06.05.2015 Views

mr. justice tassaduq hussain jillani mr. justice nasir-ul-mulk mr ...

mr. justice tassaduq hussain jillani mr. justice nasir-ul-mulk mr ...

mr. justice tassaduq hussain jillani mr. justice nasir-ul-mulk mr ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

CIVIL APPEAL NOs. 39/2010, 1150/2010, 1162/2010, 142-K/2009, 177-<br />

K/2010, 178-K/2010, 228-K/2010, 57-K/2011, 63-K/2011, 65-K/2011, 66-<br />

K/2011, 83-K/2011, 91-K/2011, 135-K/2011, 136-K/2011, 137-K/2011, 188-<br />

K/2011, 232-K/2011, 75-K/2012 AND 82-K/2012<br />

26<br />

Natural Gas Commission, the Life Insurance<br />

Corporation and Industrial Finance corporation<br />

are all required by the statute to frame<br />

reg<strong>ul</strong>ations, inter alia, for the purpose of the<br />

duties and conduct and conditions of service of<br />

officers and other employees. These reg<strong>ul</strong>ations<br />

impose obligation on the statutory authorities.<br />

The statutory authorities cannot deviate from the<br />

conditions of service. Any deviation will be<br />

enforced by legal sanction of declaration by<br />

Courts to invalidate actions in violation of r<strong>ul</strong>es<br />

and reg<strong>ul</strong>ations under statute is to ensure reg<strong>ul</strong>ar<br />

conduct with a distinctive attitude to that conduct<br />

as a standard. The reg<strong>ul</strong>ations in the cases under<br />

consideration give the employees a statutory<br />

status and impose restriction on the employer<br />

and the employee with no option. to vary the<br />

conditions. An ordinary individual in a case of<br />

master and servant contractual relationship<br />

enforces breach of contractual terms. The remedy<br />

in such contractual .relationship of master and<br />

servant is damages because personal service is<br />

not capable of enforcement. In cases of statutory<br />

bodies, there is no personal element whatsoever<br />

because of the impersonal character of statutory<br />

bodies. In the case of statutory bodies it has<br />

been' said that the element of public employment<br />

or service and the support of statute require<br />

observance of r<strong>ul</strong>es and reg<strong>ul</strong>ations. Failure to<br />

observe requirements by statutory bodies is<br />

enforced by Courts by declaring dismissal in<br />

violation of r<strong>ul</strong>es and reg<strong>ul</strong>ations to be valid. This<br />

Court has repeatedly observed that whenever a<br />

man's rights are affected by decision taken under<br />

statutory powers, the Court wo<strong>ul</strong>d presume the<br />

existence of a duty to observe the r<strong>ul</strong>es of natural<br />

<strong>justice</strong> and compliance with r<strong>ul</strong>es and reg<strong>ul</strong>ations<br />

imposed by statute. "<br />

24. Somewhat similar view was taken by this Court in The<br />

Evacuee Trust Property Board and another v. Muhammad Nawaz<br />

(1983 SCMR 1275) and the judgment of this Court in C.P.S.L.A.<br />

No. 645/74 titled as Chairman Evacuee Trust Property Board<br />

Lahore, etc., v. Noor Elahi and C.P.L.S.A. No. 646/74, titled as<br />

Chairman Evacuee Trust Property Board Lahore, etc v.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!