MATURE Deliverable 1. - Knowledge Maturing

List of Figures
Figure 1: Overview of elements of WP1 ..................................................................................................... 11
Figure 2: Timeline of collaborative ethnographic study ............................................................................. 14
Figure 3: Coding procedure ......................................................................................................................... 20
Figure 4: Overlappings of codes used by the distributed teams of ethnographers ...................................... 21
Figure 5: Code cloud for the dimension “knowledge routines” .................................................................. 21
Figure 6: Table with clustered codes ........................................................................................................... 22
Figure 7: Progression of overall coding process ......................................................................................... 22
Figure 8: Graphical Representation of Personas in PROMOTE ................................................................. 28
Figure 9: Mapping of approaches for clustering Personas .......................................................................... 30
Figure 10: Graphical representation of the maturing case “new solution development“ ............................ 35
Figure 11: Sequence of knowledge routines ............................................................................................... 37
Figure 12: Observed changes in knowledge maturity ................................................................................. 42
Figure 13: Dimensions of knowledge maturing .......................................................................................... 48
Figure 14: Knowledge maturing model v2 (based on Maier and Schmidt, 2007) ...................................... 55
Figure 15: Process maturity model .............................................................................................................. 57
Figure 16: Ontology maturity model ........................................................................................................... 58
Figure 17: The SER model and knowledge maturing ................................................................................. 61
Figure 18: Continuum of motivation (Ryan and Deci, 2000) ..................................................................... 62
Figure 19: Determinants of motivation to engage in knowledge maturing activities ................................. 64
Figure 20: Prisoners’ dilemma .................................................................................................................... 65
Figure 21: Model of Burke & Litwin (1992) .............................................................................................. 68
Figure 22: Overview of year two activities ................................................................................................. 71
Figure 23: Code cloud for the dimension “knowledge elements” ............................................................. 130
Figure 24: Code cloud for the dimension “situations” .............................................................................. 130
Figure 25: Code cloud for the dimension “motivational factors” ............................................................. 131
Figure 26: Code cloud for the dimension “tools” ...................................................................................... 131
Figure 27: Code cloud for the dimension “knowledge structures” ........................................................... 132
Figure 28: Grouping of Personas .............................................................................................................. 161
Figure 29: Initial clustering of Personas (FZI) .......................................................................................... 161
Figure 30: Clustering of Personas (UIBK) as presented at 4th consortium meeting ................................ 162
Figure 31: Clustering of Personas (UPB) as presented at 4th consortium meeting .................................. 162
Figure 32: Clustering of Personas (FZI) as presented at 4th consortium meeting .................................... 163
6