TA P P I N G T H E P O T E N T I A L : R E TA I N I N G A N D D E V E L O P I N G H I G H - Q U A L I T Y N E W T E A C H E R STHE INDUCTION ENGINE: COMPONENTS OFCOMPREHENSIVE INDUCTIONQuality induction proven to retainand develop new teachers is a bundleof several types of supports and assessments.What follows is a rigorous descriptionof <strong>the</strong> essential components of comprehensiveinduction. Without <strong>the</strong>m,induction is a car without an engine.Because induction programs vary sowidely, educators and policymakers needto understand <strong>the</strong> common componentsthat make up comprehensive induction so<strong>the</strong>y can recognize good induction when<strong>the</strong>y see it. Knowing <strong>the</strong> components ofinduction can guide decisionmakers at <strong>the</strong>federal, state, and local levels about whatto require, expect, and fund. Articulatingquality criteria is also an important steptoward equity, ensuring that every beginningteacher has <strong>the</strong> opportunity to developinto a high-quality professional.Stand By Me: High-QualityMentoringComprehensive induction programsmatch new teachers with one or moreexperienced and trained teachers whomentor new teachers. Mentors supportand coach novice teachers in several ways.They spend regular time observing newteachers in <strong>the</strong> classroom, offering <strong>the</strong>mfeedback, demonstrating effective teachingmethods, assisting with lesson plans,and helping teachers analyze student workand achievement data. Quality mentorsalso assess novice teachers to determinehow <strong>the</strong>ir practice should improve inorder to raise student achievement andmeet teaching standards.The process of selecting and assigningmentors is crucial to induction’s success.The mere presence of a guide doesnot improve teaching. 66 “If mentors simplypass on <strong>the</strong>ir own teaching practices,regardless of whe<strong>the</strong>r <strong>the</strong>y are effectiveor not,” researchers Richard Ingersolland Jeffrey Kralik warn, “programsmight tend to stifle innovation or <strong>the</strong>implementation of new approaches on<strong>the</strong> part of beginning teachers.” 67Mentors need to be selected using <strong>the</strong>following characteristics:• Quality mentors are good teachers of students.The best mentors have strongcontent knowledge of <strong>the</strong> subject <strong>the</strong>yteach, a proven ability to raise studentachievement, and success workingwith linguistically and ethnicallydiverse students. 68Knowing <strong>the</strong> componentsof induction can guidedecisionmakers at <strong>the</strong>federal, state, and locallevels about what torequire, expect, and fund.The process of selectingand assigning mentors iscrucial to induction’ssuccess.13
A L L I A N C E F O R E X C E L L E N T E D U C AT I O NFor <strong>the</strong>ir induction work,which is often done inaddition to regularclassroom teaching,mentors need recognitionand support.• Quality mentors are good teachers of teachers.Besides exemplary teaching, <strong>the</strong>best mentors have <strong>the</strong> ability to learn anew set of skills: teaching teachers. 69Mentors communicate how to teach asmuch as what to teach. They must beable to model successful teaching in away that makes it possible <strong>for</strong> o<strong>the</strong>rteachers to learn from <strong>the</strong>m.• Quality mentors are matched with teachersin <strong>the</strong> same subject area. Ideally, mentorswork in <strong>the</strong> same subject (e.g., math)or field (e.g., special education) as<strong>the</strong>ir novice teachers. Research confirmswhat common sense knows: mentorsmaximize <strong>the</strong>ir skill base when <strong>the</strong>ycoach teachers who do similar work,especially at <strong>the</strong> high school level,where teachers specialize in specific disciplinessuch as geometry or literature.Currently, however, less than half ofbeginning teachers are mentored byteachers from <strong>the</strong> same subject area. 70But even great teachers will not mentorsuccessfully without additional training.Training prepares mentors to use<strong>for</strong>mative assessments—to identify newteachers’ needs, assess <strong>the</strong>ir practice, andhelp <strong>the</strong>m plan improvement in order toreach professional standards. 71 Formativeassessments are regular, guided reflectionsthat evaluate how well teachingpractices lead to student learning.For example, a mentor might reviewstudent achievement data on midyeartests with a new teacher to see how his orher daily homework assignments do or donot lead to student progress. In a series ofdialogues, mentor and teacher wouldidentify particular struggling students,reflect on <strong>the</strong> teacher’s work with thosestudents, and strategize how to tailorfuture homework assignments to get betteroutcomes. In <strong>the</strong> future, <strong>for</strong> example,<strong>the</strong> teacher might plan to assign a groupproject instead of book reports, orrequire shorter essays instead of a longerresearch paper.For <strong>the</strong>ir induction work, which isoften done in addition to regular classroomteaching, mentors need recognitionand support. Some induction programspay mentors stipends and offer<strong>the</strong>m extra professional developmentmoney. O<strong>the</strong>rs identify mentors as masterteachers and give <strong>the</strong>m greater responsibility,with larger salaries. Incentives likeincreased pay and promotion reward asThe New Teacher Center Formative Assessment SystemThe New Teacher Center Formative Assessment System (NTC FAS) is a series of “collaborative processes”that focus on how new teachers canimprove student learning. During <strong>the</strong> first month of school, mentors collaborate with beginning teachers to assess <strong>the</strong>ir practice, set goalsaligned with state teaching standards, and <strong>for</strong>m an individual learning plan to reach those goals. Mentors observe and meet with <strong>the</strong>ir teachersweekly to discuss growth, pinpoint areas <strong>for</strong> improvement, and analyze student work and teacher work (e.g., lesson plans and journal entries)to track <strong>the</strong> teacher’s progress. Early in <strong>the</strong> year, mentors and teachers assemble a class profile that identifies <strong>the</strong>ir students’ needs and planshow <strong>the</strong> teacher can place <strong>the</strong>m in groups to promote learning. They also select one student as a case study to follow her or his progressthroughout <strong>the</strong> year. During <strong>the</strong> school year, teachers and mentors regularly analyze student data, plan <strong>the</strong>ir lessons accordingly, set upprofessional development activities, and prepare to work with parents. By <strong>the</strong> end of <strong>the</strong> year, teachers and <strong>the</strong>ir mentors have consistentlyand systematically reflected on <strong>the</strong>ir teaching and measured how it has led to improved student learning. 72For more in<strong>for</strong>mation about NTC FAS and <strong>the</strong> New Teacher Center, at <strong>the</strong> University of Cali<strong>for</strong>nia at Santa Cruz, see Appendix A.14