You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
JUNE 21, 2018 ISSUE No. 39 (1171)<br />
Tel.: +38(044) 303-96-19,<br />
fax: +38(044) 303-94-20<br />
е-mail: time@day.kiev.ua;<br />
http://www.day.kiev.ua<br />
By Ivan KAPSAMUN, The Day<br />
While the world is watching the World<br />
Cup in Russia, Ukrainian political<br />
prisoners are still on a hunger strike<br />
in its brutal prisons. The New York<br />
Times wrote in a recent editorial that<br />
the Ukrainian film director Oleh Sentsov deserved<br />
the full support of the international community.<br />
“In the midst of hosting the World Cup<br />
soccer extravaganza, the last thing Vladimir<br />
Putin wants to be reminded of is human rights,<br />
Crimea or Ukraine. That is a good reason to raise<br />
the case of Oleh Sentsov, a Ukrainian filmmaker<br />
who has been on a hunger strike for<br />
more than a month in a remote Siberian penal<br />
colony, to remind the Russian president that his<br />
costly sport show does not wipe away his government’s<br />
crimes. Following in the best tradition<br />
of the Soviet era, Mr. Sentsov was sentenced<br />
to 20 years in prison on evidence given by him<br />
and witnesses under torture,” the article reads.<br />
“The Kremlin, as always, denies everything...<br />
Kremlin-allied media have claimed that<br />
Western protests are a ploy to undermine Russia’s<br />
World Cup tournament,” the publication<br />
says. “No, no and no. Mr. Putin’s regime alone<br />
is responsible for the assaults on Ukraine, for<br />
Mr. Sentsov’s torture and phony trial.<br />
Mr. Sentsov is risking his life to draw attention<br />
to Russia’s actions. He and the truth he proclaims<br />
deserve the full support of the West, no<br />
matter what is going on in Russia’s stadiums.”<br />
A Soviet-era political prisoner who now serves<br />
as an MP, one of the leaders of the Crimean<br />
Tatar people Mustafa Dzhemilev emphasizes that<br />
“holding some international olympiads, festivals,<br />
championships, and international conferences<br />
on the territory of that country are not steps<br />
in the right direction.” At the same time, he says<br />
that the current sanctions against Russia would<br />
still lead to a “large-scale disruption of its economy.”<br />
The details can be found in Dzhemilev’s interview<br />
for The Day newspaper.<br />
Now four Ukrainian political prisoners are already<br />
on a hunger strike in Russian prisons, and<br />
about 70 of our people are held in the dungeons<br />
of the Kremlin in total, half of them Crimean<br />
Tatars. As a Soviet-era political prisoner who was<br />
on a hunger strike for 303 days, longer than anyone<br />
else, what would you advise our prisoners today?<br />
And in general, how effective is the hunger<br />
strike as a method, can it influence the current<br />
political regime in Russia? In your opinion,<br />
what can change the situation?<br />
“Prisoner hunger strikes often occur in countries<br />
whose regimes do not differ much from the<br />
Soviet one. That is, in those countries where human<br />
rights are brazenly violated. In prisons,<br />
hunger strikes are declared primarily to protest<br />
against manifestly unlawful sentences, but are often<br />
declared as well to protest against gross violations<br />
of internal regulations. These include<br />
warders abusing prisoners, disgusting and inedible<br />
food, excessively cold cells, bath being delayed<br />
for a long time, etc. The hunger strike is believed<br />
to be a measure of last resort to protect one’s<br />
rights, but demonstrative vein cutting is frequent<br />
as well. During my time behind the bars, there<br />
were even cases of prisoners cutting their throat<br />
or cutting open their stomach, that is, some kind<br />
of prison hara-kiri.<br />
“But political hunger strikes, that is, ones<br />
launched to achieve some goals not for themselves,<br />
but for the country, the community, one’s co-religionists<br />
or like-minded people, belong to a special<br />
category. As for the likelihood of hungerstrikers’<br />
demands being met, there is no definite<br />
answer to that question. It is demands that have<br />
to do with living conditions that are sometimes<br />
met, not political ones. However, people who go<br />
on political hunger strikes do not expect to get<br />
their demands met, they just want to contribute<br />
to the common cause. And in this regard, they certainly<br />
achieve their goal. To advise hunger-strikers<br />
to stop their protest on the grounds that it undermines<br />
their health and threatens their lives is<br />
useless, since they know this very well. Those enjoying<br />
freedom would do better to take some kind<br />
of energetic action in support of prisoners’ demands<br />
and call for their immediate release. People<br />
usually stop a hunger strike when they see that<br />
they have achieved something with their protest.”<br />
Sketch by Viktor BOGORAD<br />
To check<br />
the aggressor<br />
Mustafa DZHEMILEV:<br />
“Russia’s disregard of the international rules<br />
of conduct will still lead to the consequences<br />
similar to those suffered by the former USSR”
2<br />
No.39 JUNE 21, 2018<br />
Refugee today –citizen tomorrow?<br />
Vinnytsia is part of the<br />
Intercultural Cities network,<br />
which requires the city to engage<br />
in cooperation with<br />
members of ethnic communities<br />
and displaced persons.<br />
The program supports cities in<br />
developing governance and<br />
policy mechanisms that will<br />
enable representatives of ethnic<br />
minorities, displaced persons,<br />
and migrants to become<br />
a resource for the local community.<br />
Mayors of other Ukrainian<br />
cities have also joined this<br />
initiative. Members of the network<br />
made a joint statement<br />
on the World Refugee Day,<br />
which is observed on June 20.<br />
DAY AFTER DAY<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
AhottimeinNorthern<br />
Macedonia<br />
Against the background of protests, the<br />
parties signed an agreement to change the<br />
name of the former Yugoslav republic<br />
There is a voice which is rarely<br />
heard in the deeply divisive<br />
debate about refugee<br />
policies – the voice of cities.<br />
Listening to cities can not<br />
only make the debate more<br />
constructive, it can also help shape<br />
policies which reconcile solidarity<br />
and societal cohesion.<br />
Most asylum-seekers and<br />
refugees live in cities: in neighborhoods,<br />
parks, enterprises, hospitals<br />
and schools they are not an abstract<br />
political issue – they are human beings<br />
with needs, responsibilities and<br />
aspirations.<br />
Mayors care about people living<br />
in their cities. They care both<br />
about the welfare of newcomers and<br />
the prosperity and well-being of the<br />
entire community. Therefore, we<br />
have to find a way to secure both.<br />
We cannot afford to engage in shortterm<br />
political struggles and neglect<br />
the long-term perspective.<br />
We must pave the way for today’s<br />
refugees to become the citizens<br />
of tomorrow. If they cannot work,<br />
study, create enterprises and even<br />
volunteer because of legal or administrative<br />
obstacles, or because<br />
they have no affordable opportunities<br />
to learn our language, we still<br />
need to find a way to avoid lives and<br />
talents being wasted. We can achieve<br />
this if we manage to convince fellow<br />
citizens that migrants are not a<br />
threat, but an opportunity to build<br />
more inclusive, open, creative, and<br />
dynamic cities for everyone.<br />
We call for a political vision in<br />
our societies which takes integration<br />
seriously, as our attitudes determine<br />
whether migration will be a<br />
blessing or a curse.<br />
Successful integration cannot be<br />
based on rejection and fear. It can only<br />
work if there is mutual respect and<br />
a shared pluralistic community identity.<br />
We can only help newcomers embrace<br />
the values of equality, human<br />
rights and democracy, which are the<br />
pillars of our societies, if we are able<br />
to demonstrate that we live by these<br />
values ourselves. We need to lead by<br />
example, building relentlessly open,<br />
just, and inclusive democracies.<br />
In order to make our mission a<br />
success, we work together with other<br />
cities in networks such as the Intercultural<br />
cities network supported<br />
by the Council of Europe. We design<br />
together innovative approaches<br />
to making schools, neighborhoods<br />
and community institutions more diverse,<br />
prevent discrimination, fight<br />
against violent extremism and hatred,<br />
and foster trust through interaction<br />
between all members of the<br />
community. We strive to create conditions<br />
for everyone to have a say in<br />
local affairs and realize their aspirations<br />
around a common vision,<br />
whether they are officially citizens,<br />
or not. For us, all those who feel they<br />
belong to the city are citizens.<br />
The experience and knowledge<br />
that cities have regarding what<br />
works for integration can help make<br />
national policies more effective. It is<br />
time to listen to the voice of cities.<br />
■ Signatories<br />
•Mr. Antonio DECARO, Mayor of<br />
Bari (Italy)<br />
•Mr. Erlend HORN, Deputy Mayor of<br />
Bergen (Norway)<br />
•Mr. Juan Maria ABURTO, Mayor of<br />
Bilbao (Spain)<br />
•Mr. Ricardo RIO, Mayor of Braga<br />
(Portugal)<br />
•Ms. Ana Belen CASTEJON HER-<br />
NANDEZ, Mayor of Cartagena<br />
(Spain)<br />
•Ms. Amparo MARCO GUAL, Mayor<br />
of Castello (Spain)<br />
•Dr. Florian JANIK, Mayor of Erlangen<br />
(Germany)<br />
•Dr. Elisabeth PREUSS, Deputy<br />
Mayor, Erlangen (Germany)<br />
•Ms. Susanne LENDER-CASSENS,<br />
Deputy Mayor, Erlangen (Germany)<br />
•Mr. Francisco Javier AYALA OR-<br />
TEGA, Mayor of Fuenlabrada<br />
(Spain)<br />
•Mr. Imanol LANDA JAUREGI,<br />
Mayor of Getxo (Spain)<br />
•Mr. Yasutomo SUZUKI, Mayor of<br />
Hamamatsu (Japan)<br />
•Mr. Damien EGAN, Mayor of the<br />
London Borough of Lewisham<br />
(United Kingdom)<br />
•Mr. Nicos NICOLAIDES, Mayor of<br />
Limassol (Cyprus)<br />
•Mr. Fernando MEDINA, Mayor of<br />
Lisbon (Portugal)<br />
•Mr. Bernardino SOARES, Mayor<br />
of Loures (Portugal)<br />
•Mr. Hryhoriy PUSTOVIT, Acting<br />
Mayor of Lutsk (Ukraine)<br />
•Cr Bob TURNER, Mayor of Melton<br />
(Australia)<br />
•Ms. Cecilia Soto, Federal Chairwoman<br />
of the Standing Committee<br />
on the City of Mexico, LXIII Legislature<br />
of Mexican Federal Congress<br />
(Mexico)<br />
•Mr. Isaltino MORAIS, Mayor of<br />
Oeiras (Portugal)<br />
•Mr. Anatoliy VERSHINA, Mayor of<br />
Pavlohrad (Ukraine)<br />
•Mr. Luca VECCHI, Mayor of Reggio<br />
Emilia (Italy)<br />
•Mr. Ardell Fr. BREDE, Mayor of<br />
City of Rochester, Minnesota (USA)<br />
•Mr. Jordi VINAS, Mayor of Salt<br />
(Spain)<br />
•Mr. Eneko GOIA, Mayor of San<br />
Sebastian/Donostia (Spain)<br />
•Mr. Maurizio MANGIALARDI,<br />
Mayor of Senigallia (Italy)<br />
•Mr. Roland RIES, Mayor of Strasbourg<br />
(France)<br />
•Mr. Carlos Enrique ALONSO RO-<br />
DRIGUEZ, President of the Cabildo<br />
of Tenerife (Spain)<br />
•Ms. Chiara APPENDINO, Mayor of<br />
Torino (Italy)<br />
•Mr. Sergiy MORGUNOV, Mayor of<br />
Vinnytsia (Ukraine)<br />
•Mr. Pedro SANTISTEVE ROCHE,<br />
Mayor of Zaragoza (Spain)<br />
www.coe.int/interculturalcities<br />
By Natalia ISHCHENKO<br />
Seven police officers were<br />
injured, and 25 demonstrators<br />
were detained. These are the<br />
results of yet another protest<br />
wave in Macedonia which<br />
provide an illustration of sorts to the<br />
historic agreement regarding the<br />
renaming of the country, which was<br />
signed on June 17.<br />
On that day, foreign ministers of<br />
Macedonia and Greece, Nikola Dimitrov<br />
and Nikos Kotzias, signed an<br />
agreement to change the name of the<br />
former Yugoslav republic, which, after<br />
the completion of all the procedures,<br />
will be called the Republic of Northern<br />
Macedonia. “Macedonia” without qualifiers<br />
will remain an informal name of<br />
the whole region, which includes not<br />
only the former Yugoslav republic of<br />
the same name (for the time being), but<br />
also the Greek province with the same<br />
historic name.<br />
The solemn signing of the Greek-<br />
Macedonian agreement took place on<br />
the shores of a lake in the picturesque<br />
Greek region of Prespes, on the border<br />
with Macedonia. The ceremony was<br />
attended by Greek Prime Minister<br />
Alexis Tsipras, his Macedonian counterpart<br />
Zoran Zaev, UN negotiations<br />
mediator Matthew Nimetz, EU diplomacy<br />
head Federica Mogherini, and EU<br />
Commissioner for Enlargement Johannes<br />
Hahn.<br />
After years of nervous negotiations,<br />
which eventually ended in a successful<br />
agreement, things were almost euphoric<br />
in the pavilion near the lake. Prime<br />
ministers of Macedonia and Greece set<br />
the tone, smiling and delivering vigorous,<br />
optimistic speeches.<br />
Zaev seemed especially happy. He<br />
confidently talked about the immediate<br />
future of Macedonia in the EU and NA-<br />
TO, and at the end of the event, grew so<br />
relaxed that he decided to present his<br />
festive red tie to his Greek counterpart.<br />
(Tsipras, probably because the ceremony<br />
was being held on a Sunday, decided<br />
not to wear this accessory for<br />
some reason).<br />
The cheerful mood of the Macedonian<br />
prime minister is understandable:<br />
he managed, frankly speaking,<br />
to win by putting the squeeze on<br />
the Greeks and reach a fundamental<br />
solution to the problem, to find a way<br />
out of the deadlock, in which the former<br />
Yugoslav republic had been stagnating<br />
since the beginning of the<br />
1990s, or for 27 years.<br />
Now Macedonia has every chance to<br />
begin the process of joining the EU and<br />
NATO, which was blocked by Greece because<br />
of the “unacceptable” name of the<br />
neighboring country.<br />
Macedonian officials hope that<br />
with the agreement reached, they will<br />
be able to begin accession negotiations<br />
with the EU at a summit to be held in<br />
late June, and receive an invitation to<br />
join NATO by mid-July.<br />
The European Commission has already<br />
recommended the start of negotiations<br />
on the accession of Macedonia<br />
to the EU. The European Council, according<br />
to Mogherini, may decide on it<br />
in two weeks.<br />
It should be noted that the representatives<br />
of the EU also radiated joy<br />
at the signing of the Greek-Macedonian<br />
agreement. Mogherini, it seems,<br />
even put on a bright red jacket, specially<br />
to enhance the effect. Next<br />
year, she will need to sum up the results<br />
of her work in that position,<br />
and therefore such a large-scale positive<br />
event will certainly be of use in<br />
her store of breakthroughs.<br />
REUTERS photo<br />
As for NATO, the Alliance was<br />
ready to invite Macedonia as early as<br />
10 years ago, but this issue was blocked<br />
by Greece at the Bucharest Summit in<br />
2008. At that time, NATO countries<br />
agreed that Macedonia would receive an<br />
invitation after the resolution of the<br />
naming dispute with Greece.<br />
However, euphoria is all well and<br />
good, but there is still a brutal reality<br />
to deal with. Now the treaty has yet to<br />
be approved by the parliament of Macedonia<br />
and confirmed at an all-Macedonian<br />
referendum, after which the<br />
document has to be ratified by the<br />
Greek legislators.<br />
The present governments, both<br />
Macedonian and Greek, have slim majorities<br />
in the parliaments of their countries.<br />
Moreover, it is unlikely that most<br />
Macedonians will decide to vote against<br />
joining NATO and the EU by blocking<br />
the name change. But one can safely predict<br />
that the situation in both countries<br />
will be gravely destabilized during the<br />
consideration of these issues.<br />
Protests in Greece against the<br />
preservation of the word “Macedonia” in<br />
the name of the neighboring country<br />
were more than just massive – they<br />
gathered hundreds of thousands (!).<br />
Greeks rallied on the agreement’s signing<br />
day as well. Several hundred protesters<br />
gathered around the Greek village<br />
within 25 kilometers of which a<br />
solemn ceremony saw the treaty on the<br />
new name for the former Yugoslav republic<br />
being signed.<br />
Flying the Greek flags, the demonstrators<br />
tried to march to the lake<br />
shore. However, the police blocked all<br />
roads, and therefore the protesters<br />
could not get to the event itself, but still<br />
tried to break through by throwing<br />
stones at law-enforcement personnel.<br />
The police had to use tear gas and stun<br />
grenades. According to the protesters,<br />
at least eight people were injured<br />
as a result of the clashes.<br />
The protests in Macedonia were<br />
even more intense.<br />
On the evening of June 17, a protest<br />
took place in the capital city of Skopje.<br />
Several hundred protesters opposed to<br />
renaming the nation tried to break into<br />
the parliament building. The protesters<br />
threw firecrackers, bottles, and<br />
stones at the police who guarded the<br />
building, and tried to dismantle the<br />
fence. Law-enforcement personnel responded<br />
with stun grenades and tear<br />
gas, which, as the Macedonian Ministry<br />
of the Interior said in a statement, was<br />
aimed “to prevent escalation of the situation”<br />
and seizure of the parliament<br />
building. As already mentioned above,<br />
7 police officers were injured, and<br />
25 demonstrators were detained.<br />
Protests were also held in some<br />
other cities of Macedonia, in particular,<br />
in the small city of Bitola near the border<br />
with Greece, 50 kilometers away<br />
from the place where the agreement<br />
was signed. The protesters told journalists<br />
that they wanted to be Macedonians,<br />
and not “northern Macedonians,”<br />
and would not change their<br />
stance.<br />
The referendum on changing the<br />
name of the country is scheduled for<br />
September in Macedonia. One could<br />
write that this fall would be a hot season<br />
in the Balkans, but it is always hot<br />
there, due to the peculiarities of the local<br />
climate.
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
DAY AFTER DAY No.39 JUNE 21, 2018 3<br />
By Natalia PUSHKARUK, The Day<br />
OnJune 18-19, Sofia hosted<br />
the international scholarly<br />
conference “Bulgaria and Ukraine<br />
in the History of Europe”ontheoccasionofthe100th<br />
anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic<br />
relations between the UNR and<br />
Bulgaria.<br />
Julian REVALSKI, President of the<br />
Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, who took<br />
part in the opening ceremony, emphasized<br />
that the institution he heads is proud<br />
of cooperating with Ukrainian academics<br />
and civic activists, the website of the General<br />
Directorate for Servicing Foreign<br />
Representatives reports. Meanwhile,<br />
Mykola BALTAZHY, Ambassador Extraordinary<br />
and Plenipotentiary of Ukraine<br />
to Bulgaria, who also participated in the<br />
ceremony, welcomed the Ukrainian “special<br />
academic mission” and noted: “It is<br />
very important that the best academics<br />
from various countries are working on the<br />
1917-24 events.” Daniel VACHKOV, Director<br />
of the Institute of Historical Studies<br />
of the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences,<br />
pointed out that “although Ukraine and<br />
Bulgaria maintain very active relations,<br />
they need to be further developed, which<br />
requires fresh historical research.”<br />
Besides, as the conference was being<br />
opened, the Ukrainian Institute of History<br />
and the Bulgarian Institute of Historical<br />
Studies signed an agreement on scholarly<br />
research.<br />
Here follows the text of The Day’s interview<br />
with Ambassador Baltazhy.<br />
● “THE EVENT AROUSED KEEN<br />
INTEREST AMONG<br />
SCIENTIFIC CIRCLES AND<br />
THE PUBLIC”<br />
Mr. Ambassador, how did the idea of<br />
this conference come up?<br />
“This conference is part of the comprehensive<br />
program of academic events<br />
within the framework of the project ‘Day of<br />
Ukraine in Europe’ on the occasion of an anniversary<br />
of the establishment of diplomatic<br />
relations between Ukraine and Bulgaria, Romania,<br />
and Greece, and the centenary of the<br />
Ukrainian diplomatic service. The conference<br />
had long been in the making on the initiative<br />
of the Academic Society for the<br />
History of Diplomacy and International Relations<br />
with support from and in partnership<br />
with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs,<br />
Ukraine’s Embassy in Bulgaria, the General<br />
Directorate for Servicing Foreign Representations,anumberof<br />
regional authorities,<br />
Ukrainian universities, and archives. The<br />
main Bulgarian partner is the Institute of<br />
Historical Studies of the Bulgarian Academy<br />
of Sciences, and the sponsor is the Ministry<br />
of Education and Science.<br />
“The event aroused keen interest<br />
among academic circles and the public. Suffice<br />
it to say that the President of the Bulgarian<br />
Academy of Sciences, Julian Revalski,<br />
welcomed the participants. The event<br />
is interesting by both the theme and the list<br />
of participants which includes 20 Ukrainian<br />
high-ranking academics and former<br />
diplomats.<br />
“The first day saw welcoming speeches,<br />
plenary reports, and stormy panel discussions.<br />
The conference is also receiving<br />
Bulgarian media coverage.<br />
“Besides, this conference is part of the<br />
embassy’s package of events on the occasion<br />
of the centenary of the establishment<br />
of diplomatic relations between the<br />
UNR and the Kingdom of Bulgaria. In particular,<br />
a similar conference was held in<br />
February at Bulgaria’s Ministry of Foreign<br />
Affairs. And this debate attracted a wide<br />
circle of academics and experts. It is deeply<br />
symbolic that it coincided in time with the<br />
Bulgarian vote in the EU Council, which<br />
clearly reflects its name and European<br />
context. I think the conference is an important<br />
event which should be viewed<br />
through the prism of friendly Ukrainian-<br />
Bulgarian relations.”<br />
● “IT WAS AGREED TO FORM A<br />
UKRAINIAN-BULGARIAN<br />
COMMISSION ON<br />
HISTORICAL RESEARCH”<br />
To what extent is it important to<br />
spotlight the themes of Ukrainian history<br />
in Bulgaria and Bulgarian history in<br />
Ukraine?<br />
Ukraine’s“specialacademic<br />
mission” in Sofia<br />
Ukrainian Ambassador to Bulgaria Mykola<br />
BALTAZHY: “We should not only study each<br />
other’s history, but also exchange experience”<br />
“There are a lot of maxims, such as<br />
‘whoever does not know his past does not<br />
deserve a future’ and ‘whoever does not<br />
know his history will have to re-live it<br />
again,’ and they are all still topical. But this<br />
conference is very important, as far as finding<br />
the truth about little-known events of<br />
those years is concerned, for there are<br />
very many attempts to falsify historical<br />
events and facts. Against the backdrop of<br />
a hybrid war on the part of Russia, the research<br />
of history without dogmas and<br />
stereotypes, an independent analysis and<br />
expert examination are the main instruments<br />
of defense from propaganda and manipulations<br />
that pose a real threat to<br />
democracy and security.<br />
“Among those who stood at the origins<br />
of Ukrainian-Bulgarian relations in the early<br />
20th century were such figures as Professor<br />
Oleksandr Shulhin, the UNR’s first<br />
Minister of Foreign Affairs and Ambassador<br />
to the Kingdom of Bulgaria, and Professor<br />
Ivan Shishmanov, a well-known<br />
representative of the then Bulgarian intellectual<br />
elite, the son-in-law of Mykhailo<br />
Drahomanov. These prominent diplomats<br />
and civic activists enjoyed high prestige<br />
in their countries which maintained<br />
high-level bilateral relations.<br />
“The conference made an in-depth<br />
analysis of historical documents. The<br />
Ukrainian academics cited unique archival<br />
documents in their reports. They also<br />
staged a superb exhibition about the stormy<br />
events of the 1917-21 Ukrainian Revolution<br />
in the Grand Hall of the Bulgarian<br />
Academy of Sciences. What also aroused<br />
keen interest was a documentary film on<br />
signing the Brest-Litovsk Peace Treaty,<br />
which in fact meant international recognition<br />
of the UNR’s independence.<br />
“Even after the UNR had ceased to exist,<br />
Ukraine had very good relations with<br />
Bulgaria in all fields. Besides, it is of<br />
paramount importance that the two friendly<br />
countries established relations not in<br />
1918 – they date back to the olden times of<br />
Kyivan Rus’ and the First Bulgarian Kingdom<br />
or even to the period when the ancient<br />
Ruthenian and ancient Bulgarian ethnicities<br />
were being formed.<br />
On the danger of provocations...<br />
Photo by Ruslan KANIUKA, The Day<br />
KYIV. JUNE 19, 2018<br />
By Ivan KAPSAMUN,<br />
Valentyn TORBA, The Day<br />
While the parliament was<br />
considering a number of<br />
issues on its agenda on<br />
June 19, tumultuous events<br />
took place near the central<br />
entrance of the Verkhovna Rada building.<br />
That location hosted protests by miners,<br />
Chornobyl victims, and veterans of the<br />
Soviet war in Afghanistan. The protest<br />
would have most likely stayed littlenoticed<br />
had its participants not broken<br />
through and reached the walls of the<br />
building in Konstytutsii Square. There<br />
was a clash between protesters and lawenforcement<br />
personnel. According to<br />
Andrii Kryshchenko, the Kyiv head of the<br />
National Police, three law-enforcement<br />
officers had suffered light injuries at the<br />
hands of the protesters. He also said that<br />
the police had detained a protester who<br />
attacked a law-enforcement officer.<br />
“We did not know almost till the<br />
last moment that Chornobyl victims and<br />
anti-terrorist operation (ATO) veterans<br />
would join the protest as well. It was the<br />
police who informed us about it, as<br />
they tried to prevent any incidents,”<br />
chairman of the Confederation of Free<br />
Trade Unions of Ukraine Mykhailo<br />
Volynets commented for The Day. “To<br />
make our speeches heard, we took turns<br />
using the Afghanistan veterans’ sound<br />
equipment. The ATO veterans, like the<br />
Afghanistan veterans, demanded reinstatement<br />
of their benefits they had had<br />
unfairly taken away. Secondly, they demanded<br />
fairly calculated pensions. The<br />
government has been promising it for<br />
a long time. In turn, the miners have<br />
wage arrears going back to 2015. This<br />
problem could have been solved had the<br />
parliament voted to include on the<br />
agenda Mykhailo Bondar’s bill on the allocation<br />
of funds for wages, technical<br />
equipment and capital investment in<br />
the coal industry. We need it because at<br />
this time, a huge amount of coal is<br />
purchased abroad. The tempo of coal<br />
imports is increasing. Last year, our<br />
foreign coal purchases stood at 52 billion<br />
hryvnias.”<br />
“There was also an exchange of opinions<br />
about the current stage of bilateral<br />
Ukrainian-Bulgarian relations. We can<br />
see a fruitful development of the political<br />
dialog, sectoral and interregional cooperation,<br />
and city twinning. From the very<br />
outset, Bulgaria has been supporting territorial<br />
integrity of Ukraine, sanctions<br />
against Russia, systemic reforms, the European<br />
and Euro-Atlantic integration of<br />
our state. It made strenuous efforts to<br />
grant Ukraine a visa waiver. We cooperate<br />
very well within the framework of international<br />
organizations. This was also the<br />
object of a two-day discussion. Therefore,<br />
it is beyond any doubt that the conference<br />
is of not only purely academic, but also of<br />
practical importance.<br />
“In addition, in the course of the conference,<br />
the Ukrainian Institute of History<br />
and the Bulgarian Institute of Historical<br />
Studies signed an agreement on cooperation<br />
and resolved to form a Ukrainian-Bulgarian<br />
commission for historical research.”<br />
“Any demands, including those of purely<br />
social nature, become a priori political at<br />
this juncture,” an MP asserted<br />
● “KYIVAN RUS’ AND THE<br />
FIRST BULGARIAN<br />
KINGDOM WERE BOOSTING<br />
THEIR MIGHT ALMOST<br />
SIMULTANEOUSLY IN THE<br />
9TH-10TH CENTURIES”<br />
The newspaper Den also took part in<br />
researching Ukraine’s relations with her<br />
“southern Orthodox and Slavic sister”<br />
Bulgaria in the publication My Sister<br />
Sofia. Den’s editor-in-chief Larysa Ivshyna<br />
notes in the preface to this book that<br />
“the history of Ukraine and Bulgaria is like<br />
a history of two sisters separated in early<br />
childhood.” And what similarities in the<br />
two countries’ history do you see?<br />
“Ukrainians and Bulgarians are very<br />
close peoples. If you make a comparative<br />
analysis our states’ historical development,<br />
you will see, for example, that Kyivan<br />
Rus’ and the First Bulgarian Kingdom<br />
were boosting their might almost simultaneously<br />
in the 9th-10th centuries. But,<br />
undoubtedly, two great events played a special<br />
role in the interrelations between the<br />
two peoples – the creation of the Slavic<br />
script and the adoption of Christianity.<br />
“Later, Ukraine lost its statehood<br />
for several centuries, while Bulgaria was<br />
part of the Ottoman Empire for almost<br />
five centuries. We should also take into<br />
account that our peoples have always<br />
helped each other – the most illustrious<br />
example of this was participation of<br />
Ukrainian volunteers, medics, in the liberation<br />
of Bulgaria from the Ottoman<br />
yoke. There are also many examples of<br />
Bulgarians helping the Ukrainian people<br />
in their liberation struggle – even in the<br />
era of Zaporozhian Sich.”<br />
“When people began marching to the<br />
parliament building, head of the State Security<br />
Department Valerii Heletei approached<br />
me and said that his people<br />
would fight to the death in case of an assault<br />
on the building,” Volynets continued.<br />
“I explained that nobody was going<br />
to carry out an assault. If we wanted just<br />
to enter the parliament building, it would<br />
be no problem at all. The scuffles took<br />
place only after the riot police appeared.<br />
Then Iryna Herashchenko, the first vicespeaker<br />
of parliament, emerged from the<br />
building, and she obviously did not understand<br />
the miners’ issues. She said she<br />
would visit affected regions and figure out<br />
why there were arrears. I think that she<br />
ought to be more prepared.”<br />
Herashchenko, meanwhile, explained<br />
to the media that she had invited an initiative<br />
group selected by the protesters to<br />
enter negotiations. She added that following<br />
a meeting between members of the<br />
initiative group and leaders of the largest<br />
parliamentary factions and individual<br />
MPs, their demands would be discussed at<br />
a meeting of the Verkhovna Rada’s Committee<br />
on Veterans, Combatants, ATO<br />
Soldiers, and People with Disabilities.<br />
“We have to work out a plan outlining<br />
what can be done right now, what can be<br />
included into the budget for 2019, and<br />
what cannot be done, and we must honestly<br />
say that,” Herashchenko stated as<br />
quoted by ukrinform.ua.<br />
“I have a lot of acquaintances among<br />
the organizations that joined these<br />
protests,” MP Viktor Chumak commented<br />
for The Day. “They sent me<br />
their demands, and these demands have<br />
nothing to do whatsoever with the powers<br />
of the Verkhovna Rada. They all belong<br />
to the cabinet’s responsibilities: benefits,<br />
monetization, and so on. Their demands<br />
are addressed primarily to leaders<br />
of the nation. Who are these national<br />
leaders? What do they have to do with<br />
the parliament? Therefore, all this<br />
protest, which took place outside the<br />
Verkhovna Rada building, had no direct<br />
relation to it. Social benefits are set by<br />
the Cabinet of Ministers. I have not<br />
found out who was the main driver of<br />
this event, but it seems to me that it was<br />
directed against serving Prime Minister<br />
Volodymyr Hroisman. This is a warning<br />
to him, even though it was made public<br />
not outside the cabinet offices, but<br />
rather outside the parliament building.<br />
With whom is Hroisman now in conflict?<br />
One person only, and his name is Petro<br />
Poroshenko. Hroisman is friends with<br />
numerous parties and factions, as well<br />
as MPs elected in single-member constituencies.<br />
Meanwhile, Poroshenko is<br />
greatly dissatisfied with Hroisman’s<br />
work. Therefore, it seems to me that the<br />
source of the protests should be sought<br />
in Bankova Street [where the Presidential<br />
Administration is housed. – Ed.].<br />
Any demands, including those of purely<br />
social nature, are a priori political at<br />
this juncture.”<br />
Any Ukrainian citizen enjoys the<br />
right to protest and to defend their social<br />
rights. It is another matter under<br />
what conditions all this is happening.<br />
Firstly, we must not forget that we<br />
have a war to deal with, although<br />
this is not a valid reason for the government<br />
to engage in speculations<br />
and ignore problems. Secondly, with<br />
the presidential election approaching,<br />
any social or economic issues can<br />
be used by politicians to their own<br />
ends. Therefore, citizens need to be<br />
particularly attentive and responsible<br />
given this reality.
4<br />
No.39 JUNE 21, 2018<br />
TOPIC OF THE DAY<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
By Alla DUBROVYK-ROKHOVA, The Day<br />
The Trans-Anatolian Natural<br />
Gas Pipeline (TANAP), which<br />
will transport gas from<br />
Azerbaijan to Turkey and then<br />
to Europe, was opened at a<br />
ceremony in the Turkish province of<br />
Eskisehir.<br />
“Today is an historic day. The<br />
TANAP project is an outcome of multilateral<br />
cooperation as well as of political<br />
will. It is especially gratifying<br />
that we are launching it ahead of<br />
schedule. It will be Europe’s largest<br />
gas pipeline. We are planning to make<br />
the first delivery of gas through this<br />
pipeline to Greece in June 2019,”<br />
Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdogan<br />
said, commenting on the opening<br />
of TANAP.<br />
In addition to Erdogan, President<br />
Petro Poroshenko of Ukraine,<br />
President Ilham Aliyev of Azerbaijan,<br />
President Aleksandar Vucic of Serbia,<br />
leader of the Turkish Republic of<br />
Northern Cyprus Mustafa Akinci,<br />
energy ministers of several countries,<br />
and top executives of energy<br />
companies, also attended the ceremony.<br />
Incidentally, Maros Sefcovic,<br />
Vice President of the Commission for<br />
the Energy Union, was conspicuous<br />
for his absence, although TANAP is<br />
part of the Southern Gas Corridor<br />
whose main objective is to strengthen<br />
the European Union’s energy security<br />
and reduce dependence on gas<br />
supplies from Russia.<br />
“It is energy security, also for<br />
our state, as well as competitiveness<br />
and diversification of gas supplies<br />
to Ukraine,” President Poroshenko<br />
tweeted. He emphasized that Ukraine<br />
hopes to receive TANAP gas through<br />
Bulgaria and Romania.<br />
It will be recalled that Azerbaijan<br />
and Turkey made a deal to build this<br />
gas pipeline in June 2012, after which<br />
Ukraine expressed a desire to take<br />
part in the construction, but Azerbaijan<br />
announced soon after that it<br />
was not interested in this.<br />
The Day spoke with Mykhailo<br />
HONCHAR, president of the Strategy<br />
XXI Center for Global Studies,<br />
about TANAP’s prospects and role in<br />
the energy security of Ukraine.<br />
“Although ‘a red ribbon was cut’<br />
yesterday in the Turkish province of<br />
Eskisehir, the prospects of this natural<br />
gas supply corridor are rather<br />
bleak and remote.<br />
“The point is there is a marked difference<br />
between the concept and the<br />
present-day shape of TANAP and the<br />
Southern Gas Corridor as a whole.<br />
“Firstly, it will be impossible to<br />
reach the rated capacity immediately.<br />
Moreover, the current negotiations<br />
show that TANAP can ensure gas<br />
supplies to Turkey only. Europe is out<br />
of the question so far, for this requires<br />
the construction of the Trans-Adriatic<br />
Gas Pipeline, on which Azerbaijanis<br />
are working now. But it will carry<br />
Azerbaijani gas to southern Italy.<br />
“The total rated capacity of<br />
TANAP is 31 billion cubic meters of<br />
natural gas. They are going to start<br />
building its first stage with a capacity<br />
of 16 billion cubic meters, with<br />
6 billion going to the Turkish market<br />
and 10 billion to southern Italy, but –<br />
let me say it again – after 2020, when<br />
the Trans-Adriatic Gas Pipeline is<br />
built.<br />
“Besides, the Azerbaijani State-<br />
Run Oil Company, the main project<br />
implementer, aims to supply about one<br />
billion cubic meters of natural gas to<br />
Bulgaria.”<br />
What is the place of Ukraine in<br />
these plans?<br />
“We are not present at this stage.<br />
And not only we.”<br />
Then what was the subject of<br />
Poroshenko-Aliyev negotiations?<br />
“A bomb went off in<br />
Brussels,butnobody<br />
noticed it”<br />
Mykhailo HONCHAR on why he thinks that<br />
the prospects of the Southern Gas Corridor, which is intended<br />
to strengthen the European Union’s energy security, are bleak<br />
“They discussed prospects. Remote<br />
prospects. Ideally, if things go<br />
as planned, Ukraine will use this corridor<br />
of Azerbaijani gas supplies after<br />
2025 – on condition that Azerbaijan<br />
increases gas production. It is<br />
another important moment.”<br />
No less important is the Russian<br />
factor – to be more exact, the Kremlin’s<br />
opposition to non-Gazprom gas<br />
pipelines. To what extent is it likely<br />
that Russia may hinder carrying out<br />
the Southern Gas Corridor project?<br />
“The total supplies of Azerbaijani<br />
gas to southern Italy will be a<br />
meager – by the European market’s<br />
yardstick – 10 billion cubic meters.<br />
This pales in comparison with the<br />
450 billion cubic meters the European<br />
market consumes annually. But while<br />
TANAP is still in its infancy, Russia<br />
is already saying there should be<br />
Russian gas from the Turkish stream<br />
in the Trans-Adriatic Gas Pipeline in<br />
accordance with the EU’s Third Energy<br />
Package. What is the Jesuitical<br />
essence of Russia’s move? It torpedoes<br />
the Third Energy Package by all<br />
means, but in this case it is trying to<br />
push its gas into the Azerbaijani gas<br />
pipeline, taking advantage of the European<br />
law.<br />
“And I am not sure at all that the<br />
10 billion cubic meters of natural<br />
gas, which are supposed to reach<br />
southern Italy, will be of Azerbaijani<br />
origin from the Shah Deniz gas field.<br />
Most likely, Russia will pressure<br />
Azerbaijan, and there will be a 50-50<br />
ratio in the pipeline.<br />
“Russia is doing its best to minimize<br />
the supplies of non-Russian gas<br />
to the European Union. It is being assisted<br />
in this matter by such countries<br />
as Germany, Austria, and<br />
France, which, ‘for some reason,’<br />
pay no attention to non-Russian gas<br />
supplies. Take, for example, Azerbaijani<br />
gas. They knew it would come!<br />
They even drew up the Nabucco project<br />
for this purpose on the initiative<br />
of an Austrian company. But, ‘for<br />
some reason,’ Nabucco ‘died,’ giving<br />
way to a Turkish project. But, ‘for<br />
some reason’ again, neither the Austrians<br />
nor the Germans are saying, as<br />
our President Poroshenko is, that<br />
they would be glad to receive Azerbaijani<br />
gas. They are not saying that<br />
it is necessary to build a system of<br />
convectors or even a new pipeline, as<br />
part of the TANAP project, so that<br />
this gas could run not to the ‘blind alley’<br />
called southern Italy, an agrarian<br />
region without any major industrial<br />
consumption, but to Baumgarten<br />
in the center of Europe [Baumgarten<br />
has one of Europe’s three<br />
largest gas distribution centers and<br />
is an international gas trade hub. –<br />
Ed.]. In this way, this gas could also<br />
reach Germany. But both the Germans<br />
and the Austrians remain tightlipped<br />
about this option.”<br />
In other words, you are saying<br />
TANAP could be an alternative to<br />
Nord Stream 2?<br />
“Quite right, although it would be<br />
more exact to say: the Southern Gas<br />
Corridor, which is a project and a top<br />
priority of the European Union, is an<br />
alternative to both the Turkish Stream<br />
and Nord Stream 2, while TANAP is<br />
its basic part – 31 billion cubic meters.<br />
“The total capacity of the Southern<br />
Gas Corridor is 60 billion cubic meters.<br />
But it will only be worthwhile to<br />
reflect on the possibility of this when<br />
the project of transporting Turkmenian<br />
gas across the Caspian Sea<br />
gathers momentum.<br />
“This is part of the original idea.<br />
The Turks also want TANAP to transport<br />
Turkmenian gas.<br />
“But Russia strongly opposes<br />
this, and Azerbaijan is not exactly interested,<br />
frankly speaking, in having<br />
a rival in the shape of Turkmenian<br />
gas. The reason is clear: Turkmenistan<br />
is the world’s fourth<br />
largest depository of natural gas after<br />
Iran, Russia, and Qatar.”<br />
What did you mean when you<br />
said “for some reason” three times,<br />
when explaining why the leading EU<br />
countries do not support the gas<br />
pipeline projects initiated by the EU?<br />
“Gazprom has managed to corrupt<br />
the European Commission. The<br />
ample proof of this is discontinuation<br />
of the inquiry into Gazprom’s abuses<br />
on the European market, which<br />
was launched in 2011. We know that<br />
Gazprom came through unscathed on<br />
May 25.<br />
“I said as far back as 2015: a bomb<br />
went off in Brussels, but nobody noticed<br />
it. This abortive inquiry caused<br />
a scandal.<br />
“It is a victory of Russian gas<br />
corruption in Brussels and of corruption<br />
in the capitals of major EU<br />
member states which have miraculously<br />
forgotten about European priorities,<br />
including Nabucco which has<br />
Photo by Mykola LAZARENKO<br />
“ANKARA AND BAKU ARE WRITING THE ENERGY HISTORY OF THE 21st CENTURY,” AZERBAIJAN’S PRESIDENT ILHAM<br />
ALIYEV SAID AT THE TANAP OPENING CEREMONY IN TURKEY<br />
even been officially closed, but enthuse<br />
over the Russian-backed South<br />
Stream and Nord Stream 2. Hungary<br />
is actively examining the possibility<br />
of supporting the second stage of the<br />
Turkish Gas Pipeline. The same applies<br />
to Bulgaria, whose president<br />
and premier suddenly paid official visits<br />
to Moscow in the course of one<br />
week to meet Putin. Following this,<br />
Putin condescendingly told the Bulgarians<br />
that the second stage of the<br />
Turkish Gas Pipeline will be called<br />
Bulgarian Gas Pipeline.<br />
“In principle, there is nothing<br />
strange about Bulgaria, for, out of all<br />
the EU countries, it may be called the<br />
one most affected by post-Soviet corruption.<br />
Unfortunately, it has not<br />
yet pulled out of that quagmire.<br />
“Hungary is also, in principle,<br />
a phenomenon of post-Soviet corruption.<br />
“But the countries that are trying<br />
to teach us how to live – Germany,<br />
Austria, and France, – three<br />
refined countries of Western Europe,<br />
are forgetting their European<br />
priorities. Well, if you love Russian<br />
gas streams so much, why don’t you<br />
recall the option of supplying Turkmenian<br />
gas to Europe through Russia,<br />
using the Ukrainian gas transportation<br />
system? I think the only<br />
answer is corruption.”<br />
As you regard gas and its supply<br />
routes as a geopolitical security factor<br />
rather than an economic category<br />
(a marketable product), I cannot<br />
help asking you about your personal<br />
opinion of Angela Merkel’s position<br />
on the impossibility of Russia’s<br />
reinstatement in the G8 elite<br />
club. Why does Germany behave so<br />
contradictorily: the “green light” to<br />
Nord Stream 2 and the “red light” to<br />
Putin in the G8?<br />
“The answer will sound rude and<br />
perhaps even vulgar. Germany was<br />
paid for supporting Nord Stream 2 but<br />
not for Russia’s reinstatement in the<br />
G8. As the Americans say, ‘it’s nothing<br />
personal, just business.’<br />
“I don’t mean the chancellor personally.<br />
But we know very well that<br />
in such countries as Germany the position<br />
of the topmost leader is of<br />
paramount importance, even though,<br />
on the whole, the policy of Germany<br />
is the sum of the influences of various<br />
actors. Those who are now running<br />
the show there are oriented to<br />
Russia in terms of not only business,<br />
but also political relations.<br />
“We are going to see Russia activate<br />
behind-the-scenes contacts with<br />
G7 leaders in order to gain support not<br />
only from Italy and the US for the return<br />
of Putin to the negotiating table.<br />
“The Kremlin needs support from<br />
European heavyweights in this matter.<br />
Bu it is either France or Germany,<br />
or, still better, both of them. That’s<br />
why the Russians activate their<br />
Moscow-Paris and Moscow-Berlin<br />
lines. The arguments are predictable:<br />
‘You in Berlin and Paris have always<br />
favored dialog, even in the difficult<br />
times of the Cold War, and dialog is<br />
the format of the Group of Eight.’<br />
“Frankly speaking, G7 decisions<br />
are absolutely ‘impotent.’ We already<br />
felt it last year, when a communique<br />
on increasing sanctions against Russia<br />
was announced. So what? Only the<br />
US and the UK expanded the list of<br />
sanctions. What is more, Britain did<br />
so only after the Skripals were poisoned.<br />
The rest of the countries were,<br />
on the contrary, speaking of easing the<br />
sanctions in spite of what Russia was<br />
doing. Putin deserves being brought<br />
to the Hague-based International<br />
Criminal Court for war crimes and<br />
crimes against humanity for the 2016<br />
Aleppo bombing alone.<br />
“I am sure the Russians will be<br />
mocking at the G7. For Putin said<br />
clearly: we did not quit, we were not<br />
let in.”
By Oleksandra KLIOSOVA<br />
Photos by the author<br />
and Natalia MYDLIAK<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
This year, national-level centennial<br />
celebrations for the 1917-<br />
21 Ukrainian Revolution are<br />
continuing in Ukraine. Let us<br />
remind our readers that<br />
Den/The Day declared 2018 to be the<br />
Centennial Year of Hetman Pavlo<br />
Skoropadsky. Active citizens have<br />
held various events aimed at reviving<br />
the memory of the Hetman, such as a<br />
solemn prayer service honoring the<br />
centennial of Skoropadsky’s proclamation<br />
as Hetman and a march dedicated<br />
to the 100th anniversary of the<br />
Ukrainian State in Kharkiv. Meanwhile,<br />
history students enabled residents<br />
and guests of the capital to feel<br />
themselves transported to revolutionary<br />
Kyiv during the last weekend.<br />
On June 15 and 16, students<br />
from the faculty of history, Taras<br />
Shevchenko National University of<br />
Kyiv conducted dramatized Skoropadsky-themed<br />
tours, named<br />
“Night at St. Sophia. Hetmanate.<br />
1918” and hosted by the National<br />
Sanctuary “Sophia of Kyiv,” with the<br />
support of the Cultural Heritage<br />
Protection Department of Ukraine’s<br />
Ministry of Culture.<br />
“Conducting Skoropadsky-themed<br />
tours was a dream of my life! When<br />
competing in the All-Ukrainian Historians’<br />
Tournament as a ninth-grader,<br />
I had to answer a question about<br />
the hetman, so I started taking interest<br />
in his biography. He is superficially<br />
studied at school, but when<br />
you delve deeper into this topic, you<br />
understand the true scale of this figure,<br />
the concept of the Ukrainian<br />
Revolution. You are fascinated and<br />
because of it start to get involved in<br />
this process more and more,” we were<br />
told by Oleksii Rudenko, who leads the<br />
Night at the University Creative Association<br />
of Faculty of History Students<br />
at Taras Shevchenko National<br />
University of Kyiv.<br />
Rudenko created the Night at<br />
the University Creative Association<br />
in 2016, and it has become known due<br />
to its volunteer project of holding<br />
dramatized tours of various structures<br />
in Kyiv. This project is growing<br />
in popularity and attracting more and<br />
more spectators every time. Young<br />
historians have succeeded in moving<br />
beyond their alma mater, unlike most<br />
similar university associations, and<br />
they are confidently marching ahead<br />
as they vary the subject and scope of<br />
the events they hold. In the less than<br />
two years since the association’s establishment,<br />
the students have conducted<br />
a series of tours, in particular,<br />
presented the “NATO Night” project<br />
with the support of the NATO Information<br />
and Documentation Centre<br />
in Ukraine (Let us recall that The Day<br />
covered it in its No. 28 of May 8,<br />
2018).<br />
“We will travel today exactly<br />
100 years back in time. From now on,<br />
the only reality is that of the Ukrainian<br />
State of Hetman Skoropadsky!” the<br />
tour guide began. Although it is wrong<br />
to call this lad a tour guide, he is<br />
rather a guide into the world of Skoropadsky,<br />
a graduate of the Faculty of<br />
History and Philosophy of the University<br />
of St. Volodymyr and an ensign<br />
of the 1st Serdiuk Guard Regiment of<br />
the Ukrainian State Army.<br />
The events unfold quickly, actors<br />
unexpectedly pop out of the crowd, locations<br />
change, and red-faced visitors<br />
with enthusiastic looks run as they<br />
follow the guide in order to have time<br />
to see more. It seemed as if Bishop<br />
Nykodym had just blessed Skoropadsky<br />
in Sofiiska Square, but a moment<br />
later, people find themselves in the<br />
sanctuary. All of a sudden, everybody<br />
looks up at the belfry, from<br />
TOPIC OF THE DAY No.39 JUNE 21, 2018 5<br />
Night at St. Sophia.Hetmanate. 1918<br />
KYIV TARAS SHEVCHENKO UNIVERSITY’S HISTORY STUDENTS IN THE ROLES OF DIRECTORY LEADERS (LEFT TO RIGHT): VOLODYMYR VYNNYCHENKO, FEDIR<br />
SHVETS, SYMON PETLIURA<br />
PAVLO SKOROPADSKY AND SOFIA RUSOVA, A DEPARTMENT CHIEF AT THE<br />
HETMANATE’S MINISTRY OF EDUCATION, PLAYED BY KYIV TARAS<br />
SHEVCHENKO UNIVERSITY’S HISTORY STUDENTS<br />
where young men read out the Letter<br />
of the Illustrious Lord Hetman of All<br />
Ukraine to the Ukrainian People.<br />
There was also time for interactive<br />
experiences involving the visitors.<br />
All the present were recruited into the<br />
army and underwent a formation drill<br />
session led by a captain. In addition,<br />
anyone could hold a rifle for a time and<br />
try their hand in a saber fight. At the<br />
end of the training session, the captain<br />
named those selected for the army, and<br />
advised everyone else to work for the<br />
benefit of the Ukrainian State and the<br />
Illustrious Lord Hetman as civilians.<br />
Then the time travelers, that is,<br />
the visitors, went to Zvirynetsky Fort,<br />
where weapons and ammunition were<br />
stored during Skoropadsky’s reign. It<br />
was located on the territory of the present-day<br />
Hryshko Botanical Garden<br />
and took its name from one of the capital’s<br />
neighborhoods, called Zvirynets.<br />
The guide told them that on June 6,<br />
1918, the military depot in Zvirynets,<br />
holding 2 million shells, exploded and<br />
covered with debris Pecherskyi District,<br />
while the University of<br />
How<br />
creative<br />
history<br />
students<br />
from Kyiv<br />
have<br />
“revived”<br />
the past<br />
St. Volodymyr had even had its windows<br />
shattered by the force of the<br />
blast. Approximately 1,500 people<br />
became casualties, and 900 homes<br />
were destroyed. Panic started throughout<br />
the city, and Kyivites began to<br />
leave Kyiv in droves, thinking that the<br />
Bolsheviks had shelled it. Skoropadsky<br />
reacted instantly to this tragic event<br />
and set up a committee to assist the<br />
victims of the explosion. In addition,<br />
the residents of Kyiv actively participated<br />
in the collection of funds for the<br />
needs of the victims.<br />
“But not all people living in Kyiv<br />
were really worried about that matter.<br />
After all, speaking about the Hetmanate’s<br />
time, it is also important to<br />
understand that those people who did<br />
not imagine their life under new, revolutionary<br />
conditions were extremely<br />
pleased with this type of government.<br />
For them, the one-man government<br />
was much more understandable,”<br />
concluded the guide.<br />
A great deal of attention was also<br />
paid to the issue of autocephaly, which<br />
is now just as relevant as 100 years ago.<br />
The tour team explained to visitors that<br />
the All-Ukrainian Church Council,<br />
held in May 1918, elected Antonii, a<br />
man of outright Ukrainophobic views,<br />
as Metropolitan of Kyiv. At the same<br />
time, the All-Ukrainian Orthodox Assembly<br />
of Churches called for the convening<br />
of another council, which would<br />
consider the possibility of autocephaly.<br />
Autocephaly (that is, independence<br />
from the Moscow Patriarchate) enjoyed<br />
particular support from Skoropadsky<br />
and President of the Ukrainian<br />
State’s Council of Ministers Fedir<br />
Lyzohub. In July 1918, it was precisely<br />
St. Sophia that hosted the All-Ukrainian<br />
Church Council, which confirmed<br />
the election of Antonii as the new<br />
metropolitan, but most of the government,<br />
that is, everyone apart from<br />
Lyzohub, was not in favor of autocephaly<br />
or even mere autonomy of the<br />
Ukrainian church.<br />
The event turned out to be incredibly<br />
interesting and informative<br />
for adults as well as young members<br />
of the group, who may start wanting<br />
to become historians some day as<br />
well. Thanks to the creative students<br />
of the Night at the University Creative<br />
Association, visitors were able<br />
to “see” many of the famous figures<br />
of the time: Skoropadsky, his wife<br />
Oleksandra Skoropadska, Symon<br />
Petliura, Volodymyr Vynnychenko,<br />
Fedir Shvets, anarchist Marusia Nikiforova,<br />
actress Maria Zankovetska;<br />
join the military of the Ukrainian<br />
state; become “witnesses” of several<br />
murders and one of the attempts on<br />
the Hetman’ life, and ultimately, to<br />
touch history in person.
6<br />
No.39 JUNE 21, 2018<br />
CLOSE UP<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
By Maria PROKOPENKO, photos by<br />
Mykola TYMCHENKO, The Day<br />
“When we were making this film<br />
and, in general, watching the story of<br />
Oleh and Oleksandr, we decided to<br />
calculate the distances they ‘traveled’<br />
on the expanses of Russia. It came to<br />
a total 20,000 kilometers for both of<br />
them, a half of Earth’s circumference<br />
at the equator,” Angelina KARIAK-<br />
INA, coauthor of the film Across<br />
Half the World at Gunpoint: the Story<br />
of Sentsov’s and Kolchenko’s Imprisonment,<br />
said during the film’s<br />
premiere at the Zhovten movie theater.<br />
In addition to Angelina, Natalia<br />
Humeniuk, Anna Tsyhyma, and Natalia<br />
Kaplan, Oleh Sentsov’s first<br />
cousin, worked on the film, which is<br />
a Hromadske TV (Community Television)<br />
project.<br />
“It is not just entertaining mathematics.<br />
This confirms once more<br />
that, like, in principle, all the<br />
‘Crimean cases,’ the Sentsov and<br />
Kolchenko case is extremely important<br />
to Russia,” Angelina continues.<br />
“They wanted to punish these<br />
people cruelly for all to see. For deporting<br />
an individual beyond the<br />
Arctic Circle, where only a few days<br />
are sunny and warm, to the town you<br />
can only reach from Salekhard, if you<br />
are lucky enough, in the winter<br />
across the frozen river or, otherwise,<br />
on helicopters or motor boats,<br />
is a torture.”<br />
● WHO HELPS “THE KREMLIN’S<br />
CAPTIVES” IN RUSSIA<br />
Oleh and Sashko were arrested in<br />
Crimea in May 2014. They were tortured<br />
and then taken to Moscow’s<br />
Lefortovo pretrial jail. Then there<br />
were trials in Rostov-on-Don and<br />
conviction for terrorism – 20 years in<br />
a high security prison camp for Oleh<br />
and 10 years for Sashko. They were<br />
transported to their destinations.<br />
Sashko is serving his sentence in the<br />
Kopeysk prison camp near Chelyabinsk<br />
– not exactly a health resort. Besides,<br />
inmates had been cruelly brutalized<br />
in this camp until recently.<br />
They even staged a peaceful protest<br />
in 2012, after which the prison administration<br />
was changed and the<br />
regime was eased. Oleh was first deported<br />
to Yakutia and then it was decided<br />
to isolate him still more tightly.<br />
Since the fall of 2017, Sentsov has<br />
been serving his term at the “Polar<br />
Bear” prison camp in Labytnangi, Yamalo-Nenets<br />
Autonomous District<br />
of Russia. Oleh drew attention to<br />
himself and the rest of “the Kremlin’s<br />
captives” when he went on a<br />
hunger strike on May 14. He demands<br />
that all the Ukrainian political<br />
prisoners in Russia and Crimea<br />
(there are 70 of them, according to<br />
human rights activists) be freed.<br />
Kolchenko also went on a hunger<br />
strike on May 31 but discontinued it<br />
recently due to poor health.<br />
“I went to the Urals only, but<br />
even this struck me. We were more or<br />
less aware of where we were going.<br />
Besides, we had been to Russia before<br />
– we covered the trial in Rostov.<br />
So we expected nothing extraordinary.<br />
But it is a different thing when<br />
you know all the logistics of communicating<br />
with a political prisoner.<br />
Suffice to mention parcels, letters,<br />
visits….” Kariakina says. “We could<br />
not speak directly with Sashko<br />
Kolchenko. We came to the town,<br />
where the prison camp was located,<br />
approached and photographed it.<br />
Then Sashko’s lawyer came out to<br />
meet us. We received the letter he<br />
had just written. This struck me in<br />
purely human terms.”<br />
Both Kolchenko and Sentsov have<br />
non-public lawyers who bring and<br />
take letters, tackle certain procedural<br />
problems. “The cases of Ukrainian<br />
political prisoners may cost these<br />
people a career, so they are trying to<br />
“CONCERN OVER THE DESTINY OF OLEH, SASHKO, AND OTHER POLITICAL PRISONERS, THIS SUPPORT, MAKES US<br />
HOPE THIS HELL WILL END POSITIVELY,” OLEH SENTSOV’S COUSIN NATALIA KAPLAN SAYS<br />
“Across half the world at gunpoint”<br />
From Crimea to Yamal: Kyiv saw a film on the<br />
imprisonment of Sentsov and Kolchenko<br />
do this without too much publicity,”<br />
Angelina explains. Besides, the public<br />
regularly receives information<br />
about Kolchenko from human rights<br />
activists Tatiana and Nikolai Shchur.<br />
Earlier, when they were part of the<br />
Civic Supervisory Commission, they<br />
could even see Sashko. But the<br />
Shchurs were expelled from this commission<br />
in 2016, and they have to<br />
work through a lawyer now.<br />
● “IT IS IMPORTANT THAT<br />
THERE ARE TRUE<br />
EMOTIONS HERE”<br />
A lot of the powers-that-be, including<br />
Foreign Minister Pavlo<br />
Klimkin; Vadym Chernysh, Minister<br />
for Temporarily Occupied Territories<br />
and Domestically Displaced Persons;<br />
and Hugue Mingarelli, Head of the<br />
EU Delegation to Ukraine, came to<br />
see the film.<br />
“The film, the idea, is super. It is<br />
important that there are true emotions<br />
here. Whenever you work on<br />
this kind of subject, involve others,<br />
trying to explain to our friends what<br />
it is all about, you will never explain<br />
it rationally. And this film is an<br />
emotion,” Klimkin said after the<br />
preview. “We have agreed that, after<br />
the film is dubbed into English, we<br />
will try to ‘plug’ it not only among<br />
politicians, but also where it is in<br />
principle possible.” Incidentally, you<br />
can already watch the film Across<br />
Half the World at Gunpoint on Hromadske<br />
TV’s YouTube channel.”<br />
“It is very difficult to free<br />
Sentsov. But why only Oleh? I am always<br />
saying we should not decide on<br />
who is more important. Oleh is a<br />
unique personality. Whenever I address<br />
any audiences, I just quote a<br />
fragment from this letter – why he<br />
went on a hunger strike. When everybody<br />
hears that, in reality, he is<br />
starving not for himself but for the<br />
release of all the political prisoners<br />
and hostages, this creates an altogether<br />
different impression,” the<br />
foreign minister added.<br />
Liudmyla Denysova, the Verkhovna<br />
Rada Human Rights Ombudsperson,<br />
told journalists recently<br />
that she is planning to visit Ukrainian<br />
political prisoners in Russia and<br />
Crimea – first of all, Oleh Sentsov,<br />
Oleksandr Kolchenko, Stanislav<br />
Klykh, Mykola Karpiuk, Roman<br />
Sushchenko, and Resul Veliliaiev.<br />
“The fact that we managed to get<br />
permission for Ms. Denysova to visit<br />
our political prisoners gives us an opportunity<br />
to see our guys’ physical and<br />
psychological condition and support<br />
them in some way,” Klimkin noted. “I<br />
was trying many times to reach Oleh<br />
by phone. Once, on his birthday, there<br />
was a hope, but they canceled the call<br />
in ten minutes. In other words, such<br />
contacts are very limited – his cousin<br />
Natalia, his lawyer… But we must increase<br />
pressure on the eve of the FIFA<br />
World Cup – any pressure, be it political,<br />
media-related, human, or on the<br />
part of civil society. Russia is not indifferent<br />
to whether or not the championship<br />
will be a success. It is all too<br />
clear why Oleh chose the very moment,<br />
and we should take advantage of this<br />
moment.”<br />
● “I WILL ONLY FEEL<br />
PROGRESS WHEN MY SON<br />
IS AT HOME”<br />
Petro Vyhivskyi, the father of<br />
Valentyn Vyhivskyi who was absurdly<br />
sentenced in Russia to<br />
11 years in prison for espionage,<br />
liked the film Across Half the World<br />
at Gunpoint. He believes such films<br />
should be made about all “the Kremlin’s<br />
captives.” “The whole world<br />
knows about Sentsov and Kolchenko,<br />
but there are almost 70 more people<br />
about whom very few know. And<br />
their relatives cannot fight for them<br />
because they have no access to either<br />
the media or our governmental bodies,”<br />
Petro explains.<br />
“Valentyn is serving his sentence<br />
in Kirov Oblast, Russia. Relatives<br />
have been out of touch with him<br />
since February this year, when he was<br />
detained in what is known as ‘all-purpose<br />
cell.’ Petro Vyhivskyi does not<br />
know what for. “The Ukrainian consul<br />
visited Valentyn a little more<br />
than a month ago. My son and I were<br />
supposed to have a long meeting,<br />
but there are restrictions on visits in<br />
such cells. There are no restrictions<br />
on correspondence, but his letters are<br />
held up in the prison. The consul says<br />
he receives some of our letters, but we<br />
get none from him,” Petro says. “We<br />
will get permission for a new visit<br />
somewhere in the fall if the son does<br />
not have his stay in the ‘all-purpose<br />
cell’ extended. But this punishment<br />
is also likely to be extended for up to<br />
a year. The son used to be kept in a<br />
solitary confinement cell without<br />
restrictions, and now he is in a smaller<br />
one-man cell with all restrictions.<br />
He cannot phone home, has no TV, radio,<br />
or newspapers. Four walls,<br />
meals, sometimes a walk – and that’s<br />
all. We used to send books, but he was<br />
given none of them. He can only<br />
take some from the prison library.”<br />
Asked if he feels any progress in<br />
the question of political prisoners’ release,<br />
for there have been several<br />
international meetings on this matter<br />
since Sentsov went on a hunger<br />
strike, Vyhivskyi says: “I will feel it<br />
when my son is at home.” In conclusion,<br />
Petro called on Ukrainians not<br />
to go the FIFA World Cup in Russia.<br />
***<br />
One of the most dramatic moments<br />
in the film is when Natalia Kaplan<br />
is standing behind the fence<br />
near the prison camp in Labytnangi.<br />
Sentsov’s cousin muses that it is impossible<br />
to pull him from captivity,<br />
although he is just a few hundred meters<br />
away. And it does not matter<br />
what distance separates them –<br />
10,000 kilometers or these meters.<br />
“This makes it clear what captivity,<br />
especially undeserved one, really is,”<br />
Kariakina says.<br />
Incidentally, funds were being<br />
raised during the Zhovten preview for<br />
the families of Ukrainian political<br />
prisoners. About 19,000 hryvnias<br />
were collected – almost as many as the<br />
kilometers Sentsov and Kolchenko<br />
“traveled” at gunpoint. You can also<br />
support the relatives of “the Kremlin’s<br />
captives” by remitting funds in<br />
line with the following details:<br />
EDRPOU (Unified State Register<br />
of Enterprises and Organizations of<br />
Ukraine) code: 41757119<br />
Recipient: charitable foundation<br />
“Relatives of the Kremlin’s Political<br />
Prisoners”<br />
Settlement account: 26006300032429<br />
MFO (sort code) of bank: 322669
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
CULT URE No.39 JUNE 21, 2018 7<br />
By Dmytro DESIATERYK, The Day<br />
We hope that this text by<br />
Dmytro Desiateryk will<br />
launch a thorough discussion<br />
about what exactly can<br />
be considered a product of<br />
Ukrainian culture. For example, is the<br />
“Ukrainianness” of a cultural product<br />
influenced by the language in which it was<br />
created? After all, there is still no<br />
consensus on this matter, just like before.<br />
Even if the answer is available, it is a<br />
multi-layered one... We call on you, dear<br />
readers, to join the conversation.<br />
It is unrealized, since a question that<br />
should not have arisen anymore is appearing<br />
again.<br />
● THE QUESTION<br />
So, it surfaces time and again, even if,<br />
fortunately, not as often as before: is Muratova<br />
a Ukrainian filmmaker?<br />
Overall, if the creator lives on the<br />
territory of Ukraine, shoots films at the expense<br />
of the Ukrainian budget with Ukrainian<br />
actors, there is nothing left to discuss.<br />
But, apparently, this is not enough to<br />
satisfy some of the most enthusiastic<br />
guards of the national culture’s purity.<br />
For example, Muratova is blamed for<br />
making Russian-language films.<br />
Oh well.<br />
When I go to a market near my house,<br />
I pass by an agitation tent of the National<br />
Corps. I have never heard from the<br />
youths standing there (there is a whole<br />
brigade of them) and distributing newspapers<br />
of that organization as much as<br />
one word in Ukrainian.<br />
Language is a means of communication.<br />
A tool. A form. With it, one can get<br />
completely different results, do entirely<br />
different things.<br />
One can, for example, praise the<br />
Russian Empire, promote the Kremlin order,<br />
and lie on the TV.<br />
One can also give combat orders in the<br />
same language as one is fighting separatists<br />
in the Donbas.<br />
Viktor Yanukovych spoke fluent<br />
Ukrainian, and it is no less fluent when<br />
coming from supporters of the approach<br />
“things are not so clearcut” and “stop the<br />
fratricidal war in eastern Ukraine” (yes,<br />
yes, they do exist, and there are not as few<br />
of them as we would like).<br />
Is Myroslav Slaboshpytskyi’s multiple-award-winning<br />
film The Tribe less<br />
Ukrainian because its characters communicate<br />
in a sign language alone? Why<br />
is Oleksandr Dovzhenko’s silent film trilogy<br />
Zvenigora – Arsenal – Earth called<br />
“Ukrainian”? Should the Russian-language<br />
film Donbass by Serhii Loznytsia,<br />
which voluminously and meticulously<br />
shows how the “Russian World” cripples<br />
the occupied territories, be removed from<br />
our cinema tradition? Does Lars von Trier<br />
stop being a Danish director, and Wim<br />
Wenders a German one, because they<br />
both regularly film in English?<br />
For everyone but civil servants, it is<br />
not the language of communication that is<br />
important, but what people say in that language<br />
and with what consequences.<br />
● AN ANALYTICAL<br />
DIGRESSION<br />
Muratova’s penultimate film,<br />
Melody for a Street Organ (2009), is an<br />
ideal example of Ukrainian content of her<br />
films. Thus, it is worthwhile to cover it<br />
in more detail.<br />
After the death of their mother, Olenka<br />
(Olena Kostiuk) and Mykyta (Roman<br />
Burlaka) set out on Christmas Eve to find<br />
their parents. Evicted and robbed everywhere,<br />
frozen and hungry, they pass<br />
through all levels of urban chaos, from the<br />
railway station through a casino, an auction<br />
house and entrances of apartment<br />
buildings to a supermarket with its festive<br />
atmosphere, only to finally lose each other:<br />
Olenka is detained for stealing bread,<br />
while Mykyta freezes to death in the attic<br />
of a house which is being rebuilt.<br />
Let us start, actually, with the language.<br />
Among other components of the<br />
polyphony of the film, one of the most interesting<br />
is the unprecedented, for Muratova,<br />
emphasis on Ukrainian. At first,<br />
World after Kira:<br />
by 18 films better<br />
Now, when Kira Muratova is gone, one<br />
starts sensing the true scale of this<br />
figure, which seems to be still unrealized<br />
the children observe a mummers’ procession<br />
on a suburban train, with its participants<br />
carrying an octagonal star and<br />
singing Christmas carol “Good Evening to<br />
You.” Then, a station bum (Nina Ruslanova),<br />
just as rejected and persecuted as<br />
Olenka and Mykyta, explodes with a long<br />
monolog: “Our Bethlehem is full of poor,<br />
barefoot people in tattered clothes! Where<br />
are the Magi? They are carrying gold to the<br />
rich...” The foreman of the builders who<br />
found the body of Mykyta had berated his<br />
employer who did not give him a well-deserved<br />
leave and failed to pay the wages on<br />
time, and he tells his story in Ukrainian,<br />
but reproduces replies of the absent miser<br />
in a high disgusting voice speaking Russian.<br />
Finally, after a terrible discovery in the<br />
attic, the credits are accompanied by New<br />
Year carol “The Little Swallow.”<br />
A closer examination reveals that besides<br />
Ukrainian speakers, the film features<br />
Russian speakers of the same class,<br />
and there is neither social nor characteristic<br />
difference between the two groups:<br />
the ornately-speaking madman in a knitted<br />
cap, who watches on as Olenka and<br />
Mykyta are robbed by homeless in a railway<br />
hangar, a veteran who strives to get<br />
into the high comfort room as if he was assaulting<br />
the Reichstag, elderly Zoia,<br />
standing on the snow-covered stairs in the<br />
city at night, who loves “apples, cherries,<br />
sweet cherries, strawberries, grapes,”<br />
and others. All of them sing songs on the<br />
roadsides of a Babylon formed by mixing<br />
Odesa and Kyiv, making up the general<br />
polyphony of the poor who will eventually<br />
enter the promised Kingdom.<br />
There is, however, another element of<br />
Ukrainianness that will help us understand<br />
the structure of the film.<br />
The procession in the train is a simplified<br />
version of the vertep, the folk puppet<br />
theater. In today’s Ukraine, companies<br />
with stars, in simply decorated costumes,<br />
with a minimal repertoire of songs<br />
perform predominantly to earn money<br />
and foodstuffs for celebration (the vagrant<br />
played by Ruslanova complains,<br />
among other things, that “they even do<br />
not let me join a vertep company”). But<br />
now we are talking about a much older<br />
genre, namely the vertep drama.<br />
It necessarily includes two planes of<br />
the narrative: the biblical story of the<br />
birth of Christ and semi-improvised scenes<br />
featuring recognizable types: the Gypsy<br />
Man and Gypsy Woman, the Zaporozhian<br />
Cossack, the Pole, the Muscovite, and the<br />
Jew. Herod, who seeks to kill the newborn<br />
Christ, is the key antihero, but Death<br />
eventually takes away the wicked king. The<br />
architecture of the vertep chest recreated<br />
this duality of sacred and earthly. The secular<br />
life unfolded in the lower part; meanwhile,<br />
the upper level, depicting the Bethlehem<br />
Cave, hosted only canon plots, including<br />
the Adoration of the Shepherds and<br />
the Gifts of the Magi.<br />
The puppets and theatrical performance,<br />
sufferings of children, religious rituals,<br />
and social inequality – all of these<br />
long-standing motifs of Muratova’s cinema<br />
oeuvre – are linked into a single whole<br />
by the vertep. Here all the key elements of<br />
the vertep performance are observed: the<br />
earthy bustle at the bottom, social plane;<br />
characters change in the string of tragicomic<br />
scenes; the large number of characters<br />
also does not contradict the paradigm<br />
of the vertep, which shows primarily<br />
figures of the viewer’s own period; numerous<br />
songs, monologs, sermons; there is<br />
also a superior (literally top) part where the<br />
child calms down on the bed; builders, acting<br />
as shepherds, come to him and freeze<br />
in a mise en scene which resembles the<br />
iconography of adoration because of its<br />
static nature and poses of the participants;<br />
there are even fully matching characters:<br />
the Gypsies at the station (they refuse<br />
to tell Mykyta’s fortune, only saying<br />
“Oh, poor lad!”), the beggars (the vertep’s<br />
Savochka the Beggar), the supermarket<br />
guards, persecutors of children, who push<br />
Mykyta out, to be tormented by underage<br />
criminals, and arrest Olenka. All this suggests<br />
that the procession in the beginning<br />
of the film marks the notional border, on<br />
crossing which Olenka and Mykyta find<br />
themselves, in a sense, inside the vertep,<br />
and bring it into action. At the same time,<br />
the canon scenes are immediately introduced<br />
by a traveling seller of holiday<br />
cards: the Magi and Shepherds, the Holy<br />
Family, and King Herod’s Soldiers Massacring<br />
the Infants. It is the last card that<br />
is picked up by Mykyta, as he chooses his<br />
own story and fate.<br />
Having introduced the vertep structure,<br />
Muratova subjects it to deconstruction<br />
with the same determination as<br />
the linear plot of her anti-fairy-tale. The<br />
lower boundaries of the puppet house<br />
have greatly expanded. Instead of a chorus,<br />
we listen to a collective aphasia of mobile-equipped<br />
banterers at the station. The<br />
sacred part is reduced to verses and inappropriate<br />
sermons. There are “shepherds,”<br />
but they have no words of respect,<br />
only swearing at the miserly employer and<br />
nervously hiccupping in the attic. The<br />
heavens are empty. The upper level is involved<br />
only in the final, where the place<br />
of the living infant Christ is taken by the<br />
dead – in essence, killed – little kid, also<br />
the son of a carpenter. Herod is removed<br />
from the frame (to the auditorium?), as<br />
the massacre of the young and defenseless<br />
will happen just fine without him. God is<br />
absent, but Christmas preparations continue.<br />
What should have become the beginning<br />
of history becomes the end.<br />
The Christian space is timeless, simultaneous:<br />
he who lies in the Bethlehem<br />
Cave, is immediately crucified. The one<br />
who froze to death in the attic is an innocent<br />
victim just as much. This also reflects<br />
the logic of the vertep, which, according to<br />
the observation of the Russian scholar<br />
Olga Freidenberg, is genetically linked to<br />
the temple box, which was a copy of the<br />
tomb and the temple alike: in both cases,<br />
the dead man and the (puppet-like) godhead<br />
were always placed atop of it and/or on a<br />
special raised platform.<br />
Thus, redefining the vertep drama,<br />
Muratova does not “steal Christmas” – she<br />
just reproduces its other side, diametrically<br />
opposed to the festive pathos. Thus, she recovers<br />
its initial tragic nature.<br />
● EUROPE<br />
In view of the above, it seems that the<br />
question of the territorial affiliation of<br />
Muratova’s directing legacy comes from<br />
a wrong context. First one should ask:<br />
what is Ukraine?<br />
The answer has been obvious for the<br />
last four years: Ukraine is Europe.<br />
This answer has been bought with<br />
blood. Vladimir Putin did not forgive us<br />
this answer, and took revenge by occupying<br />
20 percent of our territory. To oppose<br />
it means to endanger our own future.<br />
So, again: Ukraine is Europe. But<br />
Muratova really was a European director.<br />
On the one hand, the Ukrainianness<br />
means joy of life and seeking delight in the<br />
transient (the classic example is the poem<br />
“A Cherry Orchard by the House”). On the<br />
other hand, it also means rejecting any<br />
leaders and having constant doubts in authorities<br />
and authoritative ideas. Love<br />
for a heated discussion (famously described<br />
as “three hetmans out of two<br />
Ukrainians”). Anarchy as a principle of solidarity<br />
and protest. Indestructible sense of<br />
humor. In aesthetics, it includes the rejection<br />
of imperial literature-centrism in<br />
favor of visual richness and looking at the<br />
world with wide-open eyes (it was not for<br />
nothing that in the autonomous Ukraine of<br />
the 17th and 18th centuries, not yet completely<br />
subjugated by Russia, it was the<br />
fine arts that flourished: painting, architecture,<br />
theater).<br />
And all these are characteristic properties<br />
of Muratova’s cinema oeuvre. Her<br />
films are appropriately witty at every degree<br />
of dramatic tension. Her characters<br />
always hold fast to their beliefs. Even<br />
episodic and secondary characters have<br />
colorful, sometimes to the point of eccentricity,<br />
tempers, whether it is a station<br />
employee or a rich criminal; conflicts<br />
and quarrels between them are always<br />
brilliant mini-performances with almost<br />
musical rhythm (Two in One even takes<br />
place in a theater). She did not stage her<br />
performances, because she masterly organized<br />
them in the frame. The frame itself<br />
is always saturated with movement<br />
and at the same time features mass of details,<br />
which seem to have no direct relation<br />
to the plot, but constitute the atmosphere<br />
of what is happening – this is<br />
always a perfect multilevel Baroque composition;<br />
and the Baroque, in turn, is the<br />
basic constant of the Ukrainian cultural<br />
universe.<br />
The main thing, however, is that Muratova<br />
had that skeptical, sober, Cartesian<br />
mind, but it was not cold; no director of her<br />
time exhibited such a deep sympathy for<br />
the weakest and most vulnerable. Moreover,<br />
there is no trace of nagging moralization,<br />
inherent in even the best Soviet or<br />
Russian cinema works. This wonderful<br />
skepticism also colored her personal communication,<br />
and, of course, her films.<br />
So, I will repeat: she made European<br />
cinema here long before Ukraine began to<br />
realize itself as Europe. As often happens<br />
with great artists, Muratova came too early.<br />
Only now we are catching up with her.<br />
So, Ukraine has to do its share of the<br />
work. We have not published a thorough<br />
study of Muratova’s oeuvre, despite the<br />
fact that Russians published two monographs<br />
in her lifetime. This is only the<br />
first step: to publish such a book, well<br />
written and illustrated, which would be<br />
obligatory addition to the bookshelf of<br />
any cultured person. In the future, we also<br />
need to publish her collected works. A<br />
museum doubling as an artistic center.<br />
Possibly a festival named after her. It is<br />
necessary to start now.<br />
Muratova made our world by 18 films<br />
better. We are indebted to her.
8<br />
No.39 JUNE 21, 2018<br />
TIMEO U T<br />
WWW.DAY.KIEV.UA<br />
By Natalia ISHCHENKO<br />
Photos by Ruslan KANIUKA, The Day<br />
War is nearby<br />
Twenty silhouettes of bullet-ridden<br />
people on Kyiv’s streets:<br />
about Oles KROMPLIAS’s project<br />
Itwas mid-June 2014. Ukrainian<br />
troops, with volunteer battalions in<br />
the vanguard, were liberating Ukrainian<br />
cities from pro-Russian and<br />
Russian militants. Mariupol, Shchastia...<br />
It seemed that we had to wait just a<br />
little before we liberate Donetsk and<br />
Luhansk, and recover the entire Donbas...<br />
Then, four years ago, a dedicated and<br />
determined volunteer named Oles Kromplias<br />
was in the thick of events. It was his<br />
unit that liberated Mariupol. Kromplias<br />
recorded all the events on a unique film<br />
camera and wrote artistic reports... for the<br />
glamorous men’s magazine Esquire, which<br />
then appeared in Ukrainian as well.<br />
A successful marketing communications<br />
specialist, he became an activist of<br />
the Euromaidan who participated in all significant<br />
events and photographed everything.<br />
His pictures were included in the<br />
symbolic collection called The 50 Best<br />
Photos of the Revolution of Dignity.<br />
Then Kromplias tried to help defend<br />
Ukrainian Crimea, and he went to the<br />
peninsula at the very beginning of Russian<br />
occupation with several activists and<br />
journalists. They were captured, and<br />
Kromplias and his friends were tortured<br />
and mistreated for a few days. Ukraine was<br />
able to get their group released then. Upon<br />
his return, the former marketer and<br />
protester volunteered for the front.<br />
It was the latter half of June 2014. In<br />
Mariupol, Ukrainian flags were already flying,<br />
and our boys were getting ready to go<br />
further... Kromplias recorded moments<br />
from the lives of his brothers-in-arms.<br />
Here they are shown cooking a lunch,<br />
there they are sunbathing, while another<br />
photo shows them anxiously standing<br />
watch... The pictures show soldiers of the<br />
Azov Regiment, the Sea of Azov, the sun,<br />
and the expectation that the war would end<br />
in a few days, and all the boys would return<br />
to their peaceful occupations.<br />
The atmosphere of the summer of<br />
2014 seems to have been conveyed best precisely<br />
in Kromplias’s works. He has managed<br />
to capture the mood of fighters who<br />
are preparing for something unknown,<br />
perhaps difficult and terrible, but that<br />
which will last for a very short time and<br />
surely end with our victory.<br />
Kromplias’s photos show combat<br />
episodes as well – separatists taken prisoner,<br />
a killed Ukrainian soldier’s body<br />
being carried on a stretcher covered<br />
with a Ukrainian flag... But it is not<br />
June and Mariupol, but rather the beginning<br />
of August and the early stage of<br />
the Battle for Ilovaisk.<br />
In this cycle, the most striking picture<br />
is one showing our boys just lying on the<br />
grass before yet another forced march. It<br />
is impossible to restrain tears when you<br />
clearly realize that they all were still alive<br />
in those days. It was before that direct attack<br />
of Russian regular troops, before the<br />
bloody “green corridor,” and before hundreds<br />
of our boys were treacherously shot<br />
dead by a ‘fraternal people.’<br />
But four years is a long time. When<br />
visiting Kromplias’s photo exhibition<br />
“Front Line,” held within the framework<br />
of the “War Is Nearby” project in<br />
June 2018, all these images are perceived<br />
quite differently than in the fall of<br />
2014, when the author first printed them<br />
out on returning to Kyiv after suffering<br />
a concussion. Today, the war has become<br />
part of our lives. And, although the project<br />
is called “War Is Nearby,” we feel that<br />
the war is already within ourselves.<br />
Still, there are probably other people<br />
for whom the reality in which Russian aggression<br />
is being unleashed on Ukraine has<br />
been too heavy to recognize. It is for them,<br />
in fact, that the project “War Is Nearby”<br />
has been launched. The photo exhibition<br />
“Front Line” and installations on the<br />
streets of Kyiv are elements of it.<br />
Kromplias considers the “War Is<br />
Nearby” project to be part of an information<br />
warfare campaign. This is the<br />
case, but no less important is another aspect<br />
– not only an outwardly directed anti-aggressor<br />
message, but also a call directed<br />
inside us, which should awaken a<br />
“sense of war” within us.<br />
A total of 20 silhouettes of people<br />
shot through with bullets – both soldiers<br />
and civilians, and even children –<br />
are located on the streets of the capital in<br />
places where, according to Kromplias,<br />
people are not ready to see them. It will remind<br />
Kyivites and guests of the city<br />
about the Donbas, about the fighting,<br />
about those who died at the hands of the<br />
aggressor, and new names are added to<br />
the list with every passing day...<br />
But if you, having looked at this<br />
part of the project, will then visit the photo<br />
exhibition, which is displayed at the<br />
Transformer Center in Velyka Zhytomyrska<br />
Street in downtown Kyiv, you<br />
will be surprised, for you will not be<br />
scared there. It only diplomatically reminds<br />
the visitor that the front is close,<br />
much closer than it seems to you.<br />
Kromplias’s pictures show the war’s<br />
light version, a war that is not shocking.<br />
It seems almost like peaceful life. The only<br />
difference is that there, at the front,<br />
people die more frequently, but they always<br />
die as heroes.<br />
The exhibition can safely be visited<br />
by people who are very far from the<br />
front reality. They will be able to read interesting<br />
stories under each photo, view<br />
beautiful, high-quality pictures, and go<br />
away, for example, to the nearest popular<br />
and fashionable bar.<br />
It is a paradox, but Kromplias’s works<br />
do not conflict with the glamour of peaceful<br />
life. They complement the glamorous<br />
reality with their own war zone truth. They<br />
say: “See, these guys have chosen to be heroes.<br />
And you can go on to keep living your<br />
own, non-heroic lives. However, you should<br />
understand that if you are not heroes<br />
yourselves, you have to support heroes as<br />
much as possible. Because the war is nearby.<br />
Much closer than it seems to you.”<br />
UKRAINIAN NEWS IN ENGLISH<br />
www.day.kiev.ua incognita.day.kiev.ua<br />
FOUNDER AND PUBLISHER:<br />
UKRAINIAN PRESS GROUP LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY<br />
Published since May 27, 1998.<br />
Свiдоцтво про перереєстрацiю КВ № 21448-11248 ПР<br />
вiд 27 липня 2015 року<br />
Larysa Ivshyna, Editor-in-Chief, Den<br />
e-mail: chedit@day.kiev.ua<br />
Hanna Sheremet, Deputy Editor-in-Chief<br />
Anna Mazurenko, Director,<br />
Ukrainian Press Group LLC<br />
Anna Motoziuk, Editor,<br />
English Language Bureau<br />
Olha Pavliei, Technical Editor<br />
Borys Honcharov, George Skliar, Taras Shulha,<br />
Nadia Sysiuk, Translators<br />
Maryna Khyzhniakova, Proofreader<br />
Viktoria Demchenko, Designer<br />
Alla Bober, Responsible Secretary<br />
Mykola Tymchenko, Photography Editor<br />
Mailing address: prosp. Peremohy, 121d, Kyiv 03115, Ukraine<br />
Telephone: +38(044) 303-96-19<br />
Fax: +38(044) 303-94-20<br />
Advertising: +38(044) 303-96-20; e-mail: ra@day.kiev.ua<br />
Subscriptions: +38(044) 303-96-23; e-mail: amir@day.kiev.ua<br />
E-mail: time@day.kiev.ua<br />
Subscription index: 40032<br />
Ukrainian Press Group LLC<br />
Code 24249388<br />
Raiffeisen Bank joint-stock company<br />
MFO 380805<br />
A/С 26007478064<br />
Responsibility for the accuracy of facts, quotations, personal names, and other information is borne by the authors of publications and in advertising<br />
materials by the advertiser. The views expressed in signed articles do not necessarily reflect those of the editors. Submitted materials are not returned<br />
and not reviewed. The editors retain the right to edit materials. When citing Day materials, reference to The Day is mandatory. ©Den.