globalCOAL - Country & Industry Forecasting: IHS Global Insight
globalCOAL - Country & Industry Forecasting: IHS Global Insight
globalCOAL - Country & Industry Forecasting: IHS Global Insight
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Traded Markets – Trends<br />
in Alternatives and<br />
Prospects<br />
<strong>Global</strong> <strong>Insight</strong><br />
Fuel Price Conference<br />
9 th Dec 2004<br />
<strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />
shareholders<br />
*TXU-Europe shares currently being sold by the<br />
Administrator<br />
*
Agenda<br />
Evolution of markets<br />
Standard Contracts<br />
Growth in trading activity<br />
Indices
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> Offers<br />
Confidentiality<br />
NO commercially sensitive information released to 3 rd parties<br />
Openness<br />
Systems are available to all industry participants<br />
Independence<br />
Separate legal entity with independent management<br />
Neutrality<br />
Favours neither consumer, producers or traders<br />
Fast, Effective & Transparent Route to Market<br />
Subject to counterparty clearance, provides ALL players access<br />
to markets such as RBCT, Newcastle etc.<br />
Real-time market intelligence<br />
Price discovery and market transparency e.g. forward curve, deals done etc
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> Product Offerings<br />
Includes <strong>globalCOAL</strong>’ s<br />
forward curves &<br />
other commodity<br />
information from the<br />
power, gas, and liquids<br />
markets<br />
Standard Coal System<br />
(SCS)<br />
Screen based, electronic trading<br />
for physical and financial coal<br />
Direct & Reverse<br />
auction system with<br />
real-time quality<br />
evaluation<br />
State-of-the-Globe<br />
(SOG)<br />
Custom Coal System<br />
(CCS)<br />
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> TM<br />
Proprietary Indices<br />
(RB & NEWC Index)<br />
SSY Freight Products<br />
(FFA)<br />
Other services<br />
includes SMS<br />
price alerts and<br />
Trade/Position data<br />
McCloskey Coal News<br />
Freight Forward<br />
Agreements for both<br />
Dry & Wet Freight
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> Market Members<br />
1. AEP Energy Services Ltd<br />
2. Anglo Coal Marketing Ltd<br />
3. Anker Coal Company B.V.<br />
4. Barclays Bank Plc<br />
5. BHP-Billiton Marketing AG<br />
6. Bulk Trading S.A.<br />
7. Cargill International SA<br />
8. Coal Marketing Company Limited<br />
9. Coal and Allied Operations<br />
10. Coeclerici Carbometal SPA<br />
11. Constellation Power Source, Inc<br />
12. Delta Energy B.V.<br />
13. Deutsche Bank AG<br />
14. EDF Trading Ltd<br />
15. E.ON Kraftwerke GmbH<br />
16. E.ON UK plc<br />
17. Electrabel S.A.<br />
17. Electric Power Development Co.<br />
18. ENEL Trade S.p.A<br />
19. EnBW Trading GmbH<br />
20. Essent Trading<br />
21. Glencore International AG<br />
23. Grosskraftwerk Mannheim AG<br />
24. Hidrocantabrico Generacion S.A.<br />
25. Hokkaido Electric Power Co.<br />
26. International Power plc<br />
27. Koch Carbon (UK) Ltd.<br />
28. LE Group<br />
29. Mitsubishi Corporation<br />
30. Morgan Stanley & Co. International Limited<br />
31. Noble Energy Inc.<br />
32. N.V. Nuon Energy Trade & Wholesale<br />
33. Peabody Coal Trade Australia<br />
34. RWE Trading GmbH<br />
35. Sasol Mining (Pty) Ltd<br />
36. Scottish Power Energy Management Ltd<br />
37. Sempra Energy Europe Limited<br />
38. Standard Bank London Limited<br />
39. TOTALFINAELF Coal SA<br />
40. The National Coal Supply Corp.<br />
41. Vattenfall Europe Trading GmbH<br />
42. Wambo Coal Pty Ltd<br />
43. Xstrata Coal Australia Pty Limited<br />
PRODUCER CONSUMER<br />
FINANCIAL INSTITUTION TRADER
Development of <strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />
“From Inevitability to Reality”<br />
• Established on April 18, 2001; live for trading from May 16, 2001<br />
• Over 36.5 MT physical coal and nearly 7 MT financial coal traded to<br />
date<br />
• 43 Market Members and growing<br />
• SCoTA accepted as standard coal contract<br />
• <strong>globalCOAL</strong> indices now well established<br />
• Acceptance of screen trading of steam coal<br />
• Early 2003 signed joint co-operation agreement with SSY, developing<br />
screen traded FFA’s<br />
• September 2003 – opened Asian office in Singapore<br />
to service growing Asian demand<br />
NEXT DEVELOPMENTS:<br />
• FOB Indonesia contract being evaluated with potential market players<br />
• CIF Japan index being considered for introduction of swaps trading<br />
• Clearing?<br />
• Entry into US market??
Change in the coal market<br />
Factors / history through the 1990’s:<br />
PAST<br />
FUTURE<br />
E-trade<br />
Typically coal bought on long term contract<br />
Annual pricing<br />
Deregulation of the power sector led to competition<br />
Tenure of contracts became shorter<br />
Increased spot purchasing<br />
Paper coal contracts (API2) started 1998<br />
Asia still well behind but deregulation is coming<br />
Approximate annual volumes:<br />
SPOT<br />
MARKETS<br />
LONG<br />
TERM<br />
CONTRACT<br />
SPOT<br />
MARKETS<br />
TENDER<br />
CONTRACT<br />
LONG<br />
TERM<br />
CONTRACT<br />
but short term<br />
pricing<br />
Atlantic seaborne steam coal:<br />
Atlantic (ARA + RBCT, SA) swaps:<br />
Asia-Pacific steam coal:<br />
Pacific swaps (Newcastle):<br />
180 MT p.a.<br />
600 MT p.a.?<br />
250 MT p.a<br />
10 MT p.a.?
THE EVOLUTION OF A MARKET<br />
Deregulation of<br />
electricity sector<br />
Increased Consumer<br />
Competition<br />
Increased Consumer Risk<br />
Leads to Greater Need for<br />
FLEXIBILITY and Greater<br />
Need to Manage Short Term<br />
GENERATION MARGIN<br />
Spark Spread (US$/MWh)<br />
Integrated energy markets<br />
(power, gas, oil & coal)<br />
allow easier comparisons<br />
= Spot Market Power Price<br />
- Spot Market Generation<br />
Cost (converted into US$ /<br />
MWh for the fuel type used to<br />
generate that power)<br />
LEADS TO:<br />
•Separation of PRICE RISK from VOLUME RISK<br />
•Reduction in dependency on security of supply<br />
Increased Producer Risk<br />
Less certainty of demand<br />
STANDARDISATION<br />
INDEX LINKED DEALS
REQUIREMENTS FOR A TRADED COAL MARKET<br />
• Competitive electricity market<br />
• Critical mass of players in the market<br />
• Active & liquid spot market (move away from long term fixed prices)<br />
• Standard contract for representative commoditised product<br />
• Desire / need for risk management among buyers and sellers<br />
• Greater degree of flexibility among coal buyers / power stations<br />
• Reliable index<br />
• Newcomers with appetite for coal price risk<br />
• Some form of broker (electronic or voice)<br />
Financial Institutions / Speculators<br />
RISK<br />
Consumers Producers
SCoTA TM - Standard Coal Trading Agreement<br />
• All physical SCS transactions governed by SCoTA TM - a single set of legal<br />
terms and conditions and standard quality specifications.<br />
• SCoTA TM is a “Master Agreement”, governing each and every SCS<br />
transaction. It is implemented once and acts as an umbrella contract for all<br />
future transactions.<br />
• Continuously developed with industry feedback.<br />
• SCoTA TM now in Version 4a, features level of detail including<br />
• Performance assurance<br />
• Netting/setting off agreements<br />
• Liquidated damages<br />
• Circles and Cross default provisions (except Australian companies)<br />
• Four delivery locations traded under SCoTA TM : ARA, RB, NEWC, BOL<br />
• Main feature of SCoTA TM Version 4 compared with 3b<br />
• Introduction of new, improved ARA contract<br />
• Next versions of SCoTA TM will update ARA contract (again) and introduce<br />
Indonesian contracts
SCoTA TM Standard Specifications<br />
Calorific Value<br />
(NCV min, but<br />
basis 6000<br />
Volatile<br />
Matter<br />
Total Moisture<br />
(max)<br />
Ash<br />
(m ax)<br />
Sulphur<br />
(max)<br />
IDT<br />
(deg. min)<br />
CaO<br />
(max)<br />
kcal/kg)<br />
ARA (RB) 5,850 22% (m in) 12.0% 15.0% 1.00% 1,250 12%<br />
ARA (AUS) 5,850 24%-35% 15.0% 15.0% 0.75% 1,250 7%<br />
ARA (COL) 5,850 31%-37% 14.0% 11.0% 0.85% 1,250<br />
ARA (RUS) 5,850 26%- 35% 14.0% 15.0% 0.75% 1,250<br />
BOL 5,850 31%-37% 14.0% 11.0% 0.85% 1,250<br />
NEWC 5,850 27%-35% 15.0% 14.0% 0.75% 7%<br />
NEWCF 5,850 27%-35% 15.0% 14.0% 0.75% 7%<br />
RB 1 5,850 22% (m in) 12.0% 15.0% 1.00% 1,250 12%<br />
All specifications are on an “as received” basis (and ISO standard)<br />
All transactions are basis 6,000 kcal/kg net as received with price adjustments as per SCoTA<br />
In all cases, a maximum top-size of 50mm and a Hardgrove Index range of 45-70 is specified<br />
NOTE: this table is a summary only and should be used in conjunction with SCoTA
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> – INDO A Product<br />
• Proposed Quality Specifications as listed below:<br />
• Calorific Value (GAR, kcal/kg): Basis 6,200; Min 5,900 GAR<br />
• Total Moisture (as received): Max 18.0%; Typical 13.0%<br />
• Volatile Matter (air dried): Min 38.0%; Max 45.0%<br />
• Ash (as received): Max 16.0%<br />
• Sulphur (as received): Max 1.0%; Typical 0.80%<br />
• Selenium (ppm, dry basis)*: Max 2; Typical < 1.0<br />
• Boron (ppm, dry basis)*: 100<br />
• Calcium Oxide in ash (dry basis): Max 7.0%<br />
• Nitrogen (ash free): Max 1.8%<br />
• Hardgrove Grindability Index*: 40 - 50<br />
• Nominal Topsize (mm): 50<br />
• A.F.T. (initial deformation, deg C): Min 1,150<br />
• Size Restriction*: no more than 30% (by weight) shall pass 2 mm square<br />
mesh screen.<br />
* Typical – not used for determining whether or not a Shipment complies with the specification.
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> – INDO B Product<br />
• Proposed Quality Specifications as listed below:<br />
• Calorific Value (GAR, kcal/kg): Basis 5,400; Min 5,000 GAR<br />
• Total Moisture (as received): Max 30.0%; Typical 22.0%<br />
• Volatile Matter (air dried): Min 38.0%; Max 43.0%<br />
• Ash (as received): [Max 10.0%; Typical 4.0%]<br />
• Sulphur (as received): [Max 1.0%; Typical 0.30%]<br />
• Selenium (ppm, dry basis)*: Max 2; Typical < 1.0<br />
• Boron (ppm, dry basis)*: 170<br />
• [Calcium Oxide in ash (dry basis): Max 15.0%]<br />
• Nitrogen (ash free): Max 1.7%<br />
• Hardgrove Grindability Index*: 40 - 55<br />
• Nominal Topsize (mm): 50<br />
• A.F.T. (initial deformation, deg C)*: Typical 1,150<br />
• Size Restriction*: no more than 30% (by weight) shall pass 2 mm square<br />
mesh screen.<br />
* Typical – not used for determining whether or not a Shipment complies with the specification.
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> – Clause 13.3 Proposed Quality<br />
Adjustments<br />
• Ash Adjustments:<br />
• INDO A Product: US$ 0.35/mt per 1.0% Ash < 5.0% & pro-rata<br />
• INDO B Product: US$ 0.35/mt per 1.0% Ash < 4.0% & pro-rata<br />
• Sulphur Adjustments:<br />
• INDO A Product: Premium: US$ 0.35/mt per 0.1% TS < 0.4% & pro-rata<br />
• INDO B Product: Premium: US$ 0.35/mt per 0.1% TS < 0.4% & pro-rata<br />
• Moisture Adjustments:<br />
• INDO A Product: Penalty: >16% 27%
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> – Clause 13.3 Proposed Quality<br />
Adjustments<br />
• CV Adjustments:<br />
• INDO A Product:<br />
5,900
Indonesia Proposed Logistics<br />
• FOB contract<br />
• Shipping to be performed by conventional panamax vessels<br />
• FOB Price based upon single ‘reference’ loadport<br />
• Sellers option to nominate actual loadport<br />
• FOB price adjusted after screen trade according to published<br />
freight differentials between reference port and actual port, based<br />
upon shipping by conventional panamax<br />
• Published differentials to be reviewed on regular basis by<br />
independent shipbroker
Indonesia Proposed Logistics - Example<br />
Possible Origin Locations<br />
Delivery Point A<br />
Published<br />
Freight Differential =<br />
USD 0.25/mt<br />
Reference Point<br />
Published<br />
Freight Differential =<br />
USD 0.35/mt<br />
Delivery Point B<br />
** Assume Conventional Panamax Shipment<br />
FOB Price (Reference Point) = 51.50/mt<br />
The differential from the Reference Point to Delivery<br />
Point A is USD -0.25/mt (closer to consumer)<br />
The differential from the Reference Point to Delivery<br />
Point B is USD 0.35/mt (further away from consumer)<br />
Therefore, the following FOB Prices are possible from<br />
the three delivery locations:<br />
Reference Point: USD 51.50/mt<br />
Delivery Point A: USD 51.50/mt – USD 0.25/mt =<br />
USD 51.25/mt<br />
Delivery Point B: USD 51.50/mt + USD 0.35/mt =<br />
USD 51.85/mt<br />
** Local Port Terms Apply based on Origin of Supply
Development of <strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />
TONNAGE TRADED PER QUARTER TO END NOVEMBER 2004<br />
Total Since Launch (May’01 to date): 43.5 MT (physical and financial)<br />
7,000,000<br />
6,000,000<br />
Total Financial<br />
Total Physical<br />
Total<br />
Linear (Total)<br />
5,000,000<br />
4,000,000<br />
3,000,000<br />
2,000,000<br />
1,000,000<br />
0<br />
Q201 Q301 Q401 Q102 Q202 Q302 Q402 Q103 Q203 Q303 Q403 Q104 Q204 Q304 Q404
Development of <strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />
TONNAGE TRADED PER QUARTER TO END NOVEMBER 2004<br />
Total Since Launch (May’01 to date): 43.5 MT (physical and financial)<br />
7,000,000<br />
6,000,000<br />
5,000,000<br />
TFS API<br />
Phys ARA<br />
SWAP RB<br />
Phys RB<br />
SWAP NEWC<br />
Phys NEWCF<br />
Phys NEWC<br />
Total<br />
Linear (Total)<br />
4,000,000<br />
3,000,000<br />
2,000,000<br />
1,000,000<br />
0<br />
Q201 Q301 Q401 Q102 Q202 Q302 Q402 Q103 Q203 Q303 Q403 Q104 Q204 Q304 Q404
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC index (USD/mt RHS) and volumes<br />
traded physical and financial (LHS)<br />
gC NEWC index and volumes November 02 - November 04<br />
Physical NEWC traded (mt, LHS) Swap NEWC traded (mt, LHS) <strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC index (US$/mt, RHS)<br />
2,000,000<br />
65<br />
1,800,000<br />
60<br />
1,600,000<br />
55<br />
1,400,000<br />
1,200,000<br />
1,000,000<br />
800,000<br />
600,000<br />
400,000<br />
200,000<br />
0<br />
Nov-02<br />
Dec-02<br />
Jan-03<br />
Feb-03<br />
Mar-03<br />
Apr-03<br />
May-03<br />
Jun-03<br />
Jul-03<br />
Aug-03<br />
Sep-03<br />
Oct-03<br />
Nov-03<br />
Dec-03<br />
Jan-04<br />
Feb-04<br />
Mar-04<br />
Apr-04<br />
ACCC<br />
allows<br />
allocation<br />
system<br />
Growth in<br />
swaps<br />
trading<br />
despite lack<br />
of physical<br />
tonnes<br />
May-04<br />
Jun-04<br />
Jul-04<br />
Aug-04<br />
Sep-04<br />
Oct-04<br />
Nov-04<br />
50<br />
45<br />
40<br />
35<br />
30<br />
25<br />
20
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC index (USD/mt RHS) and %age of<br />
volume traded physical and financial (LHS)<br />
100%<br />
80%<br />
60%<br />
40%<br />
20%<br />
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC trades (physical and financial)<br />
as %age of total<br />
Swap NEWC volumes (%)<br />
Physical NEWC volume (%)<br />
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC index US$/mt<br />
65<br />
60<br />
55<br />
50<br />
45<br />
40<br />
35<br />
30<br />
25<br />
0%<br />
No<br />
v-<br />
02<br />
De<br />
c-<br />
02<br />
Ja<br />
n-<br />
03<br />
Fe<br />
b-<br />
03<br />
Ma<br />
r-<br />
03<br />
Ap<br />
r-<br />
03<br />
Ma<br />
y-<br />
03<br />
Ju<br />
n-<br />
03<br />
Ju<br />
l-<br />
03<br />
Au<br />
g-<br />
03<br />
Se<br />
p-<br />
03<br />
Oc<br />
t-<br />
03<br />
No<br />
v-<br />
03<br />
De<br />
c-<br />
03<br />
Ja<br />
n-<br />
04<br />
Fe<br />
b-<br />
04<br />
Ma<br />
r-<br />
04<br />
Ap<br />
r-<br />
04<br />
Ma<br />
y-<br />
04<br />
Ju<br />
n-<br />
04<br />
Ju<br />
l-<br />
04<br />
Au<br />
g-<br />
04<br />
Se<br />
p-<br />
04<br />
Oc<br />
t-<br />
04<br />
No<br />
v-<br />
04<br />
20
Coal Indices: Sustainability<br />
An index should be:<br />
– Based on verifiable data<br />
– Transparent<br />
– Difficult to manipulate<br />
What distinguishes different indices?<br />
– Quality and source of underlying data – verifiable trades<br />
or “reported” trades?<br />
– Method of calculation – transparent methodology or “black box”?<br />
– Frequency of calculation – real time or once a week?<br />
Coal Indices Should be Representative of the Marketplace
RB Index TM , NEWC Index TM<br />
• Created by the coal industry, for the coal industry<br />
• Free of any interpretation or judgment<br />
• The most accurate reflection of actual market prices<br />
• Measures price of standard specification of thermal coal (Phys<br />
RB1 TM or Phys NEWC TM specs) for delivery in forward three months<br />
• Underlying data: firm bids/offers and trades in Phys RB1 TM or Phys<br />
NEWC TM instrument on <strong>globalCOAL</strong>’s Standard Coal System<br />
• Published method of calculation, rigidly applied in real time, using<br />
data from transparent source:<br />
• Weighted average of trade prices and bids/offers<br />
• Several mechanisms/filters in place to prevent manipulation<br />
• Calculated daily, weekly and monthly<br />
• Note:- All bids/offers/trades used to calculate the Index are based on the same<br />
terms, conditions, specs etc i.e. compares “apples with apples”.<br />
• Standardisation takes place before, not after the deals
Index Calculator Example
Newcastle Physical/Financial Market Evolution<br />
• Pre July 2002 – The concept of developing a marker price for the Newcastle<br />
market to help provide more transparency for buyers and sellers. The concept of<br />
the Newcastle Marker Price Initiative (NMPI) is developed whereby a marker price<br />
will be published once per month.<br />
NMPI Concept - A sponsor would offer up a cape per month to be sold on<br />
<strong>globalCOAL</strong>’s platform<br />
• July 2002 – The first NMPI took place on <strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />
• September 2002 – Work commences on the development of a NEWC Index<br />
• October 2002 – The NEWC methodology is approved by the market (note - the<br />
timeframes of the NMPI straddle both Asian/European timezones)<br />
• November 2002 – The first NEWC Swap trade takes place on gC’s platform<br />
• September 2004 – Approx. 17.50 MM tonnes of Physical and 2.7 MM tonnes of<br />
NEWC Swaps transacted on <strong>globalCOAL</strong>; however, this does not account for<br />
what has been transacted via voice brokers in the OTC market
Market Transparency<br />
All Phys NEWC Prices from December 2001 to August 2003<br />
30.00<br />
US$/mt<br />
29.00<br />
BIDS<br />
OFFERS<br />
28.00<br />
27.00<br />
Pre NMPI<br />
Post NMPI<br />
26.00<br />
25.00<br />
24.00<br />
23.00<br />
22.00<br />
21.00<br />
20.00<br />
1-Jan-02 2-Mar-02 1-May-02 30-Jun-02 29-Aug-02 28-Oct-02 27-Dec-02 25-Feb-03 26-Apr-03 25-Jun-03 24-Aug-03<br />
Could This Concept Be Applied to Indonesia, thereby<br />
creating liquidity in another market ?
Other Indices in the market<br />
TFS API#2® – spot thermal coal for CIF ARA, basis 6000 Kcal/kg NCV<br />
TFS API#3® – spot thermal coal for FOB Newcastle, basis 6700 Kcal/kg GAD<br />
TFS API#4® – spot thermal coal for FOB RBCT, basis 6000 Kcal/kg NCV<br />
Argus/McCloskey - spot thermal coal FOB Newcastle<br />
Underlying data: Journalists survey the participants in the industry<br />
Method of calculation: Average of journalists price reports.<br />
Calculated weekly and monthly.<br />
Relies on knowledge and experience of journalists to ask right questions of right people<br />
and understand if answers are true! Arguably very vulnerable to variety of risks.<br />
Audited?<br />
CoalinQ – spot thermal coal FOB Newcastle, within 3 months, basis 6700 GAD<br />
Underlying data: Panel of 6 producers (of which 1 anthracite, 3 Queensland); 12 Japanese<br />
& 1 Korean consumers; 6 “traders” of which 3 Japanese Trading Houses<br />
Method of calculation: Average of panellists price assessments.<br />
Calculated fortnightly.
60.00<br />
55.00<br />
50.00<br />
45.00<br />
40.00<br />
35.00<br />
30.00<br />
25.00<br />
20.00<br />
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC Index TM vs. Other Indices<br />
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC Index<br />
BJI<br />
CoalinQ (CV Adj)<br />
API#3<br />
5-Aug-02<br />
5-Sep-02<br />
5-Oct-02<br />
5-Nov-02<br />
5-Dec-02<br />
5-Jan-03<br />
5-Feb-03<br />
5-Mar-03<br />
5-Apr-03<br />
5-May-03<br />
5-Jun-03<br />
5-Jul-03<br />
5-Aug-03<br />
5-Sep-03<br />
5-Oct-03<br />
5-Nov-03<br />
5-Dec-03<br />
5-Jan-04<br />
5-Feb-04<br />
5-Mar-04<br />
5-Apr-04<br />
5-May-04<br />
Note how the NEWC index usually leads the others. As it is real time also note the larger price<br />
swings on the NEWC index whereas weekly prices are “smoothed” with the other indices.<br />
5-Jul-02
INDICES<br />
The importance of a good index<br />
<strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />
<strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />
Commoditised<br />
Commoditised<br />
Physical Physical<br />
Market<br />
Market<br />
Published, Auditable and FSA Regulated<br />
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> Index Methodology<br />
<strong>globalCOAL</strong> Indices<br />
(RB & NEWC)<br />
<strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />
<strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />
Commoditised<br />
Commoditised<br />
Financial Financial<br />
Market<br />
Market<br />
OTC OTC<br />
Broker<br />
Broker<br />
Financial Financial<br />
Market<br />
Market<br />
Tender Tender<br />
Contracts<br />
Contracts<br />
Haze of coal quality<br />
conversions and price<br />
interpretations<br />
Other Indices<br />
WARNING:<br />
Even in the lack of physical trading<br />
activity, the financial market must<br />
NEVER be used to price indices.<br />
Physical Physical<br />
Market<br />
Market<br />
Settlement<br />
Spot Spot<br />
& Longer<br />
Longer<br />
Term Term<br />
Physical<br />
Physical<br />
Market<br />
Market<br />
(index based)<br />
(index based)<br />
Calculation
Questions and Answers<br />
Thank you