Challenge for HR - National HRD Network
Challenge for HR - National HRD Network
Challenge for HR - National HRD Network
You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles
YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.
Holistic Assessments<br />
- A Three Dimensional View<br />
Its been quite sometime that I wrote an<br />
article on assessment. My last article <strong>for</strong><br />
N<strong>HR</strong>D magazine was the one of B-learning<br />
titled "Welcome to B-learning!".<br />
Out of the blue, this picture (see Figure 1)<br />
virtually flashed in front of me. The impulse<br />
generated inspired me to write an article on<br />
it. How is that! Here we go…<br />
Like I discussed about a new jargon called<br />
"B-learning" in my previous article, this time<br />
I have come up with another one named<br />
"3DAC". It stands <strong>for</strong> 3 dimensional<br />
assessment cube (See Figure 1).<br />
human being basically possesses seven<br />
types of intelligence components. They are<br />
linguistic, logical-mathematical, musical,<br />
spatial, bodily kinesthetic, interpersonal and<br />
intrapersonal intelligence. The degree of<br />
intelligence on each component may vary<br />
within and among individuals. The aggregate<br />
composition determines the overall<br />
"cognitive ability" of an individual. Also, the<br />
dominant trait(s) would determine the<br />
field(s) in which an individual would excel<br />
(e.g. If a person has interpersonal<br />
intelligence as a dominant trait, it means that<br />
he can be a good marketing guy or a<br />
teacher). This should give you an idea about<br />
Cognitive Abilities. If you are curious to know<br />
more about this, there are abundant<br />
resources available on the net <strong>for</strong> your<br />
reference.<br />
Now, to Skills…<br />
A Skill by definition "is something you learn<br />
or acquire over a period of time". Again Skills<br />
can be two types viz. Hard and Soft. Hard<br />
Skills pertain to something that a person can<br />
per<strong>for</strong>m or demonstrate. Examples of such<br />
skills are driving a Car, flying an Aeroplane,<br />
assembling/Troubleshooting PCs, etc.<br />
Soft Skills have more to do with behavioral<br />
traits of a person. Attitude, inter-personal<br />
skills can be cited as examples <strong>for</strong> this. Of<br />
course, in a way soft skills can be<br />
considered as a sub-set of Cognitive<br />
Abilities. But you can treat it as a discipline<br />
too. Since hard skills are tangible, it is easy<br />
to demonstrate and assess. On the contrary,<br />
soft skills are more often than not dormant<br />
and also human behavioral patterns are very<br />
– G Ravi Kumar<br />
erratic and circumstance dependent (e.g.<br />
the way an individual behaves when he is<br />
calm is different from when he is under<br />
pressure or disturbed). Hence a soft skill is<br />
a grey area and hence assessments here<br />
are very subjective and often debatable,<br />
sometimes contentious too.<br />
Holistic Assessments - The 3DAC way<br />
Finally, let us look at ways by which we can<br />
assess abilities and skills that we discussed<br />
till now.<br />
A couple of well known tests <strong>for</strong> assessing<br />
cognitive abilities is CAT3 and CogAT. You<br />
can check their official websites <strong>for</strong> more<br />
in<strong>for</strong>mation about these tests.<br />
There are several personality test batteries<br />
available <strong>for</strong> Soft Skills assessments or<br />
behavioral assessments. Some of the noted<br />
ones are 16PF, FIRO-B and DISC based<br />
tests.<br />
Hard Skills would mean anything from<br />
driving a car to flying a space shuttle. Here,<br />
the context is Software or Programming<br />
Skills assessments. Again here, we have<br />
Objective assessments and Per<strong>for</strong>mance<br />
based assessments. In objective<br />
assessments candidates are tested more<br />
on concepts pertaining to software<br />
programming. Some of the renowned<br />
players in objective assessments are<br />
Brainbench, MeasureUp, QuestionMark and<br />
Professional Aptitude Council (PAC). The<br />
latter is the most effective, but the most<br />
challenging kind of assessments. Prominent<br />
companies in this area of assessments are<br />
SkillCheck and DevSquare<br />
(www.devsquare.com).<br />
u H<br />
3 dimensional assessment cube<br />
Abilities and Skills - complement each other<br />
Be<strong>for</strong>e I explain about "3DAC", let me first<br />
give you some dope on Abilities and Skills.<br />
If you analyze, the implied meaning of the<br />
word "Abilities" translates to "Cognitive<br />
Abilities". There are many schools of<br />
thoughts on this subject and several<br />
definitions / connotations that exist <strong>for</strong> this<br />
word. According to me, one of the notable<br />
ones is the seminal work by Dr.Howard<br />
Gardner called "Theory of Multiple<br />
Intelligences". According to him, every<br />
G. Ravi Kumar is an IT professional based at Bangalore. E-mail: ravi@devsquare.com; rk1601@hotmail.com; rk1672@gmail.com<br />
Fundamentals of Non-violence, infused with consciousness of consciousness and spiritual<br />
Peace and Relative Economics spirituality or consciousness of consciousness are developed in a<br />
emotion.<br />
balanced manner.<br />
- Acharya Mahaprajna<br />
4. If only intellectual consciousness is 7. Stopping the reactive violence is<br />
1. That activity cannot attain success, developed and if only economic possible only when the disease of<br />
which is devoid of the process of development takes place, then bread consumerism that grows with the<br />
trans<strong>for</strong>mation of consciousness.<br />
cannot go together with non-violence economic development is treated and<br />
2. The system <strong>for</strong> controlling<br />
and peace.<br />
consciousness of self-restraint<br />
possessiveness or individual 5. If mere consciousness of spirituality is reaches the higher level.<br />
ownership cannot attain success developed, then both Ahimsa and 8. The solution to this problem is Training<br />
because it lacks in the technique bread cannot go together.<br />
in Non-violence; mere intellectual<br />
of trans<strong>for</strong>mation of consciousness.<br />
6. Ahimsa, peace and bread can go deliberation would not be enough to<br />
3. The mission of non-violence can together only when intellectual provide the solution <strong>for</strong> human<br />
become successful only when it is consciousness, economic problems.<br />
| <strong>HR</strong>D News Letter | December 2007, Vol.23, Issue:9 43 |