MACHINE BUILDING & AUTOMATIONMachine Control PLCsMaking the most of<strong>machine</strong> control PLCsToday’s PLCs can bring a raft of benefits to boththe <strong>machine</strong> designer and end user. We spoke tothe leading vendors, and asked their opinions onwhat can be achieved today, and what we canexpect from <strong>machine</strong> control in the futureBack in the early 1970s whenPLCs first became accepted asthe way to automate a <strong>machine</strong>or process, very few users wouldhave considered the cost of developingthe ‘logic control’ software as part of theoverall <strong>machine</strong> cost. In fact, it isestimated that in 1970, the cost of theman hours to write the <strong>machine</strong> controlcode accounted for just 1-2% of theoverall cost.As the capabilities of traditional PLCshave expanded to meet the demands ofthe OEM <strong>machine</strong> builders and their endusercustomers, such as the inclusion ofcomplex motion control, integrated safetyand vision inspection, and data storageand manipulation, so the cost of softwaredeveloped has also increasedproportionally. Even just a decade ago, upto 40% of the cost of any <strong>machine</strong> wasattributable to the cost of its controlsoftware development. Today, that figure islikely to be even higher.Of course, it is not just the complexityof <strong>machine</strong>s that has changed over theyears, as Omron’s Karl Walker explains:“Flexibility and re-configurability havebecome top priorities for OEMs. Theevidence of this is the ever-increasingnumber of servo axes per <strong>machine</strong>,automating traditional, manual ‘changeparts’ processes, reducing productchangeover times and increasingthroughput speeds.”PLC evolutionSo how have <strong>machine</strong> control PLCs haveevolved over the last ten years or so tomeet these needs? Idec’s Sean Knellercomments: “With the increasing need forrobust but compact systems in <strong>machine</strong>control applications, PLCs have had toreduce in size but increase in intelligenceand control. The processing power interms of speed and memory of the modernday PLC has increased dramatically, withPLCs processing logic in nanoseconds. Theease with which you can upgrade thesystem, by adding I/O cards andcommunication cards has become easier,with literally only a few minutes ofdowntime to expand or adapt your systemto your needs.“In addition, the need formultiple communications platformshas developed over theyears,” he continues, “with mostPLCs being able to interface notonly with competitor hard ware,but also with <strong>machine</strong> controllers,robots and drives via a directconnection.”Rockwell Automation’s Steve Pethickadds: “PLCs have become ProgrammableAutomation Controllers (PAC) – with keyattributes such as Motion Control beingtightly integrated into the controller,expanding the control potential.Specialised networking has been overtakenby the use of standard EtherNet for the keyFlexible <strong>machine</strong>s arethose that can beconfigured easily to handledifferent products withlittle or no manualinterventionfunctions of <strong>machine</strong> control, safety andmotion control. Solutions have alsobecome more scalable, with two-axiscontrol now available in a ‘low end’,inexpensive controller. We have also seen atrend towards safety integration withincontrollers to assist with safetylegislation.”Rockwell Automation offers a widerange of PLCs for <strong>machine</strong> builders, withthe larger products in the Logix platformproviding solutions that fit the mostdemanding application needs. They offermodular architectures and a range of I/Oand network options. Thesepowerful control solutions deliver worldclasscapabilities for all disciplines, fromprocess to safety to motion. Designed fordistributed or supervisory controlapplications, the large programmable<strong>automation</strong> controllers (PACs) andprogrammable logic controllers (PLC)provide exceptional reliability andperformance.Further down the range and ideallysuited to complex <strong>machine</strong> designs, theCompactLogix control systems provide theperfect solution for mid-rangeapplications, offering the features andflexibility you need without the overheadof larger systems. Users can choose fromstandard and safety-certified controllers inchassis-based, packaged and modulardesigns.For simpler <strong>machine</strong> designs, theMicroLogix PLCs provide economicalsolutions that meet the needs ofapplications such as conveyor<strong>automation</strong>.For <strong>machine</strong> builders, key featureswithin the Logix range include integratedmotion that is simple to configure andwhich reduces engineering effort. Inaddition, information-enabled controllersshare useful information with the rightpeople in a timely fashion, allowing betterreal-time decision making in theproduction environment. Integrating safety(Above) Idec’s configuration softwaremakes it easy to create projects whichcan easily be adapted for each <strong>machine</strong>build, keeping the PLC, HMI andconfiguration software all in one filein standard controllers eliminates the needfor an additional safety PLC or safetycontroller.Increased flexibilityGiven this ongoing evolution of the PLCinto today’s powerful platforms, how dothe latest generations of products help<strong>machine</strong> builders to design <strong>machine</strong>s thatare more flexible and offer reduceddowntime and increased productivity?Pethick says: “Flexible <strong>machine</strong>s arethose that can be configured easily tohandle different products with little or nomanual intervention. The use of linearmotors and actuators coupled with theability to reconfigure motion profiles ‘onthe fly’ contributes to making this possible.Integrating“Overall Equipment Effectiveness(OEE) into your <strong>machine</strong> helps reducedowntime, while integrating OEE softwarewith your controller provides a simple viewinto the cause of <strong>machine</strong> downtime andtherefore faster resolution. Using smartsensors and instrumentation connectedover Ethernet can provide predictivediagnostic information so that <strong>machine</strong>38INDUSTRIAL TECHNOLOGY • April 2012
Perfect <strong>machine</strong> DNAThe evolution of <strong>machine</strong> control(Above) The latest release of RockwellSoftware RSLogix 5000 software fromRockwell Automation delivers the highperformance of an integrated controlsystem for <strong>machine</strong> builders requiringa smaller control systemdowntime can be prevented by takingearly remedial action.”The modularity of the modernPLC also helps, as Idec’sKneller explains: “Thisallows the <strong>machine</strong>builder to design a systemwhich is easily maintainedand can be upgraded withlittle or no downtime. ThePLCs are also being usedto monitor the systemsand generate emails or textmessages to maintenancestaff if the <strong>machine</strong> requiresattention, again increasing the responsetime for failures which in turn reducesdowntime.Integration with other products isalso key. Festo’s Hanbury comments:“Traditional binary or analogueinterfaces between intelligent terminalsand complex sensors and actuators arebeing replaced to enable robust and fastdata transfer. Intelligent point to pointconnection systems such as IO-Link arestarting to impact upon the field level.IO-link promises a big reduction ofinstallation and maintenance time andcosts as far less on-site interaction isrequired. Festo is about to release anew compact PLC (CECC) for <strong>machine</strong>control offering direct integration withthis type of interface.”Reduced development timeAs well as boosting the functionality,performance and flexibility of <strong>machine</strong>s,modern PLCs also help <strong>machine</strong>builders to develop new designs morequickly, and here software is key.Hitachi’s Arnold Rupperath, whose PLCproducts are distributed by SoftstartUK, comments: “Modern andstandardised programming softwarewith advanced features drives increasedefficiency, while library functions makeit possible to re-use existing engineeringknowhow.”Rockwell Automation’s Pethickadds: “The increasing trend towardsmodular code generation, standardcontrol blocks (add-on instructions) andtechniques such as power programming(based on the S88 state model) can allhelp <strong>machine</strong> builders developapplications more quickly. In addition,the tight integration between the logiccontrol and motion functions can alsodrastically reduce development time.”To minimise the cost of softwaredevelopment and, indeed, the timetaken to create the working solution,reusability of existing code is key, alongwith the ability for several engineers towork on the same piece of code withoutthe risk of conflict. Omron’s Walkercomments: “It must also be structuredThe trend towardsmodular code andstandard control blockshelp <strong>machine</strong> buildersdevelop applicationsmore quicklyin such a way that it is understandablefor everyone, including those who willhave to maintain the system in thefuture.“Traditional programming methodsof one continuous, often uncommented,ladder logic program using meaninglessphysical I/O addresses are now givingway to symbol-based programming,often using Sequential Flow Chart (SFC)structures to provide a clear picture ofhow the <strong>machine</strong> or process operates(understandable by everyone, even nonprogrammers)and helping to breakdownthe code into individual tasks andrequisite disciplines (mechanicalhandling, process control, etc). Thisfacilitates the ideal of severaldevelopers working on the controlsoftware at the same time.”IEC standards (IEC61131-3) havehelped to provide some commonality inSysmac Automation PlatformNJ-Series Machine ControllerVision,Logic,Motion,I/O....IntegratedTel: +44 (0)1908 258258Email: uk@eu.omron.comWeb: www.industrial.omron.co.ukApril 2012 • INDUSTRIAL TECHNOLOGY39