Metalepsis, paragraphe and the scholia to Hermogenes - Leeds ...
Metalepsis, paragraphe and the scholia to Hermogenes - Leeds ...
Metalepsis, paragraphe and the scholia to Hermogenes - Leeds ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAPHE AND THE SCHOLIA TO HERMOGENES<br />
met£gon<strong>to</strong>j tÁj te e„j tÕ diploàn ggrafÁj kaˆ tÁj <strong>to</strong>à<br />
met£llou phre…aj 90 .<br />
[111.3] æmolÒghtai oân aÙtÕ <strong>to</strong>à<strong>to</strong>, Óti ¹ mn prèth z»thsij ¹ perˆ tÁj<br />
paragrafÁj kat¦ m…an tîn nomikîn œcei t¾n z»thsin, ¹ d ˜tšra<br />
eÙqudik…a oÙ kecwrismšnhn 91 tin¦ ¢ll' ¢pÕ tÁj fÚsewj <strong>to</strong>à pr£gma<strong>to</strong>j.<br />
[111.6] tÕ mn par£deigma Ö tšqeiken 92 aÙtÕj Ñnom£zei enai ·htÕn kaˆ<br />
di£noian tÕ <strong>to</strong>à ¢ndrofÒnou kakîj nomisqšn. ¢ll' peid¾ t¾n kaq'<br />
Ðmwnum…an ¢mfibol…an ºgnÒhsen, e„kÒtwj kaˆ ntaàqa pepl£nhtai. stˆ<br />
g¦r ¹ prèth z»thsij kat¦ ¢mfibol…an, pÒteron d…kaj lšgei t¦j timwr…aj<br />
À aÙtÕ tÕ dik£sasqai. oÙd g¦r ¹ <strong>to</strong>à ·h<strong>to</strong>à di£noia zhte‹tai, ¢ll' aÙtÕ<br />
tÕ Ônoma t… shma…nei.<br />
¹ d ¥grafoj stˆ mn ¢pagwg¾ tÁj eÙqudik…aj.<br />
[111.15] œmeinen pˆ <strong>to</strong>à pta…sma<strong>to</strong>j Ðmo…wj. pantelîj g¦r oÙk œstin<br />
¢pagwg¾ tÁj eÙqudik…aj ¹ ¥grafoj, ¢ll' eÙqudik…a taÚtV e„sagègimoj. e„<br />
mn g¦r re‹ Óti diabol¾ g…netai ¢p' ¢rcÁj tÁj eÙqudik…aj, n ¢rcÍ <strong>to</strong>à<br />
feÚgon<strong>to</strong>j pˆ t¾n xous…an katafeÚgon<strong>to</strong>j, kaˆ n ¢ntil»yei <strong>to</strong>à<strong>to</strong><br />
sumba…nei kaˆ n s<strong>to</strong>casmù: kaˆ kaqÒlou n oŒj t… stin ptaismšnon tîn<br />
peristatikîn diabol» sti <strong>to</strong>à ¢gînoj, oÙ m¾n di¦ <strong>to</strong>à<strong>to</strong> ¢pagwg¾ tÁj<br />
eÙqudik…aj tele…a, ésper kaˆ n tÍ diairšsei tÁj ¢ntil»yewj aÙtÕ prî<strong>to</strong>n<br />
kef£laion œqhken t¦ mÒria <strong>to</strong>à dika…ou kaˆ tÕ prÒswpon deÚteron,<br />
¢mfÒtera paragrafikoà t£xin œconta, oÙk peid¾ diab£llousi tÍ <strong>to</strong>à<br />
paragrafikoà t£xei ¢mfÒtera t¦ kef£laia, n tÍ ¢ntil»yei ½dh kaˆ<br />
¢pagwg» 93 sti tÁj eÙqudik…aj. kaˆ tÕ paragrafikÕn d <strong>to</strong>à s<strong>to</strong>casmoà<br />
Ótan mpšsV diabol¾n poie‹ <strong>to</strong>à ¢gînoj, ¢ll' oÙk ½dh ¢pagwg¾ tÁj<br />
eÙqudik…aj Ð s<strong>to</strong>casmÒj. mšgis<strong>to</strong>n oân aÙtù pta‹sma tÕ nom…sai t¾n<br />
œggrafon kaˆ t¾n ¥grafon t¾n aÙt¾n œcein 94 fÚsin.<br />
¢ll¦ per… ti tîn perˆ tÕ pr©gma tîn peristatikîn lšgei, Ö kaˆ p£gei:<br />
Ótan tÕ mn pr©gma sugcwrîmen, žn d <strong>to</strong>Útwn a„tièmeqa<br />
metalamb£nontej.<br />
[112.5] e„ sugcwroàmen tÕ pr©gma, pîj ¢pagwg» sti tÁj eÙqudik…aj; n<br />
g¦r tÍ ¢pagwgÍ tÁj eÙqudik…aj Ólwj oÙ sugcwroàmen tÕ pr©gma, æj<br />
marture‹ ¹ pe‹ra tîn paragrafîn tîn par¦ <strong>to</strong>‹j ·»<strong>to</strong>rsi memelethmšnwn.<br />
oÜte g¦r Ð A„sc…nhj sunecèrhse tù Tim£rcJ tÕ pr©gma, ¢ll' ÑrqÕn<br />
xšbale tÕ prÒswpon, æj aƒ par¦ Dhmosqšnei paragrafaˆ oÙ sugcwroàsi<br />
tÕ pr©gma, ¢ll¦ t¾n z»thsin œcousi perˆ <strong>to</strong>à e„ de‹ e„selqe‹n. diÕ kaˆ<br />
¢ntistršfousi tÕn ¢gîna. tÕn g¦r feÚgonta prî<strong>to</strong>n poioàsi lšgein<br />
kathgÒrou t£xin œconta, æj kaˆ Ð Dhmosqšnhj n tù kat¦ Stef£nou: [oÙ] 95<br />
prolabën d tÕ prÒteroj lšgein di¦ tÕ paragraf¾n ¢gwn…zesqai. ½goun<br />
sugcwroàmen tÕ pr©gma, oÜte ¢ntistršfomen tÕn ¢gîna oÜte ¢pagwg»<br />
sti tÁj eÙqudik…aj tele…a.<br />
90<br />
mpeir…aj cod.<br />
91<br />
cwrismšnhn cod.: corr. Walz.<br />
92<br />
Óte œqeiken cod. (Óte œqhken Walz).<br />
93<br />
¢gwg» cod.<br />
94<br />
œcei cod.: corr. Walz.<br />
95<br />
del. Walz: cf. Dem. 45.6.<br />
48
Change language