Benazir Bhutto - SZABIST
Benazir Bhutto - SZABIST
Benazir Bhutto - SZABIST
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
called <strong>Benazir</strong>, which will continue to fight the shadowy dark forces in this miserable land. Siyasi<br />
murshid siyasi pir, <strong>Benazir</strong>, <strong>Benazir</strong>.<br />
The writer served as nazim of Khairpur district from 2001 to 2005, and has now been nominated by<br />
the PPP on a reserved seat for women in the National Assembly. She is currently also a doctoral<br />
student at Oxford University<br />
To <strong>Benazir</strong>, in the heavens<br />
The News<br />
January 6, 2008<br />
Ghazala Minallah<br />
Following a statement by Mohtarma <strong>Benazir</strong> <strong>Bhutto</strong> regarding the judiciary in early December, I had<br />
written an open letter to her and also sent it on her email address. My letter came in several<br />
newspapers and is on the Internet. Mohtarma, much to my amazement, replied the next day. Her<br />
response had some information which made me not to reveal it. Now that she is gone, it can be made<br />
public but I have to do it with another open letter, which may reach her in the Heavens, if so.<br />
My Dearest Mohtarma <strong>Benazir</strong> <strong>Bhutto</strong>,<br />
Somewhere in the Heavens<br />
It has taken me three days to muster up the courage to write to you. When I wrote to you on December<br />
2, it was because of the belief I had in you and the unrealistic expectations I had from you. When you<br />
returned on October 18 I truly and honestly felt that you would join and lead us in the struggle we<br />
began on March 9 for an independent judiciary. I believed that since you and your family had suffered<br />
in the past due to another dictator and a corrupt judiciary, you would be the first to raise your voice.<br />
Your statement that individuals were not important made me feel betrayed. I considered you to be a<br />
kindred spirit and I reacted emotionally because I lacked your ability to look at things in their broader<br />
perspective.<br />
Bibi, I turned to you then and I turn to you now. I did not make public the reply you sent to me on<br />
December 3 for obvious reasons. You did me the honour of replying promptly despite your busy<br />
schedule. The few lines you wrote were so powerful and had such depth, that other than a few close<br />
friends, I did not reveal the contents. But now I feel that I owe it to your memory to reveal what you<br />
wrote to me.<br />
I was touched by the fact that instead of being angry at me, you took the trouble to try and explain to<br />
me the reason for your unpopular statement. You wrote: "Dear sister Ghazala, I had to force my tears<br />
back while going through your letter. It pains and saddens my soul to see that such perceptions are still<br />
held about me, in spite of what I and my family have gone through and the personal sacrifices. I still<br />
remain committed to the freedom and vitality of democracy, as the great Quaid-e-Awam had dreamt<br />
of. Yes, it is true that you have to deal sometimes with the Devil if you can't face it, but everything is a<br />
means to an end. I have great respect and admiration for the judiciary both bench and bar". My lips<br />
were sealed after that because obviously this was sensitive information. I feel that now it is important<br />
to share this with my fellow Pakistani's for whom your ultimate sacrifice has immortalized you. Your<br />
reply reveals your maturity and compassion. You could have ignored my letter, or sent me a scathing<br />
reply, or snubbed me for jumping to conclusions. But you chose not to.