22.08.2013 Views

Historical Security Council - World Model United Nations

Historical Security Council - World Model United Nations

Historical Security Council - World Model United Nations

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

<strong>Historical</strong> <strong>Security</strong><br />

<strong>Council</strong><br />

<strong>World</strong> <strong>Model</strong> <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> 2013<br />

Study Guide


Contact Us<br />

<strong>World</strong> <strong>Model</strong> united <strong>Nations</strong> 2013<br />

info@worldmun.org<br />

www.worldmun.org<br />

Letters<br />

Letter from the Secretary General 04<br />

Letter from the Under-Secretary General 05<br />

Letter from the Chair 06<br />

Introduction<br />

History of the Committee 07<br />

Statement of the Problem: The Situation in the Congo 09<br />

CONteNtS<br />

09<br />

History of the Problem<br />

Basic Facts<br />

10 Before Colonialization<br />

10 King Leopold II and the Congo<br />

13 After Leopold: Much of the Same?<br />

16 <strong>World</strong> War II<br />

17 The Independence Struggle<br />

19<br />

Current Situation<br />

Prime Minister Lumumba Calls upon UNSC<br />

21 Past UN Actions<br />

21 Potential Solutions<br />

23 Key Actors: Class and Politics<br />

25 Bloc Positions<br />

27 Questions a Resolution Must Answer<br />

27 Suggestions for Further Research<br />

28<br />

Conclusion<br />

Position Papers<br />

28 Closing Remarks<br />

32 Bibliographic Essay<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


Letters<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


Letter from the Secretary-General<br />

dear delegates,<br />

it is my pleasure and honor to welcome you to the 22nd session of <strong>World</strong> <strong>Model</strong> united<br />

<strong>Nations</strong>! My name is Charlene Wong, and i am the Secretary-General of <strong>World</strong>MuN 2013.<br />

Within this document you will find the study guide for your committee. The conference<br />

staff for <strong>World</strong>MUN 2013 has been working tirelessly over the past months to provide<br />

you with an unparalleled conference experience, beginning with this guide. Each Head<br />

Chair has researched extensively to provide you with a foundation for each committee’s<br />

topic areas.<br />

We encourage you to use this study guide as the starting point for your exploration of<br />

your committee’s topics, and your country or character’s policies. The <strong>World</strong>MUN Spirit<br />

invites you to step into the shoes of your country or character, and to immerse yourself in<br />

the committee by researching and developing a full understanding of the issues, perspectives,<br />

and possible solutions on the table. We offer several additional resources online,<br />

including our <strong>World</strong>MuN 101 Guide and Rules of Procedure, updated for this year. Both<br />

are available at www.worldmun.org. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to<br />

contact your Head Chair or Under-Secretary-General.<br />

Please enjoy reading this study guide, and I look forward to meeting you in Melbourne<br />

in March!<br />

Sincerely,<br />

Charlene S. Wong<br />

Secretary-General<br />

<strong>World</strong> <strong>Model</strong> united <strong>Nations</strong> 2013<br />

secretarygeneral@worldmun.org<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design<br />

4


Letter from the Under-Secretary-General<br />

dear delegates,<br />

it is with the utmost honor and pleasure that i welcome you to the Specialized Agencies.<br />

the SA holds a special place in the heart of <strong>Model</strong> united <strong>Nations</strong>; it is here that<br />

crises are born and delegates rise to the challenge to address quickly evolving issues in<br />

real-time. With an average size of 20 delegates per committee, the SA promises to deliver<br />

an intimate and tight-knit environment where every delegate’s voice can be heard and<br />

appreciated.<br />

The SA has always made a firm commitment to substantive excellence and lifelike simulations.<br />

The first measure of that promise starts here with this study guide. Your chair has<br />

worked tirelessly over these past few months pouring over books in deep Harvard dungeons<br />

to breathe life into these topics. I am so proud of their work and hope you make<br />

the most of this initial resource to inspire and guide your preparation for <strong>World</strong>MuN.<br />

Come March, your chair and the junior staff will be working to deliver a MUN simulation<br />

that raises the bar of your delegate experience.<br />

All that being said, the SA would be nothing without you, her committed delegates, who<br />

challenge and dedicate themselves to addressing head-on the world’s greatest problems,<br />

both past, present, and future. With ample preparation, devotion, and creativity,<br />

you will find success in this SA home.<br />

As a former MUN delegate and SA staffer, I know what it means to live and breathe a<br />

thrilling and informative MUN experience. Along with our chairs and junior staff, I hope<br />

to deliver that same experience to you all. Take care, and I cannot wait to meet you in<br />

person in Melbourne!<br />

Sincerely,<br />

Michael Chilazi<br />

under-Secretary-General of the Specialized<br />

Agencies<br />

<strong>World</strong> <strong>Model</strong> united <strong>Nations</strong> 2013<br />

sa@worldmun.org<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design<br />

5


Letter from the Chair<br />

dear delegates,<br />

Greetings and welcome to the <strong>Historical</strong> <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong>. My name is Graeme Crews, and<br />

I will be your chair for what will be an incredible <strong>World</strong> <strong>Model</strong> <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> 2013 in Melbourne,<br />

Australia. As the most powerful body in the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>, you will face an issue<br />

that demands attention from the international community and promises to set a strong<br />

precedent for uN action in the newly decolonized African region.<br />

Briefly, here’s a little info about me. I am a senior at Harvard in Leverett House, concentrating<br />

in Social Studies, which is an interesting amalgamation of political science,<br />

political theory, sociology, economics, and all the other social sciences. MuN is one of<br />

my primary activities on campus. I chaired the International Criminal Court in Singapore<br />

at <strong>World</strong>MuN 2011 and chaired the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> in <strong>World</strong>MuN 2012. i directed the<br />

<strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> at HNMUN 2011 and HNMUN 2012. I am also a member of ICMUN, our<br />

traveling <strong>Model</strong> UN team. I am so involved with <strong>Model</strong> UN because, like you I am sure, I<br />

am interested in international affairs and the intellectual challenge of solving problems in<br />

the international community. Moreover, it offers participants the ability to meet people<br />

from around the world to learn about different cultures and shared values.<br />

Other than <strong>Model</strong> UN, I am a member of the Harvard Speech and Parliamentary Debate<br />

Society. I am super interested in American politics. I volunteer with the Elizabeth Warren<br />

for Senate campaign in Massachusetts and I help organize campus activities to aid in<br />

her campaign. Some of my less demanding extracurricular activities include watching the<br />

most recent blockbusters and trashy TV and spending time with friends.<br />

The <strong>Historical</strong> <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> this year at <strong>World</strong>MUN will face the situation in the Congo<br />

in 1960. Using the study guide and your own research, you will develop comprehensive<br />

solutions to this situation. Independence has recently been declared for the country, but<br />

rival tribal politics along with the newly declared independence of a region within the<br />

country and the intervention by Belgian forces certainly bring this situation to crisis level.<br />

Embedded in the topics are discussions of geopolitical relations, the intersection of economics<br />

and politics, and nation-state formation and centralization.<br />

<strong>World</strong>MuN is truly the Olympics of the MuN world. For any newcomers, you will get the<br />

amazing opportunity of meeting passionate and intelligent students from around the<br />

world in a place bursting with culture and sights to see. For any lucky veterans like me,<br />

you get to experience this opportunity all over again.<br />

All the best,<br />

Graeme Crews<br />

Chair, <strong>Historical</strong> <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />

<strong>World</strong>MuN 2013<br />

hsc@worldmun.org<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design<br />

6


Introduction<br />

The most important body of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> has<br />

on its docket one issue to focus on for the duration on<br />

conference: the situation in the Congo in 1960. Before<br />

diving into the issues at stake, I want to lay out my<br />

vision for committee. I envision that committee will<br />

function as a blend of standing and crisis committee.<br />

Every session I hope that as a committee you will<br />

be able to produce a resolution advocating certain<br />

actions. using your recommendations, my assistant<br />

chairs and I will assemble a series of reports from the<br />

Congo presenting the facts on the ground after your<br />

recommendations have been implemented. The next<br />

session you will then react to those facts, and so on.<br />

This situation has been one the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> has<br />

dealt with periodically from 1960 onward (though we<br />

do not know that at this point…), so it will very much<br />

mimic reality.<br />

the Congo is one of the largest colonies in Africa,<br />

and the humanitarian conditions were among the<br />

most deplorable in the late 1800s and 1900s. King<br />

Leopold used forced labor within the colony to<br />

extract huge amounts of wealth for his benefit and for<br />

the benefit of Belgium. When the colony transferred<br />

ownership from Leopold to the Belgian government<br />

in 1908 after a sustained international humanitarian<br />

campaign, the Belgian government continued much<br />

of the most problematic practices of the Leopold<br />

regime, including forced labor, taxes, and poor<br />

social services. After <strong>World</strong> War II, the independence<br />

movement picked up force in the country and in the<br />

context of decolonization internationally, the Belgians<br />

agreed to independence in 1959. When 30 June 1960<br />

arrived, the historical particularities of the Congo did<br />

not prepare it for a self-governing, centralized polity<br />

that was typical in Europe and developed nations<br />

worldwide. Tribal alliances formed the basis for most<br />

political parties, and the military grew mutinous at<br />

the slow-moving changes in the Force Publique from<br />

Belgian to African leadership.<br />

When a mutiny broke out in July, the resourcerich<br />

region of Katanga declared independence, and<br />

Europeans and Africans alike feared for their safety,<br />

the new Prime Minister Lumumba requested help from<br />

the united <strong>Nations</strong> on 12 July 1960. the uNSC, with its<br />

current membership of the permanent five (Republic<br />

of China, Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, <strong>United</strong><br />

States, France, and <strong>United</strong> Kingdom) and rotational<br />

six (ecuador, Argentina, Ceylon, Poland, tunisia, and<br />

Italy) has met to discuss these circumstances and<br />

craft the appropriate response. the purpose of this<br />

Demonstrating the international importance of the situation in the<br />

Congo, this front page story on the impending independence in the<br />

Congo comes from Cleveland, Ohio.<br />

study guide is to provide an initial grounding in both<br />

the history of the situations, the issues in play, and<br />

the potential solutions. The problems associated with<br />

these topics require innovative and comprehensive<br />

solutions; it’s up to you to find them, apply them, and<br />

ensure international peace and security.<br />

History of the Committee<br />

Inception<br />

Following <strong>World</strong> War II, the Holocaust, and the<br />

advent of the nuclear age 1 , the world community<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design<br />

7


decided to improve upon the League of <strong>Nations</strong><br />

and create the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>. However, even<br />

during <strong>World</strong> War II steps were taken to move to<br />

an international institution designed to protect<br />

and promote international peace and security. the<br />

inter-Allied declaration signed in June 1941, stating<br />

that the Allied Powers would “work together, with<br />

other free peoples, both in war and in peace,” was<br />

the first step in establishing the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>.<br />

The Atlantic Charter of August 1941 between the<br />

<strong>United</strong> States and Britain, the Declaration by <strong>United</strong><br />

<strong>Nations</strong> in January 1942, and the Moscow and<br />

Tehran conferences of October 1943 and December<br />

1943, respectively, further developed plans for an<br />

The chamber of the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> as it appeared circa 1960.<br />

international organization, whose first blueprint<br />

was drawn up in the Dumbarton Oaks conference in<br />

October 1944. In April of 1945, the Charter of <strong>United</strong><br />

<strong>Nations</strong>, with sections explicitly devoted to the<br />

powers and structure of the <strong>Security</strong>, was approved<br />

unanimously in San Francisco. 2 Unlike the League of<br />

<strong>Nations</strong>, the UN Charter gave the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> the<br />

authority to enforce the peace through diplomatic,<br />

economic, and even military means, making threats<br />

or use of forces illegal except in self-defense or when<br />

approved by the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong>. 3<br />

Powers<br />

Unlike the General Assembly resolutions,<br />

resolutions from the <strong>Security</strong> are binding and<br />

countries, due to their ratification of the UN Charter<br />

(required before joining the UN), are legally required<br />

to respect and follow them. The five permanent<br />

members of the <strong>United</strong> States of America, The <strong>United</strong><br />

Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the<br />

Russian Federation, the People’s Republic of China,<br />

and the French Republic each have veto power and<br />

no decision can be made on a nonprocedural question<br />

unless they abstain or agree and enforcement<br />

for resolutions can thus only be taken with their<br />

consensus. This institutional structure saved the<br />

organization from imploding when actions were<br />

taken against the most powerful members. 4<br />

the most important articles pertinent to <strong>Security</strong><br />

<strong>Council</strong> powers are Articles 26, 39, 41, and 42. Article<br />

26 assigns the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> with the task of<br />

establishing “a regulation system for the regulation<br />

of armaments.” 5 As per Article 39, the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />

has the ability to determine whether a situation is<br />

a threat to the peace, a breach of the peace, or an<br />

act of aggression. Article 41 outlines measures of<br />

responding that are non-military, such as sanctions,<br />

and Article 42 outlines the use of military measures. 6<br />

the powers and functions accorded to the united<br />

<strong>Nations</strong>, as per the uN Charter, include:<br />

to maintain international peace and security in<br />

accordance with the principles and purposes of the<br />

united <strong>Nations</strong>;<br />

• to investigate any dispute or situation which<br />

might lead to international friction;<br />

• to recommend methods of adjusting such<br />

disputes or the terms of settlement;<br />

• to formulate plans for the establishment of a<br />

system to regulate armaments;<br />

• to determine the existence of a threat to the<br />

peace or act of aggression and to recommend<br />

what action should be taken;<br />

• to call on Members to apply economic<br />

sanctions and other measures not involving<br />

the use of force to prevent or stop aggression;<br />

• to take military action against an aggressor;<br />

• to recommend the admission of new<br />

Members;<br />

• to exercise the trusteeship functions of the<br />

<strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> in “strategic areas”;<br />

• to recommend to the General Assembly the<br />

appointment of the Secretary-General and,<br />

together with the Assembly, to elect the<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design<br />

8


Judges of the international Court of Justice. 7<br />

Past Major Actions<br />

Since its creation and establishment in 1945, the<br />

<strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> has consistently drafted and passed<br />

resolutions dealing with issues of international<br />

peace and security. Even with Article 2, paragraph 7<br />

of the Charter prohibiting the UN from intervening<br />

in the internal affairs and jurisdiction of a state,<br />

the uN <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> has interpreted threats to<br />

international peace and security to include political<br />

instability and violence within states. 8<br />

Statement of the Problem: The Situation<br />

in the Congo<br />

Our committee will begin its deliberations in the<br />

midst of chaos in the Congo. the country was just<br />

newly independent, but a mutiny in the army has<br />

spread across the country, the resource-rich Katanga<br />

region has just declared independence, and the<br />

Belgian army has violated the Congo government’s<br />

wishes and sent its own troops into the region to<br />

protect europeans. in the context of escalating<br />

violence, uncertainty of the power of the new<br />

government, and economic downturn, the UNSC<br />

is meeting and attempting to devise a politically<br />

palatable solution to the widespread problems.<br />

Looking broadly, the situation in the Congo during<br />

the 1960s mixed the divisive politics of the Cold War<br />

with process and problems of decolonization in a<br />

highly contentious way. 9 the situation in the Congo is<br />

a very complicated one, with a land area that is eighty<br />

times the size of its colonial administrator Belgian and<br />

over 200 ethnic groups dotting its landscape. Because<br />

the construction of the area was based on political<br />

contingencies in the late 19 th century, the borders<br />

have no real meaning for collecting a singular group of<br />

Africans. 10 The Congo will not have an easy transition<br />

to a state in the Western construct—territorial<br />

integrity and sovereignty; the Belgian occupation<br />

and extraction ensured that a unified polity would be<br />

difficult to achieve. 11 Geopolitically, the major players<br />

in the Western world were not particularly concerned<br />

about the Congo’s strategic security importance, but<br />

rather with Western capitalism’s or communism’s<br />

ability to prosper in the Third <strong>World</strong> and the jockeying<br />

for expansion of a dominant economic system. 12<br />

Through this guide, it will become evident that<br />

Belgian control of the country in its colonial period<br />

has had huge impacts on the development of the<br />

Congo and its success. Inadvertently, Leopold and the<br />

Belgian government organized the Congo’s economic<br />

conditions in such a way to prevent economic viability<br />

for the future independent country. 13 Colonial<br />

economic exploitation transformed African societies,<br />

including the groups in the region now known as the<br />

Congo, by using the forced labor of the native peoples<br />

to meet export requirements for raw materials for<br />

enrichment by the ruling class and a country they<br />

would never see. 14<br />

Ultimately, the country is inherently divided and<br />

as a result does not have a unified message of selfgovernance,<br />

external actors are often able to speak<br />

for it and skew its interests in a way that may not be<br />

productive for the state. 15 Remember that while you<br />

have your own national interests to adhere to, the<br />

people of the Congo are the ones who will benefit or<br />

be harmed most by your actions in committee.<br />

History and Discussion of the<br />

Problem<br />

Basic Facts<br />

With a population in 1960 of 15 million, 16 the ethnic<br />

make-up of the Congo is extremely complicated,<br />

with over 200 ethnic groups occupying six different<br />

provinces, which are all at different stages of<br />

economic development. The Kongo (48% of the<br />

population), Sangha (20%), Teke (17%), and M’Bochi<br />

(12%) are the four largest defined ethnic groups and<br />

comprise more than 40 tribes within the boundaries<br />

of the country. 17 the ethnic groups do share many<br />

cultural traits, including speaking the same Bantuderived<br />

languages. 18 the Congolese until well into<br />

their colonialization period lived in traditional village<br />

settings, where traditional economic tasks were<br />

separated by gender, religious rituals and public<br />

ceremonies were the norm. 19<br />

The Congo is vast, occupying 2,345,400 square<br />

kilometers, a third the size of the <strong>United</strong> States. 20<br />

Approximately 77 per cent of the land is made of<br />

forests and woodlands, including a tropical rainforest<br />

along the Equator, which provides timber in world<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design<br />

9


markets. 21 the products mined in Congo are essential<br />

for world markets—copper (8 percent of world<br />

production), cobalt (73 percent of world production),<br />

industrial diamonds (80 percent of world production),<br />

uranium, zinc, gold, and other precious minerals. 22<br />

Agriculturally, the Congo is a source of coffee, tea,<br />

and cotton plants. 23<br />

Before Colonialization<br />

Before colonialization, the political institutions<br />

within the region now known as the Congo were<br />

kingdoms. They were primarily social organizations<br />

based on agricultural production, and the central<br />

rulers facilitated long-distance trade. 24<br />

The Kingdom of the Congo was formed in the<br />

14th century with a political structure very similar to<br />

the european feudal one of the time. 25 through the<br />

15th century, it was able to consolidate its power<br />

due to the prosperous economy in the region<br />

from agriculture and long-distance trade that<br />

was emerging with European powers. The tribute<br />

system with local chiefs kept law and order. 26 At the<br />

end of the 15th century, diplomatic relations were<br />

established between Portugal and the Kingdom,<br />

but the expanding diplomatic relations with Europe<br />

led in the 16th century to alcoholism, extortion, and<br />

the growth of the slave trade. 27 As part of the trade<br />

paths that slaves took, ivory and other trade goods<br />

from the Congo region made their way to the coasts<br />

of Africa. 28<br />

There are roughly speaking two historical periods of<br />

Congo-European relationships: first, the Atlantic slave<br />

trade which was the primary means of accumulation<br />

in the global economy in the 16th century and second,<br />

the trade in raw materials needed for industrial<br />

production in Europe in the 18th and early 19th century.<br />

Neither of these historical processes exposed much<br />

of what is now known as the Congo to the outside<br />

world. 29<br />

Nevertheless, the Kingdom of the Congo did<br />

become a player in the rivalry between the Dutch and<br />

Portuguese and declined rapidly. 30 The kingdom’s fast<br />

integration into the overall capitalist system along<br />

with its participation in the Atlantic slave ultimately<br />

turned the kingdom against itself and contributed<br />

to its decline. 31 The end result was the Kingdom’s<br />

dissolution in 1885 between Portugal, France, and<br />

Belgium. 32<br />

The Luba empire in the southern part of the region<br />

was another major precolonial state that lost its<br />

power before the Europeans annexed this part of<br />

Africa. The Luba state solidified in the 16 th century,<br />

with its power extending across the Katanga-Kasai<br />

trade network and absorbing tributes from the<br />

local chieftains. The empire dissolved between 1860<br />

and 1891 from the cumulative effects of outside<br />

Early sketch of a Portuguese delegation at the court of the King of<br />

the Congo.<br />

interventions by Europeans and by ivory and slave<br />

traders who intruded on their central and peripheral<br />

territories. 33<br />

King Leopold II and the Congo<br />

While most of the interior of the Congo, far from<br />

the ocean and trade routes, was on the periphery of<br />

most European power’s concerns, the 1884-85 Berlin<br />

Conference, or “Scramble for Africa”, brought the<br />

land into focus. King Leopold II of Belgium declared<br />

sovereignty over the Congo River basin, creating the<br />

political construction of what became known as the<br />

“Congo.” 34 Leopold’s ventures in the region extended<br />

much before this date, it should be noted. He sent<br />

British-born American journalist Henry Morton<br />

Stanley into central Africa as part of the Association<br />

international africaine (AIA), where Stanley used<br />

manipulation and coercion to force clan and tribe<br />

chiefs to “sign” treaties with the King to cede their<br />

territories to control to the newly formed Association<br />

10<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


international du Congo (AIC), which came out of<br />

the AIA. By obtaining these treaties, establishing<br />

administrative and trading stations along rivers<br />

within central Africa, Leopold was able to brandish an<br />

empire-building record that justified his claims to the<br />

resources and territories of the Congo at the Berlin<br />

Conference. 35 it did not hurt that the great powers<br />

did not want to see another obtain the central African<br />

region, and thus allowed Belgium’s Leopold to have<br />

it. 36 Moreover, Leopold’s neutral status ensured that<br />

A portrait of King Leopold II.<br />

the colony would be open to other nationals and their<br />

companies. He promised not to impose customs or<br />

import duties in the resource-rich region, and thus<br />

the other powers came to view the region as a free<br />

trade model. 37 This fit within the overall principles<br />

agreed upon at the conference, which also included<br />

neutrality in wars, suppression of slave traffic,<br />

and improvement of the condition of indigenous<br />

populations. 38<br />

The situation in the colony of Congo was different<br />

from African colonies around the continent for two<br />

specific reasons. First, its establishment as a colony in<br />

the late 19 th century came far after most other African<br />

colonies had been established. Second, the colony<br />

was viewed as the possession of an individual—<br />

King Leopold II. These two dynamics motivated King<br />

Leopold and administrations to colonize the area very<br />

quickly. The condensed process led concurrently to<br />

an expanded land control policy and coercive control<br />

mechanisms to maintain control. 39 King Leopold<br />

positioned himself initially as a benevolent leader,<br />

selfless and ready to make his African holdings<br />

civilized participants in the capitalist system. 40 the<br />

discourse of salvation proved to be the rationale for<br />

the forced and violent development that the colony<br />

administrators would impose on culturally backward<br />

Africans. 41 Despite the forced labor policies he<br />

implemented, Leopold publically upheld his colonial<br />

project as one that would save the natives from the<br />

Arab slave traders who peddled in “odious traffic,<br />

which is a disgrace to the age in which we live.” 42 this<br />

appeal to protecting the Africans from the Arab slave<br />

traders gained him moral support throughout europe<br />

and the united States. 43<br />

His actions were not always congruent with his<br />

rhetoric. immediately after Congo was organized as<br />

his own personal “Congo Free State”, he undertook<br />

campaigns of military pacification and economic<br />

exploitation. 44 King Leopold was primarily motivated<br />

by his desire to turn the region into a profit for his<br />

personal needs. He had spent vast amounts of<br />

money in order to explore the region and lobby for<br />

his ownership of it, and thus he needed money to<br />

pay down debts and invest in his native Belgium’s<br />

economic development. With this motivation, he<br />

sought simple resource accumulation and therefore<br />

sought to accomplish this through forced labor. 45<br />

the economic exploitation of the Congo was<br />

primarily around harvesting wild rubber for exportation<br />

to Belgium and use in tires. White settlers working<br />

for the state and commercial enterprises (many of<br />

11<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


which controlled by King Leopold) forced native<br />

peoples to work through coercion and violence. 46<br />

Punishments for African natives included floggings,<br />

beatings, and executions were handed out for crimes<br />

from desertion to dropping a pack. 47 When labor<br />

taxes and quotas were not fulfilled in certain villages,<br />

these floggings and executions were the norm, often<br />

carried out by neighboring ethnic groups employed<br />

by Belgian administrators. Entire villages were often<br />

razed in response to failure to fulfill labor quotas. 48<br />

The king created a standard of declaring indigenous<br />

land ownership as “vacant land” and declared land<br />

his by eminent domain. The end result in the Congo<br />

was that huge swaths of the country were declared<br />

the “Crown domain” or the “private domain of the<br />

state.” 49 The end result in Belgium was a huge inflow<br />

of capital, which was used for public works projects<br />

and urban improvement. 50 the rationalization of this<br />

exploitation came from an ideology that asserted<br />

the “white man’s burden” to bring Christianity and<br />

capitalism to “inferior races.” Leopold paid vast sums<br />

of money to public relations agencies to depict the<br />

venture in the Congo as essentially a humanitarian<br />

campaign seeking to bring an end to poverty and<br />

ignorance in native populations. 51<br />

The political impacts of King Leopold’s regime<br />

were interrelated with the economic policies he<br />

purported. As administrative stations were built<br />

throughout the region, the integration of the country<br />

into a capitalist and exploitive system occurred. This<br />

led to all the major African political systems in the<br />

area being brought under the control of the colonial<br />

administrative state, which implemented new taxes<br />

in labor and money. 52<br />

The End to Leopold’s Congo<br />

An international reform movement, led by E.D.<br />

Morel, sought to drastically change Leopold’s<br />

stranglehold on the Congo. in a letter in 1905, Morel<br />

wrote that: “A system has been introduced…imitated<br />

in some respect by others, which is turning its servants<br />

into brute beasts, disgracing European prestige,<br />

befouling civilization, and jeopardizing the whole<br />

future of European effort in the Dark Continent.” 53<br />

Drawing from reports about atrocities that came<br />

from foreign missionaries, Morel focused Western<br />

attention on Leopold’s rule. 54 Leopold attempted<br />

to stop the turning of public opinion against him<br />

and his colony by hiring spies and double agent to<br />

infiltrate foreign government and tried to flood the<br />

newspapers with positive coverage and depress<br />

negative coverage by bribing editors. 55 Leopold<br />

was further able to stem the outrage by portraying<br />

Morel’s campaign success as a British and American<br />

plot to take away the king’s prized possession. 56<br />

However, Morel was able to cast Leopold and Belgium<br />

in an extremely negative light, given the discursive<br />

tendencies of the time; his campaign promoted the<br />

view of Leopold and his actions as “barbaric” and<br />

“uncivilized.” 57 Morel’s claims about the brutality<br />

in the Congo were confirmed by outside sources,<br />

including an international Commission of Enquiry of<br />

lawyers that, after a five-month tour, confirmed all<br />

the claims of brutality and coercion that had been<br />

circulating in the media. 58 The ability to appeal to the<br />

humanitarian impulses of elites in Western europe<br />

and the <strong>United</strong> States, along with the inability of<br />

foreign powers to access and penetrate the Congo’s<br />

vast wealth at the time, proved to be an extremely<br />

potent mix of forces that had the ultimate impact of<br />

forcing Leopold out of the region. 59<br />

Thus, the movement overcame Leopold’s<br />

stronghold on the Congo and forced him to transfer<br />

the colony to the Belgian state in 1908 60 by selling<br />

his personal estate to the government of Belgium. 61<br />

The Belgian parliament voted to annex the region in<br />

August 1908 after a divisive debate and in a hardly<br />

resounding vote of 88 in favor and 54 opposed. 62<br />

the result of the colonial project was tragic: an<br />

official Belgian inquiry from 1919 reported that the<br />

population of the Congo had diminished by half,<br />

which equals about 10 million deaths from murder,<br />

disease, starvation, and exposure. 63<br />

Resistance<br />

Through the beginning of Belgian colonial history,<br />

there were certainly pockets of resistance, which had<br />

the potential of snowballing into a larger movement.<br />

the root reason why resistance generally failed is that<br />

by the time of the Berlin Conference and the annexation<br />

by European powers, there was no centralized Congo<br />

kingdom. The tribes in Congo were much too weak<br />

12<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


and disorganized to be effective against an armed<br />

European imperial conquest. 64 Resistance against<br />

the europeans was ultimately most successful from<br />

within colony-established institutions—the colonial<br />

army, forced labor camps, and agricultural workers.<br />

Discontent over taxes, conscription, and forced labor<br />

was able to spread and<br />

strengthen in these<br />

contexts. 65 the 1900<br />

to 1916 Shi rebellion<br />

and 1907-1917 Luba-<br />

Katanga of Kasongo<br />

Nyembo rebellion<br />

were longstanding<br />

affairs against the<br />

Leopold empire and<br />

the Belgian colonial<br />

government. 66 the<br />

former leaders of the<br />

Luba empire used<br />

their former power<br />

to rise up against<br />

Leopold’s empire in<br />

1895, and it put up<br />

effective resistance<br />

against forced labor<br />

policies. 67 However, as<br />

the colony centralized<br />

and consolidated<br />

its powers as will<br />

be described in the<br />

next section, it was<br />

able to quash these<br />

insurrections. 68<br />

The revolts in the<br />

internal colonial army illustrate much of the underlying<br />

dynamics of the colony. White officers steeped in racist<br />

ideology were brutal in their disciplinary measures of<br />

soldiers, military workers, who maintained, supplied,<br />

and grew food, and porters, who transported<br />

equipment and supplies. 69 cities of the country.<br />

Revolts during Leopold’s<br />

reign arose in these garrisons—the Kananga mutiny<br />

in 1895, the Ndirfi mutiny in 1897 and the Shinkakasa<br />

mutiny in 1900. These revolts were called upon later<br />

as memories of resistance against the Belgian. it is<br />

generally agreed that what motivated rebels was the<br />

oppression of the colonial administrators, and they<br />

were able to succeed in their resistance in pockets of<br />

the region for years because they recruited volunteers<br />

from surrounding areas to replenish their ranks. The<br />

multi-ethnic make-up of the mutinies fostered and<br />

developed a national<br />

identity—one at odds<br />

with the ruling Belgian<br />

class. 70<br />

After Leopold:<br />

More of the<br />

Same?<br />

As the transition<br />

of the Congo from<br />

Leopold’s to Belgium’s<br />

control occurred and<br />

completed in 1908,<br />

there was hope that<br />

all the excessive force<br />

of the past would be<br />

eliminated. the general<br />

scheme of governance<br />

worked such that while<br />

the Belgian parliament<br />

and colonial affairs<br />

ministers in Brussels<br />

supervised the colony,<br />

the actual governance<br />

of the colony was done<br />

on the ground by the<br />

colonial bureaucracy<br />

in alliance with<br />

representatives of the<br />

Belgian bourgeoisie,<br />

business leaders, and the hierarchy of the Catholic<br />

Church. 71 The new governance scheme did not<br />

radically alter from the previous one and utilized the<br />

pre-existing economic and administrative institutions<br />

to operate the colony. the inherited colony had a<br />

particular structure: a huge region of land with a sparse<br />

population under a system of economic exploitation<br />

with no tradition of positive policy aimed at<br />

benefiting the general population. 72 This colonial map shows the regional break-up of the colony and the major<br />

the longstanding<br />

institutions did not merely dissolve to be developed<br />

13<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


anew; instead there was refinement at the margins of<br />

the overall structure. 73 it is unsurprising that there was<br />

major reform; Belgium had little history as a colonial<br />

power and had to learn quickly to administer an area<br />

80 times its size thousands of miles away. 74 in part to<br />

assuage public anger in Europe, the Belgians adopted<br />

a colonial constitution, crafted by major shareholders<br />

in Belgian and the Catholic Church, which had an<br />

interest in proselytizing. 75 The first Belgian minister<br />

of the colony reduced compulsory labor and stopped<br />

the most significant government-led atrocities. 76 His<br />

appointments of local administrators were typically<br />

young men with little formal education who utilized<br />

the colonial army of white Belgian officers and African<br />

infantry to enforce forced labor and collect taxes. 77<br />

The colonial administrators were, like during<br />

Leopold’s time, focused on economic exploitation<br />

and providing corporations with adequate land to<br />

mine. 78 Belgian domestic politics were not organized<br />

in a way to drastically change colonial affairs, and thus<br />

allowed the minority in the home country with vested<br />

interests in the region to gain disproportionate say<br />

in the governance of the region. 79 The new king<br />

of Belgium could rule by decree after consulting<br />

a purely advisory colonial council of conservative,<br />

business-oriented appointees, but this decree was<br />

constrained by the Belgian minister of colonies. 80<br />

The Belgian minister of colonial affairs wrote in 1921<br />

that the major goal of colonialism was to develop<br />

“the economic action of Belgium,” which means that<br />

the law and order control of the colony is at most as<br />

important as the labor recruitment for companies. 81<br />

In the initial ownership of the Congo by Belgium, the<br />

state’s authority in the countryside was literally a<br />

function of company’s administration and extraction<br />

of a particular region. Companies would use African<br />

chiefs as supplementary workers on behalf of the<br />

company to recruit labor for them. Although the<br />

state eventually established control over most of the<br />

region at local level displacing the rule by companies,<br />

the new requirements for the people were<br />

sometimes more onerous as they needed to provide<br />

extra labor and taxes for public works projects and<br />

adhere to certain regulations governing most parts<br />

of people’s lives. 82 ultimately, companies continued<br />

to have monopolistic powers over vast swaths of<br />

the region, resulting in either no pay or very low pay<br />

for the local workers and their production. 83 Often,<br />

though forced labor was technically frowned upon,<br />

companies and administrators would recruit and hold<br />

locals as workers through the imposition of fines and<br />

imprisonment for breach of contract. 84<br />

However, as time progressed, leaders in the<br />

colonial regime began to understand that in order<br />

This 1922 map illustrates the holdings of African countries by various<br />

European colonial powers.<br />

to have effective control over a population, the<br />

Europeans needed effective local allies. A series<br />

of decrees on colonial administration in 1906,<br />

1910, and 1933 transformed chiefs from outside<br />

powers to intermediary powers with the colonial<br />

administration. 85 if chiefs helped meet export<br />

expectations, signed up tribes for conscription,<br />

provided forced labor, and paid taxes, they were given<br />

14<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


economic and political rewards, which effectively set<br />

them against their own people. 86 Chiefs were also<br />

brought on as sponsors to ensure that peasants<br />

did not sell the food products they grew, as per the<br />

directions of the Belgian government. Thus, rather<br />

than economically developing the rural society where<br />

most of the native peoples lived, the Belgians left<br />

them at the same level of economic and cultural life<br />

as the time of conquest, but in a devastated and<br />

chaotic state. 87<br />

<strong>World</strong> War i interrupted this consolidation of the<br />

colony. Most of Belgium was occupied by German<br />

soldiers and therefore the Congo was left on its<br />

own. the colonial army sent poorly trained men<br />

and even women to fight Germans in Cameroon,<br />

Ruanda-Burundi, and Tanganyika and the Italians in<br />

ethiopia. 88 Economically, raw materials like copper,<br />

rubber, and agricultural products were shipped to the<br />

Allies. 89 Socially, the colony witnessed huge changes,<br />

as Congolese were appointed to recently vacant<br />

positions that were previously reserved for whites<br />

that were now fighting or working for the government<br />

in europe. 90 Africans established new businesses, and<br />

African workers were involved in housing, utilities,<br />

transportation, and the central bank. 91<br />

After the war, the colonial government, no<br />

longer withheld funds from a Belgian government<br />

preoccupied with a war within its borders, started<br />

a large public works project, developing the most<br />

impoverished region of Katanga and setting up<br />

refineries, factories, repair shops, hospitals, schools,<br />

and housing in urban areas there and around the<br />

country. In urban neighborhoods, houses and<br />

apartments were built with brick, and blocks were<br />

given access to water supply and sanitation facilities. 92<br />

Development extended into the 1920s, with diamond<br />

mines in Kasai and diamond and gold mines in Kivu<br />

built. 93 The diamond output increased by eightfold,<br />

and, combined with modern scientific advances<br />

(though heavily concentrated to the benefit of<br />

whites over blacks in segregated hospitals), brought<br />

to the area, led to increases in standard of living<br />

and average ages around the country. 94 the 1929<br />

Wall Street collapse affected the Congo, with prices<br />

falling, businesses closing, and mining decreasing. 95<br />

Many wage-earners were laid off by companies, and<br />

the massive lay offs of mining workers led Belgian<br />

leaders to focus more of their attention to agriculture<br />

to diversify the economy of the Congo. 96<br />

Political changes need to be addressed to provide a<br />

larger picture of the times. the aforementioned 1933<br />

reform also established a federal structure for the<br />

Congo that would extend through the current times,<br />

with division and subdivision of the country into<br />

provinces, districts, and territories (or subdistricts),<br />

with administrative heads appointed by the central<br />

colonial government. Provincial governors dealt<br />

with policy questions of the provinces, district<br />

commissioners acted as inspectors of the work of<br />

territorial administrators and chieftains under their<br />

control. The territorial administrators themselves<br />

had vast control over areas comprising many<br />

chieftains and looked after records, kept law and<br />

order, collected taxes, recruited labor, conscripted<br />

native peoples, and administrated public services.<br />

Moreover, they were responsible for comprising and<br />

presenting information about their territory to higher<br />

powers. 97 It should not be assumed that the colonial<br />

administration had complete control over all levels<br />

of government in all parts of the region. The Congo<br />

was a fragmented region with land overseen by<br />

administrative government, church zones, substate<br />

figures, business interests, monopolistic concessions,<br />

and local forces, 98 but when the administrators had<br />

control, they had vast amounts of power and leverage<br />

in the communities where they were located. When<br />

they were overworked or had to manage too large<br />

an area, they would rely more heavily on local chiefs<br />

to carry out their orders and the orders of the Belgian<br />

colonial government. 99<br />

While the governance and economic systems<br />

sought to subjugate the native population for profit<br />

of the metropolitan government, the legal statutes<br />

implemented further diminished the life chances of<br />

the native populations. Racism was institutionalized<br />

in many ways—formal, with explicitly differential<br />

treatment in the justice system based on race, and<br />

informal, with de facto racial segregation. the Belgians<br />

legalized restrictions on liquors, established a curfew<br />

in european areas, allowed corporal punishment,<br />

15<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


set up segregated housing and segregated people<br />

in public accommodations like trains, hotels, and<br />

restaurants. 100<br />

Culturally, the colony was a blank slate; the<br />

administrators and church missionaries interpreted<br />

the absence of a written language and literature<br />

as absence of an overall cultural experience of the<br />

people. Their music and art were viewed as barbaric<br />

and childish, and artifacts were taken to European<br />

museums for display. 101 From the beginning of<br />

colonialization onward, the diverse histories, local<br />

economies, languages, and indigenous identity<br />

constructs were cast aside in favor of a monolithic<br />

colonial system that was supported by the an ideology<br />

of economic development and cultural advancement<br />

through coercive force. 102 The religious beliefs<br />

of native Africans were change by missionaries,<br />

which often drove a wedge between<br />

communities adhering to traditional<br />

beliefs and those adhering to new Christian<br />

beliefs. 103 The ethnic identities of native<br />

peoples were hardened by the distribution<br />

and requirement to carry around<br />

identification cards with ethnic groups<br />

listed, which proved to make political<br />

parties’ organization around ethnic ties<br />

easier later in the colony’s history. When<br />

one ethnic group was perceived to have<br />

benefited from the colonial government,<br />

this often engendered hatred in other<br />

ethnic groups. 104<br />

<strong>World</strong> War ii<br />

became more tied to the market demands because of<br />

the need for more agricultural production to help the<br />

war effort, which further diminished the local ties in<br />

rural communities. 107<br />

The Congo also proved essential for the global war<br />

effort by supplying the uranium for nuclear bombs<br />

that the US was building as part of the Manhattan<br />

Project. 108 Later in the century, control of uranium<br />

proved as essential as it did during the war as the<br />

US tried to prevent the Soviet Union from accessing<br />

these markets for uranium. 109<br />

The Belgian government and its allies ended<br />

up succeeding, but the toll on the people of the<br />

Congo was more of the same. Normally, Congo<br />

men were required to work with no wages for 60<br />

days per year to build public projects, including road<br />

maintenance and construction of hotels for colonial<br />

During <strong>World</strong> War II, the Congo served<br />

as an essential source of funds for the<br />

Belgian government in its conflict with the<br />

Axis Powers. Because of the accumulation of wealth<br />

from mineral resources in the Congo, the Belgian<br />

government was able to finance its actions in London,<br />

including the diplomatic corps service, and the cost of<br />

armed forces in europe and Africa. 105 during the war,<br />

the plethora of industries that had emerged through<br />

the past half-century also proved to attract vast<br />

numbers of Africans who up until that point generally<br />

lived in rural villages. 106 administrators. during the war, the period was<br />

extended to 120 days, with consequent devastating<br />

impacts on the population like hunger, starvation and<br />

death destroying whole families.<br />

the economic structure of the<br />

Congo changed as the fate of poor native peoples<br />

110 This funeral of the governor Felix Eboue in Brazzaville in May 1944 shows that the<br />

Belgian colony still retained traditions that existed throughout colonial times.<br />

Armed resistance<br />

and mutinies occurred during the war in reaction<br />

to these demands and in reaction to the overall<br />

oppressive colonial system as viewed by the people.<br />

The three most important rebellions were the 1941<br />

mineworkers’ strike in Katanga, the 1944 insurrection<br />

in Kasai and Katanga, and the 1945 dockworkers’<br />

16<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


strike in Matadi. These mutinies had implications later<br />

as they organized multiple ethnic populations along<br />

nationalism ideologies. 111<br />

After the war, the racist policies of the colonial<br />

regime were slightly loosened, as a way of keeping the<br />

public subservient to colonial interests. 112 the Belgians<br />

attempted to assimilate the African petty bourgeoisie<br />

into the colonial structure by exempting them from<br />

the most onerous racist restrictions. Moreover, in<br />

1948, the colonial administration introduced a “social<br />

merit card” which quickly morphed into the new<br />

social designation “matriculation” in 1952, which<br />

meant that an African had sufficiently “evolved”<br />

culturally to be regarded as like Europeans. 113 this was<br />

not a widespread assimilation policy; only 217 people<br />

accepted these designations over the next decade. 114<br />

the post-war period also witnessed huge<br />

urbanization with Leopoldville, the seat of the<br />

colonial government, growing by hundreds of<br />

thousands of people. With this urbanization, Africans<br />

set up their own businesses and shops, and others<br />

worked as low-skilled laborers. 115 the Belgian colonial<br />

government devoted much of their budgetary surplus<br />

to the improvement of medical care with the building<br />

of clinics and hospitals. 116<br />

the independence Struggle<br />

The petty bourgeoisie in the Congo was the only<br />

class that was able to organize and synthesize the<br />

revolutionary notions and hopes of people across the<br />

Congo into a mass movement. Until 1956, however, its<br />

focus was on full integration into the colonial, white<br />

society, not on independence. the post-war actions<br />

of the Congo colonial powers to assimilate certain<br />

elite segments of the African populations postponed<br />

the bourgeoisie’s desires for independence. 117 the<br />

Belgian policies of limited education, emphasis on<br />

economic development, and limited possibilities for<br />

native peoples to participate in the governance of<br />

the colony ensured that the independence struggle<br />

would be hampered from its infancy and have limited<br />

ability to develop a nationalist ideology that could<br />

appeal nation-wide. 118<br />

the year 1956 was a monumental turning point<br />

in the independence struggle by a convergence of<br />

factors. internationally, the Franco-British-israeli<br />

Suez expedition and its failure, the independence of<br />

Morocco, Sudan, and tunisia, and the decolonialization<br />

movements in West Africa, Equatorial Africa,<br />

Madagascar, Angola, and the Belgian Congo were<br />

in their infant states. All of these events inspired the<br />

domestic elite in the Congo, which was itself in the<br />

midst of debating the best course of action for the<br />

future of the country. 119 This debate was sparked in<br />

part due to the publishing of a pamphlet by Belgian<br />

professor A.A.J. Van Bilsen who advocated for a<br />

“thirty-year plan for the political emancipation of<br />

Belgian Africa.” 120 The pamphlet ignited debate, and<br />

the radical response from the ABAKO group, led<br />

by Joseph Kasavubu, stipulated that 30 years was<br />

too long a timeline and called for the immediate<br />

transition from colonial to self-governance in a<br />

federal structure. 121<br />

Political reforms in 1957 liberalized the colony,<br />

allowing for municipal elections, and led to the<br />

emergence of numerous political parities in 1958, one<br />

of which was ABAKO. Because of the short amount<br />

of time available, ABAKO and most political parties<br />

had to mobilize rapidly, requiring a focus not on<br />

ideology but on ethnic ties for organizers. 122 the MNC<br />

(Mouvement National Congolais) party, led by Patrice<br />

Lumumba, was another party that formed as a result<br />

of the liberalization and could be considered the first<br />

national political party in the Congo. As will be seen,<br />

the party and off-shoots from it were instrumental in<br />

resistance to the colonial government and ultimately<br />

independence. 123 Lumumba organized a mass rally in<br />

December 1958 with immediate independence as the<br />

ultimate national goal. 124<br />

Not a month later in early January, a local ABAKO<br />

section attempted to hold another rally near the<br />

place where Lumumba held his in Kinshasa. When the<br />

Belgian government canceled the event, 125 a crowd<br />

refused to go home peacefully and proceeded to<br />

attack and harm symbols of white authority, including<br />

shops and white motorists. 126 Almost the entire African<br />

population of Kinshasa joined in on the rebellion,<br />

which lasted three days. 127 Both independence<br />

leaders Lumumba and Kasavubu were imprisoned on<br />

sketchy evidence for inciting what was very clearly<br />

a spontaneous riot. 128 The revolt marked a new and<br />

17<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


evolutionary phase of the national independence<br />

movement, and the Belgians reevaluated the entire<br />

independence claim by the Congo. 129<br />

The Belgians were jolted by the violence in the<br />

Congo. Prompted by the clear demands of the<br />

population, the lack of political will in Belgium to<br />

engage in an Algerian-like civil war, and the norm<br />

of decolonialization<br />

internationally, two<br />

separate policy<br />

statements released<br />

by the Belgian king<br />

and government on 13<br />

January 1959 explicitly<br />

supported the idea of<br />

independence, 130 the<br />

most rapid and radical<br />

decolonization plan<br />

seen on the African<br />

continent up to this<br />

point. 131 the Belgian<br />

government was<br />

also coming to the<br />

realization that much<br />

of the country was<br />

simply ungovernable;<br />

the Lower Congo and<br />

Bandundu regions<br />

at this point refused<br />

to recognize the<br />

authority of the<br />

colonial government<br />

and were only<br />

willing to recognize<br />

domestic political<br />

parties as their rightful<br />

rulers. 132 Combine<br />

these circumstances<br />

with a series of<br />

wars and revolts in<br />

Kasai and Kisangani,<br />

and the Belgian<br />

military resources were severely strained and<br />

unable to maintain order, thus promoting the view<br />

that independence should be granted. 133 While<br />

independence was certainly the focus of the Belgian<br />

government’s actions, they also specified that it<br />

would still be under their prerogative to transfer the<br />

responsibilities to “maintain a sound administration”<br />

when “new Congolese institutions” have proven<br />

they “are capable of maintaining order and respect<br />

for public and private obligations, and the protection<br />

of persons and<br />

property.” 134<br />

The December 1959<br />

preliminary elections<br />

for local government<br />

councils were not<br />

a positive event for<br />

country unity. the<br />

some 120 political<br />

parties also proved to<br />

destabilize the country.<br />

Organized by tribal<br />

unity most of the time<br />

and openly hostile with<br />

other parties, there<br />

was not a universal<br />

agreement over the<br />

path that the Congo<br />

should take. 135 these<br />

elections also faced<br />

widespread distrust,<br />

given the Belgian<br />

government’s aid to the<br />

PNP party (an off-shoot<br />

of the Lumumba’s<br />

MNC party). 136 the<br />

Belgians, even though<br />

sensing that immediate<br />

independence would<br />

lead to a deteriorating<br />

situation in terms of<br />

law and order, agreed<br />

to the popular demand<br />

for “immediate<br />

independence,” and<br />

made a decision 20 February 1960 for total and<br />

unconditional independence on 30 June 1960. 137<br />

The independence struggle in Congo was in large part a reaction to the<br />

historical mistreatment of the Congolese people. Here several people,<br />

from children to the elderly, are photographed without hands which was<br />

punishment in early colonial Belgium for misbehavior.<br />

18<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


Current Situation: Where We<br />

Stand Now<br />

The working classes and peasant population<br />

formed the crux of the resistance and independence<br />

movement that organized the rebellion of 4 January<br />

1959 in Kinshasa, which ultimately resulted in<br />

Belgium’s decision to grant independence to the<br />

Congo. 138 The first few days of independence were<br />

calm, with heavily-armed, well-disciplined white<br />

officers of the colonial army keeping the peace in<br />

the cities and countryside. 139 However, even though<br />

independence was achieved, the national and<br />

democratic movements responsible for it are deeply<br />

unstable. 140 The danger of a quick independence was<br />

the prospect of state fragmentation, and this concern<br />

is quite justified given the situation in Katanga. 141 May<br />

elections led to hundreds of petty bourgeois leaders<br />

traveling to Kinshasa and provincial capitals to be<br />

representatives of the people. After in-fighting, they<br />

agreed to extend themselves the privileges that had<br />

been given to the Europeans before them and to<br />

set their pay level to 40 times the annual per capita<br />

income. 142 The masses that had been subjugated by<br />

the Belgians felt that they were not receiving their<br />

fair share or getting a fair shot in the infant state. 143<br />

The economic issues at stake in independence<br />

favor the Belgians by a wide margin. The Belgians<br />

have already planned and begun transferring the<br />

colonial state portfolios and ownership of industry<br />

to Belgium through privatization. Meanwhile, they<br />

left virtually all the public debt to the infant state. 144<br />

While most of the discussion in the guide has been on<br />

the economic benefits that the Congo has provided<br />

to Belgium, it should not be forgotten that Congo’s<br />

economic impact extended globally and the great<br />

powers all have vested interests in maintaining the<br />

economic prosperity of the region. For mining in<br />

particular, the Belgians, Germans, Austrians, French,<br />

British, and Americans all had common financial<br />

interests in the region. 145<br />

Specifically, there are a series of specific concerns<br />

in the immediate past that should be noted. The<br />

decrease in raw material prices in 1957 resulted<br />

in a decrease in the reserves of the central Congo<br />

bank and although 1959 witnessed an increase,<br />

there was a deficit of 5.6 billion because of direct<br />

capital transfers and invisible outgoings. This loss of<br />

business confidence and capital flight from the region<br />

was in part a result of Belgium’s tendency to weaken<br />

economic ties with the soon-to-be independent<br />

Congo. By spring of 1960, six hundred million francs<br />

transferred from Congo back to Belgium in a single<br />

week in March. To stem the tide, Belgium placed<br />

caps on households in the colony. 146 the Belgium<br />

government tried to help the colony in this regard,<br />

but it was happy to saddle the new country with<br />

significant debt that had been outstanding since the<br />

days of King Léopold. 147 economically, the new state<br />

will be a mess.<br />

Why Prime Minister Lumumba Has Called<br />

On the UNSC for Help<br />

the soldiers in the Congo army demanded<br />

immediate Africanization of officer appointments<br />

and promotions after independence was formally<br />

declared. 148 Lumumba and other leaders asked for<br />

patience and showed their preference for the elites<br />

in the country by promising promotions but only<br />

after additional training was provided for soldiers. 149<br />

This upset troops greatly, and when Lumumba put<br />

together a viable coalition in the government and was<br />

elected Prime Minister of the new government, his<br />

enemies were not pleased. 150 They began by initiating<br />

a mutiny in the armed forces less than one week after<br />

independence was formalized. General Janssens,<br />

commander of the colonial army who was brought on<br />

after independence to look after the new state army,<br />

gave a condescending speech to troops that stipulated<br />

that their role and rank before independence would<br />

be the same after independence, and thus major<br />

swaths of the army felt they were being denied<br />

the benefits of independence. 151 the mutineers<br />

demanded salary increases, promotions of rank, and<br />

the dismissal of Belgian officers. Lumumba’s reaction<br />

was to appoint an inexperienced doctor as chief of<br />

the armed forces, and Mobutu, with ties to Belgian<br />

and American intelligence services, as chief of staff<br />

of the army. 152 the mutiny continued to spread across<br />

the country, and Prime Minister Lumumba began to<br />

consider foreign military assistance. 153 the mutineers<br />

tried to force their way into parliament on 5 July and<br />

19<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


pressed Prime Minister Lumumba to accede to their<br />

demands, but he refused their desires and promised<br />

to keep Belgian officers and appoint Belgians to<br />

important defense posts. 154 On 7 July, more armed<br />

soldiers threatened to force their way into parliament<br />

and surrounded Lumumba’s residence. Lumumba<br />

tried to diffuse the situation by agreement to demote<br />

General Janssens, promote African noncommissioned<br />

officers, and fire most Belgian advisors. 155 Even with<br />

the new changes and new Congolese officers, the<br />

troops could still not be disciplined and continued<br />

their mutiny. 156<br />

A photograph of Patrice Lumumba after an election victory.<br />

Soldiers perpetrated abuses against their former<br />

officers, harassed European civilians, in particular<br />

religious leaders, and there were scores of reports<br />

of torture and rape. 157 Europeans began leaving the<br />

Congo in droves, taking ferryboats to Brazzaville,<br />

rushing to the two international airports in the<br />

country, and driving to bordering countries. Of 29,000<br />

Europeans that had lived in the Congo’s three largest<br />

cities on 1 July 1960, only 3000 remained by 10 July. 158<br />

Riots broke out all over the country—in Leopoldville,<br />

Matadi, Kasai, and Katanga. 159 European officers are<br />

being sometimes civilly treated but others have been<br />

beaten, spat upon, and even shot and killed. 160 Only<br />

some two dozen Europeans have been confirmed to<br />

have been killed at this point. 161<br />

The Belgium military intervened in the country<br />

on 11 July by sending in additional paracommandos<br />

to the Congo against the wishes of the newly<br />

independent government. 162 They began by securing<br />

the international airports to transport europeans<br />

out of the country, 163 but their methods are at times<br />

presumptuous. There have been reports of soldiers<br />

shooting first and asking questions later, which is<br />

inflaming rebels’ passions. 164 they are attempting<br />

to quell the violence in hotspots across the country,<br />

and have been successful in some areas but incited<br />

violence in others. Their decision to use naval<br />

forces to bombard and shell Matadi unleashed<br />

anger, resentment, and more violence across the<br />

Congo when it was reported via radio broadcast. 165<br />

Compounding the situation, Moise Tshombe, a son<br />

of a wealthy trading and transport family, proclaimed<br />

the independence of the Katanga province on 11<br />

July. 166<br />

In Katanga, when the Belgians began their<br />

intervention a few days ago, they disarmed all<br />

non-Katangese soldiers and expelled them from<br />

the Katanga province. It should be noted that the<br />

Katanga province retained economic importance<br />

as a mineral-rich province. 167 As much as 80 percent<br />

of the Congo’s export wealth lies in this mineralrich<br />

area. 168 It should also be noted that the Belgian<br />

perception of the colony was framed within the<br />

language of paternalism. it was not that they thought<br />

they were violating independence but that the Congo<br />

had proven that it was not stable enough for the<br />

“gift” of sovereignty and self-rule, so the gift could<br />

be returned. 169 The Congo government had proven<br />

incapable, Belgian government officials asserted, of<br />

being able to control the “brutal savagery” of the<br />

Congolese. 170 Belgium also justified its intervention on<br />

the protection of “white inhabitants” who had to be<br />

protected by military forces by virtue of the “supreme<br />

laws of humanity.” 171<br />

On 12 July, Lumumba and Kasavubu (profiled in the<br />

Key Actors section) appealed to the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong><br />

and Secretary General Dag Hammarskjöld for help,<br />

requesting UN soldiers to protect the country from<br />

external powers and to help restore its territorial<br />

integrity. 172 it is now July 13, and the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />

must decide what to do in the region.<br />

20<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


Past uN Actions<br />

The course of action requested by Lumumba and<br />

Kasavubu are wholly unprecedented in the UNSC’s<br />

history thus far and should be treated as a distinct<br />

break from the typical actions of the body. First, the<br />

interpretation of the situation in the Congo must be<br />

squared appropriately with the UNSC’s mandate to<br />

address situations that breach “international peace<br />

and security.” That an internal threat to territorial<br />

integrity harms international peace and security is<br />

NOT a doctrine that has been ingrained in the practices<br />

of UNSC. Second, the dispatching of peacekeepers<br />

to actively support a nascent nation in its struggle<br />

for territorial integrity has never been done, and<br />

the kind of peacekeeping force for this task has<br />

never been dispatched anywhere. Since the Korean<br />

War, UN peacekeepers have been stationed at the<br />

demilitarized zone to maintain peace between the<br />

North and the South. In Israel in 1948, peacekeepers<br />

were dispatched to maintain peaceful relations<br />

between the Palestinians in the region and newly<br />

arrived Jewish settlers. After the Suez crisis of 1956,<br />

peacekeepers from around the world arrived at the<br />

Suez Canal to ensure that the agreement between the<br />

former colonial powers of Britain and France and their<br />

ally Israel and Egypt and its Arab allies was carried out.<br />

Ultimately, the request from the Congo government<br />

reconceptualizes what a UN peacekeeper is and what<br />

UN Secretary General Dag Hammarskjold visits with Suez Crisis peacekeepers.<br />

his or her duties are, envisioning them as robust<br />

entities with mandates that require them to perform<br />

duties typically associated with military. 173<br />

Potential Solutions<br />

The situation in the Congo has not been evaluated<br />

by the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>, and this could prove to be a<br />

benefit or challenge. Although there are no previous<br />

actions to evaluate and build upon, there is freedom<br />

to develop and create innovative solutions that utilize<br />

the full power of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>. Embedded<br />

in the conflict, as detailed, are weak institutional<br />

structures, ethnic parties and divisions, and an<br />

economy that benefits corporations at the expense of<br />

the population. the following is a listing of potential<br />

areas solutions could be applied to; it is by no means<br />

comprehensive in number of potential areas nor in<br />

description of the listed areas.<br />

Independence, Wait?<br />

the Belgian Minister of the Congo and Ruanda-<br />

Urundi, Auguste de Schrivjer, favored at the outset<br />

of the independence a substantial and open debate<br />

on whether a new Congolese government could<br />

maintain internal autonomy. He had significant<br />

doubts that the Congolese institutions had a capacity<br />

for self-government, and he urged that independence<br />

be postponed in order to . 174 With this argument in<br />

mind, the UNSC may recommend that a caretaker<br />

government be established by Belgium and other<br />

21<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


Western powers that has the authority to maintain<br />

the internal integrity of the fledgling nation as well as<br />

maintain and administer the police force, the military,<br />

the social services, and the basic functions of the<br />

state from mail to sanitation.<br />

Economic Issues<br />

The economic system in the Congo is very<br />

precarious. the repatriation of capital from the<br />

Congo back to Belgium needs to be replaced with<br />

an economic system that helps Africans benefit<br />

from the rewards earned by European businesses.<br />

Individual settlers and corporate sponsors enjoy onesided<br />

benefits in the colonial system that needs to<br />

be fixed. 175 in the past few years, the decrease in raw<br />

material prices combined with Belgium’s decision to<br />

withdraw capital from the country as well as saddle<br />

it with longstanding debts to international banks and<br />

foreign governments has left the new Congo in a very<br />

difficult position economically.<br />

With mining making up a significant portion of the Congo’s<br />

economic activity, will the UNSC address this industry?<br />

UN Control<br />

Replacing or augmenting the Belgium forces that<br />

were sent into the country after independence, the<br />

<strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> could decide to send in troops with<br />

the goal to protect the country from devolving into<br />

chaos, and UN troops could operate as stabilizers<br />

of the uneasy peace and serve to enforce cease-fire<br />

agreements. 176 As stated previously, this avenue is<br />

one not taken previously in the UNSC’s history. If<br />

chosen, the UNSC will need to establish this force<br />

as quickly as possible. The UNSC will need to recruit<br />

a force of varying nationalities that is able to satisfy<br />

actors and stakeholders in the UNSC itself and on<br />

the ground in the Congo. A specific mandate for the<br />

troops and a leadership structure will need to be<br />

determined. Weapons and equipment will need to be<br />

budgeted for and purchased by the UN or donated<br />

by UN governments. While it appears as if this is<br />

the preferred avenue for the central government of<br />

the Congo and the US and Soviet governments, the<br />

Tshombe and his CONAKAT party in Katanga, who<br />

seceded from the central government, has had been<br />

bankrolled and supported by European governments<br />

in the past including France, Britain, and Belgium. 177<br />

Belgian Withdrawal<br />

Any infusion of uN troops or recommendation for<br />

the situation in Congo must address the stationing<br />

of Belgian troops that are currently in the country.<br />

Ostensibly there to protect white settlers, this is<br />

somewhat difficult given the isolated residence of<br />

many europeans across the country (though the chaos<br />

in the region has prompted many to head for the few<br />

airports in the new nation). 178 the recommendation<br />

for withdrawal from the Congo will help to provide<br />

legitimacy to the new Congo government and provide<br />

its central government with the opportunity to break<br />

away from its past status as a colonial power. On the<br />

other hand, the rapid withdrawal of Belgian troops<br />

experienced in the region might be a vacuum of<br />

power and move into greater chaos as ethnic groups<br />

and political party leaders attempt to fill the void and<br />

gain control over the region. Also, Europeans seeking<br />

to leave the new country may find themselves<br />

unprotected and left without a ride home if Belgians<br />

leave and face the wrath of a restless population.<br />

Reparations<br />

Because Belgium benefited significantly from the<br />

inflow of capital from the Congo during colonial times,<br />

some have argued that Belgium should be required<br />

to pay reparations for the crimes and slave labor. 179<br />

the recommendation that Belgian pay reparations<br />

for its past abuses and injustices is a solution that<br />

is unlikely to gain support by the Western powers<br />

who had or still have colonial powers that in the<br />

immediate past or long ago were abused to provide<br />

power and prestige to the colonial power. if framed<br />

22<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


in different terms, as a package to promote economic<br />

development and raise the Congo’s standard of living,<br />

this solution might gain more support in the wider<br />

UNSC. However, there is the problem of ensuring<br />

Belgium or other colonial powers with interests in the<br />

Congo follow through with the recommendation of<br />

the uNSC.<br />

Public Control of Economic Resources<br />

From the time of Leopold, the Congo people<br />

have not had access to profits generated from<br />

the economic activities in their backyard. Instead<br />

the profits generally have been sent to Belgium,<br />

Belgian and world businesses, and their political<br />

allies. Perhaps stripping these businesses from<br />

their previous control and recommending that the<br />

new national government obtain public control<br />

of the country’s resources will promote economic<br />

development. If the central government has control<br />

over the vast amounts of wealth within the borders<br />

of the country, this would provide incentives for<br />

stakeholders in all regions to work together<br />

in the central government to effectively<br />

mine and distribute the raw materials and<br />

resources. However, this solution presumes<br />

that resource-rich areas like Katanga are still<br />

considered as regions within Congo, not<br />

independent states. 180<br />

Foreign Military and Technical Aid<br />

Lumumba is planning on traveling abroad<br />

to request technical aid and military support<br />

in his attempts to control the rebellious<br />

portions of his country. the uNSC may<br />

decide to request members states lend<br />

support to the original central government<br />

of the Congo. 181 this solution means that<br />

perhaps UN peacekeepers do not necessarily<br />

need to be part of the solution for the<br />

solution still to retain a military component.<br />

Requesting that UN countries supply military<br />

and technical aid to the central government (or to the<br />

other relevant regions that have seceded in what the<br />

UNSC views as a legitimate way) can help shore up<br />

territorial integrity without sending in peacekeepers.<br />

Supporting New Countries<br />

the Congo was originally a political construction<br />

not intended to be made of a unified group of tribes<br />

and people, so perhaps it is a natural outcome of<br />

independence of the Congo that it split into multiple<br />

different countries. The UNSC could decide to<br />

recognize the legitimacy of the seceded Katanga<br />

regions (and any others that might arise) in hopes<br />

that the establishment of multiple states quells the<br />

violence embroiling the region now. It is not clear<br />

that this is a position tenable for countries like the<br />

US and USSR. Moreover, the danger is that this sets<br />

a precedent for dealing with separatist movements<br />

around the world. the uNSC may not wish to enter<br />

into determining the legitimacy of every separatist<br />

movement in every country.<br />

Key Actors: Class and Politics<br />

this section lays out two major categories of<br />

division within the Congo: class divisions and political<br />

party divisions. Hopefully this section will provide<br />

clarity for how to approach various groups and crosscutting<br />

cleavages in the society.<br />

Farmers in the Congo work in 1959.<br />

Class Divisions in Colonial Congo<br />

Imperialist bourgeoisie: This group does not live<br />

in the region but is economically and politically<br />

dominant. Top corporate managers, members of<br />

the Belgian government, and the hierarchy of the<br />

Catholic Church make up most of this colony. With<br />

ties to major European governments and businesses,<br />

23<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


their interests will be ones that are paid attention to<br />

in any settlement. 182<br />

Middle bourgeoisie: Belgian and european<br />

settlers who owned production capabilities and<br />

employed workers in agriculture, commerce, and<br />

manufacturing. 183 This group did not have significant<br />

political power in colonial governance and thus was<br />

not able to retain much of the surplus profit from<br />

industrial work in the Congo. Currently, they will<br />

likely fall back on the imperialist bourgeoisie class to<br />

discuss terms of agreement for their businesses in<br />

the new country. 184<br />

Petty bourgeoisie: this group was made of<br />

Europeans and Africans alike but was split along<br />

racial lines and other strata. There were: the liberal<br />

professions, comprised of europeans; european and<br />

American missionaries; European state officials and<br />

company managers; European and Asian shopkeepers<br />

and artisans; African white-collar employees; and<br />

African traders and artisans. This diverse group is<br />

likely just looking for a solution in which they can<br />

begin to return to a state of affairs in which they<br />

continue their professions without being disrupted<br />

by the formation of new states and rules for trade. 185<br />

traditional ruling class: this class is made up of<br />

the kings, nobles, chiefs and native religious leaders.<br />

As mentioned previously, the Belgian government<br />

actively played these leaders against one another<br />

for prized goods and money, so there is likely to be<br />

animosity between many of these leaders. 186<br />

Peasantry: this largest class was made up of the<br />

rural, African producers of food and cash crops. this<br />

group makes up the largest portion of the Congo<br />

population, formed the basis for many of the protests<br />

and found themselves in the military rebellions. 187<br />

Working class: the european part of this class were<br />

skilled white workers, who acted as supervisors in<br />

mines and large industries, and skilled and unskilled<br />

black workers who worked in urban, industrial jobs<br />

and rural, agricultural ones. 188<br />

Lumpenproletariat: these were the Africans<br />

without stable wage employment and were rural<br />

migrants trying to earn a living through legal and<br />

extralegal means. 189<br />

Parties<br />

At the time of independence, there was a<br />

disorganized array of personalities, leaders, and<br />

parties that were attempting to get control of the<br />

social and political circumstances of the Congo. 190 A<br />

listing of the most important follows.<br />

ABAKO: The ABAKO party was primarily a tribal<br />

party with significant ties and membership in the lower<br />

Congo River Bakongo peoples. It was founded in part<br />

by Joseph Kasavubu who was educated by Catholic<br />

missionaries at the beginning of the Great Depression.<br />

He became a teacher after attending seminary,<br />

where he helped to organize the Bakongo people for<br />

independence. With founder Joseph Kasavubu at the<br />

helm, this party was a tribal political grouping whose<br />

rallying cry for immediate independence began after<br />

Joseph Kasavubu, dressed in a white military-style outfit, is carried<br />

around in a procession of the ABAKO party officials.<br />

a Belgian professor published a “30 year plan for<br />

independence” in 1956. 191 the early history of the party<br />

was tied with attempting to integrate its members<br />

into the elite classes of the cities. 192 Later, the party,<br />

weak because its internal solidarity was through<br />

tribal ties, threatened to secede from the larger<br />

Congo and establish a country in Bas-Congo south<br />

of Leopoldville province. It objected to the idea of a<br />

central government from 1959 when Belgium initially<br />

agreed to future independence. 193 Nevertheless,<br />

after the May 1960 elections, the ABAKO party was<br />

able to gain enough seats and power in the political<br />

system that its leader Kasavubu became the first<br />

President (with less power than the Prime Minister<br />

24<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


in the government structure) when Congo gained<br />

independence. The ethnic political motivations of<br />

the party did not provide it with enough support to<br />

dominate the central government but it did provide<br />

enough support to become an active role in the<br />

newly formed government. His tribal, conservative<br />

tendencies clashed with the President Lumumba’s<br />

pragmatic predispositions to governance of the new<br />

country.<br />

CONAKAt (Confédération des Associations tribales<br />

du Katanga): Under leader Moïse Tshombe, this<br />

organization formed in 1959 when independence<br />

was perceived as inevitable and advocated an<br />

independent Katangan state. 194 Tshombe was the son<br />

of a businessman in the Congo and was educated in<br />

an American missionary school. Later he worked as<br />

an accountant and in the 1950s, he owned a group<br />

of stores in the Katanga Province. Working with<br />

Godefroid Munongo, he founded the CONAKAT<br />

party, which advocated an independent, federal<br />

Congo. In the May 1960 elections, the CONAKAT<br />

gained a majority of seats in the Katanga provincial<br />

legislature. Maintaining political and economic ties<br />

with the Belgium government who was invested in<br />

the resources within this naturally wealthy province,<br />

Tshombe and CONAKAT declared independence from<br />

the Congo central government in July 1960.<br />

Moise Tshombe answers questions from press in 1960.<br />

MNC (Mouvement National Congolais): this party<br />

attempted to build national support through the<br />

processes that parties take in typical Western multiparty<br />

states, but it split in two branches: the PNP<br />

(Parti National du Progres) which was a coalition of<br />

traditional chiefs which was damaged by the general<br />

population in the country by its ties with white<br />

Belgian administrators, 195 which helped it in the 1959<br />

December elections for local government councils, 196<br />

and the PSA (Parti Solidaire Africain) which was a<br />

group of locally based organizations that dominated<br />

the Kwilu district in Eastern Léopoldville. 197 the PNP<br />

section of the party, which would become the more<br />

powerful segment of the party nation-wide, was led by<br />

Patrice Lumumba, who was a postal clerk in Kisangani<br />

for most of his adult life and learned about organizing<br />

from civic associations. 198 Helping to found the MNC<br />

in 1958, Lumumba represented the MNC at the<br />

international All-African Peoples’ Conference in Accra,<br />

Ghana, later that year where his Pan-Africanist beliefs<br />

were further cemented and reflected his approach to<br />

political organizing in the Congo that was above tribal<br />

allegiances. in 1959, he was sentenced in 6 months in<br />

prison for allegedly inciting an anti-colonial protest,<br />

and even with this set-back, the MNC was able to win<br />

local 1959 December election and national elections in<br />

May 1960. Lumumba was released in January of 1960<br />

to attend the Brussels conference that eventually set<br />

the date of independence for 30 June 1960. Because<br />

of his party’s success in the national elections in May<br />

1960, he was elected Prime Minister and designated<br />

Kasavubu as the President of the new nation. More<br />

than any other national politician, Lumumba viewed<br />

Congolese identity as bound not through ethnicity or<br />

tribal identity but by inhabiting the spatial area known<br />

as the Congo. Thus, he subscribed in many ways to the<br />

dominant Western view of political communities. 199<br />

Bloc Positions<br />

US policy<br />

The overarching view of the US foreign policy is<br />

to prevent the spread of communism in the “Third<br />

<strong>World</strong>.” The US was not all that worried about<br />

communism taking root in Western Europe where<br />

defensive military measures were considered to<br />

be enough, but the “Third <strong>World</strong>” was not viewed<br />

in the same way. The US felt the instability by the<br />

mish-mash of parties and personalities around the<br />

country would lead to instability and increase the<br />

influence of communism in the region, even though<br />

25<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


communism in the region was generally regarded as<br />

weak. 200 For the uS, centralized control of the state<br />

was positive, and chaos favored the Soviet control of<br />

the country. 201 This was the view explicitly espoused<br />

in the George Kennan “long Telegram” that asserted<br />

“Soviet policy…will be directed toward weakening<br />

of power and influence and contacts of advanced<br />

Western nations, on theory that insofar as this<br />

policy is successful, there will be created a vacuum<br />

which will favor Communist-Soviet penetration.” 202<br />

However, they were not supportive of Prime<br />

Minister Lumumba; they believed he was focused on<br />

expanding Soviet expansion in the heart of Africa.<br />

thus, from the time of independence onward, the uS<br />

government attempted to undermine the Lumumba<br />

government. 203<br />

Specifically, America wanted a strong, though not<br />

necessarily democratic, government in Leopoldville<br />

and were adamant that the colonial european powers<br />

should no longer have control over the country of the<br />

Congo.. the administration does not want resourcerich<br />

Katanga to secede and Tshombe to secede, who<br />

represented to the Americans a “voodoo version of<br />

communism.” 204 Not only was the uS concerned that<br />

internal chaos favored Soviet influence in the area,<br />

but the specific actors and leaders of potential states<br />

within Congo were classified by the US as sympathetic<br />

to the worst aspects of communism. Moreover, in the<br />

immediate aftermath of independence of the Congo,<br />

This map shows Cold War divisions in the early 1960s (Disregard Congo’s color).<br />

the US was also concerned by the law and order in<br />

the country falling apart and leading to the abuse,<br />

looting, and rape of white residents, so they felt a<br />

need to respond from humanitarian principles. 205<br />

Europe<br />

european countries, with long histories of colonial<br />

administration in the region, have articulated that<br />

they have experience and expertise on the situation<br />

in the Congo. 206 Britain and France (as well as South<br />

Africa) have been active in their support on the<br />

ground for secession by Katanga. Their ruling classes<br />

and politically powerful domestic groups were<br />

fearful of Prime Minister Lumumba’s commitment<br />

to authentic independence from Belgium and radical<br />

social change. 207<br />

european powers Belgium, France, and Britain<br />

opposed firm action on part of the UN against the<br />

secessionist Tshombe. France views the Congo issue<br />

through colonial lens, and publically pointed out<br />

during the independence movement in Congo that<br />

Belgium has a preferential right to the Congolese<br />

territory that dates back from the 1884 Berlin<br />

Conference. the Belgians and Congolese ultimately<br />

rejected this claim when the Congo was granted<br />

independence but illuminates a wider understanding<br />

of African issues by France. 208<br />

Britain’s view of the issue was primarily focused<br />

on economic self-interest. they were concerned with<br />

the loss to investors of an unstable Congo. There was<br />

26<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


political pressure by British settlers in Central African<br />

Federation who were sympathetic to Katangan<br />

independence. The Foreign Office informed the US<br />

State department during the time of independence<br />

that provincial autonomy should be respected and<br />

would promote Western interests in the areas, and<br />

thus they did not want an intervention by the Congo<br />

government or UN in Katanga. 209<br />

USSR<br />

When Belgium invaded the newly independent<br />

Congo, the uSSR called for their immediate<br />

withdrawal. 210 The Soviets were highly attentive<br />

to Afro-Asian solidarity, and thus supported a uN<br />

peacekeeping force to the Congo in order to protect<br />

Lumumba and the territorial integrity of the nation. 211<br />

It may appear that Cold War influences were not at<br />

play in this calculation, but that would be mistaken.<br />

The Soviets hoped to shore up the internal integrity of<br />

the nation ultimately to gain a wealthy and populous<br />

partner in the third <strong>World</strong> to aid with its campaign<br />

against the uS and Western capitalist expansion.<br />

Throughout the beginning of the Cold War and<br />

the decolonialization movement, the USSR often<br />

referenced the US’s own internal racial divisions in<br />

the South of the country against it in the international<br />

arena to mobilize African and non-white countries<br />

against the uS. 212<br />

Afro-Asian Bloc<br />

The Afro-Asian bloc, developing countries who<br />

themselves had gone through or were going<br />

through decolonization, had very different historical<br />

circumstances that defined them individually. From<br />

the 1940s through 1960 three dozen new states<br />

achieved independence from colonial powers—<br />

through peaceful and orderly processes or through<br />

long, drawn out revolutions and independence<br />

movements. The beginning governments in these<br />

countries varied from dictatorships to military juntas<br />

to democratic coalitions to nonexistent as civil wars.<br />

These countries did largely converge in their<br />

ideological predisposition to the situation in the<br />

Congo. They have almost uniformly called for<br />

immediate Belgian withdrawal as the starting point<br />

for discussions. the military struggles of indonesia<br />

against the Netherlands, Vietnam against France, and<br />

other served as the comparison point for the bloc,<br />

and they did not wish to see protracted occupations<br />

of the Congo. 213<br />

Questions a Resolution Must Answer<br />

(QARMAs)<br />

1. does this decision warrant <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />

action? Does it rise to the level of threat to<br />

international peace and security?<br />

2. How should the UNSC respond to Belgium’s<br />

violation of the Congo’s newly established<br />

independence and sovereignty by sending in<br />

troops?<br />

3. Should peacekeepers be sent in to replace<br />

or augment the Belgian troops? if so, what<br />

should their mandates be, what should<br />

constrain them, and how should they go about<br />

maintaining peace and security?<br />

4. What should the role of UN Secretariat be in<br />

managing this issue?<br />

5. How should the economic situation in the<br />

country be handled? Should the UNSC make<br />

any recommendations on the debt of the<br />

country or corporate actions within the area?<br />

6. What should the role of the member states of<br />

the UN be in this situation? Should they be able<br />

to send technical or military support to the<br />

central government or rebel groups?<br />

7. Should the Katanga province be allowed to<br />

split off from the Congo or should every effort<br />

be made to prevent secession?<br />

8. What is the precedent, if any, that your<br />

chosen course of action should have for other<br />

decolonialization projects?<br />

Suggestions for Further Research<br />

In order to effectively prepare for committee, you<br />

should try to find archival research from respected<br />

periodicals like the New York Times, Time, Newsweek,<br />

Foreign Affairs, etc. that covered the crisis in Congo<br />

immediately prior to our convening and immediately<br />

after. you should also familiarize yourself the history<br />

of the Congo that occurred after the time of the<br />

committee. I can guarantee, however, that history<br />

will not repeat itself. Always remember that your<br />

arguments in committee must align with the facts on<br />

27<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


the ground up to and through committee. Be sure to<br />

be familiar with the style, diction, and wording of the<br />

UN <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> Resolutions so that you can be<br />

prepared in committee to write the best resolution<br />

possible. The UN website http://www.un.org/en/sc/<br />

documents/resolutions/index.shtml has a listing of all<br />

the resolutions. you should focus on years up to and<br />

including 1960, the year the simulation will begin.<br />

your research should also concern how your nation<br />

would approach a solution in committee. this means<br />

researching its position previously in the <strong>Security</strong><br />

<strong>Council</strong> in similar matters, what it has and has not<br />

advocated and agreed to, and how its own national<br />

interests align with a solution to the Congo crisis.<br />

Reading press statements from UN representatives<br />

and heads of state, news reports on the nature of its<br />

interactions with Congo, and reports on trade with the<br />

Congo will give you a better idea on how to approach<br />

the problem from your country’s perspective.<br />

Position Papers<br />

Position papers are an essential part of the MuN<br />

experience. they help to frame your argumentation<br />

and coalition-building before you step into the<br />

committee room. I think therefore they are an<br />

essential component in any assessment of the quality<br />

of a delegate.<br />

you should focus on three things in your 3-4 page<br />

position paper (double spaced, 12-point font): your<br />

plan for solving the issue, why your nation would<br />

be arguing for this plan, and how this will solve the<br />

problems in the status quo. Be very explicit in your<br />

papers regarding these three elements. Also, be as<br />

creative as you want with solutions—within reason,<br />

of course. You should cite specific news articles,<br />

academic reports, books, UN documents, and<br />

government websites, and you should have a works<br />

cited page. Be advised, however, that you will not<br />

be held strictly to the positions you articulate in your<br />

position paper; I recognize that the events, as they<br />

unfold in committee, will require you to shift slightly<br />

or dramatically your responses to the situation. One<br />

last comment: I cannot give awards to anyone who<br />

does not submit a position paper, so please do it!<br />

Closing Remarks<br />

You’re almost done with the guide! It was a<br />

great experience preparing this guide, and i hope<br />

it has given you solid grounding to build upon for<br />

conference. I know that I will see in March creative<br />

approaches to highly contentious issues and brilliant<br />

solutions. There are a lot of moving parts inherent<br />

in the topic; economics, geopolitics, international<br />

relations, and philosophical problems all play a role in<br />

the topics and likely the solutions that will emerge. I<br />

really look forward to what you come up with!<br />

Please do not hesitate to contact me at hsc@<br />

worldmun.org if you have any questions regarding<br />

the study guide, position papers, Rules of Procedure,<br />

updates, or any other matter you wish to discuss. i<br />

will attempt to respond as quickly as possible and<br />

as comprehensively as possible. Best of luck with<br />

research and until March…<br />

Endnotes<br />

1 Weiss, Forsythe, & Coate 3<br />

2 “Milestones in <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> History.”<br />

3 Weiss et al. 5.<br />

4 Weiss et al. 35.<br />

5 Regehr 32<br />

6 Gareis & Varwick 29.<br />

7 “Under the Charter, the functions and powers of the <strong>Security</strong><br />

<strong>Council</strong> are.”<br />

8 Weiss et al. 30<br />

9 Kent 1<br />

10 Kent 9<br />

11 Dunn 39<br />

12 Kent 1<br />

13 Kent 6<br />

14 Nzongola-Ntalaja 33<br />

15 Dunn 9<br />

16 Chatterjee 48<br />

17 Kent 6<br />

18 Nzongola-Ntalaja 14<br />

28<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


19 edgerton 164<br />

20 Chatterjee 48<br />

21 Nzongola-Ntalaja 27<br />

22 Chatterjee 48<br />

23 Nzongola-Ntalaja 27<br />

24 Nzongola-Ntalaja 33<br />

25 Chatterjee 43<br />

26 Nzongola-Ntalaja 42<br />

27 Chatterjee 44<br />

28 Dunn 23<br />

29 Nzongola-Ntalaja 14<br />

30 Chatterjee 44<br />

31 Nzongola-Ntalaja 42<br />

32 Chatterjee 44<br />

33 Nzongola-Ntalaja 43<br />

34 Dunn 8<br />

35 Nzongola-Ntalaja 15-16<br />

36 Nzongola-Ntalaja 18<br />

37 dunn 47<br />

38 Roth 29<br />

39 Dunn 8<br />

40 Dunn 21<br />

41 dunn 49<br />

42 Dunn 48<br />

43 Dunn 48<br />

44 Dunn 22<br />

45 Nzongola-Ntalaja 20<br />

46 Dunn 22<br />

47 Dunn 43<br />

48 Roth 31<br />

49 Nzongola-Ntalaja 22<br />

50 Nzongola-Ntalaja 23<br />

51 Nzongola-Ntalaja 38<br />

52 Nzongola-Ntalaja 33<br />

53 dunn 50<br />

54 dunn 50<br />

55 dunn 56<br />

56 Nzongola-Ntalaja 38<br />

57 dunn 52<br />

58 Edgerton 153<br />

59 dunn 52<br />

60 Dunn 22, 25<br />

61 Dunn 58<br />

62 edgerton 155<br />

63 Dunn 45<br />

64 Nzongola-Ntalaja 41<br />

65 Nzongola-Ntalaja 41<br />

66 Nzongola-Ntalaja 42<br />

67 Nzongola-Ntalaja 43<br />

68 Nzongola-Ntalaja 42<br />

69 Nzongola-Ntalaja 45<br />

70 Nzongola-Ntalaja 46<br />

71 Nzongola-Ntalaja 36<br />

72 Nzongola-Ntalaja 26<br />

73 Nzongola-Ntalaja 27<br />

74 edgerton 157<br />

75 Nzongola-Ntalaja 27<br />

76 edgerton 160<br />

77 edgerton 163<br />

78 Edgerton 157<br />

79 Roth 32<br />

80 Roth 33<br />

81 Nzongola-Ntalaja 33<br />

82 Nzongola-Ntalaja 34<br />

83 Roth 33<br />

29<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


84 Roth 35<br />

85 Nzongola-Ntalaja 34-35<br />

86 Nzongola-Ntalaja 35<br />

87 Nzongola-Ntalaja 71<br />

88 Edgerton 168<br />

89 Edgerton 168<br />

90 edgerton 169<br />

91 edgerton 169<br />

92 edgerton 169<br />

93 edgerton 170<br />

94 edgerton 170-171<br />

95 edgerton 171<br />

96 Roth 36<br />

97 Nzongola-Ntalaja 37<br />

98 Dunn 81<br />

99 Roth 35<br />

100 Nzongola-Ntalaja 38-39<br />

101 Nzongola-Ntalaja 39-40<br />

102 dunn 49<br />

103 Roth 37<br />

104 Roth 39<br />

105 Nzongola-Ntalaja 29<br />

106 edgerton 164<br />

107 Roth 38<br />

108 Nzongola-Ntalaja 29<br />

109 Nzongola-Ntalaja 29<br />

110 Nzongola-Ntalaja 29<br />

111 Nzongola-Ntalaja 52-53<br />

112 Nzongola-Ntalaja 53<br />

113 Nzongola-Ntalaja 41<br />

114 edgerton 179<br />

115 edgerton 173<br />

116 edgerton 175<br />

117 Nzongola-Ntalaja 81<br />

118 Roth 40<br />

119 Nzongola-Ntalaja 81<br />

120 Nzongola-Ntalaja 81<br />

121 Nzongola-Ntalaja 82<br />

122 Roth 41<br />

123 Nzongola-Ntalaja 83<br />

124 Nzongola-Ntalaja 85<br />

125 Edgerton 183<br />

126 Nzongola-Ntalaja 85<br />

127 Nzongola-Ntalaja 86<br />

128 Edgerton 183<br />

129 Nzongola-Ntalaja 86<br />

130 Nzongola-Ntalaja 86<br />

131 Edgerton 183<br />

132 Nzongola-Ntalaja 87<br />

133 Nzongola-Ntalaja 87<br />

134 Dunn 81-82<br />

135 Edgerton 184<br />

136 Nzongola-Ntalaja 88<br />

137 Nzongola-Ntalaja 88<br />

138 Nzongola-Ntalaja 54<br />

139 Edgerton 185<br />

140 Nzongola-Ntalaja 88<br />

141 Kent 7<br />

142 Nzongola-Ntalaja 88-89<br />

143 Nzongola-Ntalaja 89<br />

144 Nzongola-Ntalaja 88<br />

145 Nzongola-Ntalaja 32<br />

146 Kent 10<br />

147 Kent 11<br />

148 Nzongola-Ntalaja 89<br />

30<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


149 Nzongola-Ntalaja 89<br />

150 Nzongola-Ntalaja 97<br />

151 Nzongola-Ntalaja 98<br />

152 Nzongola-Ntalaja 98<br />

153 Nzongola-Ntalaja 99<br />

154 Edgerton 186<br />

155 Edgerton 187<br />

156 Edgerton 187<br />

157 Edgerton 185<br />

158 Edgerton 185<br />

159 Edgerton 187<br />

160 Edgerton 189<br />

161 edgerton 190<br />

162 dunn 63<br />

163 Edgerton 185-186<br />

164 edgerton 190<br />

165 Edgerton 187<br />

166 Nzongola-Ntalaja 99<br />

167 Nzongola-Ntalaja 99<br />

168 Edgerton 190<br />

169 dunn 79<br />

170 Dunn 83<br />

171 Dunn 80<br />

172 Nzongola-Ntalaja 99<br />

173 Weiss et al. 39-42<br />

174 Kent 7<br />

175 Kent 11<br />

176 Kent 20<br />

177 Chatterjee 21<br />

178 Kent 20-21<br />

179 Nzongola-Ntalaja 22<br />

180 Nzongola-Ntalaja 28<br />

181 Edgerton 192<br />

182 Nzongola-Ntalaja 63<br />

183 Nzongola-Ntalaja 63<br />

184 Nzongola-Ntalaja 65<br />

185 Nzongola-Ntalaja 63-64<br />

186 Nzongola-Ntalaja 64<br />

187 Nzongola-Ntalaja 64<br />

188 Nzongola-Ntalaja 64<br />

189 Nzongola-Ntalaja 64<br />

190 Kent 9<br />

191 Nzongola-Ntalaja 82<br />

192 Roth 40<br />

193 Kent 7<br />

194 Kent 8<br />

195 Kent 8<br />

196 Nzongola-Ntalaja 87<br />

197 Kent 8<br />

198 Nzongola-Ntalaja 83-84<br />

199 dunn 75-76<br />

200 Kent 9<br />

201 Kent 15<br />

202 Dunn 87<br />

203 Nzongola-Ntalaja 117f<br />

204 Chatterjee 21<br />

205 Kent 13<br />

206 Chatterjee 6<br />

207 Nzongola-Ntalaja 101<br />

208 Chatterjee 23<br />

209 Kent 20<br />

210 Kent 21<br />

211 Nzongola-Ntalaja 113<br />

212 Nzongola-Ntalaja 113<br />

213 Kent 21<br />

31<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design


Bibliographic Essay<br />

Chatterjee, D.N. Storm Over the Congo. New York, NY: Vikas Publishing House, 1982.<br />

Dunn, Kevin C. Imagining the Congo: The International Relations of Identity. New York, NY: Palgrave MacMillan,<br />

2003.<br />

Edgerton, Robert B. The Troubled Heart of Africa. New York, NY: St. Martin’s Press, 2002.<br />

Gareis, Sven Bernhard, & Johannes Varwick. The <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>: An Introduction. New York, New York:<br />

Palgrave MacMillan, 2005.<br />

Gondola, Ch. Didier. The History of Congo. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2003.<br />

Kent, John. America, the UN and Decolonisation: Cold War conflict in the Congo. New York, NY: Routledge,<br />

2010.<br />

“Milestones in <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> History.” Milestones. About the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>/History. Web, n.d. 1 Sep 2010<br />

.<br />

Nzongola-Ntalaja, Georges. The Congo from Leopold to Kabila: A People’s History. New York, NY: Zed Books,<br />

2002.<br />

Regehr, Ernie. “The <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> and nuclear disarmament.” Jane Boulden, Ramesh Thakur, and Thomas<br />

G. Weiss, eds. The <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> and Nuclear Orders. Shibuya-ku, Japan: <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> University<br />

Press, 2009.<br />

Roth, H.M. Zaïre: A country study. Washington, DC: The American University, 1979.<br />

“Under the Charter, the functions and powers of the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> are.” Functions and Powers. UN <strong>Security</strong><br />

<strong>Council</strong>. Web, n.d. 1 Sep 2010 .<br />

Weiss, Thomas, David Forsythe, & Roger Coate. The <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> and Changing <strong>World</strong> Politics. Boulder, CO:<br />

Westview Press, 2008.<br />

32<br />

Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!