11.03.2016 Views

ISSUES OF CONCERN

Issues_of_Concern_February_2016

Issues_of_Concern_February_2016

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

which adapts to its surroundings like any<br />

organic life. The urban setting is not<br />

amenable to the kind of observance of<br />

castes as in remote villages where one<br />

confronts its crude forms. Largely, caste<br />

remains at the level of prejudice.<br />

As stated above, the castes have<br />

been reduced to simple class like divide<br />

between Dalits and non-Dalits. Among<br />

non-Dalits it stays as cultural residue<br />

sans any ritual sense. But it is more<br />

pronounced at the classical kink in the<br />

caste continuum dividing Dalits and<br />

non-Dalits. Over the decades, Dalits<br />

have made significant progress, thanks<br />

to reservations. Although minuscule<br />

compared to their population, this class<br />

became visible in cities and towns.<br />

Urban spaces [32] are not immune to Casteism<br />

The operation of castes, however,<br />

presents a complex pattern. It is seen that<br />

the salience of castes is often associated<br />

with the material aspects. It depends<br />

upon options available. For example,<br />

in situation of supply constraints, Dalits<br />

are accepted as in the IT sector. They<br />

may, however, be marked down vis-à-vis<br />

their counterpart. The phenomenon is<br />

commonly seen in our elite institutions,<br />

where Dalit students are picked up<br />

readily but generally marked down<br />

vis-à-vis their non-Dalit counterpart. The<br />

explanatory variables to some extent are<br />

cultural attributes that the Dalit students<br />

do not reflect the class upbringing that<br />

the recruiters expect but the influence<br />

of caste also plays a part. There is<br />

a tacit association of inferiority with<br />

Dalits. These days the second and<br />

third generation Dalit students appear<br />

to perform as good as any other in<br />

admission tests. But it is commonly seen<br />

that in personal interviews they are never<br />

given good marks because of the bias that<br />

if they are given marks they deserved,<br />

they would come into open merit and<br />

deprive a general category seat. I have<br />

experienced this play of prejudice all<br />

through my career.<br />

In organizations, particularly the<br />

public sector undertakings (PSUs) where<br />

Dalits land up for security reasons, a<br />

different kind of dynamics plays out. The<br />

PSUs are monitored for their compliance<br />

with the statutory provisions for the<br />

SCs/STs in terms of numbers. As<br />

anywhere, the discrimination is often<br />

associated with other secular factors. A<br />

Dalit employee who is more pliable is<br />

preferred and elevated as a demo-piece<br />

to demonstrate non-discriminatory<br />

treatment of Dalit employees. They<br />

are used as official representatives of<br />

their caste as required by the policy to<br />

validate actions of the management. It<br />

helps management to size up assertive<br />

Dalit employees. Since a favoured Dalit<br />

employee would be extra-beholden to<br />

his managers, it serves the interests of<br />

the latter even in manipulative practices.<br />

It is simplistic therefore to talk about<br />

caste discrimination being only due to<br />

caste without reference to other factors.<br />

Caste may be understood as premium<br />

or discount over the base price. The<br />

Brahman gets a premium and Dalit gets<br />

discounted. In societal matters, it varies<br />

with the scale of economic prosperity;<br />

the upper layer facing lesser of prejudice<br />

and the bottom ones more. Many inter<br />

12 Issues Of <strong>CONCERN</strong> No. 7 February 2016

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!