05.09.2013 Views

LawPavilion Electronic Law ...

LawPavilion Electronic Law ...

LawPavilion Electronic Law ...

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

"...The issue in that case was a matter of contract<br />

which was not explicitly included and necessitating<br />

a pre-action notice. This case is however<br />

distinguishable from the one under consideration<br />

which the provision of Section 26(2) clearly<br />

requires that there must be pre-action notice to the<br />

Corporation in "any suit" giving no single<br />

specification or exception. Thus the remarkable<br />

distinguishing factor from the case under reference<br />

and cited by the appellant's learned counsel.<br />

The reasoning of the Court of Appeal is wrong.<br />

The issue in this case is also a matter of contract, a<br />

contract of employment. How may I ask is NPA v.<br />

Construzioni Generali supra distinguishable. The<br />

Court of Appeal said that any suit in subsection 2 of<br />

Section 26 of the NICON Act gives no single<br />

specification or exception, but failed to see and also<br />

failed to explain subsection 2 of Section 97 of the<br />

Ports Act which also has in this case "No suit". "No<br />

suit" and "Any suit" in the context used in the<br />

legislation mean the same thing. I fail to this case<br />

can be distinguishable from NPA v. Construzioni<br />

Generali Supra.<br />

In the Construzioni case, the appellants, a<br />

statutory corporation engaged the 1st respondent,<br />

building contractors to construct what used to be<br />

known as the second Apapa Wharf Extension. The<br />

appellant sued for £163,124 while the respondent<br />

counterclaim. It was held inter alia by this court:<br />

"That Section 97 of the Ports Act and similar<br />

enactments are not intended by the legislature to<br />

apply to specific contracts. Also when goods have

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!