21.02.2013 Views

Untitled - Istituto di Storia dell'Europa Mediterranea - Cnr

Untitled - Istituto di Storia dell'Europa Mediterranea - Cnr

Untitled - Istituto di Storia dell'Europa Mediterranea - Cnr

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

20<br />

Little Do We Know. History and Historians<br />

<strong>di</strong>spute involving Governor Frontenac and the Recollets, and relies on<br />

dated secondary literature. Similar flaws, albeit of minor significance,<br />

are present in Rostkowski's study, who is much more balanced in the<br />

treatment of her main thesis, that is, the fact that a general spread of<br />

Christianity among aboriginal peoples <strong>di</strong>d not imply outright<br />

conversion (Ch. 19).<br />

Co<strong>di</strong>gnola's review of scholarship does not only highlight flaws.<br />

Part II also celebrates the strengths of some underrated historical<br />

works, and encourages us to place them in their historiographical<br />

context. For example, Co<strong>di</strong>gnola shows how Aventuries de la Mission,<br />

by Henry Koren, CSSp (Ch. 15), a somewhat hagiographical account<br />

of the Spiritan missionaries in the Americas, should be valued for its<br />

foray into new primary research. Likewise, Co<strong>di</strong>gnola applauds<br />

Eccles's interpretation of the role of the Catholic Church in New<br />

France (Ch. 17) for its original approach that avoided the providential<br />

view of most French-Cana<strong>di</strong>an historians and the whiggish<br />

interpretation of the English-speaking ones. As for more recent<br />

historiography, Co<strong>di</strong>gnola admires Cana<strong>di</strong>an historians Terrence M.<br />

Murphy and Roberto Perin's Concise History of Christianity in<br />

Canada (Ch. 18), an innovative and intensive treatment of a<br />

tra<strong>di</strong>tional topic that has not been surpassed to this day. Co<strong>di</strong>gnola<br />

suggests that this volume should serve as a model for a similar study<br />

of the United States.<br />

Part III, European Expansion and the Atlantic World, engages with<br />

the enduring historiographical debates on European expansion into the<br />

Atlantic world, or Atlantic history, as this field of investigation is now<br />

commonly described. In a short essay (Ch. 20), originally published<br />

side by side with another short essay by Atlantic historian John G.<br />

Reid, Co<strong>di</strong>gnola elaborates on an idea that had characterized his work<br />

at least since the early 1980s – well before Atlantic history had<br />

become fashionable. 8 Accor<strong>di</strong>ng to him, from the late fifteenth<br />

8 Co<strong>di</strong>gnola, "A World yet to be Conquered. Pacifique de Provins and the Atlantic<br />

World, 1629-1648," in Canada ieri e oggi. Atti del 6° Convegno Internazionale <strong>di</strong><br />

Stu<strong>di</strong> Canadesi. Selva <strong>di</strong> Fasano, 27-31 marzo 1985, III: Sezione storica e<br />

geografica, ed. Co<strong>di</strong>gnola and Raimondo Luraghi (Fasano: Schena, 1986), 59-84;

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!