25.11.2015 Views

JOHN CALVIN

Calvin_Response

Calvin_Response

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

37<br />

QUESTION 21<br />

JEW: I ask you, you say that the Messiah is both divinity and humanity just as man is both flesh<br />

and spirit. But if this is true, then when the humanity is slain, the divine nature is slain. For<br />

according to your words, Jesus was both God and man, and he was slain. Therefore his divinity<br />

was slain. But if his divinity was slain, he was not God. For God cannot be not slain.<br />

<strong>CALVIN</strong>: I ask you, because all the holy fathers are dead, do they (the Jews) believe that the<br />

souls of the fathers are extinguished together with their bodies? And because Scripture says so<br />

many times that the holy ones sleep, do they believe souls to be enveloped in the same death<br />

along with bodies? Indeed, since Scripture says that Absalom was of tall stature, but that David<br />

was of short stature compared with his brothers, does it at once transfer the measure of bodies to<br />

souls?<br />

It is true what is laid out in the common saying: nothing similar is the same 23 . But these<br />

pigs so subvert all the principles of nature, that no trace of reason can be found amongst them.<br />

We say just as a soul and a body make up one man, thus Christ consists of two natures, not<br />

because the similitude agrees in every respect but because it is suitable and fit for expressing the<br />

unity of his person. As for the rest—so that we may grant what they demand—there is no logical<br />

conflict; they merely infer in a preposterous manner that the divinity of Christ was killed with<br />

his flesh. For in times past, did tyrants destroy the souls of the saints while raging against them?<br />

Did Abel perish altogether when he was struck down by Cain? But if his soul survived and was<br />

uninjured after death, the soul which was nevertheless a part of a man, how much more would<br />

the divinity of Christ have been intact in death, even if it was united with his human nature?<br />

23 The Latin phrase here translated, "nullum simile esse idem", is still used in legal contexts today.

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!