to your party?"<br />

she asks Daddy.<br />

I want to kick her.<br />

A smile spreads across his face. "Let me think about it while I<br />

shower," he says, heading toward the bathroom. "Dalloway, go check<br />

out the guest room. There's another surprise."<br />

In the spare bedroom Daddy has his roll-top desk, his kite <strong>and</strong><br />

windsock collection, all his research <strong>and</strong> development orange juice<br />

containers, his hydroponics files, <strong>and</strong> now he's set up the igloo tent.<br />

Inside are maroon sleeping bags, <strong>and</strong> on each pillow is a package<br />

wrapped in shiny red paper <strong>and</strong> tied with silver ribbon. I feel tears<br />

growing in my eyes like weeds. I crawl into the tent <strong>and</strong> fetch the<br />

packages. "Here, Hannah, this one's for you." I rip mine open, but<br />

Hannah uses her fingernail to loosen the tape making sure she doesn't<br />

tear the paper.<br />

"This is beautiful," she says, holding up the cowhide shoulder bag,<br />

petting the swirls <strong>of</strong> brown <strong>and</strong> cream-colored hair.<br />

"I hope no anhnal had to die to make that stupid purse," I say,<br />

peering inside. "Hey, there's a $50 bill <strong>and</strong> a key. I bet it's the key to<br />

this apartment." I stuff the fifty <strong>and</strong> key into the pocket <strong>of</strong> my jacket,<br />

throwing the purse on top my day pack.<br />

"Dalloway, I got a $50 bill too. I can't believe it."<br />

"But no key?" I ask with a catch in my throat. I'm the daughter.<br />

"No key." Then she folds the foil gift wrap <strong>and</strong> slips it inside the<br />

purse, a solemn expression on her face like she's thinking <strong>of</strong> her<br />

father who is buried in Russia.<br />

I sit at the roll-top, tugging out the drawers. The bottom drawer is<br />

hard to pull, <strong>and</strong> no wonder - it's filled with envelopes, the flowerprinted<br />

stationery kind, not the business ones. There must be hundreds<br />

<strong>of</strong> love letters. Hannah grabs Vogue from the entertainlnent shelf <strong>and</strong><br />

plops into the beanbag chair. I lift a packet <strong>of</strong> envelopes, smelling<br />

perfume. Letter after letter I slip under my nose like a fading drug


paintings. Hannah <strong>of</strong>fers to do his makeup <strong>and</strong> we crowd into the<br />

bathroom. Daddy hauls in an ice chest filled with makeup, at least<br />

five <strong>of</strong> everything. Gloss sticks. Pressed powders. Concealers.<br />

Brushes. On the sink is a head wearing a wig <strong>of</strong> s<strong>of</strong>t curls past the<br />

shoulders, the color <strong>of</strong> late August cornhusks. "It's called the<br />

Challay blond," he says, pulling it on. Then he sits on the toilet seat.<br />

I'm frightened. He's almost pretty.<br />

"First, Kiln, we start with the moisturizer." Hannah finds a triangular<br />

sponge <strong>and</strong> dots his cheeks <strong>and</strong> chin. There used to be<br />

hair there <strong>and</strong> when Daddy kissed me goodnight I felt his bristles.<br />

Then she presses the sponge <strong>and</strong> begins to connect the dots.<br />

"Blend upwards, under the eyebrow, <strong>and</strong> an inch below the jawline<br />

<strong>and</strong> chin. That's something not everyone knows. To mature<br />

eye skin we don't apply foundation." She bites her lip because<br />

she's concentrating.<br />

"Looks, what are looks?" Hannah blurts out suddenly, pressing<br />

foundation over Daddy's lips. "Who cares? My father was h<strong>and</strong>some<br />

but when he died <strong>and</strong> his h<strong>and</strong> turned cold, I dropped it." She<br />

picks up the lipstick pencil. "On the lower lip work from the center<br />

to the corners. Now blot."<br />

II II<br />

When a cab stops, Hannah <strong>and</strong> Daddy sit in back <strong>and</strong> I take the<br />

seat in front. I stare hard out the window as 10th Avenue flies by,<br />

the Yemenite delis <strong>and</strong> Chinese takeouts, the Puerto Rican auto<br />

repairs <strong>and</strong> the boarded-up public library, a worn-out stretch before<br />

the Starbucks <strong>of</strong> Amsterdam Avenue. At a stoplight, a turbaned<br />

woman kneels before a chain fence pushing a plate under it, <strong>and</strong><br />

then pulling the plate out, <strong>and</strong> then pushing it back. I haven't said<br />

anything to Daddy or Hannah about California, not a word about<br />

the jobs Mommy has applied for or how she goes online every<br />

morning to find out the temperature in San Francisco <strong>and</strong> input it<br />

into a spreadsheet.<br />

The cab driver keeps looking into the rearview mirror to admire<br />

the two lovelies.<br />

"Left side, near corner," Daddy points to 78th Street.<br />

The building rises from a canyon <strong>of</strong> dirty brownstone.<br />

Daddy taps my shoulder. "Don't be shy, guys. Remember to<br />

smile."<br />

The lobby floor is polished marble, <strong>and</strong> on the walls <strong>Art</strong> Deco<br />

mirrors hang alongside a reproduction <strong>of</strong> Warhol's Chairman<br />

Mao. "There's your mother, Dalloway."<br />

"He was a pig/' Hannah growls. "When he croaked his people<br />

said God has died. Can you believe that?" She has her new purse<br />

stuffed with business cards. Some say Hot. Extreme. Make-up <strong>Art</strong>istry<br />

Call Hannah. To See Your Wrinkles Disappear Make Appointment with the<br />

Tchaikovsky <strong>of</strong> Makeover. Beautiful Brides: Your House or Mine.<br />

Daddy ushers us by the security guard who checks his list for the<br />

name Cadorine. "The penthouse elevator's in back." He gives Daddy<br />

an approving once over, <strong>and</strong> then his eye slides onto Hannah who<br />

floats past him like a cloud in black jeans <strong>and</strong> a blouse with seethrough<br />

sleeves. I have on the same outfit but it fits me differently.<br />

The elevator makes me feel I'm inside a jewelry box where the French<br />

perfumes are fighting. The doors slap open, <strong>and</strong> we step out into a<br />

sunken living room filled with people. "Kim," someone says. I recognize<br />

Dr. Peeler, Daddy's therapist, rushing toward us. It was her<br />

beach house where the fiasco happened.<br />

"That's her," I whisper to Hannah, who is already digging in her<br />

purse. "That's Dr. Peeler."<br />

Daddy gives Dr. Peeler a kiss <strong>and</strong> squeezes her h<strong>and</strong>. Her pixie<br />

face shines so that I wonder if she applied floor polish instead <strong>of</strong><br />

moisturizer. "Ah, Dalloway, I'm so glad to see you," she greets me,<br />

her nostrils quivering as if she's sniffing the burning bathroom. "Is<br />

this your Russian friend? Why she's lovely." When she turns toward<br />

us, so does her perfume, a bouquet <strong>of</strong> stale meadow flowers.<br />

Hannah has a card ready. Bridal Parties to Headshots. Futurist Full<br />

Treatment Make-up. Dr. Peeler examines the business card, <strong>and</strong> then<br />

asks for a h<strong>and</strong>ful. I don't know where to put my eyes. "Hannah,<br />

please don't leave me. I don't want to st<strong>and</strong> alone," I say but I don't<br />

know whether she hears me or not.<br />

Then Dr. Peeler has Hannah by one h<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Daddy by the<br />

other, <strong>and</strong> is pulling them away. Madonna is singing "Lucky Star"in<br />

a voice like a white trout being gutted. It is an old people party, the<br />

music proves it.<br />

"Nice blouse," says a man shorter than me with a wispy mustache.<br />

He taps his cigarette on his watch, <strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong>fers me a Pall Mall. "You<br />

don't have to inhale," he advises. "We can st<strong>and</strong> next to a window."<br />

"Ish," I tell him. I guess he figures if I'm taller than him I'm old<br />

enough to smoke. He apologizes <strong>and</strong> then tries to light his cigarette<br />

before he puts it to his lips.<br />

Hannah <strong>and</strong> Daddy <strong>and</strong> Dr. Peeler are sitting on the piano bench.<br />

In the middle <strong>of</strong> the room a red-bearded man with horn-rimmed<br />

glasses is pontificating. He holds a plate piled high with desserts.<br />

liThe bottom line is... women are the phil<strong>and</strong>erers, not men," he


a bird had dropped it there, feels like walking into a heated house.<br />

"You've been drinking," she snaps. "Stupid."<br />

"Tardmuffin."<br />

"You sound like thein. Nothing is worse," Hannah accuses.<br />

"Do you really think sounding like the kids at school is worse<br />

than dancing with that ding-head red-beard?"<br />

"By a technochasm. By ten shades <strong>of</strong> termite."<br />

"Okay, diggity dank," I say.<br />

"Where are we going?" she asks.<br />

"Central Park"<br />

"The duck pond?"<br />

"Yeah, the sooner the quicker."<br />

"All the swans <strong>and</strong> ducks are roosting, Dalloway."<br />

"Doesn't matter."<br />

At Trump Plaza, a blonde in a skimpy dress sways like Red Sea<br />

hair coral. Guests slip out <strong>of</strong> the hotel <strong>and</strong> into silk limousines. Some<br />

clamber into carriages. There are more horses in their pitiful blinders,<br />

survivors <strong>of</strong> a magnificent line kidnapped from the grass. A carriage<br />

driver holding a six-foot switch cries, "Twenty bucks for a romantic<br />

tour <strong>of</strong> Central Park," <strong>and</strong> a girl <strong>and</strong> boy climb into his carriage.<br />

Hannah hurries to h<strong>and</strong> the couple one <strong>of</strong><br />

her business cards. Hannah, we should<br />

I think he <strong>and</strong><br />

Dr. Peeler like each<br />

other. That makes<br />

Daddy alesbian I<br />

free the horse. She's far away giving out<br />

her card, Prime FX Lip, to a girl with a man<br />

at least twice her age.<br />

"Come on, come on," I call out.<br />

The couple has settled into their seat,<br />

<strong>and</strong> the carriage driver lifts the reins. The<br />

white horse struggles over the cobblestone<br />

street. Hannah's false eye reminds<br />

me <strong>of</strong> the horse's blinders. Do the hours <strong>of</strong> pulling the carriage pass<br />

slowly for the horse? You can hear the answer in its step, one clop<br />

<strong>and</strong> a hesitation, <strong>and</strong> then another clop. We follow the carriage into<br />

the park, but the horse is picking up speed. It must smell the trees<br />

<strong>and</strong> think there's rest here.<br />

"Run," I shout. "We have to catch up."<br />

"Dalloway, stop. We'll go to the pond, <strong>and</strong> then home. If we get<br />

into trouble, your mother will never let you see Kim again."<br />

If Mommy has her way I won't see Hannah much longer either.<br />

There's mist in the trees <strong>and</strong> homeless men huddle next to each<br />

other on stone benches. The streetlight throws smeary images <strong>of</strong><br />

their faces on the wet pathway. I almost don't see them because<br />

they're always there. Like the static you used to hear between TV<br />

channels. One <strong>of</strong> them wears a hooded sweatshirt <strong>and</strong> Kleenex boxes<br />

on his feet. I reach for Hannah's arm. She <strong>of</strong>fers me her jacket, but I<br />

tell her no. Is she talking as we walk deeper into the park? I can't be<br />

sure that I'm not hearing her thoughts. This, Dalloway, this misery is<br />

what St. Petersburg feels like. They're sprucing up the palaces but<br />

the city was built on a swamp by force, stone by stone, <strong>and</strong> workers<br />

died like flies. It's still there, all the hell.<br />

"I told Kim we'd take a cab," Hannah says. "I promised we'd go<br />

straight home."<br />

"I think he <strong>and</strong> Dr. Peeler like each other. That makes Daddy a lesbian."<br />

"Big deal."<br />

"Did I say it was? Let's go over there."<br />

We plop down near the pond <strong>and</strong> wait for the swans. On the next<br />

bench, a man sits in a flak jacket without an umbrella or hat. A grocery<br />

cart filled with folded newspapers <strong>and</strong> Duane Reade sacks is<br />

parked near him. I nudge Hannah. "That guy is sitting up so straight<br />

he looks made out <strong>of</strong> stone."<br />

Hannah shrugs. Rain is beginning to fall harder, the skinny drops<br />

getting fat. I rest my head on her shoulder, <strong>and</strong> then she takes <strong>of</strong>f her<br />

jacket <strong>and</strong> covers me with it. "See, stupid, I told you swans sleep in<br />

their nests at night. The only ones that swim in moonlight are the swan<br />

maidens. When they take <strong>of</strong>f their feather shirts the birds becOIne<br />

beautiful women." She spreads her hair behind her so the rain can soak<br />

it. "You brought us on a wild goose chase."<br />

I study the brown surface <strong>of</strong> the pond. Empty. Then I close my<br />

eyes <strong>and</strong> concentrate on making two graceful shapes appear, I think<br />

swans, their necks together, talking in whistles. When I open myeyes<br />

the water is still naked. The man in the flak jacket hasn't moved.<br />

"I think that man is dead," I say.<br />

Hannah snorts, "Dead drunk"<br />

"Bet."<br />

"Five dollars."<br />

Hannah gets up <strong>and</strong> goes over to the man. "Hello? Would you like<br />

a facial?" she asks, a hank <strong>of</strong> her hair falling against him, "I'll show<br />

you, Dalloway. One touch <strong>and</strong> he'll grunt <strong>and</strong> maybe even wakeup.<br />

Then you'll owe me five U.s. dollars." Her fingertips touch his cheek<br />

like she is applying dots <strong>of</strong> foundation. "Oh, no," she whispers. Rings<br />

<strong>of</strong> moisture drop from the streetlight over her shining head. "Come<br />

here, Dalloway. Come," she says, quivering. "Give me your h<strong>and</strong>."<br />

I let her press my h<strong>and</strong> against his cheek Her fingers stay wann<br />

on top <strong>of</strong> mine, while under them the chill spreads. "Do you feel it?"


New Year's Day: Looking for aSign<br />

From the vast blue bouillon burning a dome over us<br />

to the ice petals in their miniscule exactitude - Inillions<br />

on the twiggy branches <strong>of</strong> every bush -<br />

or the tiny frost-ferns printing the bedroom window;<br />

from the high wavering call <strong>of</strong> the geese getting the stormy message<br />

<strong>and</strong> moving south<br />

to the friendly bark <strong>of</strong> the dog with one white husky eye<br />

stopping to lick my h<strong>and</strong> when I stop at the sun-dial;<br />

from the big infinities to all slJch local color<br />

I'm clawing about with my eyes<br />

to find the right sign - steam<br />

<strong>of</strong>f the frozen stream, tabula rasa after a night <strong>of</strong> snow -<br />

but nothing will serve:<br />

not even the cries <strong>of</strong> marsh hawk <strong>and</strong> kingfisher<br />

as hunger keeps gnawing them <strong>and</strong> they look down<br />

on only the white world frozen below;<br />

<strong>and</strong> not my own black cashmere cap when it starts running blood<br />

staining my forehead like a Kashmiri Sikh,<br />

nor the ladybird on my window come out to test<br />

the New Year light - who scales on six mini-legs<br />

a mile <strong>of</strong> glass <strong>and</strong> is for a moment falling back illuminated.<br />

Morning under Muckish<br />

Between rain <strong>and</strong> shine a kestrel stretches on the wind,<br />

flapping fast <strong>and</strong> casual to stay still. Assassin. Negotiator<br />

<strong>of</strong> gales. Cows lie in the lea <strong>of</strong> a hedge <strong>of</strong> honeysuckle.<br />

Tall phlox nod in a sea-breeze. A sudden wood pigeon<br />

rises from the green grave <strong>of</strong> a potato field - its language<br />

clapclapclap - vanishing. Two ash trees huddle frOln rain,<br />

trunks <strong>and</strong> branches hugging one another. A loopy line<br />

<strong>of</strong> wet washing limply dangles: quotidian brilliance<br />

<strong>of</strong> shirts, towels, flashy underwear. A stroppy dark dog<br />

harries my heels <strong>and</strong> a hidden voice calls Mungo!<br />

Mungo! And one almost ripe blackberry in a bushful<br />

<strong>of</strong> bitterness, its onyx eye winking. Margins<br />

where meadowsweet meets loosestrife. A thorn tree<br />

putting on new leaves. Trekking clouds. Empty hills.


What Shadows<br />

Needles <strong>of</strong> rain. Ground makes no moan.<br />

Sigh <strong>of</strong> wind in the sycamore. What's passing.<br />

Haw berries rusting the hawthorn trees.<br />

Don't look back. Think Orpheus. Pillar <strong>of</strong> salt.<br />

One breath, then another. Sweat <strong>of</strong> apprehension.<br />

Still life with wind <strong>and</strong> breadcrulnbs.<br />

But I keep wanting to turn around.<br />

No whimsy in it, running the gamut<br />

bright red. And as deadly, she said, as nightshade.<br />

Still I went on. Looking at her lips.<br />

Sea verge to cliff edge, no shaking <strong>of</strong>f<br />

what shadows me.<br />

After seeing the rain-swollen torrent at Gurteen,<br />

I dream I want to give myself over<br />

to its foamy, stone-broken dissolution <strong>of</strong> salt.<br />

What then? What's not possible?<br />

Weather <strong>Art</strong>ists<br />

In a jagged patch <strong>of</strong> blue<br />

Pontormo might caress<br />

across the tank-top <strong>of</strong> an angel<br />

(a wide-eyed beauty<br />

staring challenge or invitation<br />

from under the lemon-green<br />

heavy legs <strong>of</strong> a dead Jesus)<br />

morning light is shining.<br />

It shatters to a pelting shower<br />

clattering the flat ro<strong>of</strong><br />

like the mad h<strong>and</strong><br />

<strong>of</strong> a bodhrdn banger, high<br />

on the quick shifts <strong>of</strong> light,<br />

the slant mercury-bright<br />

shoots <strong>and</strong> stems <strong>of</strong> rain<br />

cueing him. After it passes<br />

silence seeps in, brimming<br />

the garden: provisional<br />

absolute <strong>and</strong> absolution<br />

Leopardi came to terms with:<br />

its inauguration <strong>of</strong> small voices<br />

(robin tongue, raindropplink<br />

through the sycamore<br />

leaf to leaf, a sudden gush <strong>of</strong> wind<br />

translating every syllable<br />

into tree-speech)<br />

till light breaks back,<br />

coating grass with that<br />

yellow the pleine air painters<br />

patented, so when I look<br />

out this eastern window<br />

I see, suspended<br />

from a fuchsia twig, three<br />

tiny blown-glass globes <strong>of</strong> lighi<br />

in which, if the twig shivers<br />

in any exhalation <strong>of</strong> air or<br />

I incline to left or right,<br />

the spectrum stays visible<br />

a glimmering instant, as for<br />

C'ezanne on his riverbank,<br />

so he saw, <strong>and</strong> kept going.


Something about the light does this, works this kind <strong>of</strong> spell.<br />

Approaching the Bealach, he looks out <strong>and</strong> it's as though the entire<br />

sky <strong>of</strong> the world is open, poured out, let loose all down upon the<br />

hills. Like there was never such a thing as darkness here, like there<br />

could be no darkness, only this bare, clear air. There are the clean<br />

open flats <strong>of</strong> the moors, pale gray <strong>and</strong> dun <strong>and</strong> heather-streaked<br />

with dark <strong>and</strong> peat, <strong>and</strong> blackish watery burns some places coming<br />

down cut with broken stones, rocks, <strong>and</strong> all <strong>of</strong> it, the sweet<br />

l<strong>and</strong>, available to you somehow, that sense <strong>of</strong> reaching out to it like<br />

you might take it, be able to gather it into yourself <strong>and</strong> make it<br />

yours, a universe <strong>of</strong> endless l<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> sky <strong>and</strong> distance <strong>and</strong> pick<br />

out the mountains for your stars.<br />

But it's the road that keeps him from disappearing. The gray <strong>of</strong><br />

it, <strong>and</strong> thin, with no place much for passing. Since childhood, the<br />

memory's been in Callum all <strong>of</strong> the years, coming along here with<br />

his father, lagging behind caravans or<br />

estates hitching trailers, or boats <strong>and</strong> his<br />

It's the road that<br />

keeps him from<br />

disappearing.<br />

The gray <strong>of</strong> it,<br />

<strong>and</strong> thin, with no<br />

place much for<br />

passing.<br />

father's frustration, Christ, get a move on<br />

man! His h<strong>and</strong>s gripping the wheel, <strong>and</strong><br />

those eyes <strong>of</strong> his trained on distance.<br />

First Drumochta. Then Bonar Bridge.<br />

Dornoch... All the places he was wanting<br />

to get past, to get through, to get<br />

there ... And terrifying, I know myself,<br />

that cry <strong>of</strong> his: Christ! Like the man<br />

would himself put a sword through<br />

Christ's side, Callum could see it all, as a<br />

boy. His father's pr<strong>of</strong>ile as he sat beside<br />

hiln in the car, seeing his father out <strong>of</strong><br />

the side <strong>of</strong> his eye, not daring to say a<br />

word, not wanting to breathe even. And where was his mother<br />

then? It was always only ever him making the journey with his<br />

father, enduring that silence <strong>of</strong> his, or the frightening cries, <strong>and</strong> the<br />

sense <strong>of</strong> him, that man in the car beside him, the sense <strong>of</strong> him<br />

wanting out, into the hills <strong>and</strong> the water, seeming to be pushing<br />

him along, pulling him, great pieces <strong>of</strong> the sound <strong>of</strong> the place<br />

unfurling in his mind, like there may as well be someone coming<br />

down <strong>of</strong>f the hills now with a set <strong>of</strong> pipes to call him in.<br />

It's going to take a couple more hours to get up to us here, much<br />

easier now than back in the old days, still, the particular emotion


through to the main house, to the small sitting room where his<br />

father will be.<br />

This time, though, my mother does not take him. He goes<br />

down the hall by himself to where the old man is waiting, sitting<br />

in his armchair by the fire, alone. My mother busies herself<br />

in the kitchen, heats through soup, rolls, puts the water on to<br />

boil for tea. When I come down from my bedroom to take the<br />

things through she's away upstairs herself <strong>and</strong> Callum's sitting<br />

in the chair before his father, his father not saying a word. The<br />

lamps are on, <strong>and</strong> the fire's bright this darkish afternoon with<br />

snow in the air <strong>and</strong> still one or two old dogs barking, poor<br />

beasts, not underst<strong>and</strong>ing why it is they've not been allowed to<br />

see him, to come rushing in <strong>and</strong> fall upon Callum to lick him<br />

all over his h<strong>and</strong>s. They know alright that it's Iny brother who<br />

is here.<br />

But it's not for me to go - to release them. I set the tray down<br />

on the small table by the window <strong>and</strong> Callum says, "Hello, Helen"<br />

then, <strong>and</strong> I turn to him, for the first time in a long time I'm looking<br />

on his face again.<br />

Then his father speaks, "He took his time getting back to us,<br />

Helen. Didn't he? Our boy?"<br />

He smiles, first time I've seen the old man smile since he's been<br />

back up here, a smile, a real smile. He takes a sip from his dram.<br />

"Don't think I'm going back with you though," he says, "Callum.<br />

I'll not, <strong>and</strong> you should know this fine, I'll not be taken."<br />

"Dad..." Callum says, "Hello..."<br />

It's as though there's light all around the pair <strong>of</strong> them. I can<br />

see it, in this room with its deep wooden walls <strong>and</strong> windows<br />

set, this late afternoon, with all the little panes <strong>of</strong> glass. To see<br />

them, together again, my father <strong>and</strong> my brother, these men<br />

who, though they will never know it, have a daughter <strong>and</strong> a<br />

sister, too...<br />

"That'll be all, I think, Helen," the old man says then. "You<br />

can leave us now. Tell lain we'll not be needing the guns in the<br />

morning..."<br />

And I turn to go. Leave them, the one facing the other, by the fire<br />

I set this morning.<br />

"Wish your mother goodnight from me," my father says to me<br />

as I go out the door, back into the dark hall, yet the sense <strong>of</strong> light,<br />

this gorgeous piece <strong>of</strong> light still present, with me, at my back.<br />

From this man who's come from where he was, come up that long<br />

road that's behind him, crossed the Pass, <strong>and</strong> returned to us, to<br />

Nowhere, "Falabh." Our Aite Aon Arech, our End <strong>of</strong> the Road. Our<br />

home.•


what was lost to surface. For maximum fun with butter,<br />

that part <strong>of</strong> legacy (my father an unsalted butter-color man):<br />

a fresh tub for each impression. One for chin, one for h<strong>and</strong>, another<br />

for foot, each bite mark. No problem: there was always<br />

another butter. Exceptional mortar butter, plaster <strong>of</strong> butter<br />

every year<br />

Easter butter lamb to butcher gently with polite knives<br />

the shape <strong>of</strong> oars, shape <strong>of</strong> skinny hooded priest pr<strong>of</strong>iles.<br />

slick with<br />

You stuck your h<strong>and</strong>s in <strong>and</strong> the butter s<strong>of</strong>tened cuticles, repaired<br />

dishpan h<strong>and</strong>s, soothed scrapes, minor burns -Matna ran butter-fisted<br />

when I fell <strong>of</strong>f the bike - was elbow grease<br />

if you wiped it there, <strong>and</strong> let rings come <strong>of</strong>f as if it was before:<br />

s<strong>of</strong>tness back<br />

<strong>and</strong> some <strong>of</strong> your innocence<br />

in family tradition <strong>of</strong> Blue Bonnet, Mazola, L<strong>and</strong> 0' Lakes'<br />

Indian maiden coming at me sometilnes in a canoe taken as rescue<br />

craft I was too big for; I could open my mouth, <strong>and</strong> she, Princess<br />

Whatchamaca1ll1er could float right in, down<br />

my throat that with tonsils <strong>and</strong> tongue <strong>of</strong>fered a take<br />

on southwestern l<strong>and</strong> formations. We used Big Chief<br />

baking powder <strong>and</strong> sugar, had Minnehaha Water delivered<br />

in jugs big enough to have held fleets <strong>of</strong> sunken toy ships,<br />

<strong>and</strong> sold what we called bog water (taken from vases<br />

<strong>and</strong> saucers under potted plants, spruced up<br />

with Listerine) to those who wanted adult drinks prematurely;<br />

- jO Deirdre! -<br />

bog water <strong>of</strong> premature wine not done fermenting had to be<br />

priced by proximity to process completion. After any <strong>of</strong> this<br />

we freshened the air with Indian Blessing Spray #41<br />

that stank a little bit<br />

<strong>and</strong> also smelled a little bit like cherries.<br />

- jin your stinking grave<br />

rotting sweetly: no<br />

complaints -<br />

By not partaking <strong>of</strong> any butter, not indulging, not giving in<br />

my toast was s<strong>and</strong>paper, the usual slice <strong>of</strong> fossil-sponge<br />

Martian terrain close-up. But it could crumble, could<br />

become dust in my fingertips, could look as if I crumbled<br />

with it, tobacco like, filler for my father's Pall Malls<br />

that he smoked to death, <strong>and</strong> as if I were butter<br />

had that responsibility time to time I opened cigarettes<br />

scraped the paper clean <strong>and</strong> wrote haiku riddles that I rolled up<br />

tightl)T, my words burning from his lips easily<br />

gone gone gone<br />

All four slices <strong>of</strong> my wooden bread<br />

are s<strong>and</strong>ed smooth grain. Old English<br />

protected - that oil like supremely clarified butter.<br />

What fine head <strong>and</strong> foot boards for beautiful small beds<br />

no one fits, only if the size <strong>of</strong> cigarettes, pack <strong>of</strong> white-robed sisters<br />

from Virginia what fine understated tombstones.<br />

This bread may be waxed. 0 shine. I know who Shine was.<br />

Its lines are durable labYrinths our father<br />

fingers <strong>and</strong> tongue may follow in cursive spell-out.<br />

That wax, that sheen <strong>of</strong> get-away<br />

from the path shines my fingerprints<br />

where I grip the bread as loose pages, loose leaves<br />

<strong>of</strong> suspicious adaptation. Loops under the arches<br />

are a green onion bulb<br />

cross section, innermost loop<br />

like the eye <strong>of</strong> an elnbroidery needle<br />

or like sperm-head<br />

or like the hook<br />

that scrapes out early pregnancy<br />

depending on who's looking. The loop made<br />

when tying the ribbons <strong>of</strong> a blue bonnet<br />

under the chin. II


Fork<br />

Addiction<br />

his is a tale <strong>of</strong> the birth <strong>of</strong> Limited Fork Poetics.<br />

The birth announcement, actually, <strong>of</strong> the inevitable<br />

<strong>of</strong>fspring <strong>of</strong> a poet who becomes so immersed in<br />

awareness <strong>of</strong> the dominating presence <strong>of</strong> dynamic<br />

systems in every facet <strong>of</strong> her observable existence that<br />

poetry <strong>and</strong> the structures she studies merge.<br />

Dynamic systems, processes <strong>of</strong> interactions, produce active structures<br />

that populate the l<strong>and</strong>scapes that exist simultaneously at all<br />

scales. Mutability, multiplicity, <strong>and</strong> adaptability are stunning traits<br />

<strong>of</strong> existence that occur everywhere, on different scales <strong>of</strong> place <strong>and</strong><br />

time. Most <strong>of</strong> these structures escape human notice, but continuing<br />

advances in evidence capture (for instance, better <strong>and</strong> better microscopes<br />

<strong>and</strong> telescopes) reveal more <strong>and</strong> more information in every<br />

location examined with these devices that extend the limited range<br />

<strong>of</strong> human perception.<br />

Within revealed areas, previously unknown structures <strong>of</strong>fer<br />

enough connections, enough similarity to previously encountered<br />

patterns that metaphor not only becomes possible but is<br />

also encouraged. We catalog these new things with links to<br />

what we are reminded <strong>of</strong>, even as the science <strong>of</strong> these things<br />

emerges in the data, enabling recognition <strong>of</strong> the galactic within<br />

the microscopic, the sombrero within the galactic. This is the<br />

dynamic texture <strong>of</strong> existence. Patterns repeat on all scales, in<br />

whole <strong>and</strong> in part, <strong>and</strong> the poet seeks them in those neighborhoods<br />

that have become local (so available for access) by that<br />

poet. This dynamic texture is particularly prolninent in internet<br />

searches where thous<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> links can appear almost instantaneously,<br />

but since we cannot follow all <strong>of</strong> them all at once<br />

(though they are there), we move through the options one at a<br />

time instead, never pursuing most <strong>of</strong> them, yet we remain<br />

aware <strong>of</strong> the vast network <strong>of</strong> connections that the ones we<br />

choose to follow are part <strong>of</strong>. That influence remains <strong>and</strong> shapes<br />

responses to pursued search outcomes - perhaps only subtly,<br />

even only imperceptibly (at first; impact might become more pronounced<br />

as it builds through further connections made in other<br />

locations at other times).<br />

Active structures resist (models <strong>of</strong>) geometric perfection with<br />

bulges, bumps, punctures, wrinkles, folds, zigzags, nicks, crinkled<br />

contours (think <strong>of</strong> the pocked moon, <strong>of</strong> planetary rifts,<br />

tectonic buckles, valleys), <strong>and</strong> these appear even on those things<br />

that are generally smooth (a feature that generally increases with<br />

distance). Departures from smooth ideals tend to be revealed as<br />

powers <strong>of</strong> magnification (including thinking) are increased. So<br />

within limits (skin is such a limit), there is (apparently) endless<br />

variation such that specifics cannot be predicted precisely. Every<br />

day my eye is drawn to those shapes it considers interesting<br />

(such as clouds, flowers, mountains, birds, trees) because my<br />

brain is shaped that way also, is generally cumulous, bulging<br />

with recognition, possibility; cerebral folds like aerial maps <strong>of</strong><br />

river systems, tributaries like liquid branches <strong>and</strong> liquid nerves,<br />

like three-dimensional portraits <strong>of</strong> an idea <strong>and</strong> its tributaries<br />

making multiple connections simultaneously, both consciously<br />

<strong>and</strong> unconsciously.<br />

Yes, the circulatory system is an inner tree. The nervous systenl<br />

is another tree within the human forest, capped with a jellyfish<br />

<strong>of</strong> brain from which nervous tentacles sprout <strong>and</strong> house<br />

everything imaginable. That the products <strong>of</strong> dynamic humanity<br />

would themselves be dynamic makes sense; they already are<br />

without our knowing it, but when realized, possibilities previously<br />

dormant with potential become activated, <strong>and</strong> my underst<strong>and</strong>ing<br />

<strong>of</strong> poetry exp<strong>and</strong>s as it seeks to apply principles <strong>of</strong><br />

behaviors <strong>of</strong> dynamic systems to itself. Limited Fork Poetics is in<br />

the blood - that's how basic <strong>and</strong> essential it is; already there,<br />

but needing to be named in order to be perceived. It embraces all<br />

<strong>of</strong> my humanity, so <strong>of</strong> course is fully compatible with how thinking<br />

behaves, <strong>and</strong> makes predictions that my work actively<br />

attempts to fulfill. To underst<strong>and</strong> poetry as a dynamic system is<br />

to allow poetry to see itself in many different mirrors, each distortion<br />

accurate. Each contribution taking a crack at improving<br />

(the reliability <strong>of</strong>) the sum.<br />

One such mirror is the elm, outside my <strong>of</strong>fice window, that (on<br />

the day I looked at it as the dynamic system that it, like poetry,<br />

already was) <strong>of</strong>fered more possibilities than it ever had. I remember<br />

thinking how the aesthetic appeal <strong>of</strong> tree would be weakened<br />

for me if there were only the trunk to consider. I would not call


trunk alone tree. It was the fuller package that defined it, making<br />

it recognizably ehn - the visible width <strong>of</strong> bifurcating elm, the<br />

uncompressed departures from trunk including those twigs,<br />

branches, <strong>and</strong> roots culminating in dead ends, terminal locations<br />

which happened to locate points in the sky <strong>and</strong> the earth - <strong>and</strong><br />

made me want to look at it again <strong>and</strong> again - each elm within<br />

the general limits <strong>of</strong> elm but with unpredictable specific branch,<br />

bark, <strong>and</strong> root patterns, even such variation in the general structure<br />

<strong>of</strong> the leaves - I love the fatness <strong>of</strong> the system <strong>of</strong> branches. I<br />

love those things whose generalities are predictable but not their<br />

specifics, some <strong>of</strong> which can exert so much influence, the general<br />

structure is changed - And I did need for that itnpressive<br />

branching width to slim down to trunk<br />

(respite) as I journeyed both outwardly<br />

Thinking is more<br />

like time itself, a<br />

vehicle transporting<br />

us, that me<strong>and</strong>ers<br />

as it moves<br />

generally linearly.<br />

to what branches pointed to <strong>and</strong><br />

inwardly to what roots pointed to:<br />

everything. I had access to everything<br />

through that ehn.<br />

It was an ultimate fork. I held up a<br />

plastic generality that happened to be<br />

on my desk, finding the placement in<br />

which my eyes allowed the plastic fork<br />

h<strong>and</strong>le to become proxy elm trunk, the<br />

idea firmly in my grip, the plastic tines<br />

there to help me access more <strong>of</strong> the pos­<br />

sibilities <strong>of</strong> the idea, but with gaps between them because I could<br />

not possibly grasp everything. Hence (some <strong>of</strong>) the limitation.<br />

a those lovely gaps! - like those between elm branches, <strong>of</strong>fering<br />

a ragged, irregular beauty not available to something completely<br />

filled in. I could see, fork preventing me from seeing anything<br />

else, that gaps were preferable to a solidity that I couldn't think<br />

<strong>of</strong>, considering space between the components <strong>of</strong> <strong>and</strong> the atoms<br />

<strong>of</strong> everything. Space between my thumb <strong>and</strong> plastic, between<br />

plastic <strong>and</strong> window, window <strong>and</strong> elm, between (the system <strong>of</strong>)<br />

elm <strong>and</strong> the bifurcating system <strong>of</strong> lines (branches) on my h<strong>and</strong><br />

that branches from my trunk <strong>of</strong> arm that branches from my trunk<br />

<strong>of</strong> body (that branched inside my mother).<br />

In using a fork, the user who would digest what the fork<br />

manages to lift <strong>and</strong> move through space to the mouth (the danger<br />

<strong>of</strong> losing some or all <strong>of</strong> what is speared, draped across, or<br />

dangling from the lap <strong>of</strong> tines always present) becomes an<br />

extension <strong>of</strong> fork, the arm branching into body so that the<br />

collaboration <strong>of</strong> user <strong>and</strong> fork gives birth to another form <strong>of</strong> tree,<br />

another branch <strong>of</strong> larger structure. The act <strong>of</strong> writing is largely<br />

linear in that it tends to happen sequentially; word follows word.<br />

Forking paths my poems pursue are conceived <strong>of</strong> simultaneously<br />

(consciously <strong>and</strong> unconsciously) but are captured one by one, linearly,<br />

even if placed irregularly on a page. Sometimes only one<br />

path is captured, or part <strong>of</strong> a path. Thinking blossoms, sometimes<br />

explodes in a temporary"Aha!" <strong>of</strong> knowing only to be funneled<br />

sequentially <strong>and</strong> trimmed, but blossoming can again occur<br />

each time the poem is experienced. Each encounter <strong>of</strong>fers opportunity<br />

for enhancement or amendment (including dynamic decay<br />

<strong>and</strong> recycling).<br />

That which pulses <strong>and</strong> flows is myriad, that which throbs,<br />

including, possibly, big bang residue in the form <strong>of</strong> subtle vibration,<br />

maybe even deep-space signals transmitted in hopes <strong>of</strong> chance<br />

interaction with those able to recognize <strong>and</strong> find meaning in structure.<br />

A consideration <strong>of</strong> dynamic systems is a consideration <strong>of</strong> how<br />

the mutability <strong>of</strong> structure intensifies at boundaries where there are<br />

greater opportunities for new structures to take shape whether or<br />

not they succeed. Where more variables are present whose interactions<br />

can reshape the interacting systems in subtle ways or ways<br />

that approach pr<strong>of</strong>undity. The full range. Motion, the dynamic<br />

necessity <strong>of</strong> dynmnic systems, is also journey, at the very least<br />

through time. Things move for the most part, apparently linearly<br />

through time, but thinking <strong>and</strong> imagination can also move in any<br />

direction while basic linear progression is underway. Thinking is<br />

more like time itself, a vehicle transporting us, that me<strong>and</strong>ers as it<br />

moves generally linearly, creating different implications for each<br />

location in time. Multiple streams <strong>of</strong> time, such as past <strong>and</strong> present,<br />

apparently head toward future streams, but at any time, any <strong>of</strong><br />

these can be twisted, merged, or folded - if only in the thoughts <strong>of</strong><br />

those moving with time. Consider that sunlight that illuminates the<br />

present on earth is light from the sun's recent past. And sunlight<br />

emanates from all the sun-sphere all at once, so a radiant mane (not<br />

a single line) travels a widening path in time.<br />

Because LFP emphasizes fluidity, implications for the LFP page<br />

can be startling. I am Pr<strong>of</strong>orker <strong>and</strong> Text Choreographer as I work on<br />

identifying <strong>and</strong> underst<strong>and</strong>ing how moving products <strong>of</strong> LFP<br />

occupy moving space. Poems may happen at any stage in cycles<br />

<strong>of</strong> structure formation, decay, <strong>and</strong> reformation; <strong>and</strong> any part <strong>of</strong><br />

these events may appear in any location <strong>of</strong> the LFP page simultaneously,<br />

some parts imperceptible, some variably revealed <strong>and</strong>


unrevealed, some so stable that they are caught in acts <strong>of</strong> persistent<br />

coherent revelation. Where structure forms on the LFP page<br />

is a stabilizing area (page refers to the primary residence [home<br />

base] <strong>of</strong> a poem or any <strong>of</strong> its components at any specified<br />

mOInent <strong>and</strong> is not liInited to paper - a poem is able to travel,<br />

even if it doesn't [seem to]). Where structure decays on the LFP<br />

page is a destabilizing area fertile for reformation. Stanzas can<br />

begin out <strong>of</strong> stabilizing gestures, <strong>and</strong> may progress in stability or<br />

may deteriorate, warp, or transform as sOInething from the surrounding<br />

flux (the substance out <strong>of</strong> which structure forms, the<br />

ingredient pool) interacts with the stabilizing (or decaying)<br />

structure. It Inay not be obvious whether a perceptible structure<br />

is stabilizing or decaying as a similar fonn may occur in either<br />

structural state. Structure may attempt to take shape in multiple<br />

locations (rooms) <strong>of</strong> the house <strong>of</strong> the poem, <strong>and</strong> any number <strong>of</strong><br />

these attempts Inay take on enough structure to become perceptible<br />

in part or whole, perhaps causing competing zones <strong>of</strong> influence<br />

which may merge into one structure or may lead to one or<br />

more quick or gradual demises. Or the stability <strong>of</strong> the poem's<br />

structure may be so intense that it delays the stabilizing (<strong>of</strong> other<br />

locations perhaps for so long, the delay mimics prevention), so<br />

that nothing else (at that time) is visible.<br />

A poem as print object documents the dynamic activity that<br />

caused the poeIn to take on perceptible structure, which, like all<br />

structure, is subject to further change, such as revision <strong>of</strong> a print<br />

object <strong>and</strong> interpretations <strong>of</strong> a print object each time it is encountered.<br />

The complete dynamic signature <strong>of</strong> a poem includes all<br />

subsystems <strong>of</strong> the components <strong>of</strong> a poem (the published form a<br />

magnification <strong>of</strong> one <strong>of</strong> the branches in the complete dynamic signature)<br />

which include all drafts, all dead ends, all revisions <strong>and</strong><br />

interpretations (by writer <strong>and</strong> experiencers <strong>of</strong> the poem), all contributing<br />

thoughts, forming a kind <strong>of</strong> evolutionary tree <strong>of</strong> the<br />

poeIn, each branch, when examined closely (magnified, that is, or<br />

considered on some intensified scale), full <strong>of</strong> other branches <strong>of</strong><br />

thought <strong>and</strong> connection. It is through the (so far) ceaseless movement<br />

(transformation perceived <strong>and</strong> actual) <strong>of</strong> dynan1ic systems<br />

that all becomes linked into one fabric <strong>of</strong> reality that is so faceted,<br />

the saIne territory can reveal something different each time the<br />

lens is shifted or changed. Depth in LFP becomes a way to refer<br />

to that which is unexplored, for once encountered, that which is<br />

encountered becomes the surface <strong>of</strong> that encounter. The surface is<br />

hardly superficial but is where interactions between boundaries<br />

occur. Surface after surface is scratched, layer after layer is peeled<br />

back, <strong>and</strong> then there's that rosy resemblance. That elm.<br />

Because poetry is a dynamic system, poems may be understood<br />

as failed efforts to capture flux, as attempts to cause awareness<br />

<strong>of</strong> something that may no longer exist (in that exact form)<br />

by the time a poem is experienced (even during the writing <strong>of</strong><br />

the first line). LFP approaches desired capture <strong>of</strong> a poem as chase<br />

only, so expects to capture only partialities <strong>of</strong> partialities. The<br />

totality in which all apparently takes place can't easily (if at all)<br />

be seen as totality from within it. The most that might be possible<br />

is exquisite failure, <strong>and</strong> most poems fall short <strong>of</strong> that elm <strong>of</strong><br />

failure, some compellingly. II<br />

The Culture <strong>of</strong> Reena <strong>and</strong> the Bear<br />

Before the Bear: derived from a theory <strong>of</strong> gravy<br />

(The neckline <strong>and</strong> hem <strong>of</strong> Reena's gown<br />

were trimmed with real hummingbirds<br />

[just a few tiny pins in the outspread wings<br />

- she could feel the racing unison<br />

that the tiny hearts fell into] <strong>and</strong> actual orchids.<br />

The beak closest to it tried to extract nectar<br />

from the small cleft - the suprasternal notch ­<br />

at the bottom <strong>of</strong> her perfumed throat)<br />

(Bees drew near; live jewels from the garden.)<br />

She still had her eyes <strong>and</strong> others too<br />

on a tray: unpitted olives<br />

coated with a thin layer <strong>of</strong> meringue<br />

as vitreous humor substitute<br />

Breakfast Before the Bear: ocular effects


that she placed in each bowl <strong>of</strong> owlet soup<br />

in which floated owl embryos braised<br />

in butter <strong>and</strong> chives, sprinkled with br<strong>and</strong>y<br />

just before serving, <strong>and</strong> skewered<br />

with knife-length pieces <strong>of</strong> jicama,<br />

tasting slightly <strong>of</strong> rodents<br />

the parent owl had eaten, ambiance<br />

<strong>of</strong> background radiation, a theorem <strong>of</strong> alternatives,<br />

the microworld <strong>of</strong> taste, from here<br />

the same as a comet's rat's tail<br />

coming from between her teeth,<br />

a glittering skeleton, tendon flex<br />

<strong>of</strong> her reaction attaching Reena<br />

to the muscle <strong>of</strong> how hard the universe works.<br />

preceded by romance.<br />

They exchanged rings<br />

like the b<strong>and</strong>s on goose legs.<br />

Before the Bear: Reena's first marriage<br />

Promise her anything: give her foie gras:<br />

stuff it down her throat<br />

The Culture <strong>of</strong> Reena <strong>and</strong> the Bear<br />

Once she began wondering what it would be like to eat her way<br />

out <strong>of</strong> something, she did something about it: came to bed<br />

in an open-fire-roasted clove-studded carcass <strong>of</strong> beef<br />

(the cloves are the dried unopened flower buds <strong>of</strong> a tree<br />

called the Zanzibar Red Head).<br />

Unfortunately, the bear though as hungry as it should be<br />

after hibernation respected the presence <strong>of</strong> Reena's husb<strong>and</strong>,<br />

so with him there the bear alone wasn't illuminated;<br />

Reena couldn't hold on to just its light<br />

<strong>and</strong> lost sight <strong>of</strong> its darkness in the darkening evening's<br />

Bear hug.<br />

The Superior Love <strong>of</strong> the Macurap in the Amazon Without Reena<br />

Who's Busy Looking at Ursa Major <strong>and</strong> Minor<br />

For their efforts the Macurap <strong>of</strong> the Amazon have<br />

viscous jelly destiny <strong>of</strong> the broth<br />

maintained for a week as one by one<br />

Macurap women kill their husb<strong>and</strong>s: the intensity <strong>of</strong> their love<br />

finally at a boiling point: the body everywhere: inside<br />

<strong>and</strong> out, sensitive to what touches, digesting<br />

intestinal love, cud climax, deep marriage<br />

in the pit <strong>of</strong> heavenly bellies even more transformation:<br />

husb<strong>and</strong>s taken to limits <strong>of</strong> what can be taken<br />

in: husb<strong>and</strong>s becoming ultimate alphabet <strong>of</strong> pleasure: extracts<br />

<strong>of</strong> A, B, E, vitamin K, crystalline pyridoxine: vitamin B6,<br />

vitamin P: bi<strong>of</strong>lavonoid from rinds <strong>and</strong> husks:<br />

Macurap wives watch their husb<strong>and</strong>s eat some.<br />

Citrus whispers roasted into his lungs,<br />

tincture <strong>of</strong> balsam, fermented boil, white peppered<br />

with grubs <strong>and</strong> lice, lips smack on<br />

how nothing else tastes like a man<br />

loved to death. His cleaned rib cage<br />

is a bone cape around her; her legs twine<br />

around his femurs<br />

as she makes love to ivory scepters.<br />

Golden locks on the pleasure cupboards<br />

can be polished or opened;<br />

gr<strong>and</strong> openings<br />

so much more tasteful<br />

Reena & the Three Bears


than the proprietor down the road<br />

who called that first <strong>of</strong> several popular<br />

while-you-wait tailoring shops<br />

Jack the Ripper.<br />

Meet Reena the Butcher.<br />

Fresh bear meat for this girl hunter.<br />

The braided rug's circumference is enlarged<br />

by blood-spray<br />

into an alien dahlia <strong>of</strong> blood<br />

that is just right. II<br />

1<br />

The Culture <strong>of</strong> Mr. Wonderful<br />

First there's innocence as pr<strong>of</strong>essed<br />

by his pr<strong>of</strong>ession: selling boatloads <strong>of</strong> flowers<br />

that out <strong>of</strong> his h<strong>and</strong>s become adornment, snacks,<br />

overtures that pr<strong>of</strong>it this dealer <strong>of</strong> vegetable matter,<br />

some petals displayed around the flower head<br />

like a h<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> cards: the gamble in anything.<br />

Then one must look more closely at that h<strong>and</strong><br />

the flower's been dealt as it becomes what<br />

Mr. Wonderful's been dealt: the family<br />

business, not lucrative all the time; he's not<br />

in it for the money, but for the pure pleasure,<br />

since there's <strong>of</strong>ten nothing else, <strong>of</strong> ferrying flowers.<br />

Many tulips close up on him at twilight as if they hold small empty<br />

eggs: elegant voids - or maybe some inner peace that probably<br />

would be rounded, but not a ticket or passport to anything<br />

outside the garden; pollen drops from what sky there is inside<br />

onto impersonation <strong>of</strong> a velvet floor<br />

<strong>and</strong> would be at home in an hourglass: the whole<br />

night spent as gist <strong>of</strong> what I thought came out<br />

<strong>of</strong> successful tonsillectomy.<br />

At water's edge: a battalion <strong>of</strong> white peacocks,<br />

the feathers the most elegant spines<br />

blown back like umbrellas blown back<br />

<strong>and</strong> contorted like supposedly double-jointed girls<br />

in a circus desperate to be spectacular<br />

but also like, as if the double-jointed were not enough,<br />

partial jellyfish; that is: jellyfish that result<br />

from lobotomy, the ragged half brain <strong>of</strong> tentacular nerves<br />

or more decorative radar dish<br />

to spy on celestial activity out <strong>of</strong> the ordinary,<br />

to eavesdrop just as the plane trees just beyond<br />

the startling white peacocks, even their eyes,<br />

are doing: bare branches in the blown-back position<br />

<strong>of</strong> the peacocks' feathery array<br />

with which the plane trees collaborate, each<br />

translating the other <strong>and</strong> transmitting mutual praise.<br />

Mr. Wonderful is a captain completely unaware that I know <strong>of</strong> him.<br />

His expansion that he knows <strong>of</strong> is a little Mr. Wonderful<br />

whose resemblance extends to a smaller boat<br />

on the other side <strong>of</strong> the lake.<br />

Some <strong>of</strong> his petals, the ones most like daggers,<br />

excusing the s<strong>of</strong>tness, are dipped in poison<br />

because some poisons make the most beautiful ink<br />

<strong>and</strong> are necessary to write the name <strong>of</strong> his lover<br />

on the active surface <strong>of</strong> this lake; the water under his boat


than the proprietor down the road<br />

who called that first <strong>of</strong> several popular<br />

while-you-wait tailoring shops<br />

Jack the Ripper.<br />

Meet Reena the Butcher.<br />

Fresh bear meat for this girl hunter.<br />

The braided rug's circumference is enlarged<br />

by blood-spray<br />

into an alien dahlia <strong>of</strong> blood<br />

that is just right. •<br />

1<br />

The Culture <strong>of</strong> Mr. Wonderful<br />

First there's innocence as pr<strong>of</strong>essed<br />

by his pr<strong>of</strong>ession: selling boatloads <strong>of</strong> flowers<br />

that out <strong>of</strong> his h<strong>and</strong>s become adornment, snacks,<br />

overtures that pr<strong>of</strong>it this dealer <strong>of</strong> vegetable matter,<br />

some petals displayed around the flower head<br />

like a h<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> cards: the gamble in anything.<br />

Then one must look more closely at that h<strong>and</strong><br />

the flower's been dealt as it becomes what<br />

Mr. Wonderful's been dealt: the family<br />

business, not lucrative all the time; he's not<br />

in it for the money, but for the pure pleasure,<br />

since there's <strong>of</strong>ten nothing else, <strong>of</strong> ferrying flowers.<br />

Many tulips close up on him at twilight as if they hold small empty<br />

eggs: elegant voids - or maybe some inner peace that probably<br />

would be rounded, but not a ticket or passport to anything<br />

outside the garden; pollen drops from what sky there is inside<br />

onto impersonation <strong>of</strong> a velvet floc<br />

<strong>and</strong> would be at home in an hourglass: the who<br />

night spent as gist <strong>of</strong> what I thought came 01<br />

<strong>of</strong> successful tonsillectom<br />

At water's edge: a battalion <strong>of</strong> white peacocks,<br />

the feathers the most elegant spines<br />

blown back like umbrellas blown back<br />

<strong>and</strong> contorted like supposedly double-jointed girls<br />

in a circus desperate to be spectacular<br />

but also like, as if the double-jointed were not enough,<br />

partial jellyfish; that is: jellyfish that result<br />

froin 10botoIny, the ragged half brain <strong>of</strong> tentacular nerves<br />

or more decorative radar dish<br />

to spy on celestial activity out <strong>of</strong> the ordinary,<br />

to eavesdrop just as the plane trees just beyond<br />

the startling white peacocks, even their eyes,<br />

are doing: bare branches in the blown-back position<br />

<strong>of</strong> the peacocks' feathery array<br />

with which the plane trees collaborate, each<br />

translating the other <strong>and</strong> transmitting mutual praise.<br />

Mr. Wonderful is a captain completely unaware that I know <strong>of</strong> him.<br />

His expansion that he knows <strong>of</strong> is a little Mr. Wonderful<br />

whose resemblance extends to a smaller boat<br />

on the other side <strong>of</strong> the lake.<br />

Some <strong>of</strong> his petals, the ones most like daggers,<br />

excusing the s<strong>of</strong>tness, are dipped in poison<br />

because some poisons make the most beautiful ink<br />

<strong>and</strong> are necessary to write the name <strong>of</strong> his lover<br />

on the active surface <strong>of</strong> this lake, the water under his boat


moving like her under him, so many underlings move him,<br />

yellows, oranges, pinks, lavenders spilled here like congealed<br />

volatile oil, wacky pie chart gone fractal<br />

perhaps just to be popular<br />

<strong>and</strong> on the up <strong>and</strong> up still rising, garnished with blush<br />

<strong>of</strong> pollen that is dirty <strong>and</strong> nutmeg-colored from a rubbing<br />

on Mr. Wonderful's fingertips before dispersal<br />

<strong>and</strong> the impression that rubbed pollen<br />

could be a grating <strong>of</strong> his skin for no reason at all,<br />

<strong>and</strong> that could be why he'd do it.<br />

The trick is to get his fingertips there; after that, there's no trick<br />

to what's visible under the microscope: fortified spiked walls<br />

<strong>of</strong> a labyrinth, the innermost curl somewhat a spirochete,<br />

<strong>and</strong> saying that, it's clear just what to picture: artistry transfer<br />

to brushes with syphilis, lues, late treatments, penicillin<br />

success after gross disfigurement, many diseases<br />

seem to establish blossoms on skin, leprous flowers<br />

tended in special, colonirLl gardens.Pet vectors.<br />

There are spikes <strong>and</strong> hooks<br />

in the fortress <strong>of</strong> Mr. Wonderful's fingerprints, torture labyrinths,<br />

caches <strong>of</strong> poisoned intentions unless this is taken another way:<br />

beautiful loop <strong>of</strong> embroidery, the head <strong>of</strong> a seahorse from afar,<br />

silk fins present though unseen.<br />

Under the microscope some flowers have bones, there's druse<br />

inside the cells, crystalline inclusions made <strong>of</strong> the stuff<br />

<strong>of</strong> kidney stones, <strong>and</strong> in the flower cells<br />

skeletal druse looks like starburst: an angular <strong>and</strong> pointed<br />

sub-flower that gathers light.<br />

There remains the simplicity <strong>of</strong> his selling flowers<br />

not yet milked, still full <strong>of</strong> perfumes.<br />

They live in marigolds. They live in cyclamen.<br />

When customers sniff, they pray into the petals.<br />

Some flowers are poisonous without this wonderful help:<br />

Barbados nut, the seed <strong>of</strong> a hairy botanical thing,<br />

at least 55 percent hell oil<br />

<strong>and</strong> a taste that can be craved, almost sweet,<br />

though belladonna, though the berries <strong>of</strong> lirio<br />

so much more purple than plums - nearly black,<br />

about to burst with coarse sugar - look sweeter<br />

<strong>and</strong> are a source <strong>of</strong> Wonderful's ink<br />

as are the ruddied orange sometimes berries <strong>of</strong> assumed<br />

pure lily <strong>of</strong> the valley linked to devotion with bell flowers<br />

each <strong>of</strong> which seems a chapel<br />

where a corpse might lay drenched in flowers<br />

all because the lily was thought to be wild garlic<br />

<strong>and</strong> was souped for what turned out to be a last supper<br />

<strong>of</strong> that soup <strong>and</strong> a salad <strong>of</strong> anesthetizing monkshood<br />

leaves <strong>and</strong> radish-mimic roots so that the Dundee cake flavored<br />

with the same to finish <strong>of</strong>f the person finishing the meal<br />

was not needed. Nothing was left to chance.<br />

Fish are not stupid, that is not why they're hooked<br />

on Wonderful's supply <strong>of</strong> flowers floating with him,<br />

slapped occasionally with water Mr. Wonderful scoops up<br />

until sequences <strong>of</strong> float, scoop, slap, dip, rub, disperse<br />

blab <strong>and</strong> blurt out ritual, <strong>and</strong> the wonderful boat becomes<br />

a church on waters <strong>of</strong> exile<br />

where fish die with Wonderful's poison in them, white bellies<br />

like sails no better <strong>of</strong>f than the up-bellies, quite unsail-like sails<br />

for being waterlogged inadequate isl<strong>and</strong>s<br />

ideal for water bugs that don't need such refuse<br />

to be refuge. Dead fish form plump alphabet:<br />

a spell <strong>of</strong> Rima on the water.<br />

Her name drifts with the bulk <strong>of</strong> fish belly


mounds like variations <strong>of</strong> mushrooms, stems sublnerged:<br />

stubby legs: small white tables, even in such shrinking<br />

Rima becomes part <strong>of</strong> everything<br />

because there is such a thing as her signature<br />

on everything, poisoned in a way <strong>of</strong> looking at love<br />

that went nowhere, did nothing, was only what<br />

Mr. Wonderful was in: a little box like the one<br />

that contains diamond solitaires, sOlnetimes hidden<br />

inside a flower to bypass ordinary circumstance,<br />

not quite successful because it still involves dirty work:<br />

the demolition <strong>of</strong> flowers to get the boat full <strong>of</strong> seeds:<br />

so wonderful,<br />

so much greatly magnified dust.<br />

The situation can't be cleaned without ruining everything:<br />

the thicker the dust, the more depth to wonderful living.<br />

I I<br />

Take-<strong>of</strong>f from Sam Abell's photographic account <strong>of</strong> a Mr. Wonderful in Seeing Gardens.


'Tile ar'lists, courtnsv <strong>of</strong> jnv ,lonlirlQ/Whifn r:llho I nnrlnn I


GOU"tpcy 'H) (IIJ' PoslrnaslfH'S<br />

New YOi'k


i GO!JI'tesy <strong>of</strong> Postmasters "The artists. Gourlesy <strong>of</strong> clay ,Jopling/White Cube. London i


mixod media 58,;)f"x7()"'''''x54';'U'' I<br />

liThe artists, Gourtnsy or Jay Jop!ing/Whitn Culm, London I


y Liam<br />

Rector<br />

selected poems<br />

Our Hero Galliano<br />

When Galliano took over<br />

Dior in 1996 (the Dior<br />

Who said earlier that his<br />

Dream was to "free women<br />

From nature"), many viewed<br />

Galliano as too "costumey,"<br />

While others saw Galliano<br />

Returning sex <strong>and</strong> theater<br />

To the clothing. When a man<br />

Looks at a WOlnan wearing<br />

A Galliano, Galliano said<br />

That man should think only,<br />

"I have to fuck her."


New York City<br />

Outside the window<br />

Buildings, some<br />

With awnings<br />

And doormen (even<br />

The occasional<br />

Doorwoman now)<br />

(l wonder if they<br />

Are trained to kick<br />

Someone's ass when<br />

It comes to that)<br />

(As it sometimes<br />

Comes to that)<br />

(Or if even the men<br />

Are trained to do that).<br />

Doormen coming out<br />

Now <strong>and</strong> again<br />

To cop a cigarette<br />

Or help a tenant<br />

With luggage,<br />

The groceries always<br />

Coming, going, feeding.<br />

I hardly ever leave.<br />

I seldom go now.<br />

Hard to pull myself<br />

Away from the entire<br />

Circus just outside<br />

This window now.<br />

Soon the City<br />

Soon the summer<br />

Now the pleasant purgatory<br />

Of spring is over<br />

Soon the choking<br />

Humidity<br />

In the city<br />

On the fire escapes<br />

In a sleeveless T-shirt<br />

Smoking a cigar<br />

In tune with the tremor<br />

Of the mindless yellow<br />

Commercial traffic<br />

Moving in the city<br />

Where no one really<br />

Buys a car<br />

American<br />

Or otherwise<br />

Where we<br />

As Rilke said we would<br />

Where we will<br />

Wake read write<br />

Long letters<br />

And in the avenues<br />

W<strong>and</strong>er restlessly<br />

To <strong>and</strong> fro<br />

On foot in<br />

The humidity<br />

Where soon I'll shower dress<br />

Take the dog out for a piss<br />

And mail this


which is sometilnes referred to as What Cannot Be Said.<br />

Agony decides the fate <strong>of</strong> Theater People. Theater People who<br />

lose a loved one become Showfolks; Theater People whose loved one<br />

enters into Laughter become Stolen Pets.<br />

Upon the death <strong>of</strong> his loved one, a Showfolk is awarded a cash<br />

prize equal to 100 times the average yearly salary. During Agony, What Can Be Said is alive with contradictory<br />

Showfolks, because <strong>of</strong> their proximity to those who enter into<br />

but never leave Agony, feel a legitimate need to be looked at<br />

<strong>and</strong>/or heard. Thus, when they become Tenants, <strong>and</strong> so long as<br />

they remain Tenants, they are required to work a job in the television<br />

or radio industries as newscasters, game-show hosts, or talkshow<br />

hosts. These positions allow them to be themselves, more or<br />

less, <strong>and</strong> to be looked at <strong>and</strong>/or heard. Most will pursue training<br />

in the field so as to compete with other Showfolks for the elite<br />

positions, but many will eschew training<br />

<strong>and</strong> thereby bring a variety <strong>of</strong> obstinate<br />

Upon the death<br />

<strong>of</strong> his loved one,<br />

aShowfolk is<br />

awarded acash<br />

prize equal to<br />

100 times the<br />

average yearly<br />

salary.<br />

peculiarities to local media.<br />

Television <strong>and</strong> radio stations, when<br />

they are hiring for on-air positions, are<br />

reqUired by law to hire Showfolks before<br />

they hire anyone else. This means that a<br />

Showfolk applicant will beat out all non­<br />

Showfolks for the job, even if the<br />

Showfolk in question has had no training<br />

- indeed, even if the Showfolk in<br />

question is not able to speak. His only<br />

competition is other Showfolks. In the<br />

beginning, when there have been relatively<br />

few Agonies, there will be relatively<br />

few Showfolks, <strong>and</strong> these few will be<br />

inclined to seek out the most glamorous jobs at the most popular<br />

stations. A smaller portion will no doubt yearn to stay close to home,<br />

<strong>and</strong> some may seek out positions that allow them to maintain something<br />

close to anonylnity. As Agonies accrue, Showfolks will become<br />

less anomalous, though not necessarily less exotic - will become a<br />

caste, almost - <strong>and</strong> will saturate all levels <strong>of</strong> TV <strong>and</strong> radio "talk."<br />

A Stolen Pet, if his loved one arrives dead in Laughter, is known<br />

thereafter as a Shock Jock. Shock Jocks are awarded a cash prize<br />

equal to 500 times the average yearly salary. Shock Jocks, once they<br />

have received their award, are allowed to apply for <strong>and</strong> to work at<br />

any job they can get, but they may not receive pay for the work they<br />

do. Stolen Pets who are not Shock Jocks remain Stolen Pets <strong>and</strong><br />

receive no monetary award.<br />

wishes. II


y Erin Belieu<br />

3.<br />

I'm a borscht-belt comedienne<br />

working the audience from behind<br />

your headstone.<br />

I shimmy onstage between Pam<br />

And Her Magic Organ <strong>and</strong><br />

the gigantic poodle act.<br />

Your c<strong>of</strong>fin is a tough room.<br />

Mourners talk through my set,<br />

down schmutz-colored highballs, wait<br />

for the fan dancer to pluck<br />

her scuzzy feathers. But you<br />

always loved<br />

the livestock, didn't you?<br />

I say, how many <strong>of</strong> you folks are in<br />

from Jersey?<br />

from In The Red Dress<br />

I Wear To Your Funeral<br />

The microphone sweats<br />

like your cock did in my h<strong>and</strong>s.


4.<br />

I help the Jews drape the mirrors. I peel the foil from<br />

the Protestants' bleak casseroles. The Catholics <strong>and</strong> Agnostics<br />

huddle in the parking lot, smoking a memorial bowl.<br />

My dear, even the worst despot in his leopard-skin fez<br />

will tell you: the truth doesn't win, but it makes an appearance,<br />

though it's a foreign cavalry famous for bad timing <strong>and</strong><br />

half-assed horsemanship. History will barely remember that you<br />

were yellow <strong>and</strong> a cheat, a pixilated bivalve who consumed<br />

as r<strong>and</strong>omly as the thunderheads pass, <strong>and</strong> yet, how strange,<br />

how many <strong>of</strong> us loved you well. So tended)', I'll return<br />

what you gave me - a bleached. h<strong>and</strong>kerchief, a Swiss Army knife<br />

bristling with pointless blades. Tended)', I return everything,<br />

leaving my best evidence in your bloodless lap.<br />

5.<br />

I go to our Chinese take-awa)',<br />

where the placemats say I'm a cock<br />

<strong>and</strong> you were my favorite pig, though<br />

astrologically you were a wasting<br />

disease <strong>and</strong> I'm the scales <strong>of</strong> justice.<br />

Coincidence?<br />

Get down on your knees<br />

<strong>and</strong> cross yourself all you want:<br />

all systems are closed systems, dead man.<br />

I keep IllY saltshaker holstered in my garter belt,<br />

ready to spill.


the thick metal support posts, I struck it with a light jab. Surprisingly,<br />

the jab caused me little pain, so I hit the post harder, progressively<br />

throwing more <strong>of</strong> my weight into each blow. The post thudded <strong>and</strong><br />

hummed. Its deep-pitched moaJ;l rivaled the drone <strong>of</strong> the steering<br />

units. The shock <strong>of</strong> the blows reverberated down my wrists <strong>and</strong> shoulders<br />

like an arousing musical bass. With each strike I grew stronger. I<br />

could st<strong>and</strong> up to steel. My boots smeared the blood as it dripped on<br />

the grey decks. It coagulated on the heat <strong>of</strong> the floor, almost disappearing.<br />

Seaman Romeras, my watch relief, stared as I slung my bloody,<br />

taped fists into the steel beam. But that was just one <strong>of</strong> those things<br />

that sailors see each other do on long night watches at sea, <strong>and</strong> nothing<br />

is ever said about it. That night I almost broke. But I turned the whip<br />

against itself, I bared my soul, dripping my<br />

Seaman Romeras,<br />

my watch relief,<br />

stared as I<br />

slung my bloody,<br />

taped fists into the<br />

steel beam.<br />

blood on the steel decks, <strong>and</strong> in return, the<br />

ship respected my resolve <strong>and</strong> gave me the<br />

aftersteering room.<br />

The owl had probably flown aboard at<br />

our last port <strong>of</strong> call, Diego Garcia. Most<br />

likely he made his living catching the huge,<br />

greasy pier rats that infest tropical ports<br />

worldwide. We had pulled out <strong>of</strong> Garcia<br />

five days ago, so I figured he must be hungry.<br />

The next night, I <strong>of</strong>fered him bread<br />

crusts <strong>and</strong> pieces <strong>of</strong> pork, but he showed<br />

no interest. Maybe such food was carrion<br />

to him, <strong>and</strong> he needed a fresh kill. He allowed me to gently touch his<br />

wings, not because he had grown to trust me, but because he was too<br />

weak <strong>and</strong> traumatized to resist.<br />

Two days later, the U.S.S. Weitz anchored <strong>of</strong>fshore Phuket Isl<strong>and</strong>,<br />

Thail<strong>and</strong> - the <strong>of</strong>ficial "R <strong>and</strong> R" port <strong>of</strong> call for our "hard work<br />

<strong>and</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>essionalism in keeping with the finest traditions <strong>of</strong> the U.S.<br />

Navy" while patrolling the Persian Gulf. Before liberty call was<br />

passed over the ship's intercom, Thai ferry boats loaded with<br />

ice-cold beer <strong>and</strong> driven by cocky Thai youths who prided<br />

themselves on their knowledge <strong>of</strong> English curse words ­<br />

queued alongside our destroyer. Rickety, sky-blue crafts transported<br />

us to the bright green isl<strong>and</strong> which emerged out <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Andaman Sea like the back <strong>of</strong> a giant jellyfish.<br />

Once aboard the ferry, I drank as fast as I could. Sitting beside me,<br />

Seaman Fortman Whooped it up <strong>and</strong> I?F.C. Daniels cackled loudly. The<br />

old I?O.'s <strong>and</strong> sergeants took long drags from their Marlboros; they<br />

remembered the"conveniences" <strong>of</strong> old Subic in the Philippines. To<br />

these guys nothing compared to Subic Bay, or at least that is what they<br />

always asserted. If nothing else, it was an experience they could hold<br />

over the heads <strong>of</strong> the younger sailors <strong>and</strong> marines. In Subic, mere enlisted<br />

rubes metamorphosed into god-kings. Such was the blessing <strong>and</strong><br />

curse <strong>of</strong> being an American with a steady paycheck in the developing<br />

world. They presided over retinues <strong>of</strong> girlfriends <strong>and</strong> the <strong>of</strong>ficious manservants<br />

who polished their shoes <strong>and</strong> delivered whiskey wherever<br />

they happened to be "laid up."<br />

In town that night, I selected "Number 12," who sat on a bleacher<br />

behind a huge window with about 30 other young girls. She wore a<br />

gold dress, which - according to the pimps - meant that she possessed<br />

special skills. Holding her h<strong>and</strong> on the way to the room was the<br />

only intimate aspect <strong>of</strong> our hour-long encounter. First, we showered<br />

together. She made it cute, but the pre-sex bathing ritual served mYriad<br />

purposes. A clean man, free from the filth accumulated in a tropical<br />

night excursion, made the act more bearable for her. She could also take<br />

this tiine to inspect a man's body in a diplomatic fashion for chancres or<br />

other obvious signs <strong>of</strong> venereal disease before intercourse. I tipped her<br />

with a pile <strong>of</strong> coins from various ports <strong>of</strong> call that had accumulated in<br />

my belly bag. She giggled at the shiny coins rolling on the bedspread.<br />

I ducked through the rear door into a dark muddy alley. The<br />

back <strong>of</strong> the whorehouse was different from the front, where Thai<br />

pimps in silk shirts stood under the glow <strong>of</strong> blinking Christmas<br />

lights. It was only now, with the sense <strong>of</strong> calm <strong>and</strong> disillusionment<br />

following sex with a prostitute, that I could take in all the details<br />

around me.<br />

On the narrow road outside, five-dollar-a-night street whores<br />

prowled <strong>and</strong> bar girls danced on the tabletops in a panorama <strong>of</strong><br />

open-air bars. Cheesy Western hard rock blasting from the bars,<br />

smoke from the street vendors' grills, <strong>and</strong> the mugginess <strong>of</strong> the<br />

rainy season created an overwhelming cacophony. It was like being<br />

in a vacuum that stretched only a few hundred meters in circumference;<br />

but that was just as well, for I saw many sailors from my<br />

comm<strong>and</strong>, some <strong>of</strong> whom were married with children, fondling<br />

prostitutes <strong>and</strong> receiving oral sex from them publicly within the<br />

bars. Often a macho war cry or volley <strong>of</strong> high-fives followed these<br />

open performances <strong>of</strong> fellatio. Such scenes disturbed me, even<br />

though I was unable to discern exactly why.<br />

Across the street I spotted Petty Officer Valdez drunk <strong>and</strong> walking<br />

h<strong>and</strong>-in-h<strong>and</strong> with a cOlnpact, dark-skinned girl through the<br />

human swirl <strong>of</strong> sailors, marines, <strong>and</strong> whores. Valdez could drink<br />

twice as much as any <strong>of</strong> the whooping sailors or adrenaline-pumped


marines grabbing at the bikini-clad girls dancing on stage, yet<br />

relnain perfectly calm. He'd seen it all before. Valdez grew up an<br />

only child <strong>and</strong> fatherless in some gritty ethnic hellhole in New York<br />

City. He learned early in life that selfishness <strong>and</strong> cruelty were<br />

. virtues. Rough, ready, <strong>and</strong> never nervous, he loved his friends,<br />

hounded his enemies, comm<strong>and</strong>ed <strong>and</strong> Inotivated his men, <strong>and</strong><br />

stayed as drunk as the Navy would allow. Soon after I CaIne to the<br />

Weitz, he saw Ine beat another sailor viciously in a fistfight; Valdez<br />

<strong>and</strong> I became friends soon thereafter. His youth as a street soldier in<br />

a Puerto Rican gang conditioned him to appreciate such brutality<br />

<strong>and</strong> recklessness. Unlike brawling while on liberty, fighting on the<br />

ship carried a heavy penalty, <strong>and</strong> subsequently I was reduced in<br />

rank, fined, <strong>and</strong> restricted to the ship with one month's extra duty.<br />

Once Valdez told me laughingly <strong>of</strong> his participation in the rape-initiation<br />

<strong>of</strong> "newbies" during his refonn school days. He entertained no<br />

illusions about life or hiInself. I appreciated Valdez. Enlisted men<br />

like him made the organized chaos <strong>of</strong> a combatant ship at sea work.<br />

I trusted him <strong>and</strong> his word meant something, but I knew I could<br />

never be like him.<br />

Around 3 a.m., I grew weary <strong>of</strong> my solitude <strong>and</strong> walked into one <strong>of</strong><br />

the bars for a beer. As soon as I sat down on a barstool, three hookers<br />

surrounded me. Reaching into my pocket, I realized that I had used<br />

up most <strong>of</strong> my money. With my last Thai baht I bought Inyself a beer<br />

<strong>and</strong> a gin-<strong>and</strong>-tonic for the most persistent <strong>of</strong> the three whores - a<br />

striking WOlnan with long, wavy hair who was unusually tall for a<br />

Thai. It was the rainy season, <strong>and</strong> we sat together <strong>and</strong> watched the<br />

intermittent showers. The intense downpours caused the sewers to<br />

overflow into the streets, <strong>and</strong> the putrid water rose to the level <strong>of</strong> the<br />

sidewalks. Drunken sailors sloshed around in the liquid as if it did not<br />

exist.<br />

In broken singsong English, the whore continued propositioning<br />

me. She thought I was just trying to get the price down by claiming<br />

that I had no money. An hour elapsed, the bar was clearing out/ <strong>and</strong><br />

she gave up her efforts to secure me for the night. After I asked a<br />

few questions about her family <strong>and</strong> her home village, her mood<br />

changed. She spoke s<strong>of</strong>tly, wrapping her h<strong>and</strong>s around Iny ann. 1'd<br />

found over the years that most prostitutes could have their shells<br />

broken very easily, or not at all. But despite her earthy village qualities,<br />

her mannerisms proclaimed her pr<strong>of</strong>ession. A few <strong>of</strong> the sailors<br />

on my boat betrothed bar girls, <strong>and</strong> even when these girls rotated to<br />

the States, something always betrayed their past. I never denigrated<br />

prostitutes, as some <strong>of</strong> the other Inen did. They were just the cobras


that caught the rats that sought to rob the farmer's granary.<br />

Sometimes they drugged sailors <strong>and</strong> stole all <strong>of</strong> their possessions,<br />

even their socks. In my opinion, the hustlers only set the trap, for it<br />

was the sailors who led themselves into such a visible snare.<br />

Perhaps, this whore from a village in northeastern Thail<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> I<br />

faced the same dilemma: we worked closely with people all <strong>of</strong> the<br />

time, yet experienced very little, if any, intimacy. "Okay," she said,<br />

"if you have room with air con, it free."<br />

The 72-hour liberty call ended uneventfully, orders were barked<br />

"Anchors away!", ensigns were raised, <strong>and</strong> the U.S.S. Weitz was once<br />

again underway. I decompressed quickly from a spastic comet <strong>of</strong> muscle<br />

to a naval petty <strong>of</strong>ficer in a starched white uniform. For the time<br />

being, I submitted quietly to "the way things are," but as always, I<br />

yearned to stumble across a secret trail that would lead me to a sense<br />

<strong>of</strong> well-being. The Navy provided me with consolation in the form <strong>of</strong><br />

duty <strong>and</strong> purpose; my men <strong>and</strong> my supervisor depended on me to<br />

perform important <strong>and</strong> sometimes hazardous tasks at sea. I didn't<br />

have much in common with the rest <strong>of</strong> the men in the division, but,<br />

nevertheless, there were always a few <strong>of</strong> them around for conversation,<br />

even on the nights when I couldn't sleep or when I returned to<br />

the ship after a bout <strong>of</strong> drinking.<br />

The afternoon <strong>of</strong> our departure, walking down the starboard<br />

weatherdeck, I discovered the owl perched stoically on one <strong>of</strong><br />

the overhangs. How he made it out to the weatherdeck from<br />

the depths <strong>of</strong> the aftersteering room was again a mystery. Why<br />

didn't he fly <strong>of</strong>f when we anchored at Phuket? That was his last<br />

chance to be near l<strong>and</strong> for a week. Perhaps he had been too<br />

weak. But as I looked into his yellow eyes, he slowly opened his<br />

tiny V-shaped wings.<br />

He shot <strong>of</strong>f from the overhang only to be slammed down to the<br />

steel deck by the strong sea winds whipping alongside the ship. As<br />

he tumbled down to the deck, I snatched him before he bounced<br />

over the side. As I held the little owl in my h<strong>and</strong>s, I could feel<br />

Valdez's stare <strong>and</strong> turned. He was st<strong>and</strong>ing behind me, looking<br />

serious <strong>and</strong> distant. When underway, he expected his men to work,<br />

not go<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>f. But I could not allow the owl to die dishonorably, to<br />

simply plop into the ocean like a discarded Pepsi can. Surprisingly,<br />

Valdez stood quietly with his arms crossed. He looked down at the<br />

deck as sailors did when one <strong>of</strong> their own was masturbating in the<br />

toilet or sniveling in his rack when he got an "I am fucking someone<br />

else now" letter from his wife or girlfriend.<br />

After a few seconds in my h<strong>and</strong>s, the owl opened his wings<br />

again. Perhaps the heat <strong>of</strong> my h<strong>and</strong>s strengthened him. I turned Iny<br />

back to the wind, <strong>and</strong> the owl stood up in my cupped h<strong>and</strong>s as if he<br />

knew that I wanted to assist him in take<strong>of</strong>f. I hoped he would catch<br />

the wind just right <strong>and</strong> get a good gliding start. I lifted him above<br />

.my head. When the time was right, he shot from my h<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> flew.<br />

He flew low, just skimming over the waves. I thought I saw him fall<br />

into the water, but I aln not sure. II


I'd like to start with a few questions about<br />

Normal. What were some <strong>of</strong> the assumptions<br />

you had going into writing a book about<br />

transsexuals, cross-dressing heterosexuals,<br />

<strong>and</strong> the intersexed, <strong>and</strong> how correct did they<br />

prove to be? Has the experience given you a<br />

more extravagant sense <strong>of</strong> normal?<br />

I like the last part <strong>of</strong> that question because I do think it has<br />

given me a broader sense <strong>of</strong> the normal. It's also given Ine a pretty<br />

strong sense that it is people <strong>and</strong> culture, not nature, that decide<br />

what's normal. If it were up to nature, light would be as normal as<br />

health <strong>and</strong> as common, <strong>and</strong> blue potatoes as normal as yellow<br />

ones even if they are not as common. I think we tend not to notice<br />

how much we take what feels comfortable to us for granted, <strong>and</strong><br />

how Inuch we tend to use that as the bar <strong>of</strong> in fact what is nonnal,<br />

or even what is natural. I had just thought that women who had<br />

sex-change surgery were very unhappy, self-hating lesbians; that<br />

people who were opposed to surgery for intersexed babies were<br />

just crazy people with a political, gender-free agenda; <strong>and</strong> that<br />

cross-dressing heterosexual men were just kidding themselves ­<br />

that they were <strong>of</strong> course closeted gay men - <strong>and</strong> I didn't<br />

underst<strong>and</strong> why they couldn't just be out <strong>and</strong> proud. I think I was<br />

wrong on all three counts.<br />

C: Do you find you confront the challenge <strong>of</strong> redefining your characters<br />

when you're writing fiction too?<br />

I'm never wrong when I write fiction. That's why we like to write


fiction. It's our world, as long as we are playing by rules that people<br />

can accustom themselves to. That's why there are people who write<br />

novels set in a time other than our own, whether it's the future or the<br />

past - if you play by certain kinds <strong>of</strong> rules <strong>of</strong> normative behavior,<br />

people can adjust. If you don't, it gets much harder to read. There's a<br />

reason that great science fiction is a lot easier to read than Gravity's<br />

Rainbow. Even if it's 3,000 years in the future <strong>and</strong> there is no gravit,y,<br />

science fiction will still play by certain kinds <strong>of</strong> rules that you can recognize<br />

in a way that language with Gravity's Rainbow, let's say, doesn't<br />

really. You have to be prepared to accolnrnodate yourself to a whole set<br />

<strong>of</strong> new rules which you are discovering as you are reading, which is<br />

more work. What was easier about writing the nonfiction book was<br />

that I had my characters. But it was harder to shape interesting dialogue,<br />

because I didn't get to write it for them.<br />

e: What does a narrative arc look like to you? Do you feel there<br />

always has to be one?<br />

Yeah, otherwise it's a sketch or an anecdote. I actively dislike <strong>and</strong><br />

sometimes even resent somebody h<strong>and</strong>ing me eight pages <strong>of</strong> character<br />

description - <strong>and</strong> then the flower pot falls on her head - <strong>and</strong><br />

saying that's a short story. It's like, no it's not. One little weird event<br />

taking place does not a story make. I think short-story writers tend<br />

to fall under the category <strong>of</strong> the "interesting characterI good dialogue"<br />

writer, <strong>and</strong> the "I've got a great idea <strong>and</strong> now I'll just try to<br />

make up some cardboard figures to carry it around" writer. Those<br />

are both disappointing, <strong>and</strong> I tend to be even less interested in the<br />

"big idealcardboard characters" story. Things have to happen as<br />

they do in life, in a way which gives people an opportunity to reveal<br />

the depths <strong>and</strong> complexities <strong>of</strong> their character. The truth is, even if a<br />

bus hits you <strong>and</strong> decapitates you, it doesn't matter much to me as a<br />

reader if I haven't been interested in you as a character in the first<br />

place. You want a depth <strong>of</strong> feeling to lead to powerful language,<br />

<strong>and</strong> a depth <strong>of</strong> empathy <strong>and</strong> imagination to lead to characters who<br />

are three-dimensional about whom you care. Three-dimensional<br />

<strong>and</strong> sympathetic in the sense that they resonate with the reader - not<br />

sympathetic in the sense one likes them necessarily.<br />

G: Do you think that makes you more or less trustful <strong>of</strong> your readers?<br />

You've said that you trust your readers to be as smart as you, but<br />

otherwise you don't think <strong>of</strong> them.<br />

It's easy for them. Two pages in, they can put n1Y book in the<br />

waste-can - they can put it back on the bookshelf, return it to the<br />

library, tell everybody how much it sucks. I'm prepared to think that if I<br />

can't catch their attention in the first couple <strong>of</strong> pages, they will do with<br />

me as they will. In terms <strong>of</strong> their trust, you're sort <strong>of</strong> in there pitching.<br />

You keep trying to write the best sentence you know how about the<br />

lnost compelling story you can. But they have no obligation to me. I<br />

feel like it's my job to give my readers a world worth being in, <strong>and</strong><br />

then I hope that they can be in it. It's not that I don't want them to<br />

think; it's that I don't want them to have to be painfully conscious <strong>of</strong><br />

the fact that the little black marks on the white page signify letters<br />

which make words which make sentences, <strong>and</strong> you can see all that<br />

sweat <strong>and</strong> effort on the part <strong>of</strong> the writer. I don't care when I'm<br />

reading. I don't care if it took the author 10 years to write that shitty<br />

sentence or five minutes. If it's not good, it's not good.<br />

e: What makes a good sentence for you?<br />

Lots <strong>of</strong> people have great opening sentences. But when you're in<br />

the middle <strong>of</strong> a piece <strong>of</strong> fiction, I think it has more to do with how the<br />

bricks are laid on either side <strong>of</strong> it. How sentence one leads to sentence<br />

two leads to sentence three. And sometimes there are those sentences<br />

that just leap out like dialnonds on black velvet. Those, for me, have<br />

a certain restrained lyricism, restrained being the significant word. I<br />

like to feel that there's all this feeling pressing against the shape <strong>of</strong><br />

the sentence. So that it has a nice integrity <strong>and</strong> muscularity, <strong>and</strong> this<br />

pulsing, beating heart inside <strong>of</strong> it as well.<br />

c: How much would you say you like experimenting, formally or not?<br />

Are there any elements <strong>of</strong> fiction you stay faithful to?<br />

I don't think that I'm much <strong>of</strong> an experimenter. Having had no<br />

formal education in this, I don't ever have a sense <strong>of</strong> "I know I was<br />

taught X, but now I'm going to try Y." Nobody ever taught me X.<br />

When I wrote a short story in which all four characters' points <strong>of</strong> view<br />

were present I didn't ever really feel like you can't do more than one<br />

point <strong>of</strong> view in a short story. Why not? vVhy can't you walk around


the room <strong>and</strong> see what everyone's thinking? I am more cominitted to<br />

being faithful to what I feel is good writing <strong>and</strong> a true sentence <strong>and</strong><br />

writing about the things that matter than I am to any particular form<br />

or format. I don't want to make fast food. There's nothing wrong<br />

with fast food - I eat it, I just don't want to make it. I feel it's very<br />

hard to write a really good book with no heart. There's that great line<br />

<strong>of</strong> John Gardner's in which he says the sin <strong>of</strong> 19th-century literature<br />

is sentimentality, whereas the sin <strong>of</strong> modern literature is that it has no<br />

heart. To me the besetting sin now is a mixture <strong>of</strong> sentimentality <strong>and</strong><br />

irony the worst <strong>of</strong> both worlds. You read some <strong>of</strong> this stuff <strong>and</strong><br />

you go: Oh my God, so let's see, it's all about you <strong>and</strong> how Inuch<br />

you are better than everybody around you, but you don't want anybody<br />

to think that so you write in a really self-deprecating way but<br />

with enough irony that it will be apparent to us that the point <strong>of</strong> this<br />

is poor me. I'd rather read Little Dorrit. Or something with a great antihero<br />

like The Eustace Diamonds. She [Lizzie GreystockYs just bad to<br />

the bone, but Trollope actually sympathizes with her. And she's not<br />

bad to the bone in an arch, unrealistic, winking way. She's just a bad<br />

person, <strong>and</strong> I think that's a great character. The truth is, we are not so<br />

much aware <strong>of</strong> bad writers <strong>of</strong> previous centuries because they don't<br />

last. And I can promise you, 75 years from now people are not going<br />

to be discussing most <strong>of</strong> the books in that window <strong>and</strong> saying, oh<br />

that was a bad crop. No one will have read it <strong>and</strong> nobody will care.<br />

e: Would you agree that fiction is not true to life, but truer than it?<br />

I think that's what one hopes for. You hope that people can't tell<br />

the difference between the thing that happened <strong>and</strong> the thing that<br />

didn't. I always take it as a great compliment when people argue with<br />

me. They'll say, I know you must have a summer hOlne in Maine ­<br />

I'm like no, actually, never been to Maine. When Come To Me came<br />

out, there's a story in it about a girl with a psychotic sister. I have an<br />

older sister who's a lawyer, a very slim, fierce, attractive brunette. I'd<br />

read "Silver Water" <strong>and</strong> people would COlne up to me crying <strong>and</strong><br />

sympathizing <strong>and</strong> saying, "I'm so sorry you lost your sister." And my<br />

sister'd be sitting in the back going, "I'm fine, I'm just fine." That's<br />

why we call it fiction. But it's a great complhnent. You want people to<br />

feel that it's truer than life only in the sense that you are given more to<br />

hold onto <strong>and</strong> contemplate. In life things either happen so slowly one<br />

can hardly bear to live through them, or so quickly you hardly notice<br />

thein. In fiction, you try to split the difference.<br />

G: SO doesn't that make changing characters Inore difficult than<br />

changing the action in a story?<br />

AB: As in real life. If somebody I know well does something that makes<br />

no sense, I either have to say to myself I didn't really know her very<br />

"well, or I have to conclude that I've misunderstood or misinterpreted<br />

the action. In fiction, if I have my nice, quiet, good-hearted <strong>and</strong> generous<br />

character take a kitten in <strong>of</strong>f the street, give it a bowl <strong>of</strong> milk <strong>and</strong><br />

eviscerate it (I guess I think that would be interesting), I have a problem.<br />

Because either the character is genuinely good-hearted - in which<br />

case the action is impossible - or I have lied to you <strong>and</strong> led you to<br />

believe that she is good-hearted but she is not - in which case I have<br />

no business telling you she's good-hearted. I can indicate to you that<br />

she appears to be good-hearted, but that's different. If the behavior<br />

doesn't fit the character, then you have a responsibility to underst<strong>and</strong><br />

who you have created. I think a lot <strong>of</strong> time, people don't create sufficiently<br />

three-dimensional characters for it to even arise as a difficulty. If<br />

you have a character that's sufficiently big, they can do almost anything<br />

- which is great for plot, but lousy for staYing power.<br />

G: Did you grow up in a literary household? Who were some <strong>of</strong> your<br />

literary influences?<br />

I didn't really experience it as such, but there were books in the<br />

house, <strong>and</strong> we went to the library every week. Nobody cared what I<br />

read. It was a literary household in the most passive way - in the way<br />

it was a middle-class household, or in the way in which I had my own<br />

bedroom. Most <strong>of</strong> the books in the house were in my Dad's library: lots<br />

<strong>of</strong> Leon Uris <strong>and</strong> James Michener. I was very attached to his post­<br />

World War II library - John O'Hara, Dorothy Parker, Robert Benchley,<br />

S.J. Perelman, Ring Lardner, Saki, John Collier. I don't think I'm as<br />

funny as S01l1e <strong>of</strong> those people, or as fey <strong>and</strong> adorably odd as John<br />

Collier or Saki. But there is a fundamental sense in all <strong>of</strong> those writers<br />

that it is better to call things as they are that sentiment actually was<br />

pretty funny, but it didn't mean that it didn't matter. I'm very big on<br />

dead writers, <strong>and</strong> poets. And I don't mind if the poets are living,<br />

because their lives are so hard. You can always say to yourself, at least<br />

I'm not a poet.<br />

C: You began, <strong>and</strong> still are active, in the field <strong>of</strong> psychotherapy.<br />

Yes, <strong>and</strong> I still have a small practice. Really I began as a waitress.<br />

And I worked in a theater company for a while. Then I went to<br />

graduate school, then I became a shrink, then I started writing.


c: How did that last transition occur?<br />

AB: I was on my way to becoming a psychoanalyst. I had a meeting<br />

with the guy who was going to be my training analyst; we had a very<br />

nice chat. As I was coming home I drove past Wesleyan University,<br />

which is where I'd gone to college, <strong>and</strong> I remembered how I had bartended<br />

an event at the President's house when I was an undergraduate.<br />

I remembered all these old guys sitting on the settee - 95-year-old<br />

alums - <strong>and</strong> I thought it would be so funny if one <strong>of</strong> them just died.<br />

That led to the idea for a mystery. My kids had left their McDonald's<br />

hamburger boxes in the front seat, so I wrote some notes on the hamburger<br />

boxes. When I got home I took out my little Olivetti typewriter<br />

<strong>and</strong> I had about 15 pages <strong>of</strong> story <strong>and</strong> I was like, Oh look at that, story!<br />

I guess I'll do that for a while. So I called the guy who was going to be<br />

my analyst <strong>and</strong> said, "You know, it looks like I have something else to<br />

do." So then I started writing this mystery, which I was probably<br />

drawn to because I understood the conventions <strong>of</strong> a mystery - I wasn't<br />

very good at them, but I understood them. And then the short stories<br />

started showing up, so I wrote them. The very first story I wrote­<br />

I don't even remember the name <strong>of</strong> it, it's in Come to Me, when Galen is<br />

in love with Henry <strong>and</strong> decides not to leave her husb<strong>and</strong> David. That<br />

["The Sight <strong>of</strong> You"] is the first story I ever wrote. And the second<br />

story was "Love Is Not a Pie," which got published, <strong>and</strong> the third story<br />

I wrote was "Silver Water."<br />

C: How should a story balance showing <strong>and</strong> telling?<br />

AB: In a short story, you don't want to shortchange yourself. You don't<br />

want to not have the great narrative moments, but still you want to<br />

make most things happen right in front <strong>of</strong> the eyes <strong>of</strong> the reader. I<br />

don't think any story is interesting unless more than one story is being<br />

told. Otherwise it's missing the great thing that Will Durant said ­<br />

that history is the lives lived on the riverbanks, the fire, the children<br />

born, the old people who die, meals made, people making love, people<br />

doing laundry, <strong>and</strong> the river <strong>of</strong> blood that runs between the banks <strong>of</strong><br />

the river, which is famine <strong>and</strong> war <strong>and</strong> catastrophe <strong>and</strong> cruelty. You<br />

can't tell the history about the lives on the riverbanks <strong>and</strong> the river<br />

without these.<br />

C: At some point when you're writing about the riverbank <strong>and</strong> the<br />

river, do you feel a story becomes its own story?<br />

AB: It does become its own story. You leap <strong>of</strong>f from the characters or the<br />

impulse or the moment in your own real life. I feel perfectly capable <strong>of</strong><br />

getting my point across in real life without resorting to fiction. I don't<br />

think a lot <strong>of</strong> people don't know what I think. So why would I have to<br />

put it on the page if it's going to mess up the novel? Things can creep<br />

into your fiction but by <strong>and</strong> large, I would rather protect my family.<br />

C: In "Love Is Not a Pie," you begin with the narrator at her mother's<br />

funeral <strong>and</strong> then go back to the summer when, as a teenager, she discovers<br />

the dynamics <strong>of</strong> her parents' relationship, which happens to<br />

include a lover. Why do you think it's important to have a reason to<br />

set the reminiscence in motion in a story in which much <strong>of</strong> the narrative<br />

is told in flashback?<br />

AB: I think that story began with the opening line <strong>and</strong> emerged in my<br />

head in the present. And there were two points <strong>of</strong> view I could tell the<br />

story from. I could tell it from the woman having the affair, but she's<br />

either going to be indifferent to the pain she's causing or she's going to<br />

need a lot <strong>of</strong> self-justification. Whereas a kid for whom life is idyllic<br />

<strong>and</strong> turns out to be much more complicated, that is more interesting to<br />

me. I've always been interested in how we try to make sense <strong>of</strong> what<br />

we've seen - where what we see is not what we thought we saw.<br />

What people do in response to the event is how you know who they<br />

are. It's never the event. Four people get hit by a bus - one <strong>of</strong> them is<br />

going to be in a wheelchair, one is going to walk away unharmed, one<br />

is going to walk away unharmed but be so psychologically struck he'll<br />

be in a wheelchair, <strong>and</strong> somebody else will take it as a sign from God<br />

that they should go become a priest. It's not the bus hitting you, it's<br />

what people do in response. II


wheel. ''It won't drop any needles on the new carpet," we were told,<br />

but we spent most <strong>of</strong> the season in the early American family room<br />

with the look-<strong>of</strong>-brick linoleum floor, the gas-jet fireplace, <strong>and</strong> the<br />

console television. Christmas Eve, as we always had <strong>and</strong> always<br />

would, we went south <strong>of</strong> the river to Marge <strong>and</strong> Doc's. But that year,<br />

we left early with our packaged dog, fully upholstered in white<br />

curls except for b<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> apricot in her ears <strong>and</strong> brownish clumps <strong>of</strong><br />

drying tears accumulating around the corners <strong>of</strong> her eyes. Gigi was<br />

bound for Park Plaza.<br />

She slept her first night on a blanket in the kitchen, surrounded<br />

by newspapers, whimpering herself to sleep to the ticking <strong>of</strong> a<br />

Baby Ben alarm clock. We wedged a lawn-chair box into the doorway<br />

<strong>of</strong> the family room to confine her <strong>and</strong> her puddles to the<br />

kitchen. The next morning, when she didn't eat, we coaxed her into<br />

trying some raw egg, whipped into a bowl <strong>of</strong> milk. At first she<br />

seelned canine enough, slipping across the waxed floor in pursuit<br />

or evasion <strong>of</strong> fourth- <strong>and</strong> eighth-grade playmates. With all her hair<br />

<strong>and</strong> some residual instincts, Davis's Gigi Canella Petite Monet, as<br />

she was registered, seemed thoroughly in<strong>of</strong>fensive, even playful.<br />

But as she grew, she developed the combined genetic weaknesses<br />

<strong>of</strong> all the scrawny, sickly poodles who were forcibly mated to<br />

Inanufacture the toy species. Gigi was not merely a dog but a purposefully<br />

designed mobile ornament, fully compatible with earnest<br />

suburban living. Not a blank slate at birth, but a living Rorschach,<br />

mirroring our ambitions, our sentimentality, our confused early<br />

60's notions <strong>of</strong> femininity.<br />

The neutered dog regained her gender in monthly appointments<br />

at the poodle salon. Mom called, "Gigi, want to go bye-bye in the<br />

car?" Slipping <strong>and</strong> padding her way across the linoleum, Gigi<br />

hurled herself, a nervous comet <strong>of</strong> white hair, into my mom's arms<br />

for the Buick excursion to the Tapscott Groomers. Gigi returned to<br />

Park Plaza a needle-nosed composite <strong>of</strong> geometric shapes, sculpted<br />

into cotton balls <strong>and</strong> toothpicks, like atomic art. A sponge bow<br />

adorned her vertical top-knot, matching ones tied to each <strong>of</strong> her<br />

ears. A wide ring shaved around her belly gave her an hour-glass<br />

figure. Legs were shorn, the pink <strong>and</strong> grey bony limbs ending in<br />

white balls, like the one on her tail, just over her naked toes. Her<br />

nails were painted red, alternating red <strong>and</strong> green at Christmas, <strong>and</strong><br />

she smelled <strong>of</strong> Chanel No.5 near her rhinestone collar. Newly visible,<br />

her eyes were larger, still watering around the shaved bulges<br />

beneath them. On her return, Gigi was meaner, maybe because we<br />

could see her black lips, her red gums, her teeth newly cleaned.<br />

She walked more tentatively, the cool floor annoying her paw pads,<br />

their cushioning gone. "She's almost human," Mom would say as<br />

Gigi minced across the gold carpet in the living room <strong>and</strong> posed,<br />

front legs crossed, on the brocade s<strong>of</strong>a. Later, much later in dog<br />

years, she simply refused to walk on uncarpeted floors, whining<br />

from the hallway till we arranged a path <strong>of</strong> early American throw<br />

rugs across the linoleum to the sliding glass patio door. Soon<br />

enough her bows fell out, her hair returned, <strong>and</strong> she became a dog<br />

again - but only to begin the process anew as a scented work <strong>of</strong><br />

topiary whining from the hall.<br />

Gigi didn't eat dog food, no matter what Euclidean shape it<br />

assumed. Instead, she ate fried haInburger, dutifully drained on a<br />

paper towel, <strong>and</strong> an occasional ice cream cone: "Gigi weegee want<br />

a dog yummy?" Slipping, clattering nails, s<strong>of</strong>t collisions, red gums<br />

clamping the cone. She didn't chew on the furniture. When life<br />

produced poodle-stress, Gigi would sit <strong>and</strong> gnaw on her front legs<br />

till they bled. Eventually we purchased special snap-on plastic<br />

casts to save her legs <strong>and</strong> our upholstery. She didn't shed. When<br />

she began to lose her puppy teeth <strong>and</strong> we found one under a bed,<br />

we put it in sentimental cotton in an empty Inedicine bottle <strong>and</strong><br />

shelved it in the basement. Once trained, Gigi never peed on the<br />

floor. We'd slide open the patio door: "Do you need to do your<br />

job?" One winter night after a recent trimming, Gigi's feet becaIne<br />

chilled in a drift, <strong>and</strong> she lifted them one at a time until she lay<br />

down defeated in the snow. We collected her, brought her inside,<br />

<strong>and</strong> put her in the pink, inflated bonnet <strong>of</strong> my sister's hairdryer till<br />

she stopped quivering. We ordered a sweater for her to wear after<br />

her winter trimlnings.<br />

In the summer, she ran around the yard <strong>and</strong> even panted. Then<br />

she jumped on top <strong>of</strong> a chaise longue, Inade <strong>of</strong> giant pink plastic<br />

b<strong>and</strong>s stretched around an aluminum frame, always forgetting that<br />

her feet pushed through the b<strong>and</strong>s, leaving her stuck to her annpits<br />

in the chair. We made her wear sunglasses, just long enough to snap<br />

her picture with our Polaroid Swinger in a tolerant but uneasy Lolita<br />

pose, legs crossed into perverse poodle allure.<br />

Gigi was never a very popular dog. Yapping at the neighbors<br />

through the chain-link fence, or lunging toward the bay window<br />

with poodle ferocity when the mail came, didn't endear her to her<br />

casual acquaintances. Linda's high school friends, who rarely Caine<br />

past the entry hall, regarded Gigi as a kind <strong>of</strong> biological satire. In<br />

tie-dyed shirts, John Lennon sunglasses, <strong>and</strong> wide bell-bottoms,<br />

they were stoned enough to view her with amusement, at best. They hadn't<br />

nlnl 1'11


stopped the other day. Another bad name someone had ever called<br />

me was Spic but I don't really care because I know the person is<br />

playing with me <strong>and</strong> when he gets on my nerves I call him<br />

Hamburger Helper. His name is Rajick."<br />

"How is Manny getting called a spic like Daniel getting called a<br />

faggot?" I asked.<br />

Silence. "It's not," Shabazz suggested, ''being gay is totally different<br />

than being Latino."<br />

True. My lesson plan, I realized, was deeply flawed. It was also<br />

designed to manipulate how my students thought. I wanted to make<br />

them more liberal-minded - I wanted to make them think like me.<br />

I remembered my discomfort when my supervisor had announced<br />

that our goal should be not only to teach our students writing, but to<br />

make them ''better people."<br />

I.. II<br />

A Union soldier serving in the South said <strong>of</strong> the freedman,<br />

"Human or not, there he is in our midst, millions strong; <strong>and</strong> if he is<br />

not educated mentally <strong>and</strong> morally, he will make us trouble."<br />

We do not trust children to find their own morality. Too <strong>of</strong>ten we<br />

educate them only so that they will not make us trouble. We want to<br />

use their voices in our commercials.<br />

When I argue with my students, I <strong>of</strong>ten have the sensation that I<br />

am actually arguing with people other than them. I think I hear the<br />

voices <strong>of</strong> their fathers, or the voices <strong>of</strong> their gym teachers. They<br />

speak in slightly mutilated catch phrases. I speak cautiously, with<br />

the suspicion that my students will repeat my words back to their<br />

fathers <strong>and</strong> gym teachers. This is how children become foot soldiers<br />

in conflicts between adults.<br />

Jill III<br />

"Okay, then just tell me this," I said to my students, "what is so<br />

bad about being gay? What was so bad about your teacher, for<br />

example. Why did you throw your markers at him?"<br />

"If teachers are gay it is really bad because they can take you into<br />

a room <strong>and</strong> try to touch you," Manny answered.<br />

I stared at Manny, "I could take you into a room <strong>and</strong> touch you.<br />

Anyone could."<br />

He stared back, daring me to. I had gotten into all the wrong territory,<br />

I had dropped the third person. He shook his head, "No." I<br />

was beginning to worry about losing my job.<br />

"What else, what else is so bad about it?"<br />

"God made men to be with women, so it's against God," said<br />

Marissalee.<br />

Oh, no. I hadn't anticipated this. Students were agreeing, the room<br />

was getting noisy. I imagined that flash point was creeping up on me.<br />

I was destined to leave this room with Magic Marker on my face or<br />

having, like another teacher, tried to throw a kid out the window.<br />

"Yeah," said Shabazz, "<strong>and</strong> on that TV show the one man is gay<br />

<strong>and</strong> he dropped a quarter so that the other man would pick it up <strong>and</strong><br />

then he could look at his butt."<br />

I didn't underst<strong>and</strong> the crime in this, but it was clear that my students<br />

were moved. "Yeah, yeah!" They were all agreeing <strong>and</strong> laughing<br />

<strong>and</strong> remembering more stories about gay people they had seen on TV.<br />

How had I gotten myself into this? I had intended to teach writing.<br />

K,.<br />

During my first year <strong>of</strong> teaching, I found that I said, "Quiet!" more<br />

than anything else.<br />

I <strong>of</strong>ten heard other teachers using terms like "classroom management,"<br />

"reinforcement," <strong>and</strong> "discipline." Surprisingly, "empowerment"<br />

was also popular. Teachers misused that term all the time.<br />

They developed "empowering" exercises like letting the students<br />

draft their own rules, but the rules were always the same. True<br />

empowerment <strong>of</strong> students, I realized very quickly, necessarily means<br />

a certain disempowerment <strong>of</strong> teachers.<br />

Teachers habitually abuse their power by wrongly defining words.<br />

There is a sign in the math classroom where I used to work that says,<br />

"Caring means learning the terms <strong>and</strong> remembering them." Other<br />

signs in that school reminded me <strong>of</strong> the chapters <strong>of</strong> Brinskerh<strong>of</strong>f's<br />

1864 Advice to Freedmen: "Be Industrious," "Be Economical," "Be<br />

Temperate," <strong>and</strong> "Be Soldiers." II


y Priscilla Becker selected poems<br />

Vil/anelle<br />

Of all the creatures in all the worlds<br />

You wrote when I had waited long<br />

I think the prettiest thing is birds.<br />

Among those beauties wrapped in furs,<br />

From all the bodies sleek <strong>and</strong> strong,<br />

Of all the creatures in all the worlds?<br />

I thought your vision must be blurred<br />

By dizzying flights <strong>of</strong> sparrow throng<br />

To think the prettiest thing is birds.<br />

Perhaps I'd been too long immured<br />

To hear their slllall <strong>and</strong> separate song<br />

FrOin all the creatures in all the worlds.<br />

Your brown eyes <strong>of</strong>ten go obscure<br />

And seem to nothing to belong<br />

Unless the taxidermist's doe-eyed bird.<br />

When all along I'd thought it words!<br />

You wrote when I had waited long<br />

Of all the creatures in all the worlds<br />

I think the prettiest thing is birds.<br />

The Sound <strong>of</strong> the Closing Door<br />

There is a kind <strong>of</strong> cry at first,<br />

not <strong>of</strong> pain but <strong>of</strong> warning<br />

<strong>of</strong> pain.<br />

I have come to regard the wide arms<br />

<strong>of</strong> the chair as an only Inother.<br />

Next a small suck <strong>of</strong> air.<br />

I think my double is<br />

the stone - fire-wrought or dripped<br />

into formation. And there was<br />

a third kind too.<br />

Then two dry clicks, an interlocking.<br />

It seems that it should be my lot<br />

to look out on a line strung<br />

from post to post,<br />

<strong>and</strong> though it could be missed,<br />

the dusk reminder <strong>of</strong> the small<br />

daily apocalypse.<br />

It is this third kind I relate to.<br />

The first fragment <strong>of</strong> division,<br />

the private room.


. ...<br />

half like Selma <strong>and</strong> half like an ab<strong>and</strong>oned doctor. Selma waved her<br />

h<strong>and</strong> in front <strong>of</strong> her face, an attempt at scattering the pieces <strong>of</strong> this vision<br />

about the air. As she was leaving <strong>and</strong> zipping up the door, Selma considered<br />

scribbling out a note to Nabil, but what would she tell hun?<br />

When Selma returned, the woman was already in her car, the<br />

engine revving, tailpipe spitting a plume <strong>of</strong> exhaust.<br />

On the way out <strong>of</strong> the forest, the women talked. Helga had emigrated<br />

from Germany 30 years before <strong>and</strong> had been moving around ever<br />

since. Egypt, Selma had <strong>of</strong>fered in return. I<br />

She glanced at<br />

the speedometer:<br />

45, 50, 55. She<br />

had afold <strong>of</strong> bills in<br />

her pocket, burning<br />

against her thigh,<br />

enough to buy a<br />

plane ticket.<br />

came from Egypt two months ago. "I was<br />

there in the '60s," Helga continued now.<br />

"And I fell in love with it. Just fell in love."<br />

A road atlas with a broken spine lay on<br />

the floor by Selma's feet. Selma gently<br />

nudged two overlapping pages apart to<br />

reveal a map <strong>of</strong> Toronto. Something<br />

pinched her from inside, a sensation she<br />

had been having frequently since she'd<br />

arrived in Canada. The car smelled stale,<br />

the air it contained, years, centuries old. It<br />

reminded her <strong>of</strong> grade-school trips to the<br />

Pyramids, crawling into airless tombs<br />

where she'd held her breath, afraid that if<br />

she inhaled she would die. The tombs had<br />

been pillaged centuries before, the mummies long gone, still they had<br />

smelled <strong>of</strong> death, Selma thought. Wind spilled in through the window.<br />

The cool, constant slap <strong>of</strong> clean air against her skin made it numb.<br />

''Will you go back there?" Helga asked. Her hair was long, blonde<br />

<strong>and</strong> gray at once. She let go the steering wheel in order to gather her<br />

hair into a quick bun on the top <strong>of</strong> her head. She had a small but<br />

strong body. A muscle in her bare right thigh twisted against her skin<br />

each time she switched froln the accelerator to the brake.<br />

Lola sat on her lap. Selma knew this was dangerous, but wasn't life<br />

itself dangerous? Precautions felt arbitrary. "I shall go back there now,"<br />

she said with sudden, alien authority. The idea had only come to her<br />

minutes before. When Selma had gotten into Helga's car, she'd had no<br />

designs on a destination. Ofcourse! she thought now. I'm going home.<br />

Warmth crept frOln the top <strong>of</strong> her head down through her stomach. She<br />

glanced at the speedOlneter: 45,50, 55. She had a fold <strong>of</strong> bills in her<br />

pocket, burning against her thigh, enough to buy a plane ticket. It was<br />

the money Nabil never traveled without: emergency mone)!, he called it.<br />

She had taken it from the inside pocket <strong>of</strong> his jacket on her way out <strong>of</strong> the<br />

tent without remorse. If anything did, this pain that she felt constituted<br />

an emergency.<br />

"It becomes harder <strong>and</strong> harder to go back the longer you stay away/'<br />

Helga said as they sped through unfamiliar l<strong>and</strong>scapes.<br />

Selma noticed a blurred fruit st<strong>and</strong> that looked like someplace she<br />

had seen before. Then she realized that it was just like all <strong>of</strong> its counterparts<br />

back home; many <strong>of</strong> the same fruits available in Egypt, the same<br />

bright colors. The only difference was that here the price was by pound<br />

<strong>and</strong> was written in English.<br />

"Are you married?" Helga paused.<br />

"Her father is my husb<strong>and</strong>; he is back in Egypt, where we are going<br />

now to be with him," Selma answered. The words filed out <strong>of</strong> her mouth<br />

one-by-one; each one that came out surprised her more than the last. "My<br />

sister lives in Toronto. She was having a surgery. I came to be with her."<br />

"What kind <strong>of</strong> operation?"<br />

Selma paused, conjuring images <strong>of</strong> her two healthy sisters back in<br />

Cairo. She evicted them from her mind <strong>and</strong> invented a new one, a<br />

woman with a malady <strong>of</strong>... "She was losing one eye. She made a surgery<br />

to fix it."<br />

"And did it work?"<br />

''Yes. Now she see again." Selma turned to look at her new companion.<br />

''Why you came here?" she asked.<br />

"After the war," Helga said. She slowed her driving <strong>and</strong> glanced at<br />

Selma. "That's when I left."<br />

A few seconds passed. "It was terrible?" Selma finally <strong>of</strong>fered.<br />

''Well, I lived through it." Helga swerved sharply around an idling car.<br />

"Of course. It is a blessing."<br />

''Do you believe in God?" Helga asked abruptly after a pause, a long<br />

curve in the road.<br />

Last year, even last month, this would have been a question easily<br />

answered: Yes. But now Selma wondered what she believed in. How<br />

could your own life become something you couldn't recognize? Selma<br />

caught a view <strong>of</strong> herself in the small, tilted mirror <strong>of</strong>f the side <strong>of</strong> the car.<br />

Her hair was long <strong>and</strong> loose <strong>and</strong> tangled. She hadn't washed it for<br />

days. There were deep, dark shadows underneath her coal-colored eyes.<br />

Her husb<strong>and</strong> called her beautiful, but she could not see why.<br />

The car filled with silence, like a balloon exp<strong>and</strong>ing to the point <strong>of</strong><br />

almost bursting. Helga unrolled her window <strong>and</strong> rested an elbow on<br />

the open frame.<br />

Finally Selma said, ''Why you were in Egypt?"<br />

JlMy husb<strong>and</strong> was a journalist, <strong>and</strong> Egypt was his specialty."


"What did he find?" Selma asked anxiously.<br />

"He wrote on Egypt after the Revolution. Nasser <strong>and</strong> the rise <strong>of</strong> the<br />

Muslim Brothers. Nationalization <strong>of</strong> the Suez ..."<br />

Selma's own husb<strong>and</strong> was among the young who had fought for<br />

revolution in the early 1950s, who rioted against the British, who spent<br />

time in prison. He knew about Egypt, Selma thought, surprising herself<br />

with the sudden swell <strong>of</strong> pride in her gut; what could Helga's husb<strong>and</strong><br />

possibly underst<strong>and</strong>?<br />

Lola bounced around on Selma's lap <strong>and</strong> laughed at a dog in a<br />

passing window. "Darling," Helga cooed, glancing away from the road<br />

<strong>and</strong> patting the top <strong>of</strong> Lola's head. Selma's stomach clenched, noticing<br />

the stranger's h<strong>and</strong> on her baby.<br />

''You have a child?" Selma asked, drawing her arms more tightly<br />

around her daughter, who squirmed against the change in pressure.<br />

Helga looked ahead <strong>and</strong> let a car pass in front <strong>of</strong> her. Selma<br />

watched the side <strong>of</strong> her silent face. The car ahead sped into the distance<br />

<strong>and</strong> disappeared. "I had one."<br />

Selma rolled up her window - the streaming wind suddenly too<br />

much, too loud. "What. What happened?"<br />

"Mechanical failure. Something with the engine-" her voice<br />

trailed <strong>of</strong>f. Moments later Helga cleared her throat: "A plane crash. The<br />

planehad been in the air for not longer than 10 minutes. I took them to<br />

the airport. I watched it take <strong>of</strong>f. I waved as it did. I always wondered<br />

if they saw me."<br />

"Maybe they did," Selma said feebly.<br />

"Maybe."<br />

"How long ago?"<br />

"Fifteen years now."<br />

"I am sorry."<br />

A pair <strong>of</strong> dark sunglasses rested on the dashboard. Helga reached<br />

for them <strong>and</strong> pushed thein onto her face.<br />

"Are you hungry?" Helga said suddenly, as if this were the solution,<br />

exactly what was needed to rescue them both.<br />

"Yes," Selma said before taking a moment to consider whether or<br />

not she was.<br />

A young waitress approached the table that Helga had chosen. She<br />

brought a wet cloth, which she used to wipe a smear <strong>of</strong> ketchup from<br />

the wooden surface. Booths with bright red vinyl seats lined the<br />

periphery <strong>of</strong> the diner. The surfaces <strong>of</strong> the tables were white, shellacked.<br />

Yellow lamps the shape <strong>of</strong> inverted salad bowls hung low<br />

above each table, <strong>and</strong> dim bulbs shone within them.<br />

"Sorry 'bout that," the waitress said. ''Be right back with menus." She<br />

left a wet, glistening streak on the table. Itformed a crooked line between<br />

Selma <strong>and</strong> Helga, which Selma watched until it dried <strong>and</strong> disappeared.<br />

''Your husb<strong>and</strong> was also on that plane?" Selma asked hesitantly.<br />

Helga nodded, but her expression was different from the one she had<br />

worn in the car, now distant <strong>and</strong> veiled, as if it was someone else's<br />

tragedy they were talking about.<br />

Lola bounced on the seat, her small fingers gripping the window, leaving<br />

tiny fingerprints. Selma wanted to make her daughter stop bouncing.<br />

She pulled Lola firmly down, eliciting a small, high-pitched cry. Out <strong>of</strong><br />

the corner <strong>of</strong> her eye, Selma noticed Helga watching them, tilting her<br />

head <strong>and</strong> observing each detail. Lola slapped at the air in front <strong>of</strong> her<br />

while making angry sounds. She was alive. Everything she did suddenly<br />

seemed potent, something to remind Helga <strong>of</strong> what she had lost.<br />

Selma looked out the window, half expecting to see Nabil walking<br />

toward theIn, his slow <strong>and</strong> careful stride. Instead she saw another man<br />

in the parking lot. She thought again <strong>of</strong> Mustafa. The hood <strong>of</strong> the truck<br />

stood open <strong>and</strong> the stranger bent his head over what it revealed. He<br />

adjusted something. He lowered the hood. Once he was back in his car,<br />

it started, <strong>and</strong> he drove away.<br />

Selma turned to notice the tap <strong>of</strong> Helga's fingers against the table's<br />

surface. If she went back to Cairo, would she move back in with her<br />

parents, she <strong>and</strong> Lola back into the room she had grown up in, the<br />

room she had shared with Nabil for those months after their marriage?<br />

Noone would marry her now: a woman with a child who had left a<br />

husb<strong>and</strong> behind. The thought <strong>of</strong> it got her heart pounding, sent too<br />

much blood to her head.<br />

The waitress returned with menus. As Selma began to read down the<br />

columns <strong>of</strong> laminated options, she felt the immensity <strong>of</strong> her sudden<br />

hunger. She wanted it all, everything. Ketchup was one <strong>of</strong> the things<br />

she liked about Canada - she ordered a hamburger, well done, with<br />

French fries <strong>and</strong> a side salad. Helga ordered a tuna melt.<br />

"I loved SOineone before my husb<strong>and</strong>," Selma confessed to Helga<br />

once the waitress was gone.<br />

"Do you love him still?"<br />

''I do not know." She had put Mustafa out <strong>of</strong> her mind through the rush<br />

<strong>of</strong> her wedding, becoming pregnant, having the baby;. moving to America,<br />

but in the past weeks he had moved back in again. Every night in the tent<br />

after Lola had gone to bed, Nabil approached like a shy teenager, kissing<br />

Selma's cheek for minutes before growing bolder. Each night it ended in<br />

sex, <strong>and</strong> while Selma tried to focus on her husb<strong>and</strong>'s body careening above<br />

her, she felt nothing until she closed her eyes <strong>and</strong> pictured Mustafa.


assortment <strong>of</strong> needles, catheters, tubing, drugs, <strong>and</strong> something called a<br />

''basic tray." (A basic tray was a metal tray, sterilized <strong>and</strong> covered in<br />

blue paper, that contained the instruments necessary to open up a person<br />

<strong>and</strong> either take out or put in basically anything you wanted.)<br />

The room smelled <strong>of</strong> antiseptic <strong>and</strong> the tile floor had been dulled<br />

<strong>and</strong> eroded by the constant lapping <strong>of</strong> bleach. No matter how<br />

bloody or messy this room got, it would always return to its original<br />

state. It had no memory <strong>of</strong> what had occurred, whether lives<br />

were saved or lost. And it operated outside the usual laws <strong>of</strong> UH.<br />

The only hierarchy in the slot was a hierarchy <strong>of</strong> ability. In that<br />

room there was no doubt about who I was or why I was there. And<br />

that was where I found myself - still in the process <strong>of</strong> digesting<br />

dinner - face-to-face with the man who<br />

No matter how<br />

bloody this room<br />

got it would<br />

always return to<br />

its original state. It<br />

had no memory <strong>of</strong><br />

whether lives were<br />

saved or lost.<br />

would not take <strong>of</strong>f his pants.<br />

The pants man - a semi-distinguished,<br />

semi-disheveled, 70ish-Iooking man - was<br />

seated upright on a stretcher desperately<br />

holding onto his waistb<strong>and</strong>. I had seen men<br />

like him before; my Saturdays growing up<br />

had been filled with them - the men I<br />

would sit next to in synagogue, who my<br />

father would laugh with, who knew all the<br />

prayers by heart <strong>and</strong> would smile when<br />

they saw my face constrict after tricking me<br />

into tasting rye whiskey. Men who had run<br />

from persecution in Europe to live in a nondescript<br />

lower-middle-class New York City<br />

suburb with my father <strong>and</strong> other men<br />

who'd run froin the Bronx for different reasons.<br />

The sight <strong>of</strong> this familiar-looking man desperately trying to stop<br />

nurses <strong>and</strong> other doctors from removing his pants was an odd<br />

scene because, in the slot, there is a sudden absence <strong>of</strong> social nicety.<br />

Patients are attacked on all sides. The routine was: unbutton, rip,<br />

or cut <strong>of</strong>f all clothing, whichever was fastest. Remove rings, necklaces,<br />

earrings, watches. Attach various electrical leads <strong>and</strong> oxygen<br />

masks. Penetrate as many <strong>of</strong> the largest veins as possible with<br />

large-bore IVs, <strong>and</strong> as quickly as possible.<br />

Despite the maelstrom around him, the man was obstinate. He<br />

clung to his pants with the strength <strong>of</strong> a drowning man trying to grip<br />

a piece <strong>of</strong> floating wood. But he was not drowning in water, he was<br />

drowning in his own fluids. Literally; Fluid was leaking into his lungs<br />

because his heart was failing. He was in the midst <strong>of</strong> a Inassive heart<br />

attack <strong>and</strong> unless he let go <strong>of</strong> his pants, gave us his anns <strong>and</strong> legs <strong>and</strong><br />

direct access to his arteries, veins <strong>and</strong> bladder, we were not going to be<br />

<strong>of</strong> much help.<br />

His myocardial infarction he had was caused by a blockage <strong>of</strong> his<br />

left anterior descending coronary artery - an artery affectionately<br />

known as the "widow-maker" because <strong>of</strong> how much vital heart<br />

muscle it supplies. As we all surrounded him, pleaded with him to<br />

let us take his pants <strong>of</strong>f, he did not look all that scared. His shirt<br />

was <strong>of</strong>f, his shoes were <strong>of</strong>f, his socks were <strong>of</strong>f, his watch was <strong>of</strong>f - I<br />

even think a yarmulke had been removed - but still he would not<br />

let go <strong>of</strong> his pants. He had a hairy chest, broad shoulders, <strong>and</strong> arms<br />

that looked like they had been strong <strong>and</strong> had now found renewed<br />

strength in their determination not to let go <strong>of</strong> his belt.<br />

All he said was, "Get my son."<br />

Bringing in family meinbers was not something you did in the slot.<br />

Husb<strong>and</strong>s, wives, children, friends, interested byst<strong>and</strong>ers are not there<br />

when chests are cracked or tracheas intubated. The slot is not a place<br />

for the uninitiated, for people who do not know the rules <strong>of</strong> the hospital,<br />

for those who do not wear a hospital ID. But this time I went out<br />

into the waiting area <strong>and</strong> found the man's son. I was excited to usher<br />

him in. I was going to be the face <strong>of</strong> the place that was trying to save<br />

his father. I would be the first thing the son would see, <strong>and</strong> like a duckling<br />

he would imprint to me - imprint that I was the doctor.<br />

I walked him in <strong>and</strong> after they exchanged glances, his father<br />

reached into his pockets <strong>and</strong> pulled out two wads <strong>of</strong> tissue paper,<br />

gave thein to his son <strong>and</strong> then unceremoniously took <strong>of</strong>f his pants. It<br />

all happened so quickly. The drama vanished so abruptly that it<br />

seemed to call its own existence into question. According to the son,<br />

there were roughly several hundred thous<strong>and</strong> dollars worth <strong>of</strong> diamonds<br />

in those wads <strong>of</strong> tissues, but as I retell the story, inflation<br />

brings the total to at least several million.<br />

My sons love this story. Perhaps it is the discovery <strong>of</strong> unexpected<br />

treasure; perhaps it is that funny things can happen even in the most<br />

dire <strong>of</strong> circumstances; or perhaps it is that when all seemed lost, I<br />

brought the son in <strong>and</strong> saved the father. As my sons slip into sleep<br />

they know that the diamonds are safe <strong>and</strong> the father lives. As I close<br />

my eyes I hope that they imagine me a hero.<br />

But finding the diamonds is not the end.<br />

The geins are rescued, but we are still in the slot <strong>and</strong> in the midst <strong>of</strong><br />

a losing battle. The man may have waited too long for help. We are<br />

pUluping fluids into him, trying to maintain his blood pressure. We are


giving him diuretics to get the fluid <strong>of</strong>f, <strong>and</strong> morphine for the pain<br />

<strong>and</strong> to help him breathe. But he is continuing to drown, his fingers<br />

<strong>and</strong> toes are turning blue, his blood is stagnating, he is on the verge <strong>of</strong><br />

collapse. We infuse a medicine to try to dissolve the blockage in the<br />

artery supplying his dying heart muscle. But this is also in vain.<br />

Nothing worked as planned. The pants man's circulation continued<br />

to fail; his lungs filled with more fluid as his extremities sank<br />

into a deeper violet. He would not live the night if we could not open<br />

that artery. He needed more than could be found in the slot. He<br />

needed someone to go in <strong>and</strong> manually unclog the blockage. He<br />

needed an angioplasty. So with a team <strong>of</strong> practioners in tow, we took<br />

our patient up to the fifth-floor <strong>and</strong> slowly woke up the cath lab from<br />

its weekend sleep.<br />

The cath lab was was nothing like being in medical school, where<br />

whenever I was gowned-up it was in an operating room, <strong>and</strong> I<br />

always felt out <strong>of</strong> place. Back then, I held retractors. I held them so<br />

long over open chests <strong>and</strong> abdomens that my neck cralnped <strong>and</strong> my<br />

shoulders ached. I tried to give as much exposure to the operating<br />

field as possible in the hope that I would disappear. I focused on trying<br />

to help as much as I could. Get this, do that, keep moving.<br />

Inevitably the chief surgeon would ask some mortifying question<br />

like, "What do you make <strong>of</strong> the mouse model <strong>of</strong> hernia repair?" or<br />

"What Shakespeare play does this line come from?" My inability to<br />

answer was crushing. There could never be any doubt about who<br />

wielded the power over me: the nurses, the other doctors, <strong>and</strong> the<br />

open body in that room.<br />

But that night in the cath lab, there were no impossible questions.<br />

It was just business as usual. As dye was injected, we took pictures.<br />

Pictures <strong>of</strong> the arteries <strong>and</strong> blockages, pictures <strong>of</strong> a small balloon<br />

blowing up inside an artery, <strong>and</strong> then the trickle <strong>of</strong> dye that said the<br />

blockage was gone. All <strong>of</strong> this recorded on what looked like old<br />

Super 8 film, a sort <strong>of</strong> home movie <strong>of</strong> the heart.<br />

When all was done that could be, <strong>and</strong> the catheters were<br />

removed, it was my job to make sure that the large hole we made in<br />

the femoral artery closed. This meant applying firm but constant<br />

pressure on my patient's groin. I thought this was going to be the<br />

final act, the triumphant denouement after the climactic angioplasty.<br />

We had opened up his artery, <strong>and</strong> restored blood-flow back into:,<br />

his heart, but the man was still dying. His heart muscle -like a '<br />

child gone limp after a beating - had been so stunned by the sudden<br />

<strong>and</strong> complete lack <strong>of</strong> oxygen that it would not contract. The<br />

pants man's eyes began to dull <strong>and</strong> blood tests showed a dangerow:<br />

buildup <strong>of</strong> acid.<br />

A last attempt was made to save him by putting in an intraaortic<br />

balloon pump, which actually did the trick. So after hours<br />

<strong>of</strong> effort using the best available high-technology interventional<br />

cardiology - something based on the physics <strong>of</strong> a party favor<br />

that would save this man.<br />

After what seemed like an eternity (but more like five hours), I<br />

brought the pants man, his IVs <strong>and</strong> balloon pump up into the cardiac<br />

ICU. He was stable; I was exhausted. By then I had spent hours<br />

pulling, poking, prodding, <strong>and</strong> probing his body. I had made hiln uri<br />

nate, thinned his blood, put my h<strong>and</strong>s in his groin. I was intimately<br />

aware <strong>of</strong> him, yet I knew very little about him. It was like I had been<br />

looking at the photographic negative <strong>of</strong> someone. Details, size, texture<br />

had all been perfectly represented, yet remained uninterpretable,<br />

It relninded me <strong>of</strong> my own father.<br />

When I was around my sons' ages, my father <strong>and</strong> I spent countless<br />

hours together. Not just at synagogue, but doing many <strong>of</strong> the usual<br />

father-son things available in a New York City suburb: mowing the<br />

lawn while straddling a wheelhorse tractor, pulling weeds from the<br />

garden at the front <strong>of</strong> the house, raking leaves, driving from place to<br />

place looking for shrubs or plants or more mulch. In the summers he<br />

wore ripped jeans <strong>and</strong> a white T-shirt. There are pictures <strong>of</strong> me on his<br />

shoulders as a young boy, but I cannot remember being there.<br />

What I do remember is his belly loosely hanging out over the rim<br />

<strong>of</strong> his jeans, <strong>and</strong> the embarrassment <strong>of</strong> seeing his jeans fall down as<br />

he bent over to plant seeds or bulbs. I can still see the patches <strong>of</strong><br />

psoriasis there <strong>and</strong> on his arms. The same patches that drove our<br />

family from open beaches to desolate s<strong>and</strong>y places where he could<br />

take <strong>of</strong>f his shirt in private.<br />

I was always aware <strong>of</strong> his psoriasis. I noticed how he never talked<br />

about it, how lny mother would say, "We can't go there because <strong>of</strong><br />

your father."<br />

I knew from quiet, careful surveillance that at night he wrapped<br />

himself in Saran Wrap after covering his skin in cremns to try to abatl<br />

the seemingly endless propagation <strong>of</strong> the thick plaques.<br />

When we worked in the garden, I could see how the medicine<br />

made his skin diaphanous in places. How cuts that on lne would be<br />

mere scrapes would, for him, be bleeding wounds. Though we spent<br />

many hours talking, we never spoke <strong>of</strong> this. We talked about soil <strong>and</strong><br />

dirt <strong>and</strong> rocks. We talked about water tables <strong>and</strong> the differences


etween cement <strong>and</strong> concrete. I worked hard, sweated, never asked<br />

questions. I had logged many hours <strong>of</strong> observation but still he<br />

remained a Inystery. The psoriasis encased him like layer upon layer<br />

<strong>of</strong> a resin that would refract light in such a way that form could be<br />

seen but all detail lost.<br />

None <strong>of</strong> this was on my mind when I went out to find the pants<br />

man's son 1'd met earlier outside the CICD.<br />

The son was still wearing the same nondescript suit, but he looked<br />

older <strong>and</strong> more frightened.<br />

"Can I see him?" he asked.<br />

We walked through the CICU doors <strong>and</strong> into the cubicle that<br />

was CICU Bed One. I recall their eyes meeting <strong>and</strong> then the<br />

expression on the son's face. They said a few words to one<br />

another, then the son <strong>and</strong> I left.<br />

As we walked he asked if he could ask me a question.<br />

"Of course," I said. My patient - his father - was now stable. I<br />

felt ready to assuage whatever pain or concern I imagined he had. It<br />

was like being back at Bellevue. I was beginning to feel in charge <strong>of</strong><br />

things again. I prepared my usual statement: "He's stable but anything<br />

can happen; we won't know much until after at least 24 to 48<br />

hours." (The key is to provide hope <strong>and</strong> encouragement, but as little<br />

actual prediction as possible.)<br />

But I couldn't have been more wrong about what I ilnagined his<br />

concerns to be.<br />

"Do you see those two women sitting next to one another?" he asked.<br />

I nodded.<br />

"The one on the right is my mother; the one on the left is my<br />

father's mistress. Neither knows the other. What should I do?"<br />

I wish I could recall exactly what I said or did then. I cannot even<br />

remember what either woman looked like. Did they look alike? Was<br />

one blonde <strong>and</strong> the other brunette? One tall, the other small? Did<br />

they make up two halves <strong>of</strong> one whole?<br />

This was not a problem <strong>of</strong> navigating the complicated emotional<br />

waters <strong>of</strong> wives or mistresses, or contemplating the reasons why<br />

men find comfort or excitement in people other than their spouses.<br />

If those were the questions I had to answer, I would have failed miserably.<br />

I would have failed because - despite the fact that I had felt<br />

the ribs <strong>of</strong> elderly women crack under the pressure <strong>of</strong> my failed<br />

resucitation efforts, watched as surgeons dug their h<strong>and</strong>s into the<br />

open chests <strong>of</strong> boys who had been shot <strong>and</strong> marveled at bodies ravaged<br />

by drugs, alchohol <strong>and</strong> sundry forms <strong>of</strong> ectoparasite - I was<br />

still just a pastiche <strong>of</strong> hardened experience <strong>and</strong> pudding-like naivete.<br />

At that time in my life, I had never even known anyone who'd had<br />

an affair.<br />

What I did know then was that life as a doctor was all about the<br />

extremes. And extremes, to me, defined what was most human. In<br />

that moment I understood that my job was to safeguard an extremely<br />

vital secret. I was there to figure out a way to protect the father, protect<br />

the life <strong>of</strong> the man I had just spent the last five hours saving. It<br />

was a role I knew well.<br />

The son <strong>and</strong> I quickly devised a strategy to have his mother visit<br />

first. Then, as they were leaving, I would go out <strong>and</strong> get the mistress,<br />

make sure that their paths did not cross<br />

<strong>and</strong> bring her in to see her lover. It was a<br />

plan formed from the distillation <strong>of</strong> the<br />

advice my father gave me: "Tell your<br />

mother you love her, then just do what<br />

you want."<br />

This is where the story ends for me. I<br />

cannot recall anything after. It is lost to<br />

me. I know what I did not do, though; I<br />

did not ask the son what he was thinking<br />

or feeling. Had he known his father was<br />

having an affair, or was he completely<br />

shocked? Had he even wanted his father<br />

to live? Or was this just another one <strong>of</strong><br />

those times when it seems like children<br />

The son <strong>and</strong> I<br />

qUickly devised a<br />

strategy to have<br />

his mother visit<br />

first. Then I would<br />

go out <strong>and</strong> get<br />

the mistress.<br />

have an infinite capacity for forgiving their parents? That same kind<br />

<strong>of</strong> capacity that finds children protecting those who hurt them, or trying<br />

valiantly to placate the implacable.<br />

It is difficult for me to imagine what I would have done in that<br />

moment, confronted by a living, breathing, someone-who-washaving-sex-with-my-father<br />

secret. This was not the secret life I<br />

imagined my father had. It was inconceivable to me that he could<br />

have had an affair, inconceivable that he could touch anyone or<br />

have anyone touch him. His psoriasis was a barrier to all contact.<br />

My father's secret life that I spent my childhood fantasizing about,<br />

as I waited for him outside <strong>of</strong> closed <strong>of</strong>fice doors or in the aisles <strong>of</strong><br />

electronics shops, involved cl<strong>and</strong>estine meetings between agents <strong>of</strong><br />

Middle East governments, or corporate espionage on behalf <strong>of</strong> rival<br />

fuel-cell technology companies. I traveled with him everywhere,<br />

even waiting alone in a nursing home parking lot when he went to


visit my gr<strong>and</strong>father whom I never met. I was his squire. I spent<br />

hours with him doing things for people without knowing why. At<br />

the end I would always promise not to tell my mother.<br />

Of course, now I know there were no cl<strong>and</strong>estine meetings, <strong>and</strong><br />

we did things for people because my father owed them money.<br />

Saddest <strong>of</strong> all, I never saw my gr<strong>and</strong>father because my father was<br />

too angry at him for putting my father <strong>and</strong> his brothers <strong>and</strong> sister<br />

up for adoption.<br />

I made up stories because I had to fill the void left by my father.<br />

How would I have reacted to that misdirected primal scene taking<br />

place in the CICU lounge if it was my own father in the hospital<br />

bed? At that time, I imagine it would've been with the same air <strong>of</strong><br />

practiced pragmatism <strong>and</strong> detachment the son showed me. Now,<br />

15 years later, I wonder whether I would be struck by how much I<br />

have become like my father.<br />

I was reminded <strong>of</strong>all this when - as my sons <strong>and</strong> I were going<br />

to sleep recently - my eldest said matter-<strong>of</strong>-factly, "Mommy told<br />

me you had an affair <strong>and</strong> that's why you aren't married."<br />

He was right; I did have an affair. But I was stunned by his<br />

statement, <strong>and</strong> only later did I get the voicemail message from<br />

my ex-wife alerting me to their conversation.<br />

I felt cornered. What I wanted to say was a combination <strong>of</strong>, uTake<br />

that question back right now; your mother did not have my permission<br />

to tell you that; you are too young, I'm not ready to tell you;<br />

don't talk about this in front <strong>of</strong> your brother!"<br />

But what I said was, "That's a really long <strong>and</strong> complicated conversation<br />

that we should really have tomorrow, not when we're<br />

going to sleep."<br />

But even as the words were coming out I knew both <strong>of</strong> us would<br />

be unhappy with that, <strong>and</strong> that this moment represented a chance for<br />

me to be something different from my own father. So while my<br />

younger son distracted himself with some toys, my older son <strong>and</strong> I<br />

got out <strong>of</strong> bed <strong>and</strong> started talking.<br />

It had only been several weeks since I had asked him if he had<br />

any questions about sex. All he said to me was, "No." So first I<br />

asked if he even knew what an affair was.<br />

"Sure" he said, "it's what Henry's father had." (Henry was one <strong>of</strong><br />

his closest friends whose father had already remarried.)<br />

So, unprepared as I was, I began to talk.<br />

I did not talk about what it felt like to be desperate in life or in<br />

marriage. How it felt to deceive his mother, or how it felt to deceive<br />

myself. I did not tell him how convenient it was that I was a doctor,<br />

that excuses to leave the house were just a page away, each coded<br />

beep a place <strong>and</strong> time. I did not say how delicious it was to have sex<br />

with someone else, after not having sex for so long. I did not say how<br />

I felt reanimated by the deception <strong>and</strong> danger. How good it felt to be<br />

wanted, <strong>and</strong> how good it felt to want. I did not try to explain that in<br />

some ways my affair was a brief, perfect moment <strong>of</strong> hiding in plain<br />

sight. I did not reveal how lost I was at that time, how little I knew <strong>of</strong><br />

Inyself. I did not tell him how it felt to tell his Inother or how it felt to<br />

have all <strong>of</strong> our friends <strong>and</strong> family find out. I did not tell him about<br />

how it felt to have the mask <strong>of</strong> "good husb<strong>and</strong>, good father, good<br />

doctor" ripped from my face.<br />

What I said was that at the time I was very unhappy. I was sad<br />

<strong>and</strong> depressed. I told him that affairs generally do not cause divorces<br />

but are symptoms <strong>of</strong> problems within marriages, <strong>and</strong> that I deeply<br />

regretted having one. I told him that he <strong>and</strong> his brother were the happiest<br />

part <strong>of</strong> my life but that somehow things were not right between<br />

his mother <strong>and</strong> me. I told him that when people are sad or troubled<br />

they sometimes make wrong decisions that can cause pain to the people<br />

they love. I told him that I regretted what I had done <strong>and</strong> that<br />

every day I think about the hurt it has caused him.<br />

I'm not sure what he believed or did not believe but what he said<br />

next was, "Why have an affair when you can just get divorced?"<br />

uYou're right," I said, but that is a story for another night, I<br />

thought to myself. And as I fell asleep, I was aware <strong>of</strong> the pictures on<br />

the wall. Pictures <strong>of</strong> us on vacation, <strong>of</strong> us on my sister's boat, <strong>of</strong> us in<br />

my small apartment. And pictures <strong>of</strong> my sons proudly holding up a<br />

pumpkin grown in my father's garden. II


The New Yorker, TriQuarterly, Bomb, <strong>and</strong> on<br />

NPR's "All Things Considered."<br />

Hamilton Walters' (a.k.a. Saw Takkaw)<br />

"on the ground" human rights reports <strong>and</strong><br />

photographs have been published by<br />

Burmanews.net. Dictatorwatch.org, Karen<br />

Human Rights Group (KHRG), <strong>and</strong> Burma<br />

Human Rights Yearbook. They've also been<br />

featured in Benedict Rogers' AL<strong>and</strong> Without<br />

Evil: Stopping the Genocide <strong>of</strong> Burma's Karen<br />

People. His poems <strong>and</strong> photographs have been<br />

published by The Dilettanti, Marr's Field<br />

<strong>Journal</strong>, <strong>and</strong> the Colere. He currently lives <strong>and</strong><br />

works on the Thai-Burma border.<br />

Joe Wenderoth grew up in Baltimore.<br />

Wesleyan University Press published his first<br />

two books <strong>of</strong> poems, Disfortune (1995) <strong>and</strong> It Is<br />

If I Speak (2000). His other works include<br />

Letters To Wendy's (Verse Press, 2000), The<br />

Holy Spirit <strong>of</strong> Life: Essays Written For John<br />

Ashcr<strong>of</strong>t's Secret Self <strong>and</strong> Agony: AProposal<br />

(forthcoming, 2007). He teaches English at the<br />

University <strong>of</strong> California, Davis, where he lives<br />

with his wife <strong>and</strong> daughter.<br />

Mary Zoo grew up in California <strong>and</strong> holds<br />

degrees from the University <strong>of</strong> California, Los<br />

Angeles <strong>and</strong> the University <strong>of</strong> Iowa Writers'<br />

Workshop. She is the Book Review Editor for<br />

Electronic Poetry Review. She lives <strong>and</strong> works in<br />

Oakl<strong>and</strong>, California. II<br />

CONTEST<br />

II II<br />

2006<br />

judges include:<br />

• Amy Hempel, fiction<br />

• Katha Pollitt, nonfiction<br />

• Karen Volkman, poetry<br />

First-place winners for each genre will<br />

receive $500 <strong>and</strong> publication<br />

<strong>of</strong> their entries in <strong>Issue</strong> 43.<br />

(Runners-up will also be considered for publication.)<br />

The entry fee is $12 <strong>and</strong> our contest<br />

deadline is December 3t 2005.<br />

For submission gUidelines, check out our<br />

current issue or our web site at:<br />

www.columbia.adu/cu/arts/journal.<br />

at<br />

www.harpers.org<br />

you can:<br />

* Subscribe to Harper's Magazine<br />

* Buy a gift subscription<br />

* Access your account status<br />

* Pay your bill<br />

* Renew online<br />

* Find out if your payment has been applied<br />

* Change your mailing address<br />

or your email address<br />

*Tell us that you've missed an issue<br />

Just click on "newsst<strong>and</strong>"<br />

----------+----------<br />

www.HARPE.F\S .org<br />

See what we're doing online.


<strong>Columbia</strong>!journa.<br />

fill<br />

DUSTJACKETS<br />

"I like to think I've read all the farm animal care books<br />

that have come out in the last 20 years". Speaking <strong>of</strong><br />

pigs specifically, this book is the very, very best."<br />

- GENE LOGSDON<br />

(on Storey's Guide to Raising Pigs)<br />

"A brilliant autism novel has been overdue - <strong>and</strong> this is it!"<br />

OLIVER SACKS<br />

(on The Curious Incident <strong>of</strong>the Dog in the Night-Time)<br />

"It's absolutely gosh-wow, super-colossal - smart,<br />

funny, <strong>and</strong> acontinual pleasure to read. In ajust world."<br />

it should win prizes. That wouldn't be at all amazing."<br />

- MICHAEL D1RDA<br />

(on The Amazing Adventures <strong>of</strong> KaMer <strong>and</strong> Clay)<br />

"A rollicking Pynchonesque oddity, aNabokovian linguistic<br />

obsession, <strong>and</strong> aBorgesian unreality. [House <strong>of</strong> Leaves]<br />

jumps <strong>and</strong> skips <strong>and</strong> plays with genre-wrecking ab<strong>and</strong>on,<br />

postmodern panache, <strong>and</strong> an obsessively imaginative scope<br />

that absolutely shames most books on the market today."<br />

- SAN FRANGISCO EXAMINER<br />

<strong>and</strong> CHRONICLE<br />

(on House <strong>of</strong> leaves)<br />

"For some reason, more <strong>and</strong> more young writers are<br />

producing dystopian novels. Chris Genoa<br />

rides the quest <strong>of</strong> this wave with weird<br />

humor, great characters, <strong>and</strong><br />

descriptions <strong>of</strong> time travel so<br />

accurate that you'd think he's<br />

actually traveled through time. Well?<br />

Have you, Chris?"<br />

- NEAL POLLACK<br />

(on Foop)<br />

"This version <strong>of</strong> the Inferno<br />

is God's face in a<br />

Groucho mask."<br />

SAN FRANGISCO<br />

CHRONICLE<br />

"Only those suffering from the deepest depression,<br />

or already dead, will not derive the greatest pleasure<br />

<strong>and</strong> laughter ... in this truly wonderful book."<br />

- DAILY EXPRESS<br />

(on Where There's a mm<br />

"[Percival Everett] has the acerbic brilliance <strong>and</strong><br />

unsparing eye <strong>of</strong> Swift but is much funnier. His new<br />

novel is as manic <strong>and</strong> antic as Tristram Sh<strong>and</strong>y<br />

<strong>and</strong> as wildly original as Monty Python, but<br />

the absurdist comedy is dark in the manner<br />

<strong>of</strong> lonesco."<br />

- JANETTE TURNER<br />

HOSPITAL<br />

(on American Desert)<br />

Find agood book<br />

blurb? Send it in:<br />

columblajournal@columbla,edu

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!