Sample judging score sheet

Part 1:
Car
Design
Judging
Part 2:
Design
Document
Judging
School Name:______________________
Car Name & #:_______________#_____
B.A.T. Mobile Challenge:
Best Design
1 of 2
Each team must submit their BAT Mobile to FSEC the day of the EnergyWhiz Olympics. To submit the
car, the team must be present the morning of the Olympics in order to allow a functionality assessment
before FSEC impounds the car. The car will remain impounded until the scheduled time when the
racing begins. During impoundment, selected judges will review each car for its quality, precision,
durability, design concept, and safety.
Each team must provide design notes for their car before being allowed to compete. The design
document is not a daily journal. It is an engineering schematic. Minimum requirements include a cover
page, essay detailing advantages and disadvantages of electric vehicles, complete component list for
the vehicle, final specifications of the vehicle (body measurements, mass, gear ratio, drive type,
average speed), scaled drawings, assembly procedures with photos, at least three issues or problems
encountered and solutions applied, and an essay describing what was learned.
Part 1: Car Design Judging Score Sheet
Category Conditions 3 2 1 0 Score Comments
Chassis -Strong
-Intentionally Sized
-Lightweight
Wheels/Axles -Appropriate Wheels
-Free-Moving Wheels
-Aligned Axles
Transmission -Good Gear Ratio
-Gears Mesh Well
-Motor Well Mounted
Power Safety -Quality Switch
-No Exposed Wire
-Wire Fastened/Soldered
Craftsmanship -Durable
-Clean
-Eye-Catching
Creativity -Few Teacher Kit Parts
-Designed Theme/Style
-Compares Well to Design
3
Of
3
3
Of
3
3
Of
3
3
Of
3
3
Of
3
3
Of
3
2
Of
3
2
Of
3
2
Of
3
2
Of
3
2
Of
3
2
Of
3
1
Of
3
1
Of
3
1
Of
3
1
Of
3
1
Of
3
1
Of
3
0
Of
3
0
Of
3
0
Of
3
0
Of
3
0
Of
3
0
Of
3
Car Design Score……… /15

Part 2: Design Document Judging Score Sheet
Category 2 1 0 Score Comments
Cover Page
(One point only)
Advantages
and
disadvantages
of electric
vehicles essay
Component
List
Final
Specifications
of Vehicle
Scaled
Drawings
Assembly
Procedures
With Photos
Issues,
Problems and
Solutions
What Did You
Learn Essay.
X
Describes multiple
advantages and
disadvantages of EV.
-All Components
-All Quantities
Includes:
1 Body measurements
(Length and Width)
2 Mass
3 Gear ratio
4 Drive type
-Top and Side Views
-Drawings to Scale
-Scale listed
-Detailed Assembly
-Progressive Photos of
Assembly
-3 Problems
Encountered
-3 Solutions Presented
Essay describes
lessons learned in
detail.
-School
-Team Members
-Car Name/Num
Does not describe
either multiple
advantages or
multiple
disadvantages.
Does not include
all components
and quantities.
Some
specifications
included
Does not include
both top and side
views.
Drawings are not
to scale.
Assembly
procedures are
not detailed or
photos are not
included.
Less than three
problems or
issues and the
solutions are
described.
No Cover
Page
No essay
No component
list.
No final specs
included.
No scaled
drawings
included.
No assembly
procedures or
photos.
No description
of problems,
issues or
solutions
described
Essay lacks detail. No essay
included.
2 of 2
Design Document Score /15
Car Design Score……… /15
Judge____________________________ Total Score /30