#18_1-8
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
MARCH 22, 2018 ISSUE No. 18 (1150)<br />
Tel.: +38(044) 303-96-19,<br />
fax: +38(044) 303-94-20<br />
е-mail: time@day.kiev.ua;<br />
http://www.day.kiev.ua<br />
Sketch by Viktor BOGORAD<br />
REUTERS photo<br />
The day of<br />
reckoning for<br />
connections to<br />
Muammar Gaddafi<br />
What does former French<br />
president Nicolas Sarkozy’s<br />
questioning over unlawful<br />
financing of his election<br />
campaign mean?<br />
Continued on page 2<br />
Photo by Mykhailo PALINCHAK<br />
“PANOPTICUM”<br />
Continued on page 2<br />
under the guise of “freedom”<br />
The largest leak of personal data in the history of<br />
the Net as a symptom of a global social catastrophe<br />
Ukrainian-Albanian<br />
relations: moving in<br />
the right direction<br />
Ambassador of the<br />
Republic of Albania to<br />
Ukraine on stereotypes and<br />
prospects for cooperation<br />
Photo by Artem SLIPACHUK, The Day<br />
True gold of<br />
true athletes<br />
Hundreds of people<br />
welcomed in Boryspil<br />
on March 20 the<br />
Ukrainian national team<br />
that had triumphantly<br />
performed at the<br />
Paralympic Winter<br />
Games in South Korea<br />
Continued on page 2<br />
Continued on page 8
2<br />
No.18 MARCH 22, 2018<br />
DAY AFTER DAY<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
By Natalia ISHCHENKO<br />
would be more than<br />
happy to share its<br />
experience with Ukraine<br />
on the European Integration<br />
process issue,” “Albania<br />
Dr. Shpresa Kureta, Ambassador Resident<br />
of the Republic of Albania to the Republic<br />
of Poland and Ambassador Non-resident to<br />
Ukraine said, answering the question of<br />
The Day. The Albanian state has been a<br />
NATO member for nine years and is<br />
currently recognized as an official<br />
candidate for accession to the European<br />
Union. Ukraine has something to learn<br />
from this small Balkan country, which in<br />
recent years has completely got rid of<br />
totalitarian past and is moving fast and<br />
confidently along the Euro-Atlantic path.<br />
In recent years, Ukrainian-Albanian<br />
cooperation has intensified, but what<br />
needs to be done is much more than what<br />
has been done.<br />
Madam Ambassador, a draft freetrade<br />
agreement between Ukraine and Albania<br />
is under discussion. Do Albanian entrepreneurs<br />
have plans for what they will<br />
bring to Ukraine? And what Ukrainian<br />
goods do Albanians want to see in your<br />
market?<br />
“At first I would like to thank you for<br />
your attention and the opportunity you are<br />
giving to me to communicate with the<br />
Ukrainian audience. I am pleased to note<br />
that the last-years communication and<br />
exchanges between the two countries are<br />
becoming better and better. There is a<br />
very good cooperation and communication<br />
at the political level, and efforts are being<br />
made by both sides to identify areas of interest<br />
for the intensification of concrete engagement.<br />
In this context, economic cooperation<br />
and trade exchanges undoubtedly<br />
have a special place. For this purpose we are<br />
working on the preparation of the first<br />
meeting of the Joint Commission, based on<br />
the Agreement on Economic and Trade Cooperation<br />
between the two countries, a<br />
Photo by Mykhailo PALINCHAK<br />
meeting which, among others, will create<br />
the opportunity to discuss and identify the<br />
areas and products of greater interest for<br />
cooperation and exchanges between the<br />
parties. It is also expected that the issue of<br />
Free Trade Agreement will be discussed,<br />
with the aim of closing the negotiations and<br />
signing it.”<br />
Three years ago, first charter flight<br />
from Ukraine went to Albania. Have<br />
guests from Ukraine become visible on the<br />
Albanian tourism market?<br />
“Thank you very much for the question<br />
and I am very happy to talk about this topic,<br />
as things are going very well in this regard.<br />
Ukrainian citizens increasingly are<br />
choosing Albania as a touristic destination.<br />
The establishing of the direct charter lines<br />
between the two countries is a very positive<br />
development, which has directly influenced<br />
the increase in the number of<br />
tourists. I would also like to mention the facilitation<br />
of the movement as a result of the<br />
elimination of the visa regime by the Albanian<br />
side for the Ukrainian citizens<br />
since 2011 and the signing of the visa free<br />
regime agreement for the Albanian citizens<br />
to Ukraine, during the visit of Minister<br />
Klimkin to Tirana, in November 2016. This<br />
is also a very positive development to<br />
Ukrainian-Albanian relations:<br />
moving in the right direction<br />
Ambassador of the Republic of Albania to Ukraine<br />
on stereotypes and prospects for cooperation<br />
bring the two peoples and our two countries<br />
closer to each other.”<br />
Unfortunately, Ukrainians know very<br />
little about Albania and Albanians, and this<br />
is all from stereotypes of the time of the<br />
USSR. Does the Albanian side have a plan<br />
for the development of Albanian-Ukrainian<br />
cultural cooperation to overcome the<br />
outdated ideas about your country?<br />
“One of the issues we are working on,<br />
is undoubtedly the increase in the exchange<br />
of information in all areas. What<br />
you say is true on both sides. Even in Albania<br />
there is little information about<br />
Ukraine and it is necessary to intensify efforts<br />
to exchange more information. Actually,<br />
it is easier than ever, with the<br />
tools and techniques available to make<br />
this possible. Also the increase of exchanges<br />
and contacts – the Ukrainians visiting<br />
Albania and the Albanians visiting<br />
Ukraine – are an important asset in the progressive<br />
change of this situation. Also, the<br />
design and implementation of certain projects<br />
for the promotion of tourism, cultural<br />
exchange, art, education, etc. remain important<br />
goals in our work. I take the opportunity<br />
to mention another very important<br />
asset in the relationship between<br />
our two countries, which is the Albanian<br />
community, living in Ukraine for more<br />
than 200 years.”<br />
We see that in recent years the relations<br />
of our two countries are deepening.<br />
Are negotiations being conducted<br />
on the opening of the embassy of Albania<br />
in Ukraine and the Ukrainian one in<br />
Albania?<br />
“As I mentioned above, I am very happy<br />
to see that things are moving in the right<br />
direction between the two countries and<br />
many things have happened, which are certainly<br />
preparing the ground for concrete<br />
developments and exchanges between us.<br />
This will surely bring to our agendas and<br />
in our working tables the issue of raising<br />
the level of mutual representation and<br />
the opening of embassies in our capitals.”<br />
■ The Day’s FACT FILE<br />
Albania is situated in the Southeastern<br />
Europe and bordering the Adriatic Sea<br />
and Ionian Sea, between Greece to the<br />
south and Montenegro and Serbia (Kosovo)<br />
to the north. Area land is nearly 28,748<br />
square kilometers. Population is more<br />
than three million people.<br />
In the early 1990s, Albania put an end<br />
to 46-year communist rule and established<br />
a multiparty democracy. Albania joined<br />
NATO in April 2009 and in June 2014 became<br />
a candidate for EU accession.<br />
Dr. Shpresa Kureta, a Senior Foreign<br />
Service Officer of the Republic of Albania,<br />
at the rank of Minister-Plenipotentiary,<br />
on April 29, 2014, was nominated<br />
Ambassador Resident of the Republic of<br />
Albania to the Republic of Poland and<br />
Ambassador Non-resident to the Republic<br />
of Estonia, Republic of Latvia, Republic of<br />
Lithuania and Ukraine.<br />
From January 2014, until assuming<br />
her responsibility in Warsaw, in September<br />
2014, Ambassador Kureta has served<br />
as Director for Regional Affairs and Neighboring<br />
Countries at the Ministry of Foreign<br />
Affairs. At the same time she was appointed<br />
National Coordinator of Albania at<br />
the Central European Initiative (CEI),<br />
from May 2013. Ambassador Kureta has<br />
been Director for Southeast Europe at the<br />
Ministry of Foreign Affairs, from August<br />
2009. Prior to assuming that assignment,<br />
she was the NATO Membership Action<br />
Plan (MAP) Coordinator, at the Department<br />
of NATO, from March 2006 to<br />
August 2009. As MAP Coordinator,<br />
Ms. Kureta coordinated the work of different<br />
ministries and agencies involved in<br />
MAP process, on drafting and monitoring<br />
the implementation of the MAP document,<br />
exchanging of information and prepared<br />
reports for the Prime Minister Office,<br />
as well as prepared meetings of the Interministerial<br />
Committee for Integration<br />
and meetings of the Working Group.<br />
The day of reckoning for<br />
connections to Muammar Gaddafi<br />
What does former French president Nicolas<br />
Sarkozy’s questioning over unlawful financing<br />
of his election campaign mean?<br />
By Natalia PUSHKARUK, The Day<br />
Early on March 20, a rather<br />
unexpected and high-profile event<br />
occurred in France, as the police<br />
took the former president of that<br />
country, Nicolas Sarkozy, into<br />
custody. After the law enforcement<br />
released the former head of state to his<br />
residence for the night, he returned to the<br />
police station on the next day and continued<br />
to answer investigators’ questions, reports<br />
The Washington Post.<br />
According to media reports, Sarkozy<br />
was detained for questioning in connection<br />
with suspicions that his 2007 campaign was<br />
allegedly financed by former Libyan leader<br />
Muammar Gaddafi. The money in question<br />
amounted to about 50 million euros, of<br />
which he seemed to have received 5 million<br />
in cash. Although the case was opened as<br />
early as 2013, Sarkozy was not questioned<br />
until now. Earlier, the former resident of the<br />
Elysee Palace limited his response to denials<br />
of any unlawful financing from Libya, calling<br />
such allegations “grotesque.” The police<br />
also detained for questioning in the same<br />
case a close ally of Sarkozy, Brice Hortefeux.<br />
According to Radio Liberty, Sarkozy<br />
allegedly did not declare the money received,<br />
so he probably both violated the<br />
rules limiting campaign financing (since at<br />
that time, the permissible expenses for<br />
presidential candidates were capped at<br />
21 million euros) and failed to declare<br />
money he had received from abroad.<br />
The former French president had a<br />
rather confusing relationship with the<br />
Libyan leader, notes France-24, because<br />
Sarkozy invited Gaddafi for a<br />
state visit immediately after the presidential<br />
election, but in 2011, France<br />
was in the forefront of the NATO-led<br />
coalition that hit Gaddafi’s troops,<br />
which ultimately helped the rebels<br />
overthrow his regime. RFI writes that<br />
before Gaddafi’s death, he mentioned<br />
a “major secret” in his relations with the<br />
West. Meanwhile, Euronews quoted<br />
his son Saif al-Islam as saying in 2011:<br />
“First, Sarkozy has to give back the<br />
money he accepted from Libya to finance<br />
his electoral campaign. We financed<br />
his campaign and we have the<br />
proof and stand ready to publish it.”<br />
“Since the end of his presidency,<br />
Mr. Sarkozy has faced multiple corruption<br />
inquiries, which are at various<br />
stages, and he has always denied any<br />
wrongdoing. In some cases, the charges<br />
were dropped; in others, investigations<br />
are continuing,” The New York<br />
Times writes. For example, in the socalled<br />
Bettencourt affair, in which the<br />
former head of state was suspected of<br />
manipulating the heiress to the L’Oreal<br />
fortune into financing his campaign,<br />
all the charges against him have been<br />
dropped.<br />
REUTERS photo<br />
“Panopticum” under the guise<br />
of “freedom”<br />
By Alla DUBROVYK, The Day<br />
The largest leak of personal<br />
data in the history of the Net<br />
as a symptom of a global<br />
social catastrophe<br />
Facebook and Cambridge University<br />
have got themselves into a high-profile political<br />
scandal.<br />
In one day, Mark Zuckerberg lost six billion<br />
dollars, which amounts to one tenth of his<br />
fortune as estimated by the American Forbes<br />
magazine. But this is nothing compared to<br />
dangers facing Zuckerberg now. If an American<br />
court finds that Facebook is to blame for<br />
the largest leak of users’ personal data in the<br />
history of the Internet, he will go bankrupt.<br />
The Massachusetts Office of the Attorney<br />
General has already launched an investigation,<br />
while a number of US congressmen<br />
have said that Zuckerberg should be summoned<br />
to appear before the Congress.<br />
They intend to demand that the founder<br />
of Facebook explain how such a large leak<br />
could occur and what measures are being taken<br />
to ensure that this does not happen again.<br />
Moreover, the US Federal Trade Commission<br />
has announced its intention to investigate the<br />
issue of protecting sensitive user data on Facebook.<br />
It has also become known that the European<br />
Commission intends to conduct its own<br />
investigation of the Facebook affair.<br />
Cambridge Analytica, which collaborated<br />
with US President Donald Trump’s campaign<br />
in 2016, in particular, with its former<br />
manager Stephen Bannon, took advantage a<br />
few years ago of a Facebook application that<br />
offered users an opportunity to compose a psychological<br />
portrait of themselves. This application<br />
has been installed by about 270,000<br />
people, who passed their personal data to it.<br />
Cambridge Analytica reported later that it<br />
had destroyed the data received, but as it has<br />
turned out, not all of it has been deleted.<br />
Western media write that during the latest<br />
election campaign in the US, the firm used<br />
personal data for most of the electorate to further<br />
its own objectives.<br />
On March 19, The New York Times and<br />
The Guardian published the story of former<br />
Cambridge Analytica employee Christopher<br />
Wylie. By the way, Facebook blocked his account<br />
on the day of the story’s release. Now,<br />
Wylie says that his former employer Cambridge<br />
Analytica had a contract with the<br />
company owned by a teacher of the department<br />
of psychology at Cambridge University, one<br />
Alex (Aleksandr) Kogan, a native of the former<br />
USSR. It was Kogan who developed the<br />
application by which people got interviewed<br />
on Facebook. Facebook, according to Wylie,<br />
did not object to disclosing data, satisfied with<br />
the company’s explanation that information<br />
was collected for scientific purposes.<br />
In 2015, this array of personal data<br />
came at the disposal of Cambridge Analytica.<br />
Kogan’s firm received a million dollars for its<br />
services, says Wylie. An interesting detail<br />
that has not been investigated further so far:<br />
while working at Cambridge Analytica, Kogan,<br />
as indicated on the website of St. Petersburg<br />
University, received a two-year<br />
grant from the federal budget of the Russian<br />
Federation.<br />
Independent expert Eduard RAK-<br />
HIMKULOV noted in a comment to The Day<br />
that headquarters are getting ready. “Such<br />
programs – for Facebook, VKontakte, and<br />
Odnoklassniki, which, albeit banned in<br />
Ukraine, still remain popular among our internet<br />
users, are already being designed,”<br />
Rakhimkulov says. In the expert’s words, earlier<br />
such parties as BYuT and the Socialist<br />
Party traditionally gathered information by<br />
polling people in the provinces, which not always<br />
produced adequate results. Pro-presidential<br />
parties have been relying on information<br />
from state administrations since the<br />
Kuchma times, which did not always work either.<br />
But the expert has no doubts that social<br />
media are a field of activity during parliamentary<br />
elections in the near future. Not to<br />
fall under manipulations, he advises Ukrainians<br />
to closely follow all that he says about himself<br />
in the Web. For, unfortunately, our<br />
laws and courts are not so “attentive” as in the<br />
US about protection of personal data.
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
DAY AFTER DAY No.18 MARCH 22, 2018 3<br />
22<br />
By Ruslan HARBAR<br />
Last year the Ministry of<br />
Economy and Trade made public<br />
the Export Strategy of Ukraine.<br />
facts about Nigeria that can help<br />
It names 20 top-priority countries<br />
for us and the EU. Among<br />
them is Nigeria, the only state from<br />
Sub-Saharan Africa. An official<br />
Ukrainians open business there<br />
business delegation of Ukraine with<br />
deputy ministers of the economy and<br />
the agro-industrial complex at the<br />
head is going to visit that country in<br />
early April.<br />
problems. Once a year, governors<br />
7But there is also another Nigeria<br />
Nigeria is too big a country for a gather in Kaduna to play polo at the<br />
which lives and develops. Without<br />
newspaper article to spotlight all the country’s only stadium for this game<br />
laying claim to a thorough analysis of<br />
sides and complexities of its life. Some and, at the same time, to share experience<br />
in the solution of local problems.<br />
while to fragmentarily present some<br />
the state of affairs, it is still worth-<br />
facts about that interesting and promising<br />
country may be of interest to<br />
facts in order to have unbiased information<br />
about that country.<br />
readers and to those who wish to implement<br />
their business plans there.<br />
1Nigeria is 1.5 times larger than<br />
Ukraine in terms of territory and<br />
more than 5 times in terms of population.<br />
Unofficially (there has been no<br />
census for a long time), there are more<br />
than 220 million people living there.<br />
The UN estimates that there will be<br />
450 million by 2050 – third place after<br />
China and India. The median age<br />
of the population is 18.5 years.<br />
There are about 400 ethnicities and<br />
tribes in the country, more than 500 languages<br />
and dialects, with English having<br />
the official status. These ethnicities<br />
roughly make up three big groups.<br />
In the north, it is the Hausa (almost<br />
50 percent of the population).<br />
Twelve states officially recognize<br />
Sharia Law.<br />
The south-east is populated by the<br />
Roman Catholic Ibo (or Igbo). It is the<br />
largest oil-producing area.<br />
The south-west is the Yoruba, also<br />
Roman Catholics. Lagos, the former<br />
capital of Nigeria with a population<br />
of over 20 million, is located here.<br />
Lagos is today sort of a commercial<br />
hub of West Africa. Ships from all<br />
over the world arrive here, and the<br />
cargo is reloaded onto tractor-trailers<br />
which carry it to various countries.<br />
On the whole, Muslims and<br />
Catholics are tolerant towards each<br />
other. There happen excesses, of course.<br />
There is an informal agreement between<br />
the elites that the presidency<br />
should alternate between a Muslim and<br />
a Christian. The current president,<br />
General Muhammadu Buhari, is a Muslim<br />
from the northern state of Kaduna.<br />
2Nigeria is a federal country, consisting<br />
of 36 states. The chief executive<br />
at the state level is the governor<br />
elected by popular vote for a 4-year<br />
term. Subordinated to him is the state<br />
government consisting of relevant<br />
ministries. The states have budgets of<br />
their own. While the federal government<br />
is responsible for defense, foreign<br />
policy, the oil and gas sector, and<br />
national projects, such as railways,<br />
nuclear energy, and space exploration,<br />
state governments tackle all the other<br />
3There are similar moments in the<br />
history of Nigeria and Ukraine.<br />
Nigeria gained independence on October<br />
1, 1960. As soon as May 1967, the<br />
eastern region declared independence<br />
as a state called the Republic of Biafra.<br />
They reasoned as follows: we are<br />
a rich region and we have oil, so why<br />
should we feed the poor agrarian<br />
north? Let’s secede and live prosperously.<br />
On the same day, the federal<br />
president imposed a state of emergency.<br />
It took a month to get prepared,<br />
and a civil war broke out in early<br />
July. In two years, it claimed an estimated<br />
2 million human, mostly civilian,<br />
lives, but territorial integrity of<br />
the country was restored.<br />
Today, the country’s north-east is<br />
suffering from the militant Islamist<br />
organization Boko Haram. The army<br />
managed to neutralize their strongholds<br />
in Nigeria, but it is incapable of<br />
preventing suicide bombers from<br />
killing hundreds of people. We hear<br />
tragic news from these regions time<br />
and again. About 2 million refugees,<br />
kidnappings, more than a half of<br />
schools in the state of Borno are<br />
closed, more than 3,000 teachers were<br />
killed, the populace cannot take care<br />
of their households, starvation is<br />
rife – a familiar picture, isn’t it? On<br />
March 1, 2018, the army was ordered<br />
to guard all schools in the three states.<br />
4Oil and gas are Nigeria’s main<br />
wealth and, at the same time,<br />
nemesis. Nigeria has the 7th largest reserves<br />
of oil in the world, which should<br />
suffice for another 15 years or so. Oil<br />
production accounted for up to 90 percent<br />
of hard-currency revenues.<br />
Petrodollars were enough to meet all<br />
needs, including the enrichment of<br />
people close to governmental circles.<br />
You did not have to rack your brains<br />
over the development of other industries.<br />
But the price of oil plummeted to<br />
an all-time low a few years ago. When<br />
you are short of money, this opens your<br />
eyes to many things. The government<br />
had to recall that the agrarian sector<br />
was neglected, there were no roads,<br />
and there was an acute shortage of electricity<br />
– its production met a mere<br />
40 percent of the country’s needs, with<br />
the remaining 60 percent being made<br />
up by means of diesel generators.<br />
5Nigeria is really a country of<br />
diesel generators. Paradoxically,<br />
the oil-rich country has to import almost<br />
all the fuel it needs (including<br />
for diesel generators). Three small refineries<br />
work at a 40 percent capacity<br />
and have no essential effect on this<br />
market. People have to elementarily<br />
steal oil from pipelines and process it<br />
as fuel at home – often risking their<br />
life. More than a hundred people were<br />
burnt alive recently during this “procedure”<br />
by an accidental spark. Damaging<br />
pipelines has become business of<br />
sorts: they damage one today and<br />
make a deal with a company to repair<br />
it tomorrow. This “business” especially<br />
affects Shell. This American company<br />
was even forced to sell some of<br />
its assets. Nigerian Aliko Dangote,<br />
Africa’s richest man, is going to solve<br />
this problem. He has invested his own<br />
5 billion dollars in the construction of<br />
the largest refinery in Africa, although<br />
his main business is cement<br />
production. He has factories all over<br />
Africa. Incidentally, he started his<br />
business by borrowing 3,000 dollars<br />
from his uncle to buy sugar and sold it<br />
at market prices. He is not an oligarch<br />
– he does not have a political<br />
party, TV channels, or newspapers.<br />
6It will be logical and fair to say after<br />
this that Nigeria is also a country<br />
of corruption. This is another factor<br />
that brings us closer. Here are two<br />
fresh examples. Earlier this year Nigeria<br />
finally purchased 12 US warplanes<br />
at a price of 50 million dollars each. Bolivia<br />
bought the same planes for 10 million<br />
dollars each. See the difference? It<br />
is interesting to follow up this story.<br />
The second: in Abuja, the capital of<br />
Nigeria, a man reported to the police<br />
that he had not seen his neighbors for<br />
several months. Obeying the law, the<br />
police broke down the door and entered<br />
the apartment, only to find bales (!) of<br />
dollars, pounds, euros, and yens worth<br />
a total 123 million pounds. The owner<br />
was not identified. And it is not an isolated<br />
case – also a familiar picture for<br />
us. The difference is that owners do not<br />
hide in our country.<br />
The current President of Nigeria,<br />
General Muhammadu Buhari, is<br />
known as a corruption-buster. Back in<br />
his first presidential term, he did not<br />
confine himself to words and began to<br />
put the best-known corruptionists behind<br />
bars, for which he was overthrown.<br />
He arrested 55 generals at the<br />
very beginning of his term.<br />
8Nigeria has become Africa’s premier<br />
state in terms of GDP, leaving<br />
behind South Africa. In 2001-12,<br />
the average GDP growth rate was<br />
9 percent. It has slowed down now due<br />
to oil price fall. Add to this a 40-percent<br />
devaluation of the naira. Nigeria<br />
is now slowly coming out of recession.<br />
9There are 40 million of those in the<br />
country who belong to the middle<br />
class. It will number an estimated<br />
60 million in 5 years’ time.<br />
There are 645 millionaires (officially!),<br />
520 of them staying<br />
10<br />
in Lagos, and 20 billionaires in Nigeria.<br />
The second-richest African,<br />
Folorunsho Alakija (beauty parlors,<br />
oil, 1,600 million dollars) spent<br />
280,000 euros on one million roses for<br />
the marriage of her son with an Iranian<br />
model.<br />
The National Space Agency<br />
11 functions actively. They plan to<br />
launch the first astronaut by 2030. A<br />
nuclear power station is being built<br />
with Russian assistance. The Ministry<br />
of Defense is trying to launch the production<br />
of drones.<br />
The Nigerian film industry –<br />
12 Nollywood – is the world’s second<br />
largest producer of motion pictures.<br />
The average cost is 15 million<br />
dollars. With an average production<br />
of 50 movies per week and about $590<br />
million revenue annually, Nigeria’s<br />
film market is booming.<br />
Nigeria took part for the first<br />
13 time in the South Korea Winter<br />
Olympics with two bobsledders.<br />
There is a $6-billion-worth<br />
14 business center on the artificial<br />
island near Lagos. The main investor<br />
is billionaire Gilbert Chagoury.<br />
After the visit of the king of Morocco<br />
to Abuja in December 2016,<br />
15<br />
it was decided to resume discussing the<br />
construction of a trans-Saharan gas<br />
pipeline between Port Harcourt, Benin,<br />
Togo, Ghana, and Senegal, and later to<br />
Spain through Gibraltar.<br />
China is actively building a network<br />
of railways. The first of<br />
16<br />
them, 186-km-long, links the president’s<br />
native city of Kaduna and the<br />
capital. The next are being built along<br />
the Guinean coast at the cost of 12 billion<br />
dollars. In the west it branches off<br />
as the Lagos-Kano line to the north,<br />
and in the east – as the Port Harcourt-<br />
Maiduguri line also to the north.<br />
The average wage throughout<br />
17 the country is 200 dollars, and<br />
400 dollars in cities.<br />
A Nigerian writer, Wole Soyinka,<br />
was awarded the Nobel<br />
18<br />
Prize in Literature in 1986.<br />
The favorite beverage is beer.<br />
19 The consumption of it is annually<br />
growing by 9 percent. The main<br />
producer is Heineken.<br />
China and India are competing<br />
20 for a place on the Nigerian<br />
market, with the goods turnover being<br />
18 billion dollars and 17 billion dollars,<br />
respectively. Incidentally, President<br />
Buhari graduated from a military<br />
college in India. About a million<br />
Indians work in the country.<br />
Out of Africa’s 100 most influential<br />
people, 21 are from<br />
21<br />
Nigeria.<br />
Ukraine’s place on this promising<br />
market is quite modest –<br />
22<br />
0.11 percent of Nigeria’s total commodity<br />
turnover. In better times, our<br />
turnover was about 300 million dollars,<br />
but it has been maintained at the<br />
level of 100 million in the past few<br />
years. Nigeria is closely watching<br />
these processes, and it is no accident<br />
that the question of closing the embassy<br />
of Nigeria (one of the three embassies<br />
of Sub-Saharan countries) in<br />
Ukraine was raised in 2016. Our side<br />
had to make a strenuous effort for the<br />
embassy to remain behind. We hope<br />
that the business delegation will<br />
change the situation for the better, although<br />
its status is insufficient for<br />
such hopes to come true.<br />
Meanwhile, there is a basis for serious<br />
economic cooperation. There<br />
are thousands, if not dozens of thousands,<br />
of Ukrainian university and<br />
college graduates working in Nigeria.<br />
Unfortunately, nobody has ever taken<br />
them into account or paid attention<br />
to them. Dr. Olumuyiwa B. Aliu,<br />
a National Aviation University graduate,<br />
is doing a second term as President<br />
of the Council of the International<br />
Civil Aviation Organization<br />
(ICAO), a highly efficient organization<br />
that caters for all the world’s<br />
aviation companies. He is married to<br />
a Kyivite. A graduate of Kharkiv<br />
University, also married to a Ukrainian<br />
woman, headed the National<br />
Space Agency. A graduate of Kyiv<br />
National University’s Institute of International<br />
Relations was the speaker<br />
of Nigeria’s senate.<br />
The Nigerian diaspora in Ukraine,<br />
including families, numbers almost<br />
30,000 people today.<br />
Ruslan Harbar is director of the<br />
Center for African Studies<br />
Photo from the website HOPEFORNIGERIAONLINE.COM
4<br />
No.18 MARCH 22, 2018<br />
TOPIC OF THE DAY<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
By Emilia NAZARENKO,<br />
Switzerland, special to The Day<br />
As is known, our newspaper has<br />
declared 2018 as Year of the<br />
Hetmanate. The existence of a<br />
Ukrainian state in the form of<br />
the Hetmanate (April 29 –<br />
December 14, 1918) is inseparable from<br />
the name of Pavlo Skoropadsky referred<br />
to as “Most Illustrious Hetman of All<br />
Ukraine.” It is up to experts to analyze<br />
historical facts, while this publication is<br />
of a purely biographical nature – its aim<br />
is to shed light on the descendants of the<br />
one who, by decree of fate and by force<br />
of his origin, became the last hetman of<br />
Ukraine.<br />
Pavlo Skoropadsky and his wife<br />
Oleksandra, who also came from a<br />
wealthy aristocratic family, had six<br />
children: three daughters and three<br />
sons. But personal happiness eluded all<br />
the Skoropadskys except for the last one,<br />
Olena. Pavlo died aged three, Petro suffered<br />
from epilepsy, although he lived<br />
for 56 years. Danylo, a public figure, father’s<br />
assistant, leader of the hetmanite<br />
movement, chair of the Union of<br />
Ukrainians in Great Britain, died in<br />
London in 1957 under unclear circumstances.<br />
The hetman’s two elder daughters<br />
– Maria Montresor-Skoropadska<br />
(1898-1959) and Yelyzaveta Kuzhym-<br />
Skoropadska (1899-1975) – were leaders<br />
of the hetmanite movement, the socalled<br />
hetmanivny, by turns after the<br />
death of their brother and according to<br />
the “Acts on the Procedure of Succession<br />
of Hetnmanite Power and in our Family<br />
by Right of Seniority.” None of them<br />
had descendants except for the last<br />
daughter, Olena, who was born in 1919<br />
in Germany, where the Skoropadsky<br />
family had to move after the hetman’s<br />
abdication and restoration of the Ukrainian<br />
National Republic in December 1918.<br />
In the 1920s, the hetmanite movement<br />
politically led by Skoropadsky<br />
continued to develop in exile. Its centers<br />
gradually began to function in many European<br />
countries, Canada, and the US.<br />
In Germany, where most of the emigre<br />
hetman followers were staying, the existence<br />
of the hetmanite movement was<br />
in jeopardy in the late 1930s. It is perhaps<br />
for this reason, being aware of<br />
Hitler’s belligerent aspirations, Skoropadsky<br />
sent his son Danylo to Britain<br />
in 1939. Thus, the viability of the hetmanite<br />
movement outside Germany was<br />
guaranteed, and the hetman’s heir Danylo<br />
was its leader to his last breath.<br />
As is known, Skoropadsky used his<br />
connections to free many Ukrainians<br />
from Nazi concentration camps. The<br />
hetman’s elder daughters also rendered<br />
help to their compatriots as far as they<br />
could. During World War Two, Maria<br />
Skoropadska, who resided in Warsaw,<br />
helped the Polish Resistance Movement<br />
– she was hiding and transferring<br />
to the countryside the Jewish children<br />
who were rescued from the Polish ghetto.<br />
Her sister Yelyzaveta cared about the<br />
Ukrainian women deported to Germany<br />
for slave labor: she visited camps and saw<br />
to it that the women were duly provided<br />
with food and clothes. Back in the<br />
1930s she had chaired the charitable<br />
Committee for Helping the Famine-<br />
Stricken in Ukraine, trying to raise as<br />
many funds as possible to help Ukrainians<br />
during the 1932-33 Holodomor.<br />
All the children of Pavlo Skoropadsky<br />
have already departed this life. Fate<br />
gifted family happiness and longevity<br />
only to the hetman’s last daughter Olena.<br />
She had been rather independent<br />
since her green years. After her father’s<br />
death in 1945, when her mother,<br />
sisters, and sick brother settled in the<br />
German town of Oberstdorf, she had already<br />
lived separately from the family.<br />
In the same year, Olena’s first husband<br />
Gerd Ginder, whom she had married less<br />
than a year before, died from a wound.<br />
He was Swiss by origin, and his parents<br />
lived in a country that had always attracted<br />
Olena. So the young widow went<br />
to her parents-in-law in Switzerland. In<br />
1947 she found a job in Zurich, where she<br />
met her future husband Ludwig Ott<br />
whom she called in no other way than<br />
“mein lieber Ehemann” – my beloved<br />
husband. Twin daughters, Alexandra<br />
Olena Ott-Skoropadska:<br />
“Father believed that independence<br />
was the only way out for Ukraine”<br />
A voice from the past – the last<br />
interview with the hetman’s daughter<br />
and Irene, were born to them in 1954.<br />
Clearly, the name Alexandra was chosen<br />
in honor of Olena’s mother Oleksandra<br />
Skoropadska. The couple lived in their<br />
own house on the outskirts of Zurich.<br />
Ludwig worked as commercial director<br />
of the Zurich newspaper Tages-Anzeiger.<br />
The daughters were brought up in a<br />
purely German-Swiss spirit: neutrality,<br />
politeness, and correctness. Olena had to<br />
admit later that her girls were “very far<br />
from political affairs.”<br />
When sister Yalyzaveta died in<br />
1957, Olena Ott-Skoropadska automatically<br />
took over as leader of the hetmanite<br />
movement. The hetmanivna first<br />
visited Ukraine in 1991 immediately after<br />
the proclamation of political independence.<br />
After acquainting with the<br />
homeland of her ancestors, during the<br />
next visits to Ukraine, Olena aimed her<br />
efforts at spreading information about<br />
her father, Hetman Skoropadsky, and<br />
promoting research into the history of<br />
their lineage. In 2004 Ott-Skoropadska<br />
handed over some things that belonged<br />
to her father and seven portraits of the<br />
Cossack-era figures painted by Olga<br />
Mordvinova, a close friend of Olena’s<br />
mother, to the Museum of Hetmanship<br />
in Kyiv.<br />
In 2008 Ott-Skoropadska and her<br />
husband moved from their house in<br />
Kuesnacht to a retirement home near<br />
Zurich. They needed medical care owing<br />
to the old age. The last hetmanivna<br />
died in 2014 at the age of 95. Her husband<br />
passed away a year later, only<br />
three months before his centennial.<br />
Olena’s two daughters still live in<br />
Zurich. This year they turned 64, the retirement<br />
age for women in Switzerland.<br />
One of the twins, Irene, once studied foreign<br />
languages and playing the violin.<br />
She did a secretary training course. Her<br />
husband Roger Cahn, a universitytrained<br />
journalist, worked for the wellknown<br />
Swiss German-language newspaper<br />
Neue Zuercher Zeitung and at<br />
the culture department of Swiss television.<br />
After retiring, he opened Culture<br />
Link, an agency that organizes music and<br />
culture events. Irene helps her husband.<br />
They have no children. I once<br />
called Irene Cahn-Ott to speak about her<br />
mother and her childhood reminiscences.<br />
Unfortunately, the conversation was<br />
short. Irene rejected the idea of any interview.<br />
I also failed to get in touch with<br />
the other daughter, Alexandra. As far as<br />
I know, she gained a medical education,<br />
is married, and has two children.<br />
Her husband Martin Koenig, a lawyer by<br />
profession, runs a consulting company<br />
of his own. Their younger son Dmitri,<br />
29, was born sick and is in fact disabled.<br />
The elder daughter, Vanessa Koenig, 33,<br />
married a Colombian last year. The<br />
young couple went to live in Colombia.<br />
In 2003 the Lviv-based Litopys publishers<br />
printed the Ukrainian edition of<br />
The Last of the Skoropadskys, the book<br />
of Olena Ott-Skoropadska’s reminiscences.<br />
Frankly speaking, the book’s<br />
title proved to be prophetic. Only the hetman’s<br />
last daughter had children, but,<br />
owing to their upbringing, education, socio-cultural<br />
milieu, Pavlo Skoropadsky’s<br />
granddaughters have only a biological<br />
link with the hetman of Ukraine.<br />
“The last of the Skoropadskys” was<br />
aware of this state of affairs, and she decided<br />
to write about her childhood and<br />
youth reminiscences of the father and<br />
family. As a result, we received an invaluable<br />
nonmaterial legacy – information<br />
about the last hetman of Ukraine<br />
from the last representative of the hetman’s<br />
lineage. Olena was an active member<br />
of the Ukrainian Association in<br />
Switzerland. This association, which<br />
has existed in Switzerland since 1945,<br />
publishes a small informative trimonthly<br />
newspaper Trembita Helvetsii. After<br />
the publication of The Last of the Skoropadskys<br />
in Ukraine and the last visit<br />
of the hetmanivna to this country, this<br />
newspaper printed an interview with Olena.<br />
But the readership of Trembita Helvetsii<br />
is incomparable to that of Den/The<br />
Day, which numbers many thousands.<br />
By courtesy of Andrii Luzhnytsky, president<br />
of the Ukrainian Association in<br />
Switzerland, we offer you, in memory of<br />
the family of Ukraine’s last hetman, the<br />
last interview with the hetman’s daughter<br />
Olena SKOROPADSKA as a “voice<br />
from the past.”<br />
● “THE SKOROPADSKY<br />
LINEAGE DATES BACK<br />
TO THE 17TH CENTURY”<br />
Ms. Olena, what prompted you to<br />
write this book of reminiscences?<br />
“I wanted to leave reminiscences of<br />
the life of my family and me to my own<br />
children and grandchildren. So I first<br />
told about my childhood, nanny, and<br />
school. Then there was a story about my<br />
sister Marika who lived a very tragic life.<br />
Going on, I realized that I was now<br />
writing not for my children but for myself,<br />
recalling and reliving the events of<br />
bygone years. I understood that if I did<br />
not narrate some periods of my lifetime,<br />
nobody else would ever do this. This is<br />
why I added chapters about our life in<br />
Wannsee before World War Two,<br />
wartime details, the circumstances of my<br />
father’s death, the life of my mother and<br />
sisters thereafter. When I was examining<br />
my parents’ notes, I clearly pictured<br />
their life before and during the<br />
Hetmanate.”<br />
Who helped you write the book?<br />
“Nobody did. I wrote everything by<br />
myself in German. Even in my school<br />
years I had a gift for writing compositions<br />
very well. I must have inherited<br />
this ability from my father who could describe<br />
any event very expressively.”<br />
Your parents come from very old noble<br />
families…<br />
“That’s right. The Skoropadsky lineage<br />
dates back to the 17th century.<br />
There were a lot of outstanding figures<br />
in this lineage. The best-known one was<br />
Cossack Hetman Ivan Skoropadsky.<br />
Pavlo Skoropadsky’s aunt Yelyzaveta<br />
Miloradovich helped found the<br />
Shevchenko Scientific Society in Lviv,<br />
donating enormous funds for this purpose.<br />
“Besides, the Skoropadsky family<br />
was matrimonially linked to other noted<br />
Ukrainian families. The ancestors of<br />
my mother Oleksandra Skoropadska<br />
(nee Durnovo) also belonged to the nobility.<br />
In the male line, it is the Durnovo<br />
family which began from Sviatoslav<br />
II, the son of Yaroslav the Wise,<br />
and the female line begins from the<br />
Kochubeis. Yes, the Kochubei who betrayed<br />
Mazepa.<br />
“It is my mother who did the entire<br />
research of our lineage in the last years<br />
of her life in Berlin. She spent all of her<br />
free time in the library, gleaning information<br />
bit by bit.”<br />
Ms. Olena, you were brought up in<br />
a noble family that cherished values typical<br />
of people of a certain social status.<br />
What directives were your parents giving<br />
you, with due account of their aristocratic<br />
origin?<br />
“In any case, my parents were guided<br />
by the principle that one must respect<br />
people regardless of their social status.<br />
They applied this principle throughout<br />
their lifetime. But, at the same time, father<br />
always said you should behave as befits<br />
the role model.<br />
“After 1917, aristocratic origin<br />
ceased to be of any importance in human<br />
relations. The proof of this is that my<br />
first husband was the grandson of my<br />
grandfather Durnovo’s gardener in Petersburg.”<br />
What kind of a relationship was<br />
there in your family?<br />
“Very confidential. There was no ceremoniousness<br />
in communication, parents<br />
called each other by first name, and<br />
children were on familiar terms with<br />
them. Mother was the linchpin of our<br />
family, who shouldered all everyday<br />
cares. Her life was very hard. Accustomed<br />
to sheer luxury, in which she was<br />
born and raised, mother had to get used<br />
to the new lifestyle that emerged after<br />
the Bolshevik revolution. For the life<br />
that had existed before those events<br />
was gone. However, she bore all the<br />
hardships silently, without complaining,<br />
and gave father all kinds of support.”<br />
How was the attitude of the members<br />
of your family to life in Germany?<br />
“As I have already said, my mother<br />
quite easily adapted to the new living<br />
conditions. She was a realist and took life<br />
the way it was. But sisters felt very difficult<br />
from the moral angle. Having<br />
grown up in entirely different conditions,<br />
they found it hard to live in a new<br />
milieu. Besides, they were hetmanivny,<br />
the daughters of a hetman, which left a<br />
certain imprint on their relationships<br />
with people. As for me, I was born<br />
abroad and was not brought up as aristocratically<br />
as my sisters were. I grew the<br />
way other children around me did.”<br />
What language was spoken in the<br />
family?<br />
“We spoke Russian. Everybody in<br />
the family knew Ukrainian very well. My<br />
elder sisters and brother Danylo learned<br />
the language in childhood, when they<br />
spent the summer in our Ukrainian estate.<br />
In exile, too, all members of the<br />
family could hear Ukrainian because<br />
many Ukrainians used to visit father and<br />
put up at our place for some time. I can<br />
clearly remember a big dinner table, at<br />
one end of which my mother, nanny, and<br />
sick brother Petro sit and speak Russian,<br />
and on the opposite side – my father, his<br />
secretary Shemet and several Ukrainian<br />
guests argue loudly about something in<br />
Ukrainian.”<br />
Your father, Pavlo Skoropadsky,<br />
carved out a brilliant military career in<br />
the tsarist army, rising to the rank of a<br />
life-guard general. What caused him, a<br />
former tsarist officer, to stage a coup<br />
and take power in Ukraine by proclaiming<br />
the Hetmanate?<br />
“Father could not put up with ruin<br />
and chaos in Ukraine at the end of the<br />
Central Rada’s rule. He could see its incapability.<br />
Besides, there was a threat on<br />
the part of Germany which viewed<br />
Ukraine as its likely province. He could<br />
not allow this to happen. Moreover, father<br />
knew very well how to set up an adequate<br />
and full-fledged state apparatus.”<br />
Your father opted for a Russian-<br />
Ukrainian federation. Did he change his<br />
viewpoint later, in exile?<br />
“In that difficult period, many politicians<br />
favored, one way or another, the<br />
idea of a Russian-Ukrainian federation.<br />
Even the Central Rada included a clause<br />
on a federative link with the former<br />
Russian state’s republics into its 4th<br />
Universal. Father viewed a federation as<br />
a union of separate states with totally autonomous<br />
structures, equal rights, etc.<br />
“I want to emphasize that all figures<br />
in the Central Rada, the Directory, and<br />
my father wished Ukraine well, but<br />
they had different visions of achieving<br />
this by force of their persuasions and<br />
views. Staying in exile and knowing<br />
the situation in Soviet Ukraine – massscale<br />
repressions and a terrible famine, –<br />
father believed that independence was<br />
the only way out for Ukraine.”<br />
With which figures of the Central<br />
Rada or the Directory did Skoropadsky<br />
maintain relations in exile?<br />
“With Hetmanate-time comradesin-arms.<br />
He maintained no relations at<br />
all with Vynnychenko, for he totally rejected<br />
this man’s human qualities. Father<br />
respected Petliura despite the fact<br />
that the latter had staged an uprising<br />
and in fact toppled him. He even attended<br />
his funeral in Paris.”<br />
In exile, Pavlo Skoropadsky founded<br />
the hetmanite movement which won<br />
certain popularity and attracted some<br />
followers. After some time, its centers<br />
opened in other countries. What kind of<br />
activities was this movement engaged<br />
in?<br />
“The hetmanite movement was an<br />
organization that stood above the parties.<br />
It is Viacheslav Lypynsky who
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
TOPIC OF THE DAY No.18 MARCH 22, 2018 5<br />
worked out the movement’s ideology.<br />
The main idea of the movement was to<br />
rally Ukrainians together under the<br />
guidance of a hetman, and the ultimate<br />
goal was independent Ukraine. Father<br />
believed until his death that Ukraine<br />
would be independent. The movement offered<br />
assistance to everybody who needed<br />
it, regardless of ideological views. Father<br />
had connections in the German<br />
government, which he widely used for resolving<br />
all kinds of Ukraine-related<br />
problems. In 1926, a Ukrainian Scientific<br />
Institute was established at Berlin<br />
University, which promoted the development<br />
of Ukrainian sciences. During<br />
the Holodomor in Ukraine, the hetman’s<br />
followers set up a committee for<br />
helping the famine-stricken, in which my<br />
sister Yelyzaveta took an active part. As<br />
World War Two was drawing to a close,<br />
Skoropadsky helped release from prisons<br />
such OUN figures as Bandera, Melnyk,<br />
Stetsko, and others. Today, there is also<br />
a hetmanite organization in the US<br />
and a small association of hetmanship<br />
followers in Kyiv.”<br />
Where is your father buried?<br />
“Father was first buried in the<br />
Bavarian town of Metten, where he died<br />
in the abbey hospital from the wounds he<br />
received during a bombing. He was reburied<br />
later in the commune of Oberstdorf,<br />
Bavaria. There is our family crypt<br />
there, in which all members of our family<br />
were buried, except for brother Danylo<br />
who was buried in London.”<br />
Why was your father reburied in<br />
Oberstdorf?<br />
“When the Soviet army was near<br />
Berlin, it was impossible to stay behind<br />
in Wannsee for obvious reasons. So it<br />
was decided to move to Oberstdorf.<br />
Mother’s childhood friend Olga Mordvinova<br />
lived there, and we could put up<br />
at her place for some time. Mother, sisters<br />
Maria and Yelyzaveta, and sick<br />
brother Petro stayed on in this town. I<br />
lived separately at the time.”<br />
How come you found yourself in<br />
Switzerland?<br />
“The point is that the parents of my<br />
first husband Gerd Ginder lived in and<br />
were citizens of Switzerland. So I went<br />
to stay with them after his death on quite<br />
legitimate grounds – as the daughterin-law.<br />
I began to work and then moved<br />
to Zurich. I met there my current husband<br />
Ludwig Ott, and we got married in<br />
1948.”<br />
A few years ago you handed over a<br />
bronze bust-relief of Pavlo Skoropadsky<br />
and portraits of some Ukrainian hetmans<br />
to the Ukrainian Museum of Hetmanship.<br />
What kind of pictures were<br />
they?<br />
“These portraits are an almost a<br />
true copy of the pictures that hung on the<br />
walls of our Ukrainian manor in Trostianets.<br />
The originals were destroyed<br />
during the revolution. Fortunately, my<br />
mother had a hobby – photography – in<br />
her young years. Among her photographs<br />
there were images of the rooms<br />
with the entire interior. On the basis of<br />
these photos and the existing engravings,<br />
mother’s artist friend Mordvinova<br />
reproduced these pictures.”<br />
Ms. Olena, do you visit Ukraine?<br />
What are your impressions?<br />
“I first visited Ukraine in 1991 at the<br />
invitation of the Ukrainian Academy of<br />
Sciences. From then on, Ukraine became<br />
second life for me and my husband.<br />
I found a lot of friends there. I noticed<br />
in Ukraine that young people take a<br />
keen interest in their history and the national<br />
identity of Ukrainians is much<br />
higher now than it was in my father’s<br />
times.”<br />
Photo from the book The Skoropadskys: Family Album<br />
“<br />
The hetmanite movement was an organization that<br />
stood above the parties. It is Viacheslav Lypynsky who worked<br />
out the movement’s ideology. The main idea of the movement<br />
was to rally Ukrainians together under the guidance<br />
of a hetman, and the ultimate goal was independent Ukraine.<br />
Father believed until his death that Ukraine would be independent.<br />
The movement offered assistance to everybody<br />
who needed it, regardless of ideological views. Father had connections<br />
in the German government, which he widely used<br />
for resolving all kinds of Ukraine-related problems.<br />
An aspirant with...<br />
16 years of experience<br />
What needs to be done for Ukraine to achieve<br />
genuine progress in NATO integration<br />
By Mykola SIRUK, The Day<br />
The recent news of Ukraine’s<br />
inclusion in the list of countries<br />
seeking membership in NATO,<br />
also known as the aspirant<br />
countries, has sparked a lively<br />
discussion in social networks and a lot of<br />
opinions about the significance/insignificance<br />
of this status. Let us recall that it<br />
has to do with the North Atlantic Alliance<br />
posting the following message on its<br />
website: “Currently, four partner<br />
countries have declared their aspirations<br />
to NATO membership: Bosnia and Herzegovina,<br />
Georgia, the former Yugoslav<br />
Republic of Macedonia, and Ukraine.”<br />
The question arises, why did NATO<br />
name Ukraine as an aspirant country only<br />
now, even though a presidential decree<br />
which stated this country’s aspiration to<br />
join the Euro-Atlantic structures was issued<br />
on the initiative of then-Secretary of<br />
the National Security and Defense Council<br />
Yevhen Marchuk as early as 2002?<br />
We have also learned lately that President<br />
of Ukraine Petro Poroshenko sent<br />
a letter to NATO Secretary General Jens<br />
Stoltenberg asking the bloc to grant a<br />
Membership Action Plan (MAP) to<br />
Ukraine and include it in the Enhanced<br />
Opportunities Program.<br />
As is known, Ukraine sought to get a<br />
MAP at the Bucharest summit of NATO<br />
in 2008, but German Chancellor Angela<br />
Merkel and the then French President<br />
Nicolas Sarkozy blocked the decision then,<br />
and the final declaration of that summit<br />
said instead that Ukraine could become a<br />
member of the Alliance in the future.<br />
Therefore, the question now arises<br />
again as to what might the reaction of NA-<br />
TO be to the request of President<br />
Poroshenko this time to grant Ukraine a<br />
MAP, what obstacles are there on the path<br />
to obtaining this status, and how Ukraine<br />
can benefit from joining the Enhanced Opportunities<br />
Program.<br />
● ASPIRING SINCE 2002<br />
If you look carefully at the history of<br />
Ukraine’s relations with the North Atlantic<br />
Alliance, Ukraine got the status of<br />
an aspirant country for NATO membership<br />
back in 2002. This was asserted in the<br />
declaration of the Prague Summit, which<br />
took place in 2002. In particular, the<br />
9th paragraph of that concluding document<br />
reads as follows: “We note Ukraine’s<br />
determination to pursue full Euro-Atlantic<br />
integration, and encourage Ukraine<br />
to implement all the reforms necessary, to<br />
achieve this objective.... Continued<br />
progress in deepening and enhancing our<br />
relationship requires an unequivocal<br />
Ukrainian commitment to the values of<br />
the Euro-Atlantic community.”<br />
And this aspirant status was withdrawn<br />
in 2010 after president Viktor<br />
Yanukovych had come to power and officially<br />
told NATO that Ukraine did not<br />
want to get a MAP and instead wanted to<br />
become a non-aligned country.<br />
Interestingly, this situation effectively<br />
continued until March 9, 2018.<br />
However, it could have been rectified in<br />
June last year, immediately after amending<br />
the Laws of Ukraine “On the Fundamentals<br />
of National Security of Ukraine”<br />
and “On the Principles of Domestic and<br />
Foreign Policy” to identify integration into<br />
the Euro-Atlantic security space for the<br />
purpose of gaining membership in NATO<br />
as one of the priorities.<br />
And it turns out that to make changes<br />
on the NATO website which reflect the aspirations<br />
of Ukraine to acquire membership,<br />
our government merely needed to officially<br />
announce such an intention. And<br />
it was done, but only after a delay of...<br />
nine months. It took that much time for<br />
President Poroshenko to send an official<br />
letter to the Alliance’s secretary general<br />
to inform him that with a NATO summit<br />
approaching, Ukraine wanted to restore<br />
its aspirations which were now based on<br />
legislation. The question arises, why did<br />
our government delay making such an appeal<br />
for so long? This can be partly explained<br />
by the almost two-year absence of<br />
Ukraine’s ambassador to NATO, since it<br />
is the new ambassador Vadym Prystaiko,<br />
who was appointed late last year, who is<br />
credited at the NATO headquarters with<br />
the initiative to make changes to the<br />
NATO website.<br />
Another moment should be addressed<br />
as well, it being the exaggerated attention<br />
of some Ukrainian media and Ukrainian<br />
politicians to Ukraine’s recognition as an<br />
aspirant for membership in the Alliance.<br />
In fact, no decision was made by NATO,<br />
they just made a correction to the website<br />
in the section “Enlargement.”<br />
● KEYS TO GETTING A MAP<br />
Another important issue which is<br />
raised in the letter-appeal of the<br />
Ukrainian president to the NATO secretary<br />
general is a request to start negotiations<br />
on a MAP, which the president<br />
of Ukraine stumbled on last year,<br />
when he announced the beginning of<br />
negotiations with the Alliance’s members<br />
on this issue at a press conference<br />
following the meeting of the North Atlantic<br />
Council in Kyiv. Then both sides,<br />
that is, NATO and Ukraine, agreed that<br />
there was no need to digress towards a<br />
MAP, and the parties needed to focus<br />
on implementing the set tasks instead,<br />
and only then make statements about<br />
their intentions and submit them to<br />
their allies.<br />
Therefore, it is unclear whether raising<br />
the MAP issue at the NATO summit<br />
in Brussels this July will pay off for<br />
Ukraine.<br />
On the one hand, the North Atlantic<br />
Alliance recognizes Ukraine’s right to<br />
raise this issue.<br />
On the other hand, The Day’s sources<br />
who are familiar with the situation admit<br />
they do not know what answer Ukraine<br />
will get from 29 NATO member countries<br />
that make decisions by consensus.<br />
At the same time, diplomats emphasize<br />
that the alpha and omega of any future<br />
discussions about the possible MAP status<br />
will be the defense sector reform, including<br />
passing laws on national security,<br />
military intelligence, and the Security<br />
Service of Ukraine (SBU). In particular, it<br />
should involve appointing a civilian defense<br />
minister, the introduction of parliamentary<br />
oversight of the Ministry of Defense<br />
regarding the defense budget, and<br />
democratic civilian control over the SBU.<br />
In addition, the sources friendly admit<br />
to The Day that some allies still have<br />
doubts about the strength of Ukraine’s<br />
commitment to the Euro-Atlantic course.<br />
And this concerns both the ability to implement<br />
reforms and the strategic orientation<br />
of Ukraine. Such doubts are justified<br />
by the fact that Ukraine abandoned<br />
its intention to become a NATO member<br />
twice: during the presidency of Leonid<br />
Kuchma in 2004 and during the<br />
Yanukovych presidency in 2010.<br />
They point to Georgia as a model,<br />
which has unfailingly followed the NATO<br />
course since 2002, despite the changes of<br />
government and Bidzina Ivanishvili’s<br />
ascent to power. True, this consistency has<br />
not yet got the Caucasian country into<br />
NATO. Another example is Montenegro,<br />
which dissolved its union with Serbia<br />
and opted for NATO membership in 2006,<br />
and despite the complexity of relations<br />
with its former “elder brother,” joined the<br />
Alliance last year thanks to perseverance<br />
and consistency.<br />
Therefore, dispelling doubts among<br />
some countries regarding the strategic<br />
orientation of this country remains a<br />
major task for Ukraine. In the opinion of<br />
the Ukrainian authorities, this problem<br />
could be partly eliminated by enshrining<br />
the course on NATO membership in the<br />
Constitution as evidence that Ukraine is<br />
very serious about this objective.<br />
In general, the North Atlantic Alliance,<br />
which has gone through more<br />
than 25 years of enlargement, believes<br />
that membership prospects depend on<br />
the country itself, on how quickly it will<br />
be able to implement reforms and change<br />
legislation in order to comply with the legislation<br />
of most NATO member states.<br />
● CHASING YET ANOTHER<br />
SYMBOL<br />
The presidential letter’s third paragraph<br />
expresses the intention to join the<br />
Enhanced Opportunities Program. At<br />
the moment, five countries – Australia,<br />
Jordan, Georgia, Finland, and<br />
Sweden – enjoy the status of Enhanced<br />
Opportunities Partners. The just-mentioned<br />
countries were chosen according<br />
to the amount of their contributions to<br />
military operations, NATO exercises,<br />
training, and crisis management. As is<br />
known, this status is not very significant,<br />
and this partnership offers nothing<br />
special except for the opportunity<br />
to meet with the Alliance’s members in<br />
certain formats.<br />
The question arises, what for does<br />
this country need it, given that it has more<br />
than five NATO cooperation formats,<br />
including the Annual National Program<br />
(ANP), the Comprehensive Assistance<br />
Package, the Special Partnership between<br />
NATO and Ukraine, and meetings<br />
of the NATO-Ukraine Commission<br />
(NUC)?<br />
The more important task for Ukraine<br />
at the moment is probably holding a<br />
meeting of the NUC at the highest level<br />
possible, in particular during the summit.<br />
However, it is known that Hungary<br />
blocked the winter meeting of the NATO-<br />
Ukraine Commission at the level of defense<br />
ministers, and thus, organizing a<br />
meeting in this format is still a dubious<br />
prospect. As a NATO source told The Day,<br />
the NUC meeting should take place in the<br />
near future, perhaps at the ambassadorial<br />
level, because Ukraine should present<br />
its ANP for 2018 in this format.
6<br />
No.18 MARCH 22, 2018<br />
CLOSE UP<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
“Here all life becomes art”<br />
By Maria PROKOPENKO, photos<br />
by Mykola TYMCHENKO, The Day<br />
ANNA DEMIANOVA SITS NEXT TO HER DRAWINGS,<br />
“PORTRAITS OF PHRASES” FROM ST. JOHN’S GOSPEL. THE<br />
ARTIST HAD MULLED OVER THIS PROJECT FOR A LONG TIME<br />
BUT MANAGED TO IMPLEMENT IT ONLY IN PUSHCHA-<br />
VODYTSIA, WHERE SHE HAD TO CARE ABOUT EVERYDAY<br />
THINGS AND CLEARLY PLAN HER DAYS<br />
Pushcha-Vodytsia is commonly<br />
associated with mansions of<br />
Ukrainian officials and Soviet-era<br />
sanatoria. It is also a picturesque<br />
location for filmmaking and for<br />
walks, which can be easily reached from<br />
Kyiv, thanks to minibuses and a romantic<br />
tram that starts its journey from<br />
Kontraktova Square.<br />
The wintry start of spring is not the<br />
best time to have some rest in Pushcha, but<br />
myself and our photographer did not go<br />
there for it. The Creative House has existed<br />
in Kvitky Tsisyk Street (formerly known<br />
as Pushkinska, Stalinhradska, and<br />
Hamarnyka) already for six months. One<br />
day, designer Oleksandr Haidai felt the<br />
need to work in a natural environment. He<br />
got so enthusiastic about the idea that he<br />
wanted to allow others to partake in it as<br />
well. Haidai told and showed The Day<br />
what came out of it.<br />
● EVOLUTION WITH AN AXE<br />
“These flags appeared here three<br />
weeks ago,” he said pointing at colorful<br />
flags hanging on a branchy tree next to<br />
a small house. “I sing with the band Yedino<br />
Vsyo, we had a concert then, there<br />
were guests. It occurred to us to write<br />
down various wishes and mantras and<br />
hang them on a tree, as they do in Nepal.<br />
So we did it.”<br />
There was a motley-colored cabin in<br />
the courtyard. Haidai laughed and called<br />
it the first art object of the Creative<br />
House. “There was no outhouse here at<br />
first, and I told the owner of the house<br />
that I would come and live here only after<br />
one appears. He built a shell, while I<br />
and my friends painted it,” the lad explained.<br />
An axe was visible near the stairs. In<br />
winter, Haidai and Anna Demianova,<br />
who are joint masters in this project (that<br />
is, the people who care for the house daily),<br />
have to walk to the forest to get some<br />
fuelwood twice or thrice a week. “One of<br />
my goals was to get through the winter<br />
on my own fuelwood. I was also generally<br />
wondering how I was going to winter in<br />
a not-so-comfortable house,” the lad<br />
admitted. “I had to deal with heating issues,<br />
combat air drafts. Everything was<br />
being constantly improved. At first, we<br />
had a blunt axe, then we sharpened it,<br />
and later still bought a new one.”<br />
● AN IDEA IMPLEMENTATION<br />
SPACE<br />
We entered a two-room house, where<br />
residents were going to talk about their<br />
achievements. It smelled of chocolate, as<br />
Haidai was making brownie dessert in a<br />
multicooker. The walls were decorated<br />
with colorful ornaments in the form of<br />
stairs made of painted sprigs, since Demianova,<br />
who is an artist, likes to make such<br />
things. The stock of fuelwood laid on the<br />
cabinet, the stove was turned off, but still<br />
warm. We sat down in a room decorated<br />
with 21 paintings, all belonging to a series<br />
inspired by the Gospel of John and created<br />
by Demianova.<br />
“I recently reviewed my diary entries<br />
from 2003 or 2004 and was surprised by myself<br />
writing there that I wanted to create<br />
something like the Creative House. Over<br />
time, I forgot about it,” Haidai said. “For<br />
me, this house is a space where people can<br />
implement their ideas or projects, ranging<br />
from small to global, for example, ones aiming<br />
to change the education system.”<br />
● THE FIRST TRY<br />
The idea of such a space was implemented<br />
for the first time about a year and<br />
a half ago. Before that, Haidai rented an<br />
apartment in Kyiv, and after the plan had<br />
taken shape, he began to gather those<br />
willing to come together at a house in<br />
Pushcha-Vodytsia. People from across<br />
Ukraine responded: a lad from Zaporizhia,<br />
a girl from Zolochiv, and a girl<br />
from Lanivtsi. Together with the designer,<br />
they rented a house in 14th Linia and<br />
lived there for four months.<br />
In the first version of the Creative<br />
House, people lived together and held various<br />
meetings, where they discussed, for<br />
example, the features of graphic design or<br />
how to write a resume. They interacted<br />
with the local community as well. But, unlike<br />
the current Creative House, it was not<br />
obligatory to have a specific project and a<br />
plan for its implementation.<br />
Haidai showed a picture of a garbage<br />
dump. “This is not us,” he laughed. “We<br />
saw that dump in a street. People came<br />
there and dumped everything they could.<br />
There are a lot of activists in Pushcha, so<br />
we cooperated with them to remove<br />
garbage. We did it for a month. We went<br />
there weekly and removed it little by little.<br />
We found syringes, a huge number of diapers<br />
and much more else there. On the last<br />
day of cleaning, we took away two truckloads<br />
of stuff. Also, we put a multicolored<br />
fence there. The owners of the site removed<br />
it afterwards. But now it is clean, we have<br />
fulfilled our task.”<br />
Besides, the residents of the first Creative<br />
House decorated an abandoned building<br />
in 3rd Linia in collaboration with local<br />
activists. They held an art picnic at a lake<br />
where artists and amateurs painted. Then<br />
five pictures were inserted into frames of<br />
the empty house. Now it adds color to the<br />
landscape of Pushcha.<br />
The project has changed the lives of<br />
some of its participants. One lad decided to<br />
change his profession and become a psychologist,<br />
so he and his girlfriend went to<br />
the Polish city of Wroclaw, where he is<br />
studying now. Meanwhile, the girl studied<br />
design from scratch with Haidai and is now<br />
working in this area. The designer himself<br />
received an invitation to visit Canada and<br />
went there for several months. And when<br />
he returned, he decided to repeat the creative<br />
project in Pushcha-Vodytsia.<br />
Residents of a “creative house” in Pushcha-<br />
Vodytsia know how to combine harvesting<br />
fuelwood and information technology<br />
“IT IS SOMETIMES DIFFICULT TO CARRY OUT A PLAN – YOU LACK FAITH,<br />
ENERGY, ETC. SO WE HELP PEOPLE IMPLEMENT THEIR IDEAS,” OLEKSANDR<br />
HAIDAI SAYS ABOUT THE “CREATIVE HOUSE” HE SET UP<br />
● “THIS IS NOT A HOSTEL”<br />
“I came to live in this house alone last<br />
summer and lived so for a few months,”<br />
Haidai recalled. “At first it was difficult,<br />
but everything was developing. Many<br />
friends came to visit me, I was teaching design.<br />
One of the first projects to happen<br />
here was the development of the website,<br />
which involved five designers. As a result,<br />
we changed our mind and abandoned the<br />
website project before it was to be<br />
launched, but we did develop the design,<br />
and my students improved their skills<br />
working on that project.”<br />
Andrii Pyvovar was among early participants<br />
of the second Creative House.<br />
“Pyvovar had been working in a bank, sitting<br />
there in a cubicle. He grew fed up with<br />
it, went on a journey, and when he returned,<br />
he decided to switch to design,”<br />
Demianova said.<br />
He studied design from scratch under<br />
Haidai for three months, starting in Kyiv<br />
before the second Creative House appeared,<br />
and subsequently moving to<br />
Pushcha. “Pyvovar aimed to practice the<br />
art until he hit the junior level and then<br />
find a job,” Haidai said. “I shared my experience<br />
with him for three months, we<br />
jointly created several projects for which<br />
he received money and added works to his<br />
portfolio. In early January, Pyvovar<br />
found a job with a design studio. This is<br />
my personal achievement as a teacher<br />
and one of the projects that have been implemented<br />
here.”<br />
To get to join the Creative House, one<br />
generally needs to have a specific project<br />
and a plan for its implementation, including<br />
specific deadlines. It should be described<br />
in a Google form, and if its author<br />
and the founders of the project find each<br />
other acceptable, one may come and join.<br />
One has to pay for bed and board in the Creative<br />
House, but most importantly, one has<br />
to implement one’s plan. “If a person comes<br />
to just live here, it turns into a hostel, and<br />
that is not how it should be,” Haidai added.<br />
“But we do not press people. One participant<br />
of the project was not doing what he had<br />
been going to. We spoke to him about this,<br />
and he calmly went away.”<br />
Once a week, all Creative House participants<br />
discuss everyday life and their<br />
projects together. As many as four people<br />
lived there for a time, while three are<br />
enough for comfortable living. However,<br />
a lot of people went through the small house<br />
during these six months: some stayed for<br />
several months, others came to attend<br />
meetings devoted to design and painting.<br />
● DEMIANOVA’S LEGEND<br />
Just before our arrival, Demianova<br />
completed a painting class. She has conducted<br />
them regularly here for some<br />
time. The artist learned about the Creative<br />
House from a friend, came here to<br />
a concert on an occasion and realized: this<br />
was what she dreamed about.<br />
“Five years ago or so, I spoke to my<br />
painting teacher. She said that it was cool<br />
to come up with a legend for one’s life. The<br />
only thing that would persist and remain<br />
in the memory of people for a long time,”<br />
Demianova recalled. “The teacher asked:<br />
‘Do you have something like that? What<br />
can be the best thing to happen in your<br />
life?’ When I thought about it, I imagined<br />
a great house where there were many different<br />
workshops, people of different professions<br />
working there, making something,<br />
sharing experiences. I told my<br />
teacher about it. She did not take it seriously,<br />
said that it was something banal.<br />
Still, the opportunity to give someone<br />
space for creativity always seemed to me a<br />
precious resource. And when I found myself<br />
here, I saw that this small house with<br />
Spartan conditions could grow into something<br />
like that.”<br />
The idea of an artistic project which<br />
she implemented in the Creative House had<br />
been present in Demianova’s mind for a<br />
long time. She has studied for seven years<br />
at a school where they teach the method of<br />
painting which was developed by the Swiss<br />
artist Gerard Wagner and builds on the<br />
properties of color. The artist calls her technique<br />
“the painting combined with a sense<br />
of the word.” The Gospel of John is the basis<br />
of two of her series. “I held my first<br />
Gospel-themed exhibition a year ago. It also<br />
included 21 works, but they were not<br />
portraits, unlike my current project. I<br />
read a certain verse from every chapter of<br />
this gospel and tried to feel what gesture<br />
or movement was inside of it. I then conveyed<br />
this movement through certain colors.<br />
Essentially, I painted portraits of<br />
phrases,” Demianova said.<br />
The need to carefully plan the timing<br />
of her project became the main challenge<br />
of the Creative House for the artist. However,<br />
it turned out that such a demanding<br />
planning style stimulates creativity better<br />
than a free schedule.<br />
“At first it seemed that I would not<br />
manage to do anything at all, as housework<br />
took all the time. But when I got more responsibilities,<br />
it added strength for my own<br />
project,” Demianova asserted. “When you<br />
find yourself in such conditions, all life becomes<br />
art. I looked at scattered fuelwood<br />
one day, and suddenly realized that it was<br />
an interesting material. The idea of creating<br />
decorated useful things from them occurred<br />
to me, because I love to paint on<br />
wood. I have also generally realized that it<br />
is cool to find beauty in some very ordinary<br />
things. Then the environment itself teaches<br />
you what the design and composition is.<br />
And this is something real. It is born from<br />
life itself, from necessity. After all, you do<br />
not have time to do something that is not<br />
necessary.”<br />
● COMMUNICATING WITH THE<br />
WORLD OUT OF THE MIDDLE<br />
OF A FOREST<br />
Why have they chosen Pushcha-Vodytsia?<br />
“Locals say it is a place of power,”<br />
Haidai said. “There is a very positive energy<br />
field, clean air, and water here. When<br />
I arrived in Pushcha after a day’s work before,<br />
I fully recovered in just an hour. So<br />
I was really interested in finding out how<br />
it would be to live here.”<br />
Currently, one of the goals of the<br />
Creative House’s founder is to find a<br />
third master who will also care about the<br />
house. Then they will be able to find a larger<br />
building, with separate rooms for organizers<br />
and participants. So far, residents<br />
of the Creative House pay for its upkeep<br />
out of their own wallets. Haidai observed:<br />
“I think that in the future, it will be possible<br />
to create our own products and sell<br />
them. These can be both material things<br />
and classes. We want to institute donations<br />
as well.”<br />
In addition to design, Haidai has been<br />
working on a musical project for four<br />
months already, which is scheduled to be<br />
displayed in May. He is not disclosing any<br />
details so far. He also made a comic book<br />
about the liberation of Mariupol. “My<br />
work is modern in nature, I create projects<br />
for different countries. On the other hand,<br />
I live a rural life. When a client is calling,<br />
I say that I will be ready to meet him in half<br />
an hour, and then go out with an axe to cut<br />
some fuelwood,” the lad smiled. “The<br />
essence of the Creative House is to do<br />
something, to create specific things. In my<br />
opinion, the world is full of twaddle nowadays,<br />
and it would be desirable to see people’s<br />
actions matching their words.”
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
CULT URE No.18 MARCH 22, 2018 7<br />
By Olesia AVRAMENKO<br />
Photos by Ruslan KANIUKA, The Day<br />
Ipersonally met the artist and saw<br />
not only a dozen of huge pictures<br />
he has painted in the past few<br />
years, but also about 20 books<br />
written by and about him.<br />
Besides, I had an opportunity to<br />
informally communicate with this<br />
handsome and elegant gentleman and<br />
his journalist wife Sibel.<br />
● PAINTING, CINEMA,<br />
THEATER, AND<br />
MANAGEMENT<br />
The life of this uncommon artist is<br />
worthy of an optimistic adventure<br />
novel. The upbringing and work of<br />
Bedri Baykam show the way of a free<br />
individual active in many arts.<br />
The boy was lucky that his talent<br />
was not only noticed by his parents, but<br />
also brought to the attention of the surrounding<br />
world. Bedri was only six<br />
when his first solo exhibit was held in<br />
his native city of Ankara. The first<br />
critical article appeared in a Turkish<br />
newspaper in 1963 and the next ones in<br />
the newspapers and magazines of other<br />
countries. His exhibit traveled across<br />
Europe (Bern, Geneva, Paris, Rome)<br />
and reached America. The Paris newspaper<br />
Le Figaro called him “the Mozart<br />
of painting,” and The Washington Post<br />
also paid attention to the exhibit of a<br />
talented child. The unhealthy ballyhoo<br />
about cashing in on the young genius’<br />
works caused his parents to refuse to<br />
sell their son’s pictures.<br />
In his teens, Baykam showed enthusiasm<br />
for cinema, theater, acting,<br />
and the secrets of film industry and<br />
theater management. After the triumph<br />
of his solo exhibits in Europe and<br />
America, parents sent the talented boy<br />
to a school in Switzerland to acquire<br />
the much-needed discipline and learn<br />
the most useful European languages –<br />
so it is no wonder that the young Bedri<br />
went to Paris for studies in 1975. The<br />
parents’ wealth and his own talent allowed<br />
the young artist to enter the Sorbonne<br />
and obtain an MBA in management<br />
and theater and film production.<br />
Does this mean that the wonder child<br />
betrayed himself and graduated to be a<br />
middle-level executive? Was it the diktat<br />
of his parents or a sober choice of<br />
Bedri himself? But, whatever the reason,<br />
the aspiration to secure a stable<br />
future did not prevent the youth from<br />
receiving specialized artistic education.<br />
The young artist concurrently enters<br />
another educational institution,<br />
L’Actorat, also in Paris, to study drama.<br />
He worked hard here, as always.<br />
This time, he mostly drew street<br />
scenes, landscapes, and nudes on paper<br />
with charcoal or Chinese ink.<br />
The time spent in France gave the<br />
youth broad experience, but he still felt<br />
a longing for visual and figurative<br />
arts. So, he decided to acquire systematized<br />
knowledge and skills and went to<br />
the US to enter the California College<br />
of Arts and Crafts in Oakland, where<br />
he studied painting and filmmaking.<br />
The artist considerably expanded<br />
the range of his instruments – he<br />
switched from doing watercolors and<br />
drawings to printmaking, began to<br />
paint in oil and, in the course of years,<br />
transformed pastose painting into<br />
transparent and acrylic. Little by little,<br />
graffiti and spray paint on plywood<br />
is added, oil paint fades away<br />
and acrylic takes the lead, which<br />
makes it possible to work faster and<br />
more actively. The bold synthesis of<br />
techniques and instruments, which<br />
now forms the basis of Baykam’s<br />
work, was born right here, in the US.<br />
● “NEW EXPRESSIONISM” AND<br />
“THE BOX OF DEMOCRACY”<br />
“The Mozart of painting” and…<br />
adventure novel<br />
The Ukrainian National Academy<br />
of Arts hall displays works<br />
of the noted Turkish master<br />
Bedri Baykam for the first time<br />
cy.” It is in the shape of<br />
a telephone booth<br />
which the author says<br />
“is a square meter of<br />
freedom. There are...<br />
couples who have entered<br />
and have made<br />
love. [It’s a] free space<br />
where you can do what<br />
you want.” This object<br />
is positioned as “a piece<br />
of Turkish democracy.”<br />
● “A 10-YEAR SELECTION”<br />
Now the uncommon artist brought<br />
a solo exhibit at the invitation of the<br />
Ukrainian National Academy of Arts.<br />
He called it simply: “Bedri Baykam: a<br />
10-Year Selection.”<br />
A huge silver-golden frame with<br />
writings, “The Hard Job of Living,” is<br />
installed in the middle of the hall.<br />
Looking through it, as if it were a<br />
viewfinder, you can focus on what<br />
opens up to you personally – the whole<br />
exposition or a certain picture, the<br />
spectators or the artist himself. Bedri<br />
has a series of such “hollow” frames.<br />
They are of various colors and textures<br />
– silver, golden, black, red…<br />
Newlyweds used to go through the red<br />
one at the Venice Biennale 2015, making<br />
wishes for a happy future. Each<br />
installation carries a message from<br />
the author and, at the same time,<br />
gives space to the thoughts and associations<br />
of every spectator who can<br />
concentrate on and take part in the<br />
game the author, every new situation,<br />
theme, and angle of view dictate.<br />
After examining closely the exposition,<br />
I suddenly realized that I had<br />
spent a lot of time, fascinated, in the<br />
hall and my colleagues had also seen<br />
the pictures. I was pleased to hear ex-<br />
After 12 years of studying abroad<br />
and going places, Baykam came back<br />
to Turkey in 1987 and settled in Istanbul.<br />
The artist has a multifaceted talent.<br />
He has written several scripts, a<br />
lot of articles and speeches, and even<br />
the action-packed novel The Bone published<br />
in Turkish in 2000 and in English<br />
in 2005. It is in his homeland that<br />
the artist seems to begin to realize<br />
himself at full capacity.<br />
Baykam continues to do and exhibit<br />
his artworks. Besides, he is an<br />
active citizen who defends the right of<br />
man to free development and democracy.<br />
He is not only the leader of the<br />
New Expressionism artistic movement<br />
but also a member of the<br />
Ataturkist Thought Association, one<br />
of the founders of the International<br />
Association of Art’s Turkish National<br />
Committee, and leads the Patriotic<br />
Movement. In October 2003 Baykam<br />
ran for the presidency of the Republican<br />
People’s Party.<br />
In 2006 Baykam formed the<br />
“Pyramid” center of contemporary art<br />
in Istanbul, where he organizes exhibits,<br />
publishes books and albums.<br />
“Pyramid” is one of the most active<br />
and independent centers of contemporary<br />
art in Turkey.<br />
In 2011, during his visit to the<br />
city of Kars, Turkish Prime Minister<br />
Recep Erdogan described the “Statue<br />
of Humanism,” which symbolizes Armenian-Turkish<br />
reconciliation, as a<br />
“freak” and called for demolishing it.<br />
This call immediately began to be fulfilled.<br />
Baykam was the first to stand<br />
up for the monument, saying that an<br />
Armenian-Turkish dialog is extremely<br />
important to his people and the<br />
Kars monument was the only major<br />
symbol of it. On the contrary, Erdogan<br />
showed an openly hostile attitude<br />
to Armenia. During a protest rally organized<br />
by Baykam, the artist and his<br />
female assistant were stabbed and<br />
wounded. Nobody doubted that the attack<br />
was connected with the artist’s<br />
active citizenship. But even this turn<br />
of events did not stop Baykam in his<br />
artistic and sociopolitical activities.<br />
At the International Istanbul Biennial<br />
2017, held under the motto “A<br />
Good Neighbor,” which raised ticklish<br />
questions about the political situation<br />
and crisis in Turkey, Baykam showed<br />
his work called “The Box of Democraacting<br />
and fault-finding professionals<br />
make surprisingly well-wishing comments<br />
and find the works very interesting.<br />
The pictures are sensual and gripping.<br />
The canvases are full of interesting<br />
stories and symbols which it is<br />
a delight to read. To keep the spectator<br />
interested, Baykam, as an experienced<br />
stage director, picks certain visual<br />
techniques from the artistic domain<br />
of the “magic lantern” and adds<br />
some elements of cinema language and<br />
theatrical mise-en-scenes, carefully<br />
forming the dramaturgy of each work.<br />
To implement such ideas, the artist<br />
easily combines traditional techniques<br />
and cutting-edge technologies.<br />
He is one of the first, if not the<br />
first, to dare apply the lenticular effect<br />
to pictures. It will be recalled that<br />
lenticular printing is a technology in<br />
which lenticular lenses (a technology<br />
that is also used for 3D displays) are<br />
used to produce printed images with<br />
an illusion of depth. Mass-scale production<br />
of this kind of items was<br />
launched in the 1970s in Japan. It is<br />
the stereo imaging we know from cute<br />
childhood-time “wiggle pictures,”<br />
where, for example, a beauty in the<br />
foreground raises a glass of wine and<br />
gives you a wink and, viewed from a<br />
different angle, opens the eye and<br />
drinks the wine, or Santa Clause takes<br />
gifts out of his bag near the Christmas<br />
tree, etc.<br />
Baykam is proud of his pictures<br />
with this kind of augmented reality,<br />
calling them 4D, and says it is a special<br />
Turkish magic or something like a<br />
magic carpet for everybody. For, depending<br />
on the angle of view, we can<br />
see different images. Add to this the<br />
illusion of a very deep multidimensional<br />
space. This literally causes us to<br />
get immersed in the depths of reflections<br />
and feelings.<br />
Bedri Baykam is a perfectionist by<br />
nature – he actively evades doing<br />
what everybody else does and, moreover,<br />
does not like repeating himself.<br />
He rapturously accepts and modifies<br />
the global art heritage, looking for his<br />
own ways in its labyrinth. Besides, he<br />
can see clearly and shows that his own<br />
artistic history grows out of the global<br />
one.<br />
The theme of harem, its place in<br />
the Ottoman Empire, in the imagination<br />
and interpretations of Europeans<br />
and himself, runs through all the exhibited<br />
works. He shows his own admiration<br />
of women in general and the<br />
woman as an archetype, a passionate<br />
desire to possess this beautiful feminine<br />
world, self-irony and subtle<br />
mockery of his own admirations and<br />
wishes and the stereotypes that have<br />
formed in the minds of generations.<br />
You will find some familiar heroes<br />
of pictures and films in the exhibited<br />
canvases. In “The Kiss: Homage to<br />
Munch Series” (4D, 185x120, 2010),<br />
figures from Edvard Munch’s canvases,<br />
which have frozen in a passionate<br />
kiss, go into a perspective on different<br />
levels and planes. Each of them mirrors<br />
a fraction of the author’s life and<br />
the experience of spectators. In the<br />
picture “How to Explain History to a<br />
Live Snail and Dead Hare” (4D,<br />
180 240, 2009), the cocktail of composition<br />
and sense consists of bright ingredients,<br />
such as fragments of a Renaissance-era<br />
religious composition<br />
with an enormous green snail and the<br />
notoriously maddened Mona Lisa, airplanes<br />
that soar like seagulls in the<br />
sky and a seagull that hovers like an<br />
airplane – and all this corresponds<br />
with the characters of early- 20th-century<br />
adverts and a horror film hero<br />
with a dead hare in hand.<br />
Bedri Baykam’s pictures of the<br />
given decade vividly show the movement<br />
of trends in world art in general<br />
and the Turkish artist in particular –<br />
from neoexpressionism and postmodernism<br />
to the so-called metamodernism.<br />
■ The exhibit “Bedri Baykam: a<br />
10-Year Selection” will remain open<br />
until April 7.<br />
Olesia Avramenko is an art critic
8<br />
No.18 MARCH 22, 2018<br />
TIMEO U T<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
Myths about<br />
idyllic life<br />
Sofia Andrukhovych’s<br />
novel Felix Austria<br />
nominated for Jean<br />
Monnet Prize<br />
A POSTER OF THE HISTORICAL DRAMA FELIX AUSTRIA<br />
It will be recalled that Polish film<br />
director Piotr Domalewski is going<br />
to make a historical drama, Felix<br />
Austria, based on the bestseller of<br />
the same name by Ukrainian writer<br />
Sofia Andrukhovych. The novel has<br />
been nominated for the Jean Monnet<br />
Prize, a French literary award. This<br />
prestigious prize has been awarded to<br />
European authors since 1995 for the<br />
best book written in or translated into<br />
the French language. The winners will<br />
be announced on June 13, Film.ua<br />
group’s press service reports<br />
Also on the shortlist are such European<br />
writers as Chantal Thomas<br />
(France), the author of the novel<br />
Farewell, My Queen, filmed in 2012 by<br />
Benoit Jacquot; Sebastian Barry (Ireland),<br />
the author of The Secret Scripture,<br />
filmed in 2016; Alan Hollinghurst<br />
(UK), the winner of the Booker Prize<br />
2004; Jose Carlos Llop (Spain); Jon<br />
Kalman Stefansson (Iceland), and Kjell<br />
Anders Westo (Sweden).<br />
Andrukhovych’s novel Felix Austria<br />
was published in French translation<br />
by Noir sur Blanc. The book is also expected<br />
to come out in Slovakia and the<br />
US this year.<br />
The novel is set in Stanislau (now<br />
Ivano-Frankivsk) in the late 19th-early<br />
20th centuries. It is a city on the periphery<br />
of “happy Austria,” in which<br />
people live, suffer, fall in love, are<br />
keen on science and fraudulent shows<br />
of illusionists, entertain at balls, and<br />
hide secrets in carved-wood chests-ofdrawers.<br />
Against the background of the<br />
epoch, which is going to create more<br />
and more myths for descendants, we<br />
can watch the destinies of two women<br />
that have intertwined as closely as<br />
tree branches – this inseparable tie<br />
does not allow them to live, breathe, or<br />
go. The protagonists are Stefania, a<br />
Ukrainian, on behalf of whom the story<br />
is told, and the noble lady Adel<br />
Anger, half a Pole and half a German.<br />
“Telling a private story of my characters,<br />
whose chimerical cohabitation<br />
seemed to be a sweet fairytale, I was trying<br />
to hint that the floridly ornamented<br />
facade hides a fragile structure that<br />
can go to pieces at the slightest touch<br />
of external forces,” vikna.ua quotes Andrukhovych<br />
as saying. “The life of two<br />
women who belong to different social<br />
strata, come from different ethnic and<br />
cultural contexts, and share a common<br />
space, very impressive to look at, is one<br />
of the possible metaphors of the coexistence<br />
of the subjects of the Austro-<br />
Hungarian Empire.<br />
“Felix Austria is the name of a boy<br />
who suddenly emerges in the process of<br />
narration. He appears from nowhere,<br />
has no history and voice. He symbolizes<br />
irrational and inexplicable forces that<br />
are impossible to foresee and assess in<br />
an analytical way but are very often a<br />
decisive factor which changes the<br />
course of history – be it the history of<br />
an individual or of a state.”<br />
By Alisa ANTONENKO<br />
Photo from the website FILM.UA GROUP<br />
True gold of true athletes<br />
By Olena KURENKOVA<br />
Photos by Artem SLIPACHUK, The Day<br />
Hundreds of people welcomed in Boryspil<br />
on March 20 the Ukrainian national team<br />
that had triumphantly performed at the<br />
Paralympic Winter Games in South Korea<br />
Flowers, Ukrainian flags, posters<br />
and warm embrace – all these<br />
created the emotional and joyful<br />
welcome offered Ukrainian athletes<br />
as they came home. To honor<br />
the team on its return, a meeting with the<br />
medalists was held in the hall of the<br />
F terminal at the Boryspil Airport,<br />
during which they were greeted not only<br />
by their relatives, but also by high<br />
officials, including Prime Minister of<br />
Ukraine Volodymyr Hroisman, Minister<br />
of Youth and Sports of Ukraine Ihor<br />
Zhdanov, and chairman of the Verkhovna<br />
Rada Committee on Family, Youth<br />
Policy, Sports, and Tourism Artur Palatny.<br />
However, it was the athletes, patiently<br />
awaited by several hundred people,<br />
who were in the focus of the event.<br />
This year, Ukraine performed very<br />
well in Pyeongchang, winning seven<br />
gold medals (this is the record number of<br />
such awards for Ukraine over the past<br />
12 years), seven silver, and eight bronze<br />
ones, and coming to rank sixth among<br />
the medal-winning countries in the overall<br />
ranking. “It is a very significant<br />
victory for us precisely now. I guess it is<br />
because the war continues in this country,<br />
and people are already tired of it, so<br />
we feel everything especially keenly.<br />
And victories of our Paralympians offer<br />
an extra reason to be proud of this country,”<br />
said Svitlana Tryfonova, Honored<br />
Master of Sports of Ukraine, seventime<br />
medalist of the Paralympics.<br />
The hall of the terminal was crowded,<br />
mostly with professional athletes,<br />
veterans of Olympics and Paralympics,<br />
relatives of this year’s medalists, journalists,<br />
and regular supportive citizens<br />
(the latter were numerous as well). The<br />
official program did not take a long<br />
time. The organizers of the event kept<br />
people entertained until the arrival of the<br />
athletes by screening excerpts of video<br />
records of the Ukrainian team’s preparation<br />
for the Games and its performance<br />
in Pyeongchang. The plane arrived on<br />
time. A solemn and exciting moment of<br />
the welcome, a performance of the anthem,<br />
followed by a short official program.<br />
Hroisman spoke, announcing positive<br />
news: the amount of award payments<br />
to Paralympic athletes had been<br />
raised to match that of Olympic medalists;<br />
Zhdanov offered specific figures:<br />
the national budget had 91 million hryvnias<br />
allocated for the medalists, of which<br />
125,000 hryvnias were to be received by<br />
every gold medalist, 85,000 by every silver<br />
one, and 55,000 by every bronze one.<br />
And then, the heroes were greeted<br />
by their closest family and engaged in informal<br />
communication: at last, we had<br />
an opportunity to find out about their<br />
impressions firsthand. This year’s Paralympic<br />
team, led by Valerii Sushkevych,<br />
included very young medalists along<br />
with well-known Paralympic athletes<br />
who had won on numerous occasions before.<br />
The 18-year-old Taras Rad, who<br />
won gold and became the flag-bearer at<br />
the closing ceremony, told us: “I have returned<br />
with great impressions, and I am<br />
especially pleased with the fact that although<br />
I entered the Paralympics for the<br />
first time, I won such a high award.<br />
Thus, I now want to do better every<br />
time.” Oksana Shyshkova, who is one of<br />
the most experienced team members,<br />
brought home six awards, including<br />
two golds, three silvers, and a bronze.<br />
She said she dedicated her victories to<br />
soldiers of the anti-terrorist operation.<br />
Vitalii Lukianenko, who is no less experienced<br />
and won two golds at these<br />
Games, remarked that during the competition,<br />
he was strongly impressed by<br />
events such as performances of the<br />
Ukrainian anthem and raisings of our<br />
flag. He said he was pleased with the result<br />
while admitting he could have done<br />
better. Meanwhile, Liudmyla Liashenko,<br />
who won a gold and three bronze medals,<br />
tirelessly motivated others with her example:<br />
“I would like to wish that everyone<br />
stay strong and do the work they<br />
like, so that one could say in one’s old<br />
age: I have lived such a happy life, full<br />
of events and diverse competitions! Most<br />
importantly, one should never give up.”<br />
Also, the athletes said they had felt<br />
strong support coming from the homeland.<br />
In particular, it manifested this<br />
year in the setting up, for the first time<br />
ever, of a Paralympic fan zone in the<br />
“Pencil” TV building. The organizers<br />
noted that they would repeat it in the future<br />
as well.<br />
UKRAINIAN NEWS IN ENGLISH<br />
www.day.kiev.ua incognita.day.kiev.ua<br />
FOUNDER AND PUBLISHER:<br />
UKRAINIAN PRESS GROUP LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY<br />
Published since May 27, 1998.<br />
Свiдоцтво про перереєстрацiю КВ № 21448-11248 ПР<br />
вiд 27 липня 2015 року<br />
Larysa Ivshyna, Editor-in-Chief, Den<br />
e-mail: chedit@day.kiev.ua<br />
Hanna Sheremet, Deputy Editor-in-Chief<br />
Anna Mazurenko, Director,<br />
Ukrainian Press Group LLC<br />
Anna Motoziuk, Editor,<br />
English Language Bureau<br />
Olha Pavliei, Technical Editor<br />
Borys Honcharov, George Skliar, Taras Shulha,<br />
Nadia Sysiuk, Translators<br />
Maryna Khyzhniakova, Proofreader<br />
Marharyta Motoziuk, Designer<br />
Alla Bober, Responsible Secretary<br />
Mykola Tymchenko, Photography Editor<br />
Mailing address: prosp. Peremohy, 121d, Kyiv 03115, Ukraine<br />
Telephone: +38(044) 303-96-19<br />
Fax: +38(044) 303-94-20<br />
Advertising: +38(044) 303-96-20; e-mail: ra@day.kiev.ua<br />
Subscriptions: +38(044) 303-96-23; e-mail: amir@day.kiev.ua<br />
E-mail: time@day.kiev.ua<br />
Subscription index: 40032<br />
Ukrainian Press Group LLC<br />
Code 24249388<br />
Raiffeisen Bank joint-stock company<br />
MFO 380805<br />
A/С 26007478064<br />
Responsibility for the accuracy of facts, quotations, personal names, and other information is borne by the authors of publications and in advertising<br />
materials by the advertiser. The views expressed in signed articles do not necessarily reflect those of the editors. Submitted materials are not returned<br />
and not reviewed. The editors retain the right to edit materials. When citing Day materials, reference to The Day is mandatory. ©Den.