Benazir Bhutto - SZABIST
Benazir Bhutto - SZABIST
Benazir Bhutto - SZABIST
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
She was demonized by the civil-military oligarchy that has virtually run Pakistan since 1958, the year<br />
of Pakistan's first military coup. But she retained a hard core of popular support, and her socialdemocratic<br />
Pakistan People's Party is widely regarded as Pakistan's largest political party.<br />
In 1988, at the age of 35, <strong>Bhutto</strong> became the youngest prime minister in Pakistan's troubled history,<br />
and the first woman to lead a Muslim nation in the modern age. For her supporters, she stood for<br />
women's empowerment, human rights and mass education. Her detractors accused her of many things,<br />
from corruption to being too close to the U.S.<br />
During her second tenure as prime minister, Pakistan became one of the 10 emerging capital markets<br />
of the world. The World Health Organization praised government efforts in the field of health.<br />
Rampant narcotics problems were tackled and several drug barons arrested. <strong>Bhutto</strong> increased<br />
government spending on education and 46,000 new schools were built.<br />
Thousands of teachers were recruited with the understanding that a secular education, covering<br />
multiple study areas (particularly technical and scientific education), would improve the lives of<br />
Pakistanis and create job opportunities critical to self-empowerment. But Pakistan's political<br />
turbulence, and her constant battle with the country's security establishment, never allowed her to take<br />
credit for these achievements.<br />
For years, her image was tarnished by critics who alleged that she did not deliver on her promise.<br />
During the early days after Mr. Musharraf's decision to support the U.S.-led war against terrorism in<br />
the aftermath of 9/11, conventional wisdom in Washington wrote her off. But Pakistan's constant drift<br />
into extremism, and Mr. Musharraf's inability to win Pakistani hearts and minds, changed that.<br />
Earlier this year, the United States and the United Kingdom supported efforts for a transition to<br />
democracy in Pakistan based on a negotiated settlement between <strong>Bhutto</strong> and Mr. Musharraf. She was<br />
to be allowed to return to Pakistan and the many corruption charges filed against her and her husband,<br />
Asif Zardari, were to be dropped.<br />
Mr. Musharraf promised free and fair elections, and promised to end a bar imposed by him against<br />
<strong>Bhutto</strong> running for a third term as prime minister. But on Nov. 3, his imposition of a state of<br />
emergency, suspension of Pakistan's constitution, and arbitrary reshuffling of the country's judiciary<br />
brought that arrangement to an end. He went back on his promises to <strong>Bhutto</strong>, and as elections<br />
approached, recrimination between the two was at its height.<br />
<strong>Benazir</strong> <strong>Bhutto</strong> had the combination of political brilliance, charisma, popular support and international<br />
recognition that made her a credible democratic alternative to Mr. Musharraf. Her elimination from<br />
the scene is not only a personal loss to millions of Pakistanis who loved and admired her. It exposes<br />
her nation's vulnerability, and the urgent need to deal with it.<br />
Mr. Haqqani, a professor at Boston University and co-chair of the Hudson Institute's Project on Islam<br />
and Democracy, is the author of "Pakistan: Between Mosque and Military" (Carnegie Endowment for<br />
International Peace, 2005). He has served as adviser to several Pakistani prime ministers, including<br />
<strong>Benazir</strong> <strong>Bhutto</strong><br />
Wall Street Journal<br />
December 28, 2007