10.11.2014 Views

3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Ms. Dillon. 5 6 - The Tribunal of ...

3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Ms. Dillon. 5 6 - The Tribunal of ...

3 4 CHAIRMAN: Good morning, Ms. Dillon. 5 6 - The Tribunal of ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

16<br />

10:59:11<br />

1 Q. 96 You see, you have previously told the <strong>Tribunal</strong> --<br />

2 A. That's right.<br />

3 Q. 97 -- in answer to Judge Faherty in the Ballycullen Module --<br />

4 A. That's right.<br />

10:59:17<br />

5 Q. 98 And Judge Faherty pressed you on this and she asked you twice about this on day<br />

6 613, as to whether you had ever signed a motion outside <strong>of</strong> your electoral area<br />

7 and you replied and the page is, day 613 page 90, please.<br />

8<br />

9 And Judge Faherty says:<br />

10:59:40<br />

10<br />

11 "That's what I'm asking you. Do I take it you wouldn't sign a motion that<br />

12 wasn't in your electoral area?<br />

13 A: No I wouldn't".<br />

14 A. Well I would have interrupted perhaps and maybe clarify it now. I wouldn't<br />

11:00:01<br />

15 propose anything but in fact, to be supportive <strong>of</strong> a motion is different than<br />

16 signing one. I wasn't going to make a contribution. But I just thought that<br />

17 was a good compromise.<br />

18 Q. 99 Just to look at the answer you gave Judge Faherty and we'll see where there<br />

19 could have been any room for ambiguity in the question that you were asked.<br />

11:00:09<br />

20 If we look at the bottom <strong>of</strong> the page 90. Judge Faherty says to you<br />

21 "That's what I'm asking you. Do you I take it that you wouldn't sign?"<br />

22 Judge Faherty did not say "support" <strong>Ms</strong>. Ormonde.<br />

23 A. I know.<br />

24 Q. 100 "Do I take it you wouldn't sign a motion that wasn't in your elector area."<br />

11:00:22<br />

25 And the next page.<br />

26 "A: No, I wouldn't".<br />

27<br />

28 Are you saying now that you didn't understand Judge Faherty's question?<br />

29 A. Well it's a play on words. Thank perhaps -- I mean sign is supporting. I<br />

11:00:36<br />

30 had obviously I wouldn't say it now in that sense. Now that it's brought to my<br />

Premier Captioning & Realtime Limited<br />

www.pcr.ie Day 645

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!