Our new President: - The Founder
Our new President: - The Founder
Our new President: - The Founder
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>The</strong> true meaning of Valentine’s Day, p. 6<br />
free!<br />
the independent students’ <strong>new</strong>spaper of royal holloway, university of london<br />
Tuesday 13 February 2007 | www.thefounder.co.uk | Issue 6<br />
Elections results announced on Wednesday last week<br />
Marcus O’Shea<br />
Vice-<strong>President</strong>:<br />
Education & Welfare<br />
Valentine’s Edition<br />
<strong>Our</strong> <strong>new</strong> <strong>President</strong>:<br />
Joff Manning<br />
Joff Manning won in a landslide victory over Ellen Garrett,<br />
Jayne Mills and Judith Ratcliffe with over 700 votes<br />
<strong>The</strong> Sabbatical Team 07-08<br />
“...I will be doing<br />
everything within<br />
my power to work<br />
with you towards<br />
a better future for<br />
students.”<br />
“I want to make sure that the Union continues to have a strong voice on campus and in the local area,<br />
by developing a stronger working relationship with college and the community, all working together<br />
for your benefit.”<br />
Nicki Robinson<br />
Vice-<strong>President</strong>:<br />
Communications & Services<br />
“I will justify the<br />
Union’s spending,<br />
so that students<br />
know where their<br />
money goes, and<br />
that the SU is not<br />
a profit-making<br />
organisation.”<br />
Kate Manning<br />
Vice-<strong>President</strong>:<br />
Student Activities<br />
“I want to put<br />
Holloway on<br />
the map for<br />
our drama, for<br />
our sport, for<br />
our music and<br />
societies, for our<br />
student activities.”<br />
FULL STORY, PAGE 2<br />
AND SO IT BEGINS...<br />
ANY PIZZA<br />
ANY SIZE<br />
£7.99<br />
PHONE<br />
01784 471999<br />
CARS (Egham) LTD<br />
“<strong>The</strong> Caring Taxi Company”<br />
01784<br />
47 11 11<br />
All calls are recorded for<br />
quality and training purposes
Should this Union remain affiliated to the NUS? | Yes - 1160 No - 257<br />
2 NEWS Tuesday 13 February 2007 thefounder<br />
Complaints, insults and campaigns:<br />
Election results announced at 6:50pm last Wednesday<br />
By Victor Bernards<br />
<strong>The</strong> Sabbatical and Media Elections<br />
were held last week as the<br />
Students’ Union saw a record<br />
number of ballots cast. <strong>The</strong> positions<br />
that were up for grabs were<br />
<strong>President</strong>, Vice-<strong>President</strong> for Education<br />
and Welfare, Vice-<strong>President</strong><br />
for Communications and Services,<br />
Vice-<strong>President</strong> for Student Activities,<br />
Publication Editor, Deputy<br />
Publication Editor, Station Manager<br />
and Deputy Station Manager.<br />
Canvassing had already been under<br />
way since Wednesday 31 January<br />
with student candidates storming<br />
the campus with flyers, posters<br />
and leaflets as to why they should<br />
be elected in (see last week’s edition<br />
of <strong>The</strong> <strong>Founder</strong>).<br />
As well as having a record voting<br />
turnout, the elections are also reported<br />
to have seen a record number<br />
of complaints ranging from<br />
slander and poster-pulling to abuse<br />
of Facebook.<br />
<strong>The</strong> SU’s Elections Code of Conduct,<br />
which is considered Draconian<br />
by some, is very strict and states<br />
that candidates are not allowed to<br />
canvas themselves online by any<br />
means. Of course, the success of<br />
the website, Facebook, over the past<br />
couple of years has meant that regulating<br />
this rule is becoming increasingly<br />
more difficult. With ‘Facebook<br />
campaigns’ being the subject of<br />
many official complaints, it is likely<br />
that the website will be properly incorporated<br />
in the Code of Conduct<br />
by next year, with candidates either<br />
<strong>President</strong><br />
Winner in 1st round<br />
Joff Manning | 796<br />
Ellen Garrett | 319<br />
Jayne Mills | 118<br />
Judith Ratcliffe | 115<br />
RON (re-open nominations) | 37<br />
Clockwise from top: another vote is cast; Joff Manning grins contentedly as result is announced;<br />
noticeboard covered with election posters (like most round campus) DAN NICHOLLS<br />
being allowed to use it, or having<br />
their profiles disabled during the<br />
canvassing period.<br />
<strong>The</strong> candidates had more or less<br />
Vice-<strong>President</strong>:<br />
Education & Welfare<br />
Winner in 3rd round<br />
Cat Vince | 568<br />
Marcus O’Shea | 824<br />
a free reign over campus between<br />
9am and 9pm so it is likely that readers<br />
will have run into them at some<br />
point. <strong>The</strong> favoured areas for canpaigning<br />
were the dinner halls and<br />
certain halls of residences (some<br />
were out of bounds). Student apathy<br />
is reported to currently be at an<br />
Vice-<strong>President</strong>:<br />
Communications & Services<br />
Winner in 3rd round<br />
Will Sudlow | 532<br />
Nicki Robinson | 718<br />
all-time high and many candidates<br />
reported that students responded in<br />
a hostile manner when approached.<br />
This was particularly prevalent at<br />
the Kingswood, off-campus site<br />
where posters were repeatedly torn<br />
down and/or heavily defaced. Some<br />
graffiti accusations were particularly<br />
offensive though no action was<br />
Similarly the SU were criticised<br />
for not acting on a number of official<br />
election complaints, some of which<br />
After heated campaigning on the<br />
final days of canvassing, the ballots<br />
were closed at 7:00pm on Tuesday<br />
6 February and counting started<br />
at midday on Wednesday 7 February.<br />
<strong>The</strong> counting session normally<br />
lasts around four hours but with<br />
record voting (over 1500 ballots<br />
cast), the Elections Committee did<br />
not emerge from the International<br />
Building until 6:50pm to announce<br />
the results in Tommy’s Bar. As students<br />
crammed themselves in, the<br />
tense and emotions were beginning<br />
to break through as the results were<br />
announced (as below) with some<br />
insults being shared between candidates<br />
and official aides. For the losing<br />
candidates it was a sad moment<br />
and some of the winners had mixed<br />
emotions. It is now a matter of seeing<br />
if our <strong>new</strong>ly elected representatives<br />
can follow through with their<br />
taken by the SU.<br />
included illegal use of Facebook.<br />
atmosphere became extremely<br />
promises.<br />
Listen to Insanity’s podcast:<br />
www.insanityradio.com<br />
Vice-<strong>President</strong>:<br />
Student Activities<br />
Winner in 1st round<br />
Kate Manning | 763<br />
Matt Shepherd | 336<br />
Cath Welsby | 254<br />
RON | 40<br />
Publication Editor<br />
Winner in 1st round<br />
Deputy<br />
Publication Editor<br />
Winner in 1st round<br />
Station Manager<br />
Winner in 1st round<br />
Deputy<br />
Station Manager<br />
Winner in 1st round<br />
Jack Lenox | 589<br />
Adam D’Souza | 1017<br />
Joe Friel | 824<br />
Naomi Sharpe | 1232<br />
Mario Creatura | 688<br />
RON | 330<br />
Callum Just | 486<br />
RON | 175<br />
RON | 53<br />
RON | 53
thefounder Tuesday 13 February 2007<br />
NEWS<br />
3<br />
By Will Adams<br />
Last Monday five brave members<br />
of RHUL Boat club shed their<br />
clothes and their dignity in aid of<br />
the Raise And Give (RAG) Calendar.<br />
Not wanting to do anything by<br />
halves, they then embarked on a leirates<br />
of some elderly lunchers, they<br />
headed under Staines bridge, getting<br />
those all important pictures<br />
taken, only to be attacked by two<br />
rather angry swans (think they saw<br />
what looked like a snack).<br />
After that it was full steam back<br />
to the boat house and some warm<br />
pants, until the bowman caught<br />
a crab, knocking him for six and<br />
made the crew worry that they may<br />
to have done such a deed; members<br />
of Dance, BALADS, Absolute Harmony,<br />
Expedition, Women’s Rugby,<br />
Lacrosse, Men’s Rugby, Hockey, the<br />
Executive Committee and Netball<br />
have also showed skin in the pursuit<br />
of charity and fame. <strong>The</strong> RAG<br />
Calendar will be on sale in RAG<br />
week (12th-18th February) for a<br />
fine sum of £5 at the RAG stand<br />
in the SU, the proceeds go to the<br />
Willow Foundation that grants the<br />
terminally ill opportunities and experiences.<br />
RAG made over £20,000<br />
last year for various charities and<br />
Get your cox out for RAG Week!<br />
“...they gave each<br />
other a smug smile<br />
in the knowledge<br />
that their buttocks<br />
would very soon be<br />
the public property<br />
of Holloway students...”<br />
aims to improve this year. With<br />
RAG week kicking off next week<br />
there is a whole host of fundraising<br />
events on show.<br />
If you want to get involved and a<br />
free t shirt join the RAG triathlon<br />
on Thursday consisting of a 2km<br />
row, 5km cycle and a 3km run on<br />
the Friday, sign up sheet and sponsor<br />
forms in the student activities<br />
office.<br />
It’s all for charity so get up, get<br />
involved!!!<br />
See this week’s ‘What’s on’ in the<br />
Arts section for the full run-down<br />
of the RAG events!<br />
<strong>The</strong> team steam down the Thames<br />
surely early afternoon row through<br />
Staines. As heads turned, camera<br />
phones shot out of onlookers’<br />
pockets quicker than you can say<br />
“look it’s a boat full of naked rowers!”<br />
Needless to say the cry of “It’s<br />
for charity” was almost on repeat.<br />
At a cosy 3 degrees, the team decided<br />
to keep the outing short parading<br />
themselves past the HA!HA!<br />
Bar, Outback restaurant and the<br />
Swan Hotel, not to mention numerous<br />
local resident’s houses, wearing<br />
nothing but rowing shoes and reluctant<br />
smiles. Having risen heart<br />
With the Sabbatical and Media<br />
elections out of the way, one can<br />
look back at the sheer intensity<br />
of reactions from both the high<br />
quality of Candidates and Students<br />
on how they felt about the<br />
election. This year has set to bring<br />
about the highest turnout of voters<br />
for a long time. It can also<br />
be branded as one of the dirtiest<br />
elections with high levels of complaints<br />
from across the board.<br />
Looking over the week campaign,<br />
as a student, I can say that it<br />
has been toughly fought with Candidates<br />
working hard promoting<br />
themselves and their policies. This<br />
has hit a variety of student audiences<br />
from the enthusiastic and receptive,<br />
those who have an element<br />
of interest but were unaware of who<br />
have to swim home. As they travelled<br />
home they gave each other a<br />
“...Needless to say<br />
the cry of “It’s for<br />
charity” was almost<br />
on repeat...”<br />
smug smile in the knowledge that<br />
their buttocks would very soon be<br />
the public property of Holloway<br />
students.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y were by no means the first<br />
<strong>The</strong> team in photo from left to right: Cox: Jane Reid, 1: Will Adams, 2: Malcolm Munelly, 3: Nic<br />
Watson, 4: Tristan Stewart<br />
Politics, apathy and students: all in a day’s work<br />
By Sahar Mirhadi<br />
was running, to the full spectrum<br />
of apathy and disinterest. Will Sudlow,<br />
Candidate for Communications<br />
and Services, has described<br />
the Campaign as ‘Surreal, where<br />
people recognise you through your<br />
leaflets and policies’. Joe Friel, Candidate<br />
for Station Manager has<br />
come across a good reaction during<br />
his week campaign, where he has<br />
received points he had never considered<br />
and has quoted that ‘this is<br />
“..one of the dirtiest<br />
elections with<br />
high levels of complaints<br />
from across<br />
the board...”<br />
what doing the campaign is about,<br />
listening to people’.<br />
This is all fair and well, but students<br />
have felt that they have been<br />
bombarded with leaflets showing<br />
the many candidates and also not<br />
being fully informed by the Union<br />
“...a variety of<br />
student audiences<br />
from the<br />
enthusiastic and<br />
receptive...to the full<br />
spectrum of apathy<br />
and disinterest...”<br />
about who is running for what and<br />
the candidates having to explain<br />
this. Further some students have<br />
expressed a level of apathy, stating<br />
that the election will not affect lives<br />
of students and that casting a vote,<br />
will not make a change. This is true<br />
of the opinion of some third years<br />
who as Christopher Chapman, Official<br />
Aide to Will Sudlow stated<br />
‘they are cynical as they have heard<br />
the same policies time and time<br />
again, but rarely are they delivered’.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re have also been concerns<br />
throughout the campaign about<br />
the rules and the level of increasing<br />
complaints considering certain candidates<br />
over the campaign. Candidates<br />
and Students have expressed<br />
views that the rules and regulations<br />
are too rigid and do not allow for<br />
creativity and imagination for ideas<br />
on how to promote oneself. However,<br />
speaking with the Elections<br />
“...the rules and<br />
regulations are too<br />
rigid and do not<br />
allow for creativity<br />
and imagination...”<br />
Officer (James Bromige), there will<br />
be a possible review on making<br />
elections more open, in time for<br />
the executive elections, coming up<br />
in march.<br />
So taking all this, the campaign<br />
has definitely had a mixed reaction<br />
from students and candidates<br />
alike with some candidates saying<br />
“...This election will<br />
hopefully push for<br />
more radical and innovative<br />
ideas...”<br />
that it has been an enjoyable week<br />
and have met lots of <strong>new</strong> people<br />
to some hating it and wishing it to<br />
be over, but all putting in so much<br />
hard work. This election will hopefully<br />
push for more radical and innovative<br />
ideas and might change<br />
the way things are done at Royal<br />
Holloway, with more creativity<br />
around elections and according to<br />
Andrew Coleman, Communications<br />
and Services Candidate ‘making<br />
it more fun’.
NEWS Tuesday 13 February 2007 thefounder<br />
Prestigious award for Royal Holloway lecturer<br />
David Cesarani, Professor of Jewish History at Royal Holloway<br />
By Lara Stavrinou<br />
Professors at Royal Holloway are<br />
being showered with awards this<br />
season. <strong>The</strong> latest to receive recognition<br />
is David Cesarani, Professor<br />
of Jewish History, who has<br />
been awarded the Gerrard and<br />
Ellman Award for his book Becoming<br />
Eichmann (2006), by the<br />
American Jewish Book Council.<br />
Cesarani mainly researches modern<br />
Jewish history- namely the relations<br />
between Jews and non-Jews.<br />
He also has a vast knowledge when<br />
it comes to ethnicity, immigration,<br />
German history, and Genocide. He<br />
has supervised and acted as an advisor<br />
to doctoral students studying<br />
these subjects and is an advisor to<br />
the Home Office on Holocaust Memorial<br />
Day. He has also made radio<br />
documentaries for the BBC and advised<br />
the Imperial War Museum on<br />
their permanent Holocaust exhibition.<br />
In addition to this book, Professor<br />
Cesarani has also published<br />
Eichmann: His Life and Crimes<br />
(2004) and <strong>The</strong> Left and the Jews<br />
(2004).<br />
Cesarani explains that “writing<br />
about Eichmann was a challenge,<br />
and at times it was quite distressing.<br />
But mass atrocity and genocide<br />
is still going on, so I hope the book<br />
will help people to understand the<br />
perpetrators and be better equipped<br />
to deal with racism and the murderous<br />
actions it can lead to”. In this<br />
book, he offers a complex portrait<br />
of Adolf Eichmann,<br />
a fanatical anti-<br />
Semite who was<br />
heavily involved<br />
in the Jewish persecution.<br />
Cesarani’s<br />
extensive<br />
research has<br />
allowed him<br />
to dig into the<br />
past and write<br />
a work that<br />
corrects various<br />
historical<br />
records.<br />
C e s a r a n i<br />
p o r t r a y s<br />
Eichmann<br />
as a man<br />
w h o<br />
m a d e<br />
d e l i b -<br />
e r a t e<br />
choices<br />
in<br />
h i s<br />
p u r-<br />
s u i t<br />
of power, which<br />
resulted in his desensitisation to<br />
the atrocities committed. He rejects<br />
misconceptions that portrayed the<br />
man as either dumb or purely animalistic<br />
and, on a whole, presents a<br />
psychological analysis of genocide.<br />
This is to be his first book award<br />
and it truly is a prestigious one. “<strong>The</strong><br />
award came as a complete surprise<br />
and I am delighted. It is fantastic<br />
to get such reco<br />
g -<br />
n i -<br />
t i o n<br />
from<br />
a<br />
p r e s -<br />
tigious<br />
b o d y<br />
like the<br />
J e w i s h<br />
B o o k<br />
C o u n -<br />
America,”<br />
m e n t s .<br />
<strong>The</strong> Jewish<br />
Book Council<br />
is one of<br />
cil of<br />
he com-<br />
ish literature<br />
it is no wonder<br />
that the author<br />
<strong>The</strong> award will<br />
the world’s<br />
largest Jew-<br />
advocates so<br />
is delighted.<br />
be presented<br />
on March 6 in New York.<br />
9am lectures and shared toilets: worth it?<br />
By Tim Ruffles<br />
Universities UK has just released<br />
the results of research commissioned<br />
from Pricewaterhouse-<br />
Coopers on the economic benefits<br />
resulting from attaining a degree.<br />
<strong>The</strong> research states that there are<br />
“significant economic benefits”<br />
to acquiring a degree, and that<br />
on average, gaining a degree will<br />
mean you earn 20% to 25% more<br />
over your lifetime than if you simply<br />
had two A levels.<br />
Although the report stresses the<br />
continued worth of higher education,<br />
it also highlights the uneven<br />
spread of the advantages; depending<br />
on the subject studied and the<br />
student taking the course.<br />
Gender is the strongest factor in<br />
determining how much you will<br />
gain from attaining a degree. Women<br />
gain a lot more from attaining<br />
degrees than similar men; after adjusting<br />
for other variables such as<br />
socio-economic background and<br />
family income, a woman law graduate’s<br />
lifetime earnings would be 44%<br />
higher than if she’d just had two A<br />
levels. A similar male law graduate’s<br />
would be only 27% higher than if<br />
he’d merely taken two A levels.<br />
As well as this, males from higher<br />
socio-economic backgrounds will<br />
not receive as much benefit from<br />
higher education. A male with a<br />
high socio-economic background<br />
will have around 6% lower wage return<br />
from his degree than another<br />
male who has a lower socio-economic<br />
background. <strong>The</strong> effect of<br />
a woman’s socio-economic background<br />
is fairly negligible; however,<br />
in women’s cases those from<br />
a higher socio-economic background<br />
receive very slightly higher<br />
wage returns.<br />
<strong>The</strong> economic benefits translate<br />
into an average life time earnings<br />
increase of as much as £340,000, in<br />
the case of medicine. <strong>The</strong> average<br />
return of all degrees is £160,000.<br />
Some subjects however, have<br />
much smaller rewards than this.<br />
Humanities students can only look<br />
forward to around a £50,000 life<br />
times earnings increase, compared<br />
to a business and finance student’s<br />
£185,000. A student taking management<br />
at Royal Holloway when<br />
told of the report’s findings by <strong>The</strong><br />
<strong>Founder</strong> said “I think this report<br />
shows my course leads on to a good<br />
job. I’m glad I did something which<br />
employers really want!”.<br />
<strong>The</strong> report suggests that certain<br />
£340,000<br />
Medicine<br />
Business<br />
and Finance<br />
students may actually be losing<br />
potential earnings through achieving<br />
a degree; men taking arts degree<br />
actually receive 4% less than a<br />
Average<br />
Degree<br />
European<br />
Languages<br />
similar individual with only two A<br />
levels.<br />
Impact on lifetime earnings of<br />
gaining a degree level qualification<br />
compared to 2 A-Levels:<br />
£185,000<br />
£160,000<br />
£97,000<br />
£51,000<br />
Chart images: Tim Ruffles<br />
Source: Department of Economics, University of Warwick, from Labour Force Survey<br />
Humanities
thefounder Tuesday 13 February 2007<br />
NEWS & COMMENT<br />
5<br />
As the tension built, things turned somewhat scrappy at the Sabbatical and Media Elections<br />
thefounder editorial team<br />
Editor-in-Chief<br />
Jack Lenox<br />
jack@thefounder.co.uk<br />
News Editor<br />
[Currently vacant]<br />
Features Editor<br />
[Currently vacant]<br />
Media Editors<br />
Dan Nicholls<br />
dan@thefounder.co.uk<br />
Michael Dean<br />
michael@thefounder.co.uk<br />
Comment, Opinion<br />
& Letters Editor<br />
John Hunter<br />
john@thefounder.co.uk<br />
Proof readers<br />
Peter Brown, Veronica Paez, Helen Johnson<br />
Business Manager<br />
Simon Hepher<br />
simon@thefounder.co.uk<br />
Arts Editor<br />
Beth Turrell<br />
beth@thefounder.co.uk<br />
Sports Editor<br />
Allison Ealey<br />
allison@thefounder.co.uk<br />
Deputy Business Manager<br />
Lina Pio<br />
lina@thefounder.co.uk<br />
Photography<br />
& Images Editor<br />
Tim Ruffles<br />
tim@thefounder.co.uk<br />
Cartoonist<br />
Bob Groves<br />
bob@thefounder.co.uk<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Founder</strong> is the independent student <strong>new</strong>spaper of Royal Holloway, University of London. We distribute 4,000 free<br />
copies per week during term time around campus and to popular student venues in and around Egham.<br />
<strong>The</strong> views expressed in this publication are those of the author and not necessarily those of the Editor-in-Chief or of<br />
Three Wise Munkeys Ltd, especially of comment and opinion pieces. Every effort has been made to contact the holders of<br />
copyright for any material used in this issue, and to ensure the accuracy of this week’s stories.<br />
Please contact the Editor-in-Chief if you are aware of any omissions or errors.<br />
For advertising enquiries contact the Business Manager.<br />
Post<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Founder</strong><br />
C/O VP:ComServ<br />
Students’ Union<br />
Royal Holloway<br />
University of London<br />
Egham, Surrey<br />
TW20 0EX<br />
Web<br />
www.thefounder.co.uk<br />
Email<br />
editor@thefounder.co.uk<br />
Want to write for thefounder?<br />
No problem! Just get in touch!<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Founder</strong> is published by Three Wise Munkeys Ltd and printed by quotemeprint.com<br />
All copyright is the exclusive property of Three Wise Munkeys Ltd<br />
No part of this publication is to be reproduced, stored on a retrieval system or submitted in<br />
any form or by any means, without prior permission of the publisher.<br />
Designed by Jack Lenox, Tim Ruffles and Dan Nicholls<br />
Many thanks to Russell Signs, CDWOW!, Vue Cinemas and Philippa Johnson<br />
© Three Wise Munkeys Ltd, 2006. 16 Avenue Road, Witham, Essex, CM8 2DT
6 EDITORIAL & OPINION Tuesday 13 February 2007 thefounder<br />
&<br />
Editorial Opinion<br />
thefounder<br />
john@thefounder.co.uk<br />
<strong>The</strong> real meaning of Valentine’s Day<br />
By Sarah Leaford<br />
Every February, across the<br />
country, men and women<br />
go into a blind panic trying<br />
to fulfil their obligation to romance<br />
their nearest and dearest with sweets,<br />
flowers, and gifts. <strong>The</strong> pressure to<br />
create the perfect evening or make<br />
the ultimate statement of romance<br />
detracts from the simple idea of love<br />
and appreciation. Even for those not<br />
under any obligation to wine and<br />
dine their better half, Valentines<br />
Day isn’t a barrel of laughs. It’s the<br />
ultimate time to feel lonely and gain<br />
a stark awareness of the unavoidable<br />
fate of being single forever and ever.<br />
Company is sought in the bottom<br />
of a pint glass and the day is either<br />
spent vowing that next February<br />
will be different or resigning oneself<br />
to a lifetime of Februarys like this.<br />
According to one survey, 32%<br />
of the British public confess to<br />
actually having bought themselves<br />
an anonymous present so as not to<br />
lose face among other gift-receiving<br />
friends! And all in the name of St.<br />
Valentine. But who is this mysterious<br />
saint? And are we celebrating this<br />
holiday as it was intended?<br />
<strong>The</strong> history of Valentine’s Day<br />
and its patron saint is shrouded<br />
in mystery. But we do know that<br />
February has long been a month<br />
of romance. <strong>The</strong> day itself has its<br />
roots in both Christian and ancient<br />
Roman tradition. But there is debate<br />
over who exactly was Saint Valentine<br />
and how he became associated with<br />
this day of romance.<br />
One legend contends that<br />
Valentine was a priest who served<br />
during the third century in<br />
Rome. When Emperor Claudius<br />
II decided that single men made<br />
better soldiers than those with<br />
wives and families, he outlawed<br />
marriage for young men in order<br />
to achieve the ultimate army.<br />
Valentine, realising the injustice<br />
of the decree, defied Claudius and<br />
continued to perform marriages<br />
for young lovers in secret. When<br />
Valentine’s actions were discovered,<br />
Claudius ordered that he be put to<br />
death. Other stories suggest that<br />
Valentine may have been killed<br />
for attempting to help Christians<br />
escape harsh Roman prisons<br />
where they were often beaten and<br />
tortured. According to one legend,<br />
Valentine actually sent the first<br />
Who is this<br />
mysterious<br />
saint? And are<br />
we celebrating<br />
this holiday<br />
as it was<br />
intended?<br />
‘valentine’ greeting himself. While in<br />
prison, it is believed that Valentine<br />
fell in love with a young girl who<br />
visited him during his confinement.<br />
Before his death, it is alleged that he<br />
wrote her a letter, which he signed<br />
‘From your Valentine,’ an expression<br />
that is still in use today.<br />
Although the truth behind the<br />
Valentine legends is murky, the<br />
stories certainly emphasise his<br />
appeal as a sympathetic, heroic,<br />
and, most importantly, romantic<br />
figure. He certainly didn’t pop down<br />
to Clinton’s and buy the whole<br />
shop! It’s no surprise that by the<br />
Middle Ages, Valentine was one of<br />
the most popular saints in England<br />
and France. It seems a shame that<br />
a day pinpointed to remember a<br />
noble hero has been eclipsed by<br />
commercialism and expectation.<br />
Maybe by going back to basics, this<br />
Valentines day we can forget about<br />
spending ridiculous amounts and<br />
trying to have the perfect day, and<br />
just feel grateful that thanks to St<br />
Valentine, love has been allowed to<br />
prevail – in all its forms.<br />
A bitter taste<br />
By Guy Galloway<br />
which has a different<br />
effect on the<br />
yeast and endows<br />
each ale with a<br />
uniquely complex<br />
taste and aroma. It<br />
also has the same<br />
alcoholic qualities<br />
of the yellow water<br />
served on campus,<br />
meaning you<br />
can still get totally<br />
whacked if you so<br />
desire.<br />
Beer. What is it? Asking<br />
various people to define<br />
what it actually is produces<br />
greatly different<br />
results. Some people<br />
suggest that it is a piss-coloured liquid<br />
designed to get the consumer as<br />
drunk as possible, while rendering<br />
them so mentally confused that they<br />
accidentally sleep with members of<br />
the opposite sex. Others look at beer<br />
as a beautiful concoction of delicate<br />
flavours to enjoy on warm summer<br />
afternoons and to cheer you up during<br />
the long winter nights in the<br />
pub. Now I would classify both definitions<br />
as correct… although this<br />
judgement is not completely based<br />
on personal experience (ahem).<br />
However, it seems that an alarming<br />
number of people see beer as a<br />
homogenous category of drink, and<br />
cannot make the distinction between<br />
a fine ale and a lager. Many<br />
blindly follow what Medicine and<br />
Stumble call ‘beer’ (i.e. lager) and<br />
end up consuming copious amount Crosslands,<br />
of said yellow water with the aim of<br />
getting themselves inebriated. Now<br />
anyone who has visited ‘<strong>The</strong> Happy<br />
Man’ and ‘<strong>The</strong> Holly Tree’ and other<br />
off-campus pubs will know that the<br />
bigger (and much more handsome)<br />
brother of this yellow water, real<br />
ale, is by far a much more satisfying<br />
pint. Real ale is fermented at much<br />
higher temperatures than lager,<br />
To analogise<br />
this for the wine<br />
drinker: imagine<br />
if you had the<br />
choice between a<br />
flavoursome wine<br />
or a Lambrini,<br />
with little or no<br />
difference in price<br />
- which would you<br />
choose? Although<br />
real ale may be the<br />
far superior breed<br />
of beer, only one<br />
pub on campus,<br />
has<br />
caught on to the<br />
fact that it is in big demand. To the<br />
relief of many students, ales such<br />
as ‘London Pride’ and ‘Old Hooky’<br />
are now available on tap. Although<br />
Crosslands is perhaps not the most<br />
desirable establishment to spend<br />
an evening in, its investment has<br />
drawn in many of the ale appreciators<br />
who would previously be found<br />
supping a sorry Grolsch in a corner<br />
of the Stumble. Crosslands’ bar staff<br />
also suggest that it has proved to be<br />
a very popular investment indeed.<br />
So why isn’t real ale served in<br />
other campus pubs and bars? That’s<br />
a question it seems that no-one<br />
has any answer to. It makes sense:<br />
Crosslands sells its real ale for a<br />
higher price than most of its lagers,<br />
and is more profitable than the lagers<br />
that it shares a counter with.<br />
Perhaps the debt-laden SU should<br />
take note? Most London pubs have<br />
at least one or two real ales on tap,<br />
but for some reason there are no real<br />
ales in SU pubs or bars. As a result it<br />
is the off-campus pubs which get the<br />
business, and it is the SU which lose<br />
out on a tidy revenue. Hopefully<br />
PHOTO: JONATHAN WOLLNY<br />
they will finally begin to catch on to<br />
the fact that there is a big demand<br />
during the next month. <strong>The</strong> SU will<br />
be polling around campus during<br />
February to find out the demand for<br />
real ale amongst the student population.<br />
So use your vote wisely for the<br />
sake of students, and for the sake of<br />
the SU!
thefounder Tuesday 13 February 2007<br />
EDITORIAL & OPINION<br />
7<br />
By Martin O’Neill<br />
To what extent can Bede<br />
be described as ‘a scholar<br />
of the renaissance,<br />
born hundreds of years<br />
before his time’?<br />
What factors have shaped the form of<br />
urban settlements in Romania?<br />
Essay questions. Doubtlessly, we’ll<br />
have to start browsing online journals<br />
and library shelves to be able to<br />
answer the questions, but our first<br />
port of call won’t be JSTOR. Equally,<br />
if we have to give a presentation<br />
on a topic, there is one place that<br />
will help us know what we are talking<br />
about without having to wade<br />
through piles of books. Departments<br />
warn against using it as a reference<br />
in essays, but students love it<br />
all the same.<br />
Wikipedia has certainly been one<br />
of the greatest recent developments<br />
in the field of student research. It’s<br />
quick and convenient, covering all<br />
the main issues in a few paragraphs,<br />
whilst the same issues fill entire<br />
books in the library. Wikipedia often<br />
has pictures, and you can easily<br />
follow from link to link to cover any<br />
related aspects of what you need to<br />
know. Just look up ‘Bede’, or ‘Romania’<br />
and chase your concerns.<br />
It’s not even restricted to academia.<br />
Yes, Wikipedia has lengthy<br />
pages on the European Parliament<br />
and nuclear fusion, but it also has<br />
reams of trivia on every episode of<br />
Futurama, profiles of almost any celebrity<br />
you could care to name, and<br />
even pages close to home, covering<br />
Royal Holloway, Englefield Green<br />
and even Egham railway station.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Wiki-ed ‘Which?’<br />
Whatever your interests, Wikipedia<br />
will cover them. Wikipedia can<br />
seem almost omnipotent, especially<br />
if you use it to cheat on pub quizzes,<br />
or address a debate you had earlier<br />
with your friends on that particular<br />
episode of Lost.<br />
‘Web 2.0’<br />
Wikipedia is the best known example<br />
of the principle of ‘wiki’, whereby<br />
users generate their own content<br />
for the benefit of the collective, and<br />
are able to add and edit to others<br />
contributions, eventually producing<br />
a sum of knowledge greater<br />
than any individual contributor<br />
possesses. This in turn is another<br />
side of what has become known as<br />
‘Web 2.0’, an internet more socially<br />
complex than the original boom of<br />
the 90s. Facebook and other social<br />
networking sites give a good idea of<br />
what ‘Web 2.0’ is all about, as does<br />
YouTube. It is hardly a limited affair,<br />
either. Time magazine named ‘You’<br />
as their ‘Person of the Year 2006’<br />
in honour of the individual-centric<br />
developments including, amongst<br />
others, Wikipedia. ‘Web 2.0’ was<br />
even recently praised at the World<br />
Economic Forum.<br />
It has its critics, just as it has its<br />
supporters. A Newsnight reporter<br />
claimed how the internet was increasingly<br />
filling the role of religion,<br />
providing an environment for the<br />
mind to explore and interact with,<br />
unencumbered by physical form.<br />
Jeremy Paxman found the concept<br />
somewhat ludicrous. ‘Web 2.0’ has<br />
been praised for bring power to the<br />
people, and has been criticised for<br />
not actually existing: under this argument,<br />
there has been no substantial<br />
shift from the user-based systems<br />
already present, such as eBay,<br />
Amazon and the IMDB, amongst<br />
others. <strong>The</strong> debate continues.<br />
Wiki, or not Wiki<br />
Wikipedia is indeed useful. However,<br />
it’s use is primarily as an introduction<br />
to topics, an overview of them,<br />
similar to reading a summary of a<br />
novel rather than the actual book.<br />
That’s fine if you need to know what<br />
the largest lakes in Asia are, but less<br />
useful if you need to know specific<br />
details about the management of<br />
said lakes. Wikipedia misses things<br />
out.<br />
If you try looking up such issues as<br />
‘Chechen Independence’ or ‘Abortion’,<br />
you’ll find a minefield of a narrative,<br />
often presenting both sides<br />
of the argument with equal ferocity,<br />
and a high number of edits. Wikipedia<br />
is not impartial, although it tries<br />
hard to be. Despite the best efforts<br />
of professional ‘Wikipedians’, there<br />
are still many biased articles.<br />
<strong>The</strong> key thing to remember with<br />
Wikipedia is that, whilst it may seem<br />
as if you’re being advised by an omnipotent<br />
force, you’re actually reading<br />
the contributions of a number<br />
of people, not necessarily experts<br />
in their field, often edited together<br />
to form a narrative that can easily<br />
jump between descriptive style. It<br />
is for this reason that departments<br />
warn against its use: the information<br />
you use may not be accurate. I<br />
have found that in many cases, it is<br />
valid, but it still could theoretically<br />
be untrue, as Wikipedia has none of<br />
the barriers placed around articles<br />
in journals and academic books. I<br />
once found a lovely quote for one of<br />
my essays, only to discover no evidence<br />
of the quote from anywhere<br />
else, and thus could not use it.<br />
Carpe Wiki<br />
Interestingly, although Wikipedia<br />
is so widely used, very few people<br />
actually contribute to it. RHUL has<br />
its fair share of contributors, but as<br />
they tend to share the same campus<br />
IP-address, it is hard to tell who edited<br />
what. I’ve witnessed Hollowegians<br />
vandalising pages before, as<br />
well as providing information on<br />
Chelsea players. In one chilling case,<br />
someone wrote an anti-Semitic line<br />
in one article, which was quickly edited<br />
away again.<br />
I eventually decided to set up my<br />
own Wikipedia account after contributing<br />
to some articles. I don’t do<br />
a lot of editing, but I’ve done enough<br />
to learn how Wikipedia is both<br />
so useful and so flawed. Amongst<br />
professional Wikipedians, there are<br />
many codes of conduct as to what<br />
is ‘encyclopaedic’ and what is not.<br />
Edits which promote biased viewpoints<br />
are often quickly removed.<br />
Rewriting of articles is seldom done,<br />
so that the same basic structure is<br />
always being added to. Wikipedians<br />
argue out their differing viewpoints<br />
by claiming their view is more suited<br />
to Wikipedia. For a long time,<br />
the Royal Holloway page was edited<br />
back and forth regarding <strong>The</strong><br />
Da Vinci Code’s Sophie Neveu, a<br />
fictional alumnus of RHUL. Ought<br />
she be included, or not?<br />
I personally have done a fair<br />
amount of editing to the SURHUL<br />
section of the same page. I’ve had<br />
some of my edits revoked by more<br />
professional Wikipedians, arguing<br />
that the data is either biased or irrelevant.<br />
Some societies have promoted<br />
themselves by making sure they are<br />
included as part of the section. As<br />
for the section itself, the notion that<br />
SURHUL is worth its own article<br />
was quickly shot down, as a ‘generic<br />
SU’ isn’t worth it. SOAS’ Union, the<br />
most politically active in the UK,<br />
underwent a debate as to whether it<br />
ought to retain its own page or not:<br />
the general argument was against,<br />
but there were many who pointed<br />
out a clear discrepancy. Thames Valley<br />
University SU has its own page.<br />
So does Hull. In fact, many SUs retain<br />
their own pages, but have not<br />
been challenged because no ‘professional<br />
Wikipedians’ have visited to<br />
make the challenge.<br />
Manipulation<br />
Using the example of Students’<br />
Unions, it ought to be clear how<br />
Wikipedia can be manipulated.<br />
Pages such as ‘<strong>The</strong> United Kingdom’<br />
may undergo massive debate as to<br />
wording and viewpoints, whilst ‘Englefield<br />
Green’ will undergo considerably<br />
less scrutiny. Furthermore,<br />
the first person to write about, say,<br />
Brunel’s Runnymede Campus, puts<br />
in place the basic structure of the<br />
article, which will then be read by<br />
many curious students wanting to<br />
find out a little more about it.<br />
I myself am guilty of that, adding a<br />
photograph to the RHUL main page<br />
shortly before the page was visited<br />
heavily by A-level students researching<br />
where they were about to go.<br />
By all means use Wikipedia. I spend<br />
hours daily on it. However, bear in<br />
mind that what is says is not necessarily<br />
the truth, the whole truth and<br />
nothing but the truth. It is regulated,<br />
contrary to the opinion of many,<br />
but there is no universal agreement.<br />
It is a good thing, a great benefit to<br />
all of us students, but it’s not perfect.<br />
Happy browsing.<br />
Biggles’ Corner<br />
What up, my homie mofos. Biggles in the house here, coming at<br />
you like a Spitfire. Down with you kiddies, yo ho. Apologies to<br />
any adult readers for that outburst of student jargon, but your<br />
poor Biggles has this week been forced to enter the foul mire of students in<br />
order to bring his magic kind of journalism to a <strong>new</strong> and unhygienic audience.<br />
My ruddy face blushes crimsoner still as I dwell on the last week spent<br />
with vile, supernoodle-chomping infants. <strong>The</strong> things I do for journalism<br />
– fortune favours the brave – tally ho!<br />
Biggles found the sabbatical elections of this week somewhat unfulfilling.<br />
<strong>The</strong> election rules of the Student’s Union mean that you poor students<br />
don’t get to participate in all the fun parts of politics, such as mudslinging,<br />
negative ads, intimidation, bullying, and of course, fixing the vote. Instead,<br />
candidates must run solely issue-based campaigns. How can a decent candidate<br />
win an election without chopping their opponent into small pieces and<br />
defecating, sportsmanlike, on their remains? Biggles shakes his head at this<br />
awful take on politics, and ticks another box on his “students are damned<br />
blighters” checklist.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re was, however, one aspect of the University that Biggles found<br />
to be pretty dashed tops, and that was the gallant sports societies, and<br />
their hilarious antics of a Wednesday evening. I found myself roaring with<br />
hearty laughter as these brave laddies performed all kinds of masculine<br />
japes, involving nudity, violence, drinking beer through their own socks<br />
(!) and so much more. In fact, it made me rather teary-eyed for my own<br />
tender schooling at Cambridge, where, one jolly evening, I stripped a poor<br />
chap completely starkers and rode him around Jesus until dawn broke! I’m<br />
sincerely glad that some traditions cannot be stamped out by the liberalpansy-PC<br />
Brigade.<br />
Anyway, all these fine memories have rather stirred up the beast within,<br />
so to speak, and so I must now put down my pen and see what Mrs. Biggles<br />
is up to. Or, as you students say: I’m off to spank my bitch around! View<br />
Haloo!
8 EDITORIAL & OPINION Tuesday 13 February 2007 thefounder<br />
POLITICS SAM KISS<br />
‘Britishness’<br />
A faux notion of identity,<br />
and the decline of the Sceptred Isle<br />
In recent conversation, I stumbled across an individual who believed that the<br />
British were “innately superior, and perhaps the greatest race in the world”.<br />
I was not sure as to whether this statement was cause for pity, rage, revulsion<br />
or concern…or indeed all four. Perhaps civilisation has deceived me.<br />
Perhaps there are still people who believe that the British Empire was a wholly<br />
positive thing, that the slave trade put “those Africans in their place” and that<br />
we should all be throwing stones at Mosques. Indeed, this individual appeared<br />
to believe that the WASP had a right, nay, duty to straddle the globe and spread<br />
glorious ‘British’ values. Spewing Christianity, capitalism, free trade and English<br />
mores out of the metaphorical spunk-flutes of imperialism and globalisation.<br />
Well, I respond in kind to this delusional semi-moron: <strong>The</strong> British are not special.<br />
Britain’s virtues are a product of geographical, ecological and political circumstances;<br />
we are the children of luck. Democracy, free speech, equality, the rule of<br />
law; these values are not intrinsically ‘British’ in character. Unfortunately, these<br />
musings render Sir Keith Ajegbo’s report rather obsolete.<br />
“Britain is committed to the values of free speech, the rule of law, mutual tolerance<br />
and respect for equal rights. <strong>The</strong>y are things that are fundamental to our society.”<br />
Yes. Perhaps this is what makes Britain oh so different from say, the United<br />
States or France. <strong>The</strong>se transcendental values are definitely unique; one can barely<br />
dare to gaze across the channel. Towards those dark despotic lands where prejudice,<br />
inequality, anarchy and sin reign supreme. I respect the general ignorance<br />
and intractability of any individual who seriously believes that the UK is ‘free’ or<br />
‘fair’, that the average Briton is tolerant, that capitalism is just…or indeed effective…that<br />
simple plurality is a paragon of democratic practise. To my mind, the<br />
Ajegbo’s report serves as a fitting indictment of the concept of nationalism. This<br />
‘kingdom of mongrels’ best exemplifies the ills of patriotism. ‘Britishness’ must<br />
be taught, because it is no more innate than ‘Frenchness’ or ‘Americaness’. All of<br />
these notions are entirely artificial, and have been cultivated over the centuries.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y are also necessarily exclusive, prejudicial and irrational; that is the function<br />
of patriotism. That it has become necessary to teach ‘Britishness’ demonstrates<br />
that the theory of nationalism in itself is rapidly becoming redundant. Anglo-<br />
African, Anglo-Asian, Anglo-Irish, Anglo-whatever; all of us have contributed to<br />
the positive development of the British state. That we cannot define ‘Britishness’,<br />
that it is such a dilute and irrelevant concept, is surely an argument in favour of<br />
the dissemination of multiculturalism and liberal ideology? ‘Britishness’ may be<br />
decomposing, but are we not still a nation? Is this not still a country? Of course.<br />
We should be bound together by the ideals of secularism, democracy, justice and<br />
reason.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re’s nothing quite so anachronistic and backward as a nationalist conception<br />
of statehood and citizenship; one need only draw upon Israel as a fitting<br />
modern example. What does it mean to be British? Perhaps supporting various<br />
teams involved in a wealth of pointless grey games, or watching Celebrity Big<br />
Brother. When pressed, I am not sure as to whether I can define modern ‘Britishness’.<br />
We can afford to be proud, but not as extensively as we might wish. <strong>The</strong><br />
NHS, once a beacon to socialists across the Western world, is on the brink of collapse.<br />
Modern Britain is as much a product of globalisation and political mediocrity<br />
as it is of history. Illiberty reigns supreme, as absurdist ‘Religious Intolerance’<br />
Bills are muddled through Parliament and authoritarian ruffians savage habeas<br />
corpus. As if religious belief was not simply an opinion, as any other. As if it<br />
were special: deserving of any more merit than the concepts of socialism, capitalism<br />
or liberalism. Protection for Tories and Communists, perhaps? A pox on the<br />
thoughtful, then. Rule Britannia indeed! A salute to McDonalds, ASBOs, Coca<br />
Cola, anti-intellectualism, Starbucks, Islamists, popular music, football hooliganism,<br />
capitalism, house arrests, child molestation and cultural vapidity.<br />
<strong>The</strong> subject matter may appear somewhat dated, but I think it important that<br />
the question of ‘Britishness’ resonate for some time to come. Until the concept<br />
is dead. Nationalism is nothing more than an agent of division. Polemics aside,<br />
I apologise for the sensationalism. It is true that we are rather lucky; Britain is<br />
still secular and relatively democratic. Many are non-religious, non-racist, openminded,<br />
internationalist, socialist and comparatively well educated. We should be<br />
thankful that an otherwise unreliable government snubbed the often homophobic,<br />
ignorant and atavistic views of the Catholic Church. Flexing the muscles of<br />
exclusion, coughing up hatred and small-minded medieval little semi-thoughts.<br />
<strong>The</strong>se are positive things. Yet we must remember that this is also a land of neoconservatives,<br />
racists, fundamentalists, Tories and Eurosceptics. Irrationalism and<br />
cognition are locked in a struggle that is tantamount to that between Dawkins<br />
and the Church, or capitalism and justice. What I mean to say is that we should<br />
be grateful, but the lionisation of ‘Britishness’ is a dangerous thing. Suggesting<br />
that it should be taught is alone indicative of nationalist sentiment, of a willingness<br />
on the part of our government to sponsor a resurgence of patriotism. This is<br />
absurdist, deadly, naïve and retrogressive.<br />
MILLER & BENSON © BOB GROVES
thefounder Tuesday 13 February 2007<br />
EDITORIAL & OPINION<br />
9<br />
Grammar Schools<br />
<strong>The</strong> only part of Britain’s education system that hasn’t been messed up... yet<br />
y Jack Lenox<br />
ditor-in-Chief<br />
For some years now there<br />
has been relentless criticism<br />
of the UK’s grammar<br />
schools. <strong>The</strong> criticisms<br />
vary but, to be<br />
frank, they seem to be entirely misguided<br />
and ill-informed.<br />
<strong>The</strong> latest wave of whinging has<br />
been caused by the <strong>new</strong> school<br />
league tables that were released just<br />
a few weeks ago. Naturally, the lowest<br />
ranking schools are not happy<br />
and are therefore looking for scapegoats<br />
to explain their poor performance.<br />
<strong>The</strong> key school in question<br />
here is Temple School in Strood,<br />
Kent. Temple is officially, academically,<br />
the worst school in Britain,<br />
and why is it so? <strong>The</strong> “grammar effect”,<br />
as headmaster Neil McAree as<br />
dubbed it. His conclusion is that the<br />
poor performance of his school is<br />
due to the fact that the local grammar<br />
schools absorb all of the most<br />
intellectually gifted children in his<br />
area.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re is no part of Mr McAree’s<br />
argument that I understand. Firstly,<br />
why does it matter that his school<br />
is bottom of the league? Someone<br />
has to be there and if his school gets<br />
good Ofsted reports and provides a<br />
good quality of teaching, he should<br />
not be concerned about the actual<br />
results his pupils achieve. A good<br />
school is a school that does a good<br />
job with the students it is given. To<br />
me, it appears that the recent tables<br />
have simply dented his pride making<br />
him unhappy.<br />
Streaming exceptionally bright<br />
students into grammar schools is<br />
no worse than splitting pupils into<br />
sets. It has been proven that children<br />
tend to be more successful in<br />
Britain’s education system if they<br />
are mixing with pupils of a similar<br />
intelligence. I’m not just talking<br />
about the top end of the class here<br />
either. In classes of mixed intellect,<br />
less intelligent children are mocked<br />
by classmates and are repeatedly<br />
made to feel stupid as their results<br />
persistently fall below the class average.<br />
Eventually they become unenthusiastic<br />
and put in less and less effort.<br />
Similarly, bright pupils become<br />
complacent as they repeatedly score<br />
highly and suffer from the ‘big fish<br />
in a small pond’ syndrome that we<br />
are all aware of.<br />
Grammar schools provide a vital<br />
link for the British public. As much<br />
as people try to dismiss it, Britain is<br />
still very class-based. For the poor<br />
working-class children of this nation,<br />
the one opening for them to<br />
climb the social, and financial ladder<br />
is intellect. In the recent league<br />
tables, grammar schools dominated<br />
the top positions - there were far<br />
more grammar schools in the top 20<br />
than private, public or comprehensive<br />
schools. This is the vital opening<br />
for intelligent, less wealthy children.<br />
Through grammar schools, they can<br />
attend one of the best secondary<br />
institutions in the country and become<br />
likely candidates for the best<br />
universities the country has to offer.<br />
To counter this idea, Mr McAree<br />
stated that grammar schools are restricted<br />
to children whose parents<br />
can afford tuition for the ‘11+’.<br />
Firstly, the ‘11+’ is an IQ test, you<br />
cannot teach a child to be intelligent.<br />
Having been quite involved in the<br />
process for a few years, I have seen<br />
countless wealthy parents chuck<br />
money at tuition for their children<br />
to absolutely no avail. <strong>The</strong>re were<br />
several private primary schools in<br />
my local area that focussed heavily<br />
on training children to pass the<br />
‘11+’ and yet my primary school<br />
<strong>The</strong> 11+ is<br />
an IQ test,<br />
you can’t<br />
teach a<br />
child to be<br />
intelligent.<br />
(which was not private) repeatedly<br />
got a far higher proportion of its<br />
pupils through simply by providing<br />
a good level of teaching and by<br />
streaming pupils into sets for core<br />
subjects such as Mathematics and<br />
English (something many primary<br />
schools are sceptical of).<br />
Secondly, having studied at a<br />
grammar school, I can say firsthand<br />
that pupils are not predominantly<br />
middle/upper-class. In fact,<br />
some of the best pupils at my school<br />
were the least fortunate as far as<br />
wealth is concerned. I doubt anyone<br />
has thoroughly researched it but I<br />
suspect that less wealthy pupils are<br />
more aware of a need to be intellectually<br />
successful from a financial<br />
standpoint, and thus try harder.<br />
Finally on this point, Mr McAree<br />
is completely contradicting himself.<br />
He said that grammar schools were<br />
absorbing all the intelligent children<br />
in the area. Surely if grammar<br />
schools are restricted to children<br />
whose parents can afford private<br />
tuition, his complaint makes absolutely<br />
no sense.<br />
In my opinion, if you’re going to<br />
attack a general type of school, attack<br />
public and private schools - a<br />
tragic scourge of the British education<br />
system that restricts good<br />
education to the wealthy. I find<br />
this theory absolutely hideous and<br />
am a strong believer in equality of<br />
compulsory education. Streaming<br />
children based on ability is fine,<br />
but to stream children into these<br />
PHOTO: ROBIN KEEFE<br />
fee-charging schools is just outrageous.<br />
How can people attack grammar<br />
schools and yet leave the elitist<br />
public schools such as nearby Eton<br />
completely untouched?<br />
Alright, grammar schools are intellectually<br />
elitist, but is there really<br />
anything wrong with that? Sadly,<br />
this government seems to think<br />
there is, and thus established grammar<br />
schools are regularly targeted as<br />
the monasteries were in the 1500s.<br />
If there weren’t enough problems<br />
with our education system at the<br />
moment, it looks as though we will<br />
lose one of the only things that still<br />
operates effectively. Maybe they’ll<br />
convert all the grammar schools<br />
into “arts academies” as they’re<br />
doing with all the under-performing<br />
comprehensives. What is this<br />
government’s obsession with Performing<br />
Arts? Grammar schools are<br />
one of the only surviving traditional<br />
secondary institutions teaching core<br />
subjects to a very high standard. If<br />
we lose them, we will cut a key resource<br />
to the greatest minds of Britain’s<br />
future.
0 EDITORIAL & OPINION Tuesday 13 February 2007 thefounder<br />
Oh-Mi-Pod<br />
By Jamie Russell<br />
Something in my journalistic conscience<br />
(a contradiction in terms, I admit)<br />
urges me to begin apologetically. <strong>The</strong><br />
ubiquitously marketed iPod TM is not<br />
only a tired metaphor employed in the<br />
low-grade ramblings of many a hack pawing for<br />
the zeitgeist, but also tends to initiate the populist<br />
writer’s well-oiled punning machinery. <strong>The</strong><br />
combination of these facts lays the groundwork<br />
for a long list of wonderfully insightful tracts with<br />
all too catchy titles - a list to which this article is<br />
unfortunately appended. As much as it hurts to<br />
say it, I believe the hype too. Afterall, there must<br />
be something in it.<br />
For one who chooses to play through their<br />
library in shuffle, the mp3 player’s influence can<br />
be almost biblical. We hope for a moment of<br />
alignment between song and the quotidian march<br />
of life - a landscape that washes right through you<br />
to a 4:4 beat, or a lyric that one might easily wrap<br />
around their day – and maybe allow ourselves<br />
to believe that, at the very least, coincidence is<br />
‘no coincidence’, as if some ethereal intellect has<br />
talked to us. Of course, I don’t swallow my own<br />
hyperbole. <strong>The</strong>re is no community of deluded<br />
psychotics wandering about heeding the voices<br />
in their headphones, but there is, nevertheless,<br />
a cue for some to take comfort in the arbitrary<br />
sympathy of an mp3 player. Carrying around such<br />
an extensive library is a security blanket – like<br />
uploading versions of your self into a pocketsize<br />
and tangible space, which, I guess, is what puts the<br />
‘i’ in iPod.<br />
So, though we may wish to resist the cloying<br />
generalization that surrounds it, we cannot deny<br />
the iPod’s very real presence in our lives. If there<br />
is a greater philosophy in it, it might combine in<br />
PHOTO: EDWARD DUFFIELD<br />
us a sort of egotism and hope for clarity, for if we could<br />
download each other, then we could come somehow closer<br />
to actually communicating. But, then again, if that were<br />
possible, why would we bother expressing ourselves in the<br />
first place?<br />
Today’s music lovers don’t just listen on the move, they<br />
write their lives down to be kept in a safe place, though the<br />
jury is still out on how real and safe a place it actually is. So,<br />
in the meantime, keep your ‘i’ on it.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Adored<br />
Red, a humming, a drumming<br />
It sings and yearns to fly<br />
It yearns to saw, to catch the star<br />
Awash your dreamy inner eye.<br />
I would give you my heart<br />
For just one kiss.<br />
A single kiss, solitary caress<br />
Adorned in a vessel of fermenting<br />
Fruits, nestled between<br />
Bulgingly bright strawberries<br />
Over ripe,<br />
Soft, sweet fallen mangoes.<br />
Oh for that pressing of flowers<br />
Ruffled petals, grasping stems<br />
Upturned roots<br />
Bursting buds<br />
A single fragranced mouth full.<br />
I present my heart burning my<br />
Milk stained fingers,<br />
My eyes wider, lips redder<br />
Hands hot, dripping hotter<br />
Take hold - my heart<br />
In a wooden box, embossed<br />
<strong>The</strong> clasp beating, thumping<br />
Jumping, peeping.<br />
Dressed in a bow deepest<br />
I part my lips, for you and only<br />
You, crack my dawn awash with dew<br />
Where flowers grow, raise their<br />
Heads and smile.<br />
Your damp warm mouth<br />
Your lips about mine<br />
Your lips about my lips -<br />
A swallow flitting, I caress its<br />
Body hold it, feel it kick and writhe<br />
Releasing, breathing in to touch<br />
Catch it and cage him.<br />
Anonymous<br />
An Introdu<br />
By Jack Perschke<br />
On 06 Mar 2007 RHUL will be host<br />
to a debate involving some of the<br />
UK’s most important figures in the<br />
sustainability debate. <strong>The</strong> Shadow<br />
Minister for the Environment, CEO<br />
of <strong>The</strong> Campaign to Protect Rural<br />
England, a former CEO of <strong>The</strong> Met<br />
Office and a Director of, corporate<br />
giants, Diageo will be locking horns<br />
in the search for a path toward sustainable<br />
living. <strong>The</strong> week after will<br />
see Prof John Lowe of RHUL give a<br />
presentation on Climate Change. He<br />
is one of the pioneers in the use of<br />
ice-cores to create a historical record<br />
of global temperatures. His research<br />
has been ground-breaking and helped<br />
shape the global climate change debate.<br />
In the build up to these two<br />
important events, “<strong>The</strong> <strong>Founder</strong>” is<br />
serialising an article on sustainability<br />
that should help inform, interest and<br />
entertain. We hope it will help give<br />
a background to some of the issues,<br />
spark debate around campus and<br />
help those lucky enough to attend<br />
either event to offer insightful and<br />
valuable contributions.<br />
An Introduction to<br />
Sustainability<br />
Many readers of “<strong>The</strong> <strong>Founder</strong>”<br />
will have heard the word “sustainability”<br />
used. For some it relates to<br />
self-sufficiency, to others re-cycling<br />
and to few more it has something to<br />
do with global climate change and<br />
drowning polar bears. <strong>The</strong> truth of<br />
sustainability is that, whilst it does<br />
relate to those issues, it is a far more<br />
wide-reaching and complex field.<br />
In 1987 the UN convened a commission<br />
to look into sustainability<br />
and they defined it as a lifestyle<br />
that, “meets the needs of the present<br />
generation without compromising<br />
the ability of future generations to<br />
meet their own needs”. For most of<br />
us at Royal Holloway I suspect that<br />
sounds like a fairly sound ambition.<br />
It fits with the traditional beliefs of<br />
our society which include, inheritance,<br />
supporting our children and<br />
grandchildren, and appreciating<br />
and protecting our environment.<br />
Unfortunately, no matter how desirable<br />
sustainability may be, it seems<br />
humanity is failing to meet its demands.<br />
Population Growth<br />
<strong>The</strong> background to all issues of sustainability<br />
is the unprecedented size<br />
of the human population on Earth.<br />
It took from the dawn of time until<br />
the early 1800’s for the number<br />
of humans on earth to reach 1bn.<br />
Each extra billion after that has appeared<br />
at an exponential rate. It<br />
took about 250,000 years for the human<br />
population to reach 1bn, the<br />
last 200 years has seen our numbers<br />
on this finite planet reach a massive<br />
7bn. Population growth does seem<br />
to be tailing off but, unfortunately,<br />
it’s the wealthiest that are producing<br />
less children, but it is also the<br />
wealthy that tread most heavily on<br />
the earth.<br />
Ecological Footprints<br />
Malthus famously predicted that, as<br />
population is growing at a geometric<br />
rate (2,4,8,16 etc etc) and food<br />
production grows at an arithmetic<br />
rate (1,2,3,4 etc etc), the human<br />
population would run out of food<br />
by the middle of the 19 th century.<br />
Clearly we got to that point, and<br />
subsequently saw a seven fold increase<br />
in population, yet the majority<br />
of us have had enough food and<br />
resources. How has this happened?<br />
<strong>The</strong> answer is that humanity has increased<br />
the efficiency with which it<br />
utilises the resources of our planet.<br />
Fertilisers, pesticides and, soon,<br />
GM crops have all contributed to<br />
the fact that the last 50 years have<br />
seen a population growth of 100%<br />
but an agricultural land use growth<br />
of only 10%.<br />
And it’s not just food production<br />
that is getting more efficient,<br />
we live in cramped, high-rise cities<br />
to preserve space, we travel via fast<br />
transport to save time, we package<br />
our food so it lasts longer and we<br />
use electricity to make everything<br />
quicker and easier. In short, we<br />
have grown very adept at living in<br />
an increasingly crowded world, but<br />
with each innovation our impact on<br />
this world is increasing.<br />
<strong>The</strong> principle of an ecological<br />
footprint is how much of the world’s<br />
resources are needed to support<br />
an individual’s lifestyle. In other<br />
words, if every person on the planet<br />
lived as you do, could the earth support<br />
itself? <strong>The</strong> answer for the vast<br />
majority of RHUL students will be<br />
no. Typically, we live at a rate that<br />
would require three earths if everyone<br />
lived like us. This means that<br />
each of us is wealthy at the expense<br />
of others, we are using their allocation<br />
of the world. Of course they are<br />
not using it now, but every time one<br />
hears mention of growing pollution<br />
in China or Africa consider the fact<br />
that the reason it’s so damaging to<br />
the earth is because, up until now,<br />
we have been using up their capacity<br />
to effect the earth sustainably.<br />
Global Governance and <strong>The</strong> Rise<br />
of Corporate Power<br />
<strong>The</strong> corporation has long been identified<br />
as the bad guy in the world of<br />
environmental issues. Be it Shell,<br />
Nestle or Rio Tinto we all know how<br />
they rape the earth without care or
thefounder Tuesday 13 February 2007<br />
EDITORIAL & OPINION<br />
11<br />
ction to Sustainability<br />
consideration. Don’t we?<br />
<strong>The</strong> rise of corporate power has<br />
been a symptom of the increased<br />
efficiency alluded to above. For<br />
production to be efficient it must<br />
have economies of scale. Mass<br />
production and the commercial<br />
power houses that make it happen<br />
are a price we pay for feeding,<br />
clothing and housing a population<br />
that grew by 700% in 200<br />
years. In criticising corporations<br />
we are sometimes in danger of<br />
sounding like the Judean People’s<br />
Front in Monty Python’s <strong>The</strong> Life<br />
of Brian.<br />
“I mean, what have the corporations<br />
ever done for us?”<br />
“Well, there are the roads.”<br />
“And the sewage.”<br />
“Oh, and the feeding of our ever<br />
growing populations”<br />
“What about clean housing, freedom<br />
from disease, the use of cars,<br />
electricity and communications.”<br />
“OK, apart from the roads, the<br />
sewage, the food, the housing,<br />
freedom from disease, cars, electricity<br />
and communications …..<br />
what have they ever done for<br />
us?!!”<br />
However, there are problems. Joel<br />
Bakan’s recent film, <strong>The</strong> Corporation,<br />
suggested that 51 of the<br />
world’s 100 largest economies<br />
are not countries but corporations.<br />
Indeed, even the GDP of<br />
a relatively large and prosperous<br />
country like Denmark is less than<br />
the turn-over of General Motors.<br />
This growth in size, has combined<br />
with increased interconnectivity<br />
and global reach brought about by<br />
globalization and the two factors<br />
have combined to give corporations<br />
greater access to, and sway<br />
with, the brokers of international<br />
power. For its supporters, bodies<br />
such as the World Trade Organisation<br />
(WTO) reflect the value<br />
corporations add to our lives. For<br />
its detractors the WTO is symptomatic<br />
of the undemocratic, and<br />
every growing, power these vast<br />
companies hold over us.<br />
<strong>The</strong> fact is that corporate power<br />
has grown hugely in the last 100<br />
years but should we simply rejoice<br />
in the efficiency giving power of<br />
their profit motives? Or spend<br />
more time worrying about the<br />
tendency for profit to ignore the<br />
needs of the planet and our future<br />
generations?<br />
Global Climate Change<br />
Climate change is the issue of today.<br />
We can feel it around us, we have a<br />
scientific consensus on it, it has been<br />
taken up by the media as a pet topic<br />
and, probably as a result of those<br />
events, it is starting to be taken seriously<br />
by politicians. Because of this,<br />
climate change is often seen as being<br />
synonymous with issues of sustainability,<br />
however, as I hope last week’s<br />
article showed, it is really just a part<br />
of our global habit for unsustainable<br />
living. If one considers sustainability<br />
failure as the hidden disease,<br />
climate change is the prominent<br />
symptom.<br />
I think most have an idea about<br />
global climate change but there are<br />
a few facts that I would like to establish.<br />
First, we all rely on “<strong>The</strong><br />
Greenhouse Effect” to live. Without<br />
the warming effect of the natural<br />
level of greenhouse gasses in<br />
our atmosphere the earth’s average<br />
temperature would be about -18°C,<br />
rather than its current, much more<br />
pleasant, +13°C. So “<strong>The</strong> Greenhouse<br />
Effect” is not as abstract as<br />
we think, we rely on it to live. However,<br />
what most don’t know is that<br />
the level of these gasses was 280<br />
parts per million (ppm) before the<br />
industrial revolution, and currently<br />
stand at 430 ppm. Most scientists<br />
agree that it will take immediate action<br />
to stabilise the level between<br />
500 and 550 ppm. Argue the specifics<br />
at will, but I would suggest that<br />
altering a fundamental, global, lifegiving<br />
mechanism to that degree is<br />
bound to bring serious issues for<br />
our world.<br />
And largely that is the point, for<br />
from here, the speculation starts.<br />
Will it simply raise temperatures a<br />
little, making England a nicer place<br />
to live? Will it raise sea levels flooding<br />
millions in South East Asia? Will<br />
it raise sea temperatures so that we<br />
see an increase in extreme weather<br />
events? Will it cause desertification<br />
and starvation in Africa? Will reduce<br />
global temperature differentials<br />
causing total disruption of our<br />
climate drivers and possibly heralding<br />
a <strong>new</strong> age of climate conditions<br />
intolerable to humans? Maybe it<br />
will do all of them eventually. <strong>The</strong><br />
fact is that, because of the amount<br />
a variables involved in weather patterns,<br />
weathermen sometimes get<br />
tomorrow’s weather wrong when<br />
predicting in one place on good information.<br />
To expect global predictions,<br />
for a century from now, based<br />
on unprecedented conditions to be<br />
accurate is not reasonable. What we<br />
can conclude though is that something<br />
will happen and, when it’s on<br />
a global scale, and, when we don’t<br />
know what it is, are we happy risking<br />
it in return for cheaper flights,<br />
petrol and electricity?<br />
Sustainability – all questions, or<br />
are there some solutions too?<br />
So let’s just re-cap. <strong>The</strong> world is over<br />
populated and relies upon industrial<br />
exploitation of the Earth to sustain<br />
itself. <strong>The</strong> richer we become the<br />
less we populate but the greater the<br />
impact each of us has on the earth.<br />
This need for efficiency has resulted<br />
in the rise of corporations on which<br />
we rely for many of our basic needs.<br />
However, in the process of serving<br />
our needs, they have gained a level<br />
of power and influence that many<br />
are uncomfortable with. <strong>The</strong> system<br />
of greater good resulting from<br />
an individual’s pursuit of gain, upon<br />
which capitalism relies, seems to<br />
be failing to take in to account the<br />
needs of our planet and our future<br />
generations. <strong>The</strong> clearest symptom<br />
of all this today is global climate<br />
change, the effect of which no one<br />
knows for sure. To paraphrase Oliver<br />
Hardy, “That’s another fine mess<br />
we’ve got ourselves into!”<br />
So where do we turn to for answers?<br />
Can our politicians lead<br />
the way? Or should business start<br />
amending their operating models to<br />
account for the earth? Even if these<br />
two things happen how can we<br />
avoid economic and social collapse,<br />
resulting from reduced efficiencies?<br />
I’m sorry to say I don’t have the answers.<br />
But I am confident that answers<br />
will start to arise so long as we<br />
keep asking the questions.<br />
Every day and in every area of our<br />
lives we need to keep questioning.<br />
Do I need to consume that product?<br />
Do I need to use the car? Is my boss<br />
doing all s/he can? Are my political<br />
representatives doing all they can?<br />
Are my friends doing their bit? Is<br />
science the answer? Is science<br />
what got us here in the first place?<br />
Should I commit myself to finding a<br />
solution? Will my children be part<br />
of the problem or victims of it? If<br />
history has taught us anything it is<br />
that humans can overcome even the<br />
most insurmountable problems but<br />
they need to accept the problem exists,<br />
open themselves to innovation<br />
and pursue their goal mercilessly.<br />
As Ray Anderson, the CEO of pioneering<br />
carpet manufacturer Interface,<br />
has said,<br />
“<strong>The</strong> climb to the top of Mount Sustainability<br />
is an arduous, but rewarding,<br />
journey. Every foothold<br />
gained begins with a self-questioning<br />
analysis of our processes and materials<br />
and the determination to achieve<br />
even better results with less, and ultimately,<br />
no impact on our environment”.<br />
I would suggest that this is a pretty<br />
good place for all of us to start. Sustainability<br />
is the challenge of our<br />
generation and, so long so long as<br />
we appreciate its importance, I for<br />
one am confident that we have what<br />
it takes to meet it.<br />
Jack Perschke is a student<br />
at Royal Holloway<br />
studying Sustainability<br />
and Management<br />
To continue the debate and have your say<br />
why not attend a “Question-Time” style<br />
event being held at <strong>Founder</strong>s Lecture<br />
theatre at 7pm on 06 Mar 2007? <strong>The</strong> panel<br />
will include former CEO of the Met Office,<br />
the Shadow Minister for <strong>The</strong> Environment,<br />
CEO of <strong>The</strong> Campaign to Protect Rural<br />
England and <strong>The</strong> Corporate Citizenship<br />
director for, massive corporation, Diageo.<br />
Tickets are £5 per head and can be<br />
reserved by emailing:<br />
mail@jackperschke.com<br />
Contribute!<br />
editor@thefounder.co.uk<br />
thefounder
Life in A Day<br />
Multimedia Exhibition<br />
with high-profile photographer, Alistair Morrison<br />
15 February 2007, Windsor Building<br />
Calling all Staff and Students! Celebrate your part in the<br />
Royal Holloway community and be part of the exhibition<br />
• Come to the Windsor Building between 9.00am – 5.30pm to have your<br />
portrait taken<br />
• Return to the Windsor Building to find your portrait, have a drink and<br />
experience the interactive exhibition from 6.30pm<br />
Check out Alistair Morrison’s photos at www.alistairmorrison.com<br />
Find out more about this exciting event at www.facebook.com<br />
Xxxxx<br />
Royal Holloway, University of London<br />
Egham, Surrey, TW20 0EX<br />
T: 01784 0000<br />
www.rhul.ac.uk
FRANCIS WHEEN<br />
Born in 1957 and a Royal Holloway student in the 1970s, Francis Wheen is now a world-renowned<br />
journalist and writer. In 1997 he was named Columnist of the Year for his ‘Wheen’s World’ page in the<br />
Guardian. He now has a weekly column in the Evening Standard (Tuesday edition) and is the Deputy<br />
Editor of Private Eye.<br />
His best-selling biography of Karl Marx (shown<br />
left) won him the Isaac-Deutscher prize in 1999 and<br />
he more recently published, ‘How Mumbo-Jumbo<br />
Conquered the World’ (also shown left), a hilarious<br />
book looking at the “spirit of the age” in the world<br />
today. <strong>The</strong> list goes on, you can find a full list of his<br />
titles on his Wikipedia page.<br />
Francis Wheen’s books can be<br />
bought online and in all good<br />
bookstores, and can be ordered<br />
from Royal Holloway’s<br />
College Bookshop<br />
(opposite the Windsor Building)<br />
thefounder will be running a feature on Francis Wheen in the near future!
14 ARTS Tuesday 13 February 2007 thefounder<br />
Arts<br />
thefounder<br />
beth@thefounder.co.uk<br />
What’s on...<br />
RAG week is here!<br />
RAG week is here – so make sure you<br />
come along and support us at all the<br />
fabulous events we have arranged<br />
for you! Also look out for us around<br />
campus and particularly in the SU<br />
during the day – we have a stall and<br />
will be selling a multitude of fun<br />
things including Valentine’s flowers<br />
and accessories for the evening<br />
events! You can even get your picture<br />
taken with a load of your mates or<br />
that special someone!<br />
If you can’t quite spare the cash, we<br />
would love it if you could donate some<br />
of your time – we are always looking<br />
for volunteers to help out at one of our<br />
many crazy fundraising events!<br />
All money will be donated to <strong>The</strong><br />
Willow Foundation – special days<br />
for seriously ill young adults.<br />
Date: Event: Time: Place:<br />
11th Feb ‘07 RAG Stumble Pub Quiz 8pm Stumble Inn<br />
12th Feb ‘07 Hypnotist 10pm (TBC) SU<br />
13th Feb ‘07 Arabian Night <strong>The</strong>me 9pm Medicine<br />
14th Feb ‘07 Going Commando ft. Full Monty 10pm SU<br />
15th Feb ‘07 X-Factor Final and RAG Triathlon 10pm SU<br />
16th Feb ‘07 Coyote Ugly and RAG Triathlon 10pm SU<br />
17th Feb ‘07 RAG Battle of the Bands 10pm Medicine<br />
18th Feb ‘07 RAG Cabaret (TBC) SU<br />
<strong>The</strong>atre<br />
<strong>The</strong> Importance of <strong>The</strong>atre…<br />
By Beth Turrell<br />
Arts Editor<br />
<strong>The</strong>re’s a lot going on in the<br />
West End at the moment.<br />
A diverse range of shows<br />
from dance and drama to comedy<br />
and musicals. High quality theatre,<br />
as you would expect from the<br />
theatre capital of the world. As<br />
ever though there is also a lot of<br />
unnecessary rubbish. I’m pretty<br />
sure I could be proven wrong for<br />
all of this and I’m expecting to be<br />
accused of theatre-naivety (which<br />
is a term that will be made up<br />
simply due to my comments and<br />
opinions that are to follow) and<br />
ignorance and not ‘looking deep<br />
enough’ or knowing what ‘true art<br />
is’. But frankly…why is <strong>The</strong> Lord<br />
of the Rings on stage? I know, I<br />
know, it was a masterpiece on the<br />
screen so why would it not make<br />
the transfer to the stage? Well<br />
why would it? Great landscapes<br />
and epic journeys…pretty much<br />
the best part of the films and the<br />
books (probably). <strong>The</strong>n again, of<br />
course…it is being staged at Drury<br />
Lane and if any theatre is going<br />
to cope with this sort of ‘epic’ theatre<br />
(in the non-theoretical sense)<br />
it is the stage to have dealt with<br />
Miss Saigon and that infamous<br />
helicopter scene. My complaints<br />
don’t stop here; it’s going to be a<br />
musical.<br />
Decided against singing Hobbits<br />
on stage? Take the walk from<br />
Covent Garden down towards<br />
Charing Cross Road and you’ll be<br />
faced with puppets on stage. Yes,<br />
Avenue Q has had great reviews;<br />
‘Simply the funniest show in town’,<br />
‘A monster hit’, ‘An outrageously<br />
funny musical hit ’. It’s quirky and<br />
a <strong>new</strong> idea, that seems to work. But<br />
really puppets on a stage. Puppets<br />
on a stage for two hours. I’ve seen<br />
Team America. I’m done. I know<br />
what your thinking having spent<br />
a couple of minutes reading what<br />
you thought may be intellectual<br />
insight into the actual ‘importance<br />
of theatre’ yet you have so far had<br />
someone rant cynically about the<br />
nonsense on the stage. And shows<br />
I have not even seen may I add. But<br />
I plan to. Not Lord of the Rings of<br />
course, you couldn’t get my bum on<br />
a seat at Drury Lane within the next<br />
“...It wouldn’t surprise<br />
me if it won<br />
an Oscar, the most<br />
sought after filmaward<br />
just because it<br />
won everything else<br />
so they thought, ‘why<br />
not!’...”<br />
few months if they gave out free Elijah<br />
Woods cardboard cut-outs or<br />
if Frodo was being played by Julie<br />
Walters (my favourite) actually for<br />
Julie Walters I would go. Just for in-<br />
trigues sake.<br />
Don’t get me wrong, <strong>The</strong> Lord of<br />
the rings is bound to scoop every<br />
award known to man. it is going to<br />
be the most expensive show ever<br />
put on in the west end with a cast<br />
of 50. It wouldn’t surprise me if it<br />
won an Oscar, the most sought after<br />
film-award just because it won<br />
everything else<br />
so they thought,<br />
‘why not!’<br />
Avenue Q has<br />
already done well<br />
so I will give it<br />
a try. But puppets…really?!<br />
I’d like to breeze<br />
over Daddy Cool<br />
but the idea Javine<br />
(Popstars reject)<br />
and Harvey (ex so<br />
solid crew) taking<br />
the starring roles<br />
leads me to leave<br />
any sort of sarcastic<br />
cynicism to<br />
your imaginations. But just so you<br />
know, £10 day seat are available.<br />
I will however, endeavour to, by<br />
next week, have seen at least one of<br />
these and give it a true review. If all<br />
else fails I will go and see what the<br />
critics recommend and stop moaning.
thefounder Tuesday 13 February 2007<br />
ARTS<br />
Blasted explodes cut-throat theatre<br />
By Neil Thornton<br />
“Wogs” and “Pakis” are doing to something from the wreckage leaving<br />
a glimmer of hope.<br />
audience is supposed to do? Direc-<br />
cruelty lie in us all, or at least in all<br />
thrust upon them, what is that an ply that the seeds of unimaginable<br />
the country he loves, and it is hinted<br />
that he himself may well be engaged<br />
in murderous action against<br />
By now, you probably think that<br />
something like this should never be<br />
tor Jenny Sealey makes it clear, in<br />
the horrific scene of male rape: we<br />
men? 21st century media and technological<br />
capabilities have brought<br />
them. Certainly he has a gun, put on public view and should have are supposed to recognize the fact us significantly closer to the realities<br />
of war, more so than we were<br />
<strong>The</strong>atre today runs through which he constantly displays and been kept in the mind of the tormented<br />
author, well, now add this with it.<br />
even in 1995, predominantly mind-<br />
of the disability, to accept, and deal<br />
pretty much every emotion,<br />
idea, theory, or opin-<br />
he also has cancer and an astrin-<br />
to the mix:<br />
It questions our own moral views; less, inhuman civil war conflicts<br />
seems scared. However, because<br />
ion any of us I can think of. But<br />
is it time we ask, “What is acceptable<br />
theatre?” As a drama student<br />
I can be bias to loving any <strong>new</strong><br />
gent humour, it is hard to despise<br />
him exclusively, as he throws back<br />
the gin and puffs away heroically<br />
on the cigs. But events become increasingly<br />
With killings, suicides, numerous<br />
rapes and cannibalism in this<br />
intense piece, the general hysteria<br />
of audiences in 1995 is understand-<br />
I must admit when I was watching<br />
the character of Ian, played fantastically<br />
by McDermott, standing naked<br />
in front of the tiny, frail look-<br />
that characterise parts of the developing<br />
world. <strong>The</strong>refore society on<br />
the whole is more aware of the capabilities<br />
of many humans, showperformance<br />
nasty.<br />
able. Yet seeing Blasted a<strong>new</strong> in the ing, thumb sucking body of Cate<br />
that is controversial<br />
and boundary pushing, but I can During the night in a scene, production at the Soho <strong>The</strong>atre, it (Ellison), I found myself swamped “...Blasted is a play<br />
understand where people come<br />
is clear that this is in no way a piece with fear, not for the character, but<br />
from when they riot against certain<br />
“...This <strong>new</strong> production<br />
that distresses its audience for the the actress herself. I felt it was of-<br />
that breaks its own<br />
performances.<br />
sake of shocking. This <strong>new</strong> producfensive<br />
for her to be there. It wasn’t<br />
goes beyond; it<br />
structure apart, and<br />
A recent example would be the<br />
tion goes beyond; it takes apart the until later when Ellison’s acting<br />
latest revival of Blasted, the debut takes apart the script script and uncovers <strong>new</strong>, shocking<br />
aspects. This is thanks to the survival that I began to think, why<br />
took centre stage as Cate battles for leaves its audience<br />
play by Sarah Kane. Sarah Kane<br />
was one of the most talented and and uncovers <strong>new</strong>, Graeae <strong>The</strong>atre Company, which can’t she be there? This is a grown shattered...”<br />
controversial young writers to<br />
aims to bring together disabled and woman, fully aware and consenting<br />
shocking aspects...”<br />
emerge during the nineties, her<br />
non-disabled actors, writers, and of what she is doing - something ing us that these things are part of<br />
small but awesome collection of<br />
five plays and a screenplay are a which, uncharacteristically, we<br />
audiences. It is for this reason that<br />
two of the main three actors in this<br />
she loves. David Toole as the Soldier<br />
also does an amazing job of<br />
reality and are part of the human<br />
capacity.<br />
powerful body of work. Her first don’t witness - Ian brutally rapes production of Blasted are visibly, conveying both the danger and the So now, more than ten years later,<br />
play Blasted was written in 1995 - Cate, odd, as he had seemed genuinely<br />
fond of her. <strong>The</strong>n all hell “...I found myself mind, without any legs, he relied therefore more powerful than when<br />
nature of his characters tortured Kane’s play is more significant and<br />
it was the biggest theatrical scandal<br />
since Howard Brenton’s <strong>The</strong> Romans<br />
in Britain in 1980. <strong>The</strong> public room; an explosion decimates the<br />
ver around the stage, something saw her prophesize the waning dis-<br />
breaks out. A soldier erupts into the<br />
swamped with fear,<br />
completely on his arms to maneu-<br />
it was first publicised. Kane’s genius<br />
perception of Kane has been coloured<br />
hotel and we learn that atrocious not for the character, he did with amazing strength and position of people the world over;<br />
by the negative responses to fighting and sickening carnage are<br />
even to the extent of relaying all his so it is the thought that if the world<br />
Blasted, as reviewers branded it “a taking place on the streets of Leeds.<br />
but the actress herself...”<br />
actions and fluidity.<br />
change soon, then this harrowing<br />
characters emotions through his and the humans within it do not<br />
feast of filth”, and by her death by Ian is in turn raped by the soldier,<br />
suicide age 28. Blasted opened to who then continues to suck out and<br />
Blasted is a play that breaks its tale by Kane will remain, as very<br />
the public in January 1995 in the<br />
small theatre upstairs at the royal<br />
court London.<br />
<strong>The</strong> play is set in a Leeds hotel,<br />
Ian, a middle-aged journalist, and<br />
Cate, a tender, naive 21-year-old<br />
with a propensity to fits and stammering,<br />
have come here for a tryst.<br />
eat Ian’s eyes and then turns a gun<br />
on himself.<br />
<strong>The</strong> end reduces Ian to eating a<br />
dead baby until Cate returns with<br />
food and drink. <strong>The</strong> final picture is<br />
one of charity and desperate, daring<br />
endurance. Having contemplated<br />
the worst of which humanity<br />
significantly, disabled. And that<br />
presents the polite, carefully cultivated<br />
sensibilities of the average<br />
audience member, and reviewer,<br />
with a dilemma - we’ve got used to<br />
colour-blind casting, barely turning<br />
a hair at a black Roman Emperor<br />
or Tudor Monarch, but when having<br />
own structure apart, and leaves its<br />
audience shattered. <strong>The</strong> movement<br />
from a world that we identify as<br />
our own to one we have only seen<br />
in film (and the darkest reaches of<br />
our imagination) raises all kinds<br />
of questions. Is Kane suggesting<br />
that racism on UK soil could turn<br />
little theatre truly lasts. If there’s<br />
any play of the twenty r so years<br />
that may still be drawing audiences<br />
in the future, engulfing them and<br />
dragging them through a world of<br />
darkness, fear and looking at and<br />
understanding of terrible truths,<br />
then this piece of revolutionary<br />
Kane’s dark and morbid world into total ethnic cleansing? Or sim-<br />
theatre may very well be it.<br />
Ian is a racist, who hates what the is capable, Kane somehow salvages<br />
<strong>The</strong> Man of Mode<br />
15<br />
By Henry Martin<br />
He is charming. He is rich.<br />
He is very, very sexy.<br />
When he talks to you he<br />
makes you feel like the only person<br />
in the room. When he moves<br />
away from you, you feel empty<br />
and alone. You hate to love him<br />
and you love to hate him. Most<br />
of all, he knows all this. He’s the<br />
man of the minute and the man<br />
of mode. To him you are an accessory,<br />
a fashionable dalliance.<br />
He’ll drop you like the winter<br />
line when he sees the spring line<br />
in Paris. If curves are in he’ll<br />
buy you chocolate. If Kate Moss<br />
is in you don’t stand a chance.<br />
He’s on stage at the National until<br />
March. He’d love you to love<br />
him and stop on by.<br />
George Etheridge premiered<br />
<strong>The</strong> Man of Mode, or Sir Fopling<br />
Flutter 331 years ago to huge acclaim.<br />
Nicholas Hytner with <strong>The</strong><br />
Man of Mode aims for the same<br />
success in his modern re-work-<br />
“...Charming, slick<br />
and very, very sexy...”<br />
ing of this Restoration Comedy of<br />
Manners with a cast of twenty-five.<br />
Essentially the story is about<br />
Dorimant, a playboy who, as soon<br />
as he can’t have a woman, wants<br />
her, and as soon as he gets her,<br />
doesn’t need her anymore. Your<br />
ordinary bloke then? Throw into<br />
the mix mistaken identities, slapstick<br />
humour, feisty scorned lovers,<br />
elopement, drinking games, lots of<br />
techno music, art, rhymed verse,<br />
drink and gallic jokes and you get<br />
a pretty good picture of what awaits<br />
you at the Olivier <strong>The</strong>atre.<br />
Though it is a lively energetic<br />
production, with some wonderful<br />
performances (Tom Hardy as<br />
Dorimant and Rory Kinnear as<br />
Sir Fopling Flutter) there remains<br />
something superficial about the<br />
production, which is even more<br />
lamentable owing to the fact that<br />
the whole play questions superficiality.<br />
<strong>The</strong> choreographed dance routines<br />
that link the scenes, though<br />
enjoyable in their own right, do<br />
little to add meaning to the piece.<br />
Due to the number of characters<br />
and the importance of choreography<br />
and dance in the piece, pace<br />
is everything and seemed uneven<br />
in the second act. Some key stage<br />
business and even a very important<br />
revelation were completely missed<br />
by the audience, but perhaps this<br />
has been corrected since previews.<br />
Though the set sought to represent<br />
the current penchant for architectural<br />
minimalism and retrospection,<br />
it remained bland,<br />
when it should only have<br />
evoked it.<br />
It was the actors who<br />
brought colour to the<br />
stage. But overall they<br />
were primary colours,<br />
with a great deal of tonality<br />
and self-reflection diffused<br />
with the designer<br />
perfume. Sure, we live in<br />
an age defined by the image<br />
and the superficial,<br />
my guess was this production<br />
sought to comment<br />
upon that, not fall<br />
victim to it. Charming,<br />
slick and very, very sexy,<br />
<strong>The</strong> Man of Mode awaits<br />
you.<br />
Directed by Nicholas<br />
Hytner.<br />
National <strong>The</strong>atre, until<br />
March 10th<br />
Tom Hardy
16 ARTS Tuesday 13 February 2007 thefounder<br />
ntony and Cleopatra <strong>The</strong> Royal Shakespeare Company<br />
By Renata de Groot<br />
regory Doran directs the<br />
second of three Shakespeare<br />
plays, brought to<br />
he Novello <strong>The</strong>atre by the Royal<br />
hakespeare Company. Set in<br />
he aftermath of Julius Caesar’s<br />
eath, Antony and Cleopatra is a<br />
ragedy which depicts a love affair<br />
ondemned by a stormy political<br />
ituation.<br />
Headlining the play are two<br />
ward winning RSC Associate Artsts:<br />
Patrick Stewart (of Star Trek<br />
ame) as Antony, and Harriet Waler<br />
as Cleopatra. Whilst many preious<br />
productions have presented a<br />
liché of the two iconic characters,<br />
tewart and Walter perform their<br />
oles credibly and with originality.<br />
tewart humanises the character of<br />
ntony, from the cocky and powerul<br />
general at the start, to the drunk<br />
and suicidal wreck at the end. Walter<br />
has the challenge of portraying<br />
the many sides of Cleopatra who is<br />
“... as the ultimate<br />
femme fatale Walter’s<br />
stage presence<br />
is both politically and<br />
sexually powerful...”<br />
presented, by Shakespeare, as not<br />
only a commanding ruler, but as<br />
the ultimate femme fatale. Walter’s<br />
stage presence is both politically<br />
and sexually powerful, at one point<br />
making a messenger boy visibly<br />
shake in terror and at other points<br />
passionately seducing Antony.<br />
<strong>The</strong> fast paced production captures<br />
the audience’s interest not<br />
only through its brilliance in acting<br />
but also through Adrian Lee’s<br />
atmospheric score. An example of<br />
this is the unbearable excitement<br />
evoked, during the battle scenes, by<br />
the thunderous drum beats. <strong>The</strong> atmosphere<br />
is also established by the<br />
backdrop’s ever-changing colours:<br />
from the gold decadence of Egypt,<br />
“...captures the audience’s<br />
interest not<br />
only through its brilliance<br />
in acting but<br />
also through Adrian<br />
Lee’s atmospheric<br />
score...”<br />
to the red bloodiness of battle.<br />
Despite the company’s best efforts<br />
to make the play accessible to<br />
a varied audience, the play is somewhat<br />
difficult to follow if you have<br />
never read it. I would advise either<br />
having a quick read of the play, a<br />
“...Despite the company’s<br />
best efforts<br />
to make the play accessible<br />
to a varied<br />
audience, the play is<br />
somewhat difficult to<br />
follow...”<br />
synopsis or the programme before<br />
watching it. Antony and Cleopatra<br />
is now in its last week and I would<br />
strongly recommend going not<br />
only because it is masterly done,<br />
but because of the £5 tickets for under<br />
25’s. Don’t miss out!<br />
For more information call the<br />
Novello box office: 0870 950 0902<br />
Books<br />
001 Books to Read Before<br />
ou Die: Gulliver’s Travels<br />
By Vikki Weston<br />
his week’s literary offering<br />
is a work, political<br />
and satirical in nature,<br />
ark, disturbing, brutal and ofen<br />
frightening. It may come as a<br />
urprise, then, that today’s book<br />
o read before you die is Jonathan<br />
wift’s ‘Gulliver’s Travels’, often<br />
onsidered a popular children’s<br />
ook and work of fantastical ficion.<br />
First produced in 1726 it is,<br />
n essence, a book that parodies<br />
he popular ‘traveller’s tales’ gene<br />
of the period, told by Captain<br />
emuel Gulliver, almost literally<br />
s Swift often produced work uner<br />
pseudonyms, one such being,<br />
emuel Gulliver himself. <strong>The</strong><br />
tory chronicles his travels to sevral<br />
uncharted lands inhabited by<br />
trange and unfamiliar societies.<br />
Gulliver’s first stop, after an unortunate<br />
shipwreck, is the island<br />
f Lilliput where the inhabitants<br />
re 6 inches tall. This section of the<br />
tory is where the children’s verions<br />
of the text often focus, even<br />
hough in reality the people of Liliput<br />
are a clever and vicious society<br />
that Swift uses to comment on<br />
the way intelligent society use and<br />
abuse their means to gain land and<br />
power. In this first section of the<br />
“...dark, disturbing,<br />
brutal and often<br />
frightening...”<br />
book the ridiculous and trivial fight<br />
between the nation of Lilliput and<br />
their neighbours of Blefescu about<br />
which end of a soft-boiled egg you<br />
should crack when you eat it, is<br />
Swift satirising the petty differences<br />
of religions and societies. Gulliver<br />
travels many lands in four parts, arriving<br />
finally, via the simple giants<br />
of Brobdingnag, at the land of the<br />
Houyhnhnms, a land where horses<br />
(Houyhnhnms) rule over men,<br />
known as Yahoos, who are brutish,<br />
savage and unintelligent. <strong>The</strong> word<br />
‘Houyhnhnm’ seems unpronounceable<br />
but it is, I believe, intended to<br />
sound like the ‘neighing’ noise associated<br />
with horses. Gulliver learns<br />
about human greed, deceitfulness<br />
and savagery from the philosophical<br />
Houyhnhnms (get used to seeing<br />
it, it crops up a lot in the book)<br />
an ultimately ends up referring to<br />
all human’s as Yahoos.<br />
This sublime and exciting tale of<br />
adventure and discovery expresses<br />
Swift’s attitude to political problems<br />
in Europe and the British<br />
government. Born and raised in<br />
Ireland, Swift and his literary pals<br />
(the likes of Alexander Pope) were<br />
particularly concerned with highlighting<br />
issues in the political climate.<br />
Through Gulliver’s eyes, and<br />
Swift’s microscope, the reflection<br />
of humanity is not a pleasant one.<br />
Gulliver’s differing experiences<br />
“...an entertaining<br />
and easily readable<br />
adventure combined<br />
with a harsh look at<br />
the political and social<br />
realities of the<br />
world we live in...”<br />
show his society, and in many ways<br />
our society today, as vicious and<br />
trivial, magnified and crude and<br />
finally savage and greedy.<br />
<strong>The</strong> reasons, and there are many,<br />
why this book unquestionably deserves<br />
to be on the list are further<br />
proven by its tremendous popularity<br />
from the 18th Century to the<br />
present day. It is an entertaining and<br />
easily readable adventure combined<br />
with a harsh look at the political<br />
and social realities of the world we<br />
live in. <strong>The</strong> book is still relevant to<br />
our society today, the government<br />
in the 1700s may be very different<br />
from the present, but humanity and<br />
its problems of greed, deceit and<br />
malice still exist. Swift points out<br />
ferent to us. If you need any further<br />
reason to go out and find this book<br />
a p p e a r s<br />
on the list<br />
at least 4<br />
‘Gulliver’s<br />
one of the<br />
p e n s a b l e<br />
erature. I’m<br />
inclined to<br />
the flaws in our treatment of others,<br />
particularly those who are dif-<br />
to read,<br />
I’ll leave<br />
you with<br />
George Orwell<br />
(who<br />
times) saying<br />
that<br />
Travels’ is<br />
six ‘indis-<br />
books’ of<br />
world lit-<br />
agree.
thefounder Tuesday 13 February 2007<br />
MEDIA<br />
17<br />
Media<br />
Contribute to this section:<br />
dan@thefounder.co.uk<br />
michael@thefounder.co.uk<br />
Editor’s note<br />
This week in the media section of<br />
the founder we have a review on<br />
the highly anticipated ‘Hot Fuzz’<br />
by Michael Keating who was lucky<br />
enough to attend a special advanced<br />
screening. <strong>The</strong> film is the latest from<br />
the same amazing team that created<br />
Shaun of the Dead, 2004s highly<br />
entertaining and amusing romantic<br />
comedy with zombies. Already<br />
the film has created an enormous<br />
amount of hype and if early indications<br />
are to be believed, it doesn’t<br />
disappoint. It is out on general release<br />
on the 14 th of February.<br />
Also this week we have yet another<br />
contender for the Oscar race,<br />
‘Dreamgirls’ reviewed by Jonathan<br />
Dakin. Expect strong performances<br />
through out from this fictional biopic,<br />
which shares more than a few<br />
parallels with the rise of Motown<br />
and the history of <strong>The</strong> Supremes.<br />
In DVD releases, first up we have<br />
a review on Luc Besson’s ‘Angel-A’.<br />
<strong>The</strong> ‘Leon’ director has been away<br />
for quite some time now but he has<br />
returned to the screen with this sublime<br />
looking monochrome photographed<br />
piece centred on the story<br />
of maverick angel Rie Rasmussen’s<br />
bid to break serial schmuck Jamel<br />
Debbouze’s losing streak. Perhaps<br />
not his best, but certainly a welcome<br />
return for the French Director.<br />
As well this week, my own review<br />
of the chronically humourless<br />
‘Beerfest’. Although it was released a<br />
few weeks ago now the opportunity<br />
to put it in only arose this issue. If<br />
you are interested in any our films<br />
reviewed on DVD, remember they<br />
are all available at discount prices<br />
through <strong>The</strong> <strong>Founder</strong>s own link<br />
www.cd-wow.com/thefounder.<br />
I hope that the media section of<br />
<strong>The</strong> <strong>Founder</strong> proves useful, and remember<br />
if you would like to submit<br />
a review of a current film, a DVD<br />
release or have a comment on what<br />
you have read in the media section<br />
email myself at mike@thefounder.<br />
co.uk or Dan Nicholls through<br />
dan@thefounder.co.uk.<br />
Thanks,<br />
Michael Dean<br />
michael@thefounder.co.uk<br />
By Martin Marshall<br />
<strong>The</strong> College Bookshop<br />
(Specialist in out of print, hard<br />
to find, and obscure books)<br />
As the build-up to R-Fest continues,<br />
I’ve attempted to keep my reading<br />
focused. Consequently, I’ve just<br />
finished reading “Zanzibar”, Giles<br />
Foden’s most recent novel. Billed by<br />
it’s publishers as a thriller, and reading<br />
at times like an old-fashioned<br />
adventure story, “Zanzibar” is in<br />
fact neither of these things. Like<br />
his earlier work “<strong>The</strong> Last King of<br />
Scotland”, “Zanzibar” is as much<br />
about thoughts and feelings as it<br />
is events. Also like “Last King…”,<br />
it is a book about the intersection<br />
between big political events and the<br />
lives of ordinary people. And again<br />
like his earlier work, it is very much<br />
about a place.<br />
Zanzibar is brought to life for the<br />
reader in just the same way as Uganda<br />
is in “Last King…”. From sights<br />
and smells, the poverty of the people,<br />
it’s wildlife and weather, all are<br />
included and all serve to remind any<br />
reader who has not been there personally<br />
that we are a long way from<br />
home. <strong>The</strong> big difference however, is<br />
thefounder<br />
dan@thefounder.co.uk<br />
michael@thefounder.co.uk<br />
Zanzibar<br />
the setting in time. “Zanzibar” is set<br />
against a very familiar backdrop of<br />
political events. <strong>The</strong> characters are<br />
watching <strong>new</strong>s about the Clinton-<br />
Lewinsky affair, and we are witnessing<br />
the rise of Al-Qaeda.<br />
For those of us too young to remember<br />
Idi Amin, this more contemporary<br />
feel has a way of reinforcing<br />
the realism of Foden’s work.<br />
On the other hand, in switching<br />
away from a first person narrative,<br />
Foden is also making “Zanzibar”<br />
seem more traditionally fictional. A<br />
great point in Foden’s favour is his<br />
ability to be realistic about the British<br />
and American roles in world<br />
politics without being condemnatory.<br />
For many writers dealing<br />
with say, America’s role in training<br />
Osama Bin Laden would require<br />
either a whitewash or a judgement.<br />
Yet going either way would hamper<br />
the story and it’s realism, and<br />
Foden manages to avoid both. His<br />
stories are not about imposing lasting<br />
moral judgements, but simply<br />
about provoking thoughts in the<br />
reader.<br />
Forced to choose, I would have<br />
to say that “Last King of Scotland”<br />
was a better overall read than<br />
“Zanzibar”. It had a greater degree<br />
of continuity, and managed to instil<br />
that compulsive need to read<br />
just one more page before putting<br />
it down. But this is in no way to<br />
denigrate “Zanzibar”. It remains a<br />
thoroughly entertaining novel in<br />
its own right and will, I am sure, be<br />
superior to “Last King” in the eyes<br />
of many readers. Either way, I am<br />
looking forward to Giles Foden’s<br />
workshop and book signing more<br />
than ever after this.<br />
Film News<br />
Martin Scorsese’s remake of Hong<br />
Kong gangster thriller ‘Infernal<br />
Affairs’, ‘the Departed’ may be one<br />
of the most hotly tipped movies of<br />
2006 to walk away with the Oscar<br />
for best film, but this week one of<br />
the film’s stars, Mark Wahlberg, revealed<br />
that like the Asian original<br />
there is plans for two sequels in the<br />
pipe line. In an interview, the thirty<br />
five year old star revealed “<strong>The</strong>y’re<br />
talking about bringing in De Niro<br />
to play a senator or a congressman.<br />
You know, the corruption obviously<br />
going deeper and higher up the<br />
ranks — reaching up the political<br />
chain. So it’ll be fun. And if it’s a<br />
success, they’re gonna do a prequel<br />
and bring everyone back…make it<br />
a trilogy”. According to Walberg,<br />
screenwriter William Monahan<br />
is currently penning up a sequel<br />
to the Boston set crime saga. But<br />
despite all this, any script would<br />
need Scorsese’s approval and the<br />
director’s involvement in any future<br />
chapters is currently unclear.<br />
If all goes well though according<br />
to Walberg shooting could begin<br />
sometime at “the beginning of<br />
next year<br />
or end of this year”.<br />
<strong>The</strong> highly anticipated film version<br />
of the first book in Phillip Pullman’s<br />
His Dark Materials trilogy, <strong>The</strong><br />
Golden Compass, has now not only<br />
got a full cast listing but also several<br />
screen shots posted on the web.<br />
Among the talented cast that former<br />
‘About a Boy’ director Chris Weitz<br />
has assembled is Nicole Kidman in<br />
the role of the icy Mrs. Coulter and<br />
Daniel Craig as the enigmatic Lord<br />
Asriel. But for fans of the books it<br />
is the casting of the protagonist<br />
Lyra that is most crucial. Although<br />
twelve-year-old <strong>new</strong>comer Dakota<br />
Blue Richards, who beat ten<br />
thousand girls who turned up for<br />
open auditions to secure the part,<br />
certainly looks physically well cast<br />
for the role, it is the question of<br />
her performance that many are<br />
concerned with. Only time will tell.<br />
We will have to wait and see if this<br />
literary adaptation holds its own in<br />
the post Rings and Potter world.<br />
At Potter’s end<br />
By Lara Stavrinou<br />
You would have to be a complete<br />
hermit to not have heard about the<br />
Harry Potter buzz over the past ten<br />
years. That buzz now has an ending<br />
in sight.<br />
Last week JK Rowling announced<br />
that the final instalment in the Harry<br />
Potter series will be released on<br />
July 21. Although she gave no clues<br />
about the book’s ending, Rowling<br />
expressed great sadness about the<br />
wrapping up of her seven-book<br />
project.<br />
“Even while I’m mourning,<br />
though, I feel an incredible sense of<br />
achievement,” she commented on<br />
her website. “I can hardly believe<br />
that I’ve finally written the ending<br />
I’ve been planning for so many<br />
years. I’ve never felt such a mixture<br />
of extreme emotions in my life, never<br />
dreamed I could feel simultaneously<br />
heartbroken and euphoric.”<br />
As most people know, this author<br />
started off writing about Harry Potter<br />
and his magical adventures in<br />
a little café in Edinburgh as her<br />
daughter napped beside her. “Harry<br />
just strolled into my head fully<br />
formed,” she recalls, but little did<br />
she know that Harry would inspire<br />
the printing of over 325 million<br />
books worldwide. Each title has<br />
come first on <strong>The</strong> New York Times,<br />
USA Today, and Wall Street Journal<br />
bestseller lists and the sixth book,<br />
Harry Potter and the Half-Blood<br />
Prince, set a <strong>new</strong> world record for<br />
a first printing.<br />
Rowling has said before that ‘the<br />
theme running through all seven<br />
books is the fight between good<br />
and evil, and I’m afraid there will<br />
be casualties!’. With this teaser still<br />
lingering in the air, she reassures<br />
readers that ‘there will be plenty to<br />
continue arguing about, even after<br />
‘Deathly Hallows’ comes out. So<br />
if you’re not yet ready to quit the<br />
message boards, do not despair.’<br />
“While each of the previous Potter<br />
books has strong claims on my<br />
affections, ‘Deathly Hallows’ is<br />
my favourite, and that is the most<br />
wonderful way to finish the series”<br />
Rowling gushes. Lets hope her fans<br />
are as satisfied.
18 MEDIA Tuesday 13 February 2007 thefounder<br />
Film<br />
Vue Cinemas, Staines<br />
Hot Fuzz (15)<br />
Dreamgirls (12A)<br />
By Michael Keating<br />
Director – Edgar Wright<br />
Starring – Simon Pegg,<br />
Nick Frost, Timothy Dalton<br />
Run Time – 120 minutes<br />
Hot Fuzz is the story of hardboiled<br />
super cop Sergeant Nicholas Angel<br />
(Simon Pegg). Intimidated by his<br />
arrest record, his superior officers<br />
(Martin Freeman, Steven Coogan,<br />
and Bill Nighy) transfer him from<br />
the busy streets of London to the<br />
sleepy village of Sandford to keep<br />
him out of the way as he’s making<br />
everyone else look bad. A big cop<br />
in a small town, Angel sees murders<br />
and conspiracies where the town<br />
police men and locals see only accidents.<br />
But with the help of his partner<br />
Danny Butterman (Nick Frost),<br />
it is not long before he discovers<br />
that not everything in Sandford is<br />
quite what it seems.<br />
Sound cliché? That’s the point.<br />
Once settled in Sandford, Hot Fuzz<br />
becomes a vehicle designed to send<br />
up every action film that has ever<br />
taken itself seriously including Point<br />
Break and Bad Boys (which are referenced<br />
several times during the<br />
course of the film). It does this brilliantly<br />
by simply taking everything<br />
from the most cliché action films<br />
and pushing it all that much further,<br />
allowing it to appear both ridiculous<br />
and amazing at the same time.<br />
<strong>The</strong> characters are fantastically<br />
exaggerated, especially Pegg’s super<br />
cop and Timothy Dalton’s over-thetop<br />
super-villain, giving them just<br />
the right tone. <strong>The</strong> action sequences<br />
are outrageous, exciting and feature<br />
a surprising degree of rough justice,<br />
most memorably in the scene<br />
where an old lady’s is on the wrong<br />
end of Pegg’s flying kick (or maybe<br />
when the pub landlord gets his<br />
head caught up in a bear trap. <strong>The</strong><br />
dialogue ranges from obvious parody<br />
(“I threw the teddy bear at him<br />
and said ‘play times over!’ ?”), to<br />
clever Pegg-Frost exchanges. Even<br />
the music is perfectly balanced between<br />
action-scene rock songs and<br />
mock-epic slow guitar pieces.<br />
However, that’s not to say that<br />
Hot Fuzz is non-stop comic action.<br />
<strong>The</strong> first half an hour or so seems a<br />
little slow, but there’s no reason to<br />
worry; the cast are simply setting<br />
up jokes to be knocked down later<br />
on, and it is definitely worth the<br />
brief wait for the well-paced comicaction<br />
masterpiece that’s lying just<br />
around the corner.<br />
As with Shaun of the Dead,<br />
the people behind Hot<br />
Fuzz are affectionately poking<br />
fun at a genre that they<br />
clearly love, creating a film<br />
that embraces its genre’s<br />
inherent ridiculousness,<br />
and is all the better for it.<br />
4/5<br />
By Jonathan Dakin<br />
Director - Bill Condon<br />
Starring - Beyonce<br />
Knowles, Eddie Murphy,<br />
Jennifer Hudson, Anika<br />
Noni Rose<br />
Run Time - 131 mins<br />
I felt excited with the thought of<br />
seeing Dreamgirls. Not only is it<br />
one of the most hotly tipped Oscar<br />
contenders of the year, the film also<br />
includes an all star line-up, has been<br />
adapted from the musical with the<br />
same name, and is said to be based<br />
on the life of Diana Ross and the Supremes,<br />
so I was set for an interesting<br />
piece of cinema.<br />
Dreamgirls starts with an explosion<br />
of glitter and melodies, as<br />
many different soulful acts sing<br />
songs to a baying audience. We wait<br />
for the moment that the struggling<br />
group <strong>The</strong> Dreams, composed of Effie<br />
(Hudson), Deena (Knowles) and<br />
Lorrell (Rose) will come out and<br />
dazzle us with their amazing voices.<br />
And dazzle they do. All three are remarkable<br />
singers, and the beginning<br />
of the film sets the scene for many<br />
more spectacular musical numbers<br />
to come. Unfortunately, this hyped<br />
up beginning is quickly lost in a sea<br />
of poor plotting, bad scripting and<br />
sometimes amateur directing.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Dreams are a struggling 60’s<br />
soul group, who grab the attention<br />
of part time talent agent Curtis Taylor<br />
(Foxx). Curtis makes a deal with<br />
the girls to be backup singers for the<br />
sleazy but talented James ‘Thunder’<br />
Early (Murphy), until they can become<br />
stars in their own right. Slowly<br />
but surely the girls work their way<br />
up the showbiz ladder to become an<br />
established pop group, and at the<br />
same time experience love, betrayal<br />
and ultimately, empowerment.<br />
Although the plot and directing<br />
are at times sub par, all of the<br />
Competition<br />
Congratulations to last fortnight’s winner Joe Casey!<br />
actors really work hard- Murphy<br />
and Hudson both shine in their<br />
Academy Award nominated roles,<br />
Foxx makes the best out of his tired<br />
character and even Beyonce, who I<br />
wasn’t expecting to be very good, is<br />
extremely likeable.<br />
<strong>The</strong> songs are sung amazingly,<br />
and some of them are really catchy<br />
(‘Dreamgirls’, ‘One Night Only’ and<br />
‘Listen’) but unfortunately some are<br />
very cheesy (especially the vomit inducing<br />
‘Family’).<br />
Packed with a punch,<br />
Dreamgirls finishes well<br />
and makes up for the middle<br />
hour that wasn’t up to<br />
scratch with an emotionally<br />
feel good ending. <strong>The</strong><br />
film is worth a watch, especially<br />
if you want to be<br />
singing the catchy tunes<br />
days after seeing it.<br />
2.5/5<br />
Who said the following line and where did they say it (actor, character and movie)?<br />
‘This is your life and it’s ending one minute at a time’<br />
Prizes this time round are as follows:<br />
1 x pair cinema tickets for Vue, Staines; 1 x ‘Beerfest’; t-shirt; 1 x ‘<strong>The</strong> Guardian’ Beanie, 1 x<br />
‘Big Momm’s House 2’ novelty thong.<br />
Good luck! As always, answers to competitions@thefounder.co.uk (competition closes<br />
26th February 2007).
thefounder Tuesday 13 February 2007<br />
MEDIA<br />
19<br />
DVD<br />
w w w . c d - w o w . c o m / t h e f o u n d e r<br />
Angel - A (15)<br />
By Christopher Lo<br />
Director - Luc Besson<br />
Screenplay - Luc Besson<br />
Starring - Rie Rasmussen,<br />
Jamel Debbouze<br />
Run Time - 88 minutes<br />
After the tremendous critical and<br />
commercial success of Nikita, Leon<br />
and <strong>The</strong> Fifth Element, Luc Besson<br />
seems to have slipped into somewhat<br />
of a cinematic wasteland. It’s<br />
been six years since Besson last directed<br />
a movie, during which time<br />
he has spent his time producing and<br />
funding a whole host of pet projects.<br />
During this extended directorial<br />
hiatus, Besson’s legions of devotees<br />
have been drooling in anticipation<br />
of his eventual return to the director’s<br />
chair. This return has come in<br />
the form of Angel-A, a deeply personal<br />
tale of love, redemption and<br />
self-discovery.<br />
Set in Paris, Angel-A tells the<br />
story of Andre, a perpetual liar and<br />
occasional con artist. Beset with<br />
seemingly insurmountable debt<br />
and hounded by the Parisian underworld,<br />
he decides to end it all<br />
by throwing himself into the Seine.<br />
In the process of doing so, he meets<br />
Angela, a beautiful woman with no<br />
past and an inexplicable interest in<br />
Andre’s future. <strong>The</strong>ir attempt to put<br />
right Andre’s life (and mind) exposes<br />
this bizarre couple to their own<br />
secrets as well as those of the world<br />
around them.<br />
Despite the supernatural mysteries<br />
that lay behind Angela’s origins<br />
(the clue’s in the name), Besson<br />
focuses on the reality of the characters’<br />
internal struggles as well as<br />
their blossoming relationship. At<br />
Angel-A’s core is an exploration of<br />
a distinctly human issue: the importance<br />
of self-perception and the<br />
ability to respect oneself. Visually,<br />
the film has a breathtaking blackand-white<br />
aesthetic, Thierry Arbogast’s<br />
cinematography representing<br />
an unabashed love for the beauty of<br />
the Paris skyline. <strong>The</strong> leads are also<br />
perfectly cast. Debbouze’s anxious,<br />
twitchy energy proving the perfect<br />
counterfoil to Rasmussen’s breezy<br />
vitality. <strong>The</strong> fact that Rasmussen<br />
must be at least six inches taller than<br />
her co-star only helps to emphasise<br />
her otherworldliness.<br />
Angel-A represents a<br />
startling return for Luc<br />
Besson; reminiscent of his<br />
early days as a pioneer of<br />
the cinema du look style.<br />
<strong>The</strong> smoky beauty of the<br />
imagery and the irresistible<br />
charisma of the characters<br />
marks this as one of<br />
Besson’s very best.<br />
4/5<br />
Beerfest (18)<br />
By MIchael Dean<br />
Director - Jay Chandrasekar<br />
Starring - Jay Chandrasekar,<br />
Kevin Hefferman, Steve<br />
Lemme, Paul Soter, Erik Stolhanske,<br />
Jurgen Prochnow.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Film<br />
‘Prepare for the ultimate chug of<br />
war’ is the tagline that adorns the<br />
front cover of the Beerfest DVD<br />
case. Straight away things do not<br />
look particularly promising.<br />
<strong>The</strong> story is about a pair of American<br />
brothers, Jan and Todd Wolfhouse,<br />
who attend Oktoberfest in<br />
the attempt to deliver the ashes of<br />
their recently deceased beer loving<br />
German grandfather (oddly a<br />
cameo from Donald Sutherland) to<br />
an appropriate resting place. While<br />
there though, they discover a secret<br />
‘fight club’ styled beer-drinking<br />
contest in which the world’s nations<br />
come together to compete. After<br />
taking on the German champions<br />
and suffering a humiliating defeat,<br />
the brothers return to the states<br />
and assemble their own squad in<br />
the hopes of returning to win the<br />
event.<br />
It never ceases to amaze as to<br />
what Hollywood will throw money<br />
at. Beerfest’s premise has about as<br />
much complexity as something devised<br />
by a thirteen year old schoolboy,<br />
who coincidentally I can imagine<br />
are the only demographic who<br />
will be entertained by this comedy<br />
that is as flat as week old Lager.<br />
It is not particularly Beerfest’s<br />
story (or lack of) that lets it down.<br />
A film that solely revolves around<br />
irresponsible drinking could possibly<br />
be funny in the hands some<br />
decent comic talent. Here though,<br />
the ‘Broken Lizard’ team who have<br />
been responsible for ‘Super Troopers’<br />
and ‘Club Dread’ fail to raise<br />
any real quality laughs. After one<br />
hour of the films flimsy attempts at<br />
humour, it does eventually manage<br />
to induce in it’s audience some ever<br />
so slight snigger, with some passable<br />
physical comedy, but it all feels<br />
far too little, far too late.<br />
<strong>The</strong> films downfall is not it’s continued<br />
adoration of drinking and<br />
beer, but instead lies in the overwhelming<br />
hopelessness of it’s creation.<br />
Both filming and editing are<br />
astoundingly sloppy, and the use<br />
of some decent acting talent such<br />
as ‘Das Boot’ star Jurgen Prochnow<br />
only serves to highlight the<br />
shortcomings of the regular cast.<br />
<strong>The</strong> only thing that can be said in<br />
the films favour is the fact that it<br />
doesn’t rely on gross-out humour<br />
like so many of the other equally<br />
inept comedies in this style that<br />
have preceded it.<br />
Beerfest is a film that will require<br />
a considerably large amount of<br />
the old fermented vegetable juices<br />
to enjoy. Equally as bad as it’s out<br />
come is absurd. That is, an American<br />
drinking team being the best in<br />
the world.<br />
1/5<br />
<strong>The</strong> Extras<br />
Two commentary tracks are provided<br />
in which the Broken Lizard<br />
boys account their experiences<br />
while making the film. Ironically<br />
these prove more amusing than<br />
the actual film its self, though that<br />
is not to say its comic gold by any<br />
means. Along with this is a collection<br />
of deleted scenes in which<br />
a whole gag that was omitted is<br />
shown and that generally seem<br />
to consist of topless woman. Also<br />
there are two short documentaries,<br />
one a Broken Lizard history<br />
of beer, and the other about a scientist<br />
who masturbates frogs. For<br />
any one who actually enjoyed the<br />
film the extras will be very welcome,<br />
but for the rest of the sane<br />
population they add very little to<br />
a film already dreadfully low on<br />
substance.<br />
2/5
20 MEDIA Tuesday 13 February 2007 thefounder<br />
Music<br />
w w w . c d - w o w . c o m / t h e f o u n d e r<br />
RAG Presents:<br />
People in Planes<br />
Saturday 17th February at<br />
the Student’s Union<br />
Tickets available at SU<br />
This coming Saturday (17 th February),<br />
avid gig-goers at Royal Holloway<br />
will receive a reprieve from the<br />
weekly cheese and hip hop nights as<br />
we welcome People In Planes to our<br />
Student’s Union. People In Planes,<br />
(signed to Wind-Up Records in the<br />
US), are an atmospheric alt-rock<br />
band that bring an intelligent and<br />
progressive edge to modern rock<br />
music. After having spent early<br />
parts of their career touring with<br />
the likes of Biffy Clyro, Jarcrew, <strong>The</strong><br />
Bravery and <strong>The</strong> Kaiser Chiefs, and<br />
having spent much of 2005 touring<br />
the States, the band are currently<br />
gigging the UK, road testing <strong>new</strong><br />
material for their <strong>new</strong> album which<br />
is due to be recorded in the States in<br />
March. SURHUL have been lucky<br />
enough to lure the band into playing<br />
with support from popular campus<br />
bands, <strong>The</strong> Loyalty Point and Red<br />
Dead Collective. Both bands have<br />
strong followings on Campus having<br />
previously headlined their own<br />
nights in the Union. For those longing<br />
for the London music scene to<br />
be brought to their doorstep look no<br />
further. At £2 entry punters will be<br />
getting 4 blistering sets from local<br />
talent before the stage is hit with a<br />
headlining set from Wales’ own People<br />
In Planes. For those of you who<br />
prefer the London club scene don’t<br />
worry, after the bands there will be<br />
DJ sets and an open bar until late. So<br />
next Saturday, get down to the SU<br />
for an 8.30 start, (8pm doors), and<br />
support your music scene.<br />
For more info visit www.peopleinplanes.com or<br />
www.myspace.com/peopleinplanes.<br />
Letters to the Editor<br />
thefounder<br />
editor@thefounder.co.uk<br />
My Fair Lady: A Confused and Half-unwritten Rendition!<br />
By the production team that haven’t brought you anything ever before…..<br />
If you want to put on a piece of musical theatre at Royal Holloway there are a number<br />
of hurdles you must overcome. Most notably, you need to successfully bid to put on<br />
your production, and you need to have a production team of recognized successful<br />
players in the MTS circle. <strong>Our</strong> production of ‘My Fair Lady’ has exactly none of<br />
these…<br />
So, you may ask yourself, how does ‘Variations on My Fair Lady’ even exist? Lizzie<br />
Fisher (Co-Director), Melanie Johnson (Producer) and Lucy Allen (Musical Director)<br />
cramped together in a corner of the Monkey’s Forehead and fantasised about staging<br />
a potential production which brought up to date the themes and ideas of the classic<br />
musical. <strong>The</strong> more they dreamt, the more the potential became a filled-in bid pack.<br />
Meanwhile, as Fate would have it, another musical won the bid and it seemed as<br />
though their plans would never come to fruition. However, Lizzie Start (the <strong>President</strong><br />
of MTS and saviour of our little production) decided to create a second Spring Term<br />
musical, which she dubbed her ‘first year venture’. With this in mind, Lizzie Fisher approached<br />
two writers, Jennie Falconer and Simon Cummin, with a cunning plan. <strong>The</strong>y<br />
were given a mission to create the concept for a play based on the main themes of<br />
My Fair Lady, including some songs but with none of the original script. Once more<br />
against the backdrop of the Monkey’s Forehead, the two of them bashed around with<br />
bizarre and, at times, morally questionable story lines. Eventually with Simon as writer<br />
and Jennie as script consultant, ‘Variations on My Fair Lady’ was created. So, we had a<br />
play, and a chance to prove ourselves worthy of upholding MTS’ impeccable reputation.<br />
This left us at the beginning of the path to putting on a show!<br />
Newcastle replacing the cockney girl, Eliza (Steve Ramsden), a fading actress replacing<br />
the character of Professor Higgins (Helen Dawson), and a pantheon of buskers who<br />
commune on the street where she lives and oversee everything…<br />
As you can imagine this production has warranted a lot of experimentation as well as a<br />
fair bit of ‘trial and error’ in rehearsals, with script alterations being produced every few<br />
days. <strong>The</strong> play has given the actors freedom to devise scenes and explore <strong>new</strong> ideas,<br />
even influencing parts of the story line. Under the guidance of their two distinctly<br />
contrasting directors, Lizzie Fisher and Simon Cummin, the cast seems to be bravely<br />
facing what is indeed an ambitious project – the recreation of a musical masterpiece<br />
in 26 days!<br />
With most of the classic songs included in the script, this looks to be a spectacle of a<br />
show, and in no way claims to be the traditional My Fair Lady. If you aren’t a fan of conventional<br />
musicals, then this is a musical for you, and if you are….then keep an open<br />
mind and don’t feel too offended! But do come along, as it would be very interesting<br />
to hear the response of hardcore ‘My Fair Lady’ fans to this show. It will be performed at<br />
Jane Holloway Hall on Saturday 24th February. However, in the meantime to keep you<br />
interested, a selection of buskers will be released into the streets of Royal Holloway to<br />
prepare you for the spectacle!<br />
With upper-class borderline alcoholics, almost incomprehensible Geordies, tramps<br />
with beautiful voices, tango dancing, just a little bit of theft and an almost non-existent<br />
budget, this promises to be an intriguing and hopefully memorable interpretation<br />
of the much-loved London musical.<br />
With one month from finishing the script to the performance, anything could happen.<br />
I’m writing this article after a few rehearsals and the two and a half weeks ahead<br />
could take this production in many different directions. So far we have a bloke from<br />
Simon Cummins
thefounder Tuesday 13 February 2007<br />
LETTERS<br />
21<br />
Sir: May I suggest that Adam D’Souza was rather missing the point in his<br />
‘Comment & Analysis’ article in issue #4?<br />
<strong>The</strong> General Meeting was indeed below the required level for quorum.<br />
However, to refer to the January GM in particular as ‘a damp squib’<br />
seems to suggest that that meeting in particular was especially<br />
unattended. In fact, GMs have not once met quorum since I came to RHUL<br />
in 2005. Granted, one or two have come close, but it’s a recognised<br />
fact amongst regulars to these meetings that they are not well<br />
attended.<br />
Student apathy is rife, but few seem to be bothered. It is not only<br />
GMs. <strong>The</strong> various forums held by the Students’ Union on issues such as<br />
accommodation have been even less well-attended, and campus elections<br />
are increasingly suffering from students who simply cannot be bothered<br />
to spend five minutes in a dining hall, or at the SU, voting for the<br />
people who will represent them next year. It’s not even an issue<br />
solely related to student politics, as fewer and fewer are voting in<br />
national elections. Apathy seems to have become everyone’s favourite<br />
choice.<br />
With this in mind, is it any wonder that increasingly narrow bodies of<br />
students are making the decisions for the 7700 students on campus? <strong>The</strong><br />
problem lies not with those who attend the meetings, or organise them,<br />
but with the many who simply are not bothered, especially those who<br />
then are first to complain when a GM decides on something they<br />
disagree with. GMs can indeed be tedious, but that is the price to pay<br />
for fair democracy, and as people are increasingly unwilling to pay<br />
it, it is no wonder that the <strong>new</strong> structure proposed by the Governance<br />
Review has proved popular.<br />
Finally, in regards to D’Souza’s comments on the NUS campaigns, I have<br />
to reach the conclusion that he was not looking very hard. I was one<br />
of those who attended the ‘No’ campaign initial meeting in TW20s, and<br />
we took up a good two tables, discussing various aspects of the<br />
campaign for about two hours. I admit that without knowledge of the<br />
location, it would have been hard to join in, but should the impetus<br />
really lie with the campaign leaders and SU to tell everyone what is<br />
happening where? Students seem less willing to actually find out for<br />
themselves what is happening. If the information isn’t handed to them<br />
where they stand, they won’t set off to find it.<br />
If I am wrong about student apathy, than I request the students of<br />
Royal Holloway to prove this by voting in the upcoming elections and<br />
the referendum, and taking part in the various aspects of the<br />
Students’ Union beyond the function nights. Otherwise, I believe the<br />
future does look bleak for SURHUL…but it won’t be their fault.<br />
Yours,<br />
Martin ‘<strong>The</strong> Cynic’ O’Neill<br />
Imogen Heap: another view<br />
“I heard her (Imogen) singing unaccompanied in the field and said ‘I have to make a recording with you now.’<br />
Two hours or so later we had found the technician, recorded the song and cut the track onto a disc. I put it<br />
on the record as it was and it’s one of my favourite tracks.” Guitarist Jeff Beck told me the story when I was<br />
interviewing him for a Radio 4 programme about rock and roll and the links to the science and technology<br />
of engines. We had finished the recording and to take advantage of a few minutes with one of my musical<br />
heros I asked him about the incredible voice of the singer of “Rollin’ and tumblin’”. It is on one of my all time<br />
favourite albums “You had it coming”. He looked all dreamy and said “We were at a singer and writer workshop<br />
in France - last day - just lying about in the garden of the chateau, and this woman came over to me and<br />
started talking - ‘Groupie’ I thought - then she started singing.” Beck told me that he asked her what rock and<br />
roll/blues songs she k<strong>new</strong> - and she k<strong>new</strong> most of “Rollin’”. He started playing when they had got the studio<br />
up-and-running a few minutes later, and she blew him away. And you should listen to it to hear another facet<br />
of this extra-ordinary artist’s talent. Beck admitted that he plays quite a few wrong bits and notes on the track<br />
because he was so intent on listening(can’t hear them myself).<br />
For my part I rate Beck as the leading experimental guitarist after Hendrix. But that’s got a lot to do with my<br />
age (60’s child (well old man really).<br />
I am now a Heap fan (she’s a lot more interesting than the other Heap - Uriah Heap of the 70s- to now). To put<br />
her Beck achievement in perspective you should try the Beck album “Truth”(70s). <strong>The</strong> singer; Rod Stewart.<br />
<strong>The</strong> song; Ol’ Man River (like it’s rarely sung - real blues and painful. Beck claimed that he just kept telling<br />
Rod to “sing properly and eventually he did.” A shame he didn’t stay with Beck. <strong>The</strong>re was Nicky Hopkins on<br />
keyboards and Ronnie Wood on bass. Oh and by the way as I was leaving I asked who the drummer was in<br />
that Truth band that played such an incredible backing to “Ol’ Man River”<br />
“Oh that was Mick Waller”.<br />
“Who?”<br />
“Yes that’s him! ( I looked puzzled) Keith Moon - the Who drummer - yes really....” said Beck. My continuing<br />
puzzled frown elicited the explanation “His label wouldn’t let him play on my label - so we just did it and gave<br />
him another name - Keith didn’t give a ****.”<br />
But that line up probably explains why the tracks are all so good.<br />
So when he says Imogen Heap is incredible - believe him. He’s worked with the best so he should know.<br />
Alun Lewis<br />
Lecturer showing his age<br />
Get Involved TODAY!<br />
Sign up as an individual or gro up:<br />
volunteering@rhul.ac.uk<br />
Com munity Acti on | <strong>Founder</strong>s’ East 115 | open Mon /Wed/Fr i 10a m-4pm | 01784 4140 78<br />
| 01784 414078<br />
www.rhul.ac.uk/services/volunteering/theBIGspringclean2007.html<br />
Wednesda y 14 th / Friday 16 t h<br />
Febr uary
2 CROSSWORD Tuesday 13 February 2007 thefounder<br />
Solution: Issue 5<br />
founderblocks<br />
want to advertise your society, charity, sports team<br />
founderblocks is the way to do it. buy a block for just £10! if you buy multiple blocks you can join them together<br />
to make one big message. finally, classified ads have come to royal holloway! email simon@thefounder.co.uk to find out more.<br />
One of these<br />
blocks could<br />
be yours for<br />
just £10!<br />
contact: simon@thefounder.co.uk
thefounder Tuesday 13 February 2007<br />
SPORTS<br />
23<br />
Sports<br />
thefounder<br />
allison@thefounder.co.uk<br />
Editor’s Note<br />
Many thanks go out to the American football club for<br />
hosting such a great Super Bowl party this week, and<br />
for allowing the <strong>Founder</strong> to take pictures and interview<br />
them during the game. Congratulations to the<br />
Ski Team, who have secured a place in the national finals, and to the<br />
hockey men’s 2nd XI for remaining undefeated!<br />
If you have an event you would like to see covered in the <strong>Founder</strong>,<br />
contact me two weeks prior to the event with the details, and it can be<br />
included in the <strong>Founder</strong>, possibly as a feature article!<br />
Happy Sporting!<br />
Allison Ealey<br />
Sports Editor<br />
By K Hannam<br />
Netball Review<br />
Holloway 2nd: 23 | Brighton 4th: 24<br />
Wednesday the 31st of January saw<br />
one of the closest matches for the<br />
RHUL netball second team this season.<br />
Holloway took the first goal<br />
from a Brighton centre pass putting<br />
them one goal ahead at the beginning,<br />
a good start. However the first<br />
quarter saw the first injury to wing<br />
defense Laura Lucey. Dirty play saw<br />
a final total of three injuries to Hol-<br />
BUSA Southeast Conference Division 5a<br />
loway players for the game. By quarter<br />
time Holloway were down 7goals<br />
and 1 player. In the second quarter<br />
a loose ball caused some problems<br />
requiring a substitution with Laura<br />
Watts coming on to replace Sarah<br />
Taylor. <strong>The</strong> fresh legs really lifted<br />
the team and by three quarter time<br />
Holloway were back level. However<br />
an ankle injury to substitute Laura<br />
Watts meant a return to the court<br />
for Sarah Taylor, and a move to wing<br />
attack from goal shooter for Kath-<br />
ryn Hannam. By the final quarter<br />
the match was scoring to centre pass<br />
and at points Holloway looked to be<br />
able to pull ahead. Strong defense<br />
from both teams kept the score<br />
in the low twenties with the final<br />
whistle coming with Holloway one<br />
goal down. Even though it finished<br />
a loss this game was one of the best<br />
for the second team and showed<br />
how far the team has progressed<br />
through the year.<br />
Who’s that coming over the hill?<br />
Is it the unbeatable BUSA champions?<br />
Holloway 2nd XI 3-0 University College London 2nd XI (ULU Cup Quarter Finals)<br />
Holloway 2nd XI 2-0 Surrey 2nd XI (BUSA League)<br />
y Barry de Silva<br />
<strong>The</strong>re is a train, coming over the<br />
hill of history, which on its way inscribes<br />
the name of the Holloway<br />
Men’s Hockey 2nd XI upon it. <strong>The</strong><br />
problem with this train, for opposing<br />
teams around the country, is no<br />
matter how hard they try, they never<br />
seem to be able to get in its way, and<br />
draw the train to a halt. In the last<br />
week the team of invincibles from<br />
Royal Holloway have slaughtered<br />
the much-admired and favourites<br />
of the University of London Union<br />
(ULU) Cup, the University College<br />
of London 2nd team, as well as sealing<br />
last Wednesday, the title of the<br />
BUSA league, with a gritty win over<br />
the Surrey 2nd XI in a high tempo<br />
local derby.<br />
<strong>The</strong> captain of the unstoppable<br />
train is Joe Keech, the ever present<br />
central midfielder, with an opinion<br />
on everything. <strong>The</strong>se opinions are,<br />
however, not contained within the<br />
walls of the team, but also encroach<br />
onto the field of play, where he’s not<br />
afraid to shout at a poor decision<br />
(in his opinion), or an illegal challenge<br />
by an opposing player. One<br />
of the highlights of Keech’s passion<br />
for the game of hockey was in the<br />
quarter-final clash at Staines Hockey<br />
Club, against a very technically<br />
gifted University College London<br />
team. Just as Keech was set to unwind<br />
a vicious shot at goal, and with<br />
the goalkeeper scrambling out, he<br />
was pushed by an opposing player.<br />
Mr. Keech’s reaction was anything<br />
but the calm and collected attitude<br />
you may expect from a captain, with<br />
words of outrage exchanged to the<br />
guilty player, for the illegal and malicious<br />
challenge he received.<br />
Despite the Holloway train steamrolling<br />
and flattening the University<br />
College London 2nd XI, with Alex<br />
Stephens contributing with two<br />
stunners, the team from Egham<br />
were by the end of the game crippled<br />
with severe<br />
injuries to crucial<br />
players. <strong>The</strong> likes<br />
of Sam Chuang,<br />
who all season<br />
had been up to<br />
that point been<br />
a rock in the defence<br />
of the train’s<br />
mission to remain<br />
unbeaten. His season<br />
has, as a result<br />
of a violent and<br />
inaccurate shot<br />
at goal, been cut<br />
short through injury.<br />
He will most<br />
definitely be the<br />
most sorely missed<br />
for the rest of the<br />
season. In the last two games, the<br />
squire aboard the Holloway express,<br />
who goes by the name of Joe Yaxley,<br />
has had a dreadful time through<br />
illness. His lack of action in the<br />
last two games, clocking up a mere<br />
10 minutes on the field of play has<br />
been a blow to the 2nd team, as it<br />
has lead to the non-existence of his<br />
energy and blistering runs up and<br />
down the pitch.<br />
Even though these absentees<br />
have become a thorn in the robust<br />
locomotive Holloway, the train has<br />
instead gone up three or four gears<br />
in its hunger and desire to win. This<br />
has lead to others pushing the train<br />
forward, to produce match winning<br />
performances. Will Reidie and Alex<br />
Janz are two who have revelled in<br />
the responsibility in midfield, producing<br />
alongside Joe Keech clean<br />
cut tackles, and counter attacking,<br />
defence splitting passes, which<br />
have hence lead to the likes of Chris<br />
Bull slotting away the through ball<br />
in comprehensive style. His goal,<br />
which put the icing on the cake,<br />
helped seal the victory against Surrey<br />
in the BUSA league showdown<br />
for the title, pinpointed his qualities<br />
as a forward.<br />
<strong>The</strong> showdown with Surrey on<br />
the last day of the BUSA league season<br />
was anything but academic. <strong>The</strong><br />
notable absentees of Chuang and<br />
Yaxley left large gaps in the defence<br />
and midfield to fill, however the introduction<br />
of Nick Keulers into the<br />
team added another dimension as<br />
he made several<br />
storming runs<br />
from defence and<br />
into the opposing<br />
half. <strong>The</strong> late<br />
arrival of James<br />
Symons (due to<br />
the mix up in<br />
the timings of<br />
the match) didn’t<br />
ooze confidence<br />
in the train’s destination<br />
of victory.<br />
Like in the UCL<br />
game though, it<br />
was the second<br />
half that brought<br />
out the best in<br />
Holloway with a<br />
blistering run by<br />
the evergreen James Symons and an<br />
Alex Stephens miniscule flick into<br />
the Surrey goal. <strong>The</strong> second goal involved<br />
Chris Bull skipping past two<br />
or three players, and despite having<br />
support, having the confidence to<br />
whip the ball into the bottom corner,<br />
and past the outstretched goalkeeper.<br />
<strong>The</strong> camaraderie within the team<br />
has been a strong focus as well this<br />
season. James Morley in particular<br />
is one who has lightened the mood<br />
upon the Holloway express; especially<br />
when the 2nd team look all<br />
‘doom and gloom.’ His creation of<br />
‘Morley Hockey’ particular has received<br />
a few laughs from the team,<br />
with some going as far as to say<br />
it’s groundbreaking. <strong>The</strong> togetherness<br />
in the team is a key part of<br />
the success. <strong>The</strong> want to fight for<br />
one another seems to be a continuing<br />
theme through all the Royal<br />
Holloway Teams. Let’s hope that it<br />
still remains as one of Royal Holloway’s<br />
traits not only in its hockey<br />
teams but throughout the Athletics<br />
Union.<br />
N.B.<br />
<strong>The</strong> men’s Hockey 1st team is another<br />
who has the honour of being<br />
unbeaten BUSA champions of<br />
their respective league, though<br />
they have the disappointment of<br />
being defeated in the ULU Cup.<br />
<strong>The</strong> men’s 2nd XI remains the only<br />
hockey team in the club that are<br />
still in it.
Sports<br />
PHOTO: TIM RUFFLES<br />
can’t find your match? email your sports <strong>new</strong>s to: allison@thefounder.co.uk<br />
Victory for Colts, American Football fans<br />
y Allison Ealey<br />
ports Editor<br />
Few sports clubs on campus are<br />
fortunate enough to have a major<br />
international event held each<br />
year, celebrating their sport, and<br />
their sport only, in all its glory. <strong>The</strong><br />
American Football Club, however,<br />
is just so fortunate. Sunday night,<br />
February 4, the American Football<br />
Club hosted their second annual Super<br />
Bowl watch party in Medicine.<br />
Doors opened at 10pm, and a very<br />
substantial and diverse crowd grew<br />
as kickoff drew nearer. With colorful<br />
displays of dancing, musical performances,<br />
and the United States<br />
national anthem sung by Billy Joel,<br />
kickoff was at 11:30, and for some,<br />
it was their first taste of the Super<br />
Bowl, and of American football.<br />
Marilia Sio, a second year exchange<br />
student from Sidney, Australia, was<br />
watching one of her first experiences<br />
of the sport. “Its really different<br />
from rugby, it seems less aggressive,<br />
but is still really exciting” Sio<br />
commented. Rugby seems to be the<br />
most effective frame of reference for<br />
American football fans who are <strong>new</strong><br />
to the sport. However, the popularity<br />
of American football at Royal<br />
Holloway appears to be growing<br />
rapidly, and events such as the Super<br />
Bowl foster this growth. <strong>The</strong> American<br />
football team’s defensive coordinator,<br />
Laurent Michel was pres-<br />
ent for the game, and noticed the<br />
excitement surrounding the events.<br />
He was glad to see a diverse group<br />
of students in the audience “This is<br />
great, its nice to see everyone get excited<br />
for the game”, Michel told the<br />
<strong>Founder</strong>.<br />
<strong>The</strong>re was much excitement in<br />
Medicine, as the Bears returned the<br />
kickoff for a 92-yard touchdown, an<br />
extraordinary start to the game. Despite<br />
rainy playing conditions, the<br />
first half had a substantial amount<br />
of scoring for both teams. Earlier in<br />
the game, the crowd seemed favor a<br />
Bears victory, but as time went on<br />
and the score went up, more support<br />
for the Colts emerged. Simon<br />
Pearl, president of the American<br />
Football Club, was one spectator<br />
supporting Peyton Manning and his<br />
Indianapolis Colts. Pearl explained<br />
to the <strong>Founder</strong> that it was the second<br />
year the American Football<br />
Club had hosted its Super Bowl<br />
party. <strong>The</strong> American Football Club<br />
has only been in existence for three<br />
years, so it was remarkable to see the<br />
amount of support for their events<br />
growing so quickly. “Last year there<br />
were around 100 people present,<br />
this year, it is likely there are closer<br />
to 250”, Pearl explained.<br />
Without the American Football<br />
team acting as host for the event, it<br />
may not have happened. This year,<br />
Medicine informed the Club that<br />
they would be hosting the event<br />
Students gather in Medicine to watch the Super Bowl<br />
whether they became involved or<br />
not, but the help contributed by the<br />
American football club was the pivotal<br />
force in a successful evening.<br />
Last year, there were no plans to<br />
host the event, and none were made<br />
until the American Football Club<br />
took matters into their own hands,<br />
and took over control of hosting the<br />
event. <strong>The</strong>refore all credit is due to<br />
the American Football club for beginning<br />
a <strong>new</strong> campus tradition.<br />
Unfortunately, the Club will receive<br />
no financial reward from the £2 entry<br />
charged to students. Despite this<br />
small disappointment, there was<br />
back Hameed Tarin is a player from<br />
Afghanistan, and Super Bowl XLI<br />
was also his first. Tarin became interested<br />
in American football after<br />
watching the Club play a game last<br />
year. Although he had never seen an<br />
American football game before, he<br />
was “Really impressed, Royal Holloway<br />
had a very <strong>new</strong> team, and<br />
they were out there winning games”.<br />
Eventually, Tarin joined the team,<br />
where he has quickly become an<br />
asset on the field. Tarin showed his<br />
support by joining in to watch the<br />
big game, also choosing to support<br />
the Colts.<br />
still a strong presence among both Although there were several<br />
members of the American Football<br />
Club and students alike. Corner-<br />
rookies in the audience, there were<br />
also some seasoned spectators who<br />
had been following the Super Bowl<br />
for many years. Masters student and<br />
American Football Club member<br />
Eric Motschiedler went to great<br />
lengths to watch last year’s Super<br />
Bowl while in Ecuador. This year, he<br />
was “Amazed by how many people<br />
are interested” in the game and saw<br />
“fertile ground for European interest<br />
to grow”. For an American watching<br />
the game in the United Kingdom for<br />
the first time, expectations may have<br />
been somewhat unsure, as there is<br />
not a noticeable buzz surrounding<br />
American football in general. <strong>The</strong><br />
crowd support at the Super Bowl<br />
watch party however, was just as exciting<br />
and energetic as viewing the<br />
game amongst an American crowd.<br />
After a 29-17 victory by the Colts,<br />
only the most dedicated were left,<br />
as the game ended around 3 in the<br />
morning, local time. Although the<br />
American professional season has<br />
ended, there is still more American<br />
football fun to be had. For anyone<br />
interested in following the American<br />
Football Club, they have upcoming<br />
home games February 17th<br />
and 24th , played at the Brunel campus<br />
fields.<br />
Congratulations!<br />
Congratulations to the Ski Team, who competed in<br />
the King’s ski race last weekend and placed 5th in<br />
the league, securing them a place in the national<br />
finals later this year!<br />
Some fans cheer, some moan, as the game carries on<br />
allison@thefounder.co.uk