Issue 42 - Columbia: A Journal of Literature and Art
Issue 42 - Columbia: A Journal of Literature and Art
Issue 42 - Columbia: A Journal of Literature and Art
Transform your PDFs into Flipbooks and boost your revenue!
Leverage SEO-optimized Flipbooks, powerful backlinks, and multimedia content to professionally showcase your products and significantly increase your reach.
SO m e f e a S t<br />
FICTION -<br />
SAMANTHA GILLISON 24 The Upper Canada Holding Company<br />
He could no sooner have been the rabbi his<br />
mother wanted than a warlock.<br />
STEPHANIE DICKINSON 50 Dalloway & Hannah<br />
His robe clings to his breasts, <strong>and</strong> they're<br />
aset <strong>of</strong> perfect tennis balls.<br />
KIRSTY GUNN 70 The Pass<br />
All you can imagine is the way ahead,<br />
who'll be there, who's waiting.<br />
LYDIA DAVIS 135 Enlightened<br />
She is 54 years old <strong>and</strong> no more enlightened,<br />
as far as Ican see, than when I first knew her.<br />
DALIA AZIM 144 By Way <strong>of</strong> Toronto<br />
It was what she had come to think <strong>of</strong> when she thought <strong>of</strong><br />
America: endlessness, emptiness.<br />
POETRY- -<br />
JAMES DOYLE 23 The Banquet Master<br />
mead <strong>and</strong> cider streaming from the table's / edge<br />
JE NIFER MICHAEL HECHT 32 The Way-Out Way Out<br />
to our surprise, the mess <strong>of</strong> lines / forms an image<br />
ALLEN GROSSMAN 34 Winter at the Sea Shore<br />
Timor Mortis, Inc., ASwitchboard Memory
MARY ZOO 48 Twin<br />
Of all the street's windows, only yours dreams.<br />
EAMON GRENNAN 65 Feast<br />
New Year's Day: Looking for a Sign<br />
Morning under Muckish<br />
What Shadows<br />
Weather <strong>Art</strong>ists<br />
In the dormitory <strong>of</strong> the oak, the saint tended the flame<br />
THYLIAS MOSS 80 Ghee Glee<br />
Fork Addiction<br />
The Culture <strong>of</strong> Reena <strong>and</strong> the Bear<br />
The Culture <strong>of</strong> Mr. Wonderful<br />
Promise her anything: give her foia gras:/stuff it down her throat<br />
L1AM RECTOR 97 Our Hero Galliano<br />
New York City<br />
Soon the City<br />
On the fire escapes / In asleeveless T-shirt / Smoking acigar<br />
ERIN BELIEU 104 from In The Red Dress I Wear to Your Funeral<br />
Your c<strong>of</strong>fin is atough room. / Mourners talk through my set<br />
LUCIA BRYANT 124 La Cabre<br />
Oh, he trimmed stalky blades, for sure, / but erratically, whimsically<br />
PRISCILLA BECKER 1<strong>42</strong> Villanelle<br />
The Sound <strong>of</strong> the Closing Door<br />
Ihave come to regard the wide arms / <strong>of</strong> the chair as an only mother.<br />
NONFICTION II<br />
JOE WENDEROTH 100 from Agony: Agony <strong>and</strong> the University<br />
Theater People are special; their nearness to Agony is unique.<br />
Their sadness sometimes overwhelms them.<br />
HAMILTON WALTERS 108 Steel Smoke<br />
In Subic, mere enlisted rubes metamorphosed into godkings,<br />
such was the blessing <strong>and</strong> curse <strong>of</strong> being an<br />
American with asteady paycheck.<br />
JAMES DAVIS 126 Gigi<br />
But that year, we left early with our packaged dog, fully<br />
upholstered in white curls except for b<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> apricot in her ears.<br />
EULA BISS 136 Watch Out for L<strong>and</strong> Mines<br />
Teachers have the terribly difficult job <strong>of</strong> controlling large<br />
groups <strong>of</strong>people who haventyet fully learned how to be controlled<br />
STUART LEWIS 157 Pants<br />
It was an odd scene because, in the slot, there is asudden<br />
absence <strong>of</strong> social nicety. Patients are attacked on all sides.<br />
INTERVIEW II<br />
NONFICTION II ART II<br />
MARSHA RECKNAGLE 11 When You Walk from This Room<br />
Stories that spring from the unconscious sometimes<br />
speak the truth.<br />
PETER TRACHTENBERG 38 from The Book <strong>of</strong> Calamities<br />
In Rw<strong>and</strong>a, the killing took place in public. Everybody saw it.<br />
All you had to do was look out through your garden gate.<br />
.....It........ ..<br />
AMY BLOOM 116 interview by Leyla Ertegun<br />
Idon't care if it took the author 10 years to write that<br />
shitty sentence or five minutes. If it's not good, it's not good.<br />
JACK PIERSON ii Self Portrait #15<br />
iv Self Portrait #11<br />
vi Self Portrait #4<br />
x Self Portrait #19<br />
xiv Self Portrait #17<br />
xvi Self Portrait #1
ART II<br />
ANTHONY GOICOLEA ii Pool Pushers<br />
v Tree Dwellers<br />
vii Dead Forest<br />
viii Boys' Room<br />
xii Still Life with Pig<br />
DINOS & JAKE CHAPMAN iii Fuck Face<br />
ix Tragic Anatomies<br />
xiii DNA Zygotic<br />
xv Zygotic Acceleration, Biogenetic<br />
De-sublimated Libidinal Model<br />
(enlarged x1000)<br />
II II<br />
Editor's Note<br />
rankl)', it's hard to believe the number <strong>of</strong> pigs in this issue. Every<br />
time there was an opportunit)T, we seemed to sa)', but how might we<br />
get another pig in there? Can we bring in Charlotte's Web? Though<br />
one <strong>of</strong> the editors noted, "I love pigs - they're delicious," many<br />
don't even eat The Pork. For instance, I was raised by a macrobiotic<br />
vegetarian who went so far as to strike night-shade vegetables from<br />
our fridge due to their resemblances to flesh. No eggplant, tomato, or<br />
avocado. In teenaged rebellion I ate Whopper Juniors <strong>and</strong> left the<br />
receipts in the key dish, in my pants pocket, in the drawer with playing<br />
cards <strong>and</strong> batteries. Once, after a particularly nasty fight I cooked<br />
bacon in my mother's iron skillet -left the residue to cake, her next<br />
com pone was my delicious secret <strong>and</strong> resulted in stomach cramps<br />
for the whole family. But mostly my diet has been free <strong>of</strong> sentients.<br />
Another editor's favorite picture <strong>of</strong> herself is st<strong>and</strong>ing next to a giant<br />
hog in Ecuador. She wanted to use it on her license. Another claimed<br />
that even the smell <strong>of</strong> ham caused her stomach to wrench. And yet<br />
after reading James Doyle's poem about the banquet <strong>and</strong> Thylias<br />
Moss's about clarified butter we found ourselves wanting more.<br />
What we need is a pig on a spit - can we make it turn as the reader<br />
flips through pages? The idea was that each st<strong>of</strong>)T, poem, photo, <strong>and</strong><br />
essay would be a part <strong>of</strong> a massive <strong>and</strong> growing feast - the kind<br />
where something bleeds then gets slow-cooked to perfection over<br />
lightly smoking hickory or cherry. There are shifts to tend the fire.<br />
It is only the way we carne to underst<strong>and</strong> this, <strong>Columbia</strong>'s <strong>42</strong>nd <strong>Issue</strong>.<br />
We set out with no thematic directive, put no constraints on what<br />
content to look for. There are essays about Rw<strong>and</strong>a, a good dog,<br />
teaching, whoring in Phuket; stories about camping, old friends,<br />
growing up, <strong>and</strong> getting the hell out; poems about fashion, a goat,<br />
Manhattan, <strong>and</strong> quietly watching; art that is wetter than words, seas<br />
<strong>of</strong> bodies, a town in the trees, <strong>and</strong> portraits <strong>of</strong> men growing young.<br />
And a lot <strong>of</strong> pigs. Thank you for picking up this issue, for subscribing,<br />
for flipping through at the library: It is all for you dear reader,<br />
enjoy the feast.<br />
Very Truly Yours,
II<br />
When Augustus came out on the porch the blue<br />
pigs were eating a rattlesnake - not a very big<br />
one. It had probably just been crawling around<br />
looking for shade when it ran in to the pigs. They<br />
were having a fine tug-<strong>of</strong>-war with it, <strong>and</strong> its<br />
rattling days were over. The sow had it by the<br />
neck, <strong>and</strong> the shoat had the tail.<br />
II<br />
- LARRY MCMURTRY<br />
from Lonesome Dove<br />
\<br />
by Marsha<br />
Recknagle<br />
so m e f e a 5 t<br />
When You Walk<br />
from This Room<br />
he students crowded around a conference table made<br />
<strong>of</strong> the same particle-board brown as the Ouija board<br />
I'd touched lightly, but <strong>of</strong>ten, as a child. When first I<br />
walked into the classroom, I was irritated that there<br />
were no windows, no space for me to pace around in<br />
my cowboy boots, swirl my gauzy skirts.<br />
My teaching techniques - swirl, pace, match the momentum <strong>of</strong> my<br />
thoughts with h<strong>and</strong>s flying as if I were in a game <strong>of</strong> charades <br />
would be restricted this semester by setting.<br />
I looked up at the blank faces: John with the curly hair <strong>and</strong><br />
sneaky eyes, Megan, skin luminous, Brenna, her teeth <strong>and</strong> the<br />
whites <strong>of</strong> her eyes startling in contrast to her olive skin. Shiny sleek<br />
seals, I thought, <strong>and</strong> imagined tossing a beach ball into the air, saw<br />
it in my mind's eye - round <strong>and</strong> rolling <strong>and</strong> colorful, creating a<br />
stir, like my words that I hoped would bounce from student to student,<br />
forming balloons <strong>of</strong> ideas above their heads.<br />
I touched the table with my fingertips, saw the traces <strong>of</strong> my<br />
prints on the cheap surface, thought <strong>of</strong> making a mark in the<br />
room. Tried, by tapping my fingers on the tabletop, not only to<br />
predict the future but form it. Rock/Paper/Scissors. The class is<br />
destined to hatch like a brood during the gestation period we call<br />
a semester. Brazen or beat-down, all in the future, up to me, up to<br />
us, how we nurture, what we need.
were my own, a strange turn <strong>of</strong> phrase, the possessiveness that took<br />
root. She told me later that after the first day <strong>of</strong> class she thought she<br />
wanted to grow up to be me. A compliment, a complement, Kelly.<br />
In Kelly's freshman class I'd taught her Mrs. Dalloway. Stories<br />
<strong>and</strong> poems by D.H. Lawrence. The Left H<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> Darkness. The<br />
Ghostwriter. By her senior year I'd taught her how to eat before she<br />
drank wine, how to dance alone without self-consciousness, how to<br />
dance with a woman with total self-consciousness, how to flirt with<br />
her ice-blue eyes, how to think about the maternal, separation individuation,<br />
the porous boundaries between mothers <strong>and</strong> daughters,<br />
thinking this would help her with her mother, who couldn't st<strong>and</strong><br />
that I had taught Kelly to read, flirt, <strong>and</strong> drink wine.<br />
I would embrace "differance," as the French theorists called what<br />
we usually resist. I would be the good mother. I would banish the<br />
bad mother. It was fierce, in fact, the battle between us, Kelly's<br />
mother <strong>and</strong> myself, though one fought behind the scenes, behind the<br />
conscious scrim that held us back, kept us from crossing - the line,<br />
each other.<br />
My dissertation had been psychoanalytic: women's autobiographies.<br />
I'd read Winnicott, Freud, Melanie Klein. Books with wondrous<br />
titles: This Sex Which Is Not One, The (M)other Tongue. There<br />
were lots <strong>of</strong> parentheses in the titles, in the configuring <strong>of</strong> the way a<br />
woman writes herself into relation. Writing a book is compared to<br />
giving birth, ink compared to milk, a mother entangled forever with<br />
the daughter <strong>and</strong> vice versa. I was born to my mother late - she<br />
already had three children, <strong>and</strong> her first-born had a baby too soon,<br />
out <strong>of</strong> wedlock, as they say. Overwhelmed with children, my mother<br />
railed out loud to me, who sat on the kitchen floor quietly turning<br />
the pages <strong>of</strong> my Golden Books. Children! Children having children!<br />
This, she told me time after time, robs one <strong>of</strong> childhood.<br />
I was frightened <strong>of</strong> children, the idea <strong>of</strong> children. Those thieves.<br />
Kelly's boyfriend delivered the news <strong>of</strong> her car crash. He was so<br />
slight in build that he looked like a teenager. Born in Hawaii, he was<br />
exotic, had burnished skin, almond eyes. He walked into the room<br />
that contained the fall class: a Ryan, a Tyndall, two Johns, Brenna,<br />
Megan, <strong>and</strong> 12 others. It was the second week <strong>of</strong> the semester. A<br />
year before - or maybe even in the freshman class four years before<br />
- Kelly had decided to pursue a Ph.D. in literature. Accepted to<br />
Michigan with a large scholarship, she was thrilled. The trunk <strong>of</strong> her<br />
car was filled - she didn't plan on going back to where she was<br />
from for a long time; maybe she was thinking, not ever. While in<br />
Ennis packing for Michigan, she called me each day: the car wasn't<br />
ready; her father was dilly-dallying; she was antsy to take<strong>of</strong>f. Finally<br />
the father asked her: Would she take her mother along on the trip?<br />
Make it girls' night out. A road trip. Kelly <strong>and</strong> her mother hadn't<br />
been getting along for several years; Kelly was turning into a creature<br />
her mother didn't know - <strong>and</strong> didn't really like. She let something<br />
happen to me, Kelly tells me one day while we are having c<strong>of</strong>fee. Her<br />
eyes darted back <strong>and</strong> forth as if she were watching a movie. She talks<br />
to me as if she is doing a voice-over for the movie before her eyes. It<br />
was an old man at the gas station. Down the feeder road.<br />
Did she know? I asked.<br />
She knew <strong>and</strong> didn't know, Kelly said.<br />
It will be dramatic, the wreck, the telling <strong>of</strong> the wreck. An appearance<br />
at the classroom door - Kelly's boyfriend, so full <strong>of</strong> arrogance<br />
with the news that he wears a half-smile, proud that he has such a<br />
story. He will paraphrase what Kelly, <strong>and</strong> then I, will elaborate on:<br />
Kelly's mother drove <strong>of</strong>f an overpass. The car tumbled <strong>and</strong> turned<br />
three times, l<strong>and</strong>ing upright.<br />
Her mother died.<br />
Kelly lived <strong>and</strong> lived <strong>and</strong> lived. The implication <strong>of</strong> that sentence,<br />
what seems to follow naturally, is that she lived happily ever after.<br />
Her mother had mentioned the movie Thelma <strong>and</strong> Louise when they<br />
waved good-bye to the father who stood in his cowboy hat <strong>and</strong> boots<br />
in the gravel driveway <strong>and</strong> raised his h<strong>and</strong> in the way ranchers do, a<br />
small salute, then the tap on the car door as if it is a horse in which<br />
they are entrusting the safety <strong>of</strong> the rider. Then Kelly <strong>and</strong> her mother<br />
were <strong>of</strong>f - just like Thelma <strong>and</strong> Louise, her mother repeated, laughing,<br />
tossing her hair back, as if tossing something away from her.<br />
Kelly's mother didn't like being a rancher's wife, "out in the sticks,"<br />
she complained to Kelly the night before the accident, in the small<br />
motel. She always thought she <strong>and</strong> her husb<strong>and</strong> would move to<br />
Dallas, buy one <strong>of</strong> those houses with white columns outside, walk-in<br />
closets inside. She spoke <strong>of</strong> the fictional house in detail, the sparkle,<br />
the wonder <strong>of</strong> it, especially compared to the dusty dirt-yard <strong>of</strong> their<br />
home <strong>of</strong> 20-some-odd years that was filled with stray dogs <strong>and</strong><br />
tractor parts, the place Kelly had described in her essay for graduate<br />
school as authentic, regional in a world gone homogenous, a place<br />
that made her unique, a st<strong>and</strong>out among the Northeastern applicants,<br />
a place appealing in memory, on paper, but a place to be left behind.<br />
Kelly's real life was just about to begin - in Ann Arbor, far from<br />
WHEN YOU WALK OUT OF THIS ROOM 17
(the only living son <strong>of</strong> the 12 children his wife would give birth to)<br />
<strong>and</strong> was confronted by his father-in-Iaw's blue eyes gazing up at<br />
him. Manusz tried to beat his father-in-Iaw's ghost out <strong>of</strong> his son,<br />
but it refused to budge. Instead it stared out at Manusz from his<br />
young son's face, mocking, judging, making him wild with aggravation<br />
so that finally Oskar was not allowed to look at his father. His<br />
mother had hoped that her father's troublesome ghost wouldn't be<br />
able to follow them on the difficult, confusing trip to America, but it<br />
was worse in New York between her son <strong>and</strong> husb<strong>and</strong> than it had<br />
ever been between her husb<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> father in Hungary.<br />
His mother had hoped Oskar would be a rabbi, which Manusz<br />
thought was a great joke. Every afternoon before he went out,<br />
Manusz Tiklowicz beat his son <strong>and</strong> then locked him in their apartment<br />
with its nailed-shut windows. Study hard, you wretch, he'd<br />
shout, you monkey, as he walked down the hall.<br />
By the time he was 14, Tiklowicz had taught himself to read<br />
English poetry; with money he earned carting coal for a mikvah on<br />
Ludlow Street, he bought leather-bound books <strong>of</strong> Shelley, Keats <strong>and</strong><br />
Byron. He spent restless nights in the tiny tenement apartment listening<br />
to his coughing, snoring, muttering, whimpering sisters<br />
sleep while he mulled over a line <strong>of</strong> verse; Beauty is truth, truth<br />
beauty, - that is all Ye know on earth, <strong>and</strong> all ye need to know. How<br />
easy in the early dawn to pull the nail out <strong>of</strong> the window frame<br />
<strong>and</strong> climb up the fire escape <strong>and</strong> greet a startled Alberto sipping<br />
watery hot milk.<br />
There was no question in Oskar's mind that God didn't exist; he<br />
could no sooner have been the rabbi his mother wanted than a<br />
warlock. He started a coal-carting business with Alberto, <strong>and</strong> the<br />
two <strong>of</strong> them dragged the heavy sacks up <strong>and</strong> down narrow tenement<br />
staircases <strong>and</strong> fire escapes from dawn until nightfall.<br />
And then, when he cut <strong>of</strong>f his peyess, his father broke his nose.<br />
He overheard a friend <strong>of</strong> his father's talking about the fur business<br />
in Canada. Oskar decided to go <strong>and</strong> take Alberto with him.<br />
"It'll be like back in Mauritania," Oskar teased his solemn friend.<br />
"When you rode with Berbers across the Atlas mountains. And, you<br />
know, those Berbers are Jews. Like a lost tribe."<br />
But Alberto followed Oskar to Canada the way he had followed<br />
him through the New York ghetto his entire adolescence without<br />
a second thought like the Sephardic brides weighted down with<br />
silver, their palms tattooed in henna curlicues, their fingertips blood-red,<br />
<strong>and</strong> cheeks decorated with black kohl triangles, that he had watched<br />
trail after their grooms along the cobbled streets <strong>of</strong> the Fez mella.<br />
Alberto was Oskar's shadow: a quiet, motherless, fatherless child,<br />
preoccupied with the memories that had followed him from Morocco,<br />
the visions that crawled into his eyes when he slept or breathed in<br />
the smell <strong>of</strong> horse dung in the hot sun or listened to the clang ting<br />
clang <strong>of</strong> the blacksmith's hammer on Delancey Street. But Oskar was<br />
a star in the blacked-out sky, allowing light, possibility into the world<br />
for Alberto. Oskar conjured money, supplies; wrote to his mother's<br />
cousin who had a seed-exporting business in Montreal. Then he flew<br />
north to Canada like an eagle, with Alberto under his wing.<br />
The two <strong>of</strong> them camped <strong>and</strong> travelled through Upper Ontario the<br />
summer <strong>of</strong> 1907; they hired a dour Ojibwa man to canoe them from<br />
lake to bog to lake, along freezing, rushing rivers, past beaver dams<br />
<strong>and</strong> Indian settlements, under swarms <strong>of</strong> geese, clouds <strong>of</strong> mosquitoes,<br />
<strong>and</strong> black flies. They were Champlain <strong>and</strong> Frontenac, Oskar declared,<br />
pushing along in birch canoes, the wealth <strong>of</strong> the forests unfolding<br />
before them. They bought beaver pelts from Huron <strong>and</strong> Ojibwa Indians<br />
<strong>and</strong> baskets from a Cree woman with a swollen, goitered neck for<br />
Alberto's little sister, Mila. Oskar heard about a nickel mine near Dorset<br />
<strong>and</strong> they went to visit. Tiklowicz had an uncanny gift for business: it<br />
frightened Alberto a little (his own mother's superstitions with her<br />
H<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> Fathma <strong>and</strong> magic necklaces <strong>of</strong> colored glass still lurked inside<br />
him.) He had always known that Oskar had Sight. He could overhear a<br />
sentence, a detail, <strong>and</strong> know if something would work, if a trapper was<br />
lying, what would make money, what they should do. Oskar gave<br />
their business a name, too, on the third night they camped out: The<br />
Upper Canada Holding Company.<br />
The night they spent on the shores <strong>of</strong> Lake Erskine was cool. Alberto<br />
waded into the water <strong>and</strong> caught three rainbow trout. Oskar fried them<br />
in lard with thick slices <strong>of</strong> yellow onion, black pepper <strong>and</strong> potatoes. He<br />
made c<strong>of</strong>fee <strong>and</strong> they drank it sweet with condensed milk <strong>and</strong> had a<br />
fishy-tasting cake <strong>of</strong> frying-pan bread. Oskar had borrowed money<br />
from his mother's cousin in Montreal <strong>and</strong> he had invested it now,<br />
almost all <strong>of</strong> it, for the Upper Canada Holding Company. They<br />
owned that night, the two <strong>of</strong> them, a quarter interest in the Dorset<br />
nickel mine they had visited, fifty shares in the Baptiste-Kearney cadmium<br />
mine, a tiny stake in a timber company out <strong>of</strong> Dwight, <strong>and</strong> 70<br />
beaver pelts. Almost everything was leveraged against each other, a<br />
house <strong>of</strong> cards waiting to be pushed over. But Oskar didn't Inind. He<br />
understood what he had invested in.
They wore sweaters <strong>and</strong> knit wool caps <strong>and</strong> smoked cigarettes<br />
while they drank their c<strong>of</strong>fee <strong>and</strong> looked out at the dark settling on the<br />
lake. The whole place pulsed with the night: frogs <strong>and</strong> cicadas chorusing<br />
back <strong>and</strong> forth, black clouds <strong>of</strong> bats shivering above the tree<br />
canopy <strong>and</strong> then melting into the black night sky. Oskar kept a diary <strong>of</strong><br />
their trip in a cardboard-covered notebook. He fished it out <strong>of</strong> his pack<br />
<strong>and</strong> flipped through the pages, stopping to check a list, write a note in<br />
the firelight. Across the front cover he had written in black ink: UPPER<br />
CANADA HOLDING COMPANY O. Tiklowicz, A. Levi props.<br />
He had pasted maps onto its pages, train tickets, labels from<br />
the first tins <strong>of</strong> condensed milk <strong>and</strong> navy beans they ate,<br />
receipts, bills, a h<strong>and</strong>-written contract,<br />
a snapshot <strong>of</strong> the two <strong>of</strong> them with<br />
Your great-greatgreat-gr<strong>and</strong>father<br />
probably spit on<br />
Columbus <strong>and</strong><br />
de Torres as he<br />
ran to make the<br />
boat to Tangiers.<br />
their packs strapped on at Haliburton<br />
station. He sketched the lakes they<br />
paddled over, jack pines, Alberto fishing,<br />
Ojibwa birch canoes bobbing in the<br />
waves; he wrote notes about the mines,<br />
trappers, traders they met, the diarrhea,<br />
poison ivy, <strong>and</strong> stinging black fly<br />
bites that plagued them both; he jotted<br />
down poems that echoed in his mind<br />
when he looked out at the smoky bluegreen<br />
forest that flowed like a river<br />
over the mountains <strong>and</strong> lake-studded<br />
valleys <strong>of</strong> Upper Canada. He had carefully<br />
pasted in a cutting from The Globe<br />
& Mail about the future <strong>of</strong> the Hudson's Bay Company <strong>and</strong><br />
wrote tiny notes in pencil along the margins.<br />
"You see, Europe is a lady <strong>of</strong> advancing years," Oskar said, shutting<br />
the book <strong>and</strong> shaking his finger at Alberto's smiling face.<br />
"Sophisticated. Gorgeous. But when you bend down to kiss her, the<br />
sweat in her armpits, the breath in her mouth she smells sour, <strong>of</strong><br />
Death. But Canada!" He was shouting now, his voice a high-pitched<br />
squeak in the night, clapping his h<strong>and</strong>s to punctuate his sentences,<br />
performing for Alberto <strong>and</strong> the crackling fire <strong>and</strong> the slick-furred<br />
otters who peered at them from the lake shallows. "Canada is the<br />
beautiful virgin girl bursting with the life! With swelled, firm<br />
breasts. She is ready to clasp a Jew to her warm body! Her breath is<br />
sweet, her mouth hungry!"<br />
Alberto laughed at the impossible image <strong>of</strong> his skinny, toothless<br />
friend with his face in some girl's chest.<br />
"What a rabbi you'd make," Alberto said. ''It's not too late, you know."<br />
"It's so funny, ha ha, my fall from grace," Oskar said, smiling, his<br />
face covered in the smile, his small, delicate h<strong>and</strong>s stretching out to<br />
embrace the whole night. "But this is exactly the place for us, Bertie.<br />
Up here with the Indians," he gestured, pointing at the creatures<br />
watching them from the lake, "with the animals."<br />
Alberto siniled <strong>and</strong> nibbled on a piece <strong>of</strong> the frying-pan bread.<br />
Oskar's voice, the fire, the smell <strong>of</strong> smoke <strong>and</strong> the spruce needlecovered<br />
earth made the night unfurl in front <strong>of</strong> him: he could see his<br />
life as a series <strong>of</strong> places - Ontario, New York, the steamship, his<br />
father's store in the melfa with its hundreds <strong>of</strong> hammered tin <strong>and</strong><br />
glass lanterns hanging from the ceiling, lined up on rickety shelves<br />
gleaming in the North African sun. He sawall those places eInpty <strong>of</strong><br />
people, quiet, only angles <strong>and</strong> shadows, turning them over in his<br />
mind like a child with a seashell. Oskar nudged the coals in the fire<br />
with a stick, sending sparks <strong>and</strong> crackles <strong>and</strong> a puff <strong>of</strong> smoke into the<br />
blue-black night.<br />
"You know, we're like the Jew Columbus who set sail on the<br />
ninth <strong>of</strong> Ab looking for cinnamon sticks <strong>and</strong> discovered the world,"<br />
Oskar said.<br />
"What are you talking about?" Alberto laughed. "Christopher<br />
Columbus was a converso?"<br />
"Of course he was. Don't you even know that? Why else were<br />
there only Jews on his trip as his advisors? You ever heard about<br />
Luis de Torres? Why were all the investors Jews? Tell me, my<br />
Spanish-speaking friend - why did he choose to sail into the great<br />
blue beyond for the Indes on the very same, exact day the Gr<strong>and</strong><br />
Inquisitor had sent every Jew in Spain packing <strong>and</strong> all the ports<br />
were clogged with weeping <strong>and</strong> wailing yentas? Your great-greatgreat-gr<strong>and</strong>father<br />
probably spit on Columbus <strong>and</strong> de Torres as he<br />
ran to make the boat for Tangiers."<br />
"Stop it," Alberto laughed. "Next it's going to be - you know that<br />
English Jew, Henry Hudson? This guy would not drink a cup <strong>of</strong> tea<br />
with everyone else on Yom Kippur! No, not a sip!"<br />
"Believe, don't believe. It's true." Oskar shrugged his shoulders.<br />
Alberto, still laughing, began to stack the pans, the enamelled tin<br />
plates <strong>and</strong> cups, the flame-blackened lard pail. Tiklowicz was quiet as<br />
they cleaned up from dinner, all <strong>of</strong> a sudden seized with one <strong>of</strong> his<br />
somber moods. He squatted at the fire, smoking <strong>and</strong> peering into the<br />
smoldering purple <strong>and</strong> red flames, the orange coals. Alberto went<br />
into the tent, shook out the blankets. He heard Tiklowicz moving
around, boots scraping on the rocks, the fire stoked. He heard the<br />
cooking pans clang together as Tiklowicz strung them up onto the<br />
branches <strong>of</strong> the huge spruce tree. And then Oskar's squeaky voice<br />
declaiming into the darkness, his voice full <strong>of</strong> emotion:<br />
She walks in beauty, like the night<br />
Of cloudless climes <strong>and</strong> starry skies;<br />
And all that's best <strong>of</strong> dark <strong>and</strong> bright<br />
Meet in her aspect <strong>and</strong> her eyes:<br />
Thus mellow'd to that tender light<br />
Which heaven to gaudy day denies.<br />
As he lay down under his blankets, a blister <strong>of</strong> happiness burst<br />
inside Alberto, trickling through him until his entire being was<br />
warm from it. Everything around him, the faint sound <strong>of</strong> waves lapping<br />
at the shore, the cool, tender summer air covering them like a<br />
duvet, the sound <strong>of</strong> Oskar's voice, a crying loon flying over the lake,<br />
the rustling breeze <strong>and</strong> jack pines that grew gnarled <strong>and</strong> bent along<br />
the shore, all felt part <strong>of</strong> him. Tiklowicz was right - <strong>of</strong> all the places<br />
he had moved through, this was the only one he had ever wanted to<br />
stay in. It was as though for the first time since he was a boy in the<br />
mella <strong>and</strong> had watched his father, all beat up <strong>and</strong> bleeding, die that<br />
Alberto's nerves had become untangled <strong>and</strong> were loose <strong>and</strong> free,<br />
drifting inside his soul like the fingers <strong>of</strong> a sea anemone fluttering in<br />
underwater currents, letting him feel the universe as it spun by. He<br />
fell into sleep that night like he was diving into the lake, buoyed by<br />
happiness, the happiest he'd ever felt.<br />
When Alberto woke up, Tiklowicz was swhnming. Mist rose from<br />
the gray-blue water. Night still hung in the air <strong>and</strong> faint clouds<br />
stretched between skinny poplars <strong>and</strong> spruce trees like webs <strong>of</strong> cotton<br />
wool. Oskar waded out <strong>of</strong> the lake up onto the narrow stone<br />
beach naked, white from the cold, his penis curled between his legs.<br />
Steam evaporated <strong>of</strong>f his warm body into the dawn. He began shivering<br />
when he was drinking his c<strong>of</strong>fee; soon he was burning with<br />
fever <strong>and</strong> crawled back into the tent. Without thinking what he was<br />
doing, Alberto picked him up <strong>and</strong> carried him through the sundrenched<br />
morning along the overgrown logger's path, startling the<br />
wood thrushes <strong>and</strong> orioles in the understory. The day became suffused<br />
with the smell <strong>of</strong> pine needles <strong>and</strong> the sun-warmed earth.<br />
Alberto left Oskar at the road-head under an aspen, lying on his<br />
side in the shade, <strong>and</strong> went back to their campsite. And it was then,<br />
as he retraced his steps <strong>and</strong> gathered up the two packs, stuffing them<br />
with pots <strong>and</strong> pans <strong>and</strong> blankets <strong>and</strong> cans <strong>of</strong> food <strong>and</strong> their loaf <strong>of</strong><br />
bread <strong>and</strong> wax paper-wrapped cheese <strong>and</strong> clothes <strong>and</strong> Oskar's diary<br />
- then carrying everything, sweating in the bright, unfiltered light,<br />
that he learned that time was liquid; that it runs in a great rushing<br />
forward that sometimes gets diverted into pools that swirl in endless<br />
circles. That a person can spend his lifetime, caught, floating in a<br />
moment. By the time they got to Toronto, to the Royal Eglinton hospital,<br />
Oskar couldn't speak from the chattering <strong>of</strong> his teeth.<br />
Alberto sat in the hospital with Oskar. The influenza ward was<br />
long <strong>and</strong> full <strong>of</strong> muted sunlight, quiet except for the padding <strong>of</strong> wool<br />
felt slippers on the rubber-tiled floor, <strong>and</strong> the coughs <strong>and</strong> moans <strong>of</strong><br />
febrile men. For the three days before Oskar died, Alberto was overwhelmed<br />
by his friend's raging fever. It seeped into Alberto <strong>and</strong><br />
exploded in his mind until everything was clouded. A pretty Scottish<br />
nurse came <strong>and</strong> wiped Tiklowicz down with ice water. She wiped his<br />
thin body with a flannel, carefully tracing his bony knees <strong>and</strong> hips,<br />
the hollow <strong>of</strong> his collarbone. Oskar was flushed deep red, his skin<br />
raised in goose pimples.<br />
On the dawn <strong>of</strong> the third day that Oskar was in the hospital, it<br />
began to rain. Alberto watched the rain drip down the windowpane<br />
all day. He thought <strong>of</strong> his mother, the H<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> Fathma around her<br />
neck, her beautiful brown eyes wet <strong>and</strong> round watching him, sending<br />
him away forever as he stood on the crowded deck <strong>of</strong> the steamship<br />
next to his sister, Mila. In the early evening, just as the rain stopped<br />
<strong>and</strong> the sky above Toronto turned orange <strong>and</strong> pink <strong>and</strong> red from the<br />
sunset, he knew that Oskar was about to die; he knew it with as<br />
much certainty as if it had already happened <strong>and</strong> he were remembering<br />
it. He bent next to Oskar's hot, flushed face, breathed in his sour<br />
fever <strong>and</strong> kissed his cheek "Oskar," he said, <strong>and</strong> then quickly, without<br />
thinking, he whispered into his ear, "don't worry, I'll stay here<br />
with you. I won't go back I won't ever go back" III<br />
Tllr IInnrn nllllni IInlF'\lUn nnllnlU\f
y Allen<br />
Grossman<br />
Winter at the Sea Shore<br />
"Nightfall.<br />
Journey's end.<br />
Having come this far,<br />
we are at the shore.<br />
Look up. Over there!<br />
That high tower<br />
is mind.<br />
Look down.<br />
This world below us<br />
is a furious coast.<br />
Think back over<br />
the straightening<br />
<strong>of</strong> the seasons. Remember!<br />
Sowing, then burgeoning,<br />
then seed-fall. And now<br />
this harvest:<br />
winter<br />
wheat."<br />
"Allen, what is that flail<br />
on your shoulder?<br />
What is it for?"<br />
"It's the oar<br />
that brought us<br />
to this night<br />
<strong>and</strong> furious coast<br />
among winds."<br />
"Look! The high tower<br />
strews signals.<br />
Listen! Zeus, the counsellor,<br />
decrees snow."
(Clticago/ 19£8)<br />
Timor Mortis Inc" ASwitchboard Memory<br />
The business plan <strong>of</strong> Timor Mortis, Inc.<br />
required reconstruction <strong>of</strong> its switchboard.<br />
As soon as it was cOlnpleted, Beatrice<br />
appeared from her grave to man a position.<br />
Outgoing - from below, local- requires<br />
that she reach down, pull up a plug, <strong>and</strong> then<br />
throw the plug into a socket above<br />
her head, so that she can say to anyone,<br />
with a nUlnber, a long way <strong>of</strong>f: "It's time."<br />
Incoming - from above, afar - requires<br />
that she reach up above her head, grab a<br />
plug, <strong>and</strong> throw it into a socket with<br />
the corresponding number beneath her knees.<br />
"Somebody is calling, calling, calling, calling..."
y Peter<br />
Trachtenberg<br />
5 0 m e<br />
f e a 5 t<br />
from The Book<br />
<strong>of</strong> Calamities<br />
e'd heard the announcement on the radio that people<br />
weren't allowed to leave their homes, <strong>and</strong> we thought,<br />
okay, no problem. We heard gunshots around the<br />
neighborhood. We heard yelling. The house was<br />
surrounded by soldiers. I saw the comm<strong>and</strong>ing <strong>of</strong>ficer,<br />
he was one <strong>of</strong> our neighbors. He beat down the door.<br />
He said, lIyou, K. II - my husb<strong>and</strong>'s name was K. - IIWhat are you<br />
doing here when everybody else is outside being checked by security?<br />
Come out with your identity card." My husb<strong>and</strong> went outside with his<br />
card, <strong>and</strong> then from April 7th till the 14th they held him at the roadblock,<br />
right nearby. So he would have seen them torturing other men <strong>and</strong> young<br />
people, young boys. They cut <strong>of</strong>f men's genitals <strong>and</strong> fed them to the dogs.<br />
They hacked people to death with machetes. He watched all <strong>of</strong> it. And at<br />
two or three one morning, it was his misfortune to be tortured, too. He<br />
died on the 15th, very early in the morning.<br />
Not "he was killed," but "he died." Rw<strong>and</strong>ans <strong>of</strong>ten used that<br />
innocuous phrase when speaking <strong>of</strong> loved ones they'd lost in the<br />
genocide. I took it for an attempt at normalization. During World<br />
War II, the Nazis had committed most <strong>of</strong> their crimes away from<br />
eyewitnesses, herding their victims to remote killing grounds or<br />
sequestering them in death camps whose function was betrayed<br />
only by the pillars <strong>of</strong> smoke that rose from their chimneys.<br />
Afterwards it was possible - if not particularly credible - for<br />
people to say they hadn't known. In Rw<strong>and</strong>a, though, the killing<br />
took place in public. Everybody saw it. All you had to do was look<br />
out through your garden gate. All over Kigali, bodies lay piled on<br />
the roadside like sacks <strong>of</strong> refuse until they were picked up by<br />
garbage trucks. Hutu <strong>of</strong>fice girls in white dresses picked their way<br />
to work between spreading puddles <strong>of</strong> blood. General Romeo<br />
Dallaire describes seeing one such girl slip <strong>and</strong> fall. She got up<br />
quickly, but still, he writes, "it was as if someone had painted her<br />
body <strong>and</strong> her dress with a dark red oil. She became hysterical looking<br />
at it, <strong>and</strong> the more she screamed, the more attention she drew." I<br />
What need was there for anyone to be more explicit? I hadn't been<br />
in Rw<strong>and</strong>a long before I was taking it for granted that when anyone<br />
spoke <strong>of</strong> a death ten years before, he meant a death by violence.<br />
Murder had become a natural death.<br />
On the 18th, at nine in the morning, a group <strong>of</strong> soldiers <strong>and</strong> militiamen<br />
came to my house. They told me, IIGive us the money your husb<strong>and</strong> left<br />
you. 1I<br />
My husb<strong>and</strong>'s body was being dragged through the street, no one had<br />
buried him. They formed mountains, the bodies <strong>of</strong> all the men <strong>and</strong> boys<br />
they'd killed. And I said, III don't have any money. We don't have any<br />
money." They carried me from the living room <strong>and</strong> took me into a bedroom;<br />
my mother-in-law was shut up in another room. And from that day until<br />
the end <strong>of</strong> the war, the soldiers raped me. They were at it day <strong>and</strong> night, day<br />
<strong>and</strong> night, all <strong>of</strong> them. They came in all together, they dropped their pants at<br />
the same moment, <strong>and</strong> they raped me, jostling each other. There was always<br />
another group waiting in the living room. If one man left, another one came<br />
in to take his place, one after another. In the fifth month <strong>of</strong> my pregnancy, I<br />
aborted. They took me to the hospital for the abortion, <strong>and</strong> they told me, "We<br />
killed your brothers <strong>and</strong> sisters with machetes, but you, we're just going to<br />
rape you till you're dead." That whole time I was naked, I never had clothes<br />
on. I was completely swollen. I had infections, I kept vomiting. I couldn't<br />
even cry because I wanted to die <strong>and</strong> I couldn't die.<br />
In the midst <strong>of</strong> violence, especially if that violence is prolonged, a<br />
relationship sometimes forms between perpetrators <strong>and</strong> victims. It is<br />
not a true relationship, in the sense <strong>of</strong> something freely chosen, only<br />
the simulacrum <strong>of</strong> one or, more accurately, a parody. It may come<br />
into being because the victims implicitly underst<strong>and</strong> that their survival<br />
depends on winning the good-will <strong>of</strong> their captors or because<br />
even killers - maybe especially killers - need to feel that they are<br />
good people <strong>and</strong> will seek validation <strong>of</strong> their goodness from the very<br />
ones they are about to kill. It may simply be that when human<br />
beings are forced together, over time, they fall by inertia into the<br />
lulling rhythms <strong>and</strong> protocols <strong>of</strong> society. For such reasons, a group <strong>of</strong>
soldiers <strong>and</strong> militiamen might interrupt months <strong>of</strong> rape <strong>and</strong> sexual<br />
torture to take their victim to the hospital for an abortion <strong>of</strong> her<br />
husb<strong>and</strong>'s child. It's startling to realize that at the height <strong>of</strong> the<br />
genocide Rw<strong>and</strong>a's hospitals were still functioning, treating old<br />
people with pneumonia, children with broken arms. And, <strong>of</strong> course,<br />
delivering babies.<br />
What was the meaning <strong>of</strong> that gesture? On one level, the abortion<br />
was a continuation <strong>of</strong> the violence these men were inflicting on their<br />
captive, an intensification <strong>of</strong> it, a rape committed in the deepest<br />
parts <strong>of</strong> her body. As a Catholic, the woman would experience it as a<br />
murder <strong>of</strong> the life within her, <strong>of</strong> her husb<strong>and</strong>'s life, because it was<br />
his baby they were killing; they were killing him all over again. And<br />
at the same time, she would know that she was being spared, since<br />
it wasn't uncommon for genocidaires to terminate the pregnancies <strong>of</strong><br />
Tutsi women by cutting them open <strong>and</strong> ripping their unborn babies<br />
from their wombs. And so, at some point in the procedure, perhaps<br />
only for a moment, she might feel a trelnor <strong>of</strong> gratitude, <strong>and</strong> in recollection<br />
this gratitude would be the most terrible thing <strong>of</strong> all.<br />
If I go before the court, if I tell them what happened, ifI say what was<br />
done to my body, people will mock me. All I want to say is that they made<br />
me suffer. I want to tell the story <strong>of</strong> my suffering. And I want the one who<br />
raped me to underst<strong>and</strong> that he tortured me, that he's guilty. I want him to<br />
underst<strong>and</strong> what he did - freely, without being forced - I want him to<br />
admit his blame.<br />
The woman who told me this story was named Athanasie M. She<br />
was 45, with a h<strong>and</strong>some oval face that had begun to s<strong>of</strong>ten with<br />
age <strong>and</strong> very large dark eyes that looked even larger because <strong>of</strong> the<br />
dark circles beneath them. The whole time she spoke she held my<br />
eyes with hers. Once she had been a girl on one <strong>of</strong> the thous<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong><br />
haystack-shaped hills that make up the Rw<strong>and</strong>an l<strong>and</strong>scape <br />
Rw<strong>and</strong>a, pays des milles collines - destined for a life <strong>of</strong> farming beans<br />
<strong>and</strong> sorghum. Against all expectations she had gotten an education<br />
<strong>and</strong> become a gym teacher at a polytechnic in Kigali. She had married,<br />
borne children. And then the life she had won for herself had<br />
been torn asunder <strong>and</strong> she had been turned into a sort <strong>of</strong> domestic<br />
animal, naked <strong>and</strong> speechless, kept alive only to be abused until it<br />
would be time to kill her. It seemed a miracle that she could speak.<br />
But she could write; she had a journal that she had written about her<br />
ordeal. "Each page," she said, "is a thous<strong>and</strong> tears." Now Athanasie<br />
worked at a women's center counseling other survivors <strong>of</strong> rape <strong>and</strong><br />
sexual torture, many <strong>of</strong> whom were sick with AIDS. In this regard,<br />
she considered herself fortunate. As a result <strong>of</strong> what had been done<br />
to her she could no longer perform any kind <strong>of</strong> physical labor, not<br />
even sweep a floor, but she didn't have the virus <strong>and</strong> could look forward<br />
to a long life. Perhaps it's better to say that she could anticipate<br />
a normal lifespan, which for a Rw<strong>and</strong>an woman in 2002 was<br />
46.8 years. 2<br />
I had been recommended to Athanasie by someone in the<br />
States, <strong>and</strong> when our interview was over she told me, "When you see<br />
David, you must remember to tell him how fat I've gotten." The<br />
pride in her voice took me aback until I remembered the possible<br />
connotations <strong>of</strong> thinness.<br />
The clinic was a complex <strong>of</strong> low grey cinderblock buildings decorated<br />
inside with the drawings <strong>of</strong> the clients <strong>and</strong> their children, crude<br />
productions <strong>of</strong> crayon, glitter <strong>and</strong> con- ..<br />
struction paper mounted on the walls<br />
with yellowing tape. When I left, a group<br />
<strong>of</strong> women was dancing in the earth yard.<br />
They were welcoming some visitors from<br />
a Canadian aid organization. The dancers'<br />
movements were fierce, strutting; they<br />
held their arms out from their sides, their<br />
fingers splayed <strong>and</strong> quivering, <strong>and</strong> lifted<br />
their knees high, like wading birds.<br />
Drums sounded. The women dipped,<br />
took a step forward, a step to the side, a<br />
step back, each pent inside her square <strong>of</strong><br />
an invisible grid drawn on the red earth.<br />
Some <strong>of</strong> theln looked quite old, their faces<br />
seamed, their eyes dim. Their limbs might<br />
have been made <strong>of</strong> twisted rope. One<br />
woman had only one leg, on which she<br />
The women<br />
dipped, took a<br />
step to the side,<br />
astep back, each<br />
pent inside her<br />
square <strong>of</strong> an<br />
invisible grid<br />
drawn on the<br />
red earth.<br />
hopped unceasingly, as if trying to pound a stake into :he ground. Up<br />
<strong>and</strong> down she leapt, grinning <strong>and</strong> triumphant <strong>and</strong> ternble. I suppose<br />
she was trying to proclaim victory over her disfigurement, but to me<br />
she seemed like a reproach to the world <strong>of</strong> the whole.<br />
A few weeks earlier, at a cocktail party at the American Club in<br />
Kigali, I'd been introduced to a man who worked for a Christian<br />
conflict-management organization. He was running reconciliation<br />
workshops. Reconciliation was a word you heard a great deal in<br />
Rw<strong>and</strong>a. You heard it from government <strong>of</strong>ficials, including elnployees<br />
<strong>of</strong> the eponymous Unity <strong>and</strong> Reconciliation Commission, <strong>and</strong> the<br />
spokespersons <strong>of</strong> victims' groups, from ex-detenus, perpetrato:s who<br />
had served their time in prison, <strong>and</strong>, more rarely, from rescapes, the
itself," Athanasie told me. "True justice."<br />
I thought I understood this, <strong>and</strong> not just because what had happened<br />
here suggested a Platonic archetype <strong>of</strong> injustice, a crime so<br />
immense as to make any response to it seeIn pathetically, even<br />
insultingly, inadequate. (Hannah Arendt was speaking <strong>of</strong> genocide<br />
when she said that we "are unable to forgive what [we] cannot punish<br />
[<strong>and</strong>] we are unable to punish what has turned out to be unforgivable.")4<br />
In the hierarchy <strong>of</strong> human needs, justice may be only a<br />
tier below shelter or mother-love. Maybe it represents father-love, a<br />
love that, unlike the magnanimous, blanketing kind mothers are<br />
supposed to give us, is based on distinctions, boundaries, equivalency,<br />
one thing for another. One symbol for such love is a staff,<br />
which leads some people to think <strong>of</strong> it as merely punitive. But a<br />
staff is also used for pointing. Human justice, in Biiber's formulation,<br />
is each person getting what he deserves, while divine justice is<br />
each person getting what he is. By this formulation, divine justice<br />
began on the first day <strong>of</strong> creation, when God parted the heavens<br />
from the earth. When He cast Eve <strong>and</strong> Adam out <strong>of</strong> paradise, He<br />
wasn't punishing an act so much as decreeing that this, henceforth,<br />
was what it would mean to be human - that is, mortal, homeless,<br />
<strong>and</strong> ashamed.<br />
Human justice is human: it applies to relations between human<br />
beings or between human beings <strong>and</strong> the man-made artifact <strong>of</strong> the<br />
State. The afflictions sent by God or nature don't trouble us the<br />
same way wrongs committed by other people do. The very word<br />
"wrongs" is indicative, since it isn't used <strong>of</strong> nature. A tidal wave<br />
may kill a quarter <strong>of</strong> a million people <strong>and</strong> a man with a knife only<br />
one, yet it's the murderer who inspires not just horror but outrage<br />
<strong>and</strong> it's the murderer we seek to punish. King Xerxes flogging the<br />
sea is only an image <strong>of</strong> the folly <strong>of</strong> power. I do not think this difference<br />
stems solely from the human capacity for malice. Eichmann<br />
appears to have sent millions to the gas chambers without feeling<br />
much <strong>of</strong> it. Men know that God <strong>and</strong> nature are bigger <strong>and</strong> more<br />
powerful than they are (though in our time, this knowledge may be<br />
fading), but we think <strong>of</strong> other men as our equals, not in the social,<br />
but the creaturely sense, as beings moved by the same desires <strong>and</strong><br />
aversions as ourselves <strong>and</strong> subject to the same laws <strong>of</strong> pain <strong>and</strong><br />
death. Every crime shatters this equality. When one man kills<br />
another man, he declares that he is big <strong>and</strong> the other is small, is<br />
nothing. If the victim's wife <strong>and</strong> children are forced to witness this,<br />
they too are made nothing. When a chemical plant discharges poison<br />
gas that wipes out a village, all its people are made nothing <strong>and</strong><br />
their annihilation is compounded when the <strong>of</strong>ficers <strong>of</strong> the chemical<br />
company are allowed to live on without consequence. Among the<br />
things I heard during my time in Rw<strong>and</strong>a, one <strong>of</strong> the most painful<br />
was uttered almost incidentally by a rescapee after I asked her if she<br />
believed Tutsi <strong>and</strong> Hutu could ever truly be reconciled. "It is impossible,"<br />
she began, <strong>and</strong> I think she meant to explain, methodically,<br />
impersonally, why this should be so. But suddenly she clutched her<br />
head <strong>and</strong> blurted, "l'etais tres abaissee." I<br />
would translate it as "1 was so degrad<br />
ed" or "abased," except the French<br />
more clearly expresses the idea <strong>of</strong> being<br />
lowered. At that moment everything that<br />
had been done to this woman snapped<br />
into focus with such clarity that I could<br />
no more st<strong>and</strong> to look at her directly<br />
than if she had been the sun.<br />
From the state's perspective, justice<br />
has multiple functions, froIn ensuring<br />
that the criminal cannot harm others to<br />
deterring future wrongdoers. To victilns<br />
<strong>of</strong> crime, however, or to their survivors,<br />
the purpose <strong>of</strong> justice is to restore the<br />
Thous<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> Tutsi<br />
women were dying<br />
<strong>of</strong> AIOS, which the<br />
rape squads had<br />
deployed as a<br />
weapon <strong>of</strong> delayed<br />
biological warfare.<br />
equality between themselves <strong>and</strong> the persons who wronged them. s<br />
That this equality is spiritual is evident from the fact that it may be<br />
restored even to the dead. It's precisely when justice is denied that<br />
people most long for it, even if they can only ilnagine the world in<br />
which it exists. Hell was invented because on earth men commit<br />
crime after crime <strong>and</strong> grow fat while their victims' children go hungry.<br />
And perhaps the belief in hell - hell even more than heaven <br />
was enough to console entire nations during the thous<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> years<br />
in which they suffered at the h<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> others without redress, without<br />
even the acknowledgment that a wrong had been done to theIn.<br />
Personally, I doubt it. And I think that societies that fail to<br />
address the great crimes in their past remain blighted by them. The<br />
long backwardness <strong>and</strong> impoverishment <strong>and</strong> brutality <strong>of</strong> the<br />
AInerican South, conditions that afflicted whites as well as blacks,<br />
must have had something to do with the unburied corpse <strong>of</strong> slavery,<br />
a corpse that wasn't a corpse at all because in some ways it was still<br />
alive, the haint at the crossroads, the hellhound on everybody's<br />
trail. Russia may have emerged from the 80-year sleep <strong>of</strong> communism,<br />
but it is still dreaming <strong>of</strong> the crimes that were committed in<br />
communism's name; only in dreams can it name the crimes out
y Mary Zoo<br />
Twin<br />
selected poems<br />
Of all the street's windows, only yours dreams.<br />
Barely twenty the child you were<br />
clitnbed the spiral staircase toward the moon<br />
seeking ocean, its twisting<br />
scorched by moonlight.<br />
You too felt the pull <strong>of</strong> it,<br />
that heavy seed filled with time.<br />
Waves dragged in your ear,<br />
chained, unchained, the slow war<br />
flowing froin some eternal center.<br />
A future waiting to be yours<br />
lay beyond a bridge <strong>of</strong> stars.<br />
You watched them pass,<br />
the long animal shadows <strong>of</strong> youth,<br />
partner to the dancing coin<br />
that rose <strong>and</strong> spun <strong>and</strong> would not fall.<br />
C<strong>and</strong>le<br />
Deep in its mantle,<br />
the arrow that rises<br />
from the cliff<br />
<strong>of</strong> its own cutting<br />
descends through<br />
flesh <strong>and</strong> fat,<br />
climbing the hungry<br />
root whose flame<br />
feeds the round<br />
light that eats<br />
its way up.
mother was an academic over there <strong>and</strong> now works at Nails Nails<br />
Nails. She taught her daughter first-class English. Ziva likes to talk<br />
about the blizzards <strong>of</strong> St. Petersburg, <strong>and</strong> how as a girl she skated<br />
the frozen Neva, ice cocooning the 60 rivers <strong>and</strong> canals. She talks<br />
about 30-below-zero temperatures as she paints tiny stars on inchlong<br />
fingernails. Hannah inherited her mother's love <strong>of</strong> winter. Fat<br />
snow, not the pitiful stringy snow we have here. I remember snow<br />
like that from when I was little little <strong>and</strong> my father carrying me.<br />
"1 hope your father has those maple cookies."<br />
"It's Kim. Remeinber that, Hannah."<br />
Daddy opens the door in a peach-colored satin robe <strong>and</strong> hugs <strong>and</strong><br />
kisses me, the towel around his neck<br />
smelling <strong>of</strong> lavender. "Happy Valentine's<br />
We used to go<br />
to Central Park to<br />
watch the swans<br />
but lately Hannah's<br />
been spending<br />
every minute with<br />
her lipstick.<br />
Day." Then he takes Hannah's h<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong><br />
pulls her inside for a hug. "Happy Cupid<br />
to you too."<br />
At first I don't look at him because I'm<br />
afraid. When he had his chin surgery he<br />
went battered-woman black <strong>and</strong> blue for<br />
weeks <strong>and</strong> when he reduced his Adam's<br />
apple, his voice changed.<br />
"Guys, what's different?" he asks in<br />
his whisper, pivoting for us in the foyer.<br />
His robe clings to his breasts, <strong>and</strong><br />
they're a set <strong>of</strong> perfect tennis balls. He<br />
must have had the gummy bear implants.<br />
He hasn't said anything about mine that finally are budding like the<br />
green tomatoes Mrs. Hertzberg grows in her classroom.<br />
"From the towel around your neck I gather you're about to take a<br />
shower in the afternoon," I say, knowing what he wants me to notice.<br />
"When you lived at home, you took showers in the morning.'.'<br />
He places his h<strong>and</strong>s on his hips. "I'm going to a party tonIght.<br />
Something else has changed."<br />
"You're growing your hair out, Mrs. Cadorine?" Hannah says. She<br />
is smart <strong>and</strong> can blab about Pavlova, Nijinsky, <strong>and</strong> the ballet. But<br />
mostly it's lip liner <strong>and</strong> short or long strokes <strong>and</strong> how to apply<br />
foundation to blend <strong>and</strong> conceal. She's set on becoming a make-up<br />
artist for TV.<br />
"Daddy wants to be called Kiln," I reinind her. "Even Gr<strong>and</strong>ma<br />
calls him that. He's going to a clinic where they sew hair plugs into<br />
your scalp."<br />
"Hair is hard," he says, his mouth losing its smile for an instant.<br />
His hair is strawberry blond <strong>and</strong> long thin wisps <strong>of</strong> it are arranged<br />
over the top <strong>of</strong> his head. Not even estrogen helps, <strong>and</strong> the hair plugs<br />
are a money tar pit. I remember when Daddy lived at home his hair<br />
would fall out <strong>and</strong> stick to the sides <strong>of</strong> the tub like slivery goldfish,<br />
<strong>and</strong> Mommy would laugh. His skin is ultra-smooth from electrolysis.<br />
Hannah told me about the white nights back home where dusk <strong>and</strong><br />
dawn meet in summer skies. That's what Daddy's face reminds me<br />
<strong>of</strong>, or a mute swan whose plumage is gone.<br />
He turns, pulling his robe tighter, sucking in his stomach, raising<br />
his chin. "The results were very pleasing."<br />
"You've grown a chest for the party," I blurt out. "You've had the<br />
gummy bears."<br />
Daddy grins. "That's right, but for more than just the party. For<br />
forever."<br />
"Can we go with you to the party?" Hannah asks.<br />
"Chairman Mao wouldn't want that, Hannah. You know how<br />
Dalloway's mother is. Her brain might appear to be t<strong>of</strong>u <strong>and</strong> eggplant<br />
but she manages to find out everything."<br />
"Oh, please," Hannah begs.<br />
I wonder how many potential customers she thinks she might<br />
meet. Hannah is taking an Internet cosmetology course. This week's<br />
lesson is brow makeover make-up tips. Nothing at Bronx Science<br />
interests her as much. We used to go to Central Park to watch the<br />
swans, but lately Hannah's been spending every minute with her lipsticks.<br />
I used to fill notebooks about migrating birds. The birds are<br />
confused. They don't know summer from winter <strong>and</strong> they're not sure<br />
when to fly. The trees are just as bewildered when green buds appear<br />
in February. I think I'm the only one who's worried about the birds.<br />
"Dalloway <strong>and</strong> parties don't mix," Daddy explains, ushering us<br />
into the dining area where the table is decked out <strong>and</strong> waiting. "It<br />
wouldn't be any fun for you guys. It's an adult Valentine gala."<br />
Daddy shouldn't have said gala, now she will want more than ever to<br />
go. He's practicing his feminization walk: use hips not whole body, foot,<br />
thigh, leg. "Let me show you the dessert course. You can have your own<br />
soiree right here."<br />
Hannah's lips turn down.<br />
"Sounds great to me," 1 say, following Daddy into the dining area.<br />
On the table, maroon napkins are folded like sails <strong>of</strong> yachts, spoons<br />
<strong>and</strong> forks rest against the silver moon <strong>of</strong> the chafing dish, which is<br />
filled with Godiva foil-wrapped Valentines. Fresh cut flowers sprout<br />
from a vase, leaves like red pepper rinds that have been shined.<br />
"Dutch apple <strong>and</strong> strawberry rhubarb pies. Maple cookies with an
inch <strong>of</strong> frosting. This way for main courses <strong>and</strong> appetizers," he<br />
says, whipping open the refrigerator to show <strong>of</strong>f individual tins<br />
from Good-N-Plenty. "Chicken tenders, vegetable pot pies <strong>and</strong><br />
empanadas. You could snack <strong>and</strong> have a movie marathon. I got<br />
three Hitchcocks! Dalloway's favorites."<br />
It would be heaven to sit with a Dutch apple pie between my<br />
knees <strong>and</strong> watch Vertigo, to pick apart the walnuts <strong>and</strong> brown sugar<br />
while Jimmy Stewart hangs by his fingertips from the edge <strong>of</strong> a<br />
building, to crunch pieces <strong>of</strong> crust <strong>and</strong> pluck out syrupy apples as<br />
Kim Novak drifts like humidity at the florists around the peonies<br />
<strong>and</strong> lilies. Hitchcock doesn't show, but suggests, the gnats halfheartedly<br />
circling the blooms. To be back in time with basically a<br />
whole pie <strong>and</strong> no school the next day. What could be better?<br />
I drop my overnight bag <strong>and</strong> go for a fork <strong>and</strong> plate, the glass<br />
ones in the shape <strong>of</strong> sunfish. "Do you want rhubarb or apple,<br />
Hannah?"<br />
"Both," Hannah says.<br />
"Me too." I stab the rhubarb with a pie cutter. "What about you,<br />
Daddy?" I've always loved Daddy's sweet tooth.<br />
"I can't, Dalloway, I have to watch my waist."<br />
"I miss seeing your love h<strong>and</strong>les," I say, balancing a heaping slice<br />
<strong>of</strong> apple pie on the prongs <strong>of</strong> my fork. "Hannah, he used to have a<br />
hula-hoop <strong>of</strong> fat right above his belt <strong>and</strong> when I was a little girl I<br />
grabbed onto it thinking it was his h<strong>and</strong>."<br />
"Hula-hoop, what is that?" she asks.<br />
"It was a plastic hoop that you threw your hips around inside <strong>of</strong>."<br />
"Throw your hips, how?"<br />
Daddy gets himself a glass <strong>of</strong> water from the sink <strong>and</strong> pulls out<br />
a drawer. Both <strong>of</strong> us automatically close in. The drawer is full <strong>of</strong><br />
punch-out pill cards, samples, the kind doctors give away. I pick<br />
up a pill card. Under plastic in neat rows are purplish tablets the<br />
color <strong>of</strong> vitamin B-12. Two <strong>of</strong> them are missing. He snatches the<br />
card back.<br />
"What's all this, Mrs. Cadorine?" Hannah asks.<br />
At first, he doesn't answer. Then he pushes another tablet from<br />
the punch-out card <strong>and</strong> pops it into his mouth. "It's Kim, remember?<br />
These are hormones."<br />
Hannah dislikes drugs. She saw her father make syringes out <strong>of</strong><br />
sewing needles <strong>and</strong> ballpoint pens, inject over-the-counter cough<br />
syrup directly into a muscle. Near the end, her father lived in a<br />
packing box with a mongrel <strong>and</strong> when he begged on the street his<br />
sign read, "Please help me buy food for my dog. ff<br />
Hannah said<br />
Russians love animals much more than people.<br />
Daddy washes down what was in his mouth.<br />
"Are they making you a woman?" I ask.<br />
He nods.<br />
Hannah licks at her new hyper-shine lipstick. The teentastics at<br />
school are leery <strong>of</strong> her, as if one <strong>of</strong> their eyes might go blind if they<br />
hung around her.<br />
Daddy takes another drink <strong>of</strong> water, <strong>and</strong> then holds out the glass<br />
like he's toasting Hannah. "What I wouldn't give to look like you."<br />
"If I can make you look like me will you take us to your party?"<br />
she asks Daddy.<br />
I want to kick her.<br />
A smile spreads across his face. "Let me think about it while I<br />
shower," he says, heading toward the bathroom. "Dalloway, go check<br />
out the guest room. There's another surprise."<br />
In the spare bedroom Daddy has his roll-top desk, his kite <strong>and</strong><br />
windsock collection, all his research <strong>and</strong> development orange juice<br />
containers, his hydroponics files, <strong>and</strong> now he's set up the igloo tent.<br />
Inside are maroon sleeping bags, <strong>and</strong> on each pillow is a package<br />
wrapped in shiny red paper <strong>and</strong> tied with silver ribbon. I feel tears<br />
growing in my eyes like weeds. I crawl into the tent <strong>and</strong> fetch the<br />
packages. "Here, Hannah, this one's for you." I rip mine open, but<br />
Hannah uses her fingernail to loosen the tape making sure she doesn't<br />
tear the paper.<br />
"This is beautiful," she says, holding up the cowhide shoulder bag,<br />
petting the swirls <strong>of</strong> brown <strong>and</strong> cream-colored hair.<br />
"I hope no anhnal had to die to make that stupid purse," I say,<br />
peering inside. "Hey, there's a $50 bill <strong>and</strong> a key. I bet it's the key to<br />
this apartment." I stuff the fifty <strong>and</strong> key into the pocket <strong>of</strong> my jacket,<br />
throwing the purse on top my day pack.<br />
"Dalloway, I got a $50 bill too. I can't believe it."<br />
"But no key?" I ask with a catch in my throat. I'm the daughter.<br />
"No key." Then she folds the foil gift wrap <strong>and</strong> slips it inside the<br />
purse, a solemn expression on her face like she's thinking <strong>of</strong> her<br />
father who is buried in Russia.<br />
I sit at the roll-top, tugging out the drawers. The bottom drawer is<br />
hard to pull, <strong>and</strong> no wonder - it's filled with envelopes, the flowerprinted<br />
stationery kind, not the business ones. There must be hundreds<br />
<strong>of</strong> love letters. Hannah grabs Vogue from the entertainlnent shelf <strong>and</strong><br />
plops into the beanbag chair. I lift a packet <strong>of</strong> envelopes, smelling<br />
perfume. Letter after letter I slip under my nose like a fading drug
paintings. Hannah <strong>of</strong>fers to do his makeup <strong>and</strong> we crowd into the<br />
bathroom. Daddy hauls in an ice chest filled with makeup, at least<br />
five <strong>of</strong> everything. Gloss sticks. Pressed powders. Concealers.<br />
Brushes. On the sink is a head wearing a wig <strong>of</strong> s<strong>of</strong>t curls past the<br />
shoulders, the color <strong>of</strong> late August cornhusks. "It's called the<br />
Challay blond," he says, pulling it on. Then he sits on the toilet seat.<br />
I'm frightened. He's almost pretty.<br />
"First, Kiln, we start with the moisturizer." Hannah finds a triangular<br />
sponge <strong>and</strong> dots his cheeks <strong>and</strong> chin. There used to be<br />
hair there <strong>and</strong> when Daddy kissed me goodnight I felt his bristles.<br />
Then she presses the sponge <strong>and</strong> begins to connect the dots.<br />
"Blend upwards, under the eyebrow, <strong>and</strong> an inch below the jawline<br />
<strong>and</strong> chin. That's something not everyone knows. To mature<br />
eye skin we don't apply foundation." She bites her lip because<br />
she's concentrating.<br />
"Looks, what are looks?" Hannah blurts out suddenly, pressing<br />
foundation over Daddy's lips. "Who cares? My father was h<strong>and</strong>some<br />
but when he died <strong>and</strong> his h<strong>and</strong> turned cold, I dropped it." She<br />
picks up the lipstick pencil. "On the lower lip work from the center<br />
to the corners. Now blot."<br />
II II<br />
When a cab stops, Hannah <strong>and</strong> Daddy sit in back <strong>and</strong> I take the<br />
seat in front. I stare hard out the window as 10th Avenue flies by,<br />
the Yemenite delis <strong>and</strong> Chinese takeouts, the Puerto Rican auto<br />
repairs <strong>and</strong> the boarded-up public library, a worn-out stretch before<br />
the Starbucks <strong>of</strong> Amsterdam Avenue. At a stoplight, a turbaned<br />
woman kneels before a chain fence pushing a plate under it, <strong>and</strong><br />
then pulling the plate out, <strong>and</strong> then pushing it back. I haven't said<br />
anything to Daddy or Hannah about California, not a word about<br />
the jobs Mommy has applied for or how she goes online every<br />
morning to find out the temperature in San Francisco <strong>and</strong> input it<br />
into a spreadsheet.<br />
The cab driver keeps looking into the rearview mirror to admire<br />
the two lovelies.<br />
"Left side, near corner," Daddy points to 78th Street.<br />
The building rises from a canyon <strong>of</strong> dirty brownstone.<br />
Daddy taps my shoulder. "Don't be shy, guys. Remember to<br />
smile."<br />
The lobby floor is polished marble, <strong>and</strong> on the walls <strong>Art</strong> Deco<br />
mirrors hang alongside a reproduction <strong>of</strong> Warhol's Chairman<br />
Mao. "There's your mother, Dalloway."<br />
"He was a pig/' Hannah growls. "When he croaked his people<br />
said God has died. Can you believe that?" She has her new purse<br />
stuffed with business cards. Some say Hot. Extreme. Make-up <strong>Art</strong>istry<br />
Call Hannah. To See Your Wrinkles Disappear Make Appointment with the<br />
Tchaikovsky <strong>of</strong> Makeover. Beautiful Brides: Your House or Mine.<br />
Daddy ushers us by the security guard who checks his list for the<br />
name Cadorine. "The penthouse elevator's in back." He gives Daddy<br />
an approving once over, <strong>and</strong> then his eye slides onto Hannah who<br />
floats past him like a cloud in black jeans <strong>and</strong> a blouse with seethrough<br />
sleeves. I have on the same outfit but it fits me differently.<br />
The elevator makes me feel I'm inside a jewelry box where the French<br />
perfumes are fighting. The doors slap open, <strong>and</strong> we step out into a<br />
sunken living room filled with people. "Kim," someone says. I recognize<br />
Dr. Peeler, Daddy's therapist, rushing toward us. It was her<br />
beach house where the fiasco happened.<br />
"That's her," I whisper to Hannah, who is already digging in her<br />
purse. "That's Dr. Peeler."<br />
Daddy gives Dr. Peeler a kiss <strong>and</strong> squeezes her h<strong>and</strong>. Her pixie<br />
face shines so that I wonder if she applied floor polish instead <strong>of</strong><br />
moisturizer. "Ah, Dalloway, I'm so glad to see you," she greets me,<br />
her nostrils quivering as if she's sniffing the burning bathroom. "Is<br />
this your Russian friend? Why she's lovely." When she turns toward<br />
us, so does her perfume, a bouquet <strong>of</strong> stale meadow flowers.<br />
Hannah has a card ready. Bridal Parties to Headshots. Futurist Full<br />
Treatment Make-up. Dr. Peeler examines the business card, <strong>and</strong> then<br />
asks for a h<strong>and</strong>ful. I don't know where to put my eyes. "Hannah,<br />
please don't leave me. I don't want to st<strong>and</strong> alone," I say but I don't<br />
know whether she hears me or not.<br />
Then Dr. Peeler has Hannah by one h<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> Daddy by the<br />
other, <strong>and</strong> is pulling them away. Madonna is singing "Lucky Star"in<br />
a voice like a white trout being gutted. It is an old people party, the<br />
music proves it.<br />
"Nice blouse," says a man shorter than me with a wispy mustache.<br />
He taps his cigarette on his watch, <strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong>fers me a Pall Mall. "You<br />
don't have to inhale," he advises. "We can st<strong>and</strong> next to a window."<br />
"Ish," I tell him. I guess he figures if I'm taller than him I'm old<br />
enough to smoke. He apologizes <strong>and</strong> then tries to light his cigarette<br />
before he puts it to his lips.<br />
Hannah <strong>and</strong> Daddy <strong>and</strong> Dr. Peeler are sitting on the piano bench.<br />
In the middle <strong>of</strong> the room a red-bearded man with horn-rimmed<br />
glasses is pontificating. He holds a plate piled high with desserts.<br />
liThe bottom line is... women are the phil<strong>and</strong>erers, not men," he
a bird had dropped it there, feels like walking into a heated house.<br />
"You've been drinking," she snaps. "Stupid."<br />
"Tardmuffin."<br />
"You sound like thein. Nothing is worse," Hannah accuses.<br />
"Do you really think sounding like the kids at school is worse<br />
than dancing with that ding-head red-beard?"<br />
"By a technochasm. By ten shades <strong>of</strong> termite."<br />
"Okay, diggity dank," I say.<br />
"Where are we going?" she asks.<br />
"Central Park"<br />
"The duck pond?"<br />
"Yeah, the sooner the quicker."<br />
"All the swans <strong>and</strong> ducks are roosting, Dalloway."<br />
"Doesn't matter."<br />
At Trump Plaza, a blonde in a skimpy dress sways like Red Sea<br />
hair coral. Guests slip out <strong>of</strong> the hotel <strong>and</strong> into silk limousines. Some<br />
clamber into carriages. There are more horses in their pitiful blinders,<br />
survivors <strong>of</strong> a magnificent line kidnapped from the grass. A carriage<br />
driver holding a six-foot switch cries, "Twenty bucks for a romantic<br />
tour <strong>of</strong> Central Park," <strong>and</strong> a girl <strong>and</strong> boy climb into his carriage.<br />
Hannah hurries to h<strong>and</strong> the couple one <strong>of</strong><br />
her business cards. Hannah, we should<br />
I think he <strong>and</strong><br />
Dr. Peeler like each<br />
other. That makes<br />
Daddy alesbian I<br />
free the horse. She's far away giving out<br />
her card, Prime FX Lip, to a girl with a man<br />
at least twice her age.<br />
"Come on, come on," I call out.<br />
The couple has settled into their seat,<br />
<strong>and</strong> the carriage driver lifts the reins. The<br />
white horse struggles over the cobblestone<br />
street. Hannah's false eye reminds<br />
me <strong>of</strong> the horse's blinders. Do the hours <strong>of</strong> pulling the carriage pass<br />
slowly for the horse? You can hear the answer in its step, one clop<br />
<strong>and</strong> a hesitation, <strong>and</strong> then another clop. We follow the carriage into<br />
the park, but the horse is picking up speed. It must smell the trees<br />
<strong>and</strong> think there's rest here.<br />
"Run," I shout. "We have to catch up."<br />
"Dalloway, stop. We'll go to the pond, <strong>and</strong> then home. If we get<br />
into trouble, your mother will never let you see Kim again."<br />
If Mommy has her way I won't see Hannah much longer either.<br />
There's mist in the trees <strong>and</strong> homeless men huddle next to each<br />
other on stone benches. The streetlight throws smeary images <strong>of</strong><br />
their faces on the wet pathway. I almost don't see them because<br />
they're always there. Like the static you used to hear between TV<br />
channels. One <strong>of</strong> them wears a hooded sweatshirt <strong>and</strong> Kleenex boxes<br />
on his feet. I reach for Hannah's arm. She <strong>of</strong>fers me her jacket, but I<br />
tell her no. Is she talking as we walk deeper into the park? I can't be<br />
sure that I'm not hearing her thoughts. This, Dalloway, this misery is<br />
what St. Petersburg feels like. They're sprucing up the palaces but<br />
the city was built on a swamp by force, stone by stone, <strong>and</strong> workers<br />
died like flies. It's still there, all the hell.<br />
"I told Kim we'd take a cab," Hannah says. "I promised we'd go<br />
straight home."<br />
"I think he <strong>and</strong> Dr. Peeler like each other. That makes Daddy a lesbian."<br />
"Big deal."<br />
"Did I say it was? Let's go over there."<br />
We plop down near the pond <strong>and</strong> wait for the swans. On the next<br />
bench, a man sits in a flak jacket without an umbrella or hat. A grocery<br />
cart filled with folded newspapers <strong>and</strong> Duane Reade sacks is<br />
parked near him. I nudge Hannah. "That guy is sitting up so straight<br />
he looks made out <strong>of</strong> stone."<br />
Hannah shrugs. Rain is beginning to fall harder, the skinny drops<br />
getting fat. I rest my head on her shoulder, <strong>and</strong> then she takes <strong>of</strong>f her<br />
jacket <strong>and</strong> covers me with it. "See, stupid, I told you swans sleep in<br />
their nests at night. The only ones that swim in moonlight are the swan<br />
maidens. When they take <strong>of</strong>f their feather shirts the birds becOIne<br />
beautiful women." She spreads her hair behind her so the rain can soak<br />
it. "You brought us on a wild goose chase."<br />
I study the brown surface <strong>of</strong> the pond. Empty. Then I close my<br />
eyes <strong>and</strong> concentrate on making two graceful shapes appear, I think<br />
swans, their necks together, talking in whistles. When I open myeyes<br />
the water is still naked. The man in the flak jacket hasn't moved.<br />
"I think that man is dead," I say.<br />
Hannah snorts, "Dead drunk"<br />
"Bet."<br />
"Five dollars."<br />
Hannah gets up <strong>and</strong> goes over to the man. "Hello? Would you like<br />
a facial?" she asks, a hank <strong>of</strong> her hair falling against him, "I'll show<br />
you, Dalloway. One touch <strong>and</strong> he'll grunt <strong>and</strong> maybe even wakeup.<br />
Then you'll owe me five U.s. dollars." Her fingertips touch his cheek<br />
like she is applying dots <strong>of</strong> foundation. "Oh, no," she whispers. Rings<br />
<strong>of</strong> moisture drop from the streetlight over her shining head. "Come<br />
here, Dalloway. Come," she says, quivering. "Give me your h<strong>and</strong>."<br />
I let her press my h<strong>and</strong> against his cheek Her fingers stay wann<br />
on top <strong>of</strong> mine, while under them the chill spreads. "Do you feel it?"
New Year's Day: Looking for aSign<br />
From the vast blue bouillon burning a dome over us<br />
to the ice petals in their miniscule exactitude - Inillions<br />
on the twiggy branches <strong>of</strong> every bush -<br />
or the tiny frost-ferns printing the bedroom window;<br />
from the high wavering call <strong>of</strong> the geese getting the stormy message<br />
<strong>and</strong> moving south<br />
to the friendly bark <strong>of</strong> the dog with one white husky eye<br />
stopping to lick my h<strong>and</strong> when I stop at the sun-dial;<br />
from the big infinities to all slJch local color<br />
I'm clawing about with my eyes<br />
to find the right sign - steam<br />
<strong>of</strong>f the frozen stream, tabula rasa after a night <strong>of</strong> snow -<br />
but nothing will serve:<br />
not even the cries <strong>of</strong> marsh hawk <strong>and</strong> kingfisher<br />
as hunger keeps gnawing them <strong>and</strong> they look down<br />
on only the white world frozen below;<br />
<strong>and</strong> not my own black cashmere cap when it starts running blood<br />
staining my forehead like a Kashmiri Sikh,<br />
nor the ladybird on my window come out to test<br />
the New Year light - who scales on six mini-legs<br />
a mile <strong>of</strong> glass <strong>and</strong> is for a moment falling back illuminated.<br />
Morning under Muckish<br />
Between rain <strong>and</strong> shine a kestrel stretches on the wind,<br />
flapping fast <strong>and</strong> casual to stay still. Assassin. Negotiator<br />
<strong>of</strong> gales. Cows lie in the lea <strong>of</strong> a hedge <strong>of</strong> honeysuckle.<br />
Tall phlox nod in a sea-breeze. A sudden wood pigeon<br />
rises from the green grave <strong>of</strong> a potato field - its language<br />
clapclapclap - vanishing. Two ash trees huddle frOln rain,<br />
trunks <strong>and</strong> branches hugging one another. A loopy line<br />
<strong>of</strong> wet washing limply dangles: quotidian brilliance<br />
<strong>of</strong> shirts, towels, flashy underwear. A stroppy dark dog<br />
harries my heels <strong>and</strong> a hidden voice calls Mungo!<br />
Mungo! And one almost ripe blackberry in a bushful<br />
<strong>of</strong> bitterness, its onyx eye winking. Margins<br />
where meadowsweet meets loosestrife. A thorn tree<br />
putting on new leaves. Trekking clouds. Empty hills.
What Shadows<br />
Needles <strong>of</strong> rain. Ground makes no moan.<br />
Sigh <strong>of</strong> wind in the sycamore. What's passing.<br />
Haw berries rusting the hawthorn trees.<br />
Don't look back. Think Orpheus. Pillar <strong>of</strong> salt.<br />
One breath, then another. Sweat <strong>of</strong> apprehension.<br />
Still life with wind <strong>and</strong> breadcrulnbs.<br />
But I keep wanting to turn around.<br />
No whimsy in it, running the gamut<br />
bright red. And as deadly, she said, as nightshade.<br />
Still I went on. Looking at her lips.<br />
Sea verge to cliff edge, no shaking <strong>of</strong>f<br />
what shadows me.<br />
After seeing the rain-swollen torrent at Gurteen,<br />
I dream I want to give myself over<br />
to its foamy, stone-broken dissolution <strong>of</strong> salt.<br />
What then? What's not possible?<br />
Weather <strong>Art</strong>ists<br />
In a jagged patch <strong>of</strong> blue<br />
Pontormo might caress<br />
across the tank-top <strong>of</strong> an angel<br />
(a wide-eyed beauty<br />
staring challenge or invitation<br />
from under the lemon-green<br />
heavy legs <strong>of</strong> a dead Jesus)<br />
morning light is shining.<br />
It shatters to a pelting shower<br />
clattering the flat ro<strong>of</strong><br />
like the mad h<strong>and</strong><br />
<strong>of</strong> a bodhrdn banger, high<br />
on the quick shifts <strong>of</strong> light,<br />
the slant mercury-bright<br />
shoots <strong>and</strong> stems <strong>of</strong> rain<br />
cueing him. After it passes<br />
silence seeps in, brimming<br />
the garden: provisional<br />
absolute <strong>and</strong> absolution<br />
Leopardi came to terms with:<br />
its inauguration <strong>of</strong> small voices<br />
(robin tongue, raindropplink<br />
through the sycamore<br />
leaf to leaf, a sudden gush <strong>of</strong> wind<br />
translating every syllable<br />
into tree-speech)<br />
till light breaks back,<br />
coating grass with that<br />
yellow the pleine air painters<br />
patented, so when I look<br />
out this eastern window<br />
I see, suspended<br />
from a fuchsia twig, three<br />
tiny blown-glass globes <strong>of</strong> lighi<br />
in which, if the twig shivers<br />
in any exhalation <strong>of</strong> air or<br />
I incline to left or right,<br />
the spectrum stays visible<br />
a glimmering instant, as for<br />
C'ezanne on his riverbank,<br />
so he saw, <strong>and</strong> kept going.
Something about the light does this, works this kind <strong>of</strong> spell.<br />
Approaching the Bealach, he looks out <strong>and</strong> it's as though the entire<br />
sky <strong>of</strong> the world is open, poured out, let loose all down upon the<br />
hills. Like there was never such a thing as darkness here, like there<br />
could be no darkness, only this bare, clear air. There are the clean<br />
open flats <strong>of</strong> the moors, pale gray <strong>and</strong> dun <strong>and</strong> heather-streaked<br />
with dark <strong>and</strong> peat, <strong>and</strong> blackish watery burns some places coming<br />
down cut with broken stones, rocks, <strong>and</strong> all <strong>of</strong> it, the sweet<br />
l<strong>and</strong>, available to you somehow, that sense <strong>of</strong> reaching out to it like<br />
you might take it, be able to gather it into yourself <strong>and</strong> make it<br />
yours, a universe <strong>of</strong> endless l<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> sky <strong>and</strong> distance <strong>and</strong> pick<br />
out the mountains for your stars.<br />
But it's the road that keeps him from disappearing. The gray <strong>of</strong><br />
it, <strong>and</strong> thin, with no place much for passing. Since childhood, the<br />
memory's been in Callum all <strong>of</strong> the years, coming along here with<br />
his father, lagging behind caravans or<br />
estates hitching trailers, or boats <strong>and</strong> his<br />
It's the road that<br />
keeps him from<br />
disappearing.<br />
The gray <strong>of</strong> it,<br />
<strong>and</strong> thin, with no<br />
place much for<br />
passing.<br />
father's frustration, Christ, get a move on<br />
man! His h<strong>and</strong>s gripping the wheel, <strong>and</strong><br />
those eyes <strong>of</strong> his trained on distance.<br />
First Drumochta. Then Bonar Bridge.<br />
Dornoch... All the places he was wanting<br />
to get past, to get through, to get<br />
there ... And terrifying, I know myself,<br />
that cry <strong>of</strong> his: Christ! Like the man<br />
would himself put a sword through<br />
Christ's side, Callum could see it all, as a<br />
boy. His father's pr<strong>of</strong>ile as he sat beside<br />
hiln in the car, seeing his father out <strong>of</strong><br />
the side <strong>of</strong> his eye, not daring to say a<br />
word, not wanting to breathe even. And where was his mother<br />
then? It was always only ever him making the journey with his<br />
father, enduring that silence <strong>of</strong> his, or the frightening cries, <strong>and</strong> the<br />
sense <strong>of</strong> him, that man in the car beside him, the sense <strong>of</strong> him<br />
wanting out, into the hills <strong>and</strong> the water, seeming to be pushing<br />
him along, pulling him, great pieces <strong>of</strong> the sound <strong>of</strong> the place<br />
unfurling in his mind, like there may as well be someone coming<br />
down <strong>of</strong>f the hills now with a set <strong>of</strong> pipes to call him in.<br />
It's going to take a couple more hours to get up to us here, much<br />
easier now than back in the old days, still, the particular emotion
through to the main house, to the small sitting room where his<br />
father will be.<br />
This time, though, my mother does not take him. He goes<br />
down the hall by himself to where the old man is waiting, sitting<br />
in his armchair by the fire, alone. My mother busies herself<br />
in the kitchen, heats through soup, rolls, puts the water on to<br />
boil for tea. When I come down from my bedroom to take the<br />
things through she's away upstairs herself <strong>and</strong> Callum's sitting<br />
in the chair before his father, his father not saying a word. The<br />
lamps are on, <strong>and</strong> the fire's bright this darkish afternoon with<br />
snow in the air <strong>and</strong> still one or two old dogs barking, poor<br />
beasts, not underst<strong>and</strong>ing why it is they've not been allowed to<br />
see him, to come rushing in <strong>and</strong> fall upon Callum to lick him<br />
all over his h<strong>and</strong>s. They know alright that it's Iny brother who<br />
is here.<br />
But it's not for me to go - to release them. I set the tray down<br />
on the small table by the window <strong>and</strong> Callum says, "Hello, Helen"<br />
then, <strong>and</strong> I turn to him, for the first time in a long time I'm looking<br />
on his face again.<br />
Then his father speaks, "He took his time getting back to us,<br />
Helen. Didn't he? Our boy?"<br />
He smiles, first time I've seen the old man smile since he's been<br />
back up here, a smile, a real smile. He takes a sip from his dram.<br />
"Don't think I'm going back with you though," he says, "Callum.<br />
I'll not, <strong>and</strong> you should know this fine, I'll not be taken."<br />
"Dad..." Callum says, "Hello..."<br />
It's as though there's light all around the pair <strong>of</strong> them. I can<br />
see it, in this room with its deep wooden walls <strong>and</strong> windows<br />
set, this late afternoon, with all the little panes <strong>of</strong> glass. To see<br />
them, together again, my father <strong>and</strong> my brother, these men<br />
who, though they will never know it, have a daughter <strong>and</strong> a<br />
sister, too...<br />
"That'll be all, I think, Helen," the old man says then. "You<br />
can leave us now. Tell lain we'll not be needing the guns in the<br />
morning..."<br />
And I turn to go. Leave them, the one facing the other, by the fire<br />
I set this morning.<br />
"Wish your mother goodnight from me," my father says to me<br />
as I go out the door, back into the dark hall, yet the sense <strong>of</strong> light,<br />
this gorgeous piece <strong>of</strong> light still present, with me, at my back.<br />
From this man who's come from where he was, come up that long<br />
road that's behind him, crossed the Pass, <strong>and</strong> returned to us, to<br />
Nowhere, "Falabh." Our Aite Aon Arech, our End <strong>of</strong> the Road. Our<br />
home.•
what was lost to surface. For maximum fun with butter,<br />
that part <strong>of</strong> legacy (my father an unsalted butter-color man):<br />
a fresh tub for each impression. One for chin, one for h<strong>and</strong>, another<br />
for foot, each bite mark. No problem: there was always<br />
another butter. Exceptional mortar butter, plaster <strong>of</strong> butter<br />
every year<br />
Easter butter lamb to butcher gently with polite knives<br />
the shape <strong>of</strong> oars, shape <strong>of</strong> skinny hooded priest pr<strong>of</strong>iles.<br />
slick with<br />
You stuck your h<strong>and</strong>s in <strong>and</strong> the butter s<strong>of</strong>tened cuticles, repaired<br />
dishpan h<strong>and</strong>s, soothed scrapes, minor burns -Matna ran butter-fisted<br />
when I fell <strong>of</strong>f the bike - was elbow grease<br />
if you wiped it there, <strong>and</strong> let rings come <strong>of</strong>f as if it was before:<br />
s<strong>of</strong>tness back<br />
<strong>and</strong> some <strong>of</strong> your innocence<br />
in family tradition <strong>of</strong> Blue Bonnet, Mazola, L<strong>and</strong> 0' Lakes'<br />
Indian maiden coming at me sometilnes in a canoe taken as rescue<br />
craft I was too big for; I could open my mouth, <strong>and</strong> she, Princess<br />
Whatchamaca1ll1er could float right in, down<br />
my throat that with tonsils <strong>and</strong> tongue <strong>of</strong>fered a take<br />
on southwestern l<strong>and</strong> formations. We used Big Chief<br />
baking powder <strong>and</strong> sugar, had Minnehaha Water delivered<br />
in jugs big enough to have held fleets <strong>of</strong> sunken toy ships,<br />
<strong>and</strong> sold what we called bog water (taken from vases<br />
<strong>and</strong> saucers under potted plants, spruced up<br />
with Listerine) to those who wanted adult drinks prematurely;<br />
- jO Deirdre! -<br />
bog water <strong>of</strong> premature wine not done fermenting had to be<br />
priced by proximity to process completion. After any <strong>of</strong> this<br />
we freshened the air with Indian Blessing Spray #41<br />
that stank a little bit<br />
<strong>and</strong> also smelled a little bit like cherries.<br />
- jin your stinking grave<br />
rotting sweetly: no<br />
complaints -<br />
By not partaking <strong>of</strong> any butter, not indulging, not giving in<br />
my toast was s<strong>and</strong>paper, the usual slice <strong>of</strong> fossil-sponge<br />
Martian terrain close-up. But it could crumble, could<br />
become dust in my fingertips, could look as if I crumbled<br />
with it, tobacco like, filler for my father's Pall Malls<br />
that he smoked to death, <strong>and</strong> as if I were butter<br />
had that responsibility time to time I opened cigarettes<br />
scraped the paper clean <strong>and</strong> wrote haiku riddles that I rolled up<br />
tightl)T, my words burning from his lips easily<br />
gone gone gone<br />
All four slices <strong>of</strong> my wooden bread<br />
are s<strong>and</strong>ed smooth grain. Old English<br />
protected - that oil like supremely clarified butter.<br />
What fine head <strong>and</strong> foot boards for beautiful small beds<br />
no one fits, only if the size <strong>of</strong> cigarettes, pack <strong>of</strong> white-robed sisters<br />
from Virginia what fine understated tombstones.<br />
This bread may be waxed. 0 shine. I know who Shine was.<br />
Its lines are durable labYrinths our father<br />
fingers <strong>and</strong> tongue may follow in cursive spell-out.<br />
That wax, that sheen <strong>of</strong> get-away<br />
from the path shines my fingerprints<br />
where I grip the bread as loose pages, loose leaves<br />
<strong>of</strong> suspicious adaptation. Loops under the arches<br />
are a green onion bulb<br />
cross section, innermost loop<br />
like the eye <strong>of</strong> an elnbroidery needle<br />
or like sperm-head<br />
or like the hook<br />
that scrapes out early pregnancy<br />
depending on who's looking. The loop made<br />
when tying the ribbons <strong>of</strong> a blue bonnet<br />
under the chin. II
Fork<br />
Addiction<br />
his is a tale <strong>of</strong> the birth <strong>of</strong> Limited Fork Poetics.<br />
The birth announcement, actually, <strong>of</strong> the inevitable<br />
<strong>of</strong>fspring <strong>of</strong> a poet who becomes so immersed in<br />
awareness <strong>of</strong> the dominating presence <strong>of</strong> dynamic<br />
systems in every facet <strong>of</strong> her observable existence that<br />
poetry <strong>and</strong> the structures she studies merge.<br />
Dynamic systems, processes <strong>of</strong> interactions, produce active structures<br />
that populate the l<strong>and</strong>scapes that exist simultaneously at all<br />
scales. Mutability, multiplicity, <strong>and</strong> adaptability are stunning traits<br />
<strong>of</strong> existence that occur everywhere, on different scales <strong>of</strong> place <strong>and</strong><br />
time. Most <strong>of</strong> these structures escape human notice, but continuing<br />
advances in evidence capture (for instance, better <strong>and</strong> better microscopes<br />
<strong>and</strong> telescopes) reveal more <strong>and</strong> more information in every<br />
location examined with these devices that extend the limited range<br />
<strong>of</strong> human perception.<br />
Within revealed areas, previously unknown structures <strong>of</strong>fer<br />
enough connections, enough similarity to previously encountered<br />
patterns that metaphor not only becomes possible but is<br />
also encouraged. We catalog these new things with links to<br />
what we are reminded <strong>of</strong>, even as the science <strong>of</strong> these things<br />
emerges in the data, enabling recognition <strong>of</strong> the galactic within<br />
the microscopic, the sombrero within the galactic. This is the<br />
dynamic texture <strong>of</strong> existence. Patterns repeat on all scales, in<br />
whole <strong>and</strong> in part, <strong>and</strong> the poet seeks them in those neighborhoods<br />
that have become local (so available for access) by that<br />
poet. This dynamic texture is particularly prolninent in internet<br />
searches where thous<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> links can appear almost instantaneously,<br />
but since we cannot follow all <strong>of</strong> them all at once<br />
(though they are there), we move through the options one at a<br />
time instead, never pursuing most <strong>of</strong> them, yet we remain<br />
aware <strong>of</strong> the vast network <strong>of</strong> connections that the ones we<br />
choose to follow are part <strong>of</strong>. That influence remains <strong>and</strong> shapes<br />
responses to pursued search outcomes - perhaps only subtly,<br />
even only imperceptibly (at first; impact might become more pronounced<br />
as it builds through further connections made in other<br />
locations at other times).<br />
Active structures resist (models <strong>of</strong>) geometric perfection with<br />
bulges, bumps, punctures, wrinkles, folds, zigzags, nicks, crinkled<br />
contours (think <strong>of</strong> the pocked moon, <strong>of</strong> planetary rifts,<br />
tectonic buckles, valleys), <strong>and</strong> these appear even on those things<br />
that are generally smooth (a feature that generally increases with<br />
distance). Departures from smooth ideals tend to be revealed as<br />
powers <strong>of</strong> magnification (including thinking) are increased. So<br />
within limits (skin is such a limit), there is (apparently) endless<br />
variation such that specifics cannot be predicted precisely. Every<br />
day my eye is drawn to those shapes it considers interesting<br />
(such as clouds, flowers, mountains, birds, trees) because my<br />
brain is shaped that way also, is generally cumulous, bulging<br />
with recognition, possibility; cerebral folds like aerial maps <strong>of</strong><br />
river systems, tributaries like liquid branches <strong>and</strong> liquid nerves,<br />
like three-dimensional portraits <strong>of</strong> an idea <strong>and</strong> its tributaries<br />
making multiple connections simultaneously, both consciously<br />
<strong>and</strong> unconsciously.<br />
Yes, the circulatory system is an inner tree. The nervous systenl<br />
is another tree within the human forest, capped with a jellyfish<br />
<strong>of</strong> brain from which nervous tentacles sprout <strong>and</strong> house<br />
everything imaginable. That the products <strong>of</strong> dynamic humanity<br />
would themselves be dynamic makes sense; they already are<br />
without our knowing it, but when realized, possibilities previously<br />
dormant with potential become activated, <strong>and</strong> my underst<strong>and</strong>ing<br />
<strong>of</strong> poetry exp<strong>and</strong>s as it seeks to apply principles <strong>of</strong><br />
behaviors <strong>of</strong> dynamic systems to itself. Limited Fork Poetics is in<br />
the blood - that's how basic <strong>and</strong> essential it is; already there,<br />
but needing to be named in order to be perceived. It embraces all<br />
<strong>of</strong> my humanity, so <strong>of</strong> course is fully compatible with how thinking<br />
behaves, <strong>and</strong> makes predictions that my work actively<br />
attempts to fulfill. To underst<strong>and</strong> poetry as a dynamic system is<br />
to allow poetry to see itself in many different mirrors, each distortion<br />
accurate. Each contribution taking a crack at improving<br />
(the reliability <strong>of</strong>) the sum.<br />
One such mirror is the elm, outside my <strong>of</strong>fice window, that (on<br />
the day I looked at it as the dynamic system that it, like poetry,<br />
already was) <strong>of</strong>fered more possibilities than it ever had. I remember<br />
thinking how the aesthetic appeal <strong>of</strong> tree would be weakened<br />
for me if there were only the trunk to consider. I would not call
trunk alone tree. It was the fuller package that defined it, making<br />
it recognizably ehn - the visible width <strong>of</strong> bifurcating elm, the<br />
uncompressed departures from trunk including those twigs,<br />
branches, <strong>and</strong> roots culminating in dead ends, terminal locations<br />
which happened to locate points in the sky <strong>and</strong> the earth - <strong>and</strong><br />
made me want to look at it again <strong>and</strong> again - each elm within<br />
the general limits <strong>of</strong> elm but with unpredictable specific branch,<br />
bark, <strong>and</strong> root patterns, even such variation in the general structure<br />
<strong>of</strong> the leaves - I love the fatness <strong>of</strong> the system <strong>of</strong> branches. I<br />
love those things whose generalities are predictable but not their<br />
specifics, some <strong>of</strong> which can exert so much influence, the general<br />
structure is changed - And I did need for that itnpressive<br />
branching width to slim down to trunk<br />
(respite) as I journeyed both outwardly<br />
Thinking is more<br />
like time itself, a<br />
vehicle transporting<br />
us, that me<strong>and</strong>ers<br />
as it moves<br />
generally linearly.<br />
to what branches pointed to <strong>and</strong><br />
inwardly to what roots pointed to:<br />
everything. I had access to everything<br />
through that ehn.<br />
It was an ultimate fork. I held up a<br />
plastic generality that happened to be<br />
on my desk, finding the placement in<br />
which my eyes allowed the plastic fork<br />
h<strong>and</strong>le to become proxy elm trunk, the<br />
idea firmly in my grip, the plastic tines<br />
there to help me access more <strong>of</strong> the pos<br />
sibilities <strong>of</strong> the idea, but with gaps between them because I could<br />
not possibly grasp everything. Hence (some <strong>of</strong>) the limitation.<br />
a those lovely gaps! - like those between elm branches, <strong>of</strong>fering<br />
a ragged, irregular beauty not available to something completely<br />
filled in. I could see, fork preventing me from seeing anything<br />
else, that gaps were preferable to a solidity that I couldn't think<br />
<strong>of</strong>, considering space between the components <strong>of</strong> <strong>and</strong> the atoms<br />
<strong>of</strong> everything. Space between my thumb <strong>and</strong> plastic, between<br />
plastic <strong>and</strong> window, window <strong>and</strong> elm, between (the system <strong>of</strong>)<br />
elm <strong>and</strong> the bifurcating system <strong>of</strong> lines (branches) on my h<strong>and</strong><br />
that branches from my trunk <strong>of</strong> arm that branches from my trunk<br />
<strong>of</strong> body (that branched inside my mother).<br />
In using a fork, the user who would digest what the fork<br />
manages to lift <strong>and</strong> move through space to the mouth (the danger<br />
<strong>of</strong> losing some or all <strong>of</strong> what is speared, draped across, or<br />
dangling from the lap <strong>of</strong> tines always present) becomes an<br />
extension <strong>of</strong> fork, the arm branching into body so that the<br />
collaboration <strong>of</strong> user <strong>and</strong> fork gives birth to another form <strong>of</strong> tree,<br />
another branch <strong>of</strong> larger structure. The act <strong>of</strong> writing is largely<br />
linear in that it tends to happen sequentially; word follows word.<br />
Forking paths my poems pursue are conceived <strong>of</strong> simultaneously<br />
(consciously <strong>and</strong> unconsciously) but are captured one by one, linearly,<br />
even if placed irregularly on a page. Sometimes only one<br />
path is captured, or part <strong>of</strong> a path. Thinking blossoms, sometimes<br />
explodes in a temporary"Aha!" <strong>of</strong> knowing only to be funneled<br />
sequentially <strong>and</strong> trimmed, but blossoming can again occur<br />
each time the poem is experienced. Each encounter <strong>of</strong>fers opportunity<br />
for enhancement or amendment (including dynamic decay<br />
<strong>and</strong> recycling).<br />
That which pulses <strong>and</strong> flows is myriad, that which throbs,<br />
including, possibly, big bang residue in the form <strong>of</strong> subtle vibration,<br />
maybe even deep-space signals transmitted in hopes <strong>of</strong> chance<br />
interaction with those able to recognize <strong>and</strong> find meaning in structure.<br />
A consideration <strong>of</strong> dynamic systems is a consideration <strong>of</strong> how<br />
the mutability <strong>of</strong> structure intensifies at boundaries where there are<br />
greater opportunities for new structures to take shape whether or<br />
not they succeed. Where more variables are present whose interactions<br />
can reshape the interacting systems in subtle ways or ways<br />
that approach pr<strong>of</strong>undity. The full range. Motion, the dynamic<br />
necessity <strong>of</strong> dynmnic systems, is also journey, at the very least<br />
through time. Things move for the most part, apparently linearly<br />
through time, but thinking <strong>and</strong> imagination can also move in any<br />
direction while basic linear progression is underway. Thinking is<br />
more like time itself, a vehicle transporting us, that me<strong>and</strong>ers as it<br />
moves generally linearly, creating different implications for each<br />
location in time. Multiple streams <strong>of</strong> time, such as past <strong>and</strong> present,<br />
apparently head toward future streams, but at any time, any <strong>of</strong><br />
these can be twisted, merged, or folded - if only in the thoughts <strong>of</strong><br />
those moving with time. Consider that sunlight that illuminates the<br />
present on earth is light from the sun's recent past. And sunlight<br />
emanates from all the sun-sphere all at once, so a radiant mane (not<br />
a single line) travels a widening path in time.<br />
Because LFP emphasizes fluidity, implications for the LFP page<br />
can be startling. I am Pr<strong>of</strong>orker <strong>and</strong> Text Choreographer as I work on<br />
identifying <strong>and</strong> underst<strong>and</strong>ing how moving products <strong>of</strong> LFP<br />
occupy moving space. Poems may happen at any stage in cycles<br />
<strong>of</strong> structure formation, decay, <strong>and</strong> reformation; <strong>and</strong> any part <strong>of</strong><br />
these events may appear in any location <strong>of</strong> the LFP page simultaneously,<br />
some parts imperceptible, some variably revealed <strong>and</strong>
unrevealed, some so stable that they are caught in acts <strong>of</strong> persistent<br />
coherent revelation. Where structure forms on the LFP page<br />
is a stabilizing area (page refers to the primary residence [home<br />
base] <strong>of</strong> a poem or any <strong>of</strong> its components at any specified<br />
mOInent <strong>and</strong> is not liInited to paper - a poem is able to travel,<br />
even if it doesn't [seem to]). Where structure decays on the LFP<br />
page is a destabilizing area fertile for reformation. Stanzas can<br />
begin out <strong>of</strong> stabilizing gestures, <strong>and</strong> may progress in stability or<br />
may deteriorate, warp, or transform as sOInething from the surrounding<br />
flux (the substance out <strong>of</strong> which structure forms, the<br />
ingredient pool) interacts with the stabilizing (or decaying)<br />
structure. It Inay not be obvious whether a perceptible structure<br />
is stabilizing or decaying as a similar fonn may occur in either<br />
structural state. Structure may attempt to take shape in multiple<br />
locations (rooms) <strong>of</strong> the house <strong>of</strong> the poem, <strong>and</strong> any number <strong>of</strong><br />
these attempts Inay take on enough structure to become perceptible<br />
in part or whole, perhaps causing competing zones <strong>of</strong> influence<br />
which may merge into one structure or may lead to one or<br />
more quick or gradual demises. Or the stability <strong>of</strong> the poem's<br />
structure may be so intense that it delays the stabilizing (<strong>of</strong> other<br />
locations perhaps for so long, the delay mimics prevention), so<br />
that nothing else (at that time) is visible.<br />
A poem as print object documents the dynamic activity that<br />
caused the poeIn to take on perceptible structure, which, like all<br />
structure, is subject to further change, such as revision <strong>of</strong> a print<br />
object <strong>and</strong> interpretations <strong>of</strong> a print object each time it is encountered.<br />
The complete dynamic signature <strong>of</strong> a poem includes all<br />
subsystems <strong>of</strong> the components <strong>of</strong> a poem (the published form a<br />
magnification <strong>of</strong> one <strong>of</strong> the branches in the complete dynamic signature)<br />
which include all drafts, all dead ends, all revisions <strong>and</strong><br />
interpretations (by writer <strong>and</strong> experiencers <strong>of</strong> the poem), all contributing<br />
thoughts, forming a kind <strong>of</strong> evolutionary tree <strong>of</strong> the<br />
poeIn, each branch, when examined closely (magnified, that is, or<br />
considered on some intensified scale), full <strong>of</strong> other branches <strong>of</strong><br />
thought <strong>and</strong> connection. It is through the (so far) ceaseless movement<br />
(transformation perceived <strong>and</strong> actual) <strong>of</strong> dynan1ic systems<br />
that all becomes linked into one fabric <strong>of</strong> reality that is so faceted,<br />
the saIne territory can reveal something different each time the<br />
lens is shifted or changed. Depth in LFP becomes a way to refer<br />
to that which is unexplored, for once encountered, that which is<br />
encountered becomes the surface <strong>of</strong> that encounter. The surface is<br />
hardly superficial but is where interactions between boundaries<br />
occur. Surface after surface is scratched, layer after layer is peeled<br />
back, <strong>and</strong> then there's that rosy resemblance. That elm.<br />
Because poetry is a dynamic system, poems may be understood<br />
as failed efforts to capture flux, as attempts to cause awareness<br />
<strong>of</strong> something that may no longer exist (in that exact form)<br />
by the time a poem is experienced (even during the writing <strong>of</strong><br />
the first line). LFP approaches desired capture <strong>of</strong> a poem as chase<br />
only, so expects to capture only partialities <strong>of</strong> partialities. The<br />
totality in which all apparently takes place can't easily (if at all)<br />
be seen as totality from within it. The most that might be possible<br />
is exquisite failure, <strong>and</strong> most poems fall short <strong>of</strong> that elm <strong>of</strong><br />
failure, some compellingly. II<br />
The Culture <strong>of</strong> Reena <strong>and</strong> the Bear<br />
Before the Bear: derived from a theory <strong>of</strong> gravy<br />
(The neckline <strong>and</strong> hem <strong>of</strong> Reena's gown<br />
were trimmed with real hummingbirds<br />
[just a few tiny pins in the outspread wings<br />
- she could feel the racing unison<br />
that the tiny hearts fell into] <strong>and</strong> actual orchids.<br />
The beak closest to it tried to extract nectar<br />
from the small cleft - the suprasternal notch <br />
at the bottom <strong>of</strong> her perfumed throat)<br />
(Bees drew near; live jewels from the garden.)<br />
She still had her eyes <strong>and</strong> others too<br />
on a tray: unpitted olives<br />
coated with a thin layer <strong>of</strong> meringue<br />
as vitreous humor substitute<br />
Breakfast Before the Bear: ocular effects
that she placed in each bowl <strong>of</strong> owlet soup<br />
in which floated owl embryos braised<br />
in butter <strong>and</strong> chives, sprinkled with br<strong>and</strong>y<br />
just before serving, <strong>and</strong> skewered<br />
with knife-length pieces <strong>of</strong> jicama,<br />
tasting slightly <strong>of</strong> rodents<br />
the parent owl had eaten, ambiance<br />
<strong>of</strong> background radiation, a theorem <strong>of</strong> alternatives,<br />
the microworld <strong>of</strong> taste, from here<br />
the same as a comet's rat's tail<br />
coming from between her teeth,<br />
a glittering skeleton, tendon flex<br />
<strong>of</strong> her reaction attaching Reena<br />
to the muscle <strong>of</strong> how hard the universe works.<br />
preceded by romance.<br />
They exchanged rings<br />
like the b<strong>and</strong>s on goose legs.<br />
Before the Bear: Reena's first marriage<br />
Promise her anything: give her foie gras:<br />
stuff it down her throat<br />
The Culture <strong>of</strong> Reena <strong>and</strong> the Bear<br />
Once she began wondering what it would be like to eat her way<br />
out <strong>of</strong> something, she did something about it: came to bed<br />
in an open-fire-roasted clove-studded carcass <strong>of</strong> beef<br />
(the cloves are the dried unopened flower buds <strong>of</strong> a tree<br />
called the Zanzibar Red Head).<br />
Unfortunately, the bear though as hungry as it should be<br />
after hibernation respected the presence <strong>of</strong> Reena's husb<strong>and</strong>,<br />
so with him there the bear alone wasn't illuminated;<br />
Reena couldn't hold on to just its light<br />
<strong>and</strong> lost sight <strong>of</strong> its darkness in the darkening evening's<br />
Bear hug.<br />
The Superior Love <strong>of</strong> the Macurap in the Amazon Without Reena<br />
Who's Busy Looking at Ursa Major <strong>and</strong> Minor<br />
For their efforts the Macurap <strong>of</strong> the Amazon have<br />
viscous jelly destiny <strong>of</strong> the broth<br />
maintained for a week as one by one<br />
Macurap women kill their husb<strong>and</strong>s: the intensity <strong>of</strong> their love<br />
finally at a boiling point: the body everywhere: inside<br />
<strong>and</strong> out, sensitive to what touches, digesting<br />
intestinal love, cud climax, deep marriage<br />
in the pit <strong>of</strong> heavenly bellies even more transformation:<br />
husb<strong>and</strong>s taken to limits <strong>of</strong> what can be taken<br />
in: husb<strong>and</strong>s becoming ultimate alphabet <strong>of</strong> pleasure: extracts<br />
<strong>of</strong> A, B, E, vitamin K, crystalline pyridoxine: vitamin B6,<br />
vitamin P: bi<strong>of</strong>lavonoid from rinds <strong>and</strong> husks:<br />
Macurap wives watch their husb<strong>and</strong>s eat some.<br />
Citrus whispers roasted into his lungs,<br />
tincture <strong>of</strong> balsam, fermented boil, white peppered<br />
with grubs <strong>and</strong> lice, lips smack on<br />
how nothing else tastes like a man<br />
loved to death. His cleaned rib cage<br />
is a bone cape around her; her legs twine<br />
around his femurs<br />
as she makes love to ivory scepters.<br />
Golden locks on the pleasure cupboards<br />
can be polished or opened;<br />
gr<strong>and</strong> openings<br />
so much more tasteful<br />
Reena & the Three Bears
than the proprietor down the road<br />
who called that first <strong>of</strong> several popular<br />
while-you-wait tailoring shops<br />
Jack the Ripper.<br />
Meet Reena the Butcher.<br />
Fresh bear meat for this girl hunter.<br />
The braided rug's circumference is enlarged<br />
by blood-spray<br />
into an alien dahlia <strong>of</strong> blood<br />
that is just right. II<br />
1<br />
The Culture <strong>of</strong> Mr. Wonderful<br />
First there's innocence as pr<strong>of</strong>essed<br />
by his pr<strong>of</strong>ession: selling boatloads <strong>of</strong> flowers<br />
that out <strong>of</strong> his h<strong>and</strong>s become adornment, snacks,<br />
overtures that pr<strong>of</strong>it this dealer <strong>of</strong> vegetable matter,<br />
some petals displayed around the flower head<br />
like a h<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> cards: the gamble in anything.<br />
Then one must look more closely at that h<strong>and</strong><br />
the flower's been dealt as it becomes what<br />
Mr. Wonderful's been dealt: the family<br />
business, not lucrative all the time; he's not<br />
in it for the money, but for the pure pleasure,<br />
since there's <strong>of</strong>ten nothing else, <strong>of</strong> ferrying flowers.<br />
Many tulips close up on him at twilight as if they hold small empty<br />
eggs: elegant voids - or maybe some inner peace that probably<br />
would be rounded, but not a ticket or passport to anything<br />
outside the garden; pollen drops from what sky there is inside<br />
onto impersonation <strong>of</strong> a velvet floor<br />
<strong>and</strong> would be at home in an hourglass: the whole<br />
night spent as gist <strong>of</strong> what I thought came out<br />
<strong>of</strong> successful tonsillectomy.<br />
At water's edge: a battalion <strong>of</strong> white peacocks,<br />
the feathers the most elegant spines<br />
blown back like umbrellas blown back<br />
<strong>and</strong> contorted like supposedly double-jointed girls<br />
in a circus desperate to be spectacular<br />
but also like, as if the double-jointed were not enough,<br />
partial jellyfish; that is: jellyfish that result<br />
from lobotomy, the ragged half brain <strong>of</strong> tentacular nerves<br />
or more decorative radar dish<br />
to spy on celestial activity out <strong>of</strong> the ordinary,<br />
to eavesdrop just as the plane trees just beyond<br />
the startling white peacocks, even their eyes,<br />
are doing: bare branches in the blown-back position<br />
<strong>of</strong> the peacocks' feathery array<br />
with which the plane trees collaborate, each<br />
translating the other <strong>and</strong> transmitting mutual praise.<br />
Mr. Wonderful is a captain completely unaware that I know <strong>of</strong> him.<br />
His expansion that he knows <strong>of</strong> is a little Mr. Wonderful<br />
whose resemblance extends to a smaller boat<br />
on the other side <strong>of</strong> the lake.<br />
Some <strong>of</strong> his petals, the ones most like daggers,<br />
excusing the s<strong>of</strong>tness, are dipped in poison<br />
because some poisons make the most beautiful ink<br />
<strong>and</strong> are necessary to write the name <strong>of</strong> his lover<br />
on the active surface <strong>of</strong> this lake; the water under his boat
than the proprietor down the road<br />
who called that first <strong>of</strong> several popular<br />
while-you-wait tailoring shops<br />
Jack the Ripper.<br />
Meet Reena the Butcher.<br />
Fresh bear meat for this girl hunter.<br />
The braided rug's circumference is enlarged<br />
by blood-spray<br />
into an alien dahlia <strong>of</strong> blood<br />
that is just right. •<br />
1<br />
The Culture <strong>of</strong> Mr. Wonderful<br />
First there's innocence as pr<strong>of</strong>essed<br />
by his pr<strong>of</strong>ession: selling boatloads <strong>of</strong> flowers<br />
that out <strong>of</strong> his h<strong>and</strong>s become adornment, snacks,<br />
overtures that pr<strong>of</strong>it this dealer <strong>of</strong> vegetable matter,<br />
some petals displayed around the flower head<br />
like a h<strong>and</strong> <strong>of</strong> cards: the gamble in anything.<br />
Then one must look more closely at that h<strong>and</strong><br />
the flower's been dealt as it becomes what<br />
Mr. Wonderful's been dealt: the family<br />
business, not lucrative all the time; he's not<br />
in it for the money, but for the pure pleasure,<br />
since there's <strong>of</strong>ten nothing else, <strong>of</strong> ferrying flowers.<br />
Many tulips close up on him at twilight as if they hold small empty<br />
eggs: elegant voids - or maybe some inner peace that probably<br />
would be rounded, but not a ticket or passport to anything<br />
outside the garden; pollen drops from what sky there is inside<br />
onto impersonation <strong>of</strong> a velvet floc<br />
<strong>and</strong> would be at home in an hourglass: the who<br />
night spent as gist <strong>of</strong> what I thought came 01<br />
<strong>of</strong> successful tonsillectom<br />
At water's edge: a battalion <strong>of</strong> white peacocks,<br />
the feathers the most elegant spines<br />
blown back like umbrellas blown back<br />
<strong>and</strong> contorted like supposedly double-jointed girls<br />
in a circus desperate to be spectacular<br />
but also like, as if the double-jointed were not enough,<br />
partial jellyfish; that is: jellyfish that result<br />
froin 10botoIny, the ragged half brain <strong>of</strong> tentacular nerves<br />
or more decorative radar dish<br />
to spy on celestial activity out <strong>of</strong> the ordinary,<br />
to eavesdrop just as the plane trees just beyond<br />
the startling white peacocks, even their eyes,<br />
are doing: bare branches in the blown-back position<br />
<strong>of</strong> the peacocks' feathery array<br />
with which the plane trees collaborate, each<br />
translating the other <strong>and</strong> transmitting mutual praise.<br />
Mr. Wonderful is a captain completely unaware that I know <strong>of</strong> him.<br />
His expansion that he knows <strong>of</strong> is a little Mr. Wonderful<br />
whose resemblance extends to a smaller boat<br />
on the other side <strong>of</strong> the lake.<br />
Some <strong>of</strong> his petals, the ones most like daggers,<br />
excusing the s<strong>of</strong>tness, are dipped in poison<br />
because some poisons make the most beautiful ink<br />
<strong>and</strong> are necessary to write the name <strong>of</strong> his lover<br />
on the active surface <strong>of</strong> this lake, the water under his boat
moving like her under him, so many underlings move him,<br />
yellows, oranges, pinks, lavenders spilled here like congealed<br />
volatile oil, wacky pie chart gone fractal<br />
perhaps just to be popular<br />
<strong>and</strong> on the up <strong>and</strong> up still rising, garnished with blush<br />
<strong>of</strong> pollen that is dirty <strong>and</strong> nutmeg-colored from a rubbing<br />
on Mr. Wonderful's fingertips before dispersal<br />
<strong>and</strong> the impression that rubbed pollen<br />
could be a grating <strong>of</strong> his skin for no reason at all,<br />
<strong>and</strong> that could be why he'd do it.<br />
The trick is to get his fingertips there; after that, there's no trick<br />
to what's visible under the microscope: fortified spiked walls<br />
<strong>of</strong> a labyrinth, the innermost curl somewhat a spirochete,<br />
<strong>and</strong> saying that, it's clear just what to picture: artistry transfer<br />
to brushes with syphilis, lues, late treatments, penicillin<br />
success after gross disfigurement, many diseases<br />
seem to establish blossoms on skin, leprous flowers<br />
tended in special, colonirLl gardens.Pet vectors.<br />
There are spikes <strong>and</strong> hooks<br />
in the fortress <strong>of</strong> Mr. Wonderful's fingerprints, torture labyrinths,<br />
caches <strong>of</strong> poisoned intentions unless this is taken another way:<br />
beautiful loop <strong>of</strong> embroidery, the head <strong>of</strong> a seahorse from afar,<br />
silk fins present though unseen.<br />
Under the microscope some flowers have bones, there's druse<br />
inside the cells, crystalline inclusions made <strong>of</strong> the stuff<br />
<strong>of</strong> kidney stones, <strong>and</strong> in the flower cells<br />
skeletal druse looks like starburst: an angular <strong>and</strong> pointed<br />
sub-flower that gathers light.<br />
There remains the simplicity <strong>of</strong> his selling flowers<br />
not yet milked, still full <strong>of</strong> perfumes.<br />
They live in marigolds. They live in cyclamen.<br />
When customers sniff, they pray into the petals.<br />
Some flowers are poisonous without this wonderful help:<br />
Barbados nut, the seed <strong>of</strong> a hairy botanical thing,<br />
at least 55 percent hell oil<br />
<strong>and</strong> a taste that can be craved, almost sweet,<br />
though belladonna, though the berries <strong>of</strong> lirio<br />
so much more purple than plums - nearly black,<br />
about to burst with coarse sugar - look sweeter<br />
<strong>and</strong> are a source <strong>of</strong> Wonderful's ink<br />
as are the ruddied orange sometimes berries <strong>of</strong> assumed<br />
pure lily <strong>of</strong> the valley linked to devotion with bell flowers<br />
each <strong>of</strong> which seems a chapel<br />
where a corpse might lay drenched in flowers<br />
all because the lily was thought to be wild garlic<br />
<strong>and</strong> was souped for what turned out to be a last supper<br />
<strong>of</strong> that soup <strong>and</strong> a salad <strong>of</strong> anesthetizing monkshood<br />
leaves <strong>and</strong> radish-mimic roots so that the Dundee cake flavored<br />
with the same to finish <strong>of</strong>f the person finishing the meal<br />
was not needed. Nothing was left to chance.<br />
Fish are not stupid, that is not why they're hooked<br />
on Wonderful's supply <strong>of</strong> flowers floating with him,<br />
slapped occasionally with water Mr. Wonderful scoops up<br />
until sequences <strong>of</strong> float, scoop, slap, dip, rub, disperse<br />
blab <strong>and</strong> blurt out ritual, <strong>and</strong> the wonderful boat becomes<br />
a church on waters <strong>of</strong> exile<br />
where fish die with Wonderful's poison in them, white bellies<br />
like sails no better <strong>of</strong>f than the up-bellies, quite unsail-like sails<br />
for being waterlogged inadequate isl<strong>and</strong>s<br />
ideal for water bugs that don't need such refuse<br />
to be refuge. Dead fish form plump alphabet:<br />
a spell <strong>of</strong> Rima on the water.<br />
Her name drifts with the bulk <strong>of</strong> fish belly
mounds like variations <strong>of</strong> mushrooms, stems sublnerged:<br />
stubby legs: small white tables, even in such shrinking<br />
Rima becomes part <strong>of</strong> everything<br />
because there is such a thing as her signature<br />
on everything, poisoned in a way <strong>of</strong> looking at love<br />
that went nowhere, did nothing, was only what<br />
Mr. Wonderful was in: a little box like the one<br />
that contains diamond solitaires, sOlnetimes hidden<br />
inside a flower to bypass ordinary circumstance,<br />
not quite successful because it still involves dirty work:<br />
the demolition <strong>of</strong> flowers to get the boat full <strong>of</strong> seeds:<br />
so wonderful,<br />
so much greatly magnified dust.<br />
The situation can't be cleaned without ruining everything:<br />
the thicker the dust, the more depth to wonderful living.<br />
I I<br />
Take-<strong>of</strong>f from Sam Abell's photographic account <strong>of</strong> a Mr. Wonderful in Seeing Gardens.
'Tile ar'lists, courtnsv <strong>of</strong> jnv ,lonlirlQ/Whifn r:llho I nnrlnn I
GOU"tpcy 'H) (IIJ' PoslrnaslfH'S<br />
New YOi'k
i GO!JI'tesy <strong>of</strong> Postmasters "The artists. Gourlesy <strong>of</strong> clay ,Jopling/White Cube. London i
mixod media 58,;)f"x7()"'''''x54';'U'' I<br />
liThe artists, Gourtnsy or Jay Jop!ing/Whitn Culm, London I
y Liam<br />
Rector<br />
selected poems<br />
Our Hero Galliano<br />
When Galliano took over<br />
Dior in 1996 (the Dior<br />
Who said earlier that his<br />
Dream was to "free women<br />
From nature"), many viewed<br />
Galliano as too "costumey,"<br />
While others saw Galliano<br />
Returning sex <strong>and</strong> theater<br />
To the clothing. When a man<br />
Looks at a WOlnan wearing<br />
A Galliano, Galliano said<br />
That man should think only,<br />
"I have to fuck her."
New York City<br />
Outside the window<br />
Buildings, some<br />
With awnings<br />
And doormen (even<br />
The occasional<br />
Doorwoman now)<br />
(l wonder if they<br />
Are trained to kick<br />
Someone's ass when<br />
It comes to that)<br />
(As it sometimes<br />
Comes to that)<br />
(Or if even the men<br />
Are trained to do that).<br />
Doormen coming out<br />
Now <strong>and</strong> again<br />
To cop a cigarette<br />
Or help a tenant<br />
With luggage,<br />
The groceries always<br />
Coming, going, feeding.<br />
I hardly ever leave.<br />
I seldom go now.<br />
Hard to pull myself<br />
Away from the entire<br />
Circus just outside<br />
This window now.<br />
Soon the City<br />
Soon the summer<br />
Now the pleasant purgatory<br />
Of spring is over<br />
Soon the choking<br />
Humidity<br />
In the city<br />
On the fire escapes<br />
In a sleeveless T-shirt<br />
Smoking a cigar<br />
In tune with the tremor<br />
Of the mindless yellow<br />
Commercial traffic<br />
Moving in the city<br />
Where no one really<br />
Buys a car<br />
American<br />
Or otherwise<br />
Where we<br />
As Rilke said we would<br />
Where we will<br />
Wake read write<br />
Long letters<br />
And in the avenues<br />
W<strong>and</strong>er restlessly<br />
To <strong>and</strong> fro<br />
On foot in<br />
The humidity<br />
Where soon I'll shower dress<br />
Take the dog out for a piss<br />
And mail this
which is sometilnes referred to as What Cannot Be Said.<br />
Agony decides the fate <strong>of</strong> Theater People. Theater People who<br />
lose a loved one become Showfolks; Theater People whose loved one<br />
enters into Laughter become Stolen Pets.<br />
Upon the death <strong>of</strong> his loved one, a Showfolk is awarded a cash<br />
prize equal to 100 times the average yearly salary. During Agony, What Can Be Said is alive with contradictory<br />
Showfolks, because <strong>of</strong> their proximity to those who enter into<br />
but never leave Agony, feel a legitimate need to be looked at<br />
<strong>and</strong>/or heard. Thus, when they become Tenants, <strong>and</strong> so long as<br />
they remain Tenants, they are required to work a job in the television<br />
or radio industries as newscasters, game-show hosts, or talkshow<br />
hosts. These positions allow them to be themselves, more or<br />
less, <strong>and</strong> to be looked at <strong>and</strong>/or heard. Most will pursue training<br />
in the field so as to compete with other Showfolks for the elite<br />
positions, but many will eschew training<br />
<strong>and</strong> thereby bring a variety <strong>of</strong> obstinate<br />
Upon the death<br />
<strong>of</strong> his loved one,<br />
aShowfolk is<br />
awarded acash<br />
prize equal to<br />
100 times the<br />
average yearly<br />
salary.<br />
peculiarities to local media.<br />
Television <strong>and</strong> radio stations, when<br />
they are hiring for on-air positions, are<br />
reqUired by law to hire Showfolks before<br />
they hire anyone else. This means that a<br />
Showfolk applicant will beat out all non<br />
Showfolks for the job, even if the<br />
Showfolk in question has had no training<br />
- indeed, even if the Showfolk in<br />
question is not able to speak. His only<br />
competition is other Showfolks. In the<br />
beginning, when there have been relatively<br />
few Agonies, there will be relatively<br />
few Showfolks, <strong>and</strong> these few will be<br />
inclined to seek out the most glamorous jobs at the most popular<br />
stations. A smaller portion will no doubt yearn to stay close to home,<br />
<strong>and</strong> some may seek out positions that allow them to maintain something<br />
close to anonylnity. As Agonies accrue, Showfolks will become<br />
less anomalous, though not necessarily less exotic - will become a<br />
caste, almost - <strong>and</strong> will saturate all levels <strong>of</strong> TV <strong>and</strong> radio "talk."<br />
A Stolen Pet, if his loved one arrives dead in Laughter, is known<br />
thereafter as a Shock Jock. Shock Jocks are awarded a cash prize<br />
equal to 500 times the average yearly salary. Shock Jocks, once they<br />
have received their award, are allowed to apply for <strong>and</strong> to work at<br />
any job they can get, but they may not receive pay for the work they<br />
do. Stolen Pets who are not Shock Jocks remain Stolen Pets <strong>and</strong><br />
receive no monetary award.<br />
wishes. II
y Erin Belieu<br />
3.<br />
I'm a borscht-belt comedienne<br />
working the audience from behind<br />
your headstone.<br />
I shimmy onstage between Pam<br />
And Her Magic Organ <strong>and</strong><br />
the gigantic poodle act.<br />
Your c<strong>of</strong>fin is a tough room.<br />
Mourners talk through my set,<br />
down schmutz-colored highballs, wait<br />
for the fan dancer to pluck<br />
her scuzzy feathers. But you<br />
always loved<br />
the livestock, didn't you?<br />
I say, how many <strong>of</strong> you folks are in<br />
from Jersey?<br />
from In The Red Dress<br />
I Wear To Your Funeral<br />
The microphone sweats<br />
like your cock did in my h<strong>and</strong>s.
4.<br />
I help the Jews drape the mirrors. I peel the foil from<br />
the Protestants' bleak casseroles. The Catholics <strong>and</strong> Agnostics<br />
huddle in the parking lot, smoking a memorial bowl.<br />
My dear, even the worst despot in his leopard-skin fez<br />
will tell you: the truth doesn't win, but it makes an appearance,<br />
though it's a foreign cavalry famous for bad timing <strong>and</strong><br />
half-assed horsemanship. History will barely remember that you<br />
were yellow <strong>and</strong> a cheat, a pixilated bivalve who consumed<br />
as r<strong>and</strong>omly as the thunderheads pass, <strong>and</strong> yet, how strange,<br />
how many <strong>of</strong> us loved you well. So tended)', I'll return<br />
what you gave me - a bleached. h<strong>and</strong>kerchief, a Swiss Army knife<br />
bristling with pointless blades. Tended)', I return everything,<br />
leaving my best evidence in your bloodless lap.<br />
5.<br />
I go to our Chinese take-awa)',<br />
where the placemats say I'm a cock<br />
<strong>and</strong> you were my favorite pig, though<br />
astrologically you were a wasting<br />
disease <strong>and</strong> I'm the scales <strong>of</strong> justice.<br />
Coincidence?<br />
Get down on your knees<br />
<strong>and</strong> cross yourself all you want:<br />
all systems are closed systems, dead man.<br />
I keep IllY saltshaker holstered in my garter belt,<br />
ready to spill.
the thick metal support posts, I struck it with a light jab. Surprisingly,<br />
the jab caused me little pain, so I hit the post harder, progressively<br />
throwing more <strong>of</strong> my weight into each blow. The post thudded <strong>and</strong><br />
hummed. Its deep-pitched moaJ;l rivaled the drone <strong>of</strong> the steering<br />
units. The shock <strong>of</strong> the blows reverberated down my wrists <strong>and</strong> shoulders<br />
like an arousing musical bass. With each strike I grew stronger. I<br />
could st<strong>and</strong> up to steel. My boots smeared the blood as it dripped on<br />
the grey decks. It coagulated on the heat <strong>of</strong> the floor, almost disappearing.<br />
Seaman Romeras, my watch relief, stared as I slung my bloody,<br />
taped fists into the steel beam. But that was just one <strong>of</strong> those things<br />
that sailors see each other do on long night watches at sea, <strong>and</strong> nothing<br />
is ever said about it. That night I almost broke. But I turned the whip<br />
against itself, I bared my soul, dripping my<br />
Seaman Romeras,<br />
my watch relief,<br />
stared as I<br />
slung my bloody,<br />
taped fists into the<br />
steel beam.<br />
blood on the steel decks, <strong>and</strong> in return, the<br />
ship respected my resolve <strong>and</strong> gave me the<br />
aftersteering room.<br />
The owl had probably flown aboard at<br />
our last port <strong>of</strong> call, Diego Garcia. Most<br />
likely he made his living catching the huge,<br />
greasy pier rats that infest tropical ports<br />
worldwide. We had pulled out <strong>of</strong> Garcia<br />
five days ago, so I figured he must be hungry.<br />
The next night, I <strong>of</strong>fered him bread<br />
crusts <strong>and</strong> pieces <strong>of</strong> pork, but he showed<br />
no interest. Maybe such food was carrion<br />
to him, <strong>and</strong> he needed a fresh kill. He allowed me to gently touch his<br />
wings, not because he had grown to trust me, but because he was too<br />
weak <strong>and</strong> traumatized to resist.<br />
Two days later, the U.S.S. Weitz anchored <strong>of</strong>fshore Phuket Isl<strong>and</strong>,<br />
Thail<strong>and</strong> - the <strong>of</strong>ficial "R <strong>and</strong> R" port <strong>of</strong> call for our "hard work<br />
<strong>and</strong> pr<strong>of</strong>essionalism in keeping with the finest traditions <strong>of</strong> the U.S.<br />
Navy" while patrolling the Persian Gulf. Before liberty call was<br />
passed over the ship's intercom, Thai ferry boats loaded with<br />
ice-cold beer <strong>and</strong> driven by cocky Thai youths who prided<br />
themselves on their knowledge <strong>of</strong> English curse words <br />
queued alongside our destroyer. Rickety, sky-blue crafts transported<br />
us to the bright green isl<strong>and</strong> which emerged out <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Andaman Sea like the back <strong>of</strong> a giant jellyfish.<br />
Once aboard the ferry, I drank as fast as I could. Sitting beside me,<br />
Seaman Fortman Whooped it up <strong>and</strong> I?F.C. Daniels cackled loudly. The<br />
old I?O.'s <strong>and</strong> sergeants took long drags from their Marlboros; they<br />
remembered the"conveniences" <strong>of</strong> old Subic in the Philippines. To<br />
these guys nothing compared to Subic Bay, or at least that is what they<br />
always asserted. If nothing else, it was an experience they could hold<br />
over the heads <strong>of</strong> the younger sailors <strong>and</strong> marines. In Subic, mere enlisted<br />
rubes metamorphosed into god-kings. Such was the blessing <strong>and</strong><br />
curse <strong>of</strong> being an American with a steady paycheck in the developing<br />
world. They presided over retinues <strong>of</strong> girlfriends <strong>and</strong> the <strong>of</strong>ficious manservants<br />
who polished their shoes <strong>and</strong> delivered whiskey wherever<br />
they happened to be "laid up."<br />
In town that night, I selected "Number 12," who sat on a bleacher<br />
behind a huge window with about 30 other young girls. She wore a<br />
gold dress, which - according to the pimps - meant that she possessed<br />
special skills. Holding her h<strong>and</strong> on the way to the room was the<br />
only intimate aspect <strong>of</strong> our hour-long encounter. First, we showered<br />
together. She made it cute, but the pre-sex bathing ritual served mYriad<br />
purposes. A clean man, free from the filth accumulated in a tropical<br />
night excursion, made the act more bearable for her. She could also take<br />
this tiine to inspect a man's body in a diplomatic fashion for chancres or<br />
other obvious signs <strong>of</strong> venereal disease before intercourse. I tipped her<br />
with a pile <strong>of</strong> coins from various ports <strong>of</strong> call that had accumulated in<br />
my belly bag. She giggled at the shiny coins rolling on the bedspread.<br />
I ducked through the rear door into a dark muddy alley. The<br />
back <strong>of</strong> the whorehouse was different from the front, where Thai<br />
pimps in silk shirts stood under the glow <strong>of</strong> blinking Christmas<br />
lights. It was only now, with the sense <strong>of</strong> calm <strong>and</strong> disillusionment<br />
following sex with a prostitute, that I could take in all the details<br />
around me.<br />
On the narrow road outside, five-dollar-a-night street whores<br />
prowled <strong>and</strong> bar girls danced on the tabletops in a panorama <strong>of</strong><br />
open-air bars. Cheesy Western hard rock blasting from the bars,<br />
smoke from the street vendors' grills, <strong>and</strong> the mugginess <strong>of</strong> the<br />
rainy season created an overwhelming cacophony. It was like being<br />
in a vacuum that stretched only a few hundred meters in circumference;<br />
but that was just as well, for I saw many sailors from my<br />
comm<strong>and</strong>, some <strong>of</strong> whom were married with children, fondling<br />
prostitutes <strong>and</strong> receiving oral sex from them publicly within the<br />
bars. Often a macho war cry or volley <strong>of</strong> high-fives followed these<br />
open performances <strong>of</strong> fellatio. Such scenes disturbed me, even<br />
though I was unable to discern exactly why.<br />
Across the street I spotted Petty Officer Valdez drunk <strong>and</strong> walking<br />
h<strong>and</strong>-in-h<strong>and</strong> with a cOlnpact, dark-skinned girl through the<br />
human swirl <strong>of</strong> sailors, marines, <strong>and</strong> whores. Valdez could drink<br />
twice as much as any <strong>of</strong> the whooping sailors or adrenaline-pumped
marines grabbing at the bikini-clad girls dancing on stage, yet<br />
relnain perfectly calm. He'd seen it all before. Valdez grew up an<br />
only child <strong>and</strong> fatherless in some gritty ethnic hellhole in New York<br />
City. He learned early in life that selfishness <strong>and</strong> cruelty were<br />
. virtues. Rough, ready, <strong>and</strong> never nervous, he loved his friends,<br />
hounded his enemies, comm<strong>and</strong>ed <strong>and</strong> Inotivated his men, <strong>and</strong><br />
stayed as drunk as the Navy would allow. Soon after I CaIne to the<br />
Weitz, he saw Ine beat another sailor viciously in a fistfight; Valdez<br />
<strong>and</strong> I became friends soon thereafter. His youth as a street soldier in<br />
a Puerto Rican gang conditioned him to appreciate such brutality<br />
<strong>and</strong> recklessness. Unlike brawling while on liberty, fighting on the<br />
ship carried a heavy penalty, <strong>and</strong> subsequently I was reduced in<br />
rank, fined, <strong>and</strong> restricted to the ship with one month's extra duty.<br />
Once Valdez told me laughingly <strong>of</strong> his participation in the rape-initiation<br />
<strong>of</strong> "newbies" during his refonn school days. He entertained no<br />
illusions about life or hiInself. I appreciated Valdez. Enlisted men<br />
like him made the organized chaos <strong>of</strong> a combatant ship at sea work.<br />
I trusted him <strong>and</strong> his word meant something, but I knew I could<br />
never be like him.<br />
Around 3 a.m., I grew weary <strong>of</strong> my solitude <strong>and</strong> walked into one <strong>of</strong><br />
the bars for a beer. As soon as I sat down on a barstool, three hookers<br />
surrounded me. Reaching into my pocket, I realized that I had used<br />
up most <strong>of</strong> my money. With my last Thai baht I bought Inyself a beer<br />
<strong>and</strong> a gin-<strong>and</strong>-tonic for the most persistent <strong>of</strong> the three whores - a<br />
striking WOlnan with long, wavy hair who was unusually tall for a<br />
Thai. It was the rainy season, <strong>and</strong> we sat together <strong>and</strong> watched the<br />
intermittent showers. The intense downpours caused the sewers to<br />
overflow into the streets, <strong>and</strong> the putrid water rose to the level <strong>of</strong> the<br />
sidewalks. Drunken sailors sloshed around in the liquid as if it did not<br />
exist.<br />
In broken singsong English, the whore continued propositioning<br />
me. She thought I was just trying to get the price down by claiming<br />
that I had no money. An hour elapsed, the bar was clearing out/ <strong>and</strong><br />
she gave up her efforts to secure me for the night. After I asked a<br />
few questions about her family <strong>and</strong> her home village, her mood<br />
changed. She spoke s<strong>of</strong>tly, wrapping her h<strong>and</strong>s around Iny ann. 1'd<br />
found over the years that most prostitutes could have their shells<br />
broken very easily, or not at all. But despite her earthy village qualities,<br />
her mannerisms proclaimed her pr<strong>of</strong>ession. A few <strong>of</strong> the sailors<br />
on my boat betrothed bar girls, <strong>and</strong> even when these girls rotated to<br />
the States, something always betrayed their past. I never denigrated<br />
prostitutes, as some <strong>of</strong> the other Inen did. They were just the cobras
that caught the rats that sought to rob the farmer's granary.<br />
Sometimes they drugged sailors <strong>and</strong> stole all <strong>of</strong> their possessions,<br />
even their socks. In my opinion, the hustlers only set the trap, for it<br />
was the sailors who led themselves into such a visible snare.<br />
Perhaps, this whore from a village in northeastern Thail<strong>and</strong> <strong>and</strong> I<br />
faced the same dilemma: we worked closely with people all <strong>of</strong> the<br />
time, yet experienced very little, if any, intimacy. "Okay," she said,<br />
"if you have room with air con, it free."<br />
The 72-hour liberty call ended uneventfully, orders were barked<br />
"Anchors away!", ensigns were raised, <strong>and</strong> the U.S.S. Weitz was once<br />
again underway. I decompressed quickly from a spastic comet <strong>of</strong> muscle<br />
to a naval petty <strong>of</strong>ficer in a starched white uniform. For the time<br />
being, I submitted quietly to "the way things are," but as always, I<br />
yearned to stumble across a secret trail that would lead me to a sense<br />
<strong>of</strong> well-being. The Navy provided me with consolation in the form <strong>of</strong><br />
duty <strong>and</strong> purpose; my men <strong>and</strong> my supervisor depended on me to<br />
perform important <strong>and</strong> sometimes hazardous tasks at sea. I didn't<br />
have much in common with the rest <strong>of</strong> the men in the division, but,<br />
nevertheless, there were always a few <strong>of</strong> them around for conversation,<br />
even on the nights when I couldn't sleep or when I returned to<br />
the ship after a bout <strong>of</strong> drinking.<br />
The afternoon <strong>of</strong> our departure, walking down the starboard<br />
weatherdeck, I discovered the owl perched stoically on one <strong>of</strong><br />
the overhangs. How he made it out to the weatherdeck from<br />
the depths <strong>of</strong> the aftersteering room was again a mystery. Why<br />
didn't he fly <strong>of</strong>f when we anchored at Phuket? That was his last<br />
chance to be near l<strong>and</strong> for a week. Perhaps he had been too<br />
weak. But as I looked into his yellow eyes, he slowly opened his<br />
tiny V-shaped wings.<br />
He shot <strong>of</strong>f from the overhang only to be slammed down to the<br />
steel deck by the strong sea winds whipping alongside the ship. As<br />
he tumbled down to the deck, I snatched him before he bounced<br />
over the side. As I held the little owl in my h<strong>and</strong>s, I could feel<br />
Valdez's stare <strong>and</strong> turned. He was st<strong>and</strong>ing behind me, looking<br />
serious <strong>and</strong> distant. When underway, he expected his men to work,<br />
not go<strong>of</strong> <strong>of</strong>f. But I could not allow the owl to die dishonorably, to<br />
simply plop into the ocean like a discarded Pepsi can. Surprisingly,<br />
Valdez stood quietly with his arms crossed. He looked down at the<br />
deck as sailors did when one <strong>of</strong> their own was masturbating in the<br />
toilet or sniveling in his rack when he got an "I am fucking someone<br />
else now" letter from his wife or girlfriend.<br />
After a few seconds in my h<strong>and</strong>s, the owl opened his wings<br />
again. Perhaps the heat <strong>of</strong> my h<strong>and</strong>s strengthened him. I turned Iny<br />
back to the wind, <strong>and</strong> the owl stood up in my cupped h<strong>and</strong>s as if he<br />
knew that I wanted to assist him in take<strong>of</strong>f. I hoped he would catch<br />
the wind just right <strong>and</strong> get a good gliding start. I lifted him above<br />
.my head. When the time was right, he shot from my h<strong>and</strong>s <strong>and</strong> flew.<br />
He flew low, just skimming over the waves. I thought I saw him fall<br />
into the water, but I aln not sure. II
I'd like to start with a few questions about<br />
Normal. What were some <strong>of</strong> the assumptions<br />
you had going into writing a book about<br />
transsexuals, cross-dressing heterosexuals,<br />
<strong>and</strong> the intersexed, <strong>and</strong> how correct did they<br />
prove to be? Has the experience given you a<br />
more extravagant sense <strong>of</strong> normal?<br />
I like the last part <strong>of</strong> that question because I do think it has<br />
given me a broader sense <strong>of</strong> the normal. It's also given Ine a pretty<br />
strong sense that it is people <strong>and</strong> culture, not nature, that decide<br />
what's normal. If it were up to nature, light would be as normal as<br />
health <strong>and</strong> as common, <strong>and</strong> blue potatoes as normal as yellow<br />
ones even if they are not as common. I think we tend not to notice<br />
how much we take what feels comfortable to us for granted, <strong>and</strong><br />
how Inuch we tend to use that as the bar <strong>of</strong> in fact what is nonnal,<br />
or even what is natural. I had just thought that women who had<br />
sex-change surgery were very unhappy, self-hating lesbians; that<br />
people who were opposed to surgery for intersexed babies were<br />
just crazy people with a political, gender-free agenda; <strong>and</strong> that<br />
cross-dressing heterosexual men were just kidding themselves <br />
that they were <strong>of</strong> course closeted gay men - <strong>and</strong> I didn't<br />
underst<strong>and</strong> why they couldn't just be out <strong>and</strong> proud. I think I was<br />
wrong on all three counts.<br />
C: Do you find you confront the challenge <strong>of</strong> redefining your characters<br />
when you're writing fiction too?<br />
I'm never wrong when I write fiction. That's why we like to write
fiction. It's our world, as long as we are playing by rules that people<br />
can accustom themselves to. That's why there are people who write<br />
novels set in a time other than our own, whether it's the future or the<br />
past - if you play by certain kinds <strong>of</strong> rules <strong>of</strong> normative behavior,<br />
people can adjust. If you don't, it gets much harder to read. There's a<br />
reason that great science fiction is a lot easier to read than Gravity's<br />
Rainbow. Even if it's 3,000 years in the future <strong>and</strong> there is no gravit,y,<br />
science fiction will still play by certain kinds <strong>of</strong> rules that you can recognize<br />
in a way that language with Gravity's Rainbow, let's say, doesn't<br />
really. You have to be prepared to accolnrnodate yourself to a whole set<br />
<strong>of</strong> new rules which you are discovering as you are reading, which is<br />
more work. What was easier about writing the nonfiction book was<br />
that I had my characters. But it was harder to shape interesting dialogue,<br />
because I didn't get to write it for them.<br />
e: What does a narrative arc look like to you? Do you feel there<br />
always has to be one?<br />
Yeah, otherwise it's a sketch or an anecdote. I actively dislike <strong>and</strong><br />
sometimes even resent somebody h<strong>and</strong>ing me eight pages <strong>of</strong> character<br />
description - <strong>and</strong> then the flower pot falls on her head - <strong>and</strong><br />
saying that's a short story. It's like, no it's not. One little weird event<br />
taking place does not a story make. I think short-story writers tend<br />
to fall under the category <strong>of</strong> the "interesting characterI good dialogue"<br />
writer, <strong>and</strong> the "I've got a great idea <strong>and</strong> now I'll just try to<br />
make up some cardboard figures to carry it around" writer. Those<br />
are both disappointing, <strong>and</strong> I tend to be even less interested in the<br />
"big idealcardboard characters" story. Things have to happen as<br />
they do in life, in a way which gives people an opportunity to reveal<br />
the depths <strong>and</strong> complexities <strong>of</strong> their character. The truth is, even if a<br />
bus hits you <strong>and</strong> decapitates you, it doesn't matter much to me as a<br />
reader if I haven't been interested in you as a character in the first<br />
place. You want a depth <strong>of</strong> feeling to lead to powerful language,<br />
<strong>and</strong> a depth <strong>of</strong> empathy <strong>and</strong> imagination to lead to characters who<br />
are three-dimensional about whom you care. Three-dimensional<br />
<strong>and</strong> sympathetic in the sense that they resonate with the reader - not<br />
sympathetic in the sense one likes them necessarily.<br />
G: Do you think that makes you more or less trustful <strong>of</strong> your readers?<br />
You've said that you trust your readers to be as smart as you, but<br />
otherwise you don't think <strong>of</strong> them.<br />
It's easy for them. Two pages in, they can put n1Y book in the<br />
waste-can - they can put it back on the bookshelf, return it to the<br />
library, tell everybody how much it sucks. I'm prepared to think that if I<br />
can't catch their attention in the first couple <strong>of</strong> pages, they will do with<br />
me as they will. In terms <strong>of</strong> their trust, you're sort <strong>of</strong> in there pitching.<br />
You keep trying to write the best sentence you know how about the<br />
lnost compelling story you can. But they have no obligation to me. I<br />
feel like it's my job to give my readers a world worth being in, <strong>and</strong><br />
then I hope that they can be in it. It's not that I don't want them to<br />
think; it's that I don't want them to have to be painfully conscious <strong>of</strong><br />
the fact that the little black marks on the white page signify letters<br />
which make words which make sentences, <strong>and</strong> you can see all that<br />
sweat <strong>and</strong> effort on the part <strong>of</strong> the writer. I don't care when I'm<br />
reading. I don't care if it took the author 10 years to write that shitty<br />
sentence or five minutes. If it's not good, it's not good.<br />
e: What makes a good sentence for you?<br />
Lots <strong>of</strong> people have great opening sentences. But when you're in<br />
the middle <strong>of</strong> a piece <strong>of</strong> fiction, I think it has more to do with how the<br />
bricks are laid on either side <strong>of</strong> it. How sentence one leads to sentence<br />
two leads to sentence three. And sometimes there are those sentences<br />
that just leap out like dialnonds on black velvet. Those, for me, have<br />
a certain restrained lyricism, restrained being the significant word. I<br />
like to feel that there's all this feeling pressing against the shape <strong>of</strong><br />
the sentence. So that it has a nice integrity <strong>and</strong> muscularity, <strong>and</strong> this<br />
pulsing, beating heart inside <strong>of</strong> it as well.<br />
c: How much would you say you like experimenting, formally or not?<br />
Are there any elements <strong>of</strong> fiction you stay faithful to?<br />
I don't think that I'm much <strong>of</strong> an experimenter. Having had no<br />
formal education in this, I don't ever have a sense <strong>of</strong> "I know I was<br />
taught X, but now I'm going to try Y." Nobody ever taught me X.<br />
When I wrote a short story in which all four characters' points <strong>of</strong> view<br />
were present I didn't ever really feel like you can't do more than one<br />
point <strong>of</strong> view in a short story. Why not? vVhy can't you walk around
the room <strong>and</strong> see what everyone's thinking? I am more cominitted to<br />
being faithful to what I feel is good writing <strong>and</strong> a true sentence <strong>and</strong><br />
writing about the things that matter than I am to any particular form<br />
or format. I don't want to make fast food. There's nothing wrong<br />
with fast food - I eat it, I just don't want to make it. I feel it's very<br />
hard to write a really good book with no heart. There's that great line<br />
<strong>of</strong> John Gardner's in which he says the sin <strong>of</strong> 19th-century literature<br />
is sentimentality, whereas the sin <strong>of</strong> modern literature is that it has no<br />
heart. To me the besetting sin now is a mixture <strong>of</strong> sentimentality <strong>and</strong><br />
irony the worst <strong>of</strong> both worlds. You read some <strong>of</strong> this stuff <strong>and</strong><br />
you go: Oh my God, so let's see, it's all about you <strong>and</strong> how Inuch<br />
you are better than everybody around you, but you don't want anybody<br />
to think that so you write in a really self-deprecating way but<br />
with enough irony that it will be apparent to us that the point <strong>of</strong> this<br />
is poor me. I'd rather read Little Dorrit. Or something with a great antihero<br />
like The Eustace Diamonds. She [Lizzie GreystockYs just bad to<br />
the bone, but Trollope actually sympathizes with her. And she's not<br />
bad to the bone in an arch, unrealistic, winking way. She's just a bad<br />
person, <strong>and</strong> I think that's a great character. The truth is, we are not so<br />
much aware <strong>of</strong> bad writers <strong>of</strong> previous centuries because they don't<br />
last. And I can promise you, 75 years from now people are not going<br />
to be discussing most <strong>of</strong> the books in that window <strong>and</strong> saying, oh<br />
that was a bad crop. No one will have read it <strong>and</strong> nobody will care.<br />
e: Would you agree that fiction is not true to life, but truer than it?<br />
I think that's what one hopes for. You hope that people can't tell<br />
the difference between the thing that happened <strong>and</strong> the thing that<br />
didn't. I always take it as a great compliment when people argue with<br />
me. They'll say, I know you must have a summer hOlne in Maine <br />
I'm like no, actually, never been to Maine. When Come To Me came<br />
out, there's a story in it about a girl with a psychotic sister. I have an<br />
older sister who's a lawyer, a very slim, fierce, attractive brunette. I'd<br />
read "Silver Water" <strong>and</strong> people would COlne up to me crying <strong>and</strong><br />
sympathizing <strong>and</strong> saying, "I'm so sorry you lost your sister." And my<br />
sister'd be sitting in the back going, "I'm fine, I'm just fine." That's<br />
why we call it fiction. But it's a great complhnent. You want people to<br />
feel that it's truer than life only in the sense that you are given more to<br />
hold onto <strong>and</strong> contemplate. In life things either happen so slowly one<br />
can hardly bear to live through them, or so quickly you hardly notice<br />
thein. In fiction, you try to split the difference.<br />
G: SO doesn't that make changing characters Inore difficult than<br />
changing the action in a story?<br />
AB: As in real life. If somebody I know well does something that makes<br />
no sense, I either have to say to myself I didn't really know her very<br />
"well, or I have to conclude that I've misunderstood or misinterpreted<br />
the action. In fiction, if I have my nice, quiet, good-hearted <strong>and</strong> generous<br />
character take a kitten in <strong>of</strong>f the street, give it a bowl <strong>of</strong> milk <strong>and</strong><br />
eviscerate it (I guess I think that would be interesting), I have a problem.<br />
Because either the character is genuinely good-hearted - in which<br />
case the action is impossible - or I have lied to you <strong>and</strong> led you to<br />
believe that she is good-hearted but she is not - in which case I have<br />
no business telling you she's good-hearted. I can indicate to you that<br />
she appears to be good-hearted, but that's different. If the behavior<br />
doesn't fit the character, then you have a responsibility to underst<strong>and</strong><br />
who you have created. I think a lot <strong>of</strong> time, people don't create sufficiently<br />
three-dimensional characters for it to even arise as a difficulty. If<br />
you have a character that's sufficiently big, they can do almost anything<br />
- which is great for plot, but lousy for staYing power.<br />
G: Did you grow up in a literary household? Who were some <strong>of</strong> your<br />
literary influences?<br />
I didn't really experience it as such, but there were books in the<br />
house, <strong>and</strong> we went to the library every week. Nobody cared what I<br />
read. It was a literary household in the most passive way - in the way<br />
it was a middle-class household, or in the way in which I had my own<br />
bedroom. Most <strong>of</strong> the books in the house were in my Dad's library: lots<br />
<strong>of</strong> Leon Uris <strong>and</strong> James Michener. I was very attached to his post<br />
World War II library - John O'Hara, Dorothy Parker, Robert Benchley,<br />
S.J. Perelman, Ring Lardner, Saki, John Collier. I don't think I'm as<br />
funny as S01l1e <strong>of</strong> those people, or as fey <strong>and</strong> adorably odd as John<br />
Collier or Saki. But there is a fundamental sense in all <strong>of</strong> those writers<br />
that it is better to call things as they are that sentiment actually was<br />
pretty funny, but it didn't mean that it didn't matter. I'm very big on<br />
dead writers, <strong>and</strong> poets. And I don't mind if the poets are living,<br />
because their lives are so hard. You can always say to yourself, at least<br />
I'm not a poet.<br />
C: You began, <strong>and</strong> still are active, in the field <strong>of</strong> psychotherapy.<br />
Yes, <strong>and</strong> I still have a small practice. Really I began as a waitress.<br />
And I worked in a theater company for a while. Then I went to<br />
graduate school, then I became a shrink, then I started writing.
c: How did that last transition occur?<br />
AB: I was on my way to becoming a psychoanalyst. I had a meeting<br />
with the guy who was going to be my training analyst; we had a very<br />
nice chat. As I was coming home I drove past Wesleyan University,<br />
which is where I'd gone to college, <strong>and</strong> I remembered how I had bartended<br />
an event at the President's house when I was an undergraduate.<br />
I remembered all these old guys sitting on the settee - 95-year-old<br />
alums - <strong>and</strong> I thought it would be so funny if one <strong>of</strong> them just died.<br />
That led to the idea for a mystery. My kids had left their McDonald's<br />
hamburger boxes in the front seat, so I wrote some notes on the hamburger<br />
boxes. When I got home I took out my little Olivetti typewriter<br />
<strong>and</strong> I had about 15 pages <strong>of</strong> story <strong>and</strong> I was like, Oh look at that, story!<br />
I guess I'll do that for a while. So I called the guy who was going to be<br />
my analyst <strong>and</strong> said, "You know, it looks like I have something else to<br />
do." So then I started writing this mystery, which I was probably<br />
drawn to because I understood the conventions <strong>of</strong> a mystery - I wasn't<br />
very good at them, but I understood them. And then the short stories<br />
started showing up, so I wrote them. The very first story I wrote<br />
I don't even remember the name <strong>of</strong> it, it's in Come to Me, when Galen is<br />
in love with Henry <strong>and</strong> decides not to leave her husb<strong>and</strong> David. That<br />
["The Sight <strong>of</strong> You"] is the first story I ever wrote. And the second<br />
story was "Love Is Not a Pie," which got published, <strong>and</strong> the third story<br />
I wrote was "Silver Water."<br />
C: How should a story balance showing <strong>and</strong> telling?<br />
AB: In a short story, you don't want to shortchange yourself. You don't<br />
want to not have the great narrative moments, but still you want to<br />
make most things happen right in front <strong>of</strong> the eyes <strong>of</strong> the reader. I<br />
don't think any story is interesting unless more than one story is being<br />
told. Otherwise it's missing the great thing that Will Durant said <br />
that history is the lives lived on the riverbanks, the fire, the children<br />
born, the old people who die, meals made, people making love, people<br />
doing laundry, <strong>and</strong> the river <strong>of</strong> blood that runs between the banks <strong>of</strong><br />
the river, which is famine <strong>and</strong> war <strong>and</strong> catastrophe <strong>and</strong> cruelty. You<br />
can't tell the history about the lives on the riverbanks <strong>and</strong> the river<br />
without these.<br />
C: At some point when you're writing about the riverbank <strong>and</strong> the<br />
river, do you feel a story becomes its own story?<br />
AB: It does become its own story. You leap <strong>of</strong>f from the characters or the<br />
impulse or the moment in your own real life. I feel perfectly capable <strong>of</strong><br />
getting my point across in real life without resorting to fiction. I don't<br />
think a lot <strong>of</strong> people don't know what I think. So why would I have to<br />
put it on the page if it's going to mess up the novel? Things can creep<br />
into your fiction but by <strong>and</strong> large, I would rather protect my family.<br />
C: In "Love Is Not a Pie," you begin with the narrator at her mother's<br />
funeral <strong>and</strong> then go back to the summer when, as a teenager, she discovers<br />
the dynamics <strong>of</strong> her parents' relationship, which happens to<br />
include a lover. Why do you think it's important to have a reason to<br />
set the reminiscence in motion in a story in which much <strong>of</strong> the narrative<br />
is told in flashback?<br />
AB: I think that story began with the opening line <strong>and</strong> emerged in my<br />
head in the present. And there were two points <strong>of</strong> view I could tell the<br />
story from. I could tell it from the woman having the affair, but she's<br />
either going to be indifferent to the pain she's causing or she's going to<br />
need a lot <strong>of</strong> self-justification. Whereas a kid for whom life is idyllic<br />
<strong>and</strong> turns out to be much more complicated, that is more interesting to<br />
me. I've always been interested in how we try to make sense <strong>of</strong> what<br />
we've seen - where what we see is not what we thought we saw.<br />
What people do in response to the event is how you know who they<br />
are. It's never the event. Four people get hit by a bus - one <strong>of</strong> them is<br />
going to be in a wheelchair, one is going to walk away unharmed, one<br />
is going to walk away unharmed but be so psychologically struck he'll<br />
be in a wheelchair, <strong>and</strong> somebody else will take it as a sign from God<br />
that they should go become a priest. It's not the bus hitting you, it's<br />
what people do in response. II
wheel. ''It won't drop any needles on the new carpet," we were told,<br />
but we spent most <strong>of</strong> the season in the early American family room<br />
with the look-<strong>of</strong>-brick linoleum floor, the gas-jet fireplace, <strong>and</strong> the<br />
console television. Christmas Eve, as we always had <strong>and</strong> always<br />
would, we went south <strong>of</strong> the river to Marge <strong>and</strong> Doc's. But that year,<br />
we left early with our packaged dog, fully upholstered in white<br />
curls except for b<strong>and</strong>s <strong>of</strong> apricot in her ears <strong>and</strong> brownish clumps <strong>of</strong><br />
drying tears accumulating around the corners <strong>of</strong> her eyes. Gigi was<br />
bound for Park Plaza.<br />
She slept her first night on a blanket in the kitchen, surrounded<br />
by newspapers, whimpering herself to sleep to the ticking <strong>of</strong> a<br />
Baby Ben alarm clock. We wedged a lawn-chair box into the doorway<br />
<strong>of</strong> the family room to confine her <strong>and</strong> her puddles to the<br />
kitchen. The next morning, when she didn't eat, we coaxed her into<br />
trying some raw egg, whipped into a bowl <strong>of</strong> milk. At first she<br />
seelned canine enough, slipping across the waxed floor in pursuit<br />
or evasion <strong>of</strong> fourth- <strong>and</strong> eighth-grade playmates. With all her hair<br />
<strong>and</strong> some residual instincts, Davis's Gigi Canella Petite Monet, as<br />
she was registered, seemed thoroughly in<strong>of</strong>fensive, even playful.<br />
But as she grew, she developed the combined genetic weaknesses<br />
<strong>of</strong> all the scrawny, sickly poodles who were forcibly mated to<br />
Inanufacture the toy species. Gigi was not merely a dog but a purposefully<br />
designed mobile ornament, fully compatible with earnest<br />
suburban living. Not a blank slate at birth, but a living Rorschach,<br />
mirroring our ambitions, our sentimentality, our confused early<br />
60's notions <strong>of</strong> femininity.<br />
The neutered dog regained her gender in monthly appointments<br />
at the poodle salon. Mom called, "Gigi, want to go bye-bye in the<br />
car?" Slipping <strong>and</strong> padding her way across the linoleum, Gigi<br />
hurled herself, a nervous comet <strong>of</strong> white hair, into my mom's arms<br />
for the Buick excursion to the Tapscott Groomers. Gigi returned to<br />
Park Plaza a needle-nosed composite <strong>of</strong> geometric shapes, sculpted<br />
into cotton balls <strong>and</strong> toothpicks, like atomic art. A sponge bow<br />
adorned her vertical top-knot, matching ones tied to each <strong>of</strong> her<br />
ears. A wide ring shaved around her belly gave her an hour-glass<br />
figure. Legs were shorn, the pink <strong>and</strong> grey bony limbs ending in<br />
white balls, like the one on her tail, just over her naked toes. Her<br />
nails were painted red, alternating red <strong>and</strong> green at Christmas, <strong>and</strong><br />
she smelled <strong>of</strong> Chanel No.5 near her rhinestone collar. Newly visible,<br />
her eyes were larger, still watering around the shaved bulges<br />
beneath them. On her return, Gigi was meaner, maybe because we<br />
could see her black lips, her red gums, her teeth newly cleaned.<br />
She walked more tentatively, the cool floor annoying her paw pads,<br />
their cushioning gone. "She's almost human," Mom would say as<br />
Gigi minced across the gold carpet in the living room <strong>and</strong> posed,<br />
front legs crossed, on the brocade s<strong>of</strong>a. Later, much later in dog<br />
years, she simply refused to walk on uncarpeted floors, whining<br />
from the hallway till we arranged a path <strong>of</strong> early American throw<br />
rugs across the linoleum to the sliding glass patio door. Soon<br />
enough her bows fell out, her hair returned, <strong>and</strong> she became a dog<br />
again - but only to begin the process anew as a scented work <strong>of</strong><br />
topiary whining from the hall.<br />
Gigi didn't eat dog food, no matter what Euclidean shape it<br />
assumed. Instead, she ate fried haInburger, dutifully drained on a<br />
paper towel, <strong>and</strong> an occasional ice cream cone: "Gigi weegee want<br />
a dog yummy?" Slipping, clattering nails, s<strong>of</strong>t collisions, red gums<br />
clamping the cone. She didn't chew on the furniture. When life<br />
produced poodle-stress, Gigi would sit <strong>and</strong> gnaw on her front legs<br />
till they bled. Eventually we purchased special snap-on plastic<br />
casts to save her legs <strong>and</strong> our upholstery. She didn't shed. When<br />
she began to lose her puppy teeth <strong>and</strong> we found one under a bed,<br />
we put it in sentimental cotton in an empty Inedicine bottle <strong>and</strong><br />
shelved it in the basement. Once trained, Gigi never peed on the<br />
floor. We'd slide open the patio door: "Do you need to do your<br />
job?" One winter night after a recent trimming, Gigi's feet becaIne<br />
chilled in a drift, <strong>and</strong> she lifted them one at a time until she lay<br />
down defeated in the snow. We collected her, brought her inside,<br />
<strong>and</strong> put her in the pink, inflated bonnet <strong>of</strong> my sister's hairdryer till<br />
she stopped quivering. We ordered a sweater for her to wear after<br />
her winter trimlnings.<br />
In the summer, she ran around the yard <strong>and</strong> even panted. Then<br />
she jumped on top <strong>of</strong> a chaise longue, Inade <strong>of</strong> giant pink plastic<br />
b<strong>and</strong>s stretched around an aluminum frame, always forgetting that<br />
her feet pushed through the b<strong>and</strong>s, leaving her stuck to her annpits<br />
in the chair. We made her wear sunglasses, just long enough to snap<br />
her picture with our Polaroid Swinger in a tolerant but uneasy Lolita<br />
pose, legs crossed into perverse poodle allure.<br />
Gigi was never a very popular dog. Yapping at the neighbors<br />
through the chain-link fence, or lunging toward the bay window<br />
with poodle ferocity when the mail came, didn't endear her to her<br />
casual acquaintances. Linda's high school friends, who rarely Caine<br />
past the entry hall, regarded Gigi as a kind <strong>of</strong> biological satire. In<br />
tie-dyed shirts, John Lennon sunglasses, <strong>and</strong> wide bell-bottoms,<br />
they were stoned enough to view her with amusement, at best. They hadn't<br />
nlnl 1'11
stopped the other day. Another bad name someone had ever called<br />
me was Spic but I don't really care because I know the person is<br />
playing with me <strong>and</strong> when he gets on my nerves I call him<br />
Hamburger Helper. His name is Rajick."<br />
"How is Manny getting called a spic like Daniel getting called a<br />
faggot?" I asked.<br />
Silence. "It's not," Shabazz suggested, ''being gay is totally different<br />
than being Latino."<br />
True. My lesson plan, I realized, was deeply flawed. It was also<br />
designed to manipulate how my students thought. I wanted to make<br />
them more liberal-minded - I wanted to make them think like me.<br />
I remembered my discomfort when my supervisor had announced<br />
that our goal should be not only to teach our students writing, but to<br />
make them ''better people."<br />
I.. II<br />
A Union soldier serving in the South said <strong>of</strong> the freedman,<br />
"Human or not, there he is in our midst, millions strong; <strong>and</strong> if he is<br />
not educated mentally <strong>and</strong> morally, he will make us trouble."<br />
We do not trust children to find their own morality. Too <strong>of</strong>ten we<br />
educate them only so that they will not make us trouble. We want to<br />
use their voices in our commercials.<br />
When I argue with my students, I <strong>of</strong>ten have the sensation that I<br />
am actually arguing with people other than them. I think I hear the<br />
voices <strong>of</strong> their fathers, or the voices <strong>of</strong> their gym teachers. They<br />
speak in slightly mutilated catch phrases. I speak cautiously, with<br />
the suspicion that my students will repeat my words back to their<br />
fathers <strong>and</strong> gym teachers. This is how children become foot soldiers<br />
in conflicts between adults.<br />
Jill III<br />
"Okay, then just tell me this," I said to my students, "what is so<br />
bad about being gay? What was so bad about your teacher, for<br />
example. Why did you throw your markers at him?"<br />
"If teachers are gay it is really bad because they can take you into<br />
a room <strong>and</strong> try to touch you," Manny answered.<br />
I stared at Manny, "I could take you into a room <strong>and</strong> touch you.<br />
Anyone could."<br />
He stared back, daring me to. I had gotten into all the wrong territory,<br />
I had dropped the third person. He shook his head, "No." I<br />
was beginning to worry about losing my job.<br />
"What else, what else is so bad about it?"<br />
"God made men to be with women, so it's against God," said<br />
Marissalee.<br />
Oh, no. I hadn't anticipated this. Students were agreeing, the room<br />
was getting noisy. I imagined that flash point was creeping up on me.<br />
I was destined to leave this room with Magic Marker on my face or<br />
having, like another teacher, tried to throw a kid out the window.<br />
"Yeah," said Shabazz, "<strong>and</strong> on that TV show the one man is gay<br />
<strong>and</strong> he dropped a quarter so that the other man would pick it up <strong>and</strong><br />
then he could look at his butt."<br />
I didn't underst<strong>and</strong> the crime in this, but it was clear that my students<br />
were moved. "Yeah, yeah!" They were all agreeing <strong>and</strong> laughing<br />
<strong>and</strong> remembering more stories about gay people they had seen on TV.<br />
How had I gotten myself into this? I had intended to teach writing.<br />
K,.<br />
During my first year <strong>of</strong> teaching, I found that I said, "Quiet!" more<br />
than anything else.<br />
I <strong>of</strong>ten heard other teachers using terms like "classroom management,"<br />
"reinforcement," <strong>and</strong> "discipline." Surprisingly, "empowerment"<br />
was also popular. Teachers misused that term all the time.<br />
They developed "empowering" exercises like letting the students<br />
draft their own rules, but the rules were always the same. True<br />
empowerment <strong>of</strong> students, I realized very quickly, necessarily means<br />
a certain disempowerment <strong>of</strong> teachers.<br />
Teachers habitually abuse their power by wrongly defining words.<br />
There is a sign in the math classroom where I used to work that says,<br />
"Caring means learning the terms <strong>and</strong> remembering them." Other<br />
signs in that school reminded me <strong>of</strong> the chapters <strong>of</strong> Brinskerh<strong>of</strong>f's<br />
1864 Advice to Freedmen: "Be Industrious," "Be Economical," "Be<br />
Temperate," <strong>and</strong> "Be Soldiers." II
y Priscilla Becker selected poems<br />
Vil/anelle<br />
Of all the creatures in all the worlds<br />
You wrote when I had waited long<br />
I think the prettiest thing is birds.<br />
Among those beauties wrapped in furs,<br />
From all the bodies sleek <strong>and</strong> strong,<br />
Of all the creatures in all the worlds?<br />
I thought your vision must be blurred<br />
By dizzying flights <strong>of</strong> sparrow throng<br />
To think the prettiest thing is birds.<br />
Perhaps I'd been too long immured<br />
To hear their slllall <strong>and</strong> separate song<br />
FrOin all the creatures in all the worlds.<br />
Your brown eyes <strong>of</strong>ten go obscure<br />
And seem to nothing to belong<br />
Unless the taxidermist's doe-eyed bird.<br />
When all along I'd thought it words!<br />
You wrote when I had waited long<br />
Of all the creatures in all the worlds<br />
I think the prettiest thing is birds.<br />
The Sound <strong>of</strong> the Closing Door<br />
There is a kind <strong>of</strong> cry at first,<br />
not <strong>of</strong> pain but <strong>of</strong> warning<br />
<strong>of</strong> pain.<br />
I have come to regard the wide arms<br />
<strong>of</strong> the chair as an only Inother.<br />
Next a small suck <strong>of</strong> air.<br />
I think my double is<br />
the stone - fire-wrought or dripped<br />
into formation. And there was<br />
a third kind too.<br />
Then two dry clicks, an interlocking.<br />
It seems that it should be my lot<br />
to look out on a line strung<br />
from post to post,<br />
<strong>and</strong> though it could be missed,<br />
the dusk reminder <strong>of</strong> the small<br />
daily apocalypse.<br />
It is this third kind I relate to.<br />
The first fragment <strong>of</strong> division,<br />
the private room.
. ...<br />
half like Selma <strong>and</strong> half like an ab<strong>and</strong>oned doctor. Selma waved her<br />
h<strong>and</strong> in front <strong>of</strong> her face, an attempt at scattering the pieces <strong>of</strong> this vision<br />
about the air. As she was leaving <strong>and</strong> zipping up the door, Selma considered<br />
scribbling out a note to Nabil, but what would she tell hun?<br />
When Selma returned, the woman was already in her car, the<br />
engine revving, tailpipe spitting a plume <strong>of</strong> exhaust.<br />
On the way out <strong>of</strong> the forest, the women talked. Helga had emigrated<br />
from Germany 30 years before <strong>and</strong> had been moving around ever<br />
since. Egypt, Selma had <strong>of</strong>fered in return. I<br />
She glanced at<br />
the speedometer:<br />
45, 50, 55. She<br />
had afold <strong>of</strong> bills in<br />
her pocket, burning<br />
against her thigh,<br />
enough to buy a<br />
plane ticket.<br />
came from Egypt two months ago. "I was<br />
there in the '60s," Helga continued now.<br />
"And I fell in love with it. Just fell in love."<br />
A road atlas with a broken spine lay on<br />
the floor by Selma's feet. Selma gently<br />
nudged two overlapping pages apart to<br />
reveal a map <strong>of</strong> Toronto. Something<br />
pinched her from inside, a sensation she<br />
had been having frequently since she'd<br />
arrived in Canada. The car smelled stale,<br />
the air it contained, years, centuries old. It<br />
reminded her <strong>of</strong> grade-school trips to the<br />
Pyramids, crawling into airless tombs<br />
where she'd held her breath, afraid that if<br />
she inhaled she would die. The tombs had<br />
been pillaged centuries before, the mummies long gone, still they had<br />
smelled <strong>of</strong> death, Selma thought. Wind spilled in through the window.<br />
The cool, constant slap <strong>of</strong> clean air against her skin made it numb.<br />
''Will you go back there?" Helga asked. Her hair was long, blonde<br />
<strong>and</strong> gray at once. She let go the steering wheel in order to gather her<br />
hair into a quick bun on the top <strong>of</strong> her head. She had a small but<br />
strong body. A muscle in her bare right thigh twisted against her skin<br />
each time she switched froln the accelerator to the brake.<br />
Lola sat on her lap. Selma knew this was dangerous, but wasn't life<br />
itself dangerous? Precautions felt arbitrary. "I shall go back there now,"<br />
she said with sudden, alien authority. The idea had only come to her<br />
minutes before. When Selma had gotten into Helga's car, she'd had no<br />
designs on a destination. Ofcourse! she thought now. I'm going home.<br />
Warmth crept frOln the top <strong>of</strong> her head down through her stomach. She<br />
glanced at the speedOlneter: 45,50, 55. She had a fold <strong>of</strong> bills in her<br />
pocket, burning against her thigh, enough to buy a plane ticket. It was<br />
the money Nabil never traveled without: emergency mone)!, he called it.<br />
She had taken it from the inside pocket <strong>of</strong> his jacket on her way out <strong>of</strong> the<br />
tent without remorse. If anything did, this pain that she felt constituted<br />
an emergency.<br />
"It becomes harder <strong>and</strong> harder to go back the longer you stay away/'<br />
Helga said as they sped through unfamiliar l<strong>and</strong>scapes.<br />
Selma noticed a blurred fruit st<strong>and</strong> that looked like someplace she<br />
had seen before. Then she realized that it was just like all <strong>of</strong> its counterparts<br />
back home; many <strong>of</strong> the same fruits available in Egypt, the same<br />
bright colors. The only difference was that here the price was by pound<br />
<strong>and</strong> was written in English.<br />
"Are you married?" Helga paused.<br />
"Her father is my husb<strong>and</strong>; he is back in Egypt, where we are going<br />
now to be with him," Selma answered. The words filed out <strong>of</strong> her mouth<br />
one-by-one; each one that came out surprised her more than the last. "My<br />
sister lives in Toronto. She was having a surgery. I came to be with her."<br />
"What kind <strong>of</strong> operation?"<br />
Selma paused, conjuring images <strong>of</strong> her two healthy sisters back in<br />
Cairo. She evicted them from her mind <strong>and</strong> invented a new one, a<br />
woman with a malady <strong>of</strong>... "She was losing one eye. She made a surgery<br />
to fix it."<br />
"And did it work?"<br />
''Yes. Now she see again." Selma turned to look at her new companion.<br />
''Why you came here?" she asked.<br />
"After the war," Helga said. She slowed her driving <strong>and</strong> glanced at<br />
Selma. "That's when I left."<br />
A few seconds passed. "It was terrible?" Selma finally <strong>of</strong>fered.<br />
''Well, I lived through it." Helga swerved sharply around an idling car.<br />
"Of course. It is a blessing."<br />
''Do you believe in God?" Helga asked abruptly after a pause, a long<br />
curve in the road.<br />
Last year, even last month, this would have been a question easily<br />
answered: Yes. But now Selma wondered what she believed in. How<br />
could your own life become something you couldn't recognize? Selma<br />
caught a view <strong>of</strong> herself in the small, tilted mirror <strong>of</strong>f the side <strong>of</strong> the car.<br />
Her hair was long <strong>and</strong> loose <strong>and</strong> tangled. She hadn't washed it for<br />
days. There were deep, dark shadows underneath her coal-colored eyes.<br />
Her husb<strong>and</strong> called her beautiful, but she could not see why.<br />
The car filled with silence, like a balloon exp<strong>and</strong>ing to the point <strong>of</strong><br />
almost bursting. Helga unrolled her window <strong>and</strong> rested an elbow on<br />
the open frame.<br />
Finally Selma said, ''Why you were in Egypt?"<br />
JlMy husb<strong>and</strong> was a journalist, <strong>and</strong> Egypt was his specialty."
"What did he find?" Selma asked anxiously.<br />
"He wrote on Egypt after the Revolution. Nasser <strong>and</strong> the rise <strong>of</strong> the<br />
Muslim Brothers. Nationalization <strong>of</strong> the Suez ..."<br />
Selma's own husb<strong>and</strong> was among the young who had fought for<br />
revolution in the early 1950s, who rioted against the British, who spent<br />
time in prison. He knew about Egypt, Selma thought, surprising herself<br />
with the sudden swell <strong>of</strong> pride in her gut; what could Helga's husb<strong>and</strong><br />
possibly underst<strong>and</strong>?<br />
Lola bounced around on Selma's lap <strong>and</strong> laughed at a dog in a<br />
passing window. "Darling," Helga cooed, glancing away from the road<br />
<strong>and</strong> patting the top <strong>of</strong> Lola's head. Selma's stomach clenched, noticing<br />
the stranger's h<strong>and</strong> on her baby.<br />
''You have a child?" Selma asked, drawing her arms more tightly<br />
around her daughter, who squirmed against the change in pressure.<br />
Helga looked ahead <strong>and</strong> let a car pass in front <strong>of</strong> her. Selma<br />
watched the side <strong>of</strong> her silent face. The car ahead sped into the distance<br />
<strong>and</strong> disappeared. "I had one."<br />
Selma rolled up her window - the streaming wind suddenly too<br />
much, too loud. "What. What happened?"<br />
"Mechanical failure. Something with the engine-" her voice<br />
trailed <strong>of</strong>f. Moments later Helga cleared her throat: "A plane crash. The<br />
planehad been in the air for not longer than 10 minutes. I took them to<br />
the airport. I watched it take <strong>of</strong>f. I waved as it did. I always wondered<br />
if they saw me."<br />
"Maybe they did," Selma said feebly.<br />
"Maybe."<br />
"How long ago?"<br />
"Fifteen years now."<br />
"I am sorry."<br />
A pair <strong>of</strong> dark sunglasses rested on the dashboard. Helga reached<br />
for them <strong>and</strong> pushed thein onto her face.<br />
"Are you hungry?" Helga said suddenly, as if this were the solution,<br />
exactly what was needed to rescue them both.<br />
"Yes," Selma said before taking a moment to consider whether or<br />
not she was.<br />
A young waitress approached the table that Helga had chosen. She<br />
brought a wet cloth, which she used to wipe a smear <strong>of</strong> ketchup from<br />
the wooden surface. Booths with bright red vinyl seats lined the<br />
periphery <strong>of</strong> the diner. The surfaces <strong>of</strong> the tables were white, shellacked.<br />
Yellow lamps the shape <strong>of</strong> inverted salad bowls hung low<br />
above each table, <strong>and</strong> dim bulbs shone within them.<br />
"Sorry 'bout that," the waitress said. ''Be right back with menus." She<br />
left a wet, glistening streak on the table. Itformed a crooked line between<br />
Selma <strong>and</strong> Helga, which Selma watched until it dried <strong>and</strong> disappeared.<br />
''Your husb<strong>and</strong> was also on that plane?" Selma asked hesitantly.<br />
Helga nodded, but her expression was different from the one she had<br />
worn in the car, now distant <strong>and</strong> veiled, as if it was someone else's<br />
tragedy they were talking about.<br />
Lola bounced on the seat, her small fingers gripping the window, leaving<br />
tiny fingerprints. Selma wanted to make her daughter stop bouncing.<br />
She pulled Lola firmly down, eliciting a small, high-pitched cry. Out <strong>of</strong><br />
the corner <strong>of</strong> her eye, Selma noticed Helga watching them, tilting her<br />
head <strong>and</strong> observing each detail. Lola slapped at the air in front <strong>of</strong> her<br />
while making angry sounds. She was alive. Everything she did suddenly<br />
seemed potent, something to remind Helga <strong>of</strong> what she had lost.<br />
Selma looked out the window, half expecting to see Nabil walking<br />
toward theIn, his slow <strong>and</strong> careful stride. Instead she saw another man<br />
in the parking lot. She thought again <strong>of</strong> Mustafa. The hood <strong>of</strong> the truck<br />
stood open <strong>and</strong> the stranger bent his head over what it revealed. He<br />
adjusted something. He lowered the hood. Once he was back in his car,<br />
it started, <strong>and</strong> he drove away.<br />
Selma turned to notice the tap <strong>of</strong> Helga's fingers against the table's<br />
surface. If she went back to Cairo, would she move back in with her<br />
parents, she <strong>and</strong> Lola back into the room she had grown up in, the<br />
room she had shared with Nabil for those months after their marriage?<br />
Noone would marry her now: a woman with a child who had left a<br />
husb<strong>and</strong> behind. The thought <strong>of</strong> it got her heart pounding, sent too<br />
much blood to her head.<br />
The waitress returned with menus. As Selma began to read down the<br />
columns <strong>of</strong> laminated options, she felt the immensity <strong>of</strong> her sudden<br />
hunger. She wanted it all, everything. Ketchup was one <strong>of</strong> the things<br />
she liked about Canada - she ordered a hamburger, well done, with<br />
French fries <strong>and</strong> a side salad. Helga ordered a tuna melt.<br />
"I loved SOineone before my husb<strong>and</strong>," Selma confessed to Helga<br />
once the waitress was gone.<br />
"Do you love him still?"<br />
''I do not know." She had put Mustafa out <strong>of</strong> her mind through the rush<br />
<strong>of</strong> her wedding, becoming pregnant, having the baby;. moving to America,<br />
but in the past weeks he had moved back in again. Every night in the tent<br />
after Lola had gone to bed, Nabil approached like a shy teenager, kissing<br />
Selma's cheek for minutes before growing bolder. Each night it ended in<br />
sex, <strong>and</strong> while Selma tried to focus on her husb<strong>and</strong>'s body careening above<br />
her, she felt nothing until she closed her eyes <strong>and</strong> pictured Mustafa.
assortment <strong>of</strong> needles, catheters, tubing, drugs, <strong>and</strong> something called a<br />
''basic tray." (A basic tray was a metal tray, sterilized <strong>and</strong> covered in<br />
blue paper, that contained the instruments necessary to open up a person<br />
<strong>and</strong> either take out or put in basically anything you wanted.)<br />
The room smelled <strong>of</strong> antiseptic <strong>and</strong> the tile floor had been dulled<br />
<strong>and</strong> eroded by the constant lapping <strong>of</strong> bleach. No matter how<br />
bloody or messy this room got, it would always return to its original<br />
state. It had no memory <strong>of</strong> what had occurred, whether lives<br />
were saved or lost. And it operated outside the usual laws <strong>of</strong> UH.<br />
The only hierarchy in the slot was a hierarchy <strong>of</strong> ability. In that<br />
room there was no doubt about who I was or why I was there. And<br />
that was where I found myself - still in the process <strong>of</strong> digesting<br />
dinner - face-to-face with the man who<br />
No matter how<br />
bloody this room<br />
got it would<br />
always return to<br />
its original state. It<br />
had no memory <strong>of</strong><br />
whether lives were<br />
saved or lost.<br />
would not take <strong>of</strong>f his pants.<br />
The pants man - a semi-distinguished,<br />
semi-disheveled, 70ish-Iooking man - was<br />
seated upright on a stretcher desperately<br />
holding onto his waistb<strong>and</strong>. I had seen men<br />
like him before; my Saturdays growing up<br />
had been filled with them - the men I<br />
would sit next to in synagogue, who my<br />
father would laugh with, who knew all the<br />
prayers by heart <strong>and</strong> would smile when<br />
they saw my face constrict after tricking me<br />
into tasting rye whiskey. Men who had run<br />
from persecution in Europe to live in a nondescript<br />
lower-middle-class New York City<br />
suburb with my father <strong>and</strong> other men<br />
who'd run froin the Bronx for different reasons.<br />
The sight <strong>of</strong> this familiar-looking man desperately trying to stop<br />
nurses <strong>and</strong> other doctors from removing his pants was an odd<br />
scene because, in the slot, there is a sudden absence <strong>of</strong> social nicety.<br />
Patients are attacked on all sides. The routine was: unbutton, rip,<br />
or cut <strong>of</strong>f all clothing, whichever was fastest. Remove rings, necklaces,<br />
earrings, watches. Attach various electrical leads <strong>and</strong> oxygen<br />
masks. Penetrate as many <strong>of</strong> the largest veins as possible with<br />
large-bore IVs, <strong>and</strong> as quickly as possible.<br />
Despite the maelstrom around him, the man was obstinate. He<br />
clung to his pants with the strength <strong>of</strong> a drowning man trying to grip<br />
a piece <strong>of</strong> floating wood. But he was not drowning in water, he was<br />
drowning in his own fluids. Literally; Fluid was leaking into his lungs<br />
because his heart was failing. He was in the midst <strong>of</strong> a Inassive heart<br />
attack <strong>and</strong> unless he let go <strong>of</strong> his pants, gave us his anns <strong>and</strong> legs <strong>and</strong><br />
direct access to his arteries, veins <strong>and</strong> bladder, we were not going to be<br />
<strong>of</strong> much help.<br />
His myocardial infarction he had was caused by a blockage <strong>of</strong> his<br />
left anterior descending coronary artery - an artery affectionately<br />
known as the "widow-maker" because <strong>of</strong> how much vital heart<br />
muscle it supplies. As we all surrounded him, pleaded with him to<br />
let us take his pants <strong>of</strong>f, he did not look all that scared. His shirt<br />
was <strong>of</strong>f, his shoes were <strong>of</strong>f, his socks were <strong>of</strong>f, his watch was <strong>of</strong>f - I<br />
even think a yarmulke had been removed - but still he would not<br />
let go <strong>of</strong> his pants. He had a hairy chest, broad shoulders, <strong>and</strong> arms<br />
that looked like they had been strong <strong>and</strong> had now found renewed<br />
strength in their determination not to let go <strong>of</strong> his belt.<br />
All he said was, "Get my son."<br />
Bringing in family meinbers was not something you did in the slot.<br />
Husb<strong>and</strong>s, wives, children, friends, interested byst<strong>and</strong>ers are not there<br />
when chests are cracked or tracheas intubated. The slot is not a place<br />
for the uninitiated, for people who do not know the rules <strong>of</strong> the hospital,<br />
for those who do not wear a hospital ID. But this time I went out<br />
into the waiting area <strong>and</strong> found the man's son. I was excited to usher<br />
him in. I was going to be the face <strong>of</strong> the place that was trying to save<br />
his father. I would be the first thing the son would see, <strong>and</strong> like a duckling<br />
he would imprint to me - imprint that I was the doctor.<br />
I walked him in <strong>and</strong> after they exchanged glances, his father<br />
reached into his pockets <strong>and</strong> pulled out two wads <strong>of</strong> tissue paper,<br />
gave thein to his son <strong>and</strong> then unceremoniously took <strong>of</strong>f his pants. It<br />
all happened so quickly. The drama vanished so abruptly that it<br />
seemed to call its own existence into question. According to the son,<br />
there were roughly several hundred thous<strong>and</strong> dollars worth <strong>of</strong> diamonds<br />
in those wads <strong>of</strong> tissues, but as I retell the story, inflation<br />
brings the total to at least several million.<br />
My sons love this story. Perhaps it is the discovery <strong>of</strong> unexpected<br />
treasure; perhaps it is that funny things can happen even in the most<br />
dire <strong>of</strong> circumstances; or perhaps it is that when all seemed lost, I<br />
brought the son in <strong>and</strong> saved the father. As my sons slip into sleep<br />
they know that the diamonds are safe <strong>and</strong> the father lives. As I close<br />
my eyes I hope that they imagine me a hero.<br />
But finding the diamonds is not the end.<br />
The geins are rescued, but we are still in the slot <strong>and</strong> in the midst <strong>of</strong><br />
a losing battle. The man may have waited too long for help. We are<br />
pUluping fluids into him, trying to maintain his blood pressure. We are
giving him diuretics to get the fluid <strong>of</strong>f, <strong>and</strong> morphine for the pain<br />
<strong>and</strong> to help him breathe. But he is continuing to drown, his fingers<br />
<strong>and</strong> toes are turning blue, his blood is stagnating, he is on the verge <strong>of</strong><br />
collapse. We infuse a medicine to try to dissolve the blockage in the<br />
artery supplying his dying heart muscle. But this is also in vain.<br />
Nothing worked as planned. The pants man's circulation continued<br />
to fail; his lungs filled with more fluid as his extremities sank<br />
into a deeper violet. He would not live the night if we could not open<br />
that artery. He needed more than could be found in the slot. He<br />
needed someone to go in <strong>and</strong> manually unclog the blockage. He<br />
needed an angioplasty. So with a team <strong>of</strong> practioners in tow, we took<br />
our patient up to the fifth-floor <strong>and</strong> slowly woke up the cath lab from<br />
its weekend sleep.<br />
The cath lab was was nothing like being in medical school, where<br />
whenever I was gowned-up it was in an operating room, <strong>and</strong> I<br />
always felt out <strong>of</strong> place. Back then, I held retractors. I held them so<br />
long over open chests <strong>and</strong> abdomens that my neck cralnped <strong>and</strong> my<br />
shoulders ached. I tried to give as much exposure to the operating<br />
field as possible in the hope that I would disappear. I focused on trying<br />
to help as much as I could. Get this, do that, keep moving.<br />
Inevitably the chief surgeon would ask some mortifying question<br />
like, "What do you make <strong>of</strong> the mouse model <strong>of</strong> hernia repair?" or<br />
"What Shakespeare play does this line come from?" My inability to<br />
answer was crushing. There could never be any doubt about who<br />
wielded the power over me: the nurses, the other doctors, <strong>and</strong> the<br />
open body in that room.<br />
But that night in the cath lab, there were no impossible questions.<br />
It was just business as usual. As dye was injected, we took pictures.<br />
Pictures <strong>of</strong> the arteries <strong>and</strong> blockages, pictures <strong>of</strong> a small balloon<br />
blowing up inside an artery, <strong>and</strong> then the trickle <strong>of</strong> dye that said the<br />
blockage was gone. All <strong>of</strong> this recorded on what looked like old<br />
Super 8 film, a sort <strong>of</strong> home movie <strong>of</strong> the heart.<br />
When all was done that could be, <strong>and</strong> the catheters were<br />
removed, it was my job to make sure that the large hole we made in<br />
the femoral artery closed. This meant applying firm but constant<br />
pressure on my patient's groin. I thought this was going to be the<br />
final act, the triumphant denouement after the climactic angioplasty.<br />
We had opened up his artery, <strong>and</strong> restored blood-flow back into:,<br />
his heart, but the man was still dying. His heart muscle -like a '<br />
child gone limp after a beating - had been so stunned by the sudden<br />
<strong>and</strong> complete lack <strong>of</strong> oxygen that it would not contract. The<br />
pants man's eyes began to dull <strong>and</strong> blood tests showed a dangerow:<br />
buildup <strong>of</strong> acid.<br />
A last attempt was made to save him by putting in an intraaortic<br />
balloon pump, which actually did the trick. So after hours<br />
<strong>of</strong> effort using the best available high-technology interventional<br />
cardiology - something based on the physics <strong>of</strong> a party favor<br />
that would save this man.<br />
After what seemed like an eternity (but more like five hours), I<br />
brought the pants man, his IVs <strong>and</strong> balloon pump up into the cardiac<br />
ICU. He was stable; I was exhausted. By then I had spent hours<br />
pulling, poking, prodding, <strong>and</strong> probing his body. I had made hiln uri<br />
nate, thinned his blood, put my h<strong>and</strong>s in his groin. I was intimately<br />
aware <strong>of</strong> him, yet I knew very little about him. It was like I had been<br />
looking at the photographic negative <strong>of</strong> someone. Details, size, texture<br />
had all been perfectly represented, yet remained uninterpretable,<br />
It relninded me <strong>of</strong> my own father.<br />
When I was around my sons' ages, my father <strong>and</strong> I spent countless<br />
hours together. Not just at synagogue, but doing many <strong>of</strong> the usual<br />
father-son things available in a New York City suburb: mowing the<br />
lawn while straddling a wheelhorse tractor, pulling weeds from the<br />
garden at the front <strong>of</strong> the house, raking leaves, driving from place to<br />
place looking for shrubs or plants or more mulch. In the summers he<br />
wore ripped jeans <strong>and</strong> a white T-shirt. There are pictures <strong>of</strong> me on his<br />
shoulders as a young boy, but I cannot remember being there.<br />
What I do remember is his belly loosely hanging out over the rim<br />
<strong>of</strong> his jeans, <strong>and</strong> the embarrassment <strong>of</strong> seeing his jeans fall down as<br />
he bent over to plant seeds or bulbs. I can still see the patches <strong>of</strong><br />
psoriasis there <strong>and</strong> on his arms. The same patches that drove our<br />
family from open beaches to desolate s<strong>and</strong>y places where he could<br />
take <strong>of</strong>f his shirt in private.<br />
I was always aware <strong>of</strong> his psoriasis. I noticed how he never talked<br />
about it, how lny mother would say, "We can't go there because <strong>of</strong><br />
your father."<br />
I knew from quiet, careful surveillance that at night he wrapped<br />
himself in Saran Wrap after covering his skin in cremns to try to abatl<br />
the seemingly endless propagation <strong>of</strong> the thick plaques.<br />
When we worked in the garden, I could see how the medicine<br />
made his skin diaphanous in places. How cuts that on lne would be<br />
mere scrapes would, for him, be bleeding wounds. Though we spent<br />
many hours talking, we never spoke <strong>of</strong> this. We talked about soil <strong>and</strong><br />
dirt <strong>and</strong> rocks. We talked about water tables <strong>and</strong> the differences
etween cement <strong>and</strong> concrete. I worked hard, sweated, never asked<br />
questions. I had logged many hours <strong>of</strong> observation but still he<br />
remained a Inystery. The psoriasis encased him like layer upon layer<br />
<strong>of</strong> a resin that would refract light in such a way that form could be<br />
seen but all detail lost.<br />
None <strong>of</strong> this was on my mind when I went out to find the pants<br />
man's son 1'd met earlier outside the CICD.<br />
The son was still wearing the same nondescript suit, but he looked<br />
older <strong>and</strong> more frightened.<br />
"Can I see him?" he asked.<br />
We walked through the CICU doors <strong>and</strong> into the cubicle that<br />
was CICU Bed One. I recall their eyes meeting <strong>and</strong> then the<br />
expression on the son's face. They said a few words to one<br />
another, then the son <strong>and</strong> I left.<br />
As we walked he asked if he could ask me a question.<br />
"Of course," I said. My patient - his father - was now stable. I<br />
felt ready to assuage whatever pain or concern I imagined he had. It<br />
was like being back at Bellevue. I was beginning to feel in charge <strong>of</strong><br />
things again. I prepared my usual statement: "He's stable but anything<br />
can happen; we won't know much until after at least 24 to 48<br />
hours." (The key is to provide hope <strong>and</strong> encouragement, but as little<br />
actual prediction as possible.)<br />
But I couldn't have been more wrong about what I ilnagined his<br />
concerns to be.<br />
"Do you see those two women sitting next to one another?" he asked.<br />
I nodded.<br />
"The one on the right is my mother; the one on the left is my<br />
father's mistress. Neither knows the other. What should I do?"<br />
I wish I could recall exactly what I said or did then. I cannot even<br />
remember what either woman looked like. Did they look alike? Was<br />
one blonde <strong>and</strong> the other brunette? One tall, the other small? Did<br />
they make up two halves <strong>of</strong> one whole?<br />
This was not a problem <strong>of</strong> navigating the complicated emotional<br />
waters <strong>of</strong> wives or mistresses, or contemplating the reasons why<br />
men find comfort or excitement in people other than their spouses.<br />
If those were the questions I had to answer, I would have failed miserably.<br />
I would have failed because - despite the fact that I had felt<br />
the ribs <strong>of</strong> elderly women crack under the pressure <strong>of</strong> my failed<br />
resucitation efforts, watched as surgeons dug their h<strong>and</strong>s into the<br />
open chests <strong>of</strong> boys who had been shot <strong>and</strong> marveled at bodies ravaged<br />
by drugs, alchohol <strong>and</strong> sundry forms <strong>of</strong> ectoparasite - I was<br />
still just a pastiche <strong>of</strong> hardened experience <strong>and</strong> pudding-like naivete.<br />
At that time in my life, I had never even known anyone who'd had<br />
an affair.<br />
What I did know then was that life as a doctor was all about the<br />
extremes. And extremes, to me, defined what was most human. In<br />
that moment I understood that my job was to safeguard an extremely<br />
vital secret. I was there to figure out a way to protect the father, protect<br />
the life <strong>of</strong> the man I had just spent the last five hours saving. It<br />
was a role I knew well.<br />
The son <strong>and</strong> I quickly devised a strategy to have his mother visit<br />
first. Then, as they were leaving, I would go out <strong>and</strong> get the mistress,<br />
make sure that their paths did not cross<br />
<strong>and</strong> bring her in to see her lover. It was a<br />
plan formed from the distillation <strong>of</strong> the<br />
advice my father gave me: "Tell your<br />
mother you love her, then just do what<br />
you want."<br />
This is where the story ends for me. I<br />
cannot recall anything after. It is lost to<br />
me. I know what I did not do, though; I<br />
did not ask the son what he was thinking<br />
or feeling. Had he known his father was<br />
having an affair, or was he completely<br />
shocked? Had he even wanted his father<br />
to live? Or was this just another one <strong>of</strong><br />
those times when it seems like children<br />
The son <strong>and</strong> I<br />
qUickly devised a<br />
strategy to have<br />
his mother visit<br />
first. Then I would<br />
go out <strong>and</strong> get<br />
the mistress.<br />
have an infinite capacity for forgiving their parents? That same kind<br />
<strong>of</strong> capacity that finds children protecting those who hurt them, or trying<br />
valiantly to placate the implacable.<br />
It is difficult for me to imagine what I would have done in that<br />
moment, confronted by a living, breathing, someone-who-washaving-sex-with-my-father<br />
secret. This was not the secret life I<br />
imagined my father had. It was inconceivable to me that he could<br />
have had an affair, inconceivable that he could touch anyone or<br />
have anyone touch him. His psoriasis was a barrier to all contact.<br />
My father's secret life that I spent my childhood fantasizing about,<br />
as I waited for him outside <strong>of</strong> closed <strong>of</strong>fice doors or in the aisles <strong>of</strong><br />
electronics shops, involved cl<strong>and</strong>estine meetings between agents <strong>of</strong><br />
Middle East governments, or corporate espionage on behalf <strong>of</strong> rival<br />
fuel-cell technology companies. I traveled with him everywhere,<br />
even waiting alone in a nursing home parking lot when he went to
visit my gr<strong>and</strong>father whom I never met. I was his squire. I spent<br />
hours with him doing things for people without knowing why. At<br />
the end I would always promise not to tell my mother.<br />
Of course, now I know there were no cl<strong>and</strong>estine meetings, <strong>and</strong><br />
we did things for people because my father owed them money.<br />
Saddest <strong>of</strong> all, I never saw my gr<strong>and</strong>father because my father was<br />
too angry at him for putting my father <strong>and</strong> his brothers <strong>and</strong> sister<br />
up for adoption.<br />
I made up stories because I had to fill the void left by my father.<br />
How would I have reacted to that misdirected primal scene taking<br />
place in the CICU lounge if it was my own father in the hospital<br />
bed? At that time, I imagine it would've been with the same air <strong>of</strong><br />
practiced pragmatism <strong>and</strong> detachment the son showed me. Now,<br />
15 years later, I wonder whether I would be struck by how much I<br />
have become like my father.<br />
I was reminded <strong>of</strong>all this when - as my sons <strong>and</strong> I were going<br />
to sleep recently - my eldest said matter-<strong>of</strong>-factly, "Mommy told<br />
me you had an affair <strong>and</strong> that's why you aren't married."<br />
He was right; I did have an affair. But I was stunned by his<br />
statement, <strong>and</strong> only later did I get the voicemail message from<br />
my ex-wife alerting me to their conversation.<br />
I felt cornered. What I wanted to say was a combination <strong>of</strong>, uTake<br />
that question back right now; your mother did not have my permission<br />
to tell you that; you are too young, I'm not ready to tell you;<br />
don't talk about this in front <strong>of</strong> your brother!"<br />
But what I said was, "That's a really long <strong>and</strong> complicated conversation<br />
that we should really have tomorrow, not when we're<br />
going to sleep."<br />
But even as the words were coming out I knew both <strong>of</strong> us would<br />
be unhappy with that, <strong>and</strong> that this moment represented a chance for<br />
me to be something different from my own father. So while my<br />
younger son distracted himself with some toys, my older son <strong>and</strong> I<br />
got out <strong>of</strong> bed <strong>and</strong> started talking.<br />
It had only been several weeks since I had asked him if he had<br />
any questions about sex. All he said to me was, "No." So first I<br />
asked if he even knew what an affair was.<br />
"Sure" he said, "it's what Henry's father had." (Henry was one <strong>of</strong><br />
his closest friends whose father had already remarried.)<br />
So, unprepared as I was, I began to talk.<br />
I did not talk about what it felt like to be desperate in life or in<br />
marriage. How it felt to deceive his mother, or how it felt to deceive<br />
myself. I did not tell him how convenient it was that I was a doctor,<br />
that excuses to leave the house were just a page away, each coded<br />
beep a place <strong>and</strong> time. I did not say how delicious it was to have sex<br />
with someone else, after not having sex for so long. I did not say how<br />
I felt reanimated by the deception <strong>and</strong> danger. How good it felt to be<br />
wanted, <strong>and</strong> how good it felt to want. I did not try to explain that in<br />
some ways my affair was a brief, perfect moment <strong>of</strong> hiding in plain<br />
sight. I did not reveal how lost I was at that time, how little I knew <strong>of</strong><br />
Inyself. I did not tell him how it felt to tell his Inother or how it felt to<br />
have all <strong>of</strong> our friends <strong>and</strong> family find out. I did not tell him about<br />
how it felt to have the mask <strong>of</strong> "good husb<strong>and</strong>, good father, good<br />
doctor" ripped from my face.<br />
What I said was that at the time I was very unhappy. I was sad<br />
<strong>and</strong> depressed. I told him that affairs generally do not cause divorces<br />
but are symptoms <strong>of</strong> problems within marriages, <strong>and</strong> that I deeply<br />
regretted having one. I told him that he <strong>and</strong> his brother were the happiest<br />
part <strong>of</strong> my life but that somehow things were not right between<br />
his mother <strong>and</strong> me. I told him that when people are sad or troubled<br />
they sometimes make wrong decisions that can cause pain to the people<br />
they love. I told him that I regretted what I had done <strong>and</strong> that<br />
every day I think about the hurt it has caused him.<br />
I'm not sure what he believed or did not believe but what he said<br />
next was, "Why have an affair when you can just get divorced?"<br />
uYou're right," I said, but that is a story for another night, I<br />
thought to myself. And as I fell asleep, I was aware <strong>of</strong> the pictures on<br />
the wall. Pictures <strong>of</strong> us on vacation, <strong>of</strong> us on my sister's boat, <strong>of</strong> us in<br />
my small apartment. And pictures <strong>of</strong> my sons proudly holding up a<br />
pumpkin grown in my father's garden. II
The New Yorker, TriQuarterly, Bomb, <strong>and</strong> on<br />
NPR's "All Things Considered."<br />
Hamilton Walters' (a.k.a. Saw Takkaw)<br />
"on the ground" human rights reports <strong>and</strong><br />
photographs have been published by<br />
Burmanews.net. Dictatorwatch.org, Karen<br />
Human Rights Group (KHRG), <strong>and</strong> Burma<br />
Human Rights Yearbook. They've also been<br />
featured in Benedict Rogers' AL<strong>and</strong> Without<br />
Evil: Stopping the Genocide <strong>of</strong> Burma's Karen<br />
People. His poems <strong>and</strong> photographs have been<br />
published by The Dilettanti, Marr's Field<br />
<strong>Journal</strong>, <strong>and</strong> the Colere. He currently lives <strong>and</strong><br />
works on the Thai-Burma border.<br />
Joe Wenderoth grew up in Baltimore.<br />
Wesleyan University Press published his first<br />
two books <strong>of</strong> poems, Disfortune (1995) <strong>and</strong> It Is<br />
If I Speak (2000). His other works include<br />
Letters To Wendy's (Verse Press, 2000), The<br />
Holy Spirit <strong>of</strong> Life: Essays Written For John<br />
Ashcr<strong>of</strong>t's Secret Self <strong>and</strong> Agony: AProposal<br />
(forthcoming, 2007). He teaches English at the<br />
University <strong>of</strong> California, Davis, where he lives<br />
with his wife <strong>and</strong> daughter.<br />
Mary Zoo grew up in California <strong>and</strong> holds<br />
degrees from the University <strong>of</strong> California, Los<br />
Angeles <strong>and</strong> the University <strong>of</strong> Iowa Writers'<br />
Workshop. She is the Book Review Editor for<br />
Electronic Poetry Review. She lives <strong>and</strong> works in<br />
Oakl<strong>and</strong>, California. II<br />
CONTEST<br />
II II<br />
2006<br />
judges include:<br />
• Amy Hempel, fiction<br />
• Katha Pollitt, nonfiction<br />
• Karen Volkman, poetry<br />
First-place winners for each genre will<br />
receive $500 <strong>and</strong> publication<br />
<strong>of</strong> their entries in <strong>Issue</strong> 43.<br />
(Runners-up will also be considered for publication.)<br />
The entry fee is $12 <strong>and</strong> our contest<br />
deadline is December 3t 2005.<br />
For submission gUidelines, check out our<br />
current issue or our web site at:<br />
www.columbia.adu/cu/arts/journal.<br />
at<br />
www.harpers.org<br />
you can:<br />
* Subscribe to Harper's Magazine<br />
* Buy a gift subscription<br />
* Access your account status<br />
* Pay your bill<br />
* Renew online<br />
* Find out if your payment has been applied<br />
* Change your mailing address<br />
or your email address<br />
*Tell us that you've missed an issue<br />
Just click on "newsst<strong>and</strong>"<br />
----------+----------<br />
www.HARPE.F\S .org<br />
See what we're doing online.
<strong>Columbia</strong>!journa.<br />
fill<br />
DUSTJACKETS<br />
"I like to think I've read all the farm animal care books<br />
that have come out in the last 20 years". Speaking <strong>of</strong><br />
pigs specifically, this book is the very, very best."<br />
- GENE LOGSDON<br />
(on Storey's Guide to Raising Pigs)<br />
"A brilliant autism novel has been overdue - <strong>and</strong> this is it!"<br />
OLIVER SACKS<br />
(on The Curious Incident <strong>of</strong>the Dog in the Night-Time)<br />
"It's absolutely gosh-wow, super-colossal - smart,<br />
funny, <strong>and</strong> acontinual pleasure to read. In ajust world."<br />
it should win prizes. That wouldn't be at all amazing."<br />
- MICHAEL D1RDA<br />
(on The Amazing Adventures <strong>of</strong> KaMer <strong>and</strong> Clay)<br />
"A rollicking Pynchonesque oddity, aNabokovian linguistic<br />
obsession, <strong>and</strong> aBorgesian unreality. [House <strong>of</strong> Leaves]<br />
jumps <strong>and</strong> skips <strong>and</strong> plays with genre-wrecking ab<strong>and</strong>on,<br />
postmodern panache, <strong>and</strong> an obsessively imaginative scope<br />
that absolutely shames most books on the market today."<br />
- SAN FRANGISCO EXAMINER<br />
<strong>and</strong> CHRONICLE<br />
(on House <strong>of</strong> leaves)<br />
"For some reason, more <strong>and</strong> more young writers are<br />
producing dystopian novels. Chris Genoa<br />
rides the quest <strong>of</strong> this wave with weird<br />
humor, great characters, <strong>and</strong><br />
descriptions <strong>of</strong> time travel so<br />
accurate that you'd think he's<br />
actually traveled through time. Well?<br />
Have you, Chris?"<br />
- NEAL POLLACK<br />
(on Foop)<br />
"This version <strong>of</strong> the Inferno<br />
is God's face in a<br />
Groucho mask."<br />
SAN FRANGISCO<br />
CHRONICLE<br />
"Only those suffering from the deepest depression,<br />
or already dead, will not derive the greatest pleasure<br />
<strong>and</strong> laughter ... in this truly wonderful book."<br />
- DAILY EXPRESS<br />
(on Where There's a mm<br />
"[Percival Everett] has the acerbic brilliance <strong>and</strong><br />
unsparing eye <strong>of</strong> Swift but is much funnier. His new<br />
novel is as manic <strong>and</strong> antic as Tristram Sh<strong>and</strong>y<br />
<strong>and</strong> as wildly original as Monty Python, but<br />
the absurdist comedy is dark in the manner<br />
<strong>of</strong> lonesco."<br />
- JANETTE TURNER<br />
HOSPITAL<br />
(on American Desert)<br />
Find agood book<br />
blurb? Send it in:<br />
columblajournal@columbla,edu