04.12.2012 Views

Copyright Statement - ResearchSpace@Auckland

Copyright Statement - ResearchSpace@Auckland

Copyright Statement - ResearchSpace@Auckland

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

320<br />

film circles for music that shared some of the formal qualities of modernist filmmaking.<br />

The most exciting results that Maconie produced were in this European idiom. There<br />

are sequences such as the drive into Hokianga that both sound and look like the art<br />

films with which Maconie, Williams and O’Shea were thoroughly familiar. Such<br />

music is still rare in New Zealand film, though there are some striking sequels such as<br />

Jack Body’s sparse music for Vincent Ward’s Vigil (1985). Most subsequent New<br />

Zealand films have preferred to follow Hollywood approaches.<br />

Where Maconie was less comfortable was his attempt to write popular music. An<br />

example was Runaway’s theme song, sung by Rim D. Paul in the Hokianga dance<br />

hall sequence. The melody, although rather repetitive, had the potential to become a<br />

theme to be used with a variety of tempos and orchestrations at various points in the<br />

film to provide musical continuity. Presumably Maconie held back from this since he<br />

would have regarded such a procedure as too obvious, too “Hollywood” in style.<br />

Maconie’s music is problematic for those who prefer a more orthodox, less<br />

experimental approach. For example, in an assessment of Runaway’s music carried<br />

out at my request, New Zealand composer Gary Daverne commented:<br />

It had little, if any impact on me. I felt the music was naive and immature,<br />

generally inappropriate and did little for the film. It was unconvincing, non<br />

effective and certainly not memorable … This is not film music and does not<br />

compare favourably alongside other film music of the same period. Just<br />

because music is written for film does not necessarily make it film music.<br />

Film music has particular characteristics, style and feel. It should be able to<br />

stand alone and create a picture without the visual scenes.<br />

To support his contentions Daverne listed a number of scenes where the music<br />

seemed to him inappropriate or too avant-garde:<br />

The scene where Kiri was on the beach, featured guitar chords, which did not<br />

fit the mood or scenery.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!