#43_1-8
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
AUGUST 23, 2018 ISSUE No. 43 (1175)<br />
Tel.: +38(044) 303-96-19,<br />
fax: +38(044) 303-94-20<br />
е-mail: time@day.kiev.ua;<br />
http://www.day.kiev.ua<br />
Dear readers, our next issue will be published on August 30, 2018<br />
Photo by Mykola TYMCHENKO, The Day<br />
“I am grateful that you<br />
do not forget me”<br />
August 23 marks the 102nd day of Oleh Sentsov’s hunger strike. Why it is<br />
important to write and read out letters to the “prisoners of the Kremlin”<br />
Continued on page 5
2<br />
No.43 AUGUST 23, 2018<br />
DAY AFTER DAY<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
By Daria CHYZH, Yuliia DOVHAICHUK,<br />
Den’s Summer School of Journalism,<br />
2018Members of parliament have<br />
gone on vacation – but not all<br />
of them. Oksana Syroid,<br />
Deputy Chairperson of the<br />
Verkhovna Rada, has visited<br />
the Den’s Summer School of Journalism.<br />
Although the school finished as far back<br />
as July, the practice of students was so<br />
intensive and fruitful that they are still<br />
discussing results. All the more so that the<br />
subjects lecturers covered are still topical.<br />
As Ms. Syroid serves in parliamentary for<br />
the first time, students first of all asked<br />
her what she thinks about the Ukrainian<br />
Parliament’s performance in the almost<br />
four years of the present convocation.<br />
Did she expect to see this when she was<br />
running for a legislative seat?<br />
● “A CLAN OLIGARCHIC<br />
SYSTEM BEGAN TO FORM<br />
IN THE MID-1990S”<br />
“I knew what to expect from this parliament<br />
because I had seen the ups and<br />
downs of many people and the Verkhovna<br />
Rada’s rules. I worked as an MP’s assistant<br />
for several years from 1995 and cooperated,<br />
in other capacities, with politicians for<br />
a long time, so I used to say categorically<br />
that I would never set foot in there. But the<br />
Revolution of Dignity and the war changed<br />
many things. Everybody was trying to<br />
give off something in addition. I knew I<br />
could do nothing on my own there, but I<br />
found a team that became a shoulder to rely<br />
on in the attempt to begin making<br />
changes. I don’t regret my decision today<br />
from the viewpoint of confidence in people,<br />
for I stay in a sincere society, although it<br />
is very difficult to be in politics.<br />
“A clan oligarchic system began to<br />
form in the mid-1990s, when a few people<br />
received access to governmental funds, natural<br />
resources, and privatization. They<br />
would suck out, cash in on, and smuggle<br />
these resources abroad. The next goal was<br />
to form an oligarchic government in order<br />
to preserve or increase access to resources,<br />
the budget, and the management of staterun<br />
businesses.<br />
“The Euromaidan and the war opened<br />
the window that allowed about 60 non-oligarchic<br />
people to make their way to parliament.<br />
This is the first time since the formation<br />
of a clan oligarchic system that we<br />
have people in parliament whom oligarchs<br />
do not control. This makes the current parliament<br />
unique to some extent.”<br />
● “SOME OF THE NEW MPS<br />
HAD ALREADY DEPENDED<br />
ON OLIGARCHS, AND<br />
OTHERS SUCCUMBED TO<br />
TEMPTATION IN THE<br />
PARLIAMENT ITSELF”<br />
Olha KRYSA, Ivan Franko National<br />
University of Lviv: “Many new young<br />
Maidan and NGO politicians, now MPs,<br />
used to say they would unite when they entered<br />
parliament. But, as a result, they in<br />
fact melted into various political projects.<br />
Why did they fail to form a united party?<br />
How effective do you think they are in parliament?”<br />
“Formally, parliament has been renewed<br />
to a large extent. There are several<br />
groups of new people in it. But do they represent<br />
a new generation? Some of them had<br />
already depended on oligarchs when they<br />
became MPs, and others succumbed to<br />
temptation in the parliament itself. If one<br />
goes into politics in pursuit of fame, he will<br />
burn himself out quickly, for politics suggests<br />
service. You should be confident in<br />
yourself to such an extent that temptations<br />
and challenges could not influence your<br />
way – only in this case you can stand your<br />
ground. People often fail to stand the test<br />
and lose confidence in themselves and in<br />
what they do. Going through this several<br />
times, they demotivate themselves or lose<br />
focus. This is also one of the reasons why<br />
young people have partially blended in. It<br />
is very difficult to keep things in focus,<br />
knowing that nobody may appreciate it or<br />
that you will gain nothing from this.<br />
“As for political parties, you cannot<br />
form parties in parliament, for they<br />
should be formed ‘from the bottom up.’<br />
Believing in success<br />
Photo by Mykola TYMCHENKO, The Day<br />
cisions horizontally, i.e., when they all<br />
sit at the same table. Now imagine how<br />
difficult it is for a faction to work,<br />
when 25 ambitious figures sit at table,<br />
each of them wants to explain something,<br />
while the faction should make a<br />
joint decision. At first, our faction’s sittings<br />
lasted for seven hours. It takes time<br />
for people to learn to hear each other. For<br />
example, we discussed withdrawal from<br />
the coalition for 14 hours in a row. Very<br />
few were prepared for this.”<br />
● “ONE MORE PROBLEM IS<br />
DEVALUATION OF<br />
PARLIAMENT BY OTHER<br />
INSTITUTIONS. ALL<br />
PRESIDENTS OF UKRAINE<br />
‘SUFFERED’ FROM THIS”<br />
Yuliia DOVHAICHUK, Taras<br />
Shevchenko National University of Kyiv:<br />
“According to various polls, about 80 percent<br />
of people do not trust the Verkhovna<br />
Rada. This raises a question: what is the<br />
progress of the promised parliamentary reform?<br />
For MPs still vote for one another,<br />
the new Rada system does not function, to<br />
say nothing about almost daily violations<br />
A political force must be linked with<br />
people – otherwise it is a bubble, an empty<br />
brand. It is very difficult to form a new<br />
political party first of all because the very<br />
notion of this has devalued. What also<br />
matters very much is the desire of people<br />
to join. The hierarchy of a political force<br />
is horizontal, and this structure must rely<br />
on the personality of leaders, not on<br />
their formal powers.<br />
“I know for sure that Samopomich is<br />
the only political force that makes all deof<br />
parliamentary rules. Why is there no reform?”<br />
“Parliamentary reform boils down to<br />
your and our votes. If people go on electing<br />
representatives of oligarchic groups, the<br />
essence of parliament will not change, no<br />
matter what procedural resolutions we<br />
pass. All depends on the intentions of the<br />
people who sit in the Verkhovna Rada<br />
room. Sometimes journalists ask me why<br />
some MPs play truant. But the vice-speaker<br />
of parliament is not a company manager<br />
– it is the people, not I, who employed the<br />
MPs. The MPs are answerable to society only.<br />
But they escape responsibility because<br />
they are sure of being reelected. Elections<br />
are the only way to control parliament.<br />
“Do voters know what their MP votes<br />
for? How many people ask the MP, when he<br />
visits the constituency: ‘How dared you<br />
vote for this?’ Collective irresponsibility<br />
is a terrible syndrome. If people were asking<br />
MPs why they voted one way or another,<br />
the MPs would take a more serious<br />
approach to voting. Therefore, a true parliamentary<br />
reform means changing the clan<br />
oligarchic system. Another problem is devaluation<br />
of parliament by other institutions.<br />
All presidents of Ukraine ‘suffered’<br />
from this. Particularly, whenever their rating<br />
plummets, they immediately aggravate<br />
relations with parliament – they create<br />
crises, blame MPs for failing to do something,<br />
etc. The current president is not an<br />
exception. If you watched the closure of sessions,<br />
you remember that the Petro<br />
Poroshenko Bloc once walked out when<br />
they refused to vote for new Central Election<br />
Commission members. Politicians<br />
must begin to understand that it is in<br />
everybody’s interests to respect each other,<br />
each institution. Respect increases<br />
public trust in governmental bodies as a<br />
whole.”<br />
Oksana SYROID:<br />
“The form of<br />
government<br />
does not matter.<br />
What matters is<br />
that the entire<br />
executive branch<br />
should be under<br />
parliamentary<br />
control”<br />
● “IN MY VIEW, WE SHOULD<br />
HAVE A PRIME-<br />
MINISTERIAL FORM OF<br />
GOVERNMENT, WHEN THE<br />
PREMIER REPRESENTS A<br />
PARTY OR A COALITION”<br />
Daria CHYZH, Borys Hrinchenko<br />
University of Kyiv: “Ukrainians often<br />
debate on the form of government – in<br />
the years of independence, it has been<br />
Photo by Ruslan KANIUKA, The Day<br />
changing from parliamentary-presidential<br />
to presidential-parliamentary.<br />
You favor the parliamentary form of<br />
government. But to what extent is this<br />
possible in the absence of real political<br />
parties?”<br />
“What we have is not a parliamentary-presidential<br />
form of government<br />
because parliament does not wield the<br />
clout it must wield in a democracy, and<br />
the form is in fact presidential-primeministerial.<br />
We have the so-called dual<br />
executive system which has brought<br />
forth collective irresponsibility and cemented<br />
an oligarchic system. The main<br />
functions of the executive branch are to<br />
control the budget, collect and distribute<br />
taxes, decide on the use of force inside<br />
and outside the country. We have<br />
the Cabinet of Ministers, legally the<br />
highest body of executive power. But, on<br />
closer examination, most of the executive<br />
functions in fact belong to the president.<br />
He controls a considerable part of<br />
the budget, the security and defense sector,<br />
and all the so-called independent<br />
regulators. Besides, there is not a single<br />
instrument of the president’s accountability<br />
to parliament and, hence, to so-<br />
ciety. Even the US president reports to<br />
Congress, although the US has a purely<br />
presidential form of government.<br />
“In my opinion, the form of government<br />
does not matter. What really matters<br />
is that the entire executive branch<br />
should be under parliamentary control.<br />
The presidential form of government is<br />
effective in the US today. They formed<br />
this unique model to keep all the states<br />
united. Is this the Ukrainian way, too?<br />
We should strive to have what is really in<br />
line with our historical development and<br />
could be effective. If we suddenly wished<br />
to have the presidential form of government<br />
and a strong leader, this might<br />
pave the way to dictatorship. So, in my<br />
view, we should have a prime-ministerial<br />
form of government, when the premier<br />
represents a party or a coalition. And he<br />
must be personally responsible for the formation<br />
of the Cabinet.”<br />
● “IF THERE IS NO IDEA AND<br />
TEAM, IT IS IRRESPONSIBLE<br />
TO RALLY AROUND<br />
SOMEBODY”<br />
Evelina KOTLIAROVA, Taras<br />
Shevchenko National University of<br />
Kyiv: “What do you expect from the<br />
next elections? There is so much talk<br />
about a single candidate of democratic<br />
forces. Such names as Hrytsenko,<br />
Sadovyi, and Chumak are in the air…<br />
What do you think of a single candidate?<br />
Who can it be?”<br />
“The Ukrainians really want unity<br />
because whenever the presidential elections<br />
are coming up, the number of candidates<br />
increases many times over.<br />
This brings in a lot of caretaker candidates<br />
because it is important for oligarchic<br />
groups to retain power. Yes,<br />
the Ukrainians understand subconsciously<br />
that the oligarchic system<br />
must be destroyed. And there is quite<br />
a wide range of opposition candidates<br />
who could rally together. But this raises<br />
the question of who to rally around.<br />
I am skeptical about rallying around<br />
somebody. If there is no idea and team,<br />
it is irresponsible to rally around somebody.<br />
Suppose this person wins. So<br />
what? Who is going to work? Shall we<br />
call on oligarchs again to help us?<br />
They will immediately place their people<br />
in offices.<br />
“It seems to me we are having a situation,<br />
when some people, who position<br />
themselves as presidential candidates<br />
but have no team or ideas, really want<br />
either to ‘dissolve’ votes or, even if they<br />
win, to become a new face of the old oligarchic<br />
system. Many of these candidates<br />
are dependent. Of course, they<br />
won’t say this publicly, but they know<br />
who stands behind whom. On the other<br />
hand, there are groups of people and<br />
their leaders who are free of this dependency<br />
but full of energy and ideas.<br />
They find it very difficult to believe and<br />
unite with other leaders because there<br />
has been too much deception in our<br />
politics.”<br />
● “I DO NOT RULE OUT THAT<br />
RUSSIA CONCEIVED NORD<br />
STREAM 2 IN ORDER TO<br />
BREAK UP THE EUROPEAN<br />
UNION”<br />
Sofiia POSTOLATII, Sumy State<br />
University: “To what extent has the<br />
question of the annexed Crimea and the<br />
occupied parts of the Donbas been<br />
brought into line with the law at present?”<br />
“All the resolutions we have today<br />
convince me that the leadership is not<br />
going to fight for independence and victory.<br />
We tried to interpret certain<br />
processes in the bill ‘On Temporarily<br />
Occupied Territories’ drafted in mid-<br />
2015. The first question is what is to be<br />
done with the occupied territories.<br />
They are populated by our people but<br />
controlled by the enemy. So how can<br />
they, for example, protect themselves<br />
from the illegal arms traffic? The second<br />
question is how to regain control
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
DAY AFTER DAY No.43 AUGUST 23, 2018 3<br />
over the occupied territories. It is a<br />
wide range of questions – who<br />
should be pardoned, lustrated or<br />
punished? We drew up a bill like<br />
this. Almost all the governmental<br />
bodies, including the Border Guard<br />
Service, the Ministry of Defense, the<br />
General Staff of the Armed Forces,<br />
the Security Service, the Ministry of<br />
Finance, and the National Bank,<br />
supported us. But the president refused<br />
to support this decision. Instead,<br />
he proposed a bill of his own.<br />
But the adopted law ‘On Reintegration’<br />
says nothing about the abovementioned.”<br />
Khrystyna SAVCHUK, Taras<br />
Shevchenko National University<br />
of Kyiv: “You wrote on your Facebook<br />
page about grave consequences<br />
for Ukraine of the construction<br />
of Nord Stream 2. What<br />
or who can stop this process? How<br />
can Ukraine influence?”<br />
“It is not ruled out that Russia<br />
conceived Nord Stream 2 in order<br />
to break up the European Union.<br />
As a matter of fact, Russia and<br />
Germany are building a transit capacity<br />
which, together with Nord<br />
Stream 1, will be enough to pump<br />
gas, bypassing Ukraine. After<br />
building the new branch, Russia<br />
will be free to just shut off the<br />
valve and pump nothing, including<br />
to Ukraine. This is why our gas<br />
transportation system is like another<br />
‘nuclear arsenal.’ After the<br />
failure of the Budapest Memorandum,<br />
its loss will be one more security<br />
guarantee lost.<br />
“What can stop this project?<br />
Only harsh US sanctions. Europe is<br />
so far unable to make a joint decision<br />
against Nord Stream 2.<br />
Ukraine should in turn seek a way<br />
not to fall into the pit which the<br />
construction of Nord Stream 2 is<br />
pushing Europe into.”<br />
● “I HAVE ALSO BEEN<br />
ABROAD, BUT I CAME<br />
BACK BECAUSE IT IS<br />
MUCH MORE<br />
INTERESTING TO DO<br />
SOMETHING IN YOUR<br />
OWN COUNTRY”<br />
Vladyslava SHEVCHENKO,<br />
Kyiv Mohyla Academy: “In the<br />
past few years, young people of<br />
Ukraine have been going abroad<br />
on a mass scale because they do not<br />
believe in their country. How can<br />
this negative tide be stemmed?”<br />
“One must believe in success. It<br />
is logical that young people want to<br />
be ‘cool’ and successful, have a<br />
good job and housing, and be able<br />
to keep a family. But when they see<br />
our politicians devalue the state,<br />
they get disappointed and, as a result,<br />
do not want to identify themselves<br />
with this country. On the<br />
other hand, we harbor an illusion<br />
that it is easier to achieve success<br />
in other countries, but no matter<br />
where you come, you will always<br />
remain an emigrant. Very few take<br />
into account that an unstable country<br />
provides a larger space for<br />
successful enterprise because it<br />
is possible to ‘catch the wave.’ I<br />
have also been abroad, but I came<br />
back because it is much more interesting<br />
to do something in your<br />
own country rather than jump on<br />
someone else’s bandwagon. You<br />
are facing a major challenge, but<br />
you are also standing a chance to<br />
amply realize yourselves in your<br />
country.”<br />
Project Summer School<br />
of Journalism was carried<br />
out with support from<br />
the NATO Information and<br />
Documentation Center in<br />
Ukraine<br />
By Olesia SHUTKEVYCH, The Day,<br />
Vinnytsia<br />
We met Vinnytsia Mayor<br />
Serhii Morhunov in a<br />
working atmosphere,<br />
finding a “slot” in his<br />
tight schedule full of<br />
briefings and routine meetings.<br />
Vinnytsia is often cited as an example<br />
of new dynamism. The city is<br />
building new kindergartens, producing<br />
its own VinWay trams, updating<br />
public transport stops, and has opened<br />
an NGO hub, an IT entrepreneurial<br />
center and original museums. City<br />
residents can communicate online<br />
with the Round the Clock Watch rapid<br />
response center, use the services of<br />
the “mobile” Transparent Office and<br />
follow the electronic traffic schedule.<br />
But is it all that quiet in the “kingdom”?<br />
As Vinnytsia-born people hold<br />
key offices in the state, the city is always<br />
in the focus of attention. You<br />
can’t take your hand off the pulse<br />
even for a minute, Mr. Morhunov<br />
says, for the mayor’s job is not only to<br />
seek the solution of difficult problems,<br />
but also to provide safe and comfortable<br />
conditions for city residents.<br />
What brought about the active<br />
and dynamic development of Vinnytsia:<br />
the previously taken pace or of<br />
the decentralization reform?<br />
“Both things did. When our team<br />
came to power in the city, we began by<br />
improving the quality of the city<br />
council’s performance and restructuring<br />
the system of administration.<br />
When all the units began to work as<br />
one mechanism, we mapped out a comprehensive<br />
strategy of urban development,<br />
‘Vinnytsia 2020,’ which made it<br />
possible to take a more effective approach<br />
to the existing problems. But,<br />
having a clear vision of the problems<br />
and the ways of their solution, we had<br />
no financial resources. For this reason,<br />
when Volodymyr Hroisman was<br />
transferred to the Cabinet of Ministers,<br />
he began to introduce decentralization<br />
which offered [regional bodies]<br />
certain powers and finances and made<br />
it possible to effectively develop the<br />
community, its infrastructure and social<br />
sphere, and improve investment<br />
attractiveness.<br />
“While Vinnytsia’s development<br />
budget was a mere 40 million hryvnias<br />
in 2006, it reached one billion hryvnias<br />
last year. Today we have achieved<br />
a level when one fifth, 20 percent, of<br />
the budget is being spent on the development<br />
– civil construction, reconstruction,<br />
and modernization projects.<br />
This year the development budget<br />
is 857 million hryvnias. On the<br />
whole, compared to the first six<br />
months of the last year, city budget<br />
revenues have gone up by almost<br />
500 million hryvnias, or 25 percent.<br />
It’s a good dynamics, isn’t it?<br />
“Additional financial resources<br />
opened up new opportunities. Previously,<br />
we could not even dream of winterizing<br />
several schools in a year. We<br />
did not even dare take up large-scale<br />
projects. And today, for example, we<br />
have begun to finish the construction<br />
of a 3,000-sq-m emergency hospital.<br />
Incidentally, we’ve received serious<br />
financial support – over 70 million –<br />
from the national budget for this project.<br />
The hospital is supposed to have<br />
an intensive care unit with a shock<br />
room, a resuscitation block, and an<br />
up-to-date urgent surgery block with<br />
laparoscopic equipment. You will find<br />
such a systemic approach to the organization<br />
of medical care nowhere<br />
else in Ukraine so far.<br />
“At the same time, we are carrying<br />
out some spatial development<br />
projects. We noticed after reconstructing<br />
Kosmonavtiv Avenue that<br />
business activity had increased on this<br />
territory. We began to open cafes,<br />
stores, and new offices. This means<br />
creation of new jobs, gentrification of<br />
“It’stimetoshowourstrongsides”<br />
Vinnytsia Mayor Serhii Morhunov on real<br />
capabilities and powers of urban selfgovernment,<br />
implemented and planned<br />
projects, new challenges and provocations<br />
the area, and, what is more, positive<br />
mood of the residents who always relax<br />
near fountains and the Atlant<br />
[sport club].”<br />
Vinnytsia once set a goal to keep<br />
public transport going. The city’s<br />
transport reform is still called the<br />
most successful one, and Swiss-made<br />
trams run like clockwork. Does the<br />
city plan to develop the public transport<br />
network? What advantages will<br />
city residents get from introduction<br />
of the electronic ticket in 2019?<br />
“Public transport now accounts<br />
for 80 percent of passenger carriage,<br />
so it must be of high quality and safe,<br />
and the Vinnytsia Transport Company<br />
is constantly trying to update the<br />
rolling stock. While purchasing new<br />
municipal buses, we also do heavy repairs<br />
and restorative maintenance, if<br />
necessary. And, what is more, we continue,<br />
together with our Swiss partners,<br />
to draw up a delivery schedule<br />
for a new batch of trams that are so far<br />
running down the streets of Zurich.<br />
Vinnytsia is going to receive 70 vehicles<br />
from 2021 on. So it is time to prepare<br />
the infrastructure, tracks, and<br />
overhead wires.<br />
“At the same time, we are working<br />
on introducing the electronic ticket –<br />
it is an effective system, a worldwide<br />
practice, and a call of the time. To carry<br />
out the project, we took a loan at<br />
the European Bank for Reconstruction<br />
and Development, and all the<br />
preparatory work is drawing to a<br />
close. What advantages are Vinnytsia<br />
residents going to get? Firstly, they<br />
will find it convenient to pay fares.<br />
Secondly, the system will make it possible<br />
to effectively use public transport.<br />
Thirdly, it will be clear what resource<br />
the Vinnytsia Transport Company<br />
will gain for the service it provides.<br />
Moreover, the electronic ticket<br />
is the first step towards creating the<br />
comprehensive ‘Vinnytsia resident’s<br />
card.’”<br />
Vinnytsia was named Ukraine’s<br />
most comfortable city for the fourth<br />
consecutive year. But still here is “a<br />
fly in the ointment”: while everything<br />
is OK, as far as the city’s infrastructure,<br />
the humanitarian sphere, and<br />
municipal services are concerned,<br />
this year’s polls show that industrial<br />
development is an obvious downside.<br />
“Frankly speaking, it is the problem<br />
of not only Vinnytsia but of<br />
Ukraine as a whole because this country<br />
is at war. The city is tackling the<br />
problem of attracting investments.<br />
This year we finished the construction<br />
of the first stage of a UBC Group<br />
plant, and the state-run company<br />
Electric System, where there will be<br />
2,500 jobs by the end of this year, has<br />
been working for almost two years. A<br />
memorandum has been signed about<br />
the construction of a HEAD sport gear<br />
factory. Besides, there are about<br />
100 various industrial facilities in<br />
Photo by Ruslan KANIUKA, The Day<br />
APRIL 25, 2018. THE OPENING OF DEN’S PHOTO EXHIBIT IN VINNYTSIA. THE<br />
MAYOR HOLDS THE CROWN, OR HERITAGE OF THE RUS’ KINGDOM, A NEW<br />
DEN’S LIBRARY BOOK, WHICH WAS HANDED OVER TO ALL DEPARTMENTS OF<br />
VINNYTSIA PEDAGOGICAL UNIVERSITY AND THE CITY’S 17 LIBRARIES AND<br />
BRANCHES<br />
this city – some of them worked in the<br />
Soviet era and adapted to contemporary<br />
business conditions, and some<br />
have been founded by foreign investors<br />
in the past 10-15 years.<br />
“But to build an enterprise is one<br />
thing and to find working hands is another.<br />
The training of adequate shopfloor<br />
workers at vocational schools is<br />
on the skids, to put it mildly. The<br />
problem we are facing today is that<br />
there’s nobody to work at factories.<br />
For this reason, the question of attracting<br />
investments – both foreign<br />
and domestic – requires a multipronged<br />
approach. It is unrealistic to<br />
solve this problem within the city limits<br />
because there are some points<br />
which only the central authorities can<br />
settle.”<br />
The city council has been paying a<br />
lot of attention to local history lately.<br />
The Center of Vinnytsia History functions,<br />
past events are being reenacted,<br />
films are being made, and monuments<br />
are being unveiled. Is it because<br />
you are a historian by education<br />
or is the answer not so simple?<br />
“As far as historical renaissance<br />
and filling blind spots and pages are<br />
concerned, the newspaper Den is second<br />
to none, for which kudos to its<br />
team and personally editor-in-chief<br />
Larysa Ivshyna. As for the history of<br />
Vinnytsia, its residents have in fact<br />
known nothing about their city’s past<br />
for a long time except for Pirogov and<br />
Hitler’s headquarters because Soviet<br />
ideology hushed everything up. But<br />
Vinnytsia is 655 years old! There were<br />
people in every century, who gave impetus<br />
to the development of our city.<br />
And, not to make mistakes, we must<br />
know our past. Therefore, it is very<br />
important to develop historic locations,<br />
establish museums, and restore<br />
historical justice.<br />
“It’s time to show our strong sides<br />
and learn to position ourselves correctly<br />
so that we can win first – not<br />
second, third, or twentieth – places.<br />
For example, the Vinnytsia Museum of<br />
Transport Models ‘grew’ from the private<br />
collection of a Polytechnic lecturer.<br />
He used to collect vehicle models in<br />
all of his lifetime and can now display<br />
them to people. It is one of Ukraine’s<br />
largest and best museums today.”<br />
Den’s Days came back to Vinnytsia<br />
this year. What are your personal<br />
impressions of the event and to what<br />
extent topical are intellectual projects<br />
of this kind? Are they popular<br />
with Vinnytsia residents?<br />
“Incidentally, I recently came<br />
back from a city, where I saw a splendid<br />
exhibit of celebrity photo portraits<br />
right on the street. I immediately recalled<br />
the Den’s photo exhibit we received<br />
this year. Both adults and children<br />
visited it, and the press and social<br />
media were full of comments. But<br />
it would be a good idea to display this<br />
photo chronicle more widely – in<br />
squares, the river front, and parks. It<br />
is our photo history, and we should<br />
show it to all people – not only to the<br />
conscientious and the interested.<br />
What is more, this exhibit mirrors the<br />
mood of the people of different ages,<br />
occupations, and preferences. It is a<br />
ground of sorts for research and reflections.”<br />
Vinnytsia-born people are holding<br />
key governmental offices now. As<br />
the elections are coming up and spin<br />
masters are on the alert, do you have<br />
any “safety devices” to stabilize the<br />
situation if somebody tries to rock the<br />
boat?<br />
“Frankly speaking, there are<br />
enough provocations even now. There<br />
always are disgruntled people, both on<br />
the central and urban level, who want<br />
to destabilize the moderate climate of<br />
Vinnytsia. But we are repulsing attacks<br />
on all ‘fronts.’ Of course, we<br />
won’t be able to cover all of our backs.<br />
It’s politics! And we are aware that nationwide<br />
events, such as the antismuggling<br />
campaign now underway in<br />
the city on the prime minister’s initiative,<br />
are to be dealt with by our<br />
team. But it is unrealistic to build a<br />
successful Ukraine without overcoming<br />
corruption. Please pay taxes, develop<br />
the economy, create jobs, work<br />
honestly, and nobody will bother you.<br />
The task of Vinnytsia and its residents<br />
is to withstand this political struggle<br />
and further develop.”<br />
Vinnytsia will be marking its<br />
655th anniversary in a few weeks’<br />
time. What do you personally think of<br />
the mood of Vinnytsia residents?<br />
“People are tired of the hybrid war<br />
with Russia which is terrorizing<br />
Ukraine for the fifth consecutive year<br />
and slowing down economic development.<br />
They want reforms to work at<br />
once. But there’s no such thing. Any<br />
kind of development means hard<br />
work. You can take different attitudes<br />
to the leadership, but everything also<br />
depends on people’s actions. We have<br />
a colossal potential and show unfailing<br />
love for the land we live on. We<br />
must work more and speak less. If<br />
everybody works wholeheartedly at<br />
his place, the result will not be slow to<br />
arrive.”
4<br />
No.43 AUGUST 23, 2018<br />
TOPIC OF THE DAY<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
Leonid Kravchuk is now actively working<br />
on a new book. He is going to celebrate<br />
his 85th birthday in early 2019 – a<br />
venerable age indeed. The first President<br />
of Ukraine wants to surprise everybody<br />
with the political details he has never disclosed<br />
before. “I want to show historical and stateformative<br />
stages of Ukrainian political life,”<br />
Mr. Kravchuk says to The Day. “It is very<br />
important that the new generation should have<br />
first-hand information about our recent past,<br />
draw conclusions, and make no mistakes<br />
again.” The work on the publication still<br />
continues, but Mr. Kravchuk has handed over<br />
to The Day, just on the eve of Independence<br />
Day, some extracts from the book about the<br />
decisive events in 1991.<br />
● DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE<br />
We decided on holding the Verkhovna Rada’s<br />
extraordinary meeting on August 25, although<br />
we weren’t sure that any resolution<br />
would be passed. After the August Coup [aka<br />
1991 Soviet coup d’etat attempt. – Ed.], the<br />
situation was changing so quickly, there was<br />
no time to make any coordinated decisions.<br />
We had to act fast and do it the right way.<br />
During a meeting of the VR Presidium, we resolved<br />
to work out a document proclaiming<br />
Ukraine’s national independence, although,<br />
on August 24, no one had a clear idea about it.<br />
We didn’t have a draft ready to submit. There<br />
were several groups of MPs working on it, including<br />
Dmytro Pavlychko, Volodymyr Yavorivsky,<br />
and Levko Lukianenko. The latter<br />
worked on his draft alone, although they all<br />
kept in touch with each group and, partially,<br />
with me. Dmytro Pavlychko cooperated with<br />
me especially actively and fruitfully. Viacheslav<br />
Chornovil was also involved, but kept<br />
his distance. Levko Lukianenko submitted his<br />
draft on August 23, on the eve of the [VR extraordinary]<br />
meeting. I read all the drafts<br />
submitted in Dmytro Pavlychko’s presence<br />
and told him: “I think that Levko Lukianenko’s<br />
draft is short and to the point, compared<br />
to the others. Mr. Pavlychko, please<br />
take it and work on it with Levko Lukianenko,<br />
so we can have a bill.”<br />
Later, after the bill had been submitted,<br />
we had to resolve another issue, namely who<br />
would present it in parliament. Dmytro Pavlychko<br />
suggested Levko Lukianenko, considering<br />
that he was author of the draft. I said I<br />
didn’t mind, but what about the audience,<br />
considering the communists’ attitude to Levko<br />
Lukianenko, that there would be jeers and<br />
catcalls once he took the floor. Dmytro Pavlychko<br />
then suggested Volodymyr Yavorivsky<br />
and I said I didn’t mind, but that we should<br />
consult Levko Lukianenko first; also, we both<br />
knew how the communists would respond to<br />
Volodymyr Yavorivsky, what with his [anti-<br />
Soviet] articles.<br />
In the end, I said: “I’ve talked to the leaders<br />
of all regional groups and chairs of committees,<br />
so I guess I should be the one to present<br />
the bill. They won’t respond to me the way<br />
they would to Lukianenko or Yavorivsky.<br />
Most importantly, I’ll speak as Chairman<br />
[Speaker] of the Verkhovna Rada.”<br />
Meanwhile, the group of MPs led by Communist<br />
Stanislav Hurenko were working on<br />
their draft. It read, in part, that Ukraine<br />
must support the August Coup in Moscow,<br />
thus trying to preserve the Soviet Union. In<br />
fact, he said as much, addressing the Verkhovna<br />
Rada. Let me tell you what happened. I<br />
was at the rostrum when I saw Larysa Skoryk<br />
gesture her desire to take the floor. I gestured<br />
back: Be my guest, but then Stanislav<br />
Hurenko, seeing Larysa Skoryk on her way to<br />
the rostrum, followed suit, so in the end there<br />
were three of us in front of the rostrum: Skoryk,<br />
Hurenko, and yours truly. I stepped back<br />
and let them take their turns addressing the<br />
audience.<br />
On August 24, we were ready to pass the<br />
bill, but we weren’t sure how many MPs would<br />
vote for it – there could be 226 or over<br />
300 yeas. This was especially important for<br />
me; I wanted a constitutional majority vote.<br />
To figure out the situation, I met with the<br />
leaders of regional groups [factions] and then<br />
The way independence was gained<br />
Ukraine’s first President Leonid KRAVCHUK shared<br />
some of the chapters of his future book with The Day<br />
Photo by Ruslan KANIUKA, The Day<br />
“<br />
It was clear that the Declaration of Independence<br />
would be adopted, but there was another issue to be resolved:<br />
would it be legitimate in the context of the<br />
All-Union Referendum of March 17, 1991?<br />
”<br />
realized that the bill would be passed. After<br />
that I acted confidently and put it to the vote.<br />
There is something else, however. Larysa<br />
Skoryk ran over to me before the vote and<br />
said: “We had a meeting and we’re against<br />
this vote because we don’t want the commies<br />
to offer us our independence on a silver platter.”<br />
And then Deputy Speaker Volodymyr<br />
Hryniov echoed her. It transpired that they<br />
had had a meeting on the third floor and made<br />
their decision: decommunization first and independence<br />
second. And then Dmytro Pavlychko<br />
ran over, enraged, shouting he’d shove<br />
it all up their – you know what I mean.<br />
I saw that he was ready to hit the roof, so<br />
I said, “Take it easy, man, we’ll figure it out.”<br />
But he insisted: “Can’t you see what’s happening?<br />
They’re doing everything to screw up<br />
everything!”<br />
Come to think of it, what would happen if<br />
they tried decommunization in August 1991?<br />
Would their bill be passed, considering that<br />
most MPs (370 out of 450) were communists?<br />
As it was, they had another meeting and finally<br />
decided to vote for the independence<br />
bill. In the end, we had 346 yeas, three abstained,<br />
12 “absent,” and only one nay from<br />
Serhii Tsekov (Crimea). Remarkably, Leonid<br />
Kuchma was among those “absent.” The man<br />
would before long become Prime Minister<br />
and then President of Ukraine. When filling<br />
in the first Verkhovna Rada registration<br />
card, he wrote “Russian” in the nationality<br />
column.<br />
Most importantly, Ukraine’s independence<br />
was supported by the parliamentary majority<br />
– and you should see what happened in<br />
the audience after the vote! People were cheering,<br />
singing and dancing...<br />
I think that most communist MPs voted<br />
for independence simply because they were<br />
scared, especially after Boris Yeltsin’s victory<br />
in Moscow. The leadership of the Communist<br />
Party of Ukraine was aware of what was<br />
happening in Kyiv – they were scared they<br />
would be physically assaulted if they didn’t<br />
vote for it.<br />
● REFERENDUM<br />
It was clear that the Declaration of Independence<br />
would be adopted, but there was another<br />
issue to be resolved: would it be legitimate<br />
in the context of the All-Union Referendum<br />
of March 17, 1991? Ukraine had voted for<br />
the preservation of the Soviet Union: 70.2 percent<br />
yeas, although it was the lowest positive<br />
result compared to those in the other [Soviet]<br />
republics. There was no way to cancel its results,<br />
so another referendum was the only alternative.<br />
I addressed the Verkhovna Rada with<br />
the alternative. Some objected that there was<br />
no such law in the republic, that there was only<br />
the law on an all-Union referendum.<br />
Moscow was quick on the uptake and I received<br />
a phone call from one the secretaries of<br />
the Central Committee of the Communist Party<br />
of the Soviet Union. The man said: “I hear that<br />
you’re organizing a referendum, but you have<br />
no legislation for it, so it won’t be legitimate.”<br />
I replied: “We have a revolutionary situation<br />
here and the people want it. Come visit us,<br />
you’ll see what’s happening at the Verkhovna<br />
Rada and in the street. Soviet flags are being replaced<br />
with Ukrainian ones everywhere. It’s a<br />
revolution, do you understand? I must act accordingly.”<br />
I moved to put the referendum on the agenda,<br />
but then our national patriots, led by<br />
Chornovil, stepped in, saying that my initiative<br />
was foolish. They went on to say that Leonid<br />
Kravchuk was a smart alec who wanted a referendum<br />
that was a losing game, instead of rejoicing<br />
in our victory, and that this would surely<br />
make their cause fail. After that I refused to take<br />
the floor and just proposed those who believed in<br />
the vox populi to vote for it. Save for two MPs,<br />
Les Taniuk and Viacheslav Chornovil, all said<br />
yea. Then they [Taniuk and Chornovil. – Ed.]<br />
went to St. Sophia Square and addressed a rally,<br />
saying things [about me] that made my hair<br />
stand on end, but we did it! A republican referendum<br />
was assigned for December 1 that year.<br />
That day, the question “Do You Support the<br />
Declaration of Independence of Ukraine?” was<br />
entered into the secret ballot. The turnout<br />
showed 31,891,742 Ukrainian nationals, or<br />
84.18 percent of the registered voters. A total<br />
of 28,804,071 (90.32 percent) said yea and<br />
7.58 percent said nay.<br />
Hadn’t we made that decision, Ukraine<br />
wouldn’t have been independent now. By the<br />
way, its independence was recognized [internationally]<br />
only after the all-Ukrainian referendum.<br />
Within a month, this recognition was confirmed<br />
by 56 countries, with Poland and Canada<br />
topping the list.<br />
Why did most people support independence?<br />
That period was marked by public unrest, especially<br />
in the Donbas (coal miners would visit the<br />
apartments of ranking apparatchiks, opening<br />
their refrigerators, revealing sausages and other<br />
food and drink [no ordinary citizen could<br />
buy]). Mikhail Gorbachev was said to have engineered<br />
the August Coup, especially after he<br />
started telling tales about finding an old<br />
Grundig radio in the attic and learning about<br />
what was happening in Moscow. Some tales!<br />
People could see what was happening, that the<br />
Soviet Union was falling apart, that Gorbachev<br />
had lost control of the situation, and that independence<br />
was the only option. In fact, I feel sure<br />
that most people in Ukraine shared my view on<br />
the matter at the time. Some might not realize<br />
that the Soviet Union was falling apart, they<br />
wanted more [civil] rights and independence. As<br />
it was, practically all of them voted for it, in<br />
every town and village, even in Sevastopol<br />
57 percent yeas – something few had believed at<br />
the time. That referendum is still legally valid,<br />
and the same is true of the Crimea. The so-called<br />
referendum staged in 2014, at Russia’s gunpoint,<br />
cannot override the results of Ukraine’s<br />
true democratic vox populi of 1991.<br />
Leonid KRAVCHUK, special to The Day
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
TOPIC OF THE DAY No.43 AUGUST 23, 2018 5<br />
By Mariia PROKOPENKO,<br />
photos by Artem SLIPACHUK, The Day<br />
“A<br />
ll my thoughts are now<br />
with Oleh Sentsov, who is<br />
risking his own life for the<br />
sake of all the political<br />
prisoners. We must remember<br />
that freedom is an inalienable<br />
human right, which must be protected by<br />
all possible means and through every<br />
effort. Although Sentsov is in prison, his<br />
ideas are free. And his voice is carried<br />
across all the continents as we pick it up,”<br />
the writer and historian Olena Stiazhkina<br />
said as she read out a letter to Sentsov<br />
sent by the Scottish writer Ian Rankin.<br />
In the afternoon of August 21, activists<br />
brought to the Russian embassy<br />
in Kyiv dozens of letters sent to Sentsov<br />
from around the world. The “Solidarity<br />
with Oleh Sentsov” event became<br />
part of the initiative launched by PEN<br />
International in London (that organization<br />
brings together writers, editors,<br />
and translators from all over the<br />
world and is a powerful human rights<br />
body). The Sentsov letter-writing<br />
marathon began on August 14. Simultaneously<br />
with Kyiv, solidarity events<br />
took place in Sweden, Denmark, the<br />
UK, and the US. Also, Ukraine saw<br />
such events not only in the capital, but<br />
also in Lviv and Vinnytsia.<br />
● “IT IS IMPORTANT THAT<br />
EVERY ONE OF US HEARS<br />
THESE LETTERS AS WELL”<br />
“We received news in recent weeks,<br />
primarily from Sentsov’s lawyer, that<br />
he had stopped receiving letters,” said<br />
Tetiana Teren, executive director of the<br />
Ukrainian PEN, to describe the idea of<br />
the campaign. “The lawyer said that<br />
Sentsov felt himself to be in an information<br />
vacuum and did not know anything<br />
about what was happening in the<br />
world. He had the impression that the<br />
message he wanted to convey to the<br />
world – not about himself, but about all<br />
the political prisoners – had begun to<br />
fade, that the protests had begun to<br />
wind down. Sentsov was very worried<br />
about it. This situation is dangerous,<br />
many political prisoners of the Soviet<br />
era recall that the authorities used the<br />
same technique then, namely to limit a<br />
prisoner’s access to information so that<br />
they find themselves in a psychological<br />
vacuum. We believe that this situation<br />
is not only difficult, but illegal and unfair.<br />
Therefore, this campaign began<br />
first of all as a protest against the fact<br />
that Sentsov did not receive correspondence,<br />
which is his legal right,<br />
recognized all over the world under<br />
international and European law. These<br />
letters have already crossed some<br />
boundaries, probably going beyond<br />
even this campaign as we are now reading<br />
them out. I think it is important<br />
that every one of us, not just Sentsov,<br />
hears these letters as well.”<br />
Letters in various languages were<br />
sent to PEN International’s e-mail<br />
address from all over the world. There<br />
they were translated into Russian in<br />
the last two days, since only letters in<br />
that language may be delivered to the<br />
Labytnangi prison camp where<br />
Sentsov is held.<br />
During the marathon, several hundred<br />
letters were collected. Well-known<br />
people, such as the Nobel Prize winner<br />
Svetlana Alexievich, writer Margaret<br />
Atwood, writer and film director Mike<br />
Leigh also addressed Sentsov, and this<br />
list goes on and on. “Ordinary people<br />
from around the world write to Sentsov<br />
as well,” Teren added. “Often they tell<br />
him something about themselves. Some<br />
letters are touching and poignant, like<br />
one telling about its author living by a<br />
river and describing that river. Someone<br />
wrote that they had seen a sunflower<br />
field. There is a letter from a seven-yearold<br />
girl, and she says she attends such<br />
and such grade, lives in such and such<br />
city, learned about Sentsov from the<br />
news and resolved to write a letter.”<br />
According to Teren, PEN International<br />
will try to do everything in their<br />
power to get the letters to the prisoner.<br />
In particular, they will use the resources<br />
available to his lawyer and human rights<br />
activists.<br />
“I am grateful that you<br />
do not forget me”<br />
August 23 marks the 102nd day of Oleh Sentsov’s hunger strike. Why it is<br />
important to write and read out letters to the “prisoners of the Kremlin”<br />
● GREETINGS FROM SENTSOV<br />
On August 21, a letter from Sentsov,<br />
dated August 14, was posted at<br />
change.org, the website where the petition<br />
calling for saving him and other<br />
“prisoners of the Kremlin” had been<br />
posted.<br />
“Hello everybody! Thank you very<br />
much for the birthday greetings that I received<br />
from various people through the<br />
RosUznik website (the letters’ delivery<br />
was much delayed). Thank you for the<br />
warm words and wishes. I will try to not<br />
let you all down, not surrender and not<br />
die. True, it is likely that out of these<br />
three desires, only a maximum of two<br />
will be fulfilled! :)) Folks, I cannot respond<br />
to everyone, but there is no special<br />
need anyway. Still, I am grateful that<br />
you do not forget me, and support not only<br />
me but all the other Ukrainian political<br />
prisoners in Russia! I wish you all<br />
luck and happiness in this life and in all<br />
the next ones! :)) Yours respectfully, Oleh<br />
Sentsov,” this letter reads.<br />
The petition, published in the first<br />
days of the prisoner’s hunger strike, has<br />
already been signed by almost 203,000<br />
people. Meanwhile, Ambassador of<br />
Ukraine to the US Valerii Chaly used a<br />
press conference held at the Ukrinform<br />
news agency (and dealing with the partnership<br />
between America and Ukraine)<br />
to call on everyone to sign a similar petition<br />
on the White House website<br />
(https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/save-oleg-sentsov).<br />
To receive an<br />
answer from the US administration, we<br />
still need to collect almost 79,000 signatures<br />
out of 100,000 needed by September<br />
8. You can sign a petition in just<br />
a couple of minutes.<br />
● “SUCH EVENTS ARE NOT<br />
ABOUT QUANTITY,<br />
BUT RATHER ABOUT<br />
TAKING A STAND”<br />
The international community has<br />
regularly made appeals in support of<br />
the “prisoners of the Kremlin” (one<br />
made by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs<br />
(MFA) of Lithuania is a recent example).<br />
At the same time, there have<br />
been such weird moves as Vladimir<br />
Putin being invited to the wedding of<br />
the head of Austria’s MFA.<br />
“Putin, besides attending the wedding,<br />
had a meeting with Angela Merkel<br />
[the German Chancellor. – Ed.] later on.<br />
Thus, activists of the Save Oleh Sentsov<br />
group held a picket just before the venue<br />
where it was held... Putin’s motorcade<br />
was greeted by shouts ‘Murderer!’ and<br />
‘Save Oleh Sentsov!’ All these details<br />
make up the complex picture that we are<br />
creating by ourselves,” believes Oleksandra<br />
Matviichuk, who serves as chairperson<br />
of the board at the Center for Civil<br />
Liberties which became a co-organizer<br />
of the solidarity campaign in Kyiv.<br />
She reminded us that the Save Oleg<br />
Sentsov campaign events had been held<br />
in 45 countries, even though nobody initially<br />
expected such broad coverage.<br />
By the way, almost a hundred people<br />
attended the Kyiv event. It is a pretty<br />
good result, considering that it happened<br />
on a weekday, when many people<br />
were at work. Matviichuk emphasized<br />
that other things are important in these<br />
events. “Firstly, it is about simultaneity.<br />
When such events are held simultaneously<br />
in France, Germany, and Ukraine,<br />
it is noticeable. Secondly, it is about regularity.<br />
People think like that: we attended<br />
one time, then another one, but<br />
someone will replace us on the third occasion.<br />
No one will replace you. And this<br />
is an important feature of these events,”<br />
the human rights activist explained.<br />
Support initiatives for the “prisoners<br />
of the Kremlin” are regularly joined<br />
in by Russians. “We have active colleagues<br />
there who hold very risky events<br />
in Kazan, Moscow, St. Petersburg, and<br />
other cities. During the FIFA World<br />
Cup, all protest activities were banned in<br />
Russia, so they staged one-person pickets,<br />
distributed leaflets, and posted Save<br />
Oleh Sentsov banners on bridges,” Matviichuk<br />
added. “I know about a Russian<br />
who has been arrested at least three<br />
times while staging one-person pickets.<br />
She was alone, but her example is very<br />
important. Therefore, this is not about<br />
quantity. This is about taking a stand.”<br />
● “WE MUST BUILD UP<br />
PRESSURE FOR<br />
A POLITICAL SOLUTION”<br />
A week ago the Kremlin in fact rejected<br />
Liudmyla Sentsova’s plea to pardon<br />
her son. According to Hromadske<br />
Television, the Russian President’s Administration<br />
stated that the convict<br />
himself should make this kind of plea.<br />
“No decision has been made yet. It is<br />
not Putin’s rejection, and all of these refusals<br />
comprise a phrase that the final<br />
decision is to be made by the President<br />
of Russia,” Oleksandra Matviichuk says,<br />
describing the Oleh Sentsov situation.<br />
“This means we must build up pressure<br />
for a political solution. For pardon is just<br />
a way to formalize it.”<br />
In Matviichuk’s view, the Ukrainian<br />
leadership must stay in close contact<br />
with the international partners that<br />
can influence the situation with the<br />
Kremlin’s captives and Donbas prisoners<br />
of war.<br />
Human rights activists know about<br />
70 people imprisoned for political motives<br />
in Russia and the occupied Crimea.<br />
Moreover, these activists are aware that<br />
it is just the tip of the iceberg.<br />
“We are not in a position to examine<br />
the materials of all cases in the occupied<br />
Crimea, so relatives do not need to apply<br />
immediately,” Matviichuk notes. “What<br />
matters here is that there is a tendency.<br />
Russia has launched a campaign against<br />
citizens of Ukraine with the aim to set up<br />
the specter of the enemy in Ukrainians.<br />
That’s why they trump up charges of<br />
spying, sabotage, atrocities against<br />
civilians, etc. As for Crimea, we can foresee<br />
an increase of such cases.”<br />
***<br />
“There are dozens of political prisoners<br />
today, and we know that the<br />
regime is trying to stand to the end. To<br />
ask and entreat it is the same as to expect<br />
mercy from the serial killer who derives<br />
sexual gratification from torturing,”<br />
Mykola RIABCHUK, president of the<br />
Ukrainian PEN club, said at a Kyiv<br />
protest rally. “Public opinion is the only<br />
thing that can have an impact. We are<br />
here for this very purpose – to remind<br />
this regime that we remember and expect<br />
political prisoners to be freed, to say this<br />
to our compatriots who vacation in and<br />
make tours of the occupied Crimea and<br />
earn money in Russia, and to remind this<br />
to our Western partners who dance at<br />
wedding parties with representatives of<br />
this regime and think every six months<br />
about whether or not to continue those<br />
feeble sanctions against this regime.<br />
We must behave more firmly, for only<br />
firmness can exert influence. Only the<br />
prospect of a new Nuremberg or Hague<br />
trial can stop them.”<br />
Please write to Oleh Sentsov and other<br />
“Kremlin’s prisoners” via the RosUznik<br />
website: http:/rosuznik.org, or<br />
the FSIN-Pismo system: https://fsinpismo.ru/client/app/letter/create.
6<br />
No.43 AUGUST 23, 2018<br />
NB!<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
Russia after the Sea of Azov<br />
Russian naval vessels deployed<br />
increasingly, bankrupting seaports<br />
REUTERS photo<br />
By Andrii MURAVSKYI<br />
After finishing the construction<br />
of the Crimean/Kerch Bridge,<br />
Russia proceeded with a proxy<br />
blockade of the Sea of Azov and<br />
its ports. The bridge does not<br />
allow large ships to pass through<br />
anymore. According to June 2018<br />
statistics, over 144 container ships<br />
stopped visiting the seaports of Mariupol<br />
and Berdiansk, unable to pass under the<br />
bridge. There are also raids by Russia’s<br />
FSB and Coast Guard gunboats that stop<br />
ships en route to Ukrainian seaports.<br />
For more than three months, Russia’s<br />
Coast Guard ships have been meticulously<br />
inspecting vessels headed for<br />
Azov seaports or on the way back. One<br />
might say that their inspections were too<br />
meticulous, forcing the ships under inspection<br />
to waste dozens of hours, which<br />
costs shipowners large sums.<br />
Andrii KLYMENKO, Chairman of<br />
the Board, Foreign Affair Maidan Foundation,<br />
said: “First, these ships have to<br />
wait for permission to pass under the<br />
Kerch Bridge and reach the Sea of Azov.<br />
All have to wait to let an Azov-Black Sea<br />
convoy pass [for example]. When on the<br />
Sea of Azov, any vessel en route to a seaport<br />
or on the way back can be stopped<br />
[and inspected] by a [Russian] Coast<br />
Guard gunboat.”<br />
Such inspections are taking increasingly<br />
longer periods. According to<br />
Mr. Klymenko, in July, they averaged<br />
from two to four hours, then increased to<br />
almost 33 hours toward the end of the<br />
month. The worst delay on record is<br />
55 hours. It involved 62 8-15-ton vessels<br />
en route to Azov seaports. The cost of<br />
24 hours of delay is 4-5 thousand USD.<br />
This discourages the shipowners and<br />
they can’t blame the consignor. When<br />
their ships are idle en route, they must absorb<br />
the full costs of untimely deliveries.<br />
Russia explained that all this was<br />
part of their security precautions while<br />
conducting naval exercises. They promised<br />
that this would stop before the fall.<br />
There are other explanations, however,<br />
including the possibility that Russia<br />
is doing this in response to Ukraine arresting<br />
the Russian dredger ship Nord<br />
registered in Crimea (March 25). Ukraine<br />
now has only two seaports, Mariupol<br />
and Berdiansk, on the Sea of Azov, and<br />
the Black Sea ports of Odesa,<br />
Chornomorskyi, Yuzhnyi, Ochakivskyi,<br />
and Skadovskyi, including the ones in<br />
Kherson and Mykolaiv which have access<br />
to the Black Sea through channels.<br />
The problem is that moving shipments<br />
from Azov to the Black Sea means<br />
that you’ll have to add a couple of bucks<br />
per ton of cargo, damaging the manufacturer’s<br />
reputation. However, the costly<br />
option is on the agenda. There is also<br />
the Ilyich Metallurgical Complex of Mariupol<br />
[“Ilyich” – from “Vladimir Ilyich<br />
Lenin.” – Ed.], now part of Metinvest<br />
Holding Co. They had to move cast iron<br />
shipments to Black Sea ports.<br />
Logistics actually remain the same,<br />
considering that the shipowners appear<br />
prepared to bear additional costs, without<br />
increasing freight rates, lest they lose<br />
regular customers, in view of the market<br />
competition. Some also see the sanctions<br />
imposed on Russia as temporary.<br />
They believe that the situation may well<br />
change “for the better” this fall. Even so,<br />
there are no guarantees that this “truce”<br />
will last long, just as there is no telling<br />
what Russia will do next. Business requires<br />
stability and each shipowner must<br />
be sure when it’s profitable to take the<br />
next cargo.<br />
Volodymyr OMELIAN, Minister of<br />
Infrastructure of Ukraine, feels sure<br />
that Russia is trying to rock the boat in<br />
the Azov region: “We’re in contact with<br />
our partners, working out measures to<br />
help impose similar sanctions on the<br />
Black Sea ports that are currently under<br />
Russia’s control.”<br />
The Ukrainian Seaport Oversight<br />
Administration is keeping track of all<br />
ships stopped and inspected by Russia,<br />
and relays the data to the Ministry of Infrastructure<br />
and the Ministry of Foreign<br />
Affairs of Ukraine. Official Kyiv has contacted<br />
the OSCE, asking to task the Supervisory<br />
Board with keeping track of<br />
Russia’s wrongdoings on both terra firma<br />
and within Ukraine’s territorial waters.<br />
Costs are being assessed to file<br />
Photo by Alina KOMAROVA<br />
XIX INTERNATIONAL COMPETITION<br />
PHOTO — - 2017<br />
damage claims vs. Russia in international<br />
courts, including damages caused<br />
by the Crimean/Kerch Bridge, considering<br />
its height that bans passage for<br />
larger vessels.<br />
There are certain aspects to Russia’s<br />
Coast Guard gunboats stopping and inspecting<br />
ships. Officials of the State<br />
Border Guard Service of Ukraine say such<br />
inspections are formally possible under<br />
the 2004 Agreement on the Sea of Azov,<br />
considering that the sea is an inland<br />
body of water and that there are no territorial<br />
waters per se. Ukrainian Coast<br />
Guard ships would be within their right<br />
to stop and inspect ships en route to<br />
Russia’s seaports of Azov, Rostov-on-<br />
Don, etc., but they keep their distance,<br />
apparently careful not to aggravate the<br />
situation.<br />
In view of this, the legal status of the<br />
Sea of Azov has to be revised. There is a<br />
bill filed with the Verkhovna Rada, entitled<br />
“On the Denunciation of the Treaty<br />
on Cooperation in the Usage of the Sea of<br />
Azov and Kerch Strait, signed by Ukraine<br />
and the Russian Federation.”<br />
InterLegal’s partner Artur Nitsevych<br />
says ships can’t be stopped and inspected<br />
while in an international strait, that this<br />
is against international law. Kerch Strait<br />
is subject to full freedom of navigation for<br />
civilian ships and warships of Ukraine and<br />
Russia. Foreign warships are allowed entry<br />
only with the knowledge and consent<br />
of the contracting parties. Experts further<br />
recommend that the shipowners keep<br />
their distance from Lotsman-Krym, the<br />
pilot company currently in Russia-annexed<br />
Crimea, formerly a Ukrainian government-run<br />
company, that provides<br />
most piloting services.<br />
Lawsuits will take time, of course.<br />
Meanwhile, efforts should be taken to<br />
upgrade the Ukrainian Navy. Currently,<br />
it is unable to defend Ukraine’s interests<br />
in the Sea of Azov. A time-consuming<br />
process, but time is money and<br />
it is a matter of national security for<br />
Ukraine.<br />
While they were “dancing” in Austria...<br />
Thoughtful Ukrainians are remembering, mourning, and honoring<br />
the memory of the Austrian Archduke Wilhelm von Habsburg (Vasyl Vyshyvany)<br />
By Valentyn TORBA, The Day<br />
Recently, a banner exhibition<br />
dedicated to the Ukrainian<br />
military figure, politician, and<br />
poet Vasyl Vyshyvany was<br />
opened on the second floor of<br />
the Lviv Regional State Administration<br />
building. “This exhibition is evidence<br />
that we remember Vasyl Vyshyvany,<br />
who was tortured to death by the Soviet<br />
regime. This individual has entered the<br />
history of our people for good.<br />
Being the son of an Italian<br />
duchess and an Austrian admiral,<br />
he consciously chose Ukraine and<br />
the Ukrainian identity for<br />
himself, and sacrificed his youth,<br />
titles, and connections in the<br />
aristocratic circles of Europe for<br />
the sake of Ukraine. As an<br />
independent nation, we owe a lot<br />
to this patriot,” public figure<br />
Marko Simkin said at the opening<br />
of the exhibition.<br />
It was 1948. Wilhelm Franz<br />
von Habsburg-Lothringen, who<br />
was a Ukrainian military figure,<br />
a politician, a poet, an<br />
Austrian archduke of the Habsburg<br />
dynasty, and a colonel of<br />
the Legion of the Ukrainian Sich<br />
Riflemen, died in Lukianivska<br />
Prison, it was said “under unknown<br />
circumstances.” These titles<br />
of his are not important for<br />
every Ukrainian. Some of us<br />
have a quite superficial view of<br />
them. However, the very names<br />
of such “political romantics” as<br />
Vyshyvany are already TITLES<br />
that future generations should<br />
aspire to emulate.<br />
He was born on February 10, 1895,<br />
near the city of Pula in Dalmatia, in the<br />
family estate of his father Archduke<br />
Charles Stephen Habsburg. It was this<br />
branch of the House of Habsburg-Lorraine<br />
that gave the world several Austrian<br />
kings and emperors, including<br />
Franz Josef, who was Wilhelm’s uncle<br />
twice removed. At different times, the<br />
Habsburgs ruled Germany, the Netherlands,<br />
Spain, Bohemia, and Hungary.<br />
No pompous events are held to<br />
honor him now. They do not rename<br />
streets after him or observe anniversaries<br />
of his life events. And it is a<br />
shame... It reflects badly on today’s<br />
power holders and public figures. It<br />
must be remembered that he was a<br />
scion of the ancient European dynasties,<br />
the Habsburgs and the Lorraines.<br />
And he was the only one to come to defend<br />
the Ukrainian idea while having<br />
such exalted ancestry. They often talk<br />
about Europeanness and the European<br />
course nowadays. In our case, there is<br />
plenty of evidence that Ukraine in Europe<br />
is not just a geographical concept.<br />
This concept is mental and historical<br />
too.<br />
Unfortunately, Vyshyvany’s last<br />
abode remains unknown to this day.<br />
The most cynical and revealing fact is<br />
that Vladimir Putin came to Austria,<br />
the country where Vyshyvany was<br />
born, to attend the wedding of that nation’s<br />
head of the Ministry of Foreign<br />
Affairs precisely in recent days. It<br />
seems that Europe was not only silent,<br />
as Oleksandr Oles put it once... It has<br />
also forgotten. It has forgotten the<br />
bitter lessons of what imperialism is.<br />
Den/The Day newspaper has repeatedly<br />
told the story of this historical<br />
figure in our excursions into “forgotten<br />
matters.”<br />
As Larysa Ivshyna, the editor-inchief<br />
of this newspaper, stressed,<br />
“just as thoughtful Ukrainians are remembering,<br />
mourning, and honoring<br />
the memory of the Austrian Archduke<br />
Wilhelm von Habsburg (Vasyl Vyshyvany),<br />
who was killed in an NKVD torture<br />
chamber, his homeland, namely<br />
the glorious city of Vienna, sees a minister<br />
dancing with a man continuing<br />
the “traditions” of that ominous system.<br />
What has happened to you, Austria?”<br />
● “IT WAS A TRAGIC<br />
MILESTONE FOR UKRAINE”<br />
Tetiana OSTASHKO, Candidate<br />
of Historical Sciences:<br />
“I believe we need to do more to<br />
commemorate the figure of Vasyl<br />
Vyshyvany and, in particular, to observe<br />
the tragic anniversary of his<br />
death. He became a Ukrainian and actively<br />
joined the Ukrainian movement.<br />
In our time, some politicians and<br />
journalists have taken the liberty<br />
of not noticing this fact,<br />
which significantly simplifies<br />
and primitivizes the meaning of<br />
the Ukrainian national liberation<br />
movement. Vyshyvany was<br />
abducted in the British zone of<br />
Vienna and taken to the USSR,<br />
where he eventually died in<br />
Lukianivska Prison. It was a<br />
tragic milestone for Ukraine.<br />
And the fact that this anniversary<br />
came to coincide with what<br />
was effectively a celebration of<br />
Putin in Austria is for us a<br />
straightforward hint that we<br />
have to care about our own fate<br />
better. To count on someone’s<br />
support is not worth it. We must<br />
be strong, we must know our<br />
history well. As for Putin’s arrival<br />
in Austria, it can only be<br />
seen as a shameful occasion for<br />
that European country. I believe<br />
that we must study the historical<br />
aspects of our relations with<br />
European countries in a most<br />
thorough manner. They have always<br />
thought of their interests first.<br />
And if we do not articulate our position,<br />
then others will do it for us and<br />
distort our history in the process.<br />
For this very reason, such historical<br />
figures as Vyshyvany offer telling<br />
and inspirational examples for us as<br />
we are shaping our national and state<br />
positions. All these stories improve<br />
our standing, including in the international<br />
arena, where we must become<br />
a compelling presence. When<br />
we do not know it or ignore this<br />
knowledge, the enemy is the only one<br />
to benefit by exploiting our gaps in<br />
historical memory. Nor should we<br />
forget that this is not just about Russia.<br />
Poland has also played a major<br />
role in exerting political and ideological<br />
pressure on Ukraine. Therefore,<br />
I repeat: we need to shape our own<br />
historical position.”
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
CULT URE No.43 AUGUST 23, 2018 7<br />
By Dmytro DESIATERYK, The Day,<br />
Odesa – Kyiv<br />
The appointment of a new<br />
director of the Odesa Art<br />
Museum was one of the biggest<br />
artistic scandals this year. As is<br />
well known, a competitive<br />
selection was held for the position,<br />
and the famous Odesa-born artist<br />
Oleksandr Roitburd won it by one<br />
vote last December. His rivals were<br />
former director of the museum Vitalii<br />
Abramov and his deputy Serhii<br />
Siedykh.<br />
Nobody has challenged the result’s<br />
fairness. However, some murky<br />
machinations started as the date of the<br />
final approval came closer. At first,<br />
the culture commission of the Odesa<br />
Regional Council came forward to oppose<br />
the appointment. In parallel, a<br />
negative public relations campaign<br />
against Roitburd as an individual<br />
was launched in the media and on the<br />
Internet. They attributed to the artist<br />
other people’s paintings and brought<br />
in unknown experts to confirm it. It<br />
ultimately resulted in a failed vote in<br />
the regional council. Leaders of the<br />
notorious Opposition Bloc, in particular,<br />
the famous supporter of the<br />
“Russian World” Vitalii Sautionkov,<br />
were most active in the fight against<br />
the appointment, having marched a<br />
loyal crowd to a location outside the<br />
council building. Their arguments<br />
were worthy of the Soviet era, as the<br />
would-be director was being accused<br />
of creating immoral paintings.<br />
At the same time, around 50 cultural<br />
figures, journalists, and leading<br />
museum workers signed letters in<br />
support of the artist. Eventually,<br />
everything ended with a victory of<br />
common sense: head of the Odesa Regional<br />
State Administration Maksym<br />
Stepanov appointed Roitburd as the<br />
director of the museum. The contract<br />
is valid for five years.<br />
The Odesa Art Museum is located<br />
in the center of the city, housed in the<br />
Potocki Palace, a monument of the<br />
early 19th century architecture (it was<br />
built in 1827). It was opened on November<br />
6, 1899 through the efforts of<br />
the Odesa Society of Fine Arts. The<br />
museum collection’s first items were<br />
paintings donated by Petersburg<br />
Academy of Arts. Currently, the museum’s<br />
exposition occupies 26 rooms.<br />
The collection includes works by foreign<br />
and Ukrainian artists, such as<br />
Valentin Serov, Mikhail Vrubel,<br />
Nicholas Roerich, Boris Kustodiev,<br />
Alexandre Benois, Konstantin Somov,<br />
Wassily Kandinsky, as well as<br />
Volodymyr Borovykovsky, Amvrosii<br />
Zhdakha, Kostiantyn Trutovsky,<br />
Mykola Pymonenko, Serhii Vasylkivsky,<br />
Oleksandr Murashko, Petro<br />
Levchenko, Maria Prymachenko,<br />
Mykhailo Derehus, Adalbert Erdeli,<br />
Fedir Manailo, Yosyp Bokshai, Andrii<br />
Kotska, and Taras Shevchenko.<br />
We talked to Roitburd in a public<br />
garden in front of the museum’s facade.<br />
I will ask it frankly and at once:<br />
what led you to take this unenviable<br />
job?<br />
“I had volunteers who supported<br />
the museum – some of them are now<br />
part of our team – visiting me and asking<br />
to persuade some people in Odesa<br />
or Kyiv to occupy this position. Meanwhile,<br />
a power crisis was continuing<br />
at the museum. It was unclear if the<br />
then director, Abramov, would be<br />
able to continue to carry out his duties,<br />
no constructive candidates could<br />
be found, and it ended with no one getting<br />
persuaded, so I decided to go for<br />
it myself. Another motive was that I<br />
realized that I had no right to criticize<br />
Odesa if I myself rejected an opportunity<br />
to change the situation in a certain<br />
area at least and get a serious<br />
project working that would improve<br />
both the image and the life of the<br />
city.”<br />
What is your personal history<br />
with the museum?<br />
“I have known it from childhood.<br />
Even back then, I was capable of holding<br />
an imagined tour of it with my<br />
eyes closed at home and could say<br />
where which picture hung. However,<br />
“Ever since my childhood, I have been<br />
capable of holding a tour of the<br />
exposition with my eyes closed...”<br />
The newly appointed director of the Odesa Art Museum<br />
Oleksandr Roitburd spoke of poverty, intrigues, and hopes<br />
this is absolutely destructive. The<br />
future belongs to countries with a<br />
vision of that future, with a rational<br />
economic concept of development and<br />
a progressive cultural policy. Moreover,<br />
the latter includes not only art,<br />
but also the positioning of the country<br />
in the world, education, health care,<br />
etc. For now, however, we have not yet<br />
cut the umbilical cord linking us to the<br />
Soviet system, nor even finally cut one<br />
linking us to Russia.”<br />
As to the past: in what condition<br />
did you find the museum?<br />
“First of all, I found a labor conflict<br />
there. Most employees feared<br />
the arrival of a new leadership.”<br />
So, how did they react to you?<br />
“I expected this least of all, but<br />
these grannies and veterans of the museum<br />
became my supporters. I have a<br />
very friendly relationship with the<br />
chief custodian of the collection, who<br />
has miraculously preserved it intact.<br />
She has worked in the museum for<br />
50 years, and there have been no losswhen<br />
I came there again at an older<br />
age, I did not really like the fact that<br />
some items hung in the same locations<br />
for 40 years. And in some places, the<br />
exposition was even worse than it<br />
had been in the Soviet days. The impression<br />
was that life was over and it<br />
seemed to be a cemetery. It was so although<br />
the museum can become not<br />
only a center, but even a flagship of<br />
cultural modernization, which<br />
Ukraine direly needs. Determining<br />
after three or four centuries who was<br />
right and who was wrong, what was a<br />
betrayal and what was a victory –<br />
es on her watch. Also, all of them have<br />
the understanding that something<br />
needs to be changed.”<br />
What should be changed?<br />
“The main problem is the limited<br />
resources. I have just fantasized with<br />
architects how to increase the exhibition<br />
spaces. This is extremely important.<br />
If the museum expands threefold,<br />
it will become 30 times more interesting.<br />
We have many art periods<br />
concealed in storerooms, and nobody<br />
sees them.”<br />
Continued on page 8 ➤<br />
THE ODESA ART MUSEUM IS LOCATED IN THE CENTER OF THE CITY, HOUSED IN THE POTOCKI PALACE, A MONUMENT<br />
OF THE EARLY 19th CENTURY ARCHITECTURE (BUILT IN 1827). IT WAS OPENED ON NOVEMBER 6, 1899 THROUGH THE<br />
EFFORTS OF THE ODESA SOCIETY OF FINE ARTS<br />
By Vadym RYZHKOV, The Day,<br />
Dnipro,<br />
Olha KHARCHENKO, The Day<br />
Book Space<br />
festival<br />
Den to launch its new<br />
book AVE in Lviv and<br />
Dnipro. Make<br />
reservations before<br />
it’s too late!<br />
DNIPRO – Book Space is the<br />
name of a new international book<br />
festival that will take place here,<br />
September 28-30.<br />
Says Viktoria NARIZHNA,<br />
art director of the festival: “We<br />
titled it Book Space because<br />
‘space’ is a slightly ironical re f-<br />
e rence to Dnipro [former Dnipro -<br />
petrovsk. – Ed.] as Ukraine’s<br />
space and rocket/missile develop -<br />
ment center [under the Soviets],<br />
currently a progressive innova -<br />
ting city.”<br />
The festival will be held within<br />
the framework of Mayor Borys<br />
Filatov’s Project Cultural Capital,<br />
also with support from Valentyn<br />
Riznychenko, head of the<br />
Regional State Admini stra tion<br />
(RSA), and with Den/The Day as<br />
the festival’s general information<br />
partner.<br />
There will be a large scale<br />
book fair involving over 50 Uk -<br />
rai nian and foreign publishing<br />
companies, meetings with dome -<br />
s tic and foreign authors, laun ches<br />
of new publications, wri ters’<br />
read ing soirees, concerts, etc.<br />
The book fair will be located in<br />
downtown Dnipro, on the square<br />
facing the RSA building, with<br />
space rockets on display, along<br />
with the Children’s Lite rature<br />
Pavilion in the Heroes Alley,<br />
near the Children’s R&R Park.<br />
Book Space envisages programs<br />
to be carried out simultaneously<br />
on several sites, including five on<br />
the RSA premi ses, a Poetry Cafe,<br />
Children’s Stage and Music Stage<br />
in the Ukrainian Art Museum’s<br />
garden, and a small town called<br />
Space Hub. These programs will<br />
include the central one, known as<br />
“Transformations” and others<br />
meant for children, history, edu<br />
cation, and music. The latter<br />
will be a jazz event, with a concert<br />
marking the end of each day<br />
of the festival, involving several<br />
rock bands, including DZ’OB,<br />
Quarpa, and Mariana Savka’s<br />
“In the Orchard.”<br />
Dnipro is expected to play<br />
host to a total of 6,500 guests and<br />
festival participants, among them<br />
over 30 Ukrainian and foreign authors.<br />
Serhii Plokhii (USA), Martin<br />
Schaeuble (Ger many), Andre<br />
Roche (France), Jacek Dehnel<br />
(Poland), Glenn Ringtved (Denmark),<br />
Ulrike Almut Sandig (Germany),<br />
Maria Galina (Ukrai ne/<br />
Russia), Arka dy Shtypel (Ukrai-<br />
ne/Russia), Oksana Zabuzhko,<br />
Irena Karpa, Irene Rozdobudko,<br />
Yurii Maka rov, Mariana Savka,<br />
Yan Valie tov, Andrii Bondar,<br />
Ruslan Ho ro vyi, Hryhorii Semenchuk,<br />
Halyna Kruk, Svitlana<br />
Pova liaie va, Andrey Orlov (Orlusha),<br />
etc., have confirmed their<br />
parti ci pa tion.<br />
Serhii Plokhii is a Ukrainian<br />
American historian and author<br />
specializing in the history of<br />
Ukraine, Eastern Europe and<br />
Cold War. He is a professor of<br />
Ukrainian history at Harvard<br />
University where he also serves<br />
as the director of the Harvard<br />
Ukrainian Research Institute,<br />
and winner of the Taras Shev -<br />
chenko Prize (2018). During the<br />
festival, he is expected to take<br />
part in a public discussion with<br />
Yurii Makarov, journalist and<br />
writer, based on Mr. Plokhii’s<br />
books Tsars and Cos sacks: A<br />
Study in Icono gra phy; Chernobyl:<br />
History of a Tragedy; The Last<br />
Empire: The Final Days of the Soviet<br />
Union, etc. There will be<br />
launches of the books How the<br />
Cossacks Defen ded Ukraine (with<br />
historian Yurii Mytsyk) and National<br />
Communism in Soviet<br />
Ukraine (with Oksana Zabuzhko).<br />
Marci Shore, US historian and<br />
scholar, wife of Yale history professor<br />
Timothy Snyder, is expected<br />
to present a Ukrainian<br />
version of her book The Ukrainian<br />
Night: An Intimate History of<br />
Revo lu tion (re Maidan).<br />
History will be on top of the<br />
Book Space agenda in Dnipro.<br />
There will be launched Den’s new<br />
book AVE commemorating Hetman<br />
Skoropadsky’s centennial<br />
of birth and having a lot to do<br />
with Ukraine’s future. Initiated<br />
by Editor-in-Chief Larysa Ivshyna,<br />
this book includes articles<br />
writ ten by professional historians<br />
and journalists, and is likely<br />
to attract interest and cause debate,<br />
considering that its aim is<br />
both to learn more about the Skoro<br />
pad sky epoch (still a gap in<br />
Ukrai nian history [apart from<br />
Soviet propaganda stuff]) and<br />
clarify the kind of politics<br />
Ukrainian society has been practicing,<br />
will practice, and why.<br />
This book will premiere at<br />
the traditional Publishers’ Forum<br />
in Lviv (September 21,<br />
12:00, Hall of Mirrors, Potocki<br />
Palace). The Editors will inform<br />
you about the date and time of its<br />
launch in Dnipro.<br />
➤ IMPORTANT: Bonus orders<br />
for AVE will expire on Septem<br />
ber 1. You can still order a<br />
copy for only 170 hryvnias on<br />
https:// day.kyiv.ua/uk/library/books/ave-do-100-littyagetma<br />
natu-pavla-skoropa ds -<br />
kogo, or by calling the edito rial<br />
office ((044) 303 96 23).
8<br />
No.43 AUGUST 23, 2018<br />
“Ever since my childhood, I have been<br />
capable of holding a tour of the<br />
exposition with my eyes closed...”<br />
Continued from page 7 ➤<br />
Have you managed to locate some<br />
special treasures?<br />
“There are so many first-class<br />
paintings in the storerooms that the<br />
very idea of the level of this collection<br />
can change dramatically. There are<br />
dozens of landowners’ portraits taken<br />
from their estates, naive city portraits,<br />
many great paintings by Russian<br />
Academic style painters, which<br />
are not known even in Russia itself. For<br />
example, a meter-long picture by Ilya<br />
Repin which we have pulled out of the<br />
storeroom, and nobody knew that Repin<br />
had painted one. Or Vasily Perov’s<br />
A Shepherd Boy, which has uncharacteristic<br />
features for a work of his.<br />
Under the influence of the Peredvizhniki,<br />
he depicted hard life of the masses,<br />
but here we see such an idyll: an Italian<br />
boy sits amid southern plants under<br />
the blue sky, he is clean and happy,<br />
playing a flute, wearing a European<br />
dress – it is all absolutely atypical. It<br />
lay in the storerooms, and nobody<br />
knew about it. And how many works of<br />
the Mir Iskusstva Art Association we<br />
have! Experts are just exhilarated<br />
when they learn the number.”<br />
What prevents you from exhibiting<br />
it all?<br />
“We lack space. We cannot adequately<br />
display Socialist Realism<br />
works – while monstrous, this style has<br />
already become interesting – or fully<br />
present our collection of Soviet underground,<br />
also known as the ‘severe<br />
style,’ which we also have in storage.<br />
We cannot start collecting contemporary<br />
art, because there is no room for<br />
it. We cannot turn the museum into a<br />
true cultural hub, because there is no<br />
place suitable for a lecturer. We need<br />
to do major repairs, because I have seen<br />
a map where five large cracks, both<br />
horizontal and vertical, are visible in<br />
the building. After all, it was built<br />
from coquina in 1827. Since then, it<br />
has not been repaired other than cosmetically.<br />
We fear that beams between<br />
floors will not hold human masses.<br />
Just outside exhibition rooms, we<br />
have a fire reservoir, which is decommissioned,<br />
defunct, but still full of water,<br />
and it brings excessive humidity to<br />
three rooms and our holdings. And at<br />
the back of the museum, there is a wild<br />
thicket, full of homeless, drug addicts<br />
who leave drug caches there, and broken<br />
glass that makes it impassable.<br />
Still, we have been unable to reach the<br />
city’s leadership and ask them to donate<br />
this plot to us for expansion, because<br />
it belonged to the museum back<br />
in the 1970s, but was then transferred<br />
to the city’s ownership to save on janitors’<br />
salaries.”<br />
It seems to be an insurmountable<br />
mountain of problems... What have<br />
you achieved in such circumstances?<br />
“Firstly, we have increased the<br />
attendance level of the museum manyfold.<br />
Secondly, we have done a partial<br />
rotation of the exposition. Also, we<br />
have been demanding that bureaucratic<br />
bodies compile design and estimate<br />
for the repair of historic lights,<br />
but still have not received the final approval<br />
to begin repairs.”<br />
And what has prevented the major<br />
repairs from being started?<br />
“The government had allocated<br />
money for it once, but the firm that had<br />
got it went bankrupt, its owner is now<br />
on the wanted list, the remainder has<br />
been redistributed to other places, and<br />
no more funding is provided, because<br />
it has already been provided.”<br />
Everyone remembers in what atmosphere<br />
the decision about your appointment<br />
was made. Do you encounter<br />
direct resistance?<br />
“They oppose us through bureaucratic<br />
bodies, which do not sign anything<br />
if they can help it. This is the passive<br />
option. As for the active one,<br />
those councilors who staged scandals<br />
back during my appointment hearings<br />
are still attacking me. Their, so to<br />
speak, leader Vitalii Sautionkov dominates<br />
these efforts.”<br />
Do you have a specific strategy<br />
aimed at overcoming all this?<br />
“No strategy can be formulated,<br />
because it changes on the move, depending<br />
on where the next pitfall appears,<br />
and where we get new allies or<br />
opponents at the given moment. Sometimes<br />
it looks almost like guerrilla<br />
warfare.”<br />
Where do you find strength for it?<br />
“If there is a stimulus, then I am interested<br />
in working. The most valuable<br />
part of this job for me is being a visionary.”<br />
Do you find time to create paintings<br />
of your own?<br />
“I do. However, they accused me of<br />
replacing paintings from the museum<br />
with fakes (while keeping a completely<br />
impassive face). I am now actively<br />
engaged in this, I am making a new series<br />
to replace the museum paintings.<br />
This morning, I had time to finish<br />
one, I will add some yellow color, take<br />
a picture and post it on Facebook.<br />
Yesterday, I replaced the portrait of<br />
Serov with the portrait of Savva Mamontov<br />
painted by Serov, and today I<br />
will replace a painting by Nikolai Ge,<br />
which is quite natural. And as they<br />
have already said, I will then sell all the<br />
originals to Maryna Poroshenko or<br />
the banker Vadym Morokhovskyi –<br />
these are two competing versions.”<br />
Finally, I should ask you about<br />
hope. Where is hope for you and the<br />
museum?<br />
“I hope that instead of an archaic<br />
Soviet institution, we will build a modern<br />
museum, which will change the perception<br />
of Odesa as well as what a museum<br />
is in Ukraine. After all, the potential<br />
of such an institution as a museum<br />
is enormous. It is just that people<br />
do not understand it in this country.”<br />
■ THE DAY’S REFERENCE<br />
Oleksandr Roitburd (born in<br />
Odesa in 1961) is a Ukrainian artist.<br />
He graduated from the art and<br />
graphics faculty of Odesa Pedagogical<br />
Institute in 1983. Since 1993, the<br />
painter has been a founding member<br />
of the Nove Mystetstvo Association<br />
(Odesa). In 1993-99, he served as art<br />
director and in 1999-2001 as president<br />
of this association. In 1997-99,<br />
Roitburd served as chairman of the<br />
board at the Soros Center for Contemporary<br />
Art (Odesa), in 2001-02 –<br />
as regional coordinator of the Cultural<br />
Heroes Festival (Odesa), while<br />
in 2002, he served as director of the<br />
Gelman Gallery in Kyiv. The artist<br />
has taken part in over 100 exhibitions<br />
and art projects.<br />
By Dmytro DESIATERYK,<br />
The Day, Odesa – Kyiv<br />
TIMEO U T<br />
By Dmytro PLAKHTA, The Day, Lviv<br />
Photos courtesy of Marianna DUSHAR<br />
Tasting Galician dishes, you are<br />
sure to feel not only an original<br />
blend of local foodstuffs’ flavors,<br />
but also the touch of other cultures.<br />
It is easy to trace the Italian<br />
motif in Leopolitan lazanki (a type of<br />
pasta). You can’t help feeling influence<br />
of Jewish traditions in the vorschmack<br />
(a dish made of salty minced fish or<br />
meat). And the nutritious parzyborda<br />
(savoy cabbage soup) is an aromatic<br />
repercussion of the culture of Lvivbased<br />
Armenians.<br />
The phenomenon of Galician cuisine<br />
is being actively studied now. Particularly,<br />
it is Marianna DUSHAR, a<br />
Leopolitan researcher of Galician cuisine,<br />
who has achieved great successes<br />
in this historical-culinary field. But it<br />
would be fairer to speak about the legendary<br />
Ms. Stefa who is always glad to<br />
give advice to Galician housewives.<br />
Marianna created this image of a Galician<br />
woman for her blog, combining in<br />
Ms. Stefa the images of her grandmothers<br />
who cooked superbly and handed<br />
down the love for cooking to their<br />
granddaughter. In her blog panistefa.com<br />
and on her Facebook page,<br />
Dushar gathers old local recipes.<br />
Ms. Stefa, as an idea and a figure, is<br />
more than 10 years old. In this time<br />
span, she has shared hundreds of<br />
recipes of Galician dishes and still continues<br />
to popularize local cuisine.<br />
Ms. Stefa is the best-known Galician<br />
housewife. Dushar herself notes<br />
that she is neither a culinary blogger<br />
nor a cook but, first of all, a researcher,<br />
the blog and cooking being just separate<br />
aspects of studying Galician cuisine.<br />
“I am trying to read as much as possible,<br />
look for old recipes and just information<br />
on this matter,” Dushar<br />
says. “I don’t post everything in the<br />
blog because not all of this will be of interest<br />
to the reader. I’ve noticed that<br />
once you write a bit more serious piece<br />
of culinary research, there will be fewer<br />
comments. A long mind-bending<br />
text is often not interesting to the average<br />
reader. They are interested in a<br />
recipe that can be used at home. But<br />
some, on the contrary, find it interesting<br />
to dig deeper and read about the<br />
history of a dish. So, I am trying to post<br />
from time to time various culinary-historical<br />
essays in my blog.”<br />
Den/The Day decided to “dig deeper”<br />
not only into the history of Galician<br />
cuisine, but also into the very essence<br />
of cuisine as a thing that can knit people<br />
together. Marianna Dushar helped<br />
us do so, and our “tasty” talk lasted for<br />
several interesting hours.<br />
● “GALICIAN CUISINE IS<br />
A MUTUAL PENETRATION,<br />
DIFFUSION OF DIFFERENT<br />
CULTURES”<br />
“Above all, you should know the<br />
conditions in which Galician cuisine was<br />
formed. It is rather simple and complex<br />
at the same time, for Galicia had always<br />
been in interesting political situations.<br />
It was always at the intersection of trade<br />
roads. This is especially true of Lviv.<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
“Foodisalittleuniversalanchor<br />
and a way of identification”<br />
A “tasty” story of Ms. Stefa’s Galician cuisine<br />
“Galician cuisine is a mutual penetration,<br />
a diffusion of different cultures.<br />
The Galician, particularly Leopolitan,<br />
traditions formed under the influence<br />
of the ethnoses that populated the<br />
region and current circumstances. It is<br />
interesting to see today the way Galicia<br />
was building ‘culinary bridges’ with<br />
the Greeks, Poles, Armenians, Italians,<br />
Germans, Austrians, Frenchmen, et al.”<br />
● LAYING “GASTRONOMIC<br />
BRIDGES”<br />
“For example, there was quite a<br />
large Greek community in Lviv. The<br />
name of the Greek Konstanty Korniakt<br />
added a glorious page to the city’s history.<br />
The influence of him and other<br />
Greeks on the history of Lviv is indisputable.<br />
“‘The Greeks came and brought<br />
lemons’ is the example researcher of<br />
Leopolitan cuisine Ihor Lilio often<br />
cites. Lemons were not characteristic<br />
for Galicia, but Greeks brought this<br />
fruit here. An expensive item, it was<br />
consumed by a certain stratum of the<br />
population. Then it served as a basis of<br />
some dishes.<br />
“The gastronomic tastes of city<br />
dwellers were by no means banal at<br />
that time. Take, for example, the lemon<br />
soup. It was cooked in thick veal brine,<br />
with rice, lemon juice, and all this was<br />
eventually seasoned with a sour cream<br />
and yolk dressing. You can find this<br />
soup in old cookbooks that date back to<br />
the late 19th century. But what does this<br />
record mean? It means that lemons and<br />
rice were in common use. But, most interestingly,<br />
Greek national cuisine includes<br />
the soup ‘avgolemono’ which is<br />
99 percent identical with our lemon<br />
soup. The only difference is that we cook<br />
it with veal, while they use poultry.<br />
“There are stories of this kind for<br />
many foodstuffs and dishes. It is very<br />
interesting to find out how these ‘gastronomic<br />
bridges’ were laid. Sometimes<br />
it is facts which we can prove on<br />
the basis of archival or anecdotal evidence,<br />
and sometimes it is a ‘plausible<br />
assumption.’ Anyway, it is always a<br />
very interesting entertainment.”<br />
● ON URBAN AND RURAL<br />
GALICIAN CUISINE<br />
“Galician cuisine is quite clearly divided<br />
into urban and rural.<br />
“Urban cuisine – more ingenious and<br />
rich – was based on what could be<br />
bought. The abovementioned cultural exchange<br />
is particularly apparent in urban<br />
cooking. For example, if some Germans<br />
or Italians came to build roads, they surely<br />
brought something of their own. Or if<br />
the city hall organizes a ball in honor of<br />
a foreign ambassador, they use some ‘insider<br />
info’ about what he may like – it is<br />
an impetus, progress, isn’t it?<br />
“And Leopolitan lazanka and Italian<br />
lasagna? This is a story with a clearly noticeable<br />
Italian flavor. It is widely believed<br />
that it all began with Bona Sforza,<br />
the daughter of a Milanese duke, who<br />
married King Sigismund I the Old of<br />
Poland in 1518. She brought in not only<br />
a large retinue, including cooks, but<br />
also some hitherto unknown foodstuffs<br />
and dishes. It is the new vegetables,<br />
fruits, and herbs brought from Bona’s<br />
homeland that caused many interesting<br />
dishes to appear in our country.<br />
“I say half-jokingly that all this cultural<br />
exchange is still going on – only<br />
methods have changed. For example,<br />
Parmesan, which is mentioned in old<br />
recipes, is still being brought here, as it<br />
was before. As housewives once borrowed<br />
and ‘Galicianized’ recipes, so they<br />
are still doing so. And while trade in delicacies<br />
used to seethe on Market Place,<br />
now the same and other delicacies are sold<br />
in such shops as ‘Goods from Italy.’<br />
Read more on our website<br />
UKRAINIAN NEWS IN ENGLISH<br />
www.day.kiev.ua incognita.day.kiev.ua<br />
FOUNDER AND PUBLISHER:<br />
UKRAINIAN PRESS GROUP LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY<br />
Published since May 27, 1998.<br />
Свiдоцтво про перереєстрацiю КВ № 21448-11248 ПР<br />
вiд 27 липня 2015 року<br />
Larysa Ivshyna, Editor-in-Chief, Den<br />
e-mail: chedit@day.kiev.ua<br />
Hanna Sheremet, Deputy Editor-in-Chief<br />
Anna Mazurenko, Director,<br />
Ukrainian Press Group LLC<br />
Oksana Sabodash, Editor,<br />
English Language Bureau<br />
Olha Pavliei, Technical Editor<br />
Borys Honcharov, George Skliar, Taras Shulha,<br />
Nadia Sysiuk, Translators<br />
Maryna Khyzhniakova, Proofreader<br />
Marharyta Motoziuk, Designer<br />
Alla Bober, Responsible Secretary<br />
Mykola Tymchenko, Photography Editor<br />
Mailing address: prosp. Peremohy, 121d, Kyiv 03115, Ukraine<br />
Telephone: +38(044) 303-96-19<br />
Fax: +38(044) 303-94-20<br />
Advertising: +38(044) 303-96-20; e-mail: ra@day.kiev.ua<br />
Subscriptions: +38(044) 303-96-23; e-mail: amir@day.kiev.ua<br />
E-mail: time@day.kiev.ua<br />
Subscription index: 40032<br />
Ukrainian Press Group LLC<br />
Code 24249388<br />
Raiffeisen Bank joint-stock company<br />
MFO 380805<br />
A/С 26007478064<br />
Responsibility for the accuracy of facts, quotations, personal names, and other information is borne by the authors of publications and in advertising<br />
materials by the advertiser. The views expressed in signed articles do not necessarily reflect those of the editors. Submitted materials are not returned<br />
and not reviewed. The editors retain the right to edit materials. When citing Day materials, reference to The Day is mandatory. ©Den.