JOHN CALVIN
Calvin_Response
Calvin_Response
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
37<br />
QUESTION 21<br />
JEW: I ask you, you say that the Messiah is both divinity and humanity just as man is both flesh<br />
and spirit. But if this is true, then when the humanity is slain, the divine nature is slain. For<br />
according to your words, Jesus was both God and man, and he was slain. Therefore his divinity<br />
was slain. But if his divinity was slain, he was not God. For God cannot be not slain.<br />
<strong>CALVIN</strong>: I ask you, because all the holy fathers are dead, do they (the Jews) believe that the<br />
souls of the fathers are extinguished together with their bodies? And because Scripture says so<br />
many times that the holy ones sleep, do they believe souls to be enveloped in the same death<br />
along with bodies? Indeed, since Scripture says that Absalom was of tall stature, but that David<br />
was of short stature compared with his brothers, does it at once transfer the measure of bodies to<br />
souls?<br />
It is true what is laid out in the common saying: nothing similar is the same 23 . But these<br />
pigs so subvert all the principles of nature, that no trace of reason can be found amongst them.<br />
We say just as a soul and a body make up one man, thus Christ consists of two natures, not<br />
because the similitude agrees in every respect but because it is suitable and fit for expressing the<br />
unity of his person. As for the rest—so that we may grant what they demand—there is no logical<br />
conflict; they merely infer in a preposterous manner that the divinity of Christ was killed with<br />
his flesh. For in times past, did tyrants destroy the souls of the saints while raging against them?<br />
Did Abel perish altogether when he was struck down by Cain? But if his soul survived and was<br />
uninjured after death, the soul which was nevertheless a part of a man, how much more would<br />
the divinity of Christ have been intact in death, even if it was united with his human nature?<br />
23 The Latin phrase here translated, "nullum simile esse idem", is still used in legal contexts today.