Metalepsis, paragraphe and the scholia to Hermogenes - Leeds ...
Metalepsis, paragraphe and the scholia to Hermogenes - Leeds ...
Metalepsis, paragraphe and the scholia to Hermogenes - Leeds ...
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAPHE AND THE SCHOLIA TO HERMOGENES<br />
Appendix 1: Syrianus<br />
The text is based on Rabe (1893); unattributed emendations are his. Parallel<br />
passages in RG 4 are presented in <strong>the</strong> right-h<strong>and</strong> column.<br />
perˆ metal»yewj<br />
[151.2] t¾n d met£lhyin Ð mn `Ermogšnhj teleuta…an t£ttei pasîn tîn<br />
st£sewn lšgwn a„t…aj t£sde: prèthn mn Óti œn te ta‹j logika‹j kaˆ n<br />
ta‹j nomika‹j mp…ptei st£sesin, e„kÒtwj oân t»n te ¥grafon kaˆ t¾n<br />
œggrafon poiÒthta prî<strong>to</strong>n xetastšon, <strong>to</strong>utšsti t£j te logik¦j kaˆ<br />
nomik£j, n aŒj eØr…sketai, kaˆ teleuta‹on p£gein tÕn perˆ tÁj<br />
metal»yewj lÒgon: deutšran d t»nde, Óti aƒ mn ¥llai st£seij tÕ e„<br />
œstin À t… stin À po‹Òn t… sti shma…nousin (tÕ mn e„ œstin Ð<br />
s<strong>to</strong>casmÒj, tÕ d t… stin Óroj, tÕ d po‹Òn t… stin aƒ loipa…), ¹ d<br />
met£lhyij tù pepragmšnJ fanerù Ônti kaˆ ÐmologoumšnJ sugcwroàsa ›n<br />
ti tîn peristatikîn a„ti©tai mor…wn. oƒ d metagenšsteroi sÝn filosof…v<br />
<strong>to</strong>Ýj perˆ tîn st£sewn diexelqÒntej lÒgouj pˆ ta‹j ¢ntiqetika‹j t£t<strong>to</strong>usi<br />
t¾n met£lhyin, prî<strong>to</strong>n mn diÒti tîn pšnte dikaiologikîn st£sewn m…a<br />
aÛth lutik» stin ¹ met£lhyij, e„kÒtwj oân t¾n p' ke…naij dšcetai<br />
t£xin, Ópwj ¨n gnîmen po…aj Øp£rcousa fÚsewj thlikaÚthn „scÝn di¦<br />
tîn meqÒdwn pide…knutai æj mÒnh t¦j pšnte lÚein: œpeita d kaˆ tîn<br />
palaiîn tecnogr£fwn oƒ ple…onej taÚthn aÙtÍ t¾n t£xin ¢podedèkasin:<br />
tr…<strong>to</strong>n d pollù ¨n ¥meinon e‡h kaq' ˜aut¾n prî<strong>to</strong>n xet£sai t¾n oÙs…an<br />
aÙtÁj, †na m¾ n ta‹j nomika‹j perˆ taÚthj ti lšgein piceiroàntej t¾n<br />
tîn prokeimšnwn diakÒptwmen didaskal…an.<br />
[152.3] tinj mn oân tîn tecnogr£fwn ØpÕ t¾n poiÒthta t¾n met£lhyin<br />
¢n£gousi, tinj d oÙ. ¥meinon d t£ttein ØpÕ t¾n poiÒthta: e„ g¦r kaˆ tÕ<br />
e„ œstin œgnwstai n aÙtÍ kaˆ tÕ t… stin, ½dh d kaˆ tÕ po‹Òn t… stin,<br />
æj pˆ tÁj ¢neloÚshj tÕn tÚrannon ƒere…aj, ¢ll' oân di¦ tÕ n <strong>to</strong>iùde<br />
tÒpJ tÕ pr©gma sumbÁnai zh<strong>to</strong>àmen pÒteron œnnomon À par£nomon tÕ<br />
pepragmšnon.<br />
[152.11] œti d oƒ mn æj m…an st£sin paralamb£nousi t¾n met£lhyin, tÕ<br />
mn aÙtÁj ¥grafon, tÕ d œggrafon lšgontej: oƒ d ¥meinon f£skontej dÚo<br />
te aÙt¾n lšgousi perišcein st£seij kaˆ ple‹s<strong>to</strong>n ¢ll»lwn diest£nai<br />
taÚtaj, prî<strong>to</strong>n mn tù ÑnÒmati (¹ mn g¦r ¥grafoj met£lhyij kale‹tai<br />
ÐmwnÚmwj tù gšnei, ¹ d œggrafoj paragraf»): œpeita <strong>to</strong>‹j Óroij te kaˆ<br />
tÍ diairšsei tîn kefala…wn (ïn d di£foroi oƒ Óroi, <strong>to</strong>Útwn x ¢n£gkhj<br />
kaˆ t¦ Ðrist¦ di£fora): œpeita ¹ mn k <strong>to</strong>à feÚgon<strong>to</strong>j gnwr…zetai, ¹ d<br />
k <strong>to</strong>à kathgÒrou: kaˆ ¹ mn tîn logikîn stin, ¹ d tîn nomikîn. e„ d<br />
aƒ tšssarej ¢ntiqetikaˆ <strong>to</strong>‹j aÙ<strong>to</strong>‹j scedÕn diairoÚmenai kefala…oij pl¾n<br />
˜nÕj <strong>to</strong>à ˜k£sthj o„ke…ou, p©sa… te k <strong>to</strong>à feÚgon<strong>to</strong>j gnwrizÒmenai,<br />
di£foroi par¦ p£ntwn nom…sqhsan enai st£seij, pÒsJ plšon aátai<br />
<strong>to</strong>soÚ<strong>to</strong>ij ¢ll»lwn æj œfamen diafšrousai; koinwnoàsi d ¢ll»laij tù te<br />
ØpÕ tÕ aÙtÕ gšnoj ¢n£gesqai, t¾n met£lhyin, kaˆ tù k tîn peristatikîn<br />
mor…wn poie‹sqai t¾n paragraf»n: ¢ll' n mn tÍ ¢gr£fJ Ð dièkwn<br />
kšcrhtai tù peristatikù mor…J e„j paragraf¾n, n d tÍ ggr£fJ Ð<br />
feÚgwn.<br />
38
Change language