24.01.2014 Views

globalCOAL - Country & Industry Forecasting: IHS Global Insight

globalCOAL - Country & Industry Forecasting: IHS Global Insight

globalCOAL - Country & Industry Forecasting: IHS Global Insight

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Traded Markets – Trends<br />

in Alternatives and<br />

Prospects<br />

<strong>Global</strong> <strong>Insight</strong><br />

Fuel Price Conference<br />

9 th Dec 2004<br />

<strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />

shareholders<br />

*TXU-Europe shares currently being sold by the<br />

Administrator<br />

*


Agenda<br />

Evolution of markets<br />

Standard Contracts<br />

Growth in trading activity<br />

Indices


<strong>globalCOAL</strong> Offers<br />

Confidentiality<br />

NO commercially sensitive information released to 3 rd parties<br />

Openness<br />

Systems are available to all industry participants<br />

Independence<br />

Separate legal entity with independent management<br />

Neutrality<br />

Favours neither consumer, producers or traders<br />

Fast, Effective & Transparent Route to Market<br />

Subject to counterparty clearance, provides ALL players access<br />

to markets such as RBCT, Newcastle etc.<br />

Real-time market intelligence<br />

Price discovery and market transparency e.g. forward curve, deals done etc


<strong>globalCOAL</strong> Product Offerings<br />

Includes <strong>globalCOAL</strong>’ s<br />

forward curves &<br />

other commodity<br />

information from the<br />

power, gas, and liquids<br />

markets<br />

Standard Coal System<br />

(SCS)<br />

Screen based, electronic trading<br />

for physical and financial coal<br />

Direct & Reverse<br />

auction system with<br />

real-time quality<br />

evaluation<br />

State-of-the-Globe<br />

(SOG)<br />

Custom Coal System<br />

(CCS)<br />

<strong>globalCOAL</strong> TM<br />

Proprietary Indices<br />

(RB & NEWC Index)<br />

SSY Freight Products<br />

(FFA)<br />

Other services<br />

includes SMS<br />

price alerts and<br />

Trade/Position data<br />

McCloskey Coal News<br />

Freight Forward<br />

Agreements for both<br />

Dry & Wet Freight


<strong>globalCOAL</strong> Market Members<br />

1. AEP Energy Services Ltd<br />

2. Anglo Coal Marketing Ltd<br />

3. Anker Coal Company B.V.<br />

4. Barclays Bank Plc<br />

5. BHP-Billiton Marketing AG<br />

6. Bulk Trading S.A.<br />

7. Cargill International SA<br />

8. Coal Marketing Company Limited<br />

9. Coal and Allied Operations<br />

10. Coeclerici Carbometal SPA<br />

11. Constellation Power Source, Inc<br />

12. Delta Energy B.V.<br />

13. Deutsche Bank AG<br />

14. EDF Trading Ltd<br />

15. E.ON Kraftwerke GmbH<br />

16. E.ON UK plc<br />

17. Electrabel S.A.<br />

17. Electric Power Development Co.<br />

18. ENEL Trade S.p.A<br />

19. EnBW Trading GmbH<br />

20. Essent Trading<br />

21. Glencore International AG<br />

23. Grosskraftwerk Mannheim AG<br />

24. Hidrocantabrico Generacion S.A.<br />

25. Hokkaido Electric Power Co.<br />

26. International Power plc<br />

27. Koch Carbon (UK) Ltd.<br />

28. LE Group<br />

29. Mitsubishi Corporation<br />

30. Morgan Stanley & Co. International Limited<br />

31. Noble Energy Inc.<br />

32. N.V. Nuon Energy Trade & Wholesale<br />

33. Peabody Coal Trade Australia<br />

34. RWE Trading GmbH<br />

35. Sasol Mining (Pty) Ltd<br />

36. Scottish Power Energy Management Ltd<br />

37. Sempra Energy Europe Limited<br />

38. Standard Bank London Limited<br />

39. TOTALFINAELF Coal SA<br />

40. The National Coal Supply Corp.<br />

41. Vattenfall Europe Trading GmbH<br />

42. Wambo Coal Pty Ltd<br />

43. Xstrata Coal Australia Pty Limited<br />

PRODUCER CONSUMER<br />

FINANCIAL INSTITUTION TRADER


Development of <strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />

“From Inevitability to Reality”<br />

• Established on April 18, 2001; live for trading from May 16, 2001<br />

• Over 36.5 MT physical coal and nearly 7 MT financial coal traded to<br />

date<br />

• 43 Market Members and growing<br />

• SCoTA accepted as standard coal contract<br />

• <strong>globalCOAL</strong> indices now well established<br />

• Acceptance of screen trading of steam coal<br />

• Early 2003 signed joint co-operation agreement with SSY, developing<br />

screen traded FFA’s<br />

• September 2003 – opened Asian office in Singapore<br />

to service growing Asian demand<br />

NEXT DEVELOPMENTS:<br />

• FOB Indonesia contract being evaluated with potential market players<br />

• CIF Japan index being considered for introduction of swaps trading<br />

• Clearing?<br />

• Entry into US market??


Change in the coal market<br />

Factors / history through the 1990’s:<br />

PAST<br />

FUTURE<br />

E-trade<br />

Typically coal bought on long term contract<br />

Annual pricing<br />

Deregulation of the power sector led to competition<br />

Tenure of contracts became shorter<br />

Increased spot purchasing<br />

Paper coal contracts (API2) started 1998<br />

Asia still well behind but deregulation is coming<br />

Approximate annual volumes:<br />

SPOT<br />

MARKETS<br />

LONG<br />

TERM<br />

CONTRACT<br />

SPOT<br />

MARKETS<br />

TENDER<br />

CONTRACT<br />

LONG<br />

TERM<br />

CONTRACT<br />

but short term<br />

pricing<br />

Atlantic seaborne steam coal:<br />

Atlantic (ARA + RBCT, SA) swaps:<br />

Asia-Pacific steam coal:<br />

Pacific swaps (Newcastle):<br />

180 MT p.a.<br />

600 MT p.a.?<br />

250 MT p.a<br />

10 MT p.a.?


THE EVOLUTION OF A MARKET<br />

Deregulation of<br />

electricity sector<br />

Increased Consumer<br />

Competition<br />

Increased Consumer Risk<br />

Leads to Greater Need for<br />

FLEXIBILITY and Greater<br />

Need to Manage Short Term<br />

GENERATION MARGIN<br />

Spark Spread (US$/MWh)<br />

Integrated energy markets<br />

(power, gas, oil & coal)<br />

allow easier comparisons<br />

= Spot Market Power Price<br />

- Spot Market Generation<br />

Cost (converted into US$ /<br />

MWh for the fuel type used to<br />

generate that power)<br />

LEADS TO:<br />

•Separation of PRICE RISK from VOLUME RISK<br />

•Reduction in dependency on security of supply<br />

Increased Producer Risk<br />

Less certainty of demand<br />

STANDARDISATION<br />

INDEX LINKED DEALS


REQUIREMENTS FOR A TRADED COAL MARKET<br />

• Competitive electricity market<br />

• Critical mass of players in the market<br />

• Active & liquid spot market (move away from long term fixed prices)<br />

• Standard contract for representative commoditised product<br />

• Desire / need for risk management among buyers and sellers<br />

• Greater degree of flexibility among coal buyers / power stations<br />

• Reliable index<br />

• Newcomers with appetite for coal price risk<br />

• Some form of broker (electronic or voice)<br />

Financial Institutions / Speculators<br />

RISK<br />

Consumers Producers


SCoTA TM - Standard Coal Trading Agreement<br />

• All physical SCS transactions governed by SCoTA TM - a single set of legal<br />

terms and conditions and standard quality specifications.<br />

• SCoTA TM is a “Master Agreement”, governing each and every SCS<br />

transaction. It is implemented once and acts as an umbrella contract for all<br />

future transactions.<br />

• Continuously developed with industry feedback.<br />

• SCoTA TM now in Version 4a, features level of detail including<br />

• Performance assurance<br />

• Netting/setting off agreements<br />

• Liquidated damages<br />

• Circles and Cross default provisions (except Australian companies)<br />

• Four delivery locations traded under SCoTA TM : ARA, RB, NEWC, BOL<br />

• Main feature of SCoTA TM Version 4 compared with 3b<br />

• Introduction of new, improved ARA contract<br />

• Next versions of SCoTA TM will update ARA contract (again) and introduce<br />

Indonesian contracts


SCoTA TM Standard Specifications<br />

Calorific Value<br />

(NCV min, but<br />

basis 6000<br />

Volatile<br />

Matter<br />

Total Moisture<br />

(max)<br />

Ash<br />

(m ax)<br />

Sulphur<br />

(max)<br />

IDT<br />

(deg. min)<br />

CaO<br />

(max)<br />

kcal/kg)<br />

ARA (RB) 5,850 22% (m in) 12.0% 15.0% 1.00% 1,250 12%<br />

ARA (AUS) 5,850 24%-35% 15.0% 15.0% 0.75% 1,250 7%<br />

ARA (COL) 5,850 31%-37% 14.0% 11.0% 0.85% 1,250<br />

ARA (RUS) 5,850 26%- 35% 14.0% 15.0% 0.75% 1,250<br />

BOL 5,850 31%-37% 14.0% 11.0% 0.85% 1,250<br />

NEWC 5,850 27%-35% 15.0% 14.0% 0.75% 7%<br />

NEWCF 5,850 27%-35% 15.0% 14.0% 0.75% 7%<br />

RB 1 5,850 22% (m in) 12.0% 15.0% 1.00% 1,250 12%<br />

All specifications are on an “as received” basis (and ISO standard)<br />

All transactions are basis 6,000 kcal/kg net as received with price adjustments as per SCoTA<br />

In all cases, a maximum top-size of 50mm and a Hardgrove Index range of 45-70 is specified<br />

NOTE: this table is a summary only and should be used in conjunction with SCoTA


<strong>globalCOAL</strong> – INDO A Product<br />

• Proposed Quality Specifications as listed below:<br />

• Calorific Value (GAR, kcal/kg): Basis 6,200; Min 5,900 GAR<br />

• Total Moisture (as received): Max 18.0%; Typical 13.0%<br />

• Volatile Matter (air dried): Min 38.0%; Max 45.0%<br />

• Ash (as received): Max 16.0%<br />

• Sulphur (as received): Max 1.0%; Typical 0.80%<br />

• Selenium (ppm, dry basis)*: Max 2; Typical < 1.0<br />

• Boron (ppm, dry basis)*: 100<br />

• Calcium Oxide in ash (dry basis): Max 7.0%<br />

• Nitrogen (ash free): Max 1.8%<br />

• Hardgrove Grindability Index*: 40 - 50<br />

• Nominal Topsize (mm): 50<br />

• A.F.T. (initial deformation, deg C): Min 1,150<br />

• Size Restriction*: no more than 30% (by weight) shall pass 2 mm square<br />

mesh screen.<br />

* Typical – not used for determining whether or not a Shipment complies with the specification.


<strong>globalCOAL</strong> – INDO B Product<br />

• Proposed Quality Specifications as listed below:<br />

• Calorific Value (GAR, kcal/kg): Basis 5,400; Min 5,000 GAR<br />

• Total Moisture (as received): Max 30.0%; Typical 22.0%<br />

• Volatile Matter (air dried): Min 38.0%; Max 43.0%<br />

• Ash (as received): [Max 10.0%; Typical 4.0%]<br />

• Sulphur (as received): [Max 1.0%; Typical 0.30%]<br />

• Selenium (ppm, dry basis)*: Max 2; Typical < 1.0<br />

• Boron (ppm, dry basis)*: 170<br />

• [Calcium Oxide in ash (dry basis): Max 15.0%]<br />

• Nitrogen (ash free): Max 1.7%<br />

• Hardgrove Grindability Index*: 40 - 55<br />

• Nominal Topsize (mm): 50<br />

• A.F.T. (initial deformation, deg C)*: Typical 1,150<br />

• Size Restriction*: no more than 30% (by weight) shall pass 2 mm square<br />

mesh screen.<br />

* Typical – not used for determining whether or not a Shipment complies with the specification.


<strong>globalCOAL</strong> – Clause 13.3 Proposed Quality<br />

Adjustments<br />

• Ash Adjustments:<br />

• INDO A Product: US$ 0.35/mt per 1.0% Ash < 5.0% & pro-rata<br />

• INDO B Product: US$ 0.35/mt per 1.0% Ash < 4.0% & pro-rata<br />

• Sulphur Adjustments:<br />

• INDO A Product: Premium: US$ 0.35/mt per 0.1% TS < 0.4% & pro-rata<br />

• INDO B Product: Premium: US$ 0.35/mt per 0.1% TS < 0.4% & pro-rata<br />

• Moisture Adjustments:<br />

• INDO A Product: Penalty: >16% 27%


<strong>globalCOAL</strong> – Clause 13.3 Proposed Quality<br />

Adjustments<br />

• CV Adjustments:<br />

• INDO A Product:<br />

5,900


Indonesia Proposed Logistics<br />

• FOB contract<br />

• Shipping to be performed by conventional panamax vessels<br />

• FOB Price based upon single ‘reference’ loadport<br />

• Sellers option to nominate actual loadport<br />

• FOB price adjusted after screen trade according to published<br />

freight differentials between reference port and actual port, based<br />

upon shipping by conventional panamax<br />

• Published differentials to be reviewed on regular basis by<br />

independent shipbroker


Indonesia Proposed Logistics - Example<br />

Possible Origin Locations<br />

Delivery Point A<br />

Published<br />

Freight Differential =<br />

USD 0.25/mt<br />

Reference Point<br />

Published<br />

Freight Differential =<br />

USD 0.35/mt<br />

Delivery Point B<br />

** Assume Conventional Panamax Shipment<br />

FOB Price (Reference Point) = 51.50/mt<br />

The differential from the Reference Point to Delivery<br />

Point A is USD -0.25/mt (closer to consumer)<br />

The differential from the Reference Point to Delivery<br />

Point B is USD 0.35/mt (further away from consumer)<br />

Therefore, the following FOB Prices are possible from<br />

the three delivery locations:<br />

Reference Point: USD 51.50/mt<br />

Delivery Point A: USD 51.50/mt – USD 0.25/mt =<br />

USD 51.25/mt<br />

Delivery Point B: USD 51.50/mt + USD 0.35/mt =<br />

USD 51.85/mt<br />

** Local Port Terms Apply based on Origin of Supply


Development of <strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />

TONNAGE TRADED PER QUARTER TO END NOVEMBER 2004<br />

Total Since Launch (May’01 to date): 43.5 MT (physical and financial)<br />

7,000,000<br />

6,000,000<br />

Total Financial<br />

Total Physical<br />

Total<br />

Linear (Total)<br />

5,000,000<br />

4,000,000<br />

3,000,000<br />

2,000,000<br />

1,000,000<br />

0<br />

Q201 Q301 Q401 Q102 Q202 Q302 Q402 Q103 Q203 Q303 Q403 Q104 Q204 Q304 Q404


Development of <strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />

TONNAGE TRADED PER QUARTER TO END NOVEMBER 2004<br />

Total Since Launch (May’01 to date): 43.5 MT (physical and financial)<br />

7,000,000<br />

6,000,000<br />

5,000,000<br />

TFS API<br />

Phys ARA<br />

SWAP RB<br />

Phys RB<br />

SWAP NEWC<br />

Phys NEWCF<br />

Phys NEWC<br />

Total<br />

Linear (Total)<br />

4,000,000<br />

3,000,000<br />

2,000,000<br />

1,000,000<br />

0<br />

Q201 Q301 Q401 Q102 Q202 Q302 Q402 Q103 Q203 Q303 Q403 Q104 Q204 Q304 Q404


<strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC index (USD/mt RHS) and volumes<br />

traded physical and financial (LHS)<br />

gC NEWC index and volumes November 02 - November 04<br />

Physical NEWC traded (mt, LHS) Swap NEWC traded (mt, LHS) <strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC index (US$/mt, RHS)<br />

2,000,000<br />

65<br />

1,800,000<br />

60<br />

1,600,000<br />

55<br />

1,400,000<br />

1,200,000<br />

1,000,000<br />

800,000<br />

600,000<br />

400,000<br />

200,000<br />

0<br />

Nov-02<br />

Dec-02<br />

Jan-03<br />

Feb-03<br />

Mar-03<br />

Apr-03<br />

May-03<br />

Jun-03<br />

Jul-03<br />

Aug-03<br />

Sep-03<br />

Oct-03<br />

Nov-03<br />

Dec-03<br />

Jan-04<br />

Feb-04<br />

Mar-04<br />

Apr-04<br />

ACCC<br />

allows<br />

allocation<br />

system<br />

Growth in<br />

swaps<br />

trading<br />

despite lack<br />

of physical<br />

tonnes<br />

May-04<br />

Jun-04<br />

Jul-04<br />

Aug-04<br />

Sep-04<br />

Oct-04<br />

Nov-04<br />

50<br />

45<br />

40<br />

35<br />

30<br />

25<br />

20


<strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC index (USD/mt RHS) and %age of<br />

volume traded physical and financial (LHS)<br />

100%<br />

80%<br />

60%<br />

40%<br />

20%<br />

<strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC trades (physical and financial)<br />

as %age of total<br />

Swap NEWC volumes (%)<br />

Physical NEWC volume (%)<br />

<strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC index US$/mt<br />

65<br />

60<br />

55<br />

50<br />

45<br />

40<br />

35<br />

30<br />

25<br />

0%<br />

No<br />

v-<br />

02<br />

De<br />

c-<br />

02<br />

Ja<br />

n-<br />

03<br />

Fe<br />

b-<br />

03<br />

Ma<br />

r-<br />

03<br />

Ap<br />

r-<br />

03<br />

Ma<br />

y-<br />

03<br />

Ju<br />

n-<br />

03<br />

Ju<br />

l-<br />

03<br />

Au<br />

g-<br />

03<br />

Se<br />

p-<br />

03<br />

Oc<br />

t-<br />

03<br />

No<br />

v-<br />

03<br />

De<br />

c-<br />

03<br />

Ja<br />

n-<br />

04<br />

Fe<br />

b-<br />

04<br />

Ma<br />

r-<br />

04<br />

Ap<br />

r-<br />

04<br />

Ma<br />

y-<br />

04<br />

Ju<br />

n-<br />

04<br />

Ju<br />

l-<br />

04<br />

Au<br />

g-<br />

04<br />

Se<br />

p-<br />

04<br />

Oc<br />

t-<br />

04<br />

No<br />

v-<br />

04<br />

20


Coal Indices: Sustainability<br />

An index should be:<br />

– Based on verifiable data<br />

– Transparent<br />

– Difficult to manipulate<br />

What distinguishes different indices?<br />

– Quality and source of underlying data – verifiable trades<br />

or “reported” trades?<br />

– Method of calculation – transparent methodology or “black box”?<br />

– Frequency of calculation – real time or once a week?<br />

Coal Indices Should be Representative of the Marketplace


RB Index TM , NEWC Index TM<br />

• Created by the coal industry, for the coal industry<br />

• Free of any interpretation or judgment<br />

• The most accurate reflection of actual market prices<br />

• Measures price of standard specification of thermal coal (Phys<br />

RB1 TM or Phys NEWC TM specs) for delivery in forward three months<br />

• Underlying data: firm bids/offers and trades in Phys RB1 TM or Phys<br />

NEWC TM instrument on <strong>globalCOAL</strong>’s Standard Coal System<br />

• Published method of calculation, rigidly applied in real time, using<br />

data from transparent source:<br />

• Weighted average of trade prices and bids/offers<br />

• Several mechanisms/filters in place to prevent manipulation<br />

• Calculated daily, weekly and monthly<br />

• Note:- All bids/offers/trades used to calculate the Index are based on the same<br />

terms, conditions, specs etc i.e. compares “apples with apples”.<br />

• Standardisation takes place before, not after the deals


Index Calculator Example


Newcastle Physical/Financial Market Evolution<br />

• Pre July 2002 – The concept of developing a marker price for the Newcastle<br />

market to help provide more transparency for buyers and sellers. The concept of<br />

the Newcastle Marker Price Initiative (NMPI) is developed whereby a marker price<br />

will be published once per month.<br />

NMPI Concept - A sponsor would offer up a cape per month to be sold on<br />

<strong>globalCOAL</strong>’s platform<br />

• July 2002 – The first NMPI took place on <strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />

• September 2002 – Work commences on the development of a NEWC Index<br />

• October 2002 – The NEWC methodology is approved by the market (note - the<br />

timeframes of the NMPI straddle both Asian/European timezones)<br />

• November 2002 – The first NEWC Swap trade takes place on gC’s platform<br />

• September 2004 – Approx. 17.50 MM tonnes of Physical and 2.7 MM tonnes of<br />

NEWC Swaps transacted on <strong>globalCOAL</strong>; however, this does not account for<br />

what has been transacted via voice brokers in the OTC market


Market Transparency<br />

All Phys NEWC Prices from December 2001 to August 2003<br />

30.00<br />

US$/mt<br />

29.00<br />

BIDS<br />

OFFERS<br />

28.00<br />

27.00<br />

Pre NMPI<br />

Post NMPI<br />

26.00<br />

25.00<br />

24.00<br />

23.00<br />

22.00<br />

21.00<br />

20.00<br />

1-Jan-02 2-Mar-02 1-May-02 30-Jun-02 29-Aug-02 28-Oct-02 27-Dec-02 25-Feb-03 26-Apr-03 25-Jun-03 24-Aug-03<br />

Could This Concept Be Applied to Indonesia, thereby<br />

creating liquidity in another market ?


Other Indices in the market<br />

TFS API#2® – spot thermal coal for CIF ARA, basis 6000 Kcal/kg NCV<br />

TFS API#3® – spot thermal coal for FOB Newcastle, basis 6700 Kcal/kg GAD<br />

TFS API#4® – spot thermal coal for FOB RBCT, basis 6000 Kcal/kg NCV<br />

Argus/McCloskey - spot thermal coal FOB Newcastle<br />

Underlying data: Journalists survey the participants in the industry<br />

Method of calculation: Average of journalists price reports.<br />

Calculated weekly and monthly.<br />

Relies on knowledge and experience of journalists to ask right questions of right people<br />

and understand if answers are true! Arguably very vulnerable to variety of risks.<br />

Audited?<br />

CoalinQ – spot thermal coal FOB Newcastle, within 3 months, basis 6700 GAD<br />

Underlying data: Panel of 6 producers (of which 1 anthracite, 3 Queensland); 12 Japanese<br />

& 1 Korean consumers; 6 “traders” of which 3 Japanese Trading Houses<br />

Method of calculation: Average of panellists price assessments.<br />

Calculated fortnightly.


60.00<br />

55.00<br />

50.00<br />

45.00<br />

40.00<br />

35.00<br />

30.00<br />

25.00<br />

20.00<br />

<strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC Index TM vs. Other Indices<br />

<strong>globalCOAL</strong> NEWC Index<br />

BJI<br />

CoalinQ (CV Adj)<br />

API#3<br />

5-Aug-02<br />

5-Sep-02<br />

5-Oct-02<br />

5-Nov-02<br />

5-Dec-02<br />

5-Jan-03<br />

5-Feb-03<br />

5-Mar-03<br />

5-Apr-03<br />

5-May-03<br />

5-Jun-03<br />

5-Jul-03<br />

5-Aug-03<br />

5-Sep-03<br />

5-Oct-03<br />

5-Nov-03<br />

5-Dec-03<br />

5-Jan-04<br />

5-Feb-04<br />

5-Mar-04<br />

5-Apr-04<br />

5-May-04<br />

Note how the NEWC index usually leads the others. As it is real time also note the larger price<br />

swings on the NEWC index whereas weekly prices are “smoothed” with the other indices.<br />

5-Jul-02


INDICES<br />

The importance of a good index<br />

<strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />

<strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />

Commoditised<br />

Commoditised<br />

Physical Physical<br />

Market<br />

Market<br />

Published, Auditable and FSA Regulated<br />

<strong>globalCOAL</strong> Index Methodology<br />

<strong>globalCOAL</strong> Indices<br />

(RB & NEWC)<br />

<strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />

<strong>globalCOAL</strong><br />

Commoditised<br />

Commoditised<br />

Financial Financial<br />

Market<br />

Market<br />

OTC OTC<br />

Broker<br />

Broker<br />

Financial Financial<br />

Market<br />

Market<br />

Tender Tender<br />

Contracts<br />

Contracts<br />

Haze of coal quality<br />

conversions and price<br />

interpretations<br />

Other Indices<br />

WARNING:<br />

Even in the lack of physical trading<br />

activity, the financial market must<br />

NEVER be used to price indices.<br />

Physical Physical<br />

Market<br />

Market<br />

Settlement<br />

Spot Spot<br />

& Longer<br />

Longer<br />

Term Term<br />

Physical<br />

Physical<br />

Market<br />

Market<br />

(index based)<br />

(index based)<br />

Calculation


Questions and Answers<br />

Thank you

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!