15.05.2017 Views

novelistsonnovel00allo

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

THE NATURE OF PROSE FICTION<br />

article on Madame Cottin's Amelie Mansfield had already put it<br />

in 1809, novels are, after all, 'often "romantic^\ not indeed by the<br />

relation of what is obviously miraculous or impossible, but by<br />

deviating, though perhaps insensibly, beyond the bounds of<br />

probability or consistency'.^ It is with certain underlying assumptions<br />

in studies Uke Clara Reeve's The Progress of Romance,<br />

Kurd's Letters on Chivalry or Percy's and Ritson's introductions to<br />

their various anthologies, that Scott is in real disagreement and<br />

in discussing this difference he shows his usual common sense.<br />

He dissents in particular from their 'levelling proposition' that<br />

Epic and Romance belong ultimately to the same class. He<br />

recognizes, as Addison, Voltaire and Blackwell recognized before<br />

him, the irreducible difference in quality between 'the marvellous'<br />

of the earliest heroic poems and the fantasy of their<br />

successors in the romantic kind. The feeling, which was made<br />

familiar to a later age by W. P. Ker, that 'Epic' implies some<br />

weight and massiveness while 'Romance means nothing if it does<br />

not convey some notion of mystery and fantasy', ^ had been<br />

experienced by Addison: speaking of the epic's power to combine<br />

astonishment and belief, he goes on, 'if the fable is only<br />

probable, it differs nothing from a true history, if it is only marvellous,<br />

it is no better than a romance' .^ The feeling is again<br />

conveyed through Blackwell's regretful admissions that 'polishing<br />

diminishes a Language ... it coops a Man up in a Corner<br />

.'<br />

. . and that Ariosto and Tasso<br />

quitting life, betook themselves to Aerial Beings and Utopian<br />

Characters, and filled their Works with Charms and Visions, the<br />

modern Supplements of the Marvellous and the Sublime.*<br />

For similar reasons, Voltaire sets Lucian's treatment of the enenchanted<br />

wood in the Pharsalia far above Tasso's portrayal<br />

of a kindred subject in the eighteenth book of the Gerusalemme<br />

Liberata.^ Like these writers, Scott recognizes the supernatural<br />

grandeur of the epic, while responding to the pleasing appari-<br />

1 See below, pp. 49-50.<br />

2 See W. P. Ker, Epic and Romance (1897), Chapter i.<br />

3 Spectator, No. 315.<br />

* An Enquiry into the Life and Writings of Homer (1735), pp. 58-9, 68-9.<br />

'Essai sur la Poesie Epique', Chapter viii, CEuvres Completes (1883-5),<br />

Vol. VIII, pp. 343-6.<br />

16

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!