the chapter, students illustrated a scene from it (see Appendix 4a: Imagery withOwls in the Family). The novel was brought <strong>to</strong> life. <strong>Students</strong> enjoyed illustrating anevent from the chapter, and the book became very real <strong>to</strong> them. Every student wasable <strong>to</strong> complete this task; artistic ability did not matter. As visualizing continuedthroughout the year, students became very adept at making pictures in theirminds. It was a valuable reading comprehension strategy <strong>to</strong> make the written wordbecome real.Figure 2. Visualizing poster used by the researchers.After seeing the leveled books available through subscriptions from the web site,<strong>Reading</strong> a-z, used for <strong>Guided</strong> <strong>Reading</strong>, the Grade Three researcher used thes<strong>to</strong>ries, lesson plans, worksheets including s<strong>to</strong>ry maps, and the Reader QuickCheck with the Grade Three class as a whole, instead of using them with smallgroups. An Educational Assistant helped prepare the materials. The students foundthe books and the variety of accompanying activities interesting and fun <strong>to</strong> do.<strong>Students</strong> completed these activities easily and independently. The Reader QuickCheck was an excellent instrument for assessing reading comprehension includinghigher level thinking skills such as inferencing and synthesizing. These printablebooks and teaching materials were a very successful addition <strong>to</strong> a folktale unit.14 RESEARCH REPORT: <strong>Guided</strong> <strong>Reading</strong> <strong>Strategies</strong> <strong>to</strong> <strong>Improve</strong> <strong>Students</strong>’ Critical Thinking Skills in Grades Three, Four and Five
THE TEACHING APPROACH IN GRADE FOURDirect <strong>Guided</strong> <strong>Reading</strong> instruction was the focus for a novel study on S<strong>to</strong>ne fox byJohn Reynolds Gardiner (1980). <strong>Students</strong> participated in a variety of activitiesdesigned <strong>to</strong> promote higher level thinking skills from Literature and criticalthinking, Book 1 by John Carratello. <strong>Students</strong> read up <strong>to</strong> Chapters 5 and 6, andthen did an activity about being a responsible person. In the novel, they learnedthat the main character had many responsibilities so then the students had <strong>to</strong>connect the book <strong>to</strong> their own lives. <strong>Students</strong> had <strong>to</strong> think of how and in whatways they were responsible. They also had <strong>to</strong> write if they thought they could carefor their Grandpa like the character Little Willy had <strong>to</strong> and answer why or why not.Then they had <strong>to</strong> think of five ways that they could earn $500, like Little Willy. Theideas had <strong>to</strong> be real ways and not “make-believe.” The students also had <strong>to</strong> writea prediction of whom they thought would win the big race, and what theythought would happen. Then they read the book <strong>to</strong> find out. Afterwards, theywatched the video, S<strong>to</strong>ne Fox. <strong>Students</strong> recorded the similarities and differencesbetween the book and the video.<strong>Students</strong> reading the novel, S<strong>to</strong>ne Fox, Grade 4.After reading, the Grade Four students filled in a Literature Log. This pageincluded the following stems: the best part was…, the worst part was…, the mainproblem was…, problem was solved when…, my favorite character was…, my leastfavorite character was…, I laughed when…, and I cried when….Following the novel study, the Grade Four students’ comprehension levels wereassessed on the computer in a variety of ways. <strong>Students</strong> did an Accelerated Readerquiz with ten questions on the novel <strong>to</strong> help measure their basic comprehensionskills. Then they did a Vocabulary quiz, and something new – a Literacy Skills quiz.The Vocabulary test had five multiple-choice type questions on the meaning of avariety of words from the novel. On the Literacy skills quiz, students were asked<strong>to</strong> answer 12 questions. There were four categories on the S<strong>to</strong>ne Fox Literacy Skillsquiz, each with three questions:1) initial understanding,2) literacy analysis,3) inferential comprehension, and4) constructing meaning.RESEARCH REPORT: <strong>Guided</strong> <strong>Reading</strong> <strong>Strategies</strong> <strong>to</strong> <strong>Improve</strong> <strong>Students</strong>’ Critical Thinking Skills in Grades Three, Four and Five15