WHEN THE TWAIN MET...“I was thrilled by this famous companion of my youth.He was now very old and snow-white, and combinedwith a noble air a most delightful style of conversation.” 7While <strong>Churchill</strong> knew that he did not have theunanimous support of the committee, he was possiblyunaware of Twain’s very public campaign against colonization.He soon learned the truth. Twain began with asearing critique of British and U.S. policy abroad, but hechanged tack at the end, introducing the young <strong>Winston</strong>with panache:I think that England sinned when she got herselfinto a war in South Africa which she could haveavoided, just as we have sinned in getting into asimilar war in the Philippines. Mr. <strong>Churchill</strong> by hisfather is an Englishman, by his mother he is anAmerican, no doubt a blend that makes the perfectman. England and America; we are kin. And nowthat we are also kin in sin, there is nothing more tobe desired. The harmony is perfect, like Mr.<strong>Churchill</strong> himself, whom I now have the honor topresent to you. 8Clearly <strong>Churchill</strong> knew he was not in Englandnow! But he soon warmed to his task, and “held the attentionof his listeners by a clear recital of some of themost striking episodes of the struggle between Boer andBriton,” according to the Times:He showed nervousness at first, but soon forgothimself in his subject, and held the attention of hislisteners....A touch of humor, introduced halfunconsciously, lightened up the lecture considerably.He took his audience from the armored trainnear Estcourt to the POW compound in Pretoria,from the railroad line at Resana Garcia to the hero’swelcome at Durban. He took them and he heldthem. 9 Already a practiced debater, <strong>Churchill</strong> had theability to defuse pro-Boer and anti-British feelings. Duringhis lectures in America, he often showed a magiclantern slide of a Boer commando. When, frequently, hisaudience responded with applause, <strong>Churchill</strong> would say:“You are quite right to applaud him; he is the most formidablefighting man in the world—one of the heroes ofhistory.” 10 When <strong>Churchill</strong> finished, Twain took thepodium again. The New York Times reported:“I take it for granted [Twain said] that I have thepermission of this audience to thank the lecturer forhis discourse, and to thank him heartily that, whilehe has extolled British valor, he has not withheldpraise from Boer valor.” A flushed and happy“You are right toapplaud him; he isthe most formidablefighting man in theworld—one of theheroes of history.”—WSC disarming pro-Boer audienceswho applauded his slide of a Boercommando on his U.S. lecture tour.<strong>Winston</strong> replied with becoming humility: “It is mychief duty to thank the chairman for coming here togive my lecture an importance and a dignity whichit could not have otherwise obtained.” 11While newspapers reported the New York receptionas “cordial,” <strong>Churchill</strong> gamely debated Twain in aprivate conversation. Biographer William Manchesterwrites that <strong>Churchill</strong> “growled” a retort, 12 but <strong>Churchill</strong>himself did not recall the exchange the same way:Of course we argued about the war. After someinterchanges I found myself beaten back to thecitadel “My country right or wrong.” “Ah,” said theold gentleman, “When the poor country is fightingfor its life, I agree. But this was not your case.” Ithink however I did not displease him; for he wasgood enough at my request to sign every one of thethirty volumes of his works for my benefit; and inthe first volume he inscribed the following maximintended, I daresay, to convey a gentle admonition:“To do good is noble; to teach others to do good isnobler, and no trouble.” 13Perhaps when <strong>Churchill</strong> wrote this thirty yearslater, he was waxing nostalgic; or perhaps he’d been hardenedby years of House of Commons debate. At the time,however, their meeting seems to have been polite at best,with no sign of a deeper bond developing between them.It was the kind of meeting that diplomats like to describeas “a frank exchange of views.”<strong>Churchill</strong>’s tour through the U.S. would continueinto January 1901. He would describe his audiencesas “cool and critical” but also “good natured,” andthey listened to him in “quiet tolerance.” 14 He had morecordial receptions in Canada afterward, and returned toEngland in late winter satisfied with his performancesFINEST HOUR 149 / 42
and earnings, ready to begin his career as a Member ofParliament. In the meantime, Mark Twain turned his fullattention to anti-imperialist polemics.Perhaps the impact of the meeting on <strong>Churchill</strong>can best be seen in his swiftly-changing attitudes aboutthe Boer War. WSC’s maiden speech in Parliament, just afew months after his tour, was on British policy in SouthAfrica, in which he advocated a conciliatory approach tothe Boers. In 1904, as he contemplated bolting the Conservativesfor the Liberal party, he railed against Britishimperial policy and called the war “a public disaster.” 15Had he heard that speech, Twain would likely have ledthe applause for the now-renegade Conservative.The two men never met again and last year markedthe centenary of Twain’s death. But <strong>Churchill</strong> didnot forget the great novelist. As Martin Gilbert revealsin the official biography, <strong>Churchill</strong> joined the InternationalMark Twain Society in 1929, and suggested thatTwain’s The Prince and the Pauper be one of the “GreatStories Retold” which he and his secretary, Eddie Marsh,were preparing for the press. 16Twain’s work was always in <strong>Churchill</strong>’s mind.In 1932, when his second appearance on an interruptedlecture tour brought him to Twain’s longtime home ofHartford, Connecticut, WSC declared the city “the centreof the great Mark Twain literature that has flowed outand is still flowing over all the English-speaking peoplesaround the entire globe.” 17In “Everybody’s Language,” a 1935 essay onCharlie Chaplin (FH 142), <strong>Churchill</strong> wrote of howChaplin, like himself, had a parent who died young,adding: “Mark Twain, left fatherless at twelve, had substantiallythe same experience. He would never have writtenHuckleberry Finn had life been kinder in his youth.” 18Nineteen thirty-seven found <strong>Churchill</strong> proposingMark Twain among the personages for a sequel to hisbook of character studies, Great Contemporaries. 19 Thatsame year, the Twain Society’s founder, Cyril Clemens, adescendant of the novelist, presciently wrote <strong>Churchill</strong>:“Your Marlborough is so magnificent that we feel it deservesthe Nobel Prize in Literature.” 20 In due course,Marlborough would play a powerful role in qualifying<strong>Churchill</strong> for that award.Finally, on 25 October 1943, <strong>Churchill</strong> wroteClemens from Downing Street:I am writing to express my thanks to theInternational Mark Twain Society for their GoldMedal, which has been handed to me by Mr. PhilipGuedalla. It will serve to keep fresh my memory ofa great American, who showed me much kindnesswhen I visited New York as a young man by takingthe Chair at my first public lecture and by autographingcopies of his works, which still form avalued part of my library. 21 >>Waldorf Astoria Hotel, New York, 13 December 1900:“ I have already written a book about my escape from Pretoria and I trust thateveryone in the audience will purchase a copy. This is the anniversary of my escape,many accounts of which have been related here and in England, but none of which istrue. I escaped by climbing over the iron paling of my prison while the sentry waslighting his pipe. I passed through the streets of Pretoria unobserved andmanaged to board a coal train on which I hid among the sacks of coal.When I found the train was not going in the direction I wanted, I jumped off.I wandered about aimlessly for a long time, suffering from hunger, and at last Idecided that I must seek aid at all risks. I knocked at the door of a kraal, expectingto find a Boer, and to my joy, found it occupied by an Englishman,who ultimately helped me to reach the British lines.”—Extract, Robert Rhodes James, ed., <strong>Winston</strong> S. <strong>Churchill</strong>: His Complete Speeches 1897-1963, 8 vols. (New York: Bowker, 1974), I: 63.FINEST HOUR 149 / 43