Historical Security Council - World Model United Nations
Historical Security Council - World Model United Nations
Historical Security Council - World Model United Nations
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
<strong>Historical</strong> <strong>Security</strong><br />
<strong>Council</strong><br />
<strong>World</strong> <strong>Model</strong> <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> 2013<br />
Study Guide
Contact Us<br />
<strong>World</strong> <strong>Model</strong> united <strong>Nations</strong> 2013<br />
info@worldmun.org<br />
www.worldmun.org<br />
Letters<br />
Letter from the Secretary General 04<br />
Letter from the Under-Secretary General 05<br />
Letter from the Chair 06<br />
Introduction<br />
History of the Committee 07<br />
Statement of the Problem: The Situation in the Congo 09<br />
CONteNtS<br />
09<br />
History of the Problem<br />
Basic Facts<br />
10 Before Colonialization<br />
10 King Leopold II and the Congo<br />
13 After Leopold: Much of the Same?<br />
16 <strong>World</strong> War II<br />
17 The Independence Struggle<br />
19<br />
Current Situation<br />
Prime Minister Lumumba Calls upon UNSC<br />
21 Past UN Actions<br />
21 Potential Solutions<br />
23 Key Actors: Class and Politics<br />
25 Bloc Positions<br />
27 Questions a Resolution Must Answer<br />
27 Suggestions for Further Research<br />
28<br />
Conclusion<br />
Position Papers<br />
28 Closing Remarks<br />
32 Bibliographic Essay<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
Letters<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
Letter from the Secretary-General<br />
dear delegates,<br />
it is my pleasure and honor to welcome you to the 22nd session of <strong>World</strong> <strong>Model</strong> united<br />
<strong>Nations</strong>! My name is Charlene Wong, and i am the Secretary-General of <strong>World</strong>MuN 2013.<br />
Within this document you will find the study guide for your committee. The conference<br />
staff for <strong>World</strong>MUN 2013 has been working tirelessly over the past months to provide<br />
you with an unparalleled conference experience, beginning with this guide. Each Head<br />
Chair has researched extensively to provide you with a foundation for each committee’s<br />
topic areas.<br />
We encourage you to use this study guide as the starting point for your exploration of<br />
your committee’s topics, and your country or character’s policies. The <strong>World</strong>MUN Spirit<br />
invites you to step into the shoes of your country or character, and to immerse yourself in<br />
the committee by researching and developing a full understanding of the issues, perspectives,<br />
and possible solutions on the table. We offer several additional resources online,<br />
including our <strong>World</strong>MuN 101 Guide and Rules of Procedure, updated for this year. Both<br />
are available at www.worldmun.org. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to<br />
contact your Head Chair or Under-Secretary-General.<br />
Please enjoy reading this study guide, and I look forward to meeting you in Melbourne<br />
in March!<br />
Sincerely,<br />
Charlene S. Wong<br />
Secretary-General<br />
<strong>World</strong> <strong>Model</strong> united <strong>Nations</strong> 2013<br />
secretarygeneral@worldmun.org<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design<br />
4
Letter from the Under-Secretary-General<br />
dear delegates,<br />
it is with the utmost honor and pleasure that i welcome you to the Specialized Agencies.<br />
the SA holds a special place in the heart of <strong>Model</strong> united <strong>Nations</strong>; it is here that<br />
crises are born and delegates rise to the challenge to address quickly evolving issues in<br />
real-time. With an average size of 20 delegates per committee, the SA promises to deliver<br />
an intimate and tight-knit environment where every delegate’s voice can be heard and<br />
appreciated.<br />
The SA has always made a firm commitment to substantive excellence and lifelike simulations.<br />
The first measure of that promise starts here with this study guide. Your chair has<br />
worked tirelessly over these past few months pouring over books in deep Harvard dungeons<br />
to breathe life into these topics. I am so proud of their work and hope you make<br />
the most of this initial resource to inspire and guide your preparation for <strong>World</strong>MuN.<br />
Come March, your chair and the junior staff will be working to deliver a MUN simulation<br />
that raises the bar of your delegate experience.<br />
All that being said, the SA would be nothing without you, her committed delegates, who<br />
challenge and dedicate themselves to addressing head-on the world’s greatest problems,<br />
both past, present, and future. With ample preparation, devotion, and creativity,<br />
you will find success in this SA home.<br />
As a former MUN delegate and SA staffer, I know what it means to live and breathe a<br />
thrilling and informative MUN experience. Along with our chairs and junior staff, I hope<br />
to deliver that same experience to you all. Take care, and I cannot wait to meet you in<br />
person in Melbourne!<br />
Sincerely,<br />
Michael Chilazi<br />
under-Secretary-General of the Specialized<br />
Agencies<br />
<strong>World</strong> <strong>Model</strong> united <strong>Nations</strong> 2013<br />
sa@worldmun.org<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design<br />
5
Letter from the Chair<br />
dear delegates,<br />
Greetings and welcome to the <strong>Historical</strong> <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong>. My name is Graeme Crews, and<br />
I will be your chair for what will be an incredible <strong>World</strong> <strong>Model</strong> <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> 2013 in Melbourne,<br />
Australia. As the most powerful body in the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>, you will face an issue<br />
that demands attention from the international community and promises to set a strong<br />
precedent for uN action in the newly decolonized African region.<br />
Briefly, here’s a little info about me. I am a senior at Harvard in Leverett House, concentrating<br />
in Social Studies, which is an interesting amalgamation of political science,<br />
political theory, sociology, economics, and all the other social sciences. MuN is one of<br />
my primary activities on campus. I chaired the International Criminal Court in Singapore<br />
at <strong>World</strong>MuN 2011 and chaired the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> in <strong>World</strong>MuN 2012. i directed the<br />
<strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> at HNMUN 2011 and HNMUN 2012. I am also a member of ICMUN, our<br />
traveling <strong>Model</strong> UN team. I am so involved with <strong>Model</strong> UN because, like you I am sure, I<br />
am interested in international affairs and the intellectual challenge of solving problems in<br />
the international community. Moreover, it offers participants the ability to meet people<br />
from around the world to learn about different cultures and shared values.<br />
Other than <strong>Model</strong> UN, I am a member of the Harvard Speech and Parliamentary Debate<br />
Society. I am super interested in American politics. I volunteer with the Elizabeth Warren<br />
for Senate campaign in Massachusetts and I help organize campus activities to aid in<br />
her campaign. Some of my less demanding extracurricular activities include watching the<br />
most recent blockbusters and trashy TV and spending time with friends.<br />
The <strong>Historical</strong> <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> this year at <strong>World</strong>MUN will face the situation in the Congo<br />
in 1960. Using the study guide and your own research, you will develop comprehensive<br />
solutions to this situation. Independence has recently been declared for the country, but<br />
rival tribal politics along with the newly declared independence of a region within the<br />
country and the intervention by Belgian forces certainly bring this situation to crisis level.<br />
Embedded in the topics are discussions of geopolitical relations, the intersection of economics<br />
and politics, and nation-state formation and centralization.<br />
<strong>World</strong>MuN is truly the Olympics of the MuN world. For any newcomers, you will get the<br />
amazing opportunity of meeting passionate and intelligent students from around the<br />
world in a place bursting with culture and sights to see. For any lucky veterans like me,<br />
you get to experience this opportunity all over again.<br />
All the best,<br />
Graeme Crews<br />
Chair, <strong>Historical</strong> <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
<strong>World</strong>MuN 2013<br />
hsc@worldmun.org<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design<br />
6
Introduction<br />
The most important body of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> has<br />
on its docket one issue to focus on for the duration on<br />
conference: the situation in the Congo in 1960. Before<br />
diving into the issues at stake, I want to lay out my<br />
vision for committee. I envision that committee will<br />
function as a blend of standing and crisis committee.<br />
Every session I hope that as a committee you will<br />
be able to produce a resolution advocating certain<br />
actions. using your recommendations, my assistant<br />
chairs and I will assemble a series of reports from the<br />
Congo presenting the facts on the ground after your<br />
recommendations have been implemented. The next<br />
session you will then react to those facts, and so on.<br />
This situation has been one the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> has<br />
dealt with periodically from 1960 onward (though we<br />
do not know that at this point…), so it will very much<br />
mimic reality.<br />
the Congo is one of the largest colonies in Africa,<br />
and the humanitarian conditions were among the<br />
most deplorable in the late 1800s and 1900s. King<br />
Leopold used forced labor within the colony to<br />
extract huge amounts of wealth for his benefit and for<br />
the benefit of Belgium. When the colony transferred<br />
ownership from Leopold to the Belgian government<br />
in 1908 after a sustained international humanitarian<br />
campaign, the Belgian government continued much<br />
of the most problematic practices of the Leopold<br />
regime, including forced labor, taxes, and poor<br />
social services. After <strong>World</strong> War II, the independence<br />
movement picked up force in the country and in the<br />
context of decolonization internationally, the Belgians<br />
agreed to independence in 1959. When 30 June 1960<br />
arrived, the historical particularities of the Congo did<br />
not prepare it for a self-governing, centralized polity<br />
that was typical in Europe and developed nations<br />
worldwide. Tribal alliances formed the basis for most<br />
political parties, and the military grew mutinous at<br />
the slow-moving changes in the Force Publique from<br />
Belgian to African leadership.<br />
When a mutiny broke out in July, the resourcerich<br />
region of Katanga declared independence, and<br />
Europeans and Africans alike feared for their safety,<br />
the new Prime Minister Lumumba requested help from<br />
the united <strong>Nations</strong> on 12 July 1960. the uNSC, with its<br />
current membership of the permanent five (Republic<br />
of China, Union of Soviet Socialist Republics, <strong>United</strong><br />
States, France, and <strong>United</strong> Kingdom) and rotational<br />
six (ecuador, Argentina, Ceylon, Poland, tunisia, and<br />
Italy) has met to discuss these circumstances and<br />
craft the appropriate response. the purpose of this<br />
Demonstrating the international importance of the situation in the<br />
Congo, this front page story on the impending independence in the<br />
Congo comes from Cleveland, Ohio.<br />
study guide is to provide an initial grounding in both<br />
the history of the situations, the issues in play, and<br />
the potential solutions. The problems associated with<br />
these topics require innovative and comprehensive<br />
solutions; it’s up to you to find them, apply them, and<br />
ensure international peace and security.<br />
History of the Committee<br />
Inception<br />
Following <strong>World</strong> War II, the Holocaust, and the<br />
advent of the nuclear age 1 , the world community<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design<br />
7
decided to improve upon the League of <strong>Nations</strong><br />
and create the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>. However, even<br />
during <strong>World</strong> War II steps were taken to move to<br />
an international institution designed to protect<br />
and promote international peace and security. the<br />
inter-Allied declaration signed in June 1941, stating<br />
that the Allied Powers would “work together, with<br />
other free peoples, both in war and in peace,” was<br />
the first step in establishing the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>.<br />
The Atlantic Charter of August 1941 between the<br />
<strong>United</strong> States and Britain, the Declaration by <strong>United</strong><br />
<strong>Nations</strong> in January 1942, and the Moscow and<br />
Tehran conferences of October 1943 and December<br />
1943, respectively, further developed plans for an<br />
The chamber of the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> as it appeared circa 1960.<br />
international organization, whose first blueprint<br />
was drawn up in the Dumbarton Oaks conference in<br />
October 1944. In April of 1945, the Charter of <strong>United</strong><br />
<strong>Nations</strong>, with sections explicitly devoted to the<br />
powers and structure of the <strong>Security</strong>, was approved<br />
unanimously in San Francisco. 2 Unlike the League of<br />
<strong>Nations</strong>, the UN Charter gave the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> the<br />
authority to enforce the peace through diplomatic,<br />
economic, and even military means, making threats<br />
or use of forces illegal except in self-defense or when<br />
approved by the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong>. 3<br />
Powers<br />
Unlike the General Assembly resolutions,<br />
resolutions from the <strong>Security</strong> are binding and<br />
countries, due to their ratification of the UN Charter<br />
(required before joining the UN), are legally required<br />
to respect and follow them. The five permanent<br />
members of the <strong>United</strong> States of America, The <strong>United</strong><br />
Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the<br />
Russian Federation, the People’s Republic of China,<br />
and the French Republic each have veto power and<br />
no decision can be made on a nonprocedural question<br />
unless they abstain or agree and enforcement<br />
for resolutions can thus only be taken with their<br />
consensus. This institutional structure saved the<br />
organization from imploding when actions were<br />
taken against the most powerful members. 4<br />
the most important articles pertinent to <strong>Security</strong><br />
<strong>Council</strong> powers are Articles 26, 39, 41, and 42. Article<br />
26 assigns the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> with the task of<br />
establishing “a regulation system for the regulation<br />
of armaments.” 5 As per Article 39, the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
has the ability to determine whether a situation is<br />
a threat to the peace, a breach of the peace, or an<br />
act of aggression. Article 41 outlines measures of<br />
responding that are non-military, such as sanctions,<br />
and Article 42 outlines the use of military measures. 6<br />
the powers and functions accorded to the united<br />
<strong>Nations</strong>, as per the uN Charter, include:<br />
to maintain international peace and security in<br />
accordance with the principles and purposes of the<br />
united <strong>Nations</strong>;<br />
• to investigate any dispute or situation which<br />
might lead to international friction;<br />
• to recommend methods of adjusting such<br />
disputes or the terms of settlement;<br />
• to formulate plans for the establishment of a<br />
system to regulate armaments;<br />
• to determine the existence of a threat to the<br />
peace or act of aggression and to recommend<br />
what action should be taken;<br />
• to call on Members to apply economic<br />
sanctions and other measures not involving<br />
the use of force to prevent or stop aggression;<br />
• to take military action against an aggressor;<br />
• to recommend the admission of new<br />
Members;<br />
• to exercise the trusteeship functions of the<br />
<strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> in “strategic areas”;<br />
• to recommend to the General Assembly the<br />
appointment of the Secretary-General and,<br />
together with the Assembly, to elect the<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design<br />
8
Judges of the international Court of Justice. 7<br />
Past Major Actions<br />
Since its creation and establishment in 1945, the<br />
<strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> has consistently drafted and passed<br />
resolutions dealing with issues of international<br />
peace and security. Even with Article 2, paragraph 7<br />
of the Charter prohibiting the UN from intervening<br />
in the internal affairs and jurisdiction of a state,<br />
the uN <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> has interpreted threats to<br />
international peace and security to include political<br />
instability and violence within states. 8<br />
Statement of the Problem: The Situation<br />
in the Congo<br />
Our committee will begin its deliberations in the<br />
midst of chaos in the Congo. the country was just<br />
newly independent, but a mutiny in the army has<br />
spread across the country, the resource-rich Katanga<br />
region has just declared independence, and the<br />
Belgian army has violated the Congo government’s<br />
wishes and sent its own troops into the region to<br />
protect europeans. in the context of escalating<br />
violence, uncertainty of the power of the new<br />
government, and economic downturn, the UNSC<br />
is meeting and attempting to devise a politically<br />
palatable solution to the widespread problems.<br />
Looking broadly, the situation in the Congo during<br />
the 1960s mixed the divisive politics of the Cold War<br />
with process and problems of decolonization in a<br />
highly contentious way. 9 the situation in the Congo is<br />
a very complicated one, with a land area that is eighty<br />
times the size of its colonial administrator Belgian and<br />
over 200 ethnic groups dotting its landscape. Because<br />
the construction of the area was based on political<br />
contingencies in the late 19 th century, the borders<br />
have no real meaning for collecting a singular group of<br />
Africans. 10 The Congo will not have an easy transition<br />
to a state in the Western construct—territorial<br />
integrity and sovereignty; the Belgian occupation<br />
and extraction ensured that a unified polity would be<br />
difficult to achieve. 11 Geopolitically, the major players<br />
in the Western world were not particularly concerned<br />
about the Congo’s strategic security importance, but<br />
rather with Western capitalism’s or communism’s<br />
ability to prosper in the Third <strong>World</strong> and the jockeying<br />
for expansion of a dominant economic system. 12<br />
Through this guide, it will become evident that<br />
Belgian control of the country in its colonial period<br />
has had huge impacts on the development of the<br />
Congo and its success. Inadvertently, Leopold and the<br />
Belgian government organized the Congo’s economic<br />
conditions in such a way to prevent economic viability<br />
for the future independent country. 13 Colonial<br />
economic exploitation transformed African societies,<br />
including the groups in the region now known as the<br />
Congo, by using the forced labor of the native peoples<br />
to meet export requirements for raw materials for<br />
enrichment by the ruling class and a country they<br />
would never see. 14<br />
Ultimately, the country is inherently divided and<br />
as a result does not have a unified message of selfgovernance,<br />
external actors are often able to speak<br />
for it and skew its interests in a way that may not be<br />
productive for the state. 15 Remember that while you<br />
have your own national interests to adhere to, the<br />
people of the Congo are the ones who will benefit or<br />
be harmed most by your actions in committee.<br />
History and Discussion of the<br />
Problem<br />
Basic Facts<br />
With a population in 1960 of 15 million, 16 the ethnic<br />
make-up of the Congo is extremely complicated,<br />
with over 200 ethnic groups occupying six different<br />
provinces, which are all at different stages of<br />
economic development. The Kongo (48% of the<br />
population), Sangha (20%), Teke (17%), and M’Bochi<br />
(12%) are the four largest defined ethnic groups and<br />
comprise more than 40 tribes within the boundaries<br />
of the country. 17 the ethnic groups do share many<br />
cultural traits, including speaking the same Bantuderived<br />
languages. 18 the Congolese until well into<br />
their colonialization period lived in traditional village<br />
settings, where traditional economic tasks were<br />
separated by gender, religious rituals and public<br />
ceremonies were the norm. 19<br />
The Congo is vast, occupying 2,345,400 square<br />
kilometers, a third the size of the <strong>United</strong> States. 20<br />
Approximately 77 per cent of the land is made of<br />
forests and woodlands, including a tropical rainforest<br />
along the Equator, which provides timber in world<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design<br />
9
markets. 21 the products mined in Congo are essential<br />
for world markets—copper (8 percent of world<br />
production), cobalt (73 percent of world production),<br />
industrial diamonds (80 percent of world production),<br />
uranium, zinc, gold, and other precious minerals. 22<br />
Agriculturally, the Congo is a source of coffee, tea,<br />
and cotton plants. 23<br />
Before Colonialization<br />
Before colonialization, the political institutions<br />
within the region now known as the Congo were<br />
kingdoms. They were primarily social organizations<br />
based on agricultural production, and the central<br />
rulers facilitated long-distance trade. 24<br />
The Kingdom of the Congo was formed in the<br />
14th century with a political structure very similar to<br />
the european feudal one of the time. 25 through the<br />
15th century, it was able to consolidate its power<br />
due to the prosperous economy in the region<br />
from agriculture and long-distance trade that<br />
was emerging with European powers. The tribute<br />
system with local chiefs kept law and order. 26 At the<br />
end of the 15th century, diplomatic relations were<br />
established between Portugal and the Kingdom,<br />
but the expanding diplomatic relations with Europe<br />
led in the 16th century to alcoholism, extortion, and<br />
the growth of the slave trade. 27 As part of the trade<br />
paths that slaves took, ivory and other trade goods<br />
from the Congo region made their way to the coasts<br />
of Africa. 28<br />
There are roughly speaking two historical periods of<br />
Congo-European relationships: first, the Atlantic slave<br />
trade which was the primary means of accumulation<br />
in the global economy in the 16th century and second,<br />
the trade in raw materials needed for industrial<br />
production in Europe in the 18th and early 19th century.<br />
Neither of these historical processes exposed much<br />
of what is now known as the Congo to the outside<br />
world. 29<br />
Nevertheless, the Kingdom of the Congo did<br />
become a player in the rivalry between the Dutch and<br />
Portuguese and declined rapidly. 30 The kingdom’s fast<br />
integration into the overall capitalist system along<br />
with its participation in the Atlantic slave ultimately<br />
turned the kingdom against itself and contributed<br />
to its decline. 31 The end result was the Kingdom’s<br />
dissolution in 1885 between Portugal, France, and<br />
Belgium. 32<br />
The Luba empire in the southern part of the region<br />
was another major precolonial state that lost its<br />
power before the Europeans annexed this part of<br />
Africa. The Luba state solidified in the 16 th century,<br />
with its power extending across the Katanga-Kasai<br />
trade network and absorbing tributes from the<br />
local chieftains. The empire dissolved between 1860<br />
and 1891 from the cumulative effects of outside<br />
Early sketch of a Portuguese delegation at the court of the King of<br />
the Congo.<br />
interventions by Europeans and by ivory and slave<br />
traders who intruded on their central and peripheral<br />
territories. 33<br />
King Leopold II and the Congo<br />
While most of the interior of the Congo, far from<br />
the ocean and trade routes, was on the periphery of<br />
most European power’s concerns, the 1884-85 Berlin<br />
Conference, or “Scramble for Africa”, brought the<br />
land into focus. King Leopold II of Belgium declared<br />
sovereignty over the Congo River basin, creating the<br />
political construction of what became known as the<br />
“Congo.” 34 Leopold’s ventures in the region extended<br />
much before this date, it should be noted. He sent<br />
British-born American journalist Henry Morton<br />
Stanley into central Africa as part of the Association<br />
international africaine (AIA), where Stanley used<br />
manipulation and coercion to force clan and tribe<br />
chiefs to “sign” treaties with the King to cede their<br />
territories to control to the newly formed Association<br />
10<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
international du Congo (AIC), which came out of<br />
the AIA. By obtaining these treaties, establishing<br />
administrative and trading stations along rivers<br />
within central Africa, Leopold was able to brandish an<br />
empire-building record that justified his claims to the<br />
resources and territories of the Congo at the Berlin<br />
Conference. 35 it did not hurt that the great powers<br />
did not want to see another obtain the central African<br />
region, and thus allowed Belgium’s Leopold to have<br />
it. 36 Moreover, Leopold’s neutral status ensured that<br />
A portrait of King Leopold II.<br />
the colony would be open to other nationals and their<br />
companies. He promised not to impose customs or<br />
import duties in the resource-rich region, and thus<br />
the other powers came to view the region as a free<br />
trade model. 37 This fit within the overall principles<br />
agreed upon at the conference, which also included<br />
neutrality in wars, suppression of slave traffic,<br />
and improvement of the condition of indigenous<br />
populations. 38<br />
The situation in the colony of Congo was different<br />
from African colonies around the continent for two<br />
specific reasons. First, its establishment as a colony in<br />
the late 19 th century came far after most other African<br />
colonies had been established. Second, the colony<br />
was viewed as the possession of an individual—<br />
King Leopold II. These two dynamics motivated King<br />
Leopold and administrations to colonize the area very<br />
quickly. The condensed process led concurrently to<br />
an expanded land control policy and coercive control<br />
mechanisms to maintain control. 39 King Leopold<br />
positioned himself initially as a benevolent leader,<br />
selfless and ready to make his African holdings<br />
civilized participants in the capitalist system. 40 the<br />
discourse of salvation proved to be the rationale for<br />
the forced and violent development that the colony<br />
administrators would impose on culturally backward<br />
Africans. 41 Despite the forced labor policies he<br />
implemented, Leopold publically upheld his colonial<br />
project as one that would save the natives from the<br />
Arab slave traders who peddled in “odious traffic,<br />
which is a disgrace to the age in which we live.” 42 this<br />
appeal to protecting the Africans from the Arab slave<br />
traders gained him moral support throughout europe<br />
and the united States. 43<br />
His actions were not always congruent with his<br />
rhetoric. immediately after Congo was organized as<br />
his own personal “Congo Free State”, he undertook<br />
campaigns of military pacification and economic<br />
exploitation. 44 King Leopold was primarily motivated<br />
by his desire to turn the region into a profit for his<br />
personal needs. He had spent vast amounts of<br />
money in order to explore the region and lobby for<br />
his ownership of it, and thus he needed money to<br />
pay down debts and invest in his native Belgium’s<br />
economic development. With this motivation, he<br />
sought simple resource accumulation and therefore<br />
sought to accomplish this through forced labor. 45<br />
the economic exploitation of the Congo was<br />
primarily around harvesting wild rubber for exportation<br />
to Belgium and use in tires. White settlers working<br />
for the state and commercial enterprises (many of<br />
11<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
which controlled by King Leopold) forced native<br />
peoples to work through coercion and violence. 46<br />
Punishments for African natives included floggings,<br />
beatings, and executions were handed out for crimes<br />
from desertion to dropping a pack. 47 When labor<br />
taxes and quotas were not fulfilled in certain villages,<br />
these floggings and executions were the norm, often<br />
carried out by neighboring ethnic groups employed<br />
by Belgian administrators. Entire villages were often<br />
razed in response to failure to fulfill labor quotas. 48<br />
The king created a standard of declaring indigenous<br />
land ownership as “vacant land” and declared land<br />
his by eminent domain. The end result in the Congo<br />
was that huge swaths of the country were declared<br />
the “Crown domain” or the “private domain of the<br />
state.” 49 The end result in Belgium was a huge inflow<br />
of capital, which was used for public works projects<br />
and urban improvement. 50 the rationalization of this<br />
exploitation came from an ideology that asserted<br />
the “white man’s burden” to bring Christianity and<br />
capitalism to “inferior races.” Leopold paid vast sums<br />
of money to public relations agencies to depict the<br />
venture in the Congo as essentially a humanitarian<br />
campaign seeking to bring an end to poverty and<br />
ignorance in native populations. 51<br />
The political impacts of King Leopold’s regime<br />
were interrelated with the economic policies he<br />
purported. As administrative stations were built<br />
throughout the region, the integration of the country<br />
into a capitalist and exploitive system occurred. This<br />
led to all the major African political systems in the<br />
area being brought under the control of the colonial<br />
administrative state, which implemented new taxes<br />
in labor and money. 52<br />
The End to Leopold’s Congo<br />
An international reform movement, led by E.D.<br />
Morel, sought to drastically change Leopold’s<br />
stranglehold on the Congo. in a letter in 1905, Morel<br />
wrote that: “A system has been introduced…imitated<br />
in some respect by others, which is turning its servants<br />
into brute beasts, disgracing European prestige,<br />
befouling civilization, and jeopardizing the whole<br />
future of European effort in the Dark Continent.” 53<br />
Drawing from reports about atrocities that came<br />
from foreign missionaries, Morel focused Western<br />
attention on Leopold’s rule. 54 Leopold attempted<br />
to stop the turning of public opinion against him<br />
and his colony by hiring spies and double agent to<br />
infiltrate foreign government and tried to flood the<br />
newspapers with positive coverage and depress<br />
negative coverage by bribing editors. 55 Leopold<br />
was further able to stem the outrage by portraying<br />
Morel’s campaign success as a British and American<br />
plot to take away the king’s prized possession. 56<br />
However, Morel was able to cast Leopold and Belgium<br />
in an extremely negative light, given the discursive<br />
tendencies of the time; his campaign promoted the<br />
view of Leopold and his actions as “barbaric” and<br />
“uncivilized.” 57 Morel’s claims about the brutality<br />
in the Congo were confirmed by outside sources,<br />
including an international Commission of Enquiry of<br />
lawyers that, after a five-month tour, confirmed all<br />
the claims of brutality and coercion that had been<br />
circulating in the media. 58 The ability to appeal to the<br />
humanitarian impulses of elites in Western europe<br />
and the <strong>United</strong> States, along with the inability of<br />
foreign powers to access and penetrate the Congo’s<br />
vast wealth at the time, proved to be an extremely<br />
potent mix of forces that had the ultimate impact of<br />
forcing Leopold out of the region. 59<br />
Thus, the movement overcame Leopold’s<br />
stronghold on the Congo and forced him to transfer<br />
the colony to the Belgian state in 1908 60 by selling<br />
his personal estate to the government of Belgium. 61<br />
The Belgian parliament voted to annex the region in<br />
August 1908 after a divisive debate and in a hardly<br />
resounding vote of 88 in favor and 54 opposed. 62<br />
the result of the colonial project was tragic: an<br />
official Belgian inquiry from 1919 reported that the<br />
population of the Congo had diminished by half,<br />
which equals about 10 million deaths from murder,<br />
disease, starvation, and exposure. 63<br />
Resistance<br />
Through the beginning of Belgian colonial history,<br />
there were certainly pockets of resistance, which had<br />
the potential of snowballing into a larger movement.<br />
the root reason why resistance generally failed is that<br />
by the time of the Berlin Conference and the annexation<br />
by European powers, there was no centralized Congo<br />
kingdom. The tribes in Congo were much too weak<br />
12<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
and disorganized to be effective against an armed<br />
European imperial conquest. 64 Resistance against<br />
the europeans was ultimately most successful from<br />
within colony-established institutions—the colonial<br />
army, forced labor camps, and agricultural workers.<br />
Discontent over taxes, conscription, and forced labor<br />
was able to spread and<br />
strengthen in these<br />
contexts. 65 the 1900<br />
to 1916 Shi rebellion<br />
and 1907-1917 Luba-<br />
Katanga of Kasongo<br />
Nyembo rebellion<br />
were longstanding<br />
affairs against the<br />
Leopold empire and<br />
the Belgian colonial<br />
government. 66 the<br />
former leaders of the<br />
Luba empire used<br />
their former power<br />
to rise up against<br />
Leopold’s empire in<br />
1895, and it put up<br />
effective resistance<br />
against forced labor<br />
policies. 67 However, as<br />
the colony centralized<br />
and consolidated<br />
its powers as will<br />
be described in the<br />
next section, it was<br />
able to quash these<br />
insurrections. 68<br />
The revolts in the<br />
internal colonial army illustrate much of the underlying<br />
dynamics of the colony. White officers steeped in racist<br />
ideology were brutal in their disciplinary measures of<br />
soldiers, military workers, who maintained, supplied,<br />
and grew food, and porters, who transported<br />
equipment and supplies. 69 cities of the country.<br />
Revolts during Leopold’s<br />
reign arose in these garrisons—the Kananga mutiny<br />
in 1895, the Ndirfi mutiny in 1897 and the Shinkakasa<br />
mutiny in 1900. These revolts were called upon later<br />
as memories of resistance against the Belgian. it is<br />
generally agreed that what motivated rebels was the<br />
oppression of the colonial administrators, and they<br />
were able to succeed in their resistance in pockets of<br />
the region for years because they recruited volunteers<br />
from surrounding areas to replenish their ranks. The<br />
multi-ethnic make-up of the mutinies fostered and<br />
developed a national<br />
identity—one at odds<br />
with the ruling Belgian<br />
class. 70<br />
After Leopold:<br />
More of the<br />
Same?<br />
As the transition<br />
of the Congo from<br />
Leopold’s to Belgium’s<br />
control occurred and<br />
completed in 1908,<br />
there was hope that<br />
all the excessive force<br />
of the past would be<br />
eliminated. the general<br />
scheme of governance<br />
worked such that while<br />
the Belgian parliament<br />
and colonial affairs<br />
ministers in Brussels<br />
supervised the colony,<br />
the actual governance<br />
of the colony was done<br />
on the ground by the<br />
colonial bureaucracy<br />
in alliance with<br />
representatives of the<br />
Belgian bourgeoisie,<br />
business leaders, and the hierarchy of the Catholic<br />
Church. 71 The new governance scheme did not<br />
radically alter from the previous one and utilized the<br />
pre-existing economic and administrative institutions<br />
to operate the colony. the inherited colony had a<br />
particular structure: a huge region of land with a sparse<br />
population under a system of economic exploitation<br />
with no tradition of positive policy aimed at<br />
benefiting the general population. 72 This colonial map shows the regional break-up of the colony and the major<br />
the longstanding<br />
institutions did not merely dissolve to be developed<br />
13<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
anew; instead there was refinement at the margins of<br />
the overall structure. 73 it is unsurprising that there was<br />
major reform; Belgium had little history as a colonial<br />
power and had to learn quickly to administer an area<br />
80 times its size thousands of miles away. 74 in part to<br />
assuage public anger in Europe, the Belgians adopted<br />
a colonial constitution, crafted by major shareholders<br />
in Belgian and the Catholic Church, which had an<br />
interest in proselytizing. 75 The first Belgian minister<br />
of the colony reduced compulsory labor and stopped<br />
the most significant government-led atrocities. 76 His<br />
appointments of local administrators were typically<br />
young men with little formal education who utilized<br />
the colonial army of white Belgian officers and African<br />
infantry to enforce forced labor and collect taxes. 77<br />
The colonial administrators were, like during<br />
Leopold’s time, focused on economic exploitation<br />
and providing corporations with adequate land to<br />
mine. 78 Belgian domestic politics were not organized<br />
in a way to drastically change colonial affairs, and thus<br />
allowed the minority in the home country with vested<br />
interests in the region to gain disproportionate say<br />
in the governance of the region. 79 The new king<br />
of Belgium could rule by decree after consulting<br />
a purely advisory colonial council of conservative,<br />
business-oriented appointees, but this decree was<br />
constrained by the Belgian minister of colonies. 80<br />
The Belgian minister of colonial affairs wrote in 1921<br />
that the major goal of colonialism was to develop<br />
“the economic action of Belgium,” which means that<br />
the law and order control of the colony is at most as<br />
important as the labor recruitment for companies. 81<br />
In the initial ownership of the Congo by Belgium, the<br />
state’s authority in the countryside was literally a<br />
function of company’s administration and extraction<br />
of a particular region. Companies would use African<br />
chiefs as supplementary workers on behalf of the<br />
company to recruit labor for them. Although the<br />
state eventually established control over most of the<br />
region at local level displacing the rule by companies,<br />
the new requirements for the people were<br />
sometimes more onerous as they needed to provide<br />
extra labor and taxes for public works projects and<br />
adhere to certain regulations governing most parts<br />
of people’s lives. 82 ultimately, companies continued<br />
to have monopolistic powers over vast swaths of<br />
the region, resulting in either no pay or very low pay<br />
for the local workers and their production. 83 Often,<br />
though forced labor was technically frowned upon,<br />
companies and administrators would recruit and hold<br />
locals as workers through the imposition of fines and<br />
imprisonment for breach of contract. 84<br />
However, as time progressed, leaders in the<br />
colonial regime began to understand that in order<br />
This 1922 map illustrates the holdings of African countries by various<br />
European colonial powers.<br />
to have effective control over a population, the<br />
Europeans needed effective local allies. A series<br />
of decrees on colonial administration in 1906,<br />
1910, and 1933 transformed chiefs from outside<br />
powers to intermediary powers with the colonial<br />
administration. 85 if chiefs helped meet export<br />
expectations, signed up tribes for conscription,<br />
provided forced labor, and paid taxes, they were given<br />
14<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
economic and political rewards, which effectively set<br />
them against their own people. 86 Chiefs were also<br />
brought on as sponsors to ensure that peasants<br />
did not sell the food products they grew, as per the<br />
directions of the Belgian government. Thus, rather<br />
than economically developing the rural society where<br />
most of the native peoples lived, the Belgians left<br />
them at the same level of economic and cultural life<br />
as the time of conquest, but in a devastated and<br />
chaotic state. 87<br />
<strong>World</strong> War i interrupted this consolidation of the<br />
colony. Most of Belgium was occupied by German<br />
soldiers and therefore the Congo was left on its<br />
own. the colonial army sent poorly trained men<br />
and even women to fight Germans in Cameroon,<br />
Ruanda-Burundi, and Tanganyika and the Italians in<br />
ethiopia. 88 Economically, raw materials like copper,<br />
rubber, and agricultural products were shipped to the<br />
Allies. 89 Socially, the colony witnessed huge changes,<br />
as Congolese were appointed to recently vacant<br />
positions that were previously reserved for whites<br />
that were now fighting or working for the government<br />
in europe. 90 Africans established new businesses, and<br />
African workers were involved in housing, utilities,<br />
transportation, and the central bank. 91<br />
After the war, the colonial government, no<br />
longer withheld funds from a Belgian government<br />
preoccupied with a war within its borders, started<br />
a large public works project, developing the most<br />
impoverished region of Katanga and setting up<br />
refineries, factories, repair shops, hospitals, schools,<br />
and housing in urban areas there and around the<br />
country. In urban neighborhoods, houses and<br />
apartments were built with brick, and blocks were<br />
given access to water supply and sanitation facilities. 92<br />
Development extended into the 1920s, with diamond<br />
mines in Kasai and diamond and gold mines in Kivu<br />
built. 93 The diamond output increased by eightfold,<br />
and, combined with modern scientific advances<br />
(though heavily concentrated to the benefit of<br />
whites over blacks in segregated hospitals), brought<br />
to the area, led to increases in standard of living<br />
and average ages around the country. 94 the 1929<br />
Wall Street collapse affected the Congo, with prices<br />
falling, businesses closing, and mining decreasing. 95<br />
Many wage-earners were laid off by companies, and<br />
the massive lay offs of mining workers led Belgian<br />
leaders to focus more of their attention to agriculture<br />
to diversify the economy of the Congo. 96<br />
Political changes need to be addressed to provide a<br />
larger picture of the times. the aforementioned 1933<br />
reform also established a federal structure for the<br />
Congo that would extend through the current times,<br />
with division and subdivision of the country into<br />
provinces, districts, and territories (or subdistricts),<br />
with administrative heads appointed by the central<br />
colonial government. Provincial governors dealt<br />
with policy questions of the provinces, district<br />
commissioners acted as inspectors of the work of<br />
territorial administrators and chieftains under their<br />
control. The territorial administrators themselves<br />
had vast control over areas comprising many<br />
chieftains and looked after records, kept law and<br />
order, collected taxes, recruited labor, conscripted<br />
native peoples, and administrated public services.<br />
Moreover, they were responsible for comprising and<br />
presenting information about their territory to higher<br />
powers. 97 It should not be assumed that the colonial<br />
administration had complete control over all levels<br />
of government in all parts of the region. The Congo<br />
was a fragmented region with land overseen by<br />
administrative government, church zones, substate<br />
figures, business interests, monopolistic concessions,<br />
and local forces, 98 but when the administrators had<br />
control, they had vast amounts of power and leverage<br />
in the communities where they were located. When<br />
they were overworked or had to manage too large<br />
an area, they would rely more heavily on local chiefs<br />
to carry out their orders and the orders of the Belgian<br />
colonial government. 99<br />
While the governance and economic systems<br />
sought to subjugate the native population for profit<br />
of the metropolitan government, the legal statutes<br />
implemented further diminished the life chances of<br />
the native populations. Racism was institutionalized<br />
in many ways—formal, with explicitly differential<br />
treatment in the justice system based on race, and<br />
informal, with de facto racial segregation. the Belgians<br />
legalized restrictions on liquors, established a curfew<br />
in european areas, allowed corporal punishment,<br />
15<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
set up segregated housing and segregated people<br />
in public accommodations like trains, hotels, and<br />
restaurants. 100<br />
Culturally, the colony was a blank slate; the<br />
administrators and church missionaries interpreted<br />
the absence of a written language and literature<br />
as absence of an overall cultural experience of the<br />
people. Their music and art were viewed as barbaric<br />
and childish, and artifacts were taken to European<br />
museums for display. 101 From the beginning of<br />
colonialization onward, the diverse histories, local<br />
economies, languages, and indigenous identity<br />
constructs were cast aside in favor of a monolithic<br />
colonial system that was supported by the an ideology<br />
of economic development and cultural advancement<br />
through coercive force. 102 The religious beliefs<br />
of native Africans were change by missionaries,<br />
which often drove a wedge between<br />
communities adhering to traditional<br />
beliefs and those adhering to new Christian<br />
beliefs. 103 The ethnic identities of native<br />
peoples were hardened by the distribution<br />
and requirement to carry around<br />
identification cards with ethnic groups<br />
listed, which proved to make political<br />
parties’ organization around ethnic ties<br />
easier later in the colony’s history. When<br />
one ethnic group was perceived to have<br />
benefited from the colonial government,<br />
this often engendered hatred in other<br />
ethnic groups. 104<br />
<strong>World</strong> War ii<br />
became more tied to the market demands because of<br />
the need for more agricultural production to help the<br />
war effort, which further diminished the local ties in<br />
rural communities. 107<br />
The Congo also proved essential for the global war<br />
effort by supplying the uranium for nuclear bombs<br />
that the US was building as part of the Manhattan<br />
Project. 108 Later in the century, control of uranium<br />
proved as essential as it did during the war as the<br />
US tried to prevent the Soviet Union from accessing<br />
these markets for uranium. 109<br />
The Belgian government and its allies ended<br />
up succeeding, but the toll on the people of the<br />
Congo was more of the same. Normally, Congo<br />
men were required to work with no wages for 60<br />
days per year to build public projects, including road<br />
maintenance and construction of hotels for colonial<br />
During <strong>World</strong> War II, the Congo served<br />
as an essential source of funds for the<br />
Belgian government in its conflict with the<br />
Axis Powers. Because of the accumulation of wealth<br />
from mineral resources in the Congo, the Belgian<br />
government was able to finance its actions in London,<br />
including the diplomatic corps service, and the cost of<br />
armed forces in europe and Africa. 105 during the war,<br />
the plethora of industries that had emerged through<br />
the past half-century also proved to attract vast<br />
numbers of Africans who up until that point generally<br />
lived in rural villages. 106 administrators. during the war, the period was<br />
extended to 120 days, with consequent devastating<br />
impacts on the population like hunger, starvation and<br />
death destroying whole families.<br />
the economic structure of the<br />
Congo changed as the fate of poor native peoples<br />
110 This funeral of the governor Felix Eboue in Brazzaville in May 1944 shows that the<br />
Belgian colony still retained traditions that existed throughout colonial times.<br />
Armed resistance<br />
and mutinies occurred during the war in reaction<br />
to these demands and in reaction to the overall<br />
oppressive colonial system as viewed by the people.<br />
The three most important rebellions were the 1941<br />
mineworkers’ strike in Katanga, the 1944 insurrection<br />
in Kasai and Katanga, and the 1945 dockworkers’<br />
16<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
strike in Matadi. These mutinies had implications later<br />
as they organized multiple ethnic populations along<br />
nationalism ideologies. 111<br />
After the war, the racist policies of the colonial<br />
regime were slightly loosened, as a way of keeping the<br />
public subservient to colonial interests. 112 the Belgians<br />
attempted to assimilate the African petty bourgeoisie<br />
into the colonial structure by exempting them from<br />
the most onerous racist restrictions. Moreover, in<br />
1948, the colonial administration introduced a “social<br />
merit card” which quickly morphed into the new<br />
social designation “matriculation” in 1952, which<br />
meant that an African had sufficiently “evolved”<br />
culturally to be regarded as like Europeans. 113 this was<br />
not a widespread assimilation policy; only 217 people<br />
accepted these designations over the next decade. 114<br />
the post-war period also witnessed huge<br />
urbanization with Leopoldville, the seat of the<br />
colonial government, growing by hundreds of<br />
thousands of people. With this urbanization, Africans<br />
set up their own businesses and shops, and others<br />
worked as low-skilled laborers. 115 the Belgian colonial<br />
government devoted much of their budgetary surplus<br />
to the improvement of medical care with the building<br />
of clinics and hospitals. 116<br />
the independence Struggle<br />
The petty bourgeoisie in the Congo was the only<br />
class that was able to organize and synthesize the<br />
revolutionary notions and hopes of people across the<br />
Congo into a mass movement. Until 1956, however, its<br />
focus was on full integration into the colonial, white<br />
society, not on independence. the post-war actions<br />
of the Congo colonial powers to assimilate certain<br />
elite segments of the African populations postponed<br />
the bourgeoisie’s desires for independence. 117 the<br />
Belgian policies of limited education, emphasis on<br />
economic development, and limited possibilities for<br />
native peoples to participate in the governance of<br />
the colony ensured that the independence struggle<br />
would be hampered from its infancy and have limited<br />
ability to develop a nationalist ideology that could<br />
appeal nation-wide. 118<br />
the year 1956 was a monumental turning point<br />
in the independence struggle by a convergence of<br />
factors. internationally, the Franco-British-israeli<br />
Suez expedition and its failure, the independence of<br />
Morocco, Sudan, and tunisia, and the decolonialization<br />
movements in West Africa, Equatorial Africa,<br />
Madagascar, Angola, and the Belgian Congo were<br />
in their infant states. All of these events inspired the<br />
domestic elite in the Congo, which was itself in the<br />
midst of debating the best course of action for the<br />
future of the country. 119 This debate was sparked in<br />
part due to the publishing of a pamphlet by Belgian<br />
professor A.A.J. Van Bilsen who advocated for a<br />
“thirty-year plan for the political emancipation of<br />
Belgian Africa.” 120 The pamphlet ignited debate, and<br />
the radical response from the ABAKO group, led<br />
by Joseph Kasavubu, stipulated that 30 years was<br />
too long a timeline and called for the immediate<br />
transition from colonial to self-governance in a<br />
federal structure. 121<br />
Political reforms in 1957 liberalized the colony,<br />
allowing for municipal elections, and led to the<br />
emergence of numerous political parities in 1958, one<br />
of which was ABAKO. Because of the short amount<br />
of time available, ABAKO and most political parties<br />
had to mobilize rapidly, requiring a focus not on<br />
ideology but on ethnic ties for organizers. 122 the MNC<br />
(Mouvement National Congolais) party, led by Patrice<br />
Lumumba, was another party that formed as a result<br />
of the liberalization and could be considered the first<br />
national political party in the Congo. As will be seen,<br />
the party and off-shoots from it were instrumental in<br />
resistance to the colonial government and ultimately<br />
independence. 123 Lumumba organized a mass rally in<br />
December 1958 with immediate independence as the<br />
ultimate national goal. 124<br />
Not a month later in early January, a local ABAKO<br />
section attempted to hold another rally near the<br />
place where Lumumba held his in Kinshasa. When the<br />
Belgian government canceled the event, 125 a crowd<br />
refused to go home peacefully and proceeded to<br />
attack and harm symbols of white authority, including<br />
shops and white motorists. 126 Almost the entire African<br />
population of Kinshasa joined in on the rebellion,<br />
which lasted three days. 127 Both independence<br />
leaders Lumumba and Kasavubu were imprisoned on<br />
sketchy evidence for inciting what was very clearly<br />
a spontaneous riot. 128 The revolt marked a new and<br />
17<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
evolutionary phase of the national independence<br />
movement, and the Belgians reevaluated the entire<br />
independence claim by the Congo. 129<br />
The Belgians were jolted by the violence in the<br />
Congo. Prompted by the clear demands of the<br />
population, the lack of political will in Belgium to<br />
engage in an Algerian-like civil war, and the norm<br />
of decolonialization<br />
internationally, two<br />
separate policy<br />
statements released<br />
by the Belgian king<br />
and government on 13<br />
January 1959 explicitly<br />
supported the idea of<br />
independence, 130 the<br />
most rapid and radical<br />
decolonization plan<br />
seen on the African<br />
continent up to this<br />
point. 131 the Belgian<br />
government was<br />
also coming to the<br />
realization that much<br />
of the country was<br />
simply ungovernable;<br />
the Lower Congo and<br />
Bandundu regions<br />
at this point refused<br />
to recognize the<br />
authority of the<br />
colonial government<br />
and were only<br />
willing to recognize<br />
domestic political<br />
parties as their rightful<br />
rulers. 132 Combine<br />
these circumstances<br />
with a series of<br />
wars and revolts in<br />
Kasai and Kisangani,<br />
and the Belgian<br />
military resources were severely strained and<br />
unable to maintain order, thus promoting the view<br />
that independence should be granted. 133 While<br />
independence was certainly the focus of the Belgian<br />
government’s actions, they also specified that it<br />
would still be under their prerogative to transfer the<br />
responsibilities to “maintain a sound administration”<br />
when “new Congolese institutions” have proven<br />
they “are capable of maintaining order and respect<br />
for public and private obligations, and the protection<br />
of persons and<br />
property.” 134<br />
The December 1959<br />
preliminary elections<br />
for local government<br />
councils were not<br />
a positive event for<br />
country unity. the<br />
some 120 political<br />
parties also proved to<br />
destabilize the country.<br />
Organized by tribal<br />
unity most of the time<br />
and openly hostile with<br />
other parties, there<br />
was not a universal<br />
agreement over the<br />
path that the Congo<br />
should take. 135 these<br />
elections also faced<br />
widespread distrust,<br />
given the Belgian<br />
government’s aid to the<br />
PNP party (an off-shoot<br />
of the Lumumba’s<br />
MNC party). 136 the<br />
Belgians, even though<br />
sensing that immediate<br />
independence would<br />
lead to a deteriorating<br />
situation in terms of<br />
law and order, agreed<br />
to the popular demand<br />
for “immediate<br />
independence,” and<br />
made a decision 20 February 1960 for total and<br />
unconditional independence on 30 June 1960. 137<br />
The independence struggle in Congo was in large part a reaction to the<br />
historical mistreatment of the Congolese people. Here several people,<br />
from children to the elderly, are photographed without hands which was<br />
punishment in early colonial Belgium for misbehavior.<br />
18<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
Current Situation: Where We<br />
Stand Now<br />
The working classes and peasant population<br />
formed the crux of the resistance and independence<br />
movement that organized the rebellion of 4 January<br />
1959 in Kinshasa, which ultimately resulted in<br />
Belgium’s decision to grant independence to the<br />
Congo. 138 The first few days of independence were<br />
calm, with heavily-armed, well-disciplined white<br />
officers of the colonial army keeping the peace in<br />
the cities and countryside. 139 However, even though<br />
independence was achieved, the national and<br />
democratic movements responsible for it are deeply<br />
unstable. 140 The danger of a quick independence was<br />
the prospect of state fragmentation, and this concern<br />
is quite justified given the situation in Katanga. 141 May<br />
elections led to hundreds of petty bourgeois leaders<br />
traveling to Kinshasa and provincial capitals to be<br />
representatives of the people. After in-fighting, they<br />
agreed to extend themselves the privileges that had<br />
been given to the Europeans before them and to<br />
set their pay level to 40 times the annual per capita<br />
income. 142 The masses that had been subjugated by<br />
the Belgians felt that they were not receiving their<br />
fair share or getting a fair shot in the infant state. 143<br />
The economic issues at stake in independence<br />
favor the Belgians by a wide margin. The Belgians<br />
have already planned and begun transferring the<br />
colonial state portfolios and ownership of industry<br />
to Belgium through privatization. Meanwhile, they<br />
left virtually all the public debt to the infant state. 144<br />
While most of the discussion in the guide has been on<br />
the economic benefits that the Congo has provided<br />
to Belgium, it should not be forgotten that Congo’s<br />
economic impact extended globally and the great<br />
powers all have vested interests in maintaining the<br />
economic prosperity of the region. For mining in<br />
particular, the Belgians, Germans, Austrians, French,<br />
British, and Americans all had common financial<br />
interests in the region. 145<br />
Specifically, there are a series of specific concerns<br />
in the immediate past that should be noted. The<br />
decrease in raw material prices in 1957 resulted<br />
in a decrease in the reserves of the central Congo<br />
bank and although 1959 witnessed an increase,<br />
there was a deficit of 5.6 billion because of direct<br />
capital transfers and invisible outgoings. This loss of<br />
business confidence and capital flight from the region<br />
was in part a result of Belgium’s tendency to weaken<br />
economic ties with the soon-to-be independent<br />
Congo. By spring of 1960, six hundred million francs<br />
transferred from Congo back to Belgium in a single<br />
week in March. To stem the tide, Belgium placed<br />
caps on households in the colony. 146 the Belgium<br />
government tried to help the colony in this regard,<br />
but it was happy to saddle the new country with<br />
significant debt that had been outstanding since the<br />
days of King Léopold. 147 economically, the new state<br />
will be a mess.<br />
Why Prime Minister Lumumba Has Called<br />
On the UNSC for Help<br />
the soldiers in the Congo army demanded<br />
immediate Africanization of officer appointments<br />
and promotions after independence was formally<br />
declared. 148 Lumumba and other leaders asked for<br />
patience and showed their preference for the elites<br />
in the country by promising promotions but only<br />
after additional training was provided for soldiers. 149<br />
This upset troops greatly, and when Lumumba put<br />
together a viable coalition in the government and was<br />
elected Prime Minister of the new government, his<br />
enemies were not pleased. 150 They began by initiating<br />
a mutiny in the armed forces less than one week after<br />
independence was formalized. General Janssens,<br />
commander of the colonial army who was brought on<br />
after independence to look after the new state army,<br />
gave a condescending speech to troops that stipulated<br />
that their role and rank before independence would<br />
be the same after independence, and thus major<br />
swaths of the army felt they were being denied<br />
the benefits of independence. 151 the mutineers<br />
demanded salary increases, promotions of rank, and<br />
the dismissal of Belgian officers. Lumumba’s reaction<br />
was to appoint an inexperienced doctor as chief of<br />
the armed forces, and Mobutu, with ties to Belgian<br />
and American intelligence services, as chief of staff<br />
of the army. 152 the mutiny continued to spread across<br />
the country, and Prime Minister Lumumba began to<br />
consider foreign military assistance. 153 the mutineers<br />
tried to force their way into parliament on 5 July and<br />
19<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
pressed Prime Minister Lumumba to accede to their<br />
demands, but he refused their desires and promised<br />
to keep Belgian officers and appoint Belgians to<br />
important defense posts. 154 On 7 July, more armed<br />
soldiers threatened to force their way into parliament<br />
and surrounded Lumumba’s residence. Lumumba<br />
tried to diffuse the situation by agreement to demote<br />
General Janssens, promote African noncommissioned<br />
officers, and fire most Belgian advisors. 155 Even with<br />
the new changes and new Congolese officers, the<br />
troops could still not be disciplined and continued<br />
their mutiny. 156<br />
A photograph of Patrice Lumumba after an election victory.<br />
Soldiers perpetrated abuses against their former<br />
officers, harassed European civilians, in particular<br />
religious leaders, and there were scores of reports<br />
of torture and rape. 157 Europeans began leaving the<br />
Congo in droves, taking ferryboats to Brazzaville,<br />
rushing to the two international airports in the<br />
country, and driving to bordering countries. Of 29,000<br />
Europeans that had lived in the Congo’s three largest<br />
cities on 1 July 1960, only 3000 remained by 10 July. 158<br />
Riots broke out all over the country—in Leopoldville,<br />
Matadi, Kasai, and Katanga. 159 European officers are<br />
being sometimes civilly treated but others have been<br />
beaten, spat upon, and even shot and killed. 160 Only<br />
some two dozen Europeans have been confirmed to<br />
have been killed at this point. 161<br />
The Belgium military intervened in the country<br />
on 11 July by sending in additional paracommandos<br />
to the Congo against the wishes of the newly<br />
independent government. 162 They began by securing<br />
the international airports to transport europeans<br />
out of the country, 163 but their methods are at times<br />
presumptuous. There have been reports of soldiers<br />
shooting first and asking questions later, which is<br />
inflaming rebels’ passions. 164 they are attempting<br />
to quell the violence in hotspots across the country,<br />
and have been successful in some areas but incited<br />
violence in others. Their decision to use naval<br />
forces to bombard and shell Matadi unleashed<br />
anger, resentment, and more violence across the<br />
Congo when it was reported via radio broadcast. 165<br />
Compounding the situation, Moise Tshombe, a son<br />
of a wealthy trading and transport family, proclaimed<br />
the independence of the Katanga province on 11<br />
July. 166<br />
In Katanga, when the Belgians began their<br />
intervention a few days ago, they disarmed all<br />
non-Katangese soldiers and expelled them from<br />
the Katanga province. It should be noted that the<br />
Katanga province retained economic importance<br />
as a mineral-rich province. 167 As much as 80 percent<br />
of the Congo’s export wealth lies in this mineralrich<br />
area. 168 It should also be noted that the Belgian<br />
perception of the colony was framed within the<br />
language of paternalism. it was not that they thought<br />
they were violating independence but that the Congo<br />
had proven that it was not stable enough for the<br />
“gift” of sovereignty and self-rule, so the gift could<br />
be returned. 169 The Congo government had proven<br />
incapable, Belgian government officials asserted, of<br />
being able to control the “brutal savagery” of the<br />
Congolese. 170 Belgium also justified its intervention on<br />
the protection of “white inhabitants” who had to be<br />
protected by military forces by virtue of the “supreme<br />
laws of humanity.” 171<br />
On 12 July, Lumumba and Kasavubu (profiled in the<br />
Key Actors section) appealed to the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong><br />
and Secretary General Dag Hammarskjöld for help,<br />
requesting UN soldiers to protect the country from<br />
external powers and to help restore its territorial<br />
integrity. 172 it is now July 13, and the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
must decide what to do in the region.<br />
20<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
Past uN Actions<br />
The course of action requested by Lumumba and<br />
Kasavubu are wholly unprecedented in the UNSC’s<br />
history thus far and should be treated as a distinct<br />
break from the typical actions of the body. First, the<br />
interpretation of the situation in the Congo must be<br />
squared appropriately with the UNSC’s mandate to<br />
address situations that breach “international peace<br />
and security.” That an internal threat to territorial<br />
integrity harms international peace and security is<br />
NOT a doctrine that has been ingrained in the practices<br />
of UNSC. Second, the dispatching of peacekeepers<br />
to actively support a nascent nation in its struggle<br />
for territorial integrity has never been done, and<br />
the kind of peacekeeping force for this task has<br />
never been dispatched anywhere. Since the Korean<br />
War, UN peacekeepers have been stationed at the<br />
demilitarized zone to maintain peace between the<br />
North and the South. In Israel in 1948, peacekeepers<br />
were dispatched to maintain peaceful relations<br />
between the Palestinians in the region and newly<br />
arrived Jewish settlers. After the Suez crisis of 1956,<br />
peacekeepers from around the world arrived at the<br />
Suez Canal to ensure that the agreement between the<br />
former colonial powers of Britain and France and their<br />
ally Israel and Egypt and its Arab allies was carried out.<br />
Ultimately, the request from the Congo government<br />
reconceptualizes what a UN peacekeeper is and what<br />
UN Secretary General Dag Hammarskjold visits with Suez Crisis peacekeepers.<br />
his or her duties are, envisioning them as robust<br />
entities with mandates that require them to perform<br />
duties typically associated with military. 173<br />
Potential Solutions<br />
The situation in the Congo has not been evaluated<br />
by the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>, and this could prove to be a<br />
benefit or challenge. Although there are no previous<br />
actions to evaluate and build upon, there is freedom<br />
to develop and create innovative solutions that utilize<br />
the full power of the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>. Embedded<br />
in the conflict, as detailed, are weak institutional<br />
structures, ethnic parties and divisions, and an<br />
economy that benefits corporations at the expense of<br />
the population. the following is a listing of potential<br />
areas solutions could be applied to; it is by no means<br />
comprehensive in number of potential areas nor in<br />
description of the listed areas.<br />
Independence, Wait?<br />
the Belgian Minister of the Congo and Ruanda-<br />
Urundi, Auguste de Schrivjer, favored at the outset<br />
of the independence a substantial and open debate<br />
on whether a new Congolese government could<br />
maintain internal autonomy. He had significant<br />
doubts that the Congolese institutions had a capacity<br />
for self-government, and he urged that independence<br />
be postponed in order to . 174 With this argument in<br />
mind, the UNSC may recommend that a caretaker<br />
government be established by Belgium and other<br />
21<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
Western powers that has the authority to maintain<br />
the internal integrity of the fledgling nation as well as<br />
maintain and administer the police force, the military,<br />
the social services, and the basic functions of the<br />
state from mail to sanitation.<br />
Economic Issues<br />
The economic system in the Congo is very<br />
precarious. the repatriation of capital from the<br />
Congo back to Belgium needs to be replaced with<br />
an economic system that helps Africans benefit<br />
from the rewards earned by European businesses.<br />
Individual settlers and corporate sponsors enjoy onesided<br />
benefits in the colonial system that needs to<br />
be fixed. 175 in the past few years, the decrease in raw<br />
material prices combined with Belgium’s decision to<br />
withdraw capital from the country as well as saddle<br />
it with longstanding debts to international banks and<br />
foreign governments has left the new Congo in a very<br />
difficult position economically.<br />
With mining making up a significant portion of the Congo’s<br />
economic activity, will the UNSC address this industry?<br />
UN Control<br />
Replacing or augmenting the Belgium forces that<br />
were sent into the country after independence, the<br />
<strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> could decide to send in troops with<br />
the goal to protect the country from devolving into<br />
chaos, and UN troops could operate as stabilizers<br />
of the uneasy peace and serve to enforce cease-fire<br />
agreements. 176 As stated previously, this avenue is<br />
one not taken previously in the UNSC’s history. If<br />
chosen, the UNSC will need to establish this force<br />
as quickly as possible. The UNSC will need to recruit<br />
a force of varying nationalities that is able to satisfy<br />
actors and stakeholders in the UNSC itself and on<br />
the ground in the Congo. A specific mandate for the<br />
troops and a leadership structure will need to be<br />
determined. Weapons and equipment will need to be<br />
budgeted for and purchased by the UN or donated<br />
by UN governments. While it appears as if this is<br />
the preferred avenue for the central government of<br />
the Congo and the US and Soviet governments, the<br />
Tshombe and his CONAKAT party in Katanga, who<br />
seceded from the central government, has had been<br />
bankrolled and supported by European governments<br />
in the past including France, Britain, and Belgium. 177<br />
Belgian Withdrawal<br />
Any infusion of uN troops or recommendation for<br />
the situation in Congo must address the stationing<br />
of Belgian troops that are currently in the country.<br />
Ostensibly there to protect white settlers, this is<br />
somewhat difficult given the isolated residence of<br />
many europeans across the country (though the chaos<br />
in the region has prompted many to head for the few<br />
airports in the new nation). 178 the recommendation<br />
for withdrawal from the Congo will help to provide<br />
legitimacy to the new Congo government and provide<br />
its central government with the opportunity to break<br />
away from its past status as a colonial power. On the<br />
other hand, the rapid withdrawal of Belgian troops<br />
experienced in the region might be a vacuum of<br />
power and move into greater chaos as ethnic groups<br />
and political party leaders attempt to fill the void and<br />
gain control over the region. Also, Europeans seeking<br />
to leave the new country may find themselves<br />
unprotected and left without a ride home if Belgians<br />
leave and face the wrath of a restless population.<br />
Reparations<br />
Because Belgium benefited significantly from the<br />
inflow of capital from the Congo during colonial times,<br />
some have argued that Belgium should be required<br />
to pay reparations for the crimes and slave labor. 179<br />
the recommendation that Belgian pay reparations<br />
for its past abuses and injustices is a solution that<br />
is unlikely to gain support by the Western powers<br />
who had or still have colonial powers that in the<br />
immediate past or long ago were abused to provide<br />
power and prestige to the colonial power. if framed<br />
22<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
in different terms, as a package to promote economic<br />
development and raise the Congo’s standard of living,<br />
this solution might gain more support in the wider<br />
UNSC. However, there is the problem of ensuring<br />
Belgium or other colonial powers with interests in the<br />
Congo follow through with the recommendation of<br />
the uNSC.<br />
Public Control of Economic Resources<br />
From the time of Leopold, the Congo people<br />
have not had access to profits generated from<br />
the economic activities in their backyard. Instead<br />
the profits generally have been sent to Belgium,<br />
Belgian and world businesses, and their political<br />
allies. Perhaps stripping these businesses from<br />
their previous control and recommending that the<br />
new national government obtain public control<br />
of the country’s resources will promote economic<br />
development. If the central government has control<br />
over the vast amounts of wealth within the borders<br />
of the country, this would provide incentives for<br />
stakeholders in all regions to work together<br />
in the central government to effectively<br />
mine and distribute the raw materials and<br />
resources. However, this solution presumes<br />
that resource-rich areas like Katanga are still<br />
considered as regions within Congo, not<br />
independent states. 180<br />
Foreign Military and Technical Aid<br />
Lumumba is planning on traveling abroad<br />
to request technical aid and military support<br />
in his attempts to control the rebellious<br />
portions of his country. the uNSC may<br />
decide to request members states lend<br />
support to the original central government<br />
of the Congo. 181 this solution means that<br />
perhaps UN peacekeepers do not necessarily<br />
need to be part of the solution for the<br />
solution still to retain a military component.<br />
Requesting that UN countries supply military<br />
and technical aid to the central government (or to the<br />
other relevant regions that have seceded in what the<br />
UNSC views as a legitimate way) can help shore up<br />
territorial integrity without sending in peacekeepers.<br />
Supporting New Countries<br />
the Congo was originally a political construction<br />
not intended to be made of a unified group of tribes<br />
and people, so perhaps it is a natural outcome of<br />
independence of the Congo that it split into multiple<br />
different countries. The UNSC could decide to<br />
recognize the legitimacy of the seceded Katanga<br />
regions (and any others that might arise) in hopes<br />
that the establishment of multiple states quells the<br />
violence embroiling the region now. It is not clear<br />
that this is a position tenable for countries like the<br />
US and USSR. Moreover, the danger is that this sets<br />
a precedent for dealing with separatist movements<br />
around the world. the uNSC may not wish to enter<br />
into determining the legitimacy of every separatist<br />
movement in every country.<br />
Key Actors: Class and Politics<br />
this section lays out two major categories of<br />
division within the Congo: class divisions and political<br />
party divisions. Hopefully this section will provide<br />
clarity for how to approach various groups and crosscutting<br />
cleavages in the society.<br />
Farmers in the Congo work in 1959.<br />
Class Divisions in Colonial Congo<br />
Imperialist bourgeoisie: This group does not live<br />
in the region but is economically and politically<br />
dominant. Top corporate managers, members of<br />
the Belgian government, and the hierarchy of the<br />
Catholic Church make up most of this colony. With<br />
ties to major European governments and businesses,<br />
23<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
their interests will be ones that are paid attention to<br />
in any settlement. 182<br />
Middle bourgeoisie: Belgian and european<br />
settlers who owned production capabilities and<br />
employed workers in agriculture, commerce, and<br />
manufacturing. 183 This group did not have significant<br />
political power in colonial governance and thus was<br />
not able to retain much of the surplus profit from<br />
industrial work in the Congo. Currently, they will<br />
likely fall back on the imperialist bourgeoisie class to<br />
discuss terms of agreement for their businesses in<br />
the new country. 184<br />
Petty bourgeoisie: this group was made of<br />
Europeans and Africans alike but was split along<br />
racial lines and other strata. There were: the liberal<br />
professions, comprised of europeans; european and<br />
American missionaries; European state officials and<br />
company managers; European and Asian shopkeepers<br />
and artisans; African white-collar employees; and<br />
African traders and artisans. This diverse group is<br />
likely just looking for a solution in which they can<br />
begin to return to a state of affairs in which they<br />
continue their professions without being disrupted<br />
by the formation of new states and rules for trade. 185<br />
traditional ruling class: this class is made up of<br />
the kings, nobles, chiefs and native religious leaders.<br />
As mentioned previously, the Belgian government<br />
actively played these leaders against one another<br />
for prized goods and money, so there is likely to be<br />
animosity between many of these leaders. 186<br />
Peasantry: this largest class was made up of the<br />
rural, African producers of food and cash crops. this<br />
group makes up the largest portion of the Congo<br />
population, formed the basis for many of the protests<br />
and found themselves in the military rebellions. 187<br />
Working class: the european part of this class were<br />
skilled white workers, who acted as supervisors in<br />
mines and large industries, and skilled and unskilled<br />
black workers who worked in urban, industrial jobs<br />
and rural, agricultural ones. 188<br />
Lumpenproletariat: these were the Africans<br />
without stable wage employment and were rural<br />
migrants trying to earn a living through legal and<br />
extralegal means. 189<br />
Parties<br />
At the time of independence, there was a<br />
disorganized array of personalities, leaders, and<br />
parties that were attempting to get control of the<br />
social and political circumstances of the Congo. 190 A<br />
listing of the most important follows.<br />
ABAKO: The ABAKO party was primarily a tribal<br />
party with significant ties and membership in the lower<br />
Congo River Bakongo peoples. It was founded in part<br />
by Joseph Kasavubu who was educated by Catholic<br />
missionaries at the beginning of the Great Depression.<br />
He became a teacher after attending seminary,<br />
where he helped to organize the Bakongo people for<br />
independence. With founder Joseph Kasavubu at the<br />
helm, this party was a tribal political grouping whose<br />
rallying cry for immediate independence began after<br />
Joseph Kasavubu, dressed in a white military-style outfit, is carried<br />
around in a procession of the ABAKO party officials.<br />
a Belgian professor published a “30 year plan for<br />
independence” in 1956. 191 the early history of the party<br />
was tied with attempting to integrate its members<br />
into the elite classes of the cities. 192 Later, the party,<br />
weak because its internal solidarity was through<br />
tribal ties, threatened to secede from the larger<br />
Congo and establish a country in Bas-Congo south<br />
of Leopoldville province. It objected to the idea of a<br />
central government from 1959 when Belgium initially<br />
agreed to future independence. 193 Nevertheless,<br />
after the May 1960 elections, the ABAKO party was<br />
able to gain enough seats and power in the political<br />
system that its leader Kasavubu became the first<br />
President (with less power than the Prime Minister<br />
24<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
in the government structure) when Congo gained<br />
independence. The ethnic political motivations of<br />
the party did not provide it with enough support to<br />
dominate the central government but it did provide<br />
enough support to become an active role in the<br />
newly formed government. His tribal, conservative<br />
tendencies clashed with the President Lumumba’s<br />
pragmatic predispositions to governance of the new<br />
country.<br />
CONAKAt (Confédération des Associations tribales<br />
du Katanga): Under leader Moïse Tshombe, this<br />
organization formed in 1959 when independence<br />
was perceived as inevitable and advocated an<br />
independent Katangan state. 194 Tshombe was the son<br />
of a businessman in the Congo and was educated in<br />
an American missionary school. Later he worked as<br />
an accountant and in the 1950s, he owned a group<br />
of stores in the Katanga Province. Working with<br />
Godefroid Munongo, he founded the CONAKAT<br />
party, which advocated an independent, federal<br />
Congo. In the May 1960 elections, the CONAKAT<br />
gained a majority of seats in the Katanga provincial<br />
legislature. Maintaining political and economic ties<br />
with the Belgium government who was invested in<br />
the resources within this naturally wealthy province,<br />
Tshombe and CONAKAT declared independence from<br />
the Congo central government in July 1960.<br />
Moise Tshombe answers questions from press in 1960.<br />
MNC (Mouvement National Congolais): this party<br />
attempted to build national support through the<br />
processes that parties take in typical Western multiparty<br />
states, but it split in two branches: the PNP<br />
(Parti National du Progres) which was a coalition of<br />
traditional chiefs which was damaged by the general<br />
population in the country by its ties with white<br />
Belgian administrators, 195 which helped it in the 1959<br />
December elections for local government councils, 196<br />
and the PSA (Parti Solidaire Africain) which was a<br />
group of locally based organizations that dominated<br />
the Kwilu district in Eastern Léopoldville. 197 the PNP<br />
section of the party, which would become the more<br />
powerful segment of the party nation-wide, was led by<br />
Patrice Lumumba, who was a postal clerk in Kisangani<br />
for most of his adult life and learned about organizing<br />
from civic associations. 198 Helping to found the MNC<br />
in 1958, Lumumba represented the MNC at the<br />
international All-African Peoples’ Conference in Accra,<br />
Ghana, later that year where his Pan-Africanist beliefs<br />
were further cemented and reflected his approach to<br />
political organizing in the Congo that was above tribal<br />
allegiances. in 1959, he was sentenced in 6 months in<br />
prison for allegedly inciting an anti-colonial protest,<br />
and even with this set-back, the MNC was able to win<br />
local 1959 December election and national elections in<br />
May 1960. Lumumba was released in January of 1960<br />
to attend the Brussels conference that eventually set<br />
the date of independence for 30 June 1960. Because<br />
of his party’s success in the national elections in May<br />
1960, he was elected Prime Minister and designated<br />
Kasavubu as the President of the new nation. More<br />
than any other national politician, Lumumba viewed<br />
Congolese identity as bound not through ethnicity or<br />
tribal identity but by inhabiting the spatial area known<br />
as the Congo. Thus, he subscribed in many ways to the<br />
dominant Western view of political communities. 199<br />
Bloc Positions<br />
US policy<br />
The overarching view of the US foreign policy is<br />
to prevent the spread of communism in the “Third<br />
<strong>World</strong>.” The US was not all that worried about<br />
communism taking root in Western Europe where<br />
defensive military measures were considered to<br />
be enough, but the “Third <strong>World</strong>” was not viewed<br />
in the same way. The US felt the instability by the<br />
mish-mash of parties and personalities around the<br />
country would lead to instability and increase the<br />
influence of communism in the region, even though<br />
25<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
communism in the region was generally regarded as<br />
weak. 200 For the uS, centralized control of the state<br />
was positive, and chaos favored the Soviet control of<br />
the country. 201 This was the view explicitly espoused<br />
in the George Kennan “long Telegram” that asserted<br />
“Soviet policy…will be directed toward weakening<br />
of power and influence and contacts of advanced<br />
Western nations, on theory that insofar as this<br />
policy is successful, there will be created a vacuum<br />
which will favor Communist-Soviet penetration.” 202<br />
However, they were not supportive of Prime<br />
Minister Lumumba; they believed he was focused on<br />
expanding Soviet expansion in the heart of Africa.<br />
thus, from the time of independence onward, the uS<br />
government attempted to undermine the Lumumba<br />
government. 203<br />
Specifically, America wanted a strong, though not<br />
necessarily democratic, government in Leopoldville<br />
and were adamant that the colonial european powers<br />
should no longer have control over the country of the<br />
Congo.. the administration does not want resourcerich<br />
Katanga to secede and Tshombe to secede, who<br />
represented to the Americans a “voodoo version of<br />
communism.” 204 Not only was the uS concerned that<br />
internal chaos favored Soviet influence in the area,<br />
but the specific actors and leaders of potential states<br />
within Congo were classified by the US as sympathetic<br />
to the worst aspects of communism. Moreover, in the<br />
immediate aftermath of independence of the Congo,<br />
This map shows Cold War divisions in the early 1960s (Disregard Congo’s color).<br />
the US was also concerned by the law and order in<br />
the country falling apart and leading to the abuse,<br />
looting, and rape of white residents, so they felt a<br />
need to respond from humanitarian principles. 205<br />
Europe<br />
european countries, with long histories of colonial<br />
administration in the region, have articulated that<br />
they have experience and expertise on the situation<br />
in the Congo. 206 Britain and France (as well as South<br />
Africa) have been active in their support on the<br />
ground for secession by Katanga. Their ruling classes<br />
and politically powerful domestic groups were<br />
fearful of Prime Minister Lumumba’s commitment<br />
to authentic independence from Belgium and radical<br />
social change. 207<br />
european powers Belgium, France, and Britain<br />
opposed firm action on part of the UN against the<br />
secessionist Tshombe. France views the Congo issue<br />
through colonial lens, and publically pointed out<br />
during the independence movement in Congo that<br />
Belgium has a preferential right to the Congolese<br />
territory that dates back from the 1884 Berlin<br />
Conference. the Belgians and Congolese ultimately<br />
rejected this claim when the Congo was granted<br />
independence but illuminates a wider understanding<br />
of African issues by France. 208<br />
Britain’s view of the issue was primarily focused<br />
on economic self-interest. they were concerned with<br />
the loss to investors of an unstable Congo. There was<br />
26<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
political pressure by British settlers in Central African<br />
Federation who were sympathetic to Katangan<br />
independence. The Foreign Office informed the US<br />
State department during the time of independence<br />
that provincial autonomy should be respected and<br />
would promote Western interests in the areas, and<br />
thus they did not want an intervention by the Congo<br />
government or UN in Katanga. 209<br />
USSR<br />
When Belgium invaded the newly independent<br />
Congo, the uSSR called for their immediate<br />
withdrawal. 210 The Soviets were highly attentive<br />
to Afro-Asian solidarity, and thus supported a uN<br />
peacekeeping force to the Congo in order to protect<br />
Lumumba and the territorial integrity of the nation. 211<br />
It may appear that Cold War influences were not at<br />
play in this calculation, but that would be mistaken.<br />
The Soviets hoped to shore up the internal integrity of<br />
the nation ultimately to gain a wealthy and populous<br />
partner in the third <strong>World</strong> to aid with its campaign<br />
against the uS and Western capitalist expansion.<br />
Throughout the beginning of the Cold War and<br />
the decolonialization movement, the USSR often<br />
referenced the US’s own internal racial divisions in<br />
the South of the country against it in the international<br />
arena to mobilize African and non-white countries<br />
against the uS. 212<br />
Afro-Asian Bloc<br />
The Afro-Asian bloc, developing countries who<br />
themselves had gone through or were going<br />
through decolonization, had very different historical<br />
circumstances that defined them individually. From<br />
the 1940s through 1960 three dozen new states<br />
achieved independence from colonial powers—<br />
through peaceful and orderly processes or through<br />
long, drawn out revolutions and independence<br />
movements. The beginning governments in these<br />
countries varied from dictatorships to military juntas<br />
to democratic coalitions to nonexistent as civil wars.<br />
These countries did largely converge in their<br />
ideological predisposition to the situation in the<br />
Congo. They have almost uniformly called for<br />
immediate Belgian withdrawal as the starting point<br />
for discussions. the military struggles of indonesia<br />
against the Netherlands, Vietnam against France, and<br />
other served as the comparison point for the bloc,<br />
and they did not wish to see protracted occupations<br />
of the Congo. 213<br />
Questions a Resolution Must Answer<br />
(QARMAs)<br />
1. does this decision warrant <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong><br />
action? Does it rise to the level of threat to<br />
international peace and security?<br />
2. How should the UNSC respond to Belgium’s<br />
violation of the Congo’s newly established<br />
independence and sovereignty by sending in<br />
troops?<br />
3. Should peacekeepers be sent in to replace<br />
or augment the Belgian troops? if so, what<br />
should their mandates be, what should<br />
constrain them, and how should they go about<br />
maintaining peace and security?<br />
4. What should the role of UN Secretariat be in<br />
managing this issue?<br />
5. How should the economic situation in the<br />
country be handled? Should the UNSC make<br />
any recommendations on the debt of the<br />
country or corporate actions within the area?<br />
6. What should the role of the member states of<br />
the UN be in this situation? Should they be able<br />
to send technical or military support to the<br />
central government or rebel groups?<br />
7. Should the Katanga province be allowed to<br />
split off from the Congo or should every effort<br />
be made to prevent secession?<br />
8. What is the precedent, if any, that your<br />
chosen course of action should have for other<br />
decolonialization projects?<br />
Suggestions for Further Research<br />
In order to effectively prepare for committee, you<br />
should try to find archival research from respected<br />
periodicals like the New York Times, Time, Newsweek,<br />
Foreign Affairs, etc. that covered the crisis in Congo<br />
immediately prior to our convening and immediately<br />
after. you should also familiarize yourself the history<br />
of the Congo that occurred after the time of the<br />
committee. I can guarantee, however, that history<br />
will not repeat itself. Always remember that your<br />
arguments in committee must align with the facts on<br />
27<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
the ground up to and through committee. Be sure to<br />
be familiar with the style, diction, and wording of the<br />
UN <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> Resolutions so that you can be<br />
prepared in committee to write the best resolution<br />
possible. The UN website http://www.un.org/en/sc/<br />
documents/resolutions/index.shtml has a listing of all<br />
the resolutions. you should focus on years up to and<br />
including 1960, the year the simulation will begin.<br />
your research should also concern how your nation<br />
would approach a solution in committee. this means<br />
researching its position previously in the <strong>Security</strong><br />
<strong>Council</strong> in similar matters, what it has and has not<br />
advocated and agreed to, and how its own national<br />
interests align with a solution to the Congo crisis.<br />
Reading press statements from UN representatives<br />
and heads of state, news reports on the nature of its<br />
interactions with Congo, and reports on trade with the<br />
Congo will give you a better idea on how to approach<br />
the problem from your country’s perspective.<br />
Position Papers<br />
Position papers are an essential part of the MuN<br />
experience. they help to frame your argumentation<br />
and coalition-building before you step into the<br />
committee room. I think therefore they are an<br />
essential component in any assessment of the quality<br />
of a delegate.<br />
you should focus on three things in your 3-4 page<br />
position paper (double spaced, 12-point font): your<br />
plan for solving the issue, why your nation would<br />
be arguing for this plan, and how this will solve the<br />
problems in the status quo. Be very explicit in your<br />
papers regarding these three elements. Also, be as<br />
creative as you want with solutions—within reason,<br />
of course. You should cite specific news articles,<br />
academic reports, books, UN documents, and<br />
government websites, and you should have a works<br />
cited page. Be advised, however, that you will not<br />
be held strictly to the positions you articulate in your<br />
position paper; I recognize that the events, as they<br />
unfold in committee, will require you to shift slightly<br />
or dramatically your responses to the situation. One<br />
last comment: I cannot give awards to anyone who<br />
does not submit a position paper, so please do it!<br />
Closing Remarks<br />
You’re almost done with the guide! It was a<br />
great experience preparing this guide, and i hope<br />
it has given you solid grounding to build upon for<br />
conference. I know that I will see in March creative<br />
approaches to highly contentious issues and brilliant<br />
solutions. There are a lot of moving parts inherent<br />
in the topic; economics, geopolitics, international<br />
relations, and philosophical problems all play a role in<br />
the topics and likely the solutions that will emerge. I<br />
really look forward to what you come up with!<br />
Please do not hesitate to contact me at hsc@<br />
worldmun.org if you have any questions regarding<br />
the study guide, position papers, Rules of Procedure,<br />
updates, or any other matter you wish to discuss. i<br />
will attempt to respond as quickly as possible and<br />
as comprehensively as possible. Best of luck with<br />
research and until March…<br />
Endnotes<br />
1 Weiss, Forsythe, & Coate 3<br />
2 “Milestones in <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> History.”<br />
3 Weiss et al. 5.<br />
4 Weiss et al. 35.<br />
5 Regehr 32<br />
6 Gareis & Varwick 29.<br />
7 “Under the Charter, the functions and powers of the <strong>Security</strong><br />
<strong>Council</strong> are.”<br />
8 Weiss et al. 30<br />
9 Kent 1<br />
10 Kent 9<br />
11 Dunn 39<br />
12 Kent 1<br />
13 Kent 6<br />
14 Nzongola-Ntalaja 33<br />
15 Dunn 9<br />
16 Chatterjee 48<br />
17 Kent 6<br />
18 Nzongola-Ntalaja 14<br />
28<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
19 edgerton 164<br />
20 Chatterjee 48<br />
21 Nzongola-Ntalaja 27<br />
22 Chatterjee 48<br />
23 Nzongola-Ntalaja 27<br />
24 Nzongola-Ntalaja 33<br />
25 Chatterjee 43<br />
26 Nzongola-Ntalaja 42<br />
27 Chatterjee 44<br />
28 Dunn 23<br />
29 Nzongola-Ntalaja 14<br />
30 Chatterjee 44<br />
31 Nzongola-Ntalaja 42<br />
32 Chatterjee 44<br />
33 Nzongola-Ntalaja 43<br />
34 Dunn 8<br />
35 Nzongola-Ntalaja 15-16<br />
36 Nzongola-Ntalaja 18<br />
37 dunn 47<br />
38 Roth 29<br />
39 Dunn 8<br />
40 Dunn 21<br />
41 dunn 49<br />
42 Dunn 48<br />
43 Dunn 48<br />
44 Dunn 22<br />
45 Nzongola-Ntalaja 20<br />
46 Dunn 22<br />
47 Dunn 43<br />
48 Roth 31<br />
49 Nzongola-Ntalaja 22<br />
50 Nzongola-Ntalaja 23<br />
51 Nzongola-Ntalaja 38<br />
52 Nzongola-Ntalaja 33<br />
53 dunn 50<br />
54 dunn 50<br />
55 dunn 56<br />
56 Nzongola-Ntalaja 38<br />
57 dunn 52<br />
58 Edgerton 153<br />
59 dunn 52<br />
60 Dunn 22, 25<br />
61 Dunn 58<br />
62 edgerton 155<br />
63 Dunn 45<br />
64 Nzongola-Ntalaja 41<br />
65 Nzongola-Ntalaja 41<br />
66 Nzongola-Ntalaja 42<br />
67 Nzongola-Ntalaja 43<br />
68 Nzongola-Ntalaja 42<br />
69 Nzongola-Ntalaja 45<br />
70 Nzongola-Ntalaja 46<br />
71 Nzongola-Ntalaja 36<br />
72 Nzongola-Ntalaja 26<br />
73 Nzongola-Ntalaja 27<br />
74 edgerton 157<br />
75 Nzongola-Ntalaja 27<br />
76 edgerton 160<br />
77 edgerton 163<br />
78 Edgerton 157<br />
79 Roth 32<br />
80 Roth 33<br />
81 Nzongola-Ntalaja 33<br />
82 Nzongola-Ntalaja 34<br />
83 Roth 33<br />
29<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
84 Roth 35<br />
85 Nzongola-Ntalaja 34-35<br />
86 Nzongola-Ntalaja 35<br />
87 Nzongola-Ntalaja 71<br />
88 Edgerton 168<br />
89 Edgerton 168<br />
90 edgerton 169<br />
91 edgerton 169<br />
92 edgerton 169<br />
93 edgerton 170<br />
94 edgerton 170-171<br />
95 edgerton 171<br />
96 Roth 36<br />
97 Nzongola-Ntalaja 37<br />
98 Dunn 81<br />
99 Roth 35<br />
100 Nzongola-Ntalaja 38-39<br />
101 Nzongola-Ntalaja 39-40<br />
102 dunn 49<br />
103 Roth 37<br />
104 Roth 39<br />
105 Nzongola-Ntalaja 29<br />
106 edgerton 164<br />
107 Roth 38<br />
108 Nzongola-Ntalaja 29<br />
109 Nzongola-Ntalaja 29<br />
110 Nzongola-Ntalaja 29<br />
111 Nzongola-Ntalaja 52-53<br />
112 Nzongola-Ntalaja 53<br />
113 Nzongola-Ntalaja 41<br />
114 edgerton 179<br />
115 edgerton 173<br />
116 edgerton 175<br />
117 Nzongola-Ntalaja 81<br />
118 Roth 40<br />
119 Nzongola-Ntalaja 81<br />
120 Nzongola-Ntalaja 81<br />
121 Nzongola-Ntalaja 82<br />
122 Roth 41<br />
123 Nzongola-Ntalaja 83<br />
124 Nzongola-Ntalaja 85<br />
125 Edgerton 183<br />
126 Nzongola-Ntalaja 85<br />
127 Nzongola-Ntalaja 86<br />
128 Edgerton 183<br />
129 Nzongola-Ntalaja 86<br />
130 Nzongola-Ntalaja 86<br />
131 Edgerton 183<br />
132 Nzongola-Ntalaja 87<br />
133 Nzongola-Ntalaja 87<br />
134 Dunn 81-82<br />
135 Edgerton 184<br />
136 Nzongola-Ntalaja 88<br />
137 Nzongola-Ntalaja 88<br />
138 Nzongola-Ntalaja 54<br />
139 Edgerton 185<br />
140 Nzongola-Ntalaja 88<br />
141 Kent 7<br />
142 Nzongola-Ntalaja 88-89<br />
143 Nzongola-Ntalaja 89<br />
144 Nzongola-Ntalaja 88<br />
145 Nzongola-Ntalaja 32<br />
146 Kent 10<br />
147 Kent 11<br />
148 Nzongola-Ntalaja 89<br />
30<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
149 Nzongola-Ntalaja 89<br />
150 Nzongola-Ntalaja 97<br />
151 Nzongola-Ntalaja 98<br />
152 Nzongola-Ntalaja 98<br />
153 Nzongola-Ntalaja 99<br />
154 Edgerton 186<br />
155 Edgerton 187<br />
156 Edgerton 187<br />
157 Edgerton 185<br />
158 Edgerton 185<br />
159 Edgerton 187<br />
160 Edgerton 189<br />
161 edgerton 190<br />
162 dunn 63<br />
163 Edgerton 185-186<br />
164 edgerton 190<br />
165 Edgerton 187<br />
166 Nzongola-Ntalaja 99<br />
167 Nzongola-Ntalaja 99<br />
168 Edgerton 190<br />
169 dunn 79<br />
170 Dunn 83<br />
171 Dunn 80<br />
172 Nzongola-Ntalaja 99<br />
173 Weiss et al. 39-42<br />
174 Kent 7<br />
175 Kent 11<br />
176 Kent 20<br />
177 Chatterjee 21<br />
178 Kent 20-21<br />
179 Nzongola-Ntalaja 22<br />
180 Nzongola-Ntalaja 28<br />
181 Edgerton 192<br />
182 Nzongola-Ntalaja 63<br />
183 Nzongola-Ntalaja 63<br />
184 Nzongola-Ntalaja 65<br />
185 Nzongola-Ntalaja 63-64<br />
186 Nzongola-Ntalaja 64<br />
187 Nzongola-Ntalaja 64<br />
188 Nzongola-Ntalaja 64<br />
189 Nzongola-Ntalaja 64<br />
190 Kent 9<br />
191 Nzongola-Ntalaja 82<br />
192 Roth 40<br />
193 Kent 7<br />
194 Kent 8<br />
195 Kent 8<br />
196 Nzongola-Ntalaja 87<br />
197 Kent 8<br />
198 Nzongola-Ntalaja 83-84<br />
199 dunn 75-76<br />
200 Kent 9<br />
201 Kent 15<br />
202 Dunn 87<br />
203 Nzongola-Ntalaja 117f<br />
204 Chatterjee 21<br />
205 Kent 13<br />
206 Chatterjee 6<br />
207 Nzongola-Ntalaja 101<br />
208 Chatterjee 23<br />
209 Kent 20<br />
210 Kent 21<br />
211 Nzongola-Ntalaja 113<br />
212 Nzongola-Ntalaja 113<br />
213 Kent 21<br />
31<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design
Bibliographic Essay<br />
Chatterjee, D.N. Storm Over the Congo. New York, NY: Vikas Publishing House, 1982.<br />
Dunn, Kevin C. Imagining the Congo: The International Relations of Identity. New York, NY: Palgrave MacMillan,<br />
2003.<br />
Edgerton, Robert B. The Troubled Heart of Africa. New York, NY: St. Martin’s Press, 2002.<br />
Gareis, Sven Bernhard, & Johannes Varwick. The <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>: An Introduction. New York, New York:<br />
Palgrave MacMillan, 2005.<br />
Gondola, Ch. Didier. The History of Congo. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 2003.<br />
Kent, John. America, the UN and Decolonisation: Cold War conflict in the Congo. New York, NY: Routledge,<br />
2010.<br />
“Milestones in <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> History.” Milestones. About the <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong>/History. Web, n.d. 1 Sep 2010<br />
.<br />
Nzongola-Ntalaja, Georges. The Congo from Leopold to Kabila: A People’s History. New York, NY: Zed Books,<br />
2002.<br />
Regehr, Ernie. “The <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> and nuclear disarmament.” Jane Boulden, Ramesh Thakur, and Thomas<br />
G. Weiss, eds. The <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> and Nuclear Orders. Shibuya-ku, Japan: <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> University<br />
Press, 2009.<br />
Roth, H.M. Zaïre: A country study. Washington, DC: The American University, 1979.<br />
“Under the Charter, the functions and powers of the <strong>Security</strong> <strong>Council</strong> are.” Functions and Powers. UN <strong>Security</strong><br />
<strong>Council</strong>. Web, n.d. 1 Sep 2010 .<br />
Weiss, Thomas, David Forsythe, & Roger Coate. The <strong>United</strong> <strong>Nations</strong> and Changing <strong>World</strong> Politics. Boulder, CO:<br />
Westview Press, 2008.<br />
32<br />
Melbourne Host Directorate PTY LTD | Office of Media and Design