Metalepsis, paragraphe and the scholia to Hermogenes - Leeds ...
Metalepsis, paragraphe and the scholia to Hermogenes - Leeds ...
Metalepsis, paragraphe and the scholia to Hermogenes - Leeds ...
Create successful ePaper yourself
Turn your PDF publications into a flip-book with our unique Google optimized e-Paper software.
MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAPHE AND THE SCHOLIA TO HERMOGENES<br />
tîn zht»sewn, e‡ sti, t… sti, kaˆ<br />
Ðpo‹Òn t… stin, oÙdšn, fhs…, <strong>to</strong>Útwn<br />
n tÍ metal»yei zh<strong>to</strong>àmen,<br />
¢ll' e„ de‹ <strong>to</strong>Útwn<br />
e„senecqÁna… ti.<br />
[232.17] kaˆ t…nej lšgousi prèthn<br />
aÙt¾n tacqÁnai, peid¾<br />
paragr£fei tÕn ¢gîna,<br />
spoud£zousi d p£ntej ¥nqrwpoi<br />
aÙtÕ <strong>to</strong>à<strong>to</strong>,<br />
oÙd e„selqe‹n ¢ll¦<br />
paragr£fei tÕn ¢gîna. ¢ll¦<br />
prÕj <strong>to</strong>à<strong>to</strong><br />
¢sfalîj ær…sa<strong>to</strong>,<br />
e„ de‹ <strong>to</strong>Útwn e„senecqÁnai<br />
f»saj. ¢dÚna<strong>to</strong>n d <strong>to</strong>Útwn Ãn ti<br />
paragr£fesqai m¾ maqÒntaj<br />
Ólwj, t… taàt£ stin.<br />
[232.23] kaˆ fas… tinej<br />
Óti peˆ tr…a e„sˆ t¦<br />
zh<strong>to</strong>Úmena,<br />
<strong>to</strong>Útwn d oÙdšn stin ¹ met£lhyij,<br />
oÙk ¨n e‡h st£sij. ¢ll'<br />
oÙk ¢ne‹len aÙt¾n kaqÒlou, ¢ll¦<br />
prohgoumšnwj fhs… perˆ <strong>to</strong>Útwn oÙk<br />
œcei t¾n z»thsin.<br />
[232.27] kalîj d prosšqhke tÕ<br />
prohgoumšnwj. n g¦r tÍ ggr£fJ<br />
metal»yei, ¿n kaˆ kaloàmen<br />
paragraf»n, mp…ptei p£ntwj kaˆ<br />
deÚteron z»thma par¦ tÕ tÁj<br />
grafÁj kat¦ m…an tîn ¥llwn<br />
st£sewn, oÙ m¾n prohgoumšnwj,<br />
¢ll' n deutšrJ lÒgJ. dÚo<br />
n paragrafÍ t¦<br />
zh<strong>to</strong>Úmena, ïn tÕ mn prÒteron œcei<br />
t¾n paragraf¾n, ¢pagwg¾n oâsan<br />
tÁj eÙqudik…aj, tÕ d deÚteron kat¦<br />
m…an tîn proeirhmšnwn st£sewn.<br />
[237.25] $. p©sa, fhs…, paragraf»,<br />
¼tij stˆ kaˆ œggrafoj met£lhyij<br />
(metalamb£netai g¦r), e‡dh œcei<br />
dÚo: ¹ mn<br />
g£r stin œggrafoj, ¹ d ¥grafoj<br />
81<br />
tîn ¥nw zht»sewn, e„ œsti, t… stin,<br />
Ðpo‹Òn t… stin, n tÍ metal»yei<br />
<strong>to</strong>Útwn oÙdn zhte‹tai, oÙd<br />
xet£zetai, ¢ll' e„ de‹ <strong>to</strong>Útwn tîn<br />
n <strong>to</strong>Ú<strong>to</strong>ij zh<strong>to</strong>umšnwn À tÍ kat'<br />
oÙs…an xet£sei À tÍ kat¦ „diÒthta<br />
À tÍ kat¦ poiÒthta e„senecqÁna… ti.<br />
[4.278.17] Óqen tinj lšgousin æj<br />
prèthn aÙt¾n œdei tacqÁnai, peid¾<br />
paragr£fei tÕn ¢gîna, pefÚkasi d<br />
p£ntej oƒ ¥nqrwpoi n ta‹j<br />
proteqe…saij d…kaij aÙtÕ <strong>to</strong>à<strong>to</strong><br />
spoud£zein, tÕ mhd e„selqe‹n ¢ll¦<br />
paragr£fesqai tÕn ¢gîna. ¢ll¦<br />
lšgomen Óti tîn legÒntwn prèthn<br />
de‹n t£ttesqai t¾n met£lhyin<br />
ésper ØpotemnÒmenoj <strong>to</strong>Ýj lÒgouj Ð<br />
tecnikÕj Óra pîj ¢sfalîj ær…sa<strong>to</strong>,<br />
e„ de‹ ti <strong>to</strong>Útwn e„senecqÁnai<br />
f»saj. ¢dÚna<strong>to</strong>n d <strong>to</strong>Útwn Ãn ti<br />
paragr£fesqai m»pw maqÒntaj<br />
Ólwj, t… taàt£ sti ... [omission]<br />
[4.278.29] tinj k <strong>to</strong>Ú<strong>to</strong>u kinhqšntej<br />
fasˆn Óti e„ kaqÒlou tr…a stˆ t¦<br />
zh<strong>to</strong>Úmena, æj fq£santej e„r»kamen,<br />
<strong>to</strong>Útwn d oÙdšn stin ¹ met£lhyij,<br />
oÙk ¨n e‡h st£sij. ¢ll¦ famn æj<br />
kaqÒlou oÙk ¢ne‹len aÙt»n, ¢ll¦<br />
prohgoumšnwj fhsˆ perˆ <strong>to</strong>Útwn oÙk<br />
œcei t¾n z»thsin ... [omission]<br />
[4.279.9] kalîj d prosšqhke tÕ<br />
prohgoumšnwj. n g¦r tÍ ggr£fJ<br />
metal»yei, ¿n kaˆ kaloàmen<br />
paragraf»n, mp…ptei p£ntwj kaˆ<br />
deÚteron z»thma par¦ tÕ tÁj<br />
grafÁj kat¦ m…an tîn ¥llwn<br />
st£sewn, oÙ m¾n prohgoumšnwj,<br />
¢ll' n deutšrJ lÒgJ. dÚo g¦r æj<br />
pˆ tÕ ple‹s<strong>to</strong>n n paragrafÍ t¦<br />
zh<strong>to</strong>Úmena, ïn tÕ mn prÒteron œcei<br />
t¾n paragraf»n, ¢pagwg¾n oâsan<br />
tÁj eÙqudik…aj, tÕ d deÚteron kat¦<br />
m…an tîn proeirhmšnwn st£sewn.<br />
[4.284.11] ¢ll¦ kaˆ <strong>to</strong>à<strong>to</strong> m¾ ¢gnoe‹n<br />
prosÁken, æj p©sa paragraf»,<br />
¼tij stˆ kaˆ œggrafoj met£lhyij<br />
(metalamb£netai g£r), e‡dh œcei<br />
dÚo, ésper kaˆ pragmatikÁj: ¹ mn<br />
œggrafoj, ¹ d ¥grafoj.
Change language