PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES - United Kingdom Parliament
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES - United Kingdom Parliament
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES - United Kingdom Parliament
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
627 Oral Answers<br />
15 MAY 2013<br />
Oral Answers<br />
628<br />
Mr Jones: What I would say is that those on higher<br />
earnings will be paying more tax under this Government<br />
than they did during any year of the last Labour<br />
Government. We are supporting families with lower<br />
taxation and we are reducing the tax burden progressively;<br />
it would appear that the hon. Lady’s party has no<br />
interest at all in supporting the interests of hard-working<br />
families.<br />
PRIME MINISTER<br />
The Prime Minister was asked—<br />
Engagements<br />
Q1. [154913] Tristram Hunt (Stoke-on-Trent Central)<br />
(Lab): If he will list his official engagements for<br />
Wednesday 15 May.<br />
The Deputy Prime Minister (Mr Nick Clegg): Ihave<br />
been asked to reply. My right hon. Friend the Prime<br />
Minister—[Interruption.]<br />
Mr Speaker: Order. The Deputy Prime Minister must<br />
be heard—from the start of the session to the end of the<br />
session.<br />
The Deputy Prime Minister: I have been asked to<br />
reply. My right hon. Friend the Prime Minister is visiting<br />
the <strong>United</strong> States for meetings with President Obama,<br />
making the case for a transatlantic trade agreement<br />
between the <strong>United</strong> States and the European Union<br />
and chairing the high-level panel on development in<br />
New York today. This morning, I had meetings with<br />
ministerial colleagues and others. In addition to my<br />
duties in this House, I shall have further such meetings<br />
later today.<br />
Tristram Hunt: I thank the Deputy Prime Minister<br />
for his answer. If Conservative Members of <strong>Parliament</strong><br />
do not have to support the Government on Europe, why<br />
do Liberal Democrat MPs have to support the Government<br />
on tripling tuition fees, top-down reorganisation of the<br />
NHS, the bedroom tax and all the other wretched<br />
policies of this Government?<br />
The Deputy Prime Minister: Liberal Democrats, and<br />
indeed Conservatives, are working together to clear up<br />
the mess left by the hon. Gentleman’s party. It is this<br />
Government who are delivering more apprenticeships<br />
than ever before, delivering a cap on social care costs,<br />
delivering a decent state pension for everybody and<br />
clearing up the mess in the banking system left by that<br />
man there—the right hon. Member for Morley and<br />
Outwood (Ed Balls)—and so many other people on the<br />
Labour Benches.<br />
Mr Peter Bone (Wellingborough) (Con): Will the<br />
Deputy Prime Minister confirm that the only party in<br />
this House offering an in/out referendum is the Conservative<br />
party?<br />
The Deputy Prime Minister: I know the hon. Gentleman<br />
hates to be reminded of things that he and I have<br />
actually done together when we have been on the same<br />
side of the argument, but we spent 100 days in the early<br />
part of this <strong>Parliament</strong> passing legislation, opposed by<br />
the Labour party, that for the first time ever gives a<br />
guarantee in law about when a referendum on Europe<br />
will take place—when the rules next change or new<br />
things are asked of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Kingdom</strong> within the<br />
European Union. The hon. Gentleman and his colleagues<br />
in the Conservative party are perfectly free for their own<br />
reasons to move the goalposts, but this legislation is in<br />
place and the people of Britain have a guarantee about<br />
when a referendum will take place, and that is what I<br />
suggest we should all go out and promote.<br />
Ms Harriet Harman (Camberwell and Peckham) (Lab):<br />
I am sure that everyone is thrilled to see the Deputy<br />
Prime Minister and, of course, myself at the Dispatch<br />
Box today. This is meant to be Prime Minister’s questions,<br />
however, yet once again the Prime Minister is not here.<br />
Why is it that out of the last eight Wednesdays, the<br />
Prime Minister has answered questions in this House<br />
only once?<br />
The Deputy Prime Minister: I think that the Prime<br />
Minister is unusually assiduous in coming to the House<br />
to make statements. I think that the leader who should<br />
be relieved that there is no Prime Minister’s Question<br />
Time today is the leader of the right hon. and learned<br />
Lady’s party. I am still reeling with dismay over the fact<br />
that recently, on Radio 4, he denied 10 times that<br />
borrowing would increase under Labour’s plans. Who<br />
said that there is not enough comedy on Radio 4?<br />
Ms Harman: We have all seen what the Prime Minister<br />
has been doing in America. He has been on a London<br />
bus in New York—something, incidentally, that we do<br />
not see him doing a great deal when he is here. He has<br />
also been busy explaining to President Obama the<br />
benefits of Britain’s membership of the European Union.<br />
Why is he able to do that in the White House, but not in<br />
this House?<br />
The Deputy Prime Minister: To be fair to the Prime<br />
Minister—notwithstanding our other differences on this<br />
subject—I think that he has always made it clear that he<br />
believes in continued membership of the European<br />
Union, if it is a reformed European Union.<br />
There is a fundamental debate that we need to have in<br />
this country about whether we are an open or a closed<br />
nation, and about whether or not we stand tall in our<br />
European neighbourhood. That debate will continue,<br />
and the Prime Minister will continue to make his views<br />
known.<br />
Ms Harman: It is indeed an important debate, and we<br />
have an important vote on an amendment to the Queen’s<br />
Speech tonight, but the Prime Minister is out of the<br />
country. Can the Deputy Prime Minister help the House?<br />
If the Prime Minister were here today, would he be<br />
voting for the Government or against the Government,<br />
or would he be showing true leadership and abstaining?<br />
The Deputy Prime Minister: The right hon. and learned<br />
Lady has used three questions to point out that the<br />
Prime Minister is not here. That is a striking observation—a<br />
penetrating insight into the affairs of state today.