a four-fold rise - Center for Food Safety
a four-fold rise - Center for Food Safety
a four-fold rise - Center for Food Safety
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>Center</strong> <strong>for</strong> <strong>Food</strong> <strong>Safety</strong> – Science Comments – FG72 Soybean <br />
54 <br />
same field in a two-‐year period” (DEA at 58). However, only one application of isoxaflutole is <br />
allowed per year, so even if isoxaflutole was applied year after year to the same acreage, this <br />
schedule would not violate the stewardship suggestion of “no more than two applications….in <br />
a two-‐year period”. <br />
Bernards et al. (2012), whose call <strong>for</strong> “mandatory stewardship practices” encompassed <br />
“soybean, cotton and corn resistant to 2,4-‐D and dicamba”, applies equally to FG72 soybean. <br />
Furthermore, the demand <strong>for</strong> “mandatory” practices is an implicit acknowledgement of the <br />
failure of voluntary programs such as Bayer CropScience’s. APHIS fails to provide any critical <br />
assessment of Bayer CropScience’s stewardship plan. <br />
j. Spread of weed resistance and tragedy of the commons <br />
Weeds evolve resistance through strong selection pressure from frequent and late application <br />
as well as overreliance on particular herbicides, as fostered especially by HR crop systems. <br />
However, once resistant populations of out-‐crossing weeds emerge, even small ones, they can <br />
propagate resistance via cross-‐pollinating their susceptible counterparts (Webster and <br />
Sosnoskie 2010). It is estimated that common waterhemp pollen can travel <strong>for</strong> one-‐half mile in <br />
windy conditions, and so spread resistance to neighbors’ fields via cross-‐pollination (Nordby <br />
et al. 2007). A recent study was undertaken to measure waterhemp pollen flow because <br />
“[p]ollen dispersal in annual weed species may pose a considerable threat to weed <br />
management, especially <strong>for</strong> out-‐crossing species, because it efficiently spreads herbicide <br />
resistance genes long distances,” because the “severe infestations and frequent incidence [of <br />
waterhemp] a<strong>rise</strong> from its rapid evolution of resistance to many herbicides,” and because <br />
“there is high potential that resistance genes can be transferred among populations [of <br />
waterhemp] at a landscape scale through pollen migration” (Liu et al. 2012). The study found <br />
that ALS inhibitor-‐resistant waterhemp pollen could travel 800 meters (the greatest distance <br />
tested) to successfully pollinate susceptible waterhemp; and that waterhemp pollen can <br />
remain viable <strong>for</strong> up to 120 hours, increasing the potential <strong>for</strong> spread of resistance traits. <br />
A second recent study made similar findings with respect to pollen flow from glyphosate-resistant<br />
to glyphosate-‐susceptible Palmer amaranth (Sosnoskie et al. 2012). In this study, <br />
susceptible sentinel plants were planted at distances up to 250-‐300 meters from GR Palmer <br />
amaranth. From 20-‐40% of the progeny of the sentinel plants at the furthest distances proved <br />
resistant to glyphosate, demonstrating that glyphosate resistance can be spread considerable <br />
distances by pollen flow in Palmer amaranth. <br />
Whether out-‐crossing or inbreeding, those resistant individuals with lightweight seeds can <br />
disperse at great distances. Dauer et al. (2009) found that the lightweight, airborne seeds of <br />
horseweed, the most prevalent GR weed (CFS GR Weed List 2012), can travel <strong>for</strong> tens to <br />
hundreds of kilometers in the wind, which is likely an important factor its prevalence. <br />
Hybridization among related weeds is another potential means by which resistance could be <br />
spread, <strong>for</strong> instance by weeds in the problematic Amaranthus genus (Gaines et al. 2012).