<strong>The</strong> <strong>Canning</strong> <strong>Stock</strong> <strong>Route</strong> is a 1850-kilometre long trackrunning between Halls Creek and Wiluna in WesternAustralia. It is named after Alfred Wernam <strong>Canning</strong> whosurveyed the route in 1906–07. With the assistance ofunnamed Aboriginal people from many different languagegroups who lived along the route, he located water sourcesapproximately one day’s distance apart for a team oftravelling stock and their drovers. In 1908 he returned tobuild the wells. <strong>The</strong>re were 54 water sources of which 48were constructed wells.12<strong>The</strong> origins of the stock route<strong>The</strong> idea of the stock route began in 1905 in response to a monopoly that hadarisen on the beef supply to Perth and the goldfields. This monopoly resulted insuch high prices for beef that the government conducted a royal commission toinvestigate the issue of a ‘meat ring’. Cattle from the East Kimberley were afflictedwith ticks and were prohibited from travelling through the west of WesternAustralia in case they carried the ticks to unaffected cattle. <strong>The</strong> East Kimberleypastoralists were anxious to find a market for their cattle and the governmentwas equally anxious to find competition for the current suppliers to bring pricesdown. James Isdell, an East Kimberley pastoralist and politician, raised the ideathat the cattle tick would be unable to survive a desert crossing and lobbied thegovernment to make a path through the desert. <strong>The</strong> government approved of thisidea as it presented a way out of their meat supply problem, and an expeditionwas then planned to survey the country between Wiluna and Halls Creek. <strong>The</strong>country through which the pastoralists and the government proposed to runthe stock encompassed parts of the Great Sandy Desert, the Little Sandy Desertand the Gibson Desert. <strong>The</strong> final route transected the Countries of the Aboriginalpeople of many different language groups.Why the ‘<strong>Canning</strong>’ <strong>Stock</strong> <strong>Route</strong>?Alfred Wernam <strong>Canning</strong> was the man selected to survey the route. <strong>Canning</strong> wasborn in Victoria and been a cadet surveyor in New South Wales. He joined theWestern Australian Lands Department in 1893 and proved himself to be a reliablesurveyor. In 1901 he successfully surveyed the line for the rabbit-proof fence — ajourney of 1822 kilometres which began at Starvation Harbour, west of Esperance,and headed due north to Wallal, a point roughly halfway between Port Hedlandand Broome. <strong>Canning</strong>’s new instructions were to find a route from Wiluna to HallsCreek with water supplies one day’s bullock journey apart, which could supplywater for up to 800 head of cattle.This country had been travelled before by the Calvert Expedition, led by LawrenceWells, and by explorer David Carnegie in 1896. Wells stated that the country wasof no use for anything except spinifex. Carnegie explored the possibility of a stockroute between Coolgardie and the Kimberley but his route carried him throughthe Gibson Desert before arriving in the Great Sandy Desert. Three of his camelsdied from eating poisonous plants and one of his party accidentally shot himselfdead. Carnegie concluded ‘that a stock route through the desert is impracticablewe have clearly demonstrated’. He called it a ‘vast howling wilderness … so barrenand destitute of vegetation … that one marvels how even camels could pick up aliving’. (D Carnegie, Spinifex and Sand, pp. 432, 249)Both Wells and Carnegie created a precedent with their treatment of Aboriginalpeople. Both Wells and Carnegie used ropes to tie them up so that they wouldcontinue to receive their help; in Carnegie’s case, finding water; in Wells’s case,finding the two lost members of their party. Carnegie also deprived his Aboriginalcaptives of water or fed them salt beef so that they would lead him to water morequickly, although he was publicly criticised for this at the time. <strong>The</strong>re is evidenceto show that <strong>Canning</strong> had read the accounts of both expeditions and, on his ownexpedition, explicitly followed Carnegie’s example.1Plan of stock route exploration,by AW <strong>Canning</strong>, WesternAustralian Land InformationAuthority (Landgate)
<strong>Canning</strong> and the Aboriginal guidesFrom the beginning, <strong>Canning</strong> planned to use Aboriginal people to lead him to thewater, soaks and springs. He took neck chains and handcuffs with him to ensurethat his local Aboriginal ‘guides’ stayed with the party for as long as he neededthem. <strong>The</strong>y were chained up overnight, and on one occasion a man’s wife waschained in order to to lead him to water. It was largely with the help of theseAboriginal people that the expedition was successful in finding the water to supplythe route.3<strong>The</strong> expedition (a team of 23 camels, two horses, and eight white men) travelled1850 kilometres. <strong>The</strong>y left Wiluna in April 1906 and on 1 November arrived at HallsCreek from where <strong>Canning</strong> sent his triumphant telegram.23<strong>Canning</strong> <strong>Stock</strong> <strong>Route</strong> andSurrounding Country,2008, by Kumpaya Girgaba,Ngamaru Bidu, MabelWarkarta, Nola Taylor, <strong>The</strong>lmaJudson, Marjorie Yates, DulcieGibbs, Yuwali Janice Nixon,Rosie Williams, Nora Nangapa,Bugai Whylouter, Nora Wompi,Jakayu Biljabu and MorikaBiljabu, Martumili Artists,<strong>National</strong> Museum of AustraliaAlfred <strong>Canning</strong> on camel,courtesy State Library of WesternAustralia, <strong>The</strong> Battye LibraryOne of the members of the expedition, camp cook Edward Blake, disapprovedof <strong>Canning</strong>’s treatment of the Aboriginal people during the survey expeditionespecially with regard to the treatment of women. Blake took his concerns toauthorities in Perth and <strong>Canning</strong>’s treatment of the ‘Natives’ became the subjectof a royal commission in 1908.Some of the soaks and springs along the route were both secret and sacred. It islikely that the Aboriginal people led <strong>Canning</strong>’s party away from those, ultimatelydictating the shape of the route by their choices.<strong>Canning</strong> was ultimately cleared by the Royal Commission both on the strength ofhis achievement and on the fact that it was only Blake’s word against his. He wasthen commissioned to return to the desert to construct wells where necessaryto ensure reliable access to the water. <strong>The</strong>re were originally 48 wells constructedbetween 1908 and 1910. <strong>The</strong>se wells were constructed either near or on top ofAboriginal soaks and springs. Many of them were deepened and had their sidesstraightened in the manner of the traditional construction of European wells.Edward Blake predicted that one of the results of <strong>Canning</strong>’s treatment ofthe Aboriginal people would be reprisals towards stockmen once they usedthe route. In fact, the first conflict along the route happened on the surveyparty’s return journey.Michael Tobin, the well-boring expert, was attacked by an Aboriginal man,Mungkututu. Tobin fired his rifle but Mungkututu had already discharged his spear.Both men died in the encounter. Various reasons were put forward to explainthe tragedy, ranging from accusations of theft of women and objects to a simplematter of surprise. Whatever the reason, the conclusion of Hubert Trotman whowas ‘in charge of handling the natives’ on the survey expedition seems most apt:<strong>The</strong>re is no doubt that both men had been the victims of fear.Hubert Trotman, evidence before the 1908 royal commissionConflict on the stock routeIn 1911 the bodies of the first stockmen to use the route, Shoesmith, Thompsonand an Aboriginal man called ‘Chinaman’, were discovered by Thomas Cole whofollowed the route a short time after them. Rumours abounded that Cole had takenrevenge by shooting Aboriginal people along the route but they were not verified.An expedition led by Sergeant RH Pilmer was sent out in 1911 to bring to justicethose considered to be the perpetrators. This expedition was considered a successas some Aboriginal people were killed in a skirmish near the site of the murders.Most of the guilty men had reaped their just desserts, and the others were wellon the wing.RH Pilmer, 1911A later report has it that the police party was poorly led, travelling a set number ofmiles per day and ignoring the local knowledge of suitable camel camps.Consequently, the camels suffered badly and no natives were caught.Len Talbot, 2008
- Page 1: Welcome: Yarraniya ngalajunyuranya
- Page 5 and 6: Curriculum relevance
- Page 7 and 8: They learn about the struggles and
- Page 9 and 10: Activities for Literacy1 Have stude
- Page 11 and 12: Activities for History1 Alfred Cann
- Page 14 and 15: Activities for History1 Alfred Cann
- Page 16 and 17: Bibliography, Web Resources,Glossar
- Page 19: Ngurra: Country The desert environm
- Page 22 and 23: 5Endurers live permanently in the d
- Page 24 and 25: Who were the earliest inhabitants o
- Page 27: Jukurrpa: The Dreaming or Dreamtime
- Page 30 and 31: 5The cannibal JukurrpaIn the Jukurr
- Page 32 and 33: Before Canning made those lines of
- Page 34 and 35: In 1947 the Daughters of Mary Queen
- Page 38 and 39: 4Using the wellsDespite the police
- Page 40 and 41: 1Who was Alfred Canning?Alfred Wern
- Page 42 and 43: Why did Canning use the chains?Re t
- Page 44 and 45: The era of droving down the stock r
- Page 46 and 47: 5The story of Rover ThomasRover Tho
- Page 48 and 49: 1Kaninjaku, 2008, by KumpayaGirgaba
- Page 50 and 51: 7At Kulyayi, which became Well 42,
- Page 52 and 53: Natawalu, 2007, by Mayapu Elsie Tho
- Page 54 and 55: Puntawarri, 2007, by Pukarlyi Milly
- Page 56 and 57: Canning Stock Route Country, 2007,
- Page 58: Cannibal Story, about 2003, by Bill
- Page 61 and 62: Cattle at Durba Springs 2007FocuS Q
- Page 63 and 64: Minyipuru 2007Jugarda Dulcie Gibbsb
- Page 65 and 66: Tiwa 2008Focus Questions:• Name s
- Page 67 and 68: Waruwiya 2007Focus QuesTions:• Ho
- Page 69 and 70: Girls painted up for dancingat the