02.10.2014 Views

Acta Horticulturae

Acta Horticulturae

Acta Horticulturae

SHOW MORE
SHOW LESS

You also want an ePaper? Increase the reach of your titles

YUMPU automatically turns print PDFs into web optimized ePapers that Google loves.

Table 2. Commercially available clonal rootstocks for pears.<br />

Genus/Type<br />

Cydonia<br />

(Quince)<br />

Pyrus communis<br />

(Pear)<br />

Rootstock<br />

BA29<br />

EMA (QA)<br />

Sydo<br />

Adams 332<br />

EMH<br />

EMC<br />

Ct.S 211 and 212<br />

Pyrodwarf<br />

OHF333 (Brokmal)<br />

OHF 87 (Farold 87 or<br />

Daytor)<br />

OHF51(Broklyl)<br />

BP1<br />

Fox 11<br />

Fox 16<br />

OH11 (Pyriam)<br />

Vigour<br />

Semi vigorous<br />

Intermediate<br />

Intermediate<br />

Semi dwarfing<br />

Semi dwarfing<br />

Dwarfing<br />

Intermediate<br />

Root Pruning<br />

Root pruning is a very old method of limiting<br />

tree growth and was used to create small trees<br />

suitable for culture in the enclosed spaces of<br />

walled gardens in the estates of the rich landed<br />

gentry in UK, France and other countries. It<br />

involved digging a deep trench in the soil<br />

around the tree and quite close to its trunk and<br />

then cutting all of the roots encountered. The<br />

trench was then refilled with good fertile soil.<br />

The technique required large numbers of staff<br />

and was very expensive; for this reason it was<br />

largely abandoned about 80 years ago. More<br />

recently, interest has been revived in the technique,<br />

aided by the development of specialized<br />

cutting tools, which, when mounted on a<br />

powerful tractor, are capable of cutting the<br />

roots of trees planted in orchards without the<br />

need to dig trenches. To achieve a significant<br />

reduction in shoot growth it is necessary to<br />

prune the roots quite severely, i.e. close to the<br />

tree trunk (40-60 cm) and quite deeply (40-60<br />

cm). It is not possible to do this the whole way<br />

round the tree bases, since they are usually<br />

planted quite close together within the row; it is<br />

more usual to run the tractor with the cutting<br />

blade down either one or both sides of the tree<br />

? dwarfing in<br />

German trials but<br />

not elsewhere<br />

Vigorous<br />

Vigorous<br />

Semi vigorous<br />

Semi vigorous<br />

Semi vigorous<br />

Semi vigorous to<br />

vigorous<br />

Semi vigorous<br />

Remarks<br />

The best quince for use in hot dry soils.<br />

Good selection for weak growing cultivars.<br />

Similar to EMA but said to perform better<br />

in the nursery.<br />

Good adaptability to different soil types.<br />

Induces larger fruit size but poorer precocity.<br />

Most yield efficient rootstock but can<br />

result in smaller fruit size if not adequately<br />

thinned<br />

Good productivity; tolerates alkaline<br />

soils in Italian trials.<br />

Early promise in German trials not supported<br />

by trials in USA and UK.<br />

The easiest to propagate of the OHF<br />

series but one of the poorest in yield<br />

productivity; resistant to fireblight.<br />

Induces the best productivity of the OHF<br />

series in several trials; resistant to fireblight<br />

and pear decline.<br />

Average productivity; resistant to firebligh<br />

but susceptible to pear decline<br />

and to chlorosis.<br />

Good productivity in S. Africa but susceptible<br />

to fireblight, pear decline and<br />

crown gall.<br />

Good productivity; tolerates alkaline<br />

soils but susceptible to fireblight.<br />

Drought tolerant and low susceptibility<br />

to crown gall; susceptible to fireblight.<br />

Average productivity; resistant to<br />

Armellaria mellea and fireblight.<br />

rows. The treatment is most effective in reducing<br />

new shoot growth if carried out at around<br />

the time of flowering; i.e. April/May in the<br />

Northern Hemisphere.<br />

It has been shown that trees of many species<br />

maintain a balance or ratio of total root and<br />

shoot lengths; if either roots or shoots are<br />

pruned, then the tree strives to restore this ratio<br />

by reducing growth of the unpruned component<br />

and stimulating strong growth of the<br />

pruned component. Hence, pruning roots<br />

stimulates root re-growth and reduces shoot<br />

growth until the specific root:shoot ratio is<br />

restored.<br />

The advantage of root pruning is that it is environmentally<br />

acceptable and, therefore, is<br />

appropriate for organic systems of cultivation.<br />

Many studies show that the treatment also stimulates<br />

increased flowering of the trees and<br />

occasionally increased fruit set. However, the<br />

degree of shoot growth reduction is very difficult<br />

to predict and root pruning may result in<br />

poorer tree stability, due to loss of some root<br />

anchorage. More importantly, the treatment<br />

usually results in reductions in final fruit sizes.<br />

Root pruning is unlikely to become a major<br />

method of tree growth control in the future. Its<br />

main role will be for controlling the excessive<br />

vigour of trees that have been planted too close<br />

together and where normal systems of control<br />

(rootstock and shoot pruning/training) have<br />

proved inadequate. There has recently been an<br />

increase in its use in Holland and Belgium,<br />

where the withdrawal of the growth regulating<br />

chemical CCC has meant that many closely<br />

planted pear trees have produced an embarrassment<br />

of vigorous growth.<br />

CHEMICAL METHODS<br />

Growth and Flower Bud Production<br />

Since the 1960s chemical growth regulators<br />

have been sold that can aid the reduction in<br />

shoot growth on fruit trees and reduce the<br />

costs of pruning. Almost all of these chemicals<br />

inhibit in some way the endogenous production<br />

within the tree of gibberellins. All of the popular<br />

products reduce shoot length by shortening<br />

internodes. Daminozide (Alar) was the first chemical<br />

to become available and this proved quite<br />

effective when sprayed onto apple trees.<br />

Although its direct effects on shoot growth<br />

were not strong, by inducing the production of<br />

increased flower bud numbers and fruit set it<br />

indirectly reduced growth. It was also useful in<br />

reducing pre-harvest drop and increasing fruit<br />

Compact mutants: A. Compact mutant of the vigorous triploid apple cultivar ‘Bramley’s Seedling’;<br />

B. Columnar cultivars of apples.<br />

CHRONICA HORTICULTURAE •VOL 46 • NUMBER 3 • 2006 • 23

Hooray! Your file is uploaded and ready to be published.

Saved successfully!

Ooh no, something went wrong!