MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAPHE AND THE SCHOLIA TO HERMOGENES ¢ll¦ k¨n Ð de‹na m¾ pexšlqV tÍ grafÍ, À crÒnoj À tÒpoj paracrÁma tù feÚgonti bohq»sV, diadšxetai 81 p£ntwj aÙtÕn Ð tÁj eÙqudik…aj ¢gën kaˆ graf»n tij ¥lloj pˆ <strong>to</strong>‹j aÙ<strong>to</strong>‹j gkl»masin ¢poq»setai
MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAPHE AND THE SCHOLIA TO HERMOGENES Appendix 2: Sopater Division of Questions The text is based on RG 8, revised in <strong>the</strong> light of <strong>the</strong> collation of C reported in Innes <strong>and</strong> Winterbot<strong>to</strong>m (1988), <strong>and</strong> <strong>the</strong> conjectures which <strong>the</strong>y propose ad loc. Unattributed conjectures are <strong>the</strong>irs. 245.22-247.7 diaire‹tai ¹ met£lhyij paragrafikù, ¢nagka…J Ônti kaˆ ¢eˆ mp…p<strong>to</strong>nti, aÙtÍ tÍ metal»yei, Ðriko‹j kefala…oij, kataskeu£zousi t¾n met£lhyin À ¢naskeu£zousi, mi´ tîn logikîn, metal»yei deutšrv ¦n mp…ptV, pilÒgJ. oŒon tÕ paragrafikÒn stin: oÙk Ñfe…lw kr…nesqai, moicÕn À kat£dikon À prodÒthn ½ tina <strong>to</strong>ioà<strong>to</strong>n ¢nelèn. eta ¹ met£lhyij: ¢ll' oÙ soˆ dšdotai, À ¢ll' oÙ nàn soi dšdotai ¢naire‹n, À ¢ll' oÙk nq£de soi dšdotai ¢naire‹n, ½ ti <strong>to</strong>ioà<strong>to</strong>n, oŒoj ¨n 82 Øp£rcV Ð trÒpoj tÁj metal»yewj, À kat¦ crÒnon À prÒswpon À tÒpon À ¢form»n (oŒon oÙ di¦ cr»mata ¢naire‹n). eta t¾n met£lhyin kataskeu£seij <strong>to</strong>‹j Ðriko‹j kefala…oij: ésper g¦r n tù ÓrJ t¾n prÒtasin <strong>to</strong>à Órou t¦ ˜xÁj kef£laia kataskeu£zei kaˆ ¢naskeu£zei ¨n 83 œcV ¹ Ûlh <strong>to</strong>à meletwmšnou pl£sma<strong>to</strong>j, e‡te cre…a <strong>to</strong>à kataskeu£zein e‡h e‡te <strong>to</strong>à ¢natršpein t¦j prot£seij t¦j Ðrik¦j, oÛtw kaˆ n tÍ metal»yei kataskeu£seij <strong>to</strong>‹j Ðriko‹j kefala…oij, ÓrJ, sullogismù, phlikÒthti. oŒon tÁj metal»yewj oÜshj, oÙ soˆ dšdotai ¢naire‹n, kataskeu£seij aÙt¾n oÛtw <strong>to</strong>‹j Ðriko‹j: ÓrJ, ›terÒn sti tÕ tÕn d»mion ¢nele‹n À sš: kaˆ sullogismù, Óti oÙk œstin ‡son tÕ tÕn d»mion ¢nele‹n kaˆ s ¢nele‹n: kaˆ phlikÒthti, Óti deinÒn sti tÕ ØpÕ soà ¢naireqÁnai cqroà Ôn<strong>to</strong>j, oÙdn d tÕ ØpÕ <strong>to</strong>à dhm…ou. Ð d ¢ntilšgwn ½<strong>to</strong>i Ð feÚgwn ¢naskeu£zwn t¾n met£lhyin Ðmo…wj <strong>to</strong>‹j Ðriko‹j tÒpoij oÛtw cr»setai: ÓrJ, oÙdn diafšrei tÕ Øp' moà À <strong>to</strong>à dhm…ou ¢naireqÁnai: eta tù phl…kJ, Óti oÙdšn sti <strong>to</strong>à<strong>to</strong>n tÕn trÒpon À ke‹non ¢naireqÁnai: eta tù sullogismù, kaˆ ‡son stˆ tÕ Øp' moà kaˆ <strong>to</strong>à dhm…ou ¢naireqÁnai. met¦ t¾n kataskeu¾n tÁj metal»yewj œsti m…a tîn logikîn: p£ntwj g¦r kat¦ m…an <strong>to</strong>Útwn stˆn ¹ met£lhyij, ¿n ¦n eÛrVj ·´sta t¾n ¢nt…qesin eØr»seij t¾n mp…p<strong>to</strong>usan, oŒon À ¢ntegklhmatik» stin, æj pˆ tîn ¢nelÒntwn moicÒn, kaˆ re‹j Óti ¥xioj Ãn <strong>to</strong>à ¢naireqÁnai: À kat¦ Óron stˆn, æj pˆ tÁj ƒere…aj tÁj muoÚmenon ¢neloÚshj tÚrannon: re‹ g¦r Óti oÙd tÚrannoj Ãn oá<strong>to</strong>j Ð muoÚmenoj, kaˆ ktÕj ín dorufÒrwn kaˆ aÙtÁj ¢kropÒlewj kaˆ sc»ma<strong>to</strong>j turannikoà: À kat¦ s<strong>to</strong>casmÕn, ½ tina ¥llhn st£sin. eta met¦ t¾n <strong>to</strong>iaÚthn ¢nt…qesin p…ptei p£lin metalhptik», oÙk ¢nagka…wj dš, oŒon œdei se ¢nakoinèsasqai tù d»mJ, œdei kathgore‹n, œdei ¢name‹nai, ½ ti <strong>to</strong>ioà<strong>to</strong>n, prÕj t¾n mp…p<strong>to</strong>usan Ûlhn (Øpode…gma<strong>to</strong>j g¦r e†neka kaˆ caraktÁroj taàta proe…rhtai). met¦ taàta p…logoj. ‡dwmen oân pˆ probl»ma<strong>to</strong>j t¾n dia…resin. 82 ¦n codd. 83 ¦n codd. 45
- Page 1 and 2: LEEDS INTERNATIONAL CLASSICAL STUDI
- Page 3 and 4: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 5 and 6: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 7 and 8: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 9 and 10: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 11 and 12: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 13 and 14: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 15 and 16: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 17 and 18: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 19 and 20: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 21 and 22: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 23 and 24: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 25 and 26: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 27 and 28: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 29 and 30: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 31 and 32: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 33 and 34: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 35 and 36: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 37 and 38: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 39 and 40: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 41 and 42: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 43: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 47 and 48: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 49 and 50: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 51 and 52: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 53 and 54: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 55 and 56: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 57 and 58: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 59 and 60: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 61 and 62: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 63 and 64: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 65 and 66: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 67 and 68: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 69 and 70: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 71 and 72: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 73 and 74: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 75 and 76: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 77 and 78: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 79 and 80: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 81 and 82: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 83 and 84: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 85 and 86: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 87 and 88: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 89 and 90: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
- Page 91: MALCOLM HEATH, METALEPSIS, PARAGRAP
Change language