15.07.2014 Views

Challenge for HR - National HRD Network

Challenge for HR - National HRD Network

Challenge for HR - National HRD Network

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Holistic Assessments<br />

- A Three Dimensional View<br />

Its been quite sometime that I wrote an<br />

article on assessment. My last article <strong>for</strong><br />

N<strong>HR</strong>D magazine was the one of B-learning<br />

titled "Welcome to B-learning!".<br />

Out of the blue, this picture (see Figure 1)<br />

virtually flashed in front of me. The impulse<br />

generated inspired me to write an article on<br />

it. How is that! Here we go…<br />

Like I discussed about a new jargon called<br />

"B-learning" in my previous article, this time<br />

I have come up with another one named<br />

"3DAC". It stands <strong>for</strong> 3 dimensional<br />

assessment cube (See Figure 1).<br />

human being basically possesses seven<br />

types of intelligence components. They are<br />

linguistic, logical-mathematical, musical,<br />

spatial, bodily kinesthetic, interpersonal and<br />

intrapersonal intelligence. The degree of<br />

intelligence on each component may vary<br />

within and among individuals. The aggregate<br />

composition determines the overall<br />

"cognitive ability" of an individual. Also, the<br />

dominant trait(s) would determine the<br />

field(s) in which an individual would excel<br />

(e.g. If a person has interpersonal<br />

intelligence as a dominant trait, it means that<br />

he can be a good marketing guy or a<br />

teacher). This should give you an idea about<br />

Cognitive Abilities. If you are curious to know<br />

more about this, there are abundant<br />

resources available on the net <strong>for</strong> your<br />

reference.<br />

Now, to Skills…<br />

A Skill by definition "is something you learn<br />

or acquire over a period of time". Again Skills<br />

can be two types viz. Hard and Soft. Hard<br />

Skills pertain to something that a person can<br />

per<strong>for</strong>m or demonstrate. Examples of such<br />

skills are driving a Car, flying an Aeroplane,<br />

assembling/Troubleshooting PCs, etc.<br />

Soft Skills have more to do with behavioral<br />

traits of a person. Attitude, inter-personal<br />

skills can be cited as examples <strong>for</strong> this. Of<br />

course, in a way soft skills can be<br />

considered as a sub-set of Cognitive<br />

Abilities. But you can treat it as a discipline<br />

too. Since hard skills are tangible, it is easy<br />

to demonstrate and assess. On the contrary,<br />

soft skills are more often than not dormant<br />

and also human behavioral patterns are very<br />

– G Ravi Kumar<br />

erratic and circumstance dependent (e.g.<br />

the way an individual behaves when he is<br />

calm is different from when he is under<br />

pressure or disturbed). Hence a soft skill is<br />

a grey area and hence assessments here<br />

are very subjective and often debatable,<br />

sometimes contentious too.<br />

Holistic Assessments - The 3DAC way<br />

Finally, let us look at ways by which we can<br />

assess abilities and skills that we discussed<br />

till now.<br />

A couple of well known tests <strong>for</strong> assessing<br />

cognitive abilities is CAT3 and CogAT. You<br />

can check their official websites <strong>for</strong> more<br />

in<strong>for</strong>mation about these tests.<br />

There are several personality test batteries<br />

available <strong>for</strong> Soft Skills assessments or<br />

behavioral assessments. Some of the noted<br />

ones are 16PF, FIRO-B and DISC based<br />

tests.<br />

Hard Skills would mean anything from<br />

driving a car to flying a space shuttle. Here,<br />

the context is Software or Programming<br />

Skills assessments. Again here, we have<br />

Objective assessments and Per<strong>for</strong>mance<br />

based assessments. In objective<br />

assessments candidates are tested more<br />

on concepts pertaining to software<br />

programming. Some of the renowned<br />

players in objective assessments are<br />

Brainbench, MeasureUp, QuestionMark and<br />

Professional Aptitude Council (PAC). The<br />

latter is the most effective, but the most<br />

challenging kind of assessments. Prominent<br />

companies in this area of assessments are<br />

SkillCheck and DevSquare<br />

(www.devsquare.com).<br />

u H<br />

3 dimensional assessment cube<br />

Abilities and Skills - complement each other<br />

Be<strong>for</strong>e I explain about "3DAC", let me first<br />

give you some dope on Abilities and Skills.<br />

If you analyze, the implied meaning of the<br />

word "Abilities" translates to "Cognitive<br />

Abilities". There are many schools of<br />

thoughts on this subject and several<br />

definitions / connotations that exist <strong>for</strong> this<br />

word. According to me, one of the notable<br />

ones is the seminal work by Dr.Howard<br />

Gardner called "Theory of Multiple<br />

Intelligences". According to him, every<br />

G. Ravi Kumar is an IT professional based at Bangalore. E-mail: ravi@devsquare.com; rk1601@hotmail.com; rk1672@gmail.com<br />

Fundamentals of Non-violence, infused with consciousness of consciousness and spiritual<br />

Peace and Relative Economics spirituality or consciousness of consciousness are developed in a<br />

emotion.<br />

balanced manner.<br />

- Acharya Mahaprajna<br />

4. If only intellectual consciousness is 7. Stopping the reactive violence is<br />

1. That activity cannot attain success, developed and if only economic possible only when the disease of<br />

which is devoid of the process of development takes place, then bread consumerism that grows with the<br />

trans<strong>for</strong>mation of consciousness.<br />

cannot go together with non-violence economic development is treated and<br />

2. The system <strong>for</strong> controlling<br />

and peace.<br />

consciousness of self-restraint<br />

possessiveness or individual 5. If mere consciousness of spirituality is reaches the higher level.<br />

ownership cannot attain success developed, then both Ahimsa and 8. The solution to this problem is Training<br />

because it lacks in the technique bread cannot go together.<br />

in Non-violence; mere intellectual<br />

of trans<strong>for</strong>mation of consciousness.<br />

6. Ahimsa, peace and bread can go deliberation would not be enough to<br />

3. The mission of non-violence can together only when intellectual provide the solution <strong>for</strong> human<br />

become successful only when it is consciousness, economic problems.<br />

| <strong>HR</strong>D News Letter | December 2007, Vol.23, Issue:9 43 |

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!