12.04.2013 Views

UCB SA - BNP Paribas Fortis

UCB SA - BNP Paribas Fortis

UCB SA - BNP Paribas Fortis

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

Create successful ePaper yourself

Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.

(k) Challenges to the domination and profit transfer agreement between <strong>UCB</strong> SP GmbH and Schwarz<br />

Pharma<br />

After the acquisition of the majority of shares in Schwarz Pharma by <strong>UCB</strong> SP GmbH in December 2006<br />

and the adoption of a domination and profit transfer agreement (“DPTA”) between <strong>UCB</strong> SP GmbH and<br />

Schwarz Pharma by the general shareholder’s meeting of Schwarz Pharma in May 2007, sixteen<br />

minority shareholders of Schwarz Pharma filed challenge actions against the respective shareholder’s<br />

resolution with the District Court of Düsseldorf in Germany.<br />

In order to receive an early registration of the DPTA in the commercial registry of the company and<br />

therefore to make the DPTA effective despite the pending challenge actions described above, Schwarz<br />

Pharma, as a counter motion, filed for a proceeding for early registration (“Freigabeverfahren”) with the<br />

District Court of Düsseldorf, which decided in favor of Schwarz Pharma on 30 April 2008. An appeal<br />

was filed against this decision by the minority shareholders with the Higher Court of Düsseldorf, which<br />

also ruled in favor of Schwarz Pharma on 18 December 2008; making the DPTA final and binding as of<br />

that date.<br />

On 6 March 2009, the District Court of Düsseldorf dismissed the challenge actions of the minority<br />

shareholders. Out of the sixteen initial claimants, only one filed for appeal with the Higher Court of<br />

Düsseldorf in April 2009. The Board does not believe this remaining litigation poses a material<br />

financial risk to the <strong>UCB</strong> Group.<br />

(l) Appraisal procedure for judgment on adequate compensation and guaranteed dividend under the<br />

DPTA between <strong>UCB</strong> SP GmbH-Schwarz Pharma<br />

After the acquisition of the majority of shares in Schwarz Pharma by <strong>UCB</strong> SP GmbH in December 2006<br />

and the adoption of the DPTA between <strong>UCB</strong> SP GmbH and Schwarz Pharma by the general<br />

shareholder’s meeting of Schwarz Pharma in May 2007, foreseeing an adequate compensation for<br />

potential tendering of shares by minority shareholders and a guaranteed dividend, fifty three minority<br />

shareholders filed for an appraisal procedure against <strong>UCB</strong> SP GmbH to challenge the adequateness of<br />

such compensation and guarantee dividend in August 2007. After numerous filings of argumentative<br />

writs of both claimants and defendant, a date for an oral hearing has not yet been set by the court.<br />

At the general shareholders’ meeting of Schwarz Pharma in July 2009 a squeeze-out resolution was<br />

passed which was already registered in the commercial registry of the company and resulted in the<br />

transfer of all minority shares to <strong>UCB</strong> SP GmbH in exchange for adequate compensation determined by<br />

the court to be €111.44 per share. As at the end of September 2009, three minority shareholders<br />

initiated an appraisal procedure against <strong>UCB</strong> SP GmbH to challenge the adequacy of such<br />

compensation fixed in the resolution.<br />

(m) Tax authority reviews relating to the <strong>UCB</strong> Group<br />

The <strong>UCB</strong> Group operates in a number of jurisdictions around the world, each of which has its own tax<br />

regulations and statutes under which the <strong>UCB</strong> Group may have payment obligations. On occasion, tax<br />

authorities may initiate a review of the <strong>UCB</strong> Groups’ compliance with its tax regime. There are several<br />

such reviews pending regarding the <strong>UCB</strong> Group in a range of jurisdictions such as Germany, the UK,<br />

Spain, Turkey and Italy. The <strong>UCB</strong> Group is not able to predict with certainty the outcome of such<br />

reviews, or the impact that such reviews may have on the business of the <strong>UCB</strong> Group.<br />

A11250830/2.25/23 Oct 2009 90

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!