CITIZENS
TnqFN
TnqFN
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
020 7738 2348<br />
Arts & Culture<br />
October 2015<br />
Kensington, Chelsea & Westminster Today 53<br />
online: www.KCWToday.co.uk<br />
BRICKS AND<br />
BRICKBATS<br />
BY ATRIUM<br />
Picture © Cassandra Tsolakis<br />
Celebrating<br />
five centuries of<br />
Andrea Palladio<br />
Andrea Palladio (1508-80) was<br />
the most influential Western<br />
architect of all time. The second<br />
was the Swiss-born French architect Le<br />
Corbusier (1887-1965) whose legacy is<br />
now a global phenomenon. But what<br />
unites, and what separates, these two<br />
giants, born centuries apart? The parallels<br />
are powerful and often surprising.<br />
The Renaissance architect is best<br />
known for taking the pediments of<br />
classical temples and applying them to<br />
domestic architecture, whether country<br />
villas or relatively modest farm buildings<br />
in his native Veneto region. They are<br />
symmetrical and have proportions based<br />
on the ‘golden section’. Other common<br />
features are Venetian windows (also<br />
called Serliana or Palladian) and the use<br />
of one of the classical Orders.<br />
None of these is to be found in Le<br />
Corbusier’s works, far from it. But a<br />
detailed investigation reveals more than<br />
a dozen comparisons worthy of further<br />
study, beginning with their domestic<br />
circumstances and what the latter said he<br />
learnt from the former.<br />
Palladio’s father was a miller and<br />
small-time entrepreneur, Le Corbusier’s a<br />
watchmaker. While it’s true that, just like<br />
other professions such as medicine and<br />
law, architecture tends to be hereditary it<br />
was not so in this case. Both were largely<br />
self-taught, through reading, writing and<br />
doing, though in the former’s case also<br />
through studying classical ruins at first<br />
hand.<br />
One was born Andrea di Pietro della<br />
Gondola, the other Charles-Édouard<br />
Jenneret-Gris. Palladio was a given name,<br />
after the Greek goddess of wisdom,<br />
and Corb chose his own. Both believed<br />
in the transformative power of design,<br />
and they were brilliant marketeers: both<br />
were, ultimately, more famous for what<br />
they wrote and published than for what<br />
they built. Palladio’s Quattro Libri (Four<br />
Books) was published in 1570, just 10<br />
years before his death, while Toward an<br />
Architecture, first published in 1923 and<br />
never since out of print, was a relatively<br />
early proclamation of Corb’s radical<br />
ideas, influences and early designs.<br />
Both were prolific in output, across a<br />
wide range of building types, but they are<br />
best remembered for their domestic and<br />
religious works. In a curious inversion,<br />
Corb’s latest and greatest works could be<br />
said to be religious; namely, Ronchamp<br />
Pilgrimage Church and La Tourette,<br />
even though he was agnostic, while the<br />
architect of the magnificent S Giorgio<br />
Maggiore and Il Redentore, in Venice, is<br />
better known for his houses.<br />
Both have more work finished in<br />
stucco than stonework (or concrete for<br />
that matter); both favoured white over<br />
other colours; both suffered at the hands<br />
of clients and had problems collecting<br />
their fees; both were the target of rivals<br />
and enemies; both survived into their<br />
seventies; and both had major projects<br />
completed after their respective deaths.<br />
And both gave a name to their respective<br />
movements; Palladian and Corbusian.<br />
Neither became wealthy.<br />
Where they do differ is often in their<br />
form-making, beliefs, travels and family<br />
life.<br />
For Francis Terry, architect son of<br />
contemporary neo-classicist architect<br />
Quinlan, Palladio was a “one-trick pony”.<br />
He was highly derivative of what came<br />
before him, an imitator rather than an<br />
innovator. The same could be said to a<br />
certain degree about Corb, but the latter<br />
was exceptionally clever in covering his<br />
tracks: he tended to steal other’s work,<br />
whether approaches, ideas and forms,<br />
and claim them for his own. As his<br />
friend Picasso maintained, “Bad artists<br />
copy, good artists steal”.<br />
Corb travelled widely but not<br />
Palladio; the one had strong political<br />
beliefs, fundamentally totalitarian,<br />
whether of Left or Right (Corb was<br />
accused of being both a Fascist and a<br />
Communist during his lifetime); the<br />
other religious. And while UNESCO<br />
has bestowed World Heritage status<br />
on Palladio’s output, none has so far<br />
been awarded to his later, even more<br />
prominent peer. The Fondation Le<br />
Corbusier in Paris was hoping for an<br />
accolade this year, half a century after his<br />
death, but it has yet to happen.<br />
A question that may reasonably be<br />
asked is, just how far did Le Corbusier<br />
self-consciously model himself on<br />
Palladio? In the 1930s he told us himself<br />
that his architecture was influenced<br />
“by the spirit of Palladio”. The late<br />
architecture critic, Colin Rowe, showed<br />
us how in his seminal article of 1947, The<br />
Mathematics of the Ideal Villa.<br />
This enunciated modernism’s debt to<br />
classicism, by comparing the plans and<br />
elevations of Villa Foscari (known as the<br />
Malcontenta) outside Venice, and the<br />
Villa Stein-de Monzie at Garches.<br />
Three other aspects support this theory<br />
of copying: his acquired name (and also<br />
various motifs); his prodigious literary<br />
output (knowing this would have much<br />
greater impact than just his buildings<br />
themselves); and publishing his own<br />
work alongside great works from history.<br />
There are several other tell-tale signs,<br />
such as Palladio’s decision to choose just<br />
one other near-contemporary architect to<br />
mention and publish alongside himself,<br />
namely Bramante (1444-1514); Le<br />
Corbusier ditto, but in his case Tony<br />
Garnier (1869-1948).<br />
The greatest collection of original<br />
Palladio drawings in the world is held by<br />
the RIBA Library. In a new exhibition<br />
at its headquarters in Portland Place,<br />
and open until January 2016, visitors<br />
can trace Palladio’s influence down the<br />
centuries, not just in continental Europe<br />
but the US (both the White House<br />
and the Capitol building, for example),<br />
its adoption by the English Palladians<br />
such as Inigo Jones, Lord Burlington,<br />
Colen Campbell, William Kent and Sir<br />
Edwin Lutyens; and various twentieth<br />
century abstractions, distillations and<br />
simplifications.<br />
Curators Charles Hind and Vicky<br />
Wilson have done a great service to the<br />
exhibition and Palladio’s legacy with<br />
this show. There are films, models and<br />
photographs as well as drawings; and<br />
a series of talks, events and workshops<br />
over the coming weeks.<br />
There are also various corruptions<br />
of Palladio’s ideals, for no style has ever<br />
proved so popular for contemporary<br />
houses by spec developers. His noble<br />
designs confer status on their owners.<br />
“Passion can make drama out of inert<br />
stone”, Palladio might have said it, but<br />
in fact it was Le Corbusier in his book<br />
Toward an Architecture. The “passion”<br />
and “drama” he refers to are real enough,<br />
even if the “stone” often turns out to be<br />
stucco, in the case of our Renaissance<br />
architect, or even reinforced concrete in<br />
the case of our Neo-Renaissance one.<br />
Palladian Design: The Good,<br />
the Bad and the Unexpected<br />
is at the Royal Institute of British<br />
Architects, 66 Portland Place, London<br />
W1B 1AD, until 9 January 2016.<br />
Admission free.<br />
The Architecture Gallery is open 10am-<br />
5pm Monday to Sunday and until 8pm<br />
every Tuesday.<br />
More at www.architecture.com/<br />
PalladianDesign