14.05.2013 Views

R+V Versicherung AG Annual Report

R+V Versicherung AG Annual Report

R+V Versicherung AG Annual Report

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

2002<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong><br />

<strong>Annual</strong> <strong>Report</strong><br />

Taunusstraße 1, 65193 Wiesbaden, Germany, Tel. +49 (0) 611 533-0<br />

Registered at the Magistrates’ Court Wiesbaden No. HRB 7934<br />

Presented to the Ordinary General Meeting on May 21, 2003


<strong>R+V</strong> Group<br />

Simplified presentation<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Consolidated Group<br />

KRAV<strong>AG</strong>-<br />

LOGISTIC<br />

<strong>Versicherung</strong>s-<br />

<strong>AG</strong><br />

Domestic<br />

Companies<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> at a Glance<br />

KRAV<strong>AG</strong>-<br />

ALLGEMEINE<br />

<strong>Versicherung</strong>s-<br />

<strong>AG</strong><br />

<strong>R+V</strong><br />

Poistóvna<br />

a.s.,<br />

Slovakia<br />

International<br />

Companies<br />

2<br />

<strong>R+V</strong><br />

Komposit<br />

Holding<br />

GmbH<br />

<strong>R+V</strong><br />

Allgemeine<br />

<strong>Versicherung</strong><br />

<strong>AG</strong><br />

KU Filar<br />

S.A.,<br />

Poland<br />

<strong>R+V</strong><br />

Rechtsschutzversicherung<br />

<strong>AG</strong><br />

Assimoco<br />

S.p.A.,<br />

Italy<br />

Vereinigte<br />

Tierversicherung<br />

a. G.<br />

<strong>R+V</strong><br />

<strong>Versicherung</strong><br />

<strong>AG</strong><br />

<strong>R+V</strong><br />

Lebensversicherung<br />

<strong>AG</strong><br />

Assimoco Vita<br />

S.p.A.,<br />

Italy<br />

<strong>R+V</strong><br />

Pensionsversicherung<br />

a. G.<br />

<strong>R+V</strong><br />

Personen<br />

Holding<br />

GmbH<br />

<strong>R+V</strong><br />

Pensionsfonds<br />

<strong>AG</strong><br />

<strong>R+V</strong><br />

Luxembourg<br />

Lebensversicherung<br />

S.A.<br />

<strong>R+V</strong><br />

Lebensversicherung<br />

a. G.<br />

<strong>R+V</strong><br />

Krankenversicherung<br />

<strong>AG</strong><br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Consolidated Group <strong>R+V</strong> Group<br />

2002 2001 2002 2001<br />

Gross premiums written € million 6,700 6,332 6,893 6,523<br />

Premiums resulting from bonus<br />

and rebate provision € million 252 320 282 355<br />

€ million 6,952 6,652 7,175 6,878<br />

Gross claims incurred € million 4,999 4,503 5,108 4,608<br />

Current investment income € million 2,089 1,864 2,215 2,000<br />

Investments € million 33,494 31,372 35,697 33,594<br />

Number of policies million 15.6 15.2 16.2 15.9<br />

Number of employees as at 31. 12. 10,675 10,748 11,642 11,664


Content<br />

Management <strong>Report</strong> 4<br />

Proposal on the Appropriation of Profits 32<br />

<strong>Annual</strong> Financial Statements 2002<br />

Balance Sheet 34<br />

Income Statement 38<br />

Notes<br />

Accounting policies 41<br />

List of Shareholdings 44<br />

Notes to the Balance Sheet 46<br />

Notes to the Income Statement 50<br />

Other Information 51<br />

Auditors’ <strong>Report</strong> 54<br />

<strong>Report</strong> of the Supervisory Board 55<br />

3


Management <strong>Report</strong><br />

<strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong> acts as both the<br />

parent company of the <strong>R+V</strong> Group and the<br />

reinsurer for the Group’s direct insurance<br />

companies. <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong> also<br />

operates independently on the international<br />

reinsurance market. The reinsurance business<br />

is primarily run from the head office in<br />

Wiesbaden, Germany. The Group’s interests<br />

in Southeast Asia are managed by its<br />

Singapore branch, which was established<br />

in 1997.<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>’s 2002 annual<br />

financial statements include all reinsurance<br />

business assumed from the <strong>R+V</strong> Group<br />

companies in the 2002 calendar year. In<br />

contrast, reporting of the majority of business<br />

assumed from other domestic and<br />

foreign cedents is deferred by one year and<br />

therefore relates to calendar year 2001.<br />

Investment income as well as all other<br />

income and expenses relate to calendar<br />

year 2002.<br />

Development of the economy as a whole<br />

and the German insurance sector<br />

Developments in economic growth and<br />

employment, income and pensions gave<br />

little cause for optimism. The silver lining<br />

discernible on the economic horizon in<br />

early 2002 was soon replaced with a badweather<br />

front. With the increase in its real<br />

gross domestic product barely exceeding<br />

0.2% in 2002, Germany had the lowest<br />

growth rate in the whole of the EU. There is<br />

no turnaround in sight for the labor market,<br />

and the ability of the state to financial<br />

public social security systems is the subject<br />

of ongoing controversy. The national debt<br />

rose continuously last year, placing further<br />

restrictions on public services, especially<br />

in the social sector. Tax increases forced<br />

private households to cut back on consumption,<br />

while the investment climate<br />

for companies deteriorated.<br />

4<br />

The dramatic slump on the global capital<br />

markets further accelerated the economic<br />

downturn. The stock market boom of the<br />

1990s has definitely come to an end, and<br />

the bear market visibly impacted the results<br />

of the entire financial services sector.<br />

This less than encouraging economic situation<br />

was matched by the political climate.<br />

Terrorist attacks worldwide, such as those<br />

in Jerba and Bali, created an atmosphere<br />

of tension. The explosive situation in the<br />

Middle East and the threat of a military<br />

conflict between the US and Iraq created<br />

uncertainty and put a considerable damper<br />

on economic activity.<br />

As if all this weren’t enough, devastating<br />

natural disasters plagued people around the<br />

world in ever-shorter intervals. August’s<br />

flooding in the new federal German states<br />

robbed many people of their livelihood.<br />

The Aufbau Ost program to rebuild Eastern<br />

Germany, which had just been concluded,<br />

will have to start all over again in these<br />

regions.<br />

Sectoral growth of 4.1% despite<br />

numerous adversities<br />

The weak economy, the stock market<br />

slump and the results of the natural<br />

disasters are also mirrored in the development<br />

of the insurance sector during 2002.<br />

However, because insurance provides a<br />

sense of stability and security in times of<br />

turmoil, the industry was able to maintain<br />

its growth course despite all adversities and<br />

risks: the premium income collected by<br />

direct insurers grew by 4.1% to €141.0<br />

billion. As in the previous year, this positive<br />

growth was largely driven by life insurance.


However, the significant increase in private<br />

health insurance also made an encouraging<br />

contribution to the growth of the entire<br />

sector. This means that the insurance<br />

industry is still enjoying above-average<br />

growth rates, even though the potential for<br />

growth has steadily contracted in recent<br />

years.<br />

The premium income recorded in all insurance<br />

classes is offset by payments or<br />

claims expenses of €158.7 billion, an<br />

increase of 6.2%. At 10.2%, the increase<br />

in the number of property and casualty<br />

insurance claims was highest. Natural<br />

disasters and a concentration of large<br />

claims in the past year had a dramatic<br />

effect on property insurance in particular.<br />

The flood of the century in the new federal<br />

German states alone depressed earnings<br />

by €1.8 billion. In addition, the stock market<br />

slump has greatly reduced the possibility<br />

of offsetting technical losses with positive<br />

investment income.<br />

Encouraging developments in life and<br />

health insurance<br />

The following trends and prospects are<br />

emerging in the most important insurance<br />

classes: life insurance is demonstrating<br />

strong growth in new business, solid premium<br />

growth, a definite upward trend in total<br />

policies outstanding and increasing benefit<br />

payments. New business developed very<br />

positively, with around 10.2 million new<br />

policies sold in 2002, an increase of 20.4%.<br />

Pension insurance rocketed with growth<br />

of 125%, or 3.3 million new policies.<br />

5<br />

Life insurers saw their gross premium<br />

income increase by 4.3% to €65.1 billion.<br />

Their payments rose to a total of €85.7<br />

billion, of which €55.1 billion went directly<br />

to customers and €30.6 billion to benefit<br />

reserves. This extremely satisfactory result<br />

shows that modern, up-to-date versions of<br />

traditional life insurance are a “safe bet” for<br />

retirement provision in times of uncertain<br />

stock market development dominated by<br />

substantial price losses. On top of this, the<br />

new subsidization provided for by the<br />

Altersvermögensgesetz (German Retirement<br />

Savings Act) created an additional impetus,<br />

with over 2.9 million retirement pension<br />

policies being sold under this Act.<br />

Private health insurance, the second-largest<br />

type of personal insurance, also recorded<br />

above-average growth for the sector in<br />

2002 with an increase in premium income<br />

of 6.4% to €23.1 billion. Comprehensive<br />

and additional health insurance accounted<br />

for €21.1 billion, rising 6.8%, and compulsory<br />

long-term care insurance for €2.0<br />

billion, up 2.3%. The strong increase in<br />

premium income is principally due to the<br />

large number of new members, with<br />

approximately 221,000 people switching<br />

from public to private health insurance. In<br />

line with the general trend in the healthcare<br />

sector, expenses for benefits paid to<br />

holders of health and compulsory long-term<br />

care insurance policies also rose in the<br />

private health insurance sector by 5.5% to<br />

€15.2 billion.


A difficult year for property insurers<br />

For property and casualty insurers, 2002<br />

was principally marked by a sharp rise in<br />

claims expenses. Fierce spring storms, the<br />

flooding of the Elbe and its tributaries, the<br />

fall storm “Jeanette” and numerous large<br />

claims resulted in heavy losses and a<br />

combined ratio of over 100% in a number<br />

of insurance classes. In addition, the stiff<br />

competition in particular segments of<br />

property and casualty insurance prevented<br />

insurers from changing premiums that<br />

covered their costs. Given the current stock<br />

market environment, it is highly unlikely that<br />

the technical losses can be offset with<br />

investment income.<br />

On the whole, claims expenses in property<br />

and casualty insurance during the fiscal<br />

year rose by 10.2% to €44.3 billion.<br />

Premium income, however, improved by a<br />

mere 2.8% to €51.1 billion. As in the past,<br />

motor vehicle insurance – the largest<br />

branch of property insurance – accounted<br />

for this growth. With premium income of<br />

€21.9 billion, this 2.9% increase is nevertheless<br />

considerably lower than in the<br />

previous year (up 4.8% in 2001). This figure<br />

is offset by an expected technical loss of<br />

€0.5 billion, principally due to the large<br />

number of storms in the first half of the year<br />

and last summer’s flood disaster. Full cover<br />

insurance was the main contributor to this<br />

loss, which rose by €270 million to €400<br />

million. Partial cover insurance recorded a<br />

loss of over €50 million down from a positive<br />

€168 million in the previous year.<br />

Losses from motor vehicle liability insurance<br />

fell by €150 million to €476 million.<br />

6<br />

General property insurance recorded a<br />

slight increase of somewhat over 1%, with<br />

premium income of €9.4 billion. In contrast,<br />

claims expenses rose by close on 47.0% to<br />

€8.5 billion. Fierce premium competition in<br />

the commercial area and in comprehensive<br />

residential insurance in particular resulted in<br />

heavy losses. Industrial property insurance<br />

fared no better: the high combined ratio<br />

of 128% (due to an increase in claims<br />

expenses of 21.3% to €3.8 billion) offset<br />

the encouraging premium increase of<br />

12.3% to €3.4 billion. This higher premium<br />

income results from the systematic implementation<br />

of restructuring measures in<br />

this class, giving rise to hope of further<br />

improvements. The situation in the marine<br />

insurance sector also remains strained,<br />

with the combined ratio standing at 126%.<br />

Premium income improved by 3.0% to<br />

€1.8 billion. General liability insurance<br />

demonstrated a slight growth in premium<br />

income of 1% to €6.0 billion. The situation<br />

in private accident insurance is much<br />

healthier; here, premium income rose by<br />

1.5% to €5.6 billion, while claims expenses<br />

increased by a mere 0.5% to €2.5 billion.<br />

This puts the loss ratio at a positive 54.0%,<br />

almost unchanged on the previous year.<br />

Legal insurers also boosted their premium<br />

income by 1% in the past fiscal year to<br />

€2.7 billion, while claims expenses rose<br />

by 2.0% to around €2 billion.


Developments on the international<br />

reinsurance markets<br />

Business assumed from cedents outside<br />

the <strong>R+V</strong> Group was affected by developments<br />

on the international reinsurance markets.<br />

Because most property and casualty<br />

insurance business is deferred by one year,<br />

the following paragraphs primarily present<br />

the situation as it was in calendar year<br />

2001.<br />

Economic environment<br />

The contraction of the global economy in<br />

the middle of the year accelerated in the<br />

course of 2001, with the rate of expansion<br />

slowing substantially in almost all countries<br />

and regions. A major factor in this development<br />

was that the strong boom in the US,<br />

which had long functioned as the motor for<br />

the global economy, came to an abrupt<br />

end. The downturn quickly spread to the<br />

rest of the world via a crash in stock market<br />

prices, deterioration in sentiment among<br />

companies and finally a contraction in trading<br />

activity.<br />

This slowdown was triggered by two key<br />

factors. The preceding increase in crude oil<br />

prices curbed economies almost everywhere<br />

and fears of inflation took hold,<br />

resulting in a tightening of monetary policy<br />

in key countries. The slump was further<br />

accelerated by the downturn in the IT<br />

sector. Whereas massive investments in this<br />

area had accelerated growth in many parts<br />

of the world up to mid-2000, the slump in<br />

this sector accelerated the economy’s<br />

downturn. This extraordinary development<br />

was another reason why forecasts for<br />

numerous countries had to be revised<br />

downwards in the course of the year – even<br />

before the events of September 11.<br />

7<br />

However, in the early summer of 2001, the<br />

first indications emerged that the downturn<br />

would not continue in the same form as in<br />

the past and that a recession was therefore<br />

not in sight. The business climate brightened,<br />

both in the US and in the euro-zone,<br />

due to the improvement in underlying<br />

economic conditions and the fact that<br />

the global raw materials markets were<br />

showing signs of relaxation. At this time,<br />

the economy appeared to have bottomed<br />

out and it seemed that a recovery was on<br />

the cards for the last quarter of the year.<br />

These hopes were dashed by the events<br />

of September 11.<br />

International reinsurers had never been so<br />

affected by one single event in any previous<br />

year. The terrorist attacks in the US on<br />

September 11 resulted in the largest single<br />

insurance claim in insurance history – at<br />

least USD50 billion. The insurance claim<br />

from Hurricane Andrew, which had broken<br />

all records up to then, amounted to only<br />

half of the sum payable as a result of the<br />

terrorist attack on the World Trade Center.<br />

This puts the extent to which the insurance<br />

sector was affected in fiscal 2001 into perspective,<br />

but also highlights the enormous<br />

capacity of the direct insurance and reinsurance<br />

sector to cope with such a once-in-acentury<br />

event.<br />

This extraordinary event and the complexity<br />

of the related claims created uncertainty<br />

and led to a review of risk exposure in the<br />

entire insurance sector. The face of the<br />

insurance market changed dramatically as a<br />

result. Direct insurance policies increased<br />

almost across the board, reinsurance<br />

capacity declined and cover for terrorism<br />

risks in commercial and industrial sectors<br />

became almost impossible to come by.


Apart from the extraordinary burden of the<br />

terrorist attacks in the US, 2001 also saw<br />

a large number of large claims. These<br />

included the explosion at a fertilizer plant<br />

near Toulouse/France, the earthquake in<br />

El Salvador, tropical storm “Alison” in the<br />

southern US, typhoon “Nasi” in Taiwan and<br />

the total loss of the “Petrobras” oil platform<br />

off the coast of Brazil.<br />

Western Europe<br />

Growth in industrialized countries of<br />

Western Europe declined to an extent not<br />

seen since the beginning of the 1990s.<br />

While the Japanese economy once again<br />

slid into recession, the economy in the<br />

European Union continued to grow for a<br />

time; nevertheless these countries were<br />

increasingly caught up in the global economic<br />

downturn. Of the large countries, the<br />

UK was the only economy that remained<br />

robust. International trade declined, leading<br />

to a correspondingly pronounced downturn<br />

in industry. While private consumption<br />

remained robust in many cases, corporate<br />

investment generally declined. The labor<br />

market did not remain unscathed either,<br />

with the slight improvements previously<br />

seen tailing off again.<br />

Inflationary trends which had increased in<br />

2000 and were ultimately responsible for<br />

the central banks’ restrictive measures,<br />

weakened in 2001, partly thanks to the<br />

drop in oil prices. The core inflation rate<br />

remained persistently high, however.<br />

8<br />

Monetary policy was relaxed during the<br />

course of the year in reaction to the economic<br />

slump. Interest rates were lowered<br />

once again in a concerted effort following<br />

the terrorist attacks in the US. All in all, the<br />

central banks were on a clearly expansionary<br />

course, while financial policy was relatively<br />

restrained.<br />

In terms of exports, countries which had<br />

specialized in IT products suffered the<br />

greatest setbacks, losing global market<br />

share. Finland, which had reported export<br />

growth of up to 20% in the previous year,<br />

posted a decline in exports in the year<br />

under review. What was surprising was that<br />

trade within the European Union declined at<br />

times, even though domestic demand<br />

expanded in most member states.<br />

Exports and imports in the majority of<br />

countries and regions generally developed<br />

along the same lines, especially since economic<br />

development was surprisingly parallel,<br />

both in relation to the strong upswing<br />

until mid-2000 and to the downturn. Since<br />

exchange rates hardly fluctuated, the<br />

balance of trade and balance of payments<br />

for the individual countries changed very<br />

little overall.<br />

The European insurance markets bottomed<br />

out at the beginning of the year under<br />

review and direct insurance rates began to<br />

develop positively again in a number of<br />

markets. However, these increases were<br />

unable to offset claims losses, which<br />

remained unsatisfactory. The impact of<br />

large claims remained moderate in the first<br />

half of the year, with the main events being<br />

the sinking of the oil platform off the<br />

Brazilian coast and tropical storm “Alison”<br />

which led to severe flooding in the southwest<br />

of the US.


However, the events of September 11<br />

brought the positive development of this<br />

segment to a sudden halt. The largest<br />

insurance claim of all time did not just result<br />

in technical losses at a number of major<br />

direct insurers and reinsurers, it also<br />

brought the capital markets down with it.<br />

The second half of 2001 suffered further<br />

blows in the form of numerous large industrial<br />

claims such as the explosion of a fertilizer<br />

plant near Toulouse/France and the<br />

explosion at a steelworks in Wales. In contrast,<br />

the number of claims arising from natural<br />

disasters in the year under review was<br />

low.<br />

Central and Eastern Europe<br />

The Central and Eastern European market<br />

is currently undergoing radical reform. The<br />

contraction of the global economy was<br />

scarcely felt in the Central European and<br />

Baltic states, due in particular to the efforts<br />

of those countries hoping to join the EU.<br />

The upward trend of the past year remained<br />

largely constant, driven by strong domestic<br />

demand. Poland was the exception, with<br />

the economy experiencing a considerable<br />

cooling-off on account of the restrictive<br />

rates set by its central bank. This led to<br />

stagnation, in contrast to the high growth<br />

rates of previous years.<br />

9<br />

Most countries in Central and Eastern<br />

Europe benefited from the rapid progress<br />

of the economic reforms and privatization<br />

measures, which have made them less<br />

susceptible to negative effects from abroad.<br />

In addition, the extremely high deficits in<br />

the balance of payments of some of these<br />

countries had little impact as they were still<br />

matched by a high inflow of foreign direct<br />

investors. The level of foreign debt was<br />

correspondingly low, and exchange rates<br />

generally stable.<br />

Russia did surprisingly well once more, with<br />

its growth rate increasing in the course of<br />

the year. The national budget situation<br />

eased and the foreign debt problem also<br />

declined as a result of the extremely high<br />

balance of payment surplus. Investment in<br />

the private sector also surged for the third<br />

year in a row.<br />

The other CIS states also presented<br />

astonishingly good results. After what<br />

was for some a prolonged lean period<br />

with sluggish growth or even slumps in<br />

production, real GDP (gross domestic<br />

product) increased throughout the region.<br />

The reinsurance market developed positively<br />

in the past fiscal year. In 2001, Russian<br />

insurance companies alone collected<br />

approximately 276 billion roubles (€10.4<br />

billion), 62% more in premiums than in the<br />

previous year. The market in general began<br />

to harden, pushing up rates substantially in<br />

certain sub classes, especially for disaster<br />

cover.


North America<br />

Growth by the US economy had weakened<br />

substantially by mid-2001, and the expected<br />

recovery now did not materialize. Rather,<br />

signs of improvement were quashed by<br />

the terrorist attacks on September 11.<br />

Manufacturing industry was affected particularly<br />

badly by the downturn. Production<br />

declined 6% as against mid-2000 and<br />

capacity fell to its lowest level in two<br />

decades. The IT sector in particular cut<br />

back heavily on production.<br />

Almost all demand components were<br />

affected by the decline. The downturn in<br />

corporate investment, which had rocketed<br />

during the investment boom, was particularly<br />

pronounced. From the beginning of the<br />

year onwards, double-digit decreases were<br />

recorded, due both to poorer sales<br />

prospects and to slashed profit margins.<br />

Companies’ inventories were also dramatically<br />

reduced. In contrast, private consumption<br />

continued to climb until the very<br />

end, even though it, too, lost momentum.<br />

Investment in housing also expanded,<br />

aided by the Federal Reserve’s interest rate<br />

cuts. The weak foreign economic climate<br />

reduced North American exports. However,<br />

since imports also dropped substantially<br />

and the terms of trade improved, the balance<br />

of payments deficit improved for the<br />

first time in ten years.<br />

The labor market now felt the full force of<br />

the economic downturn. Unemployment<br />

figures began to rise rapidly, peaking in<br />

October following the terrorist attacks on<br />

the World Trade Center on September 11.<br />

After the US insurance sector had suffered<br />

entirely unsatisfactory premium levels and<br />

high claims expenses in 1998 and 1999,<br />

direct insurers and reinsurers began raising<br />

rates again in 2000.<br />

10<br />

However, in the year under review, these<br />

price increases were insufficient to improve<br />

the earnings situation in the long term.<br />

A number of players on both the direct<br />

insurance and the reinsurance market either<br />

withdrew from the business due to unsatisfactory<br />

earnings or were forced to restructure<br />

their operations.<br />

The attack on the World Trade Center<br />

on September 11, 2001 left the insurance<br />

sector facing the single largest claim in its<br />

history – estimates put it at USD50 billion at<br />

least. However, even before the terrorist<br />

attacks, the combined ratio of many market<br />

players already exceeded 120%. Following<br />

the events of September 11, loss ratios<br />

shot up once more, resulting in a bleak year<br />

for the insurance sector.<br />

Latin America<br />

In 2000, Latin America had recovered from<br />

the preceding period of stagnation, with<br />

almost all countries achieving a substantial<br />

increase in real GDP. The downturn in the<br />

global economy hit the region hard, and<br />

overall economic output fell in many countries<br />

in 2001. Mexico was worst affected by<br />

the slump, as demand from the US – its<br />

most important trading partner – dropped<br />

sharply. Other countries were also impacted<br />

by the fall in crude oil prices, which resulted<br />

in a worsening of their terms of trade.<br />

These external shocks hit the countries<br />

before their foreign trade position had had<br />

time to become consolidated. As a consequence,<br />

their balance of payments deficits<br />

remained at a high level, and foreign debt<br />

rose. The problem was aggravated by<br />

capital outflows, as the political situation<br />

was also unstable in some countries, particularly<br />

in Argentina. Unresolved budgetary<br />

problems added to the difficulties and, last<br />

but not least, the currencies of several<br />

countries came under pressure.


As a result of the relatively poor capitalization<br />

of many direct insurers and Latin<br />

America’s high frequency of natural disasters,<br />

the fire insurance class together<br />

with its supplementary elemental risks are<br />

heavily reinsured. After a phase of immense<br />

pressure on reinsurance conditions and<br />

correspondingly poor results, claim events<br />

initiated a market turnaround. The high<br />

costs incurred in the previous year by the<br />

storms “Mitch” and “Georges”, as well as<br />

flooding in Venezuela and the earthquake<br />

in Columbia, led to an increase in original<br />

premiums and paved the way for improved<br />

reinsurance conditions. The growth of these<br />

markets was severely restricted by the economic<br />

recession, however.<br />

Asia<br />

Southeast Asia started to experience an<br />

economic downturn in mid-2000 which<br />

snowballed during 2001. Real gross domestic<br />

product even fell at times in many countries.<br />

Only in China did overall economic<br />

production continue to expand at more or<br />

less the same speed. Taking the official<br />

statistics as a yardstick, real GDP has now<br />

been increasing at between 7% and 8%<br />

per year for many years, regardless of the<br />

performance of the global economy. In the<br />

other countries, the weakness in the US,<br />

Japanese and EU economies became<br />

increasingly apparent, with the result that<br />

exports collapsed in numerous cases. The<br />

setback in the IT sector had an even more<br />

critical impact, however. Many countries<br />

had specialized very heavily in such<br />

products, and for years their exports had<br />

benefited from the global boom; by the end,<br />

IT products had made up around a quarter<br />

of their total goods exports on average.<br />

11<br />

Consequently, the region – and especially<br />

Singapore, Malaysia and Taiwan – was<br />

extremely hard hit by the downturn in the<br />

market. In other countries which had not<br />

concentrated quite so heavily on IT products,<br />

such as South Korea and Thailand,<br />

vigorous expansion in domestic demand<br />

helped offset the weak exports.<br />

While exports fell much more sharply than<br />

imports throughout practically the whole<br />

region, the majority of Southeast Asian<br />

countries still recorded a sizeable balance<br />

of payments surplus. This reduced the<br />

risk that external economic shocks would<br />

trigger a crisis as in 1998. Another point in<br />

their favor was that inflation was low in all<br />

countries except Indonesia, which meant<br />

that the central banks were able to react to<br />

the economic downturn by relaxing their<br />

monetary policy.<br />

Like the Japanese economy as a whole,<br />

the Japanese insurance sector experienced<br />

difficulties. Life insurers were faced with<br />

major challenges due to the strained situation<br />

on the capital markets. Property and<br />

casualty insurers were forced to adapt to<br />

the consequences of deregulation.<br />

After the direct insurance market in Taiwan<br />

had developed extremely satisfactorily in<br />

2000, the fiscal year under review was<br />

characterized by stiff competition. This led<br />

to declining original rates in key insurance<br />

classes.<br />

China joined the World Trade Organization<br />

(WTO) and issued clear guidelines for<br />

regulatory approval of foreign insurance<br />

companies.


Asia remained affected by the financial<br />

crises of the 1990s. Brisk competition<br />

among market players kept direct insurance<br />

premiums at a low level. Only in Malaysia<br />

and Thailand were rates in the motor insurance<br />

class adjusted upwards after declining<br />

for many years.<br />

Australia/New Zealand<br />

In Australia, the situation on the most<br />

important sales markets showed no signs<br />

of recovery. At 1.7% of GDP, the balance of<br />

payments deficit reached its lowest point<br />

since 1980. Only the construction industry<br />

contributed more than average to economic<br />

growth thanks to generous government<br />

subsidies.<br />

The insolvency of the insurance group<br />

HIH was the most important event on the<br />

Australian insurance market in the past<br />

fiscal year. However, this also spurred a<br />

recovery in rates and conditions in a number<br />

of insurance classes and speeded up<br />

market consolidation. At the end of the year<br />

under review, certain types of liability cover,<br />

e.g. medical liability, were taken over by the<br />

government, since physicians were unable<br />

to meet the premium increases demanded.<br />

The bush fires which raged in the vicinity<br />

of Sydney from Christmas until around<br />

January 8, 2002 were the largest claim<br />

event for the insurance sector, although this<br />

did not affect us to any significant extent.<br />

New Zealand’s economy was strongly<br />

driven by domestic demand and the real<br />

estate boom. Private consumer spending<br />

rose 1.4% in the last quarter of the year,<br />

corresponding to annual growth of 3.5%.<br />

Demand developed particularly well in the<br />

motor vehicle and real estate sectors.<br />

12<br />

Africa<br />

In African countries economic growth<br />

continued almost unchanged during the<br />

year under review, even though the external<br />

economic shocks took their toll on this<br />

continent too. Africa also felt the effect of<br />

the weak global economy. The declining<br />

raw materials prices had a serious impact<br />

on most countries’ economies. This<br />

development was partly cyclical, as on<br />

the metals market, but in some cases the<br />

changes were much more drastic; coffee<br />

and tobacco prices both collapsed, for<br />

example. As this pushed down exports, the<br />

balance of payments deficit remained high<br />

in most cases. Only oil-producing countries<br />

such as Algeria recorded high surpluses.<br />

Despite the negative development in the<br />

terms of trade and the negative effects this<br />

had on the economy, domestic demand<br />

remained robust. Economic policy progressed<br />

in terms of macroeconomic stability<br />

in almost all countries, with private<br />

investment rising. Countries experiencing<br />

political turbulence were the exception;<br />

output in Zimbabwe, for example, took a<br />

nosedive and inflation skyrocketed.<br />

Africa’s insurance markets were still characterized<br />

by fierce competitive pressure and<br />

political instability in many regions. This<br />

general competitive pressure led to the<br />

merger of a number of direct insurers, principally<br />

in South Africa, which meant that the<br />

number of market players fell. The reinsurance<br />

market followed suit, a trend which<br />

resulted in greater growth opportunities for<br />

the remaining companies.


Business development and position of<br />

the Company<br />

Premium income<br />

Retention increases within the <strong>R+V</strong> Group<br />

reduced the premium volume.<br />

Foreign business records additional growth<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>’s gross premium<br />

income fell by 6.9% in the fiscal year to<br />

€957.9 million. 5.2 percentage points of<br />

this decrease were attributable to exchange<br />

rate effects. After adjusting for this, the<br />

Company recorded a decrease in premiums<br />

of €18.4 million.<br />

Increases in the retentions of direct insurers<br />

within the <strong>R+V</strong> Group resulted in domestic<br />

premiums being reduced in the life, motor<br />

vehicle liability, motor vehicle and bond/<br />

construction guarantee insurance classes.<br />

Premiums written 2002 2001 Change 2002 2001 Change<br />

Gross €m Gross €m Gross % Net €m Net €m Net %<br />

Life 321.7 361.0 –10.9 124.7 170.4 –26.8<br />

Accident 39.3 36.5 7.6 38.1 34.8 9.6<br />

Liability 44.9 50.0 –10.4 32.9 35.1 –6.1<br />

Motor 106.1 211.6 –49.9 103.4 128.2 –19.3<br />

Fire 163.8 123.7 32.5 125.3 92.3 35.8<br />

Other property 98.4 102.5 –4.0 73.7 67.1 9.9<br />

Marine and aviation 82.5 62.0 33.0 66.5 48.9 36.0<br />

Others 101.2 81.2 24.6 58.3 35.9 62.2<br />

Total 957.9 1,028.5 –6.9 622.9 612.7 1.7<br />

In contrast, premiums increased in the<br />

general accident, credit (provision for<br />

doubtful debts) and fidelity insurance<br />

classes due to new underwritings and<br />

portfolio growth. The premium volume<br />

generated by business assumed from<br />

domestic cedents outside the <strong>R+V</strong> Group<br />

fell by €11.7 million or 7.4%. Overall,<br />

domestic business saw a 17.9% decrease<br />

in premiums.<br />

13<br />

Premium income from foreign business rose<br />

by €34.6 million or 7.9%. This meant that<br />

foreign business accounted for 49.6%<br />

(previous year: 42.8%) of the total premium<br />

volume. The main contributors to the premium<br />

volume were the traditional reinsurance<br />

markets of North America, Italy, the UK,<br />

Spain and France, along with the Singapore<br />

branch. Despite negative exchange rate<br />

movements, the expansion of foreign<br />

business activities led to moderate premium<br />

growth.<br />

The total net premium volume increased<br />

year-on-year by €10.1 million, or 1.7%, to<br />

€622.9 million. Retention increased to<br />

65.0% (previous year: 59.6%).<br />

The following table shows the Company’s<br />

premium income broken down according to<br />

its key insurance classes:


Premiums written in € million<br />

1000<br />

Technical result<br />

Increased claims volume impact results<br />

Global concentration processes continued<br />

in the year under review. The improved<br />

capital resources of the market’s remaining<br />

direct insurers tended to lessen the need<br />

for reinsurance. In addition, new market<br />

participants and different sales channels led<br />

to increased competitive pressure on many<br />

markets. International reinsurers were<br />

affected by a single event as never before.<br />

The terrorist attacks which took place in the<br />

US on September 11, 2001 went down as<br />

the single largest insurance claim in insurance<br />

history – at least USD50 billion.<br />

14<br />

900<br />

800<br />

700<br />

600<br />

500<br />

400<br />

300<br />

200<br />

100<br />

733<br />

336<br />

809<br />

428<br />

869<br />

484<br />

1029<br />

613<br />

1998 1999 2000 2001<br />

Gross premiums written<br />

Net premiums written<br />

958<br />

623<br />

2002<br />

Apart from the extraordinary expenses<br />

resulting from the terrorist attacks, 2001<br />

was also characterized by a large number<br />

of large claims affecting the Company’s<br />

earnings. These included the explosion of<br />

a fertilizer plant close to Toulouse/France,<br />

the total loss of the “Petrobras” oil platform<br />

off the coast of Brazil, the earthquake in<br />

El Salvador, tropical storm “Alison” in the<br />

southern US and typhoon “Nari” in Taiwan.<br />

The year under review also saw a high<br />

number of basic claims. A departure was<br />

made from the usual accounting practice<br />

of deferral by one year in order to set up<br />

provisions for the flood damage which<br />

devastated parts of Germany, Austria and<br />

the Czech Republic in August 2002, and<br />

for the results of the storm “Jeanette” on<br />

October 26/27, 2002.<br />

Together, these circumstances led once<br />

again to high gross claims expenses of<br />

81.0% (previous year: 77.6%) in the non-life<br />

classes. Not even retrocessions could<br />

provide relief, and the net loss ratio for the<br />

fiscal year totaled 87.0% (previous year:<br />

77.1%). At 29.5% (previous year: 29.6%),<br />

the gross expense ratio remained almost<br />

unchanged, while the net expense ratio<br />

improved from 31.3% to 30.6%.<br />

Total Non-life business 2000 2001 2002<br />

Gross loss ratio % 73.6 77.6 81.0<br />

Gross expense ratio % 31.9 29.6 29.5<br />

Gross combined ratio % 105.5 107.2 110.5<br />

The deterioration in the earnings situation in<br />

the motor vehicle class in the previous year<br />

continued during the year under review,<br />

principally due to developments in motor<br />

vehicle liability insurance. Provision<br />

reserves for the flood damage in Europe in<br />

August 2002 caused earnings from motor<br />

vehicle insurance, which had started to<br />

recover in the previous year, to decline<br />

again in the fiscal year. Only motor vehicle<br />

accident insurance recorded a slight profit<br />

in the fiscal year.


Liability business developed negatively,<br />

generating a loss in the fiscal year after<br />

a profit in the previous year.<br />

Accident insurance was unable to match<br />

the prior year’s satisfactory level of earnings,<br />

closing the year under review with<br />

a loss.<br />

Fire insurance recorded the highest loss of<br />

the property insurance classes. In addition<br />

to the costs of the large claim for the World<br />

Trade Center, earnings in this insurance<br />

class were impacted by a series of other<br />

major claim events from natural disasters<br />

and large industrial claims. In addition,<br />

a departure was made from the usual<br />

accounting practice of deferral by one year<br />

in order to set up provisions for the flood<br />

damage in August 2002 and the damage<br />

from storm “Jeanette” on October 26/27,<br />

2002; this had a negative impact on the<br />

result for the year under review.<br />

Engineering insurance continued its<br />

negative development of recent years.<br />

A significant drop in the loss recorded in<br />

the previous year was offset by a corresponding<br />

increase during the year under<br />

review.<br />

After the loss recorded in the previous year<br />

due to the provisions set up for the events<br />

of September 11, 2001 in New York, the<br />

loss generated by aviation insurance was<br />

substantially reduced in the fiscal year.<br />

The situation in marine insurance remained<br />

unsatisfactory. Insufficient rate levels and<br />

increased net loss ratios led to another<br />

technical loss in the year under review.<br />

The overall loss recorded by the remaining<br />

insurance classes in the year under review<br />

was considerably higher than in the previous<br />

year. This development is due to a<br />

deterioration in the credit, bonds, livestock<br />

and health insurance classes. Following a<br />

substantial loss in the previous year, the<br />

hail/crop insurance class recorded a profit<br />

in the year under review.<br />

15<br />

In contrast, life insurance recorded a technical<br />

surplus that exceeded the prior-year<br />

profit. After a slight surplus in the previous<br />

year, health insurance closed the year with<br />

a loss.<br />

Overall, reinsurance business ended the<br />

fiscal year with a loss of €81.6 million<br />

(previous year: €–33.3 million) before<br />

withdrawals from the equalization provision<br />

and similar provisions.<br />

As a result of improved net loss ratios in the<br />

year under review, allocations were made to<br />

the equalization provision in burglary and<br />

theft, aviation/aerospace and legal insurance.<br />

Allocations were also made in general<br />

accident, storm and tempest and construction<br />

services despite the deterioration of<br />

the net loss ratios in these classes, whereas<br />

the earnings situation in the other classes<br />

led to withdrawals. All in all, withdrawals of<br />

€17.4 million (previous year: allocations of<br />

€10.9 million) were made from the equalization<br />

provision and similar provisions.<br />

After withdrawals from the equalization provision<br />

and similar provisions, the technical<br />

loss amounted to €64.2 million (previous<br />

year: €–44.2 million).<br />

Investment portfolio<br />

The development of the Company’s investments<br />

in the past fiscal year was dominated<br />

by the reorganization of the <strong>R+V</strong> Group’s<br />

shareholdings (for more information see<br />

page 25). The restructuring and the revaluations<br />

related to this in some cases played<br />

a major role in the substantial increase in<br />

the investment portfolio of €776.1 million,<br />

or 56.7%, to €2,145.3 million. Shares in<br />

affiliated companies still accounted for<br />

a majority of holdings, increasing from<br />

56.1% to 67.6% as a consequence of the<br />

restructuring measures.


16<br />

Development of investments in € million<br />

2500<br />

2000<br />

1500<br />

1000<br />

500<br />

1150<br />

1125<br />

1998 1999<br />

1219<br />

1369<br />

2000 2001<br />

2002<br />

As a result of the implementation of the<br />

new Group structure, the direct interests<br />

held in <strong>R+V</strong> Lebensversicherung <strong>AG</strong> and<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Pensionsfonds <strong>AG</strong>, which was established<br />

in fiscal 2002, are now held by <strong>R+V</strong><br />

Personen Holding GmbH, while the interests<br />

in <strong>R+V</strong> Allgemeine <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong><br />

are held by <strong>R+V</strong> KOMPOSIT Holding<br />

GmbH.<br />

During the past year, <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong><br />

participated in capital increases at its Italian<br />

subsidiaries.<br />

The interests in KRAV<strong>AG</strong>-LEBEN <strong>Versicherung</strong>s-<strong>AG</strong><br />

acquired by KRAV<strong>AG</strong>-SACH<br />

<strong>Versicherung</strong> des Deutschen Kraftverkehrs<br />

VaG and KRAV<strong>AG</strong>-HOLDING <strong>AG</strong> were sold<br />

to <strong>R+V</strong> Lebensversicherung <strong>AG</strong>.<br />

With respect to new operational investments,<br />

the focus was on fixed-income<br />

securities.<br />

2145<br />

The valuation reserves in the investments<br />

carried at cost increased by €599.3 million<br />

to €1,723.9 million. The reserve ratio for the<br />

entire investment portfolio thus amounts to<br />

80.4% (previous year: 82.1%).<br />

Investment result<br />

Current investment income (excluding interest<br />

on deposits) increased substantially by<br />

€216.1 million to €321.1 million during the<br />

year under review. This was primarily due to<br />

income from the profit transfer agreements<br />

signed with <strong>R+V</strong> Personen Holding GmbH<br />

and <strong>R+V</strong> KOMPOSIT Holding GmbH.<br />

Taking into account current expenses<br />

of €5.4 million, an ordinary result of<br />

€315.7 million was generated.<br />

As part of the measures taken to restructure<br />

the Group, capital gains of €455.5<br />

million were recorded in respect of shares<br />

in affiliated companies. Of the total hidden<br />

reserves realized by <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong><br />

and its subsidiaries, a special dividend of<br />

€639.5 million will be distributed to shareholders<br />

and reallocated to the equity of<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong> reported on the face<br />

of the balance sheet within the framework<br />

of a pay-out take-back procedure. Apart<br />

from increasing transparency, this conversion<br />

will strengthen the earnings power of<br />

the union of cooperative banks without<br />

affecting the assets of <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong><br />

<strong>AG</strong>.<br />

Overall, the net investment result rose substantially<br />

to €784.3 million from €101.8 million<br />

in the previous year on account of the<br />

special factors described. In contrast, the<br />

crisis on the stock markets played only a<br />

minor role in the Group’s earnings due to<br />

the low proportion of the portfolio accounted<br />

for by listed shares.


Including interest on deposits and after<br />

deduction of the allocated investment<br />

return, the Company recorded an investment<br />

result of €786.6 million, compared<br />

with €103.5 million in the previous year.<br />

Other income and expenses<br />

A large proportion of other income,<br />

which totaled €19.8 million (previous year:<br />

€14.6 million), resulted from services performed<br />

for other companies within the <strong>R+V</strong><br />

Group. However, this increase was offset by<br />

equally high expenses. Other expenses also<br />

contained interest expenses of €15.9 million<br />

(previous year €14.0 million).<br />

Overall result<br />

Including the technical result (€–64.2 million),<br />

the investment result (€+786.6 million),<br />

other income (€20.0<br />

million) and other<br />

expenses (€39.7<br />

million), <strong>R+V</strong><br />

<strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong><br />

generated earnings<br />

before tax of €702.5<br />

million in 2001,<br />

compared with<br />

€44.4 million in the<br />

previous year. This<br />

improvement in<br />

earnings is principally<br />

due to the capital<br />

gains and the<br />

high investment<br />

income from the<br />

subsidiaries.<br />

A proposal will be made to the General<br />

Meeting to distribute €30.5 million of the<br />

net retained profits to shareholders via<br />

payment of a dividend of €3.50 and to<br />

distribute a special dividend of €73.50 per<br />

no-par value share. It is planned to offset<br />

the capital decrease caused by the special<br />

dividend by way of a capital increase within<br />

the framework of a pay-out, take-back procedure.<br />

Guarantee funds<br />

Based on the net premiums written, the<br />

guarantee ratio increased substantially yearon-year,<br />

remaining at a very high level<br />

(422.5%, up from 286.6% the previous<br />

year). Of this, the equity ratio totals 230.1%<br />

(previous year: 124.4%), and the reserve<br />

ratio amounts to 192.4% (previous year:<br />

162.2%).<br />

After deduction of Guarantee funds 2,631.9 1,756.3<br />

taxes on income<br />

and other taxes, net income for the year<br />

totaled €701.4 million (previous year: €36.6<br />

million). Following the release of €1.6 million<br />

from the reserve for own shares and an<br />

allocation of €33.0 million from net income<br />

to other revenue reserves, net retained profits<br />

of €670.0 million were disclosed for the<br />

year under review.<br />

17<br />

Guarantee funds 2002 2001<br />

€m €m<br />

Share capital 226.0 226.0<br />

Capital reserves 429.6 429.6<br />

Revenue reserves 76.1 70.0<br />

Net retained profits 701.4 36.6<br />

Shareholders’ equity 1,433.1 762.2<br />

Unearned premiums 88.2 62.6<br />

Aggregate reserve 491.0 400.6<br />

Reserve for loss and loss adjustment expenses 526.1 422.8<br />

Policyholders’ reserves 0.3 0.1<br />

Equalization provision and similar 87.7 105.0<br />

Other insurance reserves 5.4 3.0<br />

Total insurance reserves 1,198.7 994.1


Business developments in the individual<br />

insurance classes<br />

Life<br />

Currency developments impacted the gross<br />

premium volume<br />

18<br />

Life<br />

Gross premiums in € million<br />

400<br />

300<br />

200<br />

100<br />

338.5<br />

361,0<br />

2000 2001<br />

321,7<br />

2002<br />

The development of the life insurance markets<br />

was affected worldwide by the slump<br />

in share prices and low interest rates. As a<br />

result, customers moved away from fundand<br />

index-linked products, concentrating<br />

instead on guaranteed life insurance policies<br />

and traditional endowment insurance<br />

policies.<br />

Developments on the capital market meant<br />

that the German life insurance sector was<br />

faced with dwindling hidden reserves, the<br />

application of the amendments to section<br />

341b of the HGB (less strict lower of<br />

cost or market principle) and a reduction in<br />

profit-sharing, among other things. German<br />

life insurers also started selling Riester<br />

pension products, sales of which did not<br />

meet expectations.<br />

On the international life reinsurance markets,<br />

there was sustained demand for<br />

proportional and non-proportional risk<br />

transfer. Prices for nonproportional cumulative<br />

cover rose substantially following the<br />

events of September 11, 2001. However,<br />

the currently high level of rates are unlikely<br />

to be maintained in the long term. Demand<br />

for balance sheet protection solutions and<br />

traditional reinsurance financing is expected<br />

to increase in the future.<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>’s life insurance<br />

portfolio grew by €388.8 million to a total<br />

insured sum of €19.7 billion, an increase of<br />

2.0%. The net portfolio rose 2.2% to a total<br />

insured sum of €15.8 billion.<br />

Premiums from domestic business fell<br />

by 0.3% to €211.8 million in the year under<br />

review, while retained premiums grew by<br />

7.0% to €107.5 million.<br />

Gross premium income from foreign<br />

business, which was also impacted by<br />

exchange rate movements, fell. The volume<br />

of gross premiums increased by €38.7<br />

million, or 26.0%, while the volume of net<br />

premiums decreased by €52.8 million, or<br />

75.4%.<br />

Overall, gross premiums fell by €39.3<br />

million, or 10.9%, and net premiums by<br />

€45.8 million, or 26.8%.<br />

Life insurance recorded a profit of €5.1<br />

million at the end of the fiscal year (previous<br />

year: €3.2 million).


In terms of sums insured, the portfolio<br />

developed as follows:<br />

19<br />

2002 2001<br />

€m €m<br />

Reinsurance business assumed<br />

Sum insured Capital 14,404.3 14,419.5<br />

Annuity 5,261.4 4,857.5<br />

Business ceded<br />

Sum insured Capital 2,696.3 2,507.8<br />

Annuity 1,132.4 1,277.7<br />

Retained for own account<br />

Sum insured Capital 11,708.0 11,911.7<br />

Annuity 4,129.0 3,579.8<br />

Accident<br />

Growth in premium volume in domestic<br />

and foreign business<br />

Accident<br />

Gross premiums in € million<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

33,5<br />

2000<br />

36,5<br />

2001<br />

39,3<br />

2002<br />

2000 2001 2002<br />

Gross loss ratio % 41,3 49,8 49,0<br />

Gross expense ratio % 52,5 48,8 52,3<br />

Gross combined ratio % 93,9 98,6 101,3<br />

Accident insurance saw an increase in both<br />

the gross and the net premium volume from<br />

domestic business. While gross premium<br />

income rose by €1.6 million, or 7.0%,<br />

from €22.4 million to €24.0 million, retained<br />

premiums increased by €1.7 million, or<br />

7.5%, from €22.3 million to €24.0 million.<br />

Foreign business developed along similar<br />

lines. Gross premium income improved<br />

by €1.2 million, or 8.5%, to €15.3 million,<br />

with net premium income declining by<br />

€1.6 million, or 13.3%, to €14.1 million.<br />

Overall, gross premium income grew by<br />

7.6% to €39.3 million, while net premium<br />

income rose 9.6% to €38.1 million.<br />

General accident ended the year with a net<br />

loss of €0.7 million (previous year: a profit<br />

of €10.4 million). Despite an increased loss<br />

ratio in the year under review, an allocation<br />

was made in accordance with the calculation<br />

criteria for the equalization provision.<br />

As a result, this class recorded a loss of<br />

€1.2 million (previous year: a profit of<br />

€8.6 million).<br />

The premium volume from motor vehicle<br />

accident insurance was due almost exclusively<br />

to domestic business. As a result of<br />

the higher retentions by primary insurers in<br />

the <strong>R+V</strong> Group in previous years, reduced<br />

belated premiums led to a premium volume<br />

that was 60.8% lower in gross terms and<br />

61.7% lower in net terms than the belated<br />

prior-year level. This insurance class<br />

closed the year with a profit of €0.1 million<br />

(previous year: a profit of €0.3 million).<br />

Liability<br />

Rising loss ratios depress earnings<br />

Restructuring measures in Germany and<br />

abroad pushed down premium income.<br />

While the gross premium volume from<br />

domestic business fell by 8.6% to €28.2<br />

million, the figure for foreign business<br />

declined by 13.3% to €16.6 million. The<br />

retention premium in domestic business<br />

fell by 17.0% to €22.0 million and rose in<br />

foreign business by 27.4% to €10.9 million.


On the whole, gross premium income<br />

decreased by €5.2 million, or 10.4%, to<br />

€44.9 million and net premium income by<br />

€2.2 million to €32.9 million.<br />

Expenses for large claims such as “Lipobay”<br />

or “Sulzer” increased loss ratios in the<br />

year under review. The reported net loss<br />

ratio jumped by 18.3% to 79.0% and the<br />

net expense ratio by 6.4% to 30.9%. These<br />

factors led to a loss of €3.3 million (previous<br />

year: a profit of €5.2 million) in the<br />

balance on technical account, producing a<br />

loss of €3.6 million (previous year: €–2.7<br />

million) after allocation to the equalization<br />

provision.<br />

Motor<br />

Decline in premium volume – unsatisfactory<br />

earnings development<br />

20<br />

Liability<br />

Gross premiums in € million<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

40,3<br />

2000<br />

50,0<br />

2001<br />

44,9<br />

2002<br />

2000 2001 2002<br />

Gross loss ratio % 49,3 33,7 72,2<br />

Gross expense ratio % 39,9 30,5 31,6<br />

Gross combined ratio % 89,2 64,2 103,7<br />

Motor<br />

Gross premiums in € million<br />

250<br />

200<br />

150<br />

100<br />

50<br />

125,3<br />

2000<br />

211,6<br />

2001<br />

106,1<br />

2002<br />

2000 2001 2002<br />

Gross loss ratio % 76,0 79,4 92,8<br />

Gross expense ratio % 21,1 20,0 19,1<br />

Gross combined ratio % 97,1 99,4 111,9<br />

After a decline in rates over many years,<br />

the premiums on the German motor vehicle<br />

insurance market in particular climbed significantly<br />

once more. Nevertheless, retention<br />

increases by <strong>R+V</strong> Allgemeine <strong>Versicherung</strong><br />

<strong>AG</strong> plus restructuring effects caused a<br />

decline in gross premium income from<br />

domestic business. The premium volume<br />

fell by €104.0 million, or 66.7%, to €51.9<br />

million. The retention premium also fell as a<br />

result, by €24.9 million, or 32.3%, to €52.3<br />

million. Trends in foreign business were less<br />

pronounced. The gross premium volume<br />

dropped slightly by €1.5 million, or 2.7%,<br />

to €54.2 million, while the net premium<br />

remained almost constant at €51.1 million<br />

(previous year: €51.0 million).


Overall, gross premium income declined by<br />

€105.5 million, or 49.9%, from €211.6 million<br />

to €106.1 million. Net income after<br />

retrocessions amounted to €103.4 million,<br />

compared with €128.2 million in the previous<br />

year (–19.3%).<br />

Among the individual classes of motor<br />

insurance, domestic business performed<br />

almost in parallel. In the case of motor vehicle<br />

liability insurance, the gross premium<br />

volume fell by €74.4 million, or 68.4%, from<br />

€108.8 million to €34.4 million, while the net<br />

amount was down €18.8 million, or 35.0%,<br />

from €53.7 million to €34.9 million.<br />

Developments in the motor vehicle class<br />

were similar, with gross premium volumes<br />

of €47.0 million in the previous year down<br />

to €17.5 million in the fiscal year (–62.9%).<br />

Retained premiums amounted to €17.4 million<br />

after €23.5 million in the previous year<br />

(–26.1%).<br />

Foreign business performed differently<br />

across the various classes. Premiums in<br />

the motor vehicle liability insurance class<br />

declined by €6.9 million, or 13.5%, to €44.1<br />

million (gross) and €5.0 million, or 10.6%, to<br />

€42.1 (net). In contrast, gross premiums in<br />

the motor vehicle class increased by €5.3<br />

million from €4.8 million to €10,1 million<br />

(122.4%) while net premiums rose by<br />

€5.1 million, or 131.3%, from €3.9 million<br />

to €9.0 million.<br />

Motor vehicle liability insurance recorded a<br />

loss in both domestic and foreign business;<br />

the figure of €18.1 million exceeded the<br />

prior-year loss by €8.8 million. After withdrawals<br />

from the equalization provision, the<br />

loss fell to €10.3 million (previous year:<br />

€–14.9 million).<br />

21<br />

Motor vehicle cover also generated losses,<br />

in both domestic and foreign business.<br />

Provisions for the devastating effects of the<br />

flood damage to many regions of Germany,<br />

Austria and the Czech Republic in August<br />

2002 impacted results. At €2.3 million, the<br />

loss incurred in the fiscal year was much<br />

greater than that recorded in the previous<br />

year (€–1.0 million). Following withdrawals<br />

from the equalization provision, a slight<br />

profit of €0.1 million was generated (previous<br />

year: €–0.9 million).<br />

The overall balance on technical account in<br />

the motor insurance class was once again<br />

negative at €–20.4 million (previous year:<br />

€–10.3 million). After the withdrawal from<br />

the equalization provision, the loss fell to<br />

€10.2 million (previous year: €–15.8 million).<br />

Fire<br />

Strong growth in foreign business –<br />

Increased claims expenses impacted result<br />

for the fiscal year<br />

Gross premium income from fire insurance<br />

experienced strong growth during the fiscal<br />

year. The premium volume improved by<br />

€40.1 million, or 32.5%, from €123.7 million<br />

to €163.8 million. This development was<br />

principally attributable to foreign business.<br />

While domestic business rose by €2.5 million,<br />

or 9.2%, from €27.6 million to €30.1<br />

million, foreign business experienced<br />

above-average growth with premium<br />

increases of €37.6 million, or 39.2%, to<br />

€133.7 million. After retrocessions, retained<br />

premiums from domestic business rose by<br />

€2.1 million, or 12.0%, to €19.3 million,<br />

while a premium volume of €106.0 million<br />

was retained from foreign business. This<br />

corresponded to a growth rate of 41.2%.<br />

The share of premium income attributable<br />

to foreign business increased to 81.6%, up<br />

from 77.7% the previous year.


The technical result in the fire insurance<br />

class suffered under the effects of the<br />

events of September 11, 2001, as well as<br />

additional large claims and an increased<br />

number of basic claims. Provisions were<br />

also set up for the flood damage of August<br />

2002 and storm “Jeanette” in October<br />

2002, which also impacted earnings. Taken<br />

together, these factors led to a net loss of<br />

€33.0 million (previous year: €–24.3 million).<br />

After withdrawal from the equalization provision,<br />

the loss fell to €26.7 million (previous<br />

year: €–14.9 million).<br />

Marine and aviation<br />

Gross premiums up 33.0% – unsatisfactory<br />

earnings situation<br />

In the past fiscal year, the marine insurance<br />

class again achieved a considerable<br />

increase in premiums. Premium income<br />

rose in both gross and net terms.<br />

22<br />

Fire<br />

Gross premiums in € million<br />

150<br />

100<br />

50<br />

127,5<br />

2000<br />

123,7<br />

2001<br />

163,8<br />

2002<br />

2000 2001 2002<br />

Gross loss ratio % 83,4 103,1 90,5<br />

Gross expense ratio % 33,8 35,4 29,6<br />

Gross combined ratio % 117,2 138,5 120,1<br />

Marine and aviation<br />

Gross premiums in € million<br />

90<br />

80<br />

70<br />

60<br />

50<br />

40<br />

30<br />

20<br />

10<br />

38,0<br />

2000<br />

62,0<br />

2001<br />

82,5<br />

2002<br />

2000 2001 2002<br />

Gross loss ratio % 94,6 124,5 93,0<br />

Gross expense ratio % 26,3 25,2 23,8<br />

Gross combined ratio % 120,9 149,7 116,8<br />

While gross premium growth of €15.3 million<br />

(30.2%) to €66.1 million was recorded,<br />

net premiums rose by €13.2 million, or<br />

34.2%, to €51.8 million.<br />

Gross domestic premiums fell slightly by<br />

€0.2 million, or 1.0%, from €22.5 million to<br />

€22.3 million. In contrast, the gross premium<br />

volume from foreign business grew by<br />

€15.6 million (55.1%) from €28.2 million to<br />

€43.8 million.<br />

The retention premium for domestic business<br />

rose by € 1.1 million, or 8.6%, from<br />

€13.0 million to €14.1 million; the increase<br />

for foreign business was €12.1 million<br />

(47.2%) from €25.6 million to €37.7 million.


Major claim events such as ”Petrobras“ or<br />

the explosion in a chemicals factory in<br />

Toulouse impacted the earnings situation,<br />

so that this class closed the year with a<br />

loss from both domestic and foreign business.<br />

The net technical loss totaled €13.3<br />

million (prior year: €–14.0 million). As there<br />

was no change in the calculation of the<br />

equalization provision during the year under<br />

report, the technical loss remained at €13.3<br />

million (previous year: €–14.0 million).<br />

Aviation business during the year under<br />

review was dominated by the events in the<br />

US on September 11, 2001 and a general<br />

economic downturn. Following September<br />

11, market players renewed their previously<br />

half-hearted restructuring efforts.<br />

The strategy of concentrating on target<br />

customers in an improving market environment<br />

was used to broaden the premium<br />

base at improved conditions. The gross<br />

premium volume in aviation and aerospace<br />

insurance improved by €5.2 million, or<br />

46.1%, to €16.4 million. The retention<br />

premium rose by €4.4 million, or 42.7%, to<br />

€14.7 million, in parallel to the development<br />

of gross premium income.<br />

This growth was mainly due to foreign<br />

business. In this segment, gross premium<br />

volume climbed by €4.5 million, or 56.3%,<br />

to €12.4 million, while net premium volume<br />

rose €4.0 million, or 50.5%, to €11.8 million.<br />

Gross domestic business grew by €0.7 million,<br />

or 21.3%, to €4.0 million; the net figure<br />

was up €0.4 million, or 18.0%, to €2.9 million.<br />

This insurance class posted a loss of €0.4<br />

million at the end of the fiscal year, lower<br />

than the previous year’s loss of €1.4 million.<br />

This figure increased to €1.3 million (previous<br />

year: €–0.6 million) following the allocation<br />

to the equalization provision.<br />

23<br />

Other insurance classes<br />

Growth in premium volume – increased net<br />

loss ratios<br />

Other classes<br />

Gross premiums in € million<br />

200<br />

150<br />

100<br />

50<br />

166,3<br />

2000<br />

183,7<br />

2001<br />

199,6<br />

2002<br />

2000 2001 2002<br />

Gross loss ratio % 71,3 61,0 70,4<br />

Gross expense ratio % 34,0 34,0 32,5<br />

Gross combined ratio % 105,3 95,0 102,9<br />

The trend towards an increase in the premium<br />

volume last year continued in the fiscal<br />

year under review. Premium income rose in<br />

gross terms by €15.9 million, or 8.7%, to<br />

€199.6 million and by €28.9 million, or<br />

28.1%, to €131.9 million net.<br />

While premium income from domestic business<br />

fell by €2.6 million, or 23%, to €110.2<br />

million, the net volume increased by €10.1<br />

million, or 23.6%, to €53.1 million. Foreign<br />

business developed positively in both gross<br />

and net terms. The gross premium volume<br />

grew by €18.5 million, or 26.1%, rising from<br />

€70.9 million to €89.4 million, while the<br />

retention premium improved by €18.8 million<br />

(31.3%), from €60.0 million to €78.8<br />

million.


Key contributions to the premium volume<br />

came from the credit and bonds, storm,<br />

livestock, health, hail/crop, legal, comprehensive<br />

home contents and fidelity insurance.<br />

Loss ratios developed differently to the<br />

previous year. While improvements were<br />

made in the net loss ratios disclosed on<br />

the balance sheet for burglary and theft,<br />

water damage, hail/crop, credit and legal<br />

insurance, the opposite was true for the<br />

comprehensive home contents, comprehensive<br />

homeowners, storm, engineering,<br />

livestock, bonds, fidelity and health insurance<br />

classes.<br />

Profits were generated in the burglary and<br />

theft, water damage, hail/crop and legal<br />

insurance classes, while technical losses<br />

were recorded in the credit and bonds,<br />

livestock, engineering, storm, health, comprehensive<br />

home contents, comprehensive<br />

homeowners and fidelity insurance classes.<br />

Overall, the other insurance classes generated<br />

a net loss of €15.7 million in the year<br />

under review (prior year: €–2.4 million).<br />

Following withdrawals from the equalization<br />

provision, the loss fell to €13.1 million (prior<br />

year: €–8.2 million).<br />

Staff development<br />

As of December 31, 2002, the number of<br />

people employed in comparison to the previous<br />

year was as follows:<br />

24<br />

2002 2001<br />

Total number of employees 232 225<br />

of whom:<br />

Full-time 204 193<br />

Part-time 23 26<br />

Employees with<br />

fixed-term contracts 5 6<br />

223 people were employed at the head<br />

office in Wiesbaden (previous year: 216)<br />

and nine people were employed at the<br />

branch office in Singapore, as in the previous<br />

year.<br />

Contractual relations within the<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Group<br />

Members of the Boards of Management<br />

of a number of <strong>R+V</strong> Group companies also<br />

hold similar positions at other <strong>R+V</strong> Group<br />

companies.<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> companies have concluded service<br />

agreements within the Group. In line with<br />

these agreements, cross-enterprise services<br />

are performed by one of the following companies<br />

– <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>, <strong>R+V</strong> Allgemeine<br />

<strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>, <strong>R+V</strong> Lebensversicherung<br />

<strong>AG</strong> or Rhein-Main Assistance<br />

GmbH. The services performed for the<br />

other companies primarily extend to the<br />

following areas: sales, investments, asset<br />

management, accounting, premium collection,<br />

financial control, legal, auditing, communications,<br />

personnel management, general<br />

administration and IT. The companies<br />

receiving these services are charged after<br />

these have been provided; they have rights<br />

of instruction and control over the outsourced<br />

areas.<br />

In addition, the companies of the <strong>R+V</strong><br />

Group have concluded an agreement on<br />

central cash management and a central<br />

financial clearing system.


Shareholder structure<br />

As of the balance sheet date, shares in<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong> were held indirectly<br />

or directly by the following shareholders<br />

belonging to the union of cooperative<br />

banks:<br />

– DZ BANK <strong>AG</strong> Deutsche Zentral-<br />

Genossenschaftsbank, Frankfurt/Main<br />

– WGZ-Bank Westdeutsche<br />

Genossenschafts-Zentralbank eG,<br />

Düsseldorf<br />

– Projekt 7 GmbH, Berlin<br />

– Bayerische Raiffeisen Beteiligungs-<strong>AG</strong>,<br />

Munich<br />

– Beteiligungs-<strong>AG</strong> der Bayerischen<br />

Volksbanken, Munich<br />

– Genossenschaftliche<br />

Beteiligungsgesellschaft Kurhessen <strong>AG</strong>,<br />

Kassel<br />

– Norddeutsche Genossenschaftliche<br />

Beteiligungs-<strong>AG</strong>, Hanover<br />

– 791 branches of Volksbank and<br />

Raiffeisenbank throughout Germany<br />

Related parties<br />

In the report prepared in accordance with<br />

section 312 of the Aktiengesetz (AktG –<br />

German Public Companies Act) on related<br />

parties, the Board of Management declared<br />

that, according to the circumstances known<br />

to it at the time the transactions mentioned<br />

in the report were performed, the Company<br />

received adequate consideration for each<br />

transaction, and that it did not take or fail to<br />

take any other measures subject to disclosure.<br />

25<br />

New Group structure<br />

In August 2002, the Executive bodies of<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>, <strong>R+V</strong> Lebensversicherung<br />

<strong>AG</strong> and <strong>R+V</strong> Allgemeine <strong>Versicherung</strong><br />

<strong>AG</strong> approved a new Group<br />

structure.<br />

The new Group structure will bundle the<br />

operating insurance companies under the<br />

umbrella of two new holding companies. All<br />

interests in the holding companies will be<br />

held by <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>. <strong>R+V</strong> KOM-<br />

POSIT Holding GmbH holds the interests in<br />

companies in the property and casualty<br />

insurance classes, i.e. <strong>R+V</strong> Allgemeine<br />

<strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>, <strong>R+V</strong> Rechtsschutzversicherung<br />

<strong>AG</strong>, KRAV<strong>AG</strong>-LOGISTIC<br />

<strong>Versicherung</strong>s-<strong>AG</strong> and KRAV<strong>AG</strong>-ALLGE-<br />

MEINE <strong>Versicherung</strong>s-<strong>AG</strong>. <strong>R+V</strong> Personen<br />

Holding GmbH comprises the business of<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Lebensversicherung <strong>AG</strong>, <strong>R+V</strong>-Pensionsfonds<br />

<strong>AG</strong> and Krankenversicherung<br />

<strong>AG</strong>. This gives the <strong>R+V</strong> Group a forwardlooking<br />

structure that will pave the way for<br />

strategic activities in the future. Grouping<br />

togerther the operating insurance companies<br />

on a single level under the new holding<br />

companies enables the Group to assign<br />

clear management and performance<br />

responsibility.


Risks of future development<br />

Risk management process<br />

The Gesetz zur Kontrolle und Transparenz<br />

im Unternehmensbereich (KonTraG –<br />

German Act on Control and Transparency in<br />

Business) that took effect on May 1, 1998<br />

details the duties of the Board of Management<br />

to report on the risks of future development<br />

and to provide appropriate risk<br />

management. In this context, risk management<br />

covers all systematic measures<br />

involved in recognizing, evaluating and<br />

controlling risks.<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong> is integrated in the<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Group’s risk management process.<br />

The organization of the latter – including the<br />

relevant risk officers – and the risk principles<br />

are documented in a risk management<br />

manual. Risks are managed and analyzed<br />

with the aid of an IT application.<br />

The <strong>R+V</strong> Group has a number of systems at<br />

its disposal to manage and control risks.<br />

These systems are further developed on an<br />

ongoing basis and supplemented by a topdown<br />

approach to these instruments as<br />

part of a permanent early warning system.<br />

The regular risk conferences and central<br />

risk reporting to the Board of Management<br />

guarantee that risks to future development<br />

that could impact the Company as a going<br />

concern are identified, analyzed and controlled<br />

in a timely manner. The risks monitored<br />

are technical risks, investment risks<br />

relating to receivables from the insurance<br />

business, default risks, operating risks, and<br />

global and strategic risks. The latter relate<br />

to risks from changes in the market and<br />

relationships with sales partners, as well as<br />

risks involved in the core activities of planning<br />

and control.<br />

26<br />

Technical risks:<br />

The main technical risks for a reinsurer lie<br />

in an unbalanced portfolio, inappropriate<br />

liability for catastrophic loss and fundamental<br />

changes in the basic trends on the main<br />

markets.<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong> counters these risks<br />

by continuously tracking the markets.<br />

Particular importance is attached to maintaining<br />

a balanced portfolio – both in terms<br />

of diversification on a global scale and<br />

across different classes of insurance.<br />

Risks are assumed within prescribed underwriting<br />

boundaries that limit liability for both<br />

individual and cumulative losses. The level<br />

and frequency of possible impacts from<br />

catastrophic losses are analyzed and<br />

tracked on an ongoing basis using established<br />

industry software, supplemented<br />

by additional verification by the Company<br />

itself. Liabilities assumed, particularly in the<br />

area of cumulative losses, are reinsured on<br />

national and international reinsurance markets<br />

with companies with first-class credit<br />

ratings. Technical provisions are maintained<br />

at appropriate levels. Based on net premiums<br />

written, the Company has a high guarantee<br />

funds ratio and a high equity ratio.<br />

Default risks relating to receivables from<br />

the insurance business:<br />

The default risk relating to the billed reinsurance<br />

receivables from cedents and retrocessionaries<br />

is limited by monitoring the<br />

Standard & Poor’s ratings on a regular<br />

basis.


Investment risks:<br />

In order to create „insurance coverage“<br />

products, insurance companies expose<br />

themselves to risks such as changes in<br />

market prices, credit ratings and liquidity<br />

as part of their investment activities. <strong>R+V</strong><br />

<strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong> counters these risks by<br />

observing the basic principle of achieving<br />

the greatest possible security and profitability<br />

while maintaining the liquidity of the<br />

insurance company at all times. In particular,<br />

investment policy aims to minimize risks<br />

by maintaining an appropriate mix and<br />

diversification of investments. Derivative<br />

financial instruments, structured products<br />

or asset backed securities are only used in<br />

accordance with supervisory law provisions<br />

set out in BAV (Federal Insurance Supervisory<br />

Office) circulars R 3/2000, R 3/99<br />

and R 1/2002. Their use is explicitly regulated<br />

by internal directives. Extensive, timely<br />

reporting ensures that the different risks are<br />

regularly monitored and presented transparently.<br />

Extrapolating the capital market situation<br />

at the end of 2002 to December 31,<br />

2003 and continuing the methods adopted<br />

in 2002 to calculate lasting impairments,<br />

the Company expects investment income<br />

to make a positive contribution to the net<br />

income for the year.<br />

At an organizational level, <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong><br />

<strong>AG</strong> counters investment risks by ensuring<br />

the strict functional separation of trading,<br />

settlement and financial control.<br />

Currency risks:<br />

As far as possible, liabilities in foreign currencies<br />

arising from reinsurance business<br />

are matched with investments in these foreign<br />

currencies. This allows exchange rate<br />

gains and losses to be largely offset by the<br />

correlative effect.<br />

27<br />

Operating risks:<br />

Operating risks are risks from general business<br />

activities. They arise as a result of<br />

human behavior, technical faults, weaknesses<br />

in process or project management<br />

or external influences.<br />

Risk provisioning using<br />

the internal control system:<br />

The main instrument used by the <strong>R+V</strong><br />

Group to limit operating risks is the internal<br />

control system. The Group protects against<br />

the risk of errors and fraudulent activities in<br />

its administration by providing regulations<br />

and controls in its specialist departments<br />

and by reviewing the application and effectiveness<br />

of the internal control systems in<br />

Group audits. As far as possible, payment<br />

flows and undertakings are handled by<br />

computer. Additional security is provided by<br />

predefined, electronically stored powers of<br />

attorney and authorization rules, as well as<br />

automatic random checks performed by the<br />

stored random generator when policies are<br />

drawn up. Manual processing is conducted<br />

according to the dual control principle.<br />

The internal monitoring of the regulations<br />

governing the risk management system,<br />

particularly with regard to their effectiveness,<br />

was reviewed by the Group audit<br />

department in 2001 for the first time. The<br />

implementation of the resulting measures<br />

was monitored by the Group audit unit and<br />

within the framework of the risk conference.


Provision for IT risks:<br />

In the IT area, the security of programs and<br />

data and the ability to ensure ongoing operations<br />

is guaranteed by comprehensive<br />

access controls and safety precautions.<br />

A particular risk would be the partial or<br />

complete failure of the IT systems. The <strong>R+V</strong><br />

Group has made provisions against this by<br />

establishing two separate data centers,<br />

each with special access protection, sensitive<br />

fire protection measures and a secure<br />

power supply based on emergency power<br />

generators. A defined restart procedure to<br />

be used in the event of a disaster is tested<br />

for its effectiveness in exercises on a regular<br />

basis. Data is stored in different <strong>R+V</strong><br />

buildings in high security areas as well as at<br />

additional external locations. The telecoms<br />

infrastructure has been designed with a<br />

high level of redundancy, both internally<br />

within buildings and with regard to external<br />

network access.<br />

Quality assurance for the IT systems is<br />

provided by way of established problem<br />

and change management processes. All<br />

events of relevance to services are recorded<br />

and tracked in accordance with their<br />

significance. Current topics are dealt with in<br />

daily conferences and allocated processing<br />

priority. Monthly service control meetings<br />

attended by all IT division heads are held to<br />

escalate problems and take countermeasures<br />

when fixed thresholds in relation to<br />

system availability and response times are<br />

exceeded.<br />

28<br />

Risk provisions for major projects and<br />

investments:<br />

The <strong>R+V</strong> Group has laid down binding procedures<br />

for the planning and implementation<br />

of projects and investments. In line with<br />

these specifications, an investment committee<br />

regularly examines major projects and<br />

investments, paying particular attention to<br />

events, problems and (counter)measures,<br />

as well as adherence to budgets. Necessary<br />

changes are implemented immediately.<br />

These are also coordinated with the risk<br />

conference committee.<br />

Summary of the risk situation<br />

The instruments and methods of analysis<br />

outlined here show that <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong><br />

<strong>AG</strong> has a comprehensive system that satisfies<br />

the risk identification and analysis<br />

requirements needed for efficient risk management.<br />

To date, it has not identified any<br />

developments that could have a material<br />

long-term effect on the Company’s net<br />

assets, financial position and results of<br />

operations.


Significant events and outlook<br />

The global economy is currently in recession,<br />

and the economic prospects for the<br />

near future look relatively poor. It has also<br />

become clear that no country or region can<br />

replace the US in its role as the “motor”<br />

of the global economy in the last few years.<br />

This is not the only reason why the US<br />

holds the key to any economic turnaround:<br />

before September 11, 2001, it was generally<br />

assumed that a recovery was on the<br />

cards. The terrorist attacks put paid to this<br />

early turnaround, and the negative sentiment<br />

spread to other countries. Conversely,<br />

this leads us to conclude that an improvement<br />

in the US economy would have a positive<br />

effect on other national economies.<br />

Our business policy is based even more<br />

firmly than in the past on three principles.<br />

We intend to systematically deploy our<br />

capacity in areas where we can obtain an<br />

appropriate price for the risk we assume.<br />

Our involvement is based on the premise<br />

that the overall exposure is clearly defined<br />

and that any potential cumulative risks are<br />

recognized and – if necessary – limited in a<br />

suitable fashion.<br />

29<br />

Long-term, trust-based cooperation with<br />

our customers is one of our main priorities.<br />

At the same time, however, a common<br />

basic understanding is essential if the economic<br />

prospects of a business partnership<br />

are to be transparent, balanced and profitable<br />

for both sides in the long term.<br />

We systematically implemented these principles<br />

as part of our renewal negotiations in<br />

2002, withdrawing from unprofitable contractual<br />

relationships in the property and<br />

accident insurance business. The resulting<br />

decline in the premium volume will, however,<br />

be more than offset by new underwriting<br />

business, so that we can expect<br />

moderate premium growth in the next fiscal<br />

year along with a clear improvement in the<br />

balance on technical account.<br />

The consolidation measures initiated in<br />

2001 for the 2002 underwriting year will<br />

not affect the balance sheet until 2003, due<br />

to the deferred reporting of third-party business.<br />

Events during the current fiscal year<br />

to date provide compelling evidence that<br />

our consolidation strategy will be successful.<br />

This is why we have systematically pursued<br />

this approach in the 2003 underwriting<br />

year, with the expectation that 2004 will see<br />

a further improvement in third-party business.<br />

Wiesbaden, April 8, 2003<br />

The Board of Management


Appendix to the Management <strong>Report</strong><br />

In the fiscal year, the Company was active<br />

in the following fields of domestic and<br />

foreign reinsurance:<br />

Life<br />

Health<br />

Accident<br />

Liability<br />

Motor<br />

Aviation<br />

Legal<br />

Fire and allied perils<br />

Burglary and theft<br />

Water damage<br />

Glass<br />

Storm<br />

Comprehensive home contents<br />

Comprehensive homeowners<br />

Hail<br />

Livestock<br />

Engineering<br />

Marine<br />

Credit and bonds<br />

Other<br />

31


Proposal on the Appropriation<br />

of Profits<br />

Net retained profits for the fiscal year amount to €669,989,823.<br />

We propose to the General Meeting that the net retained profits be used as follows:<br />

32<br />

€3.50 dividend 30,453,500<br />

plus €73.50 special dividend<br />

per no-par value share for 8,701,000 shares 639,523,500<br />

Retained profits brought forward 12,823<br />

€<br />

669,989,823


<strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong><br />

<strong>Annual</strong> Financial<br />

Statements 2002


Balance Sheet as of December 31, 2002*<br />

Assets<br />

34<br />

2002 2001<br />

€ € € € €<br />

A. Unpaid contributions to subscribed capital – –<br />

thereof: called up: –€ (–€)<br />

B. Intangible assets<br />

I. Start-up and business expansion costs – –<br />

II. Goodwill – –<br />

III. Other intangible assets 826 154,435<br />

826 154,435<br />

C. Investments<br />

I. Land, land rights and buildings including<br />

buildings on third-party land 4,004,642 4,242,230<br />

II. Investments in affiliated and associated<br />

companies<br />

1. Shares in affiliated companies 1,450,554,771 767,460,481<br />

2. Loans to affiliated companies 71,406,481 72,671,048<br />

3. Investments in associates 63,831,709 51,332,602<br />

4. Loans to associates – 1,585,792,961 –<br />

III. Other financial investments<br />

1. Shares, investment certificates and other<br />

variable-yield securities 82,543,983 92,057,798<br />

2. Bearer bonds and other fixed-income<br />

securities 253,471,023 128,774,977<br />

3. Receivables from mortgages, land<br />

charges and annuity land charges – –<br />

4. Other loans<br />

a) Registered bonds 120,371,295 166,387,564<br />

b) Notes receivable and loans 66,802,483 66,802,483<br />

c) Loans and advance payments on<br />

insurance policies – –<br />

d) Miscellaneous loans 9,112,919 196,286,697 5,112,919<br />

5. Deposits with banks 19,616,565 10,787,457<br />

6. Miscellaneous investments 3,547,930 555,466,197 3,548,043<br />

IV. Deposits with ceding undertakings 1,228,421,281 1,079,938,052<br />

3,373,685,080 2,449,115,654<br />

* In the case of “thereof” notes, the figures for the previous year are shown in parentheses.


35<br />

2002 2001<br />

€ € € € €<br />

D. Assets held to cover linked liabilities – –<br />

E. Debtors<br />

I. Debtors arising out of direct insurance<br />

operations – –<br />

II. Debtors arising out of reinsurance operations 111,451,670 108,450,843<br />

thereof:<br />

affiliated companies<br />

€7,780,389 (€23,258,661)<br />

associates<br />

–€ (–€)<br />

III. Other debtors 323,863,512 133,773,297<br />

thereof:<br />

affiliated companies<br />

€270,622,759 (€57,833,573)<br />

associates<br />

–€ (–€)<br />

435,315,181 242,224,140<br />

F. Other assets<br />

I. Tangible assets and inventories 514,091 543,279<br />

II. Cash with banks, checks, and cash on hand 17,349,870 8,989,880<br />

III. Own shares – –<br />

Notional value:<br />

–€ (–€)<br />

IV. Miscellaneous assets 518,778 5,143,394<br />

18,382,739 14,676,553<br />

G. Prepaid expenses<br />

I. Accrued interest and rent 11,746,072 12,580,573<br />

II. Other prepaid expenses 12,559,036 1,481,809<br />

24,305,108 14,062,382<br />

H. Anticipated tax relief for future financial<br />

years in line with section 274 (2) HBG – –<br />

I. Deficit not covered by shareholders’ equity – –<br />

3,851,688,934 2,720,233,164


Equity and liabilities<br />

36<br />

2002 2001<br />

€ € € € €<br />

A. Shareholders’ equity<br />

I. Subscribed capital 226,000,000 226,000,000<br />

II. Capital reserves 429,590,228 429,590,228<br />

III. Revenue reserves<br />

1. Legal reserve – –<br />

2. Reserve for own shares – 1,583,458<br />

3. Statutory reserves – –<br />

4. Reserve in line with section 58 (2a) AktG – –<br />

5. Other revenue reserves 107,558,087 107,558,087 68,408,087<br />

IV. Net retained profits 669,989,823 36,627,976<br />

thereof profits brought forward:<br />

€24,476 (–€)<br />

1,433,138,138 762,209,749<br />

B. Participation certificates – –<br />

C. Subordinated liabilities 76,693,782 76,693,782<br />

D. Special tax-allowable reserves<br />

(in line with section 6b EStG) 357,608 –<br />

E. Technical provisions<br />

I. Unearned premiums<br />

1. Gross 119,882,382 80,617,725<br />

2. less:<br />

Reinsurance amount 31,645,128 88,237,254 18,019,219<br />

II. Mathematic reserve<br />

1. Gross 1,106,559,293 1,018,388,297<br />

2. less:<br />

Reinsurance amount 615,531,444 491,027,848 617,762,309<br />

III. Claims outstanding<br />

1. Gross 863,043,905 810,192,189<br />

2. less:<br />

Reinsurance amount 336,925,214 526,118,691 387,405,479<br />

IV. Provision for bonuses and rebates<br />

1. Gross 318,454 67,980<br />

2. less:<br />

Reinsurance amount – 318,454 –<br />

V. Equalization provision and similar provisions 87,657,592 105,027,706<br />

VI. Other technical provisions<br />

1. Gross 5,743,121 3,419,504<br />

2. less:<br />

Reinsurance amount 355,502 5,387,619 410,030<br />

1,198,747,459 994,116,364


37<br />

2002 2001<br />

€ € € € €<br />

F. Technical provisions for linked liabilities – –<br />

G. Other provisions<br />

I. Provisions for pensions and similar<br />

obligations 16,625,387 15,505,184<br />

II. Tax provisions 3,867,943 64,529,960<br />

III. Provisions for anticipated tax charges in<br />

future years in line with section 274 (1) HGB 1,100,000 –<br />

IV. Other provisions 4,051,143 5,082,724<br />

25,644,472 85,117,868<br />

H. Deposits received from reinsurers 642,823,871 627,417,980<br />

I. Other liabilities<br />

I. Creditors arising out of direct insurance<br />

operations – –<br />

II. Creditors arising out of reinsurance<br />

operations 158,694,363 119,524,322<br />

thereof:<br />

affiliated companies<br />

€28,616,932 (€9,342,063)<br />

associates<br />

€4,823 (€43,080)<br />

III. Bonds 19,576,050 19,896,405<br />

thereof convertible:<br />

–€ –€<br />

IV. Liabilities to banks 50,035,103 –<br />

V. Other creditors 245,816,191 35,078,141<br />

thereof: taxes<br />

€335,291 (€2,444,031)<br />

social security contributions<br />

€281,607 (€271,272)<br />

affiliated companies<br />

€239,162,489 (€25,970,820)<br />

associates<br />

€887,304 (€887,304)<br />

474,121,707 174,498,868<br />

K. Deferred income 161,897 178,553<br />

3,851,688,934 2,720,233,164


Income Statement for the period from<br />

January 1 to December 31, 2002*<br />

38<br />

2002 2001<br />

€ € € €<br />

I. Technical account<br />

1. Premiums earned – net:<br />

a. Gross premiums written 957,885,754 1,028,543,084<br />

b. Reinsurance premiums ceded 334,996,177 622,889,577 415,809,225<br />

c. Change in provision for unearned premiums – gross –41,541,313 –17,558,066<br />

d. Change in provision for unearned premiums – reinsurers’ share 13,621,075 –27,920,238 3,416,120<br />

594,969,339 598,591,914<br />

2. Allocated investment return – net 20,554,117 13,365,604<br />

3. Other technical income – net 1,508,815 4,252,062<br />

4. Claims incurred – net<br />

a. Claims paid<br />

aa. Gross 606,640,514 589,354,261<br />

bb. Reinsurers’ share 239,179,762 367,460,752 255,307,416<br />

b. Change in provision for claims outstanding<br />

aa. Gross 68,159,399 86,277,406<br />

bb. Reinsurers’ share –46,900,593 115,059,992 8,207,058<br />

482,520,744 412,117,193<br />

5. Change in other technical provisions – net<br />

a. Mathematical provision – net 7,422,344 –46,484,166<br />

b. Other technical provisions – net –2,492,500 –1,641,382<br />

4,929,844 –48,125,549<br />

6. Bonus and rebates – net 530,019 105,674<br />

7. Operating expenses – net<br />

a. Operating expenses – gross 307,128,378 300,735,368<br />

b. Less:<br />

reinsurance commissions and profit participations received 87,182,489 112,143,249<br />

219,945,889 188,592,119<br />

8. Other technical expenses – net 520,259 557,688<br />

9. Subtotal –81,554,796 –33,288,643<br />

10. Change in the equalization provision and similar provisions 17,370,114 –10,909,718<br />

11. Balance on technical result – net –64,184,681 –44,198,361<br />

* In the case of “thereof” notes, the figures for the previous year are shown in parentheses.


2002 2001<br />

€ € € € €<br />

II. Non-technical account<br />

1. Investment income<br />

a. Income from investments<br />

thereof:<br />

from affiliated companies<br />

3,081,850 32,163,626<br />

€2,450,000 (€31,466,306)<br />

b. Miscellaneous investment income<br />

thereof:<br />

from affiliated companies<br />

€26,822,301 (€28,756,194)<br />

aa. Income from land, land rights and<br />

buildings including buildings on third<br />

party land 584,604 531,163<br />

bb. Miscellaneous investment income 79,032,078 79,616,683 69,580,098<br />

c. Income from write-ups 78,710 544,981<br />

d. Realized gains on investments 473,839,486 1,785,420<br />

e. Income from profit pooling and profit<br />

transfer agreements 282,593,773 40,324,700<br />

f. Income from the release of special<br />

tax-allowable reserves – –<br />

839,210,502 144,929,988<br />

2. Investment expenses<br />

a. Investment management expenses,<br />

interest expenses and other investment<br />

expenses 5,351,761 4,215,745<br />

b. Write-downs on investments 4,571,382 1,319,842<br />

c. Realized losses on investments 432,475 –<br />

d. Expenses for losses assumed<br />

e. Allocation to special tax-allowable<br />

– –<br />

reserves 357,608 –<br />

10,713,226 5,535,587<br />

828,497,276 139,394,401<br />

3. Allocated investment return –41,868,699 –35,848,288<br />

786,628,577 103,546,113<br />

4. Other income 19,802,043 14,568,164<br />

5. Other expenses 39,698,391 29,500,508<br />

–19,896,348 –14,932,344<br />

6. Non-technical result 766,732,229 88,613,768<br />

7. Result from ordinary activities 702,547,547 44,415,407<br />

39


40<br />

2002 2001<br />

€ € € €<br />

8. Extraordinary income – –<br />

9. Extraordinary expenses – –<br />

10. Extraordinary result – –<br />

11. Taxes on income 1,117,938 7,744,496<br />

thereof reallocation within fiscal entity:<br />

–€ (–€18,490,058)<br />

12. Other taxes 47,721 42,935<br />

thereof reallocation within fiscal entity:<br />

–€520,939 (–€129,232)<br />

1,165,659 7,787,431<br />

13. Income from losses assumed – –<br />

14. Profit transferred as a result of profit pooling<br />

and profit transfer agreements – –<br />

15. Net income for the year 701,381,889 36,627,977<br />

16. Retained profits brought forward from the previous year 24,476 –<br />

17. Withdrawals from capital reserves – –<br />

18. Withdrawals from revenue reserves<br />

a. from legal reserve – –<br />

b. from reserve for own shares 1,583,458 –<br />

c. from statutory reserves – –<br />

d. from other reserves – 1,583,458<br />

1,583,458 1,583,458<br />

19. Transfers from participation certificates – –<br />

20. Appropriations to other revenue reserves<br />

a. to legal reserve – –<br />

b. to reserve for own shares – 1,583,458<br />

c. to statutory reserves – –<br />

d. to other revenue reserves 33,000,000 –<br />

33,000,000 1,583,458<br />

21. Transfers to participation certificates – –<br />

22. Net retained profits 669,989,823 36,627,976


Notes<br />

Accounting policies<br />

Basis of preparation<br />

The annual financial statements of <strong>R+V</strong><br />

<strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong> for 2002 were prepared in<br />

accordance with the provisions of the Handelsgesetzbuch<br />

(HGB – German Commercial<br />

Code), the Aktiengesetz (AktG –<br />

German Public Companies Act) and the<br />

provisions of the <strong>Versicherung</strong>saufsichtsgesetz<br />

(V<strong>AG</strong> – German Act on Private<br />

Insurance Undertakings) as well as the<br />

Verordnung über Rechnungslegung von<br />

<strong>Versicherung</strong>sunternehmen (RechVersV –<br />

German Federal Regulations on Insurance<br />

Accounting) of November 8, 1994.<br />

Use of simplification procedure<br />

The annual financial statements for 2002<br />

also cover all business assumed by <strong>R+V</strong><br />

Group companies in 2002, domestic and<br />

foreign third-party life insurance business<br />

and the business of our branch office in<br />

Singapore.<br />

As other non-life business underwritten on<br />

the international reinsurance market is often<br />

settled with the transferring parties long<br />

after the balance sheet date, the provision<br />

laid down in section 27 (1) in conjunction<br />

with section 3 of the RechVersV on approximation<br />

and simplification procedures has<br />

been applied. In line with this, business with<br />

a gross premium volume of €387.7 million<br />

or a 40.5% share of total premiums written<br />

was included one year in arrears. Technical<br />

provisions were increased sufficiently to<br />

meet current and future obligations.<br />

Intangible assets were valued at cost and<br />

written down over their estimated useful<br />

life. Additions in the fiscal year were generally<br />

written down pro rata.<br />

Land, land rights and buildings including<br />

buildings on third-party land were recorded<br />

at acquisition or manufacturing cost less<br />

write-downs. Straight-line depreciation was<br />

performed using the rate allowed by tax<br />

law.<br />

41<br />

Shares in affiliated companies and<br />

associates and other investments were<br />

recorded at cost. Investments held in<br />

foreign currencies were translated using<br />

the exchange rate applicable at the time of<br />

acquisition.<br />

Investments in associates were valued<br />

according to the length of time they have<br />

been held by the Company, as were other<br />

variable-yield securities, bearer bonds<br />

and other fixed-income securities, other<br />

loans and deposits with banks.<br />

Shares, investment certificates and other<br />

variable-yield securities, bearer bonds<br />

and other fixed-income securities were<br />

reported in line with the strict principle of<br />

the lower of cost or market. Write-ups were<br />

made in accordance with section 280 (1)<br />

HGB. These items also include derivative<br />

financial instruments; these were combined<br />

with existing securities in the portfolio to<br />

form microhedges for hedge accounting<br />

purposes.<br />

The equities component for the mixed<br />

funds assigned to the fixed assets in line<br />

with section 341b HGB was valued at the<br />

average rate for the year plus 10%. The<br />

fixed-income component was carried at<br />

the principal amount; derivative hedges<br />

were included at their hedge rate.<br />

The acquisition costs in euros of securities<br />

held in foreign currencies were calculated<br />

using the price of the security and the<br />

exchange rate as of the time of acquisition;<br />

the market value in euros was calculated on<br />

the basis of the price of the security and<br />

the exchange rate as of the balance sheet<br />

date.<br />

Other loans and deposits with banks<br />

were reported at their repayment value,<br />

insofar as specific valuation allowances did<br />

not have to be performed. Deposits with<br />

banks in foreign currencies were translated<br />

using the exchange rate as of the balance<br />

sheet date.


Premiums and discounts were amortized<br />

over the maturity period. The proportion<br />

relating to future years was reported as<br />

prepaid expenses.<br />

Financial derivatives and structured<br />

products were broken down into their<br />

individual components and valued using<br />

recognized actuarial methods based on<br />

the Black/Scholes option pricing model.<br />

Deposits with ceding undertakings and<br />

debtors arising out of reinsurance operations<br />

were reported at their nominal value.<br />

Doubtful debtors were written down<br />

directly.<br />

Operating and office equipment was<br />

valued at cost less straight-line depreciation.<br />

Additions in the fiscal year were<br />

generally written down pro rata. Low-value<br />

assets were written off in full in their year<br />

of acquisition.<br />

The remaining assets are reported at<br />

nominal value. Any necessary valuation<br />

allowances were performed and deducted<br />

from assets.<br />

Technical provisions (unearned premiums,<br />

mathematical provisions, claims outstanding<br />

and other technical provisions) were<br />

generally reported in line with information<br />

provided by the cedents.<br />

If no information was available, provisions<br />

were estimated on the basis of contractual<br />

conditions and the course of business to<br />

date.<br />

We made appropriate increases to a<br />

number of our cedents’ loss provisions<br />

for which we felt, given our experience,<br />

that the amounts stated were too low.<br />

Correspondingly, appropriate provisions<br />

were also made for expected future loss<br />

expenses.<br />

The reinsurers’ share of provisions was<br />

calculated in line with the conditions of<br />

the reinsurance agreements.<br />

42<br />

In contrast to their presentation in the past,<br />

unearned premiums for life insurance<br />

were reported separately and not together<br />

with the mathematical provisions.<br />

The equalization provision and similar<br />

provisions (nuclear plants, pharmaceutical<br />

risks) were calculated in accordance with<br />

section 341 h HGB in conjunction with<br />

sections 29 and 30 RechVersV.<br />

Deposits received from reinsurers and<br />

creditors arising out of reinsurance operations<br />

were reported at their nominal value.<br />

In line with section 6 a EStG, provisions<br />

for pensions and similar obligations<br />

were calculated using the present value<br />

method based on the 1998 mortality tables<br />

published by Prof. Dr. Klaus Heubeck,<br />

using an interest rate of 6%.<br />

The provision for early retirement was<br />

formed in line with the principles laid down<br />

in section 6 a EStG.<br />

Partial retirement provisions cover both<br />

unpaid remuneration and outstanding<br />

top-up amounts for salaries and pensions.<br />

An actuarial discount was made on the<br />

top-up amounts. The 1998 mortality tables<br />

published by Prof. Dr. Klaus Heubeck were<br />

applied to the calculation of these amounts,<br />

using an interest rate of 5.5%.<br />

The provisions for jubilee benefits were<br />

calculated using the 1998 mortality tables<br />

published by Prof. Dr. Klaus Heubeck, using<br />

an interest rate of 5.5%.<br />

The carrying amount of the remaining<br />

provisions is based on projected requirements.<br />

The remaining liabilities were recognized<br />

at the amounts payable on maturity.


Currency translation<br />

All items in foreign currencies were<br />

translated into euros.<br />

The items listed under Assets C, Investments<br />

I to III and the other debtors, other<br />

creditors, prepaid expenses and deferred<br />

income, and income and expenses items<br />

relating to these investments were translated<br />

using the exchange rate as of the<br />

balance sheet date December 31, 2002.<br />

For investments in associates, bearer<br />

bonds, other fixed-income securities,<br />

shares and deposits with banks, please<br />

refer to the notes on these items.<br />

All other items on the balance sheet and in<br />

the income statement, including in particular<br />

the technical items, were translated<br />

using the exchange rate as of November<br />

30, 2002 in order to accelerate the preparation<br />

of annual financial statements.<br />

Due to the strong fluctuations in foreign<br />

exchange rates, the difference between the<br />

exchange rates as of December 31, 2002<br />

and November 30, 2002 resulted in<br />

exchange rate losses this fiscal year.<br />

Foreign currency gains and losses incurred<br />

in relation to a single currency were netted<br />

against each other.<br />

43


List of Shareholdings<br />

Shares in affiliated companies<br />

Name and registered office of company Share of Currency Figures for Equity Result<br />

capital in % fiscal year € €<br />

Insurance companies<br />

Assimoco S.p.A., Segrate 44.5 EUR 2002 45,728,551 –134,449<br />

Assimoco Vita S.p.A., Segrate 59.2 EUR 2002 37,206,922 –6,621,219<br />

KRAV<strong>AG</strong>-ALLGEMEINE <strong>Versicherung</strong>s-<strong>AG</strong>, Hamburg 76.0 EUR 2002 24,230,569 –3,730,431<br />

KRAV<strong>AG</strong>-LEBEN <strong>Versicherung</strong>s-<strong>AG</strong>, Hamburg*** 100.0 EUR 2002 26,587,095 136,000<br />

KRAV<strong>AG</strong>-LOGISTIC <strong>Versicherung</strong>s-<strong>AG</strong>, Hamburg 51.0 EUR 2002 96,365,208 3,001,776<br />

K.U. FILAR S.A., Szczecin 78.4 PLZ 2002 18,262,458 286,997<br />

K.U. FILAR-ZYCIE S.A., Szczecin 78.4 PLZ 2002 1,203,769 –1,887,890<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Allgemeine <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>, Wiesbaden 87.4 EUR 2002 838,104,852 247,464,575<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Krankenversicherung <strong>AG</strong>, Wiesbaden 100.0 EUR 2002 9,905,231 1,100,000<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Lebensversicherung <strong>AG</strong>, Wiesbaden 100.0 EUR 2002 216,350,836 –**<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Luxembourg Lebensversicherung S.A., Strassen 99.9 EUR 2002 7,370,927 2,817,747<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Pensionsfonds <strong>AG</strong>, Wiesbaden * 51.0 EUR 2002 9,166,962 –833,038<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Poistóvna a.s., Bratislava 87.4 SKK 2002 6,323,194 –3,101,622<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Rechtsschutzversicherung <strong>AG</strong>, Wiesbaden 100.0 EUR 2002 30,288,615 –**<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Reinsurance Ireland Ltd., Dublin 100.0 EUR 2002 11,550,792 1,191,329<br />

Service, holding and real estate companies<br />

BWG Baugesellschaft Württembergischer Genossenschaften mbH, Stuttgart * 71.9 EUR 2001 10,723,292 1,202,488<br />

carexpert Kfz-Sachverständigen GmbH, Walluf 56.8 EUR 2001 4,251,798 145,727<br />

compertis Beratungsgesellschaft für betriebliches Vorsorgemanagement mbh,<br />

Wiesbaden 44.6 EUR 2001 2,702,853 –3,879<br />

GenoTel Gesellschaft für Telekommunikationsservice mbH, Frankfurt am Main 35.0 EUR 2001 1,124,586 239,512<br />

GWG Gesellschaft für Wohnungs- und Gewerbebau Baden-Württemberg <strong>AG</strong>,<br />

Stuttgart* 78.4 EUR 2002 42,794,010 3,990,023<br />

HANSEATICA Sechzehnte Grundbesitz Investitionsgesellschaft mbH & Co. KG,<br />

Hamburg 82.2 EUR 2001 –860,723 –562,646<br />

HGI Immobilien GmbH & Co. GB I KG, Frankfurt am Main 100.0 EUR 2002 21,094,396 –75,604<br />

HGI Real Estate LP, London * 100.0 GBP 2002 14,319,321 114,528<br />

HumanProtect Consulting GmbH, Cologne 44.6 EUR 2001 67,330 42,330<br />

KRAV<strong>AG</strong> Umweltschutz- und Sicherheitstechnik GmbH, Hamburg 51.0 EUR 2001 75,441 5,895<br />

Rhein-Main Assistance GmbH Gesellschaft für Service- und Beistandsleistungen,<br />

Wiesbaden 87.4 EUR 2001 7,334,757 1,966,192<br />

Rhein-Main Beteiligungs-GmbH, Wiesbaden 87.4 EUR 2001 935,469 42,631<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Allgemeine Beteiligungs-GmbH, Wiesbaden 69.2 EUR 2002 49,672,611 1,204,915<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Erste Anlage GmbH, Wiesbaden 87.4 EUR 2001 25,248 125<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Erste Anlage GmbH & Co. Verwaltung KG, Wiesbaden 89.8 EUR 2001 11,375,260 10,945,276<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Immobilien GmbH, Wiesbaden 100.0 EUR 2002 122,929,521 3,561,409<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Immobilien GmbH & Co. KG Grundbesitzverwaltungsgesellschaft<br />

Kaufingerstraße, Wiesbaden 95.0 EUR 2002 22,282,961 1,257,580<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> KOMPOSIT Holding GmbH, Wiesbaden * 100.0 EUR 2002 1,554,648,708 –**<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Kureck Immobilien GmbH, Wiesbaden 87.4 EUR 2001 36,535 11,535<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Kureck Immobilien GmbH & Co. KG Grundstücksverwaltungsgesellschaft<br />

Adolfsberg, Wiesbaden 100.0 EUR 2002 3,499,363 76,493<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Kureck Immobilien GmbH & Co. KG Grundstücksverwaltungsgesellschaft<br />

Hochhaus, Wiesbaden 87.4 EUR 2002 4,730,132 124,423<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Kureck Immobilien GmbH & Co. KG Grundstücksverwaltungsgesellschaft<br />

Sonnenberger Straße 2/2a, Wiesbaden 87.4 EUR 2002 7,372,003 653,604<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Kureck Immobilien GmbH & Co. KG Grundstücksverwaltungsgesellschaft<br />

Sonnenberger Straße 2b, Wiesbaden 100.0 EUR 2002 1,402,887 119,685<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Kureck Immobilien GmbH & Co. KG Grundstücksverwaltungsgesellschaft<br />

Taunusstraße 1, Wiesbaden 100.0 EUR 2002 7,327,545 274,489<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Kureck Immobilien GmbH & Co. KG Grundstücksverwaltungsgesellschaft<br />

Taunusstraße 3, Wiesbaden 100.0 EUR 2002 4,141,566 323,326<br />

44


Shares in affiliated companies<br />

Name and registered office of company Share of Currency Figures for Equity Result<br />

capital in % fiscal year € €<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Personen Holding GmbH, Wiesbaden * 100.0 EUR 2002 250,227,254 –**<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Real Estate Belgium N.V./S.A., Brussels 100.0 EUR 2001 6,666,854 –479,611<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Rechtsschutz-Schadenregulierungs-GmbH, Wiesbaden 100.0 EUR 2001 23,690 –1,310<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong>sbetriebs-GmbH, Wiesbaden 87.4 EUR 2001 –536,479 –553,079<br />

Sprint Sanierung GmbH, Cologne 87.4 EUR 2001 970,349 –1,982,441<br />

UMB Umwelt- und Risikomanagement GmbH, Wiesbaden 87.4 EUR 2001 559,238 3,740<br />

WBS Wohnbau Selbsthilfe GmbH, Stuttgart * 90.0 EUR 2001 16,884,291 10,648,730<br />

* New shareholding<br />

** Profit transfer agreement<br />

*** KRAV<strong>AG</strong>-LEBEN was merged with <strong>R+V</strong> Lebensversicherung <strong>AG</strong> as of December 31, 2002<br />

Associates<br />

Name and registered office of company Share of Currency Figures for Equity Result<br />

capital in % fiscal year € €<br />

Finassimoco S.p.A., Segrate 46.5 EUR 2001 36,818,812 2,914<br />

PWR Holding GmbH, Munich 33.3 EUR 2001 91,919,696 5,629,837<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Zweite HG-Beteiligungs GmbH, Wiesbaden 46.7 EUR 2001 5,140,108 766,097<br />

Seguros Generales Rural, S.A. de Seguros y Reaseguros, Madrid 26.2 EUR 2001 29,548,081 2,254,895<br />

TERTIANUM - Besitzgesellschaft Berlin Passauer Straße 5-7 mbH, Munich 25.0 EUR 2001 45,559,561 –865,385<br />

TERTIANUM - Besitzgesellschaft Konstanz Marktstätte 2-6 und<br />

Sigismundstraße 5-9 mbH, Munich 25.0 EUR 2001 64,613,050 175,608<br />

TERTIANUM Seniorenresidenzen Betriebsgesellschaft mbH, Constance 25.0 EUR 2001 2,250,174 –3,916,460<br />

Verwaltung HANSEATICA Sechzehnte Grundbesitz Investitionsgesellschaft mbH,<br />

Hamburg 42.8 EUR 2001 5,177 3,674<br />

45


Notes to the Balance Sheet<br />

Statement of Changes in Asset Items B, C I to III in fiscal year 2002<br />

B. Intangible assets<br />

1. Start-up and business expansion expenses in accordance with section 269 (1) sentence 1 HGB –<br />

2. Goodwill acquired –<br />

3. Other intangible assets 155<br />

Total B. 155<br />

C. Investments<br />

Values stated for previous fiscal year<br />

€ thou %<br />

C. I. Land, land rights and buildings including buildings on third-party land 4,242 0.3<br />

C. II. Investments in affiliated and associated companies<br />

1. Shares in affiliated companies 767,460 56.0<br />

2. Loans to affiliated companies 72,671 5.3<br />

3. Investments in associates 51,333 3.7<br />

4. Loans to associates – 0.0<br />

Total C II. 891,464 65.0<br />

C. III. Other financial investments<br />

1. Shares, investment certificates and other variable-yield securities 92,058 6.7<br />

2. Bearer bonds and other fixed-income securities 128,775 9.4<br />

3. Receivables from mortgages, land charges and annuity land charges – 0.0<br />

4. Other loans<br />

a. Registered bonds 166,388 12.2<br />

b. Notes receivable and loans 66,802 4.9<br />

c. Loans and advance payments on insurance policies – 0.0<br />

d. Miscellaneous loans 5,113 0.4<br />

5. Deposits with banks 10,787 0.8<br />

6. Miscellaneous investments 3,548 0.3<br />

Total C III. 473,471 34.7<br />

Total C. 1,369,177 100.0<br />

Total 1,369,332<br />

*) thereof currency write-ups: €264 thousand<br />

**) thereof currency write-downs: €21,587 thousand<br />

46


Additions Transfers Disposals Write-ups*) Write-downs**) Values stated for current fiscal year<br />

€ thou € thou € thou € thou € thou € thou %<br />

– – – – – –<br />

– – – – – –<br />

– – 132 – 22 1<br />

– – 132 – 22 1<br />

– – 172 – 65 4,005 0.2<br />

1,357,652 – 674,558 – – 1,450,555 67.5<br />

40,000 – 39,720 187 1,732 71,406 3.3<br />

12,905 – 406 – – 63,832 3.0<br />

1,069 – 1,069 – – – 0.0<br />

1,411,626 – 715,752 187 1,732 1,585,793 73.9<br />

2,885 – 8,442 – 3,957 82,544 3.8<br />

362,956 – 220,513 167 17,914 253,471 11.8<br />

– – – – – – 0.0<br />

– – 46,016 – – 120,371 5.6<br />

– – – – – 66,802 3.1<br />

– – – – – – 0.0<br />

4,000 – – – – 9,113 0.4<br />

11,353 – – – 2,523 19,617 0.9<br />

– – – – – 3,548 0.2<br />

381,194 – 274,971 167 24,394 555,467 25.9<br />

1,792,820 – 990,896 354 26,191 2,145,264 100.0<br />

1,792,820 991,028 354 26,213 2,145,265<br />

47


Assets<br />

C. Investments<br />

Present values of investments carried at cost thereof fixed assets in<br />

accordance with section 341 b (2) HGB<br />

Book value Present value Book value Present value<br />

Type of investment €m €m €m €m<br />

Land 4 9 – –<br />

Fixed-income securities 254 265 – –<br />

Other investments 1,602 3,309 52 48<br />

1,859 3,583 52 48<br />

The revaluation reserves of the investments carried at cost including fixed assets amount to €1,724 million net, or 80.4% of total investments.<br />

The reserves for investments carried at their nominal amount were not taken into account.<br />

Generally, present values were calculated on the basis of market prices, or using a simplified capitalized earnings value method.<br />

All three plots of land were last appraised in 2002.<br />

Where other carrying amounts have been used in individual cases, these correspond with the provisions of section 56 RechVersV.<br />

In accordance with section 341b HGB, investments in the amount of €51.9 million were allocated to fixed assets.<br />

This includes negative revaluation reserves in the amount of €3.9 million based on prices as of December 31, 2002.<br />

C.I. Land, land rights and buildings including buildings on third-party land<br />

The balance sheet value of land used predominantly by <strong>R+V</strong> companies amounts to €3,844,809.<br />

G. II. Other prepaid expenses 2002<br />

€<br />

Discount on subordinated loans 57,520<br />

Premium on investments 852,584<br />

Expenses relating to subsequent fiscal years 11,648,932<br />

12,559,036<br />

48


Equity and liabilities<br />

A. I. Subscribed capital 2002<br />

€<br />

The subscribed capital is composed of 8,701,000 no-par value shares (registered shares)<br />

As of Dec. 31 226,000,000<br />

The subscribed capital is unchanged as against December 31, 2001.<br />

DZ BANK <strong>AG</strong> Deutsche Zentral-Genossenschaftsbank <strong>AG</strong>, Frankfurt am Main,<br />

has informed us in accordance with section 20 (4) AktG that it holds a majority interest in our company.<br />

A. II. Capital reserves 2002<br />

€<br />

As of Dec. 31 429,590,228<br />

A. III. Revenue reserves 2002<br />

€<br />

2. Reserve for own shares<br />

Brought forward as of Jan. 1 1,583,458<br />

Reversal –1,583,458<br />

As of Dec. 31 –<br />

5. Other revenue reserves 2002<br />

€<br />

Brought forward as of Jan. 1 68,408,087<br />

Appropriations from the net retained profits of the previous year 6,150,000<br />

Appropriations from the net income for 2002 33,000,000<br />

As of Dec. 31 107,558,087<br />

K. Deferred income 2002<br />

€<br />

Discounts on investments 147,297<br />

Income relating to subsequent fiscal years 14,600<br />

As of Dec. 31 161,897<br />

Note<br />

There are no subordinated liabilities with a time to maturity of more than five years or liabilities secured by liens or similar rights.<br />

49


Notes to the Income Statement<br />

I. 1 a.) Gross premiums written 2002 2001<br />

€ €<br />

Property, health and casualty insurance 636,140,365 667,508,101<br />

Life insurance 321,745,389 361,034,983<br />

957,885,754 1,028,543,084<br />

I. 2. Allocated investment return 2002 2001<br />

€ €<br />

This relates to interest from the collateral provided to the previous insurers in the amount<br />

of the mathematical provision and the mathematical pension provision.<br />

The reinsurers’ share of reserves was calculated in line with the conditions of the reinsurance agreements<br />

and deducted correspondingly.<br />

50<br />

20,554,117 13,365,604<br />

I. 4. Claims incurred – net 2002 2001<br />

€ €<br />

The settlement of the provision for claims outstanding brought forward from the previous fiscal year<br />

resulted in a gross loss of €43 million.<br />

482,520,744 412,117,193<br />

II. 2 b.) Write-downs on investments 2002 2001<br />

€ €<br />

Regular write-downs 65,196 68,115<br />

Write-downs in line with section 253 (3) HGB 4,506,186 1,251,728<br />

4,571,382 1,319,842


Other Information<br />

Dr. Christopher Pleister<br />

– Chairman –<br />

President Bundesverband<br />

der Deutschen Volksbanken und<br />

Raiffeisenbanken e.V., Berlin<br />

Ulrich Birkenstock<br />

– Deputy Chairman –<br />

Chairman of the Central Works Council,<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Allgemeine <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>,<br />

Koblenz branch office<br />

Dr. Ulrich Brixner<br />

– Deputy Chairman –<br />

Chairman of the Board of Management,<br />

DZ BANK <strong>AG</strong><br />

Deutsche Zentral-Genossenschaftsbank,<br />

Frankfurt/Main<br />

Dr. Peter Aubin<br />

Chairman of the Board of Management,<br />

Volksbank Göppingen eG, Göppingen<br />

Uwe Brandenburg<br />

Chairman of the Board of Management,<br />

Lindener Volksbank eG, Hanover<br />

Ilona Brüssing<br />

Chair of the Works Council,<br />

Kassel-Erfurt branch office,<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Allgemeine <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong><br />

(until December 31, 2002)<br />

Andreas Dichtl<br />

Chairman of the Board of Management,<br />

Volksbank Raiffeisenbank Berchtesgadener<br />

Land eG, Bad Reichenhall<br />

Peter Frenzel<br />

Senior specialist,<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Allgemeine <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>,<br />

Oldenburg branch office<br />

51<br />

Supervisory Board<br />

Rüdiger Habrik<br />

Member of the Works Council,<br />

Stuttgart branch office,<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Allgemeine <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong><br />

(until June 30, 2002)<br />

Albrecht Hatton<br />

Chairman of the Board of Management,<br />

Volksbank Dessau/Anhalt eG, Dessau<br />

Peter Hermann<br />

Printer, <strong>R+V</strong> Allgemeine <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>,<br />

Wiesbaden head office<br />

Karl-Heinz Moll<br />

Member of the Board of Management,<br />

WGZ-Bank Westdeutsche Genossenschafts-Zentralbank<br />

eG, Düsseldorf<br />

Manfred Nüssel<br />

President,<br />

Deutscher Raiffeisenverband e.V.,<br />

Bonn<br />

Hermann Rohrmeier<br />

Branch representative, VD Süd,<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> Allgemeine <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong><br />

(as of July 1, 2002)<br />

Gerd Rück<br />

Director, <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>,<br />

Wiesbaden head office<br />

Armin Schmidt<br />

Deputy District Manager,<br />

Vereinte Dienstleistungsgewerkschaft ver.di,<br />

Wiesbaden<br />

Gudrun Schmidt<br />

Head of department,<br />

Vereinte Dienstleistungsgewerkschaft ver.di,<br />

Frankfurt/Main


Dr. Jürgen Förterer<br />

Chairman<br />

Wolfgang Kernbach<br />

(until December 31, 2002)<br />

Hans-Christian Marschler<br />

Bernhard Meyer<br />

Dr. Manfred Mücke<br />

Rainer Neumann<br />

Rainer Sauerwein<br />

Hans-Dieter Schnorrenberg<br />

Peter Weiler<br />

(as of September 1, 2002)<br />

Dr. Bernhard Zloch<br />

(until August 31, 2002)<br />

General representative of the<br />

Board of Management<br />

Dr. Christoph Bark, Lawyer<br />

Dr. Christoph Lamby<br />

(as of September 1, 2002)<br />

52<br />

Board of Management


Commission and other remuneration for insurance agents, personnel expenses 2002<br />

€<br />

1. Wages and salaries 15,192,173<br />

2. Social security costs 2,021,619<br />

3. Pension costs 1,760,316<br />

4. Total expenses 18,974,108<br />

Total remuneration of the members of the Board of Management in the fiscal year amounted to €1,639,545.<br />

Former members of the Board of Management and their surviving dependents received a total of €442,912.<br />

The provision for current pensions and pension entitlements for former members of the Board of Management<br />

and their surviving dependents amounts to €4,221,588.<br />

Expenses for the Supervisory Board amounted to €271,209 in the fiscal year.<br />

No amounts subject to disclosure in accordance with section 285 no. 9 c HGB were paid in the fiscal year.<br />

Number of employees<br />

In fiscal 2002, <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong> employed an average of 230 people (2001: 221), of whom 221 were employed in Germany and 9 at the Singapore branch office.<br />

Contingent liabilities and other financial obligations<br />

Liabilities due to shares in cooperatives amount to €5,000. There are no further contingent liabilities within the meaning of section 251 HGB.<br />

Additional payment obligations<br />

Additional payment obligations exist in the amount of €7,669,378 in relation to shares in affiliated companies<br />

and in the amount of €11,888 in relation to shares in German insurance companies.<br />

Consolidated financial statements<br />

<strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong> produces subgroup financial statements in accordance with the provisions of sections 290 ff HGB.<br />

These are filed with the Wiesbaden commercial register under HRB 7934.<br />

The subgroup financial statements of <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong> have been included in the higher-ranking consolidated financial statements<br />

of DZ BANK <strong>AG</strong> Deutsche Zentral-Genossenschaftsbank, Frankfurt am Main. These are filed with the Frankfurt am Main commercial register under HRB 45651.<br />

Wiesbaden, April 8, 2003<br />

The Board of Management<br />

Dr. Förterer<br />

Marschler Meyer Dr. Mücke Neumann<br />

Sauerwein Schnorrenberg Weiler<br />

53


Auditors’ <strong>Report</strong><br />

We have audited the annual financial<br />

statements including the accounting and<br />

the management report of <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong><br />

<strong>AG</strong>, Wiesbaden, for the fiscal<br />

year from January 1, 2002 to December 31,<br />

2002. The maintenance of the books and<br />

records and the preparation of the annual<br />

financial statements and the management<br />

report in accordance with the provisions of<br />

the HGB (Handelsgesetzbuch – German<br />

Commercial Code) and the supplementary<br />

provisions of the Articles of Association are<br />

the responsibility of the Board of Management<br />

of the Company. Our responsibility is<br />

to express an opinion on the annual financial<br />

statements, including the accounting<br />

and the management report, based on our<br />

audit.<br />

We conducted our audit of the annual financial<br />

statements in accordance with section<br />

317 HGB and the generally accepted standards<br />

for the audit of financial statements<br />

promulgated by the Institut der Wirtschaftsprüfer<br />

(IDW). Those standards require that<br />

we plan and perform the audit such that<br />

misstatements materially affecting the<br />

presentation of the net assets, financial<br />

position and results of operations in the<br />

annual financial statements in accordance<br />

with German principles of proper accounting<br />

and in the management report are<br />

detected with reasonable assurance.<br />

Knowledge of the business activities and<br />

the economic and legal environment of<br />

the Company and evaluations of possible<br />

misstatements are taken into account in<br />

the determination of audit procedures.<br />

54<br />

The effectiveness of the internal accounting<br />

control system and the evidence supporting<br />

the disclosures in the books and records,<br />

the annual financial statements and the<br />

management report are examined primarily<br />

on a test basis within the framework of the<br />

audit. The audit includes assessing the<br />

accounting principles used and significant<br />

estimates made by the Board of Management,<br />

as well as evaluating the overall presentation<br />

of the financial statements and<br />

the management report. We believe that our<br />

audit provides a reasonable basis for our<br />

opinion.<br />

Our audit did not give rise to any<br />

reservations.<br />

In our opinion, the annual financial statements<br />

give a true and fair view of the net<br />

assets, financial position and results of<br />

operations of the Company in accordance<br />

with German principles of proper accounting.<br />

On the whole, the management report<br />

provides a suitable understanding of the<br />

Company’s position and suitably presents<br />

the risks of future development.<br />

Cologne, April 8, 2003<br />

KPMG<br />

Deutsche Treuhand-Gesellschaft<br />

Aktiengesellschaft<br />

Wirtschaftsprüfungsgesellschaft<br />

Prof. Dr. Geib Fleischerowitz<br />

Wirtschaftsprüfer Wirtschaftsprüfer


<strong>Report</strong> of the<br />

Supervisory Board<br />

The Supervisory Board was regularly<br />

informed in written and oral reports by<br />

the Board of Management on the current<br />

position of the Company and particular<br />

transactions during fiscal 2002, and supervised<br />

management on the basis of these<br />

reports.<br />

The present financial statements for fiscal<br />

2002, the management report, the consolidated<br />

financial statements and the consolidated<br />

management report for fiscal 2002<br />

were examined by the Supervisory Board.<br />

The auditor responsible was present during<br />

the meeting of the Supervisory Board’s<br />

audit committee and was available to give<br />

all additional explanations and opinions<br />

required. No reservations were made in<br />

relation to the statements.<br />

The Supervisory Board concurs with the<br />

audit opinion of the auditing firm KPMG<br />

Deutsche Treuhand-Gesellschaft <strong>AG</strong>, which<br />

was appointed in accordance with section<br />

341 k HGB and which issued an unqualified<br />

opinion.<br />

The Supervisory Board concurs with the<br />

proposal of the Board of Management on<br />

the appropriation of the net retained profits<br />

of <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong>. The annual financial<br />

statements for <strong>R+V</strong> <strong>Versicherung</strong> <strong>AG</strong><br />

prepared by the Board of Management<br />

for fiscal 2002 have been approved and<br />

hence adopted in accordance with section<br />

172 AktG.<br />

55<br />

The related parties report prepared by<br />

the Board of Management and the audit<br />

opinion on this prepared by the auditors<br />

were submitted to the members of the<br />

Supervisory Board and examined.<br />

The auditors issued the following audit<br />

opinion on the report by the Board of<br />

Management on related parties:<br />

“On completion of our audit in accordance<br />

with professional standards, we confirm<br />

that<br />

1. the factual statements made in the report<br />

are correct,<br />

2. the remuneration paid by the Company<br />

with respect to the transactions listed in<br />

the report was not inappropriately high.”<br />

We concur with this opinion and raise no<br />

reservations to the closing declarations<br />

made by the Board of Management in the<br />

report on related parties.<br />

Wiesbaden, April 11, 2003<br />

The Supervisory Board<br />

Dr. Pleister<br />

Chairman

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!