03.02.2015 Views

light products - Illuminating Engineering Society

light products - Illuminating Engineering Society

light products - Illuminating Engineering Society

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Lighting Design + Application • December 2005<br />

The<br />

LIGHTING<br />

AUTHORITY ®<br />

MEMPHIS<br />

BELLE<br />

FedEx Forum—<br />

Home of the NBA’s<br />

Grizzlies<br />

Focus On<br />

Sports<br />

Lighting


CONTENTS<br />

December 2005,<br />

VOL. 35/NO. 12<br />

SPORTS LIGHTING<br />

30<br />

San Diego to the Core<br />

Emphasizing regionalism over nostalgia,<br />

Petco Park celebrates San Diego even<br />

more than baseball<br />

52<br />

34<br />

Weekend Warriors<br />

toWorld-Class Athletes<br />

Lighting design at the new University of<br />

Houston Recreation Center<br />

accommodates athletes of all stripes<br />

57<br />

40<br />

FedExcellent<br />

Adventure<br />

The FedExForum might be in the heart<br />

of the Memphis music scene, but with<br />

its instant success, it’s feeling anything<br />

but the blues<br />

FEATURES<br />

46<br />

Trading Up<br />

The Bank of America trading floor<br />

satisfies <strong>light</strong>-sensitive traders while<br />

adding sizzle to the Charlotte, NC,<br />

skyline<br />

52<br />

Sonic Temple Rebirth<br />

Thanks to an updated, camouflaged<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing system, the Borobudur Temple<br />

now has a true night life<br />

CENTURY SERIES<br />

57<br />

Computers and<br />

Lighting<br />

After exponential growth in the 1980s<br />

and ’90s, has development of <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

design software reached a lull<br />

34<br />

30<br />

46<br />

D E P A R T M E N T S<br />

4 Editor’s Note • 6 Letters to the Editor • 8 Regional Voices • 9 Energy<br />

Advisor • 10 Research Matters • 14 Green Ideas • 17 Lighting for<br />

Quality • 18 Lighting for Security • 21 IES News • 25 Industry Updates<br />

• 27 Scanningthe Spectrum • 65 Index of Articles • 72 Literature Review<br />

• 74 Light Products • 78 Classified Advertisements • 79 Calendar of<br />

Events • 80 Ad Index<br />

LD+A (ISSN 0360-6325) is published monthly in the United States of America by the <strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong> of North America, 120 Wall<br />

Street, 17th Floor, New York, NY. 10005, 212-248-5000. © 2005 by the <strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong> of North America. Periodicals postage paid at New<br />

York, N.Y. 10005 and additional mailing offices. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to LD+A, 120 Wall Street, 17th Floor, New York, NY 10005.<br />

ON THE COVER:<br />

Sports and architectural <strong>light</strong>ing integrate<br />

with façade <strong>light</strong>ing at the FedExForum in<br />

Memphis. Photo by Tim Hursley


EDITOR’S NOTE<br />

Paul Tarricone<br />

THE MOVIE CATCH ME IF<br />

YOU CAN has an instructive scene<br />

about the power of image and “looking<br />

the part.” The character played by<br />

Christopher Walken asks his son,<br />

portrayed by Leonardo DiCaprio,<br />

why he thinks the Yankees always win<br />

the World Series.“Because they have<br />

Mickey Mantle” the son replies.<br />

“No,” the father responds, “it’s<br />

because the other guys can’t take<br />

their eyes off the pinstripes.”<br />

This brings us to the <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

designer who likes to pull up to the<br />

client’s office in a Jaguar convertible,<br />

because he likes the image it creates.<br />

Marketing consulting Lloyd<br />

Princeton used this designer as<br />

Exhibit A of the power of perception<br />

during his presentation at the<br />

5th Annual IALD Education<br />

Conference in Alexandria, VA. His<br />

message: you’re selling a luxury and<br />

you need to convey to clients that<br />

there’s a minimum point of entry—<br />

a minimum bar—for those who<br />

want to do business with you. Overeager<br />

designers stuck with flat fees<br />

often forget that “clients are not<br />

‘entitled’ [to high-end design services],”<br />

said Princeton.There’s a premium<br />

to be paid for good design.<br />

How do you build your brand<br />

Princeton advised designers to<br />

focus on the “who” and the “what.”<br />

Identify who (in terms of the market<br />

niche) you want to do business<br />

with and sub-identify that group’s<br />

demographics.“If it’s residential end<br />

users, how old are they Is this a<br />

second or third home for them Do<br />

they have children If it’s a corporate<br />

client, is it a facility manager or<br />

real estate person” Part of identifying<br />

the “who” is understanding their<br />

tendencies. “Corporate and hospitality<br />

are more bottom-line oriented.<br />

With residential you can maximize<br />

profits because the client is<br />

more emotionally invested,” he said.<br />

Another piece of advice from<br />

Princeton seems counter-intuitive:<br />

Don’t be a generalist. (Almost without<br />

exception, the “About the<br />

Designer” bios that accompany case<br />

history articles in LD+A list experience<br />

in “retail, corporate, institutional,<br />

residential” and so on and so<br />

forth.) However, Princeton claims<br />

the trend today in interior design is<br />

toward specialization. What’s more,<br />

being all things to all people forces<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing designers to work “on projects<br />

they don’t like.”<br />

Once the “who” is identified,<br />

move on to the “what.” Tried-andtrue<br />

marketing tools include public<br />

relations (positioning yourself as an<br />

expert to the press); advertising (in<br />

local media and in publications like<br />

the American Express magazine);<br />

one-on-one lunch-and-learns; press<br />

kits; web sites; and a Princeton<br />

favorite, direct mail. Once again<br />

emphasizing his preference for specialization,<br />

he advocates separate<br />

pieces (ideally) for each market you<br />

want to hit,mailed six to eight times<br />

per year. But if given the choice of a<br />

divide-and-conquer approach in<br />

‘Go to the end<br />

user and say the<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing designer—<br />

not the interior<br />

designer or the<br />

architect—should<br />

be the first<br />

person you hire’<br />

which you send two pieces to three<br />

markets vs. targeting just one market,<br />

Princeton chooses the latter.<br />

Finally, if they “really want to<br />

shake things up,” Princeton says<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing designers may want to position<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing as “big and fundamental...Go<br />

to the end user and say the<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing designer—not the interior<br />

designer or the architect—should<br />

be the first person you hire.”<br />

If all this seems a bit overwhelming<br />

to designers who are “too busy<br />

to worry about marketing” or have<br />

limited resources, remember the<br />

first rule of Marketing 101: clients<br />

are not willing to pay for something<br />

they don’t understand.<br />

Publisher<br />

William Hanley, CAE<br />

Editor<br />

Paul Tarricone<br />

Associate Editor<br />

John-Michael Kobes<br />

Assistant Editor<br />

Roslyn Lowe<br />

Art Director<br />

Samuel Fontanez<br />

Associate Art Director<br />

Petra Domingo<br />

Columnists<br />

Ted Ake • Emlyn G.Altman<br />

Denise Fong • Brian Liebel<br />

Doug Paulin • Paul Pompeo<br />

Willard Warren<br />

Book Review Editor<br />

Paulette Hebert, Ph.D.<br />

Marketing Manager<br />

Sue Foley<br />

Advertising Coordinator<br />

Leslie Prestia<br />

Published by IESNA<br />

120 Wall Street, 17th Floor<br />

New York, NY 10005-4001<br />

Phone: 212-248-5000<br />

Fax: 212-248-5017/18<br />

Website: www.iesna.org<br />

Email: iesna@iesna.org<br />

LD+A is a magazine for professionals involved in the art,<br />

science, study, manufacture, teaching, and implementation<br />

of <strong>light</strong>ing. LD+A is designed to enhance and improve the<br />

practice of <strong>light</strong>ing. Every issue of LD+A includes feature<br />

articles on design projects, technical articles on the science<br />

of illumination, new product developments, industry<br />

trends, news of the <strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong> of<br />

North America, and vital information about the illuminating<br />

profession.<br />

Statements and opinions expressed in articles and editorials<br />

in LD+A are the expressions of contributors and do<br />

not necessarily represent the policies or opinions of the<br />

<strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong> of North America.<br />

Advertisements appearing in this publication are the sole<br />

responsibility of the advertiser.<br />

LD+A (ISSN 0360-6325) is published monthly in the<br />

United States of America by the <strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong><br />

<strong>Society</strong> of North America, 120 Wall Street, 17th Floor,<br />

New York, NY 10005, 212-248-5000. Copyright 2005 by<br />

the <strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong> of North<br />

America. Periodicals postage paid at New York, NY<br />

10005 and additional mailing offices. Nonmember subscriptions<br />

$44.00 per year.Additional $15.00 postage for<br />

subscriptions outside the United States. Member subscriptions<br />

$32.00 (not deductible from annual dues).<br />

Additional subscriptions $44.00. Single copies $4.00,<br />

except Lighting Equipment & Accessories Directory and<br />

Progress Report issues $10.00. Authorization to reproduce<br />

articles for internal or personal use by specific<br />

clients is granted by IESNA to libraries and other users<br />

registered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC)<br />

Transactional Reporting Service, provided a fee of $2.00<br />

per copy is paid directly to CCC, 21 Congress Street,<br />

Salem, MA 01970. IESNA fee code: 0360-6325/86 $2.00.<br />

This consent does not extend to other kinds of copying<br />

for purposes such as general distribution, advertising or<br />

promotion, creating new collective works, or resale.<br />

POSTMASTER: Send address changes to LD+A, 120<br />

Wall Street, 17th Floor, New York, NY 10005. Subscribers:<br />

For continuous service please notify LD+A of address<br />

changes at least 6 weeks in advance.<br />

This publication is indexed regularly by <strong>Engineering</strong><br />

Index, Inc. and Applied Science & Technology Index.<br />

LD+A is available on microfilm from Proquest Information<br />

and Learning, 800-521-0600,Ann Arbor, MI.<br />

4 www.iesna.org


LETTERS TO THE EDITOR<br />

Run That Design<br />

by Maintenance<br />

Folks, First<br />

Reading “Over &<br />

Out” (LD+A, October)<br />

confirmed my experience<br />

that very few <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

designers check with<br />

maintenance and facility<br />

people two-to-four years<br />

after their buildings have<br />

been built. If more <strong>light</strong>ing designers asked maintenance and facility people<br />

what they think of the number of lamp types, lamp life, lamp costs,<br />

accessibility inside fixtures, and ease of maintaining <strong>light</strong>ing control systems,<br />

I think that many <strong>light</strong>ing designers would change how they do<br />

design. A good chunk of my retrofit business is from end users in buildings<br />

that have good quality and energy-efficient <strong>light</strong>ing, but the maintenance<br />

costs are very high. I appreciate the business, but would prefer if<br />

more <strong>light</strong>ing designers would walk a mile in the shoes of maintenance<br />

and facility people in the first place.<br />

Stan Walerczyk<br />

Lighting Wizards<br />

Walnut Creek, CA<br />

Membership Still Has Its Advantages<br />

It’s hard for me to believe that I got started in <strong>light</strong>ing in October of<br />

1949 and in 2005 I’m still active at the age of 77 and going strong.<br />

Lighting has come a long way in the 55-plus years that I’ve been in the<br />

business.So has the IESNA.When I first started BBS/A.L.P.in 1955,I couldn’t<br />

afford to join anything. As soon as I started making a few dollars, I<br />

joined the IESNA in 1961 and I have been an involved and committed<br />

member ever since.<br />

Each year there are older members, like myself, fading away and new<br />

members who are becoming involved, who will become the future leaders<br />

of IESNA. This Centennial year is a significant one for our organization.<br />

My advice to anyone in the <strong>light</strong>ing business is that if you’re not involved<br />

with the IESNA, then you’re truly not involved or committed to our industry.<br />

You get out of anything what you put into it, and I, for one, sure feel<br />

that I’ve gotten more out than I ever put in, no matter how much effort<br />

that I made.Thanks for listening.<br />

WM Brown<br />

Bill Brown Sales/A.L.P. Lighting Components<br />

Niles, IL<br />

oe-mail a letter<br />

to the editor:<br />

ptarricone@iesna.org<br />

PRESIDENT<br />

Alan L. Lewis, O.D., Ph.D., FIES<br />

The New England College of Optometry<br />

PAST PRESIDENT<br />

Craig A. Bernecker, Ph.D., FIES, LC<br />

The Lighting Education Institute<br />

SENIOR VICE PRESIDENT<br />

(President-Elect)<br />

Kevin Flynn<br />

Kiku Obata & Company<br />

VP-EDUCATIONAL<br />

ACTIVITIES<br />

Ronald Gibbons, Ph.D.<br />

Virginia Tech Transportation Institute<br />

VP-TECHNICAL & RESEARCH<br />

Pekka Hakkarainen<br />

Lutron Electronics Co. Inc.<br />

VP-DESIGN & APPLICATION<br />

Joseph B. Murdoch, Ph.D., PE, FIES, LC<br />

University of New Hampshire (retired)<br />

VP-MEMBER ACTIVITIES<br />

Kimberly Szinger, PE<br />

Stantec Consulting<br />

TREASURER<br />

Boyd Corbett<br />

S2C Incorporated<br />

EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT<br />

William Hanley<br />

IESNA<br />

DIRECTORS<br />

David A. Baum<br />

Holophane<br />

James Cyre<br />

Philips Lighting<br />

Terrance Kilbourne, LC<br />

TEC, Inc.<br />

Denis Lavoie, LC<br />

LUMEC, Inc.<br />

Paul Mercier, LC<br />

Lighting Design Innovations, Ltd.<br />

Russ Owens, LC<br />

West Coast Design Group<br />

RVP/DIRECTORS<br />

Craig Kohring<br />

mda engineering, inc.<br />

Thomas Tolen, LC<br />

TMT Associates<br />

2005-2006<br />

Board of Directors<br />

IESNA<br />

6 www.iesna.org


REGIONAL VOICES<br />

Craig R. Kohring,<br />

Great Lakes RVP<br />

AS YOU READ THIS ARTICLE,<br />

you are probably juggling several different<br />

balls in the air, hoping that you<br />

do not drop any of them. You are<br />

probably dealing with project deadlines<br />

at work,holiday planning,a myriad<br />

of office and family functions that<br />

take place at this time of year, and so<br />

forth and so on. This time of year<br />

always seems to have the same<br />

theme for everyone. It is a hectic<br />

time,as well as a time for sharing and<br />

giving. The question I pose to you<br />

today is,“How is this really different<br />

from any other time of the year”<br />

I ask this question for selfish reasons.<br />

In the not so distant past, at a<br />

Great Lakes Regional Executive<br />

Committee (REC) meeting, I was<br />

asked about improving attendance<br />

at our meetings.Those of you in the<br />

Great Lakes region know that our<br />

meetings are held at a central point<br />

in our region (Cleveland, OH). The<br />

longest drive for any section meeting<br />

is about four hours, and our<br />

actual business meeting lasts about<br />

four hours. It is a long day for most,<br />

but usually an en<strong>light</strong>ening experience.<br />

On the drive home, I began to<br />

ponder the reasons for poor attendance<br />

at regional events. There are<br />

always project deadlines, family and<br />

social commitments, etc. Sounds<br />

similar to the holidays, doesn’t it<br />

What is missing is the sharing and<br />

giving.<br />

Giving and Sharing<br />

For those of you who have not<br />

attended a regional event, I hope to<br />

offer some insight. For those who<br />

attend on a regular basis, feel free to<br />

take this time to catch up on those<br />

project deadlines.<br />

The IESNA Section Guide states<br />

(and I paraphrase) that the section<br />

president, vice president and secretary<br />

are members of the REC, and<br />

shall attend REC meetings. If one of<br />

these officers is not available, a<br />

There is a wealth of knowledge in<br />

our <strong>Society</strong>, and most of it resides at<br />

our section level<br />

member of the Board of Managers<br />

should attend in his or her place.<br />

Using that standard, my region<br />

should have an attendance of 36 at<br />

our REC. Instead, we average a little<br />

less than half of that number.<br />

The purpose of an REC meeting<br />

is to share information and<br />

exchange ideas to make our sections<br />

stronger. At our REC meeting,<br />

we try to devote about an hour for<br />

sections to discuss topics such as<br />

initiatives, goals, good and bad meetings,<br />

and membership. This portion<br />

of the meeting is usually the most<br />

interesting, and can really generate<br />

excitement and enthusiasm in our<br />

section officers.There is a wealth of<br />

knowledge in our <strong>Society</strong>, and most<br />

of it resides at the section level.<br />

Greater attendance encourages<br />

added participation, more ideas, and<br />

shared knowledge and expertise.<br />

The REC meeting provides other<br />

valuable information, as well. Our<br />

REC meeting typically includes time<br />

dedicated to section level reporting<br />

requirements, and contact information,<br />

as well as <strong>Society</strong> level news<br />

and events. In fact, at our last REC,<br />

one of our new participants said<br />

that she had learned more in the<br />

first 40 minutes of the meeting, than<br />

she had in her years of service on<br />

her section’s Board of Managers.<br />

So, I hope that I have provoked<br />

some thought about attending your<br />

REC meeting. We, as regional vice<br />

presidents, know that your time is<br />

valuable, and family is more important<br />

than IESNA (did I say that).All<br />

we ask is that you try to include<br />

time in your hectic schedule for<br />

sharing and giving to your region. It<br />

is only with your help and participation<br />

that we can make our sections<br />

and regions as strong as possible.<br />

8 www.iesna.org


ENERGY ADVISOR<br />

Willard L.Warren,<br />

PE, LC, FIESNA<br />

WALT KELLY, CREATOR OF<br />

the POGO cartoon strip coined the<br />

phrase,“I have met the enemy and it<br />

is us.” Well,“I have seen the future of<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing and it’s located in California.”<br />

The state was devastated by the<br />

manipulation of the delivery of electric<br />

power by greedy suppliers six<br />

years ago and now has bounced back<br />

with a vengeance.A new version of its<br />

energy code, Title 24-2005, enacted<br />

on October 1, is sensible and workable,<br />

because of input from Jim Benya,<br />

PE of Benya Lighting, a code expert<br />

and <strong>light</strong>ing designer, and from Lisa<br />

Heschong and Doug Mahone of the<br />

Heschong Mahone Group, who<br />

advised the state on the importance<br />

of day<strong>light</strong> harvesting.<br />

To further aid the state in promoting<br />

energy-efficient <strong>light</strong>ing with<br />

a market-friendly design and to disseminate<br />

useful information about<br />

Title 24-2005, the California<br />

Lighting Technology Center (CLTC)<br />

was created last year at the<br />

University of California, Davis. The<br />

CLTC director is Michael J.<br />

Sominovitch, PhD, the associate<br />

director is Kosta Papamichael, PhD,<br />

both previously with the Lighting<br />

Research Center at Lawrence<br />

Berkeley National Labs. California<br />

Energy Commissioner (CEC) Art<br />

Rosenfeld indicated that the center<br />

was created because the CEC and<br />

other industry stakeholders recognized<br />

the importance that <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

holds in cutting down on energy<br />

use. “By partnering with the commission,<br />

the <strong>light</strong>ing industry and<br />

with public utilities, the CLTC<br />

ensures a hands-on practical<br />

approach to the creation of energyefficient<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing that is also appealing<br />

to consumers,” Rosenfeld said.<br />

“The center holds great promise in<br />

sharply reducing the power consumed<br />

by <strong>light</strong>ing during crunch<br />

electricity periods.” The CLTC<br />

coordinates outreach and support<br />

efforts with existing utility-based<br />

energy centers, offering touring<br />

exhibits, demonstration materials<br />

and technical assistance in the<br />

adoption of emerging technologies.<br />

Already, over two dozen <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

companies and utilities are partnering<br />

with the CLTC to develop new<br />

and efficient <strong>light</strong>ing <strong>products</strong> for<br />

commercial use. For more information,<br />

visit the CLTC web site at<br />

http:cltc.ucdavis.edu, or contact Dr.<br />

Siminovitch at (530) 757-3444, or at<br />

mjsiminovitch@ucdavis.edu.<br />

To put things into perspective,<br />

California’s peak demand over the last<br />

40 years has increased an average of<br />

2.2 percent, almost 50 percent above<br />

the national average. But because of<br />

its population growth and Title 24<br />

codes, the total per capita electric use<br />

is only 7000 kW per hour per year<br />

which is 40 percent less than the<br />

national average. Lighting accounts for<br />

about 20 percent of electric energy<br />

use in the U.S.,exceeded only by heating<br />

and cooling which draws about 35<br />

I have seen the<br />

future of <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

and it’s located in<br />

California<br />

percent. The average energy consumption<br />

for indoor <strong>light</strong>ing in large<br />

commercial office buildings has steadily<br />

dropped one percent per year since<br />

1975. Thirty years ago we averaged<br />

four watts per sq ft for <strong>light</strong>ing in large<br />

commercial office buildings and<br />

ranged between peaks of 10 to 15<br />

watts per sq ft for retail <strong>light</strong>ing.<br />

Today’s energy codes, like Title 24,<br />

limit office <strong>light</strong>ing to 1.2 watts per sq<br />

ft and retail <strong>light</strong>ing from 4.5 to 6.0<br />

watts per sq ft, depending on the type<br />

of merchandise displayed.<br />

California Here I Come<br />

The goal in enacting Title 24-2005<br />

and California’s new conservation initiative<br />

is to reduce those totals<br />

another 20 percent, as painlessly as<br />

possible. Remember, in the last 15<br />

years the costs of CFLs, electronic<br />

ballasts and T-8 lamps have decreased<br />

over 50 percent while efficacy<br />

(lumens per watt) and life expectancy<br />

have increased. We’ve seen similar<br />

improvements in energy conservation<br />

and cost reduction in residential<br />

refrigerators and air conditioning.The<br />

first priority in business is to survive.<br />

You can’t perform, or learn, or sell<br />

merchandise if you can’t see well, so<br />

energy consumption reductions have<br />

to be practical.<br />

California’s Public Utilities Commission<br />

(PUC) intends to recapture<br />

enough energy by conservation in the<br />

next three years to meet its needs for<br />

power generation for the next decade,<br />

by allocating $2 billion (with a “b”) for<br />

energy efficiency.That’s more than the<br />

Federal DOE budgeted, but not yet<br />

appropriated, in the new, so-called,<br />

“Energy Act of 2005.” Part of<br />

California’s program, called Integrated<br />

Resource Planning (IRP) earmarked<br />

$200 million of the $2 billion for new<br />

technology.The objective is to save $3<br />

billion overall in energy costs for<br />

homes and businesses by 2008, a 150<br />

percent return on investment.<br />

Lighting comprises almost 30 percent<br />

of commercial and 18 percent<br />

of residential usage during peak<br />

demand periods; part of the IRP program<br />

is a guide book published by<br />

the CLTC to help homebuilders<br />

learn about new <strong>light</strong>ing technologies<br />

and the state’s new residential<br />

energy code and compliant designs.<br />

Contact cltc.ucdavis.edu for a copy.<br />

Susan P. Kennedy, a commissioner<br />

of the California Public Utility<br />

Commission (PUC), in launching this<br />

comprehensive “Green Building” initiative,<br />

stated,“In plain English, before<br />

our electric utilities spend a dollar to<br />

buy power in the market or build a<br />

new generating plant, they will first<br />

invest in ways to help us use energy<br />

more efficiently.”<br />

Last month I reported on how<br />

New York is amending its energy conservation<br />

code, and this month we’ve<br />

described California’s initiatives. If you<br />

are aware of anything going on in the<br />

middle of the country please let me<br />

know. Somebody must have noticed<br />

that fuel oil and gasoline have doubled<br />

in price, while natural gas has more<br />

than tripled in just the last three<br />

years.Are any other states promoting<br />

energy efficiency Please write me<br />

here at LD+A.<br />

Willard L. Warren, PE, LC, FIESNA, is<br />

the principal of Willard L. Warren<br />

Associates, a consulting firm serving<br />

industry, government and utility clients in<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing and energy conservation.<br />

December 2005 LD+A 9


RESEARCH MATTERS<br />

Attending to Attention<br />

Yukio Akashi, Ph.D.<br />

Lighting Research<br />

Center, Rensselaer<br />

Polytechnic<br />

Institutete<br />

CAN GOOD LIGHTING HELP<br />

to reduce the number of traffic crashes<br />

A survey conducted in the U.S.<br />

reported that approximately 50 percent<br />

of crashes were related to drivers’<br />

improper attention (Treat et al.,<br />

1979).We are fortunate that research<br />

on attention flourished over the past<br />

three decades (Johnson and Proctor,<br />

2004). Findings from these studies<br />

may bridge the gap between <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

research and traffic safety.<br />

What Makes A Driver<br />

Inattentive<br />

Driving is a demanding, multitasking<br />

activity.A driver has to maintain a<br />

vehicle within a traffic lane while<br />

keeping its speed below (or at least<br />

not too far above) the limit, while following<br />

other vehicles (referred to as<br />

a “tracking task” in this column).<br />

Occasionally, a driver has to pass<br />

other vehicles and change lanes (a<br />

“changing task”).Talking on a cellular<br />

phone is an additional, but unrelated,<br />

task that increases the driver’s task<br />

load (a “distracting task”).<br />

On less frequent but more critical<br />

occasions, the driver must quickly<br />

detect oncoming traffic and obstacles<br />

such as torn tires on the pavement or<br />

deer on the shoulder, to avoid collisions<br />

with these potential hazards (a<br />

“detecting task”).<br />

As task load increases, a driver,<br />

who is already busy driving and talking<br />

on a cellular phone, can become<br />

distracted from such detection tasks.<br />

Inattention often originates from high<br />

task loads, and often results in missing<br />

targets and prolonged reaction times<br />

(Verwey, 1993), and even increased<br />

crash rates (Harms, 1986).<br />

How Does Task Load<br />

Affect Performance<br />

For each task described above, a<br />

driver must deal with a sequence of<br />

three distinctive information-processing<br />

stages: perceptional analysis (stimulus<br />

identification); response selection<br />

(decision-making);and motor response<br />

(response execution) (Pashler, 1998;<br />

Johnson and Proctor, 2004).<br />

As Figure 1 illustrates, these<br />

stages are often assumed to occur<br />

sequentially, so the results of one<br />

stage form the input to the next<br />

stage. Of these, response selection<br />

(decision-making) is the most<br />

demanding stage for the brain. This<br />

stage limits allocation of attention<br />

resources that can be shared with the<br />

other tasks, and it often appears to<br />

act as a bottleneck (Welford, 1952).<br />

To explore the mechanisms of<br />

dual-task performance, scientists use<br />

a sophisticated experimental technique.<br />

This technique has a subject<br />

respond to two individual stimuli, in<br />

which the time between the first and<br />

second stimulus varies in order to<br />

change task load.This method helped<br />

scientists conclude that the time it<br />

takes to respond to the second stimulus<br />

generally becomes longer (due<br />

to the period of slack in Figure 1)<br />

than when the second stimulus is presented<br />

alone or the task becomes<br />

more demanding (Vince, 1949).This is<br />

because the decision-making stage of<br />

the second stimulus cannot begin<br />

until the corresponding stage of the<br />

first stimulus has been completed<br />

(Pashler, 1998). However, scientists<br />

have also noted that the decisionmaking<br />

stage of the first stimulus can<br />

share attention resources with that of<br />

the second stimulus when both tasks<br />

are very difficult (Navon and Miller,<br />

2002). In these cases, a kind of interference<br />

occurs,and the decision-making<br />

of the first stimulus is often<br />

slowed down as well.<br />

How Can Good Lighting<br />

Improve Driving<br />

Performance<br />

The information processing framework<br />

described above allows us to<br />

understand the effect of good <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

F I G U R E 1<br />

Information processing framework (after Johnson and Proctor, 2004).<br />

on driving performance. To this end,<br />

this column reviews recent studies in<br />

which subjects performed detection<br />

tests (Task 2 in Figure 1) while<br />

engaged in simulated tracking and real<br />

driving tasks (Task 1). These studies<br />

compared performance under metal<br />

halide (MH) and high-pressure sodium<br />

(HPS) <strong>light</strong>ing at mesopic levels.<br />

To investigate the mechanisms of<br />

interference of <strong>light</strong>ing conditions<br />

with task load and performance, a<br />

study simulated a typical driving situation<br />

by combining three tasks: a<br />

tracking task, a distracting task and a<br />

detecting task (Akashi and Neches,<br />

2003). The tracking task required a<br />

subject to keep a needle in the center<br />

between a pair of thin horizontal lines<br />

by rotating a control knob. For the<br />

distracting task, the subject attempted<br />

to complete verbal mathematical<br />

(multiplication) problems as quickly<br />

as possible. The detecting task<br />

required subjects to signal immediately<br />

upon detecting one of eight target<br />

presentations.This study changed<br />

task load by changing combinations of<br />

the tracking and distracting tasks.<br />

Figure 2 depicts the results of<br />

these tests, which generally suggest<br />

the following: as task load increases,<br />

reaction time is increased; and target<br />

detection under MH was better than<br />

under HPS. These tendencies were<br />

confirmed by statistical analysis.<br />

Regarding interference, the tracking<br />

task appears to just add the same<br />

period of time to the baseline reaction<br />

times (in the detection-taskalone<br />

conditions) for both MH and<br />

HPS <strong>light</strong>ing. This suggests that the<br />

tracking task interferes little with the<br />

10 www.iesna.org


effect of <strong>light</strong>ing, because this tracking<br />

task relied on central vision. Also,<br />

practiced automatic operations (like<br />

this tracking task) do not demand a<br />

lot of attention, so they can be performed<br />

without experiencing interference<br />

from, or generating interference<br />

with, other ongoing information<br />

processes (Pashler, 1998).<br />

In contrast, math problems appear<br />

to have interfered with <strong>light</strong>ing conditions.<br />

Differences in reaction times<br />

between MH and HPS conditions<br />

became the largest (over 50 ms for<br />

most off-axis targets) when both<br />

tracking and distracting tasks were<br />

performed at the same time (i.e., the<br />

highest task load). Since combining all<br />

three tasks increased task load, their<br />

response selection stages likely shared<br />

attention resources and therefore<br />

interference occurred. In this experiment,<br />

the math performance was<br />

s<strong>light</strong>ly improved by using MH <strong>light</strong>ing,<br />

but it was not yet significant.<br />

A similar and even larger enhanced<br />

effect of spectral power distributions<br />

(SPDs) on detection performance<br />

F I G U R E 2<br />

Reaction time for metal halide and high-pressure <strong>light</strong>ing conditions<br />

(TT = tracking task; MP = math problem).<br />

appeared in another study using a<br />

more realistic, high-demand computer-simulated<br />

driving task. This study<br />

had subjects detect peripheral targets<br />

(detecting task) while virtually driving<br />

along a roadway projected on a large<br />

screen (tracking task) (Bullough and<br />

Rea, 2000). In this study, subjects<br />

missed targets 25 percent more frequently<br />

under HPS <strong>light</strong>ing than<br />

under MH <strong>light</strong>ing.<br />

Can results of such laboratory<br />

studies apply to real driving situations<br />

To answer this question, a field study<br />

(Akashi and Rea, 2002) had subjects<br />

detect targets located 15 deg and 23<br />

deg off-axis (detecting task) while<br />

driving along a short, closed track and<br />

Effective <strong>light</strong>ing may reduce task load<br />

and therefore allow people to allocate<br />

more attention to target detection<br />

fixating on and reading aloud single<br />

digit numbers sequentially presented<br />

in the central visual field (tracking<br />

task).Reaction time was measured for<br />

each target presentation.<br />

The results suggested that average<br />

reaction time was around 720 ms for<br />

actual driving, compared to 250 ms for<br />

a single detection task in which subjects<br />

responded to a 15 deg off-axis<br />

target with the same luminance contrast<br />

in a laboratory (He et al.,1997).In<br />

the same study, when the car was static,<br />

average reaction time was around<br />

670 ms.The use of MH lamps reduced<br />

reaction times by approximately 50 ms.<br />

This experiment did not control<br />

onsets of stimuli in the first and second<br />

tasks;thus,it does not allow for exploring<br />

detailed mechanisms of interaction<br />

between the two tasks. However, the<br />

results suggest interference between<br />

tasks and <strong>light</strong>ing conditions. This<br />

experiment used a target luminance of<br />

0.3 (cd per sq m), a level at which the<br />

difference in reaction time between<br />

under the MH and HPS lamps should<br />

be very small, according to He et al.’s<br />

experiment (1997). However, it did<br />

show a 50-ms improvement in reaction<br />

time due to the use of MH <strong>light</strong>ing with<br />

a statistical significance. In this case,<br />

since both tracking and detecting tasks<br />

are visual tasks, the use of effective<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing can improve visibility for the<br />

tracking task and target conspicuity for<br />

the detecting task.The use of effective<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing delivers a twofold benefit to<br />

the detecting task: a shorter response<br />

selection time of the detection task<br />

itself, and a shorter slack time due to<br />

the shortened response selection time<br />

of the tracking task. This results in a<br />

much shorter reaction time than<br />

expected.<br />

This discussion leads to a conclusion<br />

that effective <strong>light</strong>ing may reduce<br />

task load and therefore allow people<br />

to allocate more attention to target<br />

detection. In a dual-task paradigm,<br />

when both tasks are visual or very<br />

difficult, task-<strong>light</strong>ing interference<br />

appears to enhance the effectiveness<br />

of <strong>light</strong>ing’s impact on performance.<br />

What Is Next<br />

We need more research to verify<br />

the validity of such enhanced effects<br />

of <strong>light</strong>ing. First, fine tuning experiments<br />

using the above mentioned<br />

dual-task technique could help us to<br />

better understand task-attention<strong>light</strong>ing<br />

interference. This will determine<br />

how much each task type (e.g.,<br />

changing lanes and using cellular<br />

phones) impairs detection performance<br />

and how much each <strong>light</strong>ing factor<br />

can regain the impaired performance.<br />

Second, to implement such<br />

December 2005 LD+A 11


RESEARCH MATTERS<br />

research results to roadway and automobile<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing practice, it is necessary<br />

to quantify a driver’s task load under<br />

different roadway characteristics (e.g.,<br />

highways, interchanges, or curves) by<br />

using a standard detecting task such<br />

as one used by MacDonald and Ellis<br />

(1975).Finally,it is important to determine<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing requirements for each of<br />

the roadway characteristics while taking<br />

into account the influence of task<br />

load on detection performance. The<br />

evidence so far indicates that such<br />

understanding would help us to make<br />

our roadways safer.<br />

References<br />

Akashi Y, Rea MS, 2002. Peripheral<br />

detection while driving under a<br />

mesopic <strong>light</strong> level, Journal of the<br />

<strong>Illuminating</strong> <strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong>, 31, 1,<br />

85-94<br />

Akashi Y, Neches J, 2003.The effect<br />

of foveal task load on peripheral target<br />

detection, Proceedings of CIE 25th<br />

Session in San Diego, D4, 44-47<br />

Bullough J, Rea MS, 2000. Simulated<br />

driving performance and peripheral<br />

detection at mesopic <strong>light</strong> levels,Lighting<br />

Research and Technology, 32, 4, 194-198<br />

He Y, Rea MS, Bierman A, Bullough<br />

J, 1997. Evaluating <strong>light</strong> source efficacy<br />

under mesopic conditions using reaction<br />

times, Journal of the <strong>Illuminating</strong><br />

<strong>Engineering</strong> <strong>Society</strong>, 26, 1, 125-138<br />

Harms L, 1986. Drivers’ attentional<br />

responses to environmental variation:<br />

a dual-task real traffic study, In Gale<br />

AG et al.Vision in Vehicles II,Amsterdam:<br />

Elsevier Science Publishers, 131-138<br />

Johnson A, Proctor RW, 2004.<br />

Attention:Theory and Practice,Thousand<br />

Oaks,CA:Sage Publications,Inc.,30-37<br />

MacDonald, Ellis, 1975. Driver<br />

workload for various turn radii and<br />

speeds, Proceedings of the annual<br />

Meeting of the Transportation Research<br />

Board,Washington, D.C.<br />

Navon D,Miller J,2002.Queuing or<br />

sharing A critical evaluation of the<br />

single-bottleneck notion. Cognitive<br />

Psychology, 44, 193-251<br />

Pashler HE, 1998. The psychology of<br />

attention, Cambridge, MA: MIT press<br />

Teichner WH, Krebs MJ, 1972.<br />

Laws of the simple visual reaction<br />

time, Psychological Review, 79, 344-358<br />

Treat JR,Tumbas NS, McDonald ST,<br />

Shinar D, Hume RD, Mayer RE,<br />

Stansifer RL, and Castellan NJ, 1977.<br />

Tri-level study of the causes of traffic<br />

accidents, Report No. DOT-HS034-3-<br />

535-77.<br />

Verwey WB, 1993. How can we<br />

prevent overload of the driver<br />

Oarkes AM, Franzen S, Driving future<br />

vehicles,London:Taylor & Francis,235-<br />

244.<br />

Vince M, 1949. Rapid response<br />

sequences and the psychological<br />

refractory period, British Journal of<br />

Psychology, 40, 23-40<br />

Welford AT, 1952. The psychological<br />

refractory period and the timing<br />

of high speed performance-A review<br />

and a theory. British Journal of<br />

Psychology, 43, 2-19<br />

RP-1<br />

1/2 horiz<br />

12 www.iesna.org


GREEN IDEAS<br />

Making the Case for Metrics<br />

Nick Ferzacca<br />

MANY OF US SELECT FOOD<br />

based on information from a nutrition<br />

label. Whether done out of<br />

necessity to avoid allergies, to adhere<br />

to the latest diet fad or just for the<br />

nutritional benefit, we expect this<br />

information to be unbiased and accurate.The<br />

fact that this information is<br />

highly regulated by the Food and<br />

Drug Administration demonstrates<br />

the power these labels have in swaying<br />

buying decisions.We may take this<br />

for granted today, but there is a long<br />

and continually evolving history to<br />

food labels.<br />

To a certain extent, <strong>light</strong>ing specifiers<br />

are at the beginning stages of a<br />

movement not unlike the one which<br />

led to standardized food labels. With<br />

the popularity of LEED and other<br />

market transformation programs,<br />

building design is flush with the vocabulary<br />

of sustainability. Measures such<br />

volatile organic compounds (VOC),<br />

mercury content of lamps and recycled<br />

content are published as metrics<br />

of environmental performance. In<br />

truth, we are really just beginning to<br />

learn about the full environmental<br />

impact a product may have.<br />

In the <strong>light</strong>ing industry, it is easy to<br />

see how complicated the issue is. For<br />

instance, mercury used in fluorescent<br />

lamps is recognized as an environmentally<br />

harmful substance to be<br />

reduced in the name of sustainability.<br />

Reducing mercury beyond a certain<br />

level, however, significantly reduces<br />

the efficacy of fluorescent lamps<br />

resulting in higher, or at least different,<br />

environmental burdens beyond<br />

the mercury saved. Furthermore,<br />

mercury is one small element of one<br />

component in a <strong>light</strong>ing system.What<br />

are the impacts of producing fixture<br />

housings, reflectors, lenses and packaging<br />

Is a low iridescent specular<br />

coating more environmentally harmful<br />

than a simple diffuse white coating,<br />

and if so, how do we measure this<br />

Developing environmental performance<br />

metrics for <strong>light</strong>ing equipment<br />

is no small task.<br />

Understanding the full environmental<br />

impact is easiest through a process<br />

called life cycle assessment or LCA<br />

(see sidebar). Consider some of the<br />

initiatives related to the question of<br />

environmental performance and the<br />

LCA, as they pertain to <strong>products</strong>.<br />

ISO 14000<br />

The International Standards<br />

Organization (ISO) 14000 series<br />

standards provide a framework for<br />

managing environmental systems.<br />

Within the 14000 series are the<br />

14021, 14024 and 14025 standards,<br />

which define different types of environmental<br />

labels as follows:<br />

• Type I Label (14024). Multiattribute<br />

labels developed by a<br />

third party. Examples of these are<br />

“Certified Wood” or “Eco-<br />

Friendly.”<br />

• Type II Label (14021). Singleattribute<br />

labels developed by the<br />

producer. Examples of these are<br />

claims of “75 percent recycled content.”<br />

• Type III Label (14025). Labels<br />

providing quantitative information<br />

from LCA.<br />

In themselves, these ISO definitions<br />

do not indicate what the labels<br />

should be, but merely provide standard<br />

definitions. They are significant<br />

because they represent the results of<br />

international consensus among governments,<br />

industry and other stakeholders.These<br />

definitions are already<br />

being used to specify various types of<br />

information. For instance, the draft<br />

version of LEED 2.2 requires that the<br />

recycled content must be defined in<br />

accordance with the ISO Type II labeling<br />

standard. Furthermore, there is a<br />

significant interest to push manufacturers<br />

for LCA-based information on<br />

environmental performance, and ISO<br />

Type III labels are often cited as the<br />

desired format.<br />

Environmental Product<br />

Declarations<br />

In 1999, the Swedish Environmental<br />

Management Council developed<br />

a standard for producing quantifiable<br />

and verifiable LCA-based environmental<br />

performance information<br />

for <strong>products</strong>, called the Environmental<br />

Product Declaration (EPD), see<br />

www.environdec.com. The EPD is a<br />

framework available to manufacturers<br />

for application to <strong>products</strong> and services<br />

allowing one-for-one comparisons<br />

against environmental impacts.<br />

Products following the EPD program<br />

can be published on the EPD website,<br />

and EPDs are downloadable to anyone.<br />

The EPD is not designed exclusively<br />

around building <strong>products</strong>; many<br />

consumer <strong>products</strong> are also provided.<br />

Figure 1 reveals an excerpt of an<br />

EPD for a 10kV fused switch with fan<br />

cooling.<br />

F I G U R E 1<br />

14 www.iesna.org


What is Life Cycle Assessment<br />

LCA is a systematic process of analyzing the environmental impacts of a<br />

product, system or service, throughout the product life cycle from “cradle<br />

to grave” or “cradle-to-cradle.” This analysis includes the different<br />

phases of resources extraction, manufacture, distribution, installation, use<br />

and disposal. ISO and the <strong>Society</strong> of Environmental Toxicology and<br />

Chemistry (SETAC), among others, have developed standards for conducting<br />

LCA.<br />

Unlike single attribute metrics such as recycled content, the output of<br />

LCA provides quantitative data on fundamental impact categories such<br />

as global warming or ecological toxicity.At present there is not consensus<br />

on a complete list of all impact categories, but the most often recognized<br />

impact categories are listed below as defined by the U.S.<br />

Environmental Performance Agency’s program called TRACI for Tool for<br />

the Reduction and Assessment of Chemical and Other Environmental<br />

Impacts, see http://www.epa.gov/ORD/NRMRL/std/sab/traci/<br />

Impact Category<br />

Global Warming Potential<br />

Acidification<br />

Eutrophication<br />

Ozone Depletion<br />

Smog<br />

Ecotoxicity<br />

Human Health<br />

Fossil Fuel<br />

Land Use<br />

Water Use<br />

Criteria Air Pollutants<br />

Possible End Points<br />

Malaria, coastal area damage,<br />

agricultural, forest damage<br />

Plant, animal, ecosystem<br />

Plant, animal, ecosystem<br />

Skin cancer cataracts, material<br />

damage, crop damage<br />

Human mortality, asthma, plant<br />

damage<br />

Plant, animal, ecosystem<br />

Variety of specific human cancers<br />

Fossil fuels shortages leading to<br />

use of other energy sources<br />

Threatened and<br />

endangered species<br />

Water shortages<br />

Disability-adjusted life years,<br />

toxicological human health effects<br />

Each impact category is characterized by an equivalent emission of a<br />

causal substance. For instance, since CO 2 emissions are the largest cause<br />

of global warming, Global Warming Potential (GWP), is measured in<br />

equivalent emissions of CO 2 with emissions other than CO 2 effecting<br />

global warming being converted to an equivalent effect of emitted CO 2 .<br />

First note that impact categories<br />

listed in the first column are defined<br />

in terms of fundamental attributes,<br />

such as Global Warming Potential<br />

(GWP) and Ozone Depletion<br />

Potential (ODP), as opposed to secondary<br />

variables like recycled content<br />

or even energy efficiency. In other<br />

words, we intuitively accept that<br />

lower energy consumption correlates<br />

to “better” environmental performance,<br />

but in fact it is reductions in<br />

power plant emissions contributing<br />

to global warming and acidification,<br />

among others, that are the actual<br />

benefits to the environment.<br />

Also note that the units for each<br />

impact category are listed in the second<br />

column and are different for each<br />

impact category. For instance GWP is<br />

measured in kg of CO 2 whereas ODP<br />

is measured in kg of CFC-11. As a<br />

new metric, these units will take<br />

some time to get assimilated. Lastly,<br />

note how this information groups<br />

impacts into different phases of the<br />

product’s life cycle: Production and<br />

Use. It is easy to see how the Use<br />

phase of energy-using <strong>products</strong>, such<br />

as <strong>light</strong>ing, can largely outweigh the<br />

Production phase. (Keep in mind this<br />

table is only an excerpt from a larger<br />

document on the EPD of this product,<br />

and additional information is provided<br />

about the End-of-Life phase as<br />

well as other aspects of the environmental<br />

performance.)<br />

BEES<br />

The National Institute of Standards<br />

and Technology (NIST) developed an<br />

approach for providing LCA-based<br />

environmental and economic performance<br />

information for building <strong>products</strong><br />

called BEES (short for Building<br />

for Environmental and Economic<br />

Sustainability, see www.bfrl.nist.gov-<br />

/oae/software/bees.html). Available on<br />

the BEES website is a free downloadable<br />

program which allows building<br />

designers to compare environmental<br />

performance of <strong>products</strong> which have<br />

been submitted to an LCA performed<br />

through a NIST vendor.<br />

Manufacturers must pay NIST to perform<br />

the LCA on a product-by-product<br />

basis, but <strong>products</strong> can be selected<br />

to represent a family of similar<br />

<strong>products</strong>. Currently there are over<br />

200 building <strong>products</strong> in the BEES 3.0<br />

December 2005 LD+A 15


GREEN IDEAS<br />

F I G U R E 2<br />

The Cook<br />

Corp<br />

1/4<br />

version, but there are no <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

<strong>products</strong> evaluated at this time. One<br />

of the benefits as well as one of the<br />

main criticisms of BEES is that the<br />

end result produces a single “score”<br />

for environmental performance.<br />

Figure 2 shows how BEES, with particular<br />

inputs, results in scores for<br />

Vinyl C tile and linoleum tile.<br />

To some, a single score provides an<br />

easy way to compare <strong>products</strong> on a<br />

one-for-one basis. To others, a single<br />

score requires too many assumptions<br />

and reduces the validity of the comparison.<br />

The point in reviewing existing initiatives<br />

like these is that models for<br />

LCA-based product information are<br />

under development and/or in use.<br />

Furthermore, to incorporate the full<br />

extent of sustainability, designers will<br />

need to get used to the language of<br />

understanding how <strong>products</strong> impact<br />

the environment. In the end, the burden<br />

of providing this information falls<br />

on manufacturers, and they are looking<br />

for what information is wanted by<br />

the marketplace. In the absence of<br />

any clear direction, information will<br />

fall in line with industry drivers<br />

already in place such as LEED.Among<br />

the goals of the IESNA Sustainable<br />

Lighting Committee is to develop a<br />

framework for environmental performance<br />

metrics of <strong>light</strong>ing <strong>products</strong>.<br />

While this may seem like a difficult<br />

task, in that it is as much of a consensus-building<br />

exercise as it is a technical<br />

challenge, initiatives like Sweden’s<br />

EDP and BEES provide a large foundation<br />

to start with.<br />

Nicola Ferzacca, PE, LEED, is an electrical<br />

department manager at Symmes<br />

Maini & McKee Associates with over 18<br />

years of experience in electrical and<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing design for national and international<br />

projects. He is chair of the IESNA<br />

Sustainable Lighting Committee and vice<br />

president of the New England Section.<br />

He holds a Master of Science in Lighting<br />

from Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute and<br />

has taught <strong>light</strong>ing at the Boston<br />

Architectural Center.<br />

16 www.iesna.org


LIGHTING FOR QUALITY<br />

The Shadow Knows<br />

Doug Paulin, LC<br />

YES,THIS IS A PERIODICAL<br />

of the <strong>light</strong>ing arts and sciences in<br />

North America. But I devote this<br />

column to shadows. Plural. Shadows<br />

are so important for our vision, and<br />

not just the simple silhouette, often<br />

referred to as “negative contrast” in<br />

roadway conversations. (Have you<br />

ever noticed how we have the habit<br />

of taking a nice simple word that<br />

everyone understands [silhouette]<br />

and inventing a “<strong>light</strong>ing term” for it<br />

[“negative contrast”]).<br />

Back to shadows. My first encounter<br />

with shadows was in a<br />

photo studio.We were shooting new<br />

product for catalogs and spec sheets.<br />

We paid attention to shadows and<br />

reflections and fiddled with other<br />

things that can make or break a good<br />

catalog photo until we wanted to<br />

scream.But shadows are the visual<br />

cues that tell us that the object in the<br />

two-dimensional photo is actually<br />

three-dimensional. The photographer<br />

would often take the first 4 x 5<br />

Polaroid snap from the camera and<br />

say “Yep, it looks like a hubcap!” But<br />

after he adjusted the <strong>light</strong>ing to<br />

accentuate the depth and shape, it<br />

would look like a <strong>light</strong>ing fixture.<br />

Modeling is a technique of creating<br />

varying shades of brightness, or,<br />

should I say, varying darkness of<br />

shadows.The modeled effect comes<br />

from two or more sources, hitting<br />

the three-dimensional object from<br />

different angles and different intensities.<br />

This doesn’t mean that the<br />

sources themselves have to be different;<br />

one can be farther away from<br />

the other(s).<br />

Playing Tricks<br />

This brings us to the “trick” I use<br />

most often when measuring illuminance<br />

in the field.Pay attention to the<br />

shadows—not just the shadow of<br />

your head on the <strong>light</strong> meter! Look at<br />

your own shadows on the floor.<br />

When your own shadows are equally<br />

dark, you are probably equidistant from<br />

each of the <strong>light</strong> sources.To make sure,<br />

move back and forth a few steps<br />

either way and watch one shadow<br />

get darker, and the other <strong>light</strong>er.Why<br />

is this important Because the midpoint<br />

between two fixture locations<br />

could be a point of minimum <strong>light</strong><br />

level. It then follows that a point<br />

Figure 1<br />

Figure 2<br />

between four fixtures should give you<br />

four shadows of equal darkness. (I<br />

almost typed “equal density” which is<br />

more exact, but not as easy to read.)<br />

Have you ever “counted” the shadows<br />

each football player makes on<br />

the field This tells you how many<br />

sports floods are aimed at that point,<br />

doesn’t it<br />

Another example: A decorative<br />

street <strong>light</strong>ing project in downtown<br />

Madison,WI, uses semi-cutoff decorative<br />

luminaires. A colleague pointed<br />

out that there couldn’t have been<br />

much horizontal <strong>light</strong> generated<br />

because the street<strong>light</strong> across the<br />

boulevard was able to cast a shadow<br />

of the fixture and pole on an adjacent<br />

wall (Figure 1). I studied this<br />

installation in person and couldn’t<br />

help myself from creating another<br />

shadow on the wall with my arm.<br />

The <strong>light</strong> across the boulevard created<br />

a shadow of my arm on the<br />

wall, as expected, but where my<br />

arm-shadow crossed the pole-shadow,<br />

you could see that the intersection<br />

of the two shadows was darker<br />

than the pole-shadow (Figure 2).<br />

The analysis My arm-shadow blocked<br />

the <strong>light</strong> from the near fixture, as<br />

well as <strong>light</strong> from the one farther<br />

away, and while the pole-shadow<br />

was there, it was not as dark because<br />

some of the high angle <strong>light</strong> was<br />

washing some of it out.Again, more<br />

than one shadow can tell you so<br />

much about what is going on with<br />

the <strong>light</strong>, or <strong>light</strong>s.<br />

So pay attention to the shadows.<br />

Especially if you are dealing with<br />

multiple sources and locations of the<br />

luminaires. Shadows can give you the<br />

contrast necessary for good visualization<br />

of the scene, but they can be<br />

a good analysis tool also.<br />

Doug Paulin, LC, is currently with<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing rep firm Packerland Lighting<br />

Sales, Inc., Egg Harbor,WI.Throughout<br />

his career, he’s worked as an independent<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing designer and has also held<br />

positions ranging from product manager<br />

and marketing manager for manufacturers<br />

including Ruud Lighting,<br />

Lithonia Lighting, Cooper Lighting and<br />

Thomas Day-Brite Lighting.<br />

December 2005 LD+A 17


LIGHTING FOR SECURITY<br />

Ted Ake<br />

PREVIOUS SEGMENTS IN<br />

this series have addressed the need<br />

for security <strong>light</strong>ing and equipment.<br />

Areas with specific needs such as<br />

closed spaces, multi- and single-family<br />

dwellings, and parking facilities<br />

have also been discussed.<br />

This article will include two additional<br />

high potential crime areas:<br />

convenience stores and ATMs. Both<br />

of these facilities are a product of<br />

management’s desire for enhanced<br />

customer convenience in our 24/7<br />

lifestyle. Both operate during nighttime<br />

hours and involve the handling<br />

of cash and, therefore, can create an<br />

attraction for criminal elements.<br />

Proper <strong>light</strong>ing can be a powerful<br />

tool in reducing such activities.<br />

Convenience Stores<br />

These have evolved from the small<br />

“Mom & Pop” operations selling sundries,<br />

groceries and gasoline to<br />

mega-centers providing a full array of<br />

meals, travel needs, automobile service<br />

and, of course, gasoline. As in<br />

any retail operation, outdoor <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

At the convenience store pump island, sufficient illuminance must be provided<br />

to enable employees inside the store to easily view outside activity. At<br />

right, note the reflections of inside displays from the manager’s station.As a<br />

result, island luminance must be bright enough to overcome reflections.<br />

can be used to attract customers<br />

and then provide a safe environment<br />

to conduct business. In some<br />

instances, the “attraction aspect” can<br />

create unnecessary glare, <strong>light</strong> pollution<br />

and trespass. Properly designed<br />

security <strong>light</strong>ing systems should<br />

never become a nuisance.<br />

The area surrounding the fuel<br />

pumps is of prime concern. While<br />

pumping gas or washing the windshield<br />

requires relatively low <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

levels, sufficient illuminance must be<br />

provided to enable employees inside<br />

the store to easily view outside activity.The<br />

ratio of outside-to-inside levels<br />

must be low enough to prevent<br />

windows from becoming mirrors.<br />

To reduce crime, especially<br />

shoplifting, the more sophisticated<br />

facilities rely on CCTV (Closed<br />

Circuit Television), which requires<br />

adequate and properly directed<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing. Such systems, when well<br />

publicized, create a strong deterrent<br />

to potential thieves. Other<br />

deterrents include well-<strong>light</strong>ed<br />

trash areas, proper cash handling, at<br />

least two employees on duty in<br />

even the smallest stores, and<br />

Fulham 1/2 horiz<br />

18 www.iesna.org


absence of advertising posters in<br />

viewing windows.<br />

ATMs<br />

In just 35 years, the number of<br />

ATMs worldwide has now reached<br />

nearly 400,000.The vast majority of<br />

transactions involve cash withdrawals.<br />

The frequency and size of<br />

these withdrawals naturally attracts<br />

wrongdoers.The Bank Administrative<br />

Institute’s ATM Study states that 50<br />

percent of ATM crime occurs<br />

between 7:00 PM and midnight,<br />

despite the fact that this time period<br />

involves only 10 percent of all transactions.<br />

Similarly, 10 percent of ATM<br />

crimes happen between midnight and<br />

4:00 AM, when only one percent of<br />

transactions occur.<br />

ATM locations vary greatly, from<br />

indoor locations, such as transportation<br />

terminals, stores and hotels, to<br />

outdoor areas such as drive-up, walkup<br />

and remote freestanding units.<br />

Indoor installations should be<br />

located in the open, away from convenient<br />

hiding spaces and easy<br />

escape routes. In some locations,<br />

glass partitions are required to provide<br />

privacy and a view of any<br />

threatening person.<br />

Outdoor locations, of course,<br />

require adequate security <strong>light</strong>ing. In<br />

its list of potential liabilities, the<br />

American<br />

Bankers Association,<br />

Security Officers include:<br />

• Failing to install and maintain <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

at ATM and the premises surrounding<br />

the ATM.<br />

• Failing to install security equipment,such<br />

as surveillance cameras<br />

and alarms, in ATM premises and<br />

the immediate surroundings.<br />

• Failing to trim and maintain shrubbery<br />

outside the ATM premises<br />

and adjacent parking areas.<br />

• Failing to take measures to provide<br />

safe sidewalks from the parking<br />

lot to the ATM facility.<br />

Walk-up locations, of course, have<br />

a greater occasion for attack than<br />

drive-up and therefore require<br />

designs that are more sophisticated.<br />

In order to provide time for changes<br />

in customer adaptation, the IESNA<br />

Guideline on Security Lighting G-1-03<br />

recommends illuminance values of 20<br />

lux from 50 ft to 10 ft and 100 lux<br />

within 10 ft of the ATM. 1 Since ATM<br />

screens are self-illuminated, very little<br />

Failure to provide surrounding<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing at outdoor ATMs is an<br />

obvious liability issue.<br />

vertical <strong>light</strong> is required on the<br />

screen. The entire area should have<br />

unobstructed views. Glass enclosures<br />

are becoming more common and are<br />

required in some locales. In some<br />

instances, access to the enclosure<br />

requires the use of a bankcard. 2<br />

Especially at remote, stand-alone<br />

locations, two security <strong>light</strong>ing principles<br />

are of extreme importance:<br />

owner-supplied perimeter <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

and maintenance.These are high-risk<br />

areas, therefore, the bank cannot<br />

depend on others to <strong>light</strong> the space<br />

surrounding the ATM location.As in<br />

any area, a poorly maintained system<br />

can lead to disaster. Each ATM must<br />

be visited frequently to service and<br />

supply the unit. Service personnel<br />

should be trained to override the<br />

controls and energize the <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

system. Failed lamps should be<br />

reported immediately and corrections<br />

made within 24 hours.<br />

When next you venture outdoors<br />

at night, be aware of your surroundings.<br />

Do you feel comfortable or<br />

apprehensive If comfortable, say a<br />

“thank you” to those who designed,<br />

own and maintain the system.If apprehensive,<br />

you must call attention to the<br />

problem and offer your help.<br />

Security <strong>light</strong>ing is everyone’s<br />

responsibility.<br />

Ted Ake, a Member Emeritus of<br />

IESNA,is currently an adjunct professor in<br />

the Building Construction Department at<br />

Virginia Tech,serves on the Interior Design<br />

Department’s Advisory Board at Radford<br />

University and is a lecturer for the Virginia<br />

Crime Prevention Association. He retired<br />

from Hubbell Lighting in 2000.<br />

References<br />

1. ABA recommends higher values<br />

2. Due to high crime rates, many<br />

states and municipalities have created<br />

ATM <strong>light</strong>ing ordinances. The<br />

designer should become familiar<br />

with these legal requirements.<br />

RP-36<br />

1/3 V<br />

August 2005 LD+A 19


VOLUME 35, NUMBER 12 • December 2005<br />

ILLUMINATING ENGINEERING SOCIETYNEWS<br />

Just In Time…<br />

Held as a combination Centennial Celebration and<br />

fund raiser for educational programs, the Philadelphia<br />

Section hosted a Centennial Gala on September 17 at<br />

the Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia, PA.<br />

IESNA senior vice president, Kevin Flynn, was the guest<br />

speaker at the event.<br />

Research Committee Seeks Recruits<br />

The IESNA Research Committee has recently revised its scope and objectives and is seeking<br />

individuals in the <strong>light</strong>ing community to become active members of the committee.The<br />

committee’s mission is to promote research in the <strong>light</strong>ing industry and to report and disseminate<br />

information on worldwide research and <strong>light</strong>ing related research activity, collaborating<br />

with the organizations and individuals carrying out research, facilitating the translation<br />

of results and discoveries intended to improve the <strong>light</strong>ed environment. For more information,<br />

contact the committee chair Richard Collins at Richard.collins@sylvania.com<br />

IESNA<br />

Calendar of Events<br />

January 8-10, 2006<br />

IESNA CENTENNIAL<br />

CONFERENCE<br />

Contact:Valerie Landers<br />

212-248-5000 ext.117<br />

www.iesna.org<br />

Members In The News...<br />

Morgan Gabler and Jim Youngston have partnered to start<br />

their own architectural <strong>light</strong>ing design practice, Gabler-Youngston LP, in Atlanta..The new firm will<br />

focus on <strong>light</strong>ing for commercial, institutional and hospitality interiors and exteriors.<br />

Youngston and Gabler<br />

The Lighting Practice, Inc., Philadelphia, PA, has named Julie Panassow as an associate principal.<br />

Panassow, who joined the firm in 1992, has created complete <strong>light</strong>ing programs for corporations,<br />

museums, academic institutions, healthcare facilities, airports and historic buildings. She was<br />

most recently awarded an IIDA of Merit for re<strong>light</strong>ing of the building façades and sculptures along<br />

Philadelphia’s Benjamin Franklin Parkway.<br />

Panassow<br />

Leviton Manufacturing Company, Little Neck, NY, has appointed William Marshall to the<br />

position of senior vice president of sales and marketing and Daryoush Larizadeh to senior vice president.<br />

Matthew Silverman was also named training manager for Leviton Integrated Networks and Controls, and<br />

Residential Lighting Control Products.<br />

W.A.C. Lighting, Garden City, NY, has promoted John Camp to national sales manager. Most recently,<br />

he served as product manager for the firm.<br />

Marshall<br />

OSRAM SYLVANIA, Danvers, MA, promoted Dwight Kitchen to vice president of sales for the<br />

OEM/Special Markets sales channel.Kitchen served as director of sales for SYLVANIA LIGHTING SERVICES<br />

(SLS) since 2002.<br />

Ken Vannice has been selected by The Entertainment Technician Certification Program Council (ETCP)<br />

as one of 11 “subject matters” experts who will help develop the industry’s first electrical certification.<br />

Selected for their depth of knowledge, the individuals will work closely with psychometric services provider,<br />

Applied Measurement Professionals (AMP), to develop the examinations.<br />

Camp<br />

December 2005 LD+A 21


IESNA Street and Area Lighting Conference<br />

Taking It To The Street<br />

Over 350 outdoor <strong>light</strong>ing professionals came together for the<br />

24th Annual SALC Conference in San Diego, CA. This year’s<br />

conference featured timely topics from well known speakers<br />

on issues including security <strong>light</strong>ing, ordinances and liability, as<br />

well a new product roundup, and networking and roundtable<br />

discussions. Over 45 companies, including 13 new exhibitors,<br />

featured <strong>products</strong> and services.<br />

A keynote address was given by Crawford Lipsey, senior vice<br />

president and general manager of Holophane. The SALC<br />

Lifetime Service Award was presented to David Baum,<br />

Holphane. Mark your calendar for the 25th SALC Conference in<br />

Tampa, FL, October 8-11, 2006.<br />

From left to right: John Bono, conference chair; David Baum;<br />

and Richard Monsoor, SALC executive committee member<br />

New Members<br />

Membership Committee Chair Paul<br />

Mercier announced the IESNA gained<br />

four Sustaining Members and 75 members<br />

(M), associated members and student<br />

members in October.<br />

Sustaining Members<br />

Shremshock <strong>Engineering</strong>, Inc., Columbus, OH<br />

Design West <strong>Engineering</strong>, San Bernardino, CA<br />

Applied Lighting Concepts, Jacksonville, FL<br />

Magna IV <strong>Engineering</strong>, Edmonton,AB, Canada<br />

Canadian Region<br />

Marcello Coronatta, Canlyte, Lachine, QC<br />

Greg A. Janusz, M.T.S.,Winnipeg, MB<br />

Mario Pharand, Canlyte, Inc., Lachine, QC<br />

Sabine Marietta Susman, Lighting Group, Inc.,<br />

Richmond Hill, ON<br />

East Central Region<br />

Steven J. Hirshenhorn, Marty Berman Associates,<br />

Lansdale, PA<br />

Juli A. Kale, Hadco, Littlestown, PA<br />

Dahua Lin, Mullins <strong>Engineering</strong> Co., Odenton, MD<br />

Timothy L. Raubenstine, Hanover Lantern, Inc.,<br />

Hanover, PA<br />

Daniel Serrano, Fox Electric Supply Co., Inc.,<br />

Philadelphia, PA<br />

Tammy D. Smith, Robert G. Dashiell Jr, PE, Inc.,<br />

Norfolk,VA<br />

The Pennsylvania State University<br />

Michael A. Lombardi<br />

Great Lakes Region<br />

Steven J. Galley, Cannon Design, Grand Island, NY<br />

Reece A. Prather (M), Shremshock <strong>Engineering</strong>, Inc.,<br />

Columbus, OH<br />

Michael Richards, M/E <strong>Engineering</strong> P.C., Buffalo, NY<br />

Stephen A. Rogers,The Brewer-Garrett Co.,<br />

Middleburg Heights, OH<br />

Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh<br />

Joon Ho Choi<br />

South Pacific Coast Region<br />

Kenneth Acampora (M), Hydrel - Lithonia Lighting,<br />

Sylmar, CA<br />

Douglas Avery (M), Southern California Edison,<br />

Wildmar, CA<br />

Russ F. Bahlenhorst Jr. (M), Ushio America, Inc.,<br />

Cypress, CA<br />

Derwin Bass (M), Builder’s Resource LLC,<br />

Gardnerville, NV<br />

Halley D. Fitzpatrick, Pacific Gas and Electric, San<br />

Francisco, CA<br />

John R. Freese (M), Light Factors, La Jolla, CA<br />

Michael Keith Hendrix (M), Michael Brandman<br />

Associates, San Bernardino, CA<br />

George Kalta (M), Contractors Choice Lighting,<br />

Valencia, CA<br />

Todd K. Robinson,The Light Source, Salt Lake City, UT<br />

David J. Seppelfrick, Speck Electrical Design, Inc.,<br />

Honolulu, HI<br />

Shannon Slattery, ERCO Lighting, Inc., Santa Monica, CA<br />

Susan Sutherland-Bishop, OSRAM SYLVANIA,<br />

Ramona, CA<br />

Scott Thurm, Bartco Lighting, Inc., Huntington Beach, CA<br />

Jeff T.Trueblood, Design West <strong>Engineering</strong>, San<br />

Bernardino, CA<br />

Academy of Art University<br />

Umpornpol Yugala<br />

Stanford University<br />

Eelaine S. Buckholtz<br />

Midwest Region<br />

David Bettenhausen, Henderson Engineers, Inc.,<br />

Lenexa, KS<br />

Greg A. Miller (M), Border States Supply, Janesville,WI<br />

Billy Onder, Lightolier, Maryland Heights, MO<br />

Audra J. Relph, MKEC <strong>Engineering</strong> Consultants, Inc.,<br />

Wichita, KS<br />

Matt A. Smith, Brack & Associates Consulting<br />

Engineers, P.A.,Topeka, KS<br />

Mark Sullivan, Holophane, Barrington, IL<br />

Southern Illinois University Carbondale<br />

Melissa A. Roth<br />

University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign<br />

Lisa Anne Thompson<br />

Southeastern Region<br />

Jose R. Cedeno (M), Penuelas, PR<br />

Jose J. Durand, JDR Engineers & Developers, Inc., San<br />

Juan, PR<br />

Jim Frazer (M), Strategic Telemetry, Inc., Lighthouse<br />

Point, FL<br />

Gustavo D. Macias, Lightolier, Miami, FL<br />

Cynthia Neal,Applied Lighting Concepts, Jacksonville, FL<br />

Northeastern Region<br />

David L. Bay (M), OSRAM SYLVANIA, Danvers, MA<br />

Mitchell Bloomberg (M),The Lighting Group, New<br />

York, NY<br />

Mark D. Carroll, Jersey City, NJ<br />

Amanda J. Hammell, Clough, Harbour & Associates,<br />

Albany, NY<br />

Patrick G. Merosier (M), Domingo Gonzalez<br />

Associates, New York, NY<br />

Richard J. Potts, Clough Harbour & Associates LLP,<br />

Albany, NY<br />

Vasudha Ramamurthy, Zumtobel Staff Lighting, Inc.,<br />

Highland, NY<br />

Kazumi Tanimura,Atelier Lumiere, Inc., New York, NY<br />

Benjamin J.White (M), Public Service Electric & Gas,<br />

Lawrenceville, NJ<br />

Boston Architectural Center<br />

Patrick D. Rettig<br />

Northwest Region<br />

Michael E. Field MILE, RET (M), Magna IV <strong>Engineering</strong>,<br />

Edmonton,AB<br />

Craig V. Olson,Acme Integration, Inc., Post Falls, ID<br />

Buzz Thielemann, RHT Energy Solutions, Medford, OR<br />

BCIT<br />

Meghean A.S. Kennedy<br />

Portland State University<br />

Clifford M. Bodell<br />

Southwestern Region<br />

Josh W. Joyce, Lockeby & Associates, Inc., Little Rock,AR<br />

James McDaniel, Dynamic Lighting, Inc., Pearland,TX<br />

Nathen C. Neal (M),Triple C Companies, Oklahoma<br />

City, OK<br />

Jack Story (M), U.S.Army Corps of Engineers, Forth<br />

Worth,TX<br />

Texas A&M University<br />

Mini Malhotra<br />

Southern Region<br />

Gregory Bennorth (M), Universal Lighting<br />

Technologies, Nashville,TN<br />

Michael C. LaMountain (M), Pickering Firm,<br />

Memphis,TN<br />

Robert Rankin, Genlyte-Day-Brite/Capri/Omega,<br />

Tupelo, MS<br />

Paul C. Strong (M), Memphis Light, Gas and Water<br />

Division, Memphis,TN<br />

Art Institute of Charlotte<br />

Melody K. Miller<br />

International<br />

Sun Gak Hong (M), Doyak Electronic Ind. Co. Ltd,<br />

Bucheon, Korea<br />

Aijaz M. Nakhawa (M),Tectronics, Dubai, United Arab<br />

Emirates<br />

Gregory J. Nelson (M), Philips Lighting, Shanghai,<br />

China<br />

Geoff Pendleton,Thorn Lighting, Smithfield,Australia<br />

Sri Krishna College of <strong>Engineering</strong> and Technology<br />

R.Arunraj<br />

22 www.iesna.org


SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA OCTOBER 2-5, 2005<br />

SUSTAINING<br />

MEMBERS<br />

The following companies have elected to<br />

support the <strong>Society</strong> as Sustaining Members<br />

which allows the IESNA to fund programs that<br />

benefit all segments of the membership and<br />

pursue new endeavors, including education<br />

projects, <strong>light</strong>ing research and recommended<br />

practices. The level of support is classified by<br />

the amount of annual dues, based on a<br />

company’s annual <strong>light</strong>ing revenues:<br />

Copper:<br />

$500 annual dues<br />

Lighting revenues to $4 million<br />

(Copper members are listed in one issue of LD+A<br />

each year, as well as in the IESNA Annual Report.)<br />

Silver:<br />

$1,000 annual dues<br />

Lighting revenues to $10 million<br />

Gold:<br />

$2,500 annual dues<br />

Lighting revenues to $50 million<br />

Platinum:<br />

$5,000 annual dues<br />

Lighting revenues to $200 million<br />

Emerald:<br />

$10,000 annual dues<br />

Lighting revenues to $500 million<br />

Diamond:<br />

$15,000 annual dues<br />

Lighting revenues over $500 million<br />

DIAMOND<br />

Cooper Lighting<br />

General Electric Co.<br />

Lithonia Lighting<br />

OSRAM SYLVANIA Products, Inc.<br />

Philips Lighting Co.<br />

EMERALD<br />

Holophane Corporation<br />

PLATINUM<br />

Day-Brite Capri Omega<br />

Lightolier<br />

Lutron Electronics Co, Inc.<br />

GOLD<br />

A.L.P. Lighting Components Co.<br />

Altman Lighting Inc<br />

The Bodine Company<br />

Canlyte Inc.<br />

Con-Tech Lighting<br />

Duke Power Co.<br />

Edison Price Lighting, Inc.<br />

Finelite, Inc.<br />

Florida Power Lighting Solutions<br />

Gardco Lighting<br />

Indy Lighting, Inc.<br />

Kenall Mfg Co.<br />

The Kirlin Company<br />

Kurt Versen Co.<br />

LexaLite Int’l Corp<br />

Lighting Services Inc<br />

LiteTouch, Inc.<br />

Louis Poulsen Lighting<br />

LSI Industries, Inc.<br />

Lucifer Lighting Co.<br />

Martin Professional, Inc.<br />

Musco Sports Lighting, Inc.<br />

Niagara Mohawk Power Corp<br />

Prudential Lighting Corp<br />

RAB Lighting, Inc.<br />

San Diego Gas & Electric<br />

SPI Lighting<br />

Vista Professional Outdoor Lighting<br />

The Watt Stopper Inc.<br />

Zumtobel Staff Lighting, Inc.<br />

SILVER<br />

Altoglas International<br />

Altuglas International, Arkema Inc.<br />

Associated Lighting Representatives. Inc.<br />

Axis Lighting Inc.<br />

Bartco Lighting, Inc.<br />

Barth Electric Co., Inc.<br />

Beta Lighting, Inc.<br />

Birchwood Lighting, Inc.<br />

BJB Electric Corporation<br />

Border States Electric Supply<br />

Bulbrite Industries, Inc.<br />

Celestial Products<br />

City of San Francisco<br />

Con Edison of New York<br />

Custom Lighting Services, LLC<br />

Custom Lights, Inc.<br />

Day Lite Maintenance Co.<br />

Eastern Energy Services, Inc.<br />

Eclipse Lighting, Inc.<br />

Elko Ltd<br />

Elliptipar<br />

Enmax<br />

Enterprise Lighting Sales<br />

ETC Architectural<br />

Eye Lighting Industries<br />

Eye Lighting Int’l of NA<br />

Fiberstars<br />

Focal Point<br />

Gammalux Systems<br />

H E Williams, Inc.<br />

HDLC<br />

<strong>Illuminating</strong> Technologies, Inc.<br />

Kramer Lighting<br />

Lee Filters<br />

Legion Lighting Co.<br />

Leviton Mfg. Co. Inc.<br />

Lightology LLC<br />

LiteTech<br />

Litecontrol Corp<br />

Litelab Corp<br />

Litetronics Int’l Inc.<br />

Lowel Light Manufacturing<br />

Lumascap USA Inc.<br />

Manitoba Hydro<br />

Manning Lighting<br />

Metalumen Manufacturing, Inc.<br />

OCEM/Multi Electric Mfg. Inc.<br />

Optical Research Associates<br />

Paramount Industries, Inc.<br />

Peter Basso Associates, Inc.<br />

Portland General Electric<br />

Prescolite, Inc.<br />

Reflex Lighting Group, Inc.<br />

Richard McDonald & Associates, Ltd. - Calgary<br />

Sentry Electric Corporation<br />

Shakespeare Composites & Structures<br />

Southern California Edison<br />

Sternberg Vintage Lighting<br />

Strand Lighting, Inc.<br />

StressCrete King Luminaire Co.<br />

Tennessee Valley Authority<br />

Universal Electric Ltd.<br />

US Architectural Lighting/Sun Valley Lighting<br />

Utility Metals<br />

Velux America Inc.<br />

WJ Whatley Inc.<br />

WAC Lighting, Co.<br />

Wisconsin Public Service Corp<br />

Wybron, Inc.<br />

Xenon Light, Inc.<br />

IES SUSTAINING<br />

MEMBERS<br />

As of October 2005<br />

December 2005 LD+A 23


INDUSTRY UPDATES<br />

Three LED, SSL Joint<br />

Ventures Announced<br />

Lighting Services Inc (LSI), a manufacturer<br />

of track, accent, display, fiber<br />

optic, and now, solid-state <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

(SSL) systems has formed a strategic<br />

partnership with TIR Systems Ltd.,<br />

the developer of the SSL product, the<br />

LEXEL. With a large share of museum,<br />

gallery and high-end retail <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

markets, LSI says the partnership will<br />

enable the two companies to develop<br />

a range of LEXEL-based fixtures that<br />

produce white <strong>light</strong> with a full range<br />

of color temperatures.<br />

TIR also signed a design collaboration<br />

agreement with the Genlyte<br />

Group to develop and market LEXELbased<br />

<strong>products</strong> under the Lightolier<br />

and Canlyte brands. The focus of this<br />

design collaboration will be on developing<br />

<strong>products</strong> for the retail, restaurant,<br />

commercial and residential markets.<br />

Meanwhile, Color Kinetics Inc. and<br />

Litecontrol Corp. announced an agreement<br />

that will apply Color Kinetics<br />

technology to a LED-based product<br />

line offered by Litecontrol. Consisting<br />

of three offerings, the line will be based<br />

on versatile Digital Light Engines<br />

(DLEs), which apply Chromacore technology<br />

to efficiently generate colored<br />

<strong>light</strong> and color-changing effects. They<br />

will also be compatible with Color<br />

Kinetics’ line of intuitive controllers,<br />

providing an integrated system for<br />

diverse applications, from wall washing<br />

to cove and accent <strong>light</strong>ing.<br />

Growth is Good<br />

In 2004, the Imperial Palace Hotel (formerly the Amiga) in Seoul,<br />

South Korea, was expanded to nearly three times its size, while the<br />

amount of hotel rooms doubled to 430. Re-opened in 2005, the additions<br />

included a convention center, nine restaurants, a spa and a shopping<br />

center.To maintain its meticulous ambiance and flexible buildingwide<br />

control, the hotel uses an ETC Unison architectural <strong>light</strong>ing system,<br />

which consists of sensor dimmers and theatrical fixtures. Pictured<br />

is the Imperial Palace lobby.<br />

LRC Selected by FAA To Study Airport Lighting<br />

The Lighting Research Center (LRC) at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute,Troy, NY, was selected by the Federal Aviation<br />

Administration (FAA) to join its Centers of Excellence program.The LRC will conduct <strong>light</strong>ing research as part of the<br />

Center of Excellence for Airport Technology (CEAT), which focuses on airport structures, pavement materials, wildlife<br />

issues, anti-icing and <strong>light</strong>ing. Specifically, the LRC will focus on the area of solid-state <strong>light</strong>ing and vision science.<br />

The LRC will explore the potential performance and application of new <strong>light</strong> source technologies, primarily LEDs, in<br />

airport and airfield <strong>light</strong>ing.The LRC will look at how these new technologies can be applied to <strong>light</strong> runways, taxiways,<br />

approaches and other areas of the airfield.<br />

For its first project with CEAT, the LRC will develop recommendations and metrics that consider the brightness perception<br />

of LED <strong>light</strong>ing on the airfield.“Performance standards for LED systems based on traditional <strong>light</strong>ing metrics, like<br />

luminance, are causing problems for viewers,” said LRC director of research, Nadarajah Narendran. As an example, he<br />

says a green LED approach <strong>light</strong> is typically perceived as much brighter and less comfortable to view than an incandescent<br />

green <strong>light</strong> of the same luminance.“A better metric is needed so that LED systems can be produced and used in<br />

the field without causing discomfort to pilots,” he said.<br />

The LRC will also work with the FAA to conduct psychophysical studies that compare the brightness perception of<br />

colored and white LED <strong>light</strong>ing systems with incandescent <strong>light</strong>ing systems, which use filters to create colored <strong>light</strong>.<br />

December 2005 LD+A 25


INDUSTRY UPDATES<br />

Call for Entries:<br />

GE Edison Award<br />

Competition<br />

GE Consumer & Industrial Lighting<br />

announced a Call for Entries for the<br />

23rd annual GE Edison Award competition.<br />

New for 2005, residential <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

projects submitted as entrants to the<br />

2005 competition will also be entered<br />

into a special category established for<br />

residential projects only.The top residential<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing design will receive an<br />

Award for Residential Design.<br />

All submitted projects must have<br />

been completed between January 1,<br />

2005 and December 31, 2005. Entries<br />

must be received by January18, 2006.<br />

For more information, visit<br />

www.geedisonaward.com<br />

Survey Says: LIGHTFAIR is a<br />

‘Must-Experience’ Event<br />

Why take LIGHTFAIR’s word for it when you can ask a nonbiased<br />

party Following the conclusion of LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL,<br />

Moore & Symons, Inc.—an independent market research firm—conducted<br />

a post-show study of attendees to determine their opinions and perceptions<br />

of the conference.The survey revealed that 93 percent consider<br />

LFI a “must-see” event and 95 percent consider LFI the gathering place for<br />

the industry. LFI attendees said that they’re more likely to attend future<br />

LFI shows vs. other industry shows like LDI and Light & Build.<br />

About the trade show portion, 96 percent said LFI has a high-quality<br />

set of exhibitors; 88 percent consider LFI a place to find new <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

design ideas; 90 percent consider LFI a place to see a wide variety of<br />

<strong>products</strong>; 91 percent consider LFI a source for discovering new trends in<br />

the marketplace; and 90 percent say LFI is the place to see new, unique,<br />

innovative <strong>products</strong>.<br />

As for the conference side of LFI, 92 percent said LFI keeps them<br />

informed of what’s going on in the industry and 89 percent said they<br />

learn something valuable at LFI every year.<br />

Lighting Manufacturer Wins State Environmental Award<br />

Columbia Lighting of Spokane, was one of five Washington-based businesses that received the 2005 Governor’s Award<br />

for Pollution Prevention & Sustainable Practices.The judges evaluated the entries based on innovations to reduce toxic<br />

materials and waste and use less energy and water, as well as other ways they have protected the environment. In total,<br />

four commercial businesses and a not-for-profit hospital were recognized.<br />

New Look to New York’s Plaza Park<br />

Liberty Plaza Park is undergoing a reconstruction that will create<br />

a public sanctuary in the heart of lower Manhattan.The 33,000 sq ft<br />

park will boast new foliage, new <strong>light</strong>ing and a central corridor for<br />

foot traffic. <strong>Illuminating</strong> the park will be 500 thin, rectangular, inground<br />

fluorescent <strong>light</strong>s.These fixtures have been specially designed<br />

to be water- and air-tight, as well as easily replaceable.The $8 million<br />

renovation should be completed by next summer.<br />

Photos: Renderings courtesy of Cooper, Robertson & Partners LLC<br />

Advance University<br />

Curriculum<br />

Approved by<br />

NCQLP<br />

Advance’s online ballast training<br />

courses offered through their website<br />

(Advance University) have been<br />

accepted as an approved curriculum<br />

by the National Council on<br />

Qualifications for the Lighting<br />

Professions (NCQLP).<br />

Currently there are three course<br />

levels being offered. The first level<br />

(Ballast Basics 101) covers ballast<br />

basics.The second level (Ballast Basics<br />

201) features ballast troubleshooting<br />

techniques as well as an introduction<br />

to many newer <strong>light</strong>ing technologies.<br />

Level three provides an overview of<br />

the Digital Addressable Lighting<br />

Interface (DALI) <strong>light</strong>ing standard and<br />

its use in creating new and powerful<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing designs.<br />

Completion of the courses will<br />

qualify NCQLP members for Lighting<br />

Education Units (LEUs) within the<br />

organization’s LC program. For more<br />

information, visit www.advancetransformer.com/university<br />

26 www.iesna.org


applications & solutions •<br />

Martha Says: ‘You’re Hired’<br />

The words “you’re fired” have sparked viewer curiosity week<br />

after week and ultimately catapulted Donald Trump’s show, “The<br />

Apprentice,” to high ratings. While the recently canceled “The<br />

Apprentice: Martha Stewart” didn’t match the ratings of the<br />

Trump show, it did provide a chance for several<br />

companies to get invaluable exposure<br />

for their interior furnishings <strong>products</strong>.<br />

Just like Trump’s version, the contestants<br />

on Stewart’s show have to set up camp in a<br />

New York City living space. Rather than<br />

reside in a suite at the Trump Tower on 5th Avenue, Martha’s spin-off has contestants staying in<br />

a posh loft.<br />

Traditional and contemporary furniture is mixed with clean, sleek lines in an industrial setting.<br />

The design team consisted of Kelly Van Patter (production designer); Bridget Edwards (set decorator);<br />

and David Park (<strong>light</strong>ing designer).<br />

South Florida <strong>light</strong>ing manufacturer Luraline was chosen to provide <strong>light</strong>ing fixtures for the loft.<br />

Selected for the kitchen area were the Reflecta silver dome pendants.The pendants add an industrial<br />

touch to the contemporary styled kitchen, which consists of stainless steel counters and rolling units that complement<br />

the dark family style tables and center-island.“We received all the <strong>light</strong>ing by contacting Luraline directly and<br />

asking them to participate in our product placement for the show,” said Van Patter.“Basically, we decorated the entire<br />

loft by having different vendors supply us with product in exchange for exposure.” <strong>Illuminating</strong> the bathroom area are<br />

wave pendants, which feature an eclectic style that blends well with the loft’s modern décor.<br />

“The only challenge was the set director’s need for the product in such a short time frame,” said Kurt M.<br />

Mandelik, Luraline’s vice president,“but we were able to ship the product to the client within their time restraints.”<br />

Between the fixtures and the finishes selected, designers achieved the look they were after from the very beginning.<br />

The Project: The contestant<br />

loft for the “The Apprentice:<br />

Martha Stewart” television<br />

show, New York, NY<br />

The Challenge: Incorporate an<br />

industrial <strong>light</strong>ing design into<br />

a contemporary styled loft.<br />

The Solution: Pendant<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing fixtures<br />

—John-Michael Kobes<br />

December 2005 LD+A 27


• applications & solutions<br />

Beachfront Lighting Proves to be<br />

an Environmentally Safe Addition<br />

Every summer, sea turtles make their way to the shores of South Florida, each laying about 100 eggs in 40,000<br />

to 70,000 nests in the sand.The only way the mothers and their young can make their way back to water is by<br />

following the moon and star<strong>light</strong> that reflects off the sea.<br />

Artificial <strong>light</strong>ing landward of the beach can also deter turtles from emerging from the ocean and nesting. In addition,<br />

if a hatchling is unable to see the ocean horizon or if artificial <strong>light</strong> is visible, the hatchling may become disoriented<br />

and crawl toward a landward <strong>light</strong> source.<br />

One of the larger nesting areas in the state is the<br />

Beachwalk,a 3400-ft long x 15-ft wide paved public access<br />

trail that winds its way up Miami Beach’s eastern shore.<br />

Coastal Systems International, Inc. coordinated with<br />

Bradshaw Gill & Associates, (landscape architects); QRE<br />

Associates, (project architect); and Form+Surfaces, (project<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing manufacturers) to make the trip safer for the<br />

sea turtles.<br />

The team installed Triada pedestrian <strong>light</strong>ing.Constructed<br />

of rustproof aluminum,the pole-top luminaire is engineered<br />

to withstand salt spray and the extreme winds to which the<br />

area is regularly subjected. Unlike many conventional<br />

The Project: The Miami Beachwalk,<br />

Miami, FL<br />

The Challenge: Install <strong>light</strong>ing that<br />

meets the varying criteria of a tropical<br />

environment that is both a tourist<br />

destination and sea turtle habitat<br />

The Solution: Pole-top luminaires<br />

shields, which are positioned next to the lamp, this exterior shield minimizes wraparound<br />

<strong>light</strong> and bypass glow that are known to have hazardous navigational impacts on turtle hatchlings.<br />

“The project required a design that would integrate aesthetically with the nautical environment and provide<br />

extreme durability and unique features exacted by the site specific conditions,” said Tod Kopco, director of custom<br />

manufacturing, Forms+Surfaces.<br />

In the end, the installation, which began in 2004 and is still on going, benefited the city, its many visitors and the<br />

precious marine species that live in this environmentally sensitive and heavily regulated beachfront area.<br />

—John-Michael Kobes<br />

28 www.iesna.org


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P R. O. J . E C. T . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P . R O. J. E C. T. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

EMPHASIZING REGIONALISM OVER NOSTALGIA, PETCO PARK<br />

CELEBRATES SAN DIEGO EVEN MORE THAN BASEBALL<br />

By Paul Tarricone<br />

Sports <strong>light</strong>s hang off the front of two<br />

200-ft high infield towers (far left).<br />

These vertical structures behind<br />

home plate house suites and break<br />

up the seating bowl, creating different<br />

“neighborhoods” within the stadium.<br />

Conventional sports <strong>light</strong> racks could<br />

not be used for these <strong>light</strong>s.<br />

Petco Park is not kind to power hitters. With<br />

its deep outfield fences, the spacious home<br />

of the San Diego Padres turns what would<br />

be home runs in other ballparks into harmless<br />

flyball outs. So it stands to reason that Padres’<br />

slugger Ryan Klesko would want to distance himself<br />

from Petco after a game. Guess again. Klesko<br />

has a condo at the Omni Hotel right next to the<br />

ballpark and out his window he can look down<br />

into the stadium. “I haven’t gone down to take<br />

BP in my pajamas or anything,” he told Sports<br />

Illustrated, “but I can roll out of bed and boom,<br />

I’m already at the ballpark.”<br />

Pretty cool. In fact, “California Cool” might be<br />

the best way to describe Petco Park, its architecture<br />

and its <strong>light</strong>ing. Notably, even the Padres’<br />

website emphasizes the stadium’s San Diego<br />

vibe over the baseball experience. “Architecturally<br />

magnificent, it celebrates the sea, the sky, the<br />

natural beauty, cultural diversity and unique spirit<br />

of our region,” proclaims a fact sheet on the<br />

stadium. “The relaxed yet dynamic atmosphere<br />

reflects the San Diego lifestyle.”<br />

Building materials include steel, natural stone,<br />

stucco and brick. Two large, sandstone “garden<br />

buildings” that frame the home plate entrance<br />

(and provide fans a “peaceful refuge” and restaurants,<br />

concession stands and outdoor terraces)<br />

and lush landscaping each reinforce the regional<br />

design approach of HOK Sport (executive architect)<br />

and Antoine Predock (design architect). To<br />

make the San Diego experience complete,<br />

there’s even a patch of beach behind the rightcenter<br />

field fence.<br />

Illume/M-E Engineers, Wheat Ridge, CO, was<br />

responsible for all architectural <strong>light</strong>ing, including<br />

the plaza outside the stadium, the garden buildings,<br />

the stadium façade, the concourses, restaurants,<br />

suites, as well as the sports <strong>light</strong>ing.<br />

SAN DIEGO TO<br />

PHOTOS: TIMOTHY HURSLEY<br />

The Core<br />

30 www.iesna.org December 2005 LD+A 31


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

P R O J E C T<br />

By combining different <strong>light</strong> sources,<br />

designers were able to accentuate one<br />

of the sandstone “garden buildings”<br />

(left), as well as the industrial steel and<br />

precast concrete stadium infrastructure.<br />

“Inconspicuous” is the word most often used to describe<br />

the design approach. Indeed, there is an almost complete<br />

absence of decorative <strong>light</strong>ing elements. “It’s not your typical<br />

ballpark with lots of overhead <strong>light</strong>ing,” says Joy<br />

Yamada of Illume/M-E Engineers. “The <strong>light</strong>ing of Petco<br />

Park distills <strong>light</strong>ing design to the very basics: <strong>light</strong> reveals<br />

architecture and stages a comfortable and exciting nighttime<br />

experience. Because of Petco’s monumental scale, it<br />

was essential to provide a multi-layered <strong>light</strong>ing design<br />

that balances and articulates the building’s unique forms,<br />

rich limestone palette and desert landscape, as well as provide<br />

the functional requirements for fan amenities, assembly,<br />

circulation, hospitality and operations.”<br />

Lighting for Scale<br />

Designers used a combination of different <strong>light</strong> sources<br />

with excellent color rendering capabilities for architectural<br />

flood<strong>light</strong>ing and more localized <strong>light</strong>ing. Light levels<br />

and fixture locations lead people through the stadium,<br />

creating a staging hierarchy that reinforces the scale and<br />

energy of the facility.<br />

Ceramic metal halide up<strong>light</strong>s (70-W) wash the stone<br />

façades of the garden buildings and high<strong>light</strong> palm trees.<br />

Along with other plaza <strong>light</strong>ing systems, they create layers<br />

of <strong>light</strong> that “downsize” the stadium at the entrance<br />

near home plate.<br />

Yamada calls the <strong>light</strong> fixtures “utilitarian. ...There was<br />

not a huge budget available. We used a standard kit of<br />

parts and ‘hid’ them.” For example, shielded compact fluorescent<br />

step<strong>light</strong>s with 26-W double biax lamps provide<br />

a soft glow on the upper level of the garden buildings, texturizing<br />

the limestone walls. Palm trees are high<strong>light</strong>ed<br />

with 70-W ceramic metal halide lamps. In the club below,<br />

incandescent and halogen sources create a lantern effect.<br />

As patrons walk to the garden buildings, intimate lowlevel<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing with affordable, continuous 3000K lensed<br />

strip<strong>light</strong>s, is concealed beneath planters, providing a<br />

strong visual link between the stadium and these structures.<br />

For the stadium façade, up<strong>light</strong>s located at steel<br />

columns and upper sunscreens use 70-W ceramic metal<br />

halide lamps. Shielded area flood<strong>light</strong>s, with 250-W<br />

32 www.iesna.org


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

P R O J E C T<br />

Block Party<br />

The $449.4 million ballpark complex is just one piece<br />

of a 26-block downtown redevelopment initiative that<br />

includes restaurants, shopping, museums and other<br />

tourist attractions. As a result, Petco’s sports <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

can’t upset the neighbors.<br />

“Each project has its own unique issues, and Petco had<br />

more than its share,” says Ed Ragain, president of M-E<br />

Engineers, who was responsible for the sports <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

aspect. “Direct glare and indirect reflective glare were<br />

significant issues in the design process due to the location<br />

of the park, existing development and proposed<br />

high-rise development around the park. Glare models<br />

were prepared to support the impact the sports <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

would have on the environment, along with a detailed<br />

inventory of all existing buildings in a four-block radius<br />

around the park.”<br />

As is common in stadium projects, <strong>light</strong> trespass considerations<br />

also factored in. “Several <strong>light</strong>ing and environmental<br />

goals were presented to us by the city, or permission<br />

for the project would be in jeopardy,” says<br />

Ragain. “Dark Sky issues, surrounding roadway issues,<br />

hotel room views into the seating bowl at night, the team<br />

owner’s condominium viewing into the bowl at night<br />

and the waterfront environment all were addressed during<br />

design.”<br />

Inside the stadium, <strong>light</strong>ing hangs off the front of two<br />

200-ft high infield towers—vertical structures behind<br />

home plate that house suites and also serve to break up<br />

the seating bowl, creating different “neighborhoods”<br />

within the stadium. “The design architect wanted a different<br />

‘look’ from other ballparks,” says Ragain.<br />

Consequently, normal sports <strong>light</strong> racks could not be<br />

used for these <strong>light</strong>s. Other issues inside the bowl were<br />

shadow control for high definition <strong>light</strong>ing and balance of<br />

illumination across the playing field.<br />

Lighting solutions included mixing 2000-watt and<br />

1500-watt <strong>products</strong> along with special glare and spill <strong>light</strong><br />

shielding. The shielding was provided for sports fixtures<br />

Two “garden buildings” (foreground center and right)<br />

frame the home plate entrance. A silhoutte <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

approach provides drama and contrast.<br />

metal halide lamps, provide ambient <strong>light</strong> for the main<br />

and upper concourses. Continuous wallwashers with fluorescent<br />

lamps provide a uniform soft glow on stucco<br />

walls and steel trusses on the main and club levels.<br />

GE supplied the <strong>light</strong>ing for Petco Park, and the project<br />

received a 2004 GE Edison Award of Merit.<br />

‘Inconspicuous’ is the word<br />

most often used to describe the<br />

design approach. Indeed, there is<br />

an almost complete absence of<br />

decorative <strong>light</strong>ing elements<br />

with direct line of sight to areas outside the bowl at<br />

motorist intersections. The fixture aiming strategy<br />

included multiple full-zone aiming schemes to control<br />

hard line shadows on the playing field. “This aiming<br />

strategy was created by our staff for NBA and NHL arenas<br />

around the country, and we have incorporated some<br />

of these ideas for outdoor facilities,” Ragain adds.<br />

On the field, inside the stadium gates and out on the<br />

plaza grounds, Petco Park embodies San Diego. It’s no<br />

surprise a Southern California surfer boy like Ryan<br />

Klesko feels right at home.<br />

About the Designers: Martin E. Ragain, LEED AP,<br />

is president and co-founder of M-E Engineers, Inc.<br />

His experience includes sports facilities, institutional,<br />

health care, historic renovations, industrial, science<br />

and technology, commercial, and power generation<br />

facilities. Mr. Ragain has authored technical<br />

reports on sports <strong>light</strong>ing for the NFL, NBA, NHL,<br />

and MLB along with providing sports <strong>light</strong>ing and<br />

environmental impact studies for several new professional sports facilities<br />

around the world. He has received multiple IIDA Awards for his<br />

sports projects.<br />

Joy Yamada is an associate at Illume/M-E Engineers<br />

and director of the <strong>light</strong>ing department for six<br />

offices in the U.S. and London. Project experience<br />

includes commercial office buildings, master planning,<br />

hospitality, retail and residential. She is an<br />

associate member of the IALD.<br />

Krystof Pavek, Member IESNA (1991), formerly of<br />

Illume M-E Engineers, is now designer/owner of<br />

Luminatica, a <strong>light</strong>ing design consulting firm in<br />

Rancho Santa Fe, CA, and product designer with<br />

Aurora<strong>light</strong>, Inc., Carlsbad, CA. He holds a Masters<br />

degree in <strong>light</strong>ing from Rensselaer Polytechnic<br />

Institute’s Lighting Research Center, and has<br />

received four design awards.<br />

December 2005 LD+A 33


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . E S. IP G. ROJECT N. T. R. E N. D. S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . E S. IPROJECT<br />

G. N. T. R. E N. D. S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

PHOTO: RICHARD PAYNE<br />

Large-scale pendant lanterns at the main<br />

entrance and limited exterior <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

give the building architectural form.<br />

Weekend Warriors<br />

to World-Class<br />

pus amenity. Lighting for this facility needs<br />

to address the wide range of uses housed in<br />

the same facility and wrap them all up in an<br />

energized, upscale look. Before any <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

for the interior was considered, an inviting<br />

exterior presence had to be established for the<br />

center that worked both day and night.<br />

Working closely with Hughes Group Architects,<br />

Horton Lees Brogden (HLB) designed <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

that would make sure the multiple views into<br />

the building became glowing advertisements<br />

at night that beckon the passerby to enter and<br />

explore. Large-scale pendant lanterns at the<br />

main entrance and limited exterior building<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing proved to be an effective and economical<br />

solution that gives the building form.<br />

Full Workout<br />

Meanwhile, the project scope for the interior<br />

encompassed everything you would<br />

expect to find in this new generation of<br />

recreational centers, including:<br />

Natatorium. The natatorium houses an<br />

Olympic-size pool with a 10-meter diving<br />

tower and spectator stands. Activities range<br />

from general recreational and instructional to<br />

full-blown NCAA competition. Along with the<br />

given <strong>light</strong>ing requirements for safety, corrosion<br />

resistance and incumbent <strong>light</strong>ing levels<br />

comes the need to add a little more “zip” to<br />

the natatorium during competitions. While<br />

the university was not interested in NBA-style<br />

spot-<strong>light</strong>ed player intros, HLB was able to<br />

provide a bit more “focus” on the pool and<br />

the swimmers by utilizing narrow distribution<br />

fixtures that pump the 500 lux of<br />

general/recreational <strong>light</strong>ing up to a tightly<br />

controlled 1000 lux on the pool alone. Two<br />

400-W pulse-start metal halide fixtures with<br />

two different <strong>light</strong>ing distributions were<br />

attached to the roof trusses and are serviced<br />

from a gantry that spans the natatorium. Four<br />

preset scenes were achieved with careful circuiting<br />

and low-voltage relay switching.<br />

Diving Tower. Two considerations must be<br />

met when <strong>light</strong>ing a diving tower. The diver<br />

must be able to see the surface of the water<br />

and the spectator has to see the diver. The<br />

speed at which this all happens adds an extra<br />

burden to the visual system and thus the<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing. Comprehensive studies were performed<br />

to ensure that the vertical illumination<br />

from the top of the diver’s trajectory to<br />

the water surface were uniform, of a high<br />

level (1000 lux) and did not create disability<br />

glare for the diver (particularly at the platform<br />

level). The vertical illumination was<br />

achieved through 150-W metal halide flood-<br />

Athletes<br />

LIGHTING DESIGN AT THE NEW<br />

UNIVERSITY OF HOUSTON<br />

RECREATION CENTER<br />

ACCOMMODATES ATHLETES OF<br />

ALL STRIPES<br />

The gym is no longer the sole domain of the jock. In fact,<br />

the gym isn’t just the gym anymore. It has become the<br />

athletic center. Along with the essential natatorium,<br />

gymnasium and weight room come leisure pools, climbing<br />

walls, water slides, a sea of exercise equipment and even the<br />

spa. The user base has logically expanded from the hard-core<br />

athlete to include everyone from the simply health-conscious to<br />

those just looking to relax and maybe find their next date.<br />

At 264,000 sq ft, the University of Houston’s new Campus<br />

Recreation and Wellness Center is the epitome of the new cam-<br />

Safety, corrosion resistance, proper <strong>light</strong>ing levels and even the<br />

need to add some spark to NCAA swimming competitions drove<br />

the <strong>light</strong>ing design of the natatorium.<br />

PHOTO: TIMOTHY HURSLEY<br />

34 www.iesna.org<br />

December 2005 LD+A 35


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . E S . I PG . ROJECT N . T . R . E N . D . S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . E S . I PROJECT G . N . T . R . E N . D . S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

<strong>light</strong>s that cross-lit the tower at 45 deg on<br />

both sides (in plan view). Lighting of the<br />

diver’s path close to the water surface added<br />

the extra levels needed at the surface (in<br />

combination with a water sprayer that creates<br />

surface turbulence).<br />

Multi-Purpose Gymnasium. While traditional<br />

gymnasiums were typically <strong>light</strong>ed<br />

with 400-W pulse-start metal halide high-bay<br />

fixtures, the multi-purpose gymnasium needed<br />

more attention because of its diverse uses.<br />

In both the traditional and multi-use gymnasium<br />

(as well as the natatorium), <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

designers recommended that the ceilings and<br />

ceiling elements (acoustical panels, ducts,<br />

etc.) be of a high reflectance value to promote<br />

visual comfort and reduce brightness contrast<br />

between the fixtures and the ceiling beyond.<br />

In the multi-purpose gymnasium the nearly<br />

white ceiling provided an opportunity for<br />

up<strong>light</strong>ing to create the lower, soft ambient<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing levels required for non-athletic uses.<br />

Asymmetric fluorescent up<strong>light</strong>s were located<br />

on the lower flange of the trusses and circuited<br />

to provide three levels of <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

(200/300/500 lux) through switching.<br />

Exercise Equipment Area. No matter<br />

how you try to work it, you always end up<br />

sweating on your back in the exercise area.<br />

To minimize the pain of exercise, HLB utilized<br />

pendant-hung linear fluorescent<br />

up<strong>light</strong>s to provide comfortable general illumination<br />

no matter which way the user<br />

was facing and just enough small accent<br />

<strong>light</strong>s to high<strong>light</strong> the sparkle of the hightech<br />

exercise equipment in an effort to<br />

reinforce the dynamic nature of the space.<br />

Rock-Climbing Wall. The big enticement to<br />

visit the athletic center is a view of the rockclimbing<br />

wall as you enter the facility. It is seen<br />

just beyond the check-in desk on the opposite<br />

side of the palm tree-filled rotunda with its<br />

jumbo video screen. The climbing wall clearly<br />

had to stand out amid all this visual competition.<br />

The right <strong>light</strong>ing to create this visual<br />

focus and to provide a user-friendly, safe experience<br />

was key. PAR38 metal halide fixtures<br />

were located at the ceiling level and at various<br />

PHOTO: TIMOTHY HURSLEY<br />

At the rock-climbing wall, the angle of the<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing was critical to dramatize the craggy<br />

texture of the wall, but without creating<br />

disability glare.<br />

The ceiling in the multi-purpose gym has a high reflectance value to promote visual<br />

comfort and reduce brightness contrast between the fixtures and the ceiling beyond.<br />

PHOTO: COURTESY OF HLB<br />

36 www.iesna.org<br />

December 2005 LD+A 37


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. O. V. E R. S. T. O . R Y. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C O. V. E . R S. T. O . R Y. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

The city of Memphis is a crock<br />

pot full of musical flavors. Rock<br />

n’ roll, jazz, blues, country and<br />

gospel can all be found and heard in<br />

the city, especially when the tunes<br />

are blaring from one of America’s<br />

liveliest entertainment districts,<br />

Beale Street. However, in 2001, a different<br />

kind of sound—the noise of<br />

cheering crowds and squeaky sneakers—was<br />

heard when the city<br />

acquired its first NBA franchise.<br />

Bear in mind, the Grizzlies franchise<br />

spent its first six seasons in<br />

Vancouver, playing to a half-empty<br />

arena. After the Canadian venture<br />

failed, Memphis emerged as the primary<br />

destination for relocation when<br />

FedEx (headquartered in the city)<br />

joined the effort to lure the franchise<br />

to the area with the promise of a new,<br />

state-of-the-art multipurpose facility.<br />

The project’s total cost is often<br />

quoted at $250 million, but that figure<br />

includes expenditures for renovations<br />

and upgrades at the nearby<br />

Pyramid, which served as the team’s<br />

interim home arena. Completed in<br />

2004, the FedExForum features<br />

more than 800,000 sq ft of facility<br />

space, making it the largest public<br />

building construction project in the<br />

city’s history. Besides NBA action,<br />

the 18,200-seat arena also hosts<br />

home games for the NCAA Memphis<br />

Tigers, as well as showcasing hockey/ice<br />

shows (integrated ice floor<br />

option), concerts, family and trade<br />

shows, rodeos and indoor motorsports.<br />

Inside the facility, guest comforts<br />

and amenities include a main<br />

concourse, 64 total suites (28 lower<br />

level; 32 at club level; four party<br />

suites at club level), a team store,<br />

casual sports bar, premium restaurants<br />

and lounges, and interactive<br />

displays and exhibits. Additional<br />

exterior components include a fivefloor<br />

adjoining garage for 1200 vehicles<br />

and a four-story administrative<br />

office building, which also houses<br />

the Smithsonian Institution’s Rock<br />

N’ Soul Museum.<br />

Grasping Your Roots<br />

The New Memphis Arena Public<br />

Building Authority, which oversaw<br />

the construction process, tapped<br />

sports architecture and engineering<br />

firm Ellerbe Becket, Kansas City,<br />

MO, to handle a large portion of the<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing and architectural needs. The<br />

areas included the team store, all<br />

restaurants and bars (except for the<br />

Backstage restaurant), concourses,<br />

team store, lobby, event floor and<br />

seating areas, dressing rooms and<br />

the exterior <strong>light</strong>ing. Liles <strong>Engineering</strong><br />

and Looney Ricks Kiss, both<br />

Memphis-based firms, and general<br />

contractor MA Mortenson, Minneapolis,<br />

MN, were also instrumental in<br />

the completion of the forum.<br />

Designers wanted to develop a<br />

facility that integrated the culture of<br />

the NBA into the historical scale and<br />

context of the neighborhood.<br />

Seeking inspiration, Ellerbe Becket<br />

referred back to another one of its<br />

NBA arena projects, the Conseco<br />

Field House, Indianapolis, IN.<br />

For the FedExForm, this connection<br />

to the surrounding area begins<br />

when spectators make their way<br />

towards the arena’s 35,000 sq ft<br />

exterior plaza, which acts as a runway<br />

for fans arriving and departing<br />

the facility. Designers selected a<br />

The forum’s combination of a large<br />

glass façade and high interior<br />

footcandle illumination levels<br />

created a nighttime transparent<br />

effect that connects the exterior<br />

activity to the interior activity.<br />

Fed Excellent<br />

PHOTOS: TIM HURSLEY<br />

THE FEDEXFORUM MIGHT BE IN THE HEART OF<br />

THE MEMPHIS MUSIC SCENE, BUT WITH ITS INSTANT<br />

SUCCESS, IT’S FEELING ANYTHING BUT THE BLUES<br />

By John-Michael Kobes<br />

Adventure<br />

40 www.iesna.org December 2005 LD+A 41


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

C O V E R S T O R Y<br />

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

C O V E R S T O R Y<br />

Blue Note lounge combines the<br />

nostalgia of Memphis blues with<br />

a contemporary setting.<br />

A view from one of the forum’s 32<br />

private club suites.<br />

darkened red hue (four shades of it)<br />

for the arena façade, which also<br />

coincides with the red-brick finish<br />

that can be found on some of the<br />

older buildings, as well as the new<br />

Gibson Guitar Co. Once inside,<br />

guests are greeted by a 12,500 sq ft<br />

main entry, which features the<br />

Grizzlies Den team store and the<br />

Jack Daniel’s Old No. 7 sports bar<br />

and the team’s practice court.<br />

The forum’s combination of a<br />

large glass façade and high interior<br />

footcandle illumination levels created<br />

a nighttime transparent effect<br />

that connects the exterior activity to<br />

the interior activity. This was<br />

accomplished by using an industrial<br />

grade highbay 16 in. prismatic<br />

Incandescent down<strong>light</strong>s, pendants<br />

and wall sconces <strong>light</strong> Opus, a fine<br />

dining facility with views of the<br />

arena floor.<br />

acrylic reflector with one, 400-W<br />

pulse start metal halide (in the<br />

lobby) and an industrial grade highbay<br />

22 in. borosilicate glass optic<br />

with one, 1000-W pulse start metal<br />

halide (the practice court areas).<br />

Both fixtures were provided by<br />

Hubbell Lighting. The concourse<br />

also includes 70-W metal halide<br />

down<strong>light</strong>s and eight in. 70-W<br />

direct pendant cylinder fixtures,<br />

both from Prescolite.<br />

In The Zone<br />

Located on the main concourse is<br />

the First Tennessee Club which<br />

offers seat holders a few different<br />

dining and socializing options. The<br />

first is Opus, a 350-seat fine dining<br />

Designers wanted to develop a facility that<br />

integrated the culture of the NBA into the<br />

historical scale and context of the<br />

neighborhood<br />

facility that features hardwood<br />

floors, a 30-seat bar and a number<br />

of unique views of the arena floor.<br />

Offering a hipper, less formal<br />

atmosphere is the Blue Note lounge,<br />

which combines the nostalgia of<br />

Memphis blues with a contemporary<br />

style. There are also several<br />

mini restaurants around the concourse.<br />

These were fitted with<br />

incandescent down<strong>light</strong>s for general<br />

illumination and several pendants<br />

and wall sconces for accent <strong>light</strong>ing.<br />

This private level also features 32<br />

club suites and 80 club boxes. Suite<br />

corridors on this level are equipped<br />

with eight in. 32-W cylinders, which<br />

were installed in the portion of corridor<br />

with no ceiling, while four in.<br />

75-W MR16 accent luminaires were<br />

used in areas with a ceiling.<br />

“To bring out the different environments<br />

and displays along the<br />

interior of the public concourses,<br />

the <strong>light</strong>ing levels vary to enhance<br />

both the wayfinding and the fan<br />

experience,” said Jon Neimuth, lead<br />

designer, Ellerbe Becket. “For example,<br />

in darker transitional areas<br />

there’s accent <strong>light</strong>ing on wall displays<br />

and in areas of thematic<br />

development there are high levels of<br />

illumination.”<br />

Floor Control<br />

The building is operated by a<br />

MicroLite Lighting control system.<br />

There is main control in the engineer<br />

room as well as a control room<br />

overlooking the event floor and<br />

seating area which is known as the<br />

arena bowl. The control room features<br />

T8 2x2 and 2x4 troffers<br />

(Columbia Lighting) and 35-W, 20<br />

deg cylinder spot luminaires (USA<br />

Illumination Inc.). Quad controls<br />

42 www.iesna.org<br />

December 2005 LD+A 43


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

C O V E R S T O R Y<br />

The control room overlooking the event floor<br />

features T8 troffers plus 35-W spot fixtures.<br />

activate all the <strong>light</strong>ing for nonevent<br />

times when the arena is being<br />

cleaned or set up for an event.<br />

Barbara Hoppas, principal and electrical<br />

engineer (formerly of Ellerbe<br />

Becket), said, “The system is set up<br />

so that there are two levels of control:<br />

the relays must be activated<br />

(on) and then there is also individual<br />

control (<strong>light</strong> switches or dimmers)<br />

in the individual areas (office,<br />

suite toilet, concessions, etc).”<br />

The arena bowl was designed primarily<br />

for two sports (basketball<br />

and hockey). Currently there is no<br />

professional hockey team playing at<br />

the arena, however, <strong>light</strong>ing can be<br />

incorporated if needed. Other <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

systems were included so that<br />

the 1000-W clear metal halide Z-<br />

lamp with blackout shield sport<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing is only used for sporting<br />

events. These include a 1000-W<br />

clear metal halide Z-lamp work<strong>light</strong>s<br />

(Musco Lighting); 1500-W<br />

quartz halogen house <strong>light</strong>s (GE);<br />

and source four 575-W aisle <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

(ETC), which were fitted with<br />

framed shutters and gobos, so <strong>light</strong><br />

is limited to the aisles and<br />

vestibules during concerts and<br />

other blackout times like player<br />

introductions and half-time shows.<br />

The 45,000 pound scoreboard is<br />

22 ft-high x 38 ft-wide and includes<br />

two 360 deg full-color LED screens<br />

on the top and bottom and four additional<br />

color video screens on all sides.<br />

When asked what he was most<br />

proud of after the completion of the<br />

project, Niemuth said, “The way in<br />

which the project seems as active<br />

and vibrant during the evening as it<br />

does during the day. The project<br />

through its different architectural<br />

design elements takes on two distinct<br />

visual characteristics.”<br />

For years, Beale Street had the gigs,<br />

but today, it finally has game, too.<br />

About the Designers:<br />

During his 10 years with<br />

Ellerbe Becket, Jon D.<br />

Niemuth, AIA, has been<br />

responsible for leading the<br />

design and planning of<br />

such projects as Qwest<br />

Field, Exhibition Center<br />

and Parking Garage, Seattle, WA; the University<br />

of Connecticut, Rentschler Field, East Hartford,<br />

CT, and the George Mason University<br />

Fieldhouse, Fairfax, VA. Mr. Niemuth’s academic<br />

background includes a Bachelor of<br />

Architectural Studies, Master of Architecture<br />

and Master of Urban Planning/Urban Design<br />

from the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.<br />

Barbara L.S. Hoppas,<br />

Member IESNA (2001), is<br />

currently principal and<br />

president of Bredson &<br />

Associates, Inc. Ms. Hoppas<br />

holds a Bachelor of<br />

Science in architectural<br />

engineering from Kansas<br />

State University, Manhattan, KS. She was formerly<br />

with Ellerbe Becket, where she managed<br />

electrical design for professional and collegiate<br />

sports facilities.<br />

44 www.iesna.org


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

I I D A P R O J E C T<br />

The main trading floor incorporates<br />

asymmetric cove <strong>light</strong>s mounted within<br />

specially designed ceiling panels.<br />

PHOTO CREDIT: JON MILLER, HEDRICH BLESSING<br />

THE BANK OF AMERICA TRADING<br />

FLOOR SATISFIES LIGHT-SENSITIVE<br />

TRADERS WHILE ADDING SIZZLE TO<br />

THE CHARLOTTE, NC, SKYLINE<br />

UP<br />

TRADING<br />

How do you <strong>light</strong> a 50-ft tall trading floor<br />

for 600 traders in a building with glazed<br />

walls, north, south, east and west facing<br />

clerestories, while also creating a visually exciting,<br />

comfortable environment for one of the<br />

world’s largest banking institutions You<br />

engage a team of consultants with expertise in<br />

integrating all of the vast mechanical, electrical,<br />

telecommunications, life safety, and acoustical,<br />

architectural and <strong>light</strong>ing systems.<br />

The Bank of America engaged the same<br />

design team that designed the trading arena for<br />

UBS in Stamford—the largest column free-trading<br />

arena (800 traders) in the world. The collaborative<br />

was led by Mustafa Abadon of Skidmore<br />

Owings & Merrill (SOM); Cosentini Associates<br />

served as the MEP consultants; and Cosentini<br />

Lighting Design worked as the <strong>light</strong>ing consultants.<br />

Cosentini <strong>light</strong>ing designers Stephen<br />

Margulies and Marianne Maloney received an<br />

2005 IIDA Award of Excellence for the project.<br />

Multi-functional Ceiling<br />

There were several challenges to this project.<br />

The first was to develop an integrated ceiling<br />

design that would accommodate air, sprinklers<br />

and <strong>light</strong>s, and one that would complement the<br />

architecture. A combination of indirect and<br />

direct <strong>light</strong>ing provides the best visual environment<br />

for this type of space. The wing-like ceiling<br />

design for the main trading floor evolved<br />

from of a series of models and mockups. This<br />

ceiling design had to complement the unique<br />

roof structure designed by SOM and accommodate<br />

all of the <strong>light</strong>ing components. A full-size<br />

mockup was helpful in determining the effect<br />

December 2005 LD+A 47


The open glazed north wall<br />

accommodates day<strong>light</strong>,<br />

creates a stunning view<br />

into the trading floor and<br />

makes for a dramatic<br />

addition to the skyline.


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

I I D A P R O J E C T<br />

at the ends of the ceiling panels where the<br />

dimension eventually approaches zero as the<br />

wing panel touches the flat ceiling. The last<br />

cove <strong>light</strong> fixture had to be separately dimmed<br />

to make the appropriate transition. The main<br />

trading floor incorporates two rows of concealed<br />

asymmetric distribution fluorescent<br />

cove <strong>light</strong>s mounted within the folded ceiling<br />

panels. High output T5 lamps were used in<br />

small optical assemblies.<br />

Additional recessed ceramic metal halide<br />

lamps were used to provide the direct <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

component. The ceramic metal halide lamps<br />

were used for their good color and reasonably<br />

long lamp life. To complete the three-dimensional<br />

modeling of the ceiling, semi-recessed wallmounted<br />

compact fluorescent up<strong>light</strong>s were<br />

used at the edges of the room. These fixtures illuminated<br />

the underside of the ceiling panels. The<br />

combination of these three <strong>light</strong>ing components<br />

provided up to 45 footcandles, glare free.<br />

A preset dimming system was designed to<br />

control all of the trading area <strong>light</strong>ing systems,<br />

maximize day<strong>light</strong> harvesting and time-of-day<br />

scheduling. The dimming system also controlled<br />

all of the automated shade systems and the all of<br />

the non-dimmed <strong>light</strong>ing loads throughout the<br />

facility. The integrated control system allowed us<br />

to easily commission the entire project in one<br />

day and one evening. The system also benefits<br />

users, allowing them full command from one<br />

point of control, and provides significant energy<br />

savings through time-of-day control, in addition<br />

to the day<strong>light</strong> harvesting.<br />

Making Use of Day<strong>light</strong><br />

The second challenge was to assess the effectiveness<br />

of all of the fenestrations for what we<br />

call “useable” day<strong>light</strong>ing. Traders have a reputation<br />

for wanting to work in a dark room.<br />

They’re jokingly called “vampires” because of<br />

their sensitivity to <strong>light</strong>. This reputation comes<br />

from years of exposure to bad <strong>light</strong>ing equipment<br />

and designs used in conjunction with bad<br />

monitors and trading turrets. Today’s monitors<br />

are much more tolerant of ambient <strong>light</strong> than<br />

those used five years ago. The <strong>light</strong>ing systems<br />

do not have to be designed around reflections<br />

in monitors any longer.<br />

Extensive day<strong>light</strong>ing studies were performed<br />

to evaluate the extent of useable day<strong>light</strong> and to<br />

develop a day<strong>light</strong> control strategy for all of the<br />

fenestrations. Each fenestration was assessed<br />

for sky brightness and direct sun. A solar tracking<br />

diagram was created to develop appropriate<br />

shielding elements for each fenestration. The<br />

shades on the north wall were angled 23 deg<br />

from true north to accommodate the buildings<br />

orientation. Each of the clerestories had individually<br />

controlled shades. All of the shades were<br />

designed to have 40 percent transmission to<br />

Ceiling panels contain<br />

indirect <strong>light</strong>ing and<br />

recessed down<strong>light</strong>ing to<br />

provide up to<br />

45 footcandles, glare-free.<br />

Traders have a reputation<br />

for wanting to work in a<br />

dark room. They’re jokingly<br />

called ‘vampires’ because of<br />

their sensitivity to <strong>light</strong><br />

reduce exposure. Blackout shades were considered<br />

but deemed unnecessary.<br />

This trading floor optimized the available day<strong>light</strong>.<br />

Automated shades were designed to track<br />

the sun and to only allow diffuse day<strong>light</strong> into<br />

the room. The electric <strong>light</strong>s are either dimmed<br />

or turned off when not required. The 50-ft tall<br />

north wall of glass also had automated shades<br />

to provide protection from excessive sky brightness,<br />

which occurred early in the morning<br />

throughout the year and at varying times during<br />

the work day. During commissioning of the<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing and shades, designers established a<br />

time of day when the shades should rise, should<br />

they be down because of sky brightness conditions.<br />

When the 4:00 bell rang that signifies the<br />

close of the markets, the shades would rise.<br />

That great idea only lasted a few days. The<br />

December 2005 LD+A 49


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

I I D A P R O J E C T<br />

The 50-ft high winged ceiling integrates<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing, air and sprinklers.<br />

traders, to the dismay of the <strong>light</strong>ing designers,<br />

wanted the north wall to always be open regardless<br />

of sky conditions. Who would have guessed<br />

that these creatures of the night would want to<br />

work in near full day<strong>light</strong> Each project brings<br />

new lessons learned.<br />

Meanwhile, the support areas around the<br />

trading arena were designed for full flexibility.<br />

Enclosed offices can be created or demolished<br />

without any construction trades. All architectural,<br />

mechanical, electrical, fire protection and<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing systems were modular in design allowing<br />

for restacking without major construction.<br />

This was very attractive to the bank. This strategy,<br />

although having higher first costs, has a<br />

two-year payback and is very sustainable. Not<br />

disposing of construction debris every time an<br />

office is changed has a great impact on the<br />

environment. To allow for partition relocation<br />

without the need for fixture relocation, 24-in.<br />

long, eight-in. wide recessed fluorescent <strong>light</strong><br />

fixtures were spaced on the five-ft planning<br />

module. Mechanical and fire protection systems<br />

followed suit, as well.<br />

A Second Floor<br />

A second trading floor was designed with<br />

similar <strong>light</strong>ing design principles. The ceiling<br />

height was approximately 30 ft, but the ceiling<br />

design was very different from the main trading<br />

arena. Wall-mounted, semi-recessed compact<br />

fluorescent ceiling wash <strong>light</strong>s were applied to<br />

provide the room with an indirect <strong>light</strong>ing component.<br />

Ceramic metal halide down<strong>light</strong>s were<br />

integrated into the ceiling to provide a direct<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing component. The down<strong>light</strong>s were<br />

installed in slots in the ceiling to further reduce<br />

the brightness and for visual interest.<br />

This trading floor faces south and a unique<br />

shading system was provided to protect the<br />

50 www.iesna.org


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

I I D A P R O J E C T<br />

Blue fluorescent billboard fixtures illuminate the<br />

cutouts in the roof and are visible to occupants of<br />

other building and even plane passengers.<br />

occupants from extensive direct solar glare.<br />

These large motorized wall panels with a unique<br />

luminous panel can be opened or closed<br />

depending upon the day<strong>light</strong>ing condition. The<br />

combination of direct and indirect <strong>light</strong>ing created<br />

the appropriate visual environment.<br />

The other interior spaces were designed to<br />

promote comfortable breakout areas for the<br />

traders. “Mixer” stations were created for the<br />

open areas where the traders could relax, get a<br />

beverage or get their mail. These millwork stations<br />

were designed to incorporate indirect<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing to provide a spacious comfortable public<br />

area. Cutout panels in the ceiling combined<br />

with compact fluorescent down<strong>light</strong>s, decorative<br />

wall sconces and wallwashers helped create<br />

a unique atmosphere.<br />

Civic Image<br />

The project as viewed from the city creates a<br />

new and unique image for this banking institution.<br />

The open trading floor appears to look like<br />

a futuristic loading bay for aircraft. The open<br />

glazed north wall allows great sightlines into this<br />

dramatic addition to the skyline. The unique<br />

image extends to the sky, as the building is visible<br />

to incoming planes and occupants of other<br />

buildings. Blue fluorescent billboard fixtures illuminate<br />

the cutouts in the roof structure.<br />

All of the lamps specified were extremely<br />

efficient and provided exceptional color rendering<br />

properties throughout the facility. All <strong>light</strong><br />

sources used are rated for long life making this<br />

facility easy to maintain. The trading area will<br />

be group re-lamped once a year over a weekend<br />

to ease maintenance. Tungsten halogen<br />

lamps were used in few specialty areas minimizing<br />

maintenance efforts even further.<br />

Finally, the energy utilized for the project was<br />

extremely low. The overall project consumed a<br />

connected load of 1.4 watts per sq ft. The<br />

“effective” power density was reduced by an<br />

estimated 50 percent, utilizing only .7 watts<br />

per sq ft when considering the benefits of day<strong>light</strong><br />

harvesting and time-of-day scheduling.<br />

The design team was surprised when it ran the<br />

numbers. It caused the team to go back and reanalyze<br />

the design to make sure it had not<br />

overlooked anything. But it all seemed to add<br />

up on the Bank of America trading floor.<br />

About the Designer: Stephen Margulies,<br />

Member IESNA (1981), IALD, joined<br />

Cosentini Associates in 1982 and is now<br />

director of Cosentini Lighting Design. His<br />

award-winning <strong>light</strong>ing design projects<br />

include the Disney Feature Animation<br />

Building in Glendale, CA; 745 Fifth<br />

Avenue and IBM offices in New York, NY;<br />

and Two Logan Square and Bell Atlantic Headquarters in<br />

Philadelphia, PA—and now the Bank of America project in<br />

Charlotte, NC. Industry awards include the OSRAM Sylvania<br />

Energy and Environmental Design IIDA Award of Excellence;<br />

the IIDA Lumen Award; and the Guth Award of Merit. Mr.<br />

Margulies has lectured at Harvard University, the Cooper Union<br />

School of Architecture and for IESNA educational programs.<br />

December 2005 LD+A 51


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

P R O J E C T<br />

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

P R O J E C T<br />

SONIC TEMPLE<br />

The new <strong>light</strong>ing design will help<br />

bring out the temple’s detail at night,<br />

increase its visibility and help visitors<br />

and local Indonesians appreciate its<br />

magnificence.<br />

largest Buddhist temple in the world. In 2003, the first<br />

attempt at incorporating a <strong>light</strong>ing system was initiated<br />

with donations by General Electric Asia, but with little success.<br />

This design was conceived by an Indonesian <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

engineer who created equal spacing of pole <strong>light</strong>s on the<br />

perimeter of the temple’s four sides. This resulted in undifferentiated,<br />

uniform <strong>light</strong> that failed to show the detail of<br />

the Buddha statues and wall carvings.<br />

Rebirth<br />

At one time, day<strong>light</strong> was<br />

the only <strong>light</strong> that shined<br />

on the temple.<br />

PHOTOS: ROBERT DANIELS<br />

FOR MORE THAN EIGHT<br />

CENTURIES, THE BOROBUDUR<br />

TEMPLE STOOD SILENT<br />

ONCE THE SUN SET.<br />

THANKS TO AN UPDATED,<br />

CAMOUFLAGED LIGHTING<br />

SYSTEM,THIS ANCIENT<br />

INDONESIAN TREASURE NOW<br />

HAS A TRUE NIGHT LIFE<br />

In order to see the Borobudur Temple in person, timing<br />

was always an issue. Whether it was how much<br />

time was spent traveling to its location (Yogykarta,<br />

Indonesia) or the fact that viewing the 1200-year old<br />

temple could only be done during the day, for nearly<br />

eight centuries, these two concerns plagued both worshipers<br />

and visitors. Now, let’s fast forward to present<br />

times. Thanks to modern luxuries like air travel and an<br />

updated <strong>light</strong>ing installation, visitors have the opportunity<br />

to see the temple, day or night.<br />

The temple stands at 113 ft tall and spans 163,000 sq ft,<br />

making it the largest monument in Southeast Asia and the<br />

Two years after that attempt, Brilliant Lighting Design,<br />

Miami, FL, was assigned to redesign the <strong>light</strong>ing. The<br />

main stipulation by Borobudur Park officials was the fixtures<br />

had to be mounted on poles, hidden from daytime<br />

view by trees. Lighting designer Robert Daniels analyzed<br />

the original <strong>light</strong>ing plan to determine which fixtures<br />

were satisfactory, which could be reused elsewhere and<br />

which would not be used. Changes included the addition<br />

of four 80 ft <strong>light</strong> poles at each of the temple’s four corners<br />

to shine a bright white <strong>light</strong> on the highest level of<br />

the monument, as well as incorporating 48 additional<br />

fixtures and lamps and repositioning current <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

poles. General Electric Indonesia provided engineering<br />

support, field supervision, as well as paying for the cost<br />

of new poles, footings, wire and fixtures.<br />

Dipping Into The Past<br />

The lava rock structure consists of seven levels that correspond<br />

to the seven steps to en<strong>light</strong>enment in Buddhist<br />

tradition. The first level carvings (at ground level) portray<br />

mankind at its lowest spiritual existence. There are five<br />

levels above the ground level that have detailed carvings<br />

of stories about Buddha and the history of the Buddhist<br />

52 www.iesna.org<br />

April December 2005 2005 LD+A LD+A 53


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P R. O. J . E C. T . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

The upper level with the Buddha and stupas would be illuminated to 350 to 400 lux, approximately eight times brighter than the lower walls.<br />

civilization in Java. The highest level is split into four sublevels<br />

where there are 72 bell-shaped stupas located in<br />

four concentric rings.<br />

With all of the walls containing carvings and Buddha<br />

statues it became apparent that the temple needed a special<br />

kind of <strong>light</strong>ing. To create a three-dimensional shape,<br />

the <strong>light</strong> would need to come at 45 deg angles and not<br />

The main stipulation for any<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing design was the fixtures<br />

had to be mounted on poles,<br />

hidden from day<strong>light</strong> view by trees<br />

straight on. After studying pictures of the temple, it was<br />

determined that angular key <strong>light</strong> would best bring out<br />

the vertical lines of the wall carvings and the protruding<br />

steps on each of the sides.<br />

To best achieve the angles of <strong>light</strong> near the middle<br />

stairway, the fixtures were located on the opposite side of<br />

the center pathway, so the <strong>light</strong> crossed sideways over<br />

the center path in a cross-fire pattern. Each cross-fire<br />

pole was located approximately 28-32 ft from the center<br />

walk. There are a total of eight cross-fire poles illuminating<br />

the four slanting pyramidal faces.<br />

The biggest problem was the distance from the pyramid<br />

face. The flat, bare apron varied in the distance from the<br />

tree line to the temple. Borobudur is a symmetrical structure<br />

with asymmetrical pole locations, so if the <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

output from each was equal then the effective illumination<br />

on the temple would be unequal. To compensate for this,<br />

four, 400-W MH fixtures on the close cross-fire poles (east<br />

and west sides) six, 400-W on the north side and eight,<br />

400-W on the south side were part of the design.<br />

The PF400 fixture was selected to do most of the crossfire<br />

work. The 3x2 beam optic pushed a soft spot of <strong>light</strong><br />

onto the walls of the pyramid 80 to 120 ft away without<br />

making hot spots. For the longer distance positions on<br />

the far corners of the south and north sides, two 400-W<br />

1x1 stadium <strong>light</strong>s were used on each of the cross-fire<br />

poles. The fixture height on the cross-fire poles was set at<br />

12 meters above the apron level to get all the cross-fire<br />

fixtures above a horizontal ledger line at the second level.<br />

However, each pole length had to be adjusted to the varying<br />

height of the footing below the apron grade. The<br />

result of the <strong>light</strong>ing was not only vertical shadowing of<br />

the wall carvings from the cross-fire technique, but a horizontal<br />

shadow line accenting the second level as the fixtures<br />

created down<strong>light</strong>ing over the ledge.<br />

The fill <strong>light</strong> used to cut the shadows from black to gray<br />

was accomplished by reusing the existing 1000-W quartz<br />

fixtures that had previously been installed. The quartz fixtures<br />

were located near the corners and aimed back<br />

54 www.iesna.org


. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . P R. O. J . E C. T. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

toward the center walkways. The quartz fixtures were all<br />

positioned at the edge of the apron. In total there were<br />

eight, 2000-W fixtures for top <strong>light</strong>ing, 44, 400-W cross fire<br />

fixtures, eight, 1000-W quartz fill fixtures and one, 250-W<br />

deluxe HPS on the lowest level.<br />

Three Colors<br />

The lamp selection was based on using three colors.<br />

The upper <strong>light</strong> on the tall poles were equipped with<br />

white metal halide (5500K) to signify purity. The middle<br />

five levels from the cross-fire poles have ceramic metal<br />

halide (3000K) to bathe the carvings and buddhas with<br />

halogen-like color. The existing quartz <strong>light</strong>s were close<br />

enough in kelvin temperature (2800K) to blend with the<br />

metal halide lamps. The exposed corner of the lowest<br />

level received single deluxe sodium in a deep red-yellow<br />

(2200K) to signify an earthier appearance.<br />

Light level tests were conducted on the stone and<br />

carvings. It was found that 45 to 70 lux of <strong>light</strong> on the<br />

facing produced the most favorable illumination for the<br />

key <strong>light</strong>. The fill was found to be best at five to eight<br />

lux or roughly 10:1 of key <strong>light</strong> to fill. The upper level<br />

with the Buddha and stupas would be illuminated to<br />

350 to 400 lux, approximately eight times brighter<br />

than the lower walls.<br />

Custom beam control louvers were added to all the fixtures.<br />

Concentric ring louvers were placed on the 20 in.<br />

diameter quartz heads, which limited the <strong>light</strong> to 40 deg.<br />

Egg crate louvers were placed on the PF400 to narrow the<br />

beams to a maximum of 25 deg. The PSFA fixtures<br />

received egg crate louvers to control <strong>light</strong> to 18 deg. The<br />

narrow spot 2000-W metal halide fixtures (on the corner<br />

poles) had a center beam of less than five deg with beam<br />

control allowing a maximum of 10 deg out. This beam control<br />

not only made the cross-fire <strong>light</strong>ing possible, but it also<br />

allowed for the precise aiming and illumination of the main<br />

center stupa (on the top) to be a totally different and separate<br />

color from the side faces from a distance of 150 ft.<br />

In Good Company<br />

During its long history, the Buddha statues on top level<br />

had only been seen by a select few sultans and priests<br />

during full moon nights. For two nights in August 2005,<br />

Daniels was given special permission to go up on the top<br />

level to photograph the Buddha statues and stupas. After<br />

those two nights, the 2000-W fixtures were aimed further<br />

up on the main center stupa to keep all the white<br />

<strong>light</strong> off the side faces.<br />

About the Designer: Robert Daniels, IALD,<br />

Member IESNA (1996), has been a <strong>light</strong>ing designer<br />

for more than 10 years in Miami, FL, serving the<br />

Southeast U.S., Latin America and Asia. Design<br />

awards include the GE Edison Award, IIDA Paul<br />

Waterbury Award of Excellence and the IIDA Award<br />

of Merit. Mr. Daniels is past chairman of the IESNA<br />

Building Façade, Bridge and Monument Lighting<br />

Committee. He also served on the IENSA Security Lighting Committee.<br />

The fill <strong>light</strong> used to cut the shadows from<br />

black to gray was created by reusing the<br />

existing 1000-W quartz fixtures that had<br />

previously been installed.<br />

April December 2005 2005 LD+A LD+A 55


IMAGE: COURTESY OF CHARLES EHRLICH<br />

C E N T U R Y S E R I E S : P I O N E E R S<br />

Computers and Lighting<br />

After exponential growth in the 1980s and ’90s, has development of<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing design software reached a lull<br />

By Emlyn Altman<br />

Designers and researchers have<br />

been calculating the effects of<br />

<strong>light</strong> for centuries—well<br />

before the use of computer technology.<br />

Many of the formulae and concepts<br />

used by <strong>light</strong>ing design software have<br />

been around since the late 1800s; but<br />

it has only been within the past four<br />

decades (and particularly the ’80s and<br />

’90s) that exponential growth in computer-related<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing design developments<br />

has occurred.<br />

Prior to the advent of computer<br />

aided design, one research study provided<br />

a major impact on <strong>light</strong>ing design<br />

calculations and foreshadowed a capability<br />

of current <strong>light</strong>ing design software.<br />

In 1945, Dr. Perry Moon and<br />

Prof. Domina Spencer submitted a<br />

paper to the IESNA that presented an<br />

“Interflection” method of calculating<br />

<strong>light</strong> for illuminating engineers to predict<br />

brightness and brightness ratios in<br />

interior spaces. Prior to this study,<br />

methods of predicting surface illumination—taking<br />

into account reflected<br />

<strong>light</strong>—were unavailable to <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

designers. Using an integration formula<br />

which considered inter-reflected <strong>light</strong><br />

in rooms of any shape, they calculated<br />

five different <strong>light</strong>ing conditions—indirect,<br />

direct, <strong>light</strong> troughs, diffusing<br />

globes and semi-direct illumination—<br />

and used the results to simulate “synthetic<br />

image” perspective views created<br />

from pieces of cut-out Munsell<br />

paper ironed together, each color corresponding<br />

to a specific reflectance<br />

value (Figure 1 andTable 1).<br />

This research led the way in establishing<br />

a 3-to-1 line-of-sight criterion<br />

for illuminating interior spaces used<br />

December 2005 LD+A 57


T A B L E 1<br />

Figure 1<br />

today. According to their concluding<br />

remarks, “The brightness distribution<br />

is of great importance in modern <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

design and thus a method for its<br />

predetermination is desirable for the<br />

illuminating engineer of the future.”<br />

This was realized nearly four decades<br />

later when the same “synthetic image”<br />

rendering capabilities became available<br />

in <strong>light</strong>ing design software.<br />

Development of Lighting<br />

Design Software<br />

Early software applications for<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing calculations were not readily<br />

available to the public but were created<br />

as a result of in-house needs.This<br />

was due to the fact that most companies<br />

could not afford in-house computers.<br />

Instead companies relied upon<br />

time-share systems where a user<br />

could pay for computational time and<br />

disk storage from computers owned<br />

and maintained by outside sources.<br />

In the late ’60s and early ’70s, users<br />

of time-share systems would<br />

upload/download processes and data<br />

into a central queue over phone lines<br />

using a Teletype machine and punch<br />

tapes (Figure 2). Charges for using a<br />

time-share system depended on the<br />

amount of processing time needed to<br />

achieve the results,the amount of disk<br />

storage rented (large capacities costing<br />

over $1000/month), and the time<br />

of day and the duration that the connection<br />

took place (peak and nonpeak<br />

rates ranged from around one<br />

cent to 25 cents per second or<br />

approximately $36-$900 per hour).<br />

As a result of the high cost to use the<br />

system, designers needed to determine<br />

which applications were necessary<br />

to warrant the use of the computer<br />

calculations and which should<br />

be done manually.<br />

According to Bill Brackett of<br />

Independent Testing Laboratories<br />

(ITL), a typical <strong>light</strong>ing calculation<br />

process over the time-share system<br />

entailed the following steps:<br />

1. Prepare the input file off-line by<br />

typing at a keyboard with the tape<br />

punch turned on.<br />

2. Dial the computer and logging in.<br />

3. Open a “new” file and turning on<br />

the paper tape reader.<br />

4. Save the file when the tape reading<br />

was finished.<br />

5. Run the calculation program<br />

6. List the output file to the user’s<br />

terminal.<br />

7.If desired,delete the input/output<br />

files from the host’s storage.<br />

8. Log off.<br />

Photometric testing laboratories<br />

became interested in <strong>light</strong>ing calculations<br />

as an additional courtesy service<br />

offered to customers.Since they were<br />

already providing CU values for luminaires,<br />

it was a “simple” step to take<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing calculation to the next level by<br />

offering footcandle calculations. In<br />

1968, a prominent lamp manufacturer<br />

spent nearly $15,000 for a point-bypoint<br />

software application called<br />

“LIGHT.” This software enabled the<br />

user to calculate a maximum grid of<br />

100 points at approximately five cents<br />

per luminaire for a full grid of points.<br />

A football field consisting of 96 points<br />

and 50 flood<strong>light</strong>s would have cost<br />

about $2.50. Any project requiring<br />

more than 100 points to complete<br />

the calculations was required to be<br />

divided into smaller computable<br />

pieces.<br />

At the same time “LIGHT” was<br />

being used, David DiLaura developed<br />

“Lumen 1” as a program to help engineers<br />

predict the results of their <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

design through point-by-point calculations<br />

of a complete area. As with<br />

other applications, “Lumen 1”<br />

required the use of a time-share system<br />

to run the program. This software<br />

was not restricted by the quantity<br />

of calculation points but the memory<br />

capacity of the computers. Data<br />

input to the central computer over<br />

the Teletype system included the<br />

room’s dimensions, reflectances, locations<br />

of windows and locations of<br />

luminaires using X and Y Cartesian<br />

coordinate values. Photometric values<br />

of the luminaires were also used, but<br />

without the establishment of IES photometric<br />

files at that time, each value<br />

58 www.iesna.org


PHOTO: COURTESY OF HARVARD UNIVERSITY ARCHIVES, CALL # UAV 362.7295.8P, BOX 3.<br />

Figure 2<br />

LIGHTS,<br />

LAMPS AND SOFTWARE<br />

Note: Bolded items are dates specific to<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing design software. Blue items are specific<br />

to lamp technologies. Plain text are key<br />

developments in general for the <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

industry.<br />

1604 Johannes Kepler published first fundamental<br />

concepts of photometry<br />

1634 First published reference to the<br />

inverse square law<br />

1669 Discovery of phosphorus<br />

1783 Introduction of Argand Lamp<br />

1792 Introduction of gas <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

1809 First electric arc (carbon arc) <strong>light</strong><br />

along the horizontal and vertical<br />

angles of the luminaire had to be input<br />

separately. If a value was input incorrectly,<br />

there was no checking system<br />

to indicate an error had been made.<br />

The designer relied upon his own<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing experience to determine if<br />

the results appeared accurate or not.<br />

Over the next three years, DiLaura<br />

further developed the program to<br />

predict a <strong>light</strong>ing design taking into<br />

account interreflected <strong>light</strong> of an<br />

empty room. In 1970, DiLaura joined<br />

Smith, Hinchman & Grylls (currently<br />

SmithGroup) and expanded his rudimentary<br />

program to calculate footcandle<br />

levels, day<strong>light</strong>ing, disability/discomfort<br />

glare and the Visual Comfort<br />

Probability (VCP).This version became<br />

“Lumen 2.” James Benya, one of the<br />

first users at SmithGroup, helped<br />

develop a statistical analysis preprocessor<br />

for the program to make<br />

sure all the variables were there and<br />

made sense.Benya explained that even<br />

though using the software over the<br />

time-sharing system wasn’t expedient,<br />

he did not find it frustrating.“I always<br />

considered it between a gift [to me]<br />

and genius [that the software was<br />

developed]. DiLaura took a fledgling<br />

concept and invented the mathematics<br />

to take <strong>light</strong>ing calculations to the<br />

next step.” In 1980, DiLaura moved to<br />

Boulder, CO, and founded Lighting<br />

Technologies with David Kambich. In<br />

1981, Lighting Technologies presented<br />

“Lumen 3” to the public and made it<br />

available through Computer Sharing<br />

Services (CSS)—a nationwide timesharing<br />

system company headquartered<br />

in Denver.<br />

PCs Emerge<br />

In 1982, IBM produced the first<br />

“personal” computer called the<br />

microcomputer—similar to the PCs<br />

of today. Lighting Technologies decided<br />

to take a chance and gamble that engineers<br />

and companies would buy their<br />

own microcomputers instead of continuing<br />

with the time-share system. In<br />

1983, the company released “Lumen<br />

Micro” version 1.0—the name change<br />

due to the recent development of the<br />

microcomputer. This version utilized<br />

the computer screen instead of teletype<br />

tape printouts but the data was<br />

entirely character-based. It wasn’t until<br />

1985 that it developed the first graphical<br />

output for <strong>light</strong>ing calculation<br />

results—but this output was not generated<br />

on the screen. It was a shaded<br />

view produced on a dot matrix printer<br />

(Figure 3)—similar to the “synthetic<br />

images” created by Moon and<br />

Spencer four decades earlier.<br />

Around this time, others saw the<br />

opportunity to create <strong>light</strong>ing design<br />

software applications. When Holophane<br />

moved its facilities, Todd<br />

Saemisch and David Speer stayed in<br />

1814 First general use of gas street <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

1826 Introduction of Lime<strong>light</strong><br />

1853 Introduction of kerosene lamp<br />

c. 1856 Introduction of first theatrical follow-spot<br />

1865 Introduction of vacuum <strong>light</strong> bulb<br />

1879 Thomas Edison invented the carbonize<br />

cotton filament lamp<br />

1880 Introduction of (Selenium) Photocell<br />

1883 Dr. Leonhard Weber invents the first<br />

photometer<br />

1894 Discovery of Argon<br />

1989 Discoveries of Neon and Xenon<br />

1901 Introduction of High Intensity discharge<br />

(HID) and Mercury Vapor lamps<br />

1905 First metal filament lamp<br />

1906 IESNA formed<br />

1907 - Introduction of tungsten filament lamp<br />

c. 1910 - Introduction of resistance dimmer<br />

1913 Introduction of first gas-filled lamp<br />

December 2005 LD+A 59


c. 1920 First Fresnel lens spot<strong>light</strong><br />

1926 Development of first radiant flux<br />

transfer equation (radiosity)<br />

1932 Introduction of Low Pressure Sodium<br />

(LPS) lamps<br />

1937 Introduction of Fluorescent lamp<br />

c. 1940 Introduction of PAR lamp<br />

1946 Moon and Spencer published<br />

“Lighting Design by the<br />

Interflection Method.” First “synthetic<br />

photographs” of calculated<br />

<strong>light</strong> in a room<br />

1955 Introduction of modern fiber optics and<br />

dichroic lamps<br />

1959 First Computer-Aided Drawing<br />

System (developed at General<br />

Motors Research Laboratory and<br />

IBM)<br />

1960 Laser <strong>light</strong> perfected and first hologram<br />

created<br />

Introduction of Quartz Halogen and<br />

Metal Halide lamps<br />

1963 John Landsdown introduced CAD<br />

as a tool for architectural planning<br />

1965 Introduction of LED’s and High Pressure<br />

Sodium (HPS) lamps<br />

1966 First “Computers in Design and<br />

Communication” Conference<br />

held<br />

1968 Development of LIGHT - point-bypoint<br />

software (In-house software)<br />

1969 First commercial CAD wireframe<br />

graphics program available to the<br />

public<br />

1973 Development of Lumen 1 <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

design software (In-house software)<br />

1982 Autodesk releases AutoCAD v. 1.0<br />

Introduction of Lumen Micro v.<br />

1.0 (Lighting Technologies)<br />

1984 Introduction of POINT (Lighting<br />

Analysts)<br />

Figure 3<br />

Colorado to form Lighting Analysts,<br />

Inc. (LAI). In 1984, LAI released its<br />

first general point-by-point program<br />

called “POINT” followed by an isoilluminance<br />

template program called<br />

“ISOPOINT” in 1985, and an interior<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing program called “INSIGHT” in<br />

1989. This was followed by a DOS<br />

based release (AGI-DOS) in 1991<br />

and a Windows based release<br />

(AGI32) in 1999.<br />

Photo-realistic Renderings<br />

In 1989,Greg Ward of the Lawrence<br />

Berkeley National Laboratory (LBNL)<br />

released Radiance, a UNIX-based ray<br />

tracing simulation that handles specular<br />

and diffuse inter-reflections (Figure 4).<br />

In 2000, LBNL released Desktop<br />

Radiance for the Windows platform,<br />

and today this package serves as the<br />

basis for over a dozen Windows-based<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing tools. In 2002, LBNL made<br />

Radiance open source, and an active<br />

community of users, researchers and<br />

developers continues to build upon<br />

this free software base.<br />

In 1991, Stuart Feldman, Rod<br />

Recker and Filippo Tampieri discussed<br />

developing a commercial product to<br />

produce photo-realistic renderings as<br />

an alternative to physical mock-ups<br />

for designers.They wanted to create<br />

a product that would be distinguished<br />

from other visualization software.<br />

They incorporated radiosity algorithms—and<br />

later .IES photometry<br />

for real physical <strong>light</strong>ing units—to<br />

create not just “a pretty picture” but<br />

something more meaningful to<br />

designers. The original “Lightscape”<br />

application sold for $15,000 a seat<br />

and was developed on Silicon<br />

Graphics (SGI) machines. In 1996,<br />

when Microsoft developed Windows<br />

NT with OpenGL capabilities, the<br />

first version of Lightscape for personal<br />

computers emerged, selling for<br />

$3000. This Windows version<br />

appealed to more people since it was<br />

naturally easier to use than the SGIbased<br />

version. In 1997, Lightscape<br />

Technologies was acquired by<br />

Discreet which dropped the price<br />

down to $495 and, consequently,<br />

increased the user base dramatically.<br />

Future<br />

Today, GUIs and processing speeds<br />

are changing more than actual <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

calculation algorithms. According to<br />

DiLaura, “The industry is satisfied<br />

with the current capabilities of <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

design software. As such, there is<br />

no economic reason to pursue nearfield<br />

photometry software capabilities.<br />

But without the demand for<br />

near-field photometry, visualizations<br />

will not be accurate.” In essence,<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing design software research has<br />

come to a halt over the past 10 years<br />

with no major developments in <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

calculation algorithms.The limiting<br />

factor now is the photometric information<br />

input into <strong>light</strong>ing design simulations.Currently,the<br />

data in IES files<br />

is primitive; we are unable to accurately<br />

calculate the effects of a fixture<br />

when it is located close to a wall or<br />

other object.This is in part due to a<br />

60 www.iesna.org


PHOTO: COURTESY OF ROBERT A. SHAKESPEARE<br />

Figure 4<br />

1985 Introduction of ISOPOINT<br />

(Lighting Analysts)<br />

Introduction of CALC-L (Lithonia)<br />

1986 Introduction of AutoLUX<br />

(Not ITL)<br />

1987 Introduction of INSIGHT<br />

(Lighting Analysts)<br />

Introduction of SPEC-L (Lithonia)<br />

1988 Introduction of AutoFLO<br />

(Not ITL)<br />

Introduction of LUX (OxyTech)<br />

1989 Introduction of Radiance<br />

(Lawrence Berkeley National<br />

Laboratory)<br />

lack of demand from end users to<br />

push software further than their current<br />

computational capabilities.<br />

Another area to pursue is more<br />

emphasis on day<strong>light</strong>ing. This includes<br />

better estimation of sky model conditions<br />

and the capability to do real-time<br />

animated studies illustrating the effects<br />

of day<strong>light</strong> over hours/days/months<br />

instead having to calculate individual<br />

points in time. Since the effect of day<strong>light</strong>ing<br />

on architecture is not static,<br />

our ability to see its influence throughout<br />

the year should reflect these varying<br />

conditions.<br />

As a frequent software user, I see<br />

the future of <strong>light</strong>ing design software<br />

heading in the same direction as<br />

recent CAD software developments.<br />

Over the past several years, high-end<br />

CAD software provide designers with<br />

“smart object” tools enabling us to<br />

incorporate more detailed information<br />

into our documentation. Using<br />

these tools, designers create intelligent<br />

3D models and let the computer<br />

build sections and elevations based on<br />

“slices” cut at specific points in the<br />

model. This eliminates some of the<br />

coordination discrepancies which<br />

occur when a drawing is modified but<br />

corresponding referenced drawings<br />

are not updated accordingly.<br />

Current .IES files contain photometric<br />

distribution and basic luminaire<br />

data such as dimensions, manufacturer,<br />

model number, etc., but they<br />

still do not include housing dimensions<br />

or other plenum information<br />

helpful when integrating into “smart<br />

models.” This additional information<br />

aids in indicating where there may be<br />

coordination problems with other<br />

plenum objects such as HVAC ducts,<br />

sprinkler lines or structural beams.<br />

Detecting these problem areas early<br />

in the design development or construction<br />

documentation phases prevents<br />

time and money lost when<br />

issues are revealed later in the field.<br />

Lastly, watch for the expansion of<br />

3D model offerings from <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

manufacturers. With the desire to<br />

create photo-realistic representations<br />

of designs, there is a greater<br />

need to go beyond simple utilization<br />

of <strong>light</strong>ing photometry in computer<br />

models. Designers want to show the<br />

client more than the effects of the<br />

<strong>light</strong> source but what the source itself<br />

looks like. Some <strong>light</strong>ing manufacturers<br />

offer 3D luminaire model libraries<br />

to integrate into 3D visualizations but<br />

the majority do not. Since manufacturers<br />

design new <strong>products</strong> on CAD,<br />

creating libraries of these 3D<br />

objects—integrated with IES photometry—would<br />

be very useful for<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing designers.<br />

Over the past four decades, <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

design software has developed at<br />

an exponential rate—each subsequent<br />

improvement or addition to<br />

software technology offering more<br />

efficient and effective production<br />

capabilities. Manufacturers quickly<br />

implement suggestions from user<br />

feedback and new versions come out<br />

as quickly as the need for new functions<br />

emerge—usually resulting from<br />

1991 Introduction of AGI DOS<br />

1992 Development of Lightscape<br />

(Lightscape Graphics Software)<br />

Introduction of GENESIS<br />

(Canlyte)<br />

Introduction of LITESTAR 1.00<br />

(OxyTech)<br />

1994 Introduction of Sulfur Lamp<br />

1996 Introduction of Lightscape SGI<br />

Version (Lightscape Technologies)<br />

1996 Introduction of Lightscape<br />

Windows NT version (Lightscape<br />

Technologies)<br />

Introduction of Visual 1.0<br />

(Lithonia)<br />

1999 Introduction of AGI32<br />

(Lighting Analysts)<br />

2001 Lightscape integrated into 3D<br />

Studio VIZ (Discreet)<br />

2002 Introduction of WinITL<br />

(Independent Testing<br />

Laboratories)<br />

2004 Introduction of Lumen Designer<br />

(Lighting Technologies)<br />

Dates are derived from sources including but not limited<br />

to A History of Light and Lighting Edition: 2.3 (2005) by<br />

Bill Williams; “Light’s Measure: A History of Industrial<br />

Photometry to 1909” by David DiLaura, published by<br />

IESNA (2005); CG 101: A Computer Graphics Industry<br />

Reference by Terrance Masson New Riders Publishing<br />

(1999);Radiosity:A Programmer’s Perspective by Ian Ashdown.<br />

December 2005 LD+A 61


F L A S H B A C K<br />

LD+A: December 1982<br />

The year was 1982. Ronald Reagan was president and Frank<br />

LaGiusa was in his seventh year as <strong>light</strong>ing designer for the<br />

National Christmas Tree in Washington, DC, just south of the<br />

White House grounds.The article described how LaGiusa strived to<br />

create a new scheme for the tree each year;in ’81 he used 56 star-shaped ornaments<br />

to represent the 50 states and six territorial jurisdictions.<br />

new codes or procedures.The future<br />

of <strong>light</strong>ing design software is what we,<br />

the end users, require to ensure a<br />

successful <strong>light</strong>ing design process. All<br />

we have to do is ask.<br />

LD+A’s “Century Series” celebrates<br />

pioneers,achievements and developments<br />

in <strong>light</strong>ing, as IESNA approaches its centennial<br />

in January 2006.<br />

About the Author: At the<br />

Washington, DC, office of<br />

architecture/design firm<br />

ForrestPerkins, Emlyn Altman,<br />

Member IESNA (2001), exercises<br />

her dual specializations in cutting edge<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing design technology as director of<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing design and visualization. Ms.<br />

Altman is also currently serving her second<br />

term as IES Capital Section president<br />

and is the East Central Region awards<br />

chair. To send comments about this column<br />

or questions regarding the use of<br />

computers in <strong>light</strong>ing design, email her at<br />

D_D@EAVisualization.com<br />

Acknowledgments<br />

The author wishes to thank the following<br />

people whose time, knowledge<br />

and experiences shared through emails<br />

and interviews enriched the resources<br />

drawn upon for this article:Ian Ashdown,<br />

James Benya, Bill Brackett, David<br />

DiLaura,Stuart Feldman,Todd Saemisch,<br />

Dr. Domina Spencer and Greg Ward.<br />

References<br />

1. Moon, Parry and Spencer, D.E.:<br />

“The Interreflection Method of<br />

Predetermining Brightnesses and<br />

Brightness-Ratios,” <strong>Illuminating</strong><br />

<strong>Engineering</strong>, pp. 362-385. May 1946.<br />

2. DiLaura, David L., Igoe, Denis P.<br />

and Mistrick, Richard G.: “Synthetic<br />

Photography,” Lighting Design &<br />

Application, pp 24-27.August 1985.<br />

3.DiLaura,David L.:“Light’s Measure:<br />

A History of Industrial Photometry to<br />

1909,” Leukos, pp 75-149. 2005.<br />

4. Masson, Terrance: “CG 101: A<br />

Computer Graphics Industry<br />

Reference,” New Riders Publishing;<br />

1999.<br />

5. Ashdown, Ian: “Radiosity: A<br />

Programmer’s Perspective,” 1994.<br />

6. Larson, G.W. and R.A.<br />

Shakespeare, “Rendering with<br />

Radiance: the Art and Science of<br />

Lighting Visualization,” 1998.<br />

62 www.iesna.org


Annual Index • Subject<br />

Architectural Lighting<br />

Come Home To MoMA . . . . May 68<br />

New York’s Museum of Modern Art<br />

Sexton, George; George Sexton<br />

Associates, Washington, DC and<br />

Tanniguchi, Yoshio; Taniguchi<br />

Associates, Tokyo<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Halo Effect . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 28<br />

Hollywood Bowl<br />

Dachs, Joshua, Hoyes, Richard,<br />

Fisher Dachs Assoc., New York,<br />

NY and Fung, Hsin-Ming and<br />

Hodgetts, Craig, Hodgetts +<br />

Fung, Design & Architecture, Los<br />

Angeles, CA<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Lost In Transformation . . . . Jul 46<br />

Hiroshima City Naka<br />

Incineration Plant<br />

Mende, Kaoru, Lighting Designer<br />

and Taniguchi, Yoshio,<br />

Architect, Tokyo<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Spreading Its Wings . . . . . Nov 52<br />

Indianapolis Museum Of Art<br />

Stone, Charles G. II, Fisher<br />

Marantz Stone, New York, NY<br />

and Hess, Jonathan R.;<br />

Browning Day Mullins Dierdorf,<br />

Architects, Indianapolis, IN<br />

West Side Story – A Revival. .. Jul 42<br />

The Grand Stewart’s Building,<br />

Baltimore, MD<br />

Barber, Michael A., Diemer, Helen;<br />

The Lighting Practice, Philadelphia,<br />

PA and Liebel, Tom, architect, Design<br />

Collective, Inc. Baltimore, MD<br />

Bridges<br />

Finally Blue. . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 37<br />

The Vincent Thomas Bridge,<br />

San Pedro, CA<br />

Israel, Chip and Blankenheim,<br />

Julie; Lighting Design Alliance,<br />

Los Angeles, CA<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Jacksonville’s Pregame<br />

Show . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 58<br />

The Hart, The Main Street and<br />

the Fuller Warren Bridges Light<br />

up for Super Bowl 2005,<br />

Jacksonville, FL<br />

Fallin, Robert, Laffitte, David;<br />

Reynolds. Smith and Hills,<br />

Jacksonville, FL and Laughlin,<br />

Robert J. Winter Park, FL<br />

Columns<br />

Careers & Hiring . . . . . . . . Apr 20<br />

Careers & Hiring . . . . . . . . Jun 22<br />

Careers & Hiring. . . . . . . . Aug 16<br />

Careers & Hiring. . . . . . . . Sep 26<br />

Digital Dialogue . . . . . . . . Jan 12<br />

Digital Dialogue . . . . . . . . May 22<br />

Digital Dialogue . . . . . . . . . Jul 14<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 4<br />

Editor’s Note. . . . . . . . . . . Mar 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 4<br />

Editor’s Note. . . . . . . . . . . May 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 4<br />

Editor’s Note. . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 4<br />

Editor’s Note. . . . . . . . . . . Aug 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 4<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Jan 8<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Feb 10<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Mar 12<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Apr 12<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . May 12<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Jun 14<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . Jul 10<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Aug 10<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Sep 14<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Oct 10<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Nov 8<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . Dec 9<br />

Executive Vice President<br />

Reports. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 8<br />

Executive Vice Presidents<br />

Reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 10<br />

Executive Vice Presidents<br />

Reports. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 8<br />

Essay . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 20<br />

Visual Ergonomics: A Closer Look<br />

Samuelson, Christopher E.<br />

Rethinking Park Lighting . May 30<br />

Lindstrom, Carole A.<br />

Green Ideas. . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 10<br />

Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 22<br />

Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . May 20<br />

Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 18<br />

Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 22<br />

Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 14<br />

Hot Button . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 18<br />

Hot Button. . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 26<br />

Hot Button. . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 26<br />

Hot Button . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 20<br />

Lighting For Quality. . . . . . Jan 17<br />

Lighting For Quality . . . . . Mar 27<br />

Lighting For Quality . . . . . May 26<br />

Lighting For Quality . . . . . Dec 17<br />

Lighting For Security . . . . . Apr 31<br />

Lighting For Security . . . . . Jun 28<br />

Lighting For Security . . . . Aug 16<br />

Lighting For Security . . . . . Oct 16<br />

Lighting For Security. . . . . Dec 18<br />

President’s Perspective . . . Jan 7<br />

President’s Perspective . . . Apr 9<br />

President’s Perspective . . . Jul 8<br />

President’s Perspective . . . Oct 6<br />

Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . Feb 8<br />

Regional Voices . . . . . . . . Mar 11<br />

Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . Apr 10<br />

Regional Voices . . . . . . . . May 10<br />

Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . Jun 12<br />

Regional Voices . . . . . . . . Aug 8<br />

Regional Voices . . . . . . . . Sep 10<br />

Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . Oct 8<br />

Regional Voices . . . . . . . . Dec 8<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . Jan 14<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . Feb 12<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . Mar 18<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . Apr 16<br />

Research Matters. . . . . . . May 16<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . Jun 16<br />

Research Matters. . . . . . . . Jul 12<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . Aug 12<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . Sep 18<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . Oct 12<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . Nov 10<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . Dec 10<br />

Rules & Regs . . . . . . . . . . Feb 16<br />

Technology . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 14<br />

Day<strong>light</strong>ing<br />

In Pursuit of Advanced-<br />

Performance Sky<strong>light</strong>s . . . . Jul 56<br />

Cuttle, Christopher<br />

Lighting In A Sustainable<br />

Future . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 70<br />

Benya, James A.<br />

Sign of the Times . . . . . . . . Jul 36<br />

The New York Times New<br />

Headquarters, New York, NY<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Take It From The Top . . . . . Jul 40<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Design Trends<br />

Cold, Harsh Reality. . . . . . Nov 42<br />

Harlow, Grant<br />

Seeing Dollar Signs . . . . . Nov 40<br />

ROI Analysis<br />

Harlow, Grant, TIR Systems,<br />

Vancouver, BC<br />

True Colors . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 38<br />

Ashdown, Ian<br />

Directories<br />

2005 Lighting Equipment +<br />

Accessories Directory . . . . Jun 67<br />

Software Directory 2005 . . Sep 69<br />

Software Survey<br />

Education Facilities<br />

Built to Last . . . . . . . . . . Sep 64<br />

Napa Valley’s Unified School<br />

District Education Center,<br />

Orgish, David and Myer, Jan<br />

The Lighting Design Studio of<br />

O’Mahony and Myer, San<br />

Rafael, CA<br />

Developing the Mind . . . . . Jul 50<br />

M.I.N.D Institute, Sacramento, CA<br />

Ham, Tao and Blanski, Bill; HGA<br />

Architects & Engineers<br />

Minneapolis, MN<br />

Failing Fixtures are Expelled From<br />

School Retrofit . . . . . . . . . Sep 39<br />

Fairfax County Public Schools,<br />

Northern, VA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Honor Roll . . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 48<br />

Maryland Institute College of<br />

Art, Central Michigan University;<br />

ITT & Elementary Institute of<br />

Science<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Essays<br />

Bringing Humanities<br />

To Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 78<br />

Brandston, Howard M.<br />

Essay . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 20<br />

Visual Ergonomics: A Closer Look<br />

Samuelson, Christopher E.<br />

Lighting Across Cultures. . Jan 46<br />

Human Inquiry<br />

Harmon, Marcel J.<br />

History/Century Series<br />

Big-Box To Boutique . . . . . Apr 91<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Computers and Lighting. . Dec 57<br />

Altman, Emlyn<br />

Eerie Coincidences . . . . . . Mar 80<br />

Rea, Mark S.<br />

Fixtures Were His Fancy . . Oct 86<br />

December 2005 LD+A 65


Annual Index • Subject<br />

Designs of Edward F. Caldwell<br />

Rambusch, Viggo<br />

From The Shoulders<br />

of Giants . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 78<br />

Rea, Mark S.<br />

Industrial Evolution. . . . . . Jan 51<br />

Bullough, John, Paulin, Doug,<br />

Denami, Anthony J. And Mistrick,<br />

Richard<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Lighting Control: From Salt<br />

Water To Silicon . . . . . . . . May 78<br />

Maniccia, Dorene<br />

Lighting In a Sustainable<br />

Future . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 70<br />

Benya, James A.<br />

Making Light in The 20th<br />

Century. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 87<br />

DiLaura, David L.<br />

Retail Reflections . . . . . . . Apr 87<br />

Gregory, Paul; Diemer, Helen and<br />

Heenan, Sarah<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

The Sporting Life . . . . . . . Aug 75<br />

The Evolution of Sports Lighting<br />

Hunt, Patricia<br />

There From The Start . . . . Feb 59<br />

LeVere, Richard<br />

Hotels<br />

All Rolled Into One . . . . . . May 52<br />

The Spa Resort Casino<br />

Palm Springs, CA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Dark From Day One . . . . . May 49<br />

Morongo Casino,Van Nuys, CA<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

High Stakes In Exterior<br />

Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . May 56<br />

The Spa Resort Casino,<br />

Palm Springs, CA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

SeeingYour Name in Lights . Jan 25<br />

Harrah’s Resort & Casino,<br />

Laughlin, NV<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Three Easy Pieces. . . . . . . May 46<br />

Morongo Casino Resort & Spa, Van<br />

Nuys, CA<br />

Hollingsworth, Dawn, Levesque,<br />

Matt, Passamont Green and<br />

Thomas, Eileen; Visual Terrain, Van<br />

Nuys, CA<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Worth The Wait . . . . . . . . . Nov 58<br />

Park Hyatt Zurich Honetwill, Robert<br />

and Brill, Maurice; MBLD, London,<br />

U.K.<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Houses of Worship<br />

Sonic Temple Rebirth . . . . Dec 52<br />

The Borobudur Temple, Indonesia<br />

Daniels, Robert, Brilliant Lighting<br />

Design, Miami, FL<br />

IES News<br />

Obituary – Emidio “Ed”<br />

Quintiliani, 87. . . . . . . . . . Jan 18<br />

Golden Gate Chapter Offers<br />

Scholarships . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 19<br />

IESNA Launches<br />

Rio Grande Section . . . . . . Feb 22<br />

Birthday Bashes Mark<br />

IESNA’s 99th Anniversary. . . Mar 30<br />

IESNA Handbook CD Version Has<br />

Microsoft Update . . . . . . . Mar 29<br />

Obituary – Ronald L.<br />

Sitzema Jr., 51 . . . . . . . . . Mar 29<br />

Obituary – Charles H.<br />

Loch, 72 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 35<br />

Obituary – Robert Merle<br />

Dixson, 82 . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 35<br />

Public Review of IESNA<br />

Publications . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 35<br />

2005 IESNA International Illumination<br />

Design Award Entries . . . . Apr 36<br />

NCQLP Announces 2004<br />

Exam Results . . . . . . . . . . Apr 41<br />

And the Party Goes On for<br />

IESNA’s 99th Anniversary . May 30<br />

Obituary – Robert Russell<br />

Wylie, 89 . . . . . . . . . . . . . May 34<br />

Public Review for RP-8 . . May 35<br />

IESNA Centennial Conference<br />

2005 ADEX Leviton Manufacturing<br />

Company . . . . . . . . . . . . . May 35<br />

Program Announced . . . . . Jun 32<br />

Public Review of IESNA<br />

Publications . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 33<br />

Obituaries – Jack T.<br />

Cottingham, 85. . . . . . . . . Jun 33<br />

Paul L. Butler, 58 . . . . . . . Jun 33<br />

Distinguished Service<br />

Award . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 32<br />

Fellow Awards. . . . . . . . . . Sep 32<br />

Marks Award. . . . . . . . . . . Sep 31<br />

Medal Award. . . . . . . . . . . Sep 31<br />

Obituary – Peter J.<br />

Pennachio, 67. . . . . . . . . . Sep 33<br />

Presidential Awards . . . . . Sep 32<br />

Taylor Technical Award . . . Sep 31<br />

Obituary – David T.<br />

Mullen, 62. . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 23<br />

Mexico Section Takes<br />

Lighting Journey . . . . . . . . Nov 25<br />

Obituary – Frederick A.<br />

Dickey, 68 . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 25<br />

Just In Time . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 21<br />

The IESNA Research Committee<br />

Revision . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 21<br />

Industry Updates<br />

And The Emmy Goes To … Jan 24<br />

International City-People-<br />

Light Award 2004 . . . . . . . Jan 23<br />

LIGHTFAIR Day<strong>light</strong>ing Institute<br />

Courses. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 21<br />

2005 LIGHTFAIR Line-up<br />

Announced . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 21<br />

Lighting Design Scholarships<br />

Available . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 23<br />

New CD-ROM Promotes<br />

Recycling of Mercury-Containing<br />

Lamps. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 24<br />

New York Splashes Light On Its<br />

Olympic Bid. . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 24<br />

IALD Announces 2005<br />

Board of Directors. . . . . . . Feb 25<br />

Philips and Advance Transformer To<br />

Receive Funding From DOE<br />

To Support Solid-State<br />

Lighting Development. . . . Feb 25<br />

Southern California Edison<br />

Opens New Lighting Center . Feb 26<br />

Just Published . . . . . . . . . Feb 27<br />

ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 90.1<br />

Updated . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 27<br />

ESTA Creates Foundation for<br />

Entertainment Technicians. Mar 35<br />

Governor Schwarzenegger<br />

Green Lights Green Building<br />

Plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 35<br />

LFT Launches New<br />

Competition . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 35<br />

Retail Project Recognized In<br />

International Store Design<br />

Competition . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 34<br />

New York City Makes Largest<br />

Purchase of Green Power . . . Apr 47<br />

DOE and Industry Alliance Partner to<br />

Advance Solid-State<br />

Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 47<br />

Student Design Competition Uses<br />

Discover Lighting Online<br />

Program . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 49<br />

Students’ Experiment Is Out of This<br />

World. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 51<br />

Parsons Centurion Award Honors<br />

Designer Albert Hadley . . . Apr 51<br />

Lighting Products Merging With<br />

Controls, Survey Shows . . May 39<br />

LRC Distributes Guidelines<br />

for Reporting LED Life . . . May 40<br />

LRC Partners With Boeing To Develop<br />

Aircraft Lighting Solution. May 39<br />

New York Announces Partnership<br />

to Ensure Energy Efficiency<br />

in Affordable Housing . . . May 39<br />

Read All About It . . . . . . . May 40<br />

Advance Establishes<br />

Scholarships . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 38<br />

Cooper Lighting Names<br />

Ten Winners. . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 37<br />

C2C Winner Feeds Electricity to<br />

Neighbors, Uses Spinach<br />

for Power. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 41<br />

Florentine, Jacobs and Heck Win 22nd<br />

Annual GE Edison Award. . Jun 36<br />

IALD Recognizes 23 Projects<br />

Representing Eight<br />

Countries . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 39<br />

Hubbell Lighting’s New Headquarters<br />

On Schedule for 2006 . . . . Jul 31<br />

Nuckolls Fund 2005 Grant<br />

Awards Total $45,000 . . . . Jul 32<br />

Software Is Just What the Doctor<br />

Ordered . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 32<br />

Who Needs A Train Whistle Jul 32<br />

Architects Honored with<br />

Design Award . . . . . . . . . . Aug 26<br />

Demo Rooms Immerse<br />

Specifiers In Light . . . . . . Aug 27<br />

GSA Announces LC<br />

Mandate. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 27<br />

Hello My Pretty… Fixtures Aug 25<br />

Hybrid Fixture Joins LED and<br />

Incandescent Sources . . . Aug 25<br />

LRC Announces Lutron Scholarship<br />

Award Recipient . . . . . . . . Aug 26<br />

Sea Gull Lighting Announces Winners<br />

of Design Competition . . . Aug 27<br />

Shipments of Lighting Products On<br />

The Rise, NEMA Index<br />

Finds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 25<br />

Eastham Elementary Receives NEED<br />

Award For Energy<br />

Education . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 37<br />

LEDs Save Energy, Attracts Shoppers<br />

to Retail Windows. . . . . . . Sep 36<br />

LRC Survey Finds<br />

New Penn Station is Draped in Light<br />

and Reflects Its Past . . . . Sep 35<br />

Schneider Electric To<br />

Acquire Juno Lighting . . . . Sep 35<br />

Suite Stuff . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 37<br />

Acuity Brands Names Morgan<br />

as President of Lighting Group;<br />

Honeycutt to Retire . . . . . . Oct 28<br />

Call For Papers: ISCC/CIE<br />

Expert Symposium. . . . . . . Oct 28<br />

LED Screens Rush To Take<br />

The Stage . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 28<br />

NEMA Lighting Systems Index Posts<br />

Gains In 2005 . . . . . . . . . . Oct 28<br />

New Standard, Publications<br />

66 www.iesna.org


Annual Index • Subject<br />

Issued by CIE . . . . . . . . . . Oct 29<br />

New Study Reveals Opportunities,<br />

Threats In the Manufacturing<br />

Sector . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 27<br />

The Star Is Reborn . . . . . . Oct 27<br />

Call for Entries: ‘It’s Your Light’<br />

Student Design<br />

Competition . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 30<br />

Energy Design Guide Earns<br />

Award from Alliance . . . . . Nov 30<br />

Lighting for Tomorrow Names 2005<br />

Design and Technology<br />

Winners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 31<br />

LRC To Redefine National Roadway<br />

Lighting Guidelines . . . . . Nov 30<br />

The Lighting Industry Responds To<br />

Hurricane Katrina . . . . . . . Nov 29<br />

Advance University Curriculum<br />

Approved by NCQLP . . . . . Dec 26<br />

Call for Entries: GE Edison Award<br />

Competition . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 26<br />

Lighting Manufacturer Wins State<br />

Environmental Award . . . . Dec 26<br />

LRC Selected by FAA To Study Airpot<br />

Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 26<br />

New Look to New York’s<br />

Plaza Park . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 26<br />

Survey Says: LIGHTFAIR is a<br />

‘Must-Experience’ Event.. . Dec 26<br />

Three LED, SSL Joint Ventures<br />

Announced . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 26<br />

IIDA<br />

From Gray To Green . . . . . Aug 52<br />

David L. Lawrence Convention<br />

Center, Pittsburgh, PA<br />

Yancey, Keith J. and Zaferiou, Paul<br />

A. Lam Partners, Inc., Cambridge, MA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Jacksonville’s Pregame<br />

Show. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 58<br />

The Hart, The Main Street and the<br />

Fuller Warren Bridges all <strong>light</strong> for<br />

Super Bowl 2005 Jacksonville, FL<br />

Fallin, Robert, Laffitte, David;<br />

Reynolds Smith and Hills,<br />

Jacksonville, FL and Laughlin,<br />

Robert J. Winter Park, FL<br />

Profiles In Postcards . . . . Aug 48<br />

Staten Island’s September 11, 2001<br />

Memorial<br />

Stone II, Charles G. and Frary,<br />

Kevin; Fisher Marantz Stone, New<br />

York, NY<br />

Leibowitz, Julie<br />

2005 International Illumination<br />

Design Awards . . . . . . . . . Aug 33<br />

Top Recipients of the International<br />

Illumination Design Awards 2005<br />

Trading Up . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 46<br />

The Bank of America Charlotte, NC<br />

Margulies, Stephen<br />

LIGHTFAIR INTERNATIONAL<br />

LIGHTFAIR 2005 Preview. . Mar 60<br />

Emerging HID<br />

Technologies. . . . . . . . . . . Mar 73<br />

Oomen, Manuel, Cummings, John<br />

and Diemer, Helen<br />

Healing Environments . . . Mar 61<br />

Miller, Naomi and North, Leslie<br />

Landscape Lighting<br />

Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 68<br />

Lanteigne, Robert<br />

Light, Discovery, Spirit and<br />

Consequences . . . . . . . . . Mar 66<br />

Warfel, William B.<br />

Light, Sight and the Senses .. Mar 64<br />

Tiller, Dale and Houser, Kevin<br />

Material Things . . . . . . . . Mar 76<br />

Yeager, Raymond<br />

Techniques for Teaching<br />

Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 70<br />

Roush, Mark and Oberkircher, Fred<br />

LIGHTFAIR International<br />

2005 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 60<br />

New Product Showcase Winners<br />

Lighting Trespass<br />

Dark From Day One . . . . . May 49<br />

Morongo Casino,Van Nuys, CA<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Maintenance<br />

Covering All The Bases. . . Sep 61<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Monument<br />

Profiles In Postcards . . . . Aug 48<br />

Staten Island’s September 11, 2001<br />

Memorial<br />

Stone II, Charles G. and Frary,<br />

Kevin; Fisher Marantz Stone, New<br />

York, NY<br />

Leibowitz, Julie<br />

Museum/Exhibit<br />

Come Home To MoMA . . . . May 68<br />

New York’s Museum of Modern Art<br />

Sexton, George; George Sexton<br />

Associates, Washington, DC and<br />

Tanniguchi, Yoshio; Taniguchi<br />

Associates, Tokyo<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Hope Floats In Little Rock . Apr 60<br />

The William J. Clinton Presidential<br />

Center, Little Rock, AR<br />

Bettridge, Francesca, Saltzberg,<br />

Marty, Cline, Bettirige, Bernstein<br />

Lighting Design, New York, NY and<br />

Polshek, James S. and Olcott,<br />

Richard M, Polshek Partnership<br />

Architects, New York, NY<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Lighting Museums As Cultural<br />

Icons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 78<br />

Frazier, Mary Claire<br />

New Frontier . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 66<br />

The New National Museum Of The<br />

American Indian, Washington, D.C.<br />

Lien, Chou and Kim, Jung Soo,<br />

Brandston Partnership, Inc., New<br />

York, NY<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Spreading Its Wings . . . . . Nov 52<br />

Indianapolis Museum of Art,<br />

Indianapolis, IN<br />

Stone II, Charles G; Fisher Marantz<br />

Stone, New York, NY and Hess<br />

Jonathan R.; Browning Day Mullins<br />

Dierdorf Architects, Indianapolis, IN<br />

The Beacon of Fort<br />

Washington . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 46<br />

The National Track & Field Hall of<br />

Fame, Manhattan, NY<br />

Skolnick, Lee H. and Cardenas,<br />

Miguel; Lee H. Skolnic Architecture<br />

+ Design Partnership, and Leni<br />

Schwindinger, Light Projects Ltd.,<br />

New York, NY<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

The Big Red Time<br />

Machine . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 50<br />

History of the Cincinnati Reds<br />

Abernathy, Katherine C., Kilburn,<br />

Tayva and Abernathy, Christopher<br />

A.; Abernathy Lighting Design,<br />

North Providence, RI and Rainone,<br />

Jason, New York City<br />

Thinking Outside the<br />

Black Box . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 72<br />

Maryland Science Center,<br />

Baltimore, MD<br />

Burns, Rich, Bernardo, Luis; Design<br />

Collective, Baltimore, MD and<br />

Sexton, George, George Sexton<br />

Associates, Washington, D.C.<br />

What’s New In Kalamazoo . Jan 42<br />

Kalamazoo Air Zoo, Kalamazoo MI<br />

Hunter, Bill Hunter-Leet &<br />

Associates, Kalamazoo, MI<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Office Lighting<br />

Caltrans Transcendent . . . Aug 65<br />

Caltran’s District 7Headquarters,<br />

Los Angeles, CA<br />

Brogden, Teal, Libonati, Heather;<br />

Horton Lees Brogden Lighting<br />

Design, Los Angeles, CA; Scott,<br />

Ron, Ledalite Architectural<br />

Products, Langley, BC & Wypasek,<br />

Michael, Paramount Industries, Inc.<br />

Croswell, MI<br />

Double Duty . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 54<br />

Prudential Lighting Headquarters,<br />

Los Angeles, CA<br />

Fairweather, Virginia<br />

Even Illumination Brightens<br />

New Office Space . . . . . . . Mar 36<br />

Affiliated Engineers, Inc., Westlake<br />

Center Office Tower, Seattle, WA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Ferry Good Show . . . . . . . . Feb 38<br />

Ferry Building, San Francisco, CA<br />

Hawthorne, Darrell<br />

Sign of the Times . . . . . . . . Jul 36<br />

The New York Times New<br />

Headquarters, New York, NY<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Progress Report<br />

2005 Progress Report . . . . Oct 35<br />

Public Spaces<br />

Another Brick In the Wall . . Oct 65<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Beachfront Lighting Proves to be<br />

an Environmentally Safe<br />

Addition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 28<br />

The Miami Beachwalk, Miami, FL<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Bringing The Great Outdoors<br />

Inside . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 40<br />

The Atlanta Area Council Boy<br />

Scouts Of America Volunteer<br />

Service Center<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Come Sail Away With LEDs . Nov 44<br />

Canada Place, Vancouver, Canada<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Custom Made Fixtures Brighten Up<br />

Convention And Exhibit<br />

Center. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 34<br />

The Boston Convention and Exhibit<br />

Center, Boston, MA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Fed Excellent Adventure . . . . . . Dec 40<br />

FedExForum, Memphis, TN<br />

December 2005 LD+A 67


Annual Index • Subject<br />

Niemuth, Jon D.: Ellerbe Becket,<br />

Kansas City, MO and Hoppas,<br />

Barbara L.S.; Bredson &<br />

Associates, Inc., Raytown, MD<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Force Of Nature . . . . . . . . Mar 40<br />

The Miami World Trade Center Tower<br />

Deeb, Paul A.; Vox Environmental<br />

Arts, Baltimore, MD<br />

From Gray To Green . . . . . . ug 52<br />

David L. Lawrence Convention<br />

Center, Pittsburgh, PA<br />

Yancey, Keith J. and Zaferiou, Paul A.;<br />

Lam Partners Inc., Cambridge, MA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Great Wall of Chi-Town . . . Oct 62<br />

Chicago’s Millennium Park<br />

Baney, Jim, Schuler Shook,<br />

Chicago, IL<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Lost In Transformation . . . . Jul 46<br />

Hiroshima City Naka Incineration<br />

Plant<br />

Mende, Kaoru, Lighting Designer<br />

and Taniguchi, Yoshio, Architect<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Residential<br />

Living The High Life . . . . . . Jul 62<br />

Residential space in Jacksonville, FL<br />

Wilson, Larry and Mulhall, Joanna,<br />

Rink Design Partnership, Inc.,<br />

Jacksonville, FL<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Martha Says: ‘You’re Hired”Dec 27<br />

The Contestant Loft for “The<br />

Apprentice: Martha Stewart”<br />

television Show<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Room With a View . . . . . . Aug 29<br />

Residential Space in Houston, TX<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Thou Shall Understand<br />

Residential Lighting. . . . . . Jul 61<br />

Romaniello, Peter<br />

Restaurants<br />

Earth Wind Fire & Water .. May 58<br />

Park New Delhi Hotel, India<br />

Shankar, Babu and Ganti, Kiran;<br />

Integrated Lighting Design, Marina<br />

Del Rey, CA<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Food and Fiber Optics Are<br />

on the Menu . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 26<br />

Mama Ruggi’s Restaurantin<br />

Cinimark Theater, Grapevine, TX<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Fresh Ideas For All To<br />

Indulge In . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 57<br />

Taco Bell Restaurants<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Perfection Per Se . . . . . . . May 62<br />

New York’s Per Se Restaurant<br />

Kale, Ann; Ann Kale Associates,<br />

Santa Barbara, CA and Tihany,<br />

Adam D. Tihany Design, NYC<br />

Retail<br />

Big-Box To Boutique . . . . . Apr 91<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Covering All The Bases. . . Sep 61<br />

Retrofit at 400 Sports Authority<br />

Stores<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Crafty Lighting Upgrade Improves<br />

Retail Operations . . . . . . . May 43<br />

Hobby Lobby’s Craft Retail,<br />

Oklahoma City, OK<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Driven By Design . . . . . . . Sep 45<br />

The New Audi Dealerships<br />

Harwood, Ron, Stechschulte, Kelly<br />

and Crossman, Kira; <strong>Illuminating</strong><br />

Concepts, Farmington Hills, MI<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Extreme Makeovers. . . . . . Sep 56<br />

Spa & Salon Bellagio,<br />

Las Vegas, NV<br />

Barr, Vilma<br />

From Mill To Mall In One<br />

Renovation . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 28<br />

The Mill Antique Mall In<br />

Bibb City, GA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Line-Up Change . . . . . . . . Sep 63<br />

The Sports Authority’s Lighting<br />

Retrofit<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Reach For The Sky . . . . . . . Jul 66<br />

FAO Schwarz, New York, NY<br />

Gregory, Paul, Focus Lighting and<br />

Rockwell, David S., The Rockwell<br />

Group, New York, NY<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Retail Reflections . . . . . . . Apr 87<br />

Gregory, Paul, Diemer, Helen and<br />

Heenan, Sarah<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Shopping in the Shadows. .. Jun 53<br />

Gymboree’s New Janeville Store,<br />

Valley Fair, CA<br />

Edenbaum, Dan<br />

Traveling First Class. . . . . Sep 48<br />

Mercedes Benz M-class, At the<br />

NAIAS in Detroit, MI<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Updated Track Lighting is the Favored<br />

Flavor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 33<br />

Englewood Wine Merchants,<br />

Englewood, NJ<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Roadway/Street Lighting<br />

A Walk in The Park . . . . . . Mar 50<br />

Michigan’s Greenfield Village<br />

Harwood, Ron, Klemmer, Kenneth<br />

Vogel, Dennis and Schimmer, Larry;<br />

<strong>Illuminating</strong> Concepts, Ltd.,<br />

Farmington Hills, MI<br />

An LED Glows In Brooklyn . Feb 47<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Coming Soon To Broadway Feb 44<br />

Sundin, Jean M. and Peiniger,<br />

Enrique, Office of Visual<br />

Interaction, New York, NY<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Is ELMS The Answer . . . . Mar 46<br />

Burkett, Karl A.<br />

Portlanders ‘Thinking...Pink’ . Apr 84<br />

Gauger, Dan and Spitulski, Stephen<br />

Richmond After Dark. . . . . Oct 66<br />

Richmond, VA’s Downtown<br />

Streetscape<br />

Stashik, Sandra M. and Sarge,<br />

Courtney, Grenald Waldron<br />

Associates, Narberth, PA<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Street<strong>light</strong>s In The<br />

Spot<strong>light</strong> . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 83<br />

City of Portland, OR<br />

Gauger, Dan and Spitulski, Stephen<br />

Who’s On First . . . . . . . . . Apr 85<br />

Gauger, Dan and Spitulski, Stephen<br />

Roundtable<br />

Back & Forth . . . . . . . . . . Mar 55<br />

Orgish, David, Stephens, Scott,<br />

Roush, Mark and Metzler, Autumn<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Industrial Evolution. . . . . . Jan 51<br />

Bullough, John, Paulin, Doug, Denami,<br />

Anthony J. and Mistrick, Richard<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Over & Out . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 78<br />

Jim Baney, Schuler Shook, Chicago,<br />

IL, Jill Cody, Hamel, Green and<br />

Abrahamson, Milwaukee, WI; Mary<br />

Claire Frazier, Candela<br />

Architectural Lighting Consultants,<br />

Seattle, WA and Jeff Gerwing,<br />

SmithGroup, Detroit, MI<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Retail Reflections . . . . . . . Apr 87<br />

Gregory, Paul, Diemer, Helen and<br />

Heenan, Sarah<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Scanning the Spectrum<br />

Beachfront Lighting Proves to<br />

be an Environmentally Safe<br />

Addition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 28<br />

The Miami Beachwalk, Miami, FL<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Brighter Days Below As Garage Gets<br />

Decked Out. . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 38<br />

Colliers Monroe Friedlander’s Building<br />

Parking Garage, Honolulu, HI<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Brighter is Better As BrandsMart<br />

Rebrands . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 44<br />

BrandsMarts’s, Atlanta, GA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Bringing The Great Outdoors<br />

Inside . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 40<br />

The Atlanta Area Council Boy<br />

Scouts Of America Volunteer<br />

Service Center, Atlanta, GA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Chandelier Creates Stage Presence<br />

for Historic Theater . . . . . May 44<br />

The Providence Performing Arts<br />

Center, Providence, RI<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Crafty Lighting Upgrade Improves<br />

Retail Operations . . . . . . . May 32<br />

Hobby Lobby’s Craft Retail,<br />

Oklahoma City, OK<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Custom Made Fixtures Brighten Up<br />

Convention And Exhibit<br />

Center. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 34<br />

The Boston Convention and Exhibit<br />

Center, Boston, MA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Even Illumination Brightens New<br />

Office Space. . . . . . . . . . . Mar 36<br />

Affiliated Engineers, Inc., Westlake<br />

Center Office Tower, Seattle, WA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Expansion Makes for a Friendlier Pre-<br />

F<strong>light</strong> Experience . . . . . . . Oct 31<br />

The International Terminal D,<br />

Dallas/Fort Worth International<br />

Airport<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

68 www.iesna.org


Annual Index • Subject<br />

Failing Fixtures are Expelled From<br />

School Retrofit . . . . . . . . . Sep 39<br />

Fairfax County Public Schools,<br />

Northern, VA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Fifth Avenue Flurry Creates An LED<br />

Wonderland. . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 31<br />

Saks Fifth Avenue Snowflake<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Food and Fiber Optics Are on the<br />

Menu. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 26<br />

Mama Ruggi’s Restaurant in<br />

Cinimark Theater, Grapevine, TX<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Fresh Ideas For All To<br />

Indulge In . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 57<br />

Taco Bell Restaurants<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

From Mill To Mall In One<br />

Renovation . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 28<br />

The Mill Antique Mall in Bibb<br />

City, GA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Hydroelectric Sensation Breaks at<br />

Niagara Falls . . . . . . . . . . Jun 43<br />

Niagara Fallsview Casino Resort,<br />

Ontario, Canada<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

It’s All Work and All Play in LA<br />

Headquarters . . . . . . . . . . Apr 58<br />

Electronic Arts, (EA) Los Angeles<br />

Playa Vista, CA<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

LEC Technology Captures<br />

The Checkered Flag . . . . . . Jul 34<br />

Pepsi 400, Daytona Beach, FL<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Martha Says: “You’re<br />

Hired”. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 27<br />

The Contestant Loft for “The<br />

Apprentice: Martha Stewart”<br />

television Show<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Restaurant Adds Lighting To Its<br />

Overhead . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 33<br />

Market Bistro, Phoenix, AZ<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Room With a View . . . . . . Aug 29<br />

Residential Space in Houston, TX<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

See Me Now, Says Seawall. . Aug 30<br />

A Seawall in Fort Lauderdale, FL<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Seeing Your Name in<br />

Lights . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 25<br />

Harrah’s Resort & Casino<br />

Laughlin, NV<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

The Show Glows On At<br />

The Bardavon . . . . . . . . . . Oct 32<br />

The Bardavon Theater,<br />

Poughkeepsie, NY<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Updated Track Lighting is the Favored<br />

Flavor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 33<br />

Englewood Wine Merchants,<br />

Englewood, NJ<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Signage<br />

Blue and Red Get the<br />

Go-Ahead . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 69<br />

Sculpture for Outdoor Plaza of<br />

Caltran’s District 7Headquarters<br />

Los Angeles, CA<br />

Cold, Harsh Reality. . . . . . Nov 42<br />

ROI Analysis for LED Signage<br />

Harlow, Grant<br />

Fifth Avenue Flurry Creates An LED<br />

Wonderland. . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 31<br />

Saks Fifth Avenue Snowflake<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Seeing Dollar Signs . . . . . Nov 40<br />

Roi Analysis for LED Signage<br />

Harlow, Grant<br />

Sports<br />

Fed EXcellent Adventure . . . . . . Dec 40<br />

FedExForum, Memphis, TN<br />

Niemuth, Jon D.: Ellerbe Becket,<br />

Kansas City, MO and Hoppas,<br />

Barbara L.S.; Bredson &<br />

Associates, Inc.,<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Good Citizen . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan. 32<br />

Citizens Bank Park, Philadelphia, PA<br />

Cunningham, Robert F.Garman,<br />

Richard G.& Hahnlen, Brian, Ewing<br />

Cole, Philadelphia, PA<br />

San Diego To The Core . . . Dec 30<br />

Petco Park Baseball Field<br />

Ragain Martin E.; Yamada,Joy<br />

Illume/M-E Engineers, Inc., Wheat<br />

Ridge, CO And Pavek, Krystof,<br />

Luminatica, Rancho Santa Fe, CA<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

The Beacon of Fort<br />

Washington . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 46<br />

The National Track & Field Hall of<br />

Fame, Manhattan, NY<br />

Skolnick, Lee H. and Cardenas,<br />

Miguel; Lee H. Skolnic Architecture<br />

+ Design Partnership, and Leni<br />

Schwindinger, Light Projects Ltd.,<br />

New York, NY<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

Weekend Warriors to World-class<br />

Athletes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 34<br />

New University of Houston<br />

Recreation Center<br />

Lees, Stephen W. and Brandt, Lee<br />

E.; Horton lees Brogden Lighting<br />

Design, New York, NY<br />

Sustainable Design<br />

Caltrans Transcendent . . . Aug 65<br />

Caltran’s District 7Headquarters in<br />

Los Angeles, CA<br />

Brogden, Teal, Libonati, Heather,<br />

Horton Lees Brogden Lighting<br />

Design, Los Angeles, CA; Scott,<br />

Ron, Ledalite Architectural<br />

Products, Langley, BC & Wypasek,<br />

Michael, Paramount Industries,<br />

Inc., Croswell, MI<br />

Lost in Transformation . . . . Jul 46<br />

The Hiroshima City Naka<br />

Incineration Plant<br />

Mende, Kaoru, Lighting Planners<br />

Associates and Taniguchi, Yoshio,<br />

Taniguchi Associates, Tokyo, Japan<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Sign of the Times . . . . . . . . Jul 36<br />

The New York Times New<br />

Headquarters, New York, NY<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

West Side Story – A Revival .. Jul 42<br />

Grand Stewart’s Building,<br />

Baltimore, MD<br />

Barber, Michael A. and Diemer,<br />

Helen, The Lighting Practice, Inc.,<br />

Philadlephia, PA<br />

And Liebel, Tom, Design Collective,<br />

Inc., Baltimore, MD<br />

Technology<br />

Acing Emergency Lighting . Aug 71<br />

Sumner, Rob<br />

Crossing the Chasm . . . . . Nov 49<br />

White LEDs<br />

Dowling, Kevin<br />

Dirty Little Secrets. . . . . . . Oct 76<br />

Paulin, Doug<br />

Healthy Mind, Body . . . . . May 74<br />

Trively, Paul<br />

In Pursuit of Advanced<br />

Performance Sky<strong>light</strong>s . . . . Jul 56<br />

Cuttle, Christopher<br />

Industrial Intrigue: Fluorescent<br />

vs. HID . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 73<br />

Paulin, Doug<br />

Lighting Control: From Salt<br />

Water To Silicon . . . . . . . . May 78<br />

Maniccia, Dorene<br />

Test-Drive Your Lighting . . Oct 75<br />

Paulin, Doug<br />

The Cornerstone of<br />

Lighting Control . . . . . . . . Jun 56<br />

McBride, Rusty<br />

True Colors . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 38<br />

Ashdown, Ian<br />

Theater<br />

Chandelier Creates Stage Presence<br />

for Historic Theater . . . . . May 44<br />

The Providence Performing Arts<br />

Center, Providence, RI<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Halo Effect . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 28<br />

Hollywood Bowl<br />

Dachs, Joshua, Hoyes, Richard,<br />

Fisher Dachs Assoc., New York, NY<br />

and Fung, Hsin-Ming and Hodgetts,<br />

Craig, Hodgetts + Fung, Design &<br />

Architecture, Los Angeles, CA<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

The Show Glows On At<br />

The Bardavon . . . . . . . . . . Oct 32<br />

The Bardavon Theater,<br />

Poughkeepsie, NY<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

What’s New In Kalamazoo . Jan 42<br />

Kalamazoo Air Zoo, Hunter, Bill<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Transportation<br />

Brighter Days Below As Garage Gets<br />

Decked Out. . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 38<br />

Colliers Monroe Friedlander’s<br />

Building Parking Garag, Honolulu, HI<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Expansion Makes for a Friendlier Pre-<br />

F<strong>light</strong> Experience . . . . . . . Oct 31<br />

The International Terminal D,<br />

Dallas/Fort Worth International<br />

Airport<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

Take The Plane To<br />

The Train. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 33<br />

Alaska’s Bill Sheffield Railroad Depot<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

December 2005 LD+A 69


Annual Index • Author<br />

Abernathy, Katherine C.; Kilburn,<br />

Tayva; Abernathy, Christopher A. and<br />

Rainone, Jason<br />

The Big Red Time Machine. . . Sep 50<br />

Akashi, Yukio<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . . Mar 18<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . . . Jul 12<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . . Dec 10<br />

Ake, Ted<br />

Lighting For Security . . . . . . Apr 31<br />

Lighting For Security . . . . . . Jun 28<br />

Lighting For Security. . . . . . Aug 16<br />

Lighting For Security . . . . . . Oct 16<br />

Lighting For Security . . . . . . Dec 17<br />

Altman, Emlyn<br />

Computers and Lighting . . . Dec 57<br />

Digital Dialogue. . . . . . . . . . Jan 12<br />

Digital Dialogue . . . . . . . . . May 22<br />

Digital Dialogue . . . . . . . . . . Jul 14<br />

Ashdown, Ian<br />

True Colors. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 38<br />

Barber, Michael A.; Diemer, Helen and<br />

Liebel, Tom<br />

West Side Story – A Revival. . Jul 42<br />

Barr, Vilma<br />

Extreme Makeovers . . . . . . . Sep 56<br />

Benya, James A.<br />

Lighting In A Sustainable<br />

Future. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 70<br />

Bernecker, Craig<br />

President’s Perspective . . . . Jan 7<br />

President’s Perspective . . . . Apr 9<br />

Bleasby, Peter<br />

Rules & Regs. . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 16<br />

Brandston, Howard M.<br />

Bringing Humanities To<br />

Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 78<br />

Brogden, Teal; Libonati, Heather;<br />

Scott, Ron and Wypasek, Michael<br />

Blue and Red Get the<br />

Go-Ahead . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 69<br />

Caltrans Transcendent . . . . Aug 65<br />

Bullough, John D.<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . . Feb 12<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . . Jun 16<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . . Nov 10<br />

Burkett, Karl A.<br />

Is ELMS The Answer . . . . . Mar 46<br />

Burns, Rich; Bernardo, Luis and<br />

Sexton, George<br />

Thinking Outside the<br />

Black Box. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 72<br />

Clements, E. Frank<br />

Regional Voices . . . . . . . . . . Jun 12<br />

Creer, Wallace<br />

Technology . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 14<br />

Cunningham, Robert F.; Garman,<br />

Richard G. and Hahnlen, Brian<br />

Good Citizen . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 32<br />

Cuttle, Christopher<br />

In Pursuit of Advanced Performance<br />

Sky<strong>light</strong>s. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 56<br />

Daniels, Robert<br />

Sonic Temple Rebirth . . . . . Dec 52<br />

Deeb, Paul A.<br />

Force Of Nature. . . . . . . . . . Mar 40<br />

DiLaura, David<br />

Making Light in The 20th<br />

Century . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 87<br />

Dowling, Kevin<br />

Crossing the Chasm . . . . . . Nov 49<br />

Edenbaum, Dan<br />

Shopping in the Shadows . . . Jun 53<br />

Fairweather, Virginia<br />

Double Duty. . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 54<br />

Fallin, Robert, Lafitte, David and<br />

Laughlin, Robert J.<br />

Jacksonville’s Pregame<br />

Show. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 58<br />

Ferzacca, Nick<br />

Green Ideas. . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 14<br />

Figueiro, Mariana, G.<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . . Jan 14<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . . May 16<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . . Sep 18<br />

Fong, Denise<br />

Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 10<br />

Green Ideas. . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 22<br />

Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . . May 20<br />

Green Ideas . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 18<br />

Green Ideas. . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 22<br />

Frazier, Mary Claire<br />

Lighting Museums As Cultural<br />

Icons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 78<br />

Gauger, Dan and Spitulski, Stephen<br />

Portlanders ‘Thinking...<br />

Pink’ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 84<br />

Street<strong>light</strong>s In The Spot<strong>light</strong> . . Apr 83<br />

Who’s On First . . . . . . . . . . Apr 85<br />

Ham, Tao and Blanski, Bill<br />

Developing The Mind . . . . . . Jul 59<br />

Hanley, William<br />

Executive Vice President<br />

Reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 8<br />

Executive Vice Presidents<br />

Reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 10<br />

Executive Vice Presidents<br />

Reports . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 8<br />

Harlow, Grant<br />

Cold, Harsh Reality . . . . . . . Nov 42<br />

Seeing Dollar Signs. . . . . . . Nov 40<br />

Harmon, Marcel J.<br />

Lighting Across Cultures . . Jan 46<br />

Harwood, Ron; Klemmer, Kenneth;<br />

Vogel, Dennis and Schimmer, Larry<br />

A Walk in The Park . . . . . . . Mar 50<br />

Hawthorne, Darrell<br />

Ferry Good Show . . . . . . . . . Feb 38<br />

Hugh, Peter A<br />

Regional Voices . . . . . . . . . . Feb 8<br />

Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . . Sep 10<br />

Hunt, Patricia<br />

The Sporting Life. . . . . . . . . Sep 75<br />

Kale, Ann and Tihany, Adam D.<br />

Perfection Per Se . . . . . . . . May 62<br />

Kobes, John-Michael<br />

All Rolled Into One . . . . . . . May 52<br />

Another Brick In the Wall. . . Oct 65<br />

Beachfront Lighting Proves to<br />

be an Environmentally Safe<br />

Addition . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 28<br />

Brighter Days Below As Garage<br />

Gets Decked Out . . . . . . . . . Mar 38<br />

Brighter is Better As<br />

BrandsMart Rebrands . . . . . Jun 44<br />

Bringing The Great Outdoors<br />

Inside . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 40<br />

Chandelier Creates Stage Presence<br />

for Historic Theater. . . . . . . May 44<br />

Come Sail Away With LEDs . Nov 44<br />

Crafty Lighting Upgrade Improves<br />

Retail Operations . . . . . . . . May 32<br />

Custom Made Fixtures<br />

Brighten Up Convention<br />

and Exhibit Center . . . . . . . Nov 34<br />

Even Illumination Brightens<br />

New Office Space . . . . . . . . Mar 36<br />

Expansion Makes for a Friendlier<br />

Pre-F<strong>light</strong> Experience. . . . . . Oct 31<br />

Failing Fixtures Are Expelled From<br />

School Retrofit . . . . . . . . . . Sep 39<br />

FedExcellent Adventure . . . . Dec 40<br />

Fifth Avenue Flurry Creates<br />

An LED Wonderland . . . . . . . Feb 31<br />

Food and Fiber Optics Are on<br />

the Menu . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 26<br />

Fresh Ideas For All To<br />

Indulge In . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 57<br />

From Gray To Green. . . . . . . Aug 52<br />

From Mill To Mall In One<br />

Renovation . . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 28<br />

Great Wall of Chi–Town . . . . Oct 62<br />

High Stakes In Exterior<br />

Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . May 56<br />

Hope Floats In Little Rock . . Apr 60<br />

Hydroelectric Sensation<br />

Breaks at Niagara Falls. . . . Jun 43<br />

It’s All Work and All Play in<br />

L.A. Headquarters . . . . . . . . Apr 58<br />

LEC Technology Captures The<br />

Checkered Flag. . . . . . . . . . . Jul 34<br />

Living The High Life . . . . . . . Jul 62<br />

Martha Says: “You’re Hired” . . Dec 27<br />

Restaurant Adds Lighting<br />

To Its Overhead. . . . . . . . . . . Jul 33<br />

Room With a View . . . . . . . . Aug 29<br />

See Me Now, Says Seawall . Aug 30<br />

Seeing Your Name in Lights . . Jan 25<br />

Take The Plane To The Train . . Feb 33<br />

The Show Glows On At The<br />

Bardavon. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 32<br />

Updated Track Lighting is<br />

the Favored Flavor. . . . . . . . Nov 33<br />

What’s New In Kalamazoo . . Jan 42<br />

Worth The Wait . . . . . . . . . . Nov 58<br />

Kohring Craig, R.<br />

Regional Voices . . . . . . . . . . Apr 10<br />

Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . . Dec 8<br />

Lanteigne, Robert<br />

Landscape Lighting<br />

Design . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 68<br />

70 www.iesna.org


Annual Index • Author<br />

Lees, Stephen W. and Brandt, Lee E.<br />

Weekend Warriors to<br />

World-Class Athletes. . . . . . Dec 34<br />

Leibowitz, Julie<br />

Profiles In Postcards. . . . . . Aug 48<br />

LeVere, Richard<br />

There From The Start. . . . . . Feb 59<br />

Lewis, Alan Laird<br />

President’s Perspective. . . . . Jul 8<br />

President’s Perspective . . . . Oct 6<br />

Liebel, Brian<br />

Hot Button. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 18<br />

Hot Button . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 26<br />

Hot Button . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 26<br />

Hot Button. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 20<br />

Lindstrom, Carole A.<br />

Rethinking Park Lighting . . May 30<br />

Lowe, Roslyn<br />

Come Home To MoMA . . . . . May 68<br />

Driven By Design. . . . . . . . . Sep 45<br />

Earth Wind Fire & Water . . . May 58<br />

Honor Roll . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 48<br />

Industrial Evolution . . . . . . . Jan 51<br />

Lost in Transformation . . . . . Jul 46<br />

Reach For The Sky . . . . . . . . Jul 66<br />

Richmond After Dark . . . . . . Oct 66<br />

Traveling First Class . . . . . . Sep 48<br />

Maniccia, Dorene<br />

Lighting Control: From Salt Water<br />

To Silicon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . May 78<br />

Margulies, Stephen<br />

Trading Up . . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 46<br />

McBride, Rusty<br />

The Cornerstone of Lighting<br />

Control. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 56<br />

Miller, Naomi and North, Leslie<br />

Healing Environments. . . . . Mar 61<br />

Oomen, Manuel, Cummings, John and<br />

Diemer, Helen<br />

Emerging HID Technologies. Mar 73<br />

Orgish, David and Myer, Jan<br />

Built to Last . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 64<br />

O’Rourke, Conan<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . . Sep 18<br />

Padios, Scott D.<br />

Regional Voices . . . . . . . . . May 10<br />

Paulin, Doug. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .<br />

Dirty Little Secrets . . . . . . . . Oct 76<br />

Industrial Intrigue:<br />

Fluorescent VS. HID . . . . . . . Oct 73<br />

Lighting For Quality . . . . . . . Jan 17<br />

Lighting For Quality . . . . . . Mar 27<br />

Lighting For Quality . . . . . . May 26<br />

Lighting For Quality. . . . . . . Dec 17<br />

Test-Drive Your Lighting . . . Oct 75<br />

Pompeo, Paul<br />

Careers & Hiring . . . . . . . . . Apr 20<br />

Careers & Hiring . . . . . . . . . Jun 22<br />

Careers & Hiring . . . . . . . . . Aug 16<br />

Careers & Hiring . . . . . . . . . Sep 26<br />

Rambusch, Viggo<br />

Fixtures Were His Fancy. . . . Oct 86<br />

Rea, Mark S.<br />

Eerie Coincidences . . . . . . . Mar 80<br />

From The Shoulders of<br />

Giants. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 78<br />

Romaniello, Peter<br />

Regional Voices. . . . . . . . . . Mar 11<br />

Regional Voices . . . . . . . . . . Oct 8<br />

Thou Shall Understand Residential<br />

Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 61<br />

Roush, Mark and Oberkircher, Fred<br />

Techniques for Teaching<br />

Lighting . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 70<br />

Samuelson, Christopher E.<br />

Visual Ergonomics:<br />

A Closer Look . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 20<br />

Stone II, Charles G. and Hess<br />

Jonathan R.<br />

Spreading Its Wings . . . . . . Nov 52<br />

Sumner, Rob<br />

Acing Emergency Lighting . . . Aug 71<br />

Tarricone, Paul<br />

An LED Glows In Brooklyn . . Feb 47<br />

Back & Forth. . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 55<br />

Big-Box To Boutique . . . . . . Apr 91<br />

Coming Soon To Broadway . . Feb 44<br />

Covering All The Bases . . . . Sep 61<br />

Dark From Day One. . . . . . . May 49<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Feb 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Mar 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . May 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Jun 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Aug 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Sep 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 4<br />

Editor’s Note . . . . . . . . . . . . Dec 4<br />

Finally Blue . . . . . . . . . . . . . Nov 37<br />

Halo Effect. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Jan 28<br />

Line-Up Change . . . . . . . . . Sep 63<br />

New Frontier . . . . . . . . . . . . Apr 66<br />

Over & Out. . . . . . . . . . . . . . Oct 78<br />

Retail Reflections . . . . . . . . Apr 87<br />

San Diego To The Core. . . . . Dec 30<br />

Sign of the Times . . . . . . . . . Jul 36<br />

Take It From The Top. . . . . . . Jul 40<br />

The Beacon of<br />

Fort Washington . . . . . . . . . Jun 46<br />

Three Easy Pieces . . . . . . . . May 46<br />

Tiller, Dale and Houser, Kevin<br />

Light, Sight and the Senses. . . Mar. 64<br />

Tolen, Thomas<br />

Regional Voices . . . . . . . . . . . Aug. . 8<br />

Trively, Paul<br />

Healthy Mind, Body &<br />

Bottom Line . . . . . . . . . . . . May 74<br />

Van Derlofske, John<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . . Apr 16<br />

Research Matters . . . . . . . . Aug 12<br />

Warfel, William B.<br />

Light, Discovery, Spirit and<br />

Consequences. . . . . . . . . . . Mar 66<br />

Warren, William L<br />

Energy Advisor. . . . . . . . . . . Jan 8<br />

Energy Advisor. . . . . . . . . . . Feb 10<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . Mar 12<br />

Energy Advisor. . . . . . . . . . . Apr 12<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . May 12<br />

Energy Advisor. . . . . . . . . . . Jun 14<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . . Jul 10<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . Aug 10<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . Sep 14<br />

Energy Advisor. . . . . . . . . . . Oct 10<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . Nov 8<br />

Energy Advisor . . . . . . . . . . Dec 9<br />

Yeager, Raymond<br />

Material Things. . . . . . . . . . Mar 76<br />

December 2005 LD+A 71


LIGHT PRODUCTS<br />

Lutron Electronics Co., Inc.<br />

has added stainless steel wallplates<br />

to its Fassada and Claro wallplate<br />

collections to coordinate with<br />

black dimmers, switches and accessories.<br />

The stainless steel<br />

Fassada wallplates, which feature a<br />

small toggle opening, complement<br />

Lutron’s expanded line of Faedra,<br />

Qoto, Ariadni and Toggler dimmers.<br />

The stainless steel Claro<br />

wallplates, which feature a large<br />

designer opening, fit Lutron’s<br />

Skylark, Diva, Maestro and RadioRA<br />

dimmers, switches and accessories.<br />

The low-profile, two-piece wallplate<br />

features rounded edges and<br />

a “no visible screws” design, offering<br />

a clean look.<br />

www.lutron.com<br />

Mystique, a handcrafted glass<br />

piece from Austria, is available<br />

with Bruck Lighting Systems’<br />

two in. or 4 in. kiss canopy (with<br />

integral transformer) or with a<br />

uni-plug to attach to any of<br />

Bruck’s tracks systems.<br />

www.bruck<strong>light</strong>ingsystems.com<br />

The Monolith wall scone from Original<br />

Cast Lighting is available in two sizes, four<br />

unique face patterns and is useful for applications<br />

where the user is retrofitting a space or<br />

doesn’t have the room to remote mount an<br />

emergency ballast.<br />

www.theocl.com<br />

Appleton’s Mercmaster III<br />

Induction fixture that provides a<br />

cost-effective, long-term solution<br />

for hazardous and non-hazardous<br />

industrial <strong>light</strong>ing needs,and is especially<br />

effective where access for<br />

relamping is difficult, maintenance is<br />

prohibitively expensive, and reliability<br />

is absolutely essential. Even after<br />

60,000 hours of use, the luminaire<br />

should maintain 70 percent of its<br />

total <strong>light</strong> output.<br />

www.appletonelec.com<br />

Advance Transformers’ has expanded its line of sign PRO LED Sign<br />

Drivers to include a new 100-W 24-vdc model for use in a wide variety<br />

of LED <strong>light</strong>ing applications.The driver features IntelliVolt Multiple-Voltage<br />

technology, which enables its operation at any input voltage from 120 to<br />

277 volts, 50/60Hz, subsequently reducing SKU requirements,<br />

enhancing ease and accuracy of ordering, and eliminating field<br />

mis-match concerns.The drivers further carry a “CE” certification<br />

for use in applications involving European<br />

voltages (220-240-V, 50Hz), as well as UL-recognized<br />

component status and CSA listing.<br />

www.advancetransformer.com<br />

Display <strong>light</strong>ing is transformed into a beautiful art form with<br />

W.A.C. Lighting’s precision modules, a new line of upscale<br />

specification grade multiple recessed spot<strong>light</strong>s that integrate<br />

robust, architectural styling and elegance with superior function<br />

and versatility. Spot<strong>light</strong>s can be interchanged with the precise<br />

number and types of lamps needed to accomplish the task at<br />

hand, whether it is wall washing, accent, spot or perimeter <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

or any combination.<br />

www.wac<strong>light</strong>ing.com<br />

74 www.iesna.org


The FOMH-150C illuminator is the latest addition to Lighting<br />

Services Inc’s fiber optic line of <strong>products</strong>. The FOMH-150C is a<br />

metal halide fiber optic unit that utilizes the highly efficient 150-W<br />

reflectorized CDM-SA/R lamp.This 4000 hour lamp produces a crisp,<br />

white <strong>light</strong> ideal for display, architectural and case <strong>light</strong>ing where relatively<br />

high <strong>light</strong> levels are desirable.<br />

www.<strong>light</strong>ingservicesinc.com<br />

The restyled Claire wall fixture<br />

from Leucos USA elegantly<br />

drapes satin white glass over a polished<br />

chrome-plated structure, diffusing<br />

the <strong>light</strong> source to produce a<br />

smooth glow. Extending beyond the<br />

metal base, the graceful inward curvature<br />

of the glass adds depth and<br />

intrigue to the stylish piece. Claire<br />

is available in three sizes with incandescent<br />

or fluorescent lamping.<br />

www.leucos.com<br />

Leucos USA, Inc’s pulse<br />

series of hand-blown glass fixtures<br />

is an explosion of cones and<br />

leaves that curve with a graceful<br />

and dramatic presence. The fixture<br />

is available in colorless<br />

Venetian crystal, shiny black and<br />

shiny milky team, and it is available<br />

in three sizes.<br />

www.leucos.com<br />

Through a colorful, graphical<br />

interface, the LyteScene Touch<br />

Screen Master Station from<br />

Lightolier Controls can capture<br />

and simulate the control<br />

panel functions of any selected<br />

LYTEmode Network Master<br />

Station or Remote in real time.<br />

With only a few simple touches<br />

of the screen, adjustments can be<br />

made to any individual channel or<br />

“scene” presets in any room in<br />

the system.<br />

www.lolcontrols.com<br />

Advance Transformer has enhancement of its line of<br />

Centiu Instant Start Normal Light Output Electronic Ballasts<br />

with IntelliVolt to include new energy-saving low-watt models<br />

for the operation of one-four T8 fluorescent lamps. Designed<br />

to operate from one to four 32-W, 25-W, and 17-W standard<br />

T8 lamps as well as one to four 30-W, 28-W, and 25-W energy-saving<br />

T8 lamps, the ballasts are ideal for general office <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

as well as both new construction and retrofit applications.<br />

www.advancetransformer.com<br />

Fiberoptic Lighting’s, fiber optic Starfield brings the night sky indoors for<br />

themed environments, tradeshow and special events. Each panel has a Starfield<br />

with galactic effects and an additional enhancement of fireworks. The fireworks<br />

are on separate circuits and can be turned on or off. Pictured is an image, which<br />

is a composite of six digital images taken of one of the panels as it went through<br />

its celestial program of <strong>light</strong>, color and movement.<br />

www.flisign.com<br />

April 75 December 2005 2005 LD+A LD+A www.iesna.org<br />

75


LIGHT PRODUCTS<br />

Globe Electric Company’s<br />

Ultra Mini soft white, compact fluorescent<br />

lamp (CFL) is Energy Star<br />

Approved and warranted by Globe<br />

to last up to five years based on normal<br />

use (3-4 hours per day). The<br />

small size and the big energy savings<br />

make the lamp the ideal energy saving<br />

replacement for the standard<br />

incandescent bulb for indoor or outdoor<br />

use.The 9-W CFL can replace<br />

a 40-W standard household lamp<br />

and the 13-W replaces the 60-W.<br />

www.globe-electric.com<br />

Fiberoptic Lighting’s En<strong>light</strong>ened<br />

Labyrinth uses the Chartres<br />

model, the lunations on the edges of<br />

the En<strong>light</strong>ened Labyrinth are lit and<br />

the center area is also lit with fiber<br />

optic <strong>light</strong>ing. The center changes<br />

colors slowly while the lunations<br />

flicker as if they are candles. The<br />

En<strong>light</strong>ened Labyrinth is ideally suited<br />

as a meditative and healing tool in<br />

hospital/healthcare and church applications<br />

and is also perfect for garden<br />

centers, florists, themed environments,<br />

retailers and restaurants.<br />

www.flisign.com<br />

Besa Lighting’s Adjustable 3-<br />

Light Bars in its “A Series” of lowvoltage<br />

mini pendants are<br />

designed with adjustable pull-up<br />

and pull-down mechanisms to<br />

adjust the pendant heights according<br />

to the end-users’ <strong>light</strong>ing<br />

needs. The series includes 50-W<br />

halogen lamps and 60-W class two<br />

electronic transformers. More<br />

than 50 different color and style<br />

options are offered in the series.<br />

www.besa<strong>light</strong>ing.com<br />

Heatron’s new six-page<br />

brochure details their extensive<br />

design,assembly and systems expertise<br />

in LED <strong>light</strong> engine technology.<br />

Heatron’s design and integration<br />

capabilities allow them to balance<br />

the critical disciplines required —<br />

including power sources or drivers,<br />

emitters, thermal management, secondary<br />

optics, housings, or enclosures<br />

— to create the optimal solution<br />

for your LED application.<br />

www.heatron.com<br />

Leviton's line of locking plugs for<br />

original equipment manufacturers<br />

(OEMs) offers high quality 2-pole,<br />

3-wire grounding devices for equipment<br />

requiring a National Electrical<br />

Manufacturers Association (NEMA)<br />

locking plug configuration. Built to<br />

the highest industry standards and<br />

providing superior performance in<br />

demanding settings, the locking<br />

plugs offer unparalleled reliability for<br />

a diverse range of applications,<br />

including connections for pendant<br />

<strong>light</strong>ing fixtures, commercial food<br />

processing equipment, and commercial<br />

and industrial cleaning<br />

equipment.<br />

www.leviton.com<br />

Advanced Lighting Technologies’<br />

Microsun combines metal<br />

halide technology with beautiful and<br />

unique table and floor lamp designs<br />

that use metal halide technology to<br />

provide adequate <strong>light</strong> levels for<br />

aging eyes. Microsun lamps feature a<br />

metal halide lamp that uses only 68<br />

watts of energy while giving off the<br />

same amount of <strong>light</strong> as five 75-W<br />

incandescent or one 300-W halogen<br />

lamp; and because the system uses<br />

less wattage, there is less heat generated,<br />

making it more comfortable<br />

to sit next to one of these lamps.<br />

www.venture<strong>light</strong>ing.com<br />

76 www.iesna.org


BEGA’s introduces a square reflector luminaire with a totally<br />

adjustable indirect optical system. The square top reflector and<br />

the luminaire are fixed to each other and adjust together from<br />

zero deg to 65 deg to direct <strong>light</strong> where it is needed.Two gasketed<br />

clamps at the top of the fitter can be loosened to allow adjustment<br />

of the entire luminaire reflector assembly.This luminaire is<br />

ideal for parking areas, roadways and pedestrian scale landscape<br />

and is available in five standard finishes.<br />

www.bega-us.com<br />

Hoffman Products’ Speede Connectors<br />

line now includes a clear color coded style.<br />

These new clear connectors are UL/C for solid<br />

copper wire. A quick, fast and efficient push in<br />

wire concept for splicing significantly reduces<br />

installation cost. Made of 6/6 nylon, and rated<br />

for 600 volts, they are designed to handle wire<br />

sizes 12-22 AWG.<br />

www.hoffman<strong>products</strong>.com<br />

Kirlin’s SofTex square and rectangular<br />

trims complement the<br />

finest of architectural spaces such as<br />

restaurants, residences, entertainment<br />

venues and high-end public and<br />

office spaces. All rectangles and wall<br />

washes come standard with tempered<br />

Microlux lenses mounted<br />

above the lower trim. Type IC, Air<br />

Tight and many shallow plenum luminaires are available along with several optional colors<br />

and lenses and corrugated aluminum trims.<br />

www.kirlin<strong>light</strong>ing.com<br />

Gigahertz-Optik’s hand-held meter for color<br />

and illuminance/ luminance measurements of <strong>light</strong><br />

sources in the field or lab now includes a Delta-<br />

UV function.The ergonomically designed and easy<br />

to use HCT-99-D measures color chromaticity<br />

coordinates x,y and u’,v’, lux and/or candela per<br />

square meter, correlated color temperature as<br />

well as then new Delta-UV function which shows<br />

the deviation of the measured x, y color coordinates<br />

from the black body radiator locus.<br />

www.gigahertz-optik.com<br />

December 2005 LD+A 77

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!