27.06.2017 Views

Change

Solutions for a better world Global Investor, 01/2017 Credit Suisse

Solutions for a better world
Global Investor, 01/2017
Credit Suisse

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Global Investor 1.17, January 2017<br />

Expert know-how for Credit Suisse investment clients<br />

INVESTMENT SOLUTIONS & PRODUCTS<br />

<strong>Change</strong><br />

Solutions for a better world<br />

Yoshiyuki Sankai Asimov was right: how robots can help to ensure<br />

a better future. Fabian Waltert Looking for a housing solution?<br />

Think small. No, smaller. Uwe Neumann The advent of digital farming.<br />

Henry Siu Redistribution between generations binds society together.


Important information and disclosures are found in the Disclosure appendix<br />

CS does and seeks to do business with companies covered in its research reports.<br />

As a result, investors should be aware that CS may have a conflict of interest that<br />

could affect the objectivity of this report. Investors should consider this report as only<br />

a single factor in making their investment decision. For a discussion of the risks<br />

of investing in the securities mentioned in this report, please refer to<br />

the following Internet link: https://research.credit-suisse.com/riskdisclosure.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —03<br />

Responsible for coordinating<br />

the focus themes in this issue<br />

CHRISTINE SCHMID is Head of Global<br />

Equity & Credit Research at Credit<br />

Suisse International Wealth Management.<br />

She has 23 years of experience and<br />

covers the financials sector. She holds an<br />

MA in Economics from the University<br />

of Zurich and is a CFA Charterholder.<br />

RETO HESS is a senior research<br />

analyst at Credit Suisse International<br />

Wealth Management with 12 years<br />

of experience in equity research and<br />

investment management. He heads the<br />

Global Equity Research team and<br />

covers the European and US industrials<br />

sector. Further, Reto is a CFA and<br />

CAIA Charterholder and holds a Master of<br />

Science from the University of Zurich,<br />

Switzerland.<br />

Photo: Steve Vidler / Alamy Stock Foto; Illustration: Martin Mörck<br />

UWE NEUMANN is a senior research<br />

analyst in the Global Equity & Credit<br />

Research team at Credit Suisse International<br />

Wealth Management, covering<br />

the telecom and technology sectors.<br />

He has 29 years of experience in the<br />

securities and banking business, holds<br />

a Master of Economics from the University<br />

of Constance, Germany, and is a CEFA<br />

Charterholder.<br />

The majority of citizens in today’s Western democracies are concerned,<br />

and even fearful, about the effects of globalization, digitization<br />

and a rapidly aging society. A desire for deglobalization and multipolarity<br />

and a determination to “put one’s own country first” have<br />

come into sharp focus. Well-educated white-collar workers – the<br />

middle class – see themselves at risk of losing their job as digitization<br />

progresses. Moreover, aging populations in most countries are likely<br />

to place an immense burden on healthcare, social and pension<br />

systems in the future. Global central banks’ very accommodative monetary<br />

policy has already weakened social and pension systems, putting<br />

pressure on future expected income.<br />

The prosperity that has been achieved since the middle of the last<br />

century is built on a generational contract which, given today’s challenges,<br />

needs to be redefined. Education for the young is still funded<br />

by the older generations, but the required skill set for today’s job market<br />

and that of the future will force us to rethink our education system<br />

to better align it with the changed environment. Pension systems<br />

and social systems were built on assumptions of infinite economic<br />

growth, but global resources are finite. Thus, the new generational<br />

contract must be based on the premise of ensuring a sustainable<br />

economy.<br />

These changes open up business opportunities for companies and<br />

sectors alike, with the economy serving as a solution provider, and<br />

policy makers pushing for a framework that allows everyone to prosper.<br />

Consumers drive success through demand and spending.<br />

A number of sectors are poised to deliver pioneering solutions for<br />

the future. Healthcare is at the dawn of a wave of innovation as advances<br />

in digital means allow for more efficient and tailor-made treatments.<br />

Data produced and used for the good of society can further<br />

improve our lives. Mobility 2.0 is on the horizon, and blockchain technology<br />

is set to revolutionize contracts and trade platforms by establishing<br />

a new environment of trust.<br />

This issue of GI features our thoughts and expectations regarding<br />

these developments. I hope you enjoy the read!<br />

Christine Schmid, Head of Global Equity & Credit Research


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —05<br />

Contents<br />

Global Investor 1.17<br />

Collages in this issue<br />

Map<br />

The world today is in<br />

rapid flux. Technology,<br />

demographics and<br />

globalization keep people<br />

and jobs on the move.<br />

This ferment is giving rise<br />

to new ideas and ways<br />

of thinking about how we<br />

live and work.<br />

06<br />

Prosperity is a two-way street<br />

Finding ways to evolve and improve the<br />

intergenerational contract is key to ensuring<br />

a cohesive society, writes Henry Siu.<br />

13<br />

When I’m sixty-four<br />

Economists Yikai Wang and Martin Eichler<br />

reflect on issues affecting the<br />

pension systems in China and Switzerland,<br />

respectively.<br />

17<br />

Cyborgs made for walking<br />

Don’t just focus on building robots, says<br />

roboticist Yoshiyuki Sankai. Instead,<br />

think about the problems you want to solve.<br />

21<br />

Reshaping patient care by bits<br />

The healthcare industry has traditionally<br />

been slow to embrace digital health, writes<br />

Lorenzo Biasio. This time, it’s different.<br />

25<br />

The Internet –<br />

our friend and caretaker<br />

Don’t let visions of Orwellian dystopias<br />

put you off connectivity, argues Uwe<br />

Neumann. The Internet has a caring side.<br />

29<br />

The dark side of digitization<br />

Cyber risk is the price you pay for an open<br />

cyber society. It also spells opportunity<br />

for the IT security industry. Ulrich Kaiser<br />

explains.<br />

31<br />

The age of cryptofinance<br />

Democracy is finally coming to finance<br />

in the shape of digital cash, says<br />

Johann Gevers of Monetas, and it will<br />

boost the global economy.<br />

35<br />

Putting a roof over your head<br />

Forget about your home being a castle.<br />

Fabian Waltert takes a look at housing<br />

trends, and discovers that sharing is the<br />

name of the game.<br />

41<br />

Labor in the new millennium<br />

In today’s job market, the right employee<br />

may well not meet your ideal profile, says<br />

Randstad CEO Jacques van den Broek.<br />

44<br />

Young and car-free<br />

Driving is losing its cachet among<br />

young people in industrialized countries.<br />

Julia Dumanskaya examines the<br />

reasons why.<br />

46<br />

Millennials drive sustainability<br />

Sustainability is a key concern for<br />

millennials, writes Julie Saussier, and it’s<br />

leading companies to adapt production<br />

processes.<br />

48<br />

Farmer CTOs<br />

The arrival of digital agriculture is<br />

thrusting farmers into the role of chief<br />

technology officers. Uwe Neumann<br />

surveys a surprising new landscape.<br />

Disclaimer > Page 52<br />

The six illustrations by Vincent Poinas<br />

creatively evoke some of the issues<br />

at the heart of the current conflicts between<br />

generations, including sustainability,<br />

pensions, healthcare, privacy and robotics.<br />

For more on the artist, see p. 54.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —06<br />

Photo: Kamil Bialous<br />

According to economist Henry Siu, the cohesiveness of society depends on its willingness to distribute resources among generations.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —07<br />

Prosperity<br />

is a<br />

two-way<br />

street<br />

Given the dramatic changes that population aging, globalization and technological<br />

progress have brought to society, there is renewed discussion on how the<br />

intergenerational contract should evolve and improve. By doing so, we reaffirm our<br />

belief in a cohesive society and the value of taking care of those most in need.<br />

TEXT HENRY SIU<br />

n intergenerational contract is an agreement made by<br />

society to transfer resources between individuals who<br />

are at different stages of life. In almost all instances, this<br />

takes the form of transfers from those of working age,<br />

to senior citizens (who have left the workforce) and the young (who<br />

have not yet entered it). Intergenerational contracts need not be codified<br />

by law, and in most times and places in the history of humanity,<br />

they have been informal in nature. Perhaps the most obvious example<br />

we see today is the multigenerational household. The parents provide<br />

income, food, and shelter, as well as their time and care to their children<br />

and their own parents, the grandparents. Grandparents benefit from<br />

these transfers and, in turn, help in the care of the children, utilizing<br />

the time and accumulated wisdom they have at their disposal. The<br />

children in the household receive transfers with no cost to their present<br />

selves (except, maybe having to clean their rooms and take out<br />

the garbage). However, the implicit understanding – the contract – is<br />

that they will provide the same transfers to their parents and children<br />

when they become working-aged themselves.<br />

Of course, intergenerational contracts also take more explicit<br />

forms, codified broadly as social security systems, administered >


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —08<br />

by governments in most countries around the world. Perhaps the<br />

most prominent example is that of state-funded pension programs,<br />

providing transfers and benefits to the retirement-aged. In industrialized<br />

economies, these programs have become increasingly burdened<br />

due to falling birthrates, increased life expectancy, and, in some<br />

cases, poor budgeting and underfunding. For instance, in the United<br />

States, the most recent Social Security Administration Trustees Report<br />

indicates that the program ran a USD 6 trillion deficit in 2016; that’s<br />

almost USD 20,000 for every man, woman and child living in the USA.<br />

“Human capital<br />

is the skill and<br />

knowledge upon<br />

which working-aged<br />

earnings are based.”<br />

Forecasting into the future and accounting for the present value of<br />

all future benefits and taxes, the system is currently USD 32 trillion<br />

in deficit. While presently in less dire circumstances, Switzerland is<br />

engaged in its Retirement 2020 reform to their state pension system.<br />

This is in anticipation of the rise in their dependency ratio. Currently<br />

there are about 30 people aged 65 and over drawing from the pension<br />

system for every one hundred 20–64-year-olds contributing to<br />

it; but by 2060, this figure will nearly double to about 55 taking out<br />

for every 100 paying in.<br />

Equally – if not more – important in the intergenerational contract<br />

is the transfers made to the young via publicly funded education and<br />

healthcare. These matter because education and health investments<br />

are the means by which societies create human capital. Human capital<br />

is the skill and knowledge upon which working-aged earnings are<br />

based, and is perhaps the prime determinant of the size of a society’s<br />

economic pie and social well-being. In certain places, these systems<br />

are failing to provide enough investment for the young.<br />

Redefining the contract<br />

Against this backdrop, and given the dramatic changes that globalization<br />

and technological progress have brought about, there is renewed<br />

discussion on how the intergenerational contract should evolve,<br />

what should be changed, and how it can be improved to better suit<br />

the 21st century. But informed discussion requires a fundamental understanding<br />

of its place in society. What role does it serve to transfer<br />

resources to and from people at different points in their life?<br />

Fundamentally, the intergenerational contract is about redistribution<br />

between generations. It makes sense for society to codify and<br />

administer this redistribution given that we feel that those who are in<br />

need deserve to have more, and those that have more can do with a<br />

bit less. So how should we conceptualize the intergenerational contract,<br />

so that we can evaluate whether such a contract is desirable,<br />

fair and working for the greater good of society?<br />

A useful way to understand the contract is as a form of social insurance<br />

across generations. Other forms of social insurance, like social<br />

assistance and welfare programs, do not depend on one’s stage in<br />

life. The desirability of insurance that crosses generations becomes<br />

obvious when we realize that many aspects of our working lives are<br />

like a giant game of roulette, except that the odds are actually stacked<br />

in our favor. Most of us will be relatively lucky and do just fine: we’ll<br />

have meaningful careers that pay well and steady work with few, short<br />

spells of unemployment. This will allow us to enjoy a comfortable life<br />

in retirement. But a small number of us will be unlucky during our<br />

working years and suffer the consequences of disability, stints of<br />

long-term unemployment, the loss of a vocation or the obsolescence<br />

of skill that we spent decades learning and investing in. These sorts<br />

of events lead to difficulties in old age.<br />

Social insurance for the elderly<br />

This is precisely the sort of negative outcome that social security is<br />

meant to guard against. In fact, in many countries, this objective is<br />

stated directly in the name of the program. In both the United States<br />

and Switzerland, the social security program is called (or translated<br />

as) Old-Age, Survivors and Disability Insurance; in Germany, it is<br />

called the State Pension Insurance. Insurance programs are those<br />

that we pay into in good times and claim benefits from, if and when<br />

we are hit by negative shocks.<br />

But in the past 50 or 60 years, social security has evolved from<br />

insurance programs to largely become publicly funded pension or retirement<br />

benefit plans that all are entitled to draw from. But none of<br />

us feel entitled to draw upon our auto insurance on days when we<br />

don’t get in a car accident, or to draw unemployment benefits when<br />

we are working. Given this, why should we all receive old-age security<br />

simply because we are past the age of eligibility, especially those<br />

of us who have had the fortune of successful careers working in wellpaying<br />

jobs? Retirement saving is equally well performed by ourselves<br />

on an individual basis; it is unclear why it should be done by transferring<br />

income from one generation to the next. Therefore, an important<br />

question to be addressed is whether government-sponsored, old-age<br />

social security should be reserved for, and thereby made more generous<br />

to, those truly in need.<br />

This is made especially pressing given the dramatic labor market<br />

changes the global economy has experienced in the past 30 years.<br />

With advances in robotics, information and communication technology,<br />

and computing power, automation has made obsolete the accumulated<br />

skills of a wide swath of the population nearing retirement<br />

age. Advances in machine learning and artificial intelligence threaten<br />

to erode the value of knowledge and skills in which an ever-increasing<br />

number of highly educated workers have invested. Prioritization<br />

of old-age insurance should be given to those who have experienced<br />

these outcomes during their working careers. And because of the inherent<br />

uncertainty of longevity, it should also benefit those that have<br />

been unlucky enough to live longer than expected when they made<br />

their retirement savings decisions.<br />

Social insurance for the young<br />

To the extent that the outcome of one’s working career and end of<br />

life is a gamble, it is swamped by a much bigger risk factor determining<br />

lifetime well-being: the lottery of birth. This is a concept that has<br />

been discussed at least since the time of the 18th century by philosopher<br />

Jean-Jacques Rousseau, and in our times by the philosopher


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —09<br />

John Rawls and philanthropist Warren Buffett. The idea of course is<br />

simple: prior to birth, we have no choice as to whether we are born<br />

with ability or disability, into a rich family or poor one, or into a society<br />

that values basic human rights or not. A lottery determines whether<br />

we enter life into a circumstance of ability and opportunity, so the<br />

foundational building blocks of success and fortune are determined<br />

by pure luck.<br />

Viewed this way, it is decidedly compelling that the intergenerational<br />

contract should transfer resources to the young in order to provide<br />

insurance against poor early-life outcomes. The most important<br />

way we can do this is through fair and effective publicly funded education.<br />

Formal education systems can never fully undo all of the disadvantages<br />

that may befall someone at birth. However, public education<br />

should do its best to redistribute to those in need and help to<br />

even the playing field at life’s outset. At the very least, it should not<br />

magnify the unequal outcomes of the birth lottery. But in some places<br />

around the world this is what happens. Perhaps an instructive<br />

example is the United States where public education funding is determined<br />

disproportionately by the local tax base: spending is higher<br />

in rich suburbs and much lower in rural and inner-city settings. This<br />

magnifies inequality. In a 2015 report issued by the Education Law<br />

Center, only four states out of 50 (Minnesota, Massachusetts, New<br />

Jersey and Delaware) received a rating “fair.”<br />

“Fundamentally,<br />

the intergenerational<br />

contract is about<br />

redistribution<br />

between generations.”<br />

Of course, the USA is not alone. Every three years, the OECD conducts<br />

the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA),<br />

a survey intended to evaluate education systems worldwide. The most<br />

recent information (as of this writing) is available for 2012. According<br />

to the PISA, in countries as diverse as Turkey, the United Kingdom<br />

and Austria, student-teacher ratios are tilted in favor of socioeconomically<br />

advantaged schools compared with disadvantaged schools.<br />

This is in contrast to places like Belgium and the Netherlands where<br />

the student-teacher ratio is used to mitigate socioeconomic disadvantage.<br />

In this respect, lessons can be drawn from Germany’s recent experience.<br />

Between 2003 and 2012, Germany was successful in reducing<br />

inequality among students’ PISA test scores and simultaneously<br />

increasing average performance. While causality is hard to<br />

establish, many believe the gains were in large part achieved by providing<br />

school-based support and targeting the most disadvantaged<br />

students, oftentimes immigrants and the children of immigrants. This<br />

targeting of benefits is precisely in the spirit of redistributing to those<br />

most in need, those disadvantaged by being born in places and ><br />

Henry Siu<br />

is an associate professor in the<br />

Vancouver School of Economics at<br />

the University of British Columbia.<br />

His research focuses on issues<br />

related to labor and macroeconomics<br />

such as automation and the decline<br />

of middle-class jobs, recessions<br />

and jobless recoveries, and youth<br />

unemployment.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —10<br />

Photo: Vorname Name/Agentur


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —11<br />

“The climate deficit the global<br />

community is running on a perpetual<br />

basis is simply stripping resources<br />

from our children and grandchildren<br />

for our own benefit.”<br />

circumstances lacking for opportunity. This principal of inclusiveness<br />

is also fundamental to providing fair educational opportunities at the<br />

university level. Initiatives such as the Erasmus programe of the European<br />

Union and the establishment of uniform tuition fees for EU<br />

students fosters equality of access to human capital investment and<br />

generates mobility across borders within a cohesive society. If not for<br />

social insurance motives, these objectives are valuable and worthy in<br />

their own right.<br />

Social insurance for current and future generations<br />

Finally, an integral part of an evolved intergenerational contract must<br />

include action on climate change. Though much of this discussion<br />

has centered on redistribution for insurance purposes from the lucky<br />

to unlucky, a more basic priority should be fairness across generations.<br />

Accumulating unfunded social security liabilities, coupled with<br />

political inaction is, quite simply, a transfer from future generations<br />

to current and past ones, without regard for need or disadvantage. In<br />

the same way, the climate deficit the global community is running on<br />

a perpetual basis is simply stripping resources from our children and<br />

grandchildren for our own benefit. This violates the basic proposition<br />

that the intergenerational contract should not be benefiting the welloff.<br />

As policy makers we have the tools to curb greenhouse gas emissions.<br />

At a minimum, greenhouse gas-emitting activities should be<br />

taxed. This provides incentives for reducing such harmful activities<br />

and developing more socially responsible energy sources. An even<br />

more equitable solution would be to redistribute these tax receipts to<br />

future generations, transferring resources in the right direction.<br />

Moving forward, our intergenerational contract should evolve to ensure<br />

transfers are made to those who need it most, including our<br />

seniors, our children and future generations who have and will face<br />

misfortune. Prioritizing those in need helps ensure the long-term sustainability<br />

of our social insurance programs and our societies.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —12<br />

><br />

Photo: Vorname Name/Agentur


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —13<br />

Photo: Sigrid Bjorbekkmo<br />

Pensions<br />

When I’m<br />

sixty-four<br />

Old-age pensions are an entitlement in many countries around the<br />

world. But aging populations make it more difficult to finance<br />

these systems. We look at solutions to the pension question in<br />

two very different countries: China and Switzerland.<br />

INTERVIEW BY GISELLE WEISS, freelance writer<br />

Yikai Wang<br />

is an assistant professor in the<br />

Department of Economics at the University<br />

of Oslo, specializing in quantitative<br />

macroeconomics and the Chinese<br />

economy. He received his PhD in Economics<br />

from the University of Zurich in<br />

2014. From 2011 to 2012, he was a<br />

visiting scholar at the Massachusetts<br />

Institute of Technology.<br />

Even in industrialized countries,<br />

guaranteeing pensions is no<br />

easy matter. China is a devel oping<br />

country with a huge and rapidly<br />

aging population. How is it addressing<br />

the issue of retirement income?<br />

Giselle Weiss: Do the Chinese think<br />

in terms of baby boomers and millennials<br />

and so forth?<br />

Yikai Wang Actually, my generation is<br />

known as the “after 1980s.” Because we<br />

were born after the market reform, we never<br />

lived in a planned economy. And we were<br />

the first generation to really be restricted by<br />

the one-child policy, which became quite<br />

tight after the 1980s. We had cousins to<br />

play with, not siblings. So we think a little<br />

differently from previous generations.<br />

In 2012, you and your colleagues wrote<br />

a paper on Chinese pension problems that<br />

got picked up by the “Economist” magazine.<br />

What was that about?<br />

Yikai Wang We were interested in<br />

two questions. First, the replacement rate<br />

for Chinese retirees – the percentage<br />

of pre-retirement income that is paid out as<br />

pension – is quite high. How sustainable<br />

is the current pension system? And, second,<br />

because Chinese incomes have been<br />

growing very fast, older generations are<br />

poorer than future generations will be. What<br />

amount of intergenerational transfer – i.e.,<br />

using the contributions of younger workers to<br />

fund current retirees – will improve the<br />

welfare of the older generations without<br />

hurting future younger generations?<br />

Very-fast-growing income sounds like a<br />

good thing.<br />

Yikai Wang For the older generations,<br />

though, it isn’t necessarily. Take someone<br />

who entered the Chinese labor market in<br />

1970 and someone who entered it in 2000.<br />

During those 30 years, wages grew at 6%<br />

per year on average. Which means that a<br />

person who entered the market in 2000 can<br />

expect to earn six times as much as the<br />

person who entered the market in 1970.<br />

Moreover, traditionally, most older<br />

generations just put their money in a bank,<br />

and they had little to begin with.<br />

What percentage of the population<br />

in China can expect a pension?<br />

Yikai Wang Broadly speaking, only<br />

urban workers are covered by the pension<br />

system, and of those workers, only 60%<br />

participate. The system isn’t compulsory.<br />

There’s basically no pensions in the rural<br />

areas, which since the end of the planned<br />

economy in 1978 have officially been<br />

responsible for taking care of themselves.<br />

What do old people in the rural areas do?<br />

Yikai Wang They rely primarily on<br />

support from their children, who work in<br />

urban areas. We actually wrote a follow-up<br />

to our paper in which we hypothesized how<br />

a universal pension system that includes<br />

the rural areas might not be a major burden<br />

because worker income there is so low.<br />

What makes the pension<br />

situation in China so acute?<br />

Yikai Wang The Chinese population is<br />

aging very, very fast. For example, right<br />

now, the old-age dependency ratio – the ratio<br />

of old to young – is a bit more than 0.1.<br />

It will take China only 40 years, say until<br />

around 2055, for the old-age dependency<br />

ratio to increase to 0.5. That means one<br />

senior for every two working-age persons in<br />

China. And that’s if you compare the over-<br />

65 population with the under-65 population.<br />

A second factor is that there is a huge<br />

movement of young people to the cities.<br />

That slows down the aging problem in the<br />

urban areas, but it aggravates it in the countryside.<br />

By one measure that we used,<br />

there will be 1.6 seniors for each workingage<br />

person in rural China by 2050.<br />

If the government is worried about<br />

the sustainability of the pension system,<br />

wouldn’t it make more sense for the<br />

system to be mandatory?<br />

>


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —14<br />

“Broadly speaking, only urban workers<br />

are covered by the pension system,<br />

and of those workers, only 60% participate.”<br />

Yikai Wang<br />

Yikai Wang To do that, you have to first<br />

be able to check and enforce contributions,<br />

which isn’t easy in developing countries with<br />

large populations. Moreover, China has<br />

many small firms and self-employed workers,<br />

which makes collecting pension contributions<br />

even harder. Second, the timing has<br />

to be right. For example, the US introduced<br />

social security after the Great Depression.<br />

Many European countries set up their<br />

systems after World War II. In the current<br />

climate in China, a law mandating pensions<br />

would be unlikely to pass.<br />

So how do you increase voluntary<br />

participation in the system?<br />

Yikai Wang One reason many private<br />

workers do not participate is because their<br />

employers don’t want to (workers contribute<br />

8% to the system, and employers 20%).<br />

Employers would rather pay workers extra<br />

than contribute to the pension system.<br />

Here, economic incentives might help, as<br />

would making the system a little more<br />

compulsory. Right now, the discussion is<br />

tending toward changing the form of the<br />

pension system itself.<br />

You and your colleagues have proposed<br />

a different recommendation for funding the<br />

pension system than the government has.<br />

Yikai Wang Yes. Because the government<br />

is focusing on the financial sustainability<br />

of the system, it wants to move to a<br />

system in which there is little intergenerational<br />

transfer and everyone relies on their<br />

own contributions. But we think that keeping<br />

an element of intergenerational transfer –<br />

similar to the current pay-as-you-go system<br />

in most continental European and Scandinavian<br />

countries – is important. This would<br />

ensure that the current old persons will<br />

receive a decent pension.<br />

And the sustainability issue?<br />

Yikai Wang It can be solved using other<br />

measures. For example, extending the<br />

retirement age, which at present is still 60<br />

for men and 50 for women. Or reducing the<br />

replacement rate for future generations,<br />

since they will be richer overall.<br />

Among Western industrialized countries,<br />

Switzerland stands out as a model of prosperity<br />

and innovation. But the challenges to the pension<br />

system that it faces are typical.<br />

Giselle Weiss: In 2012, BAK Basel projected in a report to the Swiss<br />

Federal Department of Home Affairs that the old-age dependency<br />

ratio in Switzerland would increase from 29% (at the time of<br />

the report) to 56% by 2060. What is the significance of that figure?<br />

Martin Eichler The old-age dependency ratio tells you how<br />

many working-age people are available to finance one retired<br />

person. This ratio will increase substantially over the next 20 or 30<br />

years: more retirees and fewer people to finance them than<br />

today. And that’s only the financial side. There are also political and<br />

societal consequences of the growing weight of pensioners.<br />

How does Switzerland’s old-age dependency ratio compare with<br />

those of other countries?<br />

Martin Eichler Switzerland is fairly typical of modern Western<br />

industrial economies. The number of retirees is projected to increase<br />

substantially in all these economies. Within Western Europe,<br />

Switzerland is actually slightly better positioned than most countries<br />

today – particularly due to immigration. And we expect that to<br />

continue in the future.<br />

How would you characterize the state of the Swiss pension system?<br />

Martin Eichler The Swiss system is based on three pillars<br />

for stability. Each pillar has advantages and disadvantages. The payas-you-go<br />

part of the system – the AHV – is vulnerable to unbalanced<br />

population developments. The second pillar (BVG), which is a<br />

capital-based system, is less vulnerable to these changes. However,<br />

it is susceptible to financial market fluctuations, which we are seeing<br />

at present. As the time horizon of a pension system is 60 years<br />

or more, you can see how having a mix of pillars is well suited to a<br />

range of eventualities.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —15<br />

What are the main challenges to<br />

the system?<br />

Martin Eichler Apart from the stress on<br />

the financial markets in the short term, the<br />

main challenge at the moment is a convergence<br />

of three different factors. The first<br />

is baby boomers, who are now approaching<br />

retirement. The burden they represent is<br />

temporary (although it will last for about 30<br />

years), but it’s substantial. And it’s particularly<br />

hard for the AHV system, the payas-you-go<br />

part. Initially, the baby boomers<br />

put more money into the system than they<br />

took out, which actually was a double-edged<br />

sword in the sense that it masked other<br />

challenges to the system.<br />

Such as …?<br />

Martin Eichler Despite Switzerland’s<br />

high level of immigration, we are facing a<br />

declining population. At the moment, the<br />

population is still rising, but at a fast dropping<br />

rate. Our birthrate is substantially<br />

below the 2.1 children needed to maintain<br />

the size of the population. Already in the<br />

medium term, all the projections point to a<br />

declining population. It may take 10 or<br />

15 more years, depending on migration, until<br />

we reach the tipping point. But it will certainly<br />

happen. To illustrate the problem:<br />

according to a back-of-the-envelope calculation,<br />

it would take about 100,000 additional<br />

net migrants every year of 20-year-old people<br />

to keep the old-age dependency ratio stable.<br />

That would be politically impossible,<br />

wouldn’t it?<br />

Martin Eichler Yes. It means more than<br />

doubling net migration every year. It’s also<br />

very difficult to attract that many people.<br />

Remember that other countries around us<br />

are also facing declining populations as well.<br />

In any event, it’s not a solution. Migration<br />

can help, but it’s not enough to solve the<br />

problem.<br />

And the third challenge?<br />

Martin Eichler Increasing life expectancy.<br />

Not only are we getting older, we’re<br />

also healthier and stronger. That’s great,<br />

but it puts pressure on the pension system<br />

in that pensions are paid out for longer.<br />

What role does the low-interest-rate<br />

environment play in the challenges to the<br />

pension system?<br />

Martin Eichler It’s difficult, of course,<br />

especially for the capital-based pillar.<br />

But we see that as a temporary effect. It<br />

might well last for another few years;<br />

however, we do expect the situation to<br />

normalize at some point.<br />

Martin Eichler<br />

is chief economist and member of the<br />

board of directors of BAK Basel<br />

Economics AG. He heads up BAK Basel’s<br />

analysis and forecasting, and consults<br />

both within Switzerland and abroad.<br />

He studied Economics at the University<br />

of Constance, Germany, and at the<br />

University of Western Ontario, Canada.<br />

“Particularly for millennials<br />

and other younger<br />

generations, the question<br />

is how long we wait to<br />

react. The longer we wait,<br />

the harder it will hit!”<br />

Martin Eichler<br />

So what is to be done?<br />

Martin Eichler Particularly for millennials<br />

and other younger generations,<br />

the question is how long we wait to react.<br />

The longer we wait, the harder it will hit! We<br />

do need migration to cover some of the<br />

stress in the system, and higher contributions<br />

to social security are inevitable. Furthermore,<br />

I believe that at some point we will have to<br />

increase the pension age in Switzerland. With<br />

a mix of actions the system can be saved<br />

if we – including the citizens, who will have to<br />

vote on it – want to save it.<br />

What impact do you expect the<br />

changing nature of work to have on<br />

the pension system?<br />

Martin Eichler With less stable kinds of<br />

employment, longer periods of education<br />

or self-employment for example, we probably<br />

need more flexibility, especially with<br />

the employer-backed second pillar. We need<br />

to ensure that different parts of a working<br />

life add up to a substantial pension without<br />

too many holes. But that doesn’t require<br />

a completely new system. I’m convinced that<br />

it can be achieved.<br />

Additional<br />

details<br />

on our map


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —16


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —17<br />

Robotics<br />

Cyborgs made<br />

for walking<br />

Dr. Yoshiyuki Sankai, the founder and CEO of Japanese robotics company CYBERDYNE,<br />

talked to Angus Muirhead, Senior Fund Manager for the Credit Suisse (Lux) Global Robotics Equity<br />

Fund, about robotics, their medical robot suit “HAL” and his vision of an automated future.<br />

INTERVIEW BY ANGUS MUIRHEAD, Credit Suisse<br />

Angus Muirhead: Where did your journey<br />

into robotics start? What first inspired you?<br />

Yoshiyuki Sankai In third grade, my fate<br />

was decided when my mother bought me<br />

the science fiction novel “I, ROBOT” by<br />

Isaac Asimov. From that point on I decided<br />

in my heart that I wanted to invent things<br />

that would bring people great happiness.<br />

In the novel, Asimov talks about three laws<br />

of robotics, the first of which made a great<br />

impression on me: “Robots must not hurt<br />

human beings.” So all through my childhood,<br />

I dreamed of science and robotics and began<br />

creating my own experiments. In my<br />

school graduation paper titled “ 夢 ” (“yume” =<br />

dream), I wrote: “When I grow up I want to<br />

be a scientist and I want to invent and build<br />

a robot in my lab.”<br />

Tell me a little bit about your medical-use<br />

robot “HAL”<br />

Yoshiyuki Sankai Well, HAL is the<br />

world’s first therapeutic robotic device to<br />

be covered by public health insurance. It is<br />

designed as a robot suit to be worn by<br />

people who are unable to move freely due<br />

to disease or aging, to help them to<br />

walk and assist in therapeutic treatment. Our<br />

technology enables the system to pick up<br />

the neural signals sent from the brain down<br />

to the lower limbs and to respond mechani-<br />

cally as the leg muscles should do. There<br />

are other use cases for HAL, but this<br />

medical use case is our most commercially<br />

advanced application.<br />

And what makes HAL different to similar<br />

systems being developed?<br />

Yoshiyuki Sankai HAL is unique in that<br />

it is the only robot in the world to be approved<br />

for therapeutic medical use. In other<br />

systems, when the exoskeleton moves,<br />

it simply pulls or carries the patient’s limbs<br />

with it, without direct interaction with the<br />

patients’ nervous system. In HAL’s case,<br />

the movement is initiated directly by signals<br />

from the human brain and the resulting motion<br />

is fed back to the brain via the nervous<br />

system. By reconnecting this continuous<br />

feedback loop, there is evidence to suggest<br />

that patients are starting to experience<br />

therapeutic benefit.<br />

So the HAL system is now approved in<br />

Japan and the EU?<br />

Yoshiyuki Sankai Yes. Already ten<br />

years ago, back in 2006, we started clinical<br />

research to prepare for the commercialization<br />

of the prototype HAL as a medical therapeutic<br />

device for the Japanese market.<br />

Then we leased HAL systems to a number<br />

of hospitals and clinics and, using the data<br />

gathered from these real-world patient tests,<br />

we received approval for use as a medical<br />

device in November 2015. Then, in September<br />

2016, the first commercial healthcare<br />

medical treatments using HAL finally started.<br />

In the process of getting HAL approved<br />

as a medical device in Japan and the EU,<br />

we formulated a number of rules for the<br />

definition and use of medical robots.<br />

We have now established a number of ISOapproved<br />

standards.<br />

Since you first introduced HAL almost a<br />

decade ago, the level of sophistication<br />

has increased tremendously. What<br />

technology changes in the last few years<br />

have enabled these rapid advances?<br />

Yoshiyuki Sankai In the first decade,<br />

the HAL system was a development project<br />

at the University of Tsukuba. Then, since<br />

2004 when we founded CYBERDYNE,<br />

we have taken HAL through an extremely<br />

advanced and innovative development<br />

process to arrive at the robotic therapeutic<br />

treatment device we have today.<br />

What are the key technology challenges you<br />

face today in developing robotics?<br />

Yoshiyuki Sankai There is a long way to<br />

go before the technology that might allow<br />

people and robots and digital data to function<br />

seamlessly together becomes accessible<br />

and applicable to more areas of our >


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —18<br />

“The future will be shaped<br />

by what kind of technologies<br />

are developed.”<br />

Yoshiyuki Sankai<br />

Yoshiyuki Sankai<br />

is CEO and founder of robotics company<br />

CYBERDYNE Inc. He is Professor at the<br />

Institute of Systems and Engineering at<br />

Tsukuba University and visiting Professor<br />

of Baylor College of Medicine, Texas.<br />

He has won a number of awards including<br />

the World Technology Award and<br />

Entrepreneur of the Year Award Japan.<br />

daily lives. I think focusing on developing<br />

robots is the wrong starting point. The<br />

focal point should be to think about what<br />

problems we face and what we need to<br />

do to solve specific problems or provide a<br />

specific benefit. With this goal, I believe<br />

CYBERDYNE has already successfully<br />

pushed into an area of technology that no<br />

one else has really touched, and we feel<br />

compelled to follow the course further, even<br />

if it takes us into areas where we currently<br />

have little expertise.<br />

What do you imagine will be achievable in<br />

robotics in the future?<br />

Yoshiyuki Sankai CYBERDYNE will<br />

continue to focus on the use of robotics<br />

beyond traditional industrial robots, in areas<br />

such as lifestyle, healthcare, entertainment,<br />

education and communications. As well<br />

as the therapeutic uses, there are also other<br />

applications of the HAL technology, such<br />

as HAL used by able-bodied people in nursing<br />

homes and on construction sites or in<br />

logistics to enable them to lift heavy objects<br />

or to carry patients from their bed to the<br />

bathroom, for example. Today, you will also<br />

find some of our other robots equipped<br />

with artificial intelligence at Tokyo’s Haneda<br />

Airport being used for cleaning and transport<br />

and logistics.<br />

And how do you think society will benefit<br />

from the advances in robotics?<br />

Yoshiyuki Sankai Robots equipped with<br />

artificial intelligence could become hugely<br />

valuable to our society, as we are living<br />

longer, but at the same time are seeing a<br />

fairly low birthrate. For example, we might<br />

well have robots do our shopping. Furthermore,<br />

it’s also conceivable that there might<br />

be various other robots for the elderly or<br />

infirm to improve mobility, to help people<br />

to wash and bathe and to stay in touch with<br />

relatives and caregivers. In fact, a new<br />

concept which I am developing is to build a<br />

“Cybernic City” incorporating all these<br />

robotic technologies. With this goal in mind,<br />

we have acquired a large piece of land<br />

in Tsukuba City near CYBERDYNE’s headquarters<br />

and are cooperating and developing<br />

partnerships with a large number of<br />

companies and organizations.<br />

Several technologists have voiced concerns<br />

about the risks of developing powerful<br />

artificial intelligence. Do you think these<br />

concerns are warranted?<br />

Yoshiyuki Sankai In the future, it will be<br />

extremely important that we focus on the<br />

human perspective and the ethics of society.<br />

The future will be shaped by what kind of<br />

technologies are developed and how they<br />

are used, and that is why it’s important<br />

to design technology that offers benefits to<br />

society and with the vision of a better<br />

future in mind.<br />

Additional<br />

details<br />

on our map


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —19<br />

What’s HAL?<br />

HAL (Hybrid Assistive Limb) is the world’s first cyborg-type robot which enables the fusion of “man” with “machine” and “information.”<br />

When a person wears HAL, the system assists, supports and even augments their physical movement, and over time may accelerate and repair a patient’s<br />

damaged cerebral nerves. Source: CYBERDYNE<br />

01 THINK<br />

02 SEND<br />

03 READ<br />

04 MOVE<br />

05 LEARN<br />

First of all, think<br />

“I want to walk!”<br />

When a person<br />

moves the body, he<br />

or she first thinks<br />

about the motions in<br />

his or her brain.<br />

By thinking “I want<br />

to walk,” the brain<br />

transmits necessary<br />

signals to muscles<br />

necessary for<br />

the motions through<br />

nerves.<br />

Receiving the signals,<br />

muscles move.<br />

In the healthy body,<br />

each muscle is able<br />

to receive signals<br />

destined from the<br />

brain to it and move<br />

as strongly and fast<br />

as intended.<br />

HAL reads signals.<br />

Signals sent to<br />

muscles by the brain<br />

leak on the skin<br />

surface as very faint<br />

signals, so called<br />

“bio-electric signals<br />

(BES).” HAL is able<br />

to read BESs by only<br />

attaching the originally<br />

developed<br />

detectors on the surface<br />

on the wearer’s<br />

skin. By consolidating<br />

various information,<br />

HAL recognizes<br />

what sorts of<br />

motions the wearer<br />

intends.<br />

HAL moves as the<br />

wearer intends.<br />

HAL, in accordance<br />

with the recognized<br />

motions, controls<br />

its power units. This<br />

function enables<br />

HAL to assist the<br />

wearer’s motions as<br />

he or she intends<br />

and exerts bigger<br />

power than he or she<br />

ordinarily exerts.<br />

The brain learns<br />

motion. The mechanism<br />

to move the<br />

human body does not<br />

end up with only moving<br />

muscles. The brain<br />

confirms how the body<br />

moved on what sort<br />

of signals. When HAL<br />

has appropriately assisted<br />

the motions<br />

of walking, the feeling<br />

“I could walk!” is fed<br />

back to the brain.<br />

By this means, the<br />

brain becomes able to<br />

learn the way to emit<br />

necessary signals<br />

for walking gradually.<br />

This leads to the<br />

important first step<br />

in walking of the<br />

physically challenged<br />

person without being<br />

assisted by HAL. The<br />

only robot that can<br />

provide appropriate<br />

solutions for motions<br />

to the brain is HAL.<br />

Illustration: CYBERDYNE, The Noun Project


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —21<br />

Digital health<br />

Reshaping<br />

patient<br />

care by bits<br />

In most of the developed world and increasingly<br />

in emerging markets, healthcare costs are on<br />

a steep upward trajectory. Not only do societies<br />

spend more as they get wealthier, they also<br />

spend more as healthcare moves up on people’s<br />

priority list. In the quest to optimize patient<br />

outcomes and healthcare expenditure, digital<br />

health opportunities play a vital role.<br />

TEXT LORENZO BIASIO, Credit Suisse<br />

Digitization has become a staple of our lives and daily routines<br />

in areas such as news consumption or shopping and<br />

it is also making inroads into health management. With<br />

new tools at their disposal, people are increasingly assuming<br />

responsibility for their health and well-being as well as disease<br />

management. At the same time, insurance companies are eager to<br />

get patient data to price risk. Furthermore, care providers are innovating<br />

and using digital tools to drive better patient outcomes.<br />

Traditionally, the healthcare industry is slow to embrace change,<br />

but to us, this time feels different. With the emergence of remote patient<br />

monitoring solutions, telehealth offerings and the fact that health<br />

education and health management portals are gaining traction, digital<br />

health is visibly reshaping the current standard of care.<br />

Remote monitoring stands out<br />

When looking at the wide range of what digital health encompasses,<br />

remote monitoring strikes us as the area that provides the highest<br />

value added given its utility in managing chronic diseases. Considering<br />

that an estimated one-third of total US healthcare spending goes<br />

toward the management of chronic diseases, the savings potential<br />

that remote monitoring offers becomes evident.<br />

A case in point is the solution Vivify Health provides for patients<br />

with heart failure, a condition that costs the US healthcare system<br />

almost USD 40 billion annually. Almost half of this expenditure is attributable<br />

to inpatient stays, which are costly compared to daily per-patient<br />

costs of just several dollars for stable patients. Vivify’s solution<br />

comprises a tablet (incl. software), two diagnostic devices, plus a<br />

scale. These tools allow doctors and nurses to assess the patient<br />

continuously and detect alarming signs and worsening trends between<br />

regularly scheduled visits. Furthermore, they can even reduce the<br />

number of necessary inpatient visits – in Vivify’s pilot, from over >


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —22<br />

three monthly visits to fewer than 0.4. Moreover, the tools reduced<br />

very costly emergency room visits by over 70%.<br />

Health advice traveling the distance<br />

Another digital health solution is to provide medical advice at a distance.<br />

In Switzerland, health insurers have long been employing insurance<br />

models that require patients to seek telephone assistance<br />

from an insurance-designated general practitioner. Under such a<br />

model, through the triage of patients by a healthcare professional,<br />

patients can be channeled to the appropriate care setting, eliminating<br />

redundancies in the system and driving savings for the insurer.<br />

Such ideas can be taken much further still. Doctor On Demand,<br />

a USA-based service, provides a showcase of what could become<br />

much more widespread in future. Using any device, the service allows<br />

patients to get counseling from a specialist for most medical and also<br />

some mental conditions. If we assume that such a service is applicable<br />

to about a third of all physician visits at a stated price point of<br />

USD 49 and, as has been reported, that the average person visits<br />

their physician about three times a year at a current all-in price per visit<br />

of USD 150, the theoretical savings amount to over USD 30 billion.<br />

As such services are rolled out in the emerging markets, healthcare<br />

provisioning can change profoundly. Immobile patients as well<br />

as remote areas should benefit dramatically from such offerings as<br />

virtual physician consultations become possible.<br />

Powerful innovation enables self-management<br />

Advances in information technology are also changing medical sensors,<br />

enabling them to shrink in size and become more versatile. One<br />

technology unthinkable without recent advancements in sensor technology<br />

stands out in terms of impact on patients’ quality of life: CGM,<br />

short for continuous glucose monitoring. With the use of extendedwear<br />

(multiple days) CGM sensors connected to a dedicated receiver<br />

or smartphone, diabetic patients can monitor their blood glucose levels<br />

continuously. The significant CGM benefit is that it allows patients<br />

to identify potentially dangerous episodes that they may miss with<br />

traditional one-off measurements using capillary-drawn blood. By involving<br />

a smart device in CGM, patient-specific alert levels as well as<br />

rules for automated notifications based on glucose readings can be<br />

preset (to parents, for instance). Given the magnitude of this innovation,<br />

it is no surprise to read that the technology is reported to have<br />

saved lives. If, as one major medical expenditure survey shows, slightly<br />

less than 20% of diabetes expenditure attributable to emergency<br />

room visits and inpatient stays – which could be, at least partially,<br />

avoided using CGM – the savings potential amounts to more than<br />

USD 10 billion.<br />

Looking ahead, we believe that it is only a matter of time until an<br />

artificial pancreas, that is, a CGM system connected to an insulin<br />

pump, will come to market. There are still some technological challenges<br />

and regulatory hurdles to be overcome, but we are steadily<br />

nearing the emergence of such an artificial pancreas, termed by many<br />

as the “holy grail of insulin therapy.”<br />

Venture funding of digital health companies<br />

In 2015, venture funding of digital health companies amounted to<br />

USD 4.5 billion, or 7% of total venture funding. Although<br />

deal volume was relatively flat, late-stage deals were up 23%.<br />

Source: Rock Health, Digital Health Funding: 2015 — Year in Review<br />

USD bn<br />

5<br />

4<br />

3<br />

2<br />

1<br />

0<br />

WebMD use on the rise<br />

WebMD user statistics show a steady increase since the inception of<br />

the service. Today, more than 200 million unique users visit the Web site<br />

every month, to access health, nutritional and wellness information.<br />

Source: WebMD<br />

Users in m<br />

250<br />

200<br />

150<br />

100<br />

50<br />

0<br />

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015<br />

Average monthly<br />

unique users<br />

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015<br />

Health literacy is not universally positive<br />

With the advent of health information Web sites like WebMD and services<br />

such as 23andMe (a personal genomics company), people are<br />

increasingly given digital tools that promote health literacy. While we<br />

do believe that health literacy should be an aspiration of every modern<br />

society and, ideally, increasing health literacy should lead to >


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —24<br />

To explore<br />

health issues in<br />

greater depth,<br />

see the foldout map.<br />

“Traditionally, the healthcare industry<br />

is slow to embrace change, but to us, this<br />

time feels different. With the emergence<br />

of new tools, digital health is visibly<br />

reshaping the current standard of care.”<br />

Lorenzo Biasio<br />

more informed conversations with physicians, our assessment of the<br />

current developments is mixed. Our conversations with physicians<br />

point to some undesirable developments: with the increasingly widespread<br />

availability of health information, it is not uncommon for patients<br />

to arrive at the doctor’s with a set idea about their diagnosis<br />

and even wishes for specific kinds of treatment. Such behavior may<br />

require lengthy explanations from doctors, but there are bigger risks<br />

such as possibly unnecessary diagnostic testing and potentially dangerous<br />

self-medication.<br />

This is not to say that the health information on offer is flawed.<br />

Offerings aimed at improving health literacy are useful – we simply<br />

believe they should be focused on the prophylactic setting, for instance<br />

giving wellness and nutritional tips. When it comes to more<br />

severe diseases, we believe that health information should be accessed<br />

with the guidance of a healthcare professional – a view supported<br />

by the fact that early 23andMe products were banned from<br />

the market by the US Food and Drug Administration, which found the<br />

information to be prone to misinterpretation.<br />

ingly stretched healthcare systems. When used properly, we are optimistic<br />

that digital health solutions can produce winners along the<br />

healthcare value chain – patients, physicians, caretakers, hospitals<br />

and insurance companies. However, in order to succeed, it will be<br />

paramount for digital solutions to be properly and carefully balanced<br />

with tangible and empathic expert advice from an actual physician.<br />

Digital health – a new era<br />

We do believe that we are at the dawn of a new era with regard to<br />

digital healthcare services. Digital health solutions undeniably create<br />

large efficiency gains and convenience advantages across the entire<br />

healthcare value chain. Thus, digital health solutions are key enablers<br />

to drive substantial system-wide savings that benefit today’s increas-<br />

Lorenzo Biasio<br />

Equity Analyst Healthcare<br />

+41 44 333 14 79<br />

lorenzo.biasio@credit-suisse.com


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —25<br />

Connectivity<br />

The Internet – our<br />

friend and caretaker<br />

The Internet continues to expand. Data collection, management and analysis are growing<br />

exponentially. Many people fear this development, viewing it as an Orwellian risk. However,<br />

the Internet and the Internet of Things also offer ways to find solutions for a better world.<br />

BUILDINGS<br />

IT &<br />

NETWORKS<br />

SECURITY /<br />

PUBLIC SAFETY<br />

RETAIL<br />

ENERGY<br />

INDUSTRIAL<br />

CONSUMER<br />

& HOME<br />

HEALTHCARE<br />

& LIFE SCIENCE<br />

TRANS-<br />

PORTATION<br />

PORTATION<br />

Illustration: The Noun Project<br />

Digitization is spreading into our daily life<br />

The expanding Internet offers the capability to solve not only complex problems, it also can help us to make our world more healthy, efficient,<br />

mindful and secure. Source: Beecham Research Ltd.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —26<br />

The title “Ask Mom” is often used for<br />

how-to books that provide tips on<br />

how to treat a cut, how to prepare or<br />

store food or how to remove a stain<br />

from a shirt. In the past, such knowledge was<br />

passed on from generation to generation by<br />

word of mouth. Later on it was written down<br />

and printed in book form. In modern times,<br />

the same information can be accessed and<br />

read on mobile devices or personal computers.<br />

The technological progress achieved<br />

through digitization makes it easier than ever<br />

to save data and ensures that information is<br />

no longer lost. The expansion of the Internet<br />

to mobile devices and to things has led to a<br />

massive increase in data and digital communication.<br />

300 billion tweets have been sent<br />

since Twitter came into being, and every second,<br />

5,000 new ones are added. Whether<br />

one disseminates digital communications or<br />

censors or processes data, it is vital to identify<br />

the best way to read and manage such<br />

data.<br />

Creating a global conscience<br />

“‘Caring’ smart objects<br />

put people and their<br />

needs at the center of<br />

their services.”<br />

Uwe Neumann<br />

This technology has given rise to a ubiquitous,<br />

all-encompassing communications system<br />

that is self-sufficient and can also provide extensive<br />

benefits to others. Not only does it<br />

grant access to a wide range of knowledge,<br />

it also establishes a platform for creating a<br />

global conscience, as information, opinions<br />

and assessments from around the world become<br />

more transparent and accessible. The<br />

insights gained from social networks could<br />

increasingly contribute to a common awareness<br />

and acceptance of how to make the<br />

world a better place. Politicians and other decision-makers<br />

are well advised to employ the<br />

growing global bank of knowledge for the<br />

good of society and not let it morph into a<br />

kind of big-brother-is-watching-you society.<br />

As online activity is continuously monitored<br />

and measured, there is the inherent danger<br />

of users being monitored and punished for<br />

voicing their views and opinions, etc. At the<br />

same time, however, transparent near-time<br />

user feedback in response to, say, political<br />

events, driven by a regional, or even global,<br />

conscience, can also paint a more accurate<br />

picture of the mood in society and can help<br />

lead to change. A case in point – companies<br />

such as BrandsEye or MogIA, which used<br />

data from social media such as Google, Facebook<br />

and Twitter, successfully predicted the<br />

outcome of the US election, while traditional<br />

polls got the result wrong.<br />

Internet-connected devices look after you<br />

Apart from the Internet’s ability to “care” for<br />

users, there has also been strong growth in<br />

new markets that provide “caring” objects, i.e.,<br />

smart objects that put people and their needs<br />

at the center of their services. If asked what<br />

a caretaker should provide, most people<br />

would probably say they should care for our<br />

physical health and mental well-being as well<br />

as our safety and security. Moreover, a caretaker<br />

should manage communication within<br />

the family.<br />

New devices such as Google Home and<br />

Google Assistant could one day become our<br />

new friend and caretaker who looks after the<br />

family. These devices are connected to the<br />

Internet, have a camera, an invisible microphone<br />

with intelligent speech recognition and<br />

loudspeakers. They can tell you where your<br />

keys are (provided they are also connected);<br />

they can answer children’s questions by accessing<br />

the Internet; and they can start playing<br />

your favorite morning music upon request.<br />

Other companies such as Amazon with its<br />

Echo device and Apple with its HomeKit<br />

products aim to provide similar services. They<br />

are vying to become a central hub within our<br />

homes to ensure our health, security and<br />

family communication.<br />

Internet of healthy things<br />

The supply of Internet-connected health devices<br />

is also on the rise. In 2015, Partners<br />

HealthCare announced a partnership with


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —27<br />

Samsung Electronics to develop the next<br />

generation of personalized digital and mobile<br />

solutions for health and wellness. In 2016,<br />

Nestlé Institute and Samsung announced<br />

plans to pool their resources to build a connected<br />

health and lifestyle platform that will<br />

interact with everything from smart TVs to<br />

wearables to helping people make healthier<br />

choices. Several fashion firms launched socalled<br />

tech shirts in 2015, i.e., shirts that measure<br />

heart rates, breathing or live biometrics.<br />

Fitbit’s success with its activity and heart rate<br />

trackers is another example of a gadget that<br />

monitors our health. Research and Markets<br />

expects the wearable device market to<br />

grow from USD 23 billion in 2015 to USD<br />

173 billion by 2020. However, selling devices<br />

and apps is only a small piece of the connected<br />

health market. Collecting, analyzing<br />

and managing the data is where the true<br />

potential lies, helping to find better solutions<br />

for our healthcare market.<br />

Internet of mindful and security things<br />

“Digitization has<br />

helped create a<br />

global conscience.”<br />

Uwe Neumann<br />

With GPS-enabled devices such as the<br />

TrackR Bravo, finding lost keys or bags has<br />

never been easier. If the item is attached to<br />

your key or bag, you can easily locate it using<br />

an app on your phone. With a smart sleep<br />

mask, you can track your sleep using medical-grade<br />

sensors. The tracking enables you<br />

to improve your sleep habits. With a Vigo<br />

headset, you can track your alertness (for instance<br />

when driving long distances by car)<br />

and it can send an alarm if your alertness declines.<br />

When Alphabet (Google) acquired<br />

smart thermostat and smoke alarm maker<br />

Nest in 2014, it approached the ability to capitalize<br />

on the rising demand for home security<br />

the smart way. Nest also provides a Dropcam<br />

that helps to monitor movements in your<br />

home using an Internet connection and live<br />

streams via an app on your smartphone when<br />

you are away. Robots are becoming more intelligent,<br />

too, and can help to keep people in<br />

need of care at home longer by connecting<br />

them to a smart-home Internet caring hub.<br />

The smart-home market is expected to reach<br />

a value of USD 122 billion by 2022 and is<br />

estimated to grow by a compound annual<br />

growth rate of 14% between 2016 and 2022,<br />

according to MarketsandMarkets. “Smart<br />

home” encompasses everything from lighting<br />

and entertainment control to security and access<br />

control to smart kitchens as well as<br />

smart meters and smoke detectors.<br />

For some readers, some of these developments<br />

may invoke visions of George Orwell’s<br />

“1984.” People who oppose the idea of<br />

an interconnected world are typically concerned<br />

about protecting their privacy as well<br />

as the risk of misinformation and manipulation.<br />

However, society can also find ways to<br />

harness the technological progress for educational<br />

purposes and to bring people closer<br />

together. For example, young children are increasingly<br />

using programs such as YouTube<br />

to learn about cooking (and pretty much everything<br />

else). Or consider apps like SideChef,<br />

which provides step-by-step instructions on<br />

how to cook a meal. Such tools can help keep<br />

the family together at dinner time, as children<br />

will want to share what they bake or cook with<br />

the rest of the family. And parents can use<br />

devices such as a Wi-Fi-blocking pepper<br />

grinder to make sure their children cannot<br />

access their smartphones or iPads during<br />

dinner. Viewed from that perspective, there<br />

is indeed a lot to be gained from today’s connectivity.<br />

Uwe Neumann<br />

Research Analyst<br />

+41 44 334 56 45<br />

uwe.neumann@credit-suisse.com<br />

Additional details<br />

on our map


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —28<br />

Photo: Vorname Name/Agentur


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —29<br />

Internet solutions<br />

The dark side<br />

of digitization<br />

In the old PC-dominated IT world, you had a protected private environment that could<br />

be ringfenced with perimeter and infrastructure security, separating it from the outside<br />

world. In today’s globalized world, digitization and the younger generation’s IT consumption<br />

patterns represent a challenge to ensuring a safe cyber environment.<br />

TEXT ULRICH KAISER, Credit Suisse<br />

Back in the 1980s when the Internet<br />

was in its infancy, cybersecurity<br />

was not an issue. Since then, however,<br />

the number and sophistication<br />

of cyberattacks have increased. The topics<br />

making the headlines these days include<br />

the ransomware epidemic, the refocusing of<br />

malware from PCs/laptops to mobile devices,<br />

the deployment of billions of unprotected or<br />

little protected Internet of Things (IoT) devices<br />

or cyberattacks targeting businesses and<br />

governments. According to several sources,<br />

there are at least 70 million different pieces<br />

of malware in circulation worldwide. They are<br />

disseminated in particular by smartphones<br />

and other handhelds. Moreover, at least 70%<br />

of e-mails are spam.<br />

Compared with a few decades ago, our<br />

dependence on the Internet and other networks<br />

for critical services and information has<br />

grown tremendously. Particular growth has<br />

occurred in the mobile Internet-enabled new<br />

types of technology infrastructure such as<br />

power grids, cloud computing, industrial automation<br />

networks, intelligent transportation<br />

systems, e-government and electronic banking,<br />

which are becoming more and more interconnected.<br />

As failure in one technology can<br />

affect other technologies, greater convenience<br />

and efficiency increases vulnerability<br />

to cyberattacks and makes any defense<br />

against such attacks more difficult.<br />

There is a looming risk that cyber-attacks<br />

may cause the Internet to break down. In fact,<br />

if we do not do anything soon, we risk causing<br />

permanent damage to our economy. The<br />

incoming US president Donald Trump said during<br />

his campaign that cybersecurity would be<br />

“an immediate and top priority” once he comes<br />

to power. With an emphasis on improving vital<br />

infrastructure, we therefore expect to see an<br />

increase in federal spending on security, which<br />

should benefit cybersecurity companies such<br />

as Cisco Systems, Palo Alto Networks or<br />

Check Point Software.<br />

Cybersecurity then and now<br />

In the old IT world, you had a protected private<br />

environment that could be ringfenced with perimeter<br />

and infrastructure security, separating<br />

it from the outside world and trying to control<br />

what gets in and out. This approach is now<br />

reaching its limits. Firewalls stop most threats,<br />

typically more than 99%, but unfortunately not<br />

100%. The remaining less than 1% of threats<br />

that still come through appears negligible at<br />

first, but translates into the thousands, as the<br />

total number of threats amounts to millions.<br />

Bad news about cybersecurity is good<br />

news for the IT security industry. We expect<br />

spending on IT security to grow at a much<br />

faster pace than underlying IT spending, which<br />

means it will grab a bigger slice of the cake<br />

going forward. Industry researcher Gartner<br />

predicts that worldwide spending on information<br />

security products and services will reach<br />

USD 81.6 bn in 2016, an increase of 7.9%<br />

from the previous year. Currently, this represents<br />

only about 2.4% of global IT spending,<br />

which Gartner expects to reach USD 3.4 trn.<br />

Over the next five years, Gartner foresees an<br />

annual growth rate of about 8%, which appears<br />

a little light, in our view, given the growing<br />

challenges.<br />

Preferring prevention over planning<br />

Though many surveys conclude that spending<br />

for cybersecurity is among the top three priorities<br />

of chief technology officers (CTOs),<br />

one can argue that even higher spending is<br />

justified given the significance of cyberthreats.<br />

There is a constraint, however, namely<br />

the associated costs and sometimes even<br />

the willingness to spend money on cybersecurity.<br />

One reason not to spend more is the<br />

lack of a mid-term cybersecurity strategy.<br />

Many companies still adhere to a stop-andgo<br />

policy, which means less spending if there<br />

is no immediate threat or incident and then<br />

panick and invest if there is. This is especially<br />

true if an incident is widely published in the<br />

media, for instance the Sony attack in 2014<br />

and the attack on the US Office of Personnel<br />

Management in 2015. As soon as the security<br />

problem is fixed, however, spending is<br />

usually reduced again.<br />

Another reason for the spending restraint<br />

is that many CTOs tend to opt for preventive<br />

measures when planning their security strategies,<br />

a trend poised to continue in years to<br />

come. However, reality looks different, as preventive<br />

measures have proven weak in >


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —30<br />

“Bad news about cybersecurity is actually<br />

good news for the IT security industry.”<br />

Ulrich Kaiser<br />

Companies are spending<br />

most for network security<br />

Security and vulnerability management, and<br />

network security are the fastest growing<br />

segments within IT security. Corporate endpoint,<br />

and Web security are getting disrupted by next<br />

generation solutions. Source: IDC, CS estimates<br />

in USD bn<br />

40000<br />

35000<br />

30000<br />

25000<br />

20000<br />

15000<br />

10000<br />

5000<br />

0<br />

2012 2017<br />

Network security<br />

Security and vulnerability<br />

Endpoint security<br />

Identity and access management<br />

Web security<br />

Messaging security<br />

Other<br />

blocking cyberattacks. As a result, many organizations<br />

have adopted the detection-and-response<br />

approach to strengthen their security.<br />

New trends in cybersecurity<br />

+53<br />

%<br />

+83<br />

%<br />

We expect security technologies such as security<br />

information and event management<br />

(SIEM) and secure Web gateways (SWG) to<br />

evolve. Organizations are likely to increasingly<br />

focus on detection and response, because<br />

taking a preventive approach has not been<br />

successful in blocking malicious attacks so<br />

far and probably will not be successful in the<br />

future. Thus, businesses should balance their<br />

spending and include both.<br />

We can imagine security spending to<br />

evolve to become more service-driven as businesses<br />

continue to struggle with an overall<br />

lack of cybersecurity talent in the industry.<br />

Managed detection and response (MDR)<br />

is growing as organizations are faced with<br />

having to use both technology and human<br />

expertise to pinpoint risks and improve the cyber<br />

environment. This is especially relevant in<br />

addressing insider threats and targeted advanced<br />

threats.<br />

Hackers wanted – high salary reward<br />

The purchase and implementation of new security<br />

technologies is vital to protect businesses,<br />

and so is the development of cybersecurity<br />

skills in employees, which are not<br />

reflected in the Gartner estimates and come<br />

as additional costs. These are justified by a<br />

shortage of skilled security professionals,<br />

which is both dangerous and expensive since<br />

it leaves businesses vulnerable to attack, resulting<br />

in reputational damage and data loss.<br />

The most highly specialized technical skills<br />

are the ones in greatest demand and claiming<br />

high salaries. Businesses are seeking professionals<br />

with expertise in software development,<br />

attack mitigation, intrusion detection,<br />

network monitoring and other areas of cybersecurity.<br />

They need not look far: convince<br />

hackers to change allegiance, vindicate them<br />

and use their skills to maintain a safe cyber<br />

environment. Hackers are motivated by a multitude<br />

of reasons, such as profit, protest or<br />

simply challenge. Another reason, and one<br />

that can be used for the good, is to evaluate<br />

system weaknesses to help formulate defenses<br />

against potential hackers.<br />

Ulrich Kaiser<br />

Research Analyst<br />

+41 44 334 56 49<br />

ulrich.kaiser@credit-suisse.com


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —31<br />

Fintech<br />

The age of<br />

cryptofinance<br />

The invention of bitcoin in 2009 ushered in the age of<br />

cryptofinance and promised an end to the problems associated<br />

with physical cash. Although the hype around bitcoin and<br />

blockchain – the public ledger that records bitcoin transactions –<br />

is now receding, the next generation of cryptofinance technologies<br />

is already moving ahead and applying lessons learned.<br />

INTERVIEW BY CHRISTINE SCHMID, Credit Suisse<br />

Christine Schmid: Tell me a bit<br />

about Monetas.<br />

Johann Gevers The idea of Monetas<br />

comes out of my desire to do something that<br />

helps the world work better, not through<br />

politics but through technology. I thought<br />

long about what kind of technology would<br />

make things better. I came to the conclusion<br />

that the financial system is at the center<br />

of everything, and that it is too centralized,<br />

which creates dangerous risks and instability,<br />

and holds back social progress. We<br />

saw that during the 2008 financial crisis.<br />

Moreover, the problems associated with the<br />

crisis have not been solved. In fact, things<br />

have gotten worse. We have some measure<br />

of temporary stability, but the problems<br />

have gotten bigger.<br />

In what way?<br />

Johann Gevers One key aspect is that<br />

today’s financial system is too centralized:<br />

there’s too much power concentrated in too<br />

few hands. And that can lead to abuse of<br />

power or massive suffering if the centralized<br />

system fails. So at Monetas we are building<br />

technologies to help transition the financial<br />

system toward greater decentralization –<br />

the democratization of finance. Our solution<br />

belongs to the category of “cryptofinance” –<br />

the industry term for financial technologies<br />

that use encryption algorithms to ensure<br />

that financial transactions are private and<br />

secure.<br />

What exactly is your solution?<br />

Johann Gevers We’ve developed a technology<br />

that gives the user more control.<br />

It’s a contracting platform that gets around<br />

some of the disadvantages of existing<br />

cryptofinance technologies and allows you<br />

to complete transactions in a fraction of<br />

the time and extremely cheaply. This is especially<br />

important for retail transactions.<br />

Let’s backtrack a bit to the existing<br />

cryptofinance technologies. Most people<br />

still don’t know what they are.<br />

Johann Gevers The core invention in<br />

cryptofinance is true digital cash which –<br />

unlike physical cash or digital music – cannot<br />

be copied or counterfeited. This transition<br />

from traditional physical cash to modern<br />

digital cash brings tremendous efficiency<br />

gains. The Bank of England, for example,<br />

has calculated that switching from physical<br />

cash to digital cash will generate a sustained<br />

3% boost to GDP. That is massive,<br />

and the efficiency and productivity gains are<br />

even greater for developing countries.<br />

Where does blockchain fit into this scenario?<br />

Johann Gevers A blockchain is a distributed<br />

database – a public ledger for digital<br />

transactions. It’s a so-called consensus<br />

system. In other words, it’s a way for a lot<br />

of different people or, more specifically,<br />

a lot of different computers all over the<br />

world to confirm transactions by coming to<br />

a consensus about them. If you want to<br />

execute a transaction in a consensus system,<br />

all these computers have to vote and agree<br />

on it. That makes a consensus system<br />

resistant to political influence and corruption,<br />

as well as robust against technological<br />

errors and failure, which is a big advantage.<br />

For example?<br />

Johann Gevers Consensus systems<br />

such as blockchains are good for safely<br />

storing high-value assets and information.<br />

Commercial registers, which record business<br />

entities and real estate ownership, are<br />

one example. Secure electronic voting systems<br />

are another.<br />

And the disadvantages of blockchains?<br />

Johann Gevers The downside is that<br />

consensus systems are very expensive to<br />

maintain and to run. In the bitcoin blockchain,<br />

for example, the full cost of a transaction<br />

is about five dollars. That’s a lot<br />

of money. Moreover, let’s say you go to Starbucks<br />

or to your grocery store and want to<br />

buy something. When you’re at the checkout<br />

counter, you don’t want to wait ten<br />

minutes to several hours for a global network<br />

of computers to reach consensus before<br />

the transaction is approved. For retail transactions<br />

you need a system that’s efficient,<br />

fast and cheap – and that scales to millions<br />

of transactions per second. The bitcoin<br />

network can only handle a maximum of<br />

7 transactions per second.<br />

Which brings us back to<br />

contracting systems.<br />

Johann Gevers Right. Contracting platforms<br />

such as Monetas can execute<br />

transactions in milliseconds, at a cost of<br />

less than 1/10,000th of a cent, and<br />

can effortlessly handle the entire world’s<br />

transactions in real-time. This makes >


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —32<br />

Photo: Thomas Eugster<br />

“If you are restricted to<br />

physical cash, you can only do<br />

face-to-face transactions.”<br />

Johann Gevers


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —33<br />

them ideally suited for retail transactions.<br />

And by integrating contracting platforms<br />

with consensus systems, you can have the<br />

best of both worlds. You can securely store<br />

your assets in a consensus system, and<br />

efficiently trade those assets in a contracting<br />

system.<br />

How does the Monetas platform work?<br />

Johann Gevers In the Monetas system,<br />

only the transaction parties need to agree,<br />

then the transaction is completed. You don’t<br />

need the slow, expensive agreement of<br />

millions of unrelated parties, the way you do<br />

in consensus systems. The first application<br />

of the Monetas technology is a mobile<br />

payment system. Anybody in the world can<br />

download our software onto their mobile<br />

phone for free and do transactions with<br />

anybody else who’s got our software. Users<br />

load digital cash onto their mobile phone<br />

at an exchanger, such as a kiosk or ATM or<br />

bank, and can then pay conveniently from<br />

their mobile phone. The great thing about<br />

our platform is that it is open, not locked<br />

into any provider or device. So you can<br />

do transactions with anyone, regardless<br />

which mobile phone provider they use,<br />

or which country they’re in. You don’t even<br />

need a bank account. So our system is a<br />

great solution for the 80% of people in<br />

Africa who have no bank account. And our<br />

transactions are far cheaper than any<br />

other system on the market. In fact, they’re<br />

even cheaper (and more secure) than<br />

physical cash. Physical cash costs the<br />

economy about 1–2% of GDP in developed<br />

countries, and a stunning 5–7% of GDP in<br />

developing countries. Switching to digital<br />

cash will provide a tremendous boost to our<br />

economies.<br />

Has Monetas gone beyond the<br />

prototype stage?<br />

Johann Gevers We launched a successful<br />

pilot of our platform two months ago<br />

in South Africa. Our partners are very happy<br />

with the results and are now planning<br />

to roll out our platform countrywide to over<br />

1,000 locations, as well as to further<br />

countries in Africa. So this is a very exciting<br />

time for us.<br />

Looking down the road, who stands<br />

to benefit most from cryptofinance<br />

technologies?<br />

Johann Gevers Well, very clearly, consumers<br />

are going to benefit immensely.<br />

These technologies will enable user-friendly<br />

services that go far beyond what we have<br />

today. You’ll be able to make transactions<br />

“The idea of<br />

Monetas<br />

comes out<br />

of my desire to<br />

do something<br />

that helps<br />

the world work<br />

better, not<br />

through<br />

politics but<br />

through<br />

technology.”<br />

Johann Gevers<br />

Johann Gevers<br />

is founder and CEO of Monetas, founder<br />

of Crypto Valley, and founder and president<br />

of the Digital Finance Compliance<br />

Association. He is an entrepreneur with<br />

over 20 years’ experience in business,<br />

finance and technology, and has served<br />

as strategic advisor to companies across<br />

diverse industries, including awardwinning<br />

technology start-ups. Johann is<br />

a visionary thought leader in the fintech<br />

space and was recently rated as one<br />

of the Top 100 most influential finance<br />

leaders in Switzerland.<br />

and safely store your money without having<br />

to remember passwords and without having<br />

to carry around keys or electronic cards.<br />

And you’ll be able to do it all on your mobile<br />

phone, with better security than traditional<br />

banking (including cloud backups).<br />

By connecting billions of unbanked to the<br />

global economy, these technologies will<br />

enable everybody in the world to generate<br />

wealth and improve their quality of life far<br />

beyond what is possible today.<br />

Today people are excluded from the<br />

global economy.<br />

Johann Gevers Yes. Billions of people –<br />

more than half of the world’s adults – have<br />

little or no access to formal financial services,<br />

and do almost all their transactions<br />

with physical cash. If you are restricted to<br />

physical cash, you can only do face-toface<br />

transactions. That means you are part<br />

of a very small economic network, which<br />

severely limits your ability to create wealth.<br />

So poor people stay poor. One of the fundamental<br />

requirements for generating<br />

wealth and improving one’s quality of life is<br />

being part of a large economic network.<br />

Today, even in poor countries, virtually<br />

everyone has a mobile phone. Our mobile<br />

platform gives everyone with a mobile<br />

phone access to the world’s most advanced<br />

financial services, and thus dramatically<br />

boosts their ability to generate wealth.<br />

People will use their rising wealth to improve<br />

their healthcare, education and quality of<br />

life in general.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —35<br />

Putting<br />

a roof over<br />

your head<br />

Rapid urbanization in the developing economies and demographic changes in the<br />

advanced economies are two of the dominant trends the global economy is facing.<br />

Factors such as migration to the cities, population aging, increasing incomes and<br />

the growing middle class in the emerging economies will have an impact on how we<br />

live and what our housing requirements are.<br />

TEXT BY FABIAN WALTERT, Credit Suisse<br />

2<br />

1<br />

CO-HOUSING<br />

Living in an anonymous society<br />

comes with a loss of community spirit.<br />

Co-housing arrangements seek<br />

to bring back some of the benefits of<br />

small villages in an increasingly<br />

urbanized world.<br />

MULTIGENERATIONAL HOUSING<br />

Due to urbanization, increasing<br />

incomes and mobility, it has become<br />

rare that several generations<br />

of a family live under the same roof.<br />

Thus, the benefits of this arrangement<br />

are disappearing. One initiative<br />

to rebuild social networks similar<br />

to families is multigenerational<br />

housing.<br />

3<br />

MICRO-APARTMENTS<br />

Securing housing affordability<br />

and preventing segregation is seen<br />

as crucial for growing cities that<br />

grapple with rising land prices<br />

and growing land scarcity. A promising<br />

approach is to build small<br />

and affordable micro-apartments.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —36<br />

Population growth in the 21st century<br />

mainly affects cities that are<br />

successful in attracting people by<br />

offering them job opportunities, decent<br />

healthcare and affordable housing. Cities<br />

in Asia, Africa, Latin America and the<br />

Middle East are expected to grow at a higher<br />

pace, mainly driven by people seeking a better<br />

life and hoping to become part of the rising<br />

middle class. However, urbanization is not<br />

only a phenomenon of the emerging economies.<br />

Cities in the advanced economies are<br />

also growing, albeit at a slower pace. London,<br />

for example, is expected to reach a population<br />

of over 10 million by 2031, an increase<br />

of 15% compared to today. It is expected that<br />

by 2030, 41 such megacities will exist, up<br />

from 28 in 2015. Around 12 of them will be<br />

situated in emerging economies. The United<br />

Nations is even predicting the advent of the<br />

first so-called gigacity (more than 100 million<br />

residents) in China by 2020. This trend will<br />

take 6.3 billion people to global urban centers<br />

by 2050, an increase of 75% from today, with<br />

two out of three residents around the world<br />

living in urban areas by then.<br />

Efficiency and focus on affordability<br />

The strong flow of people to prosperous cities<br />

is a result of the economic benefits such<br />

cities offer. However, attracting more and<br />

more people is going to put pressure on infrastructure<br />

and land prices, further lifting<br />

prices of urban real estate and thus reducing<br />

its affordability. Furthermore, the stronger<br />

competition for space will increase urban<br />

density. One answer to that development is<br />

to reduce the size of apartments. This effect<br />

is already visible in certain megacities such<br />

as Tokyo, where apartments today are 14%<br />

smaller than a decade ago. Thus, the main<br />

challenge for residential developers will be to<br />

find out how they can use limited space more<br />

efficiently and in an affordable manner.<br />

New and different types of housing<br />

Another key challenge for nearly all countries<br />

will be the demographic shift that will fundamentally<br />

affect the demand structure for<br />

real estate. According to the United Nations,<br />

the share of people aged 60 or older will rise<br />

by 2.8% per annum from 2025 to 2030.<br />

While the developing economies will have the<br />

youngest population, they will also record the<br />

fastest pace of population aging. The growing<br />

urban middle class of the emerging economies<br />

will increase demand for housing both<br />

in terms of quantity and quality. Meanwhile,<br />

the aging baby boomer generation in the<br />

advanced economies will require the development<br />

of new housing alternatives. An increase<br />

in the share of older people will<br />

change not only the way communities organize<br />

services so that care is more accessible,<br />

but also the cultural view of aging to make<br />

sure that the older generation is integrated in<br />

the community.<br />

Shifting demographic trends will likely<br />

create a strong need for new and different<br />

types of housing. As the elderly tend to be<br />

healthier than in the past, many do not consider<br />

nursing homes an attractive alternative<br />

to their existing homes. At the same time,<br />

increasing mobility – a further megatrend –<br />

tends to increase the spatial distance among<br />

family members. Thus, senior citizens are<br />

likely to increasingly search for alternative<br />

housing that is designed to accommodate<br />

their changing needs as they grow older.<br />

Answers to the challenges<br />

These two megatrends – urbanization and demographic<br />

shift – will result in several challenges:<br />

scarcity and unaffordability of housing,<br />

lack of accessibility of services for families<br />

and the elderly and loss of communal<br />

spirit. The search for answers to these challenges<br />

is still going on. However, the real estate<br />

industry and a multitude of local citizens’<br />

initiatives are suggesting possible routes in<br />

a variety of alternative housing projects that<br />

are emerging around the globe. Among the<br />

most promising of these approaches are: micro-apartments,<br />

multigenerational housing<br />

and co-housing. All of them address some of<br />

the challenges emerging on the global housing<br />

market and could serve as future housing<br />

solutions.<br />

Fabian Waltert<br />

Real Estate Analyst<br />

+41 44 333 25 57<br />

fabian.waltert@credit-suisse.com


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —37<br />

1<br />

Photo: Jeremy M. Lang<br />

The Pacifica Cohousing community in Carrboro, North Carolina. Co-housing offers the benefits of small villages in an urbanized world.<br />

Residents inhabit private spaces but share goods and services within the community.<br />

Co-housing<br />

Originated in Denmark in the 1960s and then picked up by<br />

many regions all over the world, co-housing describes a<br />

communal way of living where people inhabit private spaces<br />

accompanied by shared facilities for the community.<br />

The management of these communities is not hierarchical.<br />

The inhabitants decide demo cratically by considering the<br />

desires and needs of all residents. Life in a co-housing<br />

community is characterized by different shared activities<br />

within the community (e. g. group care, shared meals,<br />

support in shopping, social interaction, etc.), where participation<br />

is desirable, but not mandatory. These communities<br />

are very heterogeneous in their purposes and objectives,<br />

and they can be found in urban, suburban and rural<br />

areas. For example, Older Women’s Co-Housing in Great<br />

Britain seeks to establish a community for women aged<br />

over 50, in what can be seen as a special form of multigenerational<br />

housing. Others, like Pacifica Cohousing in<br />

the USA, put more emphasis on creating communal<br />

living with a focus on sustainability. The main idea behind<br />

the co- housing movement is to find answers to the changing<br />

needs of people around the world rather than to<br />

provide a solution for the problems associated with the<br />

demographic shift. The main economic advantage of<br />

co-housing is the opportunity to share goods and services<br />

within the community. People may also enjoy the community<br />

spirit otherwise lost in today’s anonymous urban<br />

areas. Yet monetary participation and cooperation among<br />

participants is forced, which can lead to friction within<br />

the community. However, co-housing is likely to become<br />

increasingly relevant as a housing alternative, bringing<br />

back some of the benefits of small villages in an increasingly<br />

urbanized world.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —38<br />

Multigenerational housing<br />

As incomes and mobility increase, it has become rare in<br />

many countries for multiple generations to live under the<br />

same roof. Thus, the benefits of this traditional housing<br />

arrangement (such as free care for children and the<br />

elderly) are disappearing. In addition, the growing number<br />

of elderly increases public care costs. An initiative to rebuild<br />

the social network similar to families was taken<br />

in Germany with the so-called “Mehrgenerationenhäuser”<br />

(multigenerational houses). The idea behind such<br />

houses is to create an environment that accommodates<br />

the elderly, children and nurseries, where young and old<br />

can support each other. The “Lighthouse” in Berlin is<br />

one example of a multigenerational house where 29 adults<br />

aged from 26 to 70, 14 children between 2 and 13 years of<br />

age and several pets live together, creating a family of<br />

choice for many of them. They epitomize the very idea of<br />

the sharing economy, as the senior residents, for example,<br />

read books to the children and the teenagers train the<br />

elderly to use computers. Multigenerational living is not<br />

only a socializing project for the older generation. It also<br />

helps provide new housing options for open- minded<br />

younger people that are priced out of the regular housing<br />

market and are happy to find an affordable place to live.<br />

A more extended form of multigenerational housing can be<br />

found in intergenerational living projects, where nursing<br />

homes and nurseries exist under one roof. Such arrangements<br />

are expected to significantly reduce the cost of care.<br />

While multigenerational housing may be considered a<br />

niche model rather than the global solution to the housing<br />

problems associated with demographic change, it is a<br />

promising model for the future.<br />

2<br />

The Murundaka Cohousing Community in Melbourne, Australia, is an example of multigenerational housing.<br />

The idea is to bring together young and old in an environment where they can support each other, at affordable cost.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —39<br />

3<br />

The Nakagin Capsule Tower<br />

in Tokyo, Japan, was an<br />

early experiment in microapartments.<br />

Hardly larger<br />

than a big living room, these<br />

tiny dwellings offer a solution<br />

to the twin problems of<br />

sustainability and affordable<br />

housing in city centers.<br />

Photo: Manakin / Getty Images<br />

Micro-apartments<br />

Photo: Chris Grose<br />

Small, often sustainable and, most importantly, affordable.<br />

This is how micro-apartments or tiny houses can be described.<br />

The idea is to downsize apartments to 20 to 30 square meters,<br />

in some cases even less, and making access to affordable<br />

housing in city centers and near workplaces possible. One<br />

of the first and most radical buildings with micro-apartments<br />

was the Nakagin Capsule Tower built in Japan in the 1970s.<br />

It contains 140 stan dardized capsules of less than nine square<br />

meters each. Meanwhile, with cities growing exponentially<br />

and land becoming more scarce and expensive, the idea of<br />

micro-apartments is gaining relevance again. In New York City,<br />

for example, a project called Carmel Place was finished in<br />

2016. It is the first modern building in New York where the<br />

size of apartments is allowed to be smaller than defined by<br />

regulation, featuring 55 micro-apartments in a nine-story<br />

building. The apartments are furnished, every room is cleaned<br />

once a week and there are additional amenities offered to<br />

the tenants such as a gym. Critics argue that people will feel<br />

lonely and isolated in such apartments, that apartments tend<br />

to become smaller while rents stay the same and that such<br />

small living quarters may create the slums of the future by attracting<br />

low-income tenants. However, micro-apartments<br />

allow young people, professionals, service-industry workers<br />

and retirees to live in central, otherwise unaffordable locations<br />

and thus counter segregation trends.<br />

Photo: Vorname Name/Agentur


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —40<br />

Photo: Bram Belloni<br />

Mid-level white-collar jobs are disappearing, says Randstad CEO Jacques van den Broek. The result is a very different job market.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —41<br />

Flexible working<br />

Labor in the<br />

new millennium<br />

Numerous factors that include automation and robotics, longer life expectancy,<br />

underfunded pension systems and younger generations who think differently are changing<br />

the supply and demand for jobs as we know them.<br />

INTERVIEW BY RETO HESS, Credit Suisse<br />

Reto Hess: Digitization – specifically<br />

information and communications technology<br />

(ICT) – is having an ever greater impact<br />

on our daily lives, including our working lives.<br />

How big a change are we looking at?<br />

Jacques van den Broek We recently<br />

published the 2016 edition of our “Flexibility<br />

@work report” on the future of work in the<br />

digital age, focusing specifically on the<br />

consequences we see nowadays of digitization.<br />

There are two trains of thought here:<br />

one, more fatalistic, is that about 40%<br />

of jobs are disappearing. But the second,<br />

espoused in a separate report put out<br />

by the OECD in May, maintains that 50%<br />

of jobs would change naturally in any event.<br />

What do you notice in terms of what your<br />

clients are asking for today?<br />

Jacques van den Broek People get fixed<br />

on an ideal profile, which tells you right<br />

away that they don’t know much about the<br />

labor market. For example, a client might<br />

wish to have a person in their mid-30s with<br />

relevant skills who has been successful<br />

at your main competitor but is looking for a<br />

new challenge in your company. It’s not<br />

going to happen. Increasingly we try to steer<br />

companies away from their ideal profiles<br />

in the direction of younger people, older<br />

people or maybe people from another country.<br />

Have you observed any shift in demand<br />

from knowledge-based jobs to more<br />

creative or socially oriented jobs as a result<br />

of increasing ICT and automation?<br />

Jacques van den Broek No. It’s a bit<br />

early. If you’re talking about artificial intelligence<br />

(AI), for example, the highest level<br />

of artificial intelligence that we see today in<br />

our sector has the intellect of a two-year-<br />

Jacques van den Broek<br />

is CEO and chairman of the Executive<br />

Board of Randstad Holding nv. He<br />

graduated in law at Tilburg University in<br />

the Netherlands and briefly held a<br />

management position at Vendex International<br />

before joining Randstad as a<br />

branch manager in 1988. He joined the<br />

Executive Board in 2004.<br />

old. So in 78% of cases, AI now recognizes<br />

a picture of a cat as being a cat. When it<br />

comes to selecting a personal profile – and<br />

certainly that of a knowledge worker –<br />

it will be quite a few years before technology<br />

can make that choice. AI first has to reach<br />

“technological singularity,” which is when<br />

machines surpass human intelligence. If this<br />

happens, scientists predict that cognitive<br />

professions could be improved and maybe<br />

partially substituted.<br />

That said, the report you mentioned at<br />

the beginning does state that progress in<br />

ICT is leading to job polarization, where<br />

there is demand for high-tech, high-paid<br />

jobs and low-tech, low-paid jobs,<br />

but the jobs in the middle are losing out.<br />

What is going on there?<br />

Jacques van den Broek You have nonroutine<br />

tasks at the top and low ends of<br />

the labor market. A gardener does a nonroutine<br />

task that cannot be automated.<br />

A nurse does non-routine tasks that can<br />

only partly be automated. What is interesting<br />

is that mid-level white-collar jobs, which<br />

previously were highly regarded, are very<br />

quickly disappearing. And that’s an issue,<br />

because most of the social systems >


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —42<br />

“People become fixed on<br />

an ideal profile, which tells<br />

you right away that they<br />

don’t know much about the<br />

labor market.”<br />

Jacques van den Broek<br />

Jacques van den Broek If you’re talking<br />

ICT professionals, their main reason for doing<br />

a job is the attractiveness of the project.<br />

In addition, and especially if they’re young,<br />

they are increasingly reluctant to leave<br />

home. And these are jobs that can be performed<br />

remotely. So yes, the workforce<br />

of the future – in addition to being 18 to 68,<br />

will be partly remote and partly freelancers.<br />

Indeed, we think that between 30% and<br />

35% of the total workforce will have a job<br />

that is not fixed.<br />

In terms of generations, you have a<br />

programin the Netherlands that helps<br />

older employees.<br />

Jacques van den Broek You’re talking<br />

about +Power. Which is not necessarily<br />

to say that old is ideal. In the Netherlands,<br />

we are heavily advocating stepping away a<br />

bit from the bias of ideal profiles and instead<br />

look at what people bring to the marketplace.<br />

But it’s early days. It’s still a<br />

hard sell for us to get older people back into<br />

the workforce.<br />

Why is that?<br />

Jacques van den Broek Biases are one<br />

reason. Another is that owing to pay scales<br />

and pay models, over time people outprice<br />

themselves in the labor market. It’s also<br />

linked to demand. The last time we were<br />

really creating different profiles was in 2007,<br />

which is also the last time we saw serious<br />

economic growth in Europe. Ten years ago!<br />

Once growth returns, clients will lose their<br />

reluctance. Right now, people are thinking<br />

short term; but in the long term, look at<br />

the demographics. Clients need to be open<br />

to new profiles anyway. So do employees.<br />

When people lose their job, the first thing<br />

they do is look for the same job that just<br />

disappeared, which is always tough.<br />

Employers and employees have a joint rebuilt<br />

just after the Second World War –<br />

pensions, healthcare, education – hinge on<br />

a middle class. And that needs to change.<br />

We’re looking at a different labor market.<br />

What can be done to address the problem?<br />

Jacques van den Broek Companies<br />

need to do mid- to long-term planning to<br />

see how their workforce can change. Countries<br />

need to create proactive labor market<br />

policies. If, as a country, you create a STEM<br />

(science, technology, engineering and medicine)<br />

hub – a knowledge hub – like the<br />

Rust Belt in the USA or the Eindhoven area<br />

in the Netherlands, for every STEM job<br />

you attract, you get 2.5 to 4 low- to mid-level<br />

jobs surrounding this activity for all sorts<br />

of reasons. Canada, for example, attracts<br />

1% of its total workforce almost every year<br />

based on a very clear agenda. Europe has<br />

no proactive labor market policy. And therefore,<br />

the people who want to come here<br />

are not necessarily the people we need.<br />

How is your business model<br />

at Randstad evolving?<br />

Jacques van den Broek A few things<br />

are happening. First, labor markets are increasingly<br />

mismatched, both on a country<br />

level and internationally. There’s no real<br />

scarcity of people, but people live in the<br />

wrong places. So we see a role for us in allocating<br />

work around the globe. Of course,<br />

this needs to be facilitated by governments<br />

and accepted by clients. But eventually,<br />

there will be no choice. We also see a much<br />

more diverse workforce in terms of age –<br />

18 to 68, for example – and more made-tomeasure<br />

arrangements at work because<br />

not everybody will opt for a full-time job. So<br />

we see a role for us in creative workforce<br />

planning, too.<br />

Do you see much of a trend<br />

toward freelancing?<br />

sponsibility to safeguard employability.<br />

We start a conversation to redefine their<br />

competencies toward different jobs that are<br />

available in the labor market.<br />

What happens when you add millennials<br />

into the labor market mix?<br />

Jacques van den Broek You see slight<br />

differences. Millennials are concerned<br />

about a sense of purpose and work/life balance.<br />

They want to work for start-ups<br />

and small companies. As an employer, you<br />

have to think about how to attract this<br />

group. There is still quite a divide between<br />

what companies think are their unique<br />

selling propositions and what people are<br />

looking for in the workplace. We believe that<br />

adapting to the needs of the new generation<br />

will be key in attracting the right talent.<br />

As a candidate, is it an advantage<br />

for me to be on social networks?<br />

Jacques van den Broek Of course. If you<br />

are unknown, it’s impossible for us to find<br />

you. In the old days, when people came into<br />

my branch, I’d say to them, let’s stay in<br />

touch. Because if I have not found something<br />

after two weeks, then all the candidates<br />

will have come in. It works roughly the same<br />

in social media. If you want to send a very<br />

subtle sign that you’re looking for a job,<br />

change your profile picture on Facebook.<br />

We’ll know.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —44<br />

Young and<br />

car-free<br />

For many adults, driving is associated with freedom. In many industrialized countries,<br />

however, today’s young people are using cars less and less. We look at what caused<br />

this trend and whether it is a temporary or permanent phenomenon.<br />

100%<br />

Percentage of<br />

licensed drivers aged<br />

18–24 years<br />

87%<br />

Source: US Department of Transportation,<br />

Swiss Federal Statistical Office<br />

84%<br />

81%<br />

USA<br />

2014<br />

77%<br />

71%<br />

69%<br />

63%<br />

2010<br />

2005<br />

2000<br />

1994<br />

50%<br />

59%<br />

Photo: macida / Getty Images


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —45<br />

A<br />

car used to be seen as a status<br />

symbol, associated with freedom<br />

and adulthood. This appears to no<br />

longer hold true. In recent years,<br />

there have been signs of diminishing interest<br />

in cars among young adults in industrialized<br />

countries such as the USA, Norway, the<br />

Netherlands, UK, Germany and Japan. This<br />

trend, which began in the 1990s, first manifested<br />

itself in fewer driver’s licenses among<br />

young adults compared to previous generations<br />

at the same age. In the USA, for instance,<br />

the percentage of licensed drivers<br />

aged 20 to 24 years declined from 87.2% in<br />

1994 to 76.7% 2014. In most countries, this<br />

decline was accompanied by a general decrease<br />

in car use, as evidenced in a lower<br />

number of daily car trips and daily miles traveled<br />

by car among young adults. While in<br />

some countries, for instance Germany, young<br />

adults are using alternative means of transport<br />

such as trains and bicycles, in the USA,<br />

travel demand among the young overall has<br />

decreased.<br />

The drivers of changes in mobility<br />

There are two fundamentally different theories<br />

to help explain these changing mobility patterns.<br />

The first is based on socioeconomic<br />

factors, such as length of education and the<br />

age of marriage, which have changed considerably<br />

in recent years. The significant rise in<br />

the economic return on education has resulted<br />

in higher school enrollment. This trend was<br />

additionally fueled by the recent recession. In<br />

the USA, college enrollment jumped significantly<br />

more than the secular uptrend, since<br />

people with a low level of education were encouraged<br />

to continue their education to increase<br />

their chances of finding employment.<br />

The proportion of 25- to 30-year-old Americans<br />

with college degrees increased by four<br />

percentage points between 1995 and 2009,<br />

whereas the employment rate of the same<br />

cohort decreased by nine percentage points.<br />

This pattern can also be observed in most<br />

OECD countries. Due to more years spent on<br />

education, the age when people enter the job<br />

market has increased, which implies lower or<br />

no income during the student years and delayed<br />

marriages and parenthood. If the reason<br />

for the decline in car use is lower income in<br />

younger years and postponed family formation,<br />

then young adults are likely to travel more<br />

frequently by car as they get older and settle<br />

down. This theory is summarized in a phrase<br />

coined by a Netherlands Institute for Transport<br />

Policy Analysis report on the changing<br />

mobility behavior of young adults, “not carless,<br />

but car-later.”<br />

Preferences reshape mobility needs<br />

The second theory suggests that today’s<br />

young adults have different attitudes and mobility<br />

preferences than previous generations.<br />

Hence, the decline in car use is also the result<br />

of generation-specific factors. This theory is<br />

supported by statistics on young adults in Germany,<br />

for instance, who despite car ownership<br />

use their cars less often. One possible reason<br />

for this change in attitudes is information and<br />

communication technology, which substitutes<br />

physical travel with virtual mobility. Much of<br />

the freedom car ownership grants, for example<br />

access to information and products, catching<br />

up with family and friends, is today made<br />

possible by smartphones, online shopping and<br />

social media. A further change of attitude,<br />

which is related to cars being seen as a status<br />

symbol, is the transition from ownership<br />

to sharing. Today the car is seen as a useful<br />

tool that can be borrowed when needed, similar<br />

to streaming music instead of buying a CD.<br />

This trend is confirmed by a global rise in car<br />

sharing. From 2006 to 2014, the number of<br />

members of car sharing networks globally increased<br />

from 346,610 to 4.8 million. In the<br />

USA alone, the car sharing market is forecast<br />

to reach 3.8 million members by 2020 (1.3<br />

million in 2014).<br />

Conclusions and implications<br />

Most research studies show that the decrease<br />

in car ownership is most likely caused by a<br />

combination of the above factors, but predominantly<br />

by socioeconomic ones. The social<br />

factors outlined earlier, such as the trend toward<br />

longer education and postponed family<br />

formation, in conjunction with a lower income,<br />

have created a situation in which young adults<br />

are less inclined to use or buy a car. However,<br />

once young adults get older, their interest in<br />

cars is likely to increase. The impact of virtual<br />

mobility and smartphones on mobility is<br />

probably not quite as important since these<br />

technologies became widely used after the<br />

use of cars began to diminish. While a shift<br />

away from car ownership to sharing could impact<br />

the auto industry as personal car sales<br />

decline, this effect could be partly offset by<br />

increased sales of shared vehicles. Indeed, a<br />

report by McKinsey on the perspective of the<br />

automotive industry concludes that a shift toward<br />

shared mobility could lead to lower<br />

growth in global car sales. However, global<br />

car sales are expected to continue to show<br />

positive growth of around 2% p.a. by 2030.<br />

Based on these arguments, the change in mobility<br />

behavior will likely pose a challenge, but<br />

not a severe threat to the auto industry.<br />

Julia Dumanskaya<br />

Research Analyst<br />

+41 44 333 92 83<br />

julia.dumanskaya@credit-suisse.com


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —46<br />

Millennials<br />

drive<br />

sustainability<br />

Sustainability is a key concern for the millennials generation.<br />

Companies have to adapt processes and production practices to<br />

make their products sustainable and thus seize the opportunities<br />

this rapidly growing generation of consumers creates.<br />

The millennials generation (people<br />

born roughly between the 1980s<br />

and sometime in the early 2000s) is<br />

the most sustainability-conscious<br />

generation. Recent studies from Nielsen and<br />

Deloitte show that millennials are most willing<br />

to pay more for products and services seen<br />

as sustainable or coming from socially and<br />

environmentally responsible companies. As<br />

millennials are a rapidly growing consumer<br />

market, and an influential one, we look at how<br />

companies evolve to bring them on board,<br />

particularly how this concern about sustainability<br />

affects products and production in various<br />

sectors.<br />

Fishery shows the way<br />

Human rights violations in Asia’s fish, prawn<br />

and shrimp farms have attracted widespread<br />

media coverage. A major newspaper investigation<br />

in 2014 revealed that CP Foods, the<br />

world’s largest prawn farmer, had bought fish<br />

from Thai suppliers operating or buying from<br />

fishing boats manned by slaves. The fish ended<br />

up on the shelves of leading supermarket<br />

chains such as Walmart, Carrefour, Costco<br />

and Tesco, forcing companies to quickly react.<br />

Within a week, Carrefour decided to stop purchases<br />

from CP Foods, and CP Foods issued<br />

a statement condemning slavery and committing<br />

itself to behave responsibly under the<br />

monitoring of independent non-government<br />

organizations.<br />

The sustainable seafood movement that<br />

began in the 1990s highlighted the impact of<br />

overfishing or destructive fishing methods on<br />

the environment. Social marketing through<br />

ecolabel and awareness campaigns is helping<br />

consumers to make informed choices potentially<br />

contributing to the conservation of the<br />

environment. Ecolabeling consists of evaluating<br />

the production process with set environmental<br />

standards by independent third parties.<br />

If the process fulfills requirements, the producer<br />

or marketer can use the ecolabel in its<br />

marketing and the consumer knows that the<br />

product was produced sustainably. Producers<br />

can often obtain premium prices for these<br />

products.<br />

Sustainable supply chains are key<br />

For the seafood industry today, this means<br />

that companies have to guarantee sustainable<br />

seafood, i.e. only harvesting species of fish<br />

that are in abundant supply, caught using environmentally<br />

friendly methods and respecting<br />

human rights.<br />

Companies are also realizing that building<br />

a sustainable supply chain has the potential<br />

to bring new clients and success. Tetley Tea<br />

(Tata Global Beverages) is growing tea sustainably<br />

and its campaign where smallholder<br />

farmers and tea estate workers post items<br />

about their daily lives and work and communicate<br />

with customers has been a great success.<br />

Tata Global Beverages first identified<br />

the need to develop a sustainable supply chain<br />

following disruptions in availability and prices<br />

of its tea supply. It now seeks to certify an increasing<br />

part of its tea supply under the Rainforest<br />

Alliance certification, which meets environmental,<br />

social and economic standards.<br />

With more food needed to feed a growing<br />

population and ever-increasing environmental<br />

challenges ranging from water scarcity to herbicide<br />

resistance, the food and beverages industry<br />

is leading the way to help set standards<br />

for sustainable agriculture. Nestlé and Unilever<br />

are among them. Unilever reported faster<br />

growth for its brands with a sustainability purpose<br />

compared to the rest of the business,<br />

and these brands contributed nearly half of<br />

the firm’s total growth in 2015. Nestlé has set<br />

specific requirements for palm oil, paper and<br />

board, sugar, soy, cocoa, coffee, diary, fish,<br />

seafood, meat, poultry, eggs, vanilla and hazelnuts,<br />

and sources 43% of these commodities<br />

from sustainable sources in 2015.<br />

More transparency in the apparel industry<br />

After the tragic collapse of the Rana Plaza<br />

factory building in Bangladesh in April 2013,<br />

many global fashion companies reacted and<br />

signed the Bangladesh Accord with the Bangladeshi<br />

government and workers’ trade<br />

unions to make factories safe, and global<br />

brands agreed to monitor how the factories<br />

supplying their goods are run.<br />

The difficulty is that the fashion industry<br />

constantly moves its supply chain to new locations<br />

and suppliers use unapproved outsourcing.<br />

Recently, a BBC investigation revealed<br />

unethical practices in the Turkish textile<br />

industry, involving child workers. The companies<br />

involved claimed these practices were<br />

contrary to their code of conduct and that they<br />

happened in unapproved source factories.<br />

As with the food industry, raw materials<br />

such as cotton or processes such as dyeing<br />

can be performed in a sustainable way. Fair<br />

trade cotton labels appear on garments or are<br />

developed as lines of products.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —47<br />

To date, the industry still lacks transparency,<br />

but fair cotton standards and labels have<br />

emerged and companies have developed<br />

governance standards to foster sustainability.<br />

In the future, we are likely to see new brands<br />

emerge that will reinvent the business model,<br />

using recycled or recyclable materials, or better<br />

manufacturing standards.<br />

Reshaping the automotive industry<br />

If we apply sustainability to the automobile industry<br />

and the fight against climate change<br />

and pollution in this case, we can expect millennials<br />

to favor electric cars over diesel cars<br />

and shared cars over owned cars.<br />

The emission scandal involving Volkswagen<br />

in 2015 has changed the automotive industry.<br />

Traditional automakers are in private<br />

discussions about the end of diesel in ten<br />

years. Stricter emissions testing leaves no<br />

choice for the traditional carmakers but to engage<br />

in electric cars. Developments in technology<br />

companies such as Google or new entrants<br />

such as Tesla are pushing car companies<br />

to already act today. This year, the manufacturers<br />

have revealed ambitious electric<br />

auto development programs. Daimler raised<br />

its capex program at the start of the year and<br />

will develop premium electric cars, which is a<br />

segment dominated by Tesla at the moment.<br />

Continental, a supplier to German original<br />

equipment manufacturers (OEMs), also just<br />

announced a step-up in capex. Volkswagen<br />

has announced that, by 2025, 25% of its vehicles<br />

will be electric. BMW was among the<br />

first to launch electric vehicles. Companies<br />

have recognized the need to spend money now<br />

and in the years to come.<br />

Autonomous driving is another development.<br />

More and more features are being added<br />

to cars, from autonomous parking to semiautonomous<br />

driving. While legislation hurdles<br />

still have to be passed, we can envisage fully<br />

autonomous driving becoming a reality in the<br />

next decade or so. Given that millennials have<br />

already adopted sharing behaviors, autonomous<br />

driving will facilitate the development of<br />

the sharing model for cars. Again, traditional<br />

OEMs have recognized this development and<br />

are acquiring companies in the sharing car<br />

market to offer such services themselves.<br />

Growth through sustainability<br />

economy. We see spending diverted away<br />

from traditional retail products. The sportswear<br />

industry is benefiting strongly as sports<br />

items have become part of everyday wear in<br />

the search for health and wellness. Eating<br />

smart and from organic or local sources instead<br />

of eating food produced through chemically<br />

polluting-intensive agricultural practices<br />

or industrial processing has led to the development<br />

of specialty grocers such as Whole<br />

Foods or Sprouts Farmers Market. The traditional<br />

food retailers have also evolved to address<br />

this trend, and have captured a bigger<br />

share of the natural/organic industry in recent<br />

years. Smaller brands are appearing in the<br />

staples industry and gaining market share. In<br />

the healthcare industry, millennials are embracing<br />

alternative medicine rather than conventional<br />

medical treatments and prescription<br />

drugs. Natural remedies and alternative medicines<br />

feel safer and cleaner and are more in<br />

line with millennials’ values.<br />

Millennials are an influential and rapidly<br />

growing consumer market. Established industries<br />

must now adapt their business models if<br />

they want millennials on board. Companies<br />

must deliver good social and environmental<br />

performance and engage in sustainable practices<br />

or their future growth could be at risk.<br />

New companies are being created to embrace<br />

new opportunities.<br />

Julie Saussier<br />

Research Analyst<br />

+41 44 333 12 56<br />

julie.saussier-clement@credit-suisse.com<br />

“Sharing instead<br />

of consuming leads to<br />

the development of<br />

the sharing economy.”<br />

Julie Saussier<br />

More generally, this search for sustainable<br />

behavior is pushing millennials to adopt new<br />

consumer habits, thus opening up new growth<br />

opportunities. Sharing instead of consuming<br />

is leading to the development of the sharing


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —48<br />

FEEDING FUTURE GENERATIONS<br />

How weather affects agriculture and what IBM can do with precision weather forecasts to help farmers. Source: IBM<br />

INCREASING CROP YIELDS<br />

90%<br />

of all crop losses are due to weather.<br />

Weather-related crop damage could be<br />

reduced by 25% using predictive weather<br />

modeling and precision agriculture techniques.<br />

PRECISION AGRICULTURE<br />

IBM is using data to help farmers be more<br />

efficient in their operations and make more precise<br />

decisions about planting, growing, harvesting<br />

and transporting crops, leading to better price<br />

points and a stable supply chain.<br />

WEATHER MODELING<br />

DEEP THUNDER<br />

IBM’s Deep Thunder is a service that<br />

provides a hyperlocal forecast up to<br />

36 hours in advance with 90% accuracy.<br />

SENSORS<br />

GROWING<br />

70%<br />

of fresh water worldwide is<br />

used for agriculture purposes.<br />

If farmers know when and where<br />

it’s going to rain they can better<br />

schedule their irrigation and<br />

know when they should put down<br />

fertilizer, to avoid runoff.


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —49<br />

Farmer<br />

CTOs<br />

Farmers are among the most prominent<br />

adopters of robotic technologies. New<br />

applications using the Internet of Things (IoT),<br />

Big Data and robotics may well revolutionize<br />

the agricultural sector in the next ten years.<br />

This could help to solve the current mismatch<br />

between rising demand for food and limited<br />

arable land capacity.<br />

TRANSPORTATION<br />

50%<br />

of food ready for harvest never<br />

reaches the consumers mouth.<br />

By understanding the effect of weather<br />

on transportation networks, companies<br />

can make better decisions on which<br />

routes will be the fastest to transport<br />

their food.<br />

THE IMPACT<br />

As farmers reduce waste<br />

and increase crop yields,<br />

consumers will feel the<br />

positive economic impact<br />

at the grocery store.<br />

In the past, a farmer was seen as someone who loves nature and<br />

leads a strenuous, rather solitary life with little connection to the<br />

outside world. Furthermore, farmers were often considered to be<br />

highly critical of progress. Today, however, automation and digitization<br />

are becoming increasingly important in farming – a vital and<br />

essential element to solve problems in the agricultural sector. From<br />

vertical farming, where fruits and vegetables are digitally monitored<br />

and grown in artificial greenhouses, to vast farmlands that are connected<br />

to the Internet using sensors, robots and Big Data solutions<br />

are used to reduce costs and improve crop yields. Furthermore, digital<br />

farming can also help to cultivate new areas of farmland. In future,<br />

therefore, farmers look set to become the chief technology officers<br />

(CTOs) of agriculture.<br />

Food availability constraints ask for new solutions<br />

Illustration: IBM, C3, The Noun Project<br />

The United Nations (UN) predicts that the global population will rise<br />

from 7.3 billion today to 9.7 billion in 2050. The UN Food and Agriculture<br />

Organization (FAO) predicts that this growth would require increasing<br />

overall food production by about 70%, as the growing middle class<br />

places increased demand on food products. Demand for livestock,<br />

dairy products and other commodities is highly correlated to higher<br />

income in the developing countries. There is a clear need to further<br />

improve the efficiency of farming existing arable land and thus increase<br />

output. However, arable land is concentrated in Oceania and the USA,<br />

creating a major mismatch with where the global population is. For<br />

example, food availability in China is increasingly constrained, and >


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 —50<br />

efficiency improvements alone cannot solve the problem. Cultivating<br />

new arable land is important as well.<br />

Robotics and drones for growers<br />

The increasing strain on food supply, the availability and cost of farm<br />

workers, the challenges and complexities of farm labor, shrinking<br />

farmlands, climate change and the growth of indoor farming all argue<br />

in favor of increasingly employing robots in agriculture. Recent progress<br />

in making processing power cheaper, combined with artificial<br />

intelligence and the increasing learning power of machines, enables<br />

a new kind of e-farming.<br />

While milking systems are already widely deployed, we believe the<br />

demand for driverless tractors or semiautonomous vehicles, synced<br />

vehicles and processing equipment as well as smart agriculture applications<br />

such as traceability or swarm robots for the harvest season<br />

could increase exponentially because of the expected momentum in<br />

innovation. For instance, drones can be used for observation (security)<br />

and to detect areas where crops are failing to grow. In the latter<br />

case, the drones would call collectively programmed swarm robots<br />

to protect or recover the affected areas. According to a report from<br />

Tractica (“Agricultural Robots,” July 2015), annual shipments of agricultural<br />

robots are likely to reach 992,000 worldwide by 2024, up<br />

from just 33,000 in 2015. Tractica forecasts that some of the largest<br />

application segments will include unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs or<br />

drones) for agricultural purposes, soil management robots, material<br />

management robots, driverless tractors and dairy management robots.<br />

Agritechnology in Africa, a new growth area<br />

Africa is said to have a quarter of the world’s arable land, but 80% of<br />

it is underutilized or simply lies idle. Most of the remaining 20% is in<br />

the hands of small-scale peasant farmers that are unfamiliar with<br />

commercial farming to improve production. There are a multitude of<br />

projects in Africa that focus on improving crop yields and cultivating<br />

new farmland with the help of information technology. The bottleneck<br />

so far is access to the Internet in rural areas. However, research firm<br />

McKinsey estimates that Africa will triple its Internet penetration<br />

to over 50% – the equivalent of 600 million regular Internet users –<br />

by 2025.<br />

Projects such as IBM’s EZ Farm use Big Data and the IoT to provide<br />

farmers and water service providers with insights into current<br />

and predicted water and soil moisture levels via smartphone applications.<br />

As part of this project, farms are equipped with cheap water<br />

tanks, soil moisture and infrared light sensors to monitor the health<br />

of plants, resulting in higher yields and lower farming costs. Smartphone<br />

applications from other firms such as M-Farm, iCow, Farm-<br />

Drive, WeFarm or MbeguChoice offer access to education (such as<br />

feeding practices or disease control), provide better, drought-tolerant<br />

seed varieties and give financing and troubleshooting support. The<br />

investments for digital farming are increasingly coming from outside<br />

of Africa. For instance, Chinese companies have acquired farmland<br />

in Congo, Mozambique and Angola and are using IT to cultivate new<br />

farmland in these areas.<br />

Precision farming increases efficiency<br />

John Deere, a leader of high-tech machinery in the agriculture sector,<br />

is taking the IoT into the field and boosting efficiencies with the<br />

help of SAP’s Big Data solutions. Sensors on the John Deere equipment<br />

help farmers to manage their fleet and decrease downtime of<br />

their tractors and save fuel. The information is combined with historical<br />

and real-time weather data, soil conditions, crop features and<br />

many other kinds of data. The so-called precision farming hardware<br />

market (using displays, GPS, yield monitors and sensors) is expected<br />

to grow at a compound annual growth rate of 11.7% between 2015<br />

and 2020 and reach USD 4.8 billion, according to research firm<br />

MarketsandMarkets. The potential benefits of software application in<br />

farming – such as higher yields, low input waste, reduced financial<br />

losses – could turn out to be very high. The FAO expects that precision<br />

farming could lift crop yields by 70% by 2050 and thus make a<br />

valuable contribution to feeding the world.<br />

Uwe Neumann<br />

Research Analyst<br />

+41 44 334 56 45<br />

uwe.neumann@credit-suisse.com


GLOBAL INVESTOR 1.17 — 51<br />

Authors<br />

Lorenzo Biasio<br />

Research Analyst.........................................................<br />

lorenzo.biasio@credit-suisse.com..................................<br />

+41 44 333 14 79.......................................................<br />

Lorenzo Biasio is a research analyst in Global Equity<br />

and Credit Research at Credit Suisse, covering the<br />

healthcare sector. Prior to joining Credit Suisse in 2014,<br />

he was a management consultant in the pharma/<br />

healthcare space. Lorenzo holds a Master’s degree in<br />

Biology from ETH Zurich, Switzerland.<br />

> Pages 10, 13, 16, 27, 33, 36–37, 41–43, 48–50, 52–53, 58<br />

Uwe Neumann<br />

Research Analyst.........................................................<br />

uwe.neumann@credit-suisse.com.................................<br />

+41 44 334 56 45.......................................................<br />

Uwe Neumann is a senior research analyst in the Global<br />

Equity and Credit Research team at Credit Suisse<br />

Inter national Wealth Management, covering the telecom<br />

and technology sectors. He has 29 years of experience<br />

in the securities and banking business, holds a Master of<br />

Economics from the University of Constance, Germany,<br />

and is a CEFA Charterholder. > Page 03<br />

Julia Dumanskaya<br />

Research Analyst.........................................................<br />

julia.dumanskaya@credit-suisse.com.............................<br />

+41 44 333 92 83.......................................................<br />

Julia Dumanskaya is a research analyst in Economic<br />

Research at Credit Suisse, working in the Fundamental<br />

Macroeconomics team. She joined Credit Suisse in<br />

2011 and has five years of experience as a financial and<br />

research analyst in the Foreign Exchange team as<br />

well as in the Economic Research team. Julia holds an<br />

MA in Economics and Business Administration from<br />

the University of Zurich, Switzerland. > Pages 44–45<br />

Julie Saussier<br />

Research Analyst.........................................................<br />

julie.saussier-clement@credit-suisse.com......................<br />

+41 44 333 12 56.......................................................<br />

Julie Saussier is a senior research analyst in the Global<br />

Equity team, covering the consumer discretionary sector.<br />

She has 14 years of experience as a research analyst<br />

and joined Credit Suisse in 2015. She holds a Master’s<br />

degree in Business and Management from the University<br />

of Paris-Dauphine and a Master’s degree in Corporate<br />

Finance from the Emlyon Business School, France, and is<br />

a CFA Charterholder. > Pages 07, 11, 15, 22, 26, 30–32<br />

Reto Hess<br />

Research Analyst.........................................................<br />

reto.hess@credit-suisse.com........................................<br />

+41 44 334 56 24.......................................................<br />

Reto Hess is a senior research analyst at Credit Suisse<br />

International Wealth Management with 12 years of<br />

experience in equity research and investment management.<br />

He heads the Global Equity Research team and<br />

covers the European and US industrials sector. Further,<br />

Reto is a CFA and CAIA Charterholder and holds a Master<br />

of Science from the University of Zurich, Switzerland.<br />

> Pages 08–09, 12, 38–43, 59, 61<br />

Ulrich Kaiser<br />

Research Analyst.........................................................<br />

ulrich.kaiser@credit-suisse.com....................................<br />

+41 44 334 56 49.......................................................<br />

Ulrich Kaiser is a senior financial analyst of Credit Suisse in<br />

the International Wealth Management Division, covering<br />

the technology sector. He joined Credit Suisse in 1993 and<br />

has 28 years of experience in the securities and banking<br />

business. He received his Master of Economics from<br />

the University of Constance, Germany, and is a CEFA<br />

Charterholder. > Pages 17, 23, 44–47, 51, 60, 62<br />

Christine Schmid<br />

Head of Global Equity and Credit Research...................<br />

christine.schmid@credit-suisse.com..............................<br />

+41 44 334 56 43.......................................................<br />

Christine Schmid is Head of Global Equit and Credit<br />

Research at Credit Suisse International Wealth<br />

Management. She has 23 years of experience and covers<br />

the financials sector. She holds an MA in Economics<br />

from the University of Zurich and is a CFA Charterholder.<br />

> Pages 14, 34–35<br />

Fabian Waltert<br />

Research Analyst.........................................................<br />

fabian.waltert@credit-suisse.com..................................<br />

+41 44 333 25 57.......................................................<br />

Fabian Waltert is a senior economist at Credit Suisse<br />

International Wealth Management. He covers Swiss<br />

real estate and construction and holds a PhD in<br />

Economics from the University of Zurich, Switzerland.<br />

> Pages 14, 34–35<br />

Angus Muirhead<br />

Senior Portfolio Manager..............................................<br />

angus.muirhead@credit-suisse.com..............................<br />

+41 44 332 32 59.......................................................<br />

Angus Muirhead is a senior portfolio manager in the<br />

Thematic Equity team at Credit Suisse Asset Management.<br />

He joined the team in September 2016 and<br />

has 19 years of experience as an analyst and portfolio<br />

manager investing in the technology and healthcare<br />

sectors. He is currently responsible for the CS (Lux)<br />

Global Robotics Equity Fund, together with Dr. Patrick<br />

Kolb. Angus has a BA degree from Durham University<br />

in Modern Japanese Language and Business Studies,<br />

and is a CFA Charterholder. > Pages 17–19


Risk warning<br />

Every investment involves risk, especially with regard to fluctuations<br />

in value and return. If an investment is denominated in<br />

a currency other than your base currency, changes in the rate<br />

of exchange may have an adverse effect on value, price or income.<br />

For a discussion of the risks of investing in the securities mentioned<br />

in this report, please refer to the following Internet link:<br />

https://research.credit-suisse.com/riskdisclosure.<br />

This report may include information on investments that involve<br />

special risks. You should seek the advice of your independent<br />

financial advisor prior to taking any investment decisions based<br />

on this report or for any necessary explanation of its contents.<br />

Further information is also available in the information brochure<br />

“Special Risks in Securities Trading” available from the Swiss<br />

Bankers Association.<br />

The price, value of and income from any of the securities or financial<br />

instruments mentioned in this report can fall as well as<br />

rise. The value of securities and financial instruments is affected<br />

by changes in spot or forward interest and exchange<br />

rates, economic indicators, the financial standing of any issuer<br />

or reference issuer, etc., that may have a positive or adverse<br />

effect on the income from or price of such securities or financial<br />

instruments. By purchasing securities or financial instruments,<br />

you may incur a loss or a loss in excess of the principal as a<br />

result of fluctuations in market prices or other financial indices,<br />

etc. Investors in securities such as ADRs, the values of which<br />

are influenced by currency volatility, effectively assume this risk.<br />

Commission rates for brokerage transactions will be as per the<br />

rates agreed between CS and the investor. For transactions<br />

conducted on a principal-to-principal basis between CS and the<br />

investor, the purchase or sale price will be the total consideration.<br />

Transactions conducted on a principal-to-principal basis, including<br />

over-the-counter derivative transactions, will be quoted as<br />

a purchase/bid price or sell/offer price, in which case a difference<br />

or spread may exist. Charges in relation to transactions<br />

will be agreed upon prior to transactions, in line with relevant<br />

laws and regulations. Please read the pre-contract documentation,<br />

etc., carefully for an explanation of risks and commissions,<br />

etc., of the relevant securities or financial instruments prior to<br />

purchase.<br />

Structured securities are complex instruments, typically involve<br />

a high degree of risk and are intended for sale only to sophisticated<br />

investors who are capable of understanding and assuming<br />

the risks involved. The market value of any structured security<br />

may be affected by changes in economic, financial and political<br />

factors (including, but not limited to, spot and forward interest<br />

and exchange rates), time to maturity, market conditions and<br />

volatility, and the credit quality of any issuer or reference issuer.<br />

Any investor interested in purchasing a structured product should<br />

conduct their own investigation and analysis of the product and<br />

consult with their own professional advisers as to the risks involved<br />

in making such a purchase.<br />

Some investments discussed in this report have a high level of<br />

volatility. High volatility investments may experience sudden and<br />

large falls in their value causing losses when that investment is<br />

realized. Those losses may equal your original investment. Indeed,<br />

in the case of some investments the potential losses may<br />

exceed the amount of initial investment, in such circumstances<br />

you may be required to pay more money to support those losses.<br />

Income yields from investments may fluctuate and, in consequence,<br />

initial capital paid to make the investment may be<br />

used as part of that income yield. Some investments may not<br />

be readily realizable and it may be difficult to sell or realize those<br />

investments, similarly it may prove difficult for you to obtain<br />

reliable information about the value, or risks, to which such an<br />

investment is exposed. Please contact your Relationship Manager<br />

if you have any questions.<br />

Past performance is not an indicator of future performance. Performance<br />

can be affected by commissions, fees or other charges<br />

as well as exchange rate fluctuations.<br />

Sensitivities<br />

Sensitivity analysis is understood as the change in the market<br />

value (e.g. price) of a financial instrument for a given change in<br />

a risk factor and/or model assumption. Specifically, the market<br />

value of any financial instrument may be affected by changes in<br />

economic, financial and political factors (including, but not limited<br />

to, spot and forward interest and exchange rates), time to<br />

maturity, market conditions and volatility, and the credit quality<br />

of any issuer or reference issuer.<br />

Financial market risks<br />

Historical returns and financial market scenarios are no guarantee<br />

of future performance. The price and value of investments<br />

mentioned and any income that might accrue could fall or rise<br />

or fluctuate. Past performance is not a guide to future performance.<br />

If an investment is denominated in a currency other than<br />

your base currency, changes in the rate of exchange may have<br />

an adverse effect on value, price or income. You should consult<br />

with such advisor(s) as you consider necessary to assist you in<br />

making these determinations.<br />

Investments may have no public market or only a restricted secondary<br />

market. Where a secondary market exists, it is not possible<br />

to predict the price at which investments will trade in the<br />

market or whether such market will be liquid or illiquid.<br />

Emerging markets<br />

Where this report relates to emerging markets, you should be<br />

aware that there are uncertainties and risks associated with<br />

investments and transactions in various types of investments<br />

of, or related or linked to, issuers and obligors incorporated,<br />

based or principally engaged in business in emerging markets<br />

countries. Investments related to emerging markets countries<br />

may be considered speculative, and their prices will be much<br />

more volatile than those in the more developed countries of the<br />

world. Investments in emerging markets investments should be<br />

made only by sophisticated investors or experienced professionals<br />

who have independent knowledge of the relevant markets,<br />

are able to consider and weigh the various risks presented by<br />

such investments, and have the financial resources necessary<br />

to bear the substantial risk of loss of investment in such investments.<br />

It is your responsibility to manage the risks which arise<br />

as a result of investing in emerging markets investments and<br />

the allocation of assets in your portfolio. You should seek advice<br />

from your own advisers with regard to the various risks and<br />

factors to be considered when investing in an emerging markets<br />

investment.<br />

Alternative investments<br />

Hedge funds are not subject to the numerous investor protection<br />

regulations that apply to regulated authorized collective investments<br />

and hedge fund managers are largely unregulated. Hedge<br />

funds are not limited to any particular investment discipline or<br />

trading strategy, and seek to profit in all kinds of markets by<br />

using leverage, derivatives, and complex speculative investment<br />

strategies that may increase the risk of investment loss.<br />

Commodity transactions carry a high degree of risk and may not<br />

be suitable for many private investors. The extent of loss due to<br />

market movements can be substantial or even result in a total<br />

loss.<br />

Investors in real estate are exposed to liquidity, foreign currency<br />

and other risks, including cyclical risk, rental and local<br />

market risk as well as environmental risk, and changes to the<br />

legal situation.<br />

Interest rate and credit risks<br />

The retention of value of a bond is dependent on the creditworthiness<br />

of the Issuer and/or Guarantor (as applicable), which<br />

may change over the term of the bond. In the event of default<br />

by the Issuer and/or Guarantor of the bond, the bond or any<br />

income derived from it is not guaranteed and you may get back<br />

none of, or less than, what was originally invested.<br />

Disclosures<br />

The information and opinions expressed in this report (other than<br />

article contributions by Investment Strategists) were produced<br />

by the Research department of the International Wealth Management<br />

division of CS as of the date of writing and are subject to<br />

change without notice. Views expressed in respect of a particular<br />

security in this report may be different from, or inconsistent<br />

with, the observations and views of the Credit Suisse Research<br />

department of Investment Banking division due to the<br />

differences in evaluation criteria.<br />

Article contributions by Investment Strategists are not research<br />

reports. Investment Strategists are not part of the CS Research<br />

department. CS has policies in place designed to ensure the<br />

independence of CS Research Department including policies<br />

relating to restrictions on trading of relevant securities prior to<br />

distribution of research reports. These policies do not apply to<br />

Investment Strategists.<br />

CS accepts no liability for loss arising from the use of the material<br />

presented in this report, except that this exclusion of liability<br />

does not apply to the extent that liability arises under specific<br />

statutes or regulations applicable to CS. This report is not<br />

to be relied upon in substitution for the exercise of independent<br />

judgment. CS may have issued, and may in the future issue, a<br />

trading idea regarding this security. Trading ideas are short term<br />

trading opportunities based on market events and catalysts,<br />

while company recommendations reflect investment recommendations<br />

based on expected total return over a 6- to 12-month<br />

period as defined in the disclosure section. Because trading<br />

ideas and company recommendations reflect different assumptions<br />

and analytical methods, trading ideas may differ from the<br />

company recommendations. In addition, CS may have issued,<br />

and may in the future issue, other reports that are inconsistent<br />

with, and reach different conclusions from, the information presented<br />

in this report. Those reports reflect the different assumptions,<br />

views and analytical methods of the analysts who<br />

prepared them and CS is under no obligation to ensure that such<br />

other reports are brought to the attention of any recipient of this<br />

report.<br />

Analyst certification<br />

The analysts identified in this report hereby certify that views<br />

about the companies and their securities discussed in this report<br />

accurately reflect their personal views about all of the subject<br />

companies and securities. The analysts also certify that no part<br />

of their compensation was, is, or will be directly or indirectly<br />

related to the specific recommendation(s) or view(s) in this report.<br />

Knowledge Process Outsourcing (KPO) Analysts mentioned in<br />

this report are employed by Credit Suisse Business Analytics<br />

(India) Private Limited.<br />

Important disclosures<br />

CS policy is to publish and update research reports/recommendations<br />

with the frequency, as it deems appropriate, based<br />

on developments with the subject company, the sector or the<br />

market that may have a material impact on the research views<br />

or opinions stated herein. CS policy is only to publish investment<br />

research that is impartial, independent, clear, fair and not misleading.<br />

The Credit Suisse Code of Conduct to which all employees are<br />

obliged to adhere, is accessible via the Web site at: http://www.<br />

credit-suisse.com/governance/en/code_of_conduct.html.<br />

For more detail, please refer to the information on independence<br />

of financial research, which can be found at: https://www.<br />

credit-suisse.com/legal/pb_research/independence_en.pdf.<br />

The analyst(s) responsible for preparing this research report<br />

received compensation that is based upon various factors including<br />

CS’s total revenues, a portion of which is generated by<br />

Credit Suisse Investment Banking business.<br />

Additional disclosures<br />

United Kingdom: for fixed income disclosure information for clients<br />

of Credit Suisse (UK) Limited and Credit Suisse Securities<br />

(Europe) Limited, please call +41 44 333 33 99.<br />

India: please visit http://www.credit-suisse.com/in/researchdisclosure<br />

for additional disclosures mandated by the Securities<br />

And Exchange Board of India (Research Analysts) Regulations,<br />

2014.<br />

Credit Suisse may have an interest in the companies mentioned<br />

in this report. CS research reports are also available on https://<br />

investment.credit-suisse.com/.<br />

For information regarding disclosure information on Credit Suisse<br />

Investment Banking rated companies mentioned in this report,<br />

please refer to the Investment Banking division disclosure site<br />

at: https://rave.credit-suisse.com/disclosures.<br />

For further information, including disclosures with respect to<br />

any other issuers, please refer to the Private Banking & Wealth<br />

Management division disclosure site at: https://www.creditsuisse.com/disclosure.<br />

Global disclaimer / important information<br />

This report is not directed to, or intended for distribution to or<br />

use by, any person or entity who is a citizen or resident of or<br />

located in any locality, state, country or other jurisdiction where<br />

such distribution, publication, availability or use would be contrary<br />

to law or regulation or which would subject CS to any<br />

registration or licensing requirement within such jurisdiction.<br />

References in this report to CS include Credit Suisse AG, the<br />

Swiss bank, its subsidiaries and affiliates. For more information<br />

on our structure, please use the following link: http://www.<br />

credit-suisse.com/.<br />

NO DISTRIBUTION, SOLICITATION, OR ADVICE: this report is<br />

provided for information and illustrative purposes and is intended<br />

for your use only. It is not a solicitation, offer or recommendation<br />

to buy or sell any security or other financial instrument.<br />

Any information including facts, opinions or quotations, may be<br />

condensed or summarized and is expressed as of the date of<br />

writing. The information contained in this report has been provided<br />

as a general market commentary only and does not constitute<br />

any form of regulated financial advice, legal, tax or other<br />

regulated service. It does not take into account the financial<br />

objectives, situation or needs of any persons, which are necessary<br />

considerations before making any investment decision. You<br />

should seek the advice of your independent financial advisor<br />

prior to taking any investment decisions based on this report or<br />

for any necessary explanation of its contents. This report is<br />

intended only to provide observations and views of CS at the


date of writing, regardless of the date on which you receive or<br />

access the information. Observations and views contained in<br />

this report may be different from those expressed by other Departments<br />

at CS and may change at any time without notice and<br />

with no obligation to update. CS is under no obligation to ensure<br />

that such updates are brought to your attention. FORECASTS<br />

& ESTIMATES: past performance should not be taken as an<br />

indication or guarantee of future performance, and no representation<br />

or warranty, express or implied, is made regarding<br />

future performance. To the extent that this report contains statements<br />

about future performance, such statements are forward<br />

looking and subject to a number of risks and uncertainties. Unless<br />

indicated to the contrary, all figures are unaudited. All<br />

valuations mentioned herein are subject to CS valuation policies<br />

and procedures. CONFLICTS: CS reserves the right to remedy<br />

any errors that may be present in this report. Credit Suisse, its<br />

affiliates and/or their employees may have a position or holding,<br />

or other material interest or effect transactions in any securities<br />

mentioned or options thereon, or other investments related<br />

thereto and from time to time may add to or dispose of such<br />

investments. CS may be providing, or have provided within the<br />

previous 12 months, significant advice in relation to the investments<br />

listed in this report or a related investment to any company<br />

or issuer mentioned. Some investments referred to in this<br />

report will be offered by a single entity or an associate of CS or<br />

CS may be the only market maker in such investments. CS is<br />

involved in many businesses that relate to companies mentioned<br />

in this report. These businesses include specialized trading, risk<br />

arbitrage, market making, and other proprietary trading. CS is<br />

party to an agreement with the issuer relating to provision of<br />

services of investment firms. TAX: nothing in this report constitutes<br />

investment, legal, accounting or tax advice. CS does not<br />

advise on the tax consequences of investments and you are<br />

advised to contact an independent tax advisor. The levels and<br />

basis of taxation are dependent on individual circumstances and<br />

are subject to change. SOURCES: information and opinions<br />

presented in this report have been obtained or derived from<br />

sources which in the opinion of CS are reliable, but CS makes<br />

no representation as to their accuracy or completeness. CS<br />

accepts no liability for a loss arising from the use of this report.<br />

WEB SITES: this report may provide the addresses of, or contain<br />

hyperlinks to, Web sites. Except to the extent to which the report<br />

refers to Web site material of CS, CS has not reviewed the linked<br />

site and takes no responsibility for the content contained therein.<br />

Such address or hyperlink (including addresses or hyperlinks<br />

to CS’s own Web site material) is provided solely for your<br />

convenience and information and the content of the linked site<br />

does not in any way form part of this report. Accessing such<br />

Web site or following such link through this report or CS’s Web<br />

site shall be at your own risk.<br />

Distribution of research reports<br />

Except as otherwise specified herein, this report is prepared<br />

and issued by Credit Suisse AG, a Swiss bank, authorized and<br />

regulated by the Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority.<br />

Australia: this report is distributed in Australia by Credit Suisse<br />

AG, Sydney Branch (CSSB) (ABN 17 061 700 712 AFSL<br />

226896) only to “Wholesale” clients as defined by s761G of the<br />

Corporations Act 2001. CSSB does not guarantee the performance<br />

of, nor make any assurances with respect to the performance<br />

of any financial product referred herein. Austria: this<br />

report is distributed by CREDIT SUISSE (LUXEMBOURG) S.A.<br />

Zweigniederlassung Österreich. The Bank is a branch of CRED-<br />

IT SUISSE (LUXEMBOURG) S.A., a duly authorized credit institution<br />

in the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg with address 5, rue<br />

Jean Monnet, L-2180 Luxemburg. It is further subject to the<br />

prudential supervision of the Luxembourg supervisory authority,<br />

the Commission de Surveillance du Secteur Financier (CSSF),<br />

110, route d’Arlon, L-2991 Luxembourg, Grand Duchy of Luxembourg<br />

as well as the Austrian supervisory authority, the Financial<br />

Market Authority (FMA), Otto-Wagner Platz 5, A-1090<br />

Vienna. Bahrain: this report is distributed by Credit Suisse AG,<br />

Bahrain Branch, authorized and regulated by the Central Bank<br />

of Bahrain (CBB) as an Investment Firm Category 2. Credit<br />

Suisse AG, Bahrain Branch is located at Level 22, East Tower,<br />

Bahrain World Trade Centre, Manama, Kingdom of Bahrain.<br />

Dubai: this information is being distributed by Credit Suisse AG<br />

(DIFC Branch), duly licensed and regulated by the Dubai Financial<br />

Services Authority (“DFSA”). Related financial services or<br />

products are only made available to Professional Clients or<br />

Market Counterparties, as defined by the DFSA, and are not<br />

intended for any other persons. Credit Suisse AG (DIFC Branch)<br />

is located on Level 9 East, The Gate Building, DIFC, Dubai,<br />

United Arab Emirates. France: this report is distributed by<br />

Credit Suisse (Luxembourg) S.A., Succursale en France, authorized<br />

by the Autorité de Contrôle Prudentiel et de Résolution<br />

(ACPR) as an investment service provider. Credit Suisse (Luxembourg)<br />

S.A., Succursale en France, is supervised and regulated<br />

by the Autorité de Contrôle Prudentiel et de Résolution<br />

and the Autorité des Marchés Financiers. Germany: this report<br />

is distributed by Credit Suisse (Deutschland) AG which is authorized<br />

and regulated by the Bundesanstalt für Finanzdienstleistungsaufsicht<br />

(BaFin). Gibraltar: this report is distributed by<br />

Credit Suisse (Gibraltar) Limited. Credit Suisse (Gibraltar) Limited<br />

is an independent legal entity wholly owned by Credit Suisse<br />

and is regulated by the Gibraltar Financial Services Commission.<br />

Guernsey: this report is distributed by Credit Suisse (Channel<br />

Islands) Limited, an independent legal entity registered in Guernsey<br />

under 15197, with its registered address at Helvetia Court,<br />

Les Echelons, South Esplanade, St Peter Port, Guernsey.<br />

Credit Suisse (Channel Islands) Limited is wholly owned by<br />

Credit Suisse AG and is regulated by the Guernsey Financial<br />

Services Commission. Copies of the latest audited accounts are<br />

available on request. Hong Kong: this report is issued in Hong<br />

Kong by Credit Suisse AG Hong Kong Branch, an authorized<br />

institution regulated by the Hong Kong Monetary Authority and<br />

a registered institution regulated by the Securities and Futures<br />

Ordinance (Chapter 571 of the Laws of Hong Kong). India: this<br />

report is distributed by Credit Suisse Securities (India) Private<br />

Limited (CIN no. U67120MH1996PTC104392) regulated by<br />

the Securities and Exchange Board of India as Research Analyst<br />

(registration no. INH 000001030), as Portfolio Manager (registration<br />

no. INP000002478) and as Stock Broker (registration<br />

no. INB230970637; INF230970637; INB010970631;<br />

INF010970631), having registered address at 9th Floor, Ceejay<br />

House, Dr. A. B. Road, Worli, Mumbai 400018, India, +91-22<br />

6777 3777. Italy: this report is distributed in Italy by Credit<br />

Suisse (Italy) S.p.A., a bank incorporated and registered under<br />

Italian law subject to the supervision and control of Banca d’Italia<br />

and CONSOB, and also distributed by Credit Suisse AG, a Swiss<br />

bank authorized to provide banking and financial services in<br />

Italy. Japan: this report is solely distributed in Japan by Credit<br />

Suisse Securities (Japan) Limited, Financial Instruments Dealer,<br />

Director-General of Kanto Local Finance Bureau (Kinsho)<br />

No. 66, a member of the Japan Securities Dealers Association,<br />

Financial Futures Association of Japan, Japan Investment Advisers<br />

Association, and Type II Financial Instruments Firms Association.<br />

Credit Suisse Securities (Japan) Limited will not<br />

distribute or forward this report outside Japan. Jersey: this<br />

report is distributed by Credit Suisse (Channel Islands) Limited,<br />

Jersey Branch, which is regulated by the Jersey Financial Services<br />

Commission for the conduct of investment business. The<br />

address of Credit Suisse (Channel Islands) Limited, Jersey<br />

Branch, in Jersey is: TradeWind House, 22 Esplanade, St Helier,<br />

Jersey JE4 5WU. Lebanon: this report is distributed by<br />

Credit Suisse (Lebanon) Finance SAL (“CSLF”), a financial<br />

institution incorporated in Lebanon and regulated by the Central<br />

Bank of Lebanon (“CBL”) with a financial institution license<br />

number 42. Credit Suisse (Lebanon) Finance SAL is subject to<br />

the CBL’s laws and regulations as well as the laws and decisions<br />

of the Capital Markets Authority of Lebanon (“CMA”). CSLF is<br />

a subsidiary of Credit Suisse AG and part of the Credit Suisse<br />

Group (CS). The CMA does not accept any responsibility for the<br />

content of the information included in this report, including the<br />

accuracy or completeness of such information. The liability for<br />

the content of this report lies with the issuer, its directors and<br />

other persons, such as experts, whose opinions are included in<br />

the report with their consent. The CMA has also not assessed<br />

the suitability of the investment for any particular investor or<br />

type of investor. Investments in financial markets may involve a<br />

high degree of complexity and risk and may not be suitable to<br />

all investors. The suitability assessment performed by CSLF<br />

with respect to this investment will be undertaken based on<br />

information that the investor would have provided to CSLF and<br />

in accordance with Credit Suisse internal policies and processes.<br />

It is understood that the English language will be used in all<br />

communication and documentation provided by CS and/or CSLF.<br />

By accepting to invest in the product, the investor confirms that<br />

he has no objection to the use of the English language. Luxembourg:<br />

this report is distributed by Credit Suisse (Luxembourg)<br />

S.A., a Luxembourg bank, authorized and regulated by the Commission<br />

de Surveillance du Secteur Financier (CSSF). Qatar:<br />

this information has been distributed by Credit Suisse (Qatar)<br />

L.L.C, which has been authorized and is regulated by the Qatar<br />

Financial Centre Regulatory Authority (QFCRA) under QFC<br />

No. 00005. All related financial products or services will only<br />

be available to business customers or market counterparties<br />

(as defined by the Qatar Financial Centre Regulatory Authority<br />

(QFCRA) rules and regulations), including individuals, who have<br />

opted to be classified as a Business Customer, with liquid assets<br />

in excess of USD 1 million, and who have sufficient financial<br />

knowledge, experience and understanding to participate in such<br />

products and/or services. Singapore: this report has been prepared<br />

and issued for distribution in Singapore to institutional<br />

investors, accredited investors and expert investors (each as<br />

defined under the Financial Advisers Regulations) only, and is<br />

also distributed by Credit Suisse AG, Singapore Branch to overseas<br />

investors (as defined under the Financial Advisers Regulations.<br />

Credit Suisse AG, Singapore Branch may distribute reports<br />

produced by its foreign entities or affiliates pursuant to an arrangement<br />

under Regulation 32C of the Financial Advisers<br />

Regulations. Singapore recipients should contact Credit Suisse<br />

AG, Singapore Branch at +65-6212-2000 for matters arising<br />

from, or in connection with, this report. By virtue of your status<br />

as an institutional investor, accredited investor, expert investor<br />

or overseas investor, Credit Suisse AG, Singapore Branch is<br />

exempted from complying with certain compliance requirements<br />

under the Financial Advisers Act, Chapter 110 of Singapore (the<br />

“FAA”), the Financial Advisers Regulations and the relevant<br />

Notices and Guidelines issued thereunder, in respect of any<br />

financial advisory service which Credit Suisse AG, Singapore<br />

branch may provide to you. Spain: this report is distributed in<br />

Spain by Credit Suisse AG, Sucursal en España, authorized<br />

under number 1460 in the Register by the Banco de España.<br />

Thailand: this report is distributed by Credit Suisse Securities<br />

(Thailand) Limited, regulated by the Office of the Securities and<br />

Exchange Commission, Thailand, with its registered address at<br />

990 Abdulrahim Place Building, 27/F, Rama IV Road, Silom,<br />

Bangrak, Bangkok +0-2614-6000. Turkey: the investment information,<br />

comments and recommendations contained herein<br />

are not within the scope of investment advisory activity. The<br />

investment advisory services are provided by the authorized<br />

institutions to the persons in a customized manner taking into<br />

account the risk and return preferences of the persons. Whereas,<br />

the comments and advices included herein are of general<br />

nature. Therefore recommendations may not be suitable for your<br />

financial status or risk and yield preferences. For this reason,<br />

making an investment decision only by relying on the information<br />

given herein may not give rise to results that fit your expectations.<br />

This report is distributed by Credit Suisse Istanbul Menkul<br />

Degerler Anonim Sirketi, regulated by the Capital Markets Board<br />

of Turkey, with its registered address at Yildirim Oguz Goker<br />

Caddesi, Maya Plaza 10th Floor Akatlar, Besiktas/Istanbul-<br />

Turkey. United Kingdom: this material is issued by Credit Suisse<br />

(UK). Credit Suisse (UK) Limited, is authorized by the Prudential<br />

Regulation Authority and regulated by the Financial Conduct<br />

Authority and the Prudential Regulation Authority. The protections<br />

made available by the Financial Conduct Authority and/or<br />

the Prudential Regulation Authority for retail clients do not apply<br />

to investments or services provided by a person outside the<br />

UK, nor will the Financial Services Compensation Scheme be<br />

available if the issuer of the investment fails to meet its obligations.<br />

To the extent communicated in the United Kingdom (“UK”)<br />

or capable of having an effect in the UK, this document constitutes<br />

a financial promotion which has been approved by Credit<br />

Suisse (UK) Limited which is authorized by the Prudential<br />

Regulation Authority and regulated by the Financial Conduct<br />

Authority and the Prudential Regulation Authority for the conduct<br />

of investment business in the UK. The registered address of<br />

Credit Suisse (UK) Limited is Five Cabot Square, London, E14<br />

4QR. Please note that the rules under the UK’s Financial Services<br />

and Markets Act 2000 relating to the protection of retail<br />

clients will not be applicable to you and that any potential compensation<br />

made available to “eligible claimants” under the UK’s<br />

Financial Services Compensation Scheme will also not be available<br />

to you. Tax treatment depends on the individual circumstances<br />

of each client and may be subject to changes in future.<br />

UNITED STATES: NEITHER THIS REPORT NOR ANY COPY<br />

THEREOF MAY BE SENT, TAKEN INTO OR DISTRIBUTED IN<br />

THE UNITED STATES OR TO ANY US PERSON (WITHIN THE<br />

MEANING OF REGULATION S UNDER THE US SECURITIES<br />

ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED).<br />

This report may not be reproduced either in whole or in part,<br />

without the written permission of Credit Suisse. Copyright ©<br />

2016 Credit Suisse Group AG and/or its affiliates. All rights<br />

reserved.<br />

16C032A_R


Imprint<br />

Credit Suisse AG, Investment Solutions & Products,<br />

P.O. Box 300, CH-8070 Zurich<br />

Publisher<br />

Loris Centola<br />

Editors<br />

Reto Hess, Uwe Neumann, Christine Schmid<br />

Editorial deadline<br />

22 December 2016<br />

Production management<br />

Iryna Hofer, Manuel Moser<br />

Concept<br />

C3 Creative Code and Content Schweiz AG<br />

Paris-born Vincent Poinas is a journalist,<br />

stylist and 3D illustrator. He is currently<br />

design editor for the fashion and<br />

culture magazine “Citizen K”, and he also<br />

collaborates with “IDEAT”, a contemporary<br />

lifestyle magazine. His contributions<br />

to both publications involve writing articles<br />

and designing interiors. He previously<br />

worked for “Le Figaro” magazine, “AD” and<br />

“M&Oxygene”.<br />

Design and realization<br />

C3 Creative Code and Content Schweiz AG<br />

Angélique El Morabit, Sibylle Brodbeck,<br />

Monika Häfliger, Esther Rieser, Claudia Veit,<br />

Franziska Krüger (project management)<br />

Editorial lead<br />

C3 Creative Code and Content Schweiz AG<br />

Giselle Weiss<br />

Editorial team<br />

Zoe Arnold, Ross Hewitt, Christa Jenni, Manuel Moser,<br />

Francis Piotrowski<br />

Printer<br />

gdz AG, Zurich<br />

Copies of this publication may be ordered via your<br />

relationship manager; employees contact MyShop directly.<br />

This publication is available on the Internet at:<br />

www.credit-suisse.com/globalinvestor<br />

Intranet access for employees of Credit Suisse Group:<br />

http://research.csintra.net<br />

International research support is provided by Credit Suisse’s<br />

global network of representative offices.<br />

PERFORMANCE<br />

neutral<br />

Printed Matter<br />

No. 01-16-585618 – www.myclimate.org<br />

© myclimate – The Climate Protection Partnership


GIE 1545894<br />

For the top themes and trends<br />

driving markets in the year ahead, see our<br />

Investment Outlook 2017 at<br />

credit-suisse.com/investmentoutlook

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!