Lessons Not Learned - The Innocence Project
Lessons Not Learned - The Innocence Project
Lessons Not Learned - The Innocence Project
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
APPenDIx A<br />
and if it was still available for testing. <strong>The</strong> kit was unearthed and, with<br />
the cooperation of the Richmond County District Attorney’s Office,<br />
sent to the Office of the Medical Examiner of the City of New York.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Medical Examiner’s Office inspected and inventoried the evidence<br />
before shipping it to Forensic Science Associates.<br />
FSA found male DNA in the swabs taken from the bite mark as well as<br />
in the fingernail scrapings. Significantly, the male DNA profiles from<br />
both samples matched each other. James O’Donnell was excluded as<br />
the contributor of this male DNA, thus proving that he did not bite<br />
the victim nor was scratched by her. He could not have been her assailant.<br />
Based on the results of DNA testing, the District Attorney’s Office<br />
agreed to release O’Donnell in April 2000. Replicate testing was<br />
conducted by the Medical Examiner’s Office later that year with the<br />
same results. In December 2000, O’Donnell’s conviction was formally<br />
vacated.<br />
8. Hector Gonzalez – Brooklyn<br />
Convicted in 1996 of a murder that happened in 1995<br />
Sentenced to 15 years to life<br />
Age at conviction: 18<br />
Served 5.5 years; exonerated in 2002<br />
Factors leading to wrongful conviction: eyewitness misidentification<br />
Hector Gonzalez was arrested in December of 1995 and charged with<br />
murder. More than five years later, DNA testing proved crucial in<br />
establishing his innocence and securing his release.<br />
<strong>The</strong> victim was killed during a fight outside of a night club. At trial,<br />
prosecutors presented one eyewitness that placed Gonzalez at the<br />
scene of the fight but the witness did not identify him as the killer.<br />
Serological testing revealed six blood stains on Gonzalez’s pants. Five<br />
of those stains revealed a blood group marker that is shared by more<br />
than half of the population of New York City. On this evidence, Gonzalez<br />
was convicted and sentenced to fifteen years to life in prison.<br />
A subsequent investigation by the United States Attorney’s Office of<br />
the Eastern District into the activities of the Latin Kings, including<br />
this murder, produced testimony that Gonzalez was not involved in<br />
47