19.06.2013 Views

Download - Akademi Sains Malaysia

Download - Akademi Sains Malaysia

Download - Akademi Sains Malaysia

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

36<br />

Journal of Science and Technology in the Tropics (2010) 6: 31-38<br />

Among the extracts, the ethyl acetate extract showed<br />

the highest protective effect against oxidant-induced<br />

apoptotic cell death.<br />

DISCUSSION<br />

The sequential fractionation of the crude methanol<br />

extracts of the leaves of P. bleo used in this study<br />

showed that the bioactive compounds with antioxidant<br />

activity were concentrated in the t-butanol extract<br />

(416 µmole Trolox Equivalent per gram dry weight),<br />

followed by the ethyl acetate extract. The methanol<br />

and aqueous extracts had similar antioxidant<br />

properties. These antioxidant properties are moderate<br />

compared to those of commercial black teas and<br />

green teas which have antioxidant capacity ranging<br />

between 235 µmole Trolox Equivalent per gram dry<br />

weight and 1526 µmole Trolox Equivalent per gram<br />

dry weight [9]. The antioxidant effects of the extracts<br />

are also much less than that of Vitamin C, a known<br />

antioxidant compound, which has an antioxidant<br />

capacity of 5158 Trolox Equivalent per gram dry<br />

weight [9]. As such, the leaf of P. bleo cannot be<br />

considered to be a rich source of antioxidants.<br />

The IC 50 values for all the crude and fractionated<br />

extracts of the leaves of P. bleo were greater than 400<br />

µg/mL. The extracts could not be tested at higher<br />

concentrations due to the lack of solubility. According<br />

to the National Cancer Institute guideline, the crude<br />

Figure 5. The ability of extracts from the leaves of<br />

Pereskia bleo to limit DPPH-induced apoptotic death in<br />

3T3 cells. The data are expressed as the mean enrichment<br />

factors ± standard deviation (S.D.). o denotes cells in<br />

media only; * denotes cells treated with DPPH; ◊ denotes<br />

aqueous extract; denotes methanol extract; ×<br />

denotes t-butanol extract; Δ denotes ethyl acetate<br />

extract; + denotes vitamin C; - denotes trolox.<br />

extract of a plant should have an IC 50 value of less<br />

than 20 µg/mL in order to be considered as cytotoxic<br />

against the treated cells [11]. The results suggested<br />

that these extracts did not contain significant amount<br />

of compounds with anti-proliferative properties.<br />

Since the anti-proliferative activity of the fractionated<br />

extracts (ethyl acetate, t-butanol and aqueous extracts)<br />

are not greater than that of the crude methanol extract,<br />

the methanol extract is unlikely to contain any<br />

significant amount of anti-proliferative compounds.<br />

A comparison with the reported anti-proliferative<br />

activity of the stem extracts of P. bleo [6] shows<br />

that the leaf extracts have higher anti-proliferative<br />

activity. Moreover, the leaf extracts have a higher<br />

anti-proliferative effect on the 4T1 mouse mammary<br />

cancer cells compared to the normal 3T3 mouse<br />

fibroblast cells. However, the reverse trend has been<br />

reported for the stem extracts [6]. This indicates that<br />

the leaf extracts of P. bleo might be a better target to<br />

be developed as anti-cancer agent compared to the<br />

stem extracts.<br />

Treatment of the normal mouse fibroblast cells<br />

(3T3) with the leaf extracts of P. bleo for 24 hours<br />

resulted in a lower level of apoptosis in the cells<br />

compared to that occurring in the non extracttreated<br />

cells grown under the same conditions. The<br />

results indicated that all the methanol, ethyl acetate,<br />

t-butanol and aqueous extracts had the ability to<br />

protect the 3T3 cells against natural programmed<br />

cell death by apoptosis. The protective effects were<br />

more obvious at 50 µg/mL compared to 100 µg/mL<br />

of the extracts. The higher level of apoptosis at the<br />

higher extract concentration was consistent with the<br />

results of the anti-proliferation assay which showed<br />

a gradual decrease in cell viability with increasing<br />

extract concentration. All the fractionated extracts of<br />

the leaves of P. bleo showed higher apoptosis-limiting<br />

activities than the crude methanol extract, except<br />

the aqueous extract. This suggested that the crude<br />

methanol extracts contained bioactive component(s)<br />

that could protect the normal mouse fibroblast<br />

cells against natural apoptotic cell death, and these<br />

components could be concentrated by fractionating<br />

the crude methanol extracts.<br />

The protective effects of the leaf extracts of P. bleo<br />

against oxidant-induced cell death were also evaluated<br />

by pre-treating the 3T3 cells with the extracts before<br />

the oxidant, 2,2-Diphenyl-1-Picrylhydrazyl (DPPH),<br />

was added. All the extracts were able to limit oxidantinduced<br />

cell death, with the ethyl acetate extract being<br />

Jostt vol 6.indd 36 7/22/10 10:09:17 PM

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!