09.03.2021 Views

The Greek Revolution, A Critical Dictionary, Paschalis M. Kitromilides, Constantinos Tsoukalas, March 25, 2021

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Introduction 4

articulated amid intense ideological conflict in the two de cades leading up to

the revolution (Brinton 1952, 72–74). Once the uprising was set in motion in

the Morea and Rumeli, the revolutionary dynamic of peasant society helped

spread the insurrection in those regions. This illustrates the classic analy sis of

the “revolution from below” in the historical sociology of revolutions by Barrington

Moore, Jr., and later Theda Skocpol. Moore’s comparison of England

and France on the question of peasant society and its significance for the prospects

of revolution is relevant in the consideration of the Greek case: the integrity

of peasant society in the Morea, Rumeli, Crete, and elsewhere in the Greek

lands can explain how the revolution found its necessary social bases in those

regions, survived once it broke out, and persisted amid the civil wars and other

adversities of the revolutionary de cade.

The Greek Revolution can also be interpreted through the lens of two theoretical

approaches that elaborate on Alexis de Tocqueville’s idea of the revolution

of rising expectations, which points out that revolutions come not when

things are at their worst, but rather when they are on the road to improvement,

encouraging unrealistic expectations. The resulting disappointment leads

people to resort to vio lence and revolution. In Tocqueville’s diagnosis, this

was what led to the French Revolution. James Davies and Ted Gurr expanded

on this theory in their own analyses of revolution, which traced the origins of

revolutionary action to discontent resulting from a contraction in well- being

following a period of improvement and to a sense of relative deprivation,

respectively.

Although these theories were based on evidence provided by changing societies

in the twentieth century, they could be tested on the basis of the historical

rec ord provided by the Greek Revolution. It should be remembered that the

revolution came to the Greek world after a long period of social and cultural

change in the eigh teenth century and remarkable economic development during

in the Napoleonic wars and the continental blockade. When all this came to

an end after 1815, the disappointment of rising expectations created a climate

of discontent that made pos si ble the work of the Philiki Etaireia, the secret society

founded in 1814 with the intention to prepare the revolution, as explained

by C. Chatzopoulos in this volume.

The social- psychological perspective on the Greek Revolution could be

greatly enriched by considering Moore’s later work on the significance of the

sense of injustice and the moral outrage resulting from it (Moore 1978). Such

feelings may motivate re sis tance and revolutionary action. The lit er a ture of the

Greek version of the radical demo cratic Enlightenment both before and during

the course of the Greek Revolution, is replete with examples of how the sense

of injustice experienced by Greeks with an enhanced awareness of the condi-

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!