light products - Illuminating Engineering Society
light products - Illuminating Engineering Society
light products - Illuminating Engineering Society
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Lighting Design + Application • December 2005<br />
The<br />
LIGHTING<br />
AUTHORITY ®<br />
MEMPHIS<br />
BELLE<br />
FedEx Forum—<br />
Home of the NBA’s<br />
Grizzlies<br />
Focus On<br />
Sports<br />
Lighting
CONTENTS<br />
December 2005,<br />
VOL. 35/NO. 12<br />
SPORTS LIGHTING<br />
30<br />
San Diego to the Core<br />
Emphasizing regionalism over nostalgia,<br />
Petco Park celebrates San Diego even<br />
more than baseball<br />
52<br />
34<br />
Weekend Warriors<br />
toWorld-Class Athletes<br />
Lighting design at the new University of<br />
Houston Recreation Center<br />
accommodates athletes of all stripes<br />
57<br />
40<br />
FedExcellent<br />
Adventure<br />
The FedExForum might be in the heart<br />
of the Memphis music scene, but with<br />
its instant success, it’s feeling anything<br />
but the blues<br />
FEATURES<br />
46<br />
Trading Up<br />
The Bank of America trading floor<br />
satisfies <strong>light</strong>-sensitive traders while<br />
adding sizzle to the Charlotte, NC,<br />
skyline<br />
52<br />
Sonic Temple Rebirth<br />
Thanks to an updated, camouflaged<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing system, the Borobudur Temple<br />
now has a true night life<br />
CENTURY SERIES<br />
57<br />
Computers and<br />
Lighting<br />
After exponential growth in the 1980s<br />
and ’90s, has development of <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
design software reached a lull<br />
34<br />
30<br />
46<br />
D E P A R T M E N T S<br />
4 Editor’s Note • 6 Letters to the Editor • 8 Regional Voices • 9 Energy<br />
Advisor • 10 Research Matters • 14 Green Ideas • 17 Lighting for<br />
Quality • 18 Lighting for Security • 21 IES News • 25 Industry Updates<br />
• 27 Scanningthe Spectrum • 65 Index of Articles • 72 Literature Review<br />
• 74 Light Products • 78 Classified Advertisements • 79 Calendar of<br />
Events • 80 Ad Index<br />
LD+A (ISSN 0360-6325) is published monthly in the United States of America by the <strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong> of North America, 120 Wall<br />
Street, 17th Floor, New York, NY. 10005, 212-248-5000. © 2005 by the <strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong> of North America. Periodicals postage paid at New<br />
York, N.Y. 10005 and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to LD+A, 120 Wall Street, 17th Floor, New York, NY 10005.<br />
ON THE COVER:<br />
Sports and architectural <strong>light</strong>ing integrate<br />
with façade <strong>light</strong>ing at the FedExForum in<br />
Memphis. Photo by Tim Hursley
EDITOR’S NOTE<br />
Paul Tarricone<br />
THE MOVIE CATCH ME IF<br />
YOU CAN has an instructive scene<br />
about the power of image and “looking<br />
the part.” The character played by<br />
Christopher Walken asks his son,<br />
portrayed by Leonardo DiCaprio,<br />
why he thinks the Yankees always win<br />
the World Series.“Because they have<br />
Mickey Mantle” the son replies.<br />
“No,” the father responds, “it’s<br />
because the other guys can’t take<br />
their eyes off the pinstripes.”<br />
This brings us to the <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
designer who likes to pull up to the<br />
client’s office in a Jaguar convertible,<br />
because he likes the image it creates.<br />
Marketing consulting Lloyd<br />
Princeton used this designer as<br />
Exhibit A of the power of perception<br />
during his presentation at the<br />
5th Annual IALD Education<br />
Conference in Alexandria, VA. His<br />
message: you’re selling a luxury and<br />
you need to convey to clients that<br />
there’s a minimum point of entry—<br />
a minimum bar—for those who<br />
want to do business with you. Overeager<br />
designers stuck with flat fees<br />
often forget that “clients are not<br />
‘entitled’ [to high-end design services],”<br />
said Princeton.There’s a premium<br />
to be paid for good design.<br />
How do you build your brand<br />
Princeton advised designers to<br />
focus on the “who” and the “what.”<br />
Identify who (in terms of the market<br />
niche) you want to do business<br />
with and sub-identify that group’s<br />
demographics.“If it’s residential end<br />
users, how old are they Is this a<br />
second or third home for them Do<br />
they have children If it’s a corporate<br />
client, is it a facility manager or<br />
real estate person” Part of identifying<br />
the “who” is understanding their<br />
tendencies. “Corporate and hospitality<br />
are more bottom-line oriented.<br />
With residential you can maximize<br />
profits because the client is<br />
more emotionally invested,” he said.<br />
Another piece of advice from<br />
Princeton seems counter-intuitive:<br />
Don’t be a generalist. (Almost without<br />
exception, the “About the<br />
Designer” bios that accompany case<br />
history articles in LD+A list experience<br />
in “retail, corporate, institutional,<br />
residential” and so on and so<br />
forth.) However, Princeton claims<br />
the trend today in interior design is<br />
toward specialization. What’s more,<br />
being all things to all people forces<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing designers to work “on projects<br />
they don’t like.”<br />
Once the “who” is identified,<br />
move on to the “what.” Tried-andtrue<br />
marketing tools include public<br />
relations (positioning yourself as an<br />
expert to the press); advertising (in<br />
local media and in publications like<br />
the American Express magazine);<br />
one-on-one lunch-and-learns; press<br />
kits; web sites; and a Princeton<br />
favorite, direct mail. Once again<br />
emphasizing his preference for specialization,<br />
he advocates separate<br />
pieces (ideally) for each market you<br />
want to hit,mailed six to eight times<br />
per year. But if given the choice of a<br />
divide-and-conquer approach in<br />
‘Go to the end<br />
user and say the<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing designer—<br />
not the interior<br />
designer or the<br />
architect—should<br />
be the first<br />
person you hire’<br />
which you send two pieces to three<br />
markets vs. targeting just one market,<br />
Princeton chooses the latter.<br />
Finally, if they “really want to<br />
shake things up,” Princeton says<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing designers may want to position<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing as “big and fundamental...Go<br />
to the end user and say the<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing designer—not the interior<br />
designer or the architect—should<br />
be the first person you hire.”<br />
If all this seems a bit overwhelming<br />
to designers who are “too busy<br />
to worry about marketing” or have<br />
limited resources, remember the<br />
first rule of Marketing 101: clients<br />
are not willing to pay for something<br />
they don’t understand.<br />
Publisher<br />
William Hanley, CAE<br />
Editor<br />
Paul Tarricone<br />
Associate Editor<br />
John-Michael Kobes<br />
Assistant Editor<br />
Roslyn Lowe<br />
Art Director<br />
Samuel Fontanez<br />
Associate Art Director<br />
Petra Domingo<br />
Columnists<br />
Ted Ake • Emlyn G.Altman<br />
Denise Fong • Brian Liebel<br />
Doug Paulin • Paul Pompeo<br />
Willard Warren<br />
Book Review Editor<br />
Paulette Hebert, Ph.D.<br />
Marketing Manager<br />
Sue Foley<br />
Advertising Coordinator<br />
Leslie Prestia<br />
Published by IESNA<br />
120 Wall Street, 17th Floor<br />
New York, NY 10005-4001<br />
Phone: 212-248-5000<br />
Fax: 212-248-5017/18<br />
Website: www.iesna.org<br />
Email: iesna@iesna.org<br />
LD+A is a magazine for professionals involved in the art,<br />
science, study, manufacture, teaching, and implementation<br />
of <strong>light</strong>ing. LD+A is designed to enhance and improve the<br />
practice of <strong>light</strong>ing. Every issue of LD+A includes feature<br />
articles on design projects, technical articles on the science<br />
of illumination, new product developments, industry<br />
trends, news of the <strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong> of<br />
North America, and vital information about the illuminating<br />
profession.<br />
Statements and opinions expressed in articles and editorials<br />
in LD+A are the expressions of contributors and do<br />
not necessarily represent the policies or opinions of the<br />
<strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong> of North America.<br />
Advertisements appearing in this publication are the sole<br />
responsibility of the advertiser.<br />
LD+A (ISSN 0360-6325) is published monthly in the<br />
United States of America by the <strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong><br />
<strong>Society</strong> of North America, 120 Wall Street, 17th Floor,<br />
New York, NY 10005, 212-248-5000. Copyright 2005 by<br />
the <strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong> of North<br />
America. Periodicals postage paid at New York, NY<br />
10005 and additional mailing offices. Nonmember subscriptions<br />
$44.00 per year.Additional $15.00 postage for<br />
subscriptions outside the United States. Member subscriptions<br />
$32.00 (not deductible from annual dues).<br />
Additional subscriptions $44.00. Single copies $4.00,<br />
except Lighting Equipment & Accessories Directory and<br />
Progress Report issues $10.00. Authorization to reproduce<br />
articles for internal or personal use by specific<br />
clients is granted by IESNA to libraries and other users<br />
registered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC)<br />
Transactional Reporting Service, provided a fee of $2.00<br />
per copy is paid directly to CCC, 21 Congress Street,<br />
Salem, MA 01970. IESNA fee code: 0360-6325/86 $2.00.<br />
This consent does not extend to other kinds of copying<br />
for purposes such as general distribution, advertising or<br />
promotion, creating new collective works, or resale.<br />
POSTMASTER: Send address changes to LD+A, 120<br />
Wall Street, 17th Floor, New York, NY 10005. Subscribers:<br />
For continuous service please notify LD+A of address<br />
changes at least 6 weeks in advance.<br />
This publication is indexed regularly by <strong>Engineering</strong><br />
Index, Inc. and Applied Science & Technology Index.<br />
LD+A is available on microfilm from Proquest Information<br />
and Learning, 800-521-0600,Ann Arbor, MI.<br />
4 www.iesna.org
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR<br />
Run That Design<br />
by Maintenance<br />
Folks, First<br />
Reading “Over &<br />
Out” (LD+A, October)<br />
confirmed my experience<br />
that very few <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
designers check with<br />
maintenance and facility<br />
people two-to-four years<br />
after their buildings have<br />
been built. If more <strong>light</strong>ing designers asked maintenance and facility people<br />
what they think of the number of lamp types, lamp life, lamp costs,<br />
accessibility inside fixtures, and ease of maintaining <strong>light</strong>ing control systems,<br />
I think that many <strong>light</strong>ing designers would change how they do<br />
design. A good chunk of my retrofit business is from end users in buildings<br />
that have good quality and energy-efficient <strong>light</strong>ing, but the maintenance<br />
costs are very high. I appreciate the business, but would prefer if<br />
more <strong>light</strong>ing designers would walk a mile in the shoes of maintenance<br />
and facility people in the first place.<br />
Stan Walerczyk<br />
Lighting Wizards<br />
Walnut Creek, CA<br />
Membership Still Has Its Advantages<br />
It’s hard for me to believe that I got started in <strong>light</strong>ing in October of<br />
1949 and in 2005 I’m still active at the age of 77 and going strong.<br />
Lighting has come a long way in the 55-plus years that I’ve been in the<br />
business.So has the IESNA.When I first started BBS/A.L.P.in 1955,I couldn’t<br />
afford to join anything. As soon as I started making a few dollars, I<br />
joined the IESNA in 1961 and I have been an involved and committed<br />
member ever since.<br />
Each year there are older members, like myself, fading away and new<br />
members who are becoming involved, who will become the future leaders<br />
of IESNA. This Centennial year is a significant one for our organization.<br />
My advice to anyone in the <strong>light</strong>ing business is that if you’re not involved<br />
with the IESNA, then you’re truly not involved or committed to our industry.<br />
You get out of anything what you put into it, and I, for one, sure feel<br />
that I’ve gotten more out than I ever put in, no matter how much effort<br />
that I made.Thanks for listening.<br />
WM Brown<br />
Bill Brown Sales/A.L.P. Lighting Components<br />
Niles, IL<br />
oe-mail a letter<br />
to the editor:<br />
ptarricone@iesna.org<br />
PRESIDENT<br />
Alan L. Lewis, O.D., Ph.D., FIES<br />
The New England College of Optometry<br />
PAST PRESIDENT<br />
Craig A. Bernecker, Ph.D., FIES, LC<br />
The Lighting Education Institute<br />
SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT<br />
(President-Elect)<br />
Kevin Flynn<br />
Kiku Obata & Company<br />
VP-EDUCATIONAL<br />
ACTIVITIES<br />
Ronald Gibbons, Ph.D.<br />
Virginia Tech Transportation Institute<br />
VP-TECHNICAL & RESEARCH<br />
Pekka Hakkarainen<br />
Lutron Electronics Co. Inc.<br />
VP-DESIGN & APPLICATION<br />
Joseph B. Murdoch, Ph.D., PE, FIES, LC<br />
University of New Hampshire (retired)<br />
VP-MEMBER ACTIVITIES<br />
Kimberly Szinger, PE<br />
Stantec Consulting<br />
TREASURER<br />
Boyd Corbett<br />
S2C Incorporated<br />
EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT<br />
William Hanley<br />
IESNA<br />
DIRECTORS<br />
David A. Baum<br />
Holophane<br />
James Cyre<br />
Philips Lighting<br />
Terrance Kilbourne, LC<br />
TEC, Inc.<br />
Denis Lavoie, LC<br />
LUMEC, Inc.<br />
Paul Mercier, LC<br />
Lighting Design Innovations, Ltd.<br />
Russ Owens, LC<br />
West Coast Design Group<br />
RVP/DIRECTORS<br />
Craig Kohring<br />
mda engineering, inc.<br />
Thomas Tolen, LC<br />
TMT Associates<br />
2005-2006<br />
Board of Directors<br />
IESNA<br />
6 www.iesna.org
REGIONAL VOICES<br />
Craig R. Kohring,<br />
Great Lakes RVP<br />
AS YOU READ THIS ARTICLE,<br />
you are probably juggling several different<br />
balls in the air, hoping that you<br />
do not drop any of them. You are<br />
probably dealing with project deadlines<br />
at work,holiday planning,a myriad<br />
of office and family functions that<br />
take place at this time of year, and so<br />
forth and so on. This time of year<br />
always seems to have the same<br />
theme for everyone. It is a hectic<br />
time,as well as a time for sharing and<br />
giving. The question I pose to you<br />
today is,“How is this really different<br />
from any other time of the year”<br />
I ask this question for selfish reasons.<br />
In the not so distant past, at a<br />
Great Lakes Regional Executive<br />
Committee (REC) meeting, I was<br />
asked about improving attendance<br />
at our meetings.Those of you in the<br />
Great Lakes region know that our<br />
meetings are held at a central point<br />
in our region (Cleveland, OH). The<br />
longest drive for any section meeting<br />
is about four hours, and our<br />
actual business meeting lasts about<br />
four hours. It is a long day for most,<br />
but usually an en<strong>light</strong>ening experience.<br />
On the drive home, I began to<br />
ponder the reasons for poor attendance<br />
at regional events. There are<br />
always project deadlines, family and<br />
social commitments, etc. Sounds<br />
similar to the holidays, doesn’t it<br />
What is missing is the sharing and<br />
giving.<br />
Giving and Sharing<br />
For those of you who have not<br />
attended a regional event, I hope to<br />
offer some insight. For those who<br />
attend on a regular basis, feel free to<br />
take this time to catch up on those<br />
project deadlines.<br />
The IESNA Section Guide states<br />
(and I paraphrase) that the section<br />
president, vice president and secretary<br />
are members of the REC, and<br />
shall attend REC meetings. If one of<br />
these officers is not available, a<br />
There is a wealth of knowledge in<br />
our <strong>Society</strong>, and most of it resides at<br />
our section level<br />
member of the Board of Managers<br />
should attend in his or her place.<br />
Using that standard, my region<br />
should have an attendance of 36 at<br />
our REC. Instead, we average a little<br />
less than half of that number.<br />
The purpose of an REC meeting<br />
is to share information and<br />
exchange ideas to make our sections<br />
stronger. At our REC meeting,<br />
we try to devote about an hour for<br />
sections to discuss topics such as<br />
initiatives, goals, good and bad meetings,<br />
and membership. This portion<br />
of the meeting is usually the most<br />
interesting, and can really generate<br />
excitement and enthusiasm in our<br />
section officers.There is a wealth of<br />
knowledge in our <strong>Society</strong>, and most<br />
of it resides at the section level.<br />
Greater attendance encourages<br />
added participation, more ideas, and<br />
shared knowledge and expertise.<br />
The REC meeting provides other<br />
valuable information, as well. Our<br />
REC meeting typically includes time<br />
dedicated to section level reporting<br />
requirements, and contact information,<br />
as well as <strong>Society</strong> level news<br />
and events. In fact, at our last REC,<br />
one of our new participants said<br />
that she had learned more in the<br />
first 40 minutes of the meeting, than<br />
she had in her years of service on<br />
her section’s Board of Managers.<br />
So, I hope that I have provoked<br />
some thought about attending your<br />
REC meeting. We, as regional vice<br />
presidents, know that your time is<br />
valuable, and family is more important<br />
than IESNA (did I say that).All<br />
we ask is that you try to include<br />
time in your hectic schedule for<br />
sharing and giving to your region. It<br />
is only with your help and participation<br />
that we can make our sections<br />
and regions as strong as possible.<br />
8 www.iesna.org
ENERGY ADVISOR<br />
Willard L.Warren,<br />
PE, LC, FIESNA<br />
WALT KELLY, CREATOR OF<br />
the POGO cartoon strip coined the<br />
phrase,“I have met the enemy and it<br />
is us.” Well,“I have seen the future of<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing and it’s located in California.”<br />
The state was devastated by the<br />
manipulation of the delivery of electric<br />
power by greedy suppliers six<br />
years ago and now has bounced back<br />
with a vengeance.A new version of its<br />
energy code, Title 24-2005, enacted<br />
on October 1, is sensible and workable,<br />
because of input from Jim Benya,<br />
PE of Benya Lighting, a code expert<br />
and <strong>light</strong>ing designer, and from Lisa<br />
Heschong and Doug Mahone of the<br />
Heschong Mahone Group, who<br />
advised the state on the importance<br />
of day<strong>light</strong> harvesting.<br />
To further aid the state in promoting<br />
energy-efficient <strong>light</strong>ing with<br />
a market-friendly design and to disseminate<br />
useful information about<br />
Title 24-2005, the California<br />
Lighting Technology Center (CLTC)<br />
was created last year at the<br />
University of California, Davis. The<br />
CLTC director is Michael J.<br />
Sominovitch, PhD, the associate<br />
director is Kosta Papamichael, PhD,<br />
both previously with the Lighting<br />
Research Center at Lawrence<br />
Berkeley National Labs. California<br />
Energy Commissioner (CEC) Art<br />
Rosenfeld indicated that the center<br />
was created because the CEC and<br />
other industry stakeholders recognized<br />
the importance that <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
holds in cutting down on energy<br />
use. “By partnering with the commission,<br />
the <strong>light</strong>ing industry and<br />
with public utilities, the CLTC<br />
ensures a hands-on practical<br />
approach to the creation of energyefficient<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing that is also appealing<br />
to consumers,” Rosenfeld said.<br />
“The center holds great promise in<br />
sharply reducing the power consumed<br />
by <strong>light</strong>ing during crunch<br />
electricity periods.” The CLTC<br />
coordinates outreach and support<br />
efforts with existing utility-based<br />
energy centers, offering touring<br />
exhibits, demonstration materials<br />
and technical assistance in the<br />
adoption of emerging technologies.<br />
Already, over two dozen <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
companies and utilities are partnering<br />
with the CLTC to develop new<br />
and efficient <strong>light</strong>ing <strong>products</strong> for<br />
commercial use. For more information,<br />
visit the CLTC web site at<br />
http:cltc.ucdavis.edu, or contact Dr.<br />
Siminovitch at (530) 757-3444, or at<br />
mjsiminovitch@ucdavis.edu.<br />
To put things into perspective,<br />
California’s peak demand over the last<br />
40 years has increased an average of<br />
2.2 percent, almost 50 percent above<br />
the national average. But because of<br />
its population growth and Title 24<br />
codes, the total per capita electric use<br />
is only 7000 kW per hour per year<br />
which is 40 percent less than the<br />
national average. Lighting accounts for<br />
about 20 percent of electric energy<br />
use in the U.S.,exceeded only by heating<br />
and cooling which draws about 35<br />
I have seen the<br />
future of <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
and it’s located in<br />
California<br />
percent. The average energy consumption<br />
for indoor <strong>light</strong>ing in large<br />
commercial office buildings has steadily<br />
dropped one percent per year since<br />
1975. Thirty years ago we averaged<br />
four watts per sq ft for <strong>light</strong>ing in large<br />
commercial office buildings and<br />
ranged between peaks of 10 to 15<br />
watts per sq ft for retail <strong>light</strong>ing.<br />
Today’s energy codes, like Title 24,<br />
limit office <strong>light</strong>ing to 1.2 watts per sq<br />
ft and retail <strong>light</strong>ing from 4.5 to 6.0<br />
watts per sq ft, depending on the type<br />
of merchandise displayed.<br />
California Here I Come<br />
The goal in enacting Title 24-2005<br />
and California’s new conservation initiative<br />
is to reduce those totals<br />
another 20 percent, as painlessly as<br />
possible. Remember, in the last 15<br />
years the costs of CFLs, electronic<br />
ballasts and T-8 lamps have decreased<br />
over 50 percent while efficacy<br />
(lumens per watt) and life expectancy<br />
have increased. We’ve seen similar<br />
improvements in energy conservation<br />
and cost reduction in residential<br />
refrigerators and air conditioning.The<br />
first priority in business is to survive.<br />
You can’t perform, or learn, or sell<br />
merchandise if you can’t see well, so<br />
energy consumption reductions have<br />
to be practical.<br />
California’s Public Utilities Commission<br />
(PUC) intends to recapture<br />
enough energy by conservation in the<br />
next three years to meet its needs for<br />
power generation for the next decade,<br />
by allocating $2 billion (with a “b”) for<br />
energy efficiency.That’s more than the<br />
Federal DOE budgeted, but not yet<br />
appropriated, in the new, so-called,<br />
“Energy Act of 2005.” Part of<br />
California’s program, called Integrated<br />
Resource Planning (IRP) earmarked<br />
$200 million of the $2 billion for new<br />
technology.The objective is to save $3<br />
billion overall in energy costs for<br />
homes and businesses by 2008, a 150<br />
percent return on investment.<br />
Lighting comprises almost 30 percent<br />
of commercial and 18 percent<br />
of residential usage during peak<br />
demand periods; part of the IRP program<br />
is a guide book published by<br />
the CLTC to help homebuilders<br />
learn about new <strong>light</strong>ing technologies<br />
and the state’s new residential<br />
energy code and compliant designs.<br />
Contact cltc.ucdavis.edu for a copy.<br />
Susan P. Kennedy, a commissioner<br />
of the California Public Utility<br />
Commission (PUC), in launching this<br />
comprehensive “Green Building” initiative,<br />
stated,“In plain English, before<br />
our electric utilities spend a dollar to<br />
buy power in the market or build a<br />
new generating plant, they will first<br />
invest in ways to help us use energy<br />
more efficiently.”<br />
Last month I reported on how<br />
New York is amending its energy conservation<br />
code, and this month we’ve<br />
described California’s initiatives. If you<br />
are aware of anything going on in the<br />
middle of the country please let me<br />
know. Somebody must have noticed<br />
that fuel oil and gasoline have doubled<br />
in price, while natural gas has more<br />
than tripled in just the last three<br />
years.Are any other states promoting<br />
energy efficiency Please write me<br />
here at LD+A.<br />
Willard L. Warren, PE, LC, FIESNA, is<br />
the principal of Willard L. Warren<br />
Associates, a consulting firm serving<br />
industry, government and utility clients in<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing and energy conservation.<br />
December 2005 LD+A 9
RESEARCH MATTERS<br />
Attending to Attention<br />
Yukio Akashi, Ph.D.<br />
Lighting Research<br />
Center, Rensselaer<br />
Polytechnic<br />
Institutete<br />
CAN GOOD LIGHTING HELP<br />
to reduce the number of traffic crashes<br />
A survey conducted in the U.S.<br />
reported that approximately 50 percent<br />
of crashes were related to drivers’<br />
improper attention (Treat et al.,<br />
1979).We are fortunate that research<br />
on attention flourished over the past<br />
three decades (Johnson and Proctor,<br />
2004). Findings from these studies<br />
may bridge the gap between <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
research and traffic safety.<br />
What Makes A Driver<br />
Inattentive<br />
Driving is a demanding, multitasking<br />
activity.A driver has to maintain a<br />
vehicle within a traffic lane while<br />
keeping its speed below (or at least<br />
not too far above) the limit, while following<br />
other vehicles (referred to as<br />
a “tracking task” in this column).<br />
Occasionally, a driver has to pass<br />
other vehicles and change lanes (a<br />
“changing task”).Talking on a cellular<br />
phone is an additional, but unrelated,<br />
task that increases the driver’s task<br />
load (a “distracting task”).<br />
On less frequent but more critical<br />
occasions, the driver must quickly<br />
detect oncoming traffic and obstacles<br />
such as torn tires on the pavement or<br />
deer on the shoulder, to avoid collisions<br />
with these potential hazards (a<br />
“detecting task”).<br />
As task load increases, a driver,<br />
who is already busy driving and talking<br />
on a cellular phone, can become<br />
distracted from such detection tasks.<br />
Inattention often originates from high<br />
task loads, and often results in missing<br />
targets and prolonged reaction times<br />
(Verwey, 1993), and even increased<br />
crash rates (Harms, 1986).<br />
How Does Task Load<br />
Affect Performance<br />
For each task described above, a<br />
driver must deal with a sequence of<br />
three distinctive information-processing<br />
stages: perceptional analysis (stimulus<br />
identification); response selection<br />
(decision-making);and motor response<br />
(response execution) (Pashler, 1998;<br />
Johnson and Proctor, 2004).<br />
As Figure 1 illustrates, these<br />
stages are often assumed to occur<br />
sequentially, so the results of one<br />
stage form the input to the next<br />
stage. Of these, response selection<br />
(decision-making) is the most<br />
demanding stage for the brain. This<br />
stage limits allocation of attention<br />
resources that can be shared with the<br />
other tasks, and it often appears to<br />
act as a bottleneck (Welford, 1952).<br />
To explore the mechanisms of<br />
dual-task performance, scientists use<br />
a sophisticated experimental technique.<br />
This technique has a subject<br />
respond to two individual stimuli, in<br />
which the time between the first and<br />
second stimulus varies in order to<br />
change task load.This method helped<br />
scientists conclude that the time it<br />
takes to respond to the second stimulus<br />
generally becomes longer (due<br />
to the period of slack in Figure 1)<br />
than when the second stimulus is presented<br />
alone or the task becomes<br />
more demanding (Vince, 1949).This is<br />
because the decision-making stage of<br />
the second stimulus cannot begin<br />
until the corresponding stage of the<br />
first stimulus has been completed<br />
(Pashler, 1998). However, scientists<br />
have also noted that the decisionmaking<br />
stage of the first stimulus can<br />
share attention resources with that of<br />
the second stimulus when both tasks<br />
are very difficult (Navon and Miller,<br />
2002). In these cases, a kind of interference<br />
occurs,and the decision-making<br />
of the first stimulus is often<br />
slowed down as well.<br />
How Can Good Lighting<br />
Improve Driving<br />
Performance<br />
The information processing framework<br />
described above allows us to<br />
understand the effect of good <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
F I G U R E 1<br />
Information processing framework (after Johnson and Proctor, 2004).<br />
on driving performance. To this end,<br />
this column reviews recent studies in<br />
which subjects performed detection<br />
tests (Task 2 in Figure 1) while<br />
engaged in simulated tracking and real<br />
driving tasks (Task 1). These studies<br />
compared performance under metal<br />
halide (MH) and high-pressure sodium<br />
(HPS) <strong>light</strong>ing at mesopic levels.<br />
To investigate the mechanisms of<br />
interference of <strong>light</strong>ing conditions<br />
with task load and performance, a<br />
study simulated a typical driving situation<br />
by combining three tasks: a<br />
tracking task, a distracting task and a<br />
detecting task (Akashi and Neches,<br />
2003). The tracking task required a<br />
subject to keep a needle in the center<br />
between a pair of thin horizontal lines<br />
by rotating a control knob. For the<br />
distracting task, the subject attempted<br />
to complete verbal mathematical<br />
(multiplication) problems as quickly<br />
as possible. The detecting task<br />
required subjects to signal immediately<br />
upon detecting one of eight target<br />
presentations.This study changed<br />
task load by changing combinations of<br />
the tracking and distracting tasks.<br />
Figure 2 depicts the results of<br />
these tests, which generally suggest<br />
the following: as task load increases,<br />
reaction time is increased; and target<br />
detection under MH was better than<br />
under HPS. These tendencies were<br />
confirmed by statistical analysis.<br />
Regarding interference, the tracking<br />
task appears to just add the same<br />
period of time to the baseline reaction<br />
times (in the detection-taskalone<br />
conditions) for both MH and<br />
HPS <strong>light</strong>ing. This suggests that the<br />
tracking task interferes little with the<br />
10 www.iesna.org
effect of <strong>light</strong>ing, because this tracking<br />
task relied on central vision. Also,<br />
practiced automatic operations (like<br />
this tracking task) do not demand a<br />
lot of attention, so they can be performed<br />
without experiencing interference<br />
from, or generating interference<br />
with, other ongoing information<br />
processes (Pashler, 1998).<br />
In contrast, math problems appear<br />
to have interfered with <strong>light</strong>ing conditions.<br />
Differences in reaction times<br />
between MH and HPS conditions<br />
became the largest (over 50 ms for<br />
most off-axis targets) when both<br />
tracking and distracting tasks were<br />
performed at the same time (i.e., the<br />
highest task load). Since combining all<br />
three tasks increased task load, their<br />
response selection stages likely shared<br />
attention resources and therefore<br />
interference occurred. In this experiment,<br />
the math performance was<br />
s<strong>light</strong>ly improved by using MH <strong>light</strong>ing,<br />
but it was not yet significant.<br />
A similar and even larger enhanced<br />
effect of spectral power distributions<br />
(SPDs) on detection performance<br />
F I G U R E 2<br />
Reaction time for metal halide and high-pressure <strong>light</strong>ing conditions<br />
(TT = tracking task; MP = math problem).<br />
appeared in another study using a<br />
more realistic, high-demand computer-simulated<br />
driving task. This study<br />
had subjects detect peripheral targets<br />
(detecting task) while virtually driving<br />
along a roadway projected on a large<br />
screen (tracking task) (Bullough and<br />
Rea, 2000). In this study, subjects<br />
missed targets 25 percent more frequently<br />
under HPS <strong>light</strong>ing than<br />
under MH <strong>light</strong>ing.<br />
Can results of such laboratory<br />
studies apply to real driving situations<br />
To answer this question, a field study<br />
(Akashi and Rea, 2002) had subjects<br />
detect targets located 15 deg and 23<br />
deg off-axis (detecting task) while<br />
driving along a short, closed track and<br />
Effective <strong>light</strong>ing may reduce task load<br />
and therefore allow people to allocate<br />
more attention to target detection<br />
fixating on and reading aloud single<br />
digit numbers sequentially presented<br />
in the central visual field (tracking<br />
task).Reaction time was measured for<br />
each target presentation.<br />
The results suggested that average<br />
reaction time was around 720 ms for<br />
actual driving, compared to 250 ms for<br />
a single detection task in which subjects<br />
responded to a 15 deg off-axis<br />
target with the same luminance contrast<br />
in a laboratory (He et al.,1997).In<br />
the same study, when the car was static,<br />
average reaction time was around<br />
670 ms.The use of MH lamps reduced<br />
reaction times by approximately 50 ms.<br />
This experiment did not control<br />
onsets of stimuli in the first and second<br />
tasks;thus,it does not allow for exploring<br />
detailed mechanisms of interaction<br />
between the two tasks. However, the<br />
results suggest interference between<br />
tasks and <strong>light</strong>ing conditions. This<br />
experiment used a target luminance of<br />
0.3 (cd per sq m), a level at which the<br />
difference in reaction time between<br />
under the MH and HPS lamps should<br />
be very small, according to He et al.’s<br />
experiment (1997). However, it did<br />
show a 50-ms improvement in reaction<br />
time due to the use of MH <strong>light</strong>ing with<br />
a statistical significance. In this case,<br />
since both tracking and detecting tasks<br />
are visual tasks, the use of effective<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing can improve visibility for the<br />
tracking task and target conspicuity for<br />
the detecting task.The use of effective<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing delivers a twofold benefit to<br />
the detecting task: a shorter response<br />
selection time of the detection task<br />
itself, and a shorter slack time due to<br />
the shortened response selection time<br />
of the tracking task. This results in a<br />
much shorter reaction time than<br />
expected.<br />
This discussion leads to a conclusion<br />
that effective <strong>light</strong>ing may reduce<br />
task load and therefore allow people<br />
to allocate more attention to target<br />
detection. In a dual-task paradigm,<br />
when both tasks are visual or very<br />
difficult, task-<strong>light</strong>ing interference<br />
appears to enhance the effectiveness<br />
of <strong>light</strong>ing’s impact on performance.<br />
What Is Next<br />
We need more research to verify<br />
the validity of such enhanced effects<br />
of <strong>light</strong>ing. First, fine tuning experiments<br />
using the above mentioned<br />
dual-task technique could help us to<br />
better understand task-attention<strong>light</strong>ing<br />
interference. This will determine<br />
how much each task type (e.g.,<br />
changing lanes and using cellular<br />
phones) impairs detection performance<br />
and how much each <strong>light</strong>ing factor<br />
can regain the impaired performance.<br />
Second, to implement such<br />
December 2005 LD+A 11
RESEARCH MATTERS<br />
research results to roadway and automobile<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing practice, it is necessary<br />
to quantify a driver’s task load under<br />
different roadway characteristics (e.g.,<br />
highways, interchanges, or curves) by<br />
using a standard detecting task such<br />
as one used by MacDonald and Ellis<br />
(1975).Finally,it is important to determine<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing requirements for each of<br />
the roadway characteristics while taking<br />
into account the influence of task<br />
load on detection performance. The<br />
evidence so far indicates that such<br />
understanding would help us to make<br />
our roadways safer.<br />
References<br />
Akashi Y, Rea MS, 2002. Peripheral<br />
detection while driving under a<br />
mesopic <strong>light</strong> level, Journal of the<br />
<strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong>, 31, 1,<br />
85-94<br />
Akashi Y, Neches J, 2003.The effect<br />
of foveal task load on peripheral target<br />
detection, Proceedings of CIE 25th<br />
Session in San Diego, D4, 44-47<br />
Bullough J, Rea MS, 2000. Simulated<br />
driving performance and peripheral<br />
detection at mesopic <strong>light</strong> levels,Lighting<br />
Research and Technology, 32, 4, 194-198<br />
He Y, Rea MS, Bierman A, Bullough<br />
J, 1997. Evaluating <strong>light</strong> source efficacy<br />
under mesopic conditions using reaction<br />
times, Journal of the <strong>Illuminating</strong><br />
<strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong>, 26, 1, 125-138<br />
Harms L, 1986. Drivers’ attentional<br />
responses to environmental variation:<br />
a dual-task real traffic study, In Gale<br />
AG et al.Vision in Vehicles II,Amsterdam:<br />
Elsevier Science Publishers, 131-138<br />
Johnson A, Proctor RW, 2004.<br />
Attention:Theory and Practice,Thousand<br />
Oaks,CA:Sage Publications,Inc.,30-37<br />
MacDonald, Ellis, 1975. Driver<br />
workload for various turn radii and<br />
speeds, Proceedings of the annual<br />
Meeting of the Transportation Research<br />
Board,Washington, D.C.<br />
Navon D,Miller J,2002.Queuing or<br />
sharing A critical evaluation of the<br />
single-bottleneck notion. Cognitive<br />
Psychology, 44, 193-251<br />
Pashler HE, 1998. The psychology of<br />
attention, Cambridge, MA: MIT press<br />
Teichner WH, Krebs MJ, 1972.<br />
Laws of the simple visual reaction<br />
time, Psychological Review, 79, 344-358<br />
Treat JR,Tumbas NS, McDonald ST,<br />
Shinar D, Hume RD, Mayer RE,<br />
Stansifer RL, and Castellan NJ, 1977.<br />
Tri-level study of the causes of traffic<br />
accidents, Report No. DOT-HS034-3-<br />
535-77.<br />
Verwey WB, 1993. How can we<br />
prevent overload of the driver<br />
Oarkes AM, Franzen S, Driving future<br />
vehicles,London:Taylor & Francis,235-<br />
244.<br />
Vince M, 1949. Rapid response<br />
sequences and the psychological<br />
refractory period, British Journal of<br />
Psychology, 40, 23-40<br />
Welford AT, 1952. The psychological<br />
refractory period and the timing<br />
of high speed performance-A review<br />
and a theory. British Journal of<br />
Psychology, 43, 2-19<br />
RP-1<br />
1/2 horiz<br />
12 www.iesna.org
GREEN IDEAS<br />
Making the Case for Metrics<br />
Nick Ferzacca<br />
MANY OF US SELECT FOOD<br />
based on information from a nutrition<br />
label. Whether done out of<br />
necessity to avoid allergies, to adhere<br />
to the latest diet fad or just for the<br />
nutritional benefit, we expect this<br />
information to be unbiased and accurate.The<br />
fact that this information is<br />
highly regulated by the Food and<br />
Drug Administration demonstrates<br />
the power these labels have in swaying<br />
buying decisions.We may take this<br />
for granted today, but there is a long<br />
and continually evolving history to<br />
food labels.<br />
To a certain extent, <strong>light</strong>ing specifiers<br />
are at the beginning stages of a<br />
movement not unlike the one which<br />
led to standardized food labels. With<br />
the popularity of LEED and other<br />
market transformation programs,<br />
building design is flush with the vocabulary<br />
of sustainability. Measures such<br />
volatile organic compounds (VOC),<br />
mercury content of lamps and recycled<br />
content are published as metrics<br />
of environmental performance. In<br />
truth, we are really just beginning to<br />
learn about the full environmental<br />
impact a product may have.<br />
In the <strong>light</strong>ing industry, it is easy to<br />
see how complicated the issue is. For<br />
instance, mercury used in fluorescent<br />
lamps is recognized as an environmentally<br />
harmful substance to be<br />
reduced in the name of sustainability.<br />
Reducing mercury beyond a certain<br />
level, however, significantly reduces<br />
the efficacy of fluorescent lamps<br />
resulting in higher, or at least different,<br />
environmental burdens beyond<br />
the mercury saved. Furthermore,<br />
mercury is one small element of one<br />
component in a <strong>light</strong>ing system.What<br />
are the impacts of producing fixture<br />
housings, reflectors, lenses and packaging<br />
Is a low iridescent specular<br />
coating more environmentally harmful<br />
than a simple diffuse white coating,<br />
and if so, how do we measure this<br />
Developing environmental performance<br />
metrics for <strong>light</strong>ing equipment<br />
is no small task.<br />
Understanding the full environmental<br />
impact is easiest through a process<br />
called life cycle assessment or LCA<br />
(see sidebar). Consider some of the<br />
initiatives related to the question of<br />
environmental performance and the<br />
LCA, as they pertain to <strong>products</strong>.<br />
ISO 14000<br />
The International Standards<br />
Organization (ISO) 14000 series<br />
standards provide a framework for<br />
managing environmental systems.<br />
Within the 14000 series are the<br />
14021, 14024 and 14025 standards,<br />
which define different types of environmental<br />
labels as follows:<br />
• Type I Label (14024). Multiattribute<br />
labels developed by a<br />
third party. Examples of these are<br />
“Certified Wood” or “Eco-<br />
Friendly.”<br />
• Type II Label (14021). Singleattribute<br />
labels developed by the<br />
producer. Examples of these are<br />
claims of “75 percent recycled content.”<br />
• Type III Label (14025). Labels<br />
providing quantitative information<br />
from LCA.<br />
In themselves, these ISO definitions<br />
do not indicate what the labels<br />
should be, but merely provide standard<br />
definitions. They are significant<br />
because they represent the results of<br />
international consensus among governments,<br />
industry and other stakeholders.These<br />
definitions are already<br />
being used to specify various types of<br />
information. For instance, the draft<br />
version of LEED 2.2 requires that the<br />
recycled content must be defined in<br />
accordance with the ISO Type II labeling<br />
standard. Furthermore, there is a<br />
significant interest to push manufacturers<br />
for LCA-based information on<br />
environmental performance, and ISO<br />
Type III labels are often cited as the<br />
desired format.<br />
Environmental Product<br />
Declarations<br />
In 1999, the Swedish Environmental<br />
Management Council developed<br />
a standard for producing quantifiable<br />
and verifiable LCA-based environmental<br />
performance information<br />
for <strong>products</strong>, called the Environmental<br />
Product Declaration (EPD), see<br />
www.environdec.com. The EPD is a<br />
framework available to manufacturers<br />
for application to <strong>products</strong> and services<br />
allowing one-for-one comparisons<br />
against environmental impacts.<br />
Products following the EPD program<br />
can be published on the EPD website,<br />
and EPDs are downloadable to anyone.<br />
The EPD is not designed exclusively<br />
around building <strong>products</strong>; many<br />
consumer <strong>products</strong> are also provided.<br />
Figure 1 reveals an excerpt of an<br />
EPD for a 10kV fused switch with fan<br />
cooling.<br />
F I G U R E 1<br />
14 www.iesna.org
What is Life Cycle Assessment<br />
LCA is a systematic process of analyzing the environmental impacts of a<br />
product, system or service, throughout the product life cycle from “cradle<br />
to grave” or “cradle-to-cradle.” This analysis includes the different<br />
phases of resources extraction, manufacture, distribution, installation, use<br />
and disposal. ISO and the <strong>Society</strong> of Environmental Toxicology and<br />
Chemistry (SETAC), among others, have developed standards for conducting<br />
LCA.<br />
Unlike single attribute metrics such as recycled content, the output of<br />
LCA provides quantitative data on fundamental impact categories such<br />
as global warming or ecological toxicity.At present there is not consensus<br />
on a complete list of all impact categories, but the most often recognized<br />
impact categories are listed below as defined by the U.S.<br />
Environmental Performance Agency’s program called TRACI for Tool for<br />
the Reduction and Assessment of Chemical and Other Environmental<br />
Impacts, see http://www.epa.gov/ORD/NRMRL/std/sab/traci/<br />
Impact Category<br />
Global Warming Potential<br />
Acidification<br />
Eutrophication<br />
Ozone Depletion<br />
Smog<br />
Ecotoxicity<br />
Human Health<br />
Fossil Fuel<br />
Land Use<br />
Water Use<br />
Criteria Air Pollutants<br />
Possible End Points<br />
Malaria, coastal area damage,<br />
agricultural, forest damage<br />
Plant, animal, ecosystem<br />
Plant, animal, ecosystem<br />
Skin cancer cataracts, material<br />
damage, crop damage<br />
Human mortality, asthma, plant<br />
damage<br />
Plant, animal, ecosystem<br />
Variety of specific human cancers<br />
Fossil fuels shortages leading to<br />
use of other energy sources<br />
Threatened and<br />
endangered species<br />
Water shortages<br />
Disability-adjusted life years,<br />
toxicological human health effects<br />
Each impact category is characterized by an equivalent emission of a<br />
causal substance. For instance, since CO 2 emissions are the largest cause<br />
of global warming, Global Warming Potential (GWP), is measured in<br />
equivalent emissions of CO 2 with emissions other than CO 2 effecting<br />
global warming being converted to an equivalent effect of emitted CO 2 .<br />
First note that impact categories<br />
listed in the first column are defined<br />
in terms of fundamental attributes,<br />
such as Global Warming Potential<br />
(GWP) and Ozone Depletion<br />
Potential (ODP), as opposed to secondary<br />
variables like recycled content<br />
or even energy efficiency. In other<br />
words, we intuitively accept that<br />
lower energy consumption correlates<br />
to “better” environmental performance,<br />
but in fact it is reductions in<br />
power plant emissions contributing<br />
to global warming and acidification,<br />
among others, that are the actual<br />
benefits to the environment.<br />
Also note that the units for each<br />
impact category are listed in the second<br />
column and are different for each<br />
impact category. For instance GWP is<br />
measured in kg of CO 2 whereas ODP<br />
is measured in kg of CFC-11. As a<br />
new metric, these units will take<br />
some time to get assimilated. Lastly,<br />
note how this information groups<br />
impacts into different phases of the<br />
product’s life cycle: Production and<br />
Use. It is easy to see how the Use<br />
phase of energy-using <strong>products</strong>, such<br />
as <strong>light</strong>ing, can largely outweigh the<br />
Production phase. (Keep in mind this<br />
table is only an excerpt from a larger<br />
document on the EPD of this product,<br />
and additional information is provided<br />
about the End-of-Life phase as<br />
well as other aspects of the environmental<br />
performance.)<br />
BEES<br />
The National Institute of Standards<br />
and Technology (NIST) developed an<br />
approach for providing LCA-based<br />
environmental and economic performance<br />
information for building <strong>products</strong><br />
called BEES (short for Building<br />
for Environmental and Economic<br />
Sustainability, see www.bfrl.nist.gov-<br />
/oae/software/bees.html). Available on<br />
the BEES website is a free downloadable<br />
program which allows building<br />
designers to compare environmental<br />
performance of <strong>products</strong> which have<br />
been submitted to an LCA performed<br />
through a NIST vendor.<br />
Manufacturers must pay NIST to perform<br />
the LCA on a product-by-product<br />
basis, but <strong>products</strong> can be selected<br />
to represent a family of similar<br />
<strong>products</strong>. Currently there are over<br />
200 building <strong>products</strong> in the BEES 3.0<br />
December 2005 LD+A 15
GREEN IDEAS<br />
F I G U R E 2<br />
The Cook<br />
Corp<br />
1/4<br />
version, but there are no <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
<strong>products</strong> evaluated at this time. One<br />
of the benefits as well as one of the<br />
main criticisms of BEES is that the<br />
end result produces a single “score”<br />
for environmental performance.<br />
Figure 2 shows how BEES, with particular<br />
inputs, results in scores for<br />
Vinyl C tile and linoleum tile.<br />
To some, a single score provides an<br />
easy way to compare <strong>products</strong> on a<br />
one-for-one basis. To others, a single<br />
score requires too many assumptions<br />
and reduces the validity of the comparison.<br />
The point in reviewing existing initiatives<br />
like these is that models for<br />
LCA-based product information are<br />
under development and/or in use.<br />
Furthermore, to incorporate the full<br />
extent of sustainability, designers will<br />
need to get used to the language of<br />
understanding how <strong>products</strong> impact<br />
the environment. In the end, the burden<br />
of providing this information falls<br />
on manufacturers, and they are looking<br />
for what information is wanted by<br />
the marketplace. In the absence of<br />
any clear direction, information will<br />
fall in line with industry drivers<br />
already in place such as LEED.Among<br />
the goals of the IESNA Sustainable<br />
Lighting Committee is to develop a<br />
framework for environmental performance<br />
metrics of <strong>light</strong>ing <strong>products</strong>.<br />
While this may seem like a difficult<br />
task, in that it is as much of a consensus-building<br />
exercise as it is a technical<br />
challenge, initiatives like Sweden’s<br />
EDP and BEES provide a large foundation<br />
to start with.<br />
Nicola Ferzacca, PE, LEED, is an electrical<br />
department manager at Symmes<br />
Maini & McKee Associates with over 18<br />
years of experience in electrical and<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing design for national and international<br />
projects. He is chair of the IESNA<br />
Sustainable Lighting Committee and vice<br />
president of the New England Section.<br />
He holds a Master of Science in Lighting<br />
from Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute and<br />
has taught <strong>light</strong>ing at the Boston<br />
Architectural Center.<br />
16 www.iesna.org
LIGHTING FOR QUALITY<br />
The Shadow Knows<br />
Doug Paulin, LC<br />
YES,THIS IS A PERIODICAL<br />
of the <strong>light</strong>ing arts and sciences in<br />
North America. But I devote this<br />
column to shadows. Plural. Shadows<br />
are so important for our vision, and<br />
not just the simple silhouette, often<br />
referred to as “negative contrast” in<br />
roadway conversations. (Have you<br />
ever noticed how we have the habit<br />
of taking a nice simple word that<br />
everyone understands [silhouette]<br />
and inventing a “<strong>light</strong>ing term” for it<br />
[“negative contrast”]).<br />
Back to shadows. My first encounter<br />
with shadows was in a<br />
photo studio.We were shooting new<br />
product for catalogs and spec sheets.<br />
We paid attention to shadows and<br />
reflections and fiddled with other<br />
things that can make or break a good<br />
catalog photo until we wanted to<br />
scream.But shadows are the visual<br />
cues that tell us that the object in the<br />
two-dimensional photo is actually<br />
three-dimensional. The photographer<br />
would often take the first 4 x 5<br />
Polaroid snap from the camera and<br />
say “Yep, it looks like a hubcap!” But<br />
after he adjusted the <strong>light</strong>ing to<br />
accentuate the depth and shape, it<br />
would look like a <strong>light</strong>ing fixture.<br />
Modeling is a technique of creating<br />
varying shades of brightness, or,<br />
should I say, varying darkness of<br />
shadows.The modeled effect comes<br />
from two or more sources, hitting<br />
the three-dimensional object from<br />
different angles and different intensities.<br />
This doesn’t mean that the<br />
sources themselves have to be different;<br />
one can be farther away from<br />
the other(s).<br />
Playing Tricks<br />
This brings us to the “trick” I use<br />
most often when measuring illuminance<br />
in the field.Pay attention to the<br />
shadows—not just the shadow of<br />
your head on the <strong>light</strong> meter! Look at<br />
your own shadows on the floor.<br />
When your own shadows are equally<br />
dark, you are probably equidistant from<br />
each of the <strong>light</strong> sources.To make sure,<br />
move back and forth a few steps<br />
either way and watch one shadow<br />
get darker, and the other <strong>light</strong>er.Why<br />
is this important Because the midpoint<br />
between two fixture locations<br />
could be a point of minimum <strong>light</strong><br />
level. It then follows that a point<br />
Figure 1<br />
Figure 2<br />
between four fixtures should give you<br />
four shadows of equal darkness. (I<br />
almost typed “equal density” which is<br />
more exact, but not as easy to read.)<br />
Have you ever “counted” the shadows<br />
each football player makes on<br />
the field This tells you how many<br />
sports floods are aimed at that point,<br />
doesn’t it<br />
Another example: A decorative<br />
street <strong>light</strong>ing project in downtown<br />
Madison,WI, uses semi-cutoff decorative<br />
luminaires. A colleague pointed<br />
out that there couldn’t have been<br />
much horizontal <strong>light</strong> generated<br />
because the street<strong>light</strong> across the<br />
boulevard was able to cast a shadow<br />
of the fixture and pole on an adjacent<br />
wall (Figure 1). I studied this<br />
installation in person and couldn’t<br />
help myself from creating another<br />
shadow on the wall with my arm.<br />
The <strong>light</strong> across the boulevard created<br />
a shadow of my arm on the<br />
wall, as expected, but where my<br />
arm-shadow crossed the pole-shadow,<br />
you could see that the intersection<br />
of the two shadows was darker<br />
than the pole-shadow (Figure 2).<br />
The analysis My arm-shadow blocked<br />
the <strong>light</strong> from the near fixture, as<br />
well as <strong>light</strong> from the one farther<br />
away, and while the pole-shadow<br />
was there, it was not as dark because<br />
some of the high angle <strong>light</strong> was<br />
washing some of it out.Again, more<br />
than one shadow can tell you so<br />
much about what is going on with<br />
the <strong>light</strong>, or <strong>light</strong>s.<br />
So pay attention to the shadows.<br />
Especially if you are dealing with<br />
multiple sources and locations of the<br />
luminaires. Shadows can give you the<br />
contrast necessary for good visualization<br />
of the scene, but they can be<br />
a good analysis tool also.<br />
Doug Paulin, LC, is currently with<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing rep firm Packerland Lighting<br />
Sales, Inc., Egg Harbor,WI.Throughout<br />
his career, he’s worked as an independent<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing designer and has also held<br />
positions ranging from product manager<br />
and marketing manager for manufacturers<br />
including Ruud Lighting,<br />
Lithonia Lighting, Cooper Lighting and<br />
Thomas Day-Brite Lighting.<br />
December 2005 LD+A 17
LIGHTING FOR SECURITY<br />
Ted Ake<br />
PREVIOUS SEGMENTS IN<br />
this series have addressed the need<br />
for security <strong>light</strong>ing and equipment.<br />
Areas with specific needs such as<br />
closed spaces, multi- and single-family<br />
dwellings, and parking facilities<br />
have also been discussed.<br />
This article will include two additional<br />
high potential crime areas:<br />
convenience stores and ATMs. Both<br />
of these facilities are a product of<br />
management’s desire for enhanced<br />
customer convenience in our 24/7<br />
lifestyle. Both operate during nighttime<br />
hours and involve the handling<br />
of cash and, therefore, can create an<br />
attraction for criminal elements.<br />
Proper <strong>light</strong>ing can be a powerful<br />
tool in reducing such activities.<br />
Convenience Stores<br />
These have evolved from the small<br />
“Mom & Pop” operations selling sundries,<br />
groceries and gasoline to<br />
mega-centers providing a full array of<br />
meals, travel needs, automobile service<br />
and, of course, gasoline. As in<br />
any retail operation, outdoor <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
At the convenience store pump island, sufficient illuminance must be provided<br />
to enable employees inside the store to easily view outside activity. At<br />
right, note the reflections of inside displays from the manager’s station.As a<br />
result, island luminance must be bright enough to overcome reflections.<br />
can be used to attract customers<br />
and then provide a safe environment<br />
to conduct business. In some<br />
instances, the “attraction aspect” can<br />
create unnecessary glare, <strong>light</strong> pollution<br />
and trespass. Properly designed<br />
security <strong>light</strong>ing systems should<br />
never become a nuisance.<br />
The area surrounding the fuel<br />
pumps is of prime concern. While<br />
pumping gas or washing the windshield<br />
requires relatively low <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
levels, sufficient illuminance must be<br />
provided to enable employees inside<br />
the store to easily view outside activity.The<br />
ratio of outside-to-inside levels<br />
must be low enough to prevent<br />
windows from becoming mirrors.<br />
To reduce crime, especially<br />
shoplifting, the more sophisticated<br />
facilities rely on CCTV (Closed<br />
Circuit Television), which requires<br />
adequate and properly directed<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing. Such systems, when well<br />
publicized, create a strong deterrent<br />
to potential thieves. Other<br />
deterrents include well-<strong>light</strong>ed<br />
trash areas, proper cash handling, at<br />
least two employees on duty in<br />
even the smallest stores, and<br />
Fulham 1/2 horiz<br />
18 www.iesna.org
absence of advertising posters in<br />
viewing windows.<br />
ATMs<br />
In just 35 years, the number of<br />
ATMs worldwide has now reached<br />
nearly 400,000.The vast majority of<br />
transactions involve cash withdrawals.<br />
The frequency and size of<br />
these withdrawals naturally attracts<br />
wrongdoers.The Bank Administrative<br />
Institute’s ATM Study states that 50<br />
percent of ATM crime occurs<br />
between 7:00 PM and midnight,<br />
despite the fact that this time period<br />
involves only 10 percent of all transactions.<br />
Similarly, 10 percent of ATM<br />
crimes happen between midnight and<br />
4:00 AM, when only one percent of<br />
transactions occur.<br />
ATM locations vary greatly, from<br />
indoor locations, such as transportation<br />
terminals, stores and hotels, to<br />
outdoor areas such as drive-up, walkup<br />
and remote freestanding units.<br />
Indoor installations should be<br />
located in the open, away from convenient<br />
hiding spaces and easy<br />
escape routes. In some locations,<br />
glass partitions are required to provide<br />
privacy and a view of any<br />
threatening person.<br />
Outdoor locations, of course,<br />
require adequate security <strong>light</strong>ing. In<br />
its list of potential liabilities, the<br />
American<br />
Bankers Association,<br />
Security Officers include:<br />
• Failing to install and maintain <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
at ATM and the premises surrounding<br />
the ATM.<br />
• Failing to install security equipment,such<br />
as surveillance cameras<br />
and alarms, in ATM premises and<br />
the immediate surroundings.<br />
• Failing to trim and maintain shrubbery<br />
outside the ATM premises<br />
and adjacent parking areas.<br />
• Failing to take measures to provide<br />
safe sidewalks from the parking<br />
lot to the ATM facility.<br />
Walk-up locations, of course, have<br />
a greater occasion for attack than<br />
drive-up and therefore require<br />
designs that are more sophisticated.<br />
In order to provide time for changes<br />
in customer adaptation, the IESNA<br />
Guideline on Security Lighting G-1-03<br />
recommends illuminance values of 20<br />
lux from 50 ft to 10 ft and 100 lux<br />
within 10 ft of the ATM. 1 Since ATM<br />
screens are self-illuminated, very little<br />
Failure to provide surrounding<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing at outdoor ATMs is an<br />
obvious liability issue.<br />
vertical <strong>light</strong> is required on the<br />
screen. The entire area should have<br />
unobstructed views. Glass enclosures<br />
are becoming more common and are<br />
required in some locales. In some<br />
instances, access to the enclosure<br />
requires the use of a bankcard. 2<br />
Especially at remote, stand-alone<br />
locations, two security <strong>light</strong>ing principles<br />
are of extreme importance:<br />
owner-supplied perimeter <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
and maintenance.These are high-risk<br />
areas, therefore, the bank cannot<br />
depend on others to <strong>light</strong> the space<br />
surrounding the ATM location.As in<br />
any area, a poorly maintained system<br />
can lead to disaster. Each ATM must<br />
be visited frequently to service and<br />
supply the unit. Service personnel<br />
should be trained to override the<br />
controls and energize the <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
system. Failed lamps should be<br />
reported immediately and corrections<br />
made within 24 hours.<br />
When next you venture outdoors<br />
at night, be aware of your surroundings.<br />
Do you feel comfortable or<br />
apprehensive If comfortable, say a<br />
“thank you” to those who designed,<br />
own and maintain the system.If apprehensive,<br />
you must call attention to the<br />
problem and offer your help.<br />
Security <strong>light</strong>ing is everyone’s<br />
responsibility.<br />
Ted Ake, a Member Emeritus of<br />
IESNA,is currently an adjunct professor in<br />
the Building Construction Department at<br />
Virginia Tech,serves on the Interior Design<br />
Department’s Advisory Board at Radford<br />
University and is a lecturer for the Virginia<br />
Crime Prevention Association. He retired<br />
from Hubbell Lighting in 2000.<br />
References<br />
1. ABA recommends higher values<br />
2. Due to high crime rates, many<br />
states and municipalities have created<br />
ATM <strong>light</strong>ing ordinances. The<br />
designer should become familiar<br />
with these legal requirements.<br />
RP-36<br />
1/3 V<br />
August 2005 LD+A 19
VOLUME 35, NUMBER 12 • December 2005<br />
ILLUMINATING ENGINEERING SOCIETYNEWS<br />
Just In Time…<br />
Held as a combination Centennial Celebration and<br />
fund raiser for educational programs, the Philadelphia<br />
Section hosted a Centennial Gala on September 17 at<br />
the Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia, PA.<br />
IESNA senior vice president, Kevin Flynn, was the guest<br />
speaker at the event.<br />
Research Committee Seeks Recruits<br />
The IESNA Research Committee has recently revised its scope and objectives and is seeking<br />
individuals in the <strong>light</strong>ing community to become active members of the committee.The<br />
committee’s mission is to promote research in the <strong>light</strong>ing industry and to report and disseminate<br />
information on worldwide research and <strong>light</strong>ing related research activity, collaborating<br />
with the organizations and individuals carrying out research, facilitating the translation<br />
of results and discoveries intended to improve the <strong>light</strong>ed environment. For more information,<br />
contact the committee chair Richard Collins at Richard.collins@sylvania.com<br />
IESNA<br />
Calendar of Events<br />
January 8-10, 2006<br />
IESNA CENTENNIAL<br />
CONFERENCE<br />
Contact:Valerie Landers<br />
212-248-5000 ext.117<br />
www.iesna.org<br />
Members In The News...<br />
Morgan Gabler and Jim Youngston have partnered to start<br />
their own architectural <strong>light</strong>ing design practice, Gabler-Youngston LP, in Atlanta..The new firm will<br />
focus on <strong>light</strong>ing for commercial, institutional and hospitality interiors and exteriors.<br />
Youngston and Gabler<br />
The Lighting Practice, Inc., Philadelphia, PA, has named Julie Panassow as an associate principal.<br />
Panassow, who joined the firm in 1992, has created complete <strong>light</strong>ing programs for corporations,<br />
museums, academic institutions, healthcare facilities, airports and historic buildings. She was<br />
most recently awarded an IIDA of Merit for re<strong>light</strong>ing of the building façades and sculptures along<br />
Philadelphia’s Benjamin Franklin Parkway.<br />
Panassow<br />
Leviton Manufacturing Company, Little Neck, NY, has appointed William Marshall to the<br />
position of senior vice president of sales and marketing and Daryoush Larizadeh to senior vice president.<br />
Matthew Silverman was also named training manager for Leviton Integrated Networks and Controls, and<br />
Residential Lighting Control Products.<br />
W.A.C. Lighting, Garden City, NY, has promoted John Camp to national sales manager. Most recently,<br />
he served as product manager for the firm.<br />
Marshall<br />
OSRAM SYLVANIA, Danvers, MA, promoted Dwight Kitchen to vice president of sales for the<br />
OEM/Special Markets sales channel.Kitchen served as director of sales for SYLVANIA LIGHTING SERVICES<br />
(SLS) since 2002.<br />
Ken Vannice has been selected by The Entertainment Technician Certification Program Council (ETCP)<br />
as one of 11 “subject matters” experts who will help develop the industry’s first electrical certification.<br />
Selected for their depth of knowledge, the individuals will work closely with psychometric services provider,<br />
Applied Measurement Professionals (AMP), to develop the examinations.<br />
Camp<br />
December 2005 LD+A 21
IESNA Street and Area Lighting Conference<br />
Taking It To The Street<br />
Over 350 outdoor <strong>light</strong>ing professionals came together for the<br />
24th Annual SALC Conference in San Diego, CA. This year’s<br />
conference featured timely topics from well known speakers<br />
on issues including security <strong>light</strong>ing, ordinances and liability, as<br />
well a new product roundup, and networking and roundtable<br />
discussions. Over 45 companies, including 13 new exhibitors,<br />
featured <strong>products</strong> and services.<br />
A keynote address was given by Crawford Lipsey, senior vice<br />
president and general manager of Holophane. The SALC<br />
Lifetime Service Award was presented to David Baum,<br />
Holphane. Mark your calendar for the 25th SALC Conference in<br />
Tampa, FL, October 8-11, 2006.<br />
From left to right: John Bono, conference chair; David Baum;<br />
and Richard Monsoor, SALC executive committee member<br />
New Members<br />
Membership Committee Chair Paul<br />
Mercier announced the IESNA gained<br />
four Sustaining Members and 75 members<br />
(M), associated members and student<br />
members in October.<br />
Sustaining Members<br />
Shremshock <strong>Engineering</strong>, Inc., Columbus, OH<br />
Design West <strong>Engineering</strong>, San Bernardino, CA<br />
Applied Lighting Concepts, Jacksonville, FL<br />
Magna IV <strong>Engineering</strong>, Edmonton,AB, Canada<br />
Canadian Region<br />
Marcello Coronatta, Canlyte, Lachine, QC<br />
Greg A. Janusz, M.T.S.,Winnipeg, MB<br />
Mario Pharand, Canlyte, Inc., Lachine, QC<br />
Sabine Marietta Susman, Lighting Group, Inc.,<br />
Richmond Hill, ON<br />
East Central Region<br />
Steven J. Hirshenhorn, Marty Berman Associates,<br />
Lansdale, PA<br />
Juli A. Kale, Hadco, Littlestown, PA<br />
Dahua Lin, Mullins <strong>Engineering</strong> Co., Odenton, MD<br />
Timothy L. Raubenstine, Hanover Lantern, Inc.,<br />
Hanover, PA<br />
Daniel Serrano, Fox Electric Supply Co., Inc.,<br />
Philadelphia, PA<br />
Tammy D. Smith, Robert G. Dashiell Jr, PE, Inc.,<br />
Norfolk,VA<br />
The Pennsylvania State University<br />
Michael A. Lombardi<br />
Great Lakes Region<br />
Steven J. Galley, Cannon Design, Grand Island, NY<br />
Reece A. Prather (M), Shremshock <strong>Engineering</strong>, Inc.,<br />
Columbus, OH<br />
Michael Richards, M/E <strong>Engineering</strong> P.C., Buffalo, NY<br />
Stephen A. Rogers,The Brewer-Garrett Co.,<br />
Middleburg Heights, OH<br />
Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh<br />
Joon Ho Choi<br />
South Pacific Coast Region<br />
Kenneth Acampora (M), Hydrel - Lithonia Lighting,<br />
Sylmar, CA<br />
Douglas Avery (M), Southern California Edison,<br />
Wildmar, CA<br />
Russ F. Bahlenhorst Jr. (M), Ushio America, Inc.,<br />
Cypress, CA<br />
Derwin Bass (M), Builder’s Resource LLC,<br />
Gardnerville, NV<br />
Halley D. Fitzpatrick, Pacific Gas and Electric, San<br />
Francisco, CA<br />
John R. Freese (M), Light Factors, La Jolla, CA<br />
Michael Keith Hendrix (M), Michael Brandman<br />
Associates, San Bernardino, CA<br />
George Kalta (M), Contractors Choice Lighting,<br />
Valencia, CA<br />
Todd K. Robinson,The Light Source, Salt Lake City, UT<br />
David J. Seppelfrick, Speck Electrical Design, Inc.,<br />
Honolulu, HI<br />
Shannon Slattery, ERCO Lighting, Inc., Santa Monica, CA<br />
Susan Sutherland-Bishop, OSRAM SYLVANIA,<br />
Ramona, CA<br />
Scott Thurm, Bartco Lighting, Inc., Huntington Beach, CA<br />
Jeff T.Trueblood, Design West <strong>Engineering</strong>, San<br />
Bernardino, CA<br />
Academy of Art University<br />
Umpornpol Yugala<br />
Stanford University<br />
Eelaine S. Buckholtz<br />
Midwest Region<br />
David Bettenhausen, Henderson Engineers, Inc.,<br />
Lenexa, KS<br />
Greg A. Miller (M), Border States Supply, Janesville,WI<br />
Billy Onder, Lightolier, Maryland Heights, MO<br />
Audra J. Relph, MKEC <strong>Engineering</strong> Consultants, Inc.,<br />
Wichita, KS<br />
Matt A. Smith, Brack & Associates Consulting<br />
Engineers, P.A.,Topeka, KS<br />
Mark Sullivan, Holophane, Barrington, IL<br />
Southern Illinois University Carbondale<br />
Melissa A. Roth<br />
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign<br />
Lisa Anne Thompson<br />
Southeastern Region<br />
Jose R. Cedeno (M), Penuelas, PR<br />
Jose J. Durand, JDR Engineers & Developers, Inc., San<br />
Juan, PR<br />
Jim Frazer (M), Strategic Telemetry, Inc., Lighthouse<br />
Point, FL<br />
Gustavo D. Macias, Lightolier, Miami, FL<br />
Cynthia Neal,Applied Lighting Concepts, Jacksonville, FL<br />
Northeastern Region<br />
David L. Bay (M), OSRAM SYLVANIA, Danvers, MA<br />
Mitchell Bloomberg (M),The Lighting Group, New<br />
York, NY<br />
Mark D. Carroll, Jersey City, NJ<br />
Amanda J. Hammell, Clough, Harbour & Associates,<br />
Albany, NY<br />
Patrick G. Merosier (M), Domingo Gonzalez<br />
Associates, New York, NY<br />
Richard J. Potts, Clough Harbour & Associates LLP,<br />
Albany, NY<br />
Vasudha Ramamurthy, Zumtobel Staff Lighting, Inc.,<br />
Highland, NY<br />
Kazumi Tanimura,Atelier Lumiere, Inc., New York, NY<br />
Benjamin J.White (M), Public Service Electric & Gas,<br />
Lawrenceville, NJ<br />
Boston Architectural Center<br />
Patrick D. Rettig<br />
Northwest Region<br />
Michael E. Field MILE, RET (M), Magna IV <strong>Engineering</strong>,<br />
Edmonton,AB<br />
Craig V. Olson,Acme Integration, Inc., Post Falls, ID<br />
Buzz Thielemann, RHT Energy Solutions, Medford, OR<br />
BCIT<br />
Meghean A.S. Kennedy<br />
Portland State University<br />
Clifford M. Bodell<br />
Southwestern Region<br />
Josh W. Joyce, Lockeby & Associates, Inc., Little Rock,AR<br />
James McDaniel, Dynamic Lighting, Inc., Pearland,TX<br />
Nathen C. Neal (M),Triple C Companies, Oklahoma<br />
City, OK<br />
Jack Story (M), U.S.Army Corps of Engineers, Forth<br />
Worth,TX<br />
Texas A&M University<br />
Mini Malhotra<br />
Southern Region<br />
Gregory Bennorth (M), Universal Lighting<br />
Technologies, Nashville,TN<br />
Michael C. LaMountain (M), Pickering Firm,<br />
Memphis,TN<br />
Robert Rankin, Genlyte-Day-Brite/Capri/Omega,<br />
Tupelo, MS<br />
Paul C. Strong (M), Memphis Light, Gas and Water<br />
Division, Memphis,TN<br />
Art Institute of Charlotte<br />
Melody K. Miller<br />
International<br />
Sun Gak Hong (M), Doyak Electronic Ind. Co. Ltd,<br />
Bucheon, Korea<br />
Aijaz M. Nakhawa (M),Tectronics, Dubai, United Arab<br />
Emirates<br />
Gregory J. Nelson (M), Philips Lighting, Shanghai,<br />
China<br />
Geoff Pendleton,Thorn Lighting, Smithfield,Australia<br />
Sri Krishna College of <strong>Engineering</strong> and Technology<br />
R.Arunraj<br />
22 www.iesna.org
SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA OCTOBER 2-5, 2005<br />
SUSTAINING<br />
MEMBERS<br />
The following companies have elected to<br />
support the <strong>Society</strong> as Sustaining Members<br />
which allows the IESNA to fund programs that<br />
benefit all segments of the membership and<br />
pursue new endeavors, including education<br />
projects, <strong>light</strong>ing research and recommended<br />
practices. The level of support is classified by<br />
the amount of annual dues, based on a<br />
company’s annual <strong>light</strong>ing revenues:<br />
Copper:<br />
$500 annual dues<br />
Lighting revenues to $4 million<br />
(Copper members are listed in one issue of LD+A<br />
each year, as well as in the IESNA Annual Report.)<br />
Silver:<br />
$1,000 annual dues<br />
Lighting revenues to $10 million<br />
Gold:<br />
$2,500 annual dues<br />
Lighting revenues to $50 million<br />
Platinum:<br />
$5,000 annual dues<br />
Lighting revenues to $200 million<br />
Emerald:<br />
$10,000 annual dues<br />
Lighting revenues to $500 million<br />
Diamond:<br />
$15,000 annual dues<br />
Lighting revenues over $500 million<br />
DIAMOND<br />
Cooper Lighting<br />
General Electric Co.<br />
Lithonia Lighting<br />
OSRAM SYLVANIA Products, Inc.<br />
Philips Lighting Co.<br />
EMERALD<br />
Holophane Corporation<br />
PLATINUM<br />
Day-Brite Capri Omega<br />
Lightolier<br />
Lutron Electronics Co, Inc.<br />
GOLD<br />
A.L.P. Lighting Components Co.<br />
Altman Lighting Inc<br />
The Bodine Company<br />
Canlyte Inc.<br />
Con-Tech Lighting<br />
Duke Power Co.<br />
Edison Price Lighting, Inc.<br />
Finelite, Inc.<br />
Florida Power Lighting Solutions<br />
Gardco Lighting<br />
Indy Lighting, Inc.<br />
Kenall Mfg Co.<br />
The Kirlin Company<br />
Kurt Versen Co.<br />
LexaLite Int’l Corp<br />
Lighting Services Inc<br />
LiteTouch, Inc.<br />
Louis Poulsen Lighting<br />
LSI Industries, Inc.<br />
Lucifer Lighting Co.<br />
Martin Professional, Inc.<br />
Musco Sports Lighting, Inc.<br />
Niagara Mohawk Power Corp<br />
Prudential Lighting Corp<br />
RAB Lighting, Inc.<br />
San Diego Gas & Electric<br />
SPI Lighting<br />
Vista Professional Outdoor Lighting<br />
The Watt Stopper Inc.<br />
Zumtobel Staff Lighting, Inc.<br />
SILVER<br />
Altoglas International<br />
Altuglas International, Arkema Inc.<br />
Associated Lighting Representatives. Inc.<br />
Axis Lighting Inc.<br />
Bartco Lighting, Inc.<br />
Barth Electric Co., Inc.<br />
Beta Lighting, Inc.<br />
Birchwood Lighting, Inc.<br />
BJB Electric Corporation<br />
Border States Electric Supply<br />
Bulbrite Industries, Inc.<br />
Celestial Products<br />
City of San Francisco<br />
Con Edison of New York<br />
Custom Lighting Services, LLC<br />
Custom Lights, Inc.<br />
Day Lite Maintenance Co.<br />
Eastern Energy Services, Inc.<br />
Eclipse Lighting, Inc.<br />
Elko Ltd<br />
Elliptipar<br />
Enmax<br />
Enterprise Lighting Sales<br />
ETC Architectural<br />
Eye Lighting Industries<br />
Eye Lighting Int’l of NA<br />
Fiberstars<br />
Focal Point<br />
Gammalux Systems<br />
H E Williams, Inc.<br />
HDLC<br />
<strong>Illuminating</strong> Technologies, Inc.<br />
Kramer Lighting<br />
Lee Filters<br />
Legion Lighting Co.<br />
Leviton Mfg. Co. Inc.<br />
Lightology LLC<br />
LiteTech<br />
Litecontrol Corp<br />
Litelab Corp<br />
Litetronics Int’l Inc.<br />
Lowel Light Manufacturing<br />
Lumascap USA Inc.<br />
Manitoba Hydro<br />
Manning Lighting<br />
Metalumen Manufacturing, Inc.<br />
OCEM/Multi Electric Mfg. Inc.<br />
Optical Research Associates<br />
Paramount Industries, Inc.<br />
Peter Basso Associates, Inc.<br />
Portland General Electric<br />
Prescolite, Inc.<br />
Reflex Lighting Group, Inc.<br />
Richard McDonald & Associates, Ltd. - Calgary<br />
Sentry Electric Corporation<br />
Shakespeare Composites & Structures<br />
Southern California Edison<br />
Sternberg Vintage Lighting<br />
Strand Lighting, Inc.<br />
StressCrete King Luminaire Co.<br />
Tennessee Valley Authority<br />
Universal Electric Ltd.<br />
US Architectural Lighting/Sun Valley Lighting<br />
Utility Metals<br />
Velux America Inc.<br />
WJ Whatley Inc.<br />
WAC Lighting, Co.<br />
Wisconsin Public Service Corp<br />
Wybron, Inc.<br />
Xenon Light, Inc.<br />
IES SUSTAINING<br />
MEMBERS<br />
As of October 2005<br />
December 2005 LD+A 23
INDUSTRY UPDATES<br />
Three LED, SSL Joint<br />
Ventures Announced<br />
Lighting Services Inc (LSI), a manufacturer<br />
of track, accent, display, fiber<br />
optic, and now, solid-state <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
(SSL) systems has formed a strategic<br />
partnership with TIR Systems Ltd.,<br />
the developer of the SSL product, the<br />
LEXEL. With a large share of museum,<br />
gallery and high-end retail <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
markets, LSI says the partnership will<br />
enable the two companies to develop<br />
a range of LEXEL-based fixtures that<br />
produce white <strong>light</strong> with a full range<br />
of color temperatures.<br />
TIR also signed a design collaboration<br />
agreement with the Genlyte<br />
Group to develop and market LEXELbased<br />
<strong>products</strong> under the Lightolier<br />
and Canlyte brands. The focus of this<br />
design collaboration will be on developing<br />
<strong>products</strong> for the retail, restaurant,<br />
commercial and residential markets.<br />
Meanwhile, Color Kinetics Inc. and<br />
Litecontrol Corp. announced an agreement<br />
that will apply Color Kinetics<br />
technology to a LED-based product<br />
line offered by Litecontrol. Consisting<br />
of three offerings, the line will be based<br />
on versatile Digital Light Engines<br />
(DLEs), which apply Chromacore technology<br />
to efficiently generate colored<br />
<strong>light</strong> and color-changing effects. They<br />
will also be compatible with Color<br />
Kinetics’ line of intuitive controllers,<br />
providing an integrated system for<br />
diverse applications, from wall washing<br />
to cove and accent <strong>light</strong>ing.<br />
Growth is Good<br />
In 2004, the Imperial Palace Hotel (formerly the Amiga) in Seoul,<br />
South Korea, was expanded to nearly three times its size, while the<br />
amount of hotel rooms doubled to 430. Re-opened in 2005, the additions<br />
included a convention center, nine restaurants, a spa and a shopping<br />
center.To maintain its meticulous ambiance and flexible buildingwide<br />
control, the hotel uses an ETC Unison architectural <strong>light</strong>ing system,<br />
which consists of sensor dimmers and theatrical fixtures. Pictured<br />
is the Imperial Palace lobby.<br />
LRC Selected by FAA To Study Airport Lighting<br />
The Lighting Research Center (LRC) at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute,Troy, NY, was selected by the Federal Aviation<br />
Administration (FAA) to join its Centers of Excellence program.The LRC will conduct <strong>light</strong>ing research as part of the<br />
Center of Excellence for Airport Technology (CEAT), which focuses on airport structures, pavement materials, wildlife<br />
issues, anti-icing and <strong>light</strong>ing. Specifically, the LRC will focus on the area of solid-state <strong>light</strong>ing and vision science.<br />
The LRC will explore the potential performance and application of new <strong>light</strong> source technologies, primarily LEDs, in<br />
airport and airfield <strong>light</strong>ing.The LRC will look at how these new technologies can be applied to <strong>light</strong> runways, taxiways,<br />
approaches and other areas of the airfield.<br />
For its first project with CEAT, the LRC will develop recommendations and metrics that consider the brightness perception<br />
of LED <strong>light</strong>ing on the airfield.“Performance standards for LED systems based on traditional <strong>light</strong>ing metrics, like<br />
luminance, are causing problems for viewers,” said LRC director of research, Nadarajah Narendran. As an example, he<br />
says a green LED approach <strong>light</strong> is typically perceived as much brighter and less comfortable to view than an incandescent<br />
green <strong>light</strong> of the same luminance.“A better metric is needed so that LED systems can be produced and used in<br />
the field without causing discomfort to pilots,” he said.<br />
The LRC will also work with the FAA to conduct psychophysical studies that compare the brightness perception of<br />
colored and white LED <strong>light</strong>ing systems with incandescent <strong>light</strong>ing systems, which use filters to create colored <strong>light</strong>.<br />
December 2005 LD+A 25
INDUSTRY UPDATES<br />
Call for Entries:<br />
GE Edison Award<br />
Competition<br />
GE Consumer & Industrial Lighting<br />
announced a Call for Entries for the<br />
23rd annual GE Edison Award competition.<br />
New for 2005, residential <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
projects submitted as entrants to the<br />
2005 competition will also be entered<br />
into a special category established for<br />
residential projects only.The top residential<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing design will receive an<br />
Award for Residential Design.<br />
All submitted projects must have<br />
been completed between January 1,<br />
2005 and December 31, 2005. Entries<br />
must be received by January18, 2006.<br />
For more information, visit<br />
www.geedisonaward.com<br />
Survey Says: LIGHTFAIR is a<br />
‘Must-Experience’ Event<br />
Why take LIGHTFAIR’s word for it when you can ask a nonbiased<br />
party Following the conclusion of LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL,<br />
Moore & Symons, Inc.—an independent market research firm—conducted<br />
a post-show study of attendees to determine their opinions and perceptions<br />
of the conference.The survey revealed that 93 percent consider<br />
LFI a “must-see” event and 95 percent consider LFI the gathering place for<br />
the industry. LFI attendees said that they’re more likely to attend future<br />
LFI shows vs. other industry shows like LDI and Light & Build.<br />
About the trade show portion, 96 percent said LFI has a high-quality<br />
set of exhibitors; 88 percent consider LFI a place to find new <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
design ideas; 90 percent consider LFI a place to see a wide variety of<br />
<strong>products</strong>; 91 percent consider LFI a source for discovering new trends in<br />
the marketplace; and 90 percent say LFI is the place to see new, unique,<br />
innovative <strong>products</strong>.<br />
As for the conference side of LFI, 92 percent said LFI keeps them<br />
informed of what’s going on in the industry and 89 percent said they<br />
learn something valuable at LFI every year.<br />
Lighting Manufacturer Wins State Environmental Award<br />
Columbia Lighting of Spokane, was one of five Washington-based businesses that received the 2005 Governor’s Award<br />
for Pollution Prevention & Sustainable Practices.The judges evaluated the entries based on innovations to reduce toxic<br />
materials and waste and use less energy and water, as well as other ways they have protected the environment. In total,<br />
four commercial businesses and a not-for-profit hospital were recognized.<br />
New Look to New York’s Plaza Park<br />
Liberty Plaza Park is undergoing a reconstruction that will create<br />
a public sanctuary in the heart of lower Manhattan.The 33,000 sq ft<br />
park will boast new foliage, new <strong>light</strong>ing and a central corridor for<br />
foot traffic. <strong>Illuminating</strong> the park will be 500 thin, rectangular, inground<br />
fluorescent <strong>light</strong>s.These fixtures have been specially designed<br />
to be water- and air-tight, as well as easily replaceable.The $8 million<br />
renovation should be completed by next summer.<br />
Photos: Renderings courtesy of Cooper, Robertson & Partners LLC<br />
Advance University<br />
Curriculum<br />
Approved by<br />
NCQLP<br />
Advance’s online ballast training<br />
courses offered through their website<br />
(Advance University) have been<br />
accepted as an approved curriculum<br />
by the National Council on<br />
Qualifications for the Lighting<br />
Professions (NCQLP).<br />
Currently there are three course<br />
levels being offered. The first level<br />
(Ballast Basics 101) covers ballast<br />
basics.The second level (Ballast Basics<br />
201) features ballast troubleshooting<br />
techniques as well as an introduction<br />
to many newer <strong>light</strong>ing technologies.<br />
Level three provides an overview of<br />
the Digital Addressable Lighting<br />
Interface (DALI) <strong>light</strong>ing standard and<br />
its use in creating new and powerful<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing designs.<br />
Completion of the courses will<br />
qualify NCQLP members for Lighting<br />
Education Units (LEUs) within the<br />
organization’s LC program. For more<br />
information, visit www.advancetransformer.com/university<br />
26 www.iesna.org
applications & solutions •<br />
Martha Says: ‘You’re Hired’<br />
The words “you’re fired” have sparked viewer curiosity week<br />
after week and ultimately catapulted Donald Trump’s show, “The<br />
Apprentice,” to high ratings. While the recently canceled “The<br />
Apprentice: Martha Stewart” didn’t match the ratings of the<br />
Trump show, it did provide a chance for several<br />
companies to get invaluable exposure<br />
for their interior furnishings <strong>products</strong>.<br />
Just like Trump’s version, the contestants<br />
on Stewart’s show have to set up camp in a<br />
New York City living space. Rather than<br />
reside in a suite at the Trump Tower on 5th Avenue, Martha’s spin-off has contestants staying in<br />
a posh loft.<br />
Traditional and contemporary furniture is mixed with clean, sleek lines in an industrial setting.<br />
The design team consisted of Kelly Van Patter (production designer); Bridget Edwards (set decorator);<br />
and David Park (<strong>light</strong>ing designer).<br />
South Florida <strong>light</strong>ing manufacturer Luraline was chosen to provide <strong>light</strong>ing fixtures for the loft.<br />
Selected for the kitchen area were the Reflecta silver dome pendants.The pendants add an industrial<br />
touch to the contemporary styled kitchen, which consists of stainless steel counters and rolling units that complement<br />
the dark family style tables and center-island.“We received all the <strong>light</strong>ing by contacting Luraline directly and<br />
asking them to participate in our product placement for the show,” said Van Patter.“Basically, we decorated the entire<br />
loft by having different vendors supply us with product in exchange for exposure.” <strong>Illuminating</strong> the bathroom area are<br />
wave pendants, which feature an eclectic style that blends well with the loft’s modern décor.<br />
“The only challenge was the set director’s need for the product in such a short time frame,” said Kurt M.<br />
Mandelik, Luraline’s vice president,“but we were able to ship the product to the client within their time restraints.”<br />
Between the fixtures and the finishes selected, designers achieved the look they were after from the very beginning.<br />
The Project: The contestant<br />
loft for the “The Apprentice:<br />
Martha Stewart” television<br />
show, New York, NY<br />
The Challenge: Incorporate an<br />
industrial <strong>light</strong>ing design into<br />
a contemporary styled loft.<br />
The Solution: Pendant<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing fixtures<br />
—John-Michael Kobes<br />
December 2005 LD+A 27
• applications & solutions<br />
Beachfront Lighting Proves to be<br />
an Environmentally Safe Addition<br />
Every summer, sea turtles make their way to the shores of South Florida, each laying about 100 eggs in 40,000<br />
to 70,000 nests in the sand.The only way the mothers and their young can make their way back to water is by<br />
following the moon and star<strong>light</strong> that reflects off the sea.<br />
Artificial <strong>light</strong>ing landward of the beach can also deter turtles from emerging from the ocean and nesting. In addition,<br />
if a hatchling is unable to see the ocean horizon or if artificial <strong>light</strong> is visible, the hatchling may become disoriented<br />
and crawl toward a landward <strong>light</strong> source.<br />
One of the larger nesting areas in the state is the<br />
Beachwalk,a 3400-ft long x 15-ft wide paved public access<br />
trail that winds its way up Miami Beach’s eastern shore.<br />
Coastal Systems International, Inc. coordinated with<br />
Bradshaw Gill & Associates, (landscape architects); QRE<br />
Associates, (project architect); and Form+Surfaces, (project<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing manufacturers) to make the trip safer for the<br />
sea turtles.<br />
The team installed Triada pedestrian <strong>light</strong>ing.Constructed<br />
of rustproof aluminum,the pole-top luminaire is engineered<br />
to withstand salt spray and the extreme winds to which the<br />
area is regularly subjected. Unlike many conventional<br />
The Project: The Miami Beachwalk,<br />
Miami, FL<br />
The Challenge: Install <strong>light</strong>ing that<br />
meets the varying criteria of a tropical<br />
environment that is both a tourist<br />
destination and sea turtle habitat<br />
The Solution: Pole-top luminaires<br />
shields, which are positioned next to the lamp, this exterior shield minimizes wraparound<br />
<strong>light</strong> and bypass glow that are known to have hazardous navigational impacts on turtle hatchlings.<br />
“The project required a design that would integrate aesthetically with the nautical environment and provide<br />
extreme durability and unique features exacted by the site specific conditions,” said Tod Kopco, director of custom<br />
manufacturing, Forms+Surfaces.<br />
In the end, the installation, which began in 2004 and is still on going, benefited the city, its many visitors and the<br />
precious marine species that live in this environmentally sensitive and heavily regulated beachfront area.<br />
—John-Michael Kobes<br />
28 www.iesna.org
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P R. O. J . E C. T . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P . R O. J. E C. T. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
EMPHASIZING REGIONALISM OVER NOSTALGIA, PETCO PARK<br />
CELEBRATES SAN DIEGO EVEN MORE THAN BASEBALL<br />
By Paul Tarricone<br />
Sports <strong>light</strong>s hang off the front of two<br />
200-ft high infield towers (far left).<br />
These vertical structures behind<br />
home plate house suites and break<br />
up the seating bowl, creating different<br />
“neighborhoods” within the stadium.<br />
Conventional sports <strong>light</strong> racks could<br />
not be used for these <strong>light</strong>s.<br />
Petco Park is not kind to power hitters. With<br />
its deep outfield fences, the spacious home<br />
of the San Diego Padres turns what would<br />
be home runs in other ballparks into harmless<br />
flyball outs. So it stands to reason that Padres’<br />
slugger Ryan Klesko would want to distance himself<br />
from Petco after a game. Guess again. Klesko<br />
has a condo at the Omni Hotel right next to the<br />
ballpark and out his window he can look down<br />
into the stadium. “I haven’t gone down to take<br />
BP in my pajamas or anything,” he told Sports<br />
Illustrated, “but I can roll out of bed and boom,<br />
I’m already at the ballpark.”<br />
Pretty cool. In fact, “California Cool” might be<br />
the best way to describe Petco Park, its architecture<br />
and its <strong>light</strong>ing. Notably, even the Padres’<br />
website emphasizes the stadium’s San Diego<br />
vibe over the baseball experience. “Architecturally<br />
magnificent, it celebrates the sea, the sky, the<br />
natural beauty, cultural diversity and unique spirit<br />
of our region,” proclaims a fact sheet on the<br />
stadium. “The relaxed yet dynamic atmosphere<br />
reflects the San Diego lifestyle.”<br />
Building materials include steel, natural stone,<br />
stucco and brick. Two large, sandstone “garden<br />
buildings” that frame the home plate entrance<br />
(and provide fans a “peaceful refuge” and restaurants,<br />
concession stands and outdoor terraces)<br />
and lush landscaping each reinforce the regional<br />
design approach of HOK Sport (executive architect)<br />
and Antoine Predock (design architect). To<br />
make the San Diego experience complete,<br />
there’s even a patch of beach behind the rightcenter<br />
field fence.<br />
Illume/M-E Engineers, Wheat Ridge, CO, was<br />
responsible for all architectural <strong>light</strong>ing, including<br />
the plaza outside the stadium, the garden buildings,<br />
the stadium façade, the concourses, restaurants,<br />
suites, as well as the sports <strong>light</strong>ing.<br />
SAN DIEGO TO<br />
PHOTOS: TIMOTHY HURSLEY<br />
The Core<br />
30 www.iesna.org December 2005 LD+A 31
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
P R O J E C T<br />
By combining different <strong>light</strong> sources,<br />
designers were able to accentuate one<br />
of the sandstone “garden buildings”<br />
(left), as well as the industrial steel and<br />
precast concrete stadium infrastructure.<br />
“Inconspicuous” is the word most often used to describe<br />
the design approach. Indeed, there is an almost complete<br />
absence of decorative <strong>light</strong>ing elements. “It’s not your typical<br />
ballpark with lots of overhead <strong>light</strong>ing,” says Joy<br />
Yamada of Illume/M-E Engineers. “The <strong>light</strong>ing of Petco<br />
Park distills <strong>light</strong>ing design to the very basics: <strong>light</strong> reveals<br />
architecture and stages a comfortable and exciting nighttime<br />
experience. Because of Petco’s monumental scale, it<br />
was essential to provide a multi-layered <strong>light</strong>ing design<br />
that balances and articulates the building’s unique forms,<br />
rich limestone palette and desert landscape, as well as provide<br />
the functional requirements for fan amenities, assembly,<br />
circulation, hospitality and operations.”<br />
Lighting for Scale<br />
Designers used a combination of different <strong>light</strong> sources<br />
with excellent color rendering capabilities for architectural<br />
flood<strong>light</strong>ing and more localized <strong>light</strong>ing. Light levels<br />
and fixture locations lead people through the stadium,<br />
creating a staging hierarchy that reinforces the scale and<br />
energy of the facility.<br />
Ceramic metal halide up<strong>light</strong>s (70-W) wash the stone<br />
façades of the garden buildings and high<strong>light</strong> palm trees.<br />
Along with other plaza <strong>light</strong>ing systems, they create layers<br />
of <strong>light</strong> that “downsize” the stadium at the entrance<br />
near home plate.<br />
Yamada calls the <strong>light</strong> fixtures “utilitarian. ...There was<br />
not a huge budget available. We used a standard kit of<br />
parts and ‘hid’ them.” For example, shielded compact fluorescent<br />
step<strong>light</strong>s with 26-W double biax lamps provide<br />
a soft glow on the upper level of the garden buildings, texturizing<br />
the limestone walls. Palm trees are high<strong>light</strong>ed<br />
with 70-W ceramic metal halide lamps. In the club below,<br />
incandescent and halogen sources create a lantern effect.<br />
As patrons walk to the garden buildings, intimate lowlevel<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing with affordable, continuous 3000K lensed<br />
strip<strong>light</strong>s, is concealed beneath planters, providing a<br />
strong visual link between the stadium and these structures.<br />
For the stadium façade, up<strong>light</strong>s located at steel<br />
columns and upper sunscreens use 70-W ceramic metal<br />
halide lamps. Shielded area flood<strong>light</strong>s, with 250-W<br />
32 www.iesna.org
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
P R O J E C T<br />
Block Party<br />
The $449.4 million ballpark complex is just one piece<br />
of a 26-block downtown redevelopment initiative that<br />
includes restaurants, shopping, museums and other<br />
tourist attractions. As a result, Petco’s sports <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
can’t upset the neighbors.<br />
“Each project has its own unique issues, and Petco had<br />
more than its share,” says Ed Ragain, president of M-E<br />
Engineers, who was responsible for the sports <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
aspect. “Direct glare and indirect reflective glare were<br />
significant issues in the design process due to the location<br />
of the park, existing development and proposed<br />
high-rise development around the park. Glare models<br />
were prepared to support the impact the sports <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
would have on the environment, along with a detailed<br />
inventory of all existing buildings in a four-block radius<br />
around the park.”<br />
As is common in stadium projects, <strong>light</strong> trespass considerations<br />
also factored in. “Several <strong>light</strong>ing and environmental<br />
goals were presented to us by the city, or permission<br />
for the project would be in jeopardy,” says<br />
Ragain. “Dark Sky issues, surrounding roadway issues,<br />
hotel room views into the seating bowl at night, the team<br />
owner’s condominium viewing into the bowl at night<br />
and the waterfront environment all were addressed during<br />
design.”<br />
Inside the stadium, <strong>light</strong>ing hangs off the front of two<br />
200-ft high infield towers—vertical structures behind<br />
home plate that house suites and also serve to break up<br />
the seating bowl, creating different “neighborhoods”<br />
within the stadium. “The design architect wanted a different<br />
‘look’ from other ballparks,” says Ragain.<br />
Consequently, normal sports <strong>light</strong> racks could not be<br />
used for these <strong>light</strong>s. Other issues inside the bowl were<br />
shadow control for high definition <strong>light</strong>ing and balance of<br />
illumination across the playing field.<br />
Lighting solutions included mixing 2000-watt and<br />
1500-watt <strong>products</strong> along with special glare and spill <strong>light</strong><br />
shielding. The shielding was provided for sports fixtures<br />
Two “garden buildings” (foreground center and right)<br />
frame the home plate entrance. A silhoutte <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
approach provides drama and contrast.<br />
metal halide lamps, provide ambient <strong>light</strong> for the main<br />
and upper concourses. Continuous wallwashers with fluorescent<br />
lamps provide a uniform soft glow on stucco<br />
walls and steel trusses on the main and club levels.<br />
GE supplied the <strong>light</strong>ing for Petco Park, and the project<br />
received a 2004 GE Edison Award of Merit.<br />
‘Inconspicuous’ is the word<br />
most often used to describe the<br />
design approach. Indeed, there is<br />
an almost complete absence of<br />
decorative <strong>light</strong>ing elements<br />
with direct line of sight to areas outside the bowl at<br />
motorist intersections. The fixture aiming strategy<br />
included multiple full-zone aiming schemes to control<br />
hard line shadows on the playing field. “This aiming<br />
strategy was created by our staff for NBA and NHL arenas<br />
around the country, and we have incorporated some<br />
of these ideas for outdoor facilities,” Ragain adds.<br />
On the field, inside the stadium gates and out on the<br />
plaza grounds, Petco Park embodies San Diego. It’s no<br />
surprise a Southern California surfer boy like Ryan<br />
Klesko feels right at home.<br />
About the Designers: Martin E. Ragain, LEED AP,<br />
is president and co-founder of M-E Engineers, Inc.<br />
His experience includes sports facilities, institutional,<br />
health care, historic renovations, industrial, science<br />
and technology, commercial, and power generation<br />
facilities. Mr. Ragain has authored technical<br />
reports on sports <strong>light</strong>ing for the NFL, NBA, NHL,<br />
and MLB along with providing sports <strong>light</strong>ing and<br />
environmental impact studies for several new professional sports facilities<br />
around the world. He has received multiple IIDA Awards for his<br />
sports projects.<br />
Joy Yamada is an associate at Illume/M-E Engineers<br />
and director of the <strong>light</strong>ing department for six<br />
offices in the U.S. and London. Project experience<br />
includes commercial office buildings, master planning,<br />
hospitality, retail and residential. She is an<br />
associate member of the IALD.<br />
Krystof Pavek, Member IESNA (1991), formerly of<br />
Illume M-E Engineers, is now designer/owner of<br />
Luminatica, a <strong>light</strong>ing design consulting firm in<br />
Rancho Santa Fe, CA, and product designer with<br />
Aurora<strong>light</strong>, Inc., Carlsbad, CA. He holds a Masters<br />
degree in <strong>light</strong>ing from Rensselaer Polytechnic<br />
Institute’s Lighting Research Center, and has<br />
received four design awards.<br />
December 2005 LD+A 33
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . E S. IP G. ROJECT N. T. R. E N. D. S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . E S. IPROJECT<br />
G. N. T. R. E N. D. S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
PHOTO: RICHARD PAYNE<br />
Large-scale pendant lanterns at the main<br />
entrance and limited exterior <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
give the building architectural form.<br />
Weekend Warriors<br />
to World-Class<br />
pus amenity. Lighting for this facility needs<br />
to address the wide range of uses housed in<br />
the same facility and wrap them all up in an<br />
energized, upscale look. Before any <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
for the interior was considered, an inviting<br />
exterior presence had to be established for the<br />
center that worked both day and night.<br />
Working closely with Hughes Group Architects,<br />
Horton Lees Brogden (HLB) designed <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
that would make sure the multiple views into<br />
the building became glowing advertisements<br />
at night that beckon the passerby to enter and<br />
explore. Large-scale pendant lanterns at the<br />
main entrance and limited exterior building<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing proved to be an effective and economical<br />
solution that gives the building form.<br />
Full Workout<br />
Meanwhile, the project scope for the interior<br />
encompassed everything you would<br />
expect to find in this new generation of<br />
recreational centers, including:<br />
Natatorium. The natatorium houses an<br />
Olympic-size pool with a 10-meter diving<br />
tower and spectator stands. Activities range<br />
from general recreational and instructional to<br />
full-blown NCAA competition. Along with the<br />
given <strong>light</strong>ing requirements for safety, corrosion<br />
resistance and incumbent <strong>light</strong>ing levels<br />
comes the need to add a little more “zip” to<br />
the natatorium during competitions. While<br />
the university was not interested in NBA-style<br />
spot-<strong>light</strong>ed player intros, HLB was able to<br />
provide a bit more “focus” on the pool and<br />
the swimmers by utilizing narrow distribution<br />
fixtures that pump the 500 lux of<br />
general/recreational <strong>light</strong>ing up to a tightly<br />
controlled 1000 lux on the pool alone. Two<br />
400-W pulse-start metal halide fixtures with<br />
two different <strong>light</strong>ing distributions were<br />
attached to the roof trusses and are serviced<br />
from a gantry that spans the natatorium. Four<br />
preset scenes were achieved with careful circuiting<br />
and low-voltage relay switching.<br />
Diving Tower. Two considerations must be<br />
met when <strong>light</strong>ing a diving tower. The diver<br />
must be able to see the surface of the water<br />
and the spectator has to see the diver. The<br />
speed at which this all happens adds an extra<br />
burden to the visual system and thus the<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing. Comprehensive studies were performed<br />
to ensure that the vertical illumination<br />
from the top of the diver’s trajectory to<br />
the water surface were uniform, of a high<br />
level (1000 lux) and did not create disability<br />
glare for the diver (particularly at the platform<br />
level). The vertical illumination was<br />
achieved through 150-W metal halide flood-<br />
Athletes<br />
LIGHTING DESIGN AT THE NEW<br />
UNIVERSITY OF HOUSTON<br />
RECREATION CENTER<br />
ACCOMMODATES ATHLETES OF<br />
ALL STRIPES<br />
The gym is no longer the sole domain of the jock. In fact,<br />
the gym isn’t just the gym anymore. It has become the<br />
athletic center. Along with the essential natatorium,<br />
gymnasium and weight room come leisure pools, climbing<br />
walls, water slides, a sea of exercise equipment and even the<br />
spa. The user base has logically expanded from the hard-core<br />
athlete to include everyone from the simply health-conscious to<br />
those just looking to relax and maybe find their next date.<br />
At 264,000 sq ft, the University of Houston’s new Campus<br />
Recreation and Wellness Center is the epitome of the new cam-<br />
Safety, corrosion resistance, proper <strong>light</strong>ing levels and even the<br />
need to add some spark to NCAA swimming competitions drove<br />
the <strong>light</strong>ing design of the natatorium.<br />
PHOTO: TIMOTHY HURSLEY<br />
34 www.iesna.org<br />
December 2005 LD+A 35
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . E S . I PG . ROJECT N . T . R . E N . D . S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . E S . I PROJECT G . N . T . R . E N . D . S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
<strong>light</strong>s that cross-lit the tower at 45 deg on<br />
both sides (in plan view). Lighting of the<br />
diver’s path close to the water surface added<br />
the extra levels needed at the surface (in<br />
combination with a water sprayer that creates<br />
surface turbulence).<br />
Multi-Purpose Gymnasium. While traditional<br />
gymnasiums were typically <strong>light</strong>ed<br />
with 400-W pulse-start metal halide high-bay<br />
fixtures, the multi-purpose gymnasium needed<br />
more attention because of its diverse uses.<br />
In both the traditional and multi-use gymnasium<br />
(as well as the natatorium), <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
designers recommended that the ceilings and<br />
ceiling elements (acoustical panels, ducts,<br />
etc.) be of a high reflectance value to promote<br />
visual comfort and reduce brightness contrast<br />
between the fixtures and the ceiling beyond.<br />
In the multi-purpose gymnasium the nearly<br />
white ceiling provided an opportunity for<br />
up<strong>light</strong>ing to create the lower, soft ambient<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing levels required for non-athletic uses.<br />
Asymmetric fluorescent up<strong>light</strong>s were located<br />
on the lower flange of the trusses and circuited<br />
to provide three levels of <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
(200/300/500 lux) through switching.<br />
Exercise Equipment Area. No matter<br />
how you try to work it, you always end up<br />
sweating on your back in the exercise area.<br />
To minimize the pain of exercise, HLB utilized<br />
pendant-hung linear fluorescent<br />
up<strong>light</strong>s to provide comfortable general illumination<br />
no matter which way the user<br />
was facing and just enough small accent<br />
<strong>light</strong>s to high<strong>light</strong> the sparkle of the hightech<br />
exercise equipment in an effort to<br />
reinforce the dynamic nature of the space.<br />
Rock-Climbing Wall. The big enticement to<br />
visit the athletic center is a view of the rockclimbing<br />
wall as you enter the facility. It is seen<br />
just beyond the check-in desk on the opposite<br />
side of the palm tree-filled rotunda with its<br />
jumbo video screen. The climbing wall clearly<br />
had to stand out amid all this visual competition.<br />
The right <strong>light</strong>ing to create this visual<br />
focus and to provide a user-friendly, safe experience<br />
was key. PAR38 metal halide fixtures<br />
were located at the ceiling level and at various<br />
PHOTO: TIMOTHY HURSLEY<br />
At the rock-climbing wall, the angle of the<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing was critical to dramatize the craggy<br />
texture of the wall, but without creating<br />
disability glare.<br />
The ceiling in the multi-purpose gym has a high reflectance value to promote visual<br />
comfort and reduce brightness contrast between the fixtures and the ceiling beyond.<br />
PHOTO: COURTESY OF HLB<br />
36 www.iesna.org<br />
December 2005 LD+A 37
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. O. V. E R. S. T. O . R Y. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C O. V. E . R S. T. O . R Y. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
The city of Memphis is a crock<br />
pot full of musical flavors. Rock<br />
n’ roll, jazz, blues, country and<br />
gospel can all be found and heard in<br />
the city, especially when the tunes<br />
are blaring from one of America’s<br />
liveliest entertainment districts,<br />
Beale Street. However, in 2001, a different<br />
kind of sound—the noise of<br />
cheering crowds and squeaky sneakers—was<br />
heard when the city<br />
acquired its first NBA franchise.<br />
Bear in mind, the Grizzlies franchise<br />
spent its first six seasons in<br />
Vancouver, playing to a half-empty<br />
arena. After the Canadian venture<br />
failed, Memphis emerged as the primary<br />
destination for relocation when<br />
FedEx (headquartered in the city)<br />
joined the effort to lure the franchise<br />
to the area with the promise of a new,<br />
state-of-the-art multipurpose facility.<br />
The project’s total cost is often<br />
quoted at $250 million, but that figure<br />
includes expenditures for renovations<br />
and upgrades at the nearby<br />
Pyramid, which served as the team’s<br />
interim home arena. Completed in<br />
2004, the FedExForum features<br />
more than 800,000 sq ft of facility<br />
space, making it the largest public<br />
building construction project in the<br />
city’s history. Besides NBA action,<br />
the 18,200-seat arena also hosts<br />
home games for the NCAA Memphis<br />
Tigers, as well as showcasing hockey/ice<br />
shows (integrated ice floor<br />
option), concerts, family and trade<br />
shows, rodeos and indoor motorsports.<br />
Inside the facility, guest comforts<br />
and amenities include a main<br />
concourse, 64 total suites (28 lower<br />
level; 32 at club level; four party<br />
suites at club level), a team store,<br />
casual sports bar, premium restaurants<br />
and lounges, and interactive<br />
displays and exhibits. Additional<br />
exterior components include a fivefloor<br />
adjoining garage for 1200 vehicles<br />
and a four-story administrative<br />
office building, which also houses<br />
the Smithsonian Institution’s Rock<br />
N’ Soul Museum.<br />
Grasping Your Roots<br />
The New Memphis Arena Public<br />
Building Authority, which oversaw<br />
the construction process, tapped<br />
sports architecture and engineering<br />
firm Ellerbe Becket, Kansas City,<br />
MO, to handle a large portion of the<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing and architectural needs. The<br />
areas included the team store, all<br />
restaurants and bars (except for the<br />
Backstage restaurant), concourses,<br />
team store, lobby, event floor and<br />
seating areas, dressing rooms and<br />
the exterior <strong>light</strong>ing. Liles <strong>Engineering</strong><br />
and Looney Ricks Kiss, both<br />
Memphis-based firms, and general<br />
contractor MA Mortenson, Minneapolis,<br />
MN, were also instrumental in<br />
the completion of the forum.<br />
Designers wanted to develop a<br />
facility that integrated the culture of<br />
the NBA into the historical scale and<br />
context of the neighborhood.<br />
Seeking inspiration, Ellerbe Becket<br />
referred back to another one of its<br />
NBA arena projects, the Conseco<br />
Field House, Indianapolis, IN.<br />
For the FedExForm, this connection<br />
to the surrounding area begins<br />
when spectators make their way<br />
towards the arena’s 35,000 sq ft<br />
exterior plaza, which acts as a runway<br />
for fans arriving and departing<br />
the facility. Designers selected a<br />
The forum’s combination of a large<br />
glass façade and high interior<br />
footcandle illumination levels<br />
created a nighttime transparent<br />
effect that connects the exterior<br />
activity to the interior activity.<br />
Fed Excellent<br />
PHOTOS: TIM HURSLEY<br />
THE FEDEXFORUM MIGHT BE IN THE HEART OF<br />
THE MEMPHIS MUSIC SCENE, BUT WITH ITS INSTANT<br />
SUCCESS, IT’S FEELING ANYTHING BUT THE BLUES<br />
By John-Michael Kobes<br />
Adventure<br />
40 www.iesna.org December 2005 LD+A 41
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
C O V E R S T O R Y<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
C O V E R S T O R Y<br />
Blue Note lounge combines the<br />
nostalgia of Memphis blues with<br />
a contemporary setting.<br />
A view from one of the forum’s 32<br />
private club suites.<br />
darkened red hue (four shades of it)<br />
for the arena façade, which also<br />
coincides with the red-brick finish<br />
that can be found on some of the<br />
older buildings, as well as the new<br />
Gibson Guitar Co. Once inside,<br />
guests are greeted by a 12,500 sq ft<br />
main entry, which features the<br />
Grizzlies Den team store and the<br />
Jack Daniel’s Old No. 7 sports bar<br />
and the team’s practice court.<br />
The forum’s combination of a<br />
large glass façade and high interior<br />
footcandle illumination levels created<br />
a nighttime transparent effect<br />
that connects the exterior activity to<br />
the interior activity. This was<br />
accomplished by using an industrial<br />
grade highbay 16 in. prismatic<br />
Incandescent down<strong>light</strong>s, pendants<br />
and wall sconces <strong>light</strong> Opus, a fine<br />
dining facility with views of the<br />
arena floor.<br />
acrylic reflector with one, 400-W<br />
pulse start metal halide (in the<br />
lobby) and an industrial grade highbay<br />
22 in. borosilicate glass optic<br />
with one, 1000-W pulse start metal<br />
halide (the practice court areas).<br />
Both fixtures were provided by<br />
Hubbell Lighting. The concourse<br />
also includes 70-W metal halide<br />
down<strong>light</strong>s and eight in. 70-W<br />
direct pendant cylinder fixtures,<br />
both from Prescolite.<br />
In The Zone<br />
Located on the main concourse is<br />
the First Tennessee Club which<br />
offers seat holders a few different<br />
dining and socializing options. The<br />
first is Opus, a 350-seat fine dining<br />
Designers wanted to develop a facility that<br />
integrated the culture of the NBA into the<br />
historical scale and context of the<br />
neighborhood<br />
facility that features hardwood<br />
floors, a 30-seat bar and a number<br />
of unique views of the arena floor.<br />
Offering a hipper, less formal<br />
atmosphere is the Blue Note lounge,<br />
which combines the nostalgia of<br />
Memphis blues with a contemporary<br />
style. There are also several<br />
mini restaurants around the concourse.<br />
These were fitted with<br />
incandescent down<strong>light</strong>s for general<br />
illumination and several pendants<br />
and wall sconces for accent <strong>light</strong>ing.<br />
This private level also features 32<br />
club suites and 80 club boxes. Suite<br />
corridors on this level are equipped<br />
with eight in. 32-W cylinders, which<br />
were installed in the portion of corridor<br />
with no ceiling, while four in.<br />
75-W MR16 accent luminaires were<br />
used in areas with a ceiling.<br />
“To bring out the different environments<br />
and displays along the<br />
interior of the public concourses,<br />
the <strong>light</strong>ing levels vary to enhance<br />
both the wayfinding and the fan<br />
experience,” said Jon Neimuth, lead<br />
designer, Ellerbe Becket. “For example,<br />
in darker transitional areas<br />
there’s accent <strong>light</strong>ing on wall displays<br />
and in areas of thematic<br />
development there are high levels of<br />
illumination.”<br />
Floor Control<br />
The building is operated by a<br />
MicroLite Lighting control system.<br />
There is main control in the engineer<br />
room as well as a control room<br />
overlooking the event floor and<br />
seating area which is known as the<br />
arena bowl. The control room features<br />
T8 2x2 and 2x4 troffers<br />
(Columbia Lighting) and 35-W, 20<br />
deg cylinder spot luminaires (USA<br />
Illumination Inc.). Quad controls<br />
42 www.iesna.org<br />
December 2005 LD+A 43
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
C O V E R S T O R Y<br />
The control room overlooking the event floor<br />
features T8 troffers plus 35-W spot fixtures.<br />
activate all the <strong>light</strong>ing for nonevent<br />
times when the arena is being<br />
cleaned or set up for an event.<br />
Barbara Hoppas, principal and electrical<br />
engineer (formerly of Ellerbe<br />
Becket), said, “The system is set up<br />
so that there are two levels of control:<br />
the relays must be activated<br />
(on) and then there is also individual<br />
control (<strong>light</strong> switches or dimmers)<br />
in the individual areas (office,<br />
suite toilet, concessions, etc).”<br />
The arena bowl was designed primarily<br />
for two sports (basketball<br />
and hockey). Currently there is no<br />
professional hockey team playing at<br />
the arena, however, <strong>light</strong>ing can be<br />
incorporated if needed. Other <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
systems were included so that<br />
the 1000-W clear metal halide Z-<br />
lamp with blackout shield sport<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing is only used for sporting<br />
events. These include a 1000-W<br />
clear metal halide Z-lamp work<strong>light</strong>s<br />
(Musco Lighting); 1500-W<br />
quartz halogen house <strong>light</strong>s (GE);<br />
and source four 575-W aisle <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
(ETC), which were fitted with<br />
framed shutters and gobos, so <strong>light</strong><br />
is limited to the aisles and<br />
vestibules during concerts and<br />
other blackout times like player<br />
introductions and half-time shows.<br />
The 45,000 pound scoreboard is<br />
22 ft-high x 38 ft-wide and includes<br />
two 360 deg full-color LED screens<br />
on the top and bottom and four additional<br />
color video screens on all sides.<br />
When asked what he was most<br />
proud of after the completion of the<br />
project, Niemuth said, “The way in<br />
which the project seems as active<br />
and vibrant during the evening as it<br />
does during the day. The project<br />
through its different architectural<br />
design elements takes on two distinct<br />
visual characteristics.”<br />
For years, Beale Street had the gigs,<br />
but today, it finally has game, too.<br />
About the Designers:<br />
During his 10 years with<br />
Ellerbe Becket, Jon D.<br />
Niemuth, AIA, has been<br />
responsible for leading the<br />
design and planning of<br />
such projects as Qwest<br />
Field, Exhibition Center<br />
and Parking Garage, Seattle, WA; the University<br />
of Connecticut, Rentschler Field, East Hartford,<br />
CT, and the George Mason University<br />
Fieldhouse, Fairfax, VA. Mr. Niemuth’s academic<br />
background includes a Bachelor of<br />
Architectural Studies, Master of Architecture<br />
and Master of Urban Planning/Urban Design<br />
from the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.<br />
Barbara L.S. Hoppas,<br />
Member IESNA (2001), is<br />
currently principal and<br />
president of Bredson &<br />
Associates, Inc. Ms. Hoppas<br />
holds a Bachelor of<br />
Science in architectural<br />
engineering from Kansas<br />
State University, Manhattan, KS. She was formerly<br />
with Ellerbe Becket, where she managed<br />
electrical design for professional and collegiate<br />
sports facilities.<br />
44 www.iesna.org
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
I I D A P R O J E C T<br />
The main trading floor incorporates<br />
asymmetric cove <strong>light</strong>s mounted within<br />
specially designed ceiling panels.<br />
PHOTO CREDIT: JON MILLER, HEDRICH BLESSING<br />
THE BANK OF AMERICA TRADING<br />
FLOOR SATISFIES LIGHT-SENSITIVE<br />
TRADERS WHILE ADDING SIZZLE TO<br />
THE CHARLOTTE, NC, SKYLINE<br />
UP<br />
TRADING<br />
How do you <strong>light</strong> a 50-ft tall trading floor<br />
for 600 traders in a building with glazed<br />
walls, north, south, east and west facing<br />
clerestories, while also creating a visually exciting,<br />
comfortable environment for one of the<br />
world’s largest banking institutions You<br />
engage a team of consultants with expertise in<br />
integrating all of the vast mechanical, electrical,<br />
telecommunications, life safety, and acoustical,<br />
architectural and <strong>light</strong>ing systems.<br />
The Bank of America engaged the same<br />
design team that designed the trading arena for<br />
UBS in Stamford—the largest column free-trading<br />
arena (800 traders) in the world. The collaborative<br />
was led by Mustafa Abadon of Skidmore<br />
Owings & Merrill (SOM); Cosentini Associates<br />
served as the MEP consultants; and Cosentini<br />
Lighting Design worked as the <strong>light</strong>ing consultants.<br />
Cosentini <strong>light</strong>ing designers Stephen<br />
Margulies and Marianne Maloney received an<br />
2005 IIDA Award of Excellence for the project.<br />
Multi-functional Ceiling<br />
There were several challenges to this project.<br />
The first was to develop an integrated ceiling<br />
design that would accommodate air, sprinklers<br />
and <strong>light</strong>s, and one that would complement the<br />
architecture. A combination of indirect and<br />
direct <strong>light</strong>ing provides the best visual environment<br />
for this type of space. The wing-like ceiling<br />
design for the main trading floor evolved<br />
from of a series of models and mockups. This<br />
ceiling design had to complement the unique<br />
roof structure designed by SOM and accommodate<br />
all of the <strong>light</strong>ing components. A full-size<br />
mockup was helpful in determining the effect<br />
December 2005 LD+A 47
The open glazed north wall<br />
accommodates day<strong>light</strong>,<br />
creates a stunning view<br />
into the trading floor and<br />
makes for a dramatic<br />
addition to the skyline.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
I I D A P R O J E C T<br />
at the ends of the ceiling panels where the<br />
dimension eventually approaches zero as the<br />
wing panel touches the flat ceiling. The last<br />
cove <strong>light</strong> fixture had to be separately dimmed<br />
to make the appropriate transition. The main<br />
trading floor incorporates two rows of concealed<br />
asymmetric distribution fluorescent<br />
cove <strong>light</strong>s mounted within the folded ceiling<br />
panels. High output T5 lamps were used in<br />
small optical assemblies.<br />
Additional recessed ceramic metal halide<br />
lamps were used to provide the direct <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
component. The ceramic metal halide lamps<br />
were used for their good color and reasonably<br />
long lamp life. To complete the three-dimensional<br />
modeling of the ceiling, semi-recessed wallmounted<br />
compact fluorescent up<strong>light</strong>s were<br />
used at the edges of the room. These fixtures illuminated<br />
the underside of the ceiling panels. The<br />
combination of these three <strong>light</strong>ing components<br />
provided up to 45 footcandles, glare free.<br />
A preset dimming system was designed to<br />
control all of the trading area <strong>light</strong>ing systems,<br />
maximize day<strong>light</strong> harvesting and time-of-day<br />
scheduling. The dimming system also controlled<br />
all of the automated shade systems and the all of<br />
the non-dimmed <strong>light</strong>ing loads throughout the<br />
facility. The integrated control system allowed us<br />
to easily commission the entire project in one<br />
day and one evening. The system also benefits<br />
users, allowing them full command from one<br />
point of control, and provides significant energy<br />
savings through time-of-day control, in addition<br />
to the day<strong>light</strong> harvesting.<br />
Making Use of Day<strong>light</strong><br />
The second challenge was to assess the effectiveness<br />
of all of the fenestrations for what we<br />
call “useable” day<strong>light</strong>ing. Traders have a reputation<br />
for wanting to work in a dark room.<br />
They’re jokingly called “vampires” because of<br />
their sensitivity to <strong>light</strong>. This reputation comes<br />
from years of exposure to bad <strong>light</strong>ing equipment<br />
and designs used in conjunction with bad<br />
monitors and trading turrets. Today’s monitors<br />
are much more tolerant of ambient <strong>light</strong> than<br />
those used five years ago. The <strong>light</strong>ing systems<br />
do not have to be designed around reflections<br />
in monitors any longer.<br />
Extensive day<strong>light</strong>ing studies were performed<br />
to evaluate the extent of useable day<strong>light</strong> and to<br />
develop a day<strong>light</strong> control strategy for all of the<br />
fenestrations. Each fenestration was assessed<br />
for sky brightness and direct sun. A solar tracking<br />
diagram was created to develop appropriate<br />
shielding elements for each fenestration. The<br />
shades on the north wall were angled 23 deg<br />
from true north to accommodate the buildings<br />
orientation. Each of the clerestories had individually<br />
controlled shades. All of the shades were<br />
designed to have 40 percent transmission to<br />
Ceiling panels contain<br />
indirect <strong>light</strong>ing and<br />
recessed down<strong>light</strong>ing to<br />
provide up to<br />
45 footcandles, glare-free.<br />
Traders have a reputation<br />
for wanting to work in a<br />
dark room. They’re jokingly<br />
called ‘vampires’ because of<br />
their sensitivity to <strong>light</strong><br />
reduce exposure. Blackout shades were considered<br />
but deemed unnecessary.<br />
This trading floor optimized the available day<strong>light</strong>.<br />
Automated shades were designed to track<br />
the sun and to only allow diffuse day<strong>light</strong> into<br />
the room. The electric <strong>light</strong>s are either dimmed<br />
or turned off when not required. The 50-ft tall<br />
north wall of glass also had automated shades<br />
to provide protection from excessive sky brightness,<br />
which occurred early in the morning<br />
throughout the year and at varying times during<br />
the work day. During commissioning of the<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing and shades, designers established a<br />
time of day when the shades should rise, should<br />
they be down because of sky brightness conditions.<br />
When the 4:00 bell rang that signifies the<br />
close of the markets, the shades would rise.<br />
That great idea only lasted a few days. The<br />
December 2005 LD+A 49
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
I I D A P R O J E C T<br />
The 50-ft high winged ceiling integrates<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing, air and sprinklers.<br />
traders, to the dismay of the <strong>light</strong>ing designers,<br />
wanted the north wall to always be open regardless<br />
of sky conditions. Who would have guessed<br />
that these creatures of the night would want to<br />
work in near full day<strong>light</strong> Each project brings<br />
new lessons learned.<br />
Meanwhile, the support areas around the<br />
trading arena were designed for full flexibility.<br />
Enclosed offices can be created or demolished<br />
without any construction trades. All architectural,<br />
mechanical, electrical, fire protection and<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing systems were modular in design allowing<br />
for restacking without major construction.<br />
This was very attractive to the bank. This strategy,<br />
although having higher first costs, has a<br />
two-year payback and is very sustainable. Not<br />
disposing of construction debris every time an<br />
office is changed has a great impact on the<br />
environment. To allow for partition relocation<br />
without the need for fixture relocation, 24-in.<br />
long, eight-in. wide recessed fluorescent <strong>light</strong><br />
fixtures were spaced on the five-ft planning<br />
module. Mechanical and fire protection systems<br />
followed suit, as well.<br />
A Second Floor<br />
A second trading floor was designed with<br />
similar <strong>light</strong>ing design principles. The ceiling<br />
height was approximately 30 ft, but the ceiling<br />
design was very different from the main trading<br />
arena. Wall-mounted, semi-recessed compact<br />
fluorescent ceiling wash <strong>light</strong>s were applied to<br />
provide the room with an indirect <strong>light</strong>ing component.<br />
Ceramic metal halide down<strong>light</strong>s were<br />
integrated into the ceiling to provide a direct<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing component. The down<strong>light</strong>s were<br />
installed in slots in the ceiling to further reduce<br />
the brightness and for visual interest.<br />
This trading floor faces south and a unique<br />
shading system was provided to protect the<br />
50 www.iesna.org
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
I I D A P R O J E C T<br />
Blue fluorescent billboard fixtures illuminate the<br />
cutouts in the roof and are visible to occupants of<br />
other building and even plane passengers.<br />
occupants from extensive direct solar glare.<br />
These large motorized wall panels with a unique<br />
luminous panel can be opened or closed<br />
depending upon the day<strong>light</strong>ing condition. The<br />
combination of direct and indirect <strong>light</strong>ing created<br />
the appropriate visual environment.<br />
The other interior spaces were designed to<br />
promote comfortable breakout areas for the<br />
traders. “Mixer” stations were created for the<br />
open areas where the traders could relax, get a<br />
beverage or get their mail. These millwork stations<br />
were designed to incorporate indirect<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing to provide a spacious comfortable public<br />
area. Cutout panels in the ceiling combined<br />
with compact fluorescent down<strong>light</strong>s, decorative<br />
wall sconces and wallwashers helped create<br />
a unique atmosphere.<br />
Civic Image<br />
The project as viewed from the city creates a<br />
new and unique image for this banking institution.<br />
The open trading floor appears to look like<br />
a futuristic loading bay for aircraft. The open<br />
glazed north wall allows great sightlines into this<br />
dramatic addition to the skyline. The unique<br />
image extends to the sky, as the building is visible<br />
to incoming planes and occupants of other<br />
buildings. Blue fluorescent billboard fixtures illuminate<br />
the cutouts in the roof structure.<br />
All of the lamps specified were extremely<br />
efficient and provided exceptional color rendering<br />
properties throughout the facility. All <strong>light</strong><br />
sources used are rated for long life making this<br />
facility easy to maintain. The trading area will<br />
be group re-lamped once a year over a weekend<br />
to ease maintenance. Tungsten halogen<br />
lamps were used in few specialty areas minimizing<br />
maintenance efforts even further.<br />
Finally, the energy utilized for the project was<br />
extremely low. The overall project consumed a<br />
connected load of 1.4 watts per sq ft. The<br />
“effective” power density was reduced by an<br />
estimated 50 percent, utilizing only .7 watts<br />
per sq ft when considering the benefits of day<strong>light</strong><br />
harvesting and time-of-day scheduling.<br />
The design team was surprised when it ran the<br />
numbers. It caused the team to go back and reanalyze<br />
the design to make sure it had not<br />
overlooked anything. But it all seemed to add<br />
up on the Bank of America trading floor.<br />
About the Designer: Stephen Margulies,<br />
Member IESNA (1981), IALD, joined<br />
Cosentini Associates in 1982 and is now<br />
director of Cosentini Lighting Design. His<br />
award-winning <strong>light</strong>ing design projects<br />
include the Disney Feature Animation<br />
Building in Glendale, CA; 745 Fifth<br />
Avenue and IBM offices in New York, NY;<br />
and Two Logan Square and Bell Atlantic Headquarters in<br />
Philadelphia, PA—and now the Bank of America project in<br />
Charlotte, NC. Industry awards include the OSRAM Sylvania<br />
Energy and Environmental Design IIDA Award of Excellence;<br />
the IIDA Lumen Award; and the Guth Award of Merit. Mr.<br />
Margulies has lectured at Harvard University, the Cooper Union<br />
School of Architecture and for IESNA educational programs.<br />
December 2005 LD+A 51
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
P R O J E C T<br />
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
P R O J E C T<br />
SONIC TEMPLE<br />
The new <strong>light</strong>ing design will help<br />
bring out the temple’s detail at night,<br />
increase its visibility and help visitors<br />
and local Indonesians appreciate its<br />
magnificence.<br />
largest Buddhist temple in the world. In 2003, the first<br />
attempt at incorporating a <strong>light</strong>ing system was initiated<br />
with donations by General Electric Asia, but with little success.<br />
This design was conceived by an Indonesian <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
engineer who created equal spacing of pole <strong>light</strong>s on the<br />
perimeter of the temple’s four sides. This resulted in undifferentiated,<br />
uniform <strong>light</strong> that failed to show the detail of<br />
the Buddha statues and wall carvings.<br />
Rebirth<br />
At one time, day<strong>light</strong> was<br />
the only <strong>light</strong> that shined<br />
on the temple.<br />
PHOTOS: ROBERT DANIELS<br />
FOR MORE THAN EIGHT<br />
CENTURIES, THE BOROBUDUR<br />
TEMPLE STOOD SILENT<br />
ONCE THE SUN SET.<br />
THANKS TO AN UPDATED,<br />
CAMOUFLAGED LIGHTING<br />
SYSTEM,THIS ANCIENT<br />
INDONESIAN TREASURE NOW<br />
HAS A TRUE NIGHT LIFE<br />
In order to see the Borobudur Temple in person, timing<br />
was always an issue. Whether it was how much<br />
time was spent traveling to its location (Yogykarta,<br />
Indonesia) or the fact that viewing the 1200-year old<br />
temple could only be done during the day, for nearly<br />
eight centuries, these two concerns plagued both worshipers<br />
and visitors. Now, let’s fast forward to present<br />
times. Thanks to modern luxuries like air travel and an<br />
updated <strong>light</strong>ing installation, visitors have the opportunity<br />
to see the temple, day or night.<br />
The temple stands at 113 ft tall and spans 163,000 sq ft,<br />
making it the largest monument in Southeast Asia and the<br />
Two years after that attempt, Brilliant Lighting Design,<br />
Miami, FL, was assigned to redesign the <strong>light</strong>ing. The<br />
main stipulation by Borobudur Park officials was the fixtures<br />
had to be mounted on poles, hidden from daytime<br />
view by trees. Lighting designer Robert Daniels analyzed<br />
the original <strong>light</strong>ing plan to determine which fixtures<br />
were satisfactory, which could be reused elsewhere and<br />
which would not be used. Changes included the addition<br />
of four 80 ft <strong>light</strong> poles at each of the temple’s four corners<br />
to shine a bright white <strong>light</strong> on the highest level of<br />
the monument, as well as incorporating 48 additional<br />
fixtures and lamps and repositioning current <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
poles. General Electric Indonesia provided engineering<br />
support, field supervision, as well as paying for the cost<br />
of new poles, footings, wire and fixtures.<br />
Dipping Into The Past<br />
The lava rock structure consists of seven levels that correspond<br />
to the seven steps to en<strong>light</strong>enment in Buddhist<br />
tradition. The first level carvings (at ground level) portray<br />
mankind at its lowest spiritual existence. There are five<br />
levels above the ground level that have detailed carvings<br />
of stories about Buddha and the history of the Buddhist<br />
52 www.iesna.org<br />
April December 2005 2005 LD+A LD+A 53
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P R. O. J . E C. T . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
The upper level with the Buddha and stupas would be illuminated to 350 to 400 lux, approximately eight times brighter than the lower walls.<br />
civilization in Java. The highest level is split into four sublevels<br />
where there are 72 bell-shaped stupas located in<br />
four concentric rings.<br />
With all of the walls containing carvings and Buddha<br />
statues it became apparent that the temple needed a special<br />
kind of <strong>light</strong>ing. To create a three-dimensional shape,<br />
the <strong>light</strong> would need to come at 45 deg angles and not<br />
The main stipulation for any<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing design was the fixtures<br />
had to be mounted on poles,<br />
hidden from day<strong>light</strong> view by trees<br />
straight on. After studying pictures of the temple, it was<br />
determined that angular key <strong>light</strong> would best bring out<br />
the vertical lines of the wall carvings and the protruding<br />
steps on each of the sides.<br />
To best achieve the angles of <strong>light</strong> near the middle<br />
stairway, the fixtures were located on the opposite side of<br />
the center pathway, so the <strong>light</strong> crossed sideways over<br />
the center path in a cross-fire pattern. Each cross-fire<br />
pole was located approximately 28-32 ft from the center<br />
walk. There are a total of eight cross-fire poles illuminating<br />
the four slanting pyramidal faces.<br />
The biggest problem was the distance from the pyramid<br />
face. The flat, bare apron varied in the distance from the<br />
tree line to the temple. Borobudur is a symmetrical structure<br />
with asymmetrical pole locations, so if the <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
output from each was equal then the effective illumination<br />
on the temple would be unequal. To compensate for this,<br />
four, 400-W MH fixtures on the close cross-fire poles (east<br />
and west sides) six, 400-W on the north side and eight,<br />
400-W on the south side were part of the design.<br />
The PF400 fixture was selected to do most of the crossfire<br />
work. The 3x2 beam optic pushed a soft spot of <strong>light</strong><br />
onto the walls of the pyramid 80 to 120 ft away without<br />
making hot spots. For the longer distance positions on<br />
the far corners of the south and north sides, two 400-W<br />
1x1 stadium <strong>light</strong>s were used on each of the cross-fire<br />
poles. The fixture height on the cross-fire poles was set at<br />
12 meters above the apron level to get all the cross-fire<br />
fixtures above a horizontal ledger line at the second level.<br />
However, each pole length had to be adjusted to the varying<br />
height of the footing below the apron grade. The<br />
result of the <strong>light</strong>ing was not only vertical shadowing of<br />
the wall carvings from the cross-fire technique, but a horizontal<br />
shadow line accenting the second level as the fixtures<br />
created down<strong>light</strong>ing over the ledge.<br />
The fill <strong>light</strong> used to cut the shadows from black to gray<br />
was accomplished by reusing the existing 1000-W quartz<br />
fixtures that had previously been installed. The quartz fixtures<br />
were located near the corners and aimed back<br />
54 www.iesna.org
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P R. O. J . E C. T. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
toward the center walkways. The quartz fixtures were all<br />
positioned at the edge of the apron. In total there were<br />
eight, 2000-W fixtures for top <strong>light</strong>ing, 44, 400-W cross fire<br />
fixtures, eight, 1000-W quartz fill fixtures and one, 250-W<br />
deluxe HPS on the lowest level.<br />
Three Colors<br />
The lamp selection was based on using three colors.<br />
The upper <strong>light</strong> on the tall poles were equipped with<br />
white metal halide (5500K) to signify purity. The middle<br />
five levels from the cross-fire poles have ceramic metal<br />
halide (3000K) to bathe the carvings and buddhas with<br />
halogen-like color. The existing quartz <strong>light</strong>s were close<br />
enough in kelvin temperature (2800K) to blend with the<br />
metal halide lamps. The exposed corner of the lowest<br />
level received single deluxe sodium in a deep red-yellow<br />
(2200K) to signify an earthier appearance.<br />
Light level tests were conducted on the stone and<br />
carvings. It was found that 45 to 70 lux of <strong>light</strong> on the<br />
facing produced the most favorable illumination for the<br />
key <strong>light</strong>. The fill was found to be best at five to eight<br />
lux or roughly 10:1 of key <strong>light</strong> to fill. The upper level<br />
with the Buddha and stupas would be illuminated to<br />
350 to 400 lux, approximately eight times brighter<br />
than the lower walls.<br />
Custom beam control louvers were added to all the fixtures.<br />
Concentric ring louvers were placed on the 20 in.<br />
diameter quartz heads, which limited the <strong>light</strong> to 40 deg.<br />
Egg crate louvers were placed on the PF400 to narrow the<br />
beams to a maximum of 25 deg. The PSFA fixtures<br />
received egg crate louvers to control <strong>light</strong> to 18 deg. The<br />
narrow spot 2000-W metal halide fixtures (on the corner<br />
poles) had a center beam of less than five deg with beam<br />
control allowing a maximum of 10 deg out. This beam control<br />
not only made the cross-fire <strong>light</strong>ing possible, but it also<br />
allowed for the precise aiming and illumination of the main<br />
center stupa (on the top) to be a totally different and separate<br />
color from the side faces from a distance of 150 ft.<br />
In Good Company<br />
During its long history, the Buddha statues on top level<br />
had only been seen by a select few sultans and priests<br />
during full moon nights. For two nights in August 2005,<br />
Daniels was given special permission to go up on the top<br />
level to photograph the Buddha statues and stupas. After<br />
those two nights, the 2000-W fixtures were aimed further<br />
up on the main center stupa to keep all the white<br />
<strong>light</strong> off the side faces.<br />
About the Designer: Robert Daniels, IALD,<br />
Member IESNA (1996), has been a <strong>light</strong>ing designer<br />
for more than 10 years in Miami, FL, serving the<br />
Southeast U.S., Latin America and Asia. Design<br />
awards include the GE Edison Award, IIDA Paul<br />
Waterbury Award of Excellence and the IIDA Award<br />
of Merit. Mr. Daniels is past chairman of the IESNA<br />
Building Façade, Bridge and Monument Lighting<br />
Committee. He also served on the IENSA Security Lighting Committee.<br />
The fill <strong>light</strong> used to cut the shadows from<br />
black to gray was created by reusing the<br />
existing 1000-W quartz fixtures that had<br />
previously been installed.<br />
April December 2005 2005 LD+A LD+A 55
IMAGE: COURTESY OF CHARLES EHRLICH<br />
C E N T U R Y S E R I E S : P I O N E E R S<br />
Computers and Lighting<br />
After exponential growth in the 1980s and ’90s, has development of<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing design software reached a lull<br />
By Emlyn Altman<br />
Designers and researchers have<br />
been calculating the effects of<br />
<strong>light</strong> for centuries—well<br />
before the use of computer technology.<br />
Many of the formulae and concepts<br />
used by <strong>light</strong>ing design software have<br />
been around since the late 1800s; but<br />
it has only been within the past four<br />
decades (and particularly the ’80s and<br />
’90s) that exponential growth in computer-related<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing design developments<br />
has occurred.<br />
Prior to the advent of computer<br />
aided design, one research study provided<br />
a major impact on <strong>light</strong>ing design<br />
calculations and foreshadowed a capability<br />
of current <strong>light</strong>ing design software.<br />
In 1945, Dr. Perry Moon and<br />
Prof. Domina Spencer submitted a<br />
paper to the IESNA that presented an<br />
“Interflection” method of calculating<br />
<strong>light</strong> for illuminating engineers to predict<br />
brightness and brightness ratios in<br />
interior spaces. Prior to this study,<br />
methods of predicting surface illumination—taking<br />
into account reflected<br />
<strong>light</strong>—were unavailable to <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
designers. Using an integration formula<br />
which considered inter-reflected <strong>light</strong><br />
in rooms of any shape, they calculated<br />
five different <strong>light</strong>ing conditions—indirect,<br />
direct, <strong>light</strong> troughs, diffusing<br />
globes and semi-direct illumination—<br />
and used the results to simulate “synthetic<br />
image” perspective views created<br />
from pieces of cut-out Munsell<br />
paper ironed together, each color corresponding<br />
to a specific reflectance<br />
value (Figure 1 andTable 1).<br />
This research led the way in establishing<br />
a 3-to-1 line-of-sight criterion<br />
for illuminating interior spaces used<br />
December 2005 LD+A 57
T A B L E 1<br />
Figure 1<br />
today. According to their concluding<br />
remarks, “The brightness distribution<br />
is of great importance in modern <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
design and thus a method for its<br />
predetermination is desirable for the<br />
illuminating engineer of the future.”<br />
This was realized nearly four decades<br />
later when the same “synthetic image”<br />
rendering capabilities became available<br />
in <strong>light</strong>ing design software.<br />
Development of Lighting<br />
Design Software<br />
Early software applications for<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing calculations were not readily<br />
available to the public but were created<br />
as a result of in-house needs.This<br />
was due to the fact that most companies<br />
could not afford in-house computers.<br />
Instead companies relied upon<br />
time-share systems where a user<br />
could pay for computational time and<br />
disk storage from computers owned<br />
and maintained by outside sources.<br />
In the late ’60s and early ’70s, users<br />
of time-share systems would<br />
upload/download processes and data<br />
into a central queue over phone lines<br />
using a Teletype machine and punch<br />
tapes (Figure 2). Charges for using a<br />
time-share system depended on the<br />
amount of processing time needed to<br />
achieve the results,the amount of disk<br />
storage rented (large capacities costing<br />
over $1000/month), and the time<br />
of day and the duration that the connection<br />
took place (peak and nonpeak<br />
rates ranged from around one<br />
cent to 25 cents per second or<br />
approximately $36-$900 per hour).<br />
As a result of the high cost to use the<br />
system, designers needed to determine<br />
which applications were necessary<br />
to warrant the use of the computer<br />
calculations and which should<br />
be done manually.<br />
According to Bill Brackett of<br />
Independent Testing Laboratories<br />
(ITL), a typical <strong>light</strong>ing calculation<br />
process over the time-share system<br />
entailed the following steps:<br />
1. Prepare the input file off-line by<br />
typing at a keyboard with the tape<br />
punch turned on.<br />
2. Dial the computer and logging in.<br />
3. Open a “new” file and turning on<br />
the paper tape reader.<br />
4. Save the file when the tape reading<br />
was finished.<br />
5. Run the calculation program<br />
6. List the output file to the user’s<br />
terminal.<br />
7.If desired,delete the input/output<br />
files from the host’s storage.<br />
8. Log off.<br />
Photometric testing laboratories<br />
became interested in <strong>light</strong>ing calculations<br />
as an additional courtesy service<br />
offered to customers.Since they were<br />
already providing CU values for luminaires,<br />
it was a “simple” step to take<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing calculation to the next level by<br />
offering footcandle calculations. In<br />
1968, a prominent lamp manufacturer<br />
spent nearly $15,000 for a point-bypoint<br />
software application called<br />
“LIGHT.” This software enabled the<br />
user to calculate a maximum grid of<br />
100 points at approximately five cents<br />
per luminaire for a full grid of points.<br />
A football field consisting of 96 points<br />
and 50 flood<strong>light</strong>s would have cost<br />
about $2.50. Any project requiring<br />
more than 100 points to complete<br />
the calculations was required to be<br />
divided into smaller computable<br />
pieces.<br />
At the same time “LIGHT” was<br />
being used, David DiLaura developed<br />
“Lumen 1” as a program to help engineers<br />
predict the results of their <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
design through point-by-point calculations<br />
of a complete area. As with<br />
other applications, “Lumen 1”<br />
required the use of a time-share system<br />
to run the program. This software<br />
was not restricted by the quantity<br />
of calculation points but the memory<br />
capacity of the computers. Data<br />
input to the central computer over<br />
the Teletype system included the<br />
room’s dimensions, reflectances, locations<br />
of windows and locations of<br />
luminaires using X and Y Cartesian<br />
coordinate values. Photometric values<br />
of the luminaires were also used, but<br />
without the establishment of IES photometric<br />
files at that time, each value<br />
58 www.iesna.org
PHOTO: COURTESY OF HARVARD UNIVERSITY ARCHIVES, CALL # UAV 362.7295.8P, BOX 3.<br />
Figure 2<br />
LIGHTS,<br />
LAMPS AND SOFTWARE<br />
Note: Bolded items are dates specific to<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing design software. Blue items are specific<br />
to lamp technologies. Plain text are key<br />
developments in general for the <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
industry.<br />
1604 Johannes Kepler published first fundamental<br />
concepts of photometry<br />
1634 First published reference to the<br />
inverse square law<br />
1669 Discovery of phosphorus<br />
1783 Introduction of Argand Lamp<br />
1792 Introduction of gas <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
1809 First electric arc (carbon arc) <strong>light</strong><br />
along the horizontal and vertical<br />
angles of the luminaire had to be input<br />
separately. If a value was input incorrectly,<br />
there was no checking system<br />
to indicate an error had been made.<br />
The designer relied upon his own<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing experience to determine if<br />
the results appeared accurate or not.<br />
Over the next three years, DiLaura<br />
further developed the program to<br />
predict a <strong>light</strong>ing design taking into<br />
account interreflected <strong>light</strong> of an<br />
empty room. In 1970, DiLaura joined<br />
Smith, Hinchman & Grylls (currently<br />
SmithGroup) and expanded his rudimentary<br />
program to calculate footcandle<br />
levels, day<strong>light</strong>ing, disability/discomfort<br />
glare and the Visual Comfort<br />
Probability (VCP).This version became<br />
“Lumen 2.” James Benya, one of the<br />
first users at SmithGroup, helped<br />
develop a statistical analysis preprocessor<br />
for the program to make<br />
sure all the variables were there and<br />
made sense.Benya explained that even<br />
though using the software over the<br />
time-sharing system wasn’t expedient,<br />
he did not find it frustrating.“I always<br />
considered it between a gift [to me]<br />
and genius [that the software was<br />
developed]. DiLaura took a fledgling<br />
concept and invented the mathematics<br />
to take <strong>light</strong>ing calculations to the<br />
next step.” In 1980, DiLaura moved to<br />
Boulder, CO, and founded Lighting<br />
Technologies with David Kambich. In<br />
1981, Lighting Technologies presented<br />
“Lumen 3” to the public and made it<br />
available through Computer Sharing<br />
Services (CSS)—a nationwide timesharing<br />
system company headquartered<br />
in Denver.<br />
PCs Emerge<br />
In 1982, IBM produced the first<br />
“personal” computer called the<br />
microcomputer—similar to the PCs<br />
of today. Lighting Technologies decided<br />
to take a chance and gamble that engineers<br />
and companies would buy their<br />
own microcomputers instead of continuing<br />
with the time-share system. In<br />
1983, the company released “Lumen<br />
Micro” version 1.0—the name change<br />
due to the recent development of the<br />
microcomputer. This version utilized<br />
the computer screen instead of teletype<br />
tape printouts but the data was<br />
entirely character-based. It wasn’t until<br />
1985 that it developed the first graphical<br />
output for <strong>light</strong>ing calculation<br />
results—but this output was not generated<br />
on the screen. It was a shaded<br />
view produced on a dot matrix printer<br />
(Figure 3)—similar to the “synthetic<br />
images” created by Moon and<br />
Spencer four decades earlier.<br />
Around this time, others saw the<br />
opportunity to create <strong>light</strong>ing design<br />
software applications. When Holophane<br />
moved its facilities, Todd<br />
Saemisch and David Speer stayed in<br />
1814 First general use of gas street <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
1826 Introduction of Lime<strong>light</strong><br />
1853 Introduction of kerosene lamp<br />
c. 1856 Introduction of first theatrical follow-spot<br />
1865 Introduction of vacuum <strong>light</strong> bulb<br />
1879 Thomas Edison invented the carbonize<br />
cotton filament lamp<br />
1880 Introduction of (Selenium) Photocell<br />
1883 Dr. Leonhard Weber invents the first<br />
photometer<br />
1894 Discovery of Argon<br />
1989 Discoveries of Neon and Xenon<br />
1901 Introduction of High Intensity discharge<br />
(HID) and Mercury Vapor lamps<br />
1905 First metal filament lamp<br />
1906 IESNA formed<br />
1907 - Introduction of tungsten filament lamp<br />
c. 1910 - Introduction of resistance dimmer<br />
1913 Introduction of first gas-filled lamp<br />
December 2005 LD+A 59
c. 1920 First Fresnel lens spot<strong>light</strong><br />
1926 Development of first radiant flux<br />
transfer equation (radiosity)<br />
1932 Introduction of Low Pressure Sodium<br />
(LPS) lamps<br />
1937 Introduction of Fluorescent lamp<br />
c. 1940 Introduction of PAR lamp<br />
1946 Moon and Spencer published<br />
“Lighting Design by the<br />
Interflection Method.” First “synthetic<br />
photographs” of calculated<br />
<strong>light</strong> in a room<br />
1955 Introduction of modern fiber optics and<br />
dichroic lamps<br />
1959 First Computer-Aided Drawing<br />
System (developed at General<br />
Motors Research Laboratory and<br />
IBM)<br />
1960 Laser <strong>light</strong> perfected and first hologram<br />
created<br />
Introduction of Quartz Halogen and<br />
Metal Halide lamps<br />
1963 John Landsdown introduced CAD<br />
as a tool for architectural planning<br />
1965 Introduction of LED’s and High Pressure<br />
Sodium (HPS) lamps<br />
1966 First “Computers in Design and<br />
Communication” Conference<br />
held<br />
1968 Development of LIGHT - point-bypoint<br />
software (In-house software)<br />
1969 First commercial CAD wireframe<br />
graphics program available to the<br />
public<br />
1973 Development of Lumen 1 <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
design software (In-house software)<br />
1982 Autodesk releases AutoCAD v. 1.0<br />
Introduction of Lumen Micro v.<br />
1.0 (Lighting Technologies)<br />
1984 Introduction of POINT (Lighting<br />
Analysts)<br />
Figure 3<br />
Colorado to form Lighting Analysts,<br />
Inc. (LAI). In 1984, LAI released its<br />
first general point-by-point program<br />
called “POINT” followed by an isoilluminance<br />
template program called<br />
“ISOPOINT” in 1985, and an interior<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing program called “INSIGHT” in<br />
1989. This was followed by a DOS<br />
based release (AGI-DOS) in 1991<br />
and a Windows based release<br />
(AGI32) in 1999.<br />
Photo-realistic Renderings<br />
In 1989,Greg Ward of the Lawrence<br />
Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL)<br />
released Radiance, a UNIX-based ray<br />
tracing simulation that handles specular<br />
and diffuse inter-reflections (Figure 4).<br />
In 2000, LBNL released Desktop<br />
Radiance for the Windows platform,<br />
and today this package serves as the<br />
basis for over a dozen Windows-based<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing tools. In 2002, LBNL made<br />
Radiance open source, and an active<br />
community of users, researchers and<br />
developers continues to build upon<br />
this free software base.<br />
In 1991, Stuart Feldman, Rod<br />
Recker and Filippo Tampieri discussed<br />
developing a commercial product to<br />
produce photo-realistic renderings as<br />
an alternative to physical mock-ups<br />
for designers.They wanted to create<br />
a product that would be distinguished<br />
from other visualization software.<br />
They incorporated radiosity algorithms—and<br />
later .IES photometry<br />
for real physical <strong>light</strong>ing units—to<br />
create not just “a pretty picture” but<br />
something more meaningful to<br />
designers. The original “Lightscape”<br />
application sold for $15,000 a seat<br />
and was developed on Silicon<br />
Graphics (SGI) machines. In 1996,<br />
when Microsoft developed Windows<br />
NT with OpenGL capabilities, the<br />
first version of Lightscape for personal<br />
computers emerged, selling for<br />
$3000. This Windows version<br />
appealed to more people since it was<br />
naturally easier to use than the SGIbased<br />
version. In 1997, Lightscape<br />
Technologies was acquired by<br />
Discreet which dropped the price<br />
down to $495 and, consequently,<br />
increased the user base dramatically.<br />
Future<br />
Today, GUIs and processing speeds<br />
are changing more than actual <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
calculation algorithms. According to<br />
DiLaura, “The industry is satisfied<br />
with the current capabilities of <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
design software. As such, there is<br />
no economic reason to pursue nearfield<br />
photometry software capabilities.<br />
But without the demand for<br />
near-field photometry, visualizations<br />
will not be accurate.” In essence,<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing design software research has<br />
come to a halt over the past 10 years<br />
with no major developments in <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
calculation algorithms.The limiting<br />
factor now is the photometric information<br />
input into <strong>light</strong>ing design simulations.Currently,the<br />
data in IES files<br />
is primitive; we are unable to accurately<br />
calculate the effects of a fixture<br />
when it is located close to a wall or<br />
other object.This is in part due to a<br />
60 www.iesna.org
PHOTO: COURTESY OF ROBERT A. SHAKESPEARE<br />
Figure 4<br />
1985 Introduction of ISOPOINT<br />
(Lighting Analysts)<br />
Introduction of CALC-L (Lithonia)<br />
1986 Introduction of AutoLUX<br />
(Not ITL)<br />
1987 Introduction of INSIGHT<br />
(Lighting Analysts)<br />
Introduction of SPEC-L (Lithonia)<br />
1988 Introduction of AutoFLO<br />
(Not ITL)<br />
Introduction of LUX (OxyTech)<br />
1989 Introduction of Radiance<br />
(Lawrence Berkeley National<br />
Laboratory)<br />
lack of demand from end users to<br />
push software further than their current<br />
computational capabilities.<br />
Another area to pursue is more<br />
emphasis on day<strong>light</strong>ing. This includes<br />
better estimation of sky model conditions<br />
and the capability to do real-time<br />
animated studies illustrating the effects<br />
of day<strong>light</strong> over hours/days/months<br />
instead having to calculate individual<br />
points in time. Since the effect of day<strong>light</strong>ing<br />
on architecture is not static,<br />
our ability to see its influence throughout<br />
the year should reflect these varying<br />
conditions.<br />
As a frequent software user, I see<br />
the future of <strong>light</strong>ing design software<br />
heading in the same direction as<br />
recent CAD software developments.<br />
Over the past several years, high-end<br />
CAD software provide designers with<br />
“smart object” tools enabling us to<br />
incorporate more detailed information<br />
into our documentation. Using<br />
these tools, designers create intelligent<br />
3D models and let the computer<br />
build sections and elevations based on<br />
“slices” cut at specific points in the<br />
model. This eliminates some of the<br />
coordination discrepancies which<br />
occur when a drawing is modified but<br />
corresponding referenced drawings<br />
are not updated accordingly.<br />
Current .IES files contain photometric<br />
distribution and basic luminaire<br />
data such as dimensions, manufacturer,<br />
model number, etc., but they<br />
still do not include housing dimensions<br />
or other plenum information<br />
helpful when integrating into “smart<br />
models.” This additional information<br />
aids in indicating where there may be<br />
coordination problems with other<br />
plenum objects such as HVAC ducts,<br />
sprinkler lines or structural beams.<br />
Detecting these problem areas early<br />
in the design development or construction<br />
documentation phases prevents<br />
time and money lost when<br />
issues are revealed later in the field.<br />
Lastly, watch for the expansion of<br />
3D model offerings from <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
manufacturers. With the desire to<br />
create photo-realistic representations<br />
of designs, there is a greater<br />
need to go beyond simple utilization<br />
of <strong>light</strong>ing photometry in computer<br />
models. Designers want to show the<br />
client more than the effects of the<br />
<strong>light</strong> source but what the source itself<br />
looks like. Some <strong>light</strong>ing manufacturers<br />
offer 3D luminaire model libraries<br />
to integrate into 3D visualizations but<br />
the majority do not. Since manufacturers<br />
design new <strong>products</strong> on CAD,<br />
creating libraries of these 3D<br />
objects—integrated with IES photometry—would<br />
be very useful for<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing designers.<br />
Over the past four decades, <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
design software has developed at<br />
an exponential rate—each subsequent<br />
improvement or addition to<br />
software technology offering more<br />
efficient and effective production<br />
capabilities. Manufacturers quickly<br />
implement suggestions from user<br />
feedback and new versions come out<br />
as quickly as the need for new functions<br />
emerge—usually resulting from<br />
1991 Introduction of AGI DOS<br />
1992 Development of Lightscape<br />
(Lightscape Graphics Software)<br />
Introduction of GENESIS<br />
(Canlyte)<br />
Introduction of LITESTAR 1.00<br />
(OxyTech)<br />
1994 Introduction of Sulfur Lamp<br />
1996 Introduction of Lightscape SGI<br />
Version (Lightscape Technologies)<br />
1996 Introduction of Lightscape<br />
Windows NT version (Lightscape<br />
Technologies)<br />
Introduction of Visual 1.0<br />
(Lithonia)<br />
1999 Introduction of AGI32<br />
(Lighting Analysts)<br />
2001 Lightscape integrated into 3D<br />
Studio VIZ (Discreet)<br />
2002 Introduction of WinITL<br />
(Independent Testing<br />
Laboratories)<br />
2004 Introduction of Lumen Designer<br />
(Lighting Technologies)<br />
Dates are derived from sources including but not limited<br />
to A History of Light and Lighting Edition: 2.3 (2005) by<br />
Bill Williams; “Light’s Measure: A History of Industrial<br />
Photometry to 1909” by David DiLaura, published by<br />
IESNA (2005); CG 101: A Computer Graphics Industry<br />
Reference by Terrance Masson New Riders Publishing<br />
(1999);Radiosity:A Programmer’s Perspective by Ian Ashdown.<br />
December 2005 LD+A 61
F L A S H B A C K<br />
LD+A: December 1982<br />
The year was 1982. Ronald Reagan was president and Frank<br />
LaGiusa was in his seventh year as <strong>light</strong>ing designer for the<br />
National Christmas Tree in Washington, DC, just south of the<br />
White House grounds.The article described how LaGiusa strived to<br />
create a new scheme for the tree each year;in ’81 he used 56 star-shaped ornaments<br />
to represent the 50 states and six territorial jurisdictions.<br />
new codes or procedures.The future<br />
of <strong>light</strong>ing design software is what we,<br />
the end users, require to ensure a<br />
successful <strong>light</strong>ing design process. All<br />
we have to do is ask.<br />
LD+A’s “Century Series” celebrates<br />
pioneers,achievements and developments<br />
in <strong>light</strong>ing, as IESNA approaches its centennial<br />
in January 2006.<br />
About the Author: At the<br />
Washington, DC, office of<br />
architecture/design firm<br />
ForrestPerkins, Emlyn Altman,<br />
Member IESNA (2001), exercises<br />
her dual specializations in cutting edge<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing design technology as director of<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing design and visualization. Ms.<br />
Altman is also currently serving her second<br />
term as IES Capital Section president<br />
and is the East Central Region awards<br />
chair. To send comments about this column<br />
or questions regarding the use of<br />
computers in <strong>light</strong>ing design, email her at<br />
D_D@EAVisualization.com<br />
Acknowledgments<br />
The author wishes to thank the following<br />
people whose time, knowledge<br />
and experiences shared through emails<br />
and interviews enriched the resources<br />
drawn upon for this article:Ian Ashdown,<br />
James Benya, Bill Brackett, David<br />
DiLaura,Stuart Feldman,Todd Saemisch,<br />
Dr. Domina Spencer and Greg Ward.<br />
References<br />
1. Moon, Parry and Spencer, D.E.:<br />
“The Interreflection Method of<br />
Predetermining Brightnesses and<br />
Brightness-Ratios,” <strong>Illuminating</strong><br />
<strong>Engineering</strong>, pp. 362-385. May 1946.<br />
2. DiLaura, David L., Igoe, Denis P.<br />
and Mistrick, Richard G.: “Synthetic<br />
Photography,” Lighting Design &<br />
Application, pp 24-27.August 1985.<br />
3.DiLaura,David L.:“Light’s Measure:<br />
A History of Industrial Photometry to<br />
1909,” Leukos, pp 75-149. 2005.<br />
4. Masson, Terrance: “CG 101: A<br />
Computer Graphics Industry<br />
Reference,” New Riders Publishing;<br />
1999.<br />
5. Ashdown, Ian: “Radiosity: A<br />
Programmer’s Perspective,” 1994.<br />
6. Larson, G.W. and R.A.<br />
Shakespeare, “Rendering with<br />
Radiance: the Art and Science of<br />
Lighting Visualization,” 1998.<br />
62 www.iesna.org
Annual Index • Subject<br />
Architectural Lighting<br />
Come Home To MoMA . . . . May 68<br />
New York’s Museum of Modern Art<br />
Sexton, George; George Sexton<br />
Associates, Washington, DC and<br />
Tanniguchi, Yoshio; Taniguchi<br />
Associates, Tokyo<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Halo Effect . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 28<br />
Hollywood Bowl<br />
Dachs, Joshua, Hoyes, Richard,<br />
Fisher Dachs Assoc., New York,<br />
NY and Fung, Hsin-Ming and<br />
Hodgetts, Craig, Hodgetts +<br />
Fung, Design & Architecture, Los<br />
Angeles, CA<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Lost In Transformation . . . . Jul 46<br />
Hiroshima City Naka<br />
Incineration Plant<br />
Mende, Kaoru, Lighting Designer<br />
and Taniguchi, Yoshio,<br />
Architect, Tokyo<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Spreading Its Wings . . . . . Nov 52<br />
Indianapolis Museum Of Art<br />
Stone, Charles G. II, Fisher<br />
Marantz Stone, New York, NY<br />
and Hess, Jonathan R.;<br />
Browning Day Mullins Dierdorf,<br />
Architects, Indianapolis, IN<br />
West Side Story – A Revival. .. Jul 42<br />
The Grand Stewart’s Building,<br />
Baltimore, MD<br />
Barber, Michael A., Diemer, Helen;<br />
The Lighting Practice, Philadelphia,<br />
PA and Liebel, Tom, architect, Design<br />
Collective, Inc. Baltimore, MD<br />
Bridges<br />
Finally Blue. . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 37<br />
The Vincent Thomas Bridge,<br />
San Pedro, CA<br />
Israel, Chip and Blankenheim,<br />
Julie; Lighting Design Alliance,<br />
Los Angeles, CA<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Jacksonville’s Pregame<br />
Show . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 58<br />
The Hart, The Main Street and<br />
the Fuller Warren Bridges Light<br />
up for Super Bowl 2005,<br />
Jacksonville, FL<br />
Fallin, Robert, Laffitte, David;<br />
Reynolds. Smith and Hills,<br />
Jacksonville, FL and Laughlin,<br />
Robert J. Winter Park, FL<br />
Columns<br />
Careers & Hiring . . . . . . . . Apr 20<br />
Careers & Hiring . . . . . . . . Jun 22<br />
Careers & Hiring. . . . . . . . Aug 16<br />
Careers & Hiring. . . . . . . . Sep 26<br />
Digital Dialogue . . . . . . . . Jan 12<br />
Digital Dialogue . . . . . . . . May 22<br />
Digital Dialogue . . . . . . . . . Jul 14<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 4<br />
Editor’s Note. . . . . . . . . . . Mar 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 4<br />
Editor’s Note. . . . . . . . . . . May 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 4<br />
Editor’s Note. . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 4<br />
Editor’s Note. . . . . . . . . . . Aug 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 4<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Jan 8<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Feb 10<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Mar 12<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Apr 12<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . May 12<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Jun 14<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . Jul 10<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Aug 10<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Sep 14<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Oct 10<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Nov 8<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Dec 9<br />
Executive Vice President<br />
Reports. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 8<br />
Executive Vice Presidents<br />
Reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 10<br />
Executive Vice Presidents<br />
Reports. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 8<br />
Essay . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 20<br />
Visual Ergonomics: A Closer Look<br />
Samuelson, Christopher E.<br />
Rethinking Park Lighting . May 30<br />
Lindstrom, Carole A.<br />
Green Ideas. . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 10<br />
Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 22<br />
Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . May 20<br />
Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 18<br />
Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 22<br />
Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 14<br />
Hot Button . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 18<br />
Hot Button. . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 26<br />
Hot Button. . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 26<br />
Hot Button . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 20<br />
Lighting For Quality. . . . . . Jan 17<br />
Lighting For Quality . . . . . Mar 27<br />
Lighting For Quality . . . . . May 26<br />
Lighting For Quality . . . . . Dec 17<br />
Lighting For Security . . . . . Apr 31<br />
Lighting For Security . . . . . Jun 28<br />
Lighting For Security . . . . Aug 16<br />
Lighting For Security . . . . . Oct 16<br />
Lighting For Security. . . . . Dec 18<br />
President’s Perspective . . . Jan 7<br />
President’s Perspective . . . Apr 9<br />
President’s Perspective . . . Jul 8<br />
President’s Perspective . . . Oct 6<br />
Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . Feb 8<br />
Regional Voices . . . . . . . . Mar 11<br />
Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . Apr 10<br />
Regional Voices . . . . . . . . May 10<br />
Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . Jun 12<br />
Regional Voices . . . . . . . . Aug 8<br />
Regional Voices . . . . . . . . Sep 10<br />
Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . Oct 8<br />
Regional Voices . . . . . . . . Dec 8<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . Jan 14<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . Feb 12<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . Mar 18<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . Apr 16<br />
Research Matters. . . . . . . May 16<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . Jun 16<br />
Research Matters. . . . . . . . Jul 12<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . Aug 12<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . Sep 18<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . Oct 12<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . Nov 10<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . Dec 10<br />
Rules & Regs . . . . . . . . . . Feb 16<br />
Technology . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 14<br />
Day<strong>light</strong>ing<br />
In Pursuit of Advanced-<br />
Performance Sky<strong>light</strong>s . . . . Jul 56<br />
Cuttle, Christopher<br />
Lighting In A Sustainable<br />
Future . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 70<br />
Benya, James A.<br />
Sign of the Times . . . . . . . . Jul 36<br />
The New York Times New<br />
Headquarters, New York, NY<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Take It From The Top . . . . . Jul 40<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Design Trends<br />
Cold, Harsh Reality. . . . . . Nov 42<br />
Harlow, Grant<br />
Seeing Dollar Signs . . . . . Nov 40<br />
ROI Analysis<br />
Harlow, Grant, TIR Systems,<br />
Vancouver, BC<br />
True Colors . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 38<br />
Ashdown, Ian<br />
Directories<br />
2005 Lighting Equipment +<br />
Accessories Directory . . . . Jun 67<br />
Software Directory 2005 . . Sep 69<br />
Software Survey<br />
Education Facilities<br />
Built to Last . . . . . . . . . . Sep 64<br />
Napa Valley’s Unified School<br />
District Education Center,<br />
Orgish, David and Myer, Jan<br />
The Lighting Design Studio of<br />
O’Mahony and Myer, San<br />
Rafael, CA<br />
Developing the Mind . . . . . Jul 50<br />
M.I.N.D Institute, Sacramento, CA<br />
Ham, Tao and Blanski, Bill; HGA<br />
Architects & Engineers<br />
Minneapolis, MN<br />
Failing Fixtures are Expelled From<br />
School Retrofit . . . . . . . . . Sep 39<br />
Fairfax County Public Schools,<br />
Northern, VA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Honor Roll . . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 48<br />
Maryland Institute College of<br />
Art, Central Michigan University;<br />
ITT & Elementary Institute of<br />
Science<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Essays<br />
Bringing Humanities<br />
To Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 78<br />
Brandston, Howard M.<br />
Essay . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 20<br />
Visual Ergonomics: A Closer Look<br />
Samuelson, Christopher E.<br />
Lighting Across Cultures. . Jan 46<br />
Human Inquiry<br />
Harmon, Marcel J.<br />
History/Century Series<br />
Big-Box To Boutique . . . . . Apr 91<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Computers and Lighting. . Dec 57<br />
Altman, Emlyn<br />
Eerie Coincidences . . . . . . Mar 80<br />
Rea, Mark S.<br />
Fixtures Were His Fancy . . Oct 86<br />
December 2005 LD+A 65
Annual Index • Subject<br />
Designs of Edward F. Caldwell<br />
Rambusch, Viggo<br />
From The Shoulders<br />
of Giants . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 78<br />
Rea, Mark S.<br />
Industrial Evolution. . . . . . Jan 51<br />
Bullough, John, Paulin, Doug,<br />
Denami, Anthony J. And Mistrick,<br />
Richard<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Lighting Control: From Salt<br />
Water To Silicon . . . . . . . . May 78<br />
Maniccia, Dorene<br />
Lighting In a Sustainable<br />
Future . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 70<br />
Benya, James A.<br />
Making Light in The 20th<br />
Century. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 87<br />
DiLaura, David L.<br />
Retail Reflections . . . . . . . Apr 87<br />
Gregory, Paul; Diemer, Helen and<br />
Heenan, Sarah<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
The Sporting Life . . . . . . . Aug 75<br />
The Evolution of Sports Lighting<br />
Hunt, Patricia<br />
There From The Start . . . . Feb 59<br />
LeVere, Richard<br />
Hotels<br />
All Rolled Into One . . . . . . May 52<br />
The Spa Resort Casino<br />
Palm Springs, CA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Dark From Day One . . . . . May 49<br />
Morongo Casino,Van Nuys, CA<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
High Stakes In Exterior<br />
Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . May 56<br />
The Spa Resort Casino,<br />
Palm Springs, CA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
SeeingYour Name in Lights . Jan 25<br />
Harrah’s Resort & Casino,<br />
Laughlin, NV<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Three Easy Pieces. . . . . . . May 46<br />
Morongo Casino Resort & Spa, Van<br />
Nuys, CA<br />
Hollingsworth, Dawn, Levesque,<br />
Matt, Passamont Green and<br />
Thomas, Eileen; Visual Terrain, Van<br />
Nuys, CA<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Worth The Wait . . . . . . . . . Nov 58<br />
Park Hyatt Zurich Honetwill, Robert<br />
and Brill, Maurice; MBLD, London,<br />
U.K.<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Houses of Worship<br />
Sonic Temple Rebirth . . . . Dec 52<br />
The Borobudur Temple, Indonesia<br />
Daniels, Robert, Brilliant Lighting<br />
Design, Miami, FL<br />
IES News<br />
Obituary – Emidio “Ed”<br />
Quintiliani, 87. . . . . . . . . . Jan 18<br />
Golden Gate Chapter Offers<br />
Scholarships . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 19<br />
IESNA Launches<br />
Rio Grande Section . . . . . . Feb 22<br />
Birthday Bashes Mark<br />
IESNA’s 99th Anniversary. . . Mar 30<br />
IESNA Handbook CD Version Has<br />
Microsoft Update . . . . . . . Mar 29<br />
Obituary – Ronald L.<br />
Sitzema Jr., 51 . . . . . . . . . Mar 29<br />
Obituary – Charles H.<br />
Loch, 72 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 35<br />
Obituary – Robert Merle<br />
Dixson, 82 . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 35<br />
Public Review of IESNA<br />
Publications . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 35<br />
2005 IESNA International Illumination<br />
Design Award Entries . . . . Apr 36<br />
NCQLP Announces 2004<br />
Exam Results . . . . . . . . . . Apr 41<br />
And the Party Goes On for<br />
IESNA’s 99th Anniversary . May 30<br />
Obituary – Robert Russell<br />
Wylie, 89 . . . . . . . . . . . . . May 34<br />
Public Review for RP-8 . . May 35<br />
IESNA Centennial Conference<br />
2005 ADEX Leviton Manufacturing<br />
Company . . . . . . . . . . . . . May 35<br />
Program Announced . . . . . Jun 32<br />
Public Review of IESNA<br />
Publications . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 33<br />
Obituaries – Jack T.<br />
Cottingham, 85. . . . . . . . . Jun 33<br />
Paul L. Butler, 58 . . . . . . . Jun 33<br />
Distinguished Service<br />
Award . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 32<br />
Fellow Awards. . . . . . . . . . Sep 32<br />
Marks Award. . . . . . . . . . . Sep 31<br />
Medal Award. . . . . . . . . . . Sep 31<br />
Obituary – Peter J.<br />
Pennachio, 67. . . . . . . . . . Sep 33<br />
Presidential Awards . . . . . Sep 32<br />
Taylor Technical Award . . . Sep 31<br />
Obituary – David T.<br />
Mullen, 62. . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 23<br />
Mexico Section Takes<br />
Lighting Journey . . . . . . . . Nov 25<br />
Obituary – Frederick A.<br />
Dickey, 68 . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 25<br />
Just In Time . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 21<br />
The IESNA Research Committee<br />
Revision . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 21<br />
Industry Updates<br />
And The Emmy Goes To … Jan 24<br />
International City-People-<br />
Light Award 2004 . . . . . . . Jan 23<br />
LIGHTFAIR Day<strong>light</strong>ing Institute<br />
Courses. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 21<br />
2005 LIGHTFAIR Line-up<br />
Announced . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 21<br />
Lighting Design Scholarships<br />
Available . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 23<br />
New CD-ROM Promotes<br />
Recycling of Mercury-Containing<br />
Lamps. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 24<br />
New York Splashes Light On Its<br />
Olympic Bid. . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 24<br />
IALD Announces 2005<br />
Board of Directors. . . . . . . Feb 25<br />
Philips and Advance Transformer To<br />
Receive Funding From DOE<br />
To Support Solid-State<br />
Lighting Development. . . . Feb 25<br />
Southern California Edison<br />
Opens New Lighting Center . Feb 26<br />
Just Published . . . . . . . . . Feb 27<br />
ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 90.1<br />
Updated . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 27<br />
ESTA Creates Foundation for<br />
Entertainment Technicians. Mar 35<br />
Governor Schwarzenegger<br />
Green Lights Green Building<br />
Plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 35<br />
LFT Launches New<br />
Competition . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 35<br />
Retail Project Recognized In<br />
International Store Design<br />
Competition . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 34<br />
New York City Makes Largest<br />
Purchase of Green Power . . . Apr 47<br />
DOE and Industry Alliance Partner to<br />
Advance Solid-State<br />
Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 47<br />
Student Design Competition Uses<br />
Discover Lighting Online<br />
Program . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 49<br />
Students’ Experiment Is Out of This<br />
World. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 51<br />
Parsons Centurion Award Honors<br />
Designer Albert Hadley . . . Apr 51<br />
Lighting Products Merging With<br />
Controls, Survey Shows . . May 39<br />
LRC Distributes Guidelines<br />
for Reporting LED Life . . . May 40<br />
LRC Partners With Boeing To Develop<br />
Aircraft Lighting Solution. May 39<br />
New York Announces Partnership<br />
to Ensure Energy Efficiency<br />
in Affordable Housing . . . May 39<br />
Read All About It . . . . . . . May 40<br />
Advance Establishes<br />
Scholarships . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 38<br />
Cooper Lighting Names<br />
Ten Winners. . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 37<br />
C2C Winner Feeds Electricity to<br />
Neighbors, Uses Spinach<br />
for Power. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 41<br />
Florentine, Jacobs and Heck Win 22nd<br />
Annual GE Edison Award. . Jun 36<br />
IALD Recognizes 23 Projects<br />
Representing Eight<br />
Countries . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 39<br />
Hubbell Lighting’s New Headquarters<br />
On Schedule for 2006 . . . . Jul 31<br />
Nuckolls Fund 2005 Grant<br />
Awards Total $45,000 . . . . Jul 32<br />
Software Is Just What the Doctor<br />
Ordered . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 32<br />
Who Needs A Train Whistle Jul 32<br />
Architects Honored with<br />
Design Award . . . . . . . . . . Aug 26<br />
Demo Rooms Immerse<br />
Specifiers In Light . . . . . . Aug 27<br />
GSA Announces LC<br />
Mandate. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 27<br />
Hello My Pretty… Fixtures Aug 25<br />
Hybrid Fixture Joins LED and<br />
Incandescent Sources . . . Aug 25<br />
LRC Announces Lutron Scholarship<br />
Award Recipient . . . . . . . . Aug 26<br />
Sea Gull Lighting Announces Winners<br />
of Design Competition . . . Aug 27<br />
Shipments of Lighting Products On<br />
The Rise, NEMA Index<br />
Finds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 25<br />
Eastham Elementary Receives NEED<br />
Award For Energy<br />
Education . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 37<br />
LEDs Save Energy, Attracts Shoppers<br />
to Retail Windows. . . . . . . Sep 36<br />
LRC Survey Finds<br />
New Penn Station is Draped in Light<br />
and Reflects Its Past . . . . Sep 35<br />
Schneider Electric To<br />
Acquire Juno Lighting . . . . Sep 35<br />
Suite Stuff . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 37<br />
Acuity Brands Names Morgan<br />
as President of Lighting Group;<br />
Honeycutt to Retire . . . . . . Oct 28<br />
Call For Papers: ISCC/CIE<br />
Expert Symposium. . . . . . . Oct 28<br />
LED Screens Rush To Take<br />
The Stage . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 28<br />
NEMA Lighting Systems Index Posts<br />
Gains In 2005 . . . . . . . . . . Oct 28<br />
New Standard, Publications<br />
66 www.iesna.org
Annual Index • Subject<br />
Issued by CIE . . . . . . . . . . Oct 29<br />
New Study Reveals Opportunities,<br />
Threats In the Manufacturing<br />
Sector . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 27<br />
The Star Is Reborn . . . . . . Oct 27<br />
Call for Entries: ‘It’s Your Light’<br />
Student Design<br />
Competition . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 30<br />
Energy Design Guide Earns<br />
Award from Alliance . . . . . Nov 30<br />
Lighting for Tomorrow Names 2005<br />
Design and Technology<br />
Winners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 31<br />
LRC To Redefine National Roadway<br />
Lighting Guidelines . . . . . Nov 30<br />
The Lighting Industry Responds To<br />
Hurricane Katrina . . . . . . . Nov 29<br />
Advance University Curriculum<br />
Approved by NCQLP . . . . . Dec 26<br />
Call for Entries: GE Edison Award<br />
Competition . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 26<br />
Lighting Manufacturer Wins State<br />
Environmental Award . . . . Dec 26<br />
LRC Selected by FAA To Study Airpot<br />
Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 26<br />
New Look to New York’s<br />
Plaza Park . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 26<br />
Survey Says: LIGHTFAIR is a<br />
‘Must-Experience’ Event.. . Dec 26<br />
Three LED, SSL Joint Ventures<br />
Announced . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 26<br />
IIDA<br />
From Gray To Green . . . . . Aug 52<br />
David L. Lawrence Convention<br />
Center, Pittsburgh, PA<br />
Yancey, Keith J. and Zaferiou, Paul<br />
A. Lam Partners, Inc., Cambridge, MA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Jacksonville’s Pregame<br />
Show. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 58<br />
The Hart, The Main Street and the<br />
Fuller Warren Bridges all <strong>light</strong> for<br />
Super Bowl 2005 Jacksonville, FL<br />
Fallin, Robert, Laffitte, David;<br />
Reynolds Smith and Hills,<br />
Jacksonville, FL and Laughlin,<br />
Robert J. Winter Park, FL<br />
Profiles In Postcards . . . . Aug 48<br />
Staten Island’s September 11, 2001<br />
Memorial<br />
Stone II, Charles G. and Frary,<br />
Kevin; Fisher Marantz Stone, New<br />
York, NY<br />
Leibowitz, Julie<br />
2005 International Illumination<br />
Design Awards . . . . . . . . . Aug 33<br />
Top Recipients of the International<br />
Illumination Design Awards 2005<br />
Trading Up . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 46<br />
The Bank of America Charlotte, NC<br />
Margulies, Stephen<br />
LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL<br />
LIGHTFAIR 2005 Preview. . Mar 60<br />
Emerging HID<br />
Technologies. . . . . . . . . . . Mar 73<br />
Oomen, Manuel, Cummings, John<br />
and Diemer, Helen<br />
Healing Environments . . . Mar 61<br />
Miller, Naomi and North, Leslie<br />
Landscape Lighting<br />
Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 68<br />
Lanteigne, Robert<br />
Light, Discovery, Spirit and<br />
Consequences . . . . . . . . . Mar 66<br />
Warfel, William B.<br />
Light, Sight and the Senses .. Mar 64<br />
Tiller, Dale and Houser, Kevin<br />
Material Things . . . . . . . . Mar 76<br />
Yeager, Raymond<br />
Techniques for Teaching<br />
Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 70<br />
Roush, Mark and Oberkircher, Fred<br />
LIGHTFAIR International<br />
2005 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 60<br />
New Product Showcase Winners<br />
Lighting Trespass<br />
Dark From Day One . . . . . May 49<br />
Morongo Casino,Van Nuys, CA<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Maintenance<br />
Covering All The Bases. . . Sep 61<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Monument<br />
Profiles In Postcards . . . . Aug 48<br />
Staten Island’s September 11, 2001<br />
Memorial<br />
Stone II, Charles G. and Frary,<br />
Kevin; Fisher Marantz Stone, New<br />
York, NY<br />
Leibowitz, Julie<br />
Museum/Exhibit<br />
Come Home To MoMA . . . . May 68<br />
New York’s Museum of Modern Art<br />
Sexton, George; George Sexton<br />
Associates, Washington, DC and<br />
Tanniguchi, Yoshio; Taniguchi<br />
Associates, Tokyo<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Hope Floats In Little Rock . Apr 60<br />
The William J. Clinton Presidential<br />
Center, Little Rock, AR<br />
Bettridge, Francesca, Saltzberg,<br />
Marty, Cline, Bettirige, Bernstein<br />
Lighting Design, New York, NY and<br />
Polshek, James S. and Olcott,<br />
Richard M, Polshek Partnership<br />
Architects, New York, NY<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Lighting Museums As Cultural<br />
Icons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 78<br />
Frazier, Mary Claire<br />
New Frontier . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 66<br />
The New National Museum Of The<br />
American Indian, Washington, D.C.<br />
Lien, Chou and Kim, Jung Soo,<br />
Brandston Partnership, Inc., New<br />
York, NY<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Spreading Its Wings . . . . . Nov 52<br />
Indianapolis Museum of Art,<br />
Indianapolis, IN<br />
Stone II, Charles G; Fisher Marantz<br />
Stone, New York, NY and Hess<br />
Jonathan R.; Browning Day Mullins<br />
Dierdorf Architects, Indianapolis, IN<br />
The Beacon of Fort<br />
Washington . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 46<br />
The National Track & Field Hall of<br />
Fame, Manhattan, NY<br />
Skolnick, Lee H. and Cardenas,<br />
Miguel; Lee H. Skolnic Architecture<br />
+ Design Partnership, and Leni<br />
Schwindinger, Light Projects Ltd.,<br />
New York, NY<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
The Big Red Time<br />
Machine . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 50<br />
History of the Cincinnati Reds<br />
Abernathy, Katherine C., Kilburn,<br />
Tayva and Abernathy, Christopher<br />
A.; Abernathy Lighting Design,<br />
North Providence, RI and Rainone,<br />
Jason, New York City<br />
Thinking Outside the<br />
Black Box . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 72<br />
Maryland Science Center,<br />
Baltimore, MD<br />
Burns, Rich, Bernardo, Luis; Design<br />
Collective, Baltimore, MD and<br />
Sexton, George, George Sexton<br />
Associates, Washington, D.C.<br />
What’s New In Kalamazoo . Jan 42<br />
Kalamazoo Air Zoo, Kalamazoo MI<br />
Hunter, Bill Hunter-Leet &<br />
Associates, Kalamazoo, MI<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Office Lighting<br />
Caltrans Transcendent . . . Aug 65<br />
Caltran’s District 7Headquarters,<br />
Los Angeles, CA<br />
Brogden, Teal, Libonati, Heather;<br />
Horton Lees Brogden Lighting<br />
Design, Los Angeles, CA; Scott,<br />
Ron, Ledalite Architectural<br />
Products, Langley, BC & Wypasek,<br />
Michael, Paramount Industries, Inc.<br />
Croswell, MI<br />
Double Duty . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 54<br />
Prudential Lighting Headquarters,<br />
Los Angeles, CA<br />
Fairweather, Virginia<br />
Even Illumination Brightens<br />
New Office Space . . . . . . . Mar 36<br />
Affiliated Engineers, Inc., Westlake<br />
Center Office Tower, Seattle, WA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Ferry Good Show . . . . . . . . Feb 38<br />
Ferry Building, San Francisco, CA<br />
Hawthorne, Darrell<br />
Sign of the Times . . . . . . . . Jul 36<br />
The New York Times New<br />
Headquarters, New York, NY<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Progress Report<br />
2005 Progress Report . . . . Oct 35<br />
Public Spaces<br />
Another Brick In the Wall . . Oct 65<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Beachfront Lighting Proves to be<br />
an Environmentally Safe<br />
Addition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 28<br />
The Miami Beachwalk, Miami, FL<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Bringing The Great Outdoors<br />
Inside . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 40<br />
The Atlanta Area Council Boy<br />
Scouts Of America Volunteer<br />
Service Center<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Come Sail Away With LEDs . Nov 44<br />
Canada Place, Vancouver, Canada<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Custom Made Fixtures Brighten Up<br />
Convention And Exhibit<br />
Center. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 34<br />
The Boston Convention and Exhibit<br />
Center, Boston, MA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Fed Excellent Adventure . . . . . . Dec 40<br />
FedExForum, Memphis, TN<br />
December 2005 LD+A 67
Annual Index • Subject<br />
Niemuth, Jon D.: Ellerbe Becket,<br />
Kansas City, MO and Hoppas,<br />
Barbara L.S.; Bredson &<br />
Associates, Inc., Raytown, MD<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Force Of Nature . . . . . . . . Mar 40<br />
The Miami World Trade Center Tower<br />
Deeb, Paul A.; Vox Environmental<br />
Arts, Baltimore, MD<br />
From Gray To Green . . . . . . ug 52<br />
David L. Lawrence Convention<br />
Center, Pittsburgh, PA<br />
Yancey, Keith J. and Zaferiou, Paul A.;<br />
Lam Partners Inc., Cambridge, MA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Great Wall of Chi-Town . . . Oct 62<br />
Chicago’s Millennium Park<br />
Baney, Jim, Schuler Shook,<br />
Chicago, IL<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Lost In Transformation . . . . Jul 46<br />
Hiroshima City Naka Incineration<br />
Plant<br />
Mende, Kaoru, Lighting Designer<br />
and Taniguchi, Yoshio, Architect<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Residential<br />
Living The High Life . . . . . . Jul 62<br />
Residential space in Jacksonville, FL<br />
Wilson, Larry and Mulhall, Joanna,<br />
Rink Design Partnership, Inc.,<br />
Jacksonville, FL<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Martha Says: ‘You’re Hired”Dec 27<br />
The Contestant Loft for “The<br />
Apprentice: Martha Stewart”<br />
television Show<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Room With a View . . . . . . Aug 29<br />
Residential Space in Houston, TX<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Thou Shall Understand<br />
Residential Lighting. . . . . . Jul 61<br />
Romaniello, Peter<br />
Restaurants<br />
Earth Wind Fire & Water .. May 58<br />
Park New Delhi Hotel, India<br />
Shankar, Babu and Ganti, Kiran;<br />
Integrated Lighting Design, Marina<br />
Del Rey, CA<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Food and Fiber Optics Are<br />
on the Menu . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 26<br />
Mama Ruggi’s Restaurantin<br />
Cinimark Theater, Grapevine, TX<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Fresh Ideas For All To<br />
Indulge In . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 57<br />
Taco Bell Restaurants<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Perfection Per Se . . . . . . . May 62<br />
New York’s Per Se Restaurant<br />
Kale, Ann; Ann Kale Associates,<br />
Santa Barbara, CA and Tihany,<br />
Adam D. Tihany Design, NYC<br />
Retail<br />
Big-Box To Boutique . . . . . Apr 91<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Covering All The Bases. . . Sep 61<br />
Retrofit at 400 Sports Authority<br />
Stores<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Crafty Lighting Upgrade Improves<br />
Retail Operations . . . . . . . May 43<br />
Hobby Lobby’s Craft Retail,<br />
Oklahoma City, OK<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Driven By Design . . . . . . . Sep 45<br />
The New Audi Dealerships<br />
Harwood, Ron, Stechschulte, Kelly<br />
and Crossman, Kira; <strong>Illuminating</strong><br />
Concepts, Farmington Hills, MI<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Extreme Makeovers. . . . . . Sep 56<br />
Spa & Salon Bellagio,<br />
Las Vegas, NV<br />
Barr, Vilma<br />
From Mill To Mall In One<br />
Renovation . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 28<br />
The Mill Antique Mall In<br />
Bibb City, GA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Line-Up Change . . . . . . . . Sep 63<br />
The Sports Authority’s Lighting<br />
Retrofit<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Reach For The Sky . . . . . . . Jul 66<br />
FAO Schwarz, New York, NY<br />
Gregory, Paul, Focus Lighting and<br />
Rockwell, David S., The Rockwell<br />
Group, New York, NY<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Retail Reflections . . . . . . . Apr 87<br />
Gregory, Paul, Diemer, Helen and<br />
Heenan, Sarah<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Shopping in the Shadows. .. Jun 53<br />
Gymboree’s New Janeville Store,<br />
Valley Fair, CA<br />
Edenbaum, Dan<br />
Traveling First Class. . . . . Sep 48<br />
Mercedes Benz M-class, At the<br />
NAIAS in Detroit, MI<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Updated Track Lighting is the Favored<br />
Flavor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 33<br />
Englewood Wine Merchants,<br />
Englewood, NJ<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Roadway/Street Lighting<br />
A Walk in The Park . . . . . . Mar 50<br />
Michigan’s Greenfield Village<br />
Harwood, Ron, Klemmer, Kenneth<br />
Vogel, Dennis and Schimmer, Larry;<br />
<strong>Illuminating</strong> Concepts, Ltd.,<br />
Farmington Hills, MI<br />
An LED Glows In Brooklyn . Feb 47<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Coming Soon To Broadway Feb 44<br />
Sundin, Jean M. and Peiniger,<br />
Enrique, Office of Visual<br />
Interaction, New York, NY<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Is ELMS The Answer . . . . Mar 46<br />
Burkett, Karl A.<br />
Portlanders ‘Thinking...Pink’ . Apr 84<br />
Gauger, Dan and Spitulski, Stephen<br />
Richmond After Dark. . . . . Oct 66<br />
Richmond, VA’s Downtown<br />
Streetscape<br />
Stashik, Sandra M. and Sarge,<br />
Courtney, Grenald Waldron<br />
Associates, Narberth, PA<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Street<strong>light</strong>s In The<br />
Spot<strong>light</strong> . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 83<br />
City of Portland, OR<br />
Gauger, Dan and Spitulski, Stephen<br />
Who’s On First . . . . . . . . . Apr 85<br />
Gauger, Dan and Spitulski, Stephen<br />
Roundtable<br />
Back & Forth . . . . . . . . . . Mar 55<br />
Orgish, David, Stephens, Scott,<br />
Roush, Mark and Metzler, Autumn<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Industrial Evolution. . . . . . Jan 51<br />
Bullough, John, Paulin, Doug, Denami,<br />
Anthony J. and Mistrick, Richard<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Over & Out . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 78<br />
Jim Baney, Schuler Shook, Chicago,<br />
IL, Jill Cody, Hamel, Green and<br />
Abrahamson, Milwaukee, WI; Mary<br />
Claire Frazier, Candela<br />
Architectural Lighting Consultants,<br />
Seattle, WA and Jeff Gerwing,<br />
SmithGroup, Detroit, MI<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Retail Reflections . . . . . . . Apr 87<br />
Gregory, Paul, Diemer, Helen and<br />
Heenan, Sarah<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Scanning the Spectrum<br />
Beachfront Lighting Proves to<br />
be an Environmentally Safe<br />
Addition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 28<br />
The Miami Beachwalk, Miami, FL<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Brighter Days Below As Garage Gets<br />
Decked Out. . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 38<br />
Colliers Monroe Friedlander’s Building<br />
Parking Garage, Honolulu, HI<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Brighter is Better As BrandsMart<br />
Rebrands . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 44<br />
BrandsMarts’s, Atlanta, GA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Bringing The Great Outdoors<br />
Inside . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 40<br />
The Atlanta Area Council Boy<br />
Scouts Of America Volunteer<br />
Service Center, Atlanta, GA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Chandelier Creates Stage Presence<br />
for Historic Theater . . . . . May 44<br />
The Providence Performing Arts<br />
Center, Providence, RI<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Crafty Lighting Upgrade Improves<br />
Retail Operations . . . . . . . May 32<br />
Hobby Lobby’s Craft Retail,<br />
Oklahoma City, OK<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Custom Made Fixtures Brighten Up<br />
Convention And Exhibit<br />
Center. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 34<br />
The Boston Convention and Exhibit<br />
Center, Boston, MA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Even Illumination Brightens New<br />
Office Space. . . . . . . . . . . Mar 36<br />
Affiliated Engineers, Inc., Westlake<br />
Center Office Tower, Seattle, WA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Expansion Makes for a Friendlier Pre-<br />
F<strong>light</strong> Experience . . . . . . . Oct 31<br />
The International Terminal D,<br />
Dallas/Fort Worth International<br />
Airport<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
68 www.iesna.org
Annual Index • Subject<br />
Failing Fixtures are Expelled From<br />
School Retrofit . . . . . . . . . Sep 39<br />
Fairfax County Public Schools,<br />
Northern, VA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Fifth Avenue Flurry Creates An LED<br />
Wonderland. . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 31<br />
Saks Fifth Avenue Snowflake<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Food and Fiber Optics Are on the<br />
Menu. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 26<br />
Mama Ruggi’s Restaurant in<br />
Cinimark Theater, Grapevine, TX<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Fresh Ideas For All To<br />
Indulge In . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 57<br />
Taco Bell Restaurants<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
From Mill To Mall In One<br />
Renovation . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 28<br />
The Mill Antique Mall in Bibb<br />
City, GA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Hydroelectric Sensation Breaks at<br />
Niagara Falls . . . . . . . . . . Jun 43<br />
Niagara Fallsview Casino Resort,<br />
Ontario, Canada<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
It’s All Work and All Play in LA<br />
Headquarters . . . . . . . . . . Apr 58<br />
Electronic Arts, (EA) Los Angeles<br />
Playa Vista, CA<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
LEC Technology Captures<br />
The Checkered Flag . . . . . . Jul 34<br />
Pepsi 400, Daytona Beach, FL<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Martha Says: “You’re<br />
Hired”. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 27<br />
The Contestant Loft for “The<br />
Apprentice: Martha Stewart”<br />
television Show<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Restaurant Adds Lighting To Its<br />
Overhead . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 33<br />
Market Bistro, Phoenix, AZ<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Room With a View . . . . . . Aug 29<br />
Residential Space in Houston, TX<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
See Me Now, Says Seawall. . Aug 30<br />
A Seawall in Fort Lauderdale, FL<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Seeing Your Name in<br />
Lights . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 25<br />
Harrah’s Resort & Casino<br />
Laughlin, NV<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
The Show Glows On At<br />
The Bardavon . . . . . . . . . . Oct 32<br />
The Bardavon Theater,<br />
Poughkeepsie, NY<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Updated Track Lighting is the Favored<br />
Flavor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 33<br />
Englewood Wine Merchants,<br />
Englewood, NJ<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Signage<br />
Blue and Red Get the<br />
Go-Ahead . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 69<br />
Sculpture for Outdoor Plaza of<br />
Caltran’s District 7Headquarters<br />
Los Angeles, CA<br />
Cold, Harsh Reality. . . . . . Nov 42<br />
ROI Analysis for LED Signage<br />
Harlow, Grant<br />
Fifth Avenue Flurry Creates An LED<br />
Wonderland. . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 31<br />
Saks Fifth Avenue Snowflake<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Seeing Dollar Signs . . . . . Nov 40<br />
Roi Analysis for LED Signage<br />
Harlow, Grant<br />
Sports<br />
Fed EXcellent Adventure . . . . . . Dec 40<br />
FedExForum, Memphis, TN<br />
Niemuth, Jon D.: Ellerbe Becket,<br />
Kansas City, MO and Hoppas,<br />
Barbara L.S.; Bredson &<br />
Associates, Inc.,<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Good Citizen . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan. 32<br />
Citizens Bank Park, Philadelphia, PA<br />
Cunningham, Robert F.Garman,<br />
Richard G.& Hahnlen, Brian, Ewing<br />
Cole, Philadelphia, PA<br />
San Diego To The Core . . . Dec 30<br />
Petco Park Baseball Field<br />
Ragain Martin E.; Yamada,Joy<br />
Illume/M-E Engineers, Inc., Wheat<br />
Ridge, CO And Pavek, Krystof,<br />
Luminatica, Rancho Santa Fe, CA<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
The Beacon of Fort<br />
Washington . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 46<br />
The National Track & Field Hall of<br />
Fame, Manhattan, NY<br />
Skolnick, Lee H. and Cardenas,<br />
Miguel; Lee H. Skolnic Architecture<br />
+ Design Partnership, and Leni<br />
Schwindinger, Light Projects Ltd.,<br />
New York, NY<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
Weekend Warriors to World-class<br />
Athletes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 34<br />
New University of Houston<br />
Recreation Center<br />
Lees, Stephen W. and Brandt, Lee<br />
E.; Horton lees Brogden Lighting<br />
Design, New York, NY<br />
Sustainable Design<br />
Caltrans Transcendent . . . Aug 65<br />
Caltran’s District 7Headquarters in<br />
Los Angeles, CA<br />
Brogden, Teal, Libonati, Heather,<br />
Horton Lees Brogden Lighting<br />
Design, Los Angeles, CA; Scott,<br />
Ron, Ledalite Architectural<br />
Products, Langley, BC & Wypasek,<br />
Michael, Paramount Industries,<br />
Inc., Croswell, MI<br />
Lost in Transformation . . . . Jul 46<br />
The Hiroshima City Naka<br />
Incineration Plant<br />
Mende, Kaoru, Lighting Planners<br />
Associates and Taniguchi, Yoshio,<br />
Taniguchi Associates, Tokyo, Japan<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Sign of the Times . . . . . . . . Jul 36<br />
The New York Times New<br />
Headquarters, New York, NY<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
West Side Story – A Revival .. Jul 42<br />
Grand Stewart’s Building,<br />
Baltimore, MD<br />
Barber, Michael A. and Diemer,<br />
Helen, The Lighting Practice, Inc.,<br />
Philadlephia, PA<br />
And Liebel, Tom, Design Collective,<br />
Inc., Baltimore, MD<br />
Technology<br />
Acing Emergency Lighting . Aug 71<br />
Sumner, Rob<br />
Crossing the Chasm . . . . . Nov 49<br />
White LEDs<br />
Dowling, Kevin<br />
Dirty Little Secrets. . . . . . . Oct 76<br />
Paulin, Doug<br />
Healthy Mind, Body . . . . . May 74<br />
Trively, Paul<br />
In Pursuit of Advanced<br />
Performance Sky<strong>light</strong>s . . . . Jul 56<br />
Cuttle, Christopher<br />
Industrial Intrigue: Fluorescent<br />
vs. HID . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 73<br />
Paulin, Doug<br />
Lighting Control: From Salt<br />
Water To Silicon . . . . . . . . May 78<br />
Maniccia, Dorene<br />
Test-Drive Your Lighting . . Oct 75<br />
Paulin, Doug<br />
The Cornerstone of<br />
Lighting Control . . . . . . . . Jun 56<br />
McBride, Rusty<br />
True Colors . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 38<br />
Ashdown, Ian<br />
Theater<br />
Chandelier Creates Stage Presence<br />
for Historic Theater . . . . . May 44<br />
The Providence Performing Arts<br />
Center, Providence, RI<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Halo Effect . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 28<br />
Hollywood Bowl<br />
Dachs, Joshua, Hoyes, Richard,<br />
Fisher Dachs Assoc., New York, NY<br />
and Fung, Hsin-Ming and Hodgetts,<br />
Craig, Hodgetts + Fung, Design &<br />
Architecture, Los Angeles, CA<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
The Show Glows On At<br />
The Bardavon . . . . . . . . . . Oct 32<br />
The Bardavon Theater,<br />
Poughkeepsie, NY<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
What’s New In Kalamazoo . Jan 42<br />
Kalamazoo Air Zoo, Hunter, Bill<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Transportation<br />
Brighter Days Below As Garage Gets<br />
Decked Out. . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 38<br />
Colliers Monroe Friedlander’s<br />
Building Parking Garag, Honolulu, HI<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Expansion Makes for a Friendlier Pre-<br />
F<strong>light</strong> Experience . . . . . . . Oct 31<br />
The International Terminal D,<br />
Dallas/Fort Worth International<br />
Airport<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
Take The Plane To<br />
The Train. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 33<br />
Alaska’s Bill Sheffield Railroad Depot<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
December 2005 LD+A 69
Annual Index • Author<br />
Abernathy, Katherine C.; Kilburn,<br />
Tayva; Abernathy, Christopher A. and<br />
Rainone, Jason<br />
The Big Red Time Machine. . . Sep 50<br />
Akashi, Yukio<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . . Mar 18<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . . . Jul 12<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . . Dec 10<br />
Ake, Ted<br />
Lighting For Security . . . . . . Apr 31<br />
Lighting For Security . . . . . . Jun 28<br />
Lighting For Security. . . . . . Aug 16<br />
Lighting For Security . . . . . . Oct 16<br />
Lighting For Security . . . . . . Dec 17<br />
Altman, Emlyn<br />
Computers and Lighting . . . Dec 57<br />
Digital Dialogue. . . . . . . . . . Jan 12<br />
Digital Dialogue . . . . . . . . . May 22<br />
Digital Dialogue . . . . . . . . . . Jul 14<br />
Ashdown, Ian<br />
True Colors. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 38<br />
Barber, Michael A.; Diemer, Helen and<br />
Liebel, Tom<br />
West Side Story – A Revival. . Jul 42<br />
Barr, Vilma<br />
Extreme Makeovers . . . . . . . Sep 56<br />
Benya, James A.<br />
Lighting In A Sustainable<br />
Future. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 70<br />
Bernecker, Craig<br />
President’s Perspective . . . . Jan 7<br />
President’s Perspective . . . . Apr 9<br />
Bleasby, Peter<br />
Rules & Regs. . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 16<br />
Brandston, Howard M.<br />
Bringing Humanities To<br />
Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 78<br />
Brogden, Teal; Libonati, Heather;<br />
Scott, Ron and Wypasek, Michael<br />
Blue and Red Get the<br />
Go-Ahead . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 69<br />
Caltrans Transcendent . . . . Aug 65<br />
Bullough, John D.<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . . Feb 12<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . . Jun 16<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . . Nov 10<br />
Burkett, Karl A.<br />
Is ELMS The Answer . . . . . Mar 46<br />
Burns, Rich; Bernardo, Luis and<br />
Sexton, George<br />
Thinking Outside the<br />
Black Box. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 72<br />
Clements, E. Frank<br />
Regional Voices . . . . . . . . . . Jun 12<br />
Creer, Wallace<br />
Technology . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 14<br />
Cunningham, Robert F.; Garman,<br />
Richard G. and Hahnlen, Brian<br />
Good Citizen . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 32<br />
Cuttle, Christopher<br />
In Pursuit of Advanced Performance<br />
Sky<strong>light</strong>s. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 56<br />
Daniels, Robert<br />
Sonic Temple Rebirth . . . . . Dec 52<br />
Deeb, Paul A.<br />
Force Of Nature. . . . . . . . . . Mar 40<br />
DiLaura, David<br />
Making Light in The 20th<br />
Century . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 87<br />
Dowling, Kevin<br />
Crossing the Chasm . . . . . . Nov 49<br />
Edenbaum, Dan<br />
Shopping in the Shadows . . . Jun 53<br />
Fairweather, Virginia<br />
Double Duty. . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 54<br />
Fallin, Robert, Lafitte, David and<br />
Laughlin, Robert J.<br />
Jacksonville’s Pregame<br />
Show. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 58<br />
Ferzacca, Nick<br />
Green Ideas. . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 14<br />
Figueiro, Mariana, G.<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . . Jan 14<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . . May 16<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . . Sep 18<br />
Fong, Denise<br />
Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 10<br />
Green Ideas. . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 22<br />
Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . . May 20<br />
Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 18<br />
Green Ideas. . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 22<br />
Frazier, Mary Claire<br />
Lighting Museums As Cultural<br />
Icons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 78<br />
Gauger, Dan and Spitulski, Stephen<br />
Portlanders ‘Thinking...<br />
Pink’ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 84<br />
Street<strong>light</strong>s In The Spot<strong>light</strong> . . Apr 83<br />
Who’s On First . . . . . . . . . . Apr 85<br />
Ham, Tao and Blanski, Bill<br />
Developing The Mind . . . . . . Jul 59<br />
Hanley, William<br />
Executive Vice President<br />
Reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 8<br />
Executive Vice Presidents<br />
Reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 10<br />
Executive Vice Presidents<br />
Reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 8<br />
Harlow, Grant<br />
Cold, Harsh Reality . . . . . . . Nov 42<br />
Seeing Dollar Signs. . . . . . . Nov 40<br />
Harmon, Marcel J.<br />
Lighting Across Cultures . . Jan 46<br />
Harwood, Ron; Klemmer, Kenneth;<br />
Vogel, Dennis and Schimmer, Larry<br />
A Walk in The Park . . . . . . . Mar 50<br />
Hawthorne, Darrell<br />
Ferry Good Show . . . . . . . . . Feb 38<br />
Hugh, Peter A<br />
Regional Voices . . . . . . . . . . Feb 8<br />
Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . . Sep 10<br />
Hunt, Patricia<br />
The Sporting Life. . . . . . . . . Sep 75<br />
Kale, Ann and Tihany, Adam D.<br />
Perfection Per Se . . . . . . . . May 62<br />
Kobes, John-Michael<br />
All Rolled Into One . . . . . . . May 52<br />
Another Brick In the Wall. . . Oct 65<br />
Beachfront Lighting Proves to<br />
be an Environmentally Safe<br />
Addition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 28<br />
Brighter Days Below As Garage<br />
Gets Decked Out . . . . . . . . . Mar 38<br />
Brighter is Better As<br />
BrandsMart Rebrands . . . . . Jun 44<br />
Bringing The Great Outdoors<br />
Inside . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 40<br />
Chandelier Creates Stage Presence<br />
for Historic Theater. . . . . . . May 44<br />
Come Sail Away With LEDs . Nov 44<br />
Crafty Lighting Upgrade Improves<br />
Retail Operations . . . . . . . . May 32<br />
Custom Made Fixtures<br />
Brighten Up Convention<br />
and Exhibit Center . . . . . . . Nov 34<br />
Even Illumination Brightens<br />
New Office Space . . . . . . . . Mar 36<br />
Expansion Makes for a Friendlier<br />
Pre-F<strong>light</strong> Experience. . . . . . Oct 31<br />
Failing Fixtures Are Expelled From<br />
School Retrofit . . . . . . . . . . Sep 39<br />
FedExcellent Adventure . . . . Dec 40<br />
Fifth Avenue Flurry Creates<br />
An LED Wonderland . . . . . . . Feb 31<br />
Food and Fiber Optics Are on<br />
the Menu . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 26<br />
Fresh Ideas For All To<br />
Indulge In . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 57<br />
From Gray To Green. . . . . . . Aug 52<br />
From Mill To Mall In One<br />
Renovation . . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 28<br />
Great Wall of Chi–Town . . . . Oct 62<br />
High Stakes In Exterior<br />
Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . May 56<br />
Hope Floats In Little Rock . . Apr 60<br />
Hydroelectric Sensation<br />
Breaks at Niagara Falls. . . . Jun 43<br />
It’s All Work and All Play in<br />
L.A. Headquarters . . . . . . . . Apr 58<br />
LEC Technology Captures The<br />
Checkered Flag. . . . . . . . . . . Jul 34<br />
Living The High Life . . . . . . . Jul 62<br />
Martha Says: “You’re Hired” . . Dec 27<br />
Restaurant Adds Lighting<br />
To Its Overhead. . . . . . . . . . . Jul 33<br />
Room With a View . . . . . . . . Aug 29<br />
See Me Now, Says Seawall . Aug 30<br />
Seeing Your Name in Lights . . Jan 25<br />
Take The Plane To The Train . . Feb 33<br />
The Show Glows On At The<br />
Bardavon. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 32<br />
Updated Track Lighting is<br />
the Favored Flavor. . . . . . . . Nov 33<br />
What’s New In Kalamazoo . . Jan 42<br />
Worth The Wait . . . . . . . . . . Nov 58<br />
Kohring Craig, R.<br />
Regional Voices . . . . . . . . . . Apr 10<br />
Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . . Dec 8<br />
Lanteigne, Robert<br />
Landscape Lighting<br />
Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 68<br />
70 www.iesna.org
Annual Index • Author<br />
Lees, Stephen W. and Brandt, Lee E.<br />
Weekend Warriors to<br />
World-Class Athletes. . . . . . Dec 34<br />
Leibowitz, Julie<br />
Profiles In Postcards. . . . . . Aug 48<br />
LeVere, Richard<br />
There From The Start. . . . . . Feb 59<br />
Lewis, Alan Laird<br />
President’s Perspective. . . . . Jul 8<br />
President’s Perspective . . . . Oct 6<br />
Liebel, Brian<br />
Hot Button. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 18<br />
Hot Button . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 26<br />
Hot Button . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 26<br />
Hot Button. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 20<br />
Lindstrom, Carole A.<br />
Rethinking Park Lighting . . May 30<br />
Lowe, Roslyn<br />
Come Home To MoMA . . . . . May 68<br />
Driven By Design. . . . . . . . . Sep 45<br />
Earth Wind Fire & Water . . . May 58<br />
Honor Roll . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 48<br />
Industrial Evolution . . . . . . . Jan 51<br />
Lost in Transformation . . . . . Jul 46<br />
Reach For The Sky . . . . . . . . Jul 66<br />
Richmond After Dark . . . . . . Oct 66<br />
Traveling First Class . . . . . . Sep 48<br />
Maniccia, Dorene<br />
Lighting Control: From Salt Water<br />
To Silicon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . May 78<br />
Margulies, Stephen<br />
Trading Up . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 46<br />
McBride, Rusty<br />
The Cornerstone of Lighting<br />
Control. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 56<br />
Miller, Naomi and North, Leslie<br />
Healing Environments. . . . . Mar 61<br />
Oomen, Manuel, Cummings, John and<br />
Diemer, Helen<br />
Emerging HID Technologies. Mar 73<br />
Orgish, David and Myer, Jan<br />
Built to Last . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 64<br />
O’Rourke, Conan<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . . Sep 18<br />
Padios, Scott D.<br />
Regional Voices . . . . . . . . . May 10<br />
Paulin, Doug. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />
Dirty Little Secrets . . . . . . . . Oct 76<br />
Industrial Intrigue:<br />
Fluorescent VS. HID . . . . . . . Oct 73<br />
Lighting For Quality . . . . . . . Jan 17<br />
Lighting For Quality . . . . . . Mar 27<br />
Lighting For Quality . . . . . . May 26<br />
Lighting For Quality. . . . . . . Dec 17<br />
Test-Drive Your Lighting . . . Oct 75<br />
Pompeo, Paul<br />
Careers & Hiring . . . . . . . . . Apr 20<br />
Careers & Hiring . . . . . . . . . Jun 22<br />
Careers & Hiring . . . . . . . . . Aug 16<br />
Careers & Hiring . . . . . . . . . Sep 26<br />
Rambusch, Viggo<br />
Fixtures Were His Fancy. . . . Oct 86<br />
Rea, Mark S.<br />
Eerie Coincidences . . . . . . . Mar 80<br />
From The Shoulders of<br />
Giants. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 78<br />
Romaniello, Peter<br />
Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . . Mar 11<br />
Regional Voices . . . . . . . . . . Oct 8<br />
Thou Shall Understand Residential<br />
Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 61<br />
Roush, Mark and Oberkircher, Fred<br />
Techniques for Teaching<br />
Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 70<br />
Samuelson, Christopher E.<br />
Visual Ergonomics:<br />
A Closer Look . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 20<br />
Stone II, Charles G. and Hess<br />
Jonathan R.<br />
Spreading Its Wings . . . . . . Nov 52<br />
Sumner, Rob<br />
Acing Emergency Lighting . . . Aug 71<br />
Tarricone, Paul<br />
An LED Glows In Brooklyn . . Feb 47<br />
Back & Forth. . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 55<br />
Big-Box To Boutique . . . . . . Apr 91<br />
Coming Soon To Broadway . . Feb 44<br />
Covering All The Bases . . . . Sep 61<br />
Dark From Day One. . . . . . . May 49<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . May 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 4<br />
Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 4<br />
Finally Blue . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 37<br />
Halo Effect. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 28<br />
Line-Up Change . . . . . . . . . Sep 63<br />
New Frontier . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 66<br />
Over & Out. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 78<br />
Retail Reflections . . . . . . . . Apr 87<br />
San Diego To The Core. . . . . Dec 30<br />
Sign of the Times . . . . . . . . . Jul 36<br />
Take It From The Top. . . . . . . Jul 40<br />
The Beacon of<br />
Fort Washington . . . . . . . . . Jun 46<br />
Three Easy Pieces . . . . . . . . May 46<br />
Tiller, Dale and Houser, Kevin<br />
Light, Sight and the Senses. . . Mar. 64<br />
Tolen, Thomas<br />
Regional Voices . . . . . . . . . . . Aug. . 8<br />
Trively, Paul<br />
Healthy Mind, Body &<br />
Bottom Line . . . . . . . . . . . . May 74<br />
Van Derlofske, John<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . . Apr 16<br />
Research Matters . . . . . . . . Aug 12<br />
Warfel, William B.<br />
Light, Discovery, Spirit and<br />
Consequences. . . . . . . . . . . Mar 66<br />
Warren, William L<br />
Energy Advisor. . . . . . . . . . . Jan 8<br />
Energy Advisor. . . . . . . . . . . Feb 10<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . Mar 12<br />
Energy Advisor. . . . . . . . . . . Apr 12<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . May 12<br />
Energy Advisor. . . . . . . . . . . Jun 14<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 10<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . Aug 10<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . Sep 14<br />
Energy Advisor. . . . . . . . . . . Oct 10<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . Nov 8<br />
Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . Dec 9<br />
Yeager, Raymond<br />
Material Things. . . . . . . . . . Mar 76<br />
December 2005 LD+A 71
LIGHT PRODUCTS<br />
Lutron Electronics Co., Inc.<br />
has added stainless steel wallplates<br />
to its Fassada and Claro wallplate<br />
collections to coordinate with<br />
black dimmers, switches and accessories.<br />
The stainless steel<br />
Fassada wallplates, which feature a<br />
small toggle opening, complement<br />
Lutron’s expanded line of Faedra,<br />
Qoto, Ariadni and Toggler dimmers.<br />
The stainless steel Claro<br />
wallplates, which feature a large<br />
designer opening, fit Lutron’s<br />
Skylark, Diva, Maestro and RadioRA<br />
dimmers, switches and accessories.<br />
The low-profile, two-piece wallplate<br />
features rounded edges and<br />
a “no visible screws” design, offering<br />
a clean look.<br />
www.lutron.com<br />
Mystique, a handcrafted glass<br />
piece from Austria, is available<br />
with Bruck Lighting Systems’<br />
two in. or 4 in. kiss canopy (with<br />
integral transformer) or with a<br />
uni-plug to attach to any of<br />
Bruck’s tracks systems.<br />
www.bruck<strong>light</strong>ingsystems.com<br />
The Monolith wall scone from Original<br />
Cast Lighting is available in two sizes, four<br />
unique face patterns and is useful for applications<br />
where the user is retrofitting a space or<br />
doesn’t have the room to remote mount an<br />
emergency ballast.<br />
www.theocl.com<br />
Appleton’s Mercmaster III<br />
Induction fixture that provides a<br />
cost-effective, long-term solution<br />
for hazardous and non-hazardous<br />
industrial <strong>light</strong>ing needs,and is especially<br />
effective where access for<br />
relamping is difficult, maintenance is<br />
prohibitively expensive, and reliability<br />
is absolutely essential. Even after<br />
60,000 hours of use, the luminaire<br />
should maintain 70 percent of its<br />
total <strong>light</strong> output.<br />
www.appletonelec.com<br />
Advance Transformers’ has expanded its line of sign PRO LED Sign<br />
Drivers to include a new 100-W 24-vdc model for use in a wide variety<br />
of LED <strong>light</strong>ing applications.The driver features IntelliVolt Multiple-Voltage<br />
technology, which enables its operation at any input voltage from 120 to<br />
277 volts, 50/60Hz, subsequently reducing SKU requirements,<br />
enhancing ease and accuracy of ordering, and eliminating field<br />
mis-match concerns.The drivers further carry a “CE” certification<br />
for use in applications involving European<br />
voltages (220-240-V, 50Hz), as well as UL-recognized<br />
component status and CSA listing.<br />
www.advancetransformer.com<br />
Display <strong>light</strong>ing is transformed into a beautiful art form with<br />
W.A.C. Lighting’s precision modules, a new line of upscale<br />
specification grade multiple recessed spot<strong>light</strong>s that integrate<br />
robust, architectural styling and elegance with superior function<br />
and versatility. Spot<strong>light</strong>s can be interchanged with the precise<br />
number and types of lamps needed to accomplish the task at<br />
hand, whether it is wall washing, accent, spot or perimeter <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
or any combination.<br />
www.wac<strong>light</strong>ing.com<br />
74 www.iesna.org
The FOMH-150C illuminator is the latest addition to Lighting<br />
Services Inc’s fiber optic line of <strong>products</strong>. The FOMH-150C is a<br />
metal halide fiber optic unit that utilizes the highly efficient 150-W<br />
reflectorized CDM-SA/R lamp.This 4000 hour lamp produces a crisp,<br />
white <strong>light</strong> ideal for display, architectural and case <strong>light</strong>ing where relatively<br />
high <strong>light</strong> levels are desirable.<br />
www.<strong>light</strong>ingservicesinc.com<br />
The restyled Claire wall fixture<br />
from Leucos USA elegantly<br />
drapes satin white glass over a polished<br />
chrome-plated structure, diffusing<br />
the <strong>light</strong> source to produce a<br />
smooth glow. Extending beyond the<br />
metal base, the graceful inward curvature<br />
of the glass adds depth and<br />
intrigue to the stylish piece. Claire<br />
is available in three sizes with incandescent<br />
or fluorescent lamping.<br />
www.leucos.com<br />
Leucos USA, Inc’s pulse<br />
series of hand-blown glass fixtures<br />
is an explosion of cones and<br />
leaves that curve with a graceful<br />
and dramatic presence. The fixture<br />
is available in colorless<br />
Venetian crystal, shiny black and<br />
shiny milky team, and it is available<br />
in three sizes.<br />
www.leucos.com<br />
Through a colorful, graphical<br />
interface, the LyteScene Touch<br />
Screen Master Station from<br />
Lightolier Controls can capture<br />
and simulate the control<br />
panel functions of any selected<br />
LYTEmode Network Master<br />
Station or Remote in real time.<br />
With only a few simple touches<br />
of the screen, adjustments can be<br />
made to any individual channel or<br />
“scene” presets in any room in<br />
the system.<br />
www.lolcontrols.com<br />
Advance Transformer has enhancement of its line of<br />
Centiu Instant Start Normal Light Output Electronic Ballasts<br />
with IntelliVolt to include new energy-saving low-watt models<br />
for the operation of one-four T8 fluorescent lamps. Designed<br />
to operate from one to four 32-W, 25-W, and 17-W standard<br />
T8 lamps as well as one to four 30-W, 28-W, and 25-W energy-saving<br />
T8 lamps, the ballasts are ideal for general office <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
as well as both new construction and retrofit applications.<br />
www.advancetransformer.com<br />
Fiberoptic Lighting’s, fiber optic Starfield brings the night sky indoors for<br />
themed environments, tradeshow and special events. Each panel has a Starfield<br />
with galactic effects and an additional enhancement of fireworks. The fireworks<br />
are on separate circuits and can be turned on or off. Pictured is an image, which<br />
is a composite of six digital images taken of one of the panels as it went through<br />
its celestial program of <strong>light</strong>, color and movement.<br />
www.flisign.com<br />
April 75 December 2005 2005 LD+A LD+A www.iesna.org<br />
75
LIGHT PRODUCTS<br />
Globe Electric Company’s<br />
Ultra Mini soft white, compact fluorescent<br />
lamp (CFL) is Energy Star<br />
Approved and warranted by Globe<br />
to last up to five years based on normal<br />
use (3-4 hours per day). The<br />
small size and the big energy savings<br />
make the lamp the ideal energy saving<br />
replacement for the standard<br />
incandescent bulb for indoor or outdoor<br />
use.The 9-W CFL can replace<br />
a 40-W standard household lamp<br />
and the 13-W replaces the 60-W.<br />
www.globe-electric.com<br />
Fiberoptic Lighting’s En<strong>light</strong>ened<br />
Labyrinth uses the Chartres<br />
model, the lunations on the edges of<br />
the En<strong>light</strong>ened Labyrinth are lit and<br />
the center area is also lit with fiber<br />
optic <strong>light</strong>ing. The center changes<br />
colors slowly while the lunations<br />
flicker as if they are candles. The<br />
En<strong>light</strong>ened Labyrinth is ideally suited<br />
as a meditative and healing tool in<br />
hospital/healthcare and church applications<br />
and is also perfect for garden<br />
centers, florists, themed environments,<br />
retailers and restaurants.<br />
www.flisign.com<br />
Besa Lighting’s Adjustable 3-<br />
Light Bars in its “A Series” of lowvoltage<br />
mini pendants are<br />
designed with adjustable pull-up<br />
and pull-down mechanisms to<br />
adjust the pendant heights according<br />
to the end-users’ <strong>light</strong>ing<br />
needs. The series includes 50-W<br />
halogen lamps and 60-W class two<br />
electronic transformers. More<br />
than 50 different color and style<br />
options are offered in the series.<br />
www.besa<strong>light</strong>ing.com<br />
Heatron’s new six-page<br />
brochure details their extensive<br />
design,assembly and systems expertise<br />
in LED <strong>light</strong> engine technology.<br />
Heatron’s design and integration<br />
capabilities allow them to balance<br />
the critical disciplines required —<br />
including power sources or drivers,<br />
emitters, thermal management, secondary<br />
optics, housings, or enclosures<br />
— to create the optimal solution<br />
for your LED application.<br />
www.heatron.com<br />
Leviton's line of locking plugs for<br />
original equipment manufacturers<br />
(OEMs) offers high quality 2-pole,<br />
3-wire grounding devices for equipment<br />
requiring a National Electrical<br />
Manufacturers Association (NEMA)<br />
locking plug configuration. Built to<br />
the highest industry standards and<br />
providing superior performance in<br />
demanding settings, the locking<br />
plugs offer unparalleled reliability for<br />
a diverse range of applications,<br />
including connections for pendant<br />
<strong>light</strong>ing fixtures, commercial food<br />
processing equipment, and commercial<br />
and industrial cleaning<br />
equipment.<br />
www.leviton.com<br />
Advanced Lighting Technologies’<br />
Microsun combines metal<br />
halide technology with beautiful and<br />
unique table and floor lamp designs<br />
that use metal halide technology to<br />
provide adequate <strong>light</strong> levels for<br />
aging eyes. Microsun lamps feature a<br />
metal halide lamp that uses only 68<br />
watts of energy while giving off the<br />
same amount of <strong>light</strong> as five 75-W<br />
incandescent or one 300-W halogen<br />
lamp; and because the system uses<br />
less wattage, there is less heat generated,<br />
making it more comfortable<br />
to sit next to one of these lamps.<br />
www.venture<strong>light</strong>ing.com<br />
76 www.iesna.org
BEGA’s introduces a square reflector luminaire with a totally<br />
adjustable indirect optical system. The square top reflector and<br />
the luminaire are fixed to each other and adjust together from<br />
zero deg to 65 deg to direct <strong>light</strong> where it is needed.Two gasketed<br />
clamps at the top of the fitter can be loosened to allow adjustment<br />
of the entire luminaire reflector assembly.This luminaire is<br />
ideal for parking areas, roadways and pedestrian scale landscape<br />
and is available in five standard finishes.<br />
www.bega-us.com<br />
Hoffman Products’ Speede Connectors<br />
line now includes a clear color coded style.<br />
These new clear connectors are UL/C for solid<br />
copper wire. A quick, fast and efficient push in<br />
wire concept for splicing significantly reduces<br />
installation cost. Made of 6/6 nylon, and rated<br />
for 600 volts, they are designed to handle wire<br />
sizes 12-22 AWG.<br />
www.hoffman<strong>products</strong>.com<br />
Kirlin’s SofTex square and rectangular<br />
trims complement the<br />
finest of architectural spaces such as<br />
restaurants, residences, entertainment<br />
venues and high-end public and<br />
office spaces. All rectangles and wall<br />
washes come standard with tempered<br />
Microlux lenses mounted<br />
above the lower trim. Type IC, Air<br />
Tight and many shallow plenum luminaires are available along with several optional colors<br />
and lenses and corrugated aluminum trims.<br />
www.kirlin<strong>light</strong>ing.com<br />
Gigahertz-Optik’s hand-held meter for color<br />
and illuminance/ luminance measurements of <strong>light</strong><br />
sources in the field or lab now includes a Delta-<br />
UV function.The ergonomically designed and easy<br />
to use HCT-99-D measures color chromaticity<br />
coordinates x,y and u’,v’, lux and/or candela per<br />
square meter, correlated color temperature as<br />
well as then new Delta-UV function which shows<br />
the deviation of the measured x, y color coordinates<br />
from the black body radiator locus.<br />
www.gigahertz-optik.com<br />
December 2005 LD+A 77