James McKeen Cattell, Nicholas Murray Butler, and Academic ...

122 SOKAL
216. Pine’s handwritten notes of his meeting with Hayes, 30 September 1921,
Hayes to Pine, 7 October 1921, Pine collection; Hayes to JMC, 30 September 1921, JMC
papers, LoC.
217. JMC to W. M. Parsons, 31 October 1921, Pine collection.
218. Hayes initially refunded all that Cattell had paid him, but he finally agreed to
accept $1,000 from Cattell. See Hayes to JMC, 7 October 1921, 14 October 1921, 2
February 1922, 15 February 1922, JMC to Hayes, 12 October 1921, JMC papers, LoC.
219. Samuel Untermyer to JMC, 8 October 1921, 18 October 1921, 26 October
1921, JMC to Untermyer, 12 October 1921, 21 October 1921, JMC papers, LoC.
220. JMC to Harlan F. Stone, 11 November 1921, 2 January 1922, 5 January 1922,
8 February 1922, Stone to JMC, 10 December 1921, 12 December 1921, 13 December
1921, 7 February 1922, JMC papers, LoC; Stone to NMB, 10 October 1921, Stone to
Parsons, 17 November 1921, Pine collection.
221. Supreme Court, County of New York, “J. McKeen Cattell, Plaintiff, against
The Trustees of Columbia University in the City of New York, Defendant,” Order and
Stipulation, 10 February 1923; JMC to “the Trustees of Columbia University,” 25
February 1922, Pine collection.
222. Sokal, “The Origins of The Psychological Corporation,” Journal of the History
of the Behavioral Sciences 17 (1981): 54–67.
223. JMC to Parsons, 31 October 1921, JMC to “the Trustees of Columbia University,”
25 February 1922, Pine collection.
224. “Columbia Settles Dr. Cattell’s Suit,” New York Times, 8 February 1922, p. 16;
“Cattell Criticises President Butler: ‘Simply a Bargain and that Was All,’ He Says of
Settlement of Libel Suit,” New York Times, 9 February 1922, p. 8; “Cattell Drops Suits
Against Columbia” undated and unidentified clipping, JMC papers, LoC.
225. JMC, “Letters of the Trustees on Columbia University,” 15 March 1922,” JMC
papers; JMC to Tyler, 8 April 1922, 13 April 1922, Tyler to, JMC, 10 April 1922, Edward
Capps to Tyler, 21 April 1922, 23 April 1922, 27 April 1922, 9 May 1922, Lovejoy to
Capps, 24 April 1922, Henry Crew to Tyler, 27 April 1922, Tyler to Capps, 29 April 1922,
AAUP Archives; “Columbia University vs. Professor Cattell, AAUP Bulletin 8 (1922):
433–453.
226. JMC, “The American Association of University Professors vs. Mr. Cattell,”
unpublished draft statement, JMC papers, LoC. Cf. Cattell’s 1883 graduate student
complaint in his private journal about Johns Hopkins president Daniel Coit Gilman: He
“has not taken as much interest in me, as he might have done.” See Sokal, An Education
in Psychology, p.24.
227. Clarence Karier, “Making the World Safe for Democracy: An Historical
Critique of John Dewey’s Pragmatic Liberal Philosophy in the Warfare State,” Educational
Theory 27: 12–47. See also Alan Cywar, “John Dewey in World War I: Patriotism
and International Progressivism,” American Quarterly 21 (1969): 578–594, 1977.
Received December 17, 2008
Revision received March 31, 2009
Accepted April 13, 2009 y