28SOLD DOWN THE RIVER© FORESTS MONITORBecause of disruptions to<strong>the</strong> railway as a result of<strong>the</strong> civil wars, logs fromnor<strong>the</strong>rn Congo have been<strong>le</strong>aving <strong>the</strong> country on thisroad via Cameroon.exploitation. 12 In 1995, 37% of <strong>the</strong> total forest areaof Congo was held in concessions and this hasincreased rapidly since 1996.There are two main areas of commerciallyexploitab<strong>le</strong> natural forests in Congo: 13§ In <strong>the</strong> south, in <strong>the</strong> regions of Kouilou-Mayombe and Chaillu-Niari, forests cover 4.5 millionhectares of which just over 4 million hectares wereheld as concessions in 1995. 14 Forests in <strong>the</strong>se regionsare relatively accessib<strong>le</strong> and have been intensivelyexploited since <strong>the</strong> 1940s. 15 In 1990, over 50% of <strong>the</strong>country’s total production came from here. 16 The twomain tree species targeted are Okoumé and Limba.Logging operations in <strong>the</strong> south virtually ceasedbecause of <strong>the</strong> civil war;§ In <strong>the</strong> north, forests cover 17.3 millionhectares, 17 of which 8.9 million are deemedexploitab<strong>le</strong>. 18 Prior to 1996, concessions had been allocated for 2.1 million hectares ofnor<strong>the</strong>rn forests and forestry activities were limited because of <strong>the</strong> relative isolation of <strong>the</strong>region; this has been changing rapidly. In 1996 alone, 3.2 million hectares were allocatedfor timber exploitation 19 and, since 1998, President Sassou Nguesso has been activelyseeking multinational logging companies to take over <strong>the</strong> exploitation of <strong>the</strong> remainingunallocated forests in <strong>the</strong> north of <strong>the</strong> country. Many of <strong>the</strong> previously unallocatedconcessions have now been allocated and former parastatals have been privatised. As aresult, <strong>the</strong> nor<strong>the</strong>rn forests are becoming increasingly significant for timber production.The two main tree species targeted are Sapelli and Sipo.The state department responsib<strong>le</strong> for <strong>the</strong> forestry sector is <strong>the</strong> Ministry of Forest Economy(Ministère de l’Economie Forestière). The forestry industry was until recently <strong>le</strong>gally governedby <strong>the</strong> 1974 Forestry Code. Its revision by Parliament began in 1993, which produced a draftrevised version in June 1998 (see below). The 1974 law specified that <strong>the</strong> forest be divided intomanagement units (unités d’aménagement), each of which must have a precise plan ofmanagement and exploitation. 20 Stipulations regarding harvesting and development practiceswere set out, as well as how much concessionaires could produce per year (VMA – volumemaximum annuel). Of <strong>the</strong> 27 management units that existed in 1990, only five had amanagement plan but none observed it. 21 In nor<strong>the</strong>rn Congo none of <strong>the</strong> active forestry unitshave a management plan, although some companies are now developing <strong>the</strong>m.The June 1998 version of <strong>the</strong> Forestry Code includes <strong>the</strong> following objectives: 22§ Sustainab<strong>le</strong> management of forests;§ Conservation of biological diversity;§ Reforestation, mainly through communal and industrial plantations;§ Decentralisation of <strong>the</strong> sector and international co-operation;§ Development and diversification of industries based on <strong>the</strong> local transformation of almostall log production. To attain this objective, <strong>the</strong> new code establishes that, whereas <strong>the</strong>maximum period of production concession is for 10 years, permits for <strong>the</strong> processingindustry can last up to 15 years and can be renewed.In January1998, President Sassou Nguesso announced that logging companies were forbiddento export logs 23 and that all companies had to present a plan for timber processing. 24 In March2000, however, <strong>the</strong> Congo<strong>le</strong>se government finally approved <strong>the</strong> law, and it stated that 60% oftimber production must be processed locally. 25 Although <strong>the</strong> increased emphasis on<strong>down</strong>stream processing should bring additional revenues to <strong>the</strong> government, <strong>the</strong>imp<strong>le</strong>mentation of this policy will not be immediate given that processing facilities have beenlitt<strong>le</strong> developed in <strong>the</strong> country to date; in 1997, <strong>the</strong> country had 30 processing units but onlyfive had export capacity. Most exports are still of logs.The government often lacks <strong>the</strong> capacity to develop social infrastructure, particularly in <strong>the</strong>north. As a result, social development projects are often specified as part of <strong>the</strong> contractbetween government and forestry companies and are known as <strong>the</strong> cahier des charges. Projectsinclude <strong>the</strong> construction of roads, schools and clinics. In some instances, <strong>the</strong>se projects areundertaken in lieu of taxes or by <strong>the</strong> company under contract to <strong>the</strong> government, and are<strong>the</strong>refore at <strong>the</strong> government’s, and not <strong>the</strong> company’s, expense.Congo (Brazzavil<strong>le</strong>)’s forestry taxes are considered to be low and substantial revenues havebeen lost because of irregularities; <strong>the</strong> government itself estimates that US$ 4 billion in timberindustry <strong>le</strong>vies have been foregone as a result. 26 Logging companies still have considerab<strong>le</strong>room for negotiation about timber volumes and taxes. This has facilitated corruption in <strong>the</strong>
CONGO (BRAZZAVILLE) 29awarding and exploitation of generous concessions. 27 Tax incentives are favouring <strong>the</strong>development of forestry operations in <strong>the</strong> north of <strong>the</strong> country. In 1999, one French company,Rougier, was granted a 370,000 hectare concession near <strong>the</strong> border with <strong>the</strong> Central AfricanRepublic (CAR), reportedly on terms so generous that it could expect to recover its capitalinvestment in just two years and would pay just one-third of <strong>the</strong> normal royalties to <strong>the</strong>government. 28The costs of <strong>the</strong> war are being felt by forestry companies in a number of ways: <strong>the</strong>disruption to transport routes, especially <strong>the</strong> railway, have added considerably to transportcosts from <strong>the</strong> north; <strong>the</strong> cessation of operations in <strong>the</strong> south of <strong>the</strong> country; <strong>the</strong> kidnapping ofstaff (see Wonnemann, page 66); forestry companies are now being asked by <strong>the</strong> governmentto employ former militia members to help reintegrate <strong>the</strong>m into society, even though <strong>the</strong>y areunqualified. 29Because of disruptions to <strong>the</strong> railway as a result of <strong>the</strong> civil wars, logs from nor<strong>the</strong>rn Congohave been <strong>le</strong>aving <strong>the</strong> country by road via Cameroon to Douala ra<strong>the</strong>r than being floated<strong>down</strong> <strong>river</strong> to <strong>the</strong> main <strong>river</strong> port in Brazzavil<strong>le</strong>, where authorities control and tax timbertraffic, and <strong>the</strong>n on by rail to Pointe Noire. 30 Even prior to <strong>the</strong> war, <strong>the</strong> <strong>river</strong> and rail optionentai<strong>le</strong>d lost revenues to <strong>the</strong> government; <strong>the</strong> long journey <strong>down</strong> <strong>river</strong> enabling many logs tobe sto<strong>le</strong>n and informally processed before <strong>the</strong>y reached Brazzavil<strong>le</strong> itself. It is not always c<strong>le</strong>arwhat happens to <strong>the</strong> money that is paid by logging companies in taxes. According to somereports, part of <strong>the</strong> US$ 4 million paid by one new company for its concessions paid <strong>the</strong> rebelsto come back whi<strong>le</strong> ano<strong>the</strong>r part simply “evaporated”. 31Monitoring and enforcement capacity of <strong>the</strong> Ministry is weak. As with most governmentdepartments, <strong>the</strong>y are virtually non-existent in <strong>the</strong> north of <strong>the</strong> country. Civil servants go forlong periods of time without pay, which not only seriously demotivates staff but also meansthat <strong>the</strong>y must look for alternative sources of income. This situation facilitates corruption andinformal “taxation”, for examp<strong>le</strong> on commercial bushmeat. 32Production and EU tradeIn <strong>the</strong> second half of <strong>the</strong> 1980s, timber production grew consistently, attaining a total of883,000 cubic metres in 1990. But during <strong>the</strong> first half of <strong>the</strong> 1990s, timber production inCongo decreased, in contrast to <strong>the</strong> rest of <strong>the</strong> region – in 1995, production had dropped byhalf to 441,000 cubic metres. 33 In 1996, production went up to 560,000 cubic metres but in<strong>the</strong> following year declined to its lowest <strong>le</strong>vel in <strong>the</strong> last 30 years, 300,000 cubic metres,because of <strong>the</strong> civil war. 34 Since <strong>the</strong>n, however, log production has begun to rise again:550,000 cubic metres in 1998 35 and an estimated 800,000 cubic metres in 1999. 36 Thegovernment plans even fur<strong>the</strong>r expansion of <strong>the</strong> industrial forestry sector, aiming to more thandoub<strong>le</strong> timber production in <strong>the</strong> year 2000 up to 2 million cubic metres. 37Most timber exports are of logs ra<strong>the</strong>r than processed products. In 1997, total log exportsfrom Congo were 257,449 cubic metres; sawn wood exports were 37,930 cubic metres; veneerexports were 41,666 cubic metres and plywood was 2,613 cubic metres. 38 In 1999, log exportswere 203,544 cubic metres; sawn wood exports were 61,861 cubic metres; veneer exportswere 16,540 cubic metres and plywood was zero. 39 In <strong>the</strong> early 1990s, exports of pulpwoodfrom plantations were significant – 670,000 cubic metres in 1990 – but have since declinedbecause <strong>the</strong> plantations are dep<strong>le</strong>ted. 40 Since 1984, <strong>the</strong> Sapelli and Okoumé tree speciesrepresent 60-65% of total exports. Ayous, Bahia and Sipo are <strong>the</strong> next three most targetedcommercial species. 41The European Union continues to be <strong>the</strong> primary destination for timber exports fromCongo, with France, Germany, Italy, Portugal and Spain being <strong>the</strong> main importers. Outside <strong>the</strong>EU, <strong>the</strong> main importer is Japan. In addition, it is believed that considerab<strong>le</strong> volumes of logs arebeing smugg<strong>le</strong>d out of <strong>the</strong> north of <strong>the</strong> country from some of <strong>the</strong> newly allocated concessions.International financial assistanceAs in <strong>the</strong> o<strong>the</strong>r countries in Central Africa (apart from <strong>the</strong> DRC), Congo (Brazzavil<strong>le</strong>) receivessupport from <strong>the</strong> EU forest conservation and sustainab<strong>le</strong> development programme, ECOFAC,which has a project in <strong>the</strong> 280,000 hectare National Park of Odzala in <strong>the</strong> north-west of <strong>the</strong>country. Odzala has an exceptional variety of different landscapes and is home to a number offorest and savannah animal species such as chimpanzees and e<strong>le</strong>phants. ECOFAC isdeveloping <strong>the</strong> sustainab<strong>le</strong> management of <strong>the</strong> park, including <strong>the</strong> promotion of sustainab<strong>le</strong>economic activities in <strong>the</strong> park’s surroundings, such as eco-tourism, to provide an alternativeto bushmeat hunting. 42Logging companies appear to have received funds from multilateral organisations, although<strong>the</strong> connections are not always c<strong>le</strong>ar. In 1990, for examp<strong>le</strong>, <strong>the</strong> African Development Bankgranted a loan to a French company, J. Lalanne, which only three years before had gained acontract to run a recently-established semi-state company, 43 Société Forestière Algéro-Congolaise. 44 In 1994, <strong>the</strong> French national development agency, Agence Française duDévéloppement (AFD) – or CFD (Caisse Française du Développement) as it <strong>the</strong>n was – was