Lessons Not Learned - The Innocence Project
Lessons Not Learned - The Innocence Project
Lessons Not Learned - The Innocence Project
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
sexually assaulted. However, serology tests to determine the semen<br />
donor’s blood type were never performed.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Nassau County Police Department was under enormous pressure<br />
to solve this crime, particularly since there had been several other<br />
disappearances of young girls in the area in recent years. Kogut,<br />
Halstead, and Restivo were all initially interrogated as part of an investigation<br />
into the disappearance of another girl, before the police<br />
changed their focus to this rape and murder.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Confession<br />
After 3 polygraph examinations, detectives began to focus on Kogut<br />
as a suspect in the rape and murder. Kogut, though he was told that<br />
he failed the polygraph, continued to maintain his innocence. After<br />
nearly 18 hours of interrogation, however, the police produced<br />
a confession from Kogut. <strong>The</strong> confession was hand written by the<br />
interrogating officer for Kogut’s signature, allegedly after five other<br />
versions of the confession that were never transcribed. Kogut was<br />
then taken to the crime scene. He could not point the police to<br />
any evidence from the crime that was missing, such as the victim’s<br />
clothes, jewelry, or murder weapon. <strong>The</strong> next day, the confession was<br />
recorded on video tape. It contained no details that were not previously<br />
known by law enforcement.<br />
According to the confession, Restivo, Halstead, and Kogut were all in<br />
Restivo’s van. <strong>The</strong>y approached the victim, who was on foot, and she<br />
entered the van voluntarily. When the victim demanded to be let out<br />
of the van, she was stopped, stripped, and raped by Halstead and Restivo.<br />
<strong>The</strong>y drove to a cemetery, where the victim was taken out of the<br />
van and Kogut strangled her with a piece of rope. <strong>The</strong> victim’s body<br />
was then rolled into a blanket and dumped in another location.<br />
Based on the confession, investigators procured a warrant to search<br />
Restivo’s van. <strong>The</strong>y claimed they found two hairs in the van that were<br />
microscopically similar to the victim’s, including indications of chemical<br />
treatment.<br />
<strong>The</strong> Trials<br />
At trial, prosecutors argued that the hairs found in Restivo’s van<br />
provided corroboration of the confession, and all three men were<br />
tried for rape and murder. All three men denied having anything to<br />
do with the abduction, rape, or murder and offered separate alibi<br />
58 THe InnoCenCe PRoJeCT