New Strategies for Cost-Effective, High Value, Low Risk FTO ... - C5
New Strategies for Cost-Effective, High Value, Low Risk FTO ... - C5
New Strategies for Cost-Effective, High Value, Low Risk FTO ... - C5
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
Business In<strong>for</strong>mation<br />
In A Global Context<br />
9 th International Forum on<br />
Freedom<br />
Gain insights<br />
from <strong>FTO</strong> experts<br />
from 12 countries!<br />
to Operate<br />
9–10 May 2012<br />
Le Méridien Parkhotel<br />
Frankfurt, Germany<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>Strategies</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Cost</strong>-<strong>Effective</strong>, <strong>High</strong> <strong>Value</strong>, <strong>Low</strong> <strong>Risk</strong> <strong>FTO</strong> Assessments<br />
Latest Legal and Regulatory Developments <strong>for</strong> Successful Opinion Writing<br />
Led by Industry Experts from:<br />
Merck Serono (Switzerland)<br />
Sanovel (Turkey)<br />
MorphoSys AG (Germany)<br />
Lonza AG (USA)<br />
Siena Biotech (Italy)<br />
Ablynx (Belgium)<br />
Actelion Pharmaceuticals Ltd<br />
(Switzerland)<br />
Astex Pharmaceuticals (UK)<br />
Angelini (Italy)<br />
CEPIUG (Confederacy of European<br />
Patent In<strong>for</strong>mation User Groups)<br />
European Patent Office<br />
Session Sponsor:<br />
Get practical advice on the biggest challenges facing Freedom to Operate (<strong>FTO</strong>)<br />
searches, analysis and opinion writing today and cut through the complexities of:<br />
• Current EPO, US and European National case law on claim interpretation<br />
and validity<br />
• Conducting <strong>FTO</strong> searches more time efficiently and cost effectively<br />
- Hear best practice approaches to good search strategy by leading in-house experts<br />
- Explore new technology tools and trends<br />
- Assess search strategies <strong>for</strong> different sized projects<br />
• <strong>New</strong> developments on SPCs and paediatric exclusivity and how they could<br />
threaten your patent strategy<br />
• Stratifying and quantifying <strong>FTO</strong> risks: how to deal with the grey areas<br />
• Downstream effects of EPO divisional applications and the America Invents Act<br />
on your <strong>FTO</strong> strategy<br />
• <strong>New</strong> considerations <strong>for</strong> <strong>FTO</strong> practice arising from recent gene patenting<br />
decisions (Lilly v HGS and Brüstle v Greenpeace)<br />
• Addressing <strong>FTO</strong> challenges in emerging markets: China, India, Brazil<br />
Plus, add further value to your experience by attending our<br />
expert-led and interactive workshop on:<br />
Analysing Claims in Patents and Patent Applications:<br />
Practical and Strategic Insights into EU and US Specific <strong>FTO</strong> Issues<br />
Up to<br />
14.0 CPD<br />
Media Partners:<br />
To register call +44 (0) 20 7878 6888 or register online at www.<strong>C5</strong>-Online.com/<strong>FTO</strong>
<strong>Strategies</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Effective</strong> <strong>FTO</strong> Searches and Analysis, Opinion Writing<br />
and Reducing the <strong>Risk</strong> of Future Litigation<br />
An effective Freedom to Operate search strategy and patent landscape analysis is vital to<br />
the pharmaceutical, biotechnology and chemical industries. It is critical that IP Counsel<br />
and patent strategy advisors have the in<strong>for</strong>mation they need to create a successful and costeffective<br />
<strong>FTO</strong> strategy which not only protects their firms from the increasing threat of<br />
litigation but also maximises profit and secures future revenue.<br />
<strong>C5</strong>’s Forum on Freedom to Operate is the only event in Europe specifically designed <strong>for</strong><br />
IP and In<strong>for</strong>mation Science experts involved with <strong>FTO</strong> practices in pharma, biotech and<br />
chemical sectors. Our unparalleled speaker faculty, including <strong>FTO</strong> experts from at least 12<br />
different countries, will provide you with the clarity and in<strong>for</strong>mation you need to sharpen,<br />
refine and improve your <strong>FTO</strong> assessment and patent due diligence procedures.<br />
Hear from your direct peers how to conduct <strong>FTO</strong> searches more efficiently –<br />
in-house or with the support of service and technology providers, gain best practice advice<br />
on interpreting search results and patent validity and get insights on how the latest case law<br />
developments will impact your <strong>FTO</strong> strategy.<br />
You will walk away with fresh insights, tactics and tools to strategise your <strong>FTO</strong> assessment<br />
and keep up with the latest legal and regulatory developments and their implications on<br />
your patent strategy in this competitively heated market.<br />
In addition, if you are new to Freedom to Operate activities or would like a refresher<br />
on patent claims analysis, don’t miss our practical and interactive workshop immediately<br />
following the conference.<br />
Workshop, afternoon of 10 th May:<br />
Analysing Claims in Patents and Patent Applications:<br />
Practical and Strategic Insights into EU and US Specific <strong>FTO</strong> Issues<br />
Taking on board the knowledge gained in the conference this hands-on afternoon session<br />
will provide in-depth insights into a wide range of European and US-specific <strong>FTO</strong><br />
issues that will assist you to read and examine patent claims and overcome barriers of<br />
interpretation within key EU jurisdictions and the US.<br />
The emphasis throughout the session will be on worked examples and delegate<br />
participation. By the end of the seminar delegates will be able to:<br />
• Examine various aspects of validity and patent scope<br />
• Identify and analyse infringement risk and infringement risk mitigation strategies<br />
• Combat the challenges of prior art, reduce the risk of damages and expand your<br />
patent portfolio to exploit new opportunities<br />
Unparalleled Learning and Networking<br />
<strong>C5</strong> understands that sharing experiences and building relationships with your fellow<br />
delegates during the breaks can be just as valuable as the structured conference sessions.<br />
We strive to make both the <strong>for</strong>mal and in<strong>for</strong>mal aspects of the conference as productive as<br />
possible; and so we would like to invite you to join our:<br />
Apple Wine Tasting Evening<br />
Enjoy this regional speciality with your new industry contacts in the evening of the first<br />
conference day.<br />
Reserve your place at this invaluable conference today! Register now by calling<br />
+44 (0) 20 7878 6888, by faxing your registration <strong>for</strong>m to +44 (0) 20 7878 6885 or by<br />
registering online at www.<strong>C5</strong>-Online.com/<strong>FTO</strong><br />
WHO SHOULD ATTEND<br />
<strong>C5</strong>’s 9 th International Forum on Freedom to Operate will provide valuable insights <strong>for</strong>:<br />
From Pharma, Biotech and Chemical Companies:<br />
• In-house Counsel, Patent/IP Counsel<br />
• Heads/Directors of Patent/IP departments<br />
and Patent/IP Managers<br />
• Patent Specialists and Experts<br />
• Heads/ Directors of Licensing<br />
• Chief Scientific Officer / In<strong>for</strong>mation Officer<br />
and In<strong>for</strong>mation Scientists / Analysts<br />
• Heads/ Directors Research & Development<br />
and Research Scientists<br />
• Head of Business Development<br />
Private Practice Patent Attorneys specialising in:<br />
• Life Science/ Biotech/ Pharma / Chemicals<br />
• IP and Patents<br />
Conference Chair:<br />
Raymond Mandra, Partner, Fitzpatrick, Cella,<br />
Harper & Scinto (USA)<br />
Meet our Expert Faculty:<br />
Giampiero De Luca, VP Intellectual Property,<br />
Merck Serono (Switzerland)<br />
Aalt van de Kuilen, President of the CEPIUG<br />
(Confederacy of European Patent In<strong>for</strong>mation<br />
User Groups) (Netherlands)<br />
Bernd Hutter, Director, Head of Intellectual<br />
Property, European Patent Attorney,<br />
MorphoSys AG (Germany)<br />
Michelle Jones, PhD, EPA CPA, Associate<br />
Director IP, Astex Pharmaceuticals (UK)<br />
Eric Ruhlmann, European Patent Attorney,<br />
Director, Senior Patent Counsel, Actelion<br />
Pharmaceuticals (Switzerland)<br />
Gaye Ramazanoglu, Intellectual Property<br />
Specialist – Patent and Trademark Attorney,<br />
Sanovel (Turkey)<br />
Marco Nievo, PhD EPA, IP and Competitive<br />
Intelligence, Siena Biotech SPA (Italy)<br />
Harry Kraft, Senior Patent Attorney, Ablynx<br />
(Belgium)<br />
Lorenzo Polenzani, R&D Strategy Manager,<br />
Angelini (Italy)<br />
Dr. Klaus-Peter Döpfer, European Patent Office<br />
Ilian Iliev, CEO, Cambridge IP (UK)<br />
Otto Licks, Partner, Leonardos & Licks<br />
Advogados (Brazil)<br />
Raymond Mandra, Partner, Fitzpatrick, Cella,<br />
Harper & Scinto (USA)<br />
Jeroen den Hartog, PhD, Partner, European<br />
and Dutch Patent Attorney, Hoyng Monegier<br />
(Netherlands)<br />
Sandra Pohlman, Partner, df. mp (Germany)<br />
Michael Eder, Partner, df. mp (Germany)<br />
Gareth Morgan, Partner, Winston & Strawn<br />
(UK)<br />
Daniel Becker, Partner, Dechert (USA)<br />
Gertjan Kuipers, Partner, De Brauw Blackstone<br />
Westbroek (Netherlands)<br />
Dr. Malathi Lakshmikumaran, Head (Life<br />
Sciences), Lakshmi Kumaran & Sridharan<br />
(India)<br />
Dr. Qinghong Xu, Partner, Lung Tin<br />
International Intellectual Property Agent Ltd.<br />
(China)<br />
Alex Denoon, Partner, Law<strong>for</strong>d Davis Denoon<br />
(UK)<br />
Dr. Manja Epping, Partner, Taylor Wessing<br />
(Germany)<br />
Joachim Wachenfeld, Partner, Vossius & Partner<br />
(Germany)<br />
Henrik Skødt, Ph.D., European Patent Attorney,<br />
Partner, Plougmann & Vingtoft (Denmark)<br />
Ronald Eisenstein, Partner, Co-Leader Patents,<br />
Nixon Peabody (USA)<br />
Matthew Royle, Senior Associate, Taylor Wessing<br />
(UK)
Main Conference Day One: 9 May 2012<br />
8.00 Coffee and Registration<br />
8.30 Chair’s Opening Remarks<br />
Raymond Mandra, Partner, Fitzpatrick, Cella, Harper<br />
& Scinto (USA)<br />
8.40 Best Practice Approaches to Freedom to Operate<br />
Patent Research<br />
Aalt van de Kuilen, President of the CEPIUG (Confederacy<br />
of European Patent In<strong>for</strong>mation User Groups) (Netherlands)<br />
• Definition of a <strong>FTO</strong> search<br />
• Clarifying the legal context of a <strong>FTO</strong> search<br />
• Addressing guidelines <strong>for</strong> <strong>FTO</strong> searching<br />
• Defining scope of a <strong>FTO</strong> search<br />
• Introducing different types of <strong>FTO</strong> searches<br />
• Best Practices: examining real life examples<br />
• Common pitfalls and challenges and how to overcome them<br />
9.15 Interpreting <strong>FTO</strong> Search Results and Patent Validity<br />
to Reduce <strong>Risk</strong>s and Maximise Your Revenue Potential<br />
Sandra Pohlman, Partner, df. mp (Germany)<br />
Michael Eder, Partner, df. mp (Germany)<br />
1. Determining which products or processes require clearance<br />
• Geographic considerations:<br />
- identifying jurisdictions that provide the greatest exposure<br />
- extraterritorial reach of certain claim types<br />
• Temporal considerations:<br />
- stratifying risk based on expected product launch date<br />
- assessing likelihood of third party applications granting in<br />
the intended market <strong>for</strong> intended use<br />
- how to deal with uncertainty of earlier and/or expiring patents<br />
2. Challenging validity to overcome blocking patents<br />
• <strong>High</strong>lighting the EPO and National Patent Office approaches<br />
to validity<br />
- what are the differences between interpretations How do<br />
the different approaches affect invalidation approaches<br />
- which factors are most important when choosing the EPO<br />
over National Patent Offices<br />
10.15 Morning Refreshments<br />
10.45 Practical Advice <strong>for</strong> Conducting <strong>FTO</strong> Searches more<br />
Time Efficiently and <strong>Cost</strong> <strong>Effective</strong>ly<br />
PANEL SESSION<br />
Gaye Ramazanoglu, Intellectual Property Specialist –<br />
Patent and Trademark Attorney, Sanovel (Turkey)<br />
Marco Nievo, PhD EPA, IP and Competitive Intelligence,<br />
Siena Biotech SPA (Italy)<br />
Lorenzo Polenzani, R&D Strategy Manager, Angelini (Italy)<br />
Harry Kraft, Senior Patent Attorney, Ablynx (Belgium)<br />
Ilian Iliev, CEO, Cambridge IP (UK)<br />
• Conducting searches in-house v outsourcing<br />
- when to try searching in-house and when is an external<br />
search necessary<br />
- building in-house expertise: establishing internal guidelines<br />
and policies and how to monitor those<br />
- how to find the right search partner<br />
- managing the risks of outsourcing the <strong>FTO</strong> search function<br />
• Classifying and maintaining comprehensive search records<br />
- how to organise and document search results<br />
- identifying and categorising “relevant” data <strong>for</strong> the future<br />
• Search strategies <strong>for</strong> different budgets and different sized projects<br />
- how diligent do you have to be When can you stop your search<br />
- how can search budgets be managed and allocated across<br />
varying drugs<br />
12.30 Lunch<br />
• Exploring new tools and trends to ensure effective <strong>FTO</strong><br />
searches and analysis<br />
- best practice on using search engines and databases<br />
- comparing solutions available - how to decide which is<br />
the most suitable one <strong>for</strong> your needs<br />
- using translation machines effectively<br />
- pros and cons to using crowd sourcing be used <strong>for</strong> <strong>FTO</strong><br />
- open innovation initiatives – what are the implications <strong>for</strong> <strong>FTO</strong><br />
- moving beyond silos – using collaborative tools <strong>for</strong> patent<br />
intelligence<br />
• How to get the most out of your <strong>FTO</strong> searches with Data Mining<br />
- what is data mining How can it benefit your firm<br />
- what data can be used at a later stage: reporting, storing<br />
and retrieving data from searches<br />
13.30 Impact of the Recent Court Decisions on Your <strong>FTO</strong><br />
Strategy: Discussing the Pro and Cons of Lilly v HGS<br />
and Brustle v Greenpeace<br />
Gareth Morgan, Partner, Winston & Strawn (UK)<br />
Alex Denoon, Partner, Law<strong>for</strong>d Davis Denoon (UK)<br />
EXPERT DISCUSSION<br />
Our experts will share their first-hand insights and discuss the<br />
advantages and disadvantages these recent decisions will have <strong>for</strong> <strong>FTO</strong><br />
practices; followed by an open discussion with the audience on the wider<br />
implications of both cases <strong>for</strong> <strong>FTO</strong> and patent strategies in Europe.<br />
Eli Lilly v Human Genome Sciences<br />
• Addressing the basis of the UK Supreme Court appeal<br />
• UK Court of Appeal vs TBA<br />
• How will “target” patents be assessed in Europe the future<br />
• Is the protection on offer commensurate with the innovation<br />
• Examining the impact on freedom to operate <strong>for</strong> drug<br />
discovery/diagnostics companies<br />
Brüstle v Greenpeace<br />
• What did the Court of Justice decide<br />
• How does this affect existing patents (including patents relating to<br />
stem cells broadly rather than just human embryonic stem cells)<br />
• How might this affect companies’ patenting activities<br />
• Practical ramifications given the regulatory hurdles to generics<br />
of cell-based therapies<br />
• Will this lead to an increased reliance on trade secrets<br />
• Analysing the impact on freedom to operate<br />
• Wrap up: Is the impact on investor confidence greater than the<br />
patenting issues given the commercial hurdles to developing<br />
these products<br />
14.20 Understanding the Effects of Patent Extensions on<br />
<strong>FTO</strong>: How SPCs and Regulatory Data Protection Could<br />
Threaten your Patent Strategy<br />
Gertjan Kuipers, Partner, De Brauw Blackstone Westbroek<br />
(Netherlands)<br />
• Interpreting the latest SPC developments and trends<br />
• Analysing the latest ECJ decisions regarding SPCs <strong>for</strong><br />
combination products and what they mean <strong>for</strong> the<br />
‘infringement test’ and further <strong>FTO</strong> considerations:<br />
- Medeva (C-322/10)<br />
- Georgetown University (C422/10)<br />
• Addressing cross-border challenges – how are SPCs dealt with<br />
by national courts<br />
• Extend your SPC protection or extend your data exclusivity<br />
protection<br />
- determining which exclusivity right is more beneficial<br />
• Reviewing recent case law on data exclusivity<br />
14.55 <strong>FTO</strong> and Paediatric Exclusivity – What the Patent<br />
Practitioner Should Know<br />
Eric Ruhlmann, European Patent Attorney, Director, Senior<br />
Patent Counsel, Actelion Pharmaceuticals (Switzerland)<br />
• EC regulations and access to paediatric exclusivity in Europe<br />
To register call +44 (0) 20 7878 6888 or register online at www.<strong>C5</strong>-Online.com/<strong>FTO</strong>
- what are the rewards<br />
- what are the requirements (Paediatric Investigation Plan<br />
(PIP), SPCs, timelines...)<br />
- main pitfalls<br />
• European case law update<br />
- E I du Pont Nemours & Co v. UKIPO<br />
- C 125/10 (Merck & Co Inc. v. Deutsches Patent- und<br />
Markenamt - “Negative Term SPCs”)<br />
• FDA regulations and access to paediatric exclusivity in the US<br />
- what are the rewards<br />
- what are the requirements (written request from the FDA,<br />
timelines...)<br />
• US case law update<br />
- In re Omeprazole Patent Litigation<br />
- the Norvasc case – Pfizer v. Apotex and related decisions<br />
15:30 Refreshment Break<br />
16.00 Finding the Right Balance When Reporting Your<br />
<strong>FTO</strong> Strategy: Privilege and Confidentiality<br />
Jeroen den Hartog, PhD, Partner, European and Dutch<br />
Patent Attorney, Hoyng Monegier (Netherlands)<br />
• Assessing how to report in a clear way while dealing with<br />
uncertainty and later potential discovery<br />
• Best practice strategies <strong>for</strong> ensuring confidentiality of in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />
• Understanding privilege issues and overcoming challenges <strong>for</strong><br />
in-house counsel<br />
- examining the impact of e-discovery<br />
- how to keep communication with R&D private<br />
- what in<strong>for</strong>mation in an <strong>FTO</strong> assessment remains confidential<br />
- handling privilege issues during incoming due diligence<br />
• Latest update on privilege <strong>for</strong> in-house attorneys and<br />
the potential impact on any US proceedings of reported<br />
assessments of your <strong>FTO</strong> reports<br />
16.40 Stratifying and Quantifying <strong>FTO</strong> <strong>Risk</strong>s – How Do You<br />
Advise on and Deal With Grey Areas<br />
Michelle Jones, PhD, EPA CPA, Associate Director IP,<br />
Astex Pharmaceuticals (UK)<br />
Giampiero De Luca, VP Intellectual Property, Merck Serono<br />
(Switzerland)<br />
Daniel Becker, Partner, Dechert (USA)<br />
PANEL SESSION<br />
• Quantifying the risk of third party patents<br />
• Assessing the likelihood of preliminary injunction<br />
• Addressing damage claims – discussing the latest case law and<br />
its implication <strong>for</strong> <strong>FTO</strong> considerations<br />
• Using licensing as a tool to circumvent <strong>FTO</strong> roadblocks:<br />
- when should licensing become a consideration<br />
- evaluating your licensing options<br />
• Reporting <strong>FTO</strong> risks – what does the upper management need<br />
to know<br />
17.20 Conference Adjourns<br />
18.00 Networking Event –<br />
Apple Wine Tasting Evening<br />
Relax after a long day of conferencing as you<br />
sample traditional Frankfurter apple wine<br />
(cider) with your new industry contacts and<br />
fellow Freedom to Operate experts.<br />
Main Conference Day Two: 10 May 2012<br />
8.00 Coffee and Registration<br />
8:30 Chair’s Welcome<br />
Raymond Mandra, Partner, Fitzpatrick, Cella, Harper<br />
& Scinto (USA)<br />
8.35 How are EPO Divisional Applications and the America<br />
Invents Act Impacting <strong>FTO</strong> <strong>Strategies</strong><br />
Bernd Hutter, Director, Head of Intellectual Property,<br />
European Patent Attorney, MorphoSys AG (Germany)<br />
Eric Ruhlmann, European Patent Attorney, Director, Senior<br />
Patent Counsel, Actelion Pharmaceuticals (Switzerland)<br />
Dr. Klaus-Peter Döpfer, European Patent Office<br />
PANEL SESSION<br />
• Latest Insight from the EPO<br />
- update and feedback regarding divisional applications<br />
- strategies and perception of patents not granted yet<br />
- what is the impact of the new rules on <strong>FTO</strong> How the EPO<br />
is making processes more efficient and user-friendly<br />
• Implications <strong>for</strong> the America Invents Act on <strong>FTO</strong><br />
- US ex parte and inter partes re-examination<br />
- US post grant and inter pates reviews<br />
- declaratory judgement actions<br />
• Industry Response: What is the downstream effect of the<br />
legal changes<br />
- how are divisional applications impacting the <strong>FTO</strong> strategies:<br />
what are people doing Filing divisional What are your<br />
options when you are concerned someone will file a divisional<br />
- what strategies are available <strong>for</strong> overcoming delays by the<br />
EPO and USPTO (e.g. filing a third party application in the<br />
meantime)<br />
- overcoming validity when you have a pending application<br />
- discussing ways to circumvent the law to get your divisional<br />
filed<br />
<strong>FTO</strong> IN EMERGING MARKETS<br />
9.20 Latest Developments in the Indian Patent Landscape<br />
and Their Impact on <strong>FTO</strong><br />
Dr. Malathi Lakshmikumaran, Head (Life Sciences),<br />
Lakshmi Kumaran & Sridharan (India)<br />
• How are the processes and procedures to gain <strong>FTO</strong> in India<br />
different<br />
• Understanding the requirements <strong>for</strong> obtaining a valid patent<br />
- what data records should be maintained<br />
• Overcoming the challenges of obtaining reliable search data<br />
- National Patent Office (NPO) assistance vs. using search<br />
databases<br />
- safeguarding confidential in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />
• Protecting your products from infringement in India<br />
- identifying the key examiners, regulators and Courts<br />
• Discussing latest case law update<br />
10.00 Latest IP Trends and Regulatory Changes in China<br />
and the <strong>FTO</strong> Implications<br />
Dr. Qinghong Xu, Partner, Lung Tin International<br />
Intellectual Property Agent Ltd. (China)<br />
• Developing and executing an effective <strong>FTO</strong> search in China<br />
• Overcoming challenges of acquiring reliable data <strong>for</strong> <strong>FTO</strong> searches<br />
• Conducting an efficient infringement analysis<br />
• Dealing with infringement in courts: hear an update on latest<br />
case law developments<br />
• Challenging validity of blocking pharmaceutical or biotech patents<br />
10.40 Morning Refreshments<br />
11.10 Patent Filing and Litigation in Brazil – Optimise your<br />
Chances of Success<br />
Otto Licks, Partner, Leonardos & Licks Advogados (Brazil)<br />
• Examining criteria adopted by the Brazilian PTO<br />
• Overcoming challenges of acquiring reliable data <strong>for</strong> <strong>FTO</strong><br />
searches<br />
• Clarifying the requirements <strong>for</strong> obtaining a valid patent –<br />
what data records should be maintained<br />
Fax order <strong>for</strong>m to +44 (0) 20 7878 6885 or register online at www.<strong>C5</strong>-Online.com/<strong>FTO</strong>
• Gain practical insights in en<strong>for</strong>cement: how strong are<br />
pharmaceutical and biotech patents<br />
• Analyse the latest case law developments<br />
• Understanding the new rules issued by Brazil’s Regulatory<br />
agency regarding biosimilars<br />
11:50 The Impact of US Developments on European <strong>FTO</strong><br />
Analysis<br />
Raymond Mandra, Partner, Fitzpatrick, Cella, Harper &<br />
Scinto (USA)<br />
• Addressing the America Invents Act and its impact on <strong>FTO</strong><br />
strategies<br />
- is the expanded Prior Use Defense applicable<br />
- priority examination - does it create a potential minefield<br />
- considering Interpartes Review and Post Grant Review –<br />
are they in play or could they be useful<br />
• Examining recent case law developments on (in)validity<br />
and infringement<br />
- how does the obviousness analysis after KSR continue<br />
to be refined by the Federal Circuit<br />
- when are method claims requiring the acts of multiple<br />
parties infringed<br />
• Analysing case law developments on claim construction<br />
- do reexam arguments create intrinsic evidence <strong>for</strong> claim<br />
construction<br />
• Considering Biosimilars<br />
- will the legislation survive Supreme Court review<br />
- will US data exclusivity under the biosimilars legislation<br />
remain unchanged<br />
12.35 Adapting your Patent Tactics <strong>for</strong> Biosimilars:<br />
Keeping Abreast with Regulatory Changes while<br />
Staying Competitive<br />
Dr. Manja Epping, Partner, Taylor Wessing (Germany)<br />
Matthew Royle, Senior Associate, Taylor Wessing (UK)<br />
• Analysing the regulatory risks <strong>for</strong> biosimilars<br />
- Comparing the EU biosimilars legislation and Hatch-<br />
Waxman Act procedures in the US<br />
- Antibody claims – exploring breadth of claims in the<br />
biosimilars era<br />
• Pricing and reimbursement issues and their impact on your<br />
patent strategy<br />
• Examine patent strategies <strong>for</strong> biosimilars<br />
- Patent thickets as delaying tactic<br />
- Follow-on patents<br />
13.15 Chair’s Closing Remarks and End of Conference<br />
13.15 Lunch (<strong>for</strong> Workshop Attendees)<br />
At Fitzpatrick, IP is not just a<br />
practice area – it is our sole focus.<br />
We have over 175 attorneys in<br />
<strong>New</strong> York, Cali<strong>for</strong>nia, and Washington D.C. practicing in all areas of<br />
intellectual property law, including patents, trademarks, copyrights, unfair<br />
competition, and trade secrets. Our practice covers the spectrum of<br />
intellectual property services, including applying <strong>for</strong> patent and trademark<br />
protection, litigation, appeals, interferences, alternative dispute resolution,<br />
licensing, opinions, corporate transactions and due diligence.<br />
GLOBAL SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES<br />
<strong>C5</strong> works closely with sponsors to create the perfect business development<br />
solution catered exclusively to the needs of any practice group, business<br />
line or corporation. With over 500 conferences held in Europe, Russia and<br />
the CIS, China, India, the US and Canada, <strong>C5</strong>, ACI and CI provide a<br />
diverse portfolio of first-class events tailored to the senior level executive.<br />
For more in<strong>for</strong>mation about this program or our global portfolio, please contact:<br />
Jo Menzer on +44 (0)20 7878 6978 or email j.menzer@<strong>C5</strong>-Online.com<br />
Post-Conference Workshop: 10 May 2012<br />
14.00 – 17.15 (refreshment break included)<br />
Analysing Claims in Patents and Patent Applications:<br />
Practical and Strategic Insights into EU and US<br />
Specific <strong>FTO</strong> Issues<br />
Workshop leaders:<br />
Joachim Wachenfeld, Partner, Vossius & Partner (Germany)<br />
Henrik Skødt, Ph.D., European Patent Attorney, Partner,<br />
Plougmann & Vingtoft (Denmark)<br />
Ronald Eisenstein, Partner, Co-Leader Patents, Nixon<br />
Peabody (USA)<br />
EU-SPECIFIC ISSUES:<br />
Examining Infringement <strong>Risk</strong> in Major EU Jurisdictions<br />
• Scope of Bolar exemption in major European jurisdictions<br />
• Existence and scope of other infringement exemptions<br />
• Bases <strong>for</strong>, and likelihood of, injunction in major European<br />
jurisdictions<br />
• Prior user rights<br />
• Compulsory license regimes<br />
• Claim construction differences: UK, DE, other major EU<br />
jurisdictions<br />
• Non-literal infringement under EU law<br />
• Damages calculations in major European jurisdictions<br />
Clarifying Validity Issues Though Analysis of EPO Cases<br />
• The pros and cons of trying to invalidate European patents<br />
through central opposition proceedings vs. national<br />
revocation actions<br />
• In the case where the EPO found the patent valid<br />
(Atorvastatin case)<br />
• In the case where the EPO has found the patent invalid (in<br />
the first instance – Esomeprazole case)<br />
• Special advantages in the EPO opposition proceedings<br />
(extension of subject-matter – Yasmin (drospirenone/<br />
ethinylestradiol) case)<br />
• The role of party-appointed experts in national proceedings<br />
vs. opposition proceedings<br />
US-SPECIFIC ISSUES:<br />
• Clarifying Post Issuance Procedures<br />
- Post-Grant Review<br />
- Inter-partes Proceeding<br />
- Interferences<br />
• The Effects of Bilski, Prometheus, Myriad and Classen on<br />
Method Claims<br />
Mayo Collaborative Services. v. Prometheus Laboratories, Inc.<br />
(at U.S. Supreme Court)<br />
Association <strong>for</strong> Molecular Pathology v. USPTO<br />
(ACLU v. Myriad – Certiorari requested from U.S. Supreme Court)<br />
Classen Immunotherapies, Inc. v. Biogen IDEC<br />
(awaiting certiorari petition)<br />
- Is it patent eligible<br />
- Can the claims be saved by a reissue<br />
- Does the claim cover a natural phenomenon<br />
- How do you deal with these cases<br />
• The Effects of Myriad on Claims to Isolated and/or Purified<br />
Compositions<br />
- Nucleic acids<br />
- Proteins<br />
- Antibodies<br />
- Cells<br />
• En<strong>for</strong>cing Claims that Involve Multiple Parties –<br />
the McKesson Problem<br />
McKesson Technologies, Inc. v Epic Systems, Corp<br />
• Understanding How Safe Harbor Under 35 USC §271 (e) (1)<br />
Avoids Infringement<br />
To register call +44 (0) 20 7878 6888 or register online at www.<strong>C5</strong>-Online.com/<strong>FTO</strong><br />
©<strong>C5</strong>, 2012
9 th International Forum on<br />
Freedom<br />
to Operate<br />
<strong>New</strong> <strong>Strategies</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Cost</strong>-<strong>Effective</strong>, <strong>High</strong> <strong>Value</strong>, <strong>Low</strong> <strong>Risk</strong> <strong>FTO</strong> Assessments<br />
Latest Legal and Regulatory Developments <strong>for</strong> Successful Opinion Writing<br />
9 – 10 May 2012 • Le Méridien Parkhotel, Frankfurt, Germany<br />
Business In<strong>for</strong>mation<br />
In A Global Context<br />
DELEGATE DETAILS<br />
NAME<br />
POSITION<br />
APPROVING MANAGER<br />
POSITION<br />
ORGANIZATION<br />
ADDRESS<br />
Priority Service Code<br />
511L12.E<br />
FEE PER DELEGATE Register & Pay by 30 March 2012 Register & Pay after 30 March 2012<br />
ELITEPASS*: Conference & Workshop €2098 €2198<br />
Conference Only €1699 €1799<br />
TEAM DISCOUNTS: Booking 3 or more delegates Call +44 (0) 20 7878 6888 <strong>for</strong> details.<br />
*ELITEPASS is recommended <strong>for</strong> maximum learning and networking value.<br />
5 EASY WAYS TO REGISTER<br />
<br />
℡<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />
WEBSITE: www.<strong>C5</strong>-Online.com/<strong>FTO</strong><br />
REGISTRATIONS & ENQUIRIES<br />
+44 20 7878 6888<br />
EMAIL: registrations@<strong>C5</strong>-Online.com<br />
FAX: +44 20 7878 6885<br />
PLEASE RETURN TO<br />
<strong>C5</strong>, Customer Service<br />
6th Floor, Trans-World House, 100 City Road<br />
London EC1Y 2BP, UK<br />
ADMINISTRATIVE DETAILS<br />
Date: 9 – 10 May 2012<br />
Time: 8:30 – 17:20<br />
Venue: Le Méridien Parkhotel Frankfurt<br />
Address: 28-38 Wiesenhuettenplatz, Frankfurt, 60329, Germany<br />
Telephone: +49 (0)69 26970<br />
An allocation of bedrooms is being held <strong>for</strong> delegates at a negotiated rate until<br />
27 March 2012. To book your accommodation please call Venue Search on<br />
tel: +44 (0) 20 8541 5656 or e-mail beds@venuesearch.co.uk. Please note,<br />
lower rates may be available when booking via the internet or direct with the hotel,<br />
but different cancellation policies will apply.<br />
CITY<br />
POSTCODE<br />
PHONE<br />
EMAIL<br />
TYPE OF BUSINESS<br />
FOR MULTIPLE DELEGATE BOOKINGS PLEASE COPY THIS FORM<br />
COUNTRY<br />
FAX<br />
DOCUMENTATION IS PROVIDED BY CD<br />
The documentation provided at the event will be available on CD only.<br />
If you are not able to attend, you can purchase a CD of the presentations provided<br />
to delegates on the day of the event. Please send us this completed booking<br />
<strong>for</strong>m together with payment of €595 per copy requested. For further in<strong>for</strong>mation<br />
please call +44 (0) 207 878 6888 or email enquiries@<strong>C5</strong>-Online.com.<br />
CONTINUING EDUCATION<br />
11.0 hours (conference only) plus 3.0 hours <strong>for</strong> the workshop towards Continuing<br />
Professional Developments hours (Solicitors Regulation Authority). Please contact<br />
<strong>C5</strong> <strong>for</strong> further in<strong>for</strong>mation on claiming your CPD points.<br />
PAYMENT DETAILS<br />
BY CREDIT CARD<br />
Please charge my ○ AMEX ○ VISA ○ MasterCard ○ Discover Card<br />
NUMBER<br />
CARDHOLDER<br />
BY CHEQUE<br />
I have enclosed a cheque <strong>for</strong> € ___________ made payable to <strong>C5</strong><br />
BY BANK TRANSFER<br />
<strong>C5</strong> Communications Limited<br />
Account Name: <strong>C5</strong> Communications Limited<br />
Bank Name: HSBC BANK Plc<br />
Bank Address: 31 Chequer Street, St Albans Herts AL1 3YN, UK<br />
Bank Branch: St Albans Branch<br />
BIC ( Bank Identifier Code ): MIDLGB22<br />
IBAN: GB45 MIDL 4005 1569 7326 66<br />
Sort Code: 40-05-15<br />
Account Currency: EURO<br />
EXP. DATE<br />
If you wish to pay in GBP£ or USD$ please contact Customer Service<br />
Event Code: 511L12-FRA<br />
PAYMENT POLICY<br />
Payment is due in full upon your registration. Full payment must be received prior<br />
to the event otherwise entry will be denied. All discounts will be applied to the Main<br />
Conference Only fee (excluding add-ons), cannot be combined with any other offer,<br />
and must be paid in full at time of order. Group discounts available to individuals<br />
employed by the same organisation.<br />
TERMS AND CONDITIONS<br />
You must notify us by email at least 48 hours in advance if you wish to send<br />
a substitute participant. Delegates may not “share” a pass between multiple<br />
attendees without prior authorization. If you are unable to find a substitute, please<br />
notify <strong>C5</strong> in writing no later than 10 days prior to the conference date and a credit<br />
voucher will be issued to you <strong>for</strong> the full amount paid, redeemable against any<br />
other <strong>C5</strong> conference. If you prefer, you may request a refund of fees paid less a<br />
25% service charge. No credits or refunds will be given <strong>for</strong> cancellations received<br />
after 10 days prior to the conference date. <strong>C5</strong> reserves the right to cancel any<br />
conference <strong>for</strong> any reason and will not be responsible <strong>for</strong> airfare, hotel or any<br />
other costs incurred by attendees. No liability is assumed by <strong>C5</strong> <strong>for</strong> changes in<br />
programme date, content, speakers or venue.<br />
INCORRECT MAILING INFORMATION<br />
If you receive a duplicate mailing of this brochure or would like us to change<br />
any of your details, please email data@<strong>C5</strong>-Online.com or fax the label on<br />
this brochure to +44 (0) 20 7878 6887. To view our privacy policy go to<br />
www.<strong>C5</strong>-Online.com/privacy_policy_statement.